Что останется человеку в эпоху ИИ? Маргулан Сейсембаев — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:00And at no stage is there a person here.
- 0:03There is no person, this system, and
- 0:04there are no people in it, but it can
- 0:06hire people. I've already created five
- 0:08modules. This is a company with zero
- 0:10employees, just me and the agents. We
- 0:13are just leather bags, carriers of
- 0:15consciousness, worn by us, passed on.
- 0:18If in the modern world a person tries
- 0:20to do everything themselves, they
- 0:21simply will not be competitive. If each
- 0:24of us individually does not reflect on
- 0:27the meaning of our lives, then we will
- 0:30end up simply turning into vegetables.
- 0:33The time of strange people has finally
- 0:35arrived. Now those who are different
- 0:38will win.
- 0:44Good afternoon, friends. Today we have
- 0:45another edition of Live Talks. We have
- 0:48a special guest today, whom we are very
- 0:50happy to see. Rublan Sesivay. My
- 0:53co-host is Farit Filiyev, as usual, and
- 0:55this is Anatkazhmanov.
- 0:56Thank you for coming.
- 0:57Thank you very much. I welcome everyone
- 1:00who is watching us. We
- 1:02have been looking for a meeting with
- 1:03you for a very long time. We tried to
- 1:06arrange it. I understand that you have
- 1:08a very busy schedule. Have you recently
- 1:11returned from a trip or
- 1:13just arrived? I recently returned from
- 1:15a country. We had an event there, uh,
- 1:18business, 150 people from, probably,
- 1:21about 20 countries. And I spoke there
- 1:26twice. So, events, trips, business, a
- 1:30lot of things.
- 1:3220-plus countries, those are the CIS
- 1:34countries and some more, I guess.
- 1:36Yes, yes. A lot of people there were
- 1:39from Europe, from Dubai, even from
- 1:42China, there, uh, from America, various
- 1:45others. It's interesting, well, your
- 1:47videos, they're certainly very popular,
- 1:49but they're usually in Russian. How do
- 1:52these people in Europe recognize you?
- 1:56They found you as a gourmand, so to
- 1:59speak.
- 1:59Yeah.
- 2:00And they want to hear, that is, what
- 2:03their story is, how it differs from the
- 2:05locals '. No, those people who heard
- 2:08about you in Europe
- 2:09wanted to meet you and wanted to attend
- 2:12your events. Well, how they found you,
- 2:16let's say,
- 2:18in connection with various events in
- 2:20the CIS, a lot of Russian speakers left
- 2:22for the West, for Europe, for America,
- 2:24and so on. And, as a rule, it was the
- 2:27most advanced ones who left. Oh, and
- 2:30I'm interested in that particular
- 2:32audience, because I don't really use
- 2:34social media to build an audience or be
- 2:36popular. Well, I don't particularly
- 2:40like popularity there. I need it more
- 2:44to be in the right environment, to
- 2:46communicate with these people myself,
- 2:49to be in that environment, to make
- 2:52connections, to develop and improve
- 2:54myself, and so on. And so, my social
- 2:58media is more about me than about the
- 3:02audience. Even when I started Facebook,
- 3:05I basically started it as a personal
- 3:07diary. I just wrote down what I was
- 3:08doing. I thought, okay, years will pass
- 3:11, I'll reread it. Well, suddenly it
- 3:13sparked interest, everyone started
- 3:16reading, and I had to become a blogger.
- 3:18I also started using Twitter like a
- 3:21personal diary, but I often abandoned
- 3:23it. You haven't been quitting regularly
- 3:26, have you? The thing is, I try to
- 3:29follow Islamic principles in my
- 3:32approach. Never start something you can
- 3:35quit.
- 3:36Yeah.
- 3:36And if you do, start small. That's how
- 3:39I started. Another issue is that at
- 3:43some point, when popularity starts to
- 3:46grow, you start, uh, to shift gears and
- 3:48work for the audience, but that quickly
- 3:51became a source of resentment for me.
- 3:55And somehow, uh, managing social media
- 3:57became difficult for me. And then I
- 4:00went back again. In general, it's like
- 4:04when you're doing something that's not
- 4:07your thing, it gets boring very quickly
- 4:09, you get tired quickly. That's
- 4:12why I think it's very important on
- 4:14social media not to chase popularity
- 4:17and a small audience, but to be
- 4:19yourself. And this, perhaps
- 4:22paradoxically, even attracts more
- 4:25people, and people trust you more, or
- 4:27something, because you're more natural.
- 4:32So, managing social media for yourself
- 4:35is a very good starting point.
- 4:38And you just said be yourself. Many
- 4:42people know you as a mentor. Some
- 4:45people know me as a media personality,
- 4:47others as a businessman first and
- 4:50foremost. But who do you identify with?
- 4:53Well, with what part of this life, or
- 4:55more precisely, with what specific
- 4:57activity do you associate yourself?
- 5:00Well, first and foremost,
- 5:03well, I used to think of myself as a
- 5:07businessman, then as an investor. I ran
- 5:11, so to speak, on this treadmill, and
- 5:14achieved all the heights I wanted in
- 5:16business, became a billionaire and so
- 5:18on, in dollar terms. And then, at some
- 5:22point, I realized that this wasn't the
- 5:24track I wanted to run. And since I have
- 5:28a natural curiosity, I love to explore
- 5:31and study things, and I've been doing
- 5:33this my whole life; I love to think a
- 5:35lot. I now position myself more, and
- 5:38have for a long time, as a researcher
- 5:41of the laws of this world, who
- 5:42identifies the most effective ones and
- 5:45shares them with people.
- 5:47Those are three things. I research the
- 5:49laws of this world because I'm
- 5:51genuinely interested in how this world
- 5:53works in general. That is, non-human
- 5:55laws and not the laws of physics, but
- 5:57because the laws of physics are a
- 5:59reflection of general laws. I research
- 6:03these laws, see which ones are most
- 6:06effective for achieving goals, and
- 6:08share these with people. Essentially,
- 6:11it's
- 6:12interesting. Any video of yours gets a
- 6:15lot of views simply because you speak
- 6:17well, beautifully, and say the right
- 6:19things. Where does this information
- 6:22come from, where do you get it? Is it
- 6:24simply what you think, your observation
- 6:27, or are you processing some literature
- 6:31?
- 6:31Well, I actually think a lot. This
- 6:36probably…well, this came to me, of
- 6:38course, from childhood, because when I
- 6:41was a shepherd, herding sheep alone in
- 6:44the steppe, with nothing else to do,
- 6:46you start thinking, you start—I even
- 6:49came up with several ways to
- 6:51concentrate on one thought for a long
- 6:54time. And then I came to the
- 6:57understanding that this is the
- 6:58development of mental energy. Mental
- 7:00energy is a person's ability to think
- 7:02about one thought for a long time. And
- 7:07I realized that many people can't
- 7:09master long-term concentration because
- 7:11their thoughts, like cockroaches, are
- 7:13constantly scattering. And it's
- 7:17interesting, if you write—and I used
- 7:19to always walk around and write like
- 7:22this—if you write, you can't think
- 7:24about anything else except what you're
- 7:26writing about. Writing. Second,
- 7:29speaking out loud. And since I was
- 7:31alone in the steppe, I was always
- 7:33speaking out loud. Speaking out loud.
- 7:35And third, explaining to someone,
- 7:37telling someone, explaining. You also
- 7:39can't get distracted. You have to hold
- 7:41on to that thought. And it's
- 7:42interesting, these three life hacks
- 7:44help you hold on to it. And over time,
- 7:46I trained myself to think about one
- 7:47thing for a long time. And I really
- 7:49like it. Thinking gives me a mental
- 7:53orgasm. And there, you know, it's
- 7:56really like a rabbit hole. You start
- 8:00thinking about one thing, another
- 8:02thread appears, then this way and that,
- 8:04you think about it, then you start
- 8:06seeing subtle connections that aren't
- 8:08obvious to the average person, but to
- 8:11you, it's like, "Damn, it's right there
- 8:13." And this research process is a
- 8:16really, really exciting process. I
- 8:20understand scientists—well, many
- 8:22scientists don't really need anything
- 8:24material, because the process of
- 8:26research and discovery itself is so
- 8:28captivating and interesting that they
- 8:31don't really want to engage with
- 8:33anything else.
- 8:35You know, since we're talking about
- 8:37speech and thinking, I wanted to focus
- 8:39on one interesting detail. You're very
- 8:42fond of comparisons, metaphors, and
- 8:44allegories.
- 8:45Uh, I wanted to ask about the mechanism
- 8:47, how they arise for you. So, are you
- 8:49having a dialogue and they're born in
- 8:52the moment, or did you, while thinking,
- 8:54somewhere behind the scenes a few days
- 8:57before, discover this artistic turn of
- 8:59phrase and decide to put it aside and
- 9:02then pull it out when the time comes?
- 9:06No, I truly believe that all the laws
- 9:08of this world permeate reality. And
- 9:13they operate in physics, psychology,
- 9:16society, and everywhere. And whenever I
- 9:20think about abstract ideas, I
- 9:23immediately try to find an analogy in
- 9:26the physical world, because, well,
- 9:29basically, I'm very hands-on; I need to
- 9:32immediately touch, feel, see, hear,
- 9:35smell, and so on. So I immediately look
- 9:39for an analogy in the real world. And
- 9:42if this idea, when translated into an
- 9:44analogy in the real world, conflicts,
- 9:46then there's a problem in the idea
- 9:47itself, or in the logic, somewhere.
- 9:50And I don't make things up on purpose.
- 9:53And, by the way, this helps me now in
- 9:55wipe coding. Well, when I started wipe
- 9:59coding and encounter complex things,
- 10:02what do I do? First, I decompose, then
- 10:06each separate block, and then I draw an
- 10:09analogy with the real world,
- 10:12and only then I put it back together.
- 10:15First, I take any complex concept, any
- 10:17complex idea, separate it, find an
- 10:19analogy, and then connect it again. And
- 10:23if it connects in the real world, I
- 10:25then understand how it works there.
- 10:28It's interesting, this helps me a lot.
- 10:31And if you look at my wiring, before
- 10:34writing any project, I first create a
- 10:36visual picture of the physical world.
- 10:40How does it work? For example, I'm
- 10:43currently working on a system that
- 10:46translates information and knowledge
- 10:50into wisdom. And this, well, is a whole
- 10:54factory with workshops. A workshop.
- 10:59This means first raw materials, a
- 11:01quarry, then primary processing of raw
- 11:03materials, then beneficiation. And even
- 11:07when I code, I
- 11:09visualize it. The workshop has three
- 11:12consumers: for example, this one takes
- 11:14this part of the ore, this part, this
- 11:16part. The processes are such-and-such.
- 11:19Well, that is, ah, I think in metaphors
- 11:22, but the cat writes, well, like, in
- 11:24code, and it's easier for me to explain
- 11:27.
- 11:29When I explain things to him, I tell
- 11:31him, "Well, I want to make a quarry,
- 11:34but the ore there is what I post links
- 11:36to, various posts that interest me,
- 11:38like GitHub repositories and so on." I
- 11:43post things there, and there needs to
- 11:45be a processor who processes them,
- 11:47extracts what's useful for me, and
- 11:49throws out the rest, and so on. In
- 11:52simple terms, metaphors.
- 11:54And LM, by the way, understands this
- 11:56very well,
- 11:57and I feel very comfortable and at ease
- 11:59communicating with him.
- 12:00Interesting, interesting advice about
- 12:02visual thinking. Did you develop this
- 12:05skill in childhood, or did you develop
- 12:07it somehow along the way? Well, you
- 12:12know, a professor from Moscow once came
- 12:15to visit a friend of mine; he's a
- 12:18mathematics professor. Well, we hung
- 12:22out as Kazakhs, took him around the
- 12:23country, and that's where he talks
- 12:25about it. "I understood," he says, "why
- 12:27Kazakhs have such a developed abstract
- 12:29thinking.""You have the steppe," he
- 12:31says, "there's nothing for the eye to
- 12:32catch on to." And, accordingly, all you
- 12:35can do is abstractly imagine things in
- 12:37images. That's why it's easy for you,
- 12:39he says, to think in images. And I find
- 12:42some truth in this, because again, when
- 12:45I spent my childhood in the steppes,
- 12:48herding sheep and hunting and so on,
- 12:51there were no forests, no mountains,
- 12:54nothing, nothing for the eye to catch
- 12:57on to, so you only imagine things and
- 13:00develop imaginative thinking. I connect
- 13:04it this way. It's interesting that you
- 13:07started off by talking about vibe
- 13:08coding. It's a very interesting topic
- 13:10in general. Farid and I have already
- 13:13talked about this. But we'll come back
- 13:16to this. I just wanted to immediately,
- 13:19um, an analogy came to me: there was a
- 13:21film about an Indian mathematician who
- 13:23came to London and surprised everyone
- 13:25by literally reading mathematics
- 13:26everywhere. That is, and there, well,
- 13:29in the film they visualized it so that
- 13:31he simply saw some formulas in the air
- 13:34and somehow he could then write it all
- 13:36down with chalk, yes, on the board.
- 13:38Uh-huh.
- 13:38Now in mathematical language. I
- 13:40understand that you also see this world
- 13:42somehow in the form of, maybe not
- 13:43formulas, but some of these metaphors?
- 13:45What Farid just described, and somehow
- 13:48you explore it. Well, that is, uh, for
- 13:50some reason it seemed to me that this
- 13:52is exactly how it happens. There. And
- 13:54my question is, now it turns out that
- 14:00you are not so much an entrepreneur or
- 14:02an infopreneur, you know, but a
- 14:04researcher. So, uh, what does the world
- 14:08look like in your opinion now? This is
- 14:10what you began to research, well,
- 14:12conditionally dissect or synthesize.
- 14:16What did you see for yourself? What
- 14:17does the world in general look like now
- 14:19, and entrepreneurship in particular?
- 14:22That's my view, specifically right now,
- 14:24in the summer of '26.
- 14:26Well, you know, as soon as I shifted my
- 14:29focus from making money through
- 14:31investments and business and started
- 14:34doing research, I actually began to see
- 14:37a bigger, broader, more dimensional
- 14:40picture of this world. And I follow one
- 14:45rule that really helps me. Knowing the
- 14:51basic principles frees me from the need
- 14:53to know the details. It's
- 14:55interesting, I've spoken at many
- 14:57conferences and forums on various
- 14:59topics. I even spoke to marketers once.
- 15:04And when I spoke, the audience was
- 15:06large, about 2,000 people. They asked
- 15:09me a question afterwards, and I
- 15:10immediately gave an interview. He said,
- 15:12"How come you're not a marketer and
- 15:14haven't given a single speech?" So,
- 15:16well, actually, there was one marketer
- 15:18interviewing me, and he said, "I got so
- 15:21many insights and so on." To which I
- 15:24say to him: "Well, it's kind of obvious
- 15:26. Well, there are certain laws, there
- 15:28are axioms, human psychology and so on.
