YouTube Shorts Algorithm — Explained! — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:00Hello Insiders
- 0:00I am your friendly neighborhood Creator Liaison
- 0:03and today I'm talking to Todd Sherman.
- 0:05Todd, what do you do at YouTube?
- 0:06I am the Product Lead for YouTube Shorts.
- 0:08A lot of questions we get from creators around Shorts
- 0:12first involve the Shorts algorithm.
- 0:14Is it the same as the long form algorithm?
- 0:17And when we say things like "don't think algorithm, think audience"
- 0:20does that also apply to Shorts?
- 0:22It really does.
- 0:22I think that that is a durable
- 0:25mental construct way to think about it.
- 0:27The audience is the algorithm.
- 0:29We do do different things in short form because it is a different format.
- 0:33For example on long form
- 0:35a lot of the times people are choosing which video
- 0:37by tapping on it on their phone or clicking on it on the web
- 0:41and that choice is something that drives a lot of engagement on long form.
- 0:45On short form you think that people are swiping through a feed
- 0:48and they're discovering things as they go and so that's one important difference
- 0:52and that leads us to need to measure in different ways
- 0:55and at the core of it we're, in long form and in short form,
- 0:59trying to get videos to people that they value.
- 1:03We want them to feel satisfied with it
- 1:05but there's a lot of things that we do in short form
- 1:07that are different and are focused on the fundamentals of short form
- 1:10for example how diverse the feed is is a little bit different
- 1:14when you have hundreds of videos versus maybe 10 or 20 videos.
- 1:18What counts as a view in Shorts?
- 1:20If I'm just flipping through the feed is every video I'm flipping through
- 1:23does that count as a viewed video for me?
- 1:25It doesn't and across the industry at large
- 1:29I think different platforms count views differently
- 1:32so some platforms treat a view as the very first frame
- 1:36where if you were to just flip through a feed
- 1:39- you would just be accruing lots of views - Basically Impressions
- 1:42Yeah they're basically Impressions.
- 1:43What we try and do with a view is
- 1:46have it encode for your intent of watching that thing
- 1:50so that creators feel like that view
- 1:52has some meaningful threshold that the person decided to watch it.
- 1:56It doesn't mean it's their favorite video ever
- 1:59it just meant that they are deliberately watching it.
- 2:01There's a bunch of different logic behind the scenes
- 2:04that goes into this like whether or not you explicitly
- 2:07took an action to watch it is different than if you found it in a feed
- 2:12and how much time you spend on it
- 2:14all that goes into whether or not
- 2:16the view threshold is met.
- 2:18We don't publish it because every time we look at a new surface
- 2:21or there's some new interaction we may tweak that.
- 2:23We don't want people to try and game it
- 2:25and we have a metric in YouTube analytics now
- 2:27with view versus swiped away which is not the same as click through rate
- 2:30but it's a way you can get an idea of how many people are viewing your Shorts.
- 2:33We've heard from creators that a lot of them
- 2:36will be comparing that metric across lots of their Shorts
- 2:39and they'll see which ones are grabbing the audience
- 2:42versus people maybe just deciding to swipe past them
- 2:45and whether you're making a 15-second video
- 2:47or a 60-second video
- 2:49grabbing people in the first few seconds tends to be important.
- 2:52Is there an ideal length for a Short to be?
- 2:54Like if your short is shorter will people watch more of it
- 2:56and they'll count higher
- 2:57or if it's longer is holding their attention that long
- 2:59impressive to us and then it'll get promoted?
- 3:02The thing to really think about here is
- 3:04to what length do you need to tell your story?
- 3:06Opposed to trying to target an exact length
- 3:10what we're trying to do as a platform is over time,
- 3:13videos of any length, to make sure that they
- 3:14get the audience they deserve
- 3:16Is there any thoughts to making Shorts longer?
- 3:18Longer shorts is an odd word
- 3:20like the capri pants maybe?
- 3:21We have talked about it and where we've ended up
- 3:23is that YouTube already has a bunch of great longer videos
- 3:27and I think that this is
- 3:30sometimes people bring up slippery slopes as if it's a fallacy
- 3:33I think this is actually a slippery slope because when I've talked to creators
- 3:37it's like "can I just get 90" and then other people are like
- 3:39well 2 minutes would be great well I could do 5 minutes over here
- 3:42and then eventually we're just kind of recreating
- 3:45all of the greatness that YouTube already has
- 3:47and so to date I'd say that we are going to remain focused
- 3:52on 60 and under.
