YouTube2Text

⚡НАБУ, СБУ і Хімпром. Розвідник Червінський назвав головне ім'я! — Transcript

by Yanina Sokolova · 9,096 words · 1,460 segments · language en · Watch on YouTube

Full transcript

  1. 0:00How could the top officials of the state
  2. 0:02—and I’ll remind you that the Security
  3. 0:04Service of Ukraine reports directly to
  4. 0:06the President—not know about this?
  5. 0:09>> What you’re talking about, I believe
  6. 0:11Tatarov knew personally.
  7. 0:14I don’t even rule out that he could have
  8. 0:16been gaining financial benefits from it
  9. 0:17.
  10. 0:19Burkin was carrying out tasks for
  11. 0:21Russian special services to implement
  12. 0:23Putin's plan to seize Ukraine through
  13. 0:25discredit on a global level, on the
  14. 0:27world stage.
  15. 0:28>> What are they waiting for? That NABU and
  16. 0:30the ISA are working for the Americans?
  17. 0:38Roman Chervinsky, a Ukrainian
  18. 0:40intelligence officer—a legendary one, I
  19. 0:42would say—is here with me.
  20. 0:46And as you’ve already understood, today
  21. 0:48we will talk about the SBU, about "
  22. 0:50Carthage," and why this became possible
  23. 0:52and whether it could happen without the
  24. 0:54knowledge of the state's top officials.
  25. 1:04Roman, when we, the entire Ukrainian
  26. 1:06society, listened to the "Carthage"
  27. 1:08tapes from NABU, a question naturally
  28. 1:10arises: this system, where the SBU, the
  29. 1:13National Police, and criminal figures (
  30. 1:15one of whom holds Russian Federation
  31. 1:17citizenship) cooperate on issues ranging
  32. 1:19from drug production to beating people
  33. 1:21and producing counterfeit euro bills—
  34. 1:23what else was there?
  35. 1:29What else was there regarding the drug
  36. 1:31trade? Well, it’s...it’s not drugs, the
  37. 1:34drug-related topic.
  38. 1:38And the creation of channels through
  39. 1:40which money quite likely flowed,
  40. 1:41potentially reaching the Office of the
  41. 1:43President, because for Ukrainians—I
  42. 1:45think for many—the question is, how
  43. 1:47could the top officials of the state—
  44. 1:49and I’ll remind you the Security Service
  45. 1:51of Ukraine reports directly to the
  46. 1:52President—not know about this?
  47. 1:58Well, we have this question after every
  48. 2:00set of tapes, from "Dynasty" to "
  49. 2:02Carthage."
  50. 2:05The President spent several days
  51. 2:06deciding whether to speak about it in
  52. 2:08his evening address.
  53. 2:10He eventually decided and said that the
  54. 2:12law needs to be changed.
  55. 2:15And, well, a law is already being
  56. 2:17submitted for a vote, where there will
  57. 2:19be financial disclosure for Security
  58. 2:20Service of Ukraine employees, and we’ll
  59. 2:22be able to understand how they live and
  60. 2:24what they live on.
  61. 2:30And this looks like a reaction to the
  62. 2:32apartments with crocodiles, but in
  63. 2:34reality, it won’t change anything,
  64. 2:35because a lion's share of Ukrainian
  65. 2:37officials simply declare their assets
  66. 2:39dishonestly and find 25 ways to hide
  67. 2:41what they have, often doing so
  68. 2:43successfully.
  69. 2:48What is this story even about?
  70. 2:51And my first question is: is it possible
  71. 2:53to carry out such operations without the
  72. 2:55knowledge of the Office of the President
  73. 2:56and the President of the country?
  74. 2:59You saw that they were being carried out
  75. 3:01for years. Meaning, this isn't a story
  76. 3:04from '25 or '26; it’s a story that went
  77. 3:07on since at least 2020 or 2021.
  78. 3:11And this system has always existed; it’s
  79. 3:13just that such cases hadn't been exposed
  80. 3:15before.
  81. 3:18Or is this some kind of innovation that
  82. 3:20emerged from 2019, when Zelensky became
  83. 3:22president and created such a vertical?
  84. 3:26>> Thank you, that’s a good question.
  85. 3:29I want to divide it immediately into two
  86. 3:31parts.
  87. 3:32First, could the Office of the President
  88. 3:34have known about this?
  89. 3:36And second, well, what was the SBU doing
  90. 3:38and does that mean the Office of the
  91. 3:40President knew about it, right? That is
  92. 3:42, the responsibility of the SBU and the
  93. 3:44responsibility of the Office of the
  94. 3:46President are two separate institutions
  95. 3:48that, in principle, have different
  96. 3:50functions, different tasks, and
  97. 3:51different powers, and different people
  98. 3:53work there. I mean, the SBU consists of
  99. 3:56operatives who have spent their whole
  100. 3:58lives doing operational work, tracking
  101. 4:00criminals, exposing and documenting them
  102. 4:03, fighting the Russians, conducting
  103. 4:05operations on enemy territory, and who
  104. 4:07understand what recruitment is, what
  105. 4:09recruitment based on financial
  106. 4:11dependence is, and so on. The Office of
  107. 4:13the President deals with our
  108. 4:15geopolitical issues, international
  109. 4:17negotiations, the economy, and personnel
  110. 4:19policy.
  111. 4:20>> should deal with Roman, he must.
  112. 4:22>> He must deal with it.
  113. 4:25>> Kyrylo Budanov should not have to come
  114. 4:27to Petropavlivska Borshchahivka to deal
  115. 4:28with the National Guard issue and the
  116. 4:30presence of men there who are AWOL.
  117. 4:34>> Borshchahivka, that was perhaps his
  118. 4:36personal desire or the president's
  119. 4:37request, but his functional duties are
  120. 4:40clearly defined. That is, he knows what
  121. 4:41he is doing and what he is responsible
  122. 4:43for. I would like us to learn in our
  123. 4:45country to hold a person accountable for
  124. 4:47what they are obligated to answer for,
  125. 4:48and then they won't be able to say that
  126. 4:50I didn't know, couldn't, or didn't want
  127. 4:52to, or couldn't have known, for example
  128. 4:53, right? That is why these questions
  129. 4:55will then disappear, questions like
  130. 4:57yours. I understand that we are speaking
  131. 4:59with you and ordinary people are hearing
  132. 5:01us. However, as a specialist in these
  133. 5:03areas, we clearly distinguish between
  134. 5:05these issues. Because, in reality, not
  135. 5:07all information that circulates within
  136. 5:09the Security Service of Ukraine reaches
  137. 5:10the Office of the President. It is clear
  138. 5:12that some of it penetrates there, it
  139. 5:14somehow gets there, it knocks, but the
  140. 5:17president or even Yermak, for example,
  141. 5:19would not be able to professionally
  142. 5:21verify it. However, in the Office of the
  143. 5:23President, there is a certain Tatarov,
  144. 5:26Oleh Yuriyovych, who 100%knew this, who
  145. 5:29100%appointed Malyuk to his position.
  146. 5:31Even in my own case, which you have
  147. 5:33talked about a lot and know about, the
  148. 5:35investigator even told me personally
  149. 5:37that Tatarov initiated this case, Malyuk
  150. 5:39saluted, the investigator carried it out
  151. 5:41, and the head of the investigative body
  152. 5:43was given a position for it accordingly
  153. 5:45. That is, this person, Tatarov, delves
  154. 5:47into all minor issues on behalf of the
  155. 5:49Office of the President. So, what you
  156. 5:50are talking about, Tatarov personally
  157. 5:53knew, I think.
  158. 5:57I don't even rule out that he could have
  159. 5:59had financial gain from it, as, in
  160. 6:01principle, someone who protected Malyuk
  161. 6:03in this position and who, let's say,
  162. 6:05coordinates the policy of our legal and
  163. 6:08judicial system in the interests of the
  164. 6:10President's Office.
  165. 6:14So, we can also make a distinction here
  166. 6:16: the Office might know, but perhaps
  167. 6:18only Tatarov truly knew, because he is
  168. 6:20involved and has experience in
  169. 6:22operational and investigative work, that
  170. 6:24is, working in a law enforcement agency
  171. 6:26. Therefore, I believe that all
  172. 6:28responsibility, even in this case, lies
  173. 6:30with the Security Service of Ukraine,
  174. 6:31because in reality, it has always been
  175. 6:33like that—perhaps it’s the same for a
  176. 6:35special service as it is for the Main
  177. 6:37Intelligence Directorate of the Ministry
  178. 6:39of Defense.
  179. 6:40People who go through such a sieve to
  180. 6:42enter the service are supposed to have
  181. 6:44higher moral values, superior
  182. 6:46professional qualities, and should be
  183. 6:48people who wouldn't allow themselves to
  184. 6:50act like that.
