YouTube2Text

“Özgür Özel Tutuklanacak mı?" Diye Sordular | Nevşin Mengü Bugün Ne Oldu? — Transcript

by Nevşin Mengü · 7,985 words · 1,272 segments · language en · Watch on YouTube

Full transcript

  1. 0:00Inspired by jet engine mufflers, the
  2. 0:02Dyson HCT powerfully and quietly cleans
  3. 0:05the air in areas up to 100 m². Its
  4. 0:08electrostatic filter, with a lifespan
  5. 0:10of up to 5 years, captures pollen and
  6. 0:12allergens. It cleans odors and gases
  7. 0:14all day and night. HCT is compact,
  8. 0:18powerful, and quiet.
  9. 0:20Hello. First of all, let's start by
  10. 0:23thanking our sponsor Dyson for this HCT
  11. 0:25product. As you know, especially in
  12. 0:28Istanbul, and as you know, in Ankara,
  13. 0:30urban transformation is in full swing.
  14. 0:33There's constant construction, summer
  15. 0:35and winter. Now, because the air is dry
  16. 0:37in the summer, construction dust is
  17. 0:39naturally in the air. Now, you're
  18. 0:41dusting at home, and you say, "Oh,
  19. 0:43everything's dusty." You dust. Then you
  20. 0:45say, "Okay, there's no more dust." No,
  21. 0:46actually, dust isn't just something
  22. 0:48that accumulates on tables, coffee
  23. 0:50tables, and bookshelves. It's also
  24. 0:52something that floats in the air.
  25. 0:55Therefore, we don't see the dust in the
  26. 0:56air. We see it on the table. How do we
  27. 0:59fight the dust we don't see? We fight
  28. 1:01it with HCT. You turn it on in
  29. 1:02automatic mode. Look, I'm running it in
  30. 1:04automatic mode. Now, when there's dust
  31. 1:07in the air, it traps it in the filter.
  32. 1:10It solves the problem. Thank you. I say
  33. 1:13thank you, Haşret. I'm diving into the
  34. 1:16agenda. Now, there are very important
  35. 1:18items on the agenda today. First, this
  36. 1:20framework law. President Erdoğan
  37. 1:23signed the framework law. As you know,
  38. 1:25it passed through parliament. The New
  39. 1:27Party, especially, what the New Party
  40. 1:29says, was discussed and debated a lot.
  41. 1:32New Party leaders, Özgür Özel, said
  42. 1:34yes, but the majority of MPs said no.
  43. 1:37The CHP said yes. Well, the AK Party
  44. 1:40and MHP, who prepared it, are here, but
  45. 1:42the İyi Party says no to the framework
  46. 1:44law. In fact, İyi Party members even
  47. 1:47held a rally in Balıkesir on Sunday
  48. 1:50against this framework law, against
  49. 1:52Öcalan. Now, what will happen after
  50. 1:54the President signs it? Those in prison
  51. 1:57won't be released immediately. First,
  52. 2:01the National Security Council's report
  53. 2:03is awaited. The National Security
  54. 2:04Council will report. It will say, "
  55. 2:06These caves were visited. It was seen
  56. 2:07that they were emptied. It was seen
  57. 2:09that they laid down their weapons." The
  58. 2:11process will begin based on these
  59. 2:13reports. As you know, a committee is
  60. 2:16being formed for its first meeting, and
  61. 2:18that committee is actually the critical
  62. 2:20thing. This is interesting. The board
  63. 2:22is headed by Vice President Cevdet
  64. 2:24Yılmaz. Ministers are also on this
  65. 2:26board. Actually, it seems we'll see
  66. 2:29more of this in practice. That's what
  67. 2:31constitutional experts are saying.
  68. 2:35Lawyers are saying there are many
  69. 2:37ambiguous areas here. This law was left
  70. 2:39ambiguous while it was being drafted.
  71. 2:41Now, will the board be the only one
  72. 2:43reviewing the files of those considered
  73. 2:45for release? Will they be the ones
  74. 2:46directing them to the courts? We'll see
  75. 2:48this in practice, but Cevdet Yılmaz
  76. 2:50also announced that after the
  77. 2:52President's signature, this board will
  78. 2:54hold its first meeting on August 24th.
  79. 2:57Now, let's see, the process will begin
  80. 2:59on August 24th. From what I understand,
  81. 3:01the board will be the only one dealing
  82. 3:03with the files of those likely to be
  83. 3:05released. These will be discussed. A
  84. 3:08tweet came from former President
  85. 3:10Abdullah Gül today. I think it's
  86. 3:13important that Abdullah Gül tweeted.
  87. 3:15Why? I'll get to the reason. He says
  88. 3:16that the law published in the Official
  89. 3:18Gazette today with the approval of the
  90. 3:20President has opened a new door in the
  91. 3:22solution of the Kurdish issue, one of
  92. 3:24the important issues in the history of
  93. 3:26our Republic. I congratulate the
  94. 3:29political leaders, especially President
  95. 3:31Recep Tayyip Erdoğan and MHP Chairman
  96. 3:33Devlet Bahçeli, who took this
  97. 3:35courageous step, and the state
  98. 3:37officials who prepared the ground for
  99. 3:39this agreement. I hope this law will be
  100. 3:42beneficial for Turkey. I have always
  101. 3:44maintained my belief that good things
  102. 3:46will happen. "He says. Now, Abdullah
  103. 3:49Gül struck me as interesting. Of
  104. 3:52course, he was more politically active
  105. 3:54in the first peace process; he was
  106. 3:55behind the first peace process. In this
  107. 3:58second peace process, the dynamics are
  108. 3:59different. Here, you know, Abdullah
  109. 4:02Gül's name came up, did you see?
  110. 4:05Şamil Tayyar and Erkan Mumcu, former
  111. 4:07ministers from the AK Party, clashed on
  112. 4:10Twitter. Şamil Tayyar brought up
  113. 4:12something like this. He said that in
  114. 4:152007, Abdullah Gül, Erkan Mumcu, and
  115. 4:17others came together. They were in
  116. 4:19cooperation with FETÖ. He even
  117. 4:22mentions Bülent Arınç. Bülent
  118. 4:25Arınç used an expression like, 'In
  119. 4:262007, they collaborated with FETÖ to
  120. 4:28influence the presidential election,
  121. 4:30they plotted against Erdoğan,' and so
  122. 4:32on. Erkan Mumcu wrote, 'What kind of
  123. 4:38expression is this?' And look, Şamil
  124. 4:43Tayyar says that Erkan Mumcu, regarding
  125. 4:45the 2007 presidential election, used an
  126. 4:46expression like, 'Abdullah Gül and...'
  127. 4:48" The harsh words directed at Bülent
  128. 4:50Arınç are finding serious resonance
  129. 4:51on accounts supporting the AK Party.
  130. 4:53Someone wrote something along the lines
  131. 4:54of, "The anger over Gül and Arınç's
  132. 4:56recent criticisms cannot be denied,"
  133. 4:57and Erkan Mumcu reacted to this. Let's
  134. 5:01remember what happened in the 2007
  135. 5:02election. At that time, the National
  136. 5:04Security Council (MGK) still held
  137. 5:06significant weight in Turkish politics.
  138. 5:09There were discussions about whether
  139. 5:11Abdullah Gül should be nominated,
  140. 5:12given that his wife wore a headscarf–
  141. 5:14was this creating an undesirable
  142. 5:15situation? At that time, Yaşar Yakış
  143. 5:18–actually, Yaşar Yakış served as a
  144. 5:20minister in the AK Party during that
  145. 5:21period–but he was a Turkish diplomat,
  146. 5:23you know, Yaşar Yakış…Some were
  147. 5:25saying, "Should Yaşar Yakış be the
  148. 5:27presidential candidate? He's an old
  149. 5:30bureaucrat, a neutral name," and then
  150. 5:31there were discussions about whether
  151. 5:33Abdullah Gül should be the candidate,
  152. 5:34or a more staunch AK Party supporter.