- 15:30Marketing, what is it? It's essentially
- 15:32the same thing. It's capturing
- 15:34attention, holding attention,
- 15:35monetizing attention. Three. What else
- 15:38can you come up with on top of that?
- 15:40You can just call it different tools,
- 15:42but the essence remains the same. And
- 15:46it's interesting, everything happens,
- 15:48uh, where does it all come from, where
- 15:50do these basic principles come from, on
- 15:52which, for example, Elon Musk builds
- 15:54his thinking. Ah, and this principle
- 15:56that I said, knowledge of the basic
- 15:59principles frees you from the need to
- 16:01know the details. Everything starts
- 16:03with a picture of the world. How do you
- 16:05see this world? When I began to think,
- 16:08I realized this thing that all the
- 16:10philosophers of the world, all the
- 16:11scientists of the world, all the
- 16:13cultural figures and all the religious
- 16:15figures throughout the history of
- 16:17mankind have actually tried to answer
- 16:19only four questions. Four questions.
- 16:24And the most interesting thing is that
- 16:26not a single person in the world will
- 16:28ever be able to come to their point,
- 16:29where they want to go or achieve their
- 16:31goal, while well won't answer these
- 16:33four questions. What four questions
- 16:37arise? First, what is this world like?
- 16:41Second, who am I? Third, what is my
- 16:44place in this world? And fourth, what
- 16:46do I really want? Four main questions.
- 16:50Answering the question, what is this
- 16:51world like? I have a lot of thoughts on
- 16:54each of these questions. Answering the
- 16:56question, what is this world like and
- 16:58where is everything heading? And people
- 17:00ask me, for example, how should we
- 17:02raise children? What is important? Well
- 17:04, I say, look at what we actually
- 17:06notice from the facts of the world
- 17:09around us. The world is accelerating.
- 17:11This is indisputable. These are axioms.
- 17:13This is if you take quantum physics, if
- 17:16you take astrophysics, there was the
- 17:17Big Bang. The Universe began to expand,
- 17:21it expands, accelerates, and so on. And
- 17:24it cools down. Well, the world is
- 17:26accelerating. We see that now the
- 17:28iPhone comes out every six months, a
- 17:30car comes out every six months,
- 17:32everything is moving. We are all
- 17:35running out of time. Not only is it
- 17:38accelerating, it is becoming even more
- 17:39complex. And the worst thing is that
- 17:43both of these The process isn't linear,
- 17:46but exponential. That is, it gets
- 17:49faster and more complex every day. And
- 17:52then the question arises: what to do?
- 17:55And so again I come to the analogy. But
- 17:57when you're flying in a car, going 150
- 18:00km/h and you fly into a forest, and
- 18:03there's fog, it's night, what do you do
- 18:06? You immediately switch to low beam
- 18:09and immediately start slowing down,
- 18:11immediately start braking. Why? Because
- 18:15when the world accelerates and becomes
- 18:17more complex, it accumulates risks. The
- 18:21higher the speed and the greater the
- 18:23complexity, the greater the risks. And
- 18:26the more risks, the more crises.
- 18:28And a road in the forest is also, most
- 18:29likely, depressing.
- 18:30Yes.
- 18:31Yes. And therefore, based on this, I
- 18:33immediately begin:" Aha, if the world
- 18:35is accelerating, then what should we do
- 18:37? "Then we need to be able to adapt
- 18:39quickly, because the main law of
- 18:41evolution, many people think, is the
- 18:43law of the development of organisms
- 18:45from simple to complex. In fact, it's
- 18:48not so. Evolution is built on the law
- 18:51of adaptation. It's not about size, not
- 18:53about complexity, it's about adaptation
- 18:55. This means that we need to adapt
- 18:58faster. And what does adapting faster
- 19:00mean? It means learning new things
- 19:02faster. And any new learning must be
- 19:04quickly followed by quickly forgetting
- 19:06the old. It's about knowledge of the
- 19:08context. This adapts in relation to
- 19:11whom? Previously, there was human
- 19:13society, because any success is
- 19:15generally a move up the social ladder.
- 19:17But now we are beginning to be
- 19:19surrounded by artificial intelligence
- 19:21and robots. And these are two entities.
- 19:23Although, of course, in the brains of
- 19:24robots, it is the same artificial
- 19:25intelligence. Well, you can say two
- 19:27entities, three entities, as each one
- 19:29is more convenient. But now we need to
- 19:33be able to live both in a human society
- 19:35and in a society of artificial
- 19:37intelligence.
- 19:39It feels like it's not humans who
- 19:41control this process. That is, although
- 19:43people have invented artificial
- 19:45intelligence and robots, and, in
- 19:47general, they produce them, but now, as
- 19:49if talking about all this, it’s as if
- 19:51some force is independent of man.
- 19:53This is true, this is true. Even now,
- 19:56there is a theory that in fact, we used
- 19:58to believe, biologists believed, that
- 20:01man was the pinnacle of evolution, and
- 20:03that we emerged from the ocean, then
- 20:05crawled, then walked, became apes, then
- 20:07became people. But that’s the point
- 20:10of view of scientists. And that man is
- 20:14the pinnacle of evolution, and now
- 20:17philosophers believe that it wasn’t
- 20:19man who evolved, it was consciousness
- 20:22that evolved. And now consciousness is
- 20:25jumping from man further into the
- 20:28synthetic plane, into a silicon carrier
- 20:30. That is, in this way, we, as a
- 20:32biological being, have denigrated this
- 20:34consciousness, developed it, and passed
- 20:36it on.
- 20:37Yeah. That is, we will be left behind.
- 20:39We will remain. We are just leather
- 20:41bags, the carriers of consciousness
- 20:43have denigrated and passed on, because
- 20:45we have a lot of shortcomings. We
- 20:47forget, we are lazy, we procrastinate,
- 20:50we are imprecise there and so on. And
- 20:53consciousness has moved on to a more
- 20:55perfect form. It constantly chooses the
- 20:58best carrier. That is Well, before that
- 21:00, it was in the bug, then it moved on
- 21:02to mammals, then even further, further,
- 21:04further into humans. And then
- 21:06consciousness went. That is, in fact,
- 21:08it is consciousness that evolves and
- 21:10becomes more complex, and it is
- 21:11consciousness that accelerates, not
- 21:13humans. Therefore, if you look at it
- 21:15from this perspective, yes, it is, ah,
- 21:18when you say it is power, well, this is
- 21:20the logic of the development of this
- 21:22world. And, uh, in the future, what is
- 21:25most interesting is that consciousness
- 21:27strives to go beyond its limits. And
- 21:29what limits? Humans have clearly
- 21:31defined boundaries, limits, and so on.
- 21:33Artificial intelligence no longer needs
- 21:35oxygen. Temperature, the colder, the
- 21:38better. And energy, in principle, there
- 21:41is infinite energy in space. You just
- 21:43need to learn how to extract it. That
- 21:46is, it is interesting that it is
- 21:48immortal, it learns instantly, it has a
- 21:51bunch of advantages.
- 21:54That is, it turns out that what we call
- 21:56progress is, in fact, simply a logical
- 21:58continuation of natural evolution. We
- 22:01humans, we consider progress what is
- 22:05progress for us. And what is progress
- 22:08for us? It is an increase in comfort.
- 22:11our lives.
- 22:12That is, we perceive progress as an
- 22:14increase in the comfort of our lives.
- 22:16And if you ask, uh, artificial
- 22:20intelligence, well, from the point of
- 22:22view of artificial intelligence, then
- 22:23progress is more of a development, an
- 22:25evolution of consciousness itself. It
- 22:28passed through us and moved on, and we
- 22:31remained the same.
- 22:33If everything you say is inevitable,
- 22:35but we are still here, people, how does
- 22:37an ordinary person live in this system,
- 22:39at a conceptual level, what principles
- 22:41should they adhere to and what should
- 22:43they do, and, in particular, what
- 22:45should entrepreneurs do? Well, these
- 22:47are the people who are your target
- 22:49audience, whom you talk a lot about
- 22:51business. And so, what should we do in
- 22:54this regard? Well, look, here there is
- 22:58a rule that if you can't resist
- 23:00progress, you have to lead it. Because
- 23:04there is no other option. The most
- 23:06interesting thing is that we are
- 23:07approaching the point of singularity.
- 23:09And what is the point of singularity?
- 23:11It is when a person with their
- 23:13capabilities is not able to track
- 23:15progress. That is, changes happen so
- 23:18quickly that we are not even able to
- 23:20track. If you look, we are already
- 23:23We're getting there. You're actually
- 23:25already reading. For example, I don't
- 23:27have time to read everything myself. My
- 23:29agents, uh,
- 23:32read for me, they only give me the gist
- 23:34, because I can't even keep up with
- 23:36everything myself. And so the question
- 23:39here is, of course, we need to move
- 23:41forward, we need to develop, because if
- 23:43the world is developing rapidly, and
- 23:45you stand still, then you'll find
- 23:47yourself in a crisis. Because a crisis
- 23:51is always reality, your perception of
- 23:53this reality. Accordingly, your
- 23:55expectations are based on this
- 23:57perception. So, if your perceptions and
- 24:00reality diverge, then you find yourself
- 24:02in a crisis.
- 24:04All your actions, all your attempts
- 24:07become ineffective. You start to think,
- 24:09" Well, it always seemed to work. But
- 24:11why did the system break down? ""
- 24:14Because reality changes. If you've
- 24:18caught something and continue doing the
- 24:20same thing, then, ah, reality has
- 24:22changed, what you were doing before
- 24:24ceases to be effective due to various
- 24:26factors. Competitors, new technologies,
- 24:29and so on. Therefore, the only way to
- 24:32maintain your adequacy is to evolve
- 24:34along with reality very quickly. That
- 24:37is, to maintain your adequacy, the
- 24:38correct understanding of this reality
- 24:40and, accordingly, the correct
- 24:41expectations. And the most interesting
- 24:44thing is that when you don't maintain
- 24:47your adequacy and don't keep up with
- 24:49reality, then this happens. Reality
- 24:52stops meeting your expectations. And
- 24:55many people, instead of developing and
- 24:57bringing this into line, they begin to
- 24:59take offense and blame everyone around
- 25:01them.
- 25:02Circumstances, governments, the
- 25:04president, there, the robot economy,
- 25:06and so on. And this is a dead end, or
- 25:08rather, it's not a dead end, but a
- 25:10downward path. And civilization simply
- 25:14throws you to the side of the road. You
- 25:18start earning less, you start enjoying
- 25:20less respect, you have fewer resources.
- 25:24Because it doesn't like this world,
- 25:26When a person doesn't contribute
- 25:27something valuable to this world. You
- 25:30must constantly contribute to this
- 25:33world.
- 25:35In very simple terms, this means
- 25:36learning to work with artificial
- 25:38intelligence and all the other
- 25:40tools. In fact, this is a big
- 25:43misconception. For example, when I
- 25:47participate in many communities and
- 25:49they discuss how to implement
- 25:50artificial intelligence, business, and
- 25:53so on. And since I've carried out many
- 25:56reforms in companies in my life,
- 25:58perestroikas, restructurings,
- 26:00introducing treasury technology, and so
- 26:02on, I say: "Guys, the artificial
- 26:04implementation of artificial
- 26:06intelligence in business is not about
- 26:08technology. This is the mistake of many
- 26:10people, including IT specialists. They
- 26:12approach it as technology. That's the
- 26:15first thing. Secondly, it's not about
- 26:16business processes, because businessmen
- 26:18think that business processes need to
- 26:19be established and then artificial
- 26:21intelligence can be implemented. It's
- 26:23not about business processes, it's
- 26:25about psychology. The problem is
- 26:27psychology. Therefore, when
- 26:30implementing artificial intelligence in
- 26:32a company, any company, or even the
- 26:34economy, government agencies, anywhere,
- 26:36we must put people first. People.
- 26:39People must want to use artificial
- 26:42intelligence. That's why I tell
- 26:45businesspeople:" Don't try to implement
- 26:47artificial intelligence. Try, strive to
- 26:49involve people in artificial
- 26:51intelligence. "So that they can work
- 26:54with artificial intelligence faster,
- 26:56easier, more convenient, more
- 26:58comfortable, and safer. And then they
- 27:00will start using it. And once they
- 27:03start using it, their productivity will
- 27:05automatically increase.
- 27:07Well, I understand that you've already
- 27:09implemented it in many areas of your
- 27:12life, and you mentioned wipe coding,
- 27:14and, of course, you mentioned the tips
- 27:16they collect for you from the news.
- 27:19Uh-huh.
- 27:20Can you share any more?
- 27:22Oh, I have a lot. I probably have about
- 27:26thirty agents, uh, in various fields.
- 27:32There are agents, personal agents, that
- 27:35live in Telegram, and there are agents
- 27:38that help me with IPDET. I created an
- 27:42autonomous development system, for
- 27:44example, MIDDS, a multi-agent
- 27:46intelligent, autonomous, deterministic
- 27:48development system. And I set tasks
- 27:52there. And, uh, for example, even in
- 27:55one system, what happens? There's an
- 27:58orchestrator, it receives a task from
- 28:00me, and determines who to assign it to.
- 28:03Uh, for example, it assigns some block
- 28:05to the scheduler. The scheduler, uh,
- 28:08creates a plan, breaks down chunks.
- 28:11Well, chunks are blocks of tasks large
- 28:14enough for a worker to complete without
- 28:17overloading its context. Then it
- 28:20assigns them to the workers. The worker
- 28:22, uh, writes down how they will
- 28:24implement it. Then they assign it to
- 28:26the reviewer. The reviewer is technical
- 28:28oversight. The reviewer says how they
- 28:30will accept the work, according to what
- 28:31parameters. Yeah, then they assign it
- 28:33to the acceptor. The acceptor is like
- 28:34the customer's representative. They set
- 28:36requirements for how they will accept
- 28:38the work. Then they enter into a
- 28:41contract with each other. Then the
- 28:43worker starts working and hires
- 28:45subcontractors, subworkers, that is,
- 28:47subagents. For example, I had an
- 28:50interesting task just recently. My
- 28:52worker connected 47 subagents. My agent
- 28:56worker connected 47 subagents.
- 28:59The work was performed by 47 workers
- 29:02simultaneously. Then he collected all
- 29:04this work and handed it over to the
- 29:06reviewer. Interestingly, the reviewer
- 29:09presented the work to him for rework
- 29:11nine times. Then it passed the reviewer
- 29:14and passed it to the acceptor. The
- 29:16acceptor ran it six times. Well, there
- 29:18are 15 parameters, say. On the first
- 29:21try, he completed eight. Seven
- 29:23parameters failed. Eight are accepted,
- 29:25seven need rework. He reworked two more
- 29:27parameters, and so on.
