YouTube2Text

Your Retirement Portfolio Keeps Growing. What Should You Do? (Ep 062) — Transcript

by Parallel Wealth · 13,010 words · 1,778 segments · language en · Watch on YouTube

Full transcript

  1. 0:00Welcome to episode 62 of Retirement
  2. 0:02Impact. I got myself, Adam Bourne, and
  3. 0:03Brett Martinson from our team, and uh
  4. 0:05we're jumping in to answer your
  5. 0:06questions. So, as always, if you have
  6. 0:07questions, uh comments for us, please
  7. 0:09leave those below, whatever, um median
  8. 0:11you're watching or listening this in,
  9. 0:13and we'll try to get them in a future
  10. 0:15podcast. So, first question for today,
  11. 0:18I've started a rift meltdown, but the
  12. 0:20value of my portfolio keeps going up.
  13. 0:22And this is a common thread that we hear
  14. 0:23all the time. uh maybe today as we
  15. 0:25record this market's not so great but uh
  16. 0:28in general the markets have been
  17. 0:29fantastic for a long time and so as you
  18. 0:32build out your retirement plan at you
  19. 0:33know 5 6% but you're doing 8 to 10% yeah
  20. 0:36the value keeps growing um so again this
  21. 0:39viewer says nice problem to have I know
  22. 0:41I've been moving the surplus into more
  23. 0:43fixed income GIC cash and now have 5
  24. 0:45years worth of income wedge my plan was
  25. 0:48based on 640 equity I'm now 7030 and
  26. 0:51comfortable with that ratio um CP PPP
  27. 0:54OAS planned at 65. They're currently 61.
  28. 0:57So they're wondering what to do with the
  29. 0:58surplus, you know. So they're asking at
  30. 1:01some point the equity portion is
  31. 1:02inevitably going to take a hit, which
  32. 1:05likely will. When, how much? You never
  33. 1:07know. Uh do they leave it in equity,
  34. 1:09contribute to TFSA, which they currently
  35. 1:11have room? Obviously, there will be a
  36. 1:14tax increase if they pull money out. So
  37. 1:16yeah, this is a, you know, concern or or
  38. 1:18something that a lot of people are
  39. 1:19bumping into right now of, okay, I'm
  40. 1:21pulling out the right amount. Like we
  41. 1:22have clients reach out. I'm pulling the
  42. 1:23right amount out of the RIP that I
  43. 1:25should, but the value isn't either going
  44. 1:27down like it says in the plan or it's
  45. 1:29actually increasing.
  46. 1:31And so my feedback here would be have a
  47. 1:34plan update with your planner. Now that
  48. 1:37might be you might have to pull more
  49. 1:39more money out of your RIFF. I think
  50. 1:42shortterm for a lot of clients, it's
  51. 1:44just keep following the plan. Yes, the
  52. 1:46account value it's growing, but again
  53. 1:48markets don't look at it on a one-year
  54. 1:50period. Look at it more on a three or
  55. 1:51five year period. Right? Right? If you
  56. 1:53start looking at one year, yeah, you can
  57. 1:54have big swings up or down. So, does
  58. 1:56that mean in a year where you're down
  59. 1:5710%, should you not pull money out of
  60. 1:59your rift? No, of course not. Keep
  61. 2:00following the plan. So, I would say
  62. 2:03after a three-year period, if it's okay,
  63. 2:05we've had a long period for a long time
  64. 2:08of growth, the account value is still
  65. 2:10quite high. Now, you may need to have an
  66. 2:13adjustment in how much you pull out. But
  67. 2:14short term, if it's a year, two years,
  68. 2:17um, keep following the plan. I would say
  69. 2:18at a three-year mark, if it's still kind
  70. 2:20of elevated and substantial, I mean, if
  71. 2:22you you're getting 5 to 10% more every
  72. 2:24year for three years, then you're in a
  73. 2:26tax problem. Um, you know, you want to
  74. 2:29adjust that. So, that would be my
  75. 2:30answer. Shortterm, I wouldn't change
  76. 2:32anything. If it's it's been three years
  77. 2:34now and I got a lot more than the
  78. 2:35original plan I had, you know, a number
  79. 2:37of years ago, uh, get a plan update. So,
  80. 2:39yeah, you probably need to pull some
  81. 2:40more money out and just level that out
  82. 2:42over time.
  83. 2:43Yeah, I I agree that I wouldn't be doing
  84. 2:45any um decisions based on on short- term
  85. 2:48because we we can flip this around to
  86. 2:50the other side. Um you know, god forbid
  87. 2:52the market goes down 40%, for example,
  88. 2:54and it's got done that in the past and
  89. 2:56it will do it in the future. Um, so now
  90. 2:59we're having the exact opposite
  91. 3:01conversation of, well, should I be
  92. 3:02taking money out and and this type of
  93. 3:04thing, which of course is why your
  94. 3:05income wedge is is there to be able to
  95. 3:09um I'll use the word safely safely take
  96. 3:11money out or comfortably take money out
  97. 3:13um even when the rest of the money has
  98. 3:15has gone down. So yes, in this case, if
  99. 3:18if we're talking about um three years of
  100. 3:21of consistency like this, because
  101. 3:25if if you look at any market over time,
  102. 3:29uh they it doesn't it's not the smooth
  103. 3:32line. It we have these typically number
  104. 3:36of great years and then one two really
  105. 3:40bad years and then we continue on. uh
  106. 3:432008 um 2011 wasn't as bad as 2008, but
  107. 3:46there was a bit of a downturn there.
  108. 3:482020 uh ended up being a great year, but
  109. 3:51early 2020 was uh obviously a bit of a a
  110. 3:54crash as well. So, the point I'm trying
  111. 3:57to make there is that it it's it's
  112. 4:00expected that in those good years,
  113. 4:02you're going to be a lot better off than
  114. 4:05the average rate of return that that
  115. 4:07your plan might be uh suggesting. And in
  116. 4:09those crappy years, you're going to be a
  117. 4:11lot lower than the average rate of
  118. 4:13return. So take your take your time. If
  119. 4:15it's been a a year or so, I would lean
  120. 4:18towards keeping with the plan and if it
  121. 4:21starts trending over three years, then
  122. 4:23yes, then then make an adjustment. Uh
  123. 4:26the good thing is it is a good problem
  124. 4:27to have. Um I wouldn't necessarily be
  125. 4:30yanking it out to put in your TFSA
  126. 4:32because I'd have to look at it. But my
  127. 4:34guess is going to my fear would be
  128. 4:36you're costing yourself more tax just to
  129. 4:38get it into your TFSA. Um and of course
  130. 4:42you could take it out and spend it if if
  131. 4:43you wanted uh uh to um there's nothing
  132. 4:45stopping you with with that. There's I
  133. 4:47wouldn't let tax stop you from spending
  134. 4:49it. I would probably let tax stop you
  135. 4:51from pulling it out and putting your
  136. 4:53TFSA.
  137. 4:54>> Yeah. And after three years, if it's an
  138. 4:55elevated and you redo the plans, it's
  139. 4:57like, I need to pull out an extra five
  140. 4:59or 10 grand a year for tax purposes, but
  141. 5:02you don't need that money, then yeah,
  142. 5:03that's when you start topping up the
  143. 5:04TFSA. So again, yeah, short-term rash
  144. 5:07decisions, don't let markets drive
  145. 5:09either way. Like create a plan, stay to
  146. 5:10the plan, and then over I would say take
  147. 5:13a three-year window if it's still
  148. 5:15elevated. Um, or depressed for that
  149. 5:17matter, right? We might have three years
  150. 5:18where the market's just drag and drag.
  151. 5:20It's like our account values are a lot
  152. 5:21lower, then you're doing the opposite.
  153. 5:23So, you know, do you need to like make
  154. 5:25rash decisions every year? Um, I I still
  155. 5:28think it's good loop back with your
  156. 5:29planner, have them review it, showcase
  157. 5:32if keeps going, like get an idea of it.
  158. 5:35But, um, yeah, it if you're changing
  159. 5:37your plan every year based on what the
  160. 5:39market's doing, um, it's going to be a
  161. 5:41bit of a roller coaster ride even with
  162. 5:42that income wedge.
  163. 5:44>> Yeah. And and that's where potentially
  164. 5:46uh I know quite a few do-it-yourselfers
  165. 5:49um watch watch these videos um and
  166. 5:52that's where potentially you might want
  167. 5:54to be looking at working with a trusted
  168. 5:56invest investment advisor because they
  169. 5:59will um be able to on an ongoing basis
  170. 6:03uh deal with these uh questions and and
  171. 6:06remodel things and say no we're good or
  172. 6:08yes we should be taking out more like on
  173. 6:11our side the retirement income uh
  174. 6:13program that's exactly the conversations
  175. 6:15that we tend to have with clients. Uh
  176. 6:17and and I I think they're happier for
  177. 6:21it. Those people that are happy to kind
  178. 6:23of offload that job onto somebody else
  179. 6:25because they're in a position where I
  180. 6:28just want to enjoy my retirement. Uh I
  181. 6:30don't, you know, want to continue to be,
  182. 6:33you know, great with this stuff. I'll
  183. 6:34just have somebody else do it. So, if
  184. 6:36you're continuing to do it yourself,
  185. 6:37fantastic. If you're getting to that
  186. 6:39point where it's like, you know what, I
  187. 6:40need somebody else to worry about this
  188. 6:42day in and day out, uh, and then answer
  189. 6:44your questions as you go, you know, if
  190. 6:46you've got if you or your friends or
  191. 6:47family have a trusted investment advisor
  192. 6:49that helps them with that kind of stuff.
  193. 6:51Absolutely. Uh, sit down and see if
  194. 6:53they're uh if it's worthwhile to
  195. 6:56consider that, too.
  196. 6:57>> Yeah. I talked to a lady yesterday.
  197. 6:58She's like, I look at my portfolio,
  198. 7:01DIYer for like 30 years. I look at my
  199. 7:03portfolio four times a day.
  200. 7:05>> I can't enjoy. She had been retired for
  201. 7:06six months. She's like, "I can't enjoy
  202. 7:08retirement. I love the investment side,
  203. 7:10but I need to hand it off because it's
  204. 7:12actually taken away from the joy of my
  205. 7:14retirement." And that's not the first
  206. 7:16time we've heard that, obviously. So, it
  207. 7:18is one of those things where markets are
  208. 7:20up, markets are down. Do I change stuff?
  209. 7:21What do I do? How do I manage this? You
  210. 7:23know, if it's making you lose sleep, you
  211. 7:25have to ask yourself like, is this worth
  212. 7:26it? Is it just better to like I have
  213. 7:28enough? I could pay someone, you know, a
  214. 7:30small fee to to deal with this and not
  215. 7:32have and actually enjoy retirement like
  216. 7:34you've worked 40 years to get here. So,
  217. 7:35you know, it's a conversation you need
  218. 7:36to have with yourself or your partner
  219. 7:38spouse if you have one and figure out
  220. 7:39like what is the best path forward.