  153. 5:37Anyway, Abdullah Gül's name came up
  154. 5:39most recently. It's interesting, we're
  155. 5:42in a period where even names close to
  156. 5:44the government, or those close to the
  157. 5:47government, sometimes...It turns out
  158. 5:49that some names we've known as close to
  159. 5:52the government until now aren't
  160. 5:54actually that close. Some are being
  161. 5:56ostracized, some are facing operations,
  162. 5:58and so on. In that sense, you'd
  163. 6:00normally say these discussions are just
  164. 6:02two people clashing on Twitter. I found
  165. 6:04their mutual attacks interesting in
  166. 6:06this process. Now, this framework law
  167. 6:08came into effect with the president's
  168. 6:10signature, and of course, the last
  169. 6:11delegation that went to see Abdullah
  170. 6:13Öcalan was the Democratic Party
  171. 6:14delegation. Even Pervin Buldan was in
  172. 6:20that delegation, and we knew she went
  173. 6:22despite her dizziness, wearing a
  174. 6:23headscarf. Parts of what happened at
  175. 6:26that meeting are leaking to the press.
  176. 6:29From what Abdullah Öcalan said, I see
  177. 6:31this: Abdullah Öcalan says, look...Now
  178. 6:33, of course, there are criticisms of
  179. 6:34this process from the Kurdish political
  180. 6:36movement. Those criticizing say that
  181. 6:41here, there's only one person, Abdullah
  182. 6:44Öcalan, who has been imprisoned for 25
  183. 6:47years, or maybe 27 years. His will is
  184. 6:51considered the will of the entire
  185. 6:53Kurdish political movement, and yet,
  186. 6:56until today, none of the Kurds 'demands
  187. 6:58have been taken into account. There are
  188. 7:01also those who object, saying that this
  189. 7:03process is being initiated without
  190. 7:04their input. Abdullah Öcalan also said
  191. 7:06this in his meeting with the delegation
  192. 7:08. He says, "They don't understand me."
  193. 7:10He says, "We are doing this right now."
  194. 7:12He actually gave a very interesting
  195. 7:13example. He says, "How is this possible
  196. 7:16? First of all, we are not conducting
  197. 7:17this process with the AKP. We are
  198. 7:19conducting it with the state." He
  199. 7:20particularly emphasizes this and says,
  200. 7:22"We will be a founding element here. We
  201. 7:24are going to become a founding element.
  202. 7:25" He says, "They don't understand. Look
  203. 7:27, he says,' If the MHP is a founding
  204. 7:29element now, don't look at it that way.
  205. 7:31In a few years, we will also be a
  206. 7:33founding element within this system. '"
  207. 7:35He conveys this to the members of the
  208. 7:37Democratic Party. He specifically gives
  209. 7:39the names of the people he wants to
  210. 7:41meet. He says, "Let these lawyers, who
  211. 7:43are closer to the opposition, come and
  212. 7:45see me. Let this law pass, and I want
  213. 7:47to speak more to the public." So, from
  214. 7:50the details of his meeting with the
  215. 7:51Democratic Party members that leaked to
  216. 7:53the press, I understand that Öcalan
  217. 7:54wants to speak more. He wants to be a
  218. 7:57political actor here. He wants to give
  219. 8:00statements to the press. Let me give
  220. 8:01you an example. As a founding member
  221. 8:03and politician, he wants to move on to
  222. 8:05history. How much of this will the
  223. 8:06government allow? I don't think Öcalan
  224. 8:10can be an actor in the way he wants.
  225. 8:14We'll see about that in time, but until
  226. 8:16the election, developments regarding
  227. 8:17the framework law will certainly
  228. 8:19attract attention. However, what I
  229. 8:21don't understand is, for example,
  230. 8:24Türker was arrested, as you know. He
  231. 8:28spoke on a YouTube channel in 2023. He
  232. 8:30said that the government needs to
  233. 8:32change, and he made his own
  234. 8:33interpretation. He said something like,
  235. 8:35"If it doesn't change, we'll have
  236. 8:37problems otherwise," and so on. Then, a
  237. 8:3930-second clip from that speech, which
  238. 8:42he gave back in 2023, went viral again.
  239. 8:46I saw it yesterday. Now, when something
  240. 8:50goes viral, it usually results in
  241. 8:52arrest. But it's strange. Suddenly, a
  242. 8:58clip from an old video is taken, made
  243. 9:00viral, and the people who spoke in that
  244. 9:03video are arrested. It's a somewhat
  245. 9:06unhealthy process. Türker Ertürk was
  246. 9:09one of the people who criticized this
  247. 9:10framework law and this process recently
  248. 9:12. Everyone perceived it as connected to
  249. 9:16him. Otherwise, it's a situation now,
  250. 9:19but we've seen this with other names
  251. 9:21from years ago, like, what was the last
  252. 9:23time? A gay artist. For example, he
  253. 9:30made a joke years ago wearing a
  254. 9:32headscarf. Do you remember? He made a
  255. 9:34video in a different context. Years
  256. 9:36later, it's being pulled out of the
  257. 9:38archives. "Oh, you said this, how could
  258. 9:40you say that?" An investigation is
  259. 9:41launched based on this, he's arrested,
  260. 9:42and so on. I think it's problematic to
  261. 9:46pull out snippets of these old videos.
  262. 9:49Everything should be evaluated within
  263. 9:51its own context. The conjuncture of
  264. 9:53that day, the context of that day, what
  265. 9:55news was trending that day? Because
  266. 9:58especially in current videos, where
  267. 9:59people interpret the agenda and
  268. 10:01politics according to their own
  269. 10:02perspectives, this context is important
  270. 10:04. What was the agenda that day? What
  271. 10:06was specifically being discussed that
  272. 10:08day? Sometimes politicians say
  273. 10:10something, and you comment on that. Or,
  274. 10:13something becomes a trending topic on
  275. 10:16Twitter, and you comment on that. But
  276. 10:19now, years later, when you take it out
  277. 10:21of context, well, you...Did you say
  278. 10:23this based on what a politician said?
  279. 10:25Did you say it based on something
  280. 10:27trending? When these things are taken
  281. 10:30out of context and only 30 seconds or a
  282. 10:32minute of them go viral, they're
  283. 10:34suddenly presented as if someone said
  284. 10:36something else, like, "Oh, can you
  285. 10:39really say that?" People are arrested
  286. 10:42for what they meant. But this is open
  287. 10:44to interpretation. You can arrest
  288. 10:47anyone at some point. You can pull out
  289. 10:50old tweets, videos from the time of
  290. 10:53Noah. You can say, "Oh, what did they
  291. 10:55say?" Now, something that meant one
  292. 10:57thing in the context of that day might
  293. 10:58mean something completely different
  294. 11:00today. I found it strange. I don't know
  295. 11:04any other nationalist women friends; I
  296. 11:07haven't seen any. From this perspective
  297. 11:09, you could say, "These people started
  298. 11:11a wave. They're inciting the public to
  299. 11:14rebellion. They're causing a great deal
  300. 11:16of unrest," and so on. I don't know, I
  301. 11:18only saw people being arrested. For
  302. 11:20example, who are these people? This
  303. 11:22friend was arrested. Abdullah Öcalan,
  304. 11:26that bandit, can only leave İmralı in
  305. 11:28a coffin. After he leaves, he can only
  306. 11:31go back to İmralı...He might enter in
  307. 11:32a coffin. The Turkish nation has
  308. 11:34reserved a bullet for the baby-killing
  309. 11:37terrorist ringleader. Each of these
  310. 11:40brave men is waiting for the day to
  311. 11:41shoot that baby killer in the middle of
  312. 11:43his forehead with that reserved bullet
  313. 11:45when he gets out of İmralı. Something
  314. 11:47like that was said. Who is who? For
  315. 11:49example, this person was arrested.
