WW3 DEBATE: “We’re On the Brink of Global Collapse” — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:00There's a lot to pay attention to right
- 0:01now given how many global conflicts are
- 0:04happening, shifting political powers,
- 0:06populist uprisings.
- 0:08What do you think is the biggest threat
- 0:10to global peace at the moment?
- 0:12>> The biggest threat to global peace we're
- 0:14about to see in our midterm elections.
- 0:16It's the internal divisions in the
- 0:17United States.
- 0:19Those internal divisions have been
- 0:21building for the last 5 years. They've
- 0:23been normalizing political violence in
- 0:25the United States.
- 0:26They've led to the rise of leaders in
- 0:28the United States that find the use of
- 0:30political violence increasingly normal.
- 0:33That's how we got to the Iran war. And
- 0:35so that
- 0:37a lot of the specifics that we see Chris
- 0:40around the world. I think it's very
- 0:42important to understand
- 0:45that there is a hub. The United States
- 0:47is the most important, the most powerful
- 0:49country on the planet. And what happens
- 0:52internally in the United States can have
- 0:55ripple effects around the world. And so
- 0:58I think it's really important that not
- 1:00just talk about all the other issues,
- 1:03but to see the United States is at the
- 1:05center of many, maybe not all, but many
- 1:08of those issues. And what's happening
- 1:10internally in the United States, this is
- 1:13increasingly becoming a house divided.
- 1:16>> What do you think?
- 1:17>> I think the United States right now is
- 1:19the greatest threat to global peace
- 1:21because for the past 30 years Pax
- 1:23Americana has been dominant. And now
- 1:26with the rise of other powers, United
- 1:28States refuses to see its global
- 1:30hegemony. This is why we're seeing
- 1:32conflicts around the world, specifically
- 1:33in the Middle East.
- 1:36>> I don't see a global conflict coming.
- 1:38Many regional conflicts are coming
- 1:41because the global system is
- 1:43restructuring itself. There is not
- 1:45really a global system at this point as
- 1:47there was
- 1:48during the European Imperial age or
- 1:51during the
- 1:53period of after World World II called.
- 1:57So rather than looking at a
- 1:59confrontation
- 2:01like nuclear war between the United
- 2:03States and Russia, we're looking at
- 2:06various smaller
- 2:07elements. Sometimes the United States
- 2:09gets involved.
- 2:11But as to the international conflict
- 2:13>> [snorts]
- 2:14>> I lived through the 1970s.
- 2:16It was intense in the United States. But
- 2:18it was intense over a very small war.
- 2:20>> Mhm.
- 2:20>> So, the idea that there's a global
- 2:22system at this point, it's emerging.
- 2:25But because it's not emerged yet
- 2:28many of the wars are going to be
- 2:29regional.
- 2:30>> Right. So, you still see Is it right in
- 2:31thinking that Ukraine, Iran, whatever
- 2:34happens, Taiwan, China, that these
- 2:36things are separate conflicts rather
- 2:38than part of a single global conflict?
- 2:41>> Well, I think that we may the three of
- 2:43us disagree about whether or not there
- 2:46will be a World War III, a true unified
- 2:49global war.
- 2:51I just want to point out that right now
- 2:53we're experiencing multiple regional
- 2:56conflicts. They are linked in some ways,
- 2:59but together they are wrecking the
- 3:01global economy.
- 3:02>> Mhm.
- 3:03>> They're having a major effect on the
- 3:06global economy.
- 3:09Uh what's happening in Russia with the
- 3:10Russia-Ukraine war, what's happening in
- 3:13in the Iran uh conflict, and if we had a
- 3:16conflict with Taiwan and China on top of
- 3:19that
- 3:20even if those remain three separate
- 3:23arenas, Chris uh we might be heading to
- 3:26something far worse than a 1930s
- 3:28depression so uh for the world. So, this
- 3:31would have blowback effects on Africa
- 3:33even though they wouldn't even be
- 3:35involved. So, we can usefully talk about
- 3:38whether we should expect a true World
- 3:41War III uh scenario, but we are already
- 3:45seeing global consequences
- 3:48um in ways we haven't seen since World
- 3:52War II. We did not see these global
- 3:53consequences in the Vietnam War, for
- 3:56example.
- 3:57We did not see these global consequences
- 3:59with the two what we called forever
- 4:01wars, Iraq and Afghanistan. We're seeing
- 4:03them now, and that, even if it doesn't
- 4:07become army on army, Chinese army on
- 4:10American that kind of force on force,
- 4:13this is already in amazingly
- 4:16consequential for our lives.
- 4:18>> Mhm.
- 4:19>> I think what's really important
- 4:20appreciate is that yes, these conflicts
- 4:23are regional, but there's a power
- 4:25orchestrating these conflicts, and that
- 4:26is the United States. So,
- 4:29um it is the United States that
- 4:30unilaterally, without any reason,
- 4:32decided to attack Iran, which start the
- 4:35war in the Middle East, which is right
- 4:37now threatening to destroy the global
- 4:38economy. The war in Ukraine can also be
- 4:41be blamed on the United States because
- 4:43um
- 4:44um
- 4:44after onset of the war in 2020 2022,
- 4:49uh Putin and the Zelensky would have
- 4:50come to an agreement, but Boris Johnson
- 4:52flew into Kiev and convinced Zelensky to
- 4:56fight this war. Right now in um in
- 5:00Southeast Asia, the United States is
- 5:01withdrawing, but we're seeing Japan
- 5:04being remilitarized, and we can imagine
- 5:06that Japan is being supported by the
- 5:07United States. In fact, if you look at
- 5:09the National Defense Strategy, which was
- 5:12published by the Pentagon uh earlier
- 5:14this year, it calls for the United
- 5:16States withdrawing from the global stage
- 5:18and creating balance of power in in each
- 5:20different region, Europe, um the Middle
- 5:23East, and uh uh Southeast Asia. So, you
- 5:26can make the argument that the United
- 5:28States is intent on maintaining its
- 5:30global hegemony, but it recognizes that
- 5:32it doesn't have the military power, the
- 5:34political will to control the entire
- 5:37world as it did in Pax Americana. So, it
- 5:39is um basically offloading its
- 5:41responsibilities to its regional allies,
- 5:43NATO in Europe, uh Israel and the GCC in
- 5:46the Middle East and Japan in uh
- 5:48Southeast Asia.
- 5:49>> See, I agree with about 70% of what he's
- 5:53saying. I I believe Well, I think you're
- 5:55really on it. And um I think that the
- 5:58parts I really agree with are that
- 6:01American decisions have been at the
- 6:04taproot of both of these wars, the war
- 6:08with Russia and Ukraine, and uh the Iran
- 6:11war that we're experiencing right now.
- 6:14Where I may disagree is I think that
- 6:18they're very much um a function of uh
- 6:21decisions and decision-makers
- 6:24that have been evolving given our
- 6:26internal divisions in our country. I
- 6:29think that we shouldn't look at this as
- 6:31simply a product of a global cycle of
- 6:34empires. I think we need to see that for
- 6:37the last 10 years, we have seen and 10
- 6:40years, not just 2 years, an incredible
- 6:43rise of political violence in the United
- 6:45States. That is being driven, Chris, by
- 6:48major social changes inside of the
- 6:52United States, the shift from uh a white
- 6:55majority democracy to a white minority
- 6:57democracy for the first time in our
- 6:59250-year history, the shift of uh
- 7:03massive wealth to the top 1% over the
- 7:06last several decades. These are having
- 7:09amazing consequences inside of our uh
- 7:13government. It's producing a set of
- 7:15priorities and leaders which are very
- 7:18different. So, we are now seeing leaders
- 7:22that find political violence normal. And
- 7:26what this is what you see with
- 7:28uh President Trump in both in his first
- 7:30term and now increasingly in his second
- 7:32term, and also some by uh Democratic
- 7:35leaders. You're also seeing, because of
- 7:38these internal problems, Chris, I think
- 7:42uh not sufficient attention to the
- 7:45consequences
- 7:46of these global decisions. So, I don't
- 7:49believe that we have uh over the last 10
- 7:53years devoted the amount of attention
- 7:57to the consequences of uh
- 8:00issues with Russia and Ukraine, issues
- 8:03with Iran. Uh I think that and I think
- 8:05that because I've advised every White
- 8:07House from 2001 to 2024, I know
- 8:10something about this degree
- 8:12uh of of attention, and I am um
- 8:16overall uh observing not no attention. I
- 8:20think that's not quite right, and and I
- 8:22don't mean that they're they're they're
- 8:23truly uh trivial, but nonetheless,
- 8:27um the uh the idea that we would uh
- 8:31continue to support NATO expansion and
- 8:35and uh
- 8:37make um Ukraine a much much stronger
- 8:39country even after Putin uh takes Crimea
- 8:43in 2014 without serious attention to the
- 8:46consequences. I think this is this is
- 8:49there's just not there's there's too
- 8:51much we need to see.
- 8:53As we're becoming internally absorbed,
- 8:56we're having we have less cognitive
- 8:59space for the thing that I often do,
- 9:02strategy in the rest of the world. And
- 9:05that lack of cognitive space has not
- 9:08just been a function of one president. I
- 9:10think it's been a function of multiple
- 9:12presidents, and I think that's really
- 9:14what Maybe it's not a disagreement, it's
- 9:16what I would say uh maybe an extension
- 9:18or I would add to what you're saying.
- 9:20>> I guess people keep debating whether
- 9:22America's losing its grip as a world
- 9:23superpower.
- 9:2520 years from now, do you think America
- 9:27is relatively stronger or weaker than it
- 9:29is now?
- 9:30>> I would say it's not losing it. It's
- 9:32wanting to lose it.
- 9:33The past 80 years was not been a happy
- 9:36time for the United States.
- 9:37For the United States, the fundamental
- 9:40principle is command of the sea from
- 9:43long time.
- 9:44Keeping them away from the Atlantic
- 9:45ports
- 9:46was essential in this.
- 9:48This draw drew us into creating NATO,
- 9:52creating a economic system
- 9:56based on Bretton Woods and all these
- 9:57other things that put tremendous
- 9:59pressure on the American economy.
- 10:01Even recently we had to bail out the
- 10:03Japanese in a way.
- 10:05So, what I see the United States is
- 10:07doing, okay, and these things are not
- 10:10gracefully done ever,
- 10:12is pulling back from its vulnerability
- 10:15to the world,
- 10:16not engaging. Now, the world is not
- 10:20seeing it that way because
- 10:23various things happened, okay? One, the
- 10:25Cold War ended in Ukraine.
- 10:28>> [clears throat]
- 10:28>> The Russian army could not take Ukraine
- 10:31after 5 years. This is not a military
- 10:34threat. So, now the Cold War is obsolete
- 10:38and the idea is
- 10:39that so the American re- desire,
- 10:43you know, is to dis- and was
- 10:45predictable, was to disengage to the
- 10:47extent possible.
- 10:49But what the Americans are doing is not
- 10:52increasing their power around the world.
- 10:54It's trying to remove its vulnerability
- 10:57from the world and the world feels
- 10:58betrayed.
- 10:59So, that the United States
- 11:00[clears throat] is no longer
- 11:02doing it. It no longer wants the role it
- 11:05had for the past 80 years.
- 11:07>> Mhm. But if we look out 20 years, Chris,
- 11:10and you ask the question, well, right
- 11:12now we're 26% of the world's GDP.
- 11:15China 17% of the world's GDP. So, we
- 11:17still are number one at least in terms
- 11:20of the numbers. And
- 11:21but if we look out 20 years, China has a
- 11:24tremendous advantage going forward, but
- 11:26it's not just the slope of the curve.
- 11:29A big thing is happening, Chris, and
- 11:31it's been happening for the last 20
- 11:32years, which is we are losing the next
- 11:35industrial advance, the next economic
- 11:39revolution. And we're losing it to
- 11:41China. And we're not even noticing it
- 11:44very much, Chris. So, in June of 2025,
- 11:48while we were bombing Fordo, I spent 2
- 11:50weeks in China touring China's advanced
- 11:53industries.
- 11:54Uh this was in uh Beijing, um and this
- 11:57was in Wuhan, this was in Hangzhou, this
- 12:00was in Shenzhen. Uh most people go to
- 12:02China, first of all, they stopped going
- 12:04after COVID. And most people who went
- 12:06tend to go to Beijing and Shanghai. I
- 12:08want to see the actual advanced
- 12:10industries on the shop floor.
- 12:12>> For for VOA point of view, China's in a
- 12:14terrifically difficult position
- 12:16economically.
- 12:17>> Well, let's let me just explain. You can
- 12:19challenge it, George, but let me explain
- 12:20what I mean.
- 12:22What I saw on that 2-week trip, I
- 12:24thought I was going to go and look at
- 12:25sort of Alibaba, see how they were a
- 12:27little bit ahead of different I came
- 12:29away with a completely different
- 12:31impression. It was the most important
- 12:33trip I've been I was in China in 1979,
- 12:35so I had some experience here.
- 12:37What I saw was not just uplifting of
- 12:40individual companies, Chris, uplifting
- 12:43whole cities. Wuhan, whole city. So, not
- 12:48just the advanced sector, the healthcare
- 12:51sector, the construction sector. Uh when
- 12:54you look at what's happening in the
- 12:56cities, we're we're we're getting 10%
- 12:59of the idea of what's happening inside
- 13:02of China in the New York Times and in
- 13:04the media.
- 13:05>> Yeah.
- 13:05>> Uh February, I want to organize a trip
- 13:08to go back to China, Chris. If you want
- 13:10to come, I think you'd find this really
- 13:12interesting because it's what So, I was
- 13:15born in Erie, Pennsylvania. I went to
- 13:17the University of Pittsburgh in the Rust
- 13:19Belt. That's a if you go from Chicago to
- 13:22say Pittsburgh, that's about and down to
- 13:24St. Louis, that's about 50 million
- 13:26people, give or take. Well, that's about
- 13:28the half-moon crescent from Wuhan to
- 13:32Shenzhen. Not identical, but pretty
- 13:34close as as cuz you know that area.
- 13:36>> country.
- 13:37>> Very It's a huge country, but that
- 13:38crescent we're talking about. What China
- 13:40has done, and literally in about uh 10
- 13:43or 12 years, it has some roots in the
- 13:45'90s, is they have uplifted those in
- 13:48that entire 50 million people, Chris.
- 13:53They integrate. Why are they ahead?
- 13:56They're not just building companies,
- 13:58their universities are tightly producing
- 14:01the BAs, the MAs, the PhDs. Why can't we
- 14:05produce more Patriot missiles right now?
- 14:07Why can't we just have an Operation Warp
- 14:09Speed? We don't have the workers to do
- 14:13that because we're not integrating the
- 14:17advanced workforce with the advanced
- 14:19with also advanced healthcare, and by
- 14:21the way, advanced driver's license.
- 14:24>> China's cities is not China.
- 14:28The rural areas of China are profoundly
- 14:30important.
- 14:32It is the second largest economy in the
- 14:34world. In terms of per capita income,
- 14:36it's 71st.
- 14:38The fundamental problem that China has
- 14:41is it cannot consume the products it
- 14:44produces.
- 14:46Right now, Xi, just a few weeks ago,
- 14:48announced a plan to make more
- 14:51demands possible in the rural regions,
- 14:54which are very different from the
- 14:55coastal regions.
- 14:57And so, when we look at China, we look
- 15:00at a country that has an economy too
- 15:02much too large for it to consume.
- 15:04It is dependent on exports,
- 15:07with the United States being the largest
- 15:09importer of Chinese goods.
- 15:11>> Mhm.
- 15:11>> So, when you take a look at China, and
- 15:13you take a look at how the
- 15:16the summits are evolving,
- 15:18and what's happening there,
- 15:20we see very I see a very different China
- 15:22from you.
- 15:23I see the cities in marvelous shape, the
- 15:26coastal areas in South China.
- 15:28But that's not the majority of China.
- 15:31The Chinese still have the rural area
- 15:33where
- 15:34Mao Zedong went to raise the
- 15:37a rebel army
- 15:39on the long march and brought it back.
- 15:41And that's what it did.
- 15:43Now,
- 15:44when you look at it from an economic
- 15:46point of view on a global basis, it is
- 15:48the second largest economy.
- 15:50When you look at its ability to sustain
- 15:52itself, it heavily depends on exports.
- 15:56And one of the things that
- 15:57>> Cuz it can't consume what it produces.
- 15:58>> It can't. It can't possibly. It has
- 16:00tremendous capabilities,
- 16:02but its per capita income is very low.
- 16:06So, you you see a situation emerging
- 16:10as emerged several times before,
- 16:13particularly with the United States.
- 16:14United States was a China
- 16:16>> Mhm.
- 16:16>> of the 19th century.
- 16:19That is to say,
- 16:20first,
- 16:21the Civil War took place. After that, an
- 16:24industrial rising that heavily depended
- 16:27on exports to Europe. So, when you take
- 16:30a look at
- 16:32the relationship between the economic
- 16:35issues and the political issues and so
- 16:36on and so forth, the nature of the
- 16:38United States
- 16:41is to simultaneously have deep divisions
- 16:45and be able somehow to manage it, okay?
- 16:48So, when I look at these events that I
- 16:51lived through the '70s,
- 16:53but it is this loading
- 16:56of various patterns.
- 16:58If you were not anti-war and went to
- 17:00university, you did not come out of that
- 17:02university frequently.
- 17:04So, I'm not so impressed by the tensions
- 17:07within the United States.
- 17:08>> Mhm.
- 17:08>> I don't know the period where they were
- 17:10there. We survived the Civil War, which
- 17:13was really a
- 17:15big discussion, okay?
- 17:16So, I see United States is constantly,
- 17:19dynamically evolving through tension.
- 17:22>> So, if I was to categorize at least what
- 17:24I'm hearing so far
- 17:26from your side, China very impressive,
- 17:29not just the upper trend, but the
- 17:31integration, this almost
- 17:33like systemic blending of education in
- 17:36with industry, etc., etc.
- 17:38>> Beyond what we're doing.
- 17:39>> Yes, and internal strife inside of
- 17:42America that's worrying. This could
- 17:44cause fracture and pressure.
- 17:45From your side,
- 17:47China
- 17:48Well, it's got some problems. Look at
- 17:49the rural area of this. Yes, you've got
- 17:52great development inside of the cities,
- 17:54but those are pockets that are
- 17:56relatively localized. That makes it less
- 17:58Also, you've got this high export
- 18:00dependency because you can't consume
- 18:02what it is that you produce, and
- 18:04America's been through before. It
- 18:05can probably put up with it.
- 18:06>> Most of all,
- 18:07China is vulnerable because it depends
- 18:10on these exports.
- 18:12Assume that the other economies
- 18:14falter,
- 18:15where they can't buy it, or there's a
- 18:17political shift,
- 18:19the Chinese get into trouble because
- 18:22they must have access to the global
- 18:23market, the same way the United States
- 18:25had to in the early part of the century.
- 18:28>> Yeah.
- 18:28>> So, when we look at all these things,
- 18:30okay, we say, "Okay, China has evolved
- 18:33dramatically. It has not solved its
- 18:37fundamental problem, which historically
- 18:39was there, the difference between the
- 18:41coastal regions of South China and the
- 18:44interior.
- 18:45This is what led to the revolution under
- 18:48Mao Zedong.
- 18:49>> Yeah.
- 18:49>> And he didn't solve that problem.
- 18:52>> Gang, give me your perspective. We've
- 18:53seen two two relatively diametrically
- 18:55opposed insights here. Give me your
- 18:57>> Yeah, so I am completely surprised by
- 19:00this, but unfortunately
- 19:02and my wife's going to get very angry at
- 19:03me for this, but I'm I'm going to have
- 19:04to agree with George on on this issue.
- 19:07So, let me explain my reasoning. So,
- 19:09George mentions the vulnerability of the
- 19:11empire, and that's the US dollar as
- 19:13global reserve currency. The American
- 19:15people do not want this system because
- 19:18essentially the world can become a
- 19:19parasite on America, right? So, if
- 19:22America has the global reserve currency,
- 19:24then
- 19:26then America's capital markets are
- 19:28completely free and open and liberal.
- 19:30You cannot control capital flows, and
- 19:31this caused tremendous problems, for
- 19:33example, wealth inequality and
- 19:35financialization, the hollowing out on
- 19:37the on the American manufacturing
- 19:38sector, okay? That's one issue. Another
- 19:40issue is America needs to guarantee
- 19:44global peace and security. So, that's
- 19:46why its army is spread throughout the
- 19:48world.
- 19:49That's why it's its
- 19:51Pentagon budget is a trillion dollars a
- 19:52year. So, the United States assumes a
- 19:55lot of costs, and who benefits from this
- 19:57arrangement? Well, two forces, Wall
- 20:00Street, right, because of the
- 20:01financialization,
- 20:02but also the Chinese Communist Party
- 20:05because as George points out, China is
- 20:07an export-dependent
- 20:09economy. In fact, you can make the
- 20:11argument that what China is doing is
- 20:13free riding on American system, right?
- 20:16Because because when Chinese ships
- 20:18export their goods to Europe, to the
- 20:21Middle East, to the United States, it's
- 20:23it's being protected by the US Navy. Not
- 20:25the Chinese Navy, the US Navy. China
- 20:28China doesn't even have a blue water
- 20:29navy. It's the Americans that protect
- 20:32the seas. And when Chinese do exchanges,
- 20:34when they trade, it's through the US
- 20:36dollar. So,
- 20:38China's completely dependent on Pax
- 20:40Americana. And so, the idea that as Pax
- 20:44America is falling, China will rise
- 20:46makes no sense. And
- 20:50I mean, the reality is as George points
- 20:52out, China lacks domestic consumption
- 20:54power. Its people do not spend any money
- 20:56because its people do not have any
- 20:58money. All the rich people are going
- 21:00where? United States. That's problem
- 21:02number one. But there's a huge problem
- 21:04that we haven't discussed, which is the
- 21:05demographic issue, where China's aging
- 21:07rapidly because of the one-child policy,
- 21:10China has no workforce. That's why
- 21:12China's spending everything on robotics
- 21:14and on semiconductors and on AI because
- 21:17China doesn't have the productive force
- 21:19it needs to carry it through the past 20
- 21:22for for the next 20-40 years because of
- 21:24the aging crisis. So, China's in a world
- 21:26of trouble.
- 21:27But, where I disagree with
- 21:28>> a bigger world of trouble than America?
- 21:30>> Oh, yeah, absolutely. Because regardless
- 21:33of how you feel about the United States
- 21:34right now, the United States is a
- 21:35self-sufficient,
- 21:37resource-rich
- 21:39economy with a very vibrant, energetic,
- 21:42young population. China has the opposite
- 21:44problem, which is that it is extremely
- 21:46extremely export-orientated.
- 21:49Um it's a very poor country, very
- 21:50limited resources. It's very dependent
- 21:52on global supply chains. What's breaking
- 21:54down right now are global supply chains.
- 21:56>> Tell me if this sounds familiar. You
- 21:58train regularly, you eat reasonably
- 22:00well, you feel fine, but you're just
- 22:02kind of going off vibes. Most people
- 22:05have absolutely no idea what's going on
- 22:06inside their body, and that is why I
- 22:08partnered with Function. Function gives
- 22:10you access to more than 160 advanced lab
- 22:12tests spanning hormones, heart health,
- 22:14kidney function, and even detects early
- 22:16signals linked to more than 50 types of
- 22:18cancer. To put that in perspective, your
- 22:20typical annual physical might test 20
- 22:22markers. Function runs over 160. It's
- 22:25huge. Best of all, you test twice a year
- 22:27and everything lives inside of a simple
- 22:28dashboard. So, you track trends over
- 22:30time, make sure you're moving in the
- 22:31right direction. And this level of
- 22:32testing would usually cost thousands,
- 22:34but with Function, it is $365 per year.
- 22:37Just $1 a day to actually know what's
- 22:39happening inside of your body. And right
- 22:40now, you can get $25 off, bringing it
- 22:42down to 340 bucks. Get the exact same
- 22:45blood panels that I use and save $25 by
- 22:47going to the link in the description
- 22:49below or heading to
- 22:50functionhealth.com/modernwisdom.
- 22:52That's functionhealth.com/modernwisdom.
- 22:55>> So, let me just respond in this way.
- 22:58I had exactly their image 10 years ago.
- 23:03Exactly their image. So, I first went to
- 23:05China in 1979, then I didn't go back
- 23:07until 2012, 10 trips from 2012 to 2015,
- 23:12then I went back in 2025.
- 23:15In two Even as late as 2015, I had
- 23:17exactly their image.
- 23:20Here's what happened in this trip, and
- 23:22this is what really are the core things
- 23:25that I'm seeing.
- 23:27Um number one, the Ali Baba, BYD,
- 23:32Xiaomi. I didn't just go and look at the
- 23:34shop floors. I met with their
- 23:36executives. They showed me their growth
- 23:38plans.
- 23:39Um it's not just that they have been
- 23:41spurting up since COVID. So, all this
- 23:44building massively development since
- 23:46since COVID. It's that since 2017,
- 23:49essentially the Trump tariffs that were
- 23:50first put on China in 2017 by President
- 23:53Trump, there's been a dramatic uh
- 23:56emphasis to disengage
- 23:59the uh development of the next
- 24:02generation of industries from Chi from
- 24:06America. So, you can't buy the
- 24:09cutting-edge BYD vehicles here in the
- 24:10United States. Uh you can't buy the
- 24:12next-level Teslas of Xiaomi here in the
- 24:15United States. And they're not trying to
- 24:17sell them here. Also, the whole issue
- 24:19with Walmart and um so forth, that's the
- 24:22last generation of what's occurred. They
- 24:24showed me their growth models. They are
- 24:27still export oriented, but they're not
- 24:29export oriented to Europe, and they're
- 24:31not export oriented to the United
- 24:32States, although they take a little
- 24:34crumbs on the on the edges. It is built
- 24:36around Asia. They showed me their growth
- 24:39models that are really counting on are
- 24:42in Asia. Now, true, in the short term
- 24:45here, there's some problems with the
- 24:46Iran war, and of course, Asia. So, we
- 24:48talked about that with the actual top
- 24:51VPs, the exact the top executives, and
- 24:54they explained to me that the bottom
- 24:57line is the more the United States gets
- 25:00sucked into a quagmire with Iran, yes,
- 25:03they will run into some short-term
- 25:05problems, but just like COVID, when they
- 25:08came out of those problems with the
- 25:09supply chain problem in COVID, they
- 25:11jettisoned ahead. They thought they were
- 25:14likely going to get ahead. And if you
- 25:16look at the numbers of what the BYD
- 25:18production has been this year in 2026,
- 25:22uh what the numbers of Xiaomi has been,
- 25:24uh the numbers at least we can see, uh
- 25:26they're not as good as they were hoping,
- 25:29but they're about at the same level as
- 25:30the last year. So, China's not
- 25:32collapsing.
- 25:33>> rate is down to a little over 4%.
- 25:36It was previously 5% and its greatest
- 25:38price was a 15% growth rate.