  221. 7:42>> Yep, absolutely. Um, second one here,
  222. 7:44another good session and this is
  223. 7:46referring to I think Gordon Paul's um
  224. 7:48video a little while ago. So, uh, thank
  225. 7:50you. Yeah, they're it's it's great to
  226. 7:52have all the uh the team, the planners
  227. 7:54on on the videos and glad that
  228. 7:56everybody's uh enjoying that. Um, they
  229. 7:58can't always be as good as as Adam and
  230. 8:00I, but
  231. 8:00>> you got your two favorites here, but you
  232. 8:02know, it is what it is. Yeah.
  233. 8:03>> You know, yeah. Some sometimes you got
  234. 8:05to bring in the B team.
  235. 8:06>> Yeah.
  236. 8:07>> Um [laughter] we can't do it all
  237. 8:09ourselves. Adam, could you do a video
  238. 8:11regarding gifting a rental house with
  239. 8:13mortgage to your child? Is it better for
  240. 8:15them to actually purchase the house or
  241. 8:16does gifting them uh gifting allow them
  242. 8:18to assume the mortgage? Um on the
  243. 8:21mortgage side, I'm I'm not a lending
  244. 8:23specialist, but I I'll I'll give you
  245. 8:25what I I I think is going on there. Uh
  246. 8:28first and foremost, the the mortgage is
  247. 8:31with you. Let's assume that the mortgage
  248. 8:33is with you. It certainly sounds like
  249. 8:35it. Um you can and we'll there's a few
  250. 8:39moving parts here. You can gift the um
  251. 8:42the rental house. Now there will be a
  252. 8:44taxable disposition there because it
  253. 8:46will be deemed to have been sold and
  254. 8:48then repurchased by uh your kids. Um and
  255. 8:52potentially you could continue to hold
  256. 8:54that mortgage. Now I don't know if
  257. 8:56that's what you want to do or not, but
  258. 8:58just because you've sold a property over
  259. 9:00doesn't mean the mortgage is gone. uh
  260. 9:02you could sell that property to me and I
  261. 9:04give you a bunch of money and you can
  262. 9:06decide not to pay off your mortgage. Um
  263. 9:08now of course that's where the lender
  264. 9:10gets involved and says no no no you
  265. 9:12don't have the asset anymore. You do
  266. 9:13need to pay off the mortgage. So that's
  267. 9:15>> could be a private mortgage. We've seen
  268. 9:16that happen with private mortgages.
  269. 9:18Yeah.
  270. 9:18>> So hang on to the private mortgage and
  271. 9:20woohoo, I got all this money.
  272. 9:22>> Um so but in this case, is it better for
  273. 9:25them to actually purchase the house? Um
  274. 9:27or does gifting them allow them to sue
  275. 9:28the mortgage? gifting them does not
  276. 9:30necessarily mean they're going to assume
  277. 9:31the mortgage. Is it better for them to
  278. 9:33actually purchase? Again, this is really
  279. 9:36going to come down to what makes you
  280. 9:37sleep at night uh in terms of um uh do
  281. 9:42you do you want to, you know, hand it
  282. 9:44over to them. Again, there's going to be
  283. 9:45a deemed disposition uh regardless. So,
  284. 9:48you're going to want to talk to your
  285. 9:49accountant about this. You need to hand
  286. 9:50it over at fair market value, especially
  287. 9:52when you're dealing with um what they
  288. 9:54call uh non-armslength transactions.
  289. 9:57effectively spouses, partners, and kids.
  290. 10:00There's more to that, but that's, you
  291. 10:01know, 95% of Canadians, that's what
  292. 10:03they're dealing with. Um, and there was
  293. 10:06one other point here um uh in terms of
  294. 10:10of of
  295. 10:12gifting it or or or purchasing, then it
  296. 10:15becomes a question of do you want to be
  297. 10:17the lender to them or are you going to
  298. 10:19go out and have them uh get a a new
  299. 10:22mortgage or something like that. So, I
  300. 10:24don't know if I really answered the
  301. 10:26question there, but hopefully I gave you
  302. 10:27some things to think about. But, uh,
  303. 10:29Adam,
  304. 10:29>> yeah, I think if you gift, you you got
  305. 10:32to be careful whether you gift or sell
  306. 10:33it and put a a nominal dollar, you know,
  307. 10:35$100,000 value on it, but it's worth
  308. 10:37$500,000. You have to be careful here
  309. 10:40because
  310. 10:42you you could technically give it to
  311. 10:43them at $100,000. So, that's their cost
  312. 10:46base now. But, CRA is going to say, "No,
  313. 10:47no, fair market value is what you got to
  314. 10:50pay tax on." but their adjusted cost
  315. 10:53bait is only $100,000.
  316. 10:55So, you want to make sure you're either
  317. 10:58gifting or selling it to them at a fair
  318. 11:00market value. Like Brett said, that's
  319. 11:02really important. So, when you're doing
  320. 11:03a transaction like this, uh get a tax
  321. 11:06accountant involved with this. Make sure
  322. 11:08you know everything's put in place in
  323. 11:09the right order. I think one of the
  324. 11:11concerns is if I if I whether you gift
  325. 11:14or sell this uh rental property or the
  326. 11:16cottage to uh your child, can they get a
  327. 11:20mortgage on their own? I think this is
  328. 11:21maybe what they're going after. Like I
  329. 11:22have the mortgage already. Can I just
  330. 11:23kind of pass that on to them? They may
  331. 11:25not qualify. So yeah, you might just be
  332. 11:27a co-signer, which at the end of the day
  333. 11:28is roughly the same anyway as long as
  334. 11:30they can afford that mortgage. Um I I
  335. 11:34would always do my personal opinion,
  336. 11:37don't gift, sell. It keeps it cleaner,
  337. 11:40especially non-arms length. Sell it to
  338. 11:42them at fair market value. That will
  339. 11:44collapse a mortgage on your side. They
  340. 11:46will then get a mortgage. You may have
  341. 11:48to cosign for that. But now you've
  342. 11:50transitioned the ownership to them at
  343. 11:51fair market value. You will have a tax
  344. 11:53bill to pay. Be very aware of that. Um,
  345. 11:56and again, you may also have to cosign
  346. 11:58depending on their financial situation
  347. 12:00and do they want it, right? I think a
  348. 12:02lot of people like we talked to, it's
  349. 12:04like, "Yeah, I got this cottage. I want
  350. 12:05to, you know, pass it to my kids." It's
  351. 12:06like, do the kids actually want the
  352. 12:08cottage or is it just a headache? Like,
  353. 12:11no offense, I wouldn't want a cottage
  354. 12:12passed to me. It's just it's another
  355. 12:14asset I got to deal with and maintain
  356. 12:15and there's a cost to it and now I when
  357. 12:17I go on vacation, I got to go to the
  358. 12:19same spot every time. You know, make
  359. 12:21sure they want it too. It's another
  360. 12:22piece of it.
  361. 12:22>> Yeah. In in this case of a rental house,
  362. 12:25the same kind of thing. uh do they want
  363. 12:27to take on are they going to take on the
  364. 12:29responsibilities whether that is they're
  365. 12:32going to deal with um uh any um uh
  366. 12:34maintenance that has to be done or
  367. 12:36they're going to hire the person to deal
  368. 12:37with the maintenance. Maybe you're going
  369. 12:38to try to help them with that. I would
  370. 12:40always start with what is the goal? What
  371. 12:42are you trying to accomplish? Uh are you
  372. 12:45for example trying to get that rental
  373. 12:47income into their hands? And there's
  374. 12:49ways to do that properly and there's
  375. 12:50ways to do it not properly on on CRA's
  376. 12:53side. You always want to stay on the
  377. 12:54right side of CRA. Do you want to give
  378. 12:57them the house legally? Because that's
  379. 12:58the other thing. When you do either gift
  380. 13:00it or sell it to them, it's theirs now
  381. 13:02and they can turn around and sell it
  382. 13:05tomorrow. Um so the the question is what
  383. 13:09is your goal here and how much control
  384. 13:11do you want to continue to have over
  385. 13:13that asset versus handing it over to the
  386. 13:15kids? No right or wrong answer, but I
  387. 13:18would start there and as he said, yeah,
  388. 13:19sit down with an accountant, um possibly
  389. 13:22even a um lawyer as well. Yeah, we had a
  390. 13:24client similar to this not long ago, uh,
  391. 13:27well, probably a year and a half, two,
  392. 13:28years ago now, where they they they
  393. 13:30wanted to get the rental income off of
  394. 13:32their plate because they felt they were
  395. 13:34paying high taxes and it's like, well,
  396. 13:35we're going to get give it to the kids.
  397. 13:37Let's get the income to them. But their
  398. 13:38kids were high income earners. So now
  399. 13:39they were transitioning rental income
  400. 13:41from their, I would say, lower rate.
  401. 13:43They were still collecting OAS and all
  402. 13:45that to their kids at a higher rate,
  403. 13:47right? So it's like, well, does that
  404. 13:48make sense, too? So again, there's
  405. 13:50there's more layers to this sometimes.
  406. 13:52So just understand like the full picture
  407. 13:54before you move forward on something
  408. 13:55like this.
  409. 13:56>> Yeah, absolutely.
  410. 13:58>> Uh next question uh question regarding
  411. 14:00withholding tax on RRSP withdrawals.
  412. 14:02Okay, so this is a very common issue. So
  413. 14:04uh listen carefully here. I'm doing RSP
  414. 14:06meltdown technique. No one really talks
  415. 14:08about this regarding withdrawals. If me
  416. 14:10and my spouse both withdraw 50,000 from
  417. 14:13our RRSP and it's our only income
  418. 14:15source, we would each have about 15,000
  419. 14:17of withholding tax. we would get about
  420. 14:20half that back on our next tax return,
  421. 14:22but it seems like a hassle. It seems
  422. 14:24like you need to take more out just to
  423. 14:27have enough for the year to basically
  424. 14:30pay the bills, enjoy life, etc. And this
  425. 14:31is so true and this is why part of our
  426. 14:33retirement income program in January,
  427. 14:36February, we sit down with all of our
  428. 14:38clients and go through here's your plan.
  429. 14:40Here's how much tax you're going to pay
  430. 14:42this year based on all the assumptions
  431. 14:44and draw down etc. and here's how much
  432. 14:46withholding tax. So your tax bill is
  433. 14:4810,000 for the year and your withholding
  434. 14:50tax is 15. So you're going to get five
  435. 14:52back. Can we reduce those withholding
  436. 14:54tax? Sometimes you can on pensions, etc.
  437. 14:57CPP OAS, but sometimes you can't on RIFF
  438. 14:59accounts. Or maybe it's only 5,000 being
  439. 15:02withheld. You're going to have a $5,000
  440. 15:03tax bill. Let's actually have more
  441. 15:05withheld or at least be prepared for
  442. 15:07that. Again, over 3,000 you fall into
  443. 15:09installments. So we don't like that
  444. 15:10either. But this is something that
  445. 15:12people, every Canadian will bump into in
  446. 15:14the especially the first two years of
  447. 15:16retirement where in this case, yeah,
  448. 15:19you're going to have withholding tax.