  316. 11:52Nasuh Mahruki is arrested. Nasuh
  317. 11:55Mahruki, actually the founder of AKUT,
  318. 11:57the legendary mountaineer, tweeted on
  319. 11:59July 15th. He was arrested because of
  320. 12:01that. Now he's written a letter,
  321. 12:05reminding people of his work. He says,
  322. 12:09it's the anniversary of the August 17th
  323. 12:11earthquake. He says, "I'm under arrest.
  324. 12:13" He had written a letter before. He
  325. 12:17said he had bedbugs in his place, that
  326. 12:18his whole body was being eaten by
  327. 12:20bedbugs. Now, I don't know, I really
  328. 12:23can't get used to people being arrested
  329. 12:25for a tweet, for a snippet from a video
  330. 12:27. It seems a bit strange to me. You'll
  331. 12:29say, "Nevşi, do you think you're in
  332. 12:31Stockholm? Nevşir, do you think you're
  333. 12:34in Koperak? Or Ostoda?" You're right,
  334. 12:36we're not there right now. These are
  335. 12:39the conditions we're in, but it still
  336. 12:41seems really strange to me. And this
  337. 12:43whole thing, this framework law...Now,
  338. 12:45they say the state is behind it. Okay,
  339. 12:47isn't it the state? When you talk to
  340. 12:52bureaucrats, to politicians, to the
  341. 12:53politicians who are handling this, what
  342. 12:55do they say? "Don't worry, the state is
  343. 12:58handling this. There are no concessions
  344. 13:00to terrorist organizations here. The
  345. 13:02terrorist organization is laying down
  346. 13:03its arms because it's been defeated."
  347. 13:05Okay, they're laying down their arms.
  348. 13:06You don't ask someone why they're
  349. 13:07laying down their arms. You say that in
  350. 13:10the international context, we're
  351. 13:11preparing a law accordingly. Okay. And
  352. 13:15the politicians say that there's public
  353. 13:17support for this. There's no question
  354. 13:19mark among the voters of the People's
  355. 13:21Alliance. Bahçeli is persuading them,
  356. 13:24etc. Everyone trusts President Erdoğan
  357. 13:26anyway. The voters don't have this
  358. 13:28concern. Okay, then, if there's nothing
  359. 13:30wrong, why are people being arrested? I
  360. 13:32really struggle to understand this. I
  361. 13:34think it's having a counterproductive
  362. 13:35effect on so many people. Because
  363. 13:37people think, "When anyone who dares to
  364. 13:38speak up gets arrested, then..." When
  365. 13:40someone says something and gets
  366. 13:41arrested, don't you think, "Is there
  367. 13:42something being hidden from us?" Let
  368. 13:44them say whatever they want. What's the
  369. 13:46big deal? The government largely
  370. 13:50dominates the agenda, both on social
  371. 13:52media and on mainstream television. Now
  372. 13:56we'll get to the contradiction of the
  373. 13:57new CHP party. In a place where you
  374. 13:59dominate the agenda so much, someone
  375. 14:00has come out and opposed it in their
  376. 14:01own way. You might find what they say
  377. 14:03absurd. I don't know, the statements
  378. 14:06made are childish, they don't lead
  379. 14:07anywhere. There's no causality. You
  380. 14:09might say they're just crazy statements
  381. 14:12. That's possible, but I think
  382. 14:13arresting everyone who makes crazy
  383. 14:15statements raises suspicion. Is there
  384. 14:18something being hidden? What's going on
  385. 14:19? Why is nobody wanted to say anything?
  386. 14:23I think they're saying, "There's no
  387. 14:25need to arrest everyone and throw them
  388. 14:27in jail." There's no need. Now,
  389. 14:29speaking of throwing people in jail,
  390. 14:31I've put that in the balance. The issue
  391. 14:34has come down to this: Will Özgür
  392. 14:35Özel be arrested? You know, like those
  393. 14:39illegal betting sites, like the
  394. 14:41Polimarket. A lot of politics is being
  395. 14:43done there. Even this...I wrote a short
  396. 14:46piece on the subject. In the Ukraine
  397. 14:48War, people are placing bets on things
  398. 14:50like, "Will this village fall? Will
  399. 14:52this village fall within 48 hours or
  400. 14:53not?" People are investing millions,
  401. 14:55and winning millions. Of course,
  402. 14:57corruption is rampant. The army is a
  403. 14:59separate issue, but whatever the
  404. 15:00country's agenda is, like the elections
  405. 15:01in Hungary, will the opposition or the
  406. 15:03ruling party win? People have become
  407. 15:05addicted to betting. There are bets on
  408. 15:08whether Özgür Özel will be arrested.
  409. 15:11Now, this is an abnormal situation. It
  410. 15:14shows that people are betting on this.
  411. 15:17Normally, what would you think? "Is
  412. 15:18this something you bet on?" you'd say,
  413. 15:21"The judiciary is independent. If
  414. 15:23there's a crime, they'll be arrested.
  415. 15:26If not, they won't be arrested," right?
  416. 15:28It's not something to bet on, is it?
  417. 15:31People see it this way: it's become a
  418. 15:34matter of betting. You never know what
  419. 15:37will happen in Türkiye. That's why
  420. 15:38they call it a matter of betting. And
  421. 15:39let me add this: for the last two days,
  422. 15:41the current account deficit has been
  423. 15:42discussed. It's very high. Now, how
  424. 15:45will this work with this current
  425. 15:46account deficit? How will the economy
  426. 15:48recover? All the economists are writing
  427. 15:49columns about this. He wrote. Lattadtin
  428. 15:51Aktaşlar Mahveye İlmezler wrote, and
  429. 15:53so on. I don't know, in a place where
  430. 15:55they're playing lottery games about
  431. 15:57whether the main opposition leader will
  432. 15:58be arrested or not, I don't know how
  433. 16:00the current account deficit will be
  434. 16:01closed. Okay, the global conjuncture is
  435. 16:03like this right now. Fine, provincial
  436. 16:05democracies are on the rise.
  437. 16:08Libertarian democracy is almost gone,
  438. 16:10and so on. Everyone is competing in
  439. 16:13authoritarianism, and so on, but...well
  440. 16:15, that's how it is then. That's how it
  441. 16:18is then, unfortunately. Anyway, let me
  442. 16:20still say what I find strange. Now,
  443. 16:22today, of course, there are a few
  444. 16:23interesting processes, let me move on
  445. 16:25to Özgür Özel. Whether he will be
  446. 16:27arrested or not. Well, there are two
  447. 16:31very interesting developments in
  448. 16:32Silivri. First, as you know, the second
  449. 16:34session of the Istanbul Metropolitan
  450. 16:36Municipality trial has begun in Silivri
  451. 16:38. Now, they say the second session is
  452. 16:39more important. Why? Because in the
  453. 16:41first session, we listened to the
  454. 16:43defenses of those being tried while in
  455. 16:44custody. In the second session, those
  456. 16:48being tried without being in custody,
  457. 16:50those who have benefited from effective
  458. 16:53repentance, are speaking. The defenses
  459. 16:55of those involved in the White
  460. 16:56Construction project were heard here.