  185. 6:51That is why no one could have expected
  186. 6:53this, and no one could have, let's say,
  187. 6:55predicted that such things could happen
  188. 6:57at the very core of a special service
  189. 6:59that fights, not just against internal
  190. 7:01enemies, but is counterintelligence,
  191. 7:03right? This is the highest level of law
  192. 7:05enforcement activity—
  193. 7:06counterintelligence. I mean, you could
  194. 7:08be documenting a Russian spy, but at the
  195. 7:10final stage, you might have to make a
  196. 7:12decision. You either arrest them and put
  197. 7:15them in prison, or you flip them, and
  198. 7:17they start working for Ukraine,
  199. 7:19providing more value in that context.
  200. 7:21For that, you need a high level of
  201. 7:23professionalism, knowledge, and an
  202. 7:25understanding of people and their
  203. 7:26psychology.
  204. 7:28You can't have someone who is dealing
  205. 7:30drugs here today, or killing people, or
  206. 7:32maiming people with the help of
  207. 7:34criminals, go out and successfully flip
  208. 7:36a foreign spy or diplomat.
  209. 7:39That’s why no one expected this, right?
  210. 7:42And this guilt, let’s say, that formed
  211. 7:45within the SBU's "K" units—they allowed
  212. 7:47themselves to do this, while the SBU
  213. 7:49leadership, meaning Malyuk and those he
  214. 7:52gathered around him today, all the
  215. 7:54deputies he effectively appointed, he
  216. 7:56chose such people for the highest
  217. 7:58positions in the SBU.
  218. 8:00>> Why are Roman and I talking about Malyuk
  219. 8:02right now? Because the actions described
  220. 8:05in the Carthage tapes took place under
  221. 8:06Malyuk. Right now it’s Poklad, but all
  222. 8:09of this unfolded under Malyuk.
  223. 8:10>> First of all, it was under Malyuk, and
  224. 8:12secondly, it’s his specialty. I mean, he
  225. 8:14is a man who clearly knew what the crime
  226. 8:16situation was and what criminal agency
  227. 8:18from the criminal environment was.
  228. 8:20Poklad knew the same thing, first of all
  229. 8:22. And secondly, we see that the Russian
  230. 8:24special services—I believe Burkin is a
  231. 8:26representative of the Russian special
  232. 8:27services. At a minimum, he collaborates
  233. 8:29with them, and at most, he carries out
  234. 8:31their tasks and instructions. And the
  235. 8:33fact that he is now trying, yes, to
  236. 8:35broadcast all this on air and show it,
  237. 8:37is all work for the Russian secret
  238. 8:39services.
  239. 8:39>> Well, Burkin, or the Mexican, hasn't
  240. 8:42said anything. It was Mr. Sokolov who
  241. 8:44spoke. The Mexican hasn't said anything
  242. 8:46yet.
  243. 8:47But, perhaps by the time it airs he
  244. 8:49might say something, but as of now, he
  245. 8:51hasn't said anything.
  246. 8:53And, as far as I know, he was being
  247. 8:55persecuted in the Russian Federation,
  248. 8:56according to the legend.
  249. 8:58>> Yes, that could be.
  250. 8:59>> And that is why it is unclear, by the
  251. 9:01way, if he is even here at all, because
  252. 9:03he hasn't been caught. The Mexican
  253. 9:05hasn't been caught.
  254. 9:05>> Well, do you mean in Ukraine? Well, he
  255. 9:07is definitely not in Ukraine. He is
  256. 9:09abroad. He left back in the day when
  257. 9:10they started persecuting him, during the
  258. 9:12Poroshenko era, by the way, and that's
  259. 9:13when it all started. In reality, this is
  260. 9:15just a standard drug system, a drug
  261. 9:17syndicate, a drug network that could
  262. 9:20have been taken down in, well, six
  263. 9:22months of work. If you approach it
  264. 9:24professionally, if there is a task to do
  265. 9:26it, then it is clear it is very easy to
  266. 9:28do, because this doesn't happen without
  267. 9:30the knowledge of law enforcement
  268. 9:31agencies and without their involvement.
  269. 9:34Every professional fighting drug
  270. 9:35trafficking, international drug
  271. 9:37trafficking, clearly realizes and
  272. 9:39understands this. So, despite what he
  273. 9:42says, what he didn't say, the tapes we
  274. 9:44have today clearly state what he says.
  275. 9:46He says, "I cooperate with the FSB.""I
  276. 9:49provide them with services, I am in
  277. 9:51constant contact with them.""They ask me
  278. 9:53for this, they ask me for that." This
  279. 9:54speaks to a professional contact between
  280. 9:56Burkin and the FSB. And imagine that the
  281. 9:58SBU counterintelligence, which should be
  282. 10:00detecting representatives of Russian
  283. 10:02secret services in our network, in our
  284. 10:04Ukrainian society, is itself financially
  285. 10:06dependent on them, taking money from
  286. 10:08them. They...he is recording them. And
  287. 10:11all these...now pay attention to the
  288. 10:13fact that all these recordings appeared
  289. 10:15again before another round of
  290. 10:17negotiations between Ukraine, America,
  291. 10:19and Russia regarding a truce.
  292. 10:21>> What are they hinting at? That NABU and
  293. 10:22SAP are working for the Americans?
  294. 10:24>> Who? NABU and SAP?
  295. 10:26>> SAP.
  296. 10:26>> They work within the law enforcement
  297. 10:28system, yes. That means they have
  298. 10:30information, and they are executing it.
  299. 10:33They work from the position of the law
  300. 10:35enforcement system, as an instrument of
  301. 10:37the law enforcement system. As to why
  302. 10:39this appeared right now, well, I don't
  303. 10:41know.
  304. 10:42>> I personally asked this question
  305. 10:43directly during the last releases.
  306. 10:46He said it was a coincidence.
  307. 10:48>> The second time. A second coincidence.
  308. 10:50We are having a second coincidence now.
  309. 10:52Let's put it this way: we will analyze
  310. 10:54everything, we will watch. We are also
  311. 10:56reasonable people. A coincidence is
  312. 10:57possible, well, it's not intentional.
  313. 10:59The leak could have been caused by
  314. 11:01Burkin or someone else. Because how did
  315. 11:03NABU actually go about it? They first
  316. 11:05detained Andriy, this criminal, back in
  317. 11:07August of last year, I think.
  318. 11:10They obtained information from his phone
  319. 11:12. All these recordings mainly come from
  320. 11:14his phone.
  321. 11:15Accordingly, we have Burkin's recordings
  322. 11:17separately. If you analyze all these
  323. 11:19recordings, it's clear that Burkin's are
  324. 11:21separate. We have them. And there are
  325. 11:23separate recordings of Andriy with our
  326. 11:25law enforcement officers, with Duka, and
  327. 11:27with other police officers. So, these
  328. 11:29are two stages and two levels of
  329. 11:31recordings that confirm this information
  330. 11:33.
  331. 11:35So why now? Why
  332. 11:38wait, if it could have been done in
  333. 11:40August when Andriy was detained?
  334. 11:42>> Uh-huh.
  335. 11:42>> They could have arrested him right then
  336. 11:44.
  337. 11:44>> They wanted more time to get additional
  338. 11:45information. Maybe the operation wasn't
  339. 11:47finished yet. They were still waiting.
  340. 11:49>> Maybe, yes, maybe they were identifying
  341. 11:51others and so on. But
  342. 11:52>> Roman and I touched on the topic of
  343. 11:54Maliuk's involvement.
  344. 11:56Vasyl Maliuk and the criminal Andriy
  345. 11:58Osypov are godfathers, journalist
  346. 12:00Kruchak says on Facebook.
  347. 12:03Whether this is true or not, we have yet
  348. 12:05to verify, but such information exists.
  349. 12:12Maliuk could not have been unaware of
  350. 12:14the group appearing in the Carthage case
  351. 12:16, because normally, the head of the
  352. 12:17Security Service is aware of such active
  353. 12:19criminal drug routes as Khimprom.
  354. 12:25I mean, for many years—it's terrible to
  355. 12:28say—it was the flagship of the drug
  356. 12:30production system in Ukraine, so it's
  357. 12:32impossible not to know about it.
  358. 12:35You can pretend you don't know about it
  359. 12:36or turn a blind eye, but here is an
  360. 12:38important point.
  361. 12:40I want us to show a video now.
  362. 12:44I didn't think I'd ever mention this
  363. 12:45gentleman in the context of his words on
  364. 12:47video, but it will be Illia Kyva, who,
  365. 12:49as you remember, worked under Avakov.
  366. 12:54I think he was the head of the anti-drug
  367. 12:55department.
  368. 12:58And he mentioned the following about
  369. 12:59Khimprom back then.