  449. 15:20Now, in this case, if they move their
  450. 15:21RRSP to a RIFF, there's no withholding
  451. 15:24tax on the minimum amount. So, that
  452. 15:26would be one strategy they could do to
  453. 15:28actually reduce it somewhat, but they
  454. 15:30could still have more than they're going
  455. 15:31to pay, and they're going to get a tax
  456. 15:33refund. But, of course, they need that
  457. 15:35money to live, but some of that money
  458. 15:37they need to live has gone to
  459. 15:38withholding taxes. So, they're $5,000
  460. 15:41short in actual cash in their pocket to
  461. 15:43pay bills and enjoy retirement. That's
  462. 15:46where a TFSA or something like that can
  463. 15:47buffer that. So, for an example here,
  464. 15:49let's say, let's just take their math of
  465. 15:52they pulled out $50,000 each. They
  466. 15:55didn't convert to an R or to a RIFF. So,
  467. 15:57there's 15,000 withholding tax. So, they
  468. 15:59have 100,000 out, 30,000's gone to
  469. 16:01withholding tax, but they're only going
  470. 16:03to pay 15,000 combined in taxes. those
  471. 16:0615,000 they prepaid in tax, they'll get
  472. 16:08as a refund, but they need that $15,000
  473. 16:10to enjoy their retirement that year. So,
  474. 16:12what they should do is look at their
  475. 16:14TFSA, pull an extra $15,000 from their
  476. 16:16TFSA, and when they get their tax
  477. 16:18refund, top up the TFSA account. And
  478. 16:21again, very common. It's a pain in the
  479. 16:23butt. There's no way around it a lot of
  480. 16:25times, but it's that cash flow
  481. 16:27management. So, again, sit down with
  482. 16:28your planner if you're doing it
  483. 16:29yourself. Yeah, you kind of got to
  484. 16:30figure this out. But this is something
  485. 16:32that again we work with uh with our
  486. 16:34clients in our retirement income program
  487. 16:36because it is something every single
  488. 16:38client bump ups bumps up against. So
  489. 16:41>> yeah, absolutely. Um and let let's say
  490. 16:44that now I do think in this case they uh
  491. 16:47are do need that money like they it
  492. 16:51sounds like they don't necessarily have
  493. 16:52a non-registered TFSA to pull from.
  494. 16:54Could be wrong there. If you do have a
  495. 16:56non-registered TFSA to pull from, this
  496. 16:58is where I suggest to people to keep it
  497. 17:01simple. It may not be the absolute
  498. 17:03ideal. The investment partners we work
  499. 17:05with don't follow this because they have
  500. 17:07more um sophistication to work with
  501. 17:09these types of things. But this is where
  502. 17:11I suggest that do your tax planning
  503. 17:13withdrawals, your RRSP, RIFF, LIYF
  504. 17:15withdrawals towards the end of the year
  505. 17:17because that withholding tax only stays
  506. 17:19with the government for so long before
  507. 17:21it comes back to you as a um as a a
  508. 17:23refund. So, let's say you take that
  509. 17:25$50,000 out. We're recording this early
  510. 17:27November. So, let's say you take that
  511. 17:30$50,000 out um uh now and um and you put
  512. 17:34it into a non-reg the after tax amount
  513. 17:36in a non-registered account. It gets you
  514. 17:39going for 2027. Um and then um uh then
  515. 17:42you get your tax refund and and off you
  516. 17:44go. Um and then you just live off your
  517. 17:47non-register or TFSA and then kind of do
  518. 17:49it all over again. But if that's not the
  519. 17:51case, then yes, moving it into a riff
  520. 17:55and you'll want to do this before the
  521. 17:57end of this year because if you don't,
  522. 17:59you won't have a minimum next year. So
  523. 18:02all this stuff that we've just provided
  524. 18:03you will go out the window because you
  525. 18:05won't have a minimum um uh set up. So if
  526. 18:08you move it into a RIFF before the end
  527. 18:10of this year, you'll have a minimum and
  528. 18:12you can manage what we call blended tax
  529. 18:15rate. You can manage that tax rate. no
  530. 18:17tax on the minimum, x amount of tax on
  531. 18:19on anything above the minimum, and now
  532. 18:21instead of having 30% withheld, uh you
  533. 18:25might be getting closer to 20 or 25%.
  534. 18:29The final thing I'll suggest here is is
  535. 18:31uh and you'll have to check with your
  536. 18:33financial institution on this. Let's say
  537. 18:35your effective tax rate is 10%. So,
  538. 18:38these people are paying 30% of of tax
  539. 18:41just to keep the numbers kind of quick
  540. 18:42and easy, but they really should only be
  541. 18:44paying 10% each. Um then if you're
  542. 18:48withdrawing that $50,000 uh but you're
  543. 18:51doing it not necessarily on a frequent
  544. 18:53basis like once a month or twice a once
  545. 18:56every two weeks or whatever the case may
  546. 18:57be, but you're actually doing it
  547. 19:00manually. Um you know X amount let's
  548. 19:02just call it $5,000 a month, $5,000 this
  549. 19:05month, $5,000 that month, then your
  550. 19:07withholding tax will actually be um uh
  551. 19:10lower. So there are different ways to do
  552. 19:12this. You do want to stay on the right
  553. 19:14side of CRA always uh in doing this and
  554. 19:17manage your cash flow. If you have some
  555. 19:20money in non-registered and TFSA, I
  556. 19:22think that's going to be the easiest way
  557. 19:23to do it, but there are other ways to uh
  558. 19:25to tackle it.
  559. 19:27>> Yeah. No, I agree.
  560. 19:29>> Yeah. Okay. Um this uh this came in via
  561. 19:33email. So, as as Adam said off the top
  562. 19:34there, we uh grab your questions from uh
  563. 19:37various um uh platforms that you might
  564. 19:40be listening or watching. Uh but uh also
  565. 19:43email uh people will email in questions.
  566. 19:45So this is great. Um thanks for the pod
  567. 19:47guys. Love the show. Uh I'm just going
  568. 19:50to jump down to the second part here
  569. 19:51just to kind of get to the question and
  570. 19:53then I'll back uh back fill it with the
  571. 19:55other information. I'm with an employer
  572. 19:57and through them I have a defined
  573. 19:58benefit pension plan. Our employer gives
  574. 20:00us the option to pull out the commuted
  575. 20:02value up um of our pension uh up until
  576. 20:05the day before we turn 50. So this is
  577. 20:08kind of your typical kind of 50 less a
  578. 20:10day um uh type of thing. A lot of
  579. 20:12colleagues have recently done this. Um
  580. 20:14and then months later are rehired. Uh
  581. 20:17could you talk about things you should
  582. 20:19consider and what would you say
  583. 20:20generally um is it advantageous um uh I
  584. 20:25know it's safer and I'll get to that in
  585. 20:26a second to stay with the employer until
  586. 20:29reaching a retirement age without
  587. 20:30penalty so on and so forth. So, the
  588. 20:32things that you're going to want to
  589. 20:33consider if you've got the option to uh
  590. 20:35commute out something is first of all,
  591. 20:38run the pros and cons of um uh okay, I
  592. 20:41take this lump sum out. There's a couple
  593. 20:43things that are going to be going on
  594. 20:45here. Some of that money may be taxable
  595. 20:48right away in your hands. So, let's just
  596. 20:50say the commuted value is a half a
  597. 20:51million dollars.
  598. 20:52um the the company will be able to break
  599. 20:55that down and say, "Well, a h 100,000 of
  600. 20:57it will come to you what they call in
  601. 21:00cash, basically in income, they should
  602. 21:02call it, and you're going to be taxed on
  603. 21:04that $100,000. Now, if you've got
  604. 21:06$100,000 of RSP room, you can
  605. 21:08potentially off offset that. But you
  606. 21:11there is a portion of money that's
  607. 21:13potentially going to be taxable in your
  608. 21:14hands and and you have to kind of figure
  609. 21:16out what to do with that. are you um
  610. 21:19paying more tax than you really should
  611. 21:21be or want to be uh on that? Um and then
  612. 21:25the rest goes into or a good portion of
  613. 21:27it typically goes into a locked in
  614. 21:29account. So this is not an account that
  615. 21:31you can just go in and grab $100,000
  616. 21:33depending on the jurisdiction. Um it's a
  617. 21:36it's an account where you might only be
  618. 21:38able to get a minimum maximum. So, there
  619. 21:40are things to consider here in terms of
  620. 21:42how you're going to access that money
  621. 21:43and how you're going to be taxed versus
  622. 21:45the other side of it is you don't
  623. 21:47commute out. Now, you've got that
  624. 21:49guaranteed um uh monthly um uh check
  625. 21:52coming in. And is that something that
  626. 21:55you value more than having access to uh
  627. 21:58to the bucket of cash? And then just to
  628. 22:00touch on the the the safer aspect of it,
  629. 22:03um this is something again that
  630. 22:05depending on who holds the the pension,
  631. 22:08how is that pension protected? God
  632. 22:10forbid your employer has some
  633. 22:12challenging years or goes bankrupt. Uh
  634. 22:14some pensions are protected regardless
  635. 22:17of what happens with the employer. Some
  636. 22:19uh pensions are not. So, you're going to
  637. 22:20want to look into that to know how
  638. 22:23comfortable and confident are you with
  639. 22:25that pension with wherever it um
  640. 22:28wherever it happens to be. And then the
  641. 22:29third thing is that if you're not
  642. 22:32comfortable uh and confident where that
  643. 22:34money is but still want the pension,
  644. 22:36there are uh companies that will do
  645. 22:38what's called a copycat pension. They
  646. 22:40will move it over and provide you a
  647. 22:43pension. These are typically um
  648. 22:46insurance well they are insurance
  649. 22:47companies. So you've got the backing of
  650. 22:49these large insurance companies which do
  651. 22:51have protection beyond behind um uh the
  652. 22:55money that you you provide them for this
  653. 22:57kind of stuff.
  654. 22:58I would have a plan done to see is it
  655. 23:02drastically better one way or the other.
  656. 23:04I would say in the vast majority, not
  657. 23:06always, in the vast majority of the
  658. 23:07plans that we've done, there hasn't been
  659. 23:10a drastic difference between one way or
  660. 23:12the other. So now it just becomes of,
  661. 23:13you know, do you want vanilla or
  662. 23:14strawberry? Like do you want the
  663. 23:16commuted do you value the commuted value
  664. 23:18or do you value the uh the pension a
  665. 23:20little bit more, Adam?
  666. 23:21>> Yeah. And a copycat annuity like you
  667. 23:23mentioned could be a good option there.
  668. 23:24Um but yeah, if this is an option that
  669. 23:27you have and it's this is very rare. Um
  670. 23:29but we do see it where yeah, you're
  671. 23:31coming up 50, you could commute the like
  672. 23:34sit down with an indep talk to your
  673. 23:35investment person. They will always tell
  674. 23:37you well 99% of the time tell you to
  675. 23:39take your commute value because they
  676. 23:40want to manage that asset. Um you meet
  677. 23:44with a independent financial planner
  678. 23:46that that isn't going to manage your
  679. 23:47money. No skin in the game just giving
  680. 23:49you pure and comparing apples to apples.
  681. 23:51So, we do this all the time, apples to
  682. 23:52apples. And you know, maybe you've
  683. 23:55worked for, let's say, the government,
  684. 23:56like my wife. She was a nurse,
  685. 23:58registered nurse, paid into her pension
  686. 24:01for years, and when she left, she's been
  687. 24:02raising our kids or four kids for many
  688. 24:04years. When she left, we had the option
  689. 24:06to commute her pension. And the first
  690. 24:08time around, I did the calculation
  691. 24:09apples to apples. It didn't make sense.
