٢- ولكنها تدور — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:10I have
- 0:26>> Good evening to you all.
- 0:29Welcome to the second episode of our
- 0:32series, Once Upon a Time in Science.
- 0:35We saw...In the first episode, we saw
- 0:39the beginnings of scientific thinking in
- 0:42ancient civilizations.
- 0:45Like the Assyrian civilization, ancient
- 0:48Egyptian civilization, in China, India,
- 0:51and in various parts of the world.
- 0:55But the oldest civilizations, as
- 0:57recorded and known, are the Assyrian and
- 0:59the ancient Egyptian civilization, the
- 1:01Pharaohs, the Chinese, and the Indians.
- 1:04We saw how the Indians gave us numbers
- 1:07and the Chinese gave us paper.
- 1:11The beginnings of writing for the
- 1:13Assyrians, hieroglyphics for the
- 1:15Egyptians, and some mathematics and
- 1:17geometry.
- 1:19Then the civilization that developed
- 1:22abstract scientific thinking and logic
- 1:25significantly was the Greeks, the Greek
- 1:28civilization.
- 1:30We saw many names among them whose
- 1:32influence is clear to this day: Euclid,
- 1:35Aristotle, Plato; perhaps Aristotle is
- 1:37the most prominent name.
- 1:41Among the many things they did,
- 1:45Astronomy was one.
- 1:47Astronomy naturally sparked human
- 1:50curiosity in every era.
- 1:52Especially for the ancients. Because
- 1:53they didn't know what this was. What
- 1:55stars were. What planets were.
- 1:59Aristotle, of course, is the most
- 2:01influential man.
- 2:02As we said.
- 2:05Aristotle was a student of Plato.
- 2:10But he built his own path. And Plato was
- 2:13a student of Socrates, of course, as is
- 2:15well known.
- 2:16Plato was a philosopher and had a
- 2:17spiritual side. He was, you know, a pure
- 2:20philosopher.
- 2:22His empirical approach was very limited
- 2:24or almost non-existent.
- 2:26Plato had the idea of the Platonic world
- 2:28, the world of forms. Everything you see
- 2:31on Earth has a form in the upper
- 2:33Platonic world.
- 2:36Aristotle, when he left the school...
- 2:38After a while, Plato founded his own
- 2:40school called the Peripatetics; it was
- 2:42like a portico or a corridor where they
- 2:44would walk back and forth.
- 2:47What distinguished Aristotle from Plato
- 2:49was that he started experimenting with
- 2:51his own hands; he classified living
- 2:52things.
- 2:54He would take eggs, open them, see how
- 2:56the living organism grows, and record
- 2:58his observations. He would plant crops
- 3:00and record observations.
- 3:03He observed the movement of the planets
- 3:05and recorded it, so Aristotle...He is
- 3:06the first ancient scientist; we cannot
- 3:08say scientist in the modern sense, but
- 3:10he is indeed the first ancient scientist
- 3:12.
- 3:13Naturally, he is famous as a philosopher
- 3:15, Aristotle, the master of philosophy,
- 3:17because at that time there was no such
- 3:19thing as "science," there was philosophy
- 3:21or general knowledge. You see the
- 3:23ancients specialized in everything: a
- 3:25little mechanics, a little botany, a
- 3:27little zoology, a little medicine. There
- 3:29was no such thing as science and
- 3:31scientific specialization. That would
- 3:33appear later.
- 3:35Among the things Aristotle did was look
- 3:37at the heavens, the stars, and their
- 3:39movements.
- 3:42So Aristotle said that the Earth is the
- 3:45center of the universe.
- 3:47Of course, like everyone else, not just
- 3:49him. Because, quite simply,
- 3:52The Earth isn't moving. Right now,
- 3:53intuitively, do you feel the Earth
- 3:55moving?
- 3:57The stars, the planets, and the sun are
- 4:00what move daily.
- 4:02What would make me believe that the
- 4:04Earth is moving?
- 4:05So Aristotle told you the Earth is the
- 4:07center of the universe.
- 4:09But there were other attempts saying
- 4:11that the Earth, no, is not the center of
- 4:14the universe.
- 4:16I believe Philolaus and Aristarchus of
- 4:18Samos.
- 4:20These people said, well, Aristarchus I
- 4:22think said the center of the universe
- 4:24...Was not the Earth, but a central fire
- 4:26.
- 4:28And one said that the Sun is the center
- 4:30of the universe. And these are very old
- 4:32attempts.
- 4:34But no one paid attention to them.
- 4:37Or no one gave them "weight," as we say
- 4:39, because...There was a Hellenistic
- 4:42Greek scientist, from the Hellenistic
- 4:44period, named Claudius Ptolemy.
- 4:48He came after 400 years, maybe 500 years
- 4:50.
- 4:52He didn't just say the Earth is the
- 4:53center of the universe.