  461. 16:58Today, these are two brothers, Seyfi
  462. 17:01Beyaz and Muzaffer Beyaz. Their claim
  463. 17:06is about a large project called
  464. 17:08Westside in Beylikdüzü, and when
  465. 17:10İmamoğlu was mayor and Mehmet Murat
  466. 17:13Çalık was deputy mayor, Seyfi Beyaz
  467. 17:16says that they had to pay bribes for
  468. 17:18the zoning and building permit. He says
  469. 17:22Adem Soytekin came and first asked for
  470. 17:243 million [Turkish Lira]. They gave the
  471. 17:263 million, but the permit still wasn't
  472. 17:27issued. They wanted it to be faster,
  473. 17:30and he says they gave Hasan İmamoğlu
  474. 17:344 or 3 apartments. But he says they
  475. 17:45gave those four apartments in this way:
  476. 17:47the money was deposited into our
  477. 17:49companies, and then they took it back
  478. 17:51in cash. That's his defense, and he
  479. 17:55repeated it. I stand behind it. "" When
  480. 17:59asked who organized these names, Tuncay
  481. 18:01Yılmaz's name was given. There was a
  482. 18:04debate about whether Tuncay Yılmaz was
  483. 18:07there or not. So, did the prosecution
  484. 18:09influence things or not? The defense
  485. 18:12lawyers mostly argued that Tuncay
  486. 18:14Yılmaz's name was given as a result of
  487. 18:16the prosecution's influence. That's
  488. 18:18what they defended in court. Then his
  489. 18:20brother, Muzaffer Yılmaz, made his
  490. 18:22defense. Muzaffer Beyaz, from Seyfi
  491. 18:26Beyaz, said,' I didn't see any money
  492. 18:30being given or received. I didn't see
  493. 18:33any of that. 'He said,' My brother... '
  494. 18:35Because he said' my brother, 'he said,'
  495. 18:37I don't know. 'Then Mehmet Murat
  496. 18:39Çalık asked a question. He said,' You
  497. 18:41were involved in the money exchange. '
  498. 18:43Mehmet Murat Çalık also asked,' You
  499. 18:45say the occupancy permit was given in
  500. 18:47exchange for money, but the occupancy
  501. 18:49permit was given 3 years before the
  502. 18:51date you say you gave the money. How is
  503. 18:53that possible? 'The lawyers for Beyaz
  504. 18:55Construction said,' It can be given
  505. 18:57retroactively. You give the occupancy
  506. 19:00permit on that day, but it can be shown
  507. 19:02as if it was given retroactively. 'The
  508. 19:04really interesting story is Muzaffer
  509. 19:05Beyaz saying,' I don't know, my brother
  510. 19:07knows, 'and so on. "Ekrem İmamoğlu
  511. 19:09asked a question. He said," You know,
  512. 19:11we know each other, we've had meals
  513. 19:12together as families, etc. Did I ever
  514. 19:14ask you for anything? "He was asking if
  515. 19:15anything like that had ever happened.
  516. 19:16When Muzaffer Beyaz said," No, you
  517. 19:18didn't ask me for anything, "the
  518. 19:20prosecutor requested Muzaffer Beyaz's
  519. 19:23arrest. Because the prosecutor said,"
  520. 19:26Brother, you gave a different statement
  521. 19:28to the prosecutor's office. You
  522. 19:29declared something else. You said you
  523. 19:32benefited from effective protection.
  524. 19:34Now you're turning around and saying,'
  525. 19:36I don't know. My brother said so. I
  526. 19:37wasn't there at the time. No, they
  527. 19:39didn't ask me for anything. 'So, you're
  528. 19:41giving contradictory statements, you're
  529. 19:43giving false statements, "and this time
  530. 19:45the prosecutor requested Muzaffer
  531. 19:47Beyaz's arrest. It's an interesting
  532. 19:49development. Now, while all this is
  533. 19:52happening, Antalya Mayor Muhittin
  534. 19:54Böcek–I'll call him the former
  535. 19:56Antalya Mayor because he's under arrest
  536. 19:58–gave another additional statement.
  537. 20:01How many additional statements has he
  538. 20:03given? I really don't know. He was
  539. 20:05taken with his son. If you recall,
  540. 20:07after some videos of him with his son's
  541. 20:10wife were leaked, Muhittin Böcek
  542. 20:12started giving statements one after
  543. 20:15another. He said things like," I gave
  544. 20:18money to become a candidate. I went to
  545. 20:21Manisa to become a candidate. I gave
  546. 20:24money to Özgür Özel, to Ekrem, etc.
  547. 20:26"Now, in his additional statement, he
  548. 20:28says that Ekrem İmamoğlu told him
  549. 20:30that he didn't promise the candidacy to
  550. 20:32anyone else, that he would use his
  551. 20:34preference for him, but that he wanted
  552. 20:36approximately 15 million euros in
  553. 20:37financial support for this. He said he
  554. 20:41would meet this need as much as he
  555. 20:43could over time. This is another
  556. 20:45statement Muhittin Böcek gave,
  557. 20:47according to the latest information. It
  558. 20:50seems this will be added to the file.
  559. 20:53It seems this opens up a possibility.
  560. 20:55Will Özgür Özel also be arrested? It
  561. 20:58seems this is the starting point. Now,
  562. 20:59will this be a new file? I don't know
  563. 21:02if it will be related to the congress
  564. 21:04or added to the congress file. It's
  565. 21:05interesting, but how many additional
  566. 21:07statements has Muhittin Böcek given
  567. 21:08now? I really can't keep up. Now, of
  568. 21:10course, these two statements are coming
  569. 21:13one after the other. On one hand, the
  570. 21:15IBB (Istanbul Metropolitan Municipality
  571. 21:16) case is being heard. Following the
  572. 21:17CHP's absolute decision, a new party
  573. 21:20was formed. We first saw this in
  574. 21:23Etimeskut. As you know, in Etimeskut,
  575. 21:25the CHP members split off from the new
  576. 21:27party. But the Menderes Municipality
  577. 21:30was truly where things went wrong.
  578. 21:32That's how I'll put it. What happened
  579. 21:34in Menderes Municipality? Both the New
  580. 21:36Party members and the CHP nominated
  581. 21:38candidates. An AK Party candidate was
  582. 21:41chosen. The AK Party candidate spoke
  583. 21:44with President Erdoğan. President
  584. 21:46Erdoğan congratulated him. He said," I
  585. 21:48congratulate you. "We saw that on
  586. 21:49social media. Now, however, there's
  587. 21:52something else incredibly strange going
  588. 21:54on here. First of all, Kemal
  589. 21:57Kılıçdaroğlu is completely absent
  590. 21:58from the CHP. He says," I didn't come
  591. 22:01here with a nullification decision. I
  592. 22:02came here with a court decision. Oh my
  593. 22:04God, what can I do? "But it's unclear
  594. 22:07who is running the party. Müslüm
  595. 22:10Sarı is constantly around. Müslüm
  596. 22:12Sarı is tweeting. Müslüm Sarı is
  597. 22:14making statements. You'd think Müslüm
  598. 22:16Sarı was the party's general chairman.
  599. 22:18Kemal Bey is nowhere to be seen. It's
  600. 22:20very interesting. Now, we're learning
  601. 22:22about something that happened in the
  602. 22:24Menderes Municipality elections. We
  603. 22:27learned this from Müslüm Sarıyaz.
  604. 22:29Because everyone is saying," No way,
  605. 22:30brother, how can they do this? "Now,
  606. 22:31there's a backlash against the CHP from
  607. 22:33their voters. So, in the first round,
  608. 22:37the second round, and the final round,
  609. 22:40Kemal Kılıçdaroğlu called the
  610. 22:42Menderes district chairman and said,"
  611. 22:45Don't do this. Vote for whoever the new
  612. 22:48party's candidate is, support them. "
  613. 22:50Despite this, they didn't listen. They
  614. 22:54didn't listen. Because they didn't
  615. 22:56listen, they supported the AK Party's
  616. 22:57candidate. And what happened then? The
  617. 22:59AK Party's candidate was elected. Look
  618. 23:01at the situation. Now we're facing a
  619. 23:03situation like this. If it continues
  620. 23:05like this, it seems like the Turkish
  621. 23:06election will go this way. The Cumhur
  622. 23:09Alliance consists of the AK Party, MHP,
  623. 23:11and the DEM Party–the party that
  624. 23:13actually provides external support. If
  625. 23:15this framework law continues like this,
  626. 23:17and if the current Kemal
  627. 23:18Kılıçdaroğlu CHP also supports it
  628. 23:20from the outside, they said yes to the
  629. 23:21framework law. It wasn't even discussed
  630. 23:24or debated. They say the new party's
  631. 23:25voters are reacting negatively to it.