  692. 24:11I said, I'm going to leave that risk
  693. 24:12with them. We're at the government like
  694. 24:14that. Interest rates dropped. I
  695. 24:16recalculated it. and the number we got
  696. 24:18now because again some moves to a LRA
  697. 24:20locked in account some was cash that
  698. 24:22cash amount tripled and so yes I'm
  699. 24:24paying tax on that but it made it
  700. 24:27worthwhile to actually commute the the
  701. 24:30the pension so for her pension we
  702. 24:31actually commuted it um but again not
  703. 24:34the first time around the second time
  704. 24:35around because the calculation actually
  705. 24:37worked out so this is where you know
  706. 24:39take the data run it out but like you
  707. 24:41said Brad I would say most of the time
  708. 24:42that we do this for clients which we do
  709. 24:44often is it's pretty close. And so now
  710. 24:47it's like, well, do you want to take on
  711. 24:49the risk? Do you want to leave the risk
  712. 24:51with the company? Like there's pros and
  713. 24:53cons to both sides of it. And so a lot
  714. 24:56of it comes down to personality.
  715. 24:57Sometimes it's and we've had this where
  716. 25:00you have, you know, a married couple and
  717. 25:01and they both have pensions. It's like,
  718. 25:03okay, well, you know, commute one, keep
  719. 25:06one, and what, you know, so there's
  720. 25:08those types of conversations as well.
  721. 25:11Commuting your pension, there's risk to
  722. 25:13it. So just understand the risk. Again,
  723. 25:16don't talk to an investment person about
  724. 25:18commuting your pension because you may
  725. 25:20not get uh the truth of what you should
  726. 25:22be doing. You'll get pushed, you know,
  727. 25:24and again, if you want to have a pension
  728. 25:27but not with the company that it's with
  729. 25:29because you don't trust them, that's
  730. 25:30again, like Brett said, that's where the
  731. 25:32copycat annuity can be a great solution
  732. 25:34and probably underutilized.
  733. 25:36>> Yeah. Yeah. I think I think it is
  734. 25:39underutilized or at least
  735. 25:40underconsidered. it. You know, again, it
  736. 25:43may not be the best thing for you, but I
  737. 25:44think it should be something on the menu
  738. 25:46that says you can do it this way, this
  739. 25:48way, or this way, and here's what those
  740. 25:50three things look that look like. What
  741. 25:52would you like to uh to consider? Yeah.
  742. 25:54>> Exactly. Yeah. Um and also, I'll say,
  743. 25:57well, I'll say that the last thing
  744. 25:58there, too. It's like, you know, I've
  745. 26:00had some colleagues do this and they get
  746. 26:02hired back.
  747. 26:04>> Again, you have to leave the job to take
  748. 26:05the community to value.
  749. 26:07>> So, like, are they going to hire you
  750. 26:08back? Do you still need that job? like
  751. 26:09there's those other variables that play
  752. 26:11into to it as well. So, um yeah, next
  753. 26:14question. Uh so, this goes back to a
  754. 26:16video I did. Um just, you know, I'm a
  755. 26:20retirement adviser. Here's what I tell
  756. 26:21everyone uh with $1.5 million. So, the
  757. 26:24the response or comment is, wouldn't it
  758. 26:26make more sense to drain the TFSA first
  759. 26:28since there's four times the amount in
  760. 26:31CPP when means faster growth? So, you
  761. 26:34know, some bad grammar English here, but
  762. 26:36the idea here is, you know, why wouldn't
  763. 26:38I drain my TFSA and delay my CPP even
  764. 26:41longer? You know, that would be one of
  765. 26:43the equations. Look, your your TFSA, why
  766. 26:45I added this question in here is when
  767. 26:47you walk into retirement, your TFSA is
  768. 26:49your flex account for most Canadians.
  769. 26:52Meaning that if you need a little bit
  770. 26:54more money, that's where you pull it
  771. 26:55from. If you don't need as much, that's
  772. 26:56where you leave it into. The reality is
  773. 26:58through retirement, your spending is not
  774. 27:00going to be equal. Right? If you're
  775. 27:02traveling, one year might be heavy
  776. 27:03travel and then light travel, heavy
  777. 27:04travel, light. My in-laws are a great
  778. 27:06example of this. Meaning that you need
  779. 27:08more money one year, you need less
  780. 27:10another year. That's where that TFSA say
  781. 27:12can kind of be a push or pull. You're
  782. 27:13still going to pull the same amount
  783. 27:14based on the tax plan out of your
  784. 27:16registered accounts, but maybe you've
  785. 27:17pulled more out. You don't need it all
  786. 27:19this year because you're not traveling.
  787. 27:20Pop up your TFSA. The following year,
  788. 27:22you're going to be pulling it out. So,
  789. 27:23you want to make sure you have a
  790. 27:24wellunded TFSA as you walk into
  791. 27:26retirement. Even like the previous
  792. 27:28question that we talked about, you know,
  793. 27:29the withholding tax, right? Okay,
  794. 27:31they're withholding more tax and I need
  795. 27:32money. Perfect. Pull it out of your TFSA
  796. 27:35account. That's where that buffer. So,
  797. 27:36you need that flex account. So, you
  798. 27:39know, could you deplete your, you know,
  799. 27:40they're saying, why wouldn't I deplete
  800. 27:42my TFSA and then delay CPP? Well, at the
  801. 27:46end of the day, you might get a little
  802. 27:47bit more money, but this is where a
  803. 27:48retirement plan has to work to a put
  804. 27:50more money back in your pocket, create
  805. 27:52tax strategy, but create that
  806. 27:53flexibility. And if you just complete
  807. 27:56your TFSA and then start your CPP,
  808. 27:58you've lost flexibility in your account.
  809. 28:00And that's really important, right? So,
  810. 28:01there's a lot of variables that go into
  811. 28:03a really good uh retirement plan. And,
  812. 28:06you know, having the TFSA and the flux
  813. 28:08account and that that flexibility to the
  814. 28:10ongoing cash flow and and cash flow
  815. 28:12management is really important here. So,
  816. 28:14that's why I want to include this just
  817. 28:16to make sure you as you walk in TFSA or
  818. 28:19as you walk into retirement, make sure
  819. 28:21you have a wellunded TFSA. It's going to
  820. 28:22be uh uber important to that flexibility
  821. 28:25to your account.
  822. 28:27>> Yeah. Yeah. And if especially if you're
  823. 28:29um well well first of all uh you're
  824. 28:31talking about um uh grammar and such
  825. 28:33there. Um Adam, I've seen your text
  826. 28:35messages. So
  827. 28:36>> Oh yeah. No, I
  828. 28:39do. I miss I misspell one word in every
  829. 28:41sentence. Then you know it's me, right?
  830. 28:43It's not AI. It's not I'm learning to
  831. 28:46how how do I make sure this not AI? I
  832. 28:47just Yeah. Spell something wrong every
  833. 28:49time.
  834. 28:50>> That's that's your security approach.
  835. 28:51>> It's on purpose. Yeah. I do it on
  836. 28:53purpose. Yeah.
  837. 28:54>> Perfect. So, especially if you're
  838. 28:56draining the TFSA, um, uh, like you're
  839. 28:59taking money out of the TFSA to spend it
  840. 29:02rather than a little bit more out of
  841. 29:03your RRSP RIFF. Now, yes, you can take
  842. 29:05too much out of your RRSP and RIFF, like
  843. 29:07the meltdown is a balancing act, but if
  844. 29:10you could be taking more out of your
  845. 29:12RRSP and RIFF, if this is if this is
  846. 29:13where the question is coming from, but
  847. 29:15I'm going to use my TFSA um, uh, uh,
  848. 29:18instead, then you're potentially missing
  849. 29:21some tax planning opportunities. you're
  850. 29:23potentially slowing down your RRSP
  851. 29:25meltdown, which means you're potentially
  852. 29:27going to be taxed more down the road.
  853. 29:29You know, if you pass away unexpectedly
  854. 29:31early. So, um uh it just depends on what
  855. 29:35they're trying to do here. But based
  856. 29:37based on the the video that they're um
  857. 29:40uh commenting on, I I kind of think
  858. 29:42that's where it's it's coming from. And
  859. 29:44this actually takes me back to the first
  860. 29:45question comment I was going to make
  861. 29:47there where the person was saying that
  862. 29:48they're going to take their CPP and OAS
  863. 29:50at 65 which again if that makes you
  864. 29:52sleep at night absolutely. But uh in
  865. 29:54terms of your meltdown and your RSP RIFF
  866. 29:57keeps um climbing if you deferred CPP
  867. 30:00and potentially even old age security to
  868. 30:02to 70 that does give you more time to uh
  869. 30:05take money out of the RSP RIFF. again um
  870. 30:09you want to be able to sleep at night
  871. 30:11with that's the mathemat that's
  872. 30:13potentially the mathematical answer. Now
  873. 30:15you have to answer the psychological
  874. 30:17emotional answer of of are you going to
  875. 30:19be willing to push it off? But there's I
  876. 30:22there might be some tax planning stuff
  877. 30:24left on the table here if you start uh
  878. 30:26going into your TFSA beyond the fact
  879. 30:28that oh I've got a $20,000 opportunity
  880. 30:30to go do whatever. uh if I don't have
  881. 30:33any money in my TFSA, now I got to take
  882. 30:35$20,000 more out of my RRSP RIFF. Now
  883. 30:38I'm costing myself some uh some
  884. 30:40additional taxes that I maybe I I could
  885. 30:42have avoided if I kept that flex flex
  886. 30:45account going. Um I'm hoping uh I'm
  887. 30:49hoping this uh this is the right place
  888. 30:50to get a question on the next show. This
  889. 30:52is probably one of the fastest question
  890. 30:53turnarounds I've seen. This is based on
  891. 30:56episode 60 and now we're on episode 62
  892. 30:58here. Um years ago I invested in a
  893. 31:00non-registered fund. uh and um since
  894. 31:04it's grown and I have no idea what the
  895. 31:05adjusted cost base is and how would I
  896. 31:07figure out what um what to do um with
  897. 31:10this and and how do I figure out my my
  898. 31:11adjusted cost base? I was hoping the
  899. 31:14financial institution I'm at would
  900. 31:15provide the appropriate tax form when I
  901. 31:17realized the capital gain, but I'm
  902. 31:19hearing that this is my responsibility.
  903. 31:21Uh and then there's another question uh
  904. 31:24later down about um if if I believe so.
  905. 31:27Uh no, this is another question I'm I'm
  906. 31:29thinking about. I think there there's
  907. 31:30another one. There was kind of two
  908. 31:31questions in it. So, capital gain, yes,
  909. 31:34in the end it is your responsibility.
  910. 31:37Um, the financial institution may be
  911. 31:40able to help you, especially if they
  912. 31:42have your entire history. So, you bought
  913. 31:44the stocks with them, the shares, and
  914. 31:46you kept it with them. Um but if you
  915. 31:49bought them at one place and then moved
  916. 31:51from that financial institution to
  917. 31:53another financial institution and did an
  918. 31:54inind transfer and then you know maybe
  919. 31:57moved again or something like that they
  920. 31:58only have the history that they've got.
