you found a winning ad… now what? (how to escape the creative rat race) — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:00Hey guys, Mark here. In this video, I'm
- 0:01going to be going over what you should
- 0:02do after you find a winning creative.
- 0:04So, what most people do is they
- 0:06basically go directly into testing these
- 0:09micro variations, right? They start
- 0:10testing new hooks, they start testing
- 0:12new scroll stoppers, and they just throw
- 0:14a bunch of [ __ ] at the wall that is
- 0:15very, very similar to that original
- 0:18winning creative. And then what happens?
- 0:19Well, of course, none of those micro
- 0:22variations end up being profitable, and
- 0:24then they burn all the profit that they
- 0:26were making with the winner until the
- 0:27winner dies out and then it's right back
- 0:29to ground zero. And this is basically
- 0:31what I call the creative rat race. And
- 0:34that is basically you find a winner, you
- 0:37try to create all these iterations and
- 0:39small little variations of that original
- 0:40winner. None of them end up actually
- 0:42becoming any larger than the original
- 0:44winner that you made in the first place,
- 0:46and then you basically freak out until
- 0:48the main creative that was driving all
- 0:50the results in the first place dies, and
- 0:52then once again, you're right back to
- 0:53ground zero. [ __ ] I got to find a new
- 0:55winning creative. And the cycle repeats
- 0:56over and over again until you're right
- 0:57back working at McDonald's. Now, this is
- 0:59obviously pretty bad, but let me tell
- 1:01you the worst part of this is what
- 1:02happens as a result, which is you
- 1:05thinking that oh, my creatives that were
- 1:07the problem this whole time, maybe it
- 1:09was actually the product, you know?
- 1:10Maybe the product was the reason [ __ ]
- 1:12wasn't profitable in the first place and
- 1:13I couldn't scale it. Maybe it was the
- 1:14market. Maybe it was the niche that I
- 1:16was selling in this entire time. Or even
- 1:18worse, and this one is probably one of
- 1:19the most misleading, maybe it was the
- 1:21lander. I noticed my landing page
- 1:23conversion rate went down so much. It's
- 1:25got to be the lander, man. It's got to.
- 1:27And this is basically like Facebook, if
- 1:29you don't know how to read the data.
- 1:30This is Facebook gaslighting you into
- 1:32what is the actual problem here? Because
- 1:34this all sucks, and then you end up
- 1:36being really hard on yourself and then,
- 1:37you know, emotions take over and you
- 1:39start to think that the reason you
- 1:40weren't able to scale is because of
- 1:41something other than the creative. When
- 1:43in reality, it was the creative the
- 1:44whole time. So, in this video, I'm going
- 1:45to show you how to fix all of this
- 1:46because I legitimately think most people
- 1:48don't know what to do after they find a
- 1:50winning creative. And some people
- 1:51legitimately get lucky and then they
- 1:53can't replicate that success repeatedly
- 1:55with a legitimate system. Now, let me
- 1:57introduce you the creative tier list,
- 1:59okay? Every single creative that you
- 2:01test is going to land somewhere on the
- 2:03the spectrum. That's why I don't really
- 2:04like the definition of like, "Oh, I
- 2:05found a winning creative." What really
- 2:07is a winning creative? Because a winning
- 2:08creative can be a creative that's
- 2:10profitable up to only $10,000 in spend
- 2:13or up to $1,000 a day in spend versus
- 2:15some S-tier creatives where you can
- 2:17literally spend a million dollars and
- 2:18still be profitable on that creative.
- 2:20And so, every single creative should
- 2:21fall somewhere on the spectrum. Of
- 2:23course, down here at F, this is going to
- 2:25be a creative that isn't even profitable
- 2:27at all. It's not even deemed a winner.