  632. 23:27If there are any CHP voters left,
  633. 23:29that's very interesting. It's a party
  634. 23:31without voters; it's unclear who its
  635. 23:34voters are. Perhaps the only CHP voters
  636. 23:36right now are those who don't follow
  637. 23:38the news and don't know about the new
  638. 23:40party. A party without voters. It's
  639. 23:43supporting the Cumhur Alliance within
  640. 23:45the framework of the parliamentary
  641. 23:46arithmetic. Now, can something like
  642. 23:49this happen? If so, how are they
  643. 23:51sending so many names close to the new
  644. 23:53party, so many names close to the
  645. 23:55reformists, to disciplinary action
  646. 23:56under various pretexts? If that's the
  647. 23:59case, then they should send Utku
  648. 24:00Gümrükçü and the Menderes district
  649. 24:02chairman to disciplinary action with
  650. 24:03expulsion. An instruction comes from
  651. 24:05the central office, and you don't
  652. 24:07follow that instruction. Can something
  653. 24:09like this happen? It's unbelievable.
  654. 24:13Now, Çağtay Güç from the new party
  655. 24:16says we've been talking about this for
  656. 24:21weeks...It was said," Let's nominate a
  657. 24:22candidate. "Actually, four of Barış
  658. 24:24Gülsoy's friends were going to vote
  659. 24:25for us. They came in the fourth round.
  660. 24:27Two voted for us. One voted incorrectly
  661. 24:29. Two voted for the AK Party, he says.
  662. 24:32So, even though there was an
  663. 24:33instruction from Kemal Kılıçdaroğlu
  664. 24:35at the headquarters, only two people
  665. 24:37followed Kemal Kılıçdaroğlu's
  666. 24:38instructions. That is, the provincial
  667. 24:41chairman who came with a nullification
  668. 24:43decision. Aren't they all
  669. 24:44nullificationists? Neither the
  670. 24:45provincial chairman nor the district
  671. 24:47chairman has control over their own
  672. 24:48people. It's a tragic situation. We are
  673. 24:50truly facing a tragic situation. It's
  674. 24:53something strange. Well, the operations
  675. 24:58are continuing one after another. There
  676. 25:01are operations especially targeting the
  677. 25:03leaders of these criminal organizations
  678. 25:05. They are expanding and continuing. Of
  679. 25:08course, now these are the ones in the
  680. 25:09forefront, the ones with hats, the ones
  681. 25:11with masks, Caspers, Mesper, their
  682. 25:12people are being targeted incredibly.
  683. 25:14The law enforcement and the
  684. 25:15prosecutor's office are doing the right
  685. 25:16thing. But in the meantime, miners were
  686. 25:18detained again. Gökay Çakır, the
  687. 25:20General President of the Mining Workers
  688. 25:22' Union, and Başar Aksu, the union's
  689. 25:24organizing expert, were detained. As
  690. 25:26you know, the miners are once again
  691. 25:27demanding their rights. Because these
  692. 25:29people from Yıldızlar Holding are
  693. 25:30demanding their personal rights and
  694. 25:31salaries. They continue to protest.
  695. 25:33They continue to protest in front of
  696. 25:35the Ministry of Energy. This time, they
  697. 25:37probably didn't detain the miners
  698. 25:38because they're attracting too much
  699. 25:39attention. This time, there are so many
  700. 25:41detentions and arrests that we're
  701. 25:43losing track of how to keep up.
  702. 25:46Interestingly, a sugar operation was
  703. 25:47carried out today. A sugar operation.
  704. 25:50This is very interesting. I wondered if
  705. 25:52it would be a poultry operation. It
  706. 25:54doesn't seem like it. Operations were
  707. 25:56carried out against many companies. Now
  708. 25:58, there's a very interesting balance
  709. 26:00here. In this sugar operation, there's
  710. 26:04a long-standing debate in the sugar
  711. 26:07market. There are two types of sugar:
  712. 26:11one produced from sugar beets and one
  713. 26:13produced from corn-based glucose syrup.
  714. 26:17Now, the sugar producers can't agree on
  715. 26:20this. For example, large international
  716. 26:24companies, those producing sugar from
  717. 26:26Egypt, from glucose syrup and
  718. 26:27starch-based sugars, say there is no
  719. 26:29difference between sugar produced from
  720. 26:32sugar beet and sugar produced from
  721. 26:33glucose syrup. They say they are all
  722. 26:36sugars. The body treats them the same
  723. 26:39way. But those who advocate for sugar
  724. 26:41production from sugar beet say it's not
  725. 26:44true. They say this starch-based sugar
  726. 26:47leads to metabolic syndrome. It
  727. 26:49accelerates fat storage in the liver.
  728. 26:51The body reacts differently to these,
  729. 26:53they say. There are those who support
  730. 26:56this view and those who support that
  731. 26:57view. But the main issue is that
  732. 27:00because sugar beet production is very
  733. 27:02high in Türkiye, especially farmers
  734. 27:04are pushing for sugar beet-based sugar
  735. 27:06production. Because sugar beet is such
  736. 27:09a food that you use the sugar beet in
  737. 27:11sugar production. You also use the pulp
  738. 27:14as animal feed in livestock farming.
  739. 27:17Using the pulp as animal feed is both
  740. 27:19very cheap for animals and has high
  741. 27:21nutritional value, so farmers can feed
  742. 27:24their animals cheaply. That's why
  743. 27:26farmers say," Let's not switch to
  744. 27:29starch-based sugar. "This is a cycle.
  745. 27:32This cycle is broken. The livestock
  746. 27:33industry is already in a dire state. If
  747. 27:35the production of starch-based sugar is
  748. 27:37also allowed, we will be dealt a
  749. 27:39further blow. They are telling us to
  750. 27:41continue producing sugar beet-based
  751. 27:42sugar. The first quota system for
  752. 27:46starch-based sugar was actually
  753. 27:48implemented in 2001, before the AKP
  754. 27:50came to power, due to pressure from
  755. 27:52farmers. You can produce starch-based
  756. 27:55sugar, but there's a quota. Only
  757. 27:57certain companies are allowed to
  758. 27:59produce it. And why are they only
  759. 28:01allowed? Sugar beet production is part
  760. 28:04of a cycle, and farmers want it, but
  761. 28:06it's more expensive. Then the sugar
  762. 28:08producers say that if we only produce
  763. 28:10sugar beet-based sugar, we can't
  764. 28:12compete globally. They want to allow a
  765. 28:15certain amount of starch-based sugar
  766. 28:17production. So, there's a quota.
  767. 28:21Certain companies are allowed. They
  768. 28:24have permission to sell a portion of it
  769. 28:26in the Turkish domestic market. Some
  770. 28:29companies are told," You can produce it
  771. 28:31in Türkiye, but you have to sell it
  772. 28:33abroad. "There's a quota system in
  773. 28:35place. This quota system continues. But
  774. 28:39now, the operation being carried out is
  775. 28:42based on the claim that these companies
  776. 28:45have circumvented the quota system.
  777. 28:50They produced starch-based sugar but
  778. 28:52presented it as if it were produced
  779. 28:54from sugar beets, and then released it
  780. 28:56onto the market. Why are they doing
  781. 28:58this? Because producing starch-based
  782. 28:59sugar is cheaper. So they've
  783. 29:02circumvented the procedures, sold it
  784. 29:04domestically, and presented what they
  785. 29:07were going to sell abroad as if it were
  786. 29:09produced from sugar beets. They sold it
  787. 29:11domestically. Some have evaded taxes.
  788. 29:14That's part of it. It's actually a very
  789. 29:16broad operation. We started with this
  790. 29:17sugar operation this morning. Now, when
  791. 29:20you look at it, when you listen to the
  792. 29:21farmers, when you listen to some
  793. 29:23doctors working on this issue, you say,
  794. 29:24" Okay, that's right. "Yes. You really
  795. 29:27have to protect the health of the
  796. 29:29citizens. You shouldn't harm the
  797. 29:31farmers, of course. Since there's a
  798. 29:34cycle like this, it shouldn't be broken
  799. 29:35. The health of the citizens comes
  800. 29:37before everything else. Okay, that's
  801. 29:38right. Of course, the state will
  802. 29:39monitor this. Companies shouldn't be
  803. 29:41allowed to circumvent the rules. Now,
  804. 29:42there's this side to the issue. That's
  805. 29:44right. Now, as I said, some of them
  806. 29:47have evaded taxes. They've pretended to
  807. 29:50be making donations to various
  808. 29:51foundations and so on. And that's
  809. 29:55considered a crime. It's quite a
  810. 29:59large-scale operation. But then you ask
  811. 30:01the businessmen...Businessmen say,"
  812. 30:04Okay, we understand. Yes, that's true.