- 4:55He established a complete model with
- 4:57astronomical calculations.
- 4:59Proving that the Earth is the center of
- 5:02the universe or existence.
- 5:05This man, Claudius Ptolemy, authored a
- 5:08book.
- 5:11Translated as the Almagest.
- 5:15This translation is an Arabic
- 5:16translation. Translated by someone named
- 5:19Hunayn ibn Ishaq, I believe.
- 5:22What happened to these works? The Greek
- 5:24works and the works of the Roman Empire
- 5:26behind them
- 5:29Moved to the Arab world.
- 5:33They translated, worked on, preserved,
- 5:35and expanded them before the Renaissance
- 5:38revolution began in Europe.
- 5:42The Roman Empire, as we saw in the first
- 5:45episode, split in two.
- 5:48And an emperor named Constantine went to
- 5:50the eastern part, which is
- 5:52Constantinople, or Istanbul, before it
- 5:54fell later, of course.
- 5:57So, they moved a large part of the
- 5:59science written in Latin and Greek to
- 6:02this part, Istanbul.
- 6:04So it moved to the Middle East and
- 6:07flourished there.
- 6:08We find, for example, the establishment
- 6:10of what is called the House of Wisdom in
- 6:12Baghdad.
- 6:13This House of Wisdom, ladies and
- 6:15gentlemen, was the Harvard of that time
- 6:17, the MIT of that time.
- 6:20Every genius, astronomer, physician, or
- 6:22geographer went to the House of Wisdom.
- 6:25A huge library that housed Greek and
- 6:28Roman works and such.
- 6:31And it was translated into the Arabic
- 6:33language.
- 6:34And the flourishing of Arab science
- 6:37began in medicine, geography, astronomy
- 6:41, engineering, and optics.
- 6:44The names you know: Alhazen, Al-Biruni,
- 6:47Avicenna.
- 6:48He worked on medicine and the Book of
- 6:50Healing/Canon of Medicine. It was a
- 6:52translation of the works of these Greeks
- 6:56and Romans.
- 6:59The Arabs translated and added a great
- 7:01deal to them.
- 7:02Among those things is the Almagest book
- 7:05written by Claudius Ptolemy.
- 7:10It was translated, and were it not for
- 7:11this translation, it wouldn't have moved
- 7:13to Europe later.
- 7:15Meaning, what the Arabs did was bridge
- 7:17the gap.
- 7:19Many of the original Greek and Roman
- 7:21works were unfortunately wiped out.
- 7:23The House of Wisdom was, of course,
- 7:25attacked by Hulagu and the Mongols. And
- 7:28they burned this entire library.
- 7:30They threw—it is said the river turned
- 7:32black from the number of books they
- 7:34threw into it.
- 7:36So the original works were largely lost
- 7:38, and lost even before the Mongols.
- 7:42But the translation and the movement
- 7:44that occurred among Arab scholars are
- 7:46what preserved this legacy.
- 7:49And after the fall of Constantinople, it
- 7:51headed
- 7:53Science and trade, of course, were
- 7:56moving to Sicily in Italy. And there,
- 7:58the scientific revolution or the modern
- 8:01scientific rebirth began, known as the
- 8:03Renaissance.
- 8:05The Almagest book is what made people
- 8:08believe for 2,000 years that the Earth
- 8:10is the center of the universe.
- 8:13Why, what is special about it? Because
- 8:15Ptolemy said no.
- 8:17Ptolemy provided astronomical
- 8:18calculations; he could tell you where a
- 8:20planet would be in a month.
- 8:23He could tell you when solar and lunar
- 8:24eclipses would occur. He could tell you
- 8:26why the stars appear fixed.
- 8:28He could talk to you about the summer
- 8:30and winter solstices. Navigation tables
- 8:32and the calendar.
- 8:35He provided a full-service astronomy.
- 8:39So all of these things. Any information
- 8:41you need. And the movement of planets
- 8:43and their brightness.
- 8:44I can explain them to you.
- 8:47If you assume the Earth is the center of
- 8:49the universe, the argument is sound,
- 8:51especially since Aristotle said it
- 8:52before.
- 8:54And Aristotle—well, Aristotle was sacred
- 8:57even to Arab and Muslim scholars; he was
- 9:00a very beloved figure. So everything
- 9:02Aristotle said was just, "Well,
- 9:04Aristotle said so."
- 9:07Plus, and this is perhaps more powerful
- 9:09, the Catholic Church adopted the idea
- 9:11that the Earth is the center of the
- 9:14universe as it was written in the Holy
- 9:16Bible, and you had better not say
- 9:18otherwise back in those days.
- 9:21The ages you know.
- 9:23The so-called Dark Ages.
- 9:26So they adopted Aristotle's model,
- 9:28supported by Ptolemy, and sealed by the
- 9:31Catholic Church.