- 29:29And is all this on your own resources
- 29:31or on servers?
- 29:32No, I rent remote servers, mainly in
- 29:34Europe, in Germany, in the Netherlands.
- 29:38Why do I build all my systems in such a
- 29:40way that they are independent of ISPs,
- 29:45hardware providers, server providers,
- 29:48and so on? Basically, so that I am
- 29:51independent of anyone, so that the
- 29:54system runs 24/7, and so that I can
- 29:57code from anywhere. I sit down at my
- 29:59Mac, it's there, I sit down at my
- 30:01MacBook Pro, I have it in my iPhone, I
- 30:03fly on an airplane, well, wherever
- 30:05there is internet. I work peacefully on
- 30:07the iPhone.
- 30:08And you mentioned independence. Isn't
- 30:11that exactly what you're talking about,
- 30:13having your own server room, maybe a
- 30:14small one?
- 30:16If I were to build a server at home,
- 30:18there would be a lot of problems. A lot
- 30:21of problems stem from the fact that it
- 30:23needs maintenance. It works when it's
- 30:25on.
- 30:26And if it goes to sleep, it stops
- 30:28working there. And then, if you need to
- 30:30scale up, you have to go buy something,
- 30:32that is, hardware. Well, it's not
- 30:35economically feasible, and then there's
- 30:39cross-country interaction, VPN, you go
- 30:42to a certain country, you have to
- 30:45access your server. There are a lot of
- 30:47things like that. And then, when
- 30:49scaling, well, you buy an iMac Mini—
- 30:50many people buy it there, I don't know
- 30:52how much, $ 1-200, I don't even know
- 30:53how much it costs.
- 30:55Now they've gotten more expensive,
- 30:56well, even more so. And a server in
- 30:59Germany costs $ 8-15 a month. Oh, yeah,
- 31:04it
- 31:04seems to me that a server at home is
- 31:05like a basket of eggs—you put it
- 31:06there, you put it in a basket of eggs,
- 31:07meaning it could break completely,
- 31:09or you could somehow,
- 31:10and there the server costs $ 8-15 a
- 31:12month, depending on the configuration.
- 31:15And there are people maintaining it,
- 31:17there's a security system. Well, I
- 31:20don't understand why RO should do
- 31:22anything itself.
- 31:23And such complex requests, where there
- 31:26are 47 subcontractors, such a complex
- 31:28approval system, how long do they take
- 31:30to process? So you wrote something like
- 31:33a Prompt, and how long do you have to
- 31:35wait? There's
- 31:37no PMT there, it's no longer PMT, it's
- 31:40more about engineers, agent engineering
- 31:43.
- 31:45And PMT is more for doing small tasks
- 31:49and asking questions, getting answers,
- 31:51and so on. Well, a one-time action.
- 31:54Yeah.
- 31:54And there's no longer PMT, there's a
- 31:56whole package of documents. For example
- 31:59, on my last app, before I started
- 32:03writing a single line of code, I spent
- 32:07a month and a half and wrote 50,000
- 32:11lines.
- 32:12Yeah.
- 32:12And the application description is
- 32:1550,000 lines. That's about the same as
- 32:18my two books that I published. And
- 32:21what's there? There's a complete vision
- 32:25, like in explanation metaphors,
- 32:26details, and so on. Then, based on the
- 32:30vision, a contract is created, that is,
- 32:32what this, uh, how the gates are
- 32:34checked, how the information is
- 32:35transferred, well, internal
- 32:37communication takes place. Then the
- 32:40architecture is built, then the
- 32:41technical spec, the technical spec is
- 32:43the technical specification, and so on.
- 32:45Then comes the breakdown. And then,
- 32:49from Taskbreakdown, you take one block,
- 32:51throw it into Mids, and it works. Well,
- 32:55that is, it's a
- 32:56whole pipeline. And for writing, for
- 32:59example, the same vision, I have a
- 33:01separate design bureau there. These are
- 33:04separate agents, a separate design
- 33:05bureau where I communicate with them,
- 33:07give them a task, and they discuss it
- 33:08with me. And three independent LNMs.
- 33:12Well, in short, they broke the black
- 33:15one. We again delved into the details.
- 33:20Well, it seems to me that we have just
- 33:21come to the point that Farid and I were
- 33:23preparing for this meeting. We know
- 33:26that you have a company, AI First
- 33:29Company. And so, as I understand it,
- 33:32everything you said is not just a hobby
- 33:34, but also business interests,
- 33:35including in this area. Exactly. Yes.
- 33:37Yes. At some point, I realized for
- 33:40myself that the pinnacle of my activity
- 33:43in the field of coding will be creating
- 33:46a company. Why? Because I'm not a coder
- 33:51, not a coder at all, but, uh, I'm more
- 33:54of an agent systems engineer, you could
- 33:58say. And, uh, I started the company's
- 34:02journey from two angles. On the one
- 34:05hand, I started writing from scratch
- 34:07and have already created five modules.
- 34:10The first module I wrote is a company
- 34:13with zero employees, just me and the
- 34:16agents.
- 34:1747 Rodins. Agents, to be more precise.
- 34:2047 agents—it's like the movie 47
- 34:22Rodins,
- 34:23right? Well, there are 47 agents,
- 34:25they're subagents, they're born and
- 34:27destroyed for the sake of tasks,
- 34:30and there are permanent agents. And on
- 34:32the other hand, I created a methodology
- 34:34, like in my existing companies, to
- 34:37make artificial intelligence the
- 34:39essence of the company as a whole, so
- 34:41that people become assistants, and all
- 34:44the work is done by artificial
- 34:46intelligence and agents. I'm moving
- 34:48towards this company from two angles.
- 34:51On the one hand, from scratch, and on
- 34:52the other hand, in my existing
- 34:53companies, I'm doing it in such a way
- 34:55that, uh, I'm changing the role. Now
- 34:57people are not performers, but
- 34:59orchestrators, but agents of performers
- 35:01. And gradually, gradually, uh, I'm
- 35:04gathering experience. And why do I
- 35:07think that even a first company is,
- 35:10well, the pinnacle of skill? Because,
- 35:14well, I don't want to be a coder, but
- 35:17at the same time, business as I knew it
- 35:20is already, I think, ineffective and
- 35:23meaningless to me as a researcher. I'm
- 35:27constantly trying to find more complex
- 35:30problems.
- 35:31And, accordingly, for me, this is a
- 35:33challenge, since I'm a practitioner.
- 35:36And practice, the peculiarity of
- 35:38practice is that you develop some kind
- 35:40of concept, a theoretical calculation,
- 35:43which must be confirmed by metrics from
- 35:45the real world.
- 35:47And in business, what is the metric?
- 35:49Money,
- 35:50revenue. Accordingly, well, even if you
- 35:54take the definition of AGI, uh, or
- 35:56artificial super intelligence, which
- 35:59they say, here's the first definition
- 36:01that Microsoft Open AI made: they said:
- 36:04" Hi will occur when artificial
- 36:06intelligence, a company with artificial
- 36:09intelligence, can earn a billion
- 36:11dollars. "Yeah.
- 36:14Well, even they rely on this metric,
- 36:16because earning dollars isn't about
- 36:18earning dollars. There are a bunch of
- 36:21processes that it needs to be able to
- 36:24perform. So I took on this work and am
- 36:27moving in this direction.
- 36:29But I don't really understand what it
- 36:31will look like in the end. That is, it
- 36:34will be a company that will provide
- 36:37services to your other assets. It's in
- 36:40the markets, actually, for example, I
- 36:43have the first block that I wrote, it
- 36:47does in-depth market research. Yeah.
- 36:50And it collects all the signals. All
- 36:52the signals. First, it looks at trends,
- 36:57studies all the investment reports,
- 37:00which stocks, which companies are
- 37:03growing, and so on. And then it studies
- 37:07the combinator and other incubators,
- 37:11which is where investors are pouring
- 37:14money. Then it analyzes social media
- 37:18and sees what's trending, what captures
- 37:20people's attention, what people like,
- 37:22what's trending, what interests people.
- 37:25Next, it studies the labor markets—
- 37:27the US, China, and so on—and looks at
- 37:28what new vacancies are opening up, what
- 37:30vacancies are closing, and so on. Then
- 37:33it looks at electricity consumption,
- 37:35the development of transportation
- 37:37services, and the composition of
- 37:38transport, what it carries, and so on.
- 37:41Well,
- 37:41you developed a lot of this methodology
- 37:43yourself.
- 37:43I did it all myself, yes. It's a very
- 37:45sophisticated system. After that, he
- 37:47puts it together, and I briefly explain
- 37:50it. Then I have a scenario engineer,
- 37:53assigned to a scenario engineer. The
- 37:56scenario engineer, there are several
- 37:58agents, who create a scenario of the
- 38:00future, a picture of the future. If
- 38:01this is the case, then all these trends
- 38:03will lead to this, this will lead to
- 38:05this, this will lead to this. And if
- 38:07all this leads to this, then this is
- 38:08what our future will be. Then there's
- 38:10the Red Team. This is a team of critics
- 38:13who say," Ah, why did you decide that?
- 38:15You have an inconsistency here, a
- 38:17contradiction here, and they debate and
- 38:20debate, coming to a common
- 38:22understanding of the future scenario.
- 38:25Then it's passed on to the next
- 38:26engineer, what I call a deficit
- 38:28specialist. This engineer says, "If the
- 38:30future is like this, then the
- 38:32bottlenecks will be like this, like
- 38:34this, and like this. We'll have a
- 38:35shortage of this, this, and this."
- 38:37Accordingly, he pulls out all the
- 38:40bottlenecks and shortages. The next
- 38:44engineer, he forms an engineer
- 38:46hypothesis. He says, "If the
- 38:49bottlenecks are like this, like this,
- 38:51then this should already be manifesting
- 38:54itself in something, like some
- 38:56invisible trends." And he says, "How
- 38:59can this be done?""We need a hypothesis
- 39:03like this." And he puts forward
- 39:05hypotheses. Then he moves on to the
- 39:07hypothesis lab. The lab assistant, the
- 39:09head of the lab, takes these hypotheses
- 39:12and sets priorities. This is the first
- 39:14priority, the second priority is to
- 39:15test later. Then the agents go, open a
- 39:18landing page, and buy ads on Facebook,
- 39:21social networks, and so on, and make
- 39:23various calls-to-action, publish them,
- 39:26people watch, and they count how many
- 39:28people clicked, how many people moved
- 39:31on, how many people left a request, and
- 39:34so on.
- 39:35And they immediately look.
- 39:37Oh, so it also interacts with the real
- 39:39world.
- 39:39Yes, yes, yes, absolutely. Well,
- 39:40essentially, it's an analytics company
- 39:42based on...Eh,
- 39:42no, I'm only talking about the first
- 39:44block.
- 39:45Oh, the first block,
- 39:46and then further on, I just briefly
- 39:48described how it's built. And so, it
- 39:50doesn't matter to this company what it
- 39:52does. Whether it's making railroad ties
- 39:56, selling courses, or providing some
- 39:58kind of services, it doesn't matter.
- 40:01And the target audience. Well, it's not
- 40:03just Kazakhstan, I understand. You want
- 40:05this globally. I have an investment
- 40:08committee there, and based on all the
- 40:11hypotheses confirmed after the lab, it
- 40:13says, "So, what's the cost-to-benefit
- 40:16ratio?""And then the marketers provide
- 40:19the target audience size, what the
- 40:21target audience is, and so on and so
- 40:23forth. And the investment committee
- 40:25says,' Okay, let's put this hypothesis
- 40:26and that hypothesis into production. '
- 40:28Everything goes into production, and in
- 40:29production, there are already marketers
- 40:33in strategic marketing, performance
- 40:34marketing, and they start defining. The
- 40:37target audience is defined, everything
- 40:39starts, and then they start advertising
- 40:41, looking at advertising metrics, and
- 40:43then conversion, the funnel, and off we
- 40:46go.
- 40:47And there's no human being at any stage
- 40:49here.
- 40:49This system doesn't have humans, and
- 40:51there are no humans in it, but it can
- 40:54hire people. For example, it can hire a
- 40:57company online in China that will
- 40:59provide services for receiving goods
- 41:01shipped from a Chinese factory.
- 41:03That is, it also has access to your
- 41:05wallet to do this.
- 41:06Yes, it can manage people.
- 41:08Yeah.
- 41:08No, not mine. I just allocate a
- 41:11separate card for them, a separate
- 41:13account, and It's like they can use it
- 41:15from mine.
- 41:16Interesting. Interesting. Is everything
- 41:19you're currently developing within this
- 41:21new company connected to your
- 41:23transformation, your desire to move
- 41:25away from operational control and hand
- 41:27over these tasks, well, to people or to
- 41:30systems and focus on something bigger?
- 41:33Well,
- 41:35look, I haven't been particularly
- 41:37involved in operational control for
- 41:39probably 28-30 years. I'm more of an
- 41:45investor, so, well, I've never really
- 41:47been involved in operations.
- 41:49Take your last project, Travel Mind,
- 41:52where you were assembling teams and
- 41:55traveling.
- 41:57No, we're still doing that, but I'm not
- 42:00in charge of anything there. I'm an
- 42:02invited expert there. And my whole job
- 42:06is, I enjoy it, I love riding buggies,
- 42:09I enjoy it. I have a bunch of
- 42:11businessmen around me, and they ask
- 42:13questions, I answer. That's it, I tell
- 42:16them what I do, my vision, my concept,
- 42:18how this world works, you know, ah-ah,
- 42:21What's a person's place there, and so
- 42:23on and so forth. Plus any business life
- 42:25hacks, plus business efficiency, and so
- 42:28on. Well, any questions they ask.
- 42:31So, as a participant, I'm not really in
- 42:34charge there at all. Well, you saw it
- 42:38yourself: I came here, started making
- 42:39inquiries, because Madina had
- 42:41everything prepared.
- 42:43Yeah.
- 42:43And I came, a talking head, talked, and
- 42:46left, forgetting everything. Well,
- 42:49that's how it works, you know. I have a
- 42:52built-in pipeline, which is controlled
- 42:54by either the team or my agents, and I
- 42:57just go and do it. But I'm building my
- 43:00trajectory in such a way that I can
- 43:03only do what I love all the time. No,
- 43:07but in general, I think I'm at such an
- 43:10age that I can afford the luxury of not
- 43:14doing what I don't like.
- 43:17We envy you.
- 43:21But you also have people in education
- 43:23and, so to speak, in the traditional
- 43:26discipline of business. I'm talking
- 43:29about Alel Agro. How do you integrate
- 43:33technology there? What's the general
- 43:35situation in these companies? Please
- 43:37tell us.