  370. 14:57>> If this was recorded two weeks before
  371. 14:58his murder, it happens that Ukrainian
  372. 15:00special services can eliminate a scumbag
  373. 15:02and traitor to the country who is
  374. 15:04simultaneously inconvenient to them due
  375. 15:06to their knowledge of certain things.
  376. 15:12Does such a theory exist, and is
  377. 15:13Budanov's name mentioned there?
  378. 15:19>> Regarding the Main Intelligence
  379. 15:21Directorate, I know they manipulated
  380. 15:23such things and pushed a narrative that
  381. 15:25they were allegedly controlling Khimprom
  382. 15:27to export drugs and send them to Russia
  383. 15:29, to form drug trafficking channels
  384. 15:31there, claiming that the goal was to
  385. 15:33destroy Russia from within via the drug
  386. 15:35business.
  387. 15:38>> And what does it mean they manipulated?
  388. 15:40>> Well, they spoke about it, they believed
  389. 15:42it was true, and in doing so, they tried
  390. 15:45to justify their contacts with Burkin to
  391. 15:47those in power, or perhaps to stop his
  392. 15:49legal prosecution.
  393. 15:50>> So, were they discussing this in private
  394. 15:52conversations?
  395. 15:53Allegedly talking about control over
  396. 15:55this sphere.
  397. 15:57>> Control over this sphere in the interest
  398. 15:59of fighting the Russians, in order to
  399. 16:01use this drug business in Russia and
  400. 16:03exploit its strengths, let's say, to
  401. 16:05fight the state.
  402. 16:07Well, it's clear that to us, this is a
  403. 16:09weak story. Because in reality, I know
  404. 16:12that in Ukraine, Khimprom produced
  405. 16:14synthetic drugs in huge volumes, and
  406. 16:16it's a huge tragedy for our youth, for
  407. 16:18our young people, for children in
  408. 16:20schools.
  409. 16:22Today, it's simply absurd.
  410. 16:27When I was under house arrest, I was
  411. 16:29going about my business and met a fellow
  412. 16:31, well, a person who lives there in
  413. 16:33Vasylkiv.
  414. 16:35And he turned out to be a teacher at a
  415. 16:37school, well, at a vocational school.
  416. 16:40He says he had been in Israel for a long
  417. 16:42time, used drugs himself, and now he is
  418. 16:45a teacher.
  419. 16:48He says that in schools and vocational
  420. 16:50colleges, 30 to 60 percent of people
  421. 16:52have tried this stuff, 30 percent of
  422. 16:55them use it constantly, and it is
  423. 16:57destroying our, well, our youth, our...
  424. 17:01>> Let's return to the question of
  425. 17:03controlling this situation.
  426. 17:06So, if we assume that the leaders of the
  427. 17:08SBU and the GUR at that time knew about
  428. 17:10this, then was it some kind of joint
  429. 17:12operation?
  430. 17:14>> Well, we see, yes, on the internet, that
  431. 17:16there is publicly available information
  432. 17:18that he was awarded a commendation by
  433. 17:20the GUR.
  434. 17:21>> Yes.
  435. 17:21>> That's the first thing. Second, I know
  436. 17:23...
  437. 17:23>> Let's name who was awarded.
  438. 17:25>> Burkin, that is, the leader of Khimprom
  439. 17:27, Yevhen Burkin, this is the person who
  440. 17:29headed it and really coordinated all its
  441. 17:31activities and shaped them.
  442. 17:33The Security Service of Ukraine, we see
  443. 17:35that—well, publicly I haven't heard that
  444. 17:37the Security Service of Ukraine was
  445. 17:38associated with Khimprom. The GUR, yes,
  446. 17:40has more tasks in that territory; it
  447. 17:42could have used such contacts as a cover
  448. 17:45in this exact way. Well, regarding the
  449. 17:47SBU, we see it now.
  450. 17:52I heard information from operational
  451. 17:54officers that the GUR and the SBU are
  452. 17:56also involved, but I couldn't believe
  453. 17:59this story because, for me, it was below
  454. 18:01any understanding of what a person—well
  455. 18:04, officers in the SBU, and those who
  456. 18:06serve today—could stoop to, to interact
  457. 18:08with Khimprom on the level of, let's say
  458. 18:11, drug trafficking and receiving, let's
  459. 18:13say, material benefits.
  460. 18:19I thought that even if they were
  461. 18:21interacting, perhaps it was for some
  462. 18:23operational purposes.
  463. 18:25And they rule out any dependence on the
  464. 18:27chemical industry and any permission to
  465. 18:29trade such drugs within the territory of
  466. 18:31Ukraine.
  467. 18:32About that, it turns out, I was wrong.
  468. 18:34>> Yes. Regarding the declaration after the
  469. 18:37case became public, I mentioned it today
  470. 18:39, the President announced the
  471. 18:40preparation of legislative changes that
  472. 18:42should restore mandatory disclosure.
  473. 18:45This will allow for the verification of
  474. 18:47the assets and lifestyles of special
  475. 18:49service employees as a whole.
  476. 18:52Could this be a solution?
  477. 18:56And in your opinion, how should the
  478. 18:57system be reformed so that such cases do
  479. 18:59not happen again?
  480. 19:03>> It seems to me, based on my own
  481. 19:05experience, that in a structure like the
  482. 19:07Security Service of Ukraine (perhaps
  483. 19:09it's harder in the police because they
  484. 19:11have nearly a million personnel—500,000
  485. 19:14, 400,000, 800,000), in the SBU, the
  486. 19:16number of operational officers is small
  487. 19:18; they can be vetted, they can be
  488. 19:20selected, their activities can be
  489. 19:22monitored, and it can be known for
  490. 19:24certain what they are involved in. That
  491. 19:26is to say, the structure is built in
  492. 19:27such a way that an operational officer
  493. 19:29cannot engage in such things without
  494. 19:31their superior's knowledge. That is the
  495. 19:33first point. Second, the personnel
  496. 19:35policy that exists in the SBU today, as
  497. 19:38we have seen, was geared toward other
  498. 19:40tasks.
  499. 19:42It was focused and concentrated on
  500. 19:44making money while simultaneously—in
  501. 19:46parallel—fighting the war.
  502. 19:48But specific people were identified who
  503. 19:51had the right, let's say, to impose
  504. 19:53tributes or taxes on certain businessmen
  505. 19:55. As we saw, Shilo was one before this,
  506. 19:57and Vityuk is the same thing, yes. Now,
  507. 20:00within the criminal environment, we have
  508. 20:02seen that this right was also granted to
  509. 20:04certain officers and employees to simply
  510. 20:06operate in the drug business.
  511. 20:09And what is particularly negative in
  512. 20:11this story is that Andriy, this criminal
  513. 20:13, is a friend of Malyuk, yes. He is his
  514. 20:16friend, he is the one who brought him
  515. 20:18into the SBU, recommended him to the "K
  516. 20:20" department officers who continued to
  517. 20:21work with him, and guaranteed that this
  518. 20:23person was reliable and could be dealt
  519. 20:25with. This is what it's about—that from
  520. 20:27the very top of the Security Service of
  521. 20:29Ukraine, an agent was introduced who
  522. 20:31acted...We didn't see from these
  523. 20:33conversations, perhaps they are there.
  524. 20:35Let's look for them, ask NABU to publish
  525. 20:37them, to see if there was a conversation
  526. 20:39with Andriy about, let's liquidate
  527. 20:41someone in Russia, let's kidnap some war
  528. 20:43criminal from Russian territory, let's
  529. 20:45blow up some bridge or energy
  530. 20:46infrastructure, or do something on
  531. 20:48Russian territory that would harm the
  532. 20:50enemy. I did not hear these
  533. 20:51conversations.
  534. 20:52>> I will tell you more: when Malyuk was
  535. 20:54removed, there was talk that there was
  536. 20:56not just one case exposed by NABU, but
  537. 20:58others still unpublished surrounding him
  538. 20:59, and the President knows about it,
  539. 21:01which is why he dismissed him.
  540. 21:05>> Well, I believe that if Malyuk had
  541. 21:07succeeded in his task of fighting NABU
  542. 21:09at the time when he, let's say, publicly
  543. 21:11claimed that NABU was working for Russia
  544. 21:13and was under Russian control, and this
  545. 21:16could not be proven later, yes, that is
  546. 21:18why Malyuk was removed, because people
  547. 21:20took to the streets, a standoff began
  548. 21:22between the government and the street,
  549. 21:24yes, between the government and the
  550. 21:26European Union, with representatives of
  551. 21:29the European Union, who said in the end
  552. 21:31: either we stop funding, or you leave
  553. 21:33NABU its powers. So, effectively, Malyuk
  554. 21:36said A but couldn't say B. That is, he
  555. 21:38made very baseless claims, and in the
  556. 21:40end, we saw on these tapes that they had
  557. 21:42falsified this evidence, falsified
  558. 21:45evidence regarding Magomed Rasul.