- 25:40>> And I'm saying this is the wrong
- 25:42measure. This would be like measuring
- 25:44America's growth rate without noticing
- 25:47electrification in the 1880s, which
- 25:49starts in this really small way. America
- 25:52has been great because since 1880,
- 25:56we have led every technological
- 25:59revolution since 1880. The AI revolution
- 26:03that we're right going through right
- 26:04now,
- 26:05we hope we're going to come out ahead.
- 26:08The stock market's certainly betting on
- 26:09that. I'm telling you what I saw in
- 26:11China, it's not just about deep seek and
- 26:14Alibaba. They're building the core
- 26:17infrastructure
- 26:19to be able to beat us.
- 26:21>> If I may Let me ask you this question.
- 26:23Um so, right now, Japan is
- 26:25remilitarizing rapidly.
- 26:28>> Yes.
- 26:28>> And it's building an alliance with
- 26:29India, the Philippines, and Australia,
- 26:32the Quad, right? It seems to me in the
- 26:34long term, the intention is to embargo
- 26:36China, to cut off the supply chains.
- 26:38>> Mhm.
- 26:38>> With [clears throat] With India coming
- 26:40into it, Indonesia coming into it, and
- 26:42so and so forth.
- 26:43>> So, from Japan all the way to India,
- 26:46there is at sea a blockade.
- 26:48>> That's right. So, what is China's
- 26:49response to to this possible embargo.
- 26:52So, as I look out here, um first of all,
- 26:56if you're quite right that there's
- 26:58military possible consequence here.
- 27:01Um I think President Xi's question to
- 27:03Trump was exactly the right question,
- 27:05which was um are you, President Trump,
- 27:08going to fight here if there's a
- 27:10conflict between China and Taiwan? And
- 27:13President Trump said he wouldn't answer
- 27:14that question. Because if you uh yes,
- 27:17you have the quad moving forward, but if
- 27:19you take out the United States from that
- 27:22equation, as I think we are heading in
- 27:25that direction, then this is just a very
- 27:28different competition between um
- 27:31uh the quad and China. They might fight,
- 27:33they might decide to fight just the quad
- 27:36and China, but uh and both will go down
- 27:39some, but this is not a sure winner for
- 27:42the quad over China. So, I think this
- 27:44would be a very different And notice,
- 27:47this is not China provoking the war.
- 27:49>> That's right.
- 27:50>> This is This is outsiders attacking
- 27:52China. And what is What did Mao What
- 27:54What happened with Mao? This was a a
- 27:56gigantic revolution inside of China to
- 28:00foreign conquest. So, this is not
- 28:02Talking about unifying China.
- 28:04>> could.
- 28:04>> [laughter]
- 28:05>> The Taiwan situation is profoundly
- 28:07changed.
- 28:08Inside of Taiwan,
- 28:11the population is divided almost down
- 28:13the middle
- 28:14with the KMT, the Kuomintang, which is
- 28:17decided in favor of reuniting with China
- 28:22in some sort of way.
- 28:24It's about half the population. The
- 28:26other half the population is very much
- 28:27opposed to it.
- 28:30From the Chinese point of view,
- 28:33Taiwan was a very great danger
- 28:35because between Japan and the
- 28:36Philippines, Taiwan was a blocking
- 28:38force.
- 28:39>> The first island chain.
- 28:40>> Hm?
- 28:40>> The first island chain.
- 28:41>> Yeah.
- 28:42>> Yeah.
- 28:42>> That's the first island chain.
- 28:44That they want Taiwan opened. Okay?
- 28:48The United States does not have a
- 28:49fundamental interest
- 28:52on Taiwan. So, the idea
- 28:55is
- 28:56we see that Xi is coming to the United
- 28:58States.
- 28:59And he has said this week, "We're going
- 29:01to reach many great agreements in the
- 29:04United States."
- 29:05One of the forecasts I had was that this
- 29:07year China and the United States would
- 29:08come to a fundamental understanding with
- 29:10each other. Why? China must have that
- 29:12understanding.
- 29:14The United States is not a trivial
- 29:16partner, okay? It is the number one
- 29:18trading partner. And it is the only
- 29:21military threat to China. Therefore,
- 29:23accommodation is rational for China.
- 29:26And these talks have been taking place.
- 29:28So, what I'm seeing in China
- 29:31is a tremendous amount of instability in
- 29:33the political system. The economic
- 29:35system is moving ahead properly.
- 29:39But, China
- 29:41has a fundamental problem.
- 29:42Because, as I said, it must have a
- 29:45decent relation with the United States.
- 29:47And the United States has said to it,
- 29:49"We cannot be dependent on China for its
- 29:51imports
- 29:53if it is also possible to go to war with
- 29:55us." That happened during the Arab oil
- 29:57embargo.
- 29:57>> [snorts]
- 29:58>> We were dependent on the Arabs. The
- 29:59Israelis went to war, and they cut off
- 30:01our oil embargo. It was a disaster in
- 30:03the 1970s.
- 30:04So, if we are too dependent on a country
- 30:07with whom we have hostile relations,
- 30:10that's understandable.
- 30:11>> So, you're suggesting that the US and
- 30:12China are going to become friends soon?
- 30:14>> Well, Dr. We have friends, not going to
- 30:15be lovers. They simply need each other.
- 30:18>> And here I agree. So, my whole point was
- 30:20not that we must then have conflict with
- 30:23China. In fact, when I was in China, I
- 30:24was giving talks
- 30:26arguing that given everything I just
- 30:28said, I think that China can rise
- 30:31peacefully with the United States.
- 30:33That's my big position, and it's because
- 30:35when I look out at the growth of power,
- 30:38what is power today? Power is
- 30:42modernization, technological
- 30:44development. We see that right now with
- 30:47the the drought with what we're
- 30:48experiencing with Iran. We're not losing
- 30:50to Iran because of Iran's 4% of it's
- 30:54because of we're behind in understanding
- 30:57the second precision revolution. What's
- 31:00happening, Chris, is others are
- 31:02evolving. We're used to thinking we, the
- 31:05United States, are on the cutting edge
- 31:07of everything. And what we're learning
- 31:10is we're not on the cutting edge of
- 31:12everything. Now, that doesn't mean we
- 31:13have to go to war against China. I was
- 31:15also impressed President Xi said
- 31:17basically asked Trump about the
- 31:19Thucydides trap. Are you going Are we
- 31:21going to go to war? So, I believe these
- 31:23are the right questions. I don't think
- 31:26we're heading to a war with China if
- 31:28we're smart because what we need to do
- 31:30is develop our industrial base. We need
- 31:33to develop and modernize internally.
- 31:36This is a choice. Back to your question,
- 31:38will we be
- 31:40replaced as the world's number
- 31:41[clears throat] one in 20 years? This is
- 31:43a choice. If we keep fighting these
- 31:45horrible quagmires, if we stop if we
- 31:48don't develop internally here, if we
- 31:51don't catch up to China, the answer is
- 31:54yes.
- 31:54>> Given where we're at at the moment,
- 31:57looking at your respective crystal
- 31:58balls, which country do you think is the
- 32:01most powerful in the world in 20 years'
- 32:02time?
- 32:03>> The United States is the only global
- 32:05power. China is a regional power. It
- 32:07cannot
- 32:08push force into the Atlantic and so on.
- 32:11Okay, we can. So, we're reaching a world
- 32:13that's very different.
- 32:15That doesn't mean that the United States
- 32:16is in decline.
- 32:18Okay? Certainly, I agree with you on
- 32:20many of these things, but I don't think
- 32:22it's fundamental to the position of the
- 32:24United States.
- 32:25It is the United States
- 32:27occupied a position in the world
- 32:29which cost it a great deal in many
- 32:31different dimensions.
- 32:33And that backing off from that
- 32:36reduces tensions within the United
- 32:37States and so on.
- 32:38>> It's a I was thinking that there would
- 32:39be some sort of seesaw probably between
- 32:42China and the US, but maybe there was
- 32:43another player that I I hadn't thought
- 32:45about. Uh it sounds like both are in
- 32:48some form of mild decline.
- 32:50>> They're in flux. So my position is it's
- 32:54up to our leaders who's going to be
- 32:56number one in 2020. There's three
- 32:59dimensions of global power I would look
- 33:02at. Dimension number one is uh the
- 33:04country's GDP is a fraction of world
- 33:07product. Right now we're 26% China's 17,
- 33:11but if you look forward here this could
- 33:13easily flip-flop in 20 years. Uh the
- 33:16second is allies. How many friends do
- 33:19you have in the world? Well, look at
- 33:21what's happened with the tariffs. Look
- 33:22at what's happening with Canada right
- 33:24now today. What is happening is in the
- 33:27middle of this gigantic war that we're
- 33:30having with with with uh Iran. We are
- 33:32deciding to alienate uh friends. Well,
- 33:35who's likely to pick up those friends?
- 33:37It's going to be China. And then issue
- 33:39uh number three is our technological
- 33:42base, our growth. If the world economy
- 33:45goes over a cliff with our $40 in debt,
- 33:49I think the idea that we're going to
- 33:50invest our way out of this in the AI I'm
- 33:52just Look, maybe that will all work out,
- 33:55Chris. Okay? And we're going to be fine
- 33:57with $40
- 33:58>> my way through the apocalypse. I don't
- 34:00know about you.
- 34:00>> Well, I'm just trying to explain. These
- 34:01are the problems I'm worried about. And
- 34:04I want to
- 34:05>> One second. Let's hear Let's hear from
- 34:06Professor Jang.
- 34:06>> So um I think
- 34:09that these past 30 40 40 years of Pax
- 34:11Americana have been unique in human
- 34:14history. Never before have we we had a
- 34:16power that could span the entire globe,
- 34:19that had a for the first time we had a
- 34:20global reserve currency.
- 34:22Um never before um had one nation been
- 34:25able to dictate the global economy. So I
- 34:28think Pax Americana has been unique in
- 34:29human history, and I think we're we're
- 34:31reverting back to the mean, which is
- 34:33more regional dominance.
- 34:34Um,
- 34:35>> so the way that I examine how
- 34:37nation-states
- 34:38um
- 34:39thrives or die is using three basic
- 34:42criteria, which is going to be very
- 34:43different from yours. But first, I look
- 34:45at energy. Basically, how hard-working
- 34:48are the people? Second thing is
- 34:50openness, which is how open are people
- 34:53to change? How How are they How much are
- 34:56they willing to absorb new ideas? The
- 34:58third is cohesion, which is how much do
- 35:00they value their own neighbor? If you If
- 35:02you If you actually use these three
- 35:04metrics, okay? Energy,
- 35:07uh openness, and cohesion, you find that
- 35:09in each region, one nation will dominate
- 35:11above all else. So, in East Asia, it
- 35:14will not be China that dominates. It
- 35:16will be Japan that dominates. It will be
- 35:18in uh in Europe, it will either be
- 35:20Germany or Poland, one of the two.
- 35:23Um Germany is more powerful, but Poland
- 35:24is more cohesive. And And you can tell
- 35:27me next week what what what what what
- 35:28you find.
- 35:29>> It's more dynamic.
- 35:30>> Absolutely. Absolutely.
- 35:31>> And it's more in danger, it seems. And
- 35:34that goes
- 35:34>> That's why it's more energetic.
- 35:35>> Energy.
- 35:36>> That's right. And then in in North
- 35:38America, it's It's the United States by
- 35:39far. The United States is so dominant
- 35:41that it The United States could like
- 35:43keep on electing Donald Trump for the
- 35:44next few
- 35:45>> It could face plant its way through the
- 35:46next few decades and still win.
- 35:47>> Unfortunately, unfortunately, that is
- 35:49the case for the United States. And then
- 35:50in the Middle East, I believe it is
- 35:51Israel that is most dominant.
- 35:54>> In other news, have you ever noticed how
- 35:55some websites make it ridiculously easy
- 35:57to buy, while some feel infinitely
- 35:59harder?
- 36:00>> Back in my day, I'd walk 10 miles to the
- 36:02local store.
- 36:03>> Aren't you younger than me?
- 36:04>> Yeah, but my dad got a DUI.
- 36:08>> Anyway, the reality is most businesses
- 36:10just get the website wrong. And if your
- 36:12setup is messy, you lose a ton of sales,
- 36:15which is why I'm such a massive fan of
- 36:17Shopify. They power 10% of all
- 36:20e-commerce in the United States,
- 36:22including brands like Gymshark, Skims,
- 36:23Alo, and
- 36:25Yutanic. Because when it comes to
- 36:27converting browsers into buyers, they
- 36:28are best in class. Their checkouts 36%
- 36:30better on average compared to other
- 36:32platforms, and with Shop Pay, can boost
- 36:34conversions by 50%. So, upgrade your
- 36:36business and get the exact same checkout
- 36:38that we use at Newtonic with Shopify.
- 36:40You can sign up for a free trial period
- 36:42by going to the link in the description
- 36:43below or heading to
- 36:44shopify.com/modernwisdom.
- 36:47That's shopify.com/modernwisdom.
- 36:50Interesting on the US's ability to put
- 36:53its both of its feet in its mouth and
- 36:55continue to be preeminent power. Does
- 36:57that help to smooth over some cracks and
- 37:02inefficiencies and instabilities inside
- 37:04of America? The momentum, just the sheer
- 37:06size of it, means that there can be
- 37:09issues bubbling below the surface that
- 37:11don't get seen for a little while and
- 37:12then eventually the sort of lid gets
- 37:14blown up. Obviously, you're talking
- 37:15about civil unrest. I don't know how
- 37:16likely you think civil unrest, proper
- 37:18civil unrest, is going to be due to
- 37:20this.
- 37:20>> So,
- 37:22I have coming out, Chris, a book called
- 37:24Our Own Worst Enemies: America in the
- 37:26Age of Violent Populism.
- 37:29It's pre-order now on Amazon. It'll be
- 37:31available in just a couple weeks to be
- 37:33in your mailbox.
- 37:34And I've spent five years studying this
- 37:36problem because my work on political
- 37:39violence, what I do, Chris, is I look at
- 37:42where is the biggest threat to America?
- 37:45The biggest threat. So, it changes from
- 37:48time to time. And what I started to see
- 37:51after the George Floyd protests, which
- 37:53were mostly peaceful, but what does
- 37:55mostly peaceful mean with the George
- 37:56Floyd protest? When 28 million are
- 37:58protesting and 7% are riots and
- 38:02political violence, that's millions of
- 38:04people who are unrest. And then also in
- 38:06January 6th, this is the first time in
- 38:09our history that we've had a violent mob
- 38:11supported by the president of the United
- 38:14States to try to stop the constitutional
- 38:17process of changing presidential power
- 38:20in the United States. Then we've had the
- 38:22rise of political assassinations and
- 38:24assassination attempts.
- 38:26I could go on and on. This is, I would
- 38:28say, akin to the 1960s. I agree we've
- 38:32had some periods of violent populism
- 38:34before. The book covers that. But what's
- 38:36different is it's on both the right and
- 38:38the left. The number one fact today is
- 38:41tens of millions of Americans on each
- 38:44side. I don't mean total. Each side of
- 38:47the political spectrum support political
- 38:49violence
- 38:50for the goals that they also support.
- 38:53That's why you're getting support for
- 38:55very aggressive ICE tactics that are
- 38:58against Democratic protesters even after
- 39:01ICE kills those Democratic protesters.
- 39:03>> this is not the first time happened. We
- 39:05had a Civil War.
- 39:06In that Civil War, we ripped ourselves
- 39:08apart and then came together again.
- 39:11There's a strangeness in the United
- 39:12States.
- 39:13Most countries that have that kind of
- 39:15Civil War
- 39:16could not accommodate itself again.
- 39:19We are historically, when we take a look
- 39:22at these various periods in history, at
- 39:24each other's throats.
- 39:26It is one of the dimensions of the
- 39:27United States which is based on the fact
- 39:30that we're an invented country.
- 39:32Invented not only in the sense that the
- 39:35Constitution was invented,
- 39:37but that the population was invented.
- 39:39There was no Other nations have
- 39:42histories of culture and so on. We
- 39:44constantly came together.
- 39:46So, one of the things that the United
- 39:48States is very good at,
- 39:50from the founding,
- 39:52is being deeply divided. Because as John
- 39:54Adams said, 1/3 of the people were for
- 39:57the revolution, 1/3
- 39:59of people were against the revolution,
- 40:011/3 of people didn't care.
- 40:03>> Mhm.
- 40:03>> That was his his reading.
- 40:05So, I see the divisions in a very
- 40:07different way than you do.
- 40:08>> Well, I don't think it's good enough to
- 40:10say that we survived the Civil War
- 40:12because 600,000 people died in the Civil
- 40:15War. So, let's just be clear. We are $40
- 40:18trillion in debt. The idea that sure,
- 40:21we'll just have a Civil War and no
- 40:22problem. We'll get out of this just
- 40:24fine. This is the showing how he We've
- 40:27got to go to the Civil War standard to
- 40:30to say we can survive a Civil War. No,
- 40:32we will not be able to be anything like
- 40:34We won't even be a regional power.
- 40:36>> I disagree profoundly.
- 40:39There's a cultural nature. China has a
- 40:41culture. It has a history. It has an
- 40:43evolution. Britain has a history and so
- 40:46on, okay?
- 40:46>> Thank you.
- 40:47>> When you take a look at
- 40:49>> Well, you used to.
- 40:50>> Well,
- 40:50>> [laughter]
- 40:50>> shut up, dude. All right? Shut up, okay?
- 40:54When you take a look at American
- 40:56history, you measure yourself and your
- 40:58state of your company against something.
- 41:01Otherwise, you're constantly in a
- 41:03feeling of this has never been so
- 41:06terrible.
- 41:07So, you have to have a sense of
- 41:08proportion on what goes on.
- 41:11So, when we look at the
- 41:14the division in the United States, we've
- 41:15seen World War II.
- 41:17We've seen the isolationists
- 41:19and the interventionists.
- 41:21We've constantly approached the world
- 41:24deeply divided, okay? I saw that
- 41:27mentioned the Civil War because that was
- 41:29the most extreme example.
- 41:31But, even the the revolution was not a
- 41:35joint universal [snorts]
- 41:37uprising. It was deeply divided.
- 41:40And my wife's family had to move to
- 41:43Canada because
- 41:45>> after they won That's a high price to
- 41:46pay.
- 41:47>> Well, they were The point I
- 41:49making here is that
- 41:52One of the things about the Americans is
- 41:54we're constantly having the feeling
- 41:56we're going to hell. We have the ability
- 41:58to overestimate tremendously our
- 42:02weaknesses
- 42:03and underestimate the tremendous
- 42:04strengths. This is where I have to
- 42:07respect you and disagree with you. I
- 42:09look at the past
- 42:11as a measure of the culture of the and
- 42:15its
- 42:16flexibility and viability even under
- 42:18pressure.
- 42:18>> Do you think America is a country
- 42:20permanently in strife internally or is
- 42:22there something unique about the modern
- 42:25>> Well, well, let me let me also be clear.
- 42:26My book is explaining we're not heading
- 42:28to civil war.
- 42:30We are heading to violent populism and
- 42:33we're in the middle of violent populism.
- 42:35>> what the difference is, please?
- 42:36>> Yes, civil war is where you have armies
- 42:39going toe-to-toe. Truly we're This is
- 42:42battle after battle. So, we start to see
- 42:43the movies on civil war.
- 42:45>> [snorts]
- 42:45>> These are, I think, the extreme
- 42:49scenarios and we can talk about extreme
- 42:52scenarios. I hope we would never get
- 42:53there. So, I don't find them acceptable,
- 42:55but I don't think that's really what our
- 42:57future is.
- 42:59I think our future is more we're more in
- 43:01danger of becoming Turkey, for example,
- 43:04where because we have normalized
- 43:07political violence, it starts to become
- 43:09normal for the president to absorb more
- 43:12and more powers under the presidency.
- 43:16>> [snorts]
- 43:17>> And then also to sort of hide things.
- 43:19So, this isn't just happening with
- 43:21President Trump. During President
- 43:22Biden's presidency, we had open borders
- 43:25essentially. We had 10 million plus come
- 43:28into the country and yet this was all
- 43:30the image was Oh, no, there's nothing
- 43:32happening at the border. It's literally
- 43:34not happening. And that was
- 43:37by a Democratic president. So, what I'm
- 43:39trying to point out, Chris, is that
- 43:41we're in a world where because political
- 43:44violence is becoming normal and and
- 43:47George is finding it Well, sure, it's
- 43:48just okay. It's just another day in
- 43:50America. This is what I'm This is what
- 43:53the book's about. It's about how
- 43:55political violence has become normal for
- 43:57tens of millions of Americans for the
- 43:59first time since the 1960s
- 44:02and this has consequences because it's
- 44:04on both the right and the left and we're
- 44:07coming to an election. And this
- 44:09midterms, we already have um and I was
- 44:12just on many podcasts, we have people
- 44:14who are who are who terrified that
- 44:17President Trump is going to seize ballot
- 44:18boxes. Now, why would they be terrified
- 44:21of that? Because President Trump said he
- 44:23was going to do that in February.
- 44:25>> [laughter]
- 44:25>> So so this isn't just coming out of
- 44:27nowhere. And and my and when I'm on
- 44:30those podcasts, I'm trying to say, yes,
- 44:32that may happen, but we will hold
- 44:33ourselves together, and here's how we're
- 44:35going to do it. So
- 44:36>> [clears throat]
- 44:36>> I'm not trying to tell you we're heading
- 44:38to civil war.
- 44:40I'm also not trying to tell you civil
- 44:41war would just be fine. What I am trying
- 44:44to tell you is uh the way you're going
- 44:46to see um
- 44:48uh powers absorbed by the federal
- 44:51government, uh things like use of
- 44:52martial law and so forth, is because
- 44:56political violence has become
- 44:57normalized.
- 44:59>> which is the difference on your
- 45:00>> And it creates What's your perspective
- 45:01on internal strife in America?
- 45:03>> Right. So I think like the best
- 45:05historical analogy for the United States
- 45:06right now is Roman Empire.
- 45:08And the critical turning point uh for
- 45:11the Roman Empire is uh maybe 150 BCE.
- 45:16And this is the Third Punic War. This is
- 45:18before the Third Punic War starts
- 45:19between Carthage and Rome. At this
- 45:21point, Carthage is basically um
- 45:24destroyed, and it's just an economic
- 45:26center. It's no longer a military power.
- 45:28And there's a huge debate in the Roman
- 45:30Senate about what to do with Carthage.
- 45:32Uh Cato the Elder demanded the
- 45:34destruction of Carthage. Um because
- 45:36Carthage would always be a threat to
- 45:38Rome otherwise. Everyone else was like,
- 45:40no, guys, we cannot destroy Carthage
- 45:43because if we destroy Carthage, what
- 45:45happen is we'll have no external enemy,
- 45:48and we will start to tear ourselves
- 45:49apart. Cato the Elder won, and they
- 45:51destroyed Carthage in the Third Punic
- 45:53War. And then right after What happens
- 45:54afterwards? Complete civil strife. And
- 45:57after the civil war starts, right, with
- 45:58um starting with um
- 46:00um um uh uh
- 46:03um It It starts about 100 BCE
- 46:06with something called the Social War,
- 46:08but it never really stops. It Social War
- 46:10then leads to the rise
- 46:13of Julius Caesar, which then leads leads
- 46:15to the rise of
- 46:16Augustus Caesar, which then leads to all
- 46:18sorts of wars. So, that's the problem
- 46:21with the United States. The United
- 46:22States is probably the most violent
- 46:23country on this planet, like by far.
- 46:25There are more There are more guns per
- 46:27capita There are more guns than people.
- 46:29And like America's the only nation to
- 46:31play football. Am I Am I correct to say
- 46:34only Americans play football? Um, so
- 46:36America Americans have this tremendous
- 46:38energy.
- 46:39>> Hang on. Hang on. You're going to have
- 46:40to draw the parallel between there's
- 46:42lots of guns in America and America's
- 46:44the only country to play football. I
- 46:45feel like I've missed something there.
- 46:47>> What What
- 46:48What I'm saying is that America is a
- 46:50society that prides itself on the First
- 46:53Amendment and the Second Amendment. It's
- 46:55a society that is
- 46:57by the standards of every other society,
- 46:59it's pretty aggressive and
- 47:01>> Right. The physical contact, violence,
- 47:04like doing like listening to Metallica
- 47:06and flying F-14s and right?
- 47:08>> So this energy, you can you can either,
- 47:10you know,
- 47:11direct it outwards to to, you know,
- 47:14conquering the world or if you don't
- 47:16direct it outwards, then there's a fear
- 47:17that it becomes
- 47:19directed inwards, which could lead to
- 47:21civil war. It could be violent populism.
- 47:23It could be a full full full civil war.
- 47:26It could also be an
- 47:27insurgency very much like the movie one
- 47:29battle after another. But I I do think
- 47:31that right now at this point domestic
- 47:34violence is almost unavoidable.
- 47:36>> Wait. Really? Why?
- 47:39>> Um,
- 47:40I mean like you can you can agree or
- 47:42disagree, but I think there are certain
- 47:43trends that that are in place that make
- 47:47internal violence um, unavoidable. So
- 47:50the first is just the wealth inequality,
- 47:53the financialization of society.
- 47:55>> This is what I was talking about.
- 47:57>> That's one trend, but another major
- 47:58trend
- 48:00um is
- 48:02um the gerontocracy, the baby boomers.
- 48:05So, what's happened is that um baby baby
- 48:08boomers I I apologize to to both of you,
- 48:11but the baby boomers have been up lies
- 48:13political power and have made wealth
- 48:16and social status. And if you're a young
- 48:18person,
- 48:19you have absolutely no opportunity. Um
- 48:22you know, so um James Calhoun in the
- 48:241960s, he ran a very successful
- 48:26experiment called the rat utopia
- 48:28experiment. He basically put rats in a
- 48:30paradise where there'd be no
- 48:33um um predators, free food every day,
- 48:37and all that happened was the rats just
- 48:38turned against each other and killed
- 48:40each other. And the reason why is young
- 48:42men, especially young men, they strive
- 48:44for social status. If you don't give
- 48:46them social status, if they're not able
- 48:48to climb the social social hierarchy and
- 48:51find recognition and status, they turn
- 48:53violent. And and and this is just human
- 48:55nature.
- 48:56>> So, we tried to get at this. So, this
- 48:58this book that I'm coming out with, it's
- 49:01not
- 49:02it's a product of this 5 years of
- 49:03research that we've been doing at the
- 49:05Chicago Project on Security and Threats
- 49:07at the University of Chicago.
- 49:1020 national surveys, this is where all
- 49:12that millions of dollars. So, and why we
- 49:14did all that was to try to answer some
- 49:17of the why questions. So, we asked
- 49:19questions such as how worried are you
- 49:22you won't be as prosperous as your
- 49:24parents. That kind of gets at the wealth
- 49:26inequality and the social mobility.
- 49:28Well, we didn't just find out the
- 49:30general answer to that, we wanted to
- 49:32know did that make you more likely to
- 49:34support violence, political violence.