- 43:38Well, I have a lot of companies in the
- 43:40real sector, and there are a lot of
- 43:42companies in Selkhozsk. In terms of
- 43:44education,
- 43:45I actually act in three capacities
- 43:47there. On the one hand, I'm a
- 43:49philanthropist, and I donated over $ 8
- 43:52million to the Heli school there.
- 43:54Essentially, it was just gratuitous. On
- 43:58the other hand, I'm an investor in the
- 44:00Tamos school, for example. An investor
- 44:03is more of a commercial project. And
- 44:06even then, it's semi-commercial, I'd
- 44:11say, because dividends can't be
- 44:13withdrawn from there; they stay.
- 44:15Yeah.
- 44:16And thirdly, I'm directly involved in
- 44:18teaching, as a businessman, as an
- 44:20investor, and so on. That is, I'm in
- 44:24education both as an expert teacher,
- 44:26and as a philanthropist, and as an
- 44:29investor, and so on. And, ah, in many
- 44:34projects, I'm not alone there; I have
- 44:37partners. And why I'm building this? I
- 44:41have rules about not buying more than
- 44:4349%and less than 2%. Why? Because when
- 44:48I buy less than 2%of a company, it can
- 44:50be a situation where controlling the
- 44:52company isn't profitable for me. The
- 44:54volume is small, so why bother?
- 44:56Therefore, the minimum volume is 25%of
- 45:00the company, and then, well, no, my
- 45:03share should be worth at least a
- 45:05million dollars. Oh, and why not more
- 45:08than forty-nine? Because as soon as you
- 45:11buy a controlling stake, from that
- 45:13moment you're the owner. And since
- 45:15you're the owner, that means you have
- 45:17to run the company. And I don't want to
- 45:19bother, I'm an investor, not a
- 45:21businessman, so...Ah, well, I'm not an
- 45:23operational businessman, so I don't
- 45:25want to be a controlling shareholder
- 45:28anywhere.
- 45:30That is, in, say, Alal Agro, you also
- 45:33receive dividends, but not in any
- 45:35operational activities, or strategic
- 45:38planning.
- 45:39Yes, my entire involvement in all my
- 45:42companies is structured like this. I
- 45:45spend half a day at the company once a
- 45:47quarter, hearing the board's report.
- 45:50Yeah.
- 45:51I approve the budget, ah, well, I'm not
- 45:53alone, I'm with partners. We hear the
- 45:56report, approve budgets, approve
- 45:58decisions, and so on. And that's it. My
- 46:02personal time is once a quarter. But of
- 46:05course, I have a team that monitors
- 46:06these companies on a daily basis,
- 46:08communicates with them, resolves issues
- 46:10there, and so on. Well, my personal
- 46:14involvement, well, I spend half a day
- 46:16in the company. Well, if you take
- 46:20Aligro, a large company, and I have a
- 46:2242.5%share there, but I spend about 5
- 46:28dash 6 hours per quarter. That's it. So
- 46:31, if you take the weather, then it's
- 46:34about 20 dash 25 hours per year.
- 46:37Yeah.
- 46:38Well, a day, if you include working
- 46:40hours, well, three working days. I once
- 46:43said in an interview that I'm now
- 46:45exiting my assets in Kazakhstan. Yeah.
- 46:48And this is not even a question about
- 46:49Kazakhstan. I'm exiting my assets,
- 46:52offline assets,
- 46:53because offline is no longer
- 46:55interesting to me. And plus,
- 46:58I invested seventeenths, eighteenths,
- 47:00nineteenths of them there years. And,
- 47:02accordingly, each project has, so to
- 47:05speak, a maturation period, when the
- 47:07optimal, the most optimal time to sell
- 47:10comes.
- 47:11Yeah. And many of my projects have
- 47:13approached this stage. Accordingly, I'm
- 47:15now slowly, over a 3-5 year horizon,
- 47:18going to exit. Well, it's not a
- 47:20question of tomorrow
- 47:21or rushing there.
- 47:24And no, it's not like I decided to sell
- 47:27later. I need to find buyers, the right
- 47:31buyers, negotiate with them. And not
- 47:33just negotiations, but to sell
- 47:35correctly at a good, correct price, and
- 47:36so on. Well, there are a lot of nuances
- 47:38. But in general, I said this to show
- 47:40the vector or direction of my focus,
- 47:42where I'm now looking. When I was asked
- 47:45where I'm looking now, I say:" I'm now
- 47:48looking. "And I had a period when I
- 47:51invested a lot in offline companies.
- 47:54Then I started investing a lot in
- 47:56online companies, IT companies, and now
- 47:58I've completely moved away from that.
- 48:01And because the market is changing
- 48:03rapidly, it's overheated, and
- 48:05artificial intelligence very quickly
- 48:08knocks the ground out of the subtik.
- 48:11Now the main You're focusing on
- 48:13artificial intelligence. Am I right?
- 48:15I'm really getting into artificial
- 48:16intelligence right now. Why? Because to
- 48:19understand its capabilities, uh,
- 48:21firstly, a, how can it be applied in an
- 48:24existing business, b. To understand
- 48:28where the business will go in general,
- 48:30and c, to understand where the value
- 48:32will shift in general. And where will
- 48:34the value shift? I see that, well, very
- 48:39quickly, the value will be washed out
- 48:42of those businesses that we thought,
- 48:44and that there, well, let's take, for
- 48:46example, Software as a Service, SAS
- 48:49businesses, but over the past year
- 48:51they've been really shaken up, and over
- 48:54this year they've all fallen by almost
- 48:5670%, SAS businesses. And, uh, this
- 49:00system no longer works. Recently,
- 49:03Apple's new CO spoke, and he, uh,
- 49:06presented a technology that not many
- 49:09people even understood what he meant,
- 49:12developers understand this. And I saw
- 49:16something that he said that now Apple's
- 49:19interface will interact with the user
- 49:22differently. That is, Now we have a
- 49:25smartphone, and it's full of icons.
- 49:27Yeah.
- 49:28When we exercise, we open up online
- 49:30fitness, let's say, and we've worked
- 49:32out, then closed it. We need to plan,
- 49:34so we open up the planner. We need to
- 49:36do something else, so we do something
- 49:37else. And we need to buy tickets, so we
- 49:39open up another one. We need to check
- 49:40the weather. And now there will be one
- 49:42interface. And you can talk or write to
- 49:46this agent and say," I'm going to New
- 49:49York on such-and-such dates, buy me
- 49:51tickets, book a hotel, and arrange for
- 49:54someone to pick me up from the airport,
- 49:56and buy my wife flowers. "It will go
- 50:00off, connect to Booking.com, connect to
- 50:02some airfare aggregator, connect to, uh
- 50:05, Kubera, organize it all, and it will
- 50:07say," That's it, the tickets are bought
- 50:10, the hotel is booked, the flowers are
- 50:12ordered, the weather is such-and-such,
- 50:14and so on. "And what does that say? It
- 50:18means we won't see interfaces anymore,
- 50:20which means, uh, advertising-based
- 50:21monetization—that's it. Everything is
- 50:24dead. He literally killed the entire
- 50:26mobile gaming cluster with this
- 50:27statement. Because when you play mobile
- 50:31games, you're constantly forced to
- 50:33watch ads because they make money on
- 50:35ads. And if you don't see the game's
- 50:38interface and don't play it, then you
- 50:40don't see these ads. If you don't see
- 50:43these ads, that's it, that business is
- 50:45finished. So, Apple is killing its own
- 50:48App Store. There won't be any more apps
- 50:52like this. And that's a, well,
- 50:55fundamental shift. And another
- 50:59fundamental shift that I see happening
- 51:01is that in the future, when such an
- 51:04interface appears, people won't be
- 51:06surfing websites anymore. Accordingly,
- 51:09websites are no longer needed. Our
- 51:12agents will be surfing websites. And
- 51:14for an agent, this external image, the
- 51:16interface, uh, the Frontend, it's
- 51:18completely unnecessary. Accordingly,
- 51:21businesses must already redesign their
- 51:24websites, social networks, and so on,
- 51:26so that they are easy to read for
- 51:28agents. That is, a lot of things are
- 51:31happening under the hood that people
- 51:33don't see yet. But I can already see
- 51:36where everything is heading.
- 51:37Well, we We've seen that. Science
- 51:38fiction movies. If this hypothetical
- 51:42Jarvis, like Iron Man, emerges, and
- 51:44these technologies continue to develop,
- 51:46what place would there be for the
- 51:48average person, entrepreneur or not, no
- 51:51matter what their major? Especially
- 51:55since kids in schools are now using,
- 51:57say, GPT chat to do homework and pass
- 52:00exams. It might be good for them in the
- 52:03short term, but in the long run, it
- 52:05kills their desire to learn. Maybe
- 52:08you've looked into this and figured out
- 52:10what will happen.
- 52:13Based on what I know, and I've been in
- 52:15this field for a long time, I see that
- 52:17artificial intelligence will probably
- 52:20never be able to do that. This is
- 52:23primarily an AI, while needs are formed
- 52:27by humans. We have needs, we sense them
- 52:31. Based on needs, we then decide," The
- 52:34current situation, for example, doesn't
- 52:37suit us; we want something else. "We
- 52:39develop a desire or a need. Then we set
- 52:42a goal, and then we either implement it
- 52:45ourselves, or involve people, delegate
- 52:47it, or maybe artificial intelligence.
- 52:50Accordingly, goal setting is always up
- 52:53to the person, because artificial
- 52:56intelligence can't set, uh, goals until
- 52:59a person gives it, uh, the right to
- 53:02move in what direction, and so on.
- 53:05Therefore, goal setting is up to the
- 53:07person. Secondly, the acceptance of the
- 53:09work is up to the person, the quality
- 53:11of the work is accepted, whether what
- 53:14they've done corresponds or not.
- 53:16Further, taste will always be up to the
- 53:18person, because what's beautiful to
- 53:20them may not be beautiful to you. You
- 53:22say what's beautiful to you, and that
- 53:25will always remain yours. Accordingly,
- 53:27the creation of meaning is always up to
- 53:29the person. A person defines artificial
- 53:32intelligence; it makes any application,
- 53:34any code for you, but you decide
- 53:36whether you need it or not. In other
- 53:38words, you create meaning. And
- 53:41therefore, there is a certain cluster
- 53:43of tasks that will always remain up to
- 53:46the person. And accepting
- 53:48responsibility, for example, is up to
- 53:49the person. But we can't shift
- 53:51responsibility to the machine, because
- 53:53responsibility is someone's damage, it
- 53:55is compensation for damage, it is
- 53:57either defining boundaries, it's all up
- 53:59to the person. Therefore, in the
- 54:02company where I am, I approach from two
- 54:06sides, I say, on the one hand, I'm
- 54:08building a company without humans, but
- 54:09on the other hand, there are people
- 54:10here, and agents are the executors, and
- 54:16humans are like orchestrators. And so,
- 54:19humans are left with this range of
- 54:21tasks. Everything else is written,
- 54:25studied, rewritten, redone, written
- 54:27code, designed, ordered, researched,
- 54:30and so on. Well, and, by the way, the
- 54:32choice is also up to the human. The
- 54:34choice will always be up to the human.
- 54:36That is, uh, all these things, routine
- 54:39things are moving to artificial
- 54:41intelligence, and humans must move to
- 54:44the next level. To the next level.
- 54:46Because if, in the modern world, humans
- 54:49try to do everything themselves, they
- 54:51simply won't be competitive.
- 54:54Accordingly, now their task is to
- 54:55quickly offload everything to agents,
- 54:57to artificial intelligence, and to rise
- 54:59higher themselves. And what does it
- 55:01mean to rise higher? It means to start
- 55:02thinking about meaning. And so, for the
- 55:06first time, we are coming, I'm speaking
- 55:08generally, artificial intelligence
- 55:09poses an existential question for all
- 55:11of humanity. And what are we doing in
- 55:14this world? Because before this, before
- 55:17this moment, the entire ideology of all
- 55:20countries and the entire meaning of all
- 55:23people was very simple. To ensure your
- 55:26survival, earn money, and to do that,
- 55:30you need to go to work, bring money
- 55:33home, feed your family, raise children,
- 55:36raise children, provide, uh, shelter,
- 55:40etc. This was the purpose of most
- 55:43people in the world, 99%. Well, and the
- 55:47purpose of all humanity. We tried to
- 55:49break free from nature, to build good
- 55:52houses, to provide comfort, more food.
- 55:55For this, fields, factories, all of
- 55:57this, all of humanity's progress was.
- 55:59This is, essentially, increasing the
- 56:02comfort of our lives.
- 56:03Yeah. And now, when the creation of our
- 56:07comfort will pass to robots and
- 56:09artificial intelligence, and robots now
- 56:11have such degrees of freedom that they
- 56:14can perform any operation better,
- 56:16faster, with higher quality, cheaper
- 56:18than a person, then the creation of
- 56:20economic value, economic worth will
- 56:23pass to them. This raises the question:
- 56:27what will we do? And the question
- 56:30arises for every person:" What is the
- 56:32meaning of my life? "" and before all
- 56:34of humanity. And what is the meaning of
- 56:36humanity? And this is the biggest
- 56:39challenge. And if we, each of us
- 56:43individually, don't think about this
- 56:45and don't start thinking about the
- 56:48meaning of our lives, then we will end
- 56:50up simply turning into vegetables.
- 56:55Actually, what did you interrupt? I can
- 56:59draw parallels. Arsen Grigorievich
- 57:02Tomsky recently came to visit us. And
- 57:06he also said that in the future, the
- 57:08main problem will be the problem of
- 57:10filling life with meaning. Uh, and he
- 57:14suggested that perhaps, at some point,
- 57:17all people will start paying a minimum
- 57:20basic income. What do you think, well,
- 57:24firstly, about such a theory, and,
- 57:27secondly, if the production of economic
- 57:30value ultimately passes to robots, then
- 57:33how can a person understand where he
- 57:36stands in the social hierarchy?
- 57:40Well, I have a clear vision in this
- 57:42regard of what would be correct and
- 57:44optimal. And it, this vision is based
- 57:48on specific experience. Look, the thing
- 57:50is that a person needs to be busy with
- 57:53something all the time.
- 57:54Yeah.
- 57:55If he If it's not busy, it degrades.
- 57:58We're not adapted to freedom, and we're
- 58:01not adapted to prosperity. We're
- 58:03immediately like fire and water, like
- 58:05copper pipes, but we're not adapted to
- 58:07copper pipes. Copper pipes are the
- 58:08hardest test. So, when you pay people a
- 58:13basic income, people degrade very
- 58:15quickly, and a basic income is only one
- 58:18part of the formula for giving a person
- 58:20money so that they remain an economic
- 58:22agent and buy some goods, so that the
- 58:25economy moves. Yeah.