  559. 21:47That’s why I think Malyuk was fired,
  560. 21:49because he didn’t do the president a
  561. 21:51favor at a sufficiently professional
  562. 21:53level.
  563. 21:56>> Let’s remind our viewers that Ruslan
  564. 21:58Magomed Rasulov is one of the key NABU
  565. 22:00detectives who were involved in
  566. 22:02documenting crimes, including those of
  567. 22:03the president's inner circle.
  568. 22:10And for this he was punished unjustly,
  569. 22:12he and his father, who were accused of
  570. 22:14dealing drugs, well, in short...
  571. 22:18>> Cannabis with Dagestan, with Russia, yes
  572. 22:20.
  573. 22:21>> Yes, with Dagestan, with Russia. And
  574. 22:23this case is also on these tapes, but
  575. 22:25what is it, why are we referring to
  576. 22:27Malyuk?
  577. 22:28Because the Security Service of Ukraine
  578. 22:30helped do this at a time when NABU and
  579. 22:32SAP, at the wish of the Office of the
  580. 22:34President, the President, and his circle
  581. 22:36, wanted to be subordinated to the
  582. 22:38Prosecutor General’s Office.
  583. 22:41A complicated story, I understand, but
  584. 22:43the PGO, controlled by the President—
  585. 22:45it’s called the Office of the Prosecutor
  586. 22:48General now—and the SBU helped strip
  587. 22:50away the independence and operations of
  588. 22:52NABU and SAP. And this is worth
  589. 22:54remembering, this is important in this.
  590. 22:56>> The attempt was...
  591. 22:57>> Now it is clear why.
  592. 22:58>> The foundation of this attempt and the
  593. 23:00basis of this attempt were the
  594. 23:01accusations from Malyuk and the SBU
  595. 23:03regarding NABU, that NABU was acting
  596. 23:05under Russian control.
  597. 23:06>> Yes.
  598. 23:06>> So, he stated this, and in the end, it
  599. 23:09turned out to be fake. I think that is
  600. 23:11why he was removed, because he couldn’t
  601. 23:13defeat NABU, and for the President, it
  602. 23:15was probably a big challenge, and he
  603. 23:17understood that NABU had materials that
  604. 23:19could later cause him huge problems.
  605. 23:23>> Is Poklad from the same system, or is he
  606. 23:25a new person?
  607. 23:29>> Yes, Poklad is a person who, in any case
  608. 23:31, will carry out the tasks of a
  609. 23:33higher-ranking official or the person on
  610. 23:35whom his appointment to a position
  611. 23:37depends. This is a person who will
  612. 23:40betray his friends, comrades, whoever,
  613. 23:42he is a so-called careerist, yes, he
  614. 23:44will focus on the person on whom his
  615. 23:46future appointment to a position depends
  616. 23:48. Therefore, he did everything very
  617. 23:51professionally and purposefully, and all
  618. 23:53actions were aimed specifically at the
  619. 23:56same task: discrediting NABU, only
  620. 23:58covertly.
  621. 23:59It was he who brought Khrystenko from
  622. 24:01Dubai at the time, along with other
  623. 24:03employees; it was he who negotiated his
  624. 24:06transport, and he was exchanged back
  625. 24:08then for some Chechen who was in Ukraine
  626. 24:10. They detained him here, let's say,
  627. 24:12illegally, illegally, so to speak.
  628. 24:15>> Who is Khrystenko, maybe someone...
  629. 24:17>> Khrystenko is a deputy, a people's
  630. 24:19deputy, through whom the SBU tried to
  631. 24:21accuse the NABU, claiming that it was
  632. 24:24through Khrystenko that Russia was
  633. 24:26directing the NABU system.
  634. 24:28However, they brought him in, well, and
  635. 24:30we didn't see any testimony confirming
  636. 24:32this. Although there is an agreement
  637. 24:34with Khrystenko, he is now currently out
  638. 24:36of reach; we don't even know where he is
  639. 24:38. They hid him, I understand, because he
  640. 24:39probably said something there that,
  641. 24:41likely, does not correspond to reality.
  642. 24:43Therefore, if it were the truth, I think
  643. 24:44the testimony would be public and the
  644. 24:46evidence would be unambiguous. They do
  645. 24:48not exist today. It was for this
  646. 24:49operation that Poklad received the Hero
  647. 24:51of Ukraine title from Zelensky. That is
  648. 24:53, Zelensky is trying in this way to form
  649. 24:55a circle of law enforcement officers and
  650. 24:57security officials around him who will
  651. 24:59carry out all his instructions and
  652. 25:01requests, who will, let's say, have no
  653. 25:03ambitions or interests of their own, and
  654. 25:05will do whatever he wants, even
  655. 25:07violating the law and crossing any moral
  656. 25:09principles, and so on. So Poklad is the
  657. 25:11same story, and he did all the same
  658. 25:13things as Malyuk, but Poklad, in the
  659. 25:15president's opinion, will handle it
  660. 25:17better.
  661. 25:19However, in today's scandal, we see his
  662. 25:21name appearing in the tapes as well,
  663. 25:23with the call sign "Khimik," that he was
  664. 25:25the one who helped those K-officers who
  665. 25:27coordinated the work of Andriy Kryminal
  666. 25:29and...
  667. 25:31>> And who is "Khimik"?
  668. 25:33>> It's Poklad. Yes. He brought them
  669. 25:35together...
  670. 25:36>> Why "Khimik"?
  671. 25:37>> Well, it's a call sign; everyone has
  672. 25:39their own call sign, yes, yes.
  673. 25:41>> It's just that when it was mentioned,
  674. 25:43it's good that we discussed it, I saw on
  675. 25:45social media that some Ukrainians
  676. 25:47thought "Khimik" was the "Khimik" from
  677. 25:49Azov, the famous "Khimik" who was in
  678. 25:51captivity and got out, actually. So the
  679. 25:53thoughts were specifically about "
  680. 25:54Khimik," about the well-known "Khimik."
  681. 25:56>> Yes. So we saw that Poklad also
  682. 25:59coordinates the activities of these guys
  683. 26:01, the K-officers, specifically in the
  684. 26:03context of the tasks of the Mexican,
  685. 26:05Burkin, and Khimprom, while coordinating
  686. 26:07their activities with the Ministry of
  687. 26:10Internal Affairs. That is, Poklad
  688. 26:12himself is a product of the Ministry of
  689. 26:14Internal Affairs, so he knows better and
  690. 26:16knows how to find common ground with
  691. 26:18these guys from the MVS system. He
  692. 26:20coordinated it when some issue arose, I
  693. 26:23remember, for Andriy, so Poklad gave a,
  694. 26:25let's say, contact and said that this
  695. 26:27issue needed to be resolved for the
  696. 26:29employees of Unit K. That is, in the
  697. 26:31operational world, there is no such
  698. 26:33moment where you provide a service
  699. 26:35without understanding the purpose for
  700. 26:37which you are providing it. Because the
  701. 26:39operational world is crime, it's
  702. 26:41espionage, and you can simply be used in
  703. 26:43the dark. That’s why you always ask, why
  704. 26:45do you need this, explain why this
  705. 26:47contact is needed, then I will provide
  706. 26:49it for you. So we see that Poklad is the
  707. 26:51very same story. And, well, in reality,
  708. 26:54based on what he did and is doing, we
  709. 26:56understand that he is moving in the same
  710. 26:58direction. Moreover, there was someone,
  711. 27:01if you saw, Dombrovskyi.
  712. 27:02>> Yes.
  713. 27:03>> who was in the Khimprom system. This is
  714. 27:05also a person who
  715. 27:06>> Was Dombrovskyi in the system?
  716. 27:07>> was in the Khimprom system.
  717. 27:09>> he is a blogger from Odesa.
  718. 27:12>> but he calls himself both a writer and a
  719. 27:14poet.
  720. 27:15>> Yes, he supposedly had an addiction
  721. 27:17before, a drug addiction, then he
  722. 27:19recovered and made some very
  723. 27:20high-profile videos many years ago,
  724. 27:22before the war. He is from Odesa himself
  725. 27:25, well, people in Odesa know who he is.
  726. 27:27>> Two years ago, he released videos where
  727. 27:29he accused Poklad of working with him
  728. 27:31during the Khimprom affair. He also
  729. 27:33reached out to me, asking for help,
  730. 27:35because he was afraid, he had several
  731. 27:37attempts on his life.
  732. 27:39And he said that he communicated with
  733. 27:41Burkin because, well, he knew him from
  734. 27:43before.
  735. 27:45He had his own problems with Burkin.
  736. 27:47And Poklad tried to use him to obtain
  737. 27:49information.
  738. 27:52This Dombrovskyi did something for him,
  739. 27:55some favor, and then Poklad used it to
  740. 27:57establish contact with Burkin and said,
  741. 27:59"You have a person there who is giving
  742. 28:01information on you."