- 2:28But as soon as it is, whatever that is
- 2:30for your criteria, cuz every business
- 2:32has a little bit different economics,
- 2:33maybe it's profitability, maybe you're
- 2:35playing the LTV game, just need to be
- 2:36break even, whatever it is, right? The
- 2:37more that your creative can spend, the
- 2:39higher up it's going to be. And so, you
- 2:41need to understand this because
- 2:42sometimes you'll test creatives and the
- 2:44cap for that particular creative in
- 2:46terms of the revenue it can generate
- 2:47with that particular lander is only,
- 2:49let's say like, you know, $5,000.
- 2:52Because a lot of people lose a lot of
- 2:54money trying to force a creative that
- 2:56has like a 5K a spend cap, you know,
- 2:58force it to spend 10K or 20K. When in
- 3:01reality, they just need to search for
- 3:03these winners up here that are actually
- 3:04going to spend over, you know, seven
- 3:06figures alone on one individual
- 3:08creative. Okay, so, every creative is
- 3:09going to land somewhere on here. Now,
- 3:11how do you actually multiply your
- 3:12winners? This is the bulk of what I want
- 3:14to spend this particular video on, okay?
- 3:16And this is a process that, you know,
- 3:18I'm a marketer, so I like to come up
- 3:19with fancy marketer names for [ __ ] But
- 3:21I call this basically winning variable
- 3:24extraction. And I call it a variable
- 3:26specifically because within you have all
- 3:29these terms. You have your level of
- 3:31awareness, you have your stage of
- 3:33sophistication, you have your mechanism,
- 3:35you have your authority figure, you have
- 3:37the format of the creative, the style.
- 3:39Like, there's so many different words to
- 3:41describe a creative. And I believe that
- 3:42each one of those is some sort of
- 3:44variable, but variables can go even
- 3:45deeper than that. Your job, okay? Let me
- 3:48make myself really clear. Your job, as
- 3:49soon as you find a winning creative, is
- 3:51not to go ham with [ __ ] micro
- 3:53variations, okay? Variations can work,
- 3:56but this process that I'm going to teach
- 3:58you here is going to help you create
- 4:00creatives that actually surpass the
- 4:03original profitable creative that was in
- 4:05your ad account, okay? Because most of
- 4:07you guys are literally just throwing
- 4:08[ __ ] at the wall and hoping it sticks.
- 4:10That's not how you should do creative
- 4:11testing, okay? Creative testing is one
- 4:14of the most beautiful things because
- 4:16it's literally just the scientific
- 4:18method. That's right. Do you remember
- 4:20that [ __ ] you learned in [ __ ] fifth
- 4:22grade science class about the scientific
- 4:24method? Yeah, you're actually doing it
- 4:25up until this day. You're just probably
- 4:26not aware of it, but as soon as you are,
- 4:28it's going to change the way that you do
- 4:30creative testing because ultimately you
- 4:32should be getting better and better at
- 4:33finding winning creatives because every
- 4:35creative you test, every new concept
- 4:37that you test should have some sort of
- 4:39hypothesis around it, okay? So very
- 4:42quickly, okay? We don't need to do every
- 4:44single step here, but very quickly
- 4:45you're going to observe the existing
- 4:48data in your ad account. You've tested a
- 4:49lot of ads, most of them haven't worked.
- 4:51Why? Why haven't they worked? You have
- 4:53to sit down and actually be able to draw
- 4:55conclusions from every single creative
- 4:57test because every creative test you're
- 4:59buying data. Like I say this all the
- 5:01time, you're not spending money on ads,
- 5:02you're buying data. If you are going to
- 5:05run ads on Facebook and you're spending
- 5:06money on new creative tests and you're
- 5:09not learning anything as a result, that
- 5:11is literally just burning money. The
- 5:13only reason that I call it buying data
- 5:16is if you actually use the data that you
- 5:17buy. If you're not using it, you are
- 5:19literally just burning [ __ ] money. So
- 5:21you make an observation based off all
- 5:23the existing creative tests that you've
- 5:24done. If you haven't done any, you can
- 5:26start with a swipe, you can start with
- 5:27your own research, it doesn't matter.