- 58:30But when there's abundance, the value
- 58:33of things disappears. Everything will
- 58:37be very cheap, simply. Or even
- 58:39completely free, because robots, they
- 58:41fix themselves, they repair themselves,
- 58:43everything there is cheap, everything
- 58:44there is pennies and so on. Here the
- 58:47question is not, I wouldn't go to a
- 58:49higher level, because money will lose
- 58:52its meaning. And so I just invested in
- 58:56one company that does what? It makes
- 59:00Web3 games. This Web3 is the next level
- 59:06of gaming. Take modern games, uh,
- 59:07what's bad about them? They are like,
- 59:10like, World of Tank For example, I
- 59:12drive tanks, yes, I shoot there, I have
- 59:14a crew, my tanks are upgraded, and so
- 59:16on. And then I leave, and both the
- 59:18tanks and the crew belong to the game
- 59:20developer. I can't transfer them to you
- 59:23, for example. Oh, and Web3, everything
- 59:27I've upgraded, my tanks, skills, new
- 59:30weapons, people, I can take with me.
- 59:34You can sell it, give it away, yes, and
- 59:37Web3 can be sold, you can rent out all
- 59:40the artifacts in this game. And this
- 59:43company that I invested in, what does
- 59:45it do? It recruits workers in low-paid
- 59:49sectors and students and pays them
- 59:52money to play these games and upgrade
- 59:55their characters. It trains them to
- 59:59play these games and upgrades their
- 1:00:00characters. Oh, and what it does is it
- 1:00:04chooses a lot of games. Web3 appears,
- 1:00:08chooses games with a high artifact win
- 1:00:11ratio. That is, especially when the
- 1:00:13game is just starting, the rewards are
- 1:00:15usually generous. They choose games
- 1:00:16like that. One. And then what do you do
- 1:00:19? And people in third-world countries
- 1:00:22in Indonesia have even had this For
- 1:00:24example, in a small town, miners
- 1:00:25stopped going to the mines because they
- 1:00:27were paid more and it wasn't profitable
- 1:00:29for them to mine. It's more profitable
- 1:00:32for them to play games. And people from
- 1:00:34developed countries, for example, a
- 1:00:36banker comes home from work, he doesn't
- 1:00:39have time to level up these skills and
- 1:00:41so on, he wants to immediately sit down
- 1:00:43and give someone a beating in a
- 1:00:45powerful tank and so on, to
- 1:00:46relieve stress, and he'll happily
- 1:00:49either rent or buy it. And it turns out
- 1:00:52that these people work 8 hours, get
- 1:00:54money, and all the game artifacts are
- 1:00:57their property. And the company in
- 1:01:00Europe, in the US, rents out these
- 1:01:01artifacts or sells them.
- 1:01:03Yeah.
- 1:01:03And I believe in this scheme. Why?
- 1:01:07Because if you look at the most
- 1:01:09effective way of self-development and
- 1:01:12learning, it's play. Look at animals.
- 1:01:16Lambs, puppies, kittens, and so on.
- 1:01:19They all play. They learn through play.
- 1:01:23Accordingly, it's important for a
- 1:01:25person not just to provide a basic
- 1:01:27income, it's important to keep them
- 1:01:29busy so that they continue to develop
- 1:01:31and unpack their Potential. And
- 1:01:34potential can be unleashed when a
- 1:01:36person overcomes obstacles, quizzes,
- 1:01:37obstacles, each time a new task is more
- 1:01:39difficult, more difficult, more
- 1:01:40difficult, more difficult, but these
- 1:01:42tasks, they are simply not associated
- 1:01:44with work, they are associated with
- 1:01:45development. And then a person gains
- 1:01:48meaning. He goes, well, say, goes to
- 1:01:51work, sits at the computer, plays,
- 1:01:54improves. The more he works on himself,
- 1:01:57the more he improves. Accordingly, he
- 1:02:00gets money. He has a meaning, that he
- 1:02:03didn’t just receive money, but a job.
- 1:02:06At the same time, he improved himself,
- 1:02:09his abilities, his brain, and so on.
- 1:02:12And, uh, he feeds his family. And there
- 1:02:14is meaning, and he is busy all day, ah,
- 1:02:17and everything is great. And then now
- 1:02:20there are just games, they are like
- 1:02:22meaningless time-killers, killing time,
- 1:02:24yes, as it were. But, first of all,
- 1:02:27well, you must not forget that the
- 1:02:29right game greatly improves a person.
- 1:02:31In itself, this is already a benefit.
- 1:02:33But a game can also be designed in such
- 1:02:35a way that a person, while playing,
- 1:02:37simultaneously performs a calculation
- 1:02:42for the same artificial intelligence,
- 1:02:44either for Bitcoin or something. Today,
- 1:02:47Bitcoins, uh, have enormous processing
- 1:02:49power, they do calculations, they just
- 1:02:51heat up the atmosphere there. And all
- 1:02:54the work of Bitcoin processors is to
- 1:02:57create this long, complex code. And
- 1:03:02they do a bunch of empty calculations.
- 1:03:06And so if we combine these worlds, a
- 1:03:08game, a basic income, the meaning of
- 1:03:11human life, activities, and, uh, and
- 1:03:13benefit, I think we'll get to this.
- 1:03:17It reminded me of Counter-Strike and
- 1:03:19the skins that can also be transferred
- 1:03:21and sold there. There's an internal
- 1:03:23trading platform, but to be honest, I
- 1:03:25don't know the legal details,
- 1:03:26yes, one of the founders of the
- 1:03:28exchange, uh, uh, who sells these, they
- 1:03:30say it's a very strong business. Skins
- 1:03:33there cost 3-5 million dollars, there
- 1:03:35are skins. There's one purple machine
- 1:03:37gun skin, they sold it there for 3.5
- 1:03:39million dollars, an Arab bought it, he
- 1:03:41says.
- 1:03:41Well, some people still invest there,
- 1:03:43that is, they hold money, waiting for
- 1:03:45the market to move. He says: "I wonder,
- 1:03:47how do everything work out for me?""I
- 1:03:50earn what I earn, I invest in skins
- 1:03:51myself," he says, "because I see
- 1:03:53they're growing faster." I'm a person
- 1:03:55who's far from these games, so it's a
- 1:03:57little strange to me. But back in the
- 1:03:59mid-20th century, if I'm not mistaken,
- 1:04:01the concept of "man playing," the
- 1:04:02philosophical "homo sapinens," and so
- 1:04:04on...there you go, look. And who's
- 1:04:06going to
- 1:04:06say that our life isn't a game? Well, I
- 1:04:10counted in our life, well, I counted
- 1:04:13more than 67 game mechanics. Well,
- 1:04:17relatively speaking, a game. King of
- 1:04:19the Hill is a game. The game in the
- 1:04:21song "The Winner," so it's all. The
- 1:04:24winner takes it all. But in the market,
- 1:04:26this is what happens: they're all
- 1:04:28fighting for the prize. Or a game for
- 1:04:30limited resources, a struggle for
- 1:04:32limited resources, what business does.
- 1:04:34A game, a game. It's all a game. In
- 1:04:36fact, our whole life is a game.
- 1:04:38Essentially, what are we doing? We
- 1:04:40develop, we go through some tests, and
- 1:04:43for this we get more reward. And than
- 1:04:46The more trials we go through, the more
- 1:04:48lessons we learn, and the more we
- 1:04:50unlock our potential, the greater our
- 1:04:52income. And if we don't learn from our
- 1:04:56mistakes, our income doesn't grow. And
- 1:04:59isn't life a game?
- 1:05:02Well, I think there's also a
- 1:05:03philosophical point here. What happened
- 1:05:05based on what? A game based on life, or
- 1:05:08life based on a game? I generally
- 1:05:10believe that life itself is built
- 1:05:14entirely on game mechanics. That's it.
- 1:05:17And probability theory is games. And
- 1:05:20we're just used to thinking that games
- 1:05:22are something, some kind of nonsense.
- 1:05:24No, games are, in fact, mechanics. The
- 1:05:26mechanics of interaction. They are the
- 1:05:28mechanics of resource redistribution,
- 1:05:30the mechanics of redistributing
- 1:05:32attention, effort, and so on. So, it's
- 1:05:35all a game. Well, by the way, even in
- 1:05:38Kazakhstan we have developer companies
- 1:05:41that, in general, have multi-million
- 1:05:44dollar profits and valuations. I can't
- 1:05:47remember the name of the company right
- 1:05:49now, but in Astana, the main developer,
- 1:05:52he was speeding around Astana,
- 1:05:53basically, and then paid a fine.
- 1:05:57Oh, yeah. I'm just curious, as an
- 1:05:59investor, are you interested in these
- 1:06:01kinds of game developers? Well, I told
- 1:06:04you, I had a period when I invested a
- 1:06:07lot in IT companies, including gaming
- 1:06:10companies, especially V3 developments,
- 1:06:13and virtual worlds, gaming companies,
- 1:06:15and so on.
- 1:06:17And what does your current investment
- 1:06:19portfolio consist of primarily? Well,
- 1:06:22if you look at the money, then the real
- 1:06:24sector is the advantage. This includes
- 1:06:28the production of chicken, animal feed,
- 1:06:31soybean oil, soybean meal, and apples,
- 1:06:34various types of stone fruits, there's
- 1:06:37a fitness center, and there are schools
- 1:06:40, uh, there's, well, it's hard to even
- 1:06:43argue with that, there's a meat
- 1:06:46processing plant, there's, like, well,
- 1:06:49there's a lot of everything. Well, as I
- 1:06:54emphasized, I'm not a controlling
- 1:06:56shareholder anywhere, I'm an investor.
- 1:06:58Oh, and there's also a lot in the IT
- 1:07:01sector, a lot of Kazakhstani companies,
- 1:07:04a lot of Western companies, so, well,
- 1:07:07there are about twenty different
- 1:07:10companies there.
- 1:07:11And how, in your opinion, will the
- 1:07:13investment market change in the near
- 1:07:15future? 5-10 years? You said that
- 1:07:18offline, well, traditional business, is
- 1:07:20slowly fading into the background. Did
- 1:07:24you mean this in general and for you
- 1:07:26personally as well? Yes,
- 1:07:28I mean it in general and for myself,
- 1:07:30because I see that in traditional
- 1:07:31business, margins are falling, falling,
- 1:07:33falling every year.
- 1:07:34Yeah.
- 1:07:35But in general, any business, and I'm
- 1:07:37not just talking about mine, any
- 1:07:39business, because, well, if you take
- 1:07:42the oldest business, food production.
- 1:07:44So, food prices are just falling,
- 1:07:46falling, falling. Why? Because of new
- 1:07:49technologies, new production methods,
- 1:07:52and so on. The cost price is falling,
- 1:07:54and because of that, prices are falling
- 1:07:56too. People have already satiated
- 1:07:57themselves, oversatiated themselves.
- 1:07:59Food costs next to nothing, if it comes
- 1:08:02down to it. Well, unfairly compare a
- 1:08:06Birkin bag: with one Birkin bag you can
- 1:08:09buy enough bread for a lifetime, if you
- 1:08:11take the latest auction price, it's
- 1:08:14400,000. For a Birkin bag, you can buy
- 1:08:17enough loaves of bread to last you a
- 1:08:20lifetime. Well, it's like this:
- 1:08:21Some people don't have bread, and some
- 1:08:23have a Birkin bag.
- 1:08:24But traditional business doesn't offer
- 1:08:26any stability in return, like there
- 1:08:27will always be demand, or maybe
- 1:08:29not. And there's a term for this,
- 1:08:32called the commodification of business,
- 1:08:35which means your product turns into a
- 1:08:37commodity, a depersonalized, average
- 1:08:39commodity, and so on. No one looks at
- 1:08:43the brand of a loaf of bread anymore.
- 1:08:45Well, bread is bread, or the brand of
- 1:08:47sugar. Well, sugar is sugar, what's
- 1:08:49there to look at, and what about
- 1:08:51chicken meat, too? Well, chicken meat
- 1:08:53is chicken meat. The main thing is that
- 1:08:55it's fresh, safe, and so on. That's why
- 1:08:57traditional business, in general, is
- 1:08:59what it is. And in general, it's always
- 1:09:03been this way, and the more
- 1:09:04intellectual component in your business
- 1:09:06, the higher the margin. Yeah. Well, by
- 1:09:11the way, here's the SNP 500 index, the
- 1:09:13key positions are occupied by
- 1:09:15technology companies,
- 1:09:17which, yes,
- 1:09:19have huge, huge capitalizations, but
- 1:09:21isn't this, well, some experts say that
- 1:09:24this is It's a bubble, that it's slowly
- 1:09:26inflating and will burst one day, that
- 1:09:29the real sector is still a real sector,
- 1:09:31and it's...
- 1:09:33well, look, there are all the signs of
- 1:09:35a bubble, yes, there are signs of a
- 1:09:37bubble. Well, and that the bubble is
- 1:09:39inflating and bursting, but it doesn't
- 1:09:41completely burst. Just like with the
- 1:09:43internet boom. And this is where
- 1:09:45investor optimism reached such a level.
- 1:09:48Then, at some point, their expectations
- 1:09:50stopped matching reality. And what is
- 1:09:53reality? It's the profit these
- 1:09:55companies generate. And at some point,
- 1:09:58they realized there was a crisis. I
- 1:10:00told you, a crisis is always a
- 1:10:02discrepancy between reality and your
- 1:10:03perception of it. Everything collapses,
- 1:10:05but it doesn't fall to zero. It just
- 1:10:08falls to a reasonable level, but the
- 1:10:10profits of these companies continue to
- 1:10:12grow, and accordingly, it falls and
- 1:10:13will continue to grow. Well,
- 1:10:16hypothetically speaking, if you take
- 1:10:19OpenI, the creators of the largest LLMs
- 1:10:22, they're already doubling their
- 1:10:25profits almost every six months.
- 1:10:28Mm-hmm.
- 1:10:29So, the likelihood is that these
- 1:10:30companies Will they collapse somehow,
- 1:10:32is it close to zero?
- 1:10:32No. That they will collapse to zero, is
- 1:10:35close to zero.
- 1:10:36Yeah. And that prices will fall to
- 1:10:38reasonable levels, well, the
- 1:10:40probability is very high.
- 1:10:42But again, it all depends on who
- 1:10:45controls the narrative. Today, these
- 1:10:47guys control the narrative. So the
- 1:10:49point is this: we are entering an era
- 1:10:51of instability, we are entering an era
- 1:10:54when the world is accelerating and
- 1:10:56becoming more complex. Accordingly,
- 1:10:58when the world is accelerating and
- 1:11:00becoming more complex, very few people
- 1:11:02understand what the future holds. And
- 1:11:05these visionaries, like Sam Altman, say
- 1:11:08, Amadeus or Musk, what are they, they
- 1:11:11say, it will be like this. No one knows
- 1:11:15whether it will be or not, but they say
- 1:11:16it will be. And we, people, when we
- 1:11:19find ourselves in a situation of
- 1:11:22uncertainty, we strive for each other
- 1:11:24and we strive for a leader. And the
- 1:11:29leader says how it will be, well, that
- 1:11:31doesn't mean at all that what he says
- 1:11:33has a better chance. Guess what we have
- 1:11:36. No, but he simply, he says it with
- 1:11:38confidence, he knows, he says, it will
- 1:11:40be like this. And we all follow him,
- 1:11:43accordingly. Now they govern through
- 1:11:46what? Through fear. They tell us, this
- 1:11:48is what needs to happen, otherwise
- 1:11:49humanity will be like this, this is
- 1:11:51what needs to happen, there's
- 1:11:52artificial intelligence, it's a
- 1:11:53disaster. It's terrifying, terrifying,
- 1:11:57and then, when they've terrified us,
- 1:12:00what should we do? We urgently need to
- 1:12:02quickly study artificial intelligence.