  743. 28:03And this turned out to be true. And then
  744. 28:05Burkin started, let's say, ordering
  745. 28:07attempts on Dombrovskyi again. So that’s
  746. 28:09how Poklad used it. And by that moment,
  747. 28:11he had already established contact with
  748. 28:13Burkin. And Dombrovskyi claims that
  749. 28:15Burkin told him he was paying for
  750. 28:17communication with Poklad, just for the
  751. 28:18fact that he was talking to him. Well,
  752. 28:20that was the story. So
  753. 28:22>> And before this communication, what role
  754. 28:24did Dombrovskyi play in all this?
  755. 28:26In Khimprom?
  756. 28:27>> He, I think he was in the system, yes,
  757. 28:29he was in the sales system. Well, at the
  758. 28:32same time, pay attention to the figure
  759. 28:34of Dombrovskyi.
  760. 28:36If you take him, he was part of a
  761. 28:38literary club together with Dugin, such
  762. 28:40a Russian ideologue of the "Russian
  763. 28:42Spring," who hates Ukrainians in general
  764. 28:44and believes that we do not exist, and
  765. 28:47who forms the ideology for Putin for the
  766. 28:49destruction of Ukraine.
  767. 28:52>> And he even recently made a statement
  768. 28:54that the fact that we are killing our
  769. 28:56brothers is normal, it is also love.
  770. 28:58>> It is love, re-education. So, Dombrovsky
  771. 29:01was right there. Here we see a, you know
  772. 29:03, network of people who, at a certain
  773. 29:06stage, each one was involved with some
  774. 29:08Russian roots, right? The same Burkin
  775. 29:10has Russian roots, Dugin, Dombrovsky,
  776. 29:13for some reason they are all forming
  777. 29:15this system here.
  778. 29:16And we even just watched a video from
  779. 29:19Kyiv, right?
  780. 29:21Look at the narratives he is pushing.
  781. 29:23Look, let's go back a little bit before
  782. 29:25the war, when the full-scale big war
  783. 29:27began in 2022, when Putin declared, he
  784. 29:30came out and made a huge statement on
  785. 29:32why he was going to war against Ukraine
  786. 29:34, why he believes that this state does
  787. 29:37not exist. He gave three theses. That it
  788. 29:39is a thoroughly corrupt state, that it
  789. 29:41has no history of its own, that we gave
  790. 29:43it territories during the World War. And
  791. 29:45the third is
  792. 29:48that no, no, no, it is Nazism,
  793. 29:51neo-Nazism, right?
  794. 29:53So this "thoroughly corrupt state" is
  795. 29:55exactly what they were doing. You see, I
  796. 29:57have long been saying that, in my
  797. 29:59opinion, Yermak is a person who formed a
  798. 30:02corrupt system precisely through
  799. 30:04the probable work for the Russian
  800. 30:06special services, perhaps, yes? Burkin
  801. 30:08was carrying out this task, as you can
  802. 30:10see, very directly and clearly. And we
  803. 30:12see that Kyiv also talks about this.
  804. 30:14This rhetoric also sounds in his words,
  805. 30:16that this is Ukraine, it has corruption
  806. 30:18in the highest echelons of power, that
  807. 30:20they are selling out, and these video
  808. 30:22and audio recordings simply confirm
  809. 30:24those narratives that Putin formed. And
  810. 30:26so, as a counterintelligence officer, I
  811. 30:28can assume that Burkin was fulfilling
  812. 30:30tasks for Russian special services to
  813. 30:32implement Putin's plan to capture
  814. 30:34Ukraine by discrediting it on a global
  815. 30:36level, on the world stage before our
  816. 30:38European and American partners, as a
  817. 30:40thoroughly corrupt state. And what, if
  818. 30:42not such positions, proves that even the
  819. 30:44service that was supposed to fight
  820. 30:46corruption—and not just that, but also
  821. 30:48from the position of counterintelligence
  822. 30:50—is itself corrupted by the Russians as
  823. 30:52well?
  824. 30:53>> And an important point, Roman, let me
  825. 30:55put my two cents in.
  826. 30:56At a recent press conference, Putin
  827. 30:58mentioned this with Viktor Medvedchuk.
  828. 31:02He emphasized the corruption of this
  829. 31:04state and even told a joke about NABU,
  830. 31:07where he tied together NABU, a
  831. 31:08nightstand, money, and the whole story
  832. 31:10in general.
  833. 31:12So he is emphasizing and constantly
  834. 31:14pedaling this topic.
  835. 31:16Well, uh, I’m silent on social media,
  836. 31:18they simply—it’s actually a very—
  837. 31:21>> Yes. —
  838. 31:22>> important argument for them, a tool, yes
  839. 31:24.
  840. 31:34—
  841. 31:34>> is corruption at the highest level of uh
  842. 31:36government? And that is why today we see
  843. 31:38how uh support for Ukraine is being lost
  844. 31:40. Meaning European politicians can no
  845. 31:42longer justify what is happening in
  846. 31:44Ukraine even to their own voters. How do
  847. 31:46they explain all these things? And we
  848. 31:47see how Poles are aggressive today
  849. 31:49toward some Ukrainians, some Poles—not
  850. 31:51all, but a certain category of radical
  851. 31:54people—saying things like, "get out of
  852. 31:56here."
  853. 31:57>> There is one moment where the Mexican
  854. 31:59says on these tapes in...
  855. 32:02...brackets, one of the heads of the SBU
  856. 32:04Internal Security.
  857. 32:16>> That’s, well, the head of uh Internal
  858. 32:19Security, Anton Kravchuk.
  859. 32:21>> Yes, that’s him, probably.
  860. 32:22>> It’s him. Possibly. Well, I cannot state
  861. 32:25that for sure.
  862. 32:26>> Meaning he—most likely, it is probable
  863. 32:28that he also took part in this whole
  864. 32:30story.
  865. 32:30>> You see, he doesn’t have direct contact
  866. 32:32with him. He wants to ask for something
  867. 32:34through someone to get in there. Meaning
  868. 32:36it’s clear that Kr isn't doing those,
  869. 32:38let's say, things that are needed for
  870. 32:39...
  871. 32:42...for Burkin.
  872. 32:43>> Uh-huh.
  873. 32:44>> However, he will try to influence him.
  874. 32:48Well, those big ones—the people who
  875. 32:50contacted him directly and who directly
  876. 32:52took, notice, the bribes he offered.
  877. 32:54Even the Minister of Internal Affairs is
  878. 32:57ready to pay 500,000. Please reach out
  879. 32:59to the Minister of Health. And these
  880. 33:00people who say "good" and carried out
  881. 33:02these tasks are the same people who
  882. 33:04corrupted this system. Earlier, Yermak
  883. 33:06did this, let's say, saying that "I am
  884. 33:08building a corrupt system here,
  885. 33:09appointing people to positions who will
  886. 33:11have to form corrupt budgets for me."
  887. 33:13Today, the SBU itself is doing this. And
  888. 33:16the tool in this story was the Mexican.
  889. 33:19That is why I say the SBU—it's their
  890. 33:21professional self-respect. They should
  891. 33:24have looked at this story through the
  892. 33:25prism of counterintelligence. Especially
  893. 33:27when he tells them openly that I work
  894. 33:29with the FSB.
  895. 33:31And pay attention to how he gives them
  896. 33:32the funds. He is not just an ordinary
  897. 33:34criminal. They ask there to increase the
  898. 33:37monthly payment by 50,000 dollars. They
  899. 33:39say "fine, no questions," next month I
  900. 33:41will increase this payment. Meaning—and
  901. 33:43at the same time, the criminal, this
  902. 33:45Andriy the criminal, says, "Should I
  903. 33:46tell them about this or just play dumb?
  904. 33:48" They are asking for 50,000 more.
  905. 33:50Meaning he could have not even mentioned
  906. 33:52this 50,000. Meaning he and Burkin, if
  907. 33:54he were an ordinary criminal, he would
  908. 33:56understand that if he says it or not, it
  909. 33:57means it's not a critical issue, right?
  910. 33:59He said "no, let's do it in increments
  911. 34:01over time." If they ask, let's return to
  912. 34:03this question again. I say no, no, I
  913. 34:05will pay you for the last month and I
  914. 34:06will pay you for the next one already.
  915. 34:08I’ll send this money now. So the issue
  916. 34:10is not about money. On the contrary, his
  917. 34:12task was to corrupt, to give more money
  918. 34:14. And I think that those couple of
  919. 34:16millions that they are talking about,
  920. 34:18yes, those 3.5 million dollars that
  921. 34:19passed through this crypto wallet in
  922. 34:21three years or two years.
  923. 34:23>> Yes, yes.
  924. 34:24>> not much money for Russia to
  925. 34:26>> That's peanuts. 3 million 750
  926. 34:29>> thousand.