  813. 30:08But there's another thing. In this
  814. 30:11country, income tax is 20%. Corporate
  815. 30:15tax is 30%. 20%, sorry, 20%value-added
  816. 30:19tax (VAT). 30%corporate tax, and 40%is
  817. 30:23the informal economy. So what are
  818. 30:27companies supposed to do? If everyone
  819. 30:30tries to do everything according to the
  820. 30:32rules, people go bankrupt. They say, '
  821. 30:35Is it possible to have such high taxes?
  822. 30:36' Now, you turn around and see what
  823. 30:38companies are saying. And it's not just
  824. 30:41from the sugar industry, by the way,
  825. 30:43whoever you talk to. They say the
  826. 30:45conditions are very tough, the taxes
  827. 30:48are very high, the audits are very
  828. 30:50strict. Okay, but some companies, you
  829. 30:53know, those with connections, those
  830. 30:57with influence, can use their
  831. 30:59connections to obtain various
  832. 31:02privileges. They get tax breaks, or
  833. 31:05they get some easier access to audits,
  834. 31:08for example. So what happens? Some
  835. 31:14people can get away with it by
  836. 31:15obtaining privileges despite these
  837. 31:17difficult conditions. And what happens
  838. 31:18to those who can't get privileges? "
  839. 31:19Those who don't get privileges are
  840. 31:20going bankrupt, my friend. And interest
  841. 31:23rates are still very high. Now,
  842. 31:25interest rates are high, and it seems
  843. 31:27that if there's going to be an election
  844. 31:30in the second half of 2027, these
  845. 31:32interest rates need to be lowered. But
  846. 31:35there's no such atmosphere. Because
  847. 31:37when you look at it, the situation of
  848. 31:39the new party, CHP, is clear. The DEM
  849. 31:42Party has kind of joined the Cumhur
  850. 31:44Alliance. So, without really fixing
  851. 31:47this interest rate issue, I think the
  852. 31:50government could go to an election in
  853. 31:53the second half of 2027. Why not?
  854. 31:55Because the environment is exactly as
  855. 31:57the government wants it; the new party
  856. 31:59can't even get back on its feet yet.
  857. 32:01The CHP and the new party are clashing
  858. 32:02with each other at the local level, in
  859. 32:04the municipalities and districts. Don't
  860. 32:07just think of this as a clash between
  861. 32:08them in Menderes Municipality, for
  862. 32:10example. Especially at the local level,
  863. 32:12those balances, the provincial and
  864. 32:13district organizations, party
  865. 32:15memberships, party members. Now, these
  866. 32:16are very important. When you talk about
  867. 32:19election time, what each party member
  868. 32:21does, especially in smaller towns,
  869. 32:22districts, and towns, what they do on
  870. 32:24the streets, will be very important,
  871. 32:26and the situation, for example,
  872. 32:27Menderes...Looking at what's happening
  873. 32:29in the municipality, if things continue
  874. 32:31like this, we'll see these new party
  875. 32:33members and CHP members clashing during
  876. 32:35election time. Even though CHP isn't a
  877. 32:39party with many options, what was once
  878. 32:41an attempt by the old party seems to
  879. 32:42have turned into a competition between
  880. 32:44two rival parties. There's a strange
  881. 32:47and tragic situation there. The ruling
  882. 32:49party has created a rose garden for
  883. 32:51itself despite everything. It has no
  884. 32:54rivals. That's just how it is. Even
  885. 32:58with high taxes and high interest rates
  886. 33:00, this can continue. The Turkish
  887. 33:02election could go like this, despite
  888. 33:04everything. The framework law, the
  889. 33:07political conjuncture, international
  890. 33:09balances–the wind is blowing in favor
  891. 33:12of the ruling party. Therefore, if the
  892. 33:14election is going to be like this,
  893. 33:16let's see if these economic conditions
  894. 33:18can continue. What will the private
  895. 33:19sector do then? The private sector says
  896. 33:22," Brother, the state is selectively
  897. 33:24helping. "Here, interpersonal
  898. 33:26relationships become very important.
  899. 33:28Some get tax breaks, some get some kind
  900. 33:30of privilege. Those who don't are left
  901. 33:32with these high taxes, these high
  902. 33:34corporate taxes, like a country in the
  903. 33:36middle of nowhere. In short, the people
  904. 33:38can't continue to produce. We already
  905. 33:41see this in the industrial data.
  906. 33:42There's a significant drop in
  907. 33:43industrial production. Now, there's
  908. 33:44actually that side of the picture. Of
  909. 33:47course, we comment on politics,
  910. 33:48behind-the-scenes information, etc.
  911. 33:50every day here, but actually, on the
  912. 33:52production side, on the private sector
  913. 33:53side, people are in a bloodbath. But
  914. 33:56it's not getting to that point. And of
  915. 33:58course, business people are hesitant to
  916. 34:01speak out. Now, in this tense
  917. 34:03environment, operations are being
  918. 34:05carried out everywhere. It's unclear
  919. 34:08where each operation will lead. People
  920. 34:10are hesitant. What I mean is, these
  921. 34:13conditions leave no business without a
  922. 34:20deficit. Let me put it that way.
  923. 34:22Everyone has a deficit. One way or
  924. 34:24another, to stay afloat. And when
  925. 34:27there's a deficit, what happens? When
  926. 34:29there's a deficit, everyone becomes
  927. 34:31dependent on this political balance in
  928. 34:33some way. Because everyone has a
  929. 34:36deficit. I'm talking about the
  930. 34:38production sector. So what does the
  931. 34:39people do then? This balance needs to
  932. 34:41be maintained somehow, and everyone
  933. 34:43needs to keep their mouths shut.
  934. 34:45Actually, that's the kind of
  935. 34:46environment we're facing. I don't know.
  936. 34:53For example, my friend Kuzgun Trak said
  937. 34:54something like this. My brother works
  938. 34:56at customs. All the people around the
  939. 34:58AK Party have tax exemptions. The
  940. 35:02country...You mentioned the" you're
  941. 35:03with us or you're not "system as an
  942. 35:05observation. Emre Silvan says," I'd
  943. 35:08like to remind you that we pay 65%of
  944. 35:11the taxes. It's actually a beautiful
  945. 35:13country if you weren't a citizen. Of
  946. 35:14course, there's also the employee's tax
  947. 35:16. The tax paid by the employee. It's a
  948. 35:18strange thing. "Müjde Boran says the
  949. 35:22markets are empty. Not a single leaf is
  950. 35:24turning. Only the cafes are full.
  951. 35:26Actually, the fact that the cafes are
  952. 35:28full is because, for example, they say,
  953. 35:30" the cafe economy, "and they give the
  954. 35:32example of the Greek crisis, and they
  955. 35:34say that cafes and restaurants were
  956. 35:36full then too. Why? Because there's a
  957. 35:39perspective that people were spending
  958. 35:41their money in cafes because they
  959. 35:42thought they couldn't save money anyway
  960. 35:44. I don't think that fits Türkiye's
  961. 35:46current situation. People aren't
  962. 35:49sitting in cafes thinking," I can't
  963. 35:51save money anyway, I'll eat and drink
  964. 35:53out. "I think the cafe economy is
  965. 35:54different in Türkiye. The cafe economy
  966. 35:56is actually the unemployment economy.
  967. 35:57We talk about something called"
  968. 35:58homebound youth, "right? A concept
  969. 35:59called" homebound youth "has entered
  970. 36:01our lives. 25%of the young population.