- 49:37And it turns out the more you think you
- 49:39won't be as prosperous as your parents,
- 49:42the more you support political violence
- 49:44on the right and on the left. It's a
- 49:48wedge, it drives both sides up. We also
- 49:51asked, remember I mentioned the second
- 49:52social change we're transitioning from a
- 49:54white majority democracy to a white
- 49:57minority democracy? Well, other
- 49:59countries in the world, this has played
- 50:00a huge role in political lines. That's
- 50:02why Lebanon, for instance, has had so
- 50:04much political violence over the years,
- 50:06over the decades. Well, this is not
- 50:08unique to America, but it's happening
- 50:10for us now, Chris, for the first time.
- 50:12And so we asked the question, if you are
- 50:15you happy with the transition to a white
- 50:18minority democracy or are you unhappy
- 50:21and want to reverse it? And what do we
- 50:23find? If you want to reverse it, you are
- 50:26far more likely to support political
- 50:28violence on right-wing issues. If you
- 50:30want to keep it going, you're more
- 50:32likely to support political violence on
- 50:35left-wing issues. These are not
- 50:37happening in isolation. They're not just
- 50:40swirling around and gee, it's kind of
- 50:42random why we're having a this rise of
- 50:45violent populism now. There are actual
- 50:48reasons and they overlap with some of
- 50:50what John's talking about, but we're
- 50:52able to get to the data to see, well,
- 50:54let's do some tests here and see, can we
- 50:57really see it in the data? And the
- 50:59answer is yes. And this is why
- 51:02so
- 51:03it's it's been very worrisome, Chris,
- 51:06for some time. So a year ago I published
- 51:08a big op-ed June 2025 in the New York
- 51:10Times. I was explaining this data in
- 51:13this op-ed and I was warning we're on
- 51:15the brink of major political violence.
- 51:18And what happens? The Charlie Kirk
- 51:19assassination happens. What happens? We
- 51:22get the rise of Operation Midway Blitz
- 51:25and then Metro Blitz. And that wasn't
- 51:27the first time, Chris. So a year before
- 51:29that, this data was showing a rise of
- 51:33anger to the point of violence against
- 51:35President Trump. This was in June 2024.
- 51:39So I brought it to our National Sheriffs
- 51:41Association. So I'm connected with these
- 51:43so remember, advised White Houses, etc.
- 51:46And I warned them that there's a
- 51:48non-trivial possibility that we're going
- 51:50to see a
- 51:52assassination attempt against President
- 51:54Trump.
- 51:55>> this?
- 51:55>> This was the last week of June 2024.
- 51:59So now they listened. I'm just going to
- 52:01say, Chris, they listened and guess what
- 52:03happened on July 13th at
- 52:08And then what happened in my phone is it
- 52:10blew up
- 52:11>> [laughter]
- 52:11>> because suddenly people were
- 52:13>> Mystic Mac.
- 52:15I thought I thought it literally blew
- 52:16up, but yeah.
- 52:17>> Well, no, no, [laughter] it didn't
- 52:17literally, but what I'm trying to say
- 52:19is, Chris, this is So just as my 20
- 52:22years of modeling of the Iran war has
- 52:25led to some predictions about what might
- 52:27come in advance. We haven't Well, but
- 52:29that's of course been well known in this
- 52:31at this point. This is not the first
- 52:33time. My work has been studying
- 52:36political violence not just in the
- 52:38rearview mirror, but with an eye toward
- 52:40giving real decision-makers, whether
- 52:43it's chief of staff of the Air Force,
- 52:45West Wing of the White House, uh FBI,
- 52:49um for uh I call it strategic
- 52:51intelligence. It's not tactical
- 52:53intelligence. It's where things are
- 52:55heading to see where probabilities of
- 52:59events in the future are shifting.
- 53:01That's my work.
- 53:02>> I don't I don't disagree with you.
- 53:04We are in a violent time. I simply put
- 53:07that context of American history and
- 53:10American culture.
- 53:11So
- 53:13if we're doing something that we've
- 53:15never done before,
- 53:17never done before and recovered from and
- 53:19so on,
- 53:20is very different from this is
- 53:21unprecedented.
- 53:23So when I look at
- 53:25culture,
- 53:27I take a look at the culture itself at
- 53:29its history
- 53:31and ask the question, is there a
- 53:33precedent for this? Okay? Have we Is
- 53:35this something we've never seen?
- 53:37If that's true, then there's a radical
- 53:40shift possible.
- 53:42If this is a cycle, a process like a
- 53:44cycle that periodically happens and
- 53:47comes and goes and is handled in the
- 53:49past,
- 53:50there's a high probability of a
- 53:51counteraction
- 53:53of it subsiding.
- 53:55So, this is why I go back to things that
- 53:57don't don't seem very relevant because
- 54:00they went away.
- 54:01But if you'd lived through the 1930s
- 54:05with the isolationists deeply
- 54:08in some ways anti-Semitic and everything
- 54:10else and the tensions that were there.
- 54:13Well, I've seen that. So, when I talk
- 54:15about the Civil War, it's just to say
- 54:17this was the most extreme event of this
- 54:19sort and we survived.
- 54:22So, I ask question, not only is a crisis
- 54:24coming which I completely agree with you
- 54:26on,
- 54:27but is it in the nature of the culture
- 54:29of the United States to withstand those
- 54:31crises?
- 54:32>> Yeah, I suppose that's Okay, so your
- 54:34your point is this might not be
- 54:35terminal, this might not be existential
- 54:37to the United States. I mean,
- 54:39does [snorts] anybody think like even if
- 54:40there was a civil war, there would be
- 54:41some people left and then you've got a
- 54:44country afterwards like from the ashes
- 54:46something can come back.
- 54:47>> out of that
- 54:49of Civil War
- 54:51was the most dynamic
- 54:53development economically
- 54:56perhaps in history.
- 54:57>> Is this like an accelerationist
- 54:58argument? We could
- 54:59>> No, this has has nothing to do with the
- 55:00causality or this is necessary.
- 55:03I'm simply saying to you
- 55:06that if you get a fever
- 55:08that you've never had before, well,
- 55:10that's really significant. If on the
- 55:13other hand you had another cold, you
- 55:15don't take that seriously.
- 55:17I'm trying to put this in the context
- 55:20of the American nature. So, I'm arguing
- 55:22there's a culture, there's a nature,
- 55:24there's a history.
- 55:25>> I I just want to make two quick points.
- 55:27>> now one and one thing is up.
- 55:29Every time we thought
- 55:32we were finished.
- 55:33During the '70s, the idea that the the
- 55:36killings, the
- 55:37kidnappings and everything that were
- 55:38going on.
- 55:40>> Well, they went away.
- 55:41So, I'm saying there's a cyclical
- 55:43process.
- 55:44>> A quick aside, you probably heard me
- 55:45talk about Element before, and that's
- 55:46because I've started every single
- 55:48morning the same way for the last 5
- 55:49years now, which is a cold glass of
- 55:51water with Element in it. Element is an
- 55:53electrolyte drink mixed with everything
- 55:54that you need and nothing that you
- 55:55don't. It's a science-backed electrolyte
- 55:57ratio of sodium, potassium, and
- 55:59magnesium. No sugar, no coloring, no
- 56:01artificial ingredients. It reduces
- 56:03muscle cramps and fatigue, supports
- 56:05brain function, and helps to regulate
- 56:06your appetite throughout the day. I
- 56:08genuinely notice the difference when I
- 56:10take it versus when I don't, which is
- 56:11why I don't shut up about it, and also
- 56:13why it's used by everyone from Dr.
- 56:15Andrew Huberman to Olympic athletes and
- 56:17FBI sniper teams. And they're the good
- 56:19sniper teams, not the bad ones. Also,
- 56:22they have a no questions asked refund
- 56:23policy. So, if you don't like it for any
- 56:24reason, they'll just give you your money
- 56:26back. Plus, they offer free shipping in
- 56:28the US. Right now, you can get a free
- 56:29sample pack of Element's most popular
- 56:31flavors with your first purchase by
- 56:32going to the link in the description
- 56:34below. Heading to drinklmn.com/modern
- 56:35wisdom. That's drinklmn.com/modern
- 56:40wisdom.
- 56:42Modern wisdom.
- 56:43>> So, I would just say two quick points.
- 56:45Number one is I want it on the record, I
- 56:47am not pro civil war.
- 56:49>> [laughter]
- 56:49>> That's that's the accelerationist side.
- 56:51>> I just want to be
- 56:52Just want to make sure I'm I'm on the
- 56:53record. Number two, no, hold it. Number
- 56:55two, more more more seriously. So, the
- 56:57point of the research of the book isn't
- 56:59just to give histories of the '60s, it's
- 57:01why did the violence in the '60s end? It
- 57:04ends for real reasons. It's not just we
- 57:06burn ourselves out. There were two
- 57:08drivers to the 1960s political violence.
- 57:11They're driven on social change. Change
- 57:13number one was we had a massive shift in
- 57:17migration of blacks to the the north and
- 57:20the Midwest that were that were not
- 57:22getting political representation. That
- 57:24was underneath the black riots, Malcolm
- 57:27X, the ballot or the bullet. In the by
- 57:29the mid-1970s,
- 57:31you start to have the black caucus. cuz
- 57:32you actually get some black. Now, it's
- 57:34not as good as it should be. I'm not
- 57:36trying to say it's perfect, but this is
- 57:38one of the big reasons why that violence
- 57:40comes down. There's a second driver of
- 57:42violence in the 1960s. It's the Vietnam
- 57:44War, the anti-war movement,
- 57:46conscription. What ends It's not just
- 57:49the Vietnam War ends, Chris.
- 57:50Conscription ended. We end in 1973
- 57:55conscription. So, I never had to be
- 57:58conscripted. Okay.
- 58:00>> Something structural has changed.
- 58:01>> And that took the steam out of the
- 58:03anti-war movement. As soon as the that
- 58:06That's what ended the Weatherman, the
- 58:08Weather Underground. That's what ended
- 58:10those uh that that violent protest here.
- 58:14Both of those issues end. So, my point
- 58:16is we can actually look today at the
- 58:19social causes, and I can tell you we're
- 58:22likely to have this violent populism for
- 58:24another 10 years.
- 58:26>> You think that there's another decade of
- 58:28this?
- 58:28>> Yes, because of the social changes. We
- 58:30can talk about those shifts, Chris.
- 58:32>> ask you the question, how does it end
- 58:34this time?
- 58:35>> This is up to us, and that's my point.
- 58:38My point is that this is not all in
- 58:40historical inevitability, and we
- 58:42shouldn't just throw the dice to the
- 58:44wind. We should understand what's
- 58:46happening to us, so that we can make
- 58:49more intelligent decisions going
- 58:51forward. It's not just a prediction of
- 58:54doom and gloom. It's things are going in
- 58:56a bad direction. Let's take that
- 58:58seriously, and then let's do something
- 59:00to offset it. That's been my world with
- 59:03mostly uh foreign policy elites for the
- 59:06last 30 years. I'm now trying to do that
- 59:08with the public.
- 59:09>> So, you reckon there's going to be
- 59:10internal strife for the next 10 years?
- 59:13>> Right. So, um back to the young men
- 59:15problem. So, right now there's a very
- 59:17popular phrase called hypergamy. Uh I'm
- 59:20not sure if you know the what hypergamy
- 59:23means. Do you know what it means?
- 59:24>> Are are at me as hypergamy? He's saying
- 59:27that's because I'm a high value male.
- 59:28>> That's right. That's right. Yes.
- 59:29>> yeah. Yeah. So So the problem is that
- 59:32majority of men young men are not able
- 59:35to find a suitable mate. Uh because one
- 59:38way to reduce um
- 59:42men young men's like violent tendencies
- 59:44is to get married, have children, and
- 59:46then they become productive members of
- 59:47society. But if like you know the
- 59:48majority of young men cannot get
- 59:51married, then what's the solution? Well,
- 59:53you send them off to war, right?
- 59:56So um there are two possibilities ahead
- 1:00:00for the United States. Um
- 1:00:02how do you deal with these millions of
- 1:00:03young men who cannot get laid basically?
- 1:00:06Well, you send them off send them off to
- 1:00:07war to die. If you did that if you had
- 1:00:09conscription, it's possible they they
- 1:00:11would just rather fight you, okay? So
- 1:00:13another solution is to colonize
- 1:00:18uh North and South America to turn the
- 1:00:20entire Western Hemisphere into a US
- 1:00:23colony. And they do not already with
- 1:00:25Well, they'll probably do that with
- 1:00:25Canada. They're talking talking about
- 1:00:27Greenland. Uh uh
- 1:00:28>> Do you think that realistically America
- 1:00:31would try and colonize Canada,
- 1:00:33Greenland, and Venezuela? Not just uh uh
- 1:00:36we're going to take a couple of leaders
- 1:00:37here and
- 1:00:39have soft power. They would actually try
- 1:00:41to do that.
- 1:00:41>> Yes, I do because there's no one to stop
- 1:00:43the United States from doing this.
- 1:00:45Why Why wouldn't the United States just
- 1:00:46take Alberta? What's stopping the United
- 1:00:47States from just taking Alberta? And And
- 1:00:49the parts of war is that not like Canada
- 1:00:52has what army again?
- 1:00:53>> Yeah. Yeah. The reason he's saying
- 1:00:55Alberta is that's where the oil is. So
- 1:00:58one of the things So this is This is
- 1:00:59something I would
- 1:01:01So with my classes at the University of
- 1:01:03Chicago, so not for the reason of the
- 1:01:05exactly dynamic. I won't quite go that
- 1:01:07far. But what I um so having studied
- 1:01:10violent populism, um I um watched over
- 1:01:14200 of uh President Trump's speeches as
- 1:01:16he was running for president, 200 all
- 1:01:19the way through. I went to four of his
- 1:01:21rallies, which didn't mean you just go
- 1:01:23to his rallies and listen to a Trump
- 1:01:25rally. That means you get there at 8:00
- 1:01:26a.m. You're already 3 hours late because
- 1:01:29you can And you can still barely see the
- 1:01:31stage, by the way. And you have to wait
- 1:01:3410 hours, and you can't move. If you
- 1:01:36move, you lose your place in line, and
- 1:01:38you're all the way at the back. So,
- 1:01:39that's why those hundreds of people are
- 1:01:41dropping over there. So, what do you do?
- 1:01:44I surveyed them. I talked to them. I
- 1:01:46actually literally That's what it
- 1:01:47surveys. And so, I learned a lot about
- 1:01:50what was underneath the support for
- 1:01:53Trump. I also went to Harris rallies.
- 1:01:55And
- 1:01:56it was easier to get there. You get
- 1:01:58there at 3:30, you still get to see it.
- 1:01:59So, it was a little different there. So,
- 1:02:01but nonetheless,
- 1:02:03nonetheless, what he is describing here,
- 1:02:05you could see a lot of in some of what
- 1:02:09President Trump was saying, he was
- 1:02:10planting some seeds. But come on, he's
- 1:02:13bombastic. This guy, gregarious,
- 1:02:16talky-talky. Like, isn't this a cool
- 1:02:17talk? Realistically, he's going to go to
- 1:02:20China. Hold it. Hold it. Now that's all
- 1:02:21fine, Chris, until after the election.
- 1:02:24It wasn't just talky-talky. It got
- 1:02:27seriously serious.
- 1:02:28Okay.
- 1:02:29>> [laughter]
- 1:02:29>> So, so I'm not telling you I'm not
- 1:02:31telling you I immediately jumped to the
- 1:02:33conclusion, "Oh, that would be a 99%
- 1:02:36likelihood of happening." I work in
- 1:02:38percentages.
- 1:02:39>> Okay, what do you think's the percentage
- 1:02:40likelihood that Greenland or Canada or
- 1:02:43Venezuela
- 1:02:45are
- 1:02:46brought into the American
- 1:02:49remit?
- 1:02:50>> I think it turns hugely on what happens
- 1:02:54with this election in 2028. So, if we
- 1:02:58are internally divided as I think
- 1:03:00there's likely to be, I think this
- 1:03:02external expansion is likely to go down.
- 1:03:05However, if it turns out that this is
- 1:03:07not just we're not internally divided,
- 1:03:09but we see the MAGA red wave get
- 1:03:14there's a very good chance that what
- 1:03:16Jang is talking about will come to be
- 1:03:19because these are this is what I mean by
- 1:03:21it's up to us, Chris.
- 1:03:23>> This is wild. I did not think that I was
- 1:03:25going to find out that we were maybe
- 1:03:26going to invade Canada and Greenland and
- 1:03:29Venezuela.
- 1:03:29>> Why not?
- 1:03:30>> I just it seems so
- 1:03:32so
- 1:03:33absurd and and
- 1:03:36this would be
- 1:03:37it would be invasion.
- 1:03:39>> I would agree with you.
- 1:03:39>> Well, I'm not I'm not again the
- 1:03:41probabilities here. So let's be clear.
- 1:03:43I'm not saying this is 70% likely. So I
- 1:03:46deal in the world of probabilities, but
- 1:03:48if we're talking about where there is a
- 1:03:50world where this is even a 20%
- 1:03:52probability this changes everything. The
- 1:03:55idea then if it's even 20% likely and
- 1:03:58notice what's happening with Carney.
- 1:03:59Notice what's happening with the
- 1:04:00leaders. I don't think Carney believes
- 1:04:03it's 80% likely, but if you watch his
- 1:04:06speech listen to his speech in Munich
- 1:04:07this year, he certainly thinks this is
- 1:04:10there's something on the horizon and
- 1:04:12President Trump has been talking
- 1:04:13directly to him about moving the border
- 1:04:17with Canada and the treaty and
- 1:04:19abandoning the 1908 treaty with Canada.
- 1:04:22This has been a direct conversation with
- 1:04:25the prime ministers of Canada in the
- 1:04:27last year and a half. This is I don't
- 1:04:30say it means it's it's a certainty Chris
- 1:04:32that's going too far, but to ignore that
- 1:04:35this is then translating into taking
- 1:04:39Venezuela's oil
- 1:04:41serious war planning now for Greenland.
- 1:04:45The war planning doesn't equal conquest
- 1:04:47Chris, but I think we're making a
- 1:04:49mistake to just simply dismiss it as oh
- 1:04:51this is just talk on the side.
- 1:04:53>> I I I wasn't dismissing it. I didn't
- 1:04:54even know that it was an option on the
- 1:04:55table. What do you think is more likely
- 1:04:57China into Taiwan or the US into one of
- 1:05:01Canada, Greenland, Venezuela?
- 1:05:03>> Oh, I vote for the the latter with the
- 1:05:05US. So I think that
- 1:05:06>> 100% No way. All of this talk all of
- 1:05:10with talk that people
- 1:05:12processors the microchip, all of the the
- 1:05:14China into Taiwan and the
- 1:05:15>> So, I've been arguing for decades
- 1:05:16>> more likely that we're going to go into
- 1:05:18Canada, Venezuela, or Ukraine.
- 1:05:19>> If China plays its cards right, Taiwan
- 1:05:22is going to fall right into China's lap.
- 1:05:24I've been So, President Chen brought me
- 1:05:26to Taiwan in January 2003.
- 1:05:29I was one of five air power experts.
- 1:05:31This was the president of Taiwan, okay?
- 1:05:33For a 2-day conference with the
- 1:05:34president of Taiwan. He wanted the
- 1:05:36answer to the question. This is January
- 1:05:382003.
- 1:05:40What should Taiwan do if China
- 1:05:43preemptively attacks Taiwan while the
- 1:05:45United States is preemptively attacking
- 1:05:48Iraq? So, remember, we had this thing
- 1:05:49called the Iraq war.
- 1:05:51>> Uh-huh.
- 1:05:51>> Well, for Taiwan, that was a very scary
- 1:05:54situation. So, for 2 days, I was with
- 1:05:57the president and also with the top of
- 1:06:00the Air Force and we were discussing the
- 1:06:02no-kidding discussions here.
- 1:06:05And I also got windows into their
- 1:06:07national security and I got the polls,
- 1:06:09that is the internal polls, which there
- 1:06:11was nothing classified inside, no NDAs,
- 1:06:13so I'm not revealing anything that I'm
- 1:06:15not supposed to be. But, I'm telling you
- 1:06:17that one of the absolute issues here
- 1:06:20with Taiwan is there's a large part of
- 1:06:22the population that sees growth over
- 1:06:25there.
- 1:06:26>> Mhm. [laughter]
- 1:06:26>> And they're happy to get some growth
- 1:06:27called Taipei 101. So, there's a whole
- 1:06:30lot underneath this, Chris. Doesn't mean
- 1:06:32Taiwan is certain to
- 1:06:35um uh you know, sort of go in China's
- 1:06:37way, but it what I've been arguing for
- 1:06:40some time is that if China just
- 1:06:42continues to grow, then what's going to
- 1:06:45happen is uh it will eventually dwarf
- 1:06:48Taiwan even more than it does today, and
- 1:06:51a lot of folks in Taiwan are going to
- 1:06:53want to make money in China.
- 1:06:54>> Uh.
- 1:06:55>> They already talk about that. What I
- 1:06:57want to do is not deny any of these
- 1:06:59things, put them in perspective. Take a
- 1:07:02look at a community like the United
- 1:07:04States, which is a community, common
- 1:07:05values, so on and so forth.
- 1:07:07Has there ever been deep divisions?
- 1:07:10How did we handle them?
- 1:07:12So, when we take a look as for example,
- 1:07:15immigration. Right from the beginning of
- 1:07:16the founding, there was a dread of
- 1:07:19migrants.
- 1:07:21The Scotch-Irish that came here
- 1:07:24were marginalized profoundly and so on
- 1:07:27and so forth. Okay?
- 1:07:29Along with these evolutions of
- 1:07:33uh immigration and so on and so forth,
- 1:07:34which were built on, we needed.
- 1:07:37Okay? There's also tension within though
- 1:07:39between those who wanted it and didn't
- 1:07:41want it.
- 1:07:42The businessmen wanted cheap labor.
- 1:07:45The others didn't want it. The workers
- 1:07:47didn't want it. Okay?
- 1:07:50So,
- 1:07:51we have to enter these from my point of
- 1:07:53view, and I agree with you absolutely on
- 1:07:56what's coming.
- 1:07:58I simply have a different sense of
- 1:07:59proportionality.
- 1:08:01That it's not as profoundly serious as
- 1:08:04we who have never experienced it before
- 1:08:06would want to make it be.
- 1:08:08There's precedent for it. There's a
- 1:08:10manner in which the Americans have
- 1:08:12historically gone through this. My
- 1:08:14pointing to the Civil War was only to
- 1:08:15point to the most extreme
- 1:08:17situation that even that we recovered
- 1:08:19from.
- 1:08:20>> When was the last time that you saw
- 1:08:21something you would say was
- 1:08:21unprecedented?
- 1:08:23>> Internally in America? I see a long line
- 1:08:27of continuum.
- 1:08:29Including the tensions and everything
- 1:08:31else.
- 1:08:31>> But you eventually you break you're
- 1:08:35using so much artistic license to say,
- 1:08:37"Well, you know, this thing has been
- 1:08:38it's analogous to something that's
- 1:08:39occurred before." Is there a time like
- 1:08:41I'm trying to work out when that's not
- 1:08:43that cycle hasn't
- 1:08:44>> Well, my point is my point is before I
- 1:08:47say this is
- 1:08:49catastrophic, unprecedented, and so on,
- 1:08:52I have to look back. Most stable
- 1:08:55countries
- 1:08:56go through vast cycles,
- 1:08:58periods of economic, social unrest. So,
- 1:09:03it's not a smooth flying anywhere, not
- 1:09:07even Iceland.
- 1:09:08>> Do you think it's perfectly normal for
- 1:09:09United States president to invade a
- 1:09:11country with no reason,
- 1:09:13with no strategy, no plan at all
- 1:09:17to win the war?
- 1:09:18>> say, let me see in 3 months what
- 1:09:22happens. First of all,
- 1:09:24there was a reason.
- 1:09:26>> What was the reason?
- 1:09:29>> Basically, he keeps going after nuclear
- 1:09:32material.
- 1:09:33>> Why?
- 1:09:34>> Because I was on the staff at times
- 1:09:37after 9/11
- 1:09:39doing scenarios, what is the worst-case
- 1:09:41scenario?
- 1:09:42And it was a nuclear
- 1:09:44country like Iran getting nuclear
- 1:09:46weapons,
- 1:09:48putting them on board a French ship,
- 1:09:50and sailing New York Harbor.
- 1:09:53At this point, we've had very few
- 1:09:55casualties on the American side.
- 1:09:57And
- 1:09:58two days ago, a
- 1:10:01a commander of the IRGC, a very senior
- 1:10:04commander, stood up and said, "We've got
- 1:10:06to stop this war. The people are not are
- 1:10:09suffering and everything else." What I'm
- 1:10:11saying about this war is, when you're in
- 1:10:13the middle of it, it's extraordinary.
- 1:10:16On the other hand, we see, one, it's
- 1:10:18been a very short one. There's been on
- 1:10:21the American side very small losses.
- 1:10:24On the
- 1:10:26You're seeing evolutions in Iran
- 1:10:30with very different outcomes. So, I
- 1:10:33simply say, "Okay, step back from this
- 1:10:36extraordinary event
- 1:10:38and ask the questions, and then ask, is
- 1:10:40it really extraordinary?"
- 1:10:42>> So, if the reason was a nuclear weapon,
- 1:10:45why assassinate it Why assassinate on
- 1:10:47the first day the Ayatollah? Who Who
- 1:10:51>> How do we just fought what
- 1:10:52>> The answer was because he wouldn't This
- 1:10:55president wouldn't listen to
- 1:10:58intelligence.
- 1:10:59The head of counterterrorism resigns
- 1:11:02saying that
- 1:11:04he will not allow me into his office.
- 1:11:07He's listening to Israelis.
- 1:11:09And presidents make massive mistakes. He
- 1:11:12confused
- 1:11:13the people there as a government of
- 1:11:16Iran.
- 1:11:17He confused them, killed them. That's
- 1:11:20not the government of Iran, it's IRGC.
- 1:11:23>> So on the other hand
- 1:11:24>> It is very important to say this war has
- 1:11:26lasted a few months.
- 1:11:27>> Okay?
- 1:11:29We are far from understanding how it
- 1:11:32will end.
- 1:11:33But that it will end is certain. And so
- 1:11:36on. So when I take a look at this
- 1:11:39Yeah, he did a very stupid thing. He
- 1:11:42profoundly.
- 1:11:43He's not the first president to do some
- 1:11:45very stupid things.
- 1:11:47The only thing I'm saying is that
- 1:11:50we tend to overreact to things
- 1:11:53when we don't put them in context.
- 1:11:55>> How big How big of a deal is the Iran
- 1:11:56war?
- 1:11:57>> Well, yeah, oh, it's a it's it is the
- 1:11:59biggest deal since going up against
- 1:12:01Germany in World War II. So Iran is the
- 1:12:03most difficult challenge we've had since
- 1:12:05Germany in World War II.
- 1:12:07So let me give a different window into
- 1:12:09this. So I've been modeling the bombing
- 1:12:10of Iran for 20 years.
- 1:12:13And in the modeling of the bombing of
- 1:12:15Iran, I started to do this in 2005 and
- 1:12:18here's where I partly agree with George.