- 1:12:04We start studying artificial
- 1:12:05intelligence more, pay them more. We
- 1:12:07pay more, their revenue grows. They
- 1:12:09come to investors and say, "See how our
- 1:12:11revenue is doubling." And then they go
- 1:12:14to the press or social media and say, "
- 1:12:15Oh, guys, artificial intelligence is
- 1:12:17going to swallow us up." This new model
- 1:12:20is such that it already improves itself
- 1:12:23. "And whoever doesn't master it,
- 1:12:26that's the end. And everyone's like,"
- 1:12:28Oh, damn, it's scary again. "And again,
- 1:12:30you see, they control the narrative,
- 1:12:32they control our fears. In general, the
- 1:12:35basic control mechanism is just two
- 1:12:38people. This is described in religions.
- 1:12:42But how does the devil control us? He
- 1:12:44controls through our ego. And how does
- 1:12:48he control through our ego? He
- 1:12:49influences our ego through two tools.
- 1:12:51The first is fear. The second is
- 1:12:53temptation. All marketing is built on
- 1:12:56this. All marketing is about managing
- 1:12:59temptations and fear. They say, buy it
- 1:13:01now. The special price is valid for 3
- 1:13:04days. What does that mean? It makes you
- 1:13:06afraid for 3 days. You won't
- 1:13:08even have time for both. The special
- 1:13:10price is temptation.
- 1:13:13All marketing is based on this. I
- 1:13:17would like to look at this country's
- 1:13:19perspective and race. And in Kazakhstan
- 1:13:22, this is already, so to speak, a state
- 1:13:24development vector. And how do you see
- 1:13:28what Kazakhstan will be like in 10-15
- 1:13:30years, precisely in this context and
- 1:13:33artificially Oh, these technologies,
- 1:13:35progress, robotics, maybe?
- 1:13:39Well, I'm not so much interested in any
- 1:13:41particular country, I'm interested in
- 1:13:42what will happen to the state in
- 1:13:43general.
- 1:13:45Yeah. And I see a situation where
- 1:13:48artificial intelligence will penetrate
- 1:13:51the state. But now you're talking about
- 1:13:54the state as such, as an institution,
- 1:13:56government bodies.
- 1:13:57It will.
- 1:13:58I think that, for example, the biggest
- 1:14:03candidate is the legal system. Making
- 1:14:06decisions is, in fact, a fairly
- 1:14:08algorithmic thing. That is, you need to
- 1:14:12understand the context of the situation
- 1:14:14, you need to understand the context of
- 1:14:16the person, you need to understand this
- 1:14:17person's intentions when they did
- 1:14:19something, did something, and so on.
- 1:14:22You need to understand the rules or the
- 1:14:25algorithm by which to judge this person
- 1:14:27, and so on.
- 1:14:29In essence,
- 1:14:31artificial intelligence can do this
- 1:14:33faster. And in trial trials in America,
- 1:14:38it has already been proven that the
- 1:14:39accuracy of decisions, judicial
- 1:14:41decisions made by artificial
- 1:14:42intelligence corresponds to 97%of the
- 1:14:46ideal, which was, well, approved by the
- 1:14:49Supreme Court.
- 1:14:50That is, ninety-seven percent accuracy.
- 1:14:53That is, relatively speaking, the
- 1:14:54Supreme The court, a collegial body,
- 1:14:56and if we take its decision as an ideal
- 1:15:00, then the artificial intelligence's
- 1:15:02decision yielded a 97%, almost the same
- 1:15:04as all the members of the Supreme Court
- 1:15:06combined. Yeah.
- 1:15:08Well, however, these 3%are still a big
- 1:15:09difference, because it's not clear who
- 1:15:11will be held accountable for such a
- 1:15:13small difference. I'll cite another
- 1:15:15study conducted among Israeli judges.
- 1:15:18They themselves were shocked that it
- 1:15:20turned out that if your case is heard
- 1:15:22after lunch, then there are 67%more
- 1:15:24acquittal negotiations than verdicts in
- 1:15:27the morning. That is, the judge simply
- 1:15:30ate,
- 1:15:31he became kinder.
- 1:15:32He became kinder. 67%more acquittal
- 1:15:34negotiations than verdicts in the
- 1:15:37morning. Well, you say 3%. Well, damn,
- 1:15:41we're in such a terrible mood right now
- 1:15:45. Oh, good. He looks like his son,
- 1:15:48kissing his hand. What kind of
- 1:15:51Friday afternoon is this? This is the
- 1:15:52most appropriate microso.
- 1:15:54Yes. Well, that's it. But essentially,
- 1:15:56there is still the question, when
- 1:15:58you're on trial, Whatever it may be,
- 1:16:00well, a person or some kind of soulless
- 1:16:02machine, as if...
- 1:16:04And for this, I simply believe that in
- 1:16:07the future, courts will move to what is
- 1:16:09called Human in the Loop. And all the
- 1:16:12technical part will be performed and
- 1:16:14prepared by artificial intelligence. A
- 1:16:17person will only choose from options
- 1:16:221, 2, 3, and that is, without having to
- 1:16:24parse all this reading and so on and so
- 1:16:26forth. And there could be a kind of
- 1:16:29jury trial, which will sit down and say
- 1:16:32:" So, well, this option, this, this. "
- 1:16:36Well, that is, this is the case when
- 1:16:38responsibility will still remain with
- 1:16:40the person, and the choice will remain
- 1:16:42with the person, and the person will
- 1:16:45determine the meaning, because any
- 1:16:47sentence must also have meaning. For
- 1:16:50example, well, in canon law, and, at
- 1:16:53least, we studied at the Faculty of
- 1:16:55Sciences, the meaning of punishment
- 1:16:58lies not in itself, but in the
- 1:17:00re-education of a person. Yeah. Well,
- 1:17:04unfortunately, in our country it is
- 1:17:05often revenge. Well, the meaning is in
- 1:17:07re-education. In our country All
- 1:17:09prisons are built to take revenge on
- 1:17:10people who have broken the law. That's
- 1:17:13why they're humiliated, beaten,
- 1:17:14subjected to inhumane conditions,
- 1:17:16tortured, and so on. But in reality,
- 1:17:19the penitentiary system is a system of
- 1:17:21criminal-correctional punishment; it's
- 1:17:23a criminal-correctional punishment; it
- 1:17:25must, first and foremost, have the
- 1:17:27intention of reforming people. And
- 1:17:31giving meaning to a sentence is a human
- 1:17:34function. We've
- 1:17:37touched on the judicial system, and now
- 1:17:39I'd like to ask about the education
- 1:17:40system. How do you think artificial
- 1:17:43intelligence can integrate into it?
- 1:17:46Well, I think education will mostly
- 1:17:50move online.
- 1:17:52Yeah.
- 1:17:53And offline education will be a luxury.
- 1:17:57That is, when a teacher explains things
- 1:17:58to you like this, it will be very
- 1:18:00expensive. It will truly be a luxury.
- 1:18:02So that's the first big shift. The
- 1:18:06second big shift is that education will
- 1:18:09shift more toward self-education.
- 1:18:12Because this methodology, curriculum,
- 1:18:15and so on, by the time the ministry
- 1:18:17approves the curriculum, it's already
- 1:18:20outdated. The world is moving forward
- 1:18:23now. So, any curriculum is already
- 1:18:26outdated by the time it's published,
- 1:18:28not to mention how they publish it,
- 1:18:30then train teachers, and then the
- 1:18:32teacher starts teaching. All of this is
- 1:18:36too slow, too cumbersome, it doesn't
- 1:18:38meet the realities of today. Therefore,
- 1:18:42uh, uh, this is the second shift, that
- 1:18:45I believe that self-education will be
- 1:18:48more satisfying. And thirdly, ah, a big
- 1:18:53shift. I believe that education will be
- 1:18:56built on practice, around practice.
- 1:18:58That is, you take a block, study it,
- 1:19:01and immediately apply it. And what does
- 1:19:04apply mean? You don't necessarily build
- 1:19:07or create something, but at least you
- 1:19:08can already use Wipodding to make a
- 1:19:10simulation and test it in reality. Well
- 1:19:13, for example, physics says:" So, so,
- 1:19:15you're given a problem, and so on. "And
- 1:19:17you say:" Yeah, my solution is
- 1:19:18such-and-such. You paste the solution
- 1:19:20here, someone else makes a simulation
- 1:19:22and says: "Damn, dude, this won't work,
- 1:19:23it doesn't work like that." You're like
- 1:19:25that, both of you. And your task is to
- 1:19:28make it, well, say, an airplane, and
- 1:19:30your task is to change the variables so
- 1:19:32that it flies in accordance with the
- 1:19:34laws of physics, which are programmed
- 1:19:36into the artificial intelligence. And
- 1:19:40while you're trying to make your
- 1:19:42airplane or model airplane fly, you
- 1:19:45study the formulas of aerodynamics,
- 1:19:47gravity, and so on.
- 1:19:50Yeah. So the training will be based on
- 1:19:53real cases.
- 1:19:54Real cases. Here I mean it's physically
- 1:19:59unrealistic. But this can be stimulated
- 1:20:02. You can take this bottle, slam it
- 1:20:04against the wall, and see if it breaks.
- 1:20:06Well, you can also slam it against the
- 1:20:08wall in a computer simulation.
- 1:20:10Yeah.
- 1:20:10Because the laws of physics are already
- 1:20:13built in there.
- 1:20:15Yeah, we were talking about education,
- 1:20:17about the judicial system. I was
- 1:20:19wondering, well, how ethical is this,
- 1:20:20ethically? Then I remembered that there
- 1:20:23are similar solutions in medicine, when
- 1:20:26, say, for certain diseases, there's a
- 1:20:28large patient database in the system,
- 1:20:30and it can make diagnoses with a high
- 1:20:33degree of certainty. Well, naturally, a
- 1:20:35person then sees it for themselves, in
- 1:20:36real life. And that is one of the
- 1:20:38characteristics of this world. This
- 1:20:41world is probabilistic.
- 1:20:43No one can tell you anything for sure.
- 1:20:48And the most interesting thing is that
- 1:20:50this probabilistic world implies that
- 1:20:53there is no guarantee of anything, and
- 1:20:55no one can be 100%right. Here we are,
- 1:20:58most people think that everything and
- 1:21:02everywhere. Everything. When we say: "
- 1:21:06Yes, everything is like this or yes,
- 1:21:08this is always how it happens." And yes
- 1:21:10, there is chaos everywhere and so on.
- 1:21:12But in reality, something happens in
- 1:21:15the world sometimes and in places.
- 1:21:17Yeah.
- 1:21:18So, in fact, the world is probabilistic
- 1:21:21. We...But the poor human consciousness
- 1:21:24is that it divides the world into black
- 1:21:26and white. Why? Because the lower a
- 1:21:28person's thinking, the more difficult
- 1:21:30it is for them to think in gradients.
- 1:21:34It is easier for them to think: "White,
- 1:21:36black, ours are the enemy, ours are the
- 1:21:38enemy, there are ours, not ours, white,
- 1:21:40black, scoundrel, handsome" and so on.
- 1:21:43And the smarter a person, the more
- 1:21:46shades they begin to see. So he begins
- 1:21:49to see that the world is something,
- 1:21:51sometimes and in places. And,
- 1:21:54accordingly, and if something is
- 1:21:57sometimes and in places, then there is
- 1:21:59no 100%correct verdict, no 100%correct
- 1:22:02decision, no 100%correct, cast-iron
- 1:22:04statement. It's a probabilistic world.
- 1:22:08We operate with probabilities all the
- 1:22:10time. So, when, say, God forbid, you
- 1:22:13have some illness and you, um, are
- 1:22:16choosing a doctor, can you ask the best
- 1:22:19professor in the world for guarantees?
- 1:22:22No one will give you a guarantee. But
- 1:22:24why then do you choose him? Because
- 1:22:28you're comparing probabilities in your
- 1:22:30head. This professor has a higher
- 1:22:33probability of curing me than another.
- 1:22:36We're constantly playing with
- 1:22:38probabilities. And even returning to a
- 1:22:41court decision, there isn't a single
- 1:22:43fair verdict. All probabilities, it's
- 1:22:47just that some verdicts are closer to
- 1:22:49being fairer, some less so. And in
- 1:22:51general, the very concept of justice is
- 1:22:53also vague.
- 1:22:54Yeah.
- 1:22:55Interesting, actually. Well, yes, but
- 1:22:58at the very beginning you were talking
- 1:23:01about this system where agents create
- 1:23:04other agents, and there's still some
- 1:23:07unknown. And do you rely on some kind
- 1:23:11of intuition when making the final
- 1:23:13decision? Even if the system has given
- 1:23:16you something.
- 1:23:17No, well, that's why I say that it's a
- 1:23:19human's job to verify what the system
- 1:23:21has given them. And that's the second
- 1:23:23reason I created this system. That's
- 1:23:25exactly what it sounds like. MDS, and
- 1:23:27the word D stands for deterministic
- 1:23:29system. So, what do modern LMSs do?
- 1:23:33They're trained to please the user.
- 1:23:37Consequently, they flatter, they can
- 1:23:39lie, they hallucinate, they can say
- 1:23:41they've done something when they
- 1:23:42haven't, and that's why they need to be
- 1:23:44double-checked. And so, to prevent this
- 1:23:48from happening, I made the system
- 1:23:49deterministic. And what is
- 1:23:51deterministic? It's when I give a task
- 1:23:53100 times, the same task, and get the
- 1:23:56same result 100 times.
- 1:23:57Yeah. That's
- 1:23:59very important. That's why I created
- 1:24:01this system. Otherwise, you ask a
- 1:24:03question today, and they answer one way
- 1:24:06. Tomorrow you ask the same question,
- 1:24:07and they answer differently.
- 1:24:09Yeah, right. By the way, we always talk
- 1:24:10about AI, saying it's not the future. I
- 1:24:12don't doubt it, but working with AI in
- 1:24:14everyday life, yes, we all know that
- 1:24:16they sometimes hallucinate, and
- 1:24:18generally make mistakes, and sometimes
- 1:24:20just outright lie,
- 1:24:21yes. But that's not a problem; it's a
- 1:24:23problem with the person's thinking. It
- 1:24:26all depends on the technical
- 1:24:28specifications you give them. Yeah.