- 9:33And the Earth is the center of the
- 9:35universe. Of course, why the Earth?
- 9:37Think about it: it gives humanity value
- 9:39in the universe. We are the center of
- 9:41the universe. They wanted to give man
- 9:43the center of the universe, that he is
- 9:45the basis of the universe and the
- 9:47purpose of the universe—these old ideas
- 9:49.
- 9:52After the fall of Constantinople and the
- 9:56shift of science toward Europe.
- 10:01Some of these manuscripts, which were
- 10:03translated into Arabic and some of which
- 10:05might exist in Latin, fell into the
- 10:08hands of an astronomer—who wasn't
- 10:10actually an astronomer.
- 10:12He was a Polish priest.
- 10:14In the town of Frauenburg in Poland. A
- 10:18priest, meaning he should have been the
- 10:20most...Someone who held sacred the idea
- 10:22that the Earth is the center of the
- 10:24universe, but this person would deal the
- 10:27fatal blow to the idea that the Earth is
- 10:29the center of the universe. This is
- 10:31Nicolaus Copernicus, the legendary
- 10:33revolutionary Polish astronomer. He is
- 10:36known as an astronomer now and is
- 10:38recognized as the one who started the
- 10:40scientific revolution, especially in the
- 10:43field of astronomy.
- 10:45Copernicus said, "Guys, okay.""
- 10:48Ptolemy's model explains the movement
- 10:50and brightness.""But there are other
- 10:52things it doesn't explain."
- 10:54"If the Earth is the center of the
- 10:55universe.""And the planets revolve
- 10:57around it in a perfect circle.""Of
- 11:00course, it was assumed the orbit was a
- 11:02perfect circle."
- 11:03"Then the brightness of the planet
- 11:05shouldn't change.""At any time, any
- 11:06month, or any year.""The brightness here
- 11:08is the same as here.""It's the same here
- 11:10; it's a circle."
- 11:11"But Copernicus started saying, 'No.'""
- 11:14The brightness is changing."
- 11:17"It becomes very bright.""Then it dims
- 11:19significantly.""It's impossible for this
- 11:21to be a circle."
- 11:23"Also, there is a movement.""A complex
- 11:24one.""It’s as if the Earth itself is
- 11:27moving."
- 11:28"You know when there's a car in front of
- 11:29you and you're behind it?""When you get
- 11:31closer to it and move away from it, the
- 11:33light intensity gets higher and then
- 11:35fades."
- 11:36Copernicus said, "I cannot explain this
- 11:39unless the Earth is the one moving."
- 11:43Of course, observing in Copernicus's day
- 11:46—there were no telescopes; the telescope
- 11:48would come later.
- 11:50They used astrolabes, sundials, and
- 11:52geometric and hexagonal shapes.
- 11:55Very old astronomical tools.
- 11:58Since the telescope hadn't appeared yet
- 11:59.
- 12:00And even the Arab astronomers, who added
- 12:03many observations, were used by
- 12:04Copernicus. They include Ibn al-Shatir,
- 12:07who was in what is now Syria at the time
- 12:10.
- 12:10And Nasir al-Din al-Tusi, who had built
- 12:12an observatory called the Maragheh
- 12:14Observatory, which is very important and
- 12:15located in Iran.
- 12:17And also Al-Battani and others.
- 12:19Copernicus used these observations to
- 12:22understand that the Earth is not the
- 12:24center of the universe.
- 12:27After long observations and many years,
- 12:29Copernicus said it is impossible for the
- 12:31Earth to be the center of the universe.
- 12:32"The Sun is the center."
- 12:35"And the Earth and the rest of the
- 12:37planets all revolve around the Sun." And
- 12:39just as Ptolemy did, he explained to us
- 12:41the brightness, the seasons, and the
- 12:43summer and winter solstices.
- 12:45And when eclipses occur, Copernicus
- 12:47explained all of this—and better.
- 12:50But Copernicus could not publish this
- 12:53information.
- 12:55Because the Church would, you know,
- 12:57finish him off.
- 13:00The Earth was still the center of the
- 13:01universe. This is something sacred.
- 13:04Now, this man is using his mind. He
- 13:06discovers that the Earth is not the
- 13:07center of the universe.
- 13:09After 13 years of all these observations
- 13:12, he wrote a book called "On the
- 13:14Revolutions of the Heavenly Spheres."
- 13:17But when he wrote this book and finished
- 13:20it, he was very old and near death.
- 13:23And he was afraid throughout that entire
- 13:25time to publish it.
- 13:26So he gave it to another priest or
- 13:28publisher and told him, "You publish it
- 13:30."
- 13:32This priest was also afraid, so he wrote
- 13:34in the introduction that, folks,
- 13:36Copernicus's model is just a good tool
- 13:38for observation.