  971. 36:04And this is gradually, little by little
  972. 36:05, always...When the statistics are
  973. 36:07released, we see an increase. For
  974. 36:08example, it went from 20%to 25%. So,
  975. 36:11what are these people doing? Not in
  976. 36:13education, not at work. What are they
  977. 36:15doing? Sitting at home, playing
  978. 36:16computer games. And when they get this,
  979. 36:18they go and sit in a cafe. Why? Because
  980. 36:20the least expensive thing is sitting in
  981. 36:22a cafe. I mean, a beer is very
  982. 36:24expensive, doing something else is
  983. 36:26expensive. You can't even take up a
  984. 36:28hobby. If you don't have money, if you
  985. 36:30don't have a job, if you don't have a
  986. 36:32projection for the future, you can't
  987. 36:33even take up a hobby. What kind of
  988. 36:34hobby? If I say I want to start running
  989. 36:36, a good pair of running shoes today
  990. 36:37costs 10,000 L or something. So, even
  991. 36:39the simplest thing, if you say you want
  992. 36:41to do something inexpensive, like
  993. 36:43running, or painting, you'll have to
  994. 36:45buy canvases, paints, etc., it's a lot
  995. 36:47of money. What's the least expensive
  996. 36:48thing? Again, computer games, as much
  997. 36:51as possible. And sitting in a cafe. I
  998. 36:53think the cafe economy in Türkiye
  999. 36:55emerged from that. You know, it
  1000. 36:57compared itself to Greece. How long did
  1001. 36:58Greece's crisis last? 1.5-2 years or so
  1002. 37:01. Then they recovered completely. Now,
  1003. 37:03in our case...It's been going on for
  1004. 37:04years. People sitting in cafes do so
  1005. 37:05because it's the cheapest option. They
  1006. 37:08go sit with a friend, maybe one or two
  1007. 37:11coffees a day, and that's it. We're
  1008. 37:13actually talking about something else
  1009. 37:15here. Sitting in a cafe isn't a sign of
  1010. 37:17wealth. It's not about wasting money.
  1011. 37:18Actually, I think it's an indicator of
  1012. 37:20poverty and unemployment. People need
  1013. 37:22to see sitting in a cafe a little bit
  1014. 37:23like that. Now, you said everyone has
  1015. 37:26money; if they didn't, people would
  1016. 37:28revolt. Let's not say revolt or
  1017. 37:30anything like that. Those are dangerous
  1018. 37:32words. I disagree with this. There's
  1019. 37:37always this comparison with the
  1020. 37:39previous century. Look, in my opinion,
  1021. 37:43the conditions are different today. And
  1022. 37:46of course, there's this reality, which
  1023. 37:49we see in the figures. There's a
  1024. 37:53segment of the population that earns a
  1025. 37:54lot, is very happy, and has raised its
  1026. 37:56standard of living. They're the ones
  1027. 37:58driving the economy. The story is with
  1028. 38:00those outside of that. Those outside of
  1029. 38:04that are actually...well, producing for
  1030. 38:06those outside of that, whether they're
  1031. 38:08businesspeople or working people, maybe
  1032. 38:10they're barely managing their jobs, or
  1033. 38:12the working class is tied to this
  1034. 38:14system, working but barely surviving.
  1035. 38:17He lives on the continent and all that.
  1036. 38:18Therefore, today's economy has very
  1037. 38:20different balances. I think that might
  1038. 38:23not fit. It might not fit that pattern.
  1039. 38:27You said Buse Yaşar that the left
  1040. 38:29isn't the same left, the right isn't
  1041. 38:30the same right, and money is different.
  1042. 38:32Social relations are also 100%different
  1043. 38:33worldwide. For example, an economist
  1044. 38:36published an article today that really
  1045. 38:38revitalized Darin Acemoğlu. I was
  1046. 38:40really surprised. Oh, it's breaking
  1047. 38:42news. Oh yes. Oh, they corrected
  1048. 38:48something. Okay. We mentioned the
  1049. 38:52Turanist woman we published at the
  1050. 38:55beginning. She wasn't arrested. She was
  1051. 38:59released on judicial control. Let me
  1052. 39:00underline that too. Let me not have
  1053. 39:02given a false statement. Speaking of
  1054. 39:03the left not being the same left and
  1055. 39:05the right not being the same right, I
  1056. 39:06100%agree with you. There's a very long
  1057. 39:08article in The Economist. A lynching
  1058. 39:10article against Darin Acemoğlu. You
  1059. 39:14know Darin Acemoğlu, the Turkish-born
  1060. 39:16economist who emphasizes the importance
  1061. 39:18of institutions. He's also a citizen of
  1062. 39:21the Republic of Turkey and he writes a
  1063. 39:23lot about artificial intelligence.
  1064. 39:26Artificial intelligence...Darun
  1065. 39:31Acıoğlu says that if things continue
  1066. 39:32this way and are not properly regulated
  1067. 39:34, the changes it could cause in human
  1068. 39:35life could lead to serious mass
  1069. 39:37unemployment and impoverishment, citing
  1070. 39:38the Industrial Revolution as an example
  1071. 39:40. He says," When we look back at the
  1072. 39:42Industrial Revolution, what do we say?
  1073. 39:45'Ah, the Industrial Revolution brought
  1074. 39:47prosperity to people's lives,' but
  1075. 39:49Darun Acıoğlu reminds us, 'For it to
  1076. 39:51bring prosperity, unions needed to
  1077. 39:52become stronger. Workers needed to
  1078. 39:54learn to fight for their rights. After
  1079. 39:56that, technology spread to the masses.
  1080. 39:58The prosperity brought by technology
  1081. 40:00spread to the masses. Now, the
  1082. 40:01situation is different with artificial
  1083. 40:04intelligence. For one thing, technology
  1084. 40:07doesn't kill some sectors while
  1085. 40:08creating new ones. It completely kills
  1086. 40:11some sectors. It doesn't create new
  1087. 40:13ones. Because non-human, autonomous
  1088. 40:15robots or artificial intelligence,
  1089. 40:17advanced artificial intelligence, will
  1090. 40:20do everything humans do. People could
  1091. 40:22become unemployed en masse,' and he
  1092. 40:24says that artificial intelligence needs
  1093. 40:26to be regulated. "Now, both leftists
  1094. 40:28and rightists are attacking Darun
  1095. 40:30Acıoğlu. Actually, right-wingers are
  1096. 40:32saying," This guy is so liberal, what's
  1097. 40:34going on? You're trying to stop
  1098. 40:36technology. You're trying to stop
  1099. 40:38artificial intelligence. What's your
  1100. 40:40goal? "Right-wingers are lynching him
  1101. 40:42for standing in the way of technology.
  1102. 40:45Left-wingers are also lynching him for
  1103. 40:46being too liberal. Because Darin
  1104. 40:48Acemoğlu says that the free market
  1105. 40:50economy actually works, that it's the
  1106. 40:53healthiest system with certain
  1107. 40:55regulations. On the other hand,
  1108. 40:57left-wingers are angry at Darin
  1109. 40:59Acemoğlu for that. You know how we say
  1110. 41:01in Türkiye," Turkey is so polarized,
  1111. 41:02you have to be in one neighborhood or
  1112. 41:04the other. If you're stuck in the
  1113. 41:05middle, everyone beats you up "? Well,
  1114. 41:08something similar exists in the world.
  1115. 41:10And we're seeing the results. Both
  1116. 41:13right-wingers and left-wingers are
  1117. 41:15beating people up. That's why Darin
  1118. 41:17Acemoğlu got beaten up this time. So,
  1119. 41:18you shouldn't be upset when someone
  1120. 41:20gets lynched on social media. Because
  1121. 41:22where Darin Acemoğlu was lynched,
  1122. 41:24anyone can be lynched. Is there really
  1123. 41:26any new development? I'm missing
  1124. 41:28something while I'm talking, and I
  1125. 41:30don't want to say anything wrong. Yes,
  1126. 41:38there's a development, friends. The
  1127. 41:42Istanbul Chief Public Prosecutor's
  1128. 41:44Office, Money Laundering Crimes
  1129. 41:46Investigation Bureau, has summoned
  1130. 41:49Alptürk Enginyurt, son of New Party MP
  1131. 41:51Cemal Enginyurt, and Mehmet Seda Erge,
  1132. 41:54who acted with him, for questioning as
  1133. 41:57suspects in an investigation into
  1134. 41:59crimes of harming public health and
  1135. 42:01laundering assets derived from crime.