  927. 34:31So these are the peanuts that are
  928. 34:33costing Ukraine such demoralization,
  929. 34:36such internal imbalance, and the
  930. 34:38destruction of society's trust in the
  931. 34:40state system today, that, well, imagine
  932. 34:42how this will affect mobilization today
  933. 34:45, right?
  934. 34:47It's an indirect influence, but it's a
  935. 34:48very serious influence. It is being
  936. 34:50discussed in every family. Every person
  937. 34:52who says, well, sends a son, father,
  938. 34:54husband to war, the person says, the
  939. 34:56wife says, the children say, well, and
  940. 34:58the father himself thinks, why should I
  941. 35:00go there? What is happening? Why these
  942. 35:02guys, who today, well, they all carry
  943. 35:04themselves as heroes? What struck me the
  944. 35:06most is that today 1,200—that was as of
  945. 35:09yesterday—SBU officers paid bail, paid
  946. 35:12their own funds.
  947. 35:13>> Are they all SBU officers?
  948. 35:14>> Yes, mostly it was
  949. 35:16>> There were about 1,130 of them, right?
  950. 35:18Well, that was as of yesterday, maybe
  951. 35:19even more now.
  952. 35:20>> And they paid, they, they waited for the
  953. 35:22time.
  954. 35:22>> someone is not trying. They even waited
  955. 35:24until payday and started demanding this
  956. 35:26, you understand? The supervisors
  957. 35:28collected it. This is simply absurd. It
  958. 35:30turns out that a criminal, let's say,
  959. 35:32group has taken over the Security
  960. 35:34Service of Ukraine, and everyone working
  961. 35:36there today is forced to comply with
  962. 35:38their demands. In principle, in
  963. 35:39principle, it's blackmail. In principle
  964. 35:42, it's terrorism, right? That your
  965. 35:44subordinate, you say, and there are
  966. 35:45stories going around, I don't know if
  967. 35:47it's true, but they say that, for
  968. 35:49example, they tell you, pay 40-50
  969. 35:50thousand of your salary, and we will
  970. 35:52return it to you later from other, from
  971. 35:54other schemes, yes.
  972. 35:55>> Aha.
  973. 35:56>> you do something there and you, well, we
  974. 35:57will account for it for you. So they are
  975. 35:59effectively forming a corrupt system in
  976. 36:01front of the eyes of society. And this
  977. 36:02is in general, well, this is
  978. 36:04unacceptable. That's what you are
  979. 36:05talking about, where it stems from. It
  980. 36:07all stems from within, and it was all
  981. 36:09created, I believe, by Maliuk—or perhaps
  982. 36:11Tatarov—I don't know if he coordinated
  983. 36:13it in Russia or elsewhere, but he
  984. 36:15appointed someone to a leadership
  985. 36:17position in the Security Service of
  986. 36:19Ukraine who has no grasp of personnel
  987. 36:21policy or management at all. It is
  988. 36:23impossible. If a commander, the head of
  989. 36:26an agency, engages in such things, what
  990. 36:28do you think is the motivation of 90%of
  991. 36:31our operational staff who work there?
  992. 36:34The operatives sit there; there are
  993. 36:36structures that engage in other types of
  994. 36:38activities and spend a lot of time
  995. 36:39talking among themselves. They discuss
  996. 36:41everything, they talk about everything,
  997. 36:43they see everything. How can they
  998. 36:45fulfill their official duties tomorrow?
  999. 36:47It is impossible. And so they want to
  1000. 36:49preserve this system, they want to show
  1001. 36:50that, no, it’s not like that. We see
  1002. 36:52that this is the order, and that the
  1003. 36:54Security Service of Ukraine will
  1004. 36:55continue to operate this way. And we saw
  1005. 36:57that, as you say, the president didn't
  1006. 36:58react to this story for a long time. He
  1007. 37:00acted like a typical media professional
  1008. 37:02. He waited three days—new information,
  1009. 37:04negotiations, some successes, prisoner
  1010. 37:06exchanges. Distraction, distraction,
  1011. 37:08distraction, and the attention to this
  1012. 37:10was diminished. Well, our society is
  1013. 37:13already so, let's say, desensitized;
  1014. 37:15it's in such a state, I don't know, it's
  1015. 37:17in such a condition.
  1016. 37:19>> That it's hard to be shocked by
  1017. 37:20something or for something to last a
  1018. 37:22long time.
  1019. 37:23>> Secondly, I still believe that society
  1020. 37:25will not forget this.
  1021. 37:27It sees this and
  1022. 37:28>> will forget. It is very important not to
  1023. 37:30forget.
  1024. 37:31>> To talk about the fact that this is the
  1025. 37:32root cause. This has been going on since
  1026. 37:342019. You and I have spoken more than
  1027. 37:36once about a certain Dmytro Shtanko, who
  1028. 37:38recorded Denys Yermak back in 2019, when
  1029. 37:40he came and openly said: "We are
  1030. 37:41building a corruption system." They
  1031. 37:43built it, and today they are even
  1032. 37:45fighting for its existence. Today there
  1033. 37:47is a society that is at war—ordinary
  1034. 37:49people who don't profit from corruption
  1035. 37:51, who go and pay for the war, and their
  1036. 37:53husbands, wives, and daughters are dying
  1037. 37:56today.
  1038. 37:57And there is a second society that, as
  1039. 37:59huge financial support and big money
  1040. 38:02flow into Ukraine, launders it through
  1041. 38:04drugs, and it comes back.
  1042. 38:08So this is taking shape, and let's not
  1043. 38:11forget about the standard corruption in
  1044. 38:13the procurement of military drones,
  1045. 38:15equipment, and other things—we’ve seen
  1046. 38:17it in energy and Ukrzaliznytsia.
  1047. 38:21This corruption is everywhere. Is such
  1048. 38:23an SBU system capable of overcoming this
  1049. 38:25corruption? Only military
  1050. 38:27counterintelligence has access to Armed
  1051. 38:29Forces materials and procurement today.
  1052. 38:32And they should be doing that, but as we
  1053. 38:34discussed last time we met, the
  1054. 38:36counterintelligence head is a certain
  1055. 38:38Yaroslav Merezhko, whose wife holds a
  1056. 38:41Russian passport, and so on.
  1057. 38:43Now let's generalize all this and think
  1058. 38:45: isn't Russia ruling us indirectly
  1059. 38:47today?
  1060. 38:49>> Then the viewers might ask: why can't
  1061. 38:51Zelensky strike a deal with them if his
  1062. 38:53inner circle has such close ties?
  1063. 38:57And, by the way, does such a thing even
  1064. 38:59exist?
  1065. 39:02Is there one or perhaps multiple
  1066. 39:04channels for these negotiations?
  1067. 39:06The GUR usually handles this, right?
  1068. 39:10With the Russians? Well, unofficially.
  1069. 39:12>> Yes, channels do exist. We saw
  1070. 39:14Abramovich come to us through Arakhamia
  1071. 39:17; others have come as well. So, there
  1072. 39:19are plenty of channels. The issue is
  1073. 39:21something else. Look at how the conflict
  1074. 39:23between Ukraine and Russia began under
  1075. 39:25Zelensky’s presidency, how it all
  1076. 39:26happened. At first, he promised—I
  1077. 39:28understand he made some deal through
  1078. 39:30Arakhamia—I remember in his first six
  1079. 39:32months, he said, "Let's turn the water
  1080. 39:34back on to Crimea." Everyone started
  1081. 39:36saying, "That's impossible, stop, what
  1082. 39:39are you doing?" Protests started,
  1083. 39:40negative sentiment surged on social
  1084. 39:42media, and that issue was halted. Second
  1085. 39:45issue: remember the Steinmeier formula,
  1086. 39:47the referendums in Donetsk and Luhansk,
  1087. 39:49holding them so these two entities could
  1088. 39:52be federalized within Ukraine—remaining
  1089. 39:54part of Ukraine but supposedly with
  1090. 39:56autonomous powers, like Crimea,
  1091. 39:58something similar. Again, people took to
  1092. 40:01the streets and started chanting that it
  1093. 40:03was impossible; at the President's
  1094. 40:04Office, Zelensky couldn't get it done.
  1095. 40:07So, they are demanding things he cannot
  1096. 40:09deliver. He doesn't understand these
  1097. 40:11things; he’s just an actor. He was told
  1098. 40:13, "We will write everything for you, and
  1099. 40:15you will just do it." And he is doing
  1100. 40:17that today, without understanding the
  1101. 40:19consequences. But when he approaches a
  1102. 40:21critical geopolitical decision, he sees
  1103. 40:23protests in the streets, sees comments
  1104. 40:25on social media, and says, "I can't do
  1105. 40:27this," because he is oriented toward
  1106. 40:29public support.
  1107. 40:30>> But ultimately, do you think that
  1108. 40:34negotiations will conclude anytime soon
  1109. 40:36?