- 1:12:20Um I do this in 2005 because once it is
- 1:12:24known that Iran is enriching uranium,
- 1:12:27that's when the military planning of
- 1:12:29going against Iran really jacks up. And
- 1:12:32I know cuz I was teaching for the Air
- 1:12:33Force in the 90s. I had a lot of
- 1:12:35experience. So from '79 to about 2002,
- 1:12:39we have political tensions. Yes, we
- 1:12:40occasionally do a war game. But after
- 1:12:422002 and 3, things get much more
- 1:12:45serious. I start to model the bombing of
- 1:12:47Iran in 2005.
- 1:12:49And I did it every year for 20 years. I
- 1:12:52did this in my classes at the University
- 1:12:53of Chicago. And what I'm do I lay out
- 1:12:56the target set, I lay out what There's
- 1:12:59all changes, of course. The target set
- 1:13:00changes, Fordow comes on, we get
- 1:13:04the MOABs. So we get we get the
- 1:13:06different technology changes and so
- 1:13:07forth. But the big thing that the
- 1:13:11modeling always showed is that
- 1:13:15once we, meaning America, bombed the
- 1:13:18Fordow facility, which only we could do
- 1:13:21because the Israelis didn't have the
- 1:13:23large precision ordinance to be able to
- 1:13:26do it. Once we did that,
- 1:13:29we would be 90% likely to destroy the
- 1:13:32centrifuge industrial
- 1:13:34the enrichment capability of the
- 1:13:37facility of Fordow, but we would have
- 1:13:40virtually no knowledge of whether we
- 1:13:42destroyed the 60% enriched uranium, the
- 1:13:45actual fissile material. And that's
- 1:13:48critical, Chris, because building a bomb
- 1:13:51is a piece of cake once you have the
- 1:13:54enriched material. Most people don't
- 1:13:56know that. I also teach my students how
- 1:13:57to build a bomb. So So like take them
- 1:14:00through this soup to nuts so they really
- 1:14:01understand. It's the fissile material.
- 1:14:04And then the modeling, and this is what
- 1:14:06I told my class, and I have the slides
- 1:14:08and so and so forth, and I put them on
- 1:14:09my Substack. And I said then what what
- 1:14:12happened is if we bomb Fordow,
- 1:14:14then a year or two later, we would do
- 1:14:17regime change bombing.
- 1:14:18Not just come back and bomb in general.
- 1:14:21We would literally do regime change
- 1:14:23bombing.
- 1:14:24And why would you do regime change
- 1:14:25bombing? Back to your question, so I can
- 1:14:27connect all the dots. It's because you
- 1:14:30would become once you bomb Fordow, you
- 1:14:33couldn't track for it with high
- 1:14:35confidence the dispersal of that fissile
- 1:14:38material. And we know, we have civilian
- 1:14:41satellites
- 1:14:42showing that a couple days before we
- 1:14:44bomb Fordow, stuff's coming out of
- 1:14:46Fordow. We have civilian satellite
- 1:14:49showing that Esfahan, another site, in
- 1:14:51February of this year, a month before we
- 1:14:53do the bombing,
- 1:14:55uh Iran is digging stuff out. We think
- 1:14:57that maybe they moved the stuff from
- 1:14:58Fordow to Esfahan, and now they're
- 1:15:00digging it out. So, this issue of a
- 1:15:04nuclear weapon, I think is really quite
- 1:15:06serious. Uh now, Israel, I think, is
- 1:15:09playing a role, but I in my I think it's
- 1:15:12secondary, because they have been
- 1:15:13arguing to do this for every year for 20
- 1:15:16years. What made the difference here, I
- 1:15:18believe, was the concern that we
- 1:15:21couldn't track the fissile material. And
- 1:15:24that's still going on to this day.
- 1:15:27That's why we're worried about Pick Axe
- 1:15:30Mountain, very specific. So, what all
- 1:15:32that means, Chris, is we're in an
- 1:15:35escalation trap. The trap didn't just
- 1:15:37start with killing the leader on
- 1:15:39February 28th, it starts with the
- 1:15:41bombing of Fordow. And that's the stage
- 1:15:45I published literally several days
- 1:15:47before we
- 1:15:48killed the leader. I escalation trap, I
- 1:15:50laid out the stages of what would come,
- 1:15:52would kill the leader.
- 1:15:54>> Is it following your predictive game
- 1:15:55plan thus far?
- 1:15:56>> Yes, and that's what's so scary about
- 1:15:58this. It's And what I'm really concerned
- 1:16:00about is we are coming now to a a
- 1:16:03serious stage of the escalation trap
- 1:16:06that's going to start next week and the
- 1:16:09following week. So, I've been laying out
- 1:16:11on my Substack the escalation trap, the
- 1:16:14nightmare scenario for how this is going
- 1:16:17to escalate to get worse. And that
- 1:16:20nightmare scenario, which I started
- 1:16:22laying out in July, was the rise of gas
- 1:16:25prices in the United States. Well, I
- 1:16:27don't know if you've been tracking
- 1:16:28[laughter] it, but in Chicago, they're
- 1:16:30going up. And what that is doing and and
- 1:16:33what this is doing is it creates the
- 1:16:35opportunity for Iran to really
- 1:16:39close and try to shut down Hormuz. Why?
- 1:16:42So that they can try to damage Trump
- 1:16:45politically in the midterms to
- 1:16:47irrevocably destroy his presidency. And
- 1:16:51why is And what did I say that was going
- 1:16:53to do? That was going to energize the
- 1:16:55Trump administration to start fighting
- 1:16:58back. And what is to What are we going
- 1:17:00to see literally tomorrow with Scott
- 1:17:02Bennett? Is D-Day. Okay. Now, it's an
- 1:17:05economic D-Day. But that economic D-Day
- 1:17:08is the Iran's already talking about
- 1:17:11further escalation here. If Iran
- 1:17:13escalates, are we really just going to
- 1:17:15sit back and say, "Oh, sure, we're going
- 1:17:17to" No, there's a real danger. We're in
- 1:17:20the spiral phase of the escalation trap.
- 1:17:23As those gas prices went up, this
- 1:17:26created a window of maximum leverage for
- 1:17:29Iran. They're using that maximum
- 1:17:31leverage to wreck Trump's presidency in
- 1:17:35the for the midterms. And I think that
- 1:17:38what President Trump is doing is trying
- 1:17:39to figure a way to It's not just how to
- 1:17:42deal with Iran now. It's What does he do
- 1:17:45to show he is going to do something as
- 1:17:48Iran is really doing great damage to our
- 1:17:51economy and his presidency. We're We're
- 1:17:53seeing the collapse of the global
- 1:17:55economy because for the past 30-40
- 1:17:57years, there's a very simple deal that
- 1:18:00governed the world, which is that the
- 1:18:02United States would provide protection
- 1:18:04to the GCC and to Japan. In return,
- 1:18:07Japan and the GCC would buy US
- 1:18:10Treasuries. And that was a deal that
- 1:18:12made the American economy so vibrant.
- 1:18:14The GCC now is being destroyed by this
- 1:18:16war. And because Japan gets most of its
- 1:18:18oil from the GCC, the Japanese yen is
- 1:18:22weakening, which means that these two
- 1:18:26regions of the world that provided most
- 1:18:28of the world's liquidity, especially to
- 1:18:29the United States, they can no longer do
- 1:18:31so. So, what Scott Bennett is worried
- 1:18:33about is
- 1:18:35um
- 1:18:36um
- 1:18:37the GCC and Japan can't buy US
- 1:18:39treasuries and so and so what that means
- 1:18:41is United States cannot refinance its
- 1:18:44$42 hundred debt.
- 1:18:46This is this is the apocalypse. This is
- 1:18:48a catastrophe. This is not just a short
- 1:18:50war.
- 1:18:51>> We should also take a look at the other
- 1:18:52side.
- 1:18:53What Iran is experiencing, what is
- 1:18:55happening in Iran. This is not simply
- 1:18:57the United States.
- 1:18:59There's a
- 1:19:00a significant split happening in Iran. A
- 1:19:03speech the other day made by a major
- 1:19:06leader said, "Look, our people are
- 1:19:08starving. We cannot continue this war."
- 1:19:11Okay?
- 1:19:12The Artesh is there, which is the
- 1:19:14secular army.
- 1:19:16So, in other words, look at this war not
- 1:19:17just from our side and the consequences
- 1:19:19to us. See the pain pain on the other
- 1:19:22side. Okay? So, we assume that the IRGC
- 1:19:25is super powerful, can continue to do
- 1:19:28anything it wants, has no resistance.
- 1:19:31We forget that there was
- 1:19:33about 20,000 people killed in an
- 1:19:35uprising before the war.
- 1:19:38Okay?
- 1:19:39That division is not gone.
- 1:19:41>> Iran has been under sanctions for the
- 1:19:42past 50 years. It's a poor place. People
- 1:19:45are used being poor. Are Americans going
- 1:19:47to put up with $10 $10
- 1:19:49gallon gas prices?
- 1:19:50>> If you're going to spend an hour in the
- 1:19:51gym, you might as well look hot and feel
- 1:19:53comfortable while you're doing it. And
- 1:19:55honestly, who wants to be in the
- 1:19:56background of a TikTok highlight reel
- 1:19:58dressed like a champ? Gymshark makes
- 1:19:59some of the best men's and women's
- 1:20:01training gear on the planet. And
- 1:20:03something that I realized a few years
- 1:20:04ago is that when you actually like what
- 1:20:06you're wearing in the gym, you show up
- 1:20:07differently. You train harder, you stay
- 1:20:09longer, and
- 1:20:10get way more high fives. The hybrid
- 1:20:11shorts are my go-to. They are the
- 1:20:14perfect length, super lightweight, easy
- 1:20:16to wash and dry, and the sleeveless
- 1:20:18t-shirts are what I've trained in every
- 1:20:19day for basically the last decade.
- 1:20:21They're the ideal fit, they're
- 1:20:22breathable, they hold their shape
- 1:20:23perfectly. No more looking like Adam
- 1:20:25Sandler's your stylist. Basically,
- 1:20:27everything they make is unbelievably
- 1:20:29well designed. You already know about
- 1:20:31them, they're high quality. You get 30
- 1:20:32days of free returns globally with
- 1:20:34global shipping and a 10% discount
- 1:20:37site-wide. So, get that 10% discount by
- 1:20:39going to the link in the description
- 1:20:40below or heading to gym.sh/modernwisdom
- 1:20:43and using the code modernwisdom10
- 1:20:45at checkout. That's gym.sh/modernwisdom
- 1:20:48and modernwisdom10 at checkout.
- 1:20:50>> So, for 30 years I've been studying air
- 1:20:53power, economic sanctions, blockades.
- 1:20:58I've focused on American political
- 1:21:00violence. So, again, it's the
- 1:21:01intersection of these military action
- 1:21:04and politics.
- 1:21:05Uh
- 1:21:06one thing that's very important to know
- 1:21:08in advance of what Scott Horton is about
- 1:21:10to tell us is since World War I not
- 1:21:14going back before World War I, since
- 1:21:16World War I
- 1:21:17even heavy economic pressure alone, I
- 1:21:21mean alone without other military force,
- 1:21:24has never won a major war.
- 1:21:26Never won a major war.
- 1:21:30All I want, and this is going to there's
- 1:21:31going to be a big Substack tomorrow as I
- 1:21:33put this out, all I want is I want the
- 1:21:36reporters at that news conference to ask
- 1:21:39a very simple question.
- 1:21:41So, the British blockade on Germany in
- 1:21:43World War I did not defeat Germany even
- 1:21:46though it killed over 700,000
- 1:21:49Ger- German civilians and we still had
- 1:21:52to have ground power to end that
- 1:21:54conflict. So, the economic sanctions on
- 1:21:57Japan before World War I and then during
- 1:21:59World War II and then during World War
- 1:22:01II itself did not stop us from bombing
- 1:22:04its cities, using the atomic bomb, and
- 1:22:07then also Russian entry into the war
- 1:22:09with ground forces. That's how we
- 1:22:11defeated Japan.
- 1:22:13If we look at Iraq from 1990 to 2003,
- 1:22:18it was our American military that kicked
- 1:22:20Saddam out of Kuwait and once Saddam was
- 1:22:22out of Kuwait from '91 to 2003, we had
- 1:22:25fifth had sanctions that crushed the
- 1:22:27Iraqi economy by 50% each year for all
- 1:22:32those years and what did we have to do?
- 1:22:34150,000 you see you get my point.
- 1:22:36>> Every time you speak I feel like I'm
- 1:22:38treading on egg shell. I'm like I don't
- 1:22:39want to know what comes next.
- 1:22:41>> Well now you [laughter] now you feel now
- 1:22:42you see what it was like when I taught
- 1:22:44for the Air Force because see
- 1:22:45awful.
- 1:22:46>> That's how they describe it a prison of
- 1:22:48faith. [laughter] He gets you in the
- 1:22:50data so you can't get out.
- 1:22:52>> We see Iran as a completely united
- 1:22:54country.
- 1:22:55No factions and so and so forth, okay?
- 1:22:59That's obviously delusion because there
- 1:23:01are always factions and so and so forth.
- 1:23:04So I'm not saying that it's economic
- 1:23:05force.
- 1:23:07But there were great divisions that we
- 1:23:09saw before. Those divisions
- 1:23:12are still there in some ways.
- 1:23:15So the question is not just the economic
- 1:23:17consequences.
- 1:23:19But also the fact that it's very rare to
- 1:23:22have a country that is totally united in
- 1:23:24this way and this is not the country
- 1:23:26like that.
- 1:23:27>> George the external force is bringing
- 1:23:29those divisions closer together. They're
- 1:23:32not breaking them apart.
- 1:23:34>> profoundly disagree. They can sometimes
- 1:23:36push them together.
- 1:23:38Sometimes I say as we did in Vietnam
- 1:23:40war.
- 1:23:40>> All I All I say is what's the case since
- 1:23:42World War I? All I need is one case. All
- 1:23:43I need is one case. All I need is one
- 1:23:43case. All I need is one case. All I need
- 1:23:44is one case. All I need is one case.
- 1:23:46>> One case
- 1:23:46>> One case where our external pressure our
- 1:23:50economic pressure where we've had and
- 1:23:53again I just gave you four another five.
- 1:23:56>> particularly said at no meaning economic
- 1:23:58pressure.
- 1:23:59I'm talking about the inherent
- 1:24:01differences within this vast country.
- 1:24:05>> Why does that matter?
- 1:24:06>> It matters because when
- 1:24:09the attacks start to happen and the pain
- 1:24:11starts to rise
- 1:24:12they become
- 1:24:14more powerful in the sense that others
- 1:24:16look at them and say you were right.
- 1:24:18This was not the government we should
- 1:24:19have.
- 1:24:20So
- 1:24:21>> But did they not already try and uprise
- 1:24:23before and that didn't work? Of course.
- 1:24:25No, they killed them all. Now, what did
- 1:24:27he circumstance?
- 1:24:28>> Is that going to stop?
- 1:24:30>> Well, this is the fundamental question,
- 1:24:33okay?
- 1:24:34>> And all we need is a case, George. Just
- 1:24:36give us even a case of bombing. So,
- 1:24:38let's widen it beyond military pressure.
- 1:24:40Where is the case that without ground
- 1:24:42forces bombing alone wrecked the
- 1:24:46government?
- 1:24:47>> answer is
- 1:24:49that the question in my mind is not
- 1:24:51bombing, okay?
- 1:24:53It is the disunity of the country
- 1:24:55itself, which we saw the weeks before
- 1:24:58the war began.
- 1:24:58>> Is your suggestion that if Iran had
- 1:25:01sufficient disunity inside that the
- 1:25:05government would choose to give up
- 1:25:08because it's got so much pressure
- 1:25:09happening internally?
- 1:25:10>> is the government itself
- 1:25:13the statement that was made and was
- 1:25:15transmitted all over the world by this
- 1:25:17leader of the IRGC, a former head of the
- 1:25:19IRGC, that we must not continue this.
- 1:25:23So, I'm saying that the the
- 1:25:25as in Vietnam
- 1:25:27the government was US government's
- 1:25:29complete frequently divided on what
- 1:25:31should be done.
- 1:25:32>> I
- 1:25:33at least from what I know, tiny amount I
- 1:25:35know about Iran, I don't get the sense
- 1:25:37that the government is going to be too
- 1:25:39concerned about the quality of life of
- 1:25:40its citizens to give over to what
- 1:25:43Trump's pressure is going to be.
- 1:25:45>> All I have is one speech from the former
- 1:25:47president that was published. He is
- 1:25:50still alive, apparently.
- 1:25:52So, when you take a look at a country
- 1:25:54take a look at the fragments within our
- 1:25:56own country and don't assume that this
- 1:25:58country is totally united or
- 1:26:02simply afraid of the regime. The regime
- 1:26:05itself
- 1:26:07is divided. We've seen it. Unless this
- 1:26:10speech that
- 1:26:11I saw and everything has translated
- 1:26:15was made up by something, buddy.
- 1:26:18This represented
- 1:26:19a significant thing. Now, the Pakistani
- 1:26:23uh head of the military is coming to
- 1:26:26talk to the Iranians. Uh he's already
- 1:26:28may already be there, okay?
- 1:26:30There's been talk this morning about
- 1:26:33Iran being allowed to become part of the
- 1:26:36the entity that was created.
- 1:26:39In other words, wars don't end because
- 1:26:41of the bombings. I totally agree with
- 1:26:43you. They end through political
- 1:26:46processes sometimes within countries.
- 1:26:48You don't totally defeat them.
- 1:26:51But it's we have to be
- 1:26:54aware that these are human beings.
- 1:26:57They're not all fanatics who are ready
- 1:26:59to die.
- 1:27:00>> think there's a difference between do we
- 1:27:02see all of the citizens of Iran as
- 1:27:06supporting a regime that we are
- 1:27:09concerned about that might be part of
- 1:27:11global terror or something like that. I
- 1:27:12don't think anybody's making that claim.
- 1:27:14I think the concern
- 1:27:15is no matter what's going on internally,
- 1:27:18whether it's divided or cohesive,
- 1:27:21whether they're in support or against,
- 1:27:24like the the war is going on from the
- 1:27:26people at the top of Iran and the people
- 1:27:27at the top of America, regardless of
- 1:27:29what the people below that think.
- 1:27:31>> who is at top of Iran, this man,
- 1:27:34>> Mhm.
- 1:27:34>> made this speech.
- 1:27:35>> no longer in power, right?
- 1:27:37>> No, he's not in power. He he's not in
- 1:27:38power, but he has tremendous influence.
- 1:27:41>> Mhm.
- 1:27:43That's what that's
- 1:27:44Here's the since World War I starts with
- 1:27:47Giulio Douhet. He wrote a book, Command
- 1:27:49of the Air, mostly has to do with air
- 1:27:51power. There's been a hope with either
- 1:27:53economic blockades or air power that air
- 1:27:56power or blockades without a ground
- 1:27:58force could incite a popular revolt to
- 1:28:01topple the government so that we would
- 1:28:03>> want to do it, you do it for us.
- 1:28:05>> Exactly. And this has been a hope now
- 1:28:07and it hasn't happened.
- 1:28:09>> one I have not talked about toppling the
- 1:28:11government.
- 1:28:12I am saying that the government itself
- 1:28:14is split in various ways. The IRGC is
- 1:28:18not totally unified.
- 1:28:21As
- 1:28:22we go into wars, we are not totally
- 1:28:24unified and sometimes the disunification
- 1:28:27>> We have to take a look at the internals.
- 1:28:28>> So so one factor that we need to look at
- 1:28:30is
- 1:28:32that right now the Iranians have chosen
- 1:28:34to adopt something called the Mosaic
- 1:28:35defense, which is a decentralized
- 1:28:38command and control
- 1:28:40military warfare, which means that it's
- 1:28:43entirely possible no one is in charge of
- 1:28:47Iran right now. So it doesn't really
- 1:28:49matter what the people want, doesn't
- 1:28:51really matter what the leadership wants
- 1:28:54because you have 31 commanders spread
- 1:28:56out all over the country and as long as
- 1:28:58one of them wants to keep on fighting,
- 1:28:59the show will almost remain closed and
- 1:29:02this war will continue. That's a
- 1:29:03problem.
- 1:29:04>> Sounds like decentralization, but it
- 1:29:06might just be leaderlessness in that
- 1:29:09way.
- 1:29:09>> It's They run the government through
- 1:29:11consensus. We saw this with the Taliban
- 1:29:14in Afghanistan as well. So it's There's
- 1:29:16different models for how you govern.
- 1:29:19Some are very rigid top-down. Gaddafi
- 1:29:22ran his government very rigid top-down.
- 1:29:24That's absolutely the case. Others are
- 1:29:27more very very decentralized, fragmented
- 1:29:30almost. I don't think that's where Iran
- 1:29:32is. Iran is in this middle of consensus
- 1:29:35and it's hard to see because this is
- 1:29:38where the supreme leader, when he made a
- 1:29:40statement, remember the MOU? The supreme
- 1:29:42leader made a statement saying that he
- 1:29:44personally didn't agree with the MOU,
- 1:29:46but he was going to give it a chance and
- 1:29:49support those who did, which meant there
- 1:29:51was a division just as George is saying
- 1:29:53and that side of getting a negotiated
- 1:29:56outcome won in on June 17th. That has
- 1:30:00now been replaced, I believe, by the
- 1:30:02other side, the supreme leader's side
- 1:30:05the and that's what you see with the
- 1:30:07replacement of the whole command
- 1:30:08structure of the IRGC in the last
- 1:30:11several weeks. It's all in one
- 1:30:13direction.
- 1:30:14>> was a major turning point because before
- 1:30:16the MOU, I think George is right. There
- 1:30:18were these factions and
- 1:30:20the MOU was a compromise. And
- 1:30:25what the Americans have shown is
- 1:30:27for the reason they will not abide by
- 1:30:29the terms of the MOU. And so the
- 1:30:32Iranians after at some point said,
- 1:30:35"Screw this. We are not going to
- 1:30:36negotiate. We are not going to
- 1:30:38compromise. We're going to fight this to
- 1:30:40the end." So now the Houthis have been
- 1:30:41brought into the war. And this war is
- 1:30:43just expanding very rapidly.
- 1:30:45>> What do you think is the likely outcome
- 1:30:46of the Iran war?
- 1:30:48>> It doesn't end. It What's going to
- 1:30:50happen is eventually the Ukraine war and
- 1:30:52the Iran war merge. Already we're seeing
- 1:30:54that after Zelensky bombed an Iranian
- 1:30:58cargo ship in the Caspian Sea and and
- 1:31:00Zelensky was very proud of this. Like
- 1:31:02you you see
- 1:31:04I can do this for for the Americans. So
- 1:31:07it is very likely that all the world
- 1:31:08powers are brought are brought in. China
- 1:31:10is brought into the war. Russia is
- 1:31:12brought into the war.
- 1:31:14Um
- 1:31:14>> This sounds a lot like the World War
- 1:31:15that we said wasn't going to happen at
- 1:31:17the top of this episode.
- 1:31:18>> Except it's a different world.
- 1:31:20So
- 1:31:20>> I mean it's a it's a good time.
- 1:31:22>> No. No. He No. He No. He actually thinks
- 1:31:24World War is is kind of coming quickly.
- 1:31:27>> Okay.
- 1:31:27>> Here's where my Here's where I would So
- 1:31:29I see the trends that Janga is saying. I
- 1:31:31don't want to disagree with the trends.
- 1:31:33I think January of this year is going to
- 1:31:37be a focal point moment.
- 1:31:38>> January of next year?
- 1:31:39>> Of next year. I mean January 2027 will
- 1:31:41be a focal point moment where all the
- 1:31:45actors, the United States, China, Iran,
- 1:31:48have a chance to reset. Now where they
- 1:31:51go, here's what I but why January?
- 1:31:54Keep Go back to what I just said, which
- 1:31:56is Iran has a strategy for the US
- 1:31:58midterms. It sees the oil inventories
- 1:32:01running down. It sees its period of
- 1:32:04maximum pressure. The opportunity here
- 1:32:07is uh to destroy Trump's presidency
- 1:32:11politically. Not to knock him out of
- 1:32:14office, but so that he is the lamest of
- 1:32:16lame ducks.
- 1:32:17Well, will that happen or not? We'll
- 1:32:19know uh quite a bit in the first week in
- 1:32:22January. Now, we won't necessarily know
- 1:32:24100%, but we'll know a lot of
- 1:32:27information. And I believe what's going
- 1:32:30to happen is once we get to the first
- 1:32:32week in January, everybody will be
- 1:32:35recalibrating
- 1:32:37for a post-Trump world. Now, or a future
- 1:32:41Trump world. It'll either
- 1:32:42>> Yeah. How do you feel about this?
- 1:32:43>> Well, look, the problem is we're trying
- 1:32:45to see this from an economical lens. And
- 1:32:48the reason why the MOU fell apart is
- 1:32:50Israel refused to abide by the terms.
- 1:32:53One of the major terms of the MOU signed
- 1:32:55between the United States and and Iran
- 1:32:57is that all terms all peace terms that
- 1:33:00apply to Iran would also apply to Iran's
- 1:33:03allies, especially Hezbollah in Lebanon.
- 1:33:06And that required Israel to withdraw its
- 1:33:09forces from southern Lebanon. Israel
- 1:33:11refused to do so, and Israel has only
- 1:33:14accelerated its attacks on Hezbollah.
- 1:33:17So, we think that it's entirely between
- 1:33:20um
- 1:33:22United States and Iran, but Israel has a
- 1:33:26lot of options. And right now, for the
- 1:33:29reason we can discuss this, Israel is
- 1:33:31choosing to um escalate the war. And we
- 1:33:35And also, the Houthis have been brought
- 1:33:37in. And the thing about the Houthis is
- 1:33:39that they are religious fanatics. They
- 1:33:41are They are They are very poor people.
- 1:33:43They live in mountains, and they're not
- 1:33:44afraid to die. And right now, they're
- 1:33:47fighting this war against Saudi Arabia.
- 1:33:49So, Saudi Arabia economical facilities
- 1:33:51are being hit. The
- 1:33:53The other strait uh in the Middle East
- 1:33:55the uh the Bab el-Mandeb Strait has been
- 1:33:58closed by by the Houthis. So, we're
- 1:34:00seeing this war escalate. And again,
- 1:34:02we're trying to see this from economic
- 1:34:03lens. But if you if you look at what the
- 1:34:05Houthis are Houthis are doing if you
- 1:34:07look at the what the IRGC and the
- 1:34:09Israelis are doing, I would say this is
- 1:34:10almost like a religious war. It's a
- 1:34:12crusade. It's an eschatological uh war.
- 1:34:14But there's a other dimension we have to
- 1:34:16see.
- 1:34:17The alliance
- 1:34:19between Saudi Arabia, Turkey,
- 1:34:22and Pakistan.
- 1:34:25Now, if you take a look at map or all
- 1:34:27around them, these countries, Saudi
- 1:34:29Arabia has no use for Iran.
- 1:34:33The
- 1:34:33the
- 1:34:34Turks are seeking to evolve themselves
- 1:34:37into a major point, scaring the Israelis
- 1:34:40to death.
- 1:34:41And Pakistan itself is evolving
- 1:34:45dramatically in this war at the very
- 1:34:47sophisticated state.