- 13:39No one should take it literally; it
- 13:41doesn't mean the Earth is the center of
- 13:43the universe.
- 13:44It is just for navigation, calendars,
- 13:46things like that, and seasons; a good
- 13:48tool for observation.
- 13:50He wrote these words in the introduction
- 13:52of the book. Unfortunately, this
- 13:54publisher wrote those words as if
- 13:55Copernicus had said them.
- 13:58So he lied in Copernicus's name, and
- 13:59this is a bad thing. Copernicus did not
- 14:01write those words. So it delayed the
- 14:04Copernican revolution a little.
- 14:07After Copernicus, there was a great
- 14:09Danish astronomer named Tycho Brahe. He
- 14:12built an observatory on an island in
- 14:14Denmark.
- 14:15An island located between Denmark and
- 14:18Sweden, I believe.
- 14:20I must mention that when I was in
- 14:21Germany, I wanted to visit it to see it
- 14:23. But it didn't happen; the island is a
- 14:27bit far.
- 14:28He built an observatory there. It is
- 14:30considered one of the most important
- 14:32observatories in ancient astronomical
- 14:34history.
- 14:37He recorded tons of observations:
- 14:38positions of stars, their movement,
- 14:40their altitude, when they shine, when
- 14:42they dim, huge quantities.
- 14:44Let us remember, ladies and gentlemen,
- 14:45that astronomy at that time was not like
- 14:47now.
- 14:48You now immediately think of the sun
- 14:49with planets orbiting it, which you
- 14:51learned in school.
- 14:52But the subject was not that simple.
- 14:55Also, not to mention the sanctification
- 14:56of the idea that the Earth is the center
- 14:57of the universe.
- 14:59Tycho Brahe collected a huge amount of
- 15:02data.
- 15:03He said neither Ptolemy's model is
- 15:05correct, nor Copernicus's model.
- 15:10Let us take a middle ground based on his
- 15:12astronomical observations, not on mood.
- 15:14He said, "Okay, the Earth is the center
- 15:16of the universe, that's correct."
- 15:18"And the sun and the moon orbit the
- 15:20Earth.""But the rest of the planets
- 15:23orbit the sun."
- 15:25Meaning he wants to please both sides. I
- 15:26don't know if he wanted to please both.
- 15:28He believed that this aligns with his
- 15:30massive astronomical observations.
- 15:33So, okay, the Earth is the center of the
- 15:34universe, but not everything orbits it.
- 15:35Around it, some things orbit the sun,
- 15:38which orbits the Earth—Coper...Coper...
- 15:40Brahe.
- 15:43On his deathbed, he handed his data and
- 15:45huge information to an assistant of his
- 15:47.
- 15:48And as we say, it fell into the right
- 15:50hands. It reached the right hands 100%.
- 15:54The assistant to whom Tycho Brahe gave
- 15:57all this data or astronomical
- 15:59information is named Johannes Kepler.
- 16:03The great German astronomer, one of the
- 16:06most prominent faces in science and
- 16:08astronomy.
- 16:12One of the giants upon whose shoulders
- 16:14Isaac Newton would later stand.
- 16:17Kepler is a German astronomer.
- 16:21He suffered from a difficult childhood,
- 16:23poverty.
- 16:25And even when he grew up, his children
- 16:28died; his life was very hard and he was
- 16:31sickly, but he was a very, very genius.
- 16:34Kepler took all of Tycho Brahe's
- 16:36information and studied it for maybe 20
- 16:39years with immense precision.
- 16:42Kepler discovered that the orbit—even if
- 16:45we said the Earth is the center of the
- 16:48universe—the orbit cannot be a perfect
- 16:51circle, but rather oval.
- 16:55Not a circle, an ellipse. A compressed
- 16:57circle; if you press it from top and
- 16:59bottom, it becomes oval-shaped. Why does
- 17:01he say it’s clearly changing?
- 17:04The planet reaches a certain point and
- 17:07dims,
- 17:10then its brightness increases. Something
- 17:12is moving closer and further in an
- 17:13elliptical shape.
- 17:14He also saw that the planet's orbit on
- 17:17one side of the sun lags by eight
- 17:20minutes compared to the other side. This
- 17:23would be impossible if the orbit were
- 17:24circular.
- 17:26A circular orbit means that whenever you
- 17:27measure, it should be eight minutes at
- 17:29any time.
- 17:31But when the orbit is elliptical, the
- 17:33orbit on the other side becomes longer
- 17:36than when it is near the sun.
- 17:41He keeps collecting and collecting until
- 17:44he discovers three important laws that
- 17:47are still taught in schools today:
- 17:49Kepler's laws.
- 17:52The first law is that Earth or the
- 17:54orbits around the sun are elliptical,
- 17:56not circular.
- 17:59The second law is that the planet
- 18:01orbiting the sun sweeps out equal areas
- 18:04during equal times.