  1110. 40:38I don't mean months, I mean within a
  1111. 40:40year—that an agreement will be signed.
  1112. 40:43>> That will definitely happen. But it
  1113. 40:45depends on the circumstances, because we
  1114. 40:47see that there is exhaustion on both our
  1115. 40:49side and the Russian side.
  1116. 40:51We need to understand how much
  1117. 40:53information they have about our internal
  1118. 40:55state and how much we have about theirs
  1119. 40:57.
  1120. 40:59>> Judging by what’s on those tapes, they
  1121. 41:00have people everywhere who can tell them
  1122. 41:02everything.
  1123. 41:03>> They know about us, we know about them;
  1124. 41:04I don't think there's anything critical
  1125. 41:06we don't know. But there are
  1126. 41:07intelligence agencies from other states
  1127. 41:09, European and American, that can
  1128. 41:11coordinate us.
  1129. 41:13So, I will continue my thought: he
  1130. 41:15cannot sign an agreement now without
  1131. 41:17harming himself personally, as someone
  1132. 41:19who is still dependent on public support
  1133. 41:21.
  1134. 41:22And right now, they are pressuring him
  1135. 41:24to give up Donbas. Giving up Donbas is,
  1136. 41:26well, it’s just not justifiable in any
  1137. 41:29way. He has no right to do that. It is a
  1138. 41:31crime, first of all, on Ukrainian
  1139. 41:32territory, and he wouldn't be able to
  1140. 41:34stay here, so he is standing his ground
  1141. 41:36; he understands the messages coming
  1142. 41:38through all channels, saying "let's talk
  1143. 41:40" and so on. I understand, that is
  1144. 41:42probably how it is. But he cannot sign
  1145. 41:44it because it is impossible today.
  1146. 41:46It requires great motivation. You see,
  1147. 41:49he already floated the question to the
  1148. 41:51public: maybe hold a referendum
  1149. 41:52regarding Donbas? Maybe so, maybe so.
  1150. 41:55Well, none of that is supported, none of
  1151. 41:58it works, and that’s why he cannot put
  1152. 42:00an end to this issue today.
  1153. 42:03>> What, then, is the likelihood of a
  1154. 42:05cessation of hostilities?
  1155. 42:09>> Uh.
  1156. 42:10>> Well, you spoke about the exhaustion of
  1157. 42:12both sides, but Russia is a country
  1158. 42:17that is not three, but five times larger
  1159. 42:19than Ukraine.
  1160. 42:22And with resources to match.
  1161. 42:25Accordingly, this could drag on; they
  1162. 42:27could certainly fight until 2030.
  1163. 42:30They have plans even beyond 2030.
  1164. 42:34>> That is where my question and concern
  1165. 42:36arise, regarding the moment when Putin
  1166. 42:38realizes we are exhausted—and we will be
  1167. 42:40exhausted when the support from European
  1168. 42:43countries and America runs out.
  1169. 42:46America has already stepped aside, we
  1170. 42:48see today, at least with the Republicans
  1171. 42:50. And Europe, we see, is also starting
  1172. 42:52to scale back that support. And for
  1173. 42:55instance, we saw about three weeks ago,
  1174. 42:57Zelensky stated that we lack the funds
  1175. 42:59allocated for the next two years. For
  1176. 43:02this year, 90—it was 90 billion in total
  1177. 43:04, 45 for this year and 45 for the next.
  1178. 43:06He says we need another 70 billion on
  1179. 43:08top of those 90. And the Europeans have
  1180. 43:10already said, we will think about it,
  1181. 43:11and there is no answer to this question
  1182. 43:13. So we understand that this is the
  1183. 43:15moment of exhaustion.
  1184. 43:16If Putin realizes that we aren't getting
  1185. 43:19those 70 billion and we use up what we
  1186. 43:21have, he will know he can take us, and
  1187. 43:23he will set even greater demands later.
  1188. 43:26So, here is the art of diplomacy, the
  1189. 43:28art of understanding. Where are we, well
  1190. 43:30, you and I? We are with you in the
  1191. 43:32studio. But Zelensky has an entire
  1192. 43:34apparatus, he has intelligence,
  1193. 43:35counterintelligence, an economic
  1194. 43:37component, the Cabinet of Ministers, he
  1195. 43:38understands what that is, he has
  1196. 43:40diplomats, the Ministry of Foreign
  1197. 43:41Affairs, and we know what is happening
  1198. 43:43in all those directions everywhere.
  1199. 43:45Behind closed doors, they are speaking
  1200. 43:47openly, I think, I hope, our allies are
  1201. 43:49with our president. And they are
  1202. 43:50informing him, we can only support you
  1203. 43:52for this much longer. For example, I
  1204. 43:53know that Merz, he doesn't expect to be
  1205. 43:55in office longer than December. He is a
  1206. 43:57person who is clearly and firmly
  1207. 43:59>> Yes. and he is currently emphasizing
  1208. 44:01that if you don't approve this aid now,
  1209. 44:03then I will not vote for the EU budget.
  1210. 44:06I will not vote. Therefore, he
  1211. 44:08understands that time is short and is
  1212. 44:10trying to help us. But then Merz will
  1213. 44:12leave, then Macron will leave, then Le
  1214. 44:14Pen will come, and clearly someone after
  1215. 44:16Merz who might not be pro-Ukrainian. We
  1216. 44:18see the numbers in Germany.
  1217. 44:20>> Yes, I think this is a logical situation
  1218. 44:22, because why is Merz losing his support
  1219. 44:24? Because they portray it in such a way
  1220. 44:26that he supposedly supports the war and
  1221. 44:27the war in Europe has tired everyone out
  1222. 44:29, right? And that is exactly why he is
  1223. 44:31losing support. And so the next
  1224. 44:32politician who comes after him will
  1225. 44:34definitely change their position,
  1226. 44:35because they will be oriented towards
  1227. 44:37their electorate, towards the European,
  1228. 44:39towards the German electorate.
  1229. 44:40>> And what should Zelensky do then, when
  1230. 44:42that support is no longer there?
  1231. 44:43>> Understand and feel that moment when he
  1232. 44:45must find, well, some kind of solution
  1233. 44:47that will be optimal for us. If he
  1234. 44:49misses that moment, then tomorrow we
  1235. 44:51could end up in an even worse situation
  1236. 44:53. Therefore, he must trust himself.
  1237. 44:55Because it is not you and I who have
  1238. 44:57such authority. He came, he took
  1239. 44:59responsibility in 2019 and said that I
  1240. 45:01can, I know how to end the war. Please,
  1241. 45:04he has all the tools for that. We are
  1242. 45:06all fighting, we are all talking about
  1243. 45:08this. The fact that we are talking about
  1244. 45:10this, we are saying certain things, our
  1245. 45:11thoughts, he has the right to react to
  1246. 45:13this, he has the right to hear and
  1247. 45:14consider it. We don't want anything bad
  1248. 45:16for him, we are simply describing the
  1249. 45:18situation, because he
  1250. 45:19>> is in a warm bath.
  1251. 45:20>> We remember how the war started. He
  1252. 45:22surrounded himself with such people, I
  1253. 45:24say again, Tatarov, Yermak, Demchenko,
  1254. 45:26those people who simply didn't report
  1255. 45:28the start of the war, who said no, it
  1256. 45:30won't happen. I’ll say this: everyone
  1257. 45:32talks about how Budanov warned us. I
  1258. 45:34recently met with people from the NSDC,
  1259. 45:36and they said they were at a session on
  1260. 45:39February 17, 2022, when the Americans
  1261. 45:41said war was coming, and an off-site
  1262. 45:43NSDC meeting was held in Kharkiv. So,
  1263. 45:45both Budanov and Zaluzhny said the war
  1264. 45:47would happen, but we knew the attack
  1265. 45:50would come from the territory of the DPR
  1266. 45:52and LPR. And all the troops were
  1267. 45:54gathered and sent there. So, how did it
  1268. 45:56happen that we exposed the directions we
  1269. 45:59were actually warned about—Kyiv, Crimea
  1270. 46:01—and sent everything there?
  1271. 46:04We saw that he surrounded himself with
  1272. 46:06the wrong people.
  1273. 46:09>> But, Roman, I remember an interview with
  1274. 46:11Dmytro Kuleba, the foreign minister at
  1275. 46:13the time, who said that back then, there
  1276. 46:15were the Americans and there were the
  1277. 46:17Europeans.
  1278. 46:21The British and the French were
  1279. 46:22integrated there; as I understand it
  1280. 46:24from Kuleba’s words, relying on him
  1281. 46:26again, agents convinced them that no,
  1282. 46:28these are just scare tactics, there will
  1283. 46:30be no offensive.
  1284. 46:32And Zelensky and his team believed the
  1285. 46:34Europeans.