- 1:34:49So, when you take a look at the
- 1:34:50situation of Iran, let's not just talk
- 1:34:52about the bombing and everything,
- 1:34:54but the geopolitical development. Now,
- 1:34:55today there was a story, I don't know if
- 1:34:57it's true or not,
- 1:34:59that Iran is going to be asked to join
- 1:35:01this coalition. In other words, submit.
- 1:35:04Whether they do it or not, whether this
- 1:35:05is an actual offer or anything, I have
- 1:35:08no idea, but it was there.
- 1:35:10But this created a new structure in the
- 1:35:13Middle East, this alliance.
- 1:35:15A very different one with a very
- 1:35:17powerful country. Israel
- 1:35:20is terrified of
- 1:35:23Turkey. Because they know they don't
- 1:35:26>> It just bombed. [laughter]
- 1:35:27It just It just bombed me.
- 1:35:29>> Turkish officials in in Syria.
- 1:35:30>> My my Yes, and that was part of it.
- 1:35:34Because this is a country they cannot
- 1:35:36defeat.
- 1:35:37They've only fought countries along
- 1:35:39their borders.
- 1:35:40And they were able for since the
- 1:35:42founding of Israel
- 1:35:44to hold those borders.
- 1:35:47The Turkish army
- 1:35:49is
- 1:35:50three times as large as the Israeli
- 1:35:52army.
- 1:35:54And while I don't believe that the Turks
- 1:35:56really have any desire to fight them,
- 1:35:59these Israeli
- 1:36:02>> [snorts]
- 1:36:02>> shall we say society is built around
- 1:36:06a commitment to the belief that they're
- 1:36:08going to try to destroy us.
- 1:36:11There is a built-in paranoia. So, when
- 1:36:15this end you know, this problem ends a
- 1:36:18little bit,
- 1:36:20they bomb
- 1:36:21uh
- 1:36:23Syria.
- 1:36:24They then tell the American ambassador
- 1:36:26they didn't bomb Syria.
- 1:36:28Then they say,
- 1:36:30"Turkey is our greatest fear."
- 1:36:33Built into Israel
- 1:36:37by nature, by history is a paranoia. Who
- 1:36:40is my greatest enemy? I have one.
- 1:36:42Now they're facing for the first time an
- 1:36:45enemy that they cannot because of both
- 1:36:47geography and military capability
- 1:36:51defeat. All right?
- 1:36:53Now,
- 1:36:55when Runstedt was asked what to do after
- 1:36:57the Battle of the Bulge, he said, "Make
- 1:36:59peace, you fools."
- 1:37:01And this is the situation that Israel is
- 1:37:03in. It's an internal crisis. It has
- 1:37:06reached a point where its military
- 1:37:08capability is not enough.
- 1:37:10>> So, the reason I think the midterms are
- 1:37:13a decisive threshold
- 1:37:15>> agree.
- 1:37:16>> not just a minor threshold is
- 1:37:19it will determine whether the Democrats
- 1:37:22control Congress.
- 1:37:23If the Democrats control Congress, which
- 1:37:26is still an if, but we'll know in
- 1:37:27January,
- 1:37:28there is going to be two things that are
- 1:37:30going to happen.
- 1:37:32And we see this in the Democratic
- 1:37:33policies already.
- 1:37:35Number one is there'll be tremendous
- 1:37:37pressure to literally end the Iran war.
- 1:37:40So, we saw this in 1974 by Congress.
- 1:37:43Congress has not played much of a role
- 1:37:44in foreign policy. The last time it got
- 1:37:46involved was 74 with Vietnam to truly
- 1:37:49constrain the executive. There'll be a
- 1:37:52battle about this, of course, but number
- 1:37:54one is the Democrats wanting to shut
- 1:37:56down this, and that would stop it from
- 1:37:58becoming a forever war.
- 1:38:00One more one more point, and then I'll
- 1:38:01let you. The second point is they're
- 1:38:03going to want to constrain Israel.
- 1:38:05There's a huge push in the Democratic
- 1:38:08Party to shut down all of the Look at
- 1:38:11all the Democrats that are
- 1:38:14that were pro-Israel that are losing.
- 1:38:17>> [laughter]
- 1:38:17>> And they're losing because there's a
- 1:38:19huge movement inside of the Democratic
- 1:38:21Party
- 1:38:23to zero out the budgets to Israel. And
- 1:38:26that means that come January
- 1:38:30Israel's going to have to calibrate
- 1:38:32Iran Others are going to calibrate based
- 1:38:35on the results of whether the Democrats
- 1:38:37control Congress. Now, we don't know
- 1:38:40whether the Democrats will control
- 1:38:41Congress, but what I'm saying is it's
- 1:38:43too soon to truly project out beyond
- 1:38:46January because come January we'll know
- 1:38:49are we in a forever war or not. And by
- 1:38:51the way, if the Democrats, even though
- 1:38:53they control Congress, support the war,
- 1:38:56oh, yeah, we're in a forever war.
- 1:38:58>> So, which major Democratic leader has
- 1:39:01come out against the war and and which
- 1:39:03leader has said we must end this war
- 1:39:05right now? Which which leader?
- 1:39:07>> Oh, jeez, almost all of them. I mean, it
- 1:39:09just watch CNN. They come on all the
- 1:39:11time. So, what they are If you If you
- 1:39:13listen, Zhang, to the Democrat No, well,
- 1:39:16if you listen to the Democratic leaders,
- 1:39:18this has just been a mantra to end the
- 1:39:20Vietnam war I'm sorry, to end the the
- 1:39:22Iran war. And the real question is going
- 1:39:26to be, Zhang, whether or not, once they
- 1:39:29control, will they take responsibility
- 1:39:32for that? Because right now it's easy to
- 1:39:36run against the Iran war because gas
- 1:39:39prices going up, you know, bad mistakes
- 1:39:41by the the Trump administration, which
- 1:39:43they hate they hate anyway. Where it
- 1:39:46will become difficult will be once the
- 1:39:48Democrats
- 1:39:50assume power because if it turns out
- 1:39:53that the Democrats stop the war and Iran
- 1:39:56gets a nuclear weapon,
- 1:39:58think about that for the Democratic
- 1:39:59Party. That could bring the Republicans
- 1:40:01right back in in 2028. So, I think these
- 1:40:04are the real issues and that's why it's
- 1:40:06about not just what you claim you're
- 1:40:09going to do, but what you do when you're
- 1:40:10in power.
- 1:40:11>> So, so I must have missed the news, but
- 1:40:13can you name me one major Democratic
- 1:40:15leader whether whether it's Trump
- 1:40:16>> Hakeem Jeffries has was just on CNN, I
- 1:40:18think it was 3 days ago arguing that the
- 1:40:20war should end now.
- 1:40:22I just listened to the woman who just
- 1:40:24ran
- 1:40:25the progressive who just won the Senate
- 1:40:28for the Senate seat in the primary here
- 1:40:30on Ford. I was just on a
- 1:40:32a podcast with her the Joy Reid Show
- 1:40:34just 2 days ago talking about this issue
- 1:40:37and she was hugely uh uh against the
- 1:40:41against the war and and thought it was a
- 1:40:43total mistake and it should end. So, I
- 1:40:45mean those are at least two people right
- 1:40:47there.
- 1:40:47>> So, so did Hakeem Jeffries say that if
- 1:40:50the Democrats were to win the house in
- 1:40:53November, they would immediately try to
- 1:40:56restrict Trump's war powers and try to
- 1:40:58>> I haven't said anybody has gone that
- 1:41:00far. That's the next step. That's the
- 1:41:03real issue here and that's what I'm
- 1:41:05saying is you won't be able to know
- 1:41:08whether they'll do it until they're in
- 1:41:10power, Jang. And if they're in power and
- 1:41:13they support the war for fear that they
- 1:41:15will lose their political viability as
- 1:41:17Hillary Clinton was worried about with
- 1:41:19the Iraq war, then this will That's how
- 1:41:21you got a forever war. You get both
- 1:41:23parties in favor of the war because
- 1:41:25neither one will stop it. Now you have a
- 1:41:28forever war.
- 1:41:29>> But in this particular case, both the
- 1:41:31Republicans
- 1:41:33opposed the war because that's one of
- 1:41:35the
- 1:41:36bases on which he won the election was
- 1:41:38not to get into these forever wars.
- 1:41:41Democrats also are doing it. When you
- 1:41:43take a look at the poll numbers on this
- 1:41:45war,
- 1:41:46they're enormously unpopular.
- 1:41:49Congress tends to do what's popular.
- 1:41:52And [snorts] ending the war is popular
- 1:41:54not only in the Democrats but with the
- 1:41:56Republicans. This is the
- 1:41:58fundamental difference that I've never
- 1:42:00seen, which is that his own party feels
- 1:42:02betrayed.
- 1:42:03So, I think there's one of the things I
- 1:42:06think the Iranians are saying, let's
- 1:42:09wait. Let's wait to see if they come
- 1:42:12apart. The same way I'm talking about
- 1:42:14Iran having internal problems, we have
- 1:42:16enormous internal problems.
- 1:42:18I'm seeing the Iranians trying to put
- 1:42:21this off
- 1:42:22as long as possible and then try to make
- 1:42:24a deal
- 1:42:26at in September and or October before
- 1:42:30the elections.
- 1:42:31>> So fascinating that
- 1:42:32uh Trump's
- 1:42:36positioning and his desire to be seen as
- 1:42:39a a competent president and obviously
- 1:42:41the last couple of years of his legacy
- 1:42:43uh that is being used as a geopolitical
- 1:42:46tool. That's almost a weapon that other
- 1:42:49people can insert themselves into
- 1:42:51because they know that this is going to
- 1:42:52be it's a a point of weakness or it's a
- 1:42:55point of leverage that can be used to
- 1:42:57play with the incentives that the US has
- 1:43:02got. Would they want to push further? Do
- 1:43:03they want to pull back?
- 1:43:04>> I've seen and again, advised four White
- 1:43:07Houses 2001 to 2004, two Democrat, two
- 1:43:11two Republican.
- 1:43:13Legacy matters to let's call it the
- 1:43:16White House, if not the president. I
- 1:43:18also think the president, but let's just
- 1:43:20make it that legacy is beyond just
- 1:43:23getting the next win. Legacy is what
- 1:43:26you're remembered for. And I think this
- 1:43:30is what is important that we miss when
- 1:43:32we talk about presidents in the United
- 1:43:34States. We think, well, you can't run
- 1:43:36for re-election again, therefore you
- 1:43:38don't care anymore about anything. Uh
- 1:43:41no, I think what they what I see is even
- 1:43:45in their first term, they're thinking
- 1:43:46about their legacy going forward. And
- 1:43:50that legacy, there have only been 47
- 1:43:53presidents in our history. This is
- 1:43:55there's not that many presidents.
- 1:43:58>> sample size.
- 1:43:58>> So I really Well, it's not that. It's
- 1:44:00It's that they know they're one of 47 4
- 1:44:03or 48. It's the other way around,
- 1:44:04[clears throat] Chris. It's because it's
- 1:44:06a tiny club, their legacy is going to be
- 1:44:09with them after they're dead for 100
- 1:44:12years plus.
- 1:44:12>> But if he's so worried about his legacy,
- 1:44:15why did he attack Iran in the first
- 1:44:17place?
- 1:44:18>> I think again back to the modeling.
- 1:44:20Um I'm just going to keep going back to
- 1:44:22the modeling cuz I I made a prediction
- 1:44:24to my classes for 20 years in a row
- 1:44:28that once we bomb Fordow
- 1:44:30>> Uh but we Why?
- 1:44:31>> we would panic about Iran getting a
- 1:44:34nuclear weapon in a way we couldn't see,
- 1:44:36and we would get intel, whether it's
- 1:44:38Israel or somebody else, that was
- 1:44:40showing us they were getting
- 1:44:42intelligence, and we would try to
- 1:44:44resolve it through regime change. Not
- 1:44:47because regime change was magically
- 1:44:48thought to be a better strategy, but it
- 1:44:51was really the only way you could come
- 1:44:53up with even a half-plausible idea.
- 1:44:56>> question about why to do the bombing in
- 1:44:58the first place, though.
- 1:44:59>> So so so I
- 1:45:00>> Take a step back from that. Yeah. I I
- 1:45:02I want to present another theory, okay?
- 1:45:03Besides your modeling.
- 1:45:04>> No, please.
- 1:45:05>> Well, so 1996
- 1:45:07um is a clean break memo.
- 1:45:09>> Yes.
- 1:45:09>> Right? And you you probably know the
- 1:45:10people who wrote that, right?
- 1:45:12>> Very No, Paul Wolfowitz is very
- 1:45:14>> Paul Wolfowitz is from my department,
- 1:45:15Jenk.
- 1:45:16>> Okay. All right.
- 1:45:16>> 71 PhD, University of Chicago. So I know
- 1:45:19these people pretty well.
- 1:45:19>> So So just for some for for for some
- 1:45:21context
- 1:45:22>> So they get in the room. Thank you.
- 1:45:23>> Yeah, the clean break memo was a
- 1:45:25proposal to Benjamin Netanyahu. And the
- 1:45:28argument is that United that Israel
- 1:45:31under Netanyahu should withdraw from the
- 1:45:33peace law from the sorry from the from
- 1:45:35the Oslo peace accords because in order
- 1:45:39to assure peace in the Middle East,
- 1:45:41Israel had to be strong.
- 1:45:45Conduct regime change in Iraq and Syria.
- 1:45:48Also, Israel needed to be
- 1:45:50self-sufficient economically and
- 1:45:52militarily. It needed to basically stop
- 1:45:54being dependent on the United States.
- 1:45:56And if you want to resolve the
- 1:45:57Palestinian issue, then you beat the
- 1:45:58crap out of them rather than try to
- 1:46:00compromise and give them land. That
- 1:46:02would just make them more greedy.
- 1:46:03Instead, you
- 1:46:05you establish peace through strength.
- 1:46:08Though that those are the exact terms.
- 1:46:09Peace through strength. Okay? So that's
- 1:46:11the 1996 Clean Break memo. What is
- 1:46:14important is if you look at the Clean
- 1:46:16Break memo and you look at today, they
- 1:46:17basically implemented every single point
- 1:46:20of the Clean Break memo, right? Every
- 1:46:22single point. That's number one. Number
- 1:46:23two is what's interesting is the people
- 1:46:25who were responsible for the Clean Break
- 1:46:26memo,
- 1:46:27Richard Perle,
- 1:46:29Douglas Feith, went on to work in the
- 1:46:32Bush administration. And they were along
- 1:46:34with Paul Wolfowitz, your friend, the
- 1:46:35architects
- 1:46:36>> my friend.
- 1:46:37>> Okay, so I'm sorry. No, no, that's going
- 1:46:38too far.
- 1:46:38>> But the three of them, okay? The three
- 1:46:40of them in the Pentagon [laughter]
- 1:46:42were the architects of the Iraq War.
- 1:46:45Right? And then
- 1:46:47after 9/11, Wesley Clark appears on
- 1:46:49stage with Amy Goodman. And Amy
- 1:46:52Goodman's Amy Goodman is like, "What's
- 1:46:54the plan?" And Wesley Clark is like,
- 1:46:56"We're going to go after seven nations
- 1:46:58in five years." And these seven nations
- 1:46:59include Iraq,
- 1:47:02Syria, Libya,
- 1:47:05Lebanon,
- 1:47:06Sudan, Somalia. And there's one more,
- 1:47:08Iran.
- 1:47:10So if I'm just looking at it from like a
- 1:47:13like top-down um bird's-eye view, I
- 1:47:16would say that this was was always the
- 1:47:19plan
- 1:47:21ever since 1996, Break memo to attack
- 1:47:23Iran eventually because they've been
- 1:47:25saying this for the past
- 1:47:2830 years. And so
- 1:47:31it's not a good reason to attack Iran
- 1:47:34because that was always the plan.
- 1:47:35>> me first of all, number one, I I agree
- 1:47:37with your characterization of the
- 1:47:39Cleanbreak Cleanbreak plan. Number two,
- 1:47:41I agree it was a plan.
- 1:47:43What I see from 2005 on
- 1:47:47and I was working with the Bush
- 1:47:50administration about how to essentially
- 1:47:52calm down the Iraq war. So many, many
- 1:47:54interactions here with the Bush
- 1:47:56administration because
- 1:47:58I was warning before we did Iraq that we
- 1:48:00would touch off the largest suicide
- 1:48:01terrorist campaign of modern times.
- 1:48:04We did invade Iraq. We did touch off the
- 1:48:06largest suicide terrorist campaign of
- 1:48:07modern times. And who started my center
- 1:48:10at the University of Chicago, the
- 1:48:11Chicago Project used to be on suicide
- 1:48:14terrorism?
- 1:48:15It was actually the Bush administration.
- 1:48:18Think about that for a moment because
- 1:48:19suddenly somebody made a unique
- 1:48:22prediction. None of other terrorism
- 1:48:24expert was predicting that. And I gave
- 1:48:26it directly to Paul Wolfowitz here. He
- 1:48:29was did Iraq anyway. He touched it off
- 1:48:32anyway. And so now suddenly I'm engaging
- 1:48:35with with them.
- 1:48:37We never put an army in a certain
- 1:48:39African country. Think Somalia. That was
- 1:48:41a possibility. That did not happen.
- 1:48:43Certain things that did not happen also
- 1:48:46are important to note. So one of the
- 1:48:48things that happened during this period
- 1:48:50after the
- 1:48:52uh the Iraq war became a disaster is all
- 1:48:56that influence but Wolfowitz left, Feith
- 1:48:59left, Pearl left. And it's because it
- 1:49:03became widely understood what the real
- 1:49:06dangers were of going into Iran. Much I
- 1:49:09mean Iraq was already a problem that
- 1:49:11Iran is a much bigger I said the biggest
- 1:49:14challenge since Germany in World War II.
- 1:49:18This was widely understood at the time
- 1:49:21and is widely understood by the
- 1:49:23military. It's widely understood in both
- 1:49:26white Democrat and Republican White
- 1:49:28Houses. This is not a unique situation
- 1:49:32here. I think you really run into
- 1:49:35an issue with why did President Trump
- 1:49:38bomb Fordow? So, I've talked to the
- 1:49:40people from the administration who have
- 1:49:42left in detail about this and uh in May.
- 1:49:46I think you have to understand one
- 1:49:48thing. Which is although President Trump
- 1:49:52decided to reject Netanyahu in his first
- 1:49:54administration,
- 1:49:55President Trump has become his own
- 1:49:58national security adviser, his own
- 1:50:00secretary of defense, his own secretary
- 1:50:03of state. If you look at all the
- 1:50:05decisions that are happening, everybody
- 1:50:08else is essentially executing his
- 1:50:10policies and occasionally he'll get mad
- 1:50:13at them and blame them for something.
- 1:50:15But, he's not really following closely
- 1:50:19the advice of any of those people around
- 1:50:22him. I think what's happening is that
- 1:50:26our president our system gives the
- 1:50:29president in ordinate discretion when it
- 1:50:32comes to the use of force.
- 1:50:34>> You're saying that this was a personal
- 1:50:36bias and the whim.
- 1:50:37>> I think it was
- 1:50:38yes, largely so, but I would say it's
- 1:50:41because I would say that what you're
- 1:50:42seeing here is that the style of
- 1:50:46president what what it doesn't matter if
- 1:50:49he if he fires Pete Hegseth next week or
- 1:50:52he fires Scott Bessent next week, do we
- 1:50:54really think the style of the president
- 1:50:57is going to change? I think that we need
- 1:50:59to understand that we our system of
- 1:51:01government, we have given in ordinate
- 1:51:05power to the president. I'm not calling
- 1:51:07for a change of the constitution, but I
- 1:51:09am saying that that means if the
- 1:51:11president wakes up one day and uh uh
- 1:51:15and by the way Abraham there's famous
- 1:51:17Abraham Lincoln famous story in Doris
- 1:51:19Kearns Goodwin's of a team of rivals
- 1:51:21where Abraham Lincoln goes around the
- 1:51:23table ask the entire cabinet and and
- 1:51:25they all say no no no no no and they
- 1:51:27come to the and Lincoln's and and
- 1:51:29Lincoln says I and gentlemen the eyes
- 1:51:32have it.
- 1:51:33>> [laughter]
- 1:51:33>> This is what happened. What does Trump
- 1:51:36have against Iran?
- 1:51:38He can't even find Iran on a map. He
- 1:51:41I mean he can't.
- 1:51:42>> Well look I have I guarantee he cannot
- 1:51:43do it. Well look I think we've pushed we
- 1:51:46I I like to talk to people directly.
- 1:51:50I've never in this case
- 1:51:52everybody I've talked to who's been
- 1:51:55around this who've actually briefed the
- 1:51:57president on this they only go so far
- 1:52:00and willing to say why he did certain
- 1:52:02things and I'm saying it's because of
- 1:52:04the way he has chosen to make his
- 1:52:08decisions. There's not the process we're
- 1:52:10used to seeing here. So what that would
- 1:52:12mean is and I've never talked to
- 1:52:13President Trump is unless I could
- 1:52:16actually talk to Trump I won't go
- 1:52:17further than I've currently said because
- 1:52:20I do think that this is though how we
- 1:52:22got here and once he did Fordell
- 1:52:25I don't know that at all he understood
- 1:52:27the consequences but I think then he was
- 1:52:29sunk Jang because once he did that and
- 1:52:32he sees the satellite imagery I'm seeing
- 1:52:35in the civilian world and there's
- 1:52:36probably more he he knows if they
- 1:52:39develop if they test nukes on his watch
- 1:52:41man he's sunk for all of history.
- 1:52:43>> Jang what's what's your psychoanalysis
- 1:52:44of
- 1:52:45>> So so so let us look at his pattern of
- 1:52:47behavior in his both his first term and
- 1:52:50second term right? First time he comes
- 1:52:51to office he he he cancels the JCPOA
- 1:52:56which is the Iran nuclear deal under
- 1:52:57Obama right? He's like we're not doing
- 1:52:59this anymore guys. That's number one.
- 1:53:01Then he recognizes so then what what
- 1:53:05does is he um transfers the American
- 1:53:08Embassy from Tally Tel Aviv to
- 1:53:10Jerusalem. Which is one of the most
- 1:53:12provocative acts an American person has
- 1:53:13ever done in the Middle East. You don't
- 1:53:15You don't do that. Okay, that's number
- 1:53:17two. Number three is he recognizes
- 1:53:19Israel's control of the Golan Heights.
- 1:53:21Then the the most dramatic thing he does
- 1:53:23is in January 2020, he orders the
- 1:53:26assassination of General Qassem
- 1:53:28Soleimani, who was Iran's de facto
- 1:53:30ambassador in the Middle East. So, for
- 1:53:33those this seemed a logical extension of
- 1:53:36his actions. He is the most pro-Israel
- 1:53:39president the United States has ever
- 1:53:40had.
- 1:53:42Right? It seems like if you just look at
- 1:53:43the Clean Break memo of 1996 and you
- 1:53:46look at what what Trump is doing in
- 1:53:49um in the Middle East, it seems like he
- 1:53:51is trying to create the Greater Israel
- 1:53:52project. Did you Did you Sorry, do you
- 1:53:55know what the Greater Israel project is?
- 1:53:57Um right.
- 1:53:58So, the Greater Israel project is um
- 1:54:01the idea that um Israel should occupy
- 1:54:05all biblical lands or the lands that
- 1:54:08Yahweh, God, promised to Abraham. And
- 1:54:10these lands
- 1:54:12um extend from Egypt So, sorry, extend
- 1:54:14from the Nile in Egypt all the way to
- 1:54:17Euphrates in Iraq. So, if you look at
- 1:54:19the entire map of what the United States
- 1:54:22has been doing for the past 20 years,
- 1:54:23attacking Iraq, Libya, Syria,
- 1:54:27um and now this war which promised to
- 1:54:30engulf um Saudi Arabia, Turkey, Lebanon,
- 1:54:34Jordan, it seems like this is all to
- 1:54:38achieve the Greater Israel project.
- 1:54:40>> I I believe
- 1:54:41>> he was only interested in Israel, why
- 1:54:44Venezuela? Why Greenland? Why Canada?
- 1:54:48>> Well, he got to have something to do on
- 1:54:49the weekend.
- 1:54:50>> Well, what I'm just what I'm pointing
- 1:54:51out when I'm pointing So, I agree with
- 1:54:54you, that's the second most important
- 1:54:56reason, Israel. I'm not saying it
- 1:54:57doesn't matter at all. I think that what
- 1:54:59we need to see is um that first of all
- 1:55:02President Trump is really
- 1:55:04enthralled with the use of violence.
- 1:55:07Enthralled with the use of violence.
- 1:55:08He's part and parcel of violent
- 1:55:10populism. He's both a cause and a
- 1:55:12symptom of it at the same time. And it's
- 1:55:14not just in the term
- 1:55:16>> He did not start a war.
- 1:55:17>> Well
- 1:55:18>> He kept his promise. I will not start
- 1:55:19new wars.
- 1:55:20>> violent and after January 6th I think
- 1:55:24the process leading up to January 6th
- 1:55:26and then in chapter five the book I
- 1:55:28track I trace this out that in aftermath
- 1:55:31of January 6th this has radicalized
- 1:55:33MAGA. MAGA is not the same
- 1:55:37sort of group political movement
- 1:55:39>> policy, not just internal policy.
- 1:55:41>> once you have norm once political
- 1:55:43violence is normal for you at home it's
- 1:55:46a lot easier to use it abroad.
- 1:55:48>> He was in office from way before 2017.
- 1:55:49>> But what what I'm trying to tell you is
- 1:55:50that it it there's a there's a
- 1:55:52trajectory that's emerging. It's not
- 1:55:54that he comes in planning on you know
- 1:55:562017 to do January 6th. There is a a
- 1:55:59trajectory that emerges and I think that
- 1:56:02we're we need to see that yes Israel's
- 1:56:05playing a role, but there's a lot more
- 1:56:07that he is doing than
- 1:56:09>> the number one reason is this escalating
- 1:56:12acceptance
- 1:56:12>> normalization of political violence. It
- 1:56:14is the thing that is underneath him.
- 1:56:16>> there's something else to look at.
- 1:56:18I think there is also in Trump
- 1:56:22a fear
- 1:56:23of a 9/11. And there's in
- 1:56:26ways it should be, okay?
- 1:56:29So when you take a look at Iran
- 1:56:31and their relationship with al-Qaeda
- 1:56:34ruined, but [clears throat] still there
- 1:56:37something comes to mind at times, which
- 1:56:39is what would happen if instead of 9/11
- 1:56:42happening with aircraft
- 1:56:44a ship sailed in with a nuclear weapon
- 1:56:47just New York Harbor and detonated.
- 1:56:50So given the ideology of Iran
- 1:56:53given the fact that they have nuclear
- 1:56:55materials
- 1:56:57and so and the presence of al-Qaeda, we
- 1:56:59can say we can say all the various
- 1:57:01things we say about Trump in various
- 1:57:03ways and I agree with much of them.
- 1:57:05There's also a rational fear
- 1:57:07that could evolve. This is why his
- 1:57:11fundamental demand has been the nuclear
- 1:57:13weapons. Now,
- 1:57:15he attacked them first. He claimed it
- 1:57:17succeeded. It failed, okay?