  1136. 42:05Well, that's interesting. I'm looking
  1137. 42:07at it, wondering what the connection is
  1138. 42:10. There's something going on in
  1139. 42:13Ümitköy. He opened a fitness center
  1140. 42:16called Red Jim in the Nokta Residence.
  1141. 42:20I'm trying to figure out if it's
  1142. 42:21related to that. We can't keep up with
  1143. 42:24all these new files, friends. I'm
  1144. 42:26really struggling to understand because
  1145. 42:28I can't keep up with the files. Now,
  1146. 42:31the information and reports reflected
  1147. 42:33in the investigation file allege that
  1148. 42:35the Red Jim sports center operating in
  1149. 42:37Ankara is selling protein powder,
  1150. 42:39performance-enhancing products, and
  1151. 42:40various prohibited substances off the
  1152. 42:42books, outside the registration and
  1153. 42:44control systems of the relevant public
  1154. 42:46institutions. Alptürk Enginyurt has
  1155. 42:51been summoned for questioning on
  1156. 42:54allegations of selling unregistered
  1157. 42:56protein powder and steroids. MASAK (
  1158. 43:00Financial Crimes Investigation Board)
  1159. 43:01has also examined the money inflows and
  1160. 43:02outflows in Alptürk Enginyurt's
  1161. 43:02accounts. Between 2021 and 2024, there
  1162. 43:06were 15 million inflows and outflows.
  1163. 43:08In 2025 alone, there were 25 million
  1164. 43:11inflows and outflows. There were also
  1165. 43:1518,966,000 TL with Cemal Enginyurt,
  1166. 43:18over 2 million TL with Astürk
  1167. 43:20Akaryakıt, and 2 million TL with
  1168. 43:22Mehmet Kürşat Şahin. So, money
  1169. 43:33inflows and outflows within the family
  1170. 43:35are now consistently included in MASAK
  1171. 43:37reports. This could be interesting.
  1172. 43:40Maybe his father sent money to get him
  1173. 43:41to open a case file, I don't know, but
  1174. 43:43look what we said. Why did they put it
  1175. 43:47on the cover? We said there's a bet on
  1176. 43:49whether Özgür Özel will be arrested.
  1177. 43:52I don't know, because since the money
  1178. 43:54inflows and outflows with his father
  1179. 43:56are also being investigated, I wonder
  1180. 43:57if this file will expand to include
  1181. 43:59Cemal Enginyurt? These aren't exactly
  1182. 44:03similar events, but Adnan Beki was one
  1183. 44:05of the MPs who defected to the party.
  1184. 44:07His son was also removed, if you
  1185. 44:09remember. After his son was removed,
  1186. 44:13Adnan Beki became more passive; he used
  1187. 44:15to be more active alongside Özgür
  1188. 44:18Özel, one of Adnan Beki's important
  1189. 44:20politicians. Now, we don't see him much
  1190. 44:24anymore. How should we put it? Let's
  1191. 44:27say he quietly withdrew from the
  1192. 44:29political scene. Now let's look at
  1193. 44:32Cemal Enginyurt. Especially since Cemal
  1194. 44:34Enginyurt is an MP with nationalist
  1195. 44:36roots, and because of his nationalist
  1196. 44:38background, he was active during the
  1197. 44:40discussions about the parliamentary ban
  1198. 44:42, so he's also noteworthy. Interesting.
  1199. 44:46Well, since everyone's talking about
  1200. 44:47who will be removed, I'll say this too.
  1201. 44:53I guess it's become normalized in
  1202. 44:54people's lives because someone is
  1203. 44:56removed every day. It's settled into
  1204. 44:58our lives. Do you know Yaren? I didn't
  1205. 45:02know her, honestly. Cansu told me. She
  1206. 45:04said," May it be auspicious. "Yaren.
  1207. 45:07Now, Yaren is apparently constantly
  1208. 45:08covering herself and uncovering herself
  1209. 45:09. She's like a social media phenomenon,
  1210. 45:12like a contestant on a reality show.
  1211. 45:17Because she's constantly covering
  1212. 45:18herself and uncovering herself, when
  1213. 45:19she does uncover herself, she shares
  1214. 45:20photos in revealing bikinis and things
  1215. 45:22like that. And honestly, we saw that
  1216. 45:24everyone in the comments is calling on
  1217. 45:26the police and the Ministry of Interior
  1218. 45:28to arrest her. I mean, you can find
  1219. 45:32something wrong with what someone is
  1220. 45:34doing. You can find it inappropriate,
  1221. 45:37but trying to have everyone arrested is
  1222. 45:39a bit strange, isn't it? If you don't
  1223. 45:41like something, you can dislike it, or
  1224. 45:43report it to Instagram, or leave a
  1225. 45:45comment. Isn't what you're doing wrong,
  1226. 45:47brother? You're using your headscarf
  1227. 45:49for popularity. Shame on you. You can
  1228. 45:52react against the companies sponsoring
  1229. 45:54this phenomenon. You can say you won't
  1230. 45:57shop from them because they sponsor you
  1231. 45:59, but we can't turn our country into a
  1232. 46:02rose garden without thorns by having
  1233. 46:04everyone we dislike or are angry at
  1234. 46:06thrown in jail. It just doesn't work.
  1235. 46:09It won't work. We can't all agree. And
  1236. 46:12not everyone can live like us. I'm
  1237. 46:14saying this for each and every one of
  1238. 46:14us. We may all have an ideal person and
  1239. 46:17an ideal society in our minds. This can
  1240. 46:19vary depending on everyone's position,
  1241. 46:20perspective, and point of view. However
  1242. 46:23, some may think differently than us.
  1243. 46:25For some, the ideal person is something
  1244. 46:27else entirely. For others, the ideal
  1245. 46:29society is something else entirely.
  1246. 46:30What are we going to do? We will agree
  1247. 46:32on common ground. We will respect each
  1248. 46:35other. But we cannot demand respect
  1249. 46:37from each other by arresting people.
  1250. 46:40That would be a difficult situation. We
  1251. 46:42don't need to bring such a difficult
  1252. 46:43situation into our lives. There are
  1253. 46:45other ways to react. I mean, this is
  1254. 46:48constantly being closed and reopened,
  1255. 46:49and we can't just say," They've made a
  1256. 46:50mockery of it, so they should be
  1257. 46:52arrested. "What will be the end of this
  1258. 46:53? Will 80 million of us constantly be
  1259. 46:55going in and out of jail? If everyone
  1260. 46:57who gets angry has someone else
  1261. 46:59arrested, how will we live together in
  1262. 47:01peace and brotherhood? I'm prompting
  1263. 47:04you to think, and I'll end here. See
  1264. 47:06you later. Inspired by jet engine
  1265. 47:10mufflers, the Dyson Hret powerfully and
  1266. 47:13silently cleans the air in areas up to
  1267. 47:15100 square meters. With its
  1268. 47:17electrostatic filter that lasts up to 5
  1269. 47:19years, it captures pollen and allergens
  1270. 47:21. It cleans odors and gases all day and
  1271. 47:25night. The device is compact, powerful,
  1272. 47:28and quiet.

About this transcript

This page contains the full transcript of “Özgür Özel Tutuklanacak mı?" Diye Sordular | Nevşin Mengü Bugün Ne Oldu? by Nevşin Mengü, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 7,985 words across 1,272 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.

What you can do with it

Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.

Free YouTube transcript tool

YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.