  1286. 46:34>> I agree, let me clarify the situation a
  1287. 46:36bit. The British said the offensive
  1288. 46:38would happen.
  1289. 46:39>> Uh-huh.
  1290. 46:39>> The Americans said the offensive would
  1291. 46:41happen. Uh, the other Europeans, the
  1292. 46:43French and the rest.
  1293. 46:44>> More.
  1294. 46:44>> The Germans didn't know anything at all
  1295. 46:46in parallel, right? The Germans, well, I
  1296. 46:48wouldn't be surprised, considering
  1297. 46:49Russian agents are being detained in
  1298. 46:50German intelligence services today. So
  1299. 46:52the Germans, they just don't, well, they
  1300. 46:54don't coordinate, right. The question is
  1301. 46:56>> that even they said: okay, if you aren't
  1302. 46:59sure if the war will happen or not, you
  1303. 47:01still have to be ready for war. That
  1304. 47:03doesn't rule out the fact that you have
  1305. 47:04to be ready. We weren't forced, and we
  1306. 47:06shouldn't have had to start attacking
  1307. 47:08Russia because of this information.
  1308. 47:10>> Of course, Roman, I remember the
  1309. 47:12directions clearly. The clear directions
  1310. 47:15were known to us. This is going back to
  1311. 47:17your speech regarding the Donbas. There
  1312. 47:19were clear directions. It was the Kyiv
  1313. 47:21region, it was the Chernihiv region.
  1314. 47:22>> We should have expected them. But
  1315. 47:24instead, we moved troops away from here
  1316. 47:26. So my question is, who advised the
  1317. 47:28President to do that, and is he capable
  1318. 47:30today? And that is why we are talking
  1319. 47:32about how our conversations, dialogues,
  1320. 47:34and discussions—which I know the
  1321. 47:36President listens to, just like other
  1322. 47:38people, maybe not ours, but he hears a
  1323. 47:41lot—he should take them as us wanting to
  1324. 47:43help with information, so that the
  1325. 47:45people around him who effectively
  1326. 47:47deceived him in 2022, led him astray, or
  1327. 47:49he led them astray, so that he doesn't
  1328. 47:51rely on their information.
  1329. 47:53>> You know, from time to time, I happen to
  1330. 47:55see, out of inertia and not on purpose,
  1331. 47:57videos from those who work for the
  1332. 47:59President's Office, certain bloggers. I
  1333. 48:01won't say now who they are.
  1334. 48:04And I see that when these tapes come out
  1335. 48:06, already for the second time, they
  1336. 48:08convey the message that the President
  1337. 48:10has been left alone.
  1338. 48:13Can you imagine what it's like inside a
  1339. 48:15person who has been left alone? He has
  1340. 48:17no one left to trust because everyone
  1341. 48:19turns out to be a traitor, says this
  1342. 48:20blogger.
  1343. 48:23So, I mean that when someone has
  1344. 48:25betrayed you—well, even in the life of
  1345. 48:27everyone watching this broadcast—we draw
  1346. 48:30conclusions internally about how we
  1347. 48:32should select or surround ourselves with
  1348. 48:34people so they don't have the qualities
  1349. 48:36and the background of those who betrayed
  1350. 48:38us and, ultimately, betrayed the country
  1351. 48:41.
  1352. 48:43It seems to me that it's, well, it's
  1353. 48:45very easy to understand.
  1354. 48:47I don't know if the President
  1355. 48:48understands this. We will see by his
  1356. 48:50actions. Everything can be seen through
  1357. 48:52actions and words.
  1358. 48:53>> I would add to your words that they
  1359. 48:55didn't just betray the President, they
  1360. 48:56betrayed Ukraine.
  1361. 48:57>> 100%.
  1362. 48:58>> He has the right and
  1363. 48:59>> the opportunity to look around Ukraine,
  1364. 49:01to analyze who the people are that did
  1365. 49:03not betray Ukraine, who went and took up
  1366. 49:05arms, who started to fight. Let him look
  1367. 49:07to these people and listen to them. And
  1368. 49:09maybe something will change. But he kept
  1369. 49:10the same people around him who betrayed
  1370. 49:12him and now says he has no one to listen
  1371. 49:14to. Well, that's his problem and that's
  1372. 49:16his choice.
  1373. 49:17>> It is his choice. And ultimately, I feel
  1374. 49:19, I would like to discuss this right now
  1375. 49:22, and I will.
  1376. 49:24He should come out—if he isn't planning
  1377. 49:26to run for a second term or if our
  1378. 49:28country and he himself are important to
  1379. 49:30him, since his children, his wife, his
  1380. 49:33family, his parents, quite rightly, if
  1381. 49:35there is a truce soon, will live in our
  1382. 49:37country. And if it's not soon, they will
  1383. 49:39live here anyway. God grant everyone
  1384. 49:41health.
  1385. 49:42He should come out and say that I will
  1386. 49:44not run for a second term.
  1387. 49:47I want to, right now, having drawn
  1388. 49:49conclusions, finish my work, reform and
  1389. 49:51strengthen the country, jail all those—
  1390. 49:54not just Kolomoisky, but all those who
  1391. 49:56commit crimes here—and select qualified
  1392. 49:59people. I think there are people to
  1393. 50:01choose from, there are people to choose
  1394. 50:03from, there is simply no desire to do so
  1395. 50:04. And when he says that he will not
  1396. 50:06remain for a second term, it's not just
  1397. 50:08a question about him. It is also a
  1398. 50:10question about his inner circle, who
  1399. 50:12realize that there will be no one left
  1400. 50:14to protect them.
  1401. 50:16Because he simply won't be running.
  1402. 50:17>> Today, a second term is understandable.
  1403. 50:20He needs to bring his first term to a
  1404. 50:22logical conclusion—that's the first
  1405. 50:24thing. And I think that only after he
  1406. 50:25completes it will he decide whether to
  1407. 50:27go further or not.
  1408. 50:28>> Yes, but if I were in his place, I would
  1409. 50:31accept our, our...him going further now
  1410. 50:33.
  1411. 50:34>> No, I'm telling you, he thinks: what if
  1412. 50:36there's a victory, what if Russia
  1413. 50:37collapses tomorrow and we win, what if
  1414. 50:40its economy tomorrow...
  1415. 50:41>> We are realists, we see that there are
  1416. 50:43things that likely will not happen.
  1417. 50:45>> Thinking something like that.
  1418. 50:47Therefore, I don't think he will take
  1419. 50:49that step.
  1420. 50:51>> For now, we will just keep watching.
  1421. 50:53Roman, I thank you for the analysis.
  1422. 50:55Roman Chervinsky, a legendary Ukrainian
  1423. 50:57intelligence officer. By the way, for
  1424. 51:00those who are not aware of Roman
  1425. 51:02Chervinsky and his actions, I will
  1426. 51:04remind you that Roman Chervinsky headed
  1427. 51:06the SBU's Fifth Directorate, which at
  1428. 51:08one time liquidated Givi and Motorola,
  1429. 51:10led a GUR unit that was involved in the
  1430. 51:12operation later named Wagnergate, and
  1431. 51:15was involved in kidnapping a witness in
  1432. 51:17the 2014 Malaysia Airlines flight
  1433. 51:19downing case.
  1434. 51:20And, as you know, he faced suspicion
  1435. 51:23from the SBU over the alleged
  1436. 51:24recruitment of a Russian pilot, which
  1437. 51:26led to the shelling of the Kanatove
  1438. 51:29airfield. American media write that
  1439. 51:31Chervinsky is involved in the bombing of
  1440. 51:33the Nord Stream pipeline. More.
  1441. 51:35More.
  1442. 51:37For now.
  1443. 51:38For now. Friends, thank you for watching
  1444. 51:40our conversation to the end, and I hope
  1445. 51:42you found it interesting. Write in the
  1446. 51:44comments what you think. Don't forget to
  1447. 51:45subscribe to this channel where you are
  1448. 51:47watching this video.
  1449. 51:50And in the description, as always, we
  1450. 51:52are raising funds for our soldiers—this
  1451. 51:55time for Mavics.
  1452. 51:57So go ahead, take a look at what the
  1453. 51:58fundraiser is for. Maybe when you watch
  1454. 52:00the stream, there will be a different
  1455. 52:02fundraiser, or maybe we will have closed
  1456. 52:03that one. But keep helping the Armed
  1457. 52:05Forces. That is the most important thing
  1458. 52:07—to help the Defense Forces. Subscribe,
  1459. 52:09leave a like. Stay on this channel.
  1460. 52:11Thank you.

About this transcript

This page contains the full transcript of ⚡НАБУ, СБУ і Хімпром. Розвідник Червінський назвав головне ім'я! by Yanina Sokolova, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 9,096 words across 1,460 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.

What you can do with it

Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.

Free YouTube transcript tool

YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.