  921. 32:01So ultimately it is your responsibility
  922. 32:03to keep track of your adjusted cost
  923. 32:05base. Not fun. I get that. But uh but it
  924. 32:08is uh so there are a couple things here.
  925. 32:11I actually answered to this one and said
  926. 32:12like you might have to sit down with a
  927. 32:14um uh an accountant or tax accountant
  928. 32:17who can potentially go back into at
  929. 32:20least the history of the the investment,
  930. 32:23but they're not going to know
  931. 32:24specifically how much did you buy on
  932. 32:27what day, when did you sell, and all
  933. 32:28these things along the way. So,
  934. 32:30unfortunately, you're going to have to
  935. 32:32um dig that out. Uh, and if you can't
  936. 32:34dig that out, again, an accountant might
  937. 32:36have a suggestion on how you deal with
  938. 32:38that type of stuff if you don't have the
  939. 32:40information to back up whatever uh
  940. 32:43you're going to use. But it is going to
  941. 32:45be a little bit of a um an investigation
  942. 32:48to figure out what your adjusted cost
  943. 32:50base uh is if your financial institution
  944. 32:54does not have uh a perfect series of of
  945. 32:57history from uh either when all the time
  946. 33:00that you owned it or if you brought it
  947. 33:03in um what we call in cash. So you sold
  948. 33:06it, it came into the new financial
  949. 33:08institution and then they bought
  950. 33:09whatever else again. Then well the
  951. 33:12adjusted cost base was equal to the fair
  952. 33:14market value of that day and then they
  953. 33:16should have the the history from there.
  954. 33:18So
  955. 33:19>> and we've seen clients run into this.
  956. 33:20Yeah. Even with um like US so you got
  957. 33:23the the FX. It's like well I bought this
  958. 33:26stock you know years ago but the current
  959. 33:28the exchange rate was this and now it's
  960. 33:30this. So when I sell like the the game's
  961. 33:32different. So it's it's not just the
  962. 33:34value of the stock going up. It's
  963. 33:35actually like FX or currency can play a
  964. 33:38factor in as well. So um yeah, talk to
  965. 33:41your financial institution. They they
  966. 33:43should have something some history on
  967. 33:44there. Um one other idea, and this is
  968. 33:47totally outside, but you know, this is
  969. 33:48from Ken Scott 1082. If you're someone
  970. 33:51that uh does donations, you could
  971. 33:55consider donating this in kind. Then you
  972. 33:58don't have to worry about your cost
  973. 33:59base. you'll get a full donation for the
  974. 34:01full amount. Um cost base means nothing.
  975. 34:03There's no taxes to be paid. So that
  976. 34:06might be a nice clean way to do it. And
  977. 34:07we've seen that uh with a few clients
  978. 34:09over time as well. So if you're not sure
  979. 34:11about your cost base and it's like, oh,
  980. 34:13I donate anyway, maybe this could be a
  981. 34:15solution to taking that headache off
  982. 34:17headache off the table as well. So
  983. 34:19>> yeah. Yeah. Exactly. And and for people
  984. 34:21that are potentially dealing with this
  985. 34:24issue or starting to deal with the
  986. 34:25issue, I I guess the best advice and
  987. 34:27maybe the advice an accountant is
  988. 34:28probably going to give is uh just update
  989. 34:31your keep a track record every year of
  990. 34:33your adjusted cost base. sit down maybe
  991. 34:35at tax time, look at the previous year,
  992. 34:37when you bought, when you sold, update
  993. 34:39your adjusted cost base, record it um
  994. 34:41and then go on so that if you do end up
  995. 34:43in this kind of situation, at least
  996. 34:45you've got um something to back it up
  997. 34:47when you do um uh sell and you can show
  998. 34:52CRA the adjusted cost base if they ask
  999. 34:54for it.
  1000. 34:55>> Yeah. Yeah. Next question is regarding
  1001. 34:58uh Saskatchewan uh Luras. So
  1002. 35:00Saskatchewan has a different rules on
  1003. 35:02LERs and of course they have different
  1004. 35:04tax rates as many know. Uh every
  1005. 35:06province does but it seems all
  1006. 35:07[clears throat] channels focus on
  1007. 35:08Ontario. Not true. We try and hit
  1008. 35:10everywhere here but um you know Ontario
  1009. 35:12is the center of the universe. So we got
  1010. 35:14to be careful that we include them
  1011. 35:15mainly. Uh can you go over this
  1012. 35:18>> Niagara is the center of the univer is
  1013. 35:19the center of uh of Ontario. So
  1014. 35:22>> there you go. So you're right in the
  1015. 35:23smack dab. Yeah.
  1016. 35:24>> You got it. I've got my thumb on the
  1017. 35:26pulse of everything. And well, I no one
  1018. 35:28likes to talk about BC Leras because
  1019. 35:30they're the worst out there um because
  1020. 35:32you can't unlock them. So, uh do you go
  1021. 35:34over the scenario of a person with a
  1022. 35:36LERA in Saskatchewan and converting to a
  1023. 35:38PRIFF at 55 as well? Is there a benefit
  1024. 35:40of retiring in another province? So,
  1025. 35:42there's there's layers to this. So,
  1026. 35:44>> yeah,
  1027. 35:45>> converting a P to a PRF at 55, which you
  1028. 35:47can do 100% of your LERA can go to a PRF
  1029. 35:50um at age 55. The difference with a PRIF
  1030. 35:53and a riff, uh there's a minimum amount.
  1031. 35:55A PRIFF is more like an RRSP where
  1032. 35:57there's actually no maximum. You can
  1033. 35:59take out the whole thing if you wanted
  1034. 36:00to. [snorts]
  1035. 36:01>> Uh so next part of it is there a benefit
  1036. 36:04of retiring in another province say
  1037. 36:06Alberta with generous tax advantages but
  1038. 36:08higher cost of living which is better
  1039. 36:10for retirement income longevity assuming
  1040. 36:12the LRA have 250,000 at age 55 also
  1041. 36:16RRSPs etc. So yeah moving to another
  1042. 36:18province we've had a lot of clients do
  1043. 36:20that. Uh oftentimes it's following uh
  1044. 36:23family members, kids, that kind of thing
  1045. 36:25to another province. Um we just had a
  1046. 36:26client move from BC to Alberta. Yeah.
  1047. 36:29Again, if you're moving for tax
  1048. 36:31purposes, yeah, we and we've done that,
  1049. 36:32too, where we've had a client say, "I'm
  1050. 36:34willing to retire in one of these two
  1051. 36:36provinces, can you do a plan for each
  1052. 36:38province and see what it looks like?" Of
  1053. 36:40course, yeah, moving from Saskatchewan
  1054. 36:41to Alberta, you will pay a little bit
  1055. 36:43less tax, but cost of living will be
  1056. 36:46more. So, you got to weigh that of of
  1057. 36:47you know, and again, you can do this
  1058. 36:49with your financial planner, put it
  1059. 36:50through a plan. Um, it doesn't change
  1060. 36:53your uh LERA designation. And I say that
  1061. 36:57because we've had clients ask, well, I
  1062. 36:58have a BC LERA.
  1063. 37:01If I move to Saskatchewan where you can
  1064. 37:03unlock 100%, can I, you know, do that?
  1065. 37:06No. No. The each LERA is proincially
  1066. 37:10jurisdicted, meaning that if it's in BC,
  1067. 37:12it's in BC. Even if you move to
  1068. 37:14Saskatchewan, your LER is BC
  1069. 37:16jurisdiction. So moving won't change the
  1070. 37:18jurisdiction, but yeah, of course you
  1071. 37:20can move and pay less tax or more tax
  1072. 37:22depending on what province you move to.
  1073. 37:24Um, so yeah, two two parts of that
  1074. 37:26question.
  1075. 37:27>> Yeah, I I'll I'll tackle the the moving
  1076. 37:30part first and and you know, c could it
  1077. 37:33be better? like I don't know if I would
  1078. 37:36optimi try to optimize my retirement by
  1079. 37:39choosing some combination of uh province
  1080. 37:41and and taxes and cost of living.
  1081. 37:44Obviously, that's all to be considered,
  1082. 37:47but I would probably be choosing where
  1083. 37:49I'm going to live in retirement based on
  1084. 37:51am I going to enjoy it there? You know,
  1085. 37:53what's do I want to be in a big city, a
  1086. 37:55small city? Do I want to be close to the
  1087. 37:58coast? You know, whatever the case may
  1088. 37:59be. Uh, so I'm not saying that there
  1089. 38:02won't be a difference in your retirement
  1090. 38:05if you move to one province or the
  1091. 38:06other. I would probably guess that that
  1092. 38:10difference is going to be low enough
  1093. 38:12that it really isn't going to move the
  1094. 38:14needle too much. It's going to be more
  1095. 38:15of where do you want to live? Um, and
  1096. 38:18and where are you going to enjoy living?
  1097. 38:20Uh the PRF um uh I I touched on in the
  1098. 38:24YouTube comments here that the the the
  1099. 38:26main different actually it's it's not in
  1100. 38:28the the one I think that's going to show
  1101. 38:30up on the YouTube screen, but uh the
  1102. 38:32main difference there is a PRIFF is um
  1103. 38:36it's keeping the pension or sorry it is
  1104. 38:38requiring a spouse or partner to sign
  1105. 38:41off to wave any of their rights that
  1106. 38:44were under the pension legislation to
  1107. 38:46move it into the PRIFF called a
  1108. 38:47prescribed RIFF. That's the only
  1109. 38:50difference that I believe exists between
  1110. 38:53a PR riff and a riff. Everything else is
  1111. 38:55exactly like a um uh exactly like a
  1112. 38:57riff. And then later on there was a
  1113. 38:59question about uh whis whiskey kuck. Uh
  1114. 39:02I've asked a comparable question about
  1115. 39:03Quebec in earlier videos in particular
  1116. 39:05are there differences between CBP and
  1117. 39:07QPP noting? And just to touch on there,
  1118. 39:11u uh the difference there is is uh
  1119. 39:14depending on your providence of
  1120. 39:15residence when you apply for your uh
  1121. 39:18federal provincial plan, you'll either
  1122. 39:20get QPP or CPP and uh QPP you can now
  1123. 39:24defer up till 72 as of the last twoish
  1124. 39:27years I think it has been. Uh where CPP
  1125. 39:29is still deferred only up to um to 70.
  1126. 39:32Uh so those are the only two differences
  1127. 39:34I can think in in those cases. Um, but I
  1128. 39:37again wouldn't necessarily move from
  1129. 39:38Quebec to another province just to get a
  1130. 39:40CPP and I wouldn't necessarily move from
  1131. 39:42a province into Quebec just to get a a
  1132. 39:44QPP.
  1133. 39:45>> Yeah. No, agree. And if you see Brett
  1134. 39:47Martin Planner respond, I'm sure we'll
  1135. 39:50get copycats out soon now. So
  1136. 39:52>> Oh, yeah.