- 1:57:21And we really don't know, I think, for
- 1:57:23sure where the nuclear capabilities are.
- 1:57:27We don't know how to destroy them and
- 1:57:28we're looking at that.
- 1:57:30But I think that underneath it, if you
- 1:57:33take a look at the question of what
- 1:57:34happens if there's a nuclear weapon,
- 1:57:37especially a secret one, developed in
- 1:57:40Iran,
- 1:57:41given the ideology, what might happen.
- 1:57:45And I think, in many ways,
- 1:57:47when you look at
- 1:57:50you know,
- 1:57:51how we will be viewed in history,
- 1:57:54if from that, if that were allowed to
- 1:57:56happen under his watch, would be also
- 1:57:58driving him.
- 1:57:59>> Do you think the JCPOA was working?
- 1:58:04>> It didn't fail.
- 1:58:06Whether it was working is another
- 1:58:07matter. The
- 1:58:09The fundamental thing was to
- 1:58:11denuclearize
- 1:58:13these areas.
- 1:58:14>> So, if Trump is most concerned about
- 1:58:16Iran developing nuclear weapon, why did
- 1:58:18we withdraw from the JCPOA?
- 1:58:21>> Because
- 1:58:22I he wanted more control, I think. I
- 1:58:25have no idea what is going through his
- 1:58:26mind. He wanted to have a direct
- 1:58:28American control
- 1:58:30on that. He thought that would be more
- 1:58:31effective. When you take a look at his
- 1:58:33practices, okay?
- 1:58:35He clearly doesn't go through alliance
- 1:58:37systems. He doesn't want to have
- 1:58:39dependence on others. He wants that
- 1:58:42power in his own hand. He can't have it.
- 1:58:44He does it as well. I don't I can't
- 1:58:47psychoanalyze him, but what I see
- 1:58:49happening is that
- 1:58:52and this is something I wrote on the
- 1:58:54Bruce Bogler
- 1:58:56the fundamental fear was the nuclear
- 1:58:589/11.
- 1:58:59And he keeps coming back to that.
- 1:59:00>> So if he was
- 1:59:02if he was afraid of a nuclear weapon, he
- 1:59:04should have avoided avoided three
- 1:59:05things, okay? One is withdraw from the
- 1:59:07JCPOA, second is do not assassinate the
- 1:59:09Ayatollah Khamenei cuz he
- 1:59:12he didn't he refused to ever use a
- 1:59:15nuclear weapon. And number three is do
- 1:59:17not attack Iran. And Trump did all three
- 1:59:20>> Yes, but that doesn't mean that the
- 1:59:22operational action
- 1:59:24didn't have a certain end in mind.
- 1:59:26So in other words,
- 1:59:28it was rational to be concerned about
- 1:59:30it.
- 1:59:31He proceeded irrationally in action.
- 1:59:34>> Yes, and I think the choice that is
- 1:59:36interesting here. So I agree by the way
- 1:59:39with with George that there's a a
- 1:59:42rational fear of a nuclear weapon with
- 1:59:44Iran. There is an an element of a
- 1:59:46rational fear that I think we can learn
- 1:59:48to live with it by the way. So I don't
- 1:59:50think it means that once you're
- 1:59:52concerned about an Iranian nuclear
- 1:59:54weapon, the solution is the force
- 1:59:57direction. But I would but but but yeah,
- 1:59:59I thought you might. But let me say that
- 2:00:01what we saw with the JCPOA was not just
- 2:00:04that Trump ripped up the JCPOA, but he
- 2:00:07replaced it with a maximum pressure
- 2:00:09campaign. So what President Trump has
- 2:00:11done very often in his career, and this
- 2:00:14is what I would say is and this is
- 2:00:15before January 6th, but he has there's a
- 2:00:18trajectory here, which is he is more and
- 2:00:20more comfortable with force domestically
- 2:00:24and internationally as he becomes as he
- 2:00:27goes through his presidencies, his two
- 2:00:29presidencies. And I that's what I mean
- 2:00:31by the normalization of it. It becomes
- 2:00:33more normal. You you
- 2:00:36uh because he didn't just rip it up the
- 2:00:38JCOP OA. He thought a pressure campaign
- 2:00:42would be better. And I think that he
- 2:00:45learned from that failure cuz it didn't
- 2:00:47stop Iran that he should have more
- 2:00:49pressure. A lot of others of us would
- 2:00:52say you should learn from that by seeing
- 2:00:54that the pressure campaign is making
- 2:00:56things worse. And I think that this is
- 2:00:59what we're we're seeing with our
- 2:01:00president. He finds a lot of comfort in
- 2:01:04the use of political violence.
- 2:01:07>> doesn't really understand
- 2:01:09power.
- 2:01:10He overestimates what he has. He went
- 2:01:13into that war expecting it to be readily
- 2:01:16done. He did not understand the Mosaic
- 2:01:18system. He did not care about responses.
- 2:01:22So, one of the problems have, I don't
- 2:01:25necessarily disagree with pressure as
- 2:01:28measure.
- 2:01:29He doesn't understand how to apply the
- 2:01:32pressure, nor does he have a clear
- 2:01:35understanding of just how much power he
- 2:01:38has.
- 2:01:38>> My question is, if this is just complete
- 2:01:40chaos, if this is just one guy behaving
- 2:01:42irrationally, why all events helping to
- 2:01:46create the Greater Israel project?
- 2:01:48That's That's my question.
- 2:01:49>> Well, and my challenge to you is that
- 2:01:51explain the Western Hemisphere cuz if
- 2:01:53you really want to build the Greater
- 2:01:56Israel project and you look out here
- 2:01:59over time, what you would like is you'd
- 2:02:02like President Trump, um, completely
- 2:02:04focused on the Middle East. And yet
- 2:02:06President Trump starts out with his
- 2:02:07tariffs. Again, very which is not quite
- 2:02:10violent, but again, very aggressive, uh,
- 2:02:12against our own allies. Uh, then he
- 2:02:14moves to actual military ideas with
- 2:02:18between one and and our allies, Canada.
- 2:02:20And so, what he's doing, Jang, is it's
- 2:02:22not that I just again, I want to be very
- 2:02:24clear. I think that Israel is the second
- 2:02:26most important driver here. This is This
- 2:02:29is where I I I just, um,
- 2:02:32I think also with the 2003 Iraq war, um,
- 2:02:35some of the people I most respect in the
- 2:02:36world believe the number one reason we
- 2:02:38did the Iraq war in 2003 was Israel. I
- 2:02:42think it's uh what happened after 9/11.
- 2:02:46I think 9/11 created enormous fear of
- 2:02:48Muslims in the United States, including
- 2:02:51with the people at the very top. It
- 2:02:53wasn't only Israel.
- 2:02:54>> Right. So, one thing uh that people
- 2:02:57don't appreciate appreciate about the
- 2:02:58greater Israel project is the major
- 2:03:00impediment to that thing is actually the
- 2:03:03US military. Because the US military
- 2:03:05provides balance of power in the Middle
- 2:03:08East. The US military provides uh
- 2:03:10protection to the GCC.
- 2:03:13So, if Israel were to become the
- 2:03:14dominant nation, it would need a way to
- 2:03:17remove the United States from the
- 2:03:18equation, right? And this Iran war is
- 2:03:21it's it it is a solution to this
- 2:03:23problem. Because if the if the Americans
- 2:03:25send in ground troops, which is part of
- 2:03:27the escalation trap
- 2:03:28>> Yeah, yeah, yeah.
- 2:03:29>> then there's then the United States
- 2:03:31would probably lose this war, and the
- 2:03:33United States would be forced to
- 2:03:34withdraw back into the Western
- 2:03:36Hemisphere.
- 2:03:36>> Hang on. Are you saying that Israel
- 2:03:38managed to convince Trump to go into
- 2:03:41Iran to do the bomb, which then gets
- 2:03:43into the escalation trap, which means
- 2:03:45that you need to put boots on the
- 2:03:46ground, which means that America
- 2:03:47ultimately loses, which means that
- 2:03:49America then has to withdraw to make
- 2:03:51room for Israel?
- 2:03:52>> I do not know if this was intentional. I
- 2:03:54don't know if this was [laughter]
- 2:03:55planned, but it's turning out this way.
- 2:03:58>> But if you're wrong, Jonathan
- 2:04:00>> If you're right, then and I I did a
- 2:04:02piece on my Professor Peeps Substack on
- 2:04:05this, what will happen if America truly,
- 2:04:08truly withdraws is a much smaller
- 2:04:11Israel.
- 2:04:12>> I think it really
- 2:04:13>> a nuclear Sparta. It doesn't quite get
- 2:04:15wiped off the map, but a much smaller
- 2:04:17>> is.
- 2:04:18>> Yeah, Israel is much weaker.
- 2:04:19>> What if Israel took over CENTCOM?
- 2:04:23What if all of America's military
- 2:04:26apparatus, okay, the planes, the troops,
- 2:04:28all then
- 2:04:30uh became under the control of Israel,
- 2:04:33which is happening right now, right?
- 2:04:34Because you have deep
- 2:04:36deep Israelification right now in the
- 2:04:38Middle East, which means that all these
- 2:04:40planes, all of all this weaponry is now
- 2:04:42forced to go to Israel because it's the
- 2:04:45only safe space for them.
- 2:04:46>> Under that hypothetical, I agree with
- 2:04:48you, but what you see with let's take
- 2:04:50the Democratic Party and about a third
- 2:04:52of the Republican Party is
- 2:04:54they're not having that. So, what you
- 2:04:56see is as that exactly your scenario by
- 2:04:59the way is one of the big reasons why
- 2:05:02there's been so much anger against
- 2:05:04Israel. So, there's two actors or two
- 2:05:07two actors that are getting blamed for
- 2:05:09this war in Iran, which is wrecking the
- 2:05:12world's economy. It's number one,
- 2:05:13President Trump, and number two, it's
- 2:05:15Israel. And both of those are in deep
- 2:05:18trouble as we go forward and that
- 2:05:20Israel's in trouble with the American
- 2:05:23public. Israel is losing the American
- 2:05:25public in droves.
- 2:05:26>> Israel is losing profoundly
- 2:05:30because
- 2:05:31Israel [clears throat] has always faced
- 2:05:32enemies that it could defeat. With this
- 2:05:34alliance that occurred, with Turkey
- 2:05:37evolving, Israel is much too weak to do
- 2:05:40this. Therefore, Israel has to change
- 2:05:42its fundamental strategy.
- 2:05:44Which to face the fact that it's a small
- 2:05:47country
- 2:05:49in an area that doesn't welcome it.
- 2:05:52Make peace. Try to find ways to enter
- 2:05:54it.
- 2:05:55So, when Israel takes a look at this
- 2:05:58alliance that was formed
- 2:05:59there are two ways to look at it. One,
- 2:06:01it it
- 2:06:02might restrain non-state actors.
- 2:06:05Other, it is a massive alliance that
- 2:06:07threatens Israel. So, at this point
- 2:06:10Israel is making very strange sounds
- 2:06:12like
- 2:06:13you know
- 2:06:14we're going to do something about
- 2:06:15Turkey. They can't do it. From This is a
- 2:06:18situation in which Israel has now found
- 2:06:20itself in
- 2:06:22where it does not have the military
- 2:06:24power
- 2:06:25to deal with the threat. So
- 2:06:28you look at this from two sides. One,
- 2:06:30yes, I think the Israelis manipulated
- 2:06:33Trump's thinking. That's was very clear.
- 2:06:37At the same time, Netanyahu has made
- 2:06:39massive dis-
- 2:06:41mistakes in overestimating his influence
- 2:06:44and his power.
- 2:06:45>> Do you think Congress will pass the
- 2:06:47NDAA, which will allow Israel to access
- 2:06:50data and intelligence from the US
- 2:06:52military?
- 2:06:53>> Not if the Democrats stay in Congress.
- 2:06:54>> imagine that happening.
- 2:06:55>> Not if the Democrats. And I don't even
- 2:06:57think if the Democrats don't, cuz I
- 2:06:59think that this is you And And you've
- 2:07:01been part of the reason that's uh your
- 2:07:03your attention bring this attention
- 2:07:05social media. I think it's been very
- 2:07:07important, Shang, because um I think
- 2:07:09that the more sunlight that falls on
- 2:07:12that, the much less likely this is to
- 2:07:14happen. Israel's grand strategic problem
- 2:07:18from the beginning and to this day is it
- 2:07:22is 7 million Jews surrounded by three
- 2:07:25>> I think.
- 2:07:26>> Well, 9 million 7 million
- 2:07:28>> total. Yeah, sorry. Yeah, you got it.
- 2:07:29>> 9 million who don't That's right. That's
- 2:07:31right. 7 million Jews
- 2:07:32>> is 71 miles wide at its widest point.
- 2:07:36>> but 7 million Jews surrounded by 3 to
- 2:07:39400 million Muslims, depending on how
- 2:07:42far you out you want to count with
- 2:07:44Pakistan.
- 2:07:45>> I I would
- 2:07:46>> So, that ratio, the only way you can
- 2:07:49have Israel the greater project is with
- 2:07:52American power. So, with If you have
- 2:07:55American power withdraw completely from
- 2:07:58the Middle East with the way Iran wants
- 2:08:00it to be and and that may end up being
- 2:08:02the outcome, uh then Israel's in deep
- 2:08:05trouble. If they can't stop Iran now and
- 2:08:08those missiles coming into Iran now with
- 2:08:10America's presence still there, what's
- 2:08:12going to happen a year or two from now
- 2:08:14when there's no military from America
- 2:08:17there? Israel Those 7 million are going
- 2:08:20to be on their own up against those
- 2:08:23three to 400 million. I don't think this
- 2:08:26means Israel, by the way, gets wiped off
- 2:08:28the face of the map, but I do think it
- 2:08:30becomes a at least a a set It'll be a
- 2:08:33second-tier power at best.
- 2:08:36>> Israel was successful in wars.
- 2:08:39It gave it an illusion
- 2:08:41of power.
- 2:08:42What is evolving now geopolitically, the
- 2:08:44Middle East,
- 2:08:46is terrifying to the Israelis,
- 2:08:49particularly with the rise of Turkey. At
- 2:08:51the same time, the United States now
- 2:08:52wants to withdraw from these various
- 2:08:55conflicts and even wants to reduce our
- 2:08:58its
- 2:09:00reliability on Israel, as well. And
- 2:09:02there's movements in the United States
- 2:09:03in the public and also in strategists in
- 2:09:06the
- 2:09:07The fundamental crisis in Israel is one
- 2:09:10that the Americans can't solve
- 2:09:13because the American public is not going
- 2:09:14to go that deeply into it.
- 2:09:17But there is the possibility of
- 2:09:18accommodation by Israel.
- 2:09:21Now, Netanyahu does not believe in
- 2:09:23accommodation. He believes he must use
- 2:09:25force in all cases.
- 2:09:28He can't.
- 2:09:30Now, he's had a peace treaty with Israel
- 2:09:32with Egypt for many years and it's held.
- 2:09:35The theory that Netanyahu has that no
- 2:09:37agreement with the Arabs will ever be
- 2:09:40honored.
- 2:09:41In this particular case, um he's wrong
- 2:09:44because the Egyptians did.
- 2:09:46Certainly, Saudi Arabia has nothing
- 2:09:49hostile to Israel. They've been quietly
- 2:09:51working with them on intelligence
- 2:09:52matters in a range of things, okay?
- 2:09:55Pakistan has no fundamental interest in
- 2:09:57Israel.
- 2:09:59And Turkey
- 2:10:01really has many bigger fish to fry as it
- 2:10:04evolves
- 2:10:05than Israel.
- 2:10:07At the same time, Israel does not know
- 2:10:09how not to call attention on itself.
- 2:10:12It somehow always gets into it because
- 2:10:15its grand strategy has been since its
- 2:10:17founding always attack, be stronger than
- 2:10:20the other guy, but they've reached a
- 2:10:22point where they're not and they won't
- 2:10:24be.
- 2:10:25So, the question is how does Israel
- 2:10:27evolve in this situation along with how
- 2:10:30does the American relationship with
- 2:10:32Israel evolve? Very deep questions for
- 2:10:34these areas, but I think you're
- 2:10:36absolutely right that Israel is at the
- 2:10:38heart of this as a problem.
- 2:10:41But at this point, it's profoundly
- 2:10:43weakening
- 2:10:44hour by hour almost.
- 2:10:46>> Why is it that Israel's got so much
- 2:10:48influence over the US?
- 2:10:49>> Money. It's It's money. It's AIPAC. This
- 2:10:52is in the Israel Lobby, John Mearsheimer
- 2:10:54and Stephen Walt's book. They lay it
- 2:10:55out.
- 2:10:56Um and it's fundamentally it's a very
- 2:10:59simple story, which is that although
- 2:11:02anybody can give money to elections,
- 2:11:04it's a it's a free and open process. It
- 2:11:07just turns out if you look at all the
- 2:11:09data
- 2:11:10uh that Jews as a group give more money
- 2:11:13than any other group per capita and as a
- 2:11:16group overall about a third of all money
- 2:11:18in elections is coming from Jewish
- 2:11:21Americans.
- 2:11:21>> different reason.
- 2:11:23During the Cold War,
- 2:11:25the Soviets
- 2:11:27had relationships with Syria, had
- 2:11:30relationships with Egypt, and so on.
- 2:11:33The Cold War was fought there as well.
- 2:11:36When the Arabs of attacked Israel in
- 2:11:391973,
- 2:11:41okay, it was with Soviet weapons, Soviet
- 2:11:44training, many cases Soviet tactics
- 2:11:47imposed.
- 2:11:50Israel at that point was one of the few
- 2:11:53countries that was pro-American.
- 2:11:55And it had a strategic point that it
- 2:11:57could undermine Egypt, it could
- 2:11:58undermine these things.
- 2:12:00So, remember ever since the Suez crisis,
- 2:12:04the Soviets had gotten involved in it.
- 2:12:07The Cold War is over now. These are not
- 2:12:09relevant to this thing.
- 2:12:10But it's not simply money or something.
- 2:12:12I Well, that was there, too.
- 2:12:15But that when the Cold War, you take a
- 2:12:17look at the situation
- 2:12:19that the Russians had and the amount of
- 2:12:21influence they had even in Lebanon and
- 2:12:23so on and so forth, this destabilizing
- 2:12:26it was deeply involved in the region and
- 2:12:29the United States didn't have very firm
- 2:12:30allies that it had Iran as an ally
- 2:12:33had Israel as an ally and they were
- 2:12:36players. So they were
- 2:12:38So that that situation is obsolete. The
- 2:12:41Soviets are now no longer there and so
- 2:12:45>> So to answer your question, why Israel
- 2:12:47has so much power, there's an alliance
- 2:12:49between Zionist capital,
- 2:12:51um
- 2:12:52um basically AIPAC as well as um
- 2:12:56Christian evangelicals, uh which is
- 2:12:58about a quarter of the population. Among
- 2:13:00these Christian evangelicals,
- 2:13:02um
- 2:13:03maybe a minority are Christian Zionists,
- 2:13:07uh which and they believe that um Israel
- 2:13:10is God's plan to save the world. So
- 2:13:13Israel has to has to be has to be
- 2:13:15protected at all costs, okay? So you
- 2:13:17have this massive alliance between um
- 2:13:20Zionist capital and then you have these
- 2:13:22fanatical Christian evangelicals.
- 2:13:25Um so one of the most powerful um
- 2:13:28organizations in the United States is
- 2:13:29something called Christian Christian
- 2:13:31United for Israel, run by someone named
- 2:13:33John Hagee. They have about 7 million
- 2:13:35members and all they care about is
- 2:13:36Israel. So if you're a congressman and
- 2:13:38you say anything bad about issue, you
- 2:13:39have like millions of people literally
- 2:13:41calling up every single day bitching at
- 2:13:43you. Like literally. Um these are the
- 2:13:46people who are funding uh the West Bank
- 2:13:48settlements settlers and they are the
- 2:13:50main cause of friction between
- 2:13:53uh
- 2:13:54the Israelis and the Arabs um because
- 2:13:57these West Bank settlers are just
- 2:14:00complete nutsos. They're they're they're
- 2:14:02they're crazy.
- 2:14:03Um so
- 2:14:05um you say that okay, in November the
- 2:14:08Israel lobby will will be taught a
- 2:14:09lesson, but if you got like this
- 2:14:12alliance in place, right? Between
- 2:14:14Zionist capital. And we're we're talking
- 2:14:15like a lot of money, right? They put in
- 2:14:17like $30 million to defeat Thomas Massie
- 2:14:19in Kentucky. They put in $70 million to
- 2:14:21defeat
- 2:14:23Abdul El-Sayed in in Michigan. That's a
- 2:14:25lot of money for a primary, right? They
- 2:14:27have almost have access to unlimited
- 2:14:28capital. Then you have someone like
- 2:14:31Larry and David Ellison who who's able
- 2:14:32to buy up CBS News and install Barry
- 2:14:35Weiss. So, this alliance is almost
- 2:14:38unprecedented in American politics.
- 2:14:41So, I don't see how just discuss with
- 2:14:44Israel can
- 2:14:47um
- 2:14:47um
- 2:14:49negate the power of of the Israel lobby.
- 2:14:52>> you're saying that um
- 2:14:53Jewish uh representatives running for
- 2:14:56Congress are losing left and left. And
- 2:14:58also the
- 2:14:59So, it's not just whether they are Jews
- 2:15:02running for the American Congress,
- 2:15:04whether they are the Christian Zionists
- 2:15:06running for the Congress. And um one of
- 2:15:08the big things that's um underneath that
- 2:15:11is that there is a large movement um
- 2:15:14among the right. So, most of the the
- 2:15:16evangelicals are on the right. They're
- 2:15:18they're not on the left. They're not
- 2:15:20Democrats. They're they're
- 2:15:21conservatives. Uh
- 2:15:23many of the folks supporting, say,
- 2:15:25Tucker Carlson, uh Joe Kent has run for
- 2:15:28office several times.
- 2:15:29Um they are uh folks that are extremely
- 2:15:33unhappy with the role of Israel in
- 2:15:36driving the foreign wars as they see it.
- 2:15:38Uh I see it as a secondary factor. They
- 2:15:40agree with you, Shine, that it's a
- 2:15:41number one factor. And what they're
- 2:15:43doing is they're voting the bums out.
- 2:15:45They're literally voting the bums out
- 2:15:48and replacing them with new people who
- 2:15:51they think um are going to zero out the
- 2:15:54money for Israel.
- 2:15:55>> And I think they're going to hold those
- 2:15:56people to account. They want that
- 2:15:57Israel's money to be zeroed out.
- 2:16:01>> Not realizing that the primary use of
- 2:16:04Israel is obsolete.
- 2:16:08Syria does not have Russian bases,
- 2:16:10Soviet bases.
- 2:16:11Egypt is not a Soviet power.
- 2:16:15Pot- potentially blocking the Suez Canal
- 2:16:17and so on and so forth.
- 2:16:19So, Israel was once a vital asset for
- 2:16:22the United States under the
- 2:16:24circumstances.
- 2:16:24>> long as Israel has money, it's a vital
- 2:16:26asset for the United States.
- 2:16:27>> No, the answer is
- 2:16:29a lot of countries have a far more money
- 2:16:31than Israel.
- 2:16:32>> Can they put it into American politics
- 2:16:33as easily as Israel can?
- 2:16:36>> If that was the only thing that was
- 2:16:37doing it,
- 2:16:39the uh that'd be true.
- 2:16:41On the other hand, if you go back to the
- 2:16:43Cold War and how desperate it was,
- 2:16:47the relationship between the US and
- 2:16:48Israel
- 2:16:50doesn't isn't based on money and nobody
- 2:16:52owns it because the Soviets were so
- 2:16:54powerful there.
- 2:16:55>> The the reason this is happening now,
- 2:16:58this anger against Israel, is not just
- 2:17:01it's another forever war, it's because
- 2:17:04this is the war that's hurting the
- 2:17:06American pocketbook in a serious way. If
- 2:17:10you go back since 1991,
- 2:17:13uh and you can even go back further, but
- 2:17:14if if listeners will just go back to
- 2:17:161991 and call up on Google and say,
- 2:17:19"Give me a chart of annual GDP growth or
- 2:17:22decline in the United States since 1991
- 2:17:25to today." They're going to see some
- 2:17:27great patterns. They're going to see
- 2:17:29number one, GDP growth goes down during
- 2:17:32the 19 2007, say, housing crisis, COVID,
- 2:17:36but it does not go down during the uh
- 2:17:38Gulf War in '91. It does not go down in
- 2:17:40Kosovo. It does not go down in 2003 when
- 2:17:43we invade Iraq. It does not go down
- 2:17:45during the forever wars in Iraq and
- 2:17:47Afghanistan. This war is different, and
- 2:17:50the reason it's different is not just
- 2:17:52it's another war in a long period of
- 2:17:55time. It's different because this is the
- 2:17:58war that Americans are feeling it in
- 2:18:00their pocketbook for real. So So if if
- 2:18:04it is a case that the American public is
- 2:18:06turning against Israel, and I certainly
- 2:18:07hope so, how did Thomas Massie, who was
- 2:18:11one of the um most ardent anti-Israel
- 2:18:14voices in Congress
- 2:18:15>> Trump went after him in a big way. You
- 2:18:17got the So Trump Trump targeted Massie
- 2:18:20with and he targeted Marjorie Taylor
- 2:18:22Greene, he targeted Massie. And when
- 2:18:25you're targeted by Trump, and we know
- 2:18:27this most from Marjorie Taylor Greene,
- 2:18:29this means assassination attempts
- 2:18:31against you and your kids and your
- 2:18:33families. So this isn't just a small uh
- 2:18:37this isn't just a political targeting
- 2:18:39we're talking about.
- 2:18:39>> So So let's summarize what you're
- 2:18:42saying. Number one is you believe money
- 2:18:44has a significant impact on American
- 2:18:46politics.
- 2:18:47>> Oh, yeah.
- 2:18:48>> And the Zionists have a lot of money to
- 2:18:50spend. Okay, that's number one. Number
- 2:18:52two is Trump is very powerful within the
- 2:18:56um Republican Party. So if he if he
- 2:18:58targets you, whether you be in torture
- 2:19:00>> Massie or uh MTG, um
- 2:19:04you will you will you will lose.
- 2:19:05>> Right, but I think Trump's influence is
- 2:19:07waning. I think it's it's up for grabs
- 2:19:09between now and January. That's what I'm
- 2:19:11saying, and it's what's driving the
- 2:19:12escalation trap. His desire to hold on
- 2:19:14to power is what's really driving the
- 2:19:16escalation trap between now and January.
- 2:19:19And and I am willing to I definitely
- 2:19:21agree it's an uphill battle because of
- 2:19:23all the money and all the uh sort of uh
- 2:19:25you know, institutionalization,
- 2:19:27as you were explaining it. That's all
- 2:19:29true. However, that can crumble within a
- 2:19:32period of just a couple of years. I
- 2:19:35don't think this idea that that it will
- 2:19:37take 5 or 10 years. In fact, by 2028,
- 2:19:41I'm expecting there will be a candidate
- 2:19:43for the Democratic presidency of the
- 2:19:45United States that will be avowedly
- 2:19:48anti-Zionist. Not just kind of on the
- 2:19:51edges and I think this is just
- 2:19:53>> what they'll almost run on.