- 18:06It sweeps......sweeps equal distances in
- 18:09equal times, all through calculation.
- 18:12The third law concerns the distance and
- 18:14the time it takes for a planet to orbit
- 18:16the sun.
- 18:18That the cube of the time is
- 18:19proportional to, or the square of the
- 18:21time is proportional to the cube of the
- 18:23distance.
- 18:25And whoever wants to derive Kepler's
- 18:27laws mathematically and see them in
- 18:28terms of math, follow my lectures on
- 18:30physics from scratch.
- 18:32The lectures dedicated to Kepler's laws
- 18:34are a mathematical derivation.
- 18:37Kepler is a very revolutionary person
- 18:40now. He moves to mathematics, applying
- 18:42math to astronomy.
- 18:45So Kepler, I mean, finished it. This
- 18:49matter, Kepler is saying it’s impossible
- 18:51that Earth is the center of the universe
- 18:53.
- 18:54Of course, they didn't know what the
- 18:55universe was. You see, they still
- 18:56thought it was this small distance they
- 18:58could see with the eye. They thought the
- 19:00universe was just these few stars and
- 19:01planets.
- 19:02Of course, there was no Hubble telescope
- 19:04like we have. And we are talking about
- 19:07the 1500s back then. In the 16th century
- 19:11,
- 19:15Kepler deals the death blow to the idea
- 19:18that Earth is the center of the universe
- 19:21.
- 19:22What Kepler did was a revolutionary act
- 19:24. He published it in a book called "The
- 19:25Harmony of the World."
- 19:28One of the key books in astronomy.
- 19:33Unfortunately. Few accepted Kepler's
- 19:35work for two reasons. First, it was very
- 19:39difficult; what he did was revolutionary
- 19:41, talking about mathematics and areas.
- 19:45Secondly, it meant that if his words
- 19:47were true, the Earth was not the center
- 19:50of the universe.
- 19:52So many denied his work, but
- 19:54unfortunately, one of those who denied
- 19:56him is the next legend.
- 19:59One of those who denied Kepler was
- 20:02Galileo Galilei.
- 20:05Galileo Galilei, ladies and gentlemen.
- 20:08This man is the first scientist in the
- 20:11modern sense.
- 20:13When you say a scientist in the sense
- 20:15you understand, it is Galileo.
- 20:17We cannot call Aristotle a scientist in
- 20:19the modern sense; a scientist in the...
- 20:21...old sense, yes. Even Kepler, despite
- 20:23everything he did in astronomy, had some
- 20:25spirituality.
- 20:27For example, he believed that when
- 20:29planets moved, they produced music or
- 20:31melodies.
- 20:34So he had spirituality and also the
- 20:36triangle model.
- 20:38Despite his genius, he still had an
- 20:41emotion connected to the universe.
- 20:45Or he projected his personality onto the
- 20:47universe.
- 20:49The one who completely separated human
- 20:52emotions from reality was Galileo
- 20:54Galilei. And he is titled the father of
- 20:57modern science.
- 20:58And it is a title that Galileo deserves
- 21:00.
- 21:01Galileo and Kepler, unfortunately, were
- 21:03not in agreement. Perhaps because of
- 21:04jealousy.
- 21:06This is something natural and expected
- 21:08even among scientists. This one is
- 21:10legendary in astronomy. And this one
- 21:11will also become legendary in astronomy
- 21:13. So they were not compatible. Even
- 21:15though if they had cooperated, the
- 21:16matter would have ended earlier. I mean
- 21:18.
- 21:20Galileo would no longer measure the
- 21:22stars with an astrolabe or anything. No
- 21:26, Galileo would invent the telescope.
- 21:29The first person to invent the telescope
- 21:31wanted to see what was out there.
- 21:35So he made the first telescope, Galileo
- 21:37, and started looking.
- 21:40He pointed it toward Jupiter.
- 21:43He saw that there were moons orbiting
- 21:44Jupiter. This meant not everything
- 21:46orbits the Earth. The matter was settled
- 21:48just by looking. No need for math or
- 21:50anything else.
- 21:51If everything orbited the Earth, how
- 21:53could Jupiter's moons orbit Jupiter?
- 21:56He directs it at Saturn and sees rings.
- 21:59Of course, note that at the time, they
- 22:01believed the creation of planets was
- 22:03perfect.
- 22:04Perfect circles orbiting in perfect
- 22:06circles around the Earth.
- 22:10Ptolemy’s model was complicated and
- 22:12messy. I mean, circles within circles
- 22:14within circles. The whole thing was very
- 22:16complex.
- 22:18We saw Kepler go slightly off-track when
- 22:20he said they weren't circles. But rather
- 22:23, the movement of planets is elliptical
- 22:25. Galileo was aware of that.