- 5:29But you're going to have to start buying
- 5:30data. As soon as you do buy data of what
- 5:32works and what doesn't, now you
- 5:34construct a hypothesis of, "Okay, I
- 5:37tested this one thing in this last
- 5:38concept test and I had a very high hook
- 5:40rate but very poor conversions.
- 5:41Therefore, I think that this specific
- 5:43variable in the hook is good for getting
- 5:45people's attention but not good for
- 5:46converting them. So I'm going to take
- 5:48that hook and I'm going to test with a
- 5:49new body." That is a hypothesis. If I
- 5:51change this one variable and I keep
- 5:53everything else the same, then I'll be
- 5:55able to use this piece of data that I
- 5:57got with a very high hook rate and apply
- 5:59it directly to my next concept test,
- 6:01okay? As soon as you got that
- 6:02hypothesis, you make the creatives, you
- 6:05run the experiment, you actually get
- 6:06real data, you let the ad spend, and
- 6:08then once again, you just bought more
- 6:10data. And here's the beautiful thing
- 6:12about this process, and I'm going to go
- 6:14a lot deeper in just a second, but the
- 6:15beautiful thing about this is you should
- 6:17be getting better. And what's going to
- 6:19happen is you're going to step start to
- 6:21test all these different elements of
- 6:22your ads, right? All these different
- 6:23variables. You're going to test hooks,
- 6:25authority figures, you're going to test
- 6:26levels of awareness, you're going to
- 6:27test different formats, you're going to
- 6:29test different camera angles, you're
- 6:30going to test different, you know,
- 6:31wording of the hooks, like whether, you
- 6:33know, short copy sentences does better
- 6:35versus the longer more emotional
- 6:36sentences. Like you're going to get all
- 6:38these data points. And what's going to
- 6:39happen, the way that you create those
- 6:41S-tier creatives that I was talking
- 6:43about, it's not by accident. It's not by
- 6:45random, and it's usually not by swiping
- 6:47directly, either. Usually it's from
- 6:49accumulating all these winning variables
- 6:51and stacking them on top of each other,
- 6:53one after the other, to create like this
- 6:55[ __ ] super creative, you know? That
- 6:58is how the biggest creatives in your
- 7:00account are going to be made. They're
- 7:02not found, they are created from you
- 7:04buying so much data and creating smart
- 7:06conclusions from them. So everything
- 7:08comes down to the scientific method,
- 7:10creating real hypotheses around what
- 7:12you're testing, getting data from them,
- 7:13and it's stacking your [ __ ] list of
- 7:15winning variables. That's it. If you can
- 7:17do that, making ads will be like
- 7:19something that comes easy to you. But
- 7:21not because you got lucky or because you
- 7:22have intuition, it's cuz you simply
- 7:24bought the data to know actually what
- 7:26works with 100% confidence. And what I
- 7:29did to kind of automate this process is
- 7:31I literally created a custom skill that
- 7:33you can use in Claude or Codex or
- 7:34whatever your favorite, you know, LLM of
- 7:35choice is, and you just upload your
- 7:37winning ads, and it'll actually do a
- 7:38legitimate variable extraction for you.
- 7:41In the case that maybe you don't see
- 7:42something, it'll actually help you
- 7:44extract those variables. So I have that
- 7:45built into my processes, and I want to
- 7:47give it away to you for free if you want
- 7:48to use it. Just go to my Instagram, it's
- 7:50@markbuildsbrands, DM me the word
- 7:52extract, and I'll send it to you. Okay,
- 7:54so now I want to talk about what a
- 7:55winning variable actually is and how to
- 7:58stack them together. And what I'm going
- 7:59to do is I'm actually going to look at
- 8:00an ad completely live with you guys to
- 8:03show you how to think about this, okay?