  1137. 39:53>> Just be aware. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Uh,
  1138. 39:55next question. Just discovered this
  1139. 39:56video. How does the joint account work
  1140. 40:00when the account is a work perk for a
  1141. 40:02younger person? And uh I I want to say
  1142. 40:06thank you for watching a video from I
  1143. 40:08believe six years ago now. So this is an
  1144. 40:10older thumbnail, an older vid, one of
  1145. 40:12the the original videos I want to say in
  1146. 40:14the first 10 15 videos I ever did. So,
  1147. 40:17um, yeah, if you have a joint work
  1148. 40:18account, that is a non-registered, um,
  1149. 40:21which is what this is about. Uncommon,
  1150. 40:24not typically like work accounts are
  1151. 40:26usually RRSPs. Sometimes you have TFSA,
  1152. 40:28but if [snorts] you have a joint
  1153. 40:29non-registered account at work and
  1154. 40:31you're a younger person, uh, you should
  1155. 40:33be able to transfer that out once a year
  1156. 40:35or a couple times a year. Um, consider
  1157. 40:37moving it to a TFSA, consider moving it
  1158. 40:39to a first home savings account if you
  1159. 40:41qualify for that. Um, so again, any work
  1160. 40:45perk, if you get a matching or any
  1161. 40:47contribution from your work at any time
  1162. 40:49for any reason, take advantage of that.
  1163. 40:51Even if it is a non-registered account,
  1164. 40:54you should be able to transfer that out.
  1165. 40:56Especially on registered accounts, you
  1166. 40:57got to leave there typically, but
  1167. 40:58non-reg and TFSAs typically you can move
  1168. 41:00out once a year and then you have more
  1169. 41:02flexibility within that. So
  1170. 41:04>> yeah. Yeah, you're the non-registered
  1171. 41:08and TFSA work accounts do exist. they
  1172. 41:10just don't exist as as often as the
  1173. 41:12other ones that you talked about. Uh but
  1174. 41:14they work exactly like uh a regular
  1175. 41:17non-registered account in terms of I
  1176. 41:19always say the type of account just
  1177. 41:21tells the government how to tax your
  1178. 41:22money in that account. TFSAs are taxed
  1179. 41:24in a certain way, not taxed, RRSPs are
  1180. 41:26taxed in a certain way, so on and so
  1181. 41:27forth. Um, but yes, if if you are
  1182. 41:31getting free money from your company,
  1183. 41:33uh, regardless of the type of account it
  1184. 41:35is, uh, I can't think of a situation
  1185. 41:37that I've come across where I've said,
  1186. 41:39"No, that that doesn't make sense for
  1187. 41:41you instead." Yeah, exactly. Yeah. So,
  1188. 41:45>> by the way, if you're if you're
  1189. 41:46listening to the podcast and not
  1190. 41:47watching it, um, Brett talks with his
  1191. 41:50hand, so he does bump his mic every once
  1192. 41:51in a while. So, apologies.
  1193. 41:53>> I bump I bumped it once and I just
  1194. 41:56bumped it right now. So, my my
  1195. 41:57apologies.
  1196. 41:58>> Holy.
  1197. 41:58>> I realized I stole your question, too.
  1198. 42:01>> Yeah, you did. Uh, so I'm gonna steal
  1199. 42:03yours. By the way, that video was from
  1200. 42:04five years ago. I just looked it up.
  1201. 42:06>> Oh, there you go.
  1202. 42:07>> Um, yeah. Uh, okay. So, next one is, can
  1203. 42:11I contribute to an RRSP before 71 and
  1204. 42:14then carry forward the deduction to a
  1205. 42:15higher income year after 71? And this is
  1206. 42:19this is an interesting question because
  1207. 42:21we actually we've dealt with this
  1208. 42:23before, but I as soon as I read this
  1209. 42:25question, I remembered that about a year
  1210. 42:27or so ago, we actually um had a bit of a
  1211. 42:30planner huddle because somebody was uh
  1212. 42:32dealing with this um uh I I'll call an
  1213. 42:35opportunity where they felt that they
  1214. 42:37could make a contribution now when the
  1215. 42:39person was I think about 69 years old
  1216. 42:41and make use of it later on. I can't
  1217. 42:43remember the specifics of why, but the
  1218. 42:46the point is yes, you uh can make an
  1219. 42:49RRSP contribution up to the end of the
  1220. 42:53year in which you turn um uh 71.
  1221. 42:56>> Um I got that right. E why why why am I
  1222. 42:59pausing on that? Yeah, it's not 70, it's
  1223. 43:01not 72. Yeah, the end of the year in
  1224. 43:02which you turn 71. Um but you don't have
  1225. 43:05to need you don't have to use that
  1226. 43:06deduction against that tax year. you can
  1227. 43:09carry it forward to 75 to I don't think
  1228. 43:12there's any um limit on how far you can
  1229. 43:16carry that uh that forward. you'd want
  1230. 43:18to be pretty confident that either a the
  1231. 43:21money that you put in there uh when you
  1232. 43:24take it out of the riff um let let's say
  1233. 43:27you you you don't end up having the
  1234. 43:29opportunity to make use of that
  1235. 43:30deduction um then you might be costing
  1236. 43:34yourself more money by um putting it in
  1237. 43:36not getting any tax break on it and then
  1238. 43:38taking it out um at a this is a rare
  1239. 43:42higher tax bracket. Yeah. So, you'd want
  1240. 43:44to be sure that you are going to make
  1241. 43:46use of that. Maybe you're selling a
  1242. 43:48cottage um a few years down the road and
  1243. 43:50and something like that. But yes, you
  1244. 43:52can do it. The answer is yes.
  1245. 43:54>> Yeah. Yeah. And we've had clients ask
  1246. 43:56like, you know, I'm taking out my, you
  1247. 43:58know, money out of my RIFF and I've been
  1248. 44:00drawing down and I still have RSP
  1249. 44:02contribution room. Should I take some of
  1250. 44:05my money and put money into an RRSP?
  1251. 44:07It's like, no, no, you're taking it from
  1252. 44:09one hand, putting it in the other. Like,
  1253. 44:10there it's a wash. It makes no sense.
  1254. 44:12Um, this would be a rare scenario like
  1255. 44:15you said, Brett, you have an expected
  1256. 44:19increase in income at some point. I
  1257. 44:21probably in the next 5 to 10 years where
  1258. 44:23it's I can get the deduction here, hold
  1259. 44:25on to it and utilize it down the road.
  1260. 44:27Again, it's rare, but it does happen
  1261. 44:29once in a while. So, if that is you, um,
  1262. 44:32like Brett said, the answer is yes, you
  1263. 44:33can carry it forward. So, that's a key
  1264. 44:35part there.
  1265. 44:36>> So,
  1266. 44:36>> you know who hits their microphone a
  1267. 44:38lot? It's Matthew.
  1268. 44:39>> Matthew Dennis. Matthew.
  1269. 44:41>> Yeah. And it's not his microphone. It's
  1270. 44:42his It's his desk. He He He talks with
  1271. 44:45slamming his Yeah. So
  1272. 44:46>> Yeah. He's He's an aggressive
  1273. 44:48individual.
  1274. 44:48>> Deal deal with that guy.
  1275. 44:50>> Deal with that guy. Yeah.
  1276. 44:51>> Yeah. He works out too much. He's too
  1277. 44:53strong.
  1278. 44:53>> Yeah. Exactly. I know, right? Yeah. Uh
  1279. 44:55okay. We're going to bring in uh Paul
  1280. 44:57from the team to uh share a bit of a
  1281. 44:58case study that he's working on um with
  1282. 45:00the current client. So, welcome Paul.
  1283. 45:03So, for what we learned this week, we
  1284. 45:04got Paul from our team sharing a case
  1285. 45:06study and and really conversation that
  1286. 45:08he's having with a lot of clients. So,
  1287. 45:09he thought he'd share it here and and
  1288. 45:10maybe you're bumping into this. So, uh,
  1289. 45:11Paul, I'll let you take over.
  1290. 45:14>> Yeah, this has been coming up u quite
  1291. 45:16frequently lately and um it's it's the
  1292. 45:19question around uh working kind of
  1293. 45:22beyond a standard retirement age. And
  1294. 45:26so, recently working with some clients
  1295. 45:28in their late60s
  1296. 45:30and you know, I look through their
  1297. 45:31questionnaire and uh I think to myself,
  1298. 45:34geez, these people, they have a lot of
  1299. 45:36wealth. They've got rental properties.
  1300. 45:38Um they're still working. Heck, these
  1301. 45:41people could have retired years ago.
  1302. 45:43What are they still doing? Um, and so I
  1303. 45:45I end up getting into a conversation
  1304. 45:47with the folks, of course, and and in
  1305. 45:49their final planned delivery. Uh, come
  1306. 45:51to the realization that uh he is um
  1307. 45:54being laid off work. His company is is
  1308. 45:57uh being restructured and and I thought,
  1309. 46:00"Oh, okay. Well, this this is a great
  1310. 46:02opportunity, right? Take the package.
  1311. 46:04You can retire. Uh you've got plenty of
  1312. 46:06of wealth to enjoy. all of your
  1313. 46:08retirement goals, they're all being
  1314. 46:10met." And he looks at me and he says,
  1315. 46:11"No, Paul, you've got it wrong. I'm not
  1316. 46:14ready to retire. I I'm enjoying this. I
  1317. 46:18want to do more consulting work." And
  1318. 46:20and I asked the same of the wife and and
  1319. 46:22she says, "No, no, I'm I'm
  1320. 46:24self-employed, not earning a ton from
  1321. 46:26that uh venture, but I want to continue
  1322. 46:29working till I'm 75 as well." And so I
  1323. 46:33think sometimes right like we we uh
  1324. 46:36specialize in retirement planning and I
  1325. 46:38think sometimes we assume that uh
  1326. 46:41everybody wants to retire and that isn't
  1327. 46:43always the case and and so I deliver the
  1328. 46:46plan and he comes back and says well
  1329. 46:48what happens if I keep working? Is is
  1330. 46:51this going to ruin my plan? Like what
  1331. 46:53happens to my plan? And I said, "Well,
  1332. 46:57things are always going to change and
  1333. 46:59the plan is always going to need a
  1334. 47:02review. It's always going to need uh to
  1335. 47:05to to be worked on. And so, um certainly
  1336. 47:08absolutely you can go back to work,
  1337. 47:10right? Additional income is never a bad
  1338. 47:12thing. It's only going to improve your
  1339. 47:16financial position. Um, so sure it may,
  1340. 47:21you know, reduce our ability to optimize
  1341. 47:23the tax plan and and optimize the RRSP
  1342. 47:27meltdown, but at the end of the day, um,
  1343. 47:30more income is is is going to improve uh
  1344. 47:33your position. Um, and and if it's
  1345. 47:35bringing you joy, if it's if it's
  1346. 47:38bringing you purpose, absolutely, right?
  1347. 47:41Don't feel pressured to retire. Whether
  1348. 47:44you're 50, whether you're 60, whether
  1349. 47:46you're 70, if you're enjoying it, it's
  1350. 47:50bringing you purpose.
  1351. 47:52Keep working.