- 3:53Thumbnail customization, there's sort of two camps on this.
- 3:56There's one Camp who's like "I want to control every aspect
- 3:58of the experience that I present to people on YouTube"
- 4:01and the other Camp is "I am making 30 different variations
- 4:04of this thumbnail already, it's taken me eight days to get it done
- 4:06I don't want that to be part of my Shorts pipeline."
- 4:08How do you think about and balance those?
- 4:10I've heard it from a lot of creators and I think that it's worth thinking about
- 4:15that being in the shelf on Shorts is not really
- 4:18where most of the traffic comes from on Shorts
- 4:21it's being in the feed and the shelf on Home happens to be an entry point
- 4:24and thumbnails are seen there but most thumbnails are
- 4:27never seen because people are in the feed
- 4:29and they're swiping and consuming and enjoying Shorts
- 4:31So where we've ended up on this is opposed to
- 4:34opening up to custom thumbnails allowing you to select the frame
- 4:38from your video on iOS and Android
- 4:41aligning with the observation that most thumbnails are not seen
- 4:45we really don't want creators to over-invest in thumbnails
- 4:48and that work that effort is probably better invested in making another video.
- 4:52Do hashtags matter on Shorts?
- 4:54Because we've seen this inconsistently across other platforms
- 4:57that you have to do 30, you have to do three,
- 5:00Do people want to be on the hashtag pages or have the hashtag in their title?
- 5:04If the question is are they required: no, of course not.
- 5:07Are they meaningful? I think they they could be
- 5:09but it's hard to generalize across every vertical for every creator.
- 5:12Sometimes a hashtag can be associated with a real world thing that's happened
- 5:16and in that way it's like an event and you want to associate it with it
- 5:20other times they're focused on topics
- 5:22and I think in both those cases creators should consider using them.
- 5:26Does the time of day play any factor?
- 5:27No, it's not something that we think about optimizing for.
- 5:31I think that for certain things freshness may be more of a factor
- 5:34for example if somebody's focused on news then the timeliness of that could matter,
- 5:38that's a little less about time of day and more about quickly responding.
- 5:42What about quantity?
- 5:43We have people who think that they have to post 10 shorts a day
- 5:46to get any attention.
- 5:47I think that it's very difficult to be prescriptive here
- 5:49but there is nothing in our systems that's like
- 5:51when you hit the five video or 10 Short threshold per day
- 5:55that you somehow unlock a secret
- 5:58that's not how it works.
- 5:59If you generated a bunch of relatively lower quality videos
- 6:02and then posted those and got meager engagement on them
- 6:06that energy is probably better spent in just making a better video
- 6:09and fewer of them.
- 6:10There's also something to be said about iterating and posting a video
- 6:14and learning from that what worked or what didn't.
- 6:16Sometimes shorts will take off
- 6:18and they'll get a few hundred or a few thousand views
- 6:21and then just drop completely.
- 6:22How is that working?
- 6:23There are parts of the algorithm that try and find people
- 6:28find creators and audience
- 6:29and sometimes those algorithms will go and effectively find a seed audience
- 6:36find a set of people that may enjoy your video
- 6:39and depending on how that goes
- 6:41it may get a lot more traffic or it may kind of taper off
- 6:45and so sometimes videos can, I hear it from creators,
- 6:48it feels like it gets stuck or something like that
- 6:50I think that those could be some of the drivers there.
- 6:52I think also for creators
- 6:53we're used to Impressions, click-through rates
- 6:56and that doesn't exist in a feed and so those views feel to me
- 7:00more like Impressions than traditional views.
- 7:02If it does increase then it's competitive
- 7:04it's working really well and it's going to keep going
- 7:06but if it just didn't garner any interest
- 7:08it's going to drop off the way Impressions do.
- 7:10That's right. I think that
- 7:11especially creators starting out I think a lot of those early views
- 7:15they're very exploratory as we're trying to
- 7:19proactively help you find the audience that enjoys your content
- 7:22If a Short doesn't take off should I delete it
- 7:24and then just keep reposting it until it does?
- 7:26No, don't.
- 7:29I would not advise that.
- 7:30I've heard people talk about this as a growth hack on Twitter or something
- 7:34I think that there is a risk there that that gets seen as spam in our systems.
- 7:37My advice to folks is if that didn't go how you wanted it to go
- 7:41learn from it and move forward and try again.