- 22:28But he started seeing things that
- 22:29weren't "perfect," so to speak. Galileo
- 22:31was fascinated by circular motion. He
- 22:33didn't really like elliptical motion. He
- 22:36was like all the other astronomers at
- 22:38the time.
- 22:40He set it up and saw the moon. No,
- 22:42things got bigger.
- 22:44The moon is ugly, full of craters and
- 22:47hills and valleys.
- 22:50Even today, when someone wants to flirt
- 22:51, they compare their beloved to the moon
- 22:53. But the moon isn't actually pretty.
- 22:55If you look closely, it’s all craters,
- 22:58ridges, and...Maybe it’s because of that
- 23:01, I don't know the reason for poets. But
- 23:03in any case, he discovered it was jagged
- 23:06and not perfect.
- 23:08They thought it was a perfect circle.
- 23:10He even started looking at the sun. This
- 23:12is dangerous and could cause blindness,
- 23:14so he looked cautiously.
- 23:17And he saw spots on the sun that weren't
- 23:19perfect.
- 23:21Saturn, what are these rings?
- 23:24Galileo ruined everything. I mean, what
- 23:27Ptolemy said wasn't correct. Not even
- 23:30Kepler knew there were these
- 23:31irregularities. This is because he built
- 23:33a telescope and started seeing through
- 23:34it.
- 23:36He also started collecting astronomical
- 23:38observations.
- 23:40And he discovered that, indeed, the
- 23:41Earth is not the center of the universe
- 23:43.
- 23:44Of course, he would say Copernicus
- 23:46stated this. He wouldn't mention Kepler
- 23:48because of jealousy.
- 23:50He says, yes, the moon orbits the Earth
- 23:53. And the Earth orbits the sun, along
- 23:55with the rest of the planets.
- 23:57But what was Galileo's problem in Rome,
- 23:59in the heart of the Catholic Church?
- 24:03I mean, if you're brave enough, go
- 24:04declare that at the time.
- 24:07But Galileo, in addition to being a
- 24:09scientist, was also brave. Or maybe he
- 24:11was just saying, "This is the reality,
- 24:13what can I do?"
- 24:15So he published his words in a book
- 24:17called "Dialogue Concerning the Two
- 24:19Chief World Systems."
- 24:22It was in the form of a dialogue, with a
- 24:23character representing Aristotle, and a
- 24:25character representing Copernicus.
- 24:26The one representing Aristotle was a bit
- 24:29ignorant. And the one representing
- 24:31Copernicus was understanding and
- 24:32knowledgeable. Of course, Galileo wasn't
- 24:34just a scientist. He was a science
- 24:35popularizer. And this was also a reason
- 24:38for his fame. He would talk to people
- 24:39and write books for them.
- 24:42He is considered not just the first
- 24:44scientist, but also the first science
- 24:45communicator. Galileo published these
- 24:47words in his book "Dialogue Concerning
- 24:49the Two Chief World Systems." And he
- 24:50fell into the hands of the Church.
- 24:52They told him, "Come here, we have a
- 24:54judgment."
- 24:55Galileo, you all know this story.
- 24:59They made him get on his knees and
- 25:01apologize.
- 25:02And say that the Earth is not the center
- 25:03of the universe.
- 25:05And there is a famous story that says
- 25:07after he said that, he whispered to
- 25:09himself, "And yet it moves."
- 25:11I don't know if that's true or not, of
- 25:12course. If he said it, it came from the
- 25:15symbolic stories he knew. Legends are
- 25:18always spun around these historical
- 25:21figures.
- 25:23But he was judged, and of course, he was
- 25:26not executed, Galileo. Some of you might
- 25:28think he was executed. He was sentenced
- 25:30to house arrest in his home. He could
- 25:32not leave Florence. I believe he had a
- 25:35daughter, and she passed away.
- 25:40He lived the rest of his life as an old
- 25:42man, completely isolated from people.
- 25:45But he wrote another book called Two New
- 25:47Sciences.
- 25:49It was the foundation of modern physics
- 25:51.
- 25:53If you think that this alone is
- 25:54Galileo’s only achievement, you are
- 25:56mistaken, but. This was enough to give
- 25:58him the status he has. But Galileo was
- 26:00more than just that. Galileo was the one
- 26:02who started physics.
- 26:04Aristotle also said that heavy objects
- 26:07fall faster than light ones.
- 26:11Once again, he was relying on his
- 26:12intuition. Intuition, ladies and
- 26:14gentlemen, is always wrong.
- 26:16I mean, intuition tells you that the sun
- 26:18moves. But the Earth revolves around its
- 26:20axis.
- 26:21Intuition tells you that the stars are
- 26:23fixed in the sky. Intuition tells you
- 26:25that these stars are where they are now
- 26:26.
- 26:27It all ends. Human intuition is simple.