  1352. 47:53>> Yeah. No, absolutely. And I think a lot
  1353. 47:55of people feel like, well, I'm 65. I
  1354. 47:56have to retire. But I have nothing to
  1355. 47:58retire to, right? And that's a dangerous
  1356. 48:00like you're better to keep working if
  1357. 48:02you love it than to retire to nothing
  1358. 48:04because things will go downhill pretty
  1359. 48:05quickly for a lot of people. So, um,
  1360. 48:08yeah, I think retirement is an age,
  1361. 48:09right? like you know freedom 55 I always
  1362. 48:11say freedom 55 is when your kids are 55
  1363. 48:13now but you know we kind of adapted to
  1364. 48:15this like mentality of like well when we
  1365. 48:17hit an age we need to retire and you
  1366. 48:20know people think well you know retire
  1367. 48:21early everyone gets praised for retiring
  1368. 48:23at 50 55 early but I think if you have a
  1369. 48:26skill set and a passion you love what
  1370. 48:28you do yeah you're continuing to add to
  1371. 48:30your your your company or society
  1372. 48:32through working longer so um yeah but
  1373. 48:35again it's good to have a checkin to see
  1374. 48:38can I retire do I need to keep working
  1375. 48:40could you know what does this all look
  1376. 48:41like and if I do continue maybe I can
  1377. 48:43retire like you said Paul but what's
  1378. 48:45what's the financial impact to keep
  1379. 48:46working there's a tax implication to
  1380. 48:49that and how does that all flow out
  1381. 48:51>> yeah and and you know in in this case
  1382. 48:54right if he does decide to go back to
  1383. 48:56work and continue working well yeah
  1384. 48:58we're we're going to need to manipulate
  1385. 49:00his plan a little bit maybe we reduce uh
  1386. 49:02some of those RSP withdrawals and and
  1387. 49:05push the the RSP meltdown out a little
  1388. 49:07bit now you can only do that for so
  1389. 49:09wrong. Um but um yeah, it's it's it's a
  1390. 49:14document that needs constant work. So um
  1391. 49:16yeah, my my takeaway here is uh yeah,
  1392. 49:19don't don't always assume that everybody
  1393. 49:21wants to retire regardless of their age.
  1394. 49:23And uh if you're enjoying it, keep at
  1395. 49:25it. Good on you.
  1396. 49:26>> Yeah, absolutely. Well, Paul, thanks for
  1397. 49:28joining us on this one. We'll do it
  1398. 49:29again soon.
  1399. 49:30>> Okay, back uh with the last one with the
  1400. 49:32tip of the week here. uh uh instead of
  1401. 49:34keeping a cash wedge or an income wedge,
  1402. 49:36can you use your heliloc home equity
  1403. 49:38line of credit as a potential cash wedge
  1404. 49:40to write out the stock market downturns?
  1405. 49:43You pay interest. Uh but if you do the
  1406. 49:45Smith maneuver, the interest will be tax
  1407. 49:47deductible against your RIFF
  1408. 49:48withdrawals. Uh so I'm going to set
  1409. 49:51aside the Smith REM maneuver for a
  1410. 49:53second here and just focus on using your
  1411. 49:56HELOC as an as an income wedge. Uh you
  1412. 49:58could you you certainly could. Uh the
  1413. 50:01challenge I would say with that is that
  1414. 50:04you don't necessarily control the
  1415. 50:06heliloc, meaning you don't control what
  1416. 50:08the interest rate is at any uh given uh
  1417. 50:10time. You might have to pull that money
  1418. 50:12out at the worst possible time. Yes, if
  1419. 50:15you are doing a Smith maneuver, which
  1420. 50:17we'll get into a second, um then you can
  1421. 50:19deduct that money u uh the sorry the
  1422. 50:22interest on that, but you're only
  1423. 50:24deducting the interest. You're not if
  1424. 50:25you're taking $50,000 out of your
  1425. 50:27helock, you're not deducting $50,000.
  1426. 50:30Um whereas you control your income
  1427. 50:32wedge. Uh that's the whole point of the
  1428. 50:34income wedge is the vast majority of
  1429. 50:36your funds are still growing for the
  1430. 50:38long term. They're still there to ride
  1431. 50:40out whatever happens over the next three
  1432. 50:42five plus years. The income wedge and
  1433. 50:46again in general I would say it's about
  1434. 50:4810ish 15ish% of everybody's uh the total
  1435. 50:51investment amount that es and flows but
  1436. 50:53in that area. So it's there almost as
  1437. 50:57insurance against the when the market
  1438. 50:59does go down and it goes down at the
  1439. 51:01worst possible time that you wouldn't
  1440. 51:04want all your money in uh in the market.
  1441. 51:06So is it possible? Yes. Um and in terms
  1442. 51:10of tax deductibility I would always say
  1443. 51:13don't do something just for I remember
  1444. 51:15my father who's an accountant used to
  1445. 51:17say to me uh don't do something just for
  1446. 51:19the uh the tax break. like do it because
  1447. 51:22there's a a good reason to do it and
  1448. 51:24then the tax break just becomes a bonus
  1449. 51:26to that. Um so the question is you're
  1450. 51:30pulling it out of the HELOC um but if
  1451. 51:32you're doing the Smith maneuver well
  1452. 51:34then that money has to um be that money
  1453. 51:38is not necessarily going into spending.
  1454. 51:40It has to if if I remember correctly has
  1455. 51:42to support the Smith maneuver. Um, and
  1456. 51:45so even if it you could do it and do it
  1457. 51:50with a Smith maneuver and you're getting
  1458. 51:51the tax deductibility, I I just really
  1459. 51:54question uh the overall benefit of it.
  1460. 51:56I'm not the biggest fan of the Smith
  1461. 51:58maneuver just because anecdotally
  1462. 52:01throughout the plans that I've done with
  1463. 52:03the the Smith maneuver and and through
  1464. 52:06clients that have done it, I just really
  1465. 52:08haven't seen a great benefit. Now, some
  1466. 52:11people, I'm sure, just like anything
  1467. 52:12else, yeah, go to town. Um, I would
  1468. 52:15still just I would I would just control
  1469. 52:17it myself and do an income wedge. I I
  1470. 52:19don't know what downside we're avoiding
  1471. 52:22by not doing a um an income wedge, Adam.
  1472. 52:26>> Yeah. And they, you know, instead of
  1473. 52:28keeping cash wedge, can you use a
  1474. 52:29heliloc as a potential cash wedge? Well,
  1475. 52:31the whole idea of an income or cash
  1476. 52:33wedge is having availability like safe
  1477. 52:36money in each account. So, if you're
  1478. 52:38just pulling out your heliloc, it's
  1479. 52:39like, well, now you haven't triggered
  1480. 52:41RSP money and taxable income. So, you've
  1481. 52:43kind of derailed your tax plan. So, that
  1482. 52:45that's part of the issue here. Um,
  1483. 52:48now let's say, you know, it's like
  1484. 52:50finally the light bulb went on and it's
  1485. 52:52like, yeah, I'm retiring in January 1st
  1486. 52:54of 2027 and I I haven't built out this
  1487. 52:56income wedge and now the market's
  1488. 52:58dropping and I'm kind of playing
  1489. 53:00catch-up. What you could do, and again,
  1490. 53:02this is kind of a side thought, and
  1491. 53:03again, this is for people that haven't
  1492. 53:04planned ahead and it's like, oh shoot,
  1493. 53:06I'm here and I'm too late. Um, you still
  1494. 53:08want to pull money out of your riff.
  1495. 53:10like you still want to follow the tax
  1496. 53:11plan. Now again, you're selling, let's
  1497. 53:14say the market's down 20%, you're
  1498. 53:15selling whatever is in your RRSP at 20%
  1499. 53:18loss. Not ideal. Could you take a
  1500. 53:21heliloc and reby it in a nonregistered
  1501. 53:24account, the same investment? So, you
  1502. 53:26pull money out of your RRSP or RIFF.
  1503. 53:28You're using that and then you're using
  1504. 53:30your HELOC to reby that equity to hold
  1505. 53:32on to to let it bounce back up and then
  1506. 53:34sell it and kind of offset that a bit.
  1507. 53:35Obviously, you're paying tax on your
  1508. 53:36RIFF withdrawal, but you need that tax.
  1509. 53:38It's part of the tax plan. You could in
  1510. 53:40theory borrow against your heliloc
  1511. 53:42invest deducted interest which is again
  1512. 53:45a moot point really. Um could you do
  1513. 53:48that? Yeah. A lot of moving parts. Super
  1514. 53:50complicated. I I think the key here
  1515. 53:52though is no. You can't use a heliloc
  1516. 53:54for your income wedge or cash wedge
  1517. 53:55because you're not pulling it from the
  1518. 53:57right accounts. You're yes you're giving
  1519. 53:59yourself income which you need but
  1520. 54:01you're derailing the tax fund. Kind of
  1521. 54:02goes back to the very you know first
  1522. 54:04question of like hey markets are doing
  1523. 54:06really well. Do I adjust? It's like,
  1524. 54:08yeah, you might need to adjust, but keep
  1525. 54:10following the tax plan here. You've
  1526. 54:13completely derailed your tax plan. Build
  1527. 54:15out that income wedge. And and this goes
  1528. 54:17back to like the core of the income
  1529. 54:18wedge. And you know, there's a lot of
  1530. 54:20smart people on social media and, you
  1531. 54:23know, in journals and all over the place
  1532. 54:25saying an income wedge doesn't make
  1533. 54:26sense from a financial standpoint. Um,
  1534. 54:29but the reality is is is this question
  1535. 54:32right here doesn't make sense from a
  1536. 54:33financial standpoint either, right? And
  1537. 54:36that's where the income wedge is really
  1538. 54:37psychological. You you want to make sure
  1539. 54:39you're protecting it so that you can
  1540. 54:41enjoy retirement. You work 40 years to
  1541. 54:43get here and now markets are down. So
  1542. 54:45you're pulling from a heliloc and not
  1543. 54:46following the tax plan. You're going to
  1544. 54:48pay more tax. It's like how long do you
  1545. 54:49wait for it to come back? And there's
  1546. 54:51just protect. And again, most people
  1547. 54:53have like a 60 40 or 7030 asset mix
  1548. 54:56anyway. So it's not like you're, you
  1549. 54:58know, holding more fixed income or safe
  1550. 55:00money than you would otherwise. You're
  1551. 55:01just allocating that in the right areas.
  1552. 55:03And I think that's what most people
  1553. 55:04miss. Most people like, well, I don't
  1554. 55:05want to hold cash because that, you
  1555. 55:07know, it's not earning for me and I'm
  1556. 55:08falling behind, whatever. It's like,
  1557. 55:09well, what's your risk tolerance? 70 30
  1558. 55:1160 40. Um, well, then put that 30 or 40%
  1559. 55:15of fixed income in the proper bucket and
  1560. 55:18now you probably have five or seven
  1561. 55:19years of income which actually built out
  1562. 55:21naturally without you even realizing it,
  1563. 55:24right? So, it's it's not this
  1564. 55:25complicated process. It's just there is
  1565. 55:27a bit of a process to it. Again, it's
  1566. 55:28moving away from maybe ETFs and mutual
  1567. 55:30funds because those are more bundled
  1568. 55:31products. So you might have to adjust
  1569. 55:33the product or the investment solution a
  1570. 55:35little bit, but for most people
  1571. 55:38naturally, you have an income wedge. So
  1572. 55:41just understand how that works, the
  1573. 55:43nuances of it. It's it's not it's not
  1574. 55:45something that most people are not
  1575. 55:46doing. It's just they're they're not
  1576. 55:47aware of it or it's not structured in
  1577. 55:49the proper way.