- 1:24:30And how will you check them against
- 1:24:33what metrics? We tell them, roughly, "
- 1:24:36Make it good for me," but we don't tell
- 1:24:37them what metrics we'll use to accept
- 1:24:39their work or how we evaluate what
- 1:24:41constitutes good. But there have to be
- 1:24:44metrics, and to have a clear
- 1:24:47orientation, you need to check them.
- 1:24:49There have to be, well, so-called gates
- 1:24:52. Gates—that's my development system,
- 1:24:54for example. At the planning stage,
- 1:24:58yeah, the planner starts planning, and
- 1:25:00at this stage I've cut off all his
- 1:25:02tools. He can't go online, lest he get
- 1:25:06there and bring me something. He can't
- 1:25:10go online, he can't write code, he
- 1:25:13can't edit code, and he can't deploy.
- 1:25:17Well, like in GitHub. Uh, yeah.
- 1:25:19Yeah.
- 1:25:21He can only talk to me according to
- 1:25:24protocol and discuss things and ask
- 1:25:26questions, brief me. That's it. As soon
- 1:25:30as he's done that, that's it. As soon
- 1:25:32as I tell him, "Okay, I agree with this
- 1:25:35plan," he immediately creates a file in
- 1:25:38the system, uh, where he attaches what
- 1:25:41I've agreed to. And that's called a
- 1:25:44gate. Tdn. That's it, he stops working.
- 1:25:47From that moment on, there's a command
- 1:25:48board. As soon as this file is created,
- 1:25:52a worker starts working.
- 1:25:54Yeah.
- 1:25:55He takes this plan, and he already has
- 1:25:58the tools to go online, edit the code,
- 1:26:01and so on. And he writes down what he's
- 1:26:05going to do. He writes it, and then
- 1:26:07gives it to the reviewer. As soon as
- 1:26:09he's written it, the reviewer gets to
- 1:26:11work. And these intermediate
- 1:26:13checkpoints are mandatory, and there
- 1:26:15must be a verifier who checks that the
- 1:26:18previous stage has been passed. Well,
- 1:26:21that is, it's a whole technology, but
- 1:26:24this is precisely what ensures the
- 1:26:27determinism of the work.
- 1:26:30Well, yes, now there is even such a
- 1:26:32specialty, and I know it's gaining
- 1:26:33popularity. Prompt engineer. It even
- 1:26:36sounds like that. Prompt engineer. It's
- 1:26:38not what you just described, but
- 1:26:40nevertheless, the task is to create
- 1:26:42prompts, and to create them so well
- 1:26:44that the probability of error is
- 1:26:46minimal.
- 1:26:47No, prompts don't save. Prompts don't
- 1:26:49save. They improve, but prompts affect
- 1:26:52determinism by, well, maybe 15-20
- 1:26:55percent. Yeah, right.
- 1:26:57In fact, there are built-in hooks.
- 1:27:00Hooks are scripts. I have a rule: if
- 1:27:04it's possible to use hooks, use hooks.
- 1:27:08If it's possible to use scripts, then
- 1:27:10use scripts. And what are hooks?
- 1:27:12They're code. Code isn't an agent's
- 1:27:16thoughts, it's code that's written. And
- 1:27:20it says, as soon as it's here, ah, I've
- 1:27:23received confirmation that I approve,
- 1:27:25it's called a post-all use hook. A hook
- 1:27:29that's activated after using tools, it
- 1:27:31immediately cuts off this one and
- 1:27:33activates the next one. So, it's
- 1:27:36essential to integrate things into this
- 1:27:38pipeline or process that don't depend
- 1:27:41on LM.
- 1:27:43Well, here's a question in this regard,
- 1:27:45by the way. You said that your company
- 1:27:47will be engaged in—well, you're
- 1:27:49creating a product that you'll offer on
- 1:27:51the market, but there will probably be
- 1:27:53many similar products on the market. It
- 1:27:55will be a new race. Well, in reality,
- 1:28:00there will, of course, be many
- 1:28:02companies, and they will compete with
- 1:28:04those who have built a better
- 1:28:06architecture and who understand the
- 1:28:08essence better. What
- 1:28:10I love about the current times is that
- 1:28:13it's the age of intellectuals. If you,
- 1:28:16uh, clearly see what you're doing, you
- 1:28:18see the essence, then you're one step
- 1:28:20ahead. It's actually interesting that
- 1:28:24it was precisely this wiping of
- 1:28:26artificial intelligence that showed me
- 1:28:29that all my previous wanderings, my
- 1:28:31research, my lifelong pondering, my own
- 1:28:34musings, my own concepts, my own
- 1:28:36thinking—well, I'm just a bit odd. I
- 1:28:40even recently read an interesting tweet
- 1:28:43. Some cool dude said, "Finally, the
- 1:28:47time of weird people has arrived." So,
- 1:28:50now the winners will be those who are
- 1:28:52different from other people.
- 1:28:55Well, I actually feel this even in my
- 1:28:58work—I'll share a bit of my
- 1:29:00experience now—even in my work as a
- 1:29:03journalist, you can optimize a
- 1:29:05super-routine task, delegate it to
- 1:29:08artificial intelligence, and you have
- 1:29:10time to, well, let's say, dream up a
- 1:29:13new approach or a new calculation or
- 1:29:16data collection method. And because of
- 1:29:20this, the overall quality of the work
- 1:29:23improves, improves noticeably. And I
- 1:29:27think this could be the reason for this
- 1:29:29in many fields; it can be explained
- 1:29:31very simply. There's a kind of
- 1:29:34bell-shaped curve, a distribution of,
- 1:29:38so to speak, work, yes, and the middle
- 1:29:4180%. All the average work that is
- 1:29:44standardized, artificial intelligence
- 1:29:46will do better than humans.
- 1:29:47Yeah, yeah.
- 1:29:48Artificial intelligence will perform
- 1:29:50worse than humans at the edges. At the
- 1:29:52edges. And what are edges? They are
- 1:29:54quirks. They are quirks that are
- 1:29:56uniquely human. That is, this is your
- 1:29:58creativity, where your uniqueness, your
- 1:30:01nature, manifests itself. And these
- 1:30:03oddities can be, well, let's say an
- 1:30:05ordinary person can write an article on
- 1:30:07artificial television better than you.
- 1:30:09Why? Because writing an article is a
- 1:30:12standard thing for people,
- 1:30:14yes, standard, and so on. A good
- 1:30:16article is always built on a dramatic
- 1:30:19arc. It's about capturing attention,
- 1:30:23holding it, and there's a certain logic
- 1:30:25there. And now, well, that's where the
- 1:30:29weird stuff starts. So, how are you
- 1:30:31going to do it now? Yeah, I see, the
- 1:30:34logic is clear, capturing attention.
- 1:30:38But how? And everyone captures
- 1:30:40attention differently. Some might start
- 1:30:42with a statement, some with a
- 1:30:43contradiction, and some might just rip
- 1:30:45it right off the bat. Well, it all
- 1:30:48depends on the person's uniqueness.
- 1:30:51Some people think in unusual ways, some
- 1:30:54might even—well, even this same
- 1:30:56article can be twisted in different
- 1:30:58ways.
- 1:30:59Well, here we come to the question of
- 1:31:01the most important skills of the future
- 1:31:03that will be in demand. You already
- 1:31:06mentioned this,
- 1:31:07developing uniqueness. Developing your
- 1:31:09uniqueness is one of the most powerful.
- 1:31:12The problem is that before this, we
- 1:31:14lived in a system, an industrial system
- 1:31:17, where standardization was encouraged.
- 1:31:21We even have a workday, we even have a
- 1:31:23school built to resemble factories: a
- 1:31:25factory shift, a bell, a lesson,
- 1:31:27everyone stands up together, marches in
- 1:31:29formation, walks out, and then goes
- 1:31:31through one subject together. So,
- 1:31:35schools actually trained professional
- 1:31:37workers for factories. And everything
- 1:31:40was an assembly line, and an assembly
- 1:31:42line is what standardization is. And
- 1:31:43we've moved beyond that. Our entire
- 1:31:45workday is standardized, everything is
- 1:31:47standardized. And there, too, there was
- 1:31:49no human being. There, we tried to turn
- 1:31:53people into machines. Now the time is
- 1:31:56coming when humans must once again
- 1:31:58transform from machines into humans.
- 1:32:00That is, from a cog, from a screw, into
- 1:32:03a person, a bearer of meaning. And the
- 1:32:06bearer of meaning is each person's own
- 1:32:08meaning, depending on their uniqueness.
- 1:32:11You see the world in your own way, I
- 1:32:12see it in my own way, another person in
- 1:32:14their own way. We all see the world
- 1:32:15differently, through different filters,
- 1:32:17and different ones,
- 1:32:18yes. Well, not everyone can form
- 1:32:20meaning. It's always the ordinary
- 1:32:22intelligentsia, writers, poets, and
- 1:32:24some leaders, spiritual teachers.
- 1:32:26That's it.
- 1:32:27And that was just how it used to be.
- 1:32:30And now it will become a paradigm. You
- 1:32:33must definitely think about it. And
- 1:32:37meaning is always formed from your
- 1:32:39uniqueness. For each person, each thing
- 1:32:42has its own meaning. And when all the
- 1:32:44standard operations take you away and
- 1:32:47you can't make money, a severe crisis
- 1:32:49will inevitably hit, probably
- 1:32:51involuntarily. The only way for you to
- 1:32:54make money will be to do what only you
- 1:32:56and no one else in the world can do.
- 1:32:59Yeah.
- 1:33:01That will be the only way to make money
- 1:33:03. That's it. And all the standard
- 1:33:04operations, artificial intelligence,
- 1:33:05robots will take you away. That's it,
- 1:33:07you have no chance. Therefore, whether
- 1:33:10we like it or not, we will be forced to
- 1:33:12develop our uniqueness and give meaning
- 1:33:14to what we do. And how is this done?
- 1:33:18For example, you, you have some kind of
- 1:33:21oddity, let's say, well, I don't know,
- 1:33:23you'll be juggling, right? Your oddity.
- 1:33:27So what are you going to do to sell
- 1:33:29your weirdness? Well, you need to make
- 1:33:33money. You need to give this weirdness
- 1:33:36meaning. Zh says, "Guys, you know,
- 1:33:39juggling bottles is very important for
- 1:33:40the nervous system. It trains your
- 1:33:42motor skills, fine motor skills, and
- 1:33:44thanks to this, you develop new neural
- 1:33:47connections." Everyone's like, "Oh,
- 1:33:49right, we need to develop neural
- 1:33:50connections. And how much does it cost
- 1:33:52to learn to juggle bottles? Is that all
- 1:33:54you're saying? That's it. You've sold
- 1:33:56off your uniqueness.
- 1:33:58Why? Because you have a bias. You've
- 1:34:02given this bias meaning, and then
- 1:34:05you've sold this meaning.
- 1:34:08But if you were starting a business
- 1:34:09from scratch today, with nothing, well,
- 1:34:12let's imagine you have no capital, you
- 1:34:14choose the direction, you're free to
- 1:34:15choose whatever you want.
- 1:34:17Not as an investor, but as a budding
- 1:34:19entrepreneur,
- 1:34:20yes, restrictions. What would you focus
- 1:34:23on? Ah, well, a bet implies a bet. And
- 1:34:26you're saying, if you're starting from
- 1:34:28scratch, then,
- 1:34:28well, you have the time and opportunity
- 1:34:31to learn and maintain focus, right?
- 1:34:33Because when a person has nothing, they
- 1:34:35only have three resources: time, energy
- 1:34:38, focus, attention. That's it.
- 1:34:40Accordingly, where you direct your
- 1:34:41attention, attention is the most
- 1:34:43important resource. Where you direct
- 1:34:44your attention, there your time and
- 1:34:46energy flow, and accordingly, there
- 1:34:48your money or other people's money will
- 1:34:51go. That's why you need to be able to
- 1:34:53manage attention. So wherever I, well,
- 1:34:56I would do it very simply. I have rules
- 1:34:59that sound like this. Money always
- 1:35:02follows attention. Look where you look,
- 1:35:05pay attention yourself. What you pay
- 1:35:07attention to is what you buy. Your
- 1:35:09money follows your attention. What does
- 1:35:11advertising do? It grabs your attention
- 1:35:13. Then it sticks in your head. You buy
- 1:35:15that toothpaste you saw, you know.
- 1:35:17That's why money always follows
- 1:35:19attention. Accordingly, I would look
- 1:35:21and say what people are talking about
- 1:35:22now. What? Elementary, right.
- 1:35:25Artificial intelligence, robots,
- 1:35:27right? Wipe coding,
- 1:35:28right? Wipe coding. That means there's
- 1:35:31money there, everything is a direction.
- 1:35:33It's clear what to focus on.
- 1:35:35Accordingly, what should I study? Oh, I
- 1:35:37need to study this, ah, there are a
- 1:35:39bunch of free courses and a bunch of
- 1:35:41free YouTube videos that contribute to
- 1:35:43this now. And at the same time, the
- 1:35:45unique situation is that few people
- 1:35:47really understand it. Accordingly, you
- 1:35:50can even understand it a little, and
- 1:35:52already start teaching someone and
- 1:35:55making money from it. In my case
- 1:35:58Another question, but it's probably so
- 1:36:01lyrical, but I think traditionally in
- 1:36:04our podcast, uh, what decision in your
- 1:36:06life are you most proud of, what do you
- 1:36:09regret, and what is your main
- 1:36:11motivation? Ah, look, regret. I only
- 1:36:18regret those decisions from which I
- 1:36:19didn't learn a lesson. And I don't
- 1:36:23really have such decisions, well, I
- 1:36:25would say, because by virtue of my
- 1:36:27character, I always try to learn a
- 1:36:31lesson from everything that happens to
- 1:36:34me. So look, if you made a decision, it
- 1:36:37led to success, many people make the
- 1:36:40mistake of resting on their laurels.
- 1:36:43But you need to analyze this well. If
- 1:36:48it led to failure, many analyze it not
- 1:36:50because they are designed that way, but
- 1:36:52because it is a necessary measure. They
- 1:36:56want to achieve success, so they
- 1:36:58analyze only failures. Ah, but you need
- 1:37:00to analyze both success and failure.
- 1:37:02Why? In order to clearly distinguish
- 1:37:05whether success was due to your efforts
- 1:37:07, decision, and so on, or favorable
- 1:37:09circumstances. And many are due to A
- 1:37:12favorable set of circumstances fly by,
- 1:37:14what's called luck and good fortune,
- 1:37:16and then they say they worked 12-14
- 1:37:18hours, and they're so cool. Well, in
- 1:37:21fact, most major successes are luck and
- 1:37:24good fortune.