- 26:30Humans evolved from. Their ancestors to
- 26:33reproduce, eat, drink, and sleep.
- 26:36Not to discover that the Earth is the
- 26:38center of the universe.
- 26:40Nor to discover elements or minerals.
- 26:44As we saw, the hunter-gatherer human did
- 26:46not have time to think about these
- 26:47things. That came after civilizations
- 26:49and the securing of food, sleep, and
- 26:51safety. This is natural.
- 26:55So. If you rely on your senses to
- 26:57understand the world—what I see is true
- 26:59, what I hear, what I smell—then you are
- 27:021,000 years behind.
- 27:05Today, the James Webb Telescope is
- 27:07seeing the beginnings of the Big Bang
- 27:10and the oldest galaxies.
- 27:13Today, a chemist will not rely on their
- 27:15sense of smell.
- 27:17As for hearing, you cannot hear
- 27:18ultrasonic or infrasonic waves, and your
- 27:20eyes only see visible light; everything
- 27:22else is done with instruments.
- 27:25Galileo was one of the first people to
- 27:27create these tools, like the telescope—
- 27:30a word that means bringing the distant
- 27:32closer—and the microscope, which is the
- 27:35opposite. Magnifying the small.
- 27:38Anyway. Galileo was an experimental
- 27:41scientist in every sense of the word.
- 27:43Aristotle said the Earth is the center.
- 27:45That was destroyed now. Aristotle said
- 27:47heavy objects fall before light ones.
- 27:50Okay, let’s test it. You know the famous
- 27:52experiment, he went up the Tower of Pisa
- 27:54and dropped two things. Of course, this
- 27:57experiment likely never happened, as it
- 27:59is one of the myths that are told, but
- 28:01he saw that objects fall together.
- 28:04If you dropped.
- 28:07An elephant and a piece of foam, and
- 28:09ignored the air, they would fall
- 28:11together.
- 28:13Why?
- 28:14Einstein would come many years later.
- 28:16And explain it.
- 28:18But right in front of us, what we are
- 28:21seeing now, they fall at the same time.
- 28:25If we ignore air resistance. Of course,
- 28:27Galileo didn’t do that experiment
- 28:28perhaps.
- 28:29What he did was bring curved surfaces
- 28:31and started placing balls on them,
- 28:34letting them roll, and recording the
- 28:36time it took for the ball to fall.
- 28:40He discovered a relationship between the
- 28:42time elapsed and the distance; the
- 28:44square of the time is proportional to
- 28:46the distance.
- 28:48This means the falling object gains
- 28:50additional speed as it falls.
- 28:54He discovered, ladies and gentlemen,
- 28:57acceleration. Now, when you drop
- 29:00something from up there, there is an
- 29:02acceleration of 9.8 meters per second
- 29:05squared, okay? This means your speed
- 29:08increases every second by about 10. And
- 29:11this makes the falling object increase
- 29:13its speed in a crazy way.
- 29:15If, if it were. Things fall at a
- 29:17constant speed before they are damaged
- 29:19upon hitting the ground, but in reality
- 29:21, they accelerate, adding speed upon
- 29:23speed, at a crazy speed.
- 29:25And that is what is called acceleration
- 29:27.
- 29:30That's not all Galileo discovered.
- 29:34Before, they used to say if the Earth
- 29:36moves.
- 29:37I mean, imagine the Earth is moving. If
- 29:39an apple fell from a tree, it shouldn't
- 29:41fall straight down. It should fall to
- 29:43the side, like if you throw. Something
- 29:45from a car while you are moving.
- 29:47The ancients used to say if the Earth
- 29:48moves. The air should hit us hard, like
- 29:51in a car.
- 29:53Galileo was the one who discovered what
- 29:56is called inertia.
- 29:58Which would be Newton's first law.
- 30:03Galileo said the natural state of a body
- 30:04isn't. Moving, actually it isn't fixed;
- 30:08simply put, when you are in a plane
- 30:11moving at a very high speed, you eat
- 30:14normally inside the plane, even though
- 30:17it's moving at 700, 800 kilometers per
- 30:21hour.
- 30:22Something terrible if you were to go out
- 30:25. Out of the plane, you would fly away.
- 30:27But you behave normally inside the plane
- 30:30. The reason is inertia.
- 30:33So, naturally, the apple won't fall to
- 30:34the side. Nor will there be wind there.
- 30:36We are naturally inert.
- 30:41When you drive a car, you set a certain
- 30:44speed.
- 30:46If we closed. The windows on you and
- 30:48turned off the engine sound. You
- 30:49wouldn't know if you are moving or
- 30:51stationary. Literally, you wouldn't know
- 30:53. A natural behavior called the
- 30:55principle. Of inertia, which is the
- 30:57foundation of physics, that Isaac Newton
- 31:00would later describe in his three
- 31:02well-known laws. Galileo studied the
- 31:05motion of the pendulum, and let's note,
- 31:08gentlemen, that in Galileo's days, when
- 31:11he was calculating the speed of a ball,
- 31:13there were no watches, no Apple Watches
- 31:16; he relied on his heartbeat or the
- 31:19motion of the pendulum—meaning he was
- 31:21also one of the first people to think in
- 31:24seconds, like, how do you calculate it?