- 2:19:55>> I think at least one person. Because
- 2:19:56yes, almost run on, because somebody's
- 2:19:59going to be blamed for all the wreckage
- 2:20:03of this Iran war. And who are you going
- 2:20:06to blame?
- 2:20:07>> you just blame Trump?
- 2:20:08>> Because Trump will already be toast by
- 2:20:11that point. You're going to this isn't
- 2:20:13this this wreckage is going to go on for
- 2:20:16a while, Chris.
- 2:20:16>> an you need an active candidate that you
- 2:20:18can sell.
- 2:20:19>> we don't we're not going to be done
- 2:20:20blaming people because you know, Iran
- 2:20:23>> Iran war is one of the biggest messes in
- 2:20:26modern history.
- 2:20:27>> It's the biggest mess it's the biggest
- 2:20:29mess since we have had in our country
- 2:20:31since since since really all the go back
- 2:20:35to all the way World War I. There's no
- 2:20:37bigger
- 2:20:37>> Biggest mess in 100 years.
- 2:20:38>> Yes, not because of the casualties. So
- 2:20:41we we're used to
- 2:20:42>> basically been at least on
- 2:20:43>> It's the economic consequences that are
- 2:20:46so big and as you're hearing and I agree
- 2:20:49with the Pizzy economic analysis here.
- 2:20:51He's talking about massive economic
- 2:20:54>> of the world
- 2:20:55>> on me. Oh my gosh, it's massive and I I
- 2:20:58I hope he's wrong. I mean, this is where
- 2:20:59I'm predicting the you're predicting the
- 2:21:01other and [laughter] I I think we each
- 2:21:03hope the other is not quite right, but I
- 2:21:05am really concerned with his analysis
- 2:21:08because I can't chip away. I brought
- 2:21:10Jeff Curry on my Substack to do these
- 2:21:13you know, sort of like what you do here
- 2:21:15here because I think he's just an
- 2:21:17amazing economist and so forth. He's
- 2:21:19right there. I mean,
- 2:21:21so he's right with him.
- 2:21:22>> Can Can you Can I like to say
- 2:21:25I agree.
- 2:21:27This will be the biggest crisis if it
- 2:21:30doesn't end.
- 2:21:32If it ends, it'll become like those
- 2:21:34other wars that we've had in the past
- 2:21:36and it goes on.
- 2:21:37The fundamental question is
- 2:21:40how does it end? How could it end and so
- 2:21:43and so forth?
- 2:21:46We don't understand I don't understand
- 2:21:48fully the nature of political systems in
- 2:21:52Russia
- 2:21:53or in Iran and how they continue the
- 2:21:55wars.
- 2:21:56So, before we're ready to say this is
- 2:21:59the biggest disaster, I would say, yes,
- 2:22:01if it continues, it will certainly be
- 2:22:03that.
- 2:22:04So far, it has not created the kind of
- 2:22:07crisis in the United States, for
- 2:22:09example, that Vietnam did, by far.
- 2:22:13So, it's a question of how does this
- 2:22:15end? And it's very
- 2:22:16>> would it have to go on for? If it goes
- 2:22:18on for another year, would you say it's
- 2:22:19the biggest crisis?
- 2:22:20>> I I have no way to see it
- 2:22:23because I don't know the consequences,
- 2:22:24nor do I know how to foretell the
- 2:22:26thought or what will happen in the
- 2:22:28Straits of Hormuz and so on. So, if they
- 2:22:30were in the Straits of Hormuz and so on,
- 2:22:32if they were secured and the war went
- 2:22:34on, it might have one path, and this is
- 2:22:37another path.
- 2:22:38>> But Trump, don't you see, George, that
- 2:22:39Trump's effort to end the war quickly
- 2:22:42with a victory for Trump is what is
- 2:22:45likely to create the Pyrrhic victory
- 2:22:47that's going to go on and on?
- 2:22:49>> The answer is, I probably agree with
- 2:22:52you, but I'm not certain because I'm not
- 2:22:55certain about how Iran is evolving.
- 2:22:59So, I agree with you certainly that if
- 2:23:02this war continues, the consequences
- 2:23:05will be massive.
- 2:23:07I also agree with you that Trump will
- 2:23:08have a great deal of difficulty ending
- 2:23:11it on his own terms.
- 2:23:13But there's a variable there that we
- 2:23:15have to take seriously,
- 2:23:17the internal capabilities of Iran.
- 2:23:18>> to put some probabilities between now
- 2:23:22and November, which is what, 75 days? I
- 2:23:24think between now and November to expect
- 2:23:27Iran to implode, which is possible. I
- 2:23:30wouldn't I would say possible, but I
- 2:23:32wouldn't even give it a 10% chance
- 2:23:34between now and November.
- 2:23:36>> I think they're using the election to
- 2:23:38try to force Trump into a position that
- 2:23:40he has to end it
- 2:23:42even by making massive concessions.
- 2:23:44>> We we agree. There we agree. The
- 2:23:46question
- 2:23:46>> What's the likelihood of Trump
- 2:23:47voluntarily ending it?
- 2:23:49>> Well, I think this it without more force
- 2:23:52All right.
- 2:23:53>> 0%
- 2:23:53>> 0% Yeah, I think that what you're seeing
- 2:23:55is the opposite. He He is more likely to
- 2:23:58use force or and it's starting with
- 2:24:01economic force to get a symbolic victory
- 2:24:04and I don't think Iran is going to play
- 2:24:06their part. Iran is just not willing to
- 2:24:09give him the victory that he can Yeah,
- 2:24:10they're giving him the middle finger.
- 2:24:12>> In the same way that we say
- 2:24:15Trump doesn't have the power to do these
- 2:24:16things, we have to take a look at the
- 2:24:18power of Iran as well.
- 2:24:20So,
- 2:24:21one of the things that Trump wants is to
- 2:24:23end the war and not be a crippled
- 2:24:26president above all else.
- 2:24:28>> Yep.
- 2:24:30>> I Iranians seem to be operating trying
- 2:24:33to push it out. Now,
- 2:24:35come October, he can't
- 2:24:38the president cannot make a deal.
- 2:24:40That'll
- 2:24:41They're trying to force him into a
- 2:24:43position negotiation and they're
- 2:24:44succeeding because he understands he's
- 2:24:47going to lose power if he continues
- 2:24:49this.
- 2:24:50So, now we ask the question
- 2:24:52psychologically that I can't answer.
- 2:24:53Does Trump care more about remaining
- 2:24:56powerful as president
- 2:24:59or more about beating the Iranians
- 2:25:01because he started the war and he wanted
- 2:25:02to be successful. I have no idea which
- 2:25:04way it goes.
- 2:25:05But, the Iranians I think are
- 2:25:07sophisticated
- 2:25:08and are using it
- 2:25:10and using the election as a bargaining
- 2:25:13chip.
- 2:25:14>> If Trump wants to win this war and bring
- 2:25:18world peace and prosperity,
- 2:25:20he he needs to do two things, okay? If
- 2:25:22he does these two things, I guarantee
- 2:25:23you this war will this war will end. The
- 2:25:25United States will come up on top. And
- 2:25:27these two things are: one, give $2
- 2:25:29trillion to Iran.
- 2:25:31$2 trillion in Iran.
- 2:25:32>> Two Excuse me.
- 2:25:33>> $2 trillion in Iran. The United States
- 2:25:36is $42 trillion in debt. Give $2
- 2:25:37trillion $2 trillion to Iran. Not a big
- 2:25:39deal. The second thing is
- 2:25:42control Israel. embargo Israel. Saying
- 2:25:44like if you misbehave, we will cut off
- 2:25:46arms to you guys and will no longer
- 2:25:49support you, right? So withdraw from
- 2:25:51Lebanon, stop the seven wars you're
- 2:25:54fighting right now,
- 2:25:56um come to peace with the Palestinians.
- 2:25:58So if he does these these these two
- 2:26:00things, he will he will be remembered as
- 2:26:01the greatest president in US history.
- 2:26:04>> you think he would have been doing?
- 2:26:04>> no, no, no.
- 2:26:05>> 0%
- 2:26:05>> No, no, no, no. First [laughter] of all
- 2:26:07First of all, I I think so so I think
- 2:26:10that the problem with the plan First of
- 2:26:13all, I I think that um containing Israel
- 2:26:17is becoming uh more and more part of
- 2:26:19President Trump's repertoire. He's not
- 2:26:21doing as much as I think he should be,
- 2:26:22but it's become The bigger part is your
- 2:26:24first point. The key problem President
- 2:26:28Trump faces is he's trying to end this
- 2:26:31conflict between now and the midterms or
- 2:26:34now and say January, but really now in
- 2:26:36the midterms. And if he were to give $2
- 2:26:39trillion, what would happen is Iran
- 2:26:42would say, "Sure, we also want you to
- 2:26:44pull all your forces out." Fine. Trump
- 2:26:47pulls all the forces out
- 2:26:48>> It's already happened.
- 2:26:49>> No, hold it. Hold it. And $2 trillion.
- 2:26:52And what then is Iran going to do? It's
- 2:26:54going to likely topple the governments
- 2:26:57in the Gulf states. It's not going to
- 2:27:00sit back and say, "Oh, sure."
- 2:27:03>> free reign because there's no oversight.
- 2:27:04>> a power vacuum.
- 2:27:05>> Yeah, yeah.
- 2:27:06>> What is created what's been created now,
- 2:27:09and this would make it even worse, is a
- 2:27:11power vacuum where it used to be America
- 2:27:13preeminent, Israel on the rise, Iran
- 2:27:16declining. Well, now the power vacuum is
- 2:27:18because this is changing. And what's
- 2:27:20going to fill that power vacuum is
- 2:27:23critical for the future. Iran, if under
- 2:27:26your plan, they will fill the vacuum for
- 2:27:29Iran, and this will wreck Trump's
- 2:27:32future. This is They It's not just Trump
- 2:27:34won't viscerally do it. This is just
- 2:27:37going to wreck Trump's future.
- 2:27:39>> did not say give Iran two two trillion
- 2:27:42dollars of gold. I said give them two
- 2:27:43trillion dollars, two trillion US
- 2:27:45dollars. Which means that
- 2:27:47>> going to be worthless anyway. You're
- 2:27:49just
- 2:27:49>> Well, yeah, that's the point. [laughter]
- 2:27:50If you want the two trillion dollars
- 2:27:51deal.
- 2:27:52>> Oh, you want to give them a sucker deal.
- 2:27:53>> If you want the two trillion dollars,
- 2:27:54okay? You need to participate in the
- 2:27:57global economy. You need to make sure
- 2:27:58the Middle East is able to send oil to
- 2:28:02East Asia.
- 2:28:03>> Well, now this is a version of J.D.
- 2:28:04Vance's idea of pay for performance. And
- 2:28:07as I argued before when the MOU was
- 2:28:09coming up, I Vance's whole approach to
- 2:28:11this as a business deal, I think was
- 2:28:13completely misguided. What Iran is doing
- 2:28:15is not a business deal, pay for
- 2:28:17performance like a like playing a
- 2:28:18football player. What what they want is
- 2:28:20power. Power is what's at issue. So,
- 2:28:24that's why I'm describing this there's a
- 2:28:25power vacuum, who's going to fill the
- 2:28:27vacuum. It's not about the money per se,
- 2:28:30it's about power because in
- 2:28:33international politics that's what
- 2:28:35determines outcomes.
- 2:28:37>> 20 years ago, um there was a philosophy
- 2:28:40in Washington called neoliberalism. I'm
- 2:28:42not I'm not sure if it's still around,
- 2:28:43but the idea was
- 2:28:44>> fast.
- 2:28:45>> Well, the idea was that trade would
- 2:28:46promote peace, right? So, if you wanted
- 2:28:48peace in Middle East, you just traded
- 2:28:50with Iran. Iran has a lot of oil, you
- 2:28:52let them sell their oil and and then you
- 2:28:54have peace.
- 2:28:55>> Yeah.
- 2:28:56>> Is there anything wrong with that idea?
- 2:28:58>> There's nothing inherently wrong with it
- 2:29:00as long as you had a big protector like
- 2:29:03uh
- 2:29:03the United States that could enforce the
- 2:29:05stability on which that deal rested.
- 2:29:09That And this is your point about how
- 2:29:10globalization is coming unglued. So, uh
- 2:29:13I agree. I wrote a piece in Foreign
- 2:29:15Affairs laying out that what's happening
- 2:29:17uh with the Iran war is America as
- 2:29:21protector of the global rules of power
- 2:29:24meaning stability for commerce is simply
- 2:29:28coming unglued. So, it's not just here
- 2:29:30in the Middle East, it's going to be
- 2:29:32around the world. And what uh in '91,
- 2:29:35when America won this stunning victory
- 2:29:37in the Middle East, it wasn't just
- 2:29:39confidence that America could police the
- 2:29:41sea lanes in the Middle East, there was
- 2:29:43confidence America could police the sea
- 2:29:46lanes globally. That's why trade went
- 2:29:48from 38% of world product to 62% of
- 2:29:52world product. Think about that. Because
- 2:29:54it became cheaper to trade. You didn't
- 2:29:56have to worry about instability as much.
- 2:29:59Now, instability is back. What does that
- 2:30:03mean? Trade is more expensive, more
- 2:30:05risky, insurance rates. And what does
- 2:30:07that mean? Anything that becomes more
- 2:30:09expensive, you get less of it.
- 2:30:11>> think Trump's really serious about
- 2:30:12pulling out of NATO?
- 2:30:14>> Oh, I don't think it even I I think
- 2:30:16NATO's already dead in terms of the key
- 2:30:19element of NATO, Chris.
- 2:30:20>> it not symbolic to do that?
- 2:30:22>> It's not about that. NATO at its core is
- 2:30:25not just a political alliance. What's in
- 2:30:28Article 5? Is that once Article 5 is
- 2:30:31declared, a US general, there's no other
- 2:30:35decision, it's a US general, Saceur, who
- 2:30:38commands all the NATO troops, not just
- 2:30:41US troops.
- 2:30:42All the NATO troops, the British troops,
- 2:30:45the German troops, France not in NATO
- 2:30:47for this reason. And that is what NATO
- 2:30:50is. NATO is a unified It's It's a
- 2:30:53war-fighting unified alliance where you
- 2:30:56decide in advance the Americans call the
- 2:31:00shots for everybody.
- 2:31:01>> Mhm.
- 2:31:02>> Who's going to be in Europe is going to
- 2:31:04after what they've been through, who's
- 2:31:06going to let America run British troops?
- 2:31:09>> But you should also remember that the
- 2:31:10Americans don't want to be exposed
- 2:31:12there.
- 2:31:13Always in when you're looking at Trump,
- 2:31:16okay?
- 2:31:17And he was serious about these forever
- 2:31:19wars that he clumsily, stupidly got
- 2:31:22involved in one is true. But he
- 2:31:25hit out of a fundamental principle of
- 2:31:28the United States, we did not want to be
- 2:31:31involved in these wars, these endless
- 2:31:33wars that we lost. It never helped.
- 2:31:35>> There's actually a much simpler reason.
- 2:31:37Trump really hates the Europeans. He
- 2:31:39hates the Europeans much more than he
- 2:31:40hates the Iranians. He blames I'm
- 2:31:42serious. He blames the Europeans for his
- 2:31:442020 20 election loss. He thinks that
- 2:31:47Obama conspired with the Europeans to
- 2:31:49defeat him. That's That's why he went
- 2:31:51out of NATO.
- 2:31:51>> Mhm. I I I'd be doing a patriotic
- 2:31:53disservice if I didn't bring it up. Is
- 2:31:55the UK ever seriously going to be
- 2:31:57considered in discussions of world
- 2:31:59powers moving forward again?
- 2:32:00>> Well, if you So, I look at percentages
- 2:32:03of a country's world product compared to
- 2:32:05world product. If you look at the UK in
- 2:32:071990, that was around 6 to 6 and 1/2% of
- 2:32:11world GDP. What is it today? Just under
- 2:32:144%. So, what's happened since 1990? So,
- 2:32:18again, I track power with some key
- 2:32:20metrics that we can observe.
- 2:32:22And in 1990, America was 26% of world's
- 2:32:26GDP. China was 2%.
- 2:32:28>> Wow.
- 2:32:29>> and the Europeans varied from about 5 to
- 2:32:327%. Germany the highest. You look today
- 2:32:36and America's flat at 26. China's up
- 2:32:39from 2 to 17. And what's happened to all
- 2:32:42those Europeans? They're down by a third
- 2:32:45or more. Who's the sucker here? So,
- 2:32:48people say we've been Uncle So, this is
- 2:32:50my one of my complaints against uh this
- 2:32:52argument that America's Uncle Sucker.
- 2:32:55No, we played the Europeans here, not
- 2:32:58the other way around. And Japan, so this
- 2:33:00is why I don't worry about Japan was um
- 2:33:03over 10% of world's GDP at that point.
- 2:33:07Where are they today? 4%.
- 2:33:104%. So, if you just This is all World
- 2:33:13Bank numbers. People listening can go
- 2:33:14and Google it. You will see that we have
- 2:33:18been inordinate inordinately privileged
- 2:33:21by this period called the Cold War,
- 2:33:24which this war
- 2:33:26is ending. At the expense of other
- 2:33:28countries.
- 2:33:29>> One of the things you should point out,
- 2:33:30however,
- 2:33:31is that Japan responded by massively
- 2:33:34increasing its military power. So, it
- 2:33:36did not simply look at us
- 2:33:39at the United States and say, "Where are
- 2:33:40you going?"
- 2:33:42It took action, and China now worries a
- 2:33:45great deal about Japan.
- 2:33:47The Europeans thought it was an moral
- 2:33:50act, improper,
- 2:33:52to want to pull back and depend on them.
- 2:33:57The American point of view was the EU is
- 2:34:00larger than China economically. There is
- 2:34:02no possible reason
- 2:34:04why we should be the primary defender of
- 2:34:07Europe. That was a fundamental reason
- 2:34:10for many years. But, why now?
- 2:34:12So, I don't think this should be put
- 2:34:13into the Trump load. I think with or
- 2:34:16without Trump,
- 2:34:17this questioning of whether or not we
- 2:34:22should remain exposed
- 2:34:24in NATO and what NATO should evolve into
- 2:34:27would have been put on the table by any
- 2:34:30president at this point.
- 2:34:32The China example is very much what
- 2:34:36Europe should have done.
- 2:34:37We pulled back from that. The Japanese
- 2:34:41created a much
- 2:34:44>> [snorts]
- 2:34:44>> is creating a much greater force along
- 2:34:46with the Australians,
- 2:34:48and along with the Vietnamese who are
- 2:34:49now involved in that, too. So, many
- 2:34:51things are happening.
- 2:34:53So, I think there are limits to what we
- 2:34:55can blame Trump for.
- 2:34:56>> We mentioned this earlier on.
- 2:34:58>> Well, I wasn't really blaming Trump.
- 2:34:59That needs to be clear. I was just
- 2:35:01showing the hole in the argument.
- 2:35:02>> I understand that. I'm simply saying
- 2:35:04that
- 2:35:05there is a very reasonable
- 2:35:07redefinition of Europe after
- 2:35:11Ukraine
- 2:35:12defeated, essentially, Russia.
- 2:35:14>> We uh Uh, we mentioned this earlier on,
- 2:35:16changing demographics, specifically in
- 2:35:18China, but this is happening globally.
- 2:35:19Looks like global population is going to
- 2:35:21peak
- 2:35:222100, something like that. Maybe we'll
- 2:35:24>> And wait, decline is happening not just
- 2:35:26in the United States, but in Europe as
- 2:35:28well. This will also
- 2:35:29>> of 10 billion, maybe, and then it's
- 2:35:32going to do this, unless there's some
- 2:35:34intervention that we can't yet foresee.
- 2:35:36When it comes to you guys planning out
- 2:35:39how you think about the future
- 2:35:40geopolitically,
- 2:35:42how much of a
- 2:35:44causal ball is the potential changing
- 2:35:47demographics? Obviously, we've got AI
- 2:35:49and robotics and automation coming in at
- 2:35:51the same time, but what it seems like
- 2:35:53China's doing is basically trying to
- 2:35:55speedrun
- 2:35:57using humans to build robots so that the
- 2:35:59robots can replace the humans once the
- 2:36:00humans have off. What How do you
- 2:36:03think about global population decline
- 2:36:05playing into your models moving forward?
- 2:36:07>> So, this war in the Middle East,
- 2:36:10people don't really appreciate the
- 2:36:13geopolitical consequences. So, right
- 2:36:15now, we're about at 8 billion people,
- 2:36:17but if you talk to economists, they'll
- 2:36:19tell you that the Earth by itself can
- 2:36:21only support about 2 billion people. The
- 2:36:23The way we get around this is with
- 2:36:24fertilizer, right? So, the Middle East
- 2:36:26is important not just because it
- 2:36:27provides cheap energy, but also provides
- 2:36:29a lot of fertilizer
- 2:36:31to the world. I can't remember the exact
- 2:36:33number, maybe a quarter to a third of
- 2:36:35the world's fertilizer. So, if a quarter
- 2:36:37to a third of the world's fertilizer
- 2:36:39goes offline for a year, then you're
- 2:36:42going to have millions of people starve
- 2:36:44to death. Um, so there's no way we're
- 2:36:46we're we're we'll reach 9 billion
- 2:36:48people. You will see massive starvation
- 2:36:50throughout Africa at some point.
- 2:36:52>> you think this is going to happen? You
- 2:36:53don't think
- 2:36:54>> Oh, oh, oh, it I I think it's baked in
- 2:36:55already.
- 2:36:56>> So, I I agree, maybe for slightly
- 2:36:58different angle on this, which is So, I
- 2:37:02think about power, balance of power.
- 2:37:04You're hearing me come at everything
- 2:37:06from a balance of power perspective.
- 2:37:08That's why I sometimes agree, disagree
- 2:37:09with the other. But, from the balance of
- 2:37:12power, what's happening? America was
- 2:37:14preeminent from 1991
- 2:37:17until this war.
- 2:37:18America's being knocked back because for
- 2:37:21the first time since '91, a state beat
- 2:37:25America. Just think about that. And
- 2:37:27everybody's learning that lesson that
- 2:37:29America can be beaten.
- 2:37:32Well, that means America's global
- 2:37:34influence, that we call it the world
- 2:37:36empire, you can call it American
- 2:37:37hegemony, this is now fading fast.
- 2:37:41What's going to replace it? We could say
- 2:37:43it's multipolarity. I think it's going
- 2:37:45to be more fragmented than that. I think
- 2:37:47you're going to see you might even call
- 2:37:49it a emerging anarchy that's going to
- 2:37:52occur. And under those conditions here,
- 2:37:55this is because of the states that used
- 2:37:58to be under America's protection,
- 2:38:01they're not under America's protection
- 2:38:03before you're talking we're talking
- 2:38:04about Japan building force. And notice
- 2:38:06we're not saying Japan getting America
- 2:38:08to come and help it, we're talking about
- 2:38:09Japan on its own. Many states around the
- 2:38:13around the world are thinking this way.
- 2:38:15That's what I mean by an emerging
- 2:38:17anarchy. It's not really quite a
- 2:38:18multipolar world, it's more fragmented
- 2:38:21than that.
- 2:38:22>> who would be the poles or who would be
- 2:38:23>> It'll be it'll be a center
- 2:38:25US and China
- 2:38:27have aligning interests
- 2:38:28>> fundamentally.
- 2:38:30And we are seeing that diplomatic
- 2:38:32process playing out. I think it will
- 2:38:35succeed with an understanding.
- 2:38:37>> Okay.
- 2:38:38>> But at the same time, China is not the
- 2:38:41Soviet Union. It doesn't occupy
- 2:38:43countries.
- 2:38:44It uses economic influence in those
- 2:38:46countries, investment, and so on and so
- 2:38:48forth. So, it's a very different
- 2:38:50country, not too different from the
- 2:38:52United States in the way it operates as
- 2:38:54well.
- 2:38:55Although the US ops
- 2:38:56The US actually operates with more
- 2:38:59military power.
- 2:39:00>> Okay.
- 2:39:01>> But in this emerging anarchy, you will
- 2:39:03see greater incentives for nuclear
- 2:39:05proliferation, for example. with greater
- 2:39:08incentive and you already saw that with
- 2:39:10Saudi Iran, Saudi Arabia, you will see
- 2:39:13this
- 2:39:14these incentives start to spread as a
- 2:39:16result of this war. What will also
- 2:39:19happen as a result of the incentives for
- 2:39:21proliferation is concerns about
- 2:39:24preventive wars, preemptive wars to stop
- 2:39:27that. So, we've worried about for some
- 2:39:30time Poland might start to think about
- 2:39:33going nuclear. People are already
- 2:39:35noticing Putin has been focusing on
- 2:39:38Poland. Why would Putin focus on Poland?
- 2:39:41>> I'm going to Poland next week to meet
- 2:39:43the president.
- 2:39:44>> There you go.
- 2:39:44>> Ask him if he's got any nukes.
- 2:39:46>> [laughter]
- 2:39:46>> The answer is
- 2:39:48Poland is the eastern front of Europe.
- 2:39:52It cannot trust the western front
- 2:39:54because it's the alliance of the
- 2:39:56willing, okay? And with that statement,
- 2:39:59that shows it.
- 2:40:01Poland is evolving dramatically and it
- 2:40:04has the capability and is discussing
- 2:40:06becoming a nuclear power.
- 2:40:07>> There you go.
- 2:40:08>> So, the question of because when I talk
- 2:40:10to them, I constantly hear back,
- 2:40:13you know,
- 2:40:15we're not counting on the United States.
- 2:40:17We have 10,000 troops there, but we're
- 2:40:19not counting on the United States.
- 2:40:21So, it's evolving dramatically
- 2:40:23and it's going to be looking at that.
- 2:40:25So, I agree with you
- 2:40:27that the need to have nuclear weapons,
- 2:40:30okay, or the supposed need to have
- 2:40:31nuclear weapons will create But at the
- 2:40:34same time, I see the economic alliance
- 2:40:38between the United States and China.
- 2:40:41And I think that's going to happen
- 2:40:44is going to create a strange poll
- 2:40:47between the two.
- 2:40:49Because they have very similar
- 2:40:50interests.
- 2:40:51>> disagree with you. I don't disagree with
- 2:40:53Zhang. What I'm saying is we're moving
- 2:40:55to a more war-prone
- 2:40:58world.
- 2:40:58>> Yep.
- 2:40:59Well, the world is a full of war for a
- 2:41:02while.
- 2:41:02>> It but this is about to get much worse.
- 2:41:05>> What are the places that you're keeping
- 2:41:06an eye on with regards to conflicts that
- 2:41:08aren't just going to expand from
- 2:41:10existing ones now?
- 2:41:11>> North Korea.
- 2:41:12North Korea's the big one.
- 2:41:15>> If I'm North Korea and I'm you know, I'm
- 2:41:18poor but I've got nuclear weapons and
- 2:41:21Japan, China, South Korea are all
- 2:41:23distracted, why don't I just extort
- 2:41:25everyone?