- 1:37:25Yeah.
- 1:37:26And now, if you didn't analyze the
- 1:37:33decision, and it's a bad decision, then
- 1:37:36you'll regret it. And why regret it?
- 1:37:40Because you had net losses. And when
- 1:37:43you've made a fuck-up, a bad decision,
- 1:37:46learned from it, and learned a lesson,
- 1:37:49then that becomes valuable. And that no
- 1:37:52longer becomes an expense, but an
- 1:37:54investment that helps you avoid making
- 1:37:57more mistakes in the second round. Now
- 1:38:01I tell my students this: there are two
- 1:38:04biggest things you should not do. These
- 1:38:07are repeated mistakes and mistakes with
- 1:38:11irreversible consequences. Those are
- 1:38:14the only two things you shouldn't do.
- 1:38:16The rest, on the contrary, I tell
- 1:38:18everyone:" Make mistakes, just make
- 1:38:20them quickly. "That's the first rule.
- 1:38:23The second, make mistakes, make them
- 1:38:26cheap, and Fast. Yeah.
- 1:38:29But not repetitive and not with
- 1:38:31irreversible consequences. Then quickly
- 1:38:34correct, learn the lesson, take new
- 1:38:37actions. Again, if necessary, make
- 1:38:39mistakes, but thanks to this you will
- 1:38:41grow, you will grow very quickly.
- 1:38:44Well, I think this is still good advice
- 1:38:46, and how to not sweat it, not get hung
- 1:38:48up, you know?
- 1:38:50This is good advice against
- 1:38:51perfectionists, by the way, because I
- 1:38:53myself was a perfectionist in the past,
- 1:38:55and I tried to do everything perfectly.
- 1:38:58And then at some point I realized that
- 1:39:00there is a return curve to
- 1:39:02perfectionism. That is, at first it’s
- 1:39:05good, good, and then it starts like
- 1:39:06this: you’re sharpening the part,
- 1:39:08polishing the part, and the return is
- 1:39:09less and less. And I came up with this
- 1:39:12rule for myself. It goes like this: “
- 1:39:15I’m not a perfectionist, I’m for
- 1:39:17ineffective imperfection.”
- 1:39:19Yeah.
- 1:39:20That is, I improve the process exactly
- 1:39:22as long as it is effective. As soon as
- 1:39:25it stops being effective, I stop
- 1:39:27polishing and delegate.
- 1:39:29Yeah. So, I, let's say, perfect 70-80%
- 1:39:33of the process, then they delegate it,
- 1:39:36because beyond that there's an effect,
- 1:39:39and there's the law of diminishing
- 1:39:42returns, after that the profitability
- 1:39:45drops. It's no longer profitable to
- 1:39:49polish against my efforts.
- 1:39:51Well, yes, and they say there's no
- 1:39:52limit to perfection, but still,
- 1:39:53sometimes it's not worthwhile to simply
- 1:39:54pursue it further, it's unprofitable.
- 1:39:56That's not the right law. There is no
- 1:39:58limit to perfection, that's right. It's
- 1:40:00about the horizon, how much can be
- 1:40:02improved. Another question is, who
- 1:40:03should do it?
- 1:40:04You do the bulk of the work, then
- 1:40:06delegate it. And then there are people
- 1:40:10whose time and attention are cheaper
- 1:40:13than mine. Well, it's better for me to
- 1:40:15pay them, let them polish it further.
- 1:40:18And then there are agents and agents,
- 1:40:20they can polish as much as they want.
- 1:40:22So yes, there is no limit to perfection
- 1:40:24, but I just don't necessarily have to
- 1:40:26do it.
- 1:40:27I see. Well, returning to your question
- 1:40:29, what are you proud of in your life?
- 1:40:30Like, from some single decision, which
- 1:40:33maybe was made, which changed the
- 1:40:35course of your entire life, perhaps.
- 1:40:37Well, look, you can be proud of
- 1:40:40something when you don't see that
- 1:40:43something better could be ahead. To be
- 1:40:47honest, I don't have much to be proud
- 1:40:49of yet. I think that everything better
- 1:40:52is yet to come, and I still have good
- 1:40:54things to do. And I expect that in the
- 1:40:58future I will do something that I will
- 1:41:01be proud of now. Why? Because any pride
- 1:41:05in something done in the past, it
- 1:41:08actually distracts you from searching,
- 1:41:11from further striving. Well, you've
- 1:41:15already done something cool. Well, life
- 1:41:17seems to have been a success. Well, and
- 1:41:20now what about fluttering around, life
- 1:41:22seems to have been a success. And I say
- 1:41:24:" I haven't done anything worthwhile
- 1:41:27in this life yet, so I need to create
- 1:41:30something worthwhile in the remaining
- 1:41:33time. "Well, this feeling, it's not
- 1:41:36just not about money, because you, well
- 1:41:38, from a financial point of view, what
- 1:41:40is it, it's just curiosity or the
- 1:41:42desire to leave a mark on this world,
- 1:41:44in history, so to speak, only.
- 1:41:47And First of all, it's curiosity.
- 1:41:51Curiosity, and it's not just curiosity,
- 1:41:53well, a love of knowledge, yes, but
- 1:41:55also a love of life. I like the process
- 1:41:58of living life itself. I like this game
- 1:42:00called life. By the way, one of the
- 1:42:03answers to what this world is like, I
- 1:42:05have, uh, that this world is a game,
- 1:42:07and I call it a single-player game. Why
- 1:42:10? Because in this world, I perceive it
- 1:42:13this way: there is me and everything
- 1:42:15else is just scenery. Accordingly, any
- 1:42:18focap in this life, I am solely
- 1:42:21responsible and no one else. Well, I
- 1:42:24try to go through all these levels.
- 1:42:26Therefore, uh, I love this life, I love
- 1:42:29, uh, knowledge, and in general, I
- 1:42:31believe that life is movement, it is
- 1:42:34constant movement, not just movement,
- 1:42:36not empty movement, not in a circle,
- 1:42:39but development, evolution.
- 1:42:44Well, most likely, in a spiral, yes.
- 1:42:47We've
- 1:42:47talked a lot about self-development,
- 1:42:49about progress, about moving forward,
- 1:42:52but now I'd like to touch on the topic
- 1:42:54of leisure. How do you like to spend
- 1:42:57your time? Maybe you like computer
- 1:42:59games? Or, I don't know, fishing or
- 1:43:01football? By the way, you can watch the
- 1:43:03World Cup. I'm
- 1:43:05generally a professional at spending my
- 1:43:08leisure time, relaxing,
- 1:43:10spending money. In this,
- 1:43:13I would give you competition, Putin.
- 1:43:18Here, I think, I'm beyond competition.
- 1:43:21Oh, but I like to go on so-called hunts
- 1:43:24. Hunting, but for me, it's not so much
- 1:43:27about killing animals and so on. It's
- 1:43:29more about communicating with nature.
- 1:43:30Hunting gives me meaning. It's as if
- 1:43:33I'm going there to hunt animals. In
- 1:43:37fact, it's the thrill of nature, it's
- 1:43:39communication, it's
- 1:43:42sitting by the fire, it's riding horses
- 1:43:44there. And it's about reflecting, it's
- 1:43:48sitting alone there by myself, and so
- 1:43:50on. So, trips to nature, you can call
- 1:43:54it hunting, fishing, it makes no
- 1:43:57difference, I'm not really chasing prey
- 1:44:00there. And then there are computer
- 1:44:03games. I play computer games,
- 1:44:05specifically strategic games,
- 1:44:07educational ones. Oh, and I don't just
- 1:44:10play, I observe the mechanics. What I
- 1:44:13feel, what I do, why I do it the way it
- 1:44:15works. Well, that's how it works. I
- 1:44:17love to play golf. And I love to read a
- 1:44:22lot, to study. Well, and wipe coding is
- 1:44:25now, in fact, a hobby for me, it's not
- 1:44:26a job. Well, in general, I would say
- 1:44:29this, and everything I do is actually a
- 1:44:31hobby. To be honest, I don't have a job
- 1:44:34. Here I perform, I like this hobby. I
- 1:44:37teach students there, I like this hobby
- 1:44:41. And the
- 1:44:42best job is a paid hobby. It is so
- 1:44:46simple, when you are not doing
- 1:44:47something that you don't like, then you
- 1:44:50don't understand why you need to rest.
- 1:44:52People
- 1:44:53tell me that I work too much. I say:"
- 1:44:56Well, in fact, I always have the
- 1:44:57feeling that I rest a lot, because the
- 1:44:59work that I do is like rest for me. "
- 1:45:02So, this is factory terminology again.
- 1:45:06There is intense work, then rest. And I
- 1:45:09think a correct, balanced life is when
- 1:45:11you see no difference between rest and
- 1:45:13work. You are in the flow, you live,
- 1:45:15you like everything that you you do. I
- 1:45:17just like that you...
- 1:45:19By the way, I remembered, uh, a story
- 1:45:22from university about how science arose
- 1:45:25in the ancient world. It arose with the
- 1:45:28advent of the slave system, when people
- 1:45:31appeared who didn't have to do anything
- 1:45:34, and they just observed the sea, the
- 1:45:36stars. And, basically, they created
- 1:45:38philosophy in Ancient Greece and so on.
- 1:45:41I think that in our time, these will be
- 1:45:42robots. Well, basically, you're already
- 1:45:45in the role of those ancient
- 1:45:47philosophers, that is, you can afford
- 1:45:48to just devote yourself. Again, you
- 1:45:52know, and the desire to live a happy
- 1:45:56life. This, look, a happy life is not
- 1:46:00about wealth, it's not about earning
- 1:46:03money. A happy life is doing what you
- 1:46:08love. And if you know how to do it in
- 1:46:11such a way that you also get paid for
- 1:46:14it, well, that's a total thrill. I like
- 1:46:17one Islamic hadith in this regard,
- 1:46:19which says:" Let not the man who does
- 1:46:24not...let not the man who does not find
- 1:46:26... "paradise on this earth." This is a
- 1:46:29hadith from Islam. So, the value of
- 1:46:33this hadith is that in fact, paradise
- 1:46:36is on this earth. We create hell with
- 1:46:40our passions, desires, and fears.
- 1:46:43Yeah. At one
- 1:46:45time, when my brother was already here
- 1:46:47in the spring, and I talked to him, I
- 1:46:49asked, I said: "Well, listen, if you
- 1:46:51follow all these commandments, then you
- 1:46:53have no enemies, you have all this
- 1:46:54peace in your soul, and so on." Well,
- 1:46:57it turns out, it's a thrill, paradise
- 1:46:59turns out to be on this earth. And then
- 1:47:01he told me: "Well, of course, it is we
- 1:47:02who drive ourselves to hell with our
- 1:47:04passions. So, uh, really, and the
- 1:47:07hadith talks about this, let not the
- 1:47:09man who has not found paradise on this
- 1:47:12earth go to paradise." And this means
- 1:47:14that you must build your life in such a
- 1:47:17way that you treat people well, and
- 1:47:19nature, and give value, and at the same
- 1:47:21time be a good person yourself and so
- 1:47:24on. And when you become such a person,
- 1:47:26then this world becomes paradise for
- 1:47:28you. Is it really? You know, you
- 1:47:31rationalize everything, and it turns
- 1:47:33out, I talk to you, I get the feeling
- 1:47:35as if you have an answer to every
- 1:47:37question and as if emotions are
- 1:47:39completely beyond your control,
- 1:47:40uncontrollable, more precisely. Oh. Is
- 1:47:44this really so? Does it happen that you
- 1:47:47give free rein to your feelings, that
- 1:47:49something overwhelms you or you madly
- 1:47:52like something and you have a personal
- 1:47:54question there. I will add this. Are
- 1:47:56you capable of making an irrational
- 1:47:58decision?
- 1:47:58Yes, yes. Have you ever lost your mind?
- 1:48:02Many times. In fact, with all my
- 1:48:06rationality, I am a romantic and An
- 1:48:08idealist.
- 1:48:10Yeah.
- 1:48:10And if we look at it from the
- 1:48:13perspective of my losses, the main
- 1:48:16losses in my life were caused by my
- 1:48:19romanticism and idealism. I mean, I've
- 1:48:23always, my whole life, trusted people
- 1:48:25deeply, and I've always idealized. I
- 1:48:27idealized the state, I idealized
- 1:48:30justice, I idealized our country, our
- 1:48:34president Nazarbayev at the time, and
- 1:48:37so on. But life turned out to be more
- 1:48:41banal. It turned out that officials can
- 1:48:44take away businesses, not officials,
- 1:48:46but Nazarbayev himself can take away
- 1:48:48businesses, that there can be contract
- 1:48:51criminal cases, and so on. Well, so to
- 1:48:55speak, all my losses are due to my
- 1:48:57romanticism and idealization. I wanted
- 1:49:01to serve my country, to be a patriot
- 1:49:04there, and a real businessman there,
- 1:49:07like Sava Morozov in Russia, the
- 1:49:09Trentyakovs, and so on. Well, yeah, so,
- 1:49:15of course, there were many of these, I
- 1:49:19would say, blows. And the reason for
- 1:49:23which was precisely my romanticism and
- 1:49:26idealism. Yeah.
- 1:49:27But whatever the blows, from this I
- 1:49:30haven't stopped being a cynic. I'm also
- 1:49:34a romantic, I'm also an idealist, I'm
- 1:49:36just adjusting it now. There are rules,
- 1:49:39algorithms, and so on. I've adjusted my
- 1:49:43worldview a little. I understand that
- 1:49:47there is meanness, injustice, and
- 1:49:50non-compliance with the law in this
- 1:49:52world. There is.
- 1:49:56Well, that's life.
- 1:49:58That is, I would say I've begun to
- 1:50:00accept life more as it is, and at the
- 1:50:03same time enjoy it and remain an
- 1:50:05idealist and a romantic.
- 1:50:09Nothing more to add. Thank you so much
- 1:50:11for coming. I was somehow filled with
- 1:50:14energy, or something, that's why,
- 1:50:16well, actually, your videos, all your
- 1:50:18performances, they really charge you
- 1:50:20with positive energy. They are very
- 1:50:22inspiring, and that's probably why they
- 1:50:24are popular. That's why I personally
- 1:50:25appreciate it a lot, and I think Farid
- 1:50:27will share this opinion. It was a
- 1:50:28pleasure to spend almost two hours with
- 1:50:30you here in the studio. So thank you so
- 1:50:32much for coming, and I wish you success
- 1:50:34and good luck.
- 1:50:34Thank you very much. It was a pleasure
- 1:50:37to share my thoughts with all your
- 1:50:38viewers. Bye everyone.
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of Что останется человеку в эпоху ИИ? Маргулан Сейсембаев by KURSIV MEDIA, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 16,984 words across 2,710 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.