- 8:04Obviously this is not going to be one of
- 8:06my brands, but just imagine this was a
- 8:08huge winner in the account. This is how
- 8:09I would be breaking it down. So, we got
- 8:11a brand here running video ads to this,
- 8:13you know, on-page VSL here. I don't even
- 8:15know what the brand is, but let's take a
- 8:16look at the ad. The thing about variable
- 8:18extraction is there's so much to pull
- 8:20out, okay? So, before I even press play
- 8:23on the video, I can probably identify in
- 8:25this case at least like three or four
- 8:27different winning variables that allowed
- 8:29this hook to be so successful, okay? The
- 8:31first of which, again, I'm just going to
- 8:33be speaking as if I don't know the data,
- 8:35but I've ran a lot of ads, so maybe it's
- 8:36right, maybe it's not. But, the
- 8:37important thing is how to think about
- 8:39it. The first thing that I'm noticing is
- 8:41the type of clip in the scroll stopper.
- 8:43So, I know for the pet market, for the
- 8:44security market especially, using these
- 8:47home camera footage clips that are super
- 8:50duper shocking as a scroll stopper are
- 8:52highly effective. That could be winning
- 8:54variable number one. Winning variable
- 8:55number two is the quality of said video.
- 8:57If the quality is too high, I would
- 8:58think you guys understand. I literally
- 9:00lower the resolution of some of my ads
- 9:02that I upload simply because they're
- 9:03more likely to be seen as native.
- 9:06And also, I think Facebook low-key
- 9:07penalizes like super highly produced
- 9:09ads. Sometimes, you know, sometimes
- 9:10maybe not, but that's just a conspiracy
- 9:12theory I have. The next is going to be,
- 9:14as soon as I play the video, how
- 9:15incredibly shocking the video actually
- 9:17is, right? So, let's play it real quick.
- 9:18>> I came home and his crate was destroyed.
- 9:21Then
- 9:21>> So, here we have the hook itself, which
- 9:23is the copy, "When I came home, his
- 9:25crate was destroyed."
- 9:26>> I came home and his crate was destroyed.
- 9:29>> And then we have the visual on top of
- 9:31that of this particular, you know,
- 9:34camera capturing this dog going crazy
- 9:35inside of his [ __ ] crate. And we're
- 9:37only 2 seconds in. Keep in mind, hook
- 9:39rate is the first 3 seconds. Not the
- 9:41first five, not the first 10, it's first
- 9:423 seconds. And your KPI is over 50%.
- 9:45Next, we also have the actual text on
- 9:47screen being a potential variable. And
- 9:49again, these are all things that should
- 9:50be tested to see which of these actually
- 9:53have an impact on conversions or on the
- 9:55soft metrics themselves like your CTR,
- 9:57your hook rate, etc.
- 9:58>> Then I checked the camera and saw this.
- 10:00>> And then, of course, we have the
- 10:01structure of a hook where kind of an
- 10:03astonishing statement and then a open
- 10:05loop of I checked the camera and then I
- 10:07saw this, right? So, already in the
- 10:08first 4 seconds, I haven't even gotten
- 10:10to the fifth second of this particular
- 10:12creative, we have so many potential
- 10:14winning variables. And you know, again,
- 10:16this isn't my brand. I don't know if
- 10:17they're all winning, but I do know I've
- 10:18broken down my own winning creatives
- 10:20that have spent over seven figures and I
- 10:22can tell you there was purpose and
- 10:25reason and data behind every single tiny
- 10:27little detail that was there. And I
- 10:29could tell you exactly when we tested
- 10:31all these other variables to know the
- 10:32truth about why we're doing things the
- 10:34way that we are. So I just Let's keep
- 10:36going for just a little bit longer.
- 10:37>> saw that video and
- 10:38>> Oh, [ __ ]
- 10:39>> So I just saw that video and honestly,
- 10:41if that looks familiar to you, if your
- 10:43dog does anything close to that when you
- 10:45leave the house or when a storm rolls
- 10:46in, I need you to understand something
- 10:48that most vets will never explain to
- 10:50>> Okay, so let's talk about winning
- 10:52variables here. We're going from a very
- 10:53shocking initial video that is basically
- 10:56footage from a, you know, a camera and
- 10:58now we're going into an official
- 11:00well-put-together Asian podcaster dude.