- 7:44Make a better version.
- 7:45Take everything you learn from that and make a better version of it.
- 7:48Is Shorts cannibalizing long form?
- 7:51That's not how we think about it.
- 7:52We're really trying to be responsive to users' desires.
- 7:57It's unsurprising that the demand for short form video
- 8:00amongst viewers has really ballooned and we follow that viewer domain
- 8:05so if people are interested in watching lots of short form video
- 8:09and maybe it's a testament to this conversation
- 8:12they are interested in watching lots of short form video
- 8:14we follow that demand and try and satisfy
- 8:16the user's desire for that content.
- 8:19And to the degree that creators can make lots of great videos
- 8:22of all different types then that grows, right?
- 8:25Speaking just for me
- 8:27there are some things I enjoy watching on Shorts more
- 8:29that I would love to watch 30 seconds of that,
- 8:32I wouldn't necessarily want to watch 12 minutes of that.
- 8:34I think that there is a lot of people like that.
- 8:36They're really satisfying, I think, in some ways different needs.
- 8:41There's so many early YouTube videos that by today's standards
- 8:44are closer to short form video than they are to what we think about as long form video
- 8:48and long form video now can be like
- 8:50Marques Brownlee doing 8K video with robots filming it
- 8:53and that can feel like an intimidating barrier of entry
- 8:56if you're just like "I'm going to do a cold start into YouTube"
- 8:59but Shorts can be those moments that you were talking about
- 9:02and that just opens the gates to
- 9:04we have this whole generation of creators that have grown up on YouTube
- 9:08and now we have this new generation that can grow up using Shorts.
- 9:11Totally, and people get started in different ways
- 9:13so I think that short form deliberately has a lower barrier
- 9:17so that people can participate more easily
- 9:20and they might start out at something that's pretty lightweight
- 9:23that's a moment or a scene
- 9:25and it's only minutes creating a video that's 10 or 20 seconds long
- 9:27other people are going to do that and say "I want to focus on craft here"
- 9:31and they may move over to one minute videos
- 9:33they may cut their teeth on the lighter-weight thing
- 9:37but then decide to move into more of a purposeful craft.
- 9:40Another question we get quite a lot is parody between the different surfaces.
- 9:44like right now you can select a frame to use as a thumbnail on mobile
- 9:48but not on desktop,
- 9:49if you upload on desktop it's higher resolution than mobile
- 9:51and it feels like you have to pick and choose.
- 9:53Usually it's a matter of time.
- 9:54Usually we we try and align our priorities where everything happens at once
- 9:59but sometimes that doesn't work out that way
- 10:02and so we usually work towards parody.
- 10:05Shorts are often seen like they're
- 10:06really really good for discovery, for reach
- 10:08but not very good for community
- 10:10but we've launched 'reply with a Short' now
- 10:12which I think starts to bridge that gap into making Community really interesting on Shorts
- 10:17I think it's going to be a great way
- 10:19for creators that make very short videos that want to engage with their audience
- 10:24sometimes they may take that comment as creative direction for the next Short
- 10:27or if you're a long form creator and you want to use this as a tool
- 10:32to engage for the style of community that you've cultivated
- 10:35that's like another new sub, right?
- 10:36And so I think that it has multiple uses
- 10:38and you could see how both of those are a little bit different.
- 10:41We're seeing whole channels now where people just reply to comment
- 10:44like media commentary channels, political commentary channels,
- 10:47it seems like every Short is a reply to comment and it just keeps going.
- 10:49Yeah, exactly.
- 10:50As you look ahead to the future of Shorts
- 10:53are you thinking about more interactivity
- 10:55are you thinking about more feature parody
- 10:57are you thinking about- I guess AI is the giant elephant
- 10:59in every room these days.
- 11:01There's just so many things that I think are interesting in the pipeline
- 11:04lots of things around interactivity
- 11:07lots of interesting things that I will give no hint about related to to AI.
- 11:13AI is something that could help creators of many different types
- 11:17in many different use cases make progress toward their goals.
- 11:20It's just so exciting to be building these products.
- 11:23- Thank you so much for your time Todd. - It's been great, thank you so much.
- 11:25And thank you so much Insiders for joining us
- 11:27if you have any questions, any comments just leave them down below
- 11:31and keep it real.
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of YouTube Shorts Algorithm — Explained! by Creator Insider, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 2,395 words across 252 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.