- 31:28Galileo also, as we will see later, had
- 31:29attempts to calculate the speed of light
- 31:31. Even though, of course, the number was
- 31:33entirely wrong.
- 31:36But this man started the science of
- 31:38physics itself, with this great Italian
- 31:41scientist, Galileo.
- 31:43Galileo is titled the father of modern
- 31:46science.
- 31:49This Galileo, and even a bit of Kepler.
- 31:54And others as well.
- 31:57Some of them, like Descartes, for
- 31:58example, and Francis Bacon the
- 32:00philosopher.
- 32:03They didn't just start a revolution in
- 32:04discoveries; they started a revolution
- 32:06in the way of thinking. In this
- 32:08Renaissance, there became a willingness
- 32:10to admit ignorance, that we don't know.
- 32:13Before that, no, we knew everything.
- 32:15What do you want? The Earth, Aristotle
- 32:16said, the church said.
- 32:18Meaning, at that time, a simple person
- 32:20who wanted to know something would go
- 32:21ask a clergyman.
- 32:23How does the Earth move? The clergyman.
- 32:26Did you get sick? The clergyman.
- 32:29What do you want?
- 32:31Plants, insects, the origin of plants,
- 32:33you ask the clergyman, and there was a
- 32:35belief that everything important in the
- 32:37world we already knew; the rest were
- 32:38trivialities we didn't need.
- 32:41But science is the first revolution. The
- 32:44revolution of science is a revolution of
- 32:45admitting ignorance. A revolution of
- 32:47discovering ignorance. We discovered.
- 32:49That we know nothing, literally we know
- 32:51nothing; we discovered that Aristotle,
- 32:53true, said many beautiful things, but he
- 32:56erred a lot; we discovered that there is
- 32:58no sanctity for any person.
- 33:02For 2000 years, the Ptolemaic and
- 33:04Aristotelian model was dismantled by
- 33:06observations.
- 33:08Meaning, what happened in the age? The
- 33:10Renaissance, before they would wish for
- 33:12something and go try to prove it. "The
- 33:15Earth is the center of the universe," so
- 33:16let's go prove that idea. Which is
- 33:17purely imaginary on your part.
- 33:19The situation changed. Francis Bacon, an
- 33:21English philosopher, says we must
- 33:22observe first. Induction; we observe and
- 33:25collect many observations. Then we
- 33:27interpret what we saw. Not interpreting
- 33:28based on our whims.
- 33:30Also, being prepared to admit that
- 33:32everything we had was wrong. Or a large
- 33:34part of it is wrong.
- 33:36Being prepared to say we don't know.
- 33:40Man admits his ignorance, ladies and
- 33:41gentlemen.
- 33:43This is what made science soar.
- 33:45Admitting ignorance.
- 33:48I am prepared to say.
- 33:50That I have a model or observations that
- 33:54might be wrong, I am prepared.
- 33:59That even the idea that the Earth is the
- 34:01center of the universe—meaning before
- 34:02Kepler they believed the Earth was the
- 34:04center of the universe—we are also
- 34:06prepared to say that this idea is wrong
- 34:07, and it is indeed wrong; the Earth is
- 34:09not the center of the universe.
- 34:11The Earth, I mean, it’s not even an
- 34:13extra in the universe.
- 34:15It is not the center of the Milky Way
- 34:17galaxy. Just something thrown in. A
- 34:18corner of the Milky Way.
- 34:22The scientific revolution, ladies and
- 34:23gentlemen, is a revolution of admitting
- 34:24ignorance.
- 34:27This is the Renaissance with its known
- 34:30figures: Kepler, Galileo, Brahe, Newton
- 34:34—we will see them and those after them
- 34:38to this day. Science is based on this
- 34:42method. Meaning, I don't wait for when
- 34:45science works, I. Wait for when science
- 34:48doesn't work, to discover more.
- 34:51I wait for when quantum mechanics
- 34:53doesn't work, to discover something.
- 34:56Deeper.
- 34:57Sanctity is removed entirely. There is
- 34:59no such thing as "Aristotle said.""
- 35:00Newton said.""Einstein said."
- 35:03There is no such thing as the final
- 35:05scientist.
- 35:06It's over.
- 35:07This topic, in fact, I received a call
- 35:09that broke my train of thought.
- 35:12Anyway, thank you, and I will meet you
- 35:14in the next episode.
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of ٢- ولكنها تدور by يوسف البناي, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 5,258 words across 925 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.