  1578. 55:50>> Yeah. And that's a good point, too, is
  1579. 55:52is that even if you're pulling that
  1580. 55:53money out of a RRSP or RIFF, let's say
  1581. 55:56you're pulling $50,000 out a year. Um,
  1582. 55:59and but you don't need to pull it out
  1583. 56:01for spending. Maybe you've got a great
  1584. 56:02pension, maybe you've got a big
  1585. 56:04non-registered account who, you know,
  1586. 56:06whatever happens. So you're not you
  1587. 56:07don't need it to live your life, but
  1588. 56:10you're trying to smooth out those taxes
  1589. 56:13uh between now and and early to mid80s
  1590. 56:15so that you don't end up with uh a big
  1591. 56:18tax bill or somebody ends up with a big
  1592. 56:19tax bill uh when you're forced to take
  1593. 56:22it out or when you um when you pass
  1594. 56:24away. So, if you're taking that $50,000
  1595. 56:27uh out a year, that's the $50,000 um
  1596. 56:31like next year's $50,000 is probably
  1597. 56:33sitting in a GIC, let's just just say,
  1598. 56:35or maybe it's cash money, market fund,
  1599. 56:37like you whatever the case may be. The
  1600. 56:39next year, like the next year after
  1601. 56:41that, so 2028 is $50,000. Maybe it's
  1602. 56:44again GIC bond, you know, again
  1603. 56:48something that is uh very unlikely to go
  1604. 56:52negative or or guaranteed to not go
  1605. 56:54negative and and so on and so forth. And
  1606. 56:57I I' I've told people, imagine that's
  1607. 57:00your paycheck. Okay? So your boss comes
  1608. 57:02to you and go, "Okay, I'm going to pay
  1609. 57:03you $50,000 a year, but I can't
  1610. 57:06guarantee it. Uh I'm going to put that
  1611. 57:08$50,000 in the market. And if the market
  1612. 57:11crashes and that $50,000 turns into
  1613. 57:13$20,000, that's what you're going to get
  1614. 57:14paid next year, you know, or you can
  1615. 57:18take more money and get the $50,000 out,
  1616. 57:20but you're now borrowing against your
  1617. 57:22your next year's paycheck or the next
  1618. 57:24year's paycheck. Nobody would agree to
  1619. 57:25that. Nobody would. And that's exactly
  1620. 57:27what we're trying to do uh here with the
  1621. 57:29income wedge is to take that relatively
  1622. 57:32small portion that Adam as you said
  1623. 57:34probably already exists in your 6040
  1624. 57:367030 whatever the case may be
  1625. 57:38>> and just use it intentionally that oh
  1626. 57:42that amount of money is coming out of
  1627. 57:43that account so I'm going to need an
  1628. 57:45income wedge to help with that whereas
  1629. 57:47for example I'm not touching my TFSA for
  1630. 57:49the next 15 years I don't need an income
  1631. 57:51wedge in my TFSA you might want to have
  1632. 57:54a little one just in case you need you
  1633. 57:56know 10 or $20,000 down the road. But uh
  1634. 57:59yeah, I wouldn't use a heliloc because
  1635. 58:02as you said, then we stop tax planning.
  1636. 58:05>> Yeah. Yeah. If you think about your
  1637. 58:06RRSP, like if you're someone sitting
  1638. 58:08there saying, "Yeah, I'm about a 7030 7%
  1639. 58:11stocks, 30% fixed income." And you build
  1640. 58:14a plan, you're like, "Okay, I'm pulling
  1641. 58:167% of my riff out every year." Well,
  1642. 58:19three years, that's 21%. So you have
  1643. 58:23essentially over four years of income
  1644. 58:25wedge in your account. You didn't even
  1645. 58:28know it, right? And I think this is what
  1646. 58:30people are thinking. Like people think
  1647. 58:31income wedge is like this whole another
  1648. 58:32thing I got to create. A lot of people
  1649. 58:34you already have it. You might have to
  1650. 58:35rejig it. Like I said a little bit, but
  1651. 58:37you probably already have unless you're
  1652. 58:38100% equity, you already have an income
  1653. 58:41wedge. It's just how is that structured?
  1654. 58:43How is it built out? Is it going to be
  1655. 58:44there for you? Um, again, if you have,
  1656. 58:47you know, GIC's that mature in five
  1657. 58:49years and you need money next year, you
  1658. 58:51might have an income wedge, but it's not
  1659. 58:52structured properly. Um, so again, you
  1660. 58:55might have a balanced mutual fund.
  1661. 58:56Again, not structured properly. You have
  1662. 58:57to kind of detach that balance fund into
  1663. 59:00maybe an equity and a bond fund or
  1664. 59:02something like that. Um, again, won't
  1665. 59:04get into how to invest it, but the the
  1666. 59:06concept is there for sure. So, um, yeah,
  1667. 59:10>> and that's long answer, but just
  1668. 59:12>> Yeah. And that's quick comment on that.
  1669. 59:15That's again where potentially a trusted
  1670. 59:17investment advisor is going to help you
  1671. 59:18because there is a lot of nuances to it.
  1672. 59:20I used to do it when I was um handling
  1673. 59:23investments and insurance and financial
  1674. 59:24planning uh at Sunlife. Uh our our
  1675. 59:27investment partner BCV uh uh does it uh
  1676. 59:30and there is a decent amount of work and
  1677. 59:32nuance to it. Um and and I can
  1678. 59:35understand that it's not as easy just to
  1679. 59:37kind of talk about it on a video and
  1680. 59:38then somebody's like, "Oh, I know
  1681. 59:40exactly what an income wedge is." Like I
  1682. 59:42understand there's nuance to it and some
  1683. 59:44people are going to go out and learn
  1684. 59:46that nuance and be able to implement it.
  1685. 59:47Fantastic. Some people again they may
  1686. 59:50want to just say you know what I'm going
  1687. 59:51to talk to my friends and family. Who
  1688. 59:52are you using for this? I want to talk
  1689. 59:54to them. See if it's a good fit uh for
  1690. 59:56me. Um but yeah. Yeah.
  1691. 59:58>> Well and I think it's a good question
  1692. 1:00:00like if you're someone looking for a new
  1693. 1:00:02investment advisor or a change of
  1694. 1:00:05investments and you're entering into
  1695. 1:00:07retirement ask like how do you you know
  1696. 1:00:10how do you protect my income? How do you
  1697. 1:00:11build this income wedge to make sure I'm
  1698. 1:00:13getting my income regardless of what the
  1699. 1:00:14market's doing? That should be a primary
  1700. 1:00:16question that you ask, not what's your,
  1701. 1:00:18you know, rate of return over time and
  1702. 1:00:20this and that. Like, yeah, that's all
  1703. 1:00:21important. How do you protect my income?
  1704. 1:00:24How do you build an income wage? And
  1705. 1:00:25again, that's why we utilize Silverlark
  1706. 1:00:27and BCB and some of these investment
  1707. 1:00:29firms that buy individual bonds, have
  1708. 1:00:31some alternative, have dividends, like
  1709. 1:00:33they have this natural cash flow coming
  1710. 1:00:35in, but your your quote unquote fixed
  1711. 1:00:37income or safe money, your income wedge
  1712. 1:00:38is still earning something for you,
  1713. 1:00:40which is really important.
  1714. 1:00:41>> Yeah. Yeah. And while you're
  1715. 1:00:42interviewing those people, um, also ask
  1716. 1:00:44them uh about financial planning, like
  1717. 1:00:46like h how how do you plan for this uh
  1718. 1:00:50uh how do you plan for my my taxable uh
  1719. 1:00:53uh registered accounts? uh you know all
  1720. 1:00:55all those questions will give you a
  1721. 1:00:58general idea of how they approach that
  1722. 1:01:00kind of stuff. Uh they may say I just
  1723. 1:01:02leave your I leave your RSPs riffs uh as
  1724. 1:01:04long as possible which may or may not be
  1725. 1:01:06the right answer for you. It it it may
  1726. 1:01:09be that you should leave them as long as
  1727. 1:01:10possible. In our um
  1728. 1:01:13>> in our case it's
  1729. 1:01:15it certainly is the minority. But yeah,
  1730. 1:01:17those are some uh good questions to uh
  1731. 1:01:20interview somebody. So there two tips of
  1732. 1:01:21the week. Two tips of the week. And if
  1733. 1:01:23you need help with that, like we do have
  1734. 1:01:24our retirement income program, right?
  1735. 1:01:26Not to plug our services on here. We try
  1736. 1:01:27and keep it free of our services, but a
  1737. 1:01:29lot of people are struggling with this
  1738. 1:01:30or they've had a great investment
  1739. 1:01:31advisor for 20, 30 years. It's like
  1740. 1:01:34>> they're not great on the the draw down
  1741. 1:01:35or they're not doing proper planning or
  1742. 1:01:37whatever. Like our retirement income
  1743. 1:01:38program combines the planning and
  1744. 1:01:40investments. You know, our team does the
  1745. 1:01:42planning. We have third party investment
  1746. 1:01:43managers that take care of the
  1747. 1:01:44investments, not just to grow your
  1748. 1:01:46money, but to protect that cash flow.
  1749. 1:01:48Just what we talked about. And we work
  1750. 1:01:49hand in hand like it's a zipper
  1751. 1:01:51relationship. And so yeah, you know,
  1752. 1:01:53reach out to our office info@p
  1753. 1:01:54parallelwealth.com.
  1754. 1:01:56Um, you know, I'd have be happy to have
  1755. 1:01:58uh, you know, someone on our team have a
  1756. 1:01:59chat with you to go through that to see
  1757. 1:02:00if it makes sense for you. Um, and we
  1758. 1:02:03also again have our fee for service. So
  1759. 1:02:05if you have a good investment advisor
  1760. 1:02:06but need some retirement planning, we do
  1761. 1:02:08that too. So anyway, we'll end it there.
  1762. 1:02:10Brett, thanks for taking the time to do
  1763. 1:02:12this. Thank you everyone for watching,
  1764. 1:02:13listening, whatever platform you're on.
  1765. 1:02:15And again, if you have questions for us,
  1766. 1:02:16please leave those below and we'll try
  1767. 1:02:18to get them in a future podcast. Thanks
  1768. 1:02:20for joining us on this week's episode of
  1769. 1:02:22Retirement Unpacked. If you found
  1770. 1:02:24today's conversation helpful, don't
  1771. 1:02:26forget to subscribe so you don't miss
  1772. 1:02:27next week's episode. And remember, the
  1773. 1:02:30ideas we talk about are general in
  1774. 1:02:32nature. They may not fit your personal
  1775. 1:02:34situation. Always consult a qualified
  1776. 1:02:36financial planner before making
  1777. 1:02:38decisions about your retirement. Take
  1778. 1:02:40care and we'll see you next

About this transcript

This page contains the full transcript of Your Retirement Portfolio Keeps Growing. What Should You Do? (Ep 062) by Parallel Wealth, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 13,010 words across 1,778 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.

What you can do with it

Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.

Free YouTube transcript tool

YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.