- 11:02And you know, I said Asian, yeah, but
- 11:05that's also another variable that is to
- 11:06be tested like let's not, you know, [ __ ]
- 11:09ourselves here. You should be testing
- 11:10all ethnicities to see which one is
- 11:12going to have the biggest impact on your
- 11:13conversions because like it or not, you
- 11:15know, human nature doesn't [ __ ] lie.
- 11:16There's a reason behind everything. So
- 11:18not only do we have this authority
- 11:19figure and all these other variables
- 11:21associated with just the authority
- 11:23figure like the race, the age, the
- 11:24gender, everything that you can possibly
- 11:26think of. We also have the foreground in
- 11:29the background of this video as well
- 11:30being at a, you know, a black desk with
- 11:32this particular background with the blue
- 11:34shirt. All these are variables. Like you
- 11:36have to be psychotic about the details
- 11:37because I really believe that they
- 11:39matter and the more of them that you can
- 11:40stack on top of each other that are
- 11:42winning, again, that is how you create
- 11:44those S-tier creatives. These are
- 11:45literally the creatives that set you up
- 11:47for life. If you want to talk about
- 11:48getting real financial freedom and being
- 11:50able to create a brand or run ads that
- 11:52are so profitable like your life will
- 11:53literally change, it's going to be
- 11:55through this. It's going to be through
- 11:56nothing else but testing a whole lot of
- 11:58[ __ ] Most of it fails. Take note of
- 12:00what actually fails and what wins, you
- 12:02start stacking a bank, a library of all
- 12:05these winning variables that you can
- 12:07translate into every single new concept
- 12:09test that you run. And ultimately, guys,
- 12:12once again, if you want to get really
- 12:13good at ads, you shouldn't be guessing
- 12:16on a lot of stuff. Ultimately,
- 12:17everything should be very scientific.
- 12:19Every once in a while, can you throw
- 12:20some random [ __ ] at the wall and it's
- 12:21going to [ __ ] work, and you're not
- 12:22going to know why. That's okay. But, the
- 12:24majority of your testing should be
- 12:26precise, and it should be deliberate,
- 12:27and there should be a reason behind
- 12:29every single little thing that you're
- 12:31testing, instead of just going on to
- 12:32like Get Hooked or whatever your
- 12:33favorite spy tool is, and just like
- 12:35ripping other brands like one-to-one. In
- 12:37my experience, and for the, you know,
- 12:39very successful brand owners way more
- 12:40successful than me that I speak to
- 12:42literally on a weekly basis, their
- 12:44biggest winners ever are usually not the
- 12:46swipes. Sometimes swipes will do okay,
- 12:48but it'll be another data point for
- 12:50them. Sometimes for me, swipes
- 12:51traditionally don't beat my controls.
- 12:53So, don't be afraid to just listen and
- 12:55trust your own data, and use that to
- 12:57construct new concept tests for your
- 12:59creative testing, cuz that's truly how
- 13:01you multiply your winners. It's not
- 13:02through variations. I'm not saying
- 13:04variations are dead, because they can
- 13:05still 100% work, but they're not going
- 13:07to have to scale as this process of
- 13:09extracting winning variables. Other than
- 13:11that, guys, that's going to be it for
- 13:12this video. Thank you so much for
- 13:13watching. If you ever do want to work
- 13:15with me more closely, you can always
- 13:16apply for my mentorship program, Brand
- 13:18Builders Academy. It's first link in
- 13:19description. Other than that, see you on
- 13:20the next video. Peace.
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of you found a winning ad… now what? (how to escape the creative rat race) by Mark Builds Brands, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 3,172 words across 449 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.