- 2:41:26Right? What why don't I why don't I just
- 2:41:28like you know, hold a gun to everyone's
- 2:41:29head and make them just like pay up or
- 2:41:30I'll just blow you all up.
- 2:41:32>> China itself has tensions with North
- 2:41:34Korea.
- 2:41:34>> That's right.
- 2:41:35>> Okay.
- 2:41:35>> Why is it why is it the case this
- 2:41:37whatever you want to call it global
- 2:41:40quasi anarchist world? Why? Why why is
- 2:41:44that happening?
- 2:41:44>> Because we have lived under a certain
- 2:41:48amount of stability from 1991
- 2:41:51when the Cold War ended, the Soviet
- 2:41:53Union that Cold War conflict receded. It
- 2:41:56was immediately followed by the first
- 2:41:59Gulf War which showed America could
- 2:42:02easily beat Iraq which was a power
- 2:42:05trying to control the world's economy
- 2:42:07through
- 2:42:07>> Now people know that daddy can't look
- 2:42:09after everybody.
- 2:42:09>> Daddy can't take care of you anymore.
- 2:42:11Daddy's either too old a baby boomer so
- 2:42:13maybe you know the too old. Daddy's too
- 2:42:15old.
- 2:42:16>> And he's not calling the shots anymore.
- 2:42:17>> And he doesn't have all his marbles.
- 2:42:19>> And I also assert the other thing. The
- 2:42:21United States doesn't want that role.
- 2:42:24So it's not only they can't do it, it
- 2:42:26doesn't want to do it.
- 2:42:27>> So it's it's strange to think that you
- 2:42:29can have a
- 2:42:31a globe with a bunch of different nation
- 2:42:33states, individual countries who are
- 2:42:35competing with each other and sometimes
- 2:42:37in tension with each other but you still
- 2:42:38kind of need somebody in charge.
- 2:42:40>> Yeah.
- 2:42:41>> And now there's nobody in charge.
- 2:42:42>> So you know what? If you go back to
- 2:42:442000,
- 2:42:46the world was perfect. But then
- 2:42:48>> [laughter]
- 2:42:49>> I'm serious. The world was perfect in
- 2:42:502000.
- 2:42:50>> perfect.
- 2:42:51>> Yeah. Nickelback was about to come
- 2:42:52along.
- 2:42:52>> decided to go invade Iraq,
- 2:42:55Libya,
- 2:42:57Syria and create all this chaos in the
- 2:42:59Middle East. Um and
- 2:43:02then it start to sanction Russia. NATO
- 2:43:05start to expand westwards.
- 2:43:07And then you have this conflict in
- 2:43:10Ukraine between Russia.
- 2:43:12So,
- 2:43:14um
- 2:43:14I mean, I think it's hubris. Uh so it's
- 2:43:17not just the United States becoming
- 2:43:19exhausted doesn't want its power. I
- 2:43:20think it's also hubris.
- 2:43:21>> So this makes the
- 2:43:23uh Iran war even more stupid.
- 2:43:26>> Oh yeah. It It sort of
- 2:43:28uh expedited something that was already
- 2:43:30kind
- 2:43:31>> I modeled other wars and conflicts for
- 2:43:33years. This was the one I modeled for 20
- 2:43:36years, year after year, in and out.
- 2:43:38>> Why?
- 2:43:38>> And it was because this was the next
- 2:43:41German This was the biggest problem if
- 2:43:44we took it on that we would find for the
- 2:43:46United States since Germany
- 2:43:48>> do you mean?
- 2:43:48>> [laughter]
- 2:43:48>> He knows. That's what
- 2:43:49>> He knows. That's what I'm asking, right?
- 2:43:51>> We're We're We're trying to We're trying
- 2:43:53to tell you the reasons, but we will be
- 2:43:56debating this, Chris, for decades.
- 2:43:58>> some I I will agree with you that if it
- 2:44:01extends, it will become that. It has not
- 2:44:04extended. Let's not overestimate it yet.
- 2:44:07I I I I understand on that, but if you
- 2:44:09say
- 2:44:10this is a insane move, which if you give
- 2:44:14it enough time, and it's not that much
- 2:44:16time, presumably 18 months or 2 and 1/2
- 2:44:18years or something like that, it's a
- 2:44:19really big deal. Like if you if you
- 2:44:22we don't need to worry about it. It
- 2:44:23wasn't that big of an error if we don't
- 2:44:26reach the end of the gang plank. It's
- 2:44:27like, "No, no, no. Like you're already
- 2:44:29on the plank. You're walking. There's
- 2:44:30water either side of you. If you just
- 2:44:32about manage to turn around at the end
- 2:44:33of the plank and reverse your direction,
- 2:44:35And the difference between life and
- 2:44:37death is how far you go down the plank.
- 2:44:39>> Oh, are you
- 2:44:40>> So that is very [laughter] disagree.
- 2:44:42>> I'm still on the plank. I'm less com-
- 2:44:44com- confident about the decision that's
- 2:44:45been made.
- 2:44:46>> wind that pushes you off the
- 2:44:47>> [laughter]
- 2:44:48>> Yeah. Um but it it it really is like,
- 2:44:50"Oh, this was the worst thing you could
- 2:44:53do.
- 2:44:53>> This was absolutely Yes, and I think
- 2:44:55this was where
- 2:44:57the real issue with President Trump
- 2:45:00walling himself off from anything like
- 2:45:03strong advisors. So, if you just look at
- 2:45:06the advisors around Trump I'm sorry.
- 2:45:09This is just an extremely weak group of
- 2:45:12advisors. It's
- 2:45:13>> And and Natalie Harper as well.
- 2:45:14>> Well, just don't want to I don't want to
- 2:45:16get into the some of the
- 2:45:18>> Vietnam was far worse than this war from
- 2:45:20the American point of view. On the our
- 2:45:22global point of view, it was not that
- 2:45:24terrible.
- 2:45:24>> Exactly.
- 2:45:25>> But for the Americans, this was the
- 2:45:27moment.
- 2:45:28>> That's why after Vietnam, we could just
- 2:45:29shift over to deal with Europe, try to
- 2:45:32defend the Europe from the Soviet Union.
- 2:45:34This war, we're not shifting.
- 2:45:36>> Dude, if this if this turns out if if
- 2:45:39history looks back and does its analysis
- 2:45:41and finds out that one guy one morning
- 2:45:44just decided to press the button
- 2:45:45>> Yes.
- 2:45:46>> Like that Oh, what what was the
- 2:45:47motivation? Was it some deeply
- 2:45:49sought-after analyst-fueled thing? It's
- 2:45:52like, no, some guy just woke up and
- 2:45:53decided to press a button. You will
- 2:45:55think
- 2:45:56how was it that we allowed power to be
- 2:45:58centralized so much behind one human
- 2:46:00who's got my season?
- 2:46:01>> There was a famous commercial by Hillary
- 2:46:04Clinton in 2016, which is the red phone
- 2:46:07is ringing. It's 3:00 a.m. And that
- 2:46:09means that was the phone to the nuclear
- 2:46:12weapons. Who do you want to answer that
- 2:46:14phone? This is the way we've built our
- 2:46:16Constitution, Chris.
- 2:46:18One person makes that decision.
- 2:46:21>> that
- 2:46:23don't overestimate.
- 2:46:26Okay? If you extrapolate all the way
- 2:46:28forward
- 2:46:29okay?
- 2:46:30But see the forces that are
- 2:46:32making Iran itself consider what to do
- 2:46:36and so on. So, yes, if this war
- 2:46:38continued, it would have massive
- 2:46:40effects.
- 2:46:42It's already had significant effects.
- 2:46:44On the other hand do not assume that we
- 2:46:47understand
- 2:46:49at this point just how far Iran can go
- 2:46:52as well.
- 2:46:53Yes, one man started this war, okay?
- 2:46:56He's failed to win it.
- 2:46:58But do not assume
- 2:47:00that this war cannot end except
- 2:47:03go on forever.
- 2:47:04>> I don't I I very much hope that it does.
- 2:47:07>> Well, when I say January, we'll know the
- 2:47:09answer to that.
- 2:47:09>> Is January kind of a point of no return
- 2:47:11for you?
- 2:47:11>> It's a point It's a It's a It's an
- 2:47:13inflection point because in January,
- 2:47:16either President Trump will have the uh
- 2:47:19wherewithal to be able to continue the
- 2:47:21war or he won't. And that's because of
- 2:47:25the Democrats in Congress. So, the
- 2:47:27Democrats will either win Congress or
- 2:47:29not. And if they win Congress, they'll
- 2:47:31either act to shut down the war or not.
- 2:47:33We will know this in January.
- 2:47:35>> The damage has already been done to like
- 2:47:38a lot of the facilities, the energy
- 2:47:40facilities of of the They've been shut
- 2:47:42down. It's going to take them like 6
- 2:47:43months. Let's assume the war ends today
- 2:47:45or tomorrow. It's going to take 6 months
- 2:47:47to restart all these facilities.
- 2:47:49>> Yes, well, then 6 months it'll get
- 2:47:50better then. So, we're talking about a
- 2:47:53fundamental shift in the nature of life
- 2:47:57on [snorts] Earth,
- 2:47:58which could happen,
- 2:48:00but not in the shorter run.
- 2:48:02>> Well, well, wait a minute. But here's I
- 2:48:04don't think the two of you are as far
- 2:48:05apart because remember you're speaking
- 2:48:07in very very broad strokes. What he is
- 2:48:10saying is that even by January, my my
- 2:48:13threshold, um he's very concerned about
- 2:48:16the debt crisis. He's very concerned
- 2:48:18about the world. He's worried about the
- 2:48:20world economy. So, and your point is
- 2:48:23even if we have a a world recession or
- 2:48:25depression, we'll recover. You two are
- 2:48:28not as far apart as you might think. Uh
- 2:48:30but he The point is I think that we are
- 2:48:33at a bookend with this war. The one
- 2:48:35thing that won't come back is confidence
- 2:48:39in America as the protector of that
- 2:48:42global system, that's not coming back
- 2:48:44for decades.
- 2:48:45>> it is this is exactly
- 2:48:49what we in Texas want.
- 2:48:51Because we had because we served during
- 2:48:55the Cold War
- 2:48:57at the Fulda Gap.
- 2:48:59>> Uh
- 2:48:59>> And there's really a desire in the
- 2:49:02United States in the public not to have
- 2:49:05this role.
- 2:49:07Okay?
- 2:49:08Among those of us
- 2:49:10>> working this we this is natural thing
- 2:49:11that should we should have this role.
- 2:49:13But when I talk to my neighbors
- 2:49:17the idea that we are responsible for the
- 2:49:19world. And one of the reasons this
- 2:49:21hostility from the Texas Republicans
- 2:49:24with their
- 2:49:25toward Trump very much so is that he did
- 2:49:29what he promised he wouldn't do, get us
- 2:49:31involved again.
- 2:49:32>> Yes, and I'm not arguing for taking care
- 2:49:35of the world to take care of the world.
- 2:49:37I'm saying that America's primacy is not
- 2:49:40coming back.
- 2:49:41>> Is there a
- 2:49:42>> And again, I will say
- 2:49:45>> That means its economy is
- 2:49:46>> for America.
- 2:49:47>> Well, the economy losing the if if we
- 2:49:51are if this is right, then the future of
- 2:49:53social security is is not long for this
- 2:49:56world. Um and that's a tremendous
- 2:49:58problem. I have a 97-year-old
- 2:50:01um
- 2:50:01mother-in-law. And I am seeing already
- 2:50:04that we are horrendous in this country
- 2:50:06at I've been um at taking care of people
- 2:50:09in their 90s. And we're going to have
- 2:50:11more people living in their 90s. What if
- 2:50:13social security goes away as a result of
- 2:50:16this war?
- 2:50:18>> I don't know how the connection can be
- 2:50:19made that would have be possible.
- 2:50:22>> Well, this is his more his area than
- 2:50:24mine.
- 2:50:24>> Well, I would argue that the American
- 2:50:28production and trade and everything else
- 2:50:30is critical to the world.
- 2:50:32It's the debt
- 2:50:33>> It's these financial underpinnings that
- 2:50:35are being stressed so significantly.
- 2:50:38>> you look at world trade, you look at who
- 2:50:40consumes it and who can't consume it,
- 2:50:43you know, I say still has a role.
- 2:50:45Okay?
- 2:50:47>> Artificial intelligence now accounts for
- 2:50:4950% of GDP growth in the United States.
- 2:50:5150% of GDP growth are are they these AI
- 2:50:54data data centers?
- 2:50:56Guess who's financing these data
- 2:50:57centers? The GCC.
- 2:50:59>> Mhm.
- 2:50:59>> So, imagine a scenario where this war
- 2:51:02continues, the GCC
- 2:51:04is no longer able to provide any
- 2:51:06financing, the bubble, the AI bubble
- 2:51:08burst, you have like millions of
- 2:51:11unemployed Americans.
- 2:51:13I mean,
- 2:51:14the consequences will will be very dire.
- 2:51:19>> There's different models that may play
- 2:51:21out. That may be one of them.
- 2:51:23But I see it happening somewhat
- 2:51:25differently.
- 2:51:27Which is that the United States
- 2:51:30dominating the Western Hemisphere,
- 2:51:33not having the price to pay
- 2:51:36in
- 2:51:37in terms of defense and everything else,
- 2:51:39may well get by.
- 2:51:42So, the issue here is not that the world
- 2:51:44isn't changing. I think we all agree
- 2:51:46that a radical new system is emerging.
- 2:51:48Okay?
- 2:51:49We may not agree on what it would look
- 2:51:51like, but it's certainly going to be
- 2:51:53different.
- 2:51:54At the same time,
- 2:51:56I don't view this evolution as
- 2:51:58catastrophic from the American point of
- 2:52:00view or from the global point of view.
- 2:52:02>> Is there a a conflict
- 2:52:04or a war or a
- 2:52:06area of focus that everyone's preparing
- 2:52:09for right now that probably won't
- 2:52:11happen? Is there something that a lot of
- 2:52:13attention is being paid to
- 2:52:15a type of war?
- 2:52:15>> Nuclear war.
- 2:52:17Nuclear war Nuclear war will not happen.
- 2:52:20>> Why?
- 2:52:21>> Because um there's no incentive for
- 2:52:25these nations to blow themselves up.
- 2:52:27>> MAD.
- 2:52:27>> It's yeah, it's it's madness, right?
- 2:52:29>> Mutually assured destruction.
- 2:52:31>> Yeah. Yeah.
- 2:52:32>> Which is why we haven't had any such
- 2:52:33wars.
- 2:52:34>> Yeah.
- 2:52:34>> Right? So, I I don't see any scenario
- 2:52:36where nuclear weapons are used, even
- 2:52:37tactically.
- 2:52:38>> [snorts]
- 2:52:39>> Um I think that before the war started
- 2:52:42on February 28th, I put the odds of a
- 2:52:45nuclear weapon being used by the United
- 2:52:48States in this conflict, cuz I modeled
- 2:52:50for 20 years, as under 5%. By Israel at
- 2:52:54about 15%. So, just to tell you where
- 2:52:56this has been. I've now essentially been
- 2:52:59doubling those over time because um the
- 2:53:03nature of um the player. So, the
- 2:53:06modeling is agnostic to the decision
- 2:53:09makers, right, over time because you
- 2:53:10have different presidents come in.
- 2:53:12>> Mhm.
- 2:53:12>> But what we've already seen is that uh
- 2:53:15President Trump um is already
- 2:53:18inordinately looking into nuclear
- 2:53:20weapons. Uh a dolphin, which is a
- 2:53:22nuclear which is a nuclear uh
- 2:53:24arms-carrying submarine by Israel,
- 2:53:26Israel moved it into the Red Sea within
- 2:53:29firing range of Tehran. Now, these are
- 2:53:31not by themselves dispositive.
- 2:53:32>> You just need deterrence.
- 2:53:33>> These are These are just movements. So,
- 2:53:35I understand that, but nonetheless, um
- 2:53:38these are encouraging Iran to move
- 2:53:42forward to do nuclear tests.
- 2:53:44>> Mhm.
- 2:53:44>> So, as you look at uh I'm not saying uh
- 2:53:48So, as you just look at strategic
- 2:53:49interaction, so that's what a model is.
- 2:53:52It's not just one player, it's strategic
- 2:53:54interaction. Uh the reason I've up my
- 2:53:57percentages is because I've seen actions
- 2:53:59by Israel and the United States that I
- 2:54:02believe are increasing Iran's incentives
- 2:54:06to do nuclear tests.
- 2:54:08And that once Iran would actually
- 2:54:11literally prepare to do nuclear tests,
- 2:54:14if we see those coming,
- 2:54:16that is another interaction. So, that's
- 2:54:18my dynamic that I'm concerned about, but
- 2:54:21it's not at the level of 50-70%.
- 2:54:24>> Right now, Iran cannot develop a nuclear
- 2:54:25weapon because of a FATF one in place.
- 2:54:27So, for the fatwa to be rescinded, the
- 2:54:29supreme leader would need to organize a
- 2:54:31council, and they would need to
- 2:54:34>> that they could subvert the religious
- 2:54:36doctrine.
- 2:54:37>> a theocracy. It's It's It's like saying
- 2:54:38like, you know, let's ignore the First
- 2:54:39Amendment of the Constitution.
- 2:54:40>> Yeah, but that could be arranged pretty
- 2:54:42quickly.
- 2:54:43>> Well, um
- 2:54:44>> And they're about to withdraw from the
- 2:54:46NPT possibly. So, they're already
- 2:54:48talking about with So, these are these
- 2:54:50under the hood actions.
- 2:54:52>> that fatwa, okay? According to the
- 2:54:54system. So, Iran would only develop a
- 2:54:57nuclear weapon if Israel and the United
- 2:54:59States were to attack first. Right? But
- 2:55:02if you're Iran Oh, sorry. If you're
- 2:55:03Israel and the United States, you
- 2:55:04usually attack a nuclear weapon
- 2:55:06somewhere maybe on Pik as Mountain,
- 2:55:07right?
- 2:55:08>> Built
- 2:55:08>> What What do you What do you achieve?
- 2:55:09>> Building the deliverable nuclear weapon
- 2:55:12is much more complex
- 2:55:15than testing one.
- 2:55:16You have to have all sorts of elements
- 2:55:19come together. It would take time. And
- 2:55:21>> Well, that's true for hydrogen
- 2:55:23generation two weapons, but not atomic
- 2:55:26weapons, Fat Man and Little Boy. So, Fat
- 2:55:28Man and Little Boy are undergraduate
- 2:55:31Well, well, no. Fat Man and Little Boy
- 2:55:33are delivered on was delivered on
- 2:55:35aircraft. This was not a put into a The
- 2:55:38second generation was miniaturized to
- 2:55:40put into the missiles. But once we look
- 2:55:42>> I I simply am saying that developing a
- 2:55:45nuclear weapon and testing it and making
- 2:55:48sure it works
- 2:55:50takes a lot bit of time.
- 2:55:51>> Well, if North Korea, the 212th poorest
- 2:55:53country on the planet can do 60, pretty
- 2:55:56sure this country can conquer this
- 2:55:59>> Over a period of time, yes.
- 2:56:01>> Well, just pointing out it's it's your
- 2:56:03your raising it to the bar it must be
- 2:56:05miniaturized and look like our If once
- 2:56:07we go back to World War II level nuclear
- 2:56:10weapons, which you just have to keep
- 2:56:12keep in mind, um killed well over
- 2:56:14100,000 people in those two explosions.
- 2:56:17>> Korean nuclear program lasted many
- 2:56:19>> The nuclear program in North Korea that
- 2:56:21many years.
- 2:56:22>> Well, that's because they went to
- 2:56:23miniaturize it, too. I'm just pointing
- 2:56:25out that Iran may go much more quickly
- 2:56:28to a time
- 2:56:30>> I see the risk of nuclear war even with
- 2:56:33Iraq
- 2:56:34down the road with plenty of time to do
- 2:56:36it. Just we're talking about things
- 2:56:39you're
- 2:56:39>> If Iran tests two nuclear devices, I I
- 2:56:43think that the odds that we're going to
- 2:56:45look at those two nuclear tests, let's
- 2:56:47say it's an October surprise.
- 2:56:49>> If they test two nuclear weapons in
- 2:56:51October, are you telling me, George?
- 2:56:52>> No.
- 2:56:52>> We're going to look at those two nuclear
- 2:56:54tests and say, "Don't worry, folks. It's
- 2:56:56going to be years before they can hit
- 2:56:58New York."
- 2:56:59>> nuclear two nuclear weapons
- 2:57:01>> in October
- 2:57:02>> devices, you're absolutely right.
- 2:57:05I am saying, however, knowing something
- 2:57:07about developing nuclear weapons
- 2:57:10that first test will probably fail and
- 2:57:12so on and so forth. There is time is all
- 2:57:14I'm saying, okay? Nothing more than
- 2:57:17that.
- 2:57:18>> What should people be paying the most
- 2:57:20attention to? Let's say the next 2
- 2:57:23years, something like that. People that
- 2:57:25are listening, what are the
- 2:57:27uh warning signs? Nuclear tests coming
- 2:57:29out of Iran, one of those. Uh what are
- 2:57:32the
- 2:57:33uh little hurdles in terms of timing?
- 2:57:35You mentioned November, you also
- 2:57:36mentioned January.
- 2:57:37>> the bad signs or some of the good signs?
- 2:57:40>> just what should people be paying
- 2:57:41attention to if this is the sort of uh
- 2:57:43change which occurs? What would be the
- 2:57:45big inflection points that you guys are
- 2:57:47paying attention to over the next 2
- 2:57:49years or so?
- 2:57:49>> inflection
- 2:57:50>> point I'm tracking, and again, building
- 2:57:52on what I just told you about January,
- 2:57:54is whether we will see the Democrats win
- 2:57:58one or both houses of Congress and
- 2:58:00seated peacefully, seated peacefully.
- 2:58:04So, we need to understand that um what
- 2:58:06we saw uh in November 2020 was an
- 2:58:11election did not go President Trump's
- 2:58:12way.
- 2:58:13Now, we have not seen President Trump as
- 2:58:15president have that happen again.
- 2:58:18He is about to be president and we're
- 2:58:20going to see in November 2026
- 2:58:22will a election not go President Trump's
- 2:58:25way? And if it doesn't go President
- 2:58:27Trump's way, is he going to do anything
- 2:58:31to disturb the process of it going and
- 2:58:34that will go on for months because the
- 2:58:35election is November 3rd, seating the
- 2:58:38Congress is January 3rd. If that's what
- 2:58:40I'm really focused on cuz if that goes
- 2:58:42south all of these issues are going to
- 2:58:45get much much much worse.
- 2:58:46>> I I see the positive one evolving
- 2:58:49is US-China
- 2:58:51economic entente
- 2:58:53and reducing tensions within them. If
- 2:58:56those two countries get together
- 2:58:59the global system changes and possibly
- 2:59:02with proper presidents stabilizes in a
- 2:59:05different form.
- 2:59:06So I'm looking at that as the most
- 2:59:09critical thing coming.
- 2:59:10>> Mhm.
- 2:59:11>> My question is will the United States
- 2:59:13target criticals of an infrastructure in
- 2:59:16Iran next one or two months? If Iran
- 2:59:19start sorry, if the United States starts
- 2:59:20targeting power plants or these these
- 2:59:22these election plants en masse, this war
- 2:59:25is now out of control. We are now beyond
- 2:59:27the escalation trap.
- 2:59:29Um it's it's complete madness.
- 2:59:31>> Even if it's done remotely, it doesn't
- 2:59:32need to be boots on the ground. It
- 2:59:33doesn't need to be nukes.
- 2:59:35>> If the United States targets Iranian
- 2:59:37power plants
- 2:59:39Iran will target in any way.
- 2:59:41>> In any way, Iran will target all of the
- 2:59:43Middle East energy infrastructure. The
- 2:59:45pipelines, the energy fields, and it's
- 2:59:47easy to do with drones.
- 2:59:49>> I I agree with this. I just put the
- 2:59:51internal problem a little bit higher,
- 2:59:53but I agree with his assessment that and
- 2:59:55this is part of my nightmare scenario.
- 2:59:57>> like these two things are existing
- 2:59:59separately.
- 2:59:59>> They actually go together. That's what
- 3:00:01I'm trying to say. These things actually
- 3:00:02go together and then I gave this
- 3:00:04presentation in my Substack about the
- 3:00:06four steps that would be the nightmare
- 3:00:08scenario just in the Iran war and this
- 3:00:12is
- 3:00:13this is the critical step because once
- 3:00:15you hit and I when I taught for the US
- 3:00:18Air Force in the 1990s, targeting
- 3:00:20electric power plants was one of the
- 3:00:22critical things we studied for months
- 3:00:24and months. We have fortunately did it
- 3:00:26in the unclassified world so that I was
- 3:00:28I'm able to talk about this. We brought
- 3:00:30in people that ran the power plants, the
- 3:00:32engineers that built them. So I have a
- 3:00:35fair idea of the different places you
- 3:00:36would target the plants, what the
- 3:00:38consequences are. And there's a great
- 3:00:41paper that if people are listening by
- 3:00:44Thomas Griffith called Targeting
- 3:00:46Electric Power. He was a military
- 3:00:49officer when he wrote this paper. It is
- 3:00:51the best paper on the consequences of
- 3:00:54targeting military power.
- 3:00:56And on my substack, I wrote a lengthy
- 3:00:58piece what targeting Tehran would really
- 3:01:02mean for the people of Tehran. When you
- 3:01:05take out the electric power in Tehran
- 3:01:07for a month and I walked through it. Uh
- 3:01:11but really
- 3:01:11>> Not good, I imagine.
- 3:01:12>> Starvation. Oh my god. You would you
- 3:01:14it's Oh yeah, it's much because all of
- 3:01:17the
- 3:01:18uh so much of the food 25% of the food
- 3:01:21in Tehran is under refrigeration and
- 3:01:25that includes all the supermarkets all
- 3:01:27there's so much that is and then you
- 3:01:30really start to run out of the ability
- 3:01:32to pump water. So things like water
- 3:01:35pumping stations in the Middle East
- 3:01:37where you depend on water. So there's Uh
- 3:01:40there's so much of detail underneath
- 3:01:42this summary of
- 3:01:44uh um droughts, starvation, um massive
- 3:01:47evacuations of the city. But where do
- 3:01:49these 10 million people go? It's not
- 3:01:52like they just run to some other place
- 3:01:54and turn on the faucet. So this is the
- 3:01:57the targeting of electric power is much
- 3:02:00worse than most people think.
- 3:02:02>> Oh my god.
- 3:02:02>> It's It's actually worse than a nuclear
- 3:02:04option. To do that would be worse than
- 3:02:06using a tactical nuke on pickaxe men.
- 3:02:08>> In terms of destruction, quality of life
- 3:02:11change.
- 3:02:12>> In terms of the escalation ladder.
- 3:02:13>> Oh, right. Okay. Oh, the escalation
- 3:02:15ladder, civilian deaths.
- 3:02:16>> No way. So, if you hit You're saying if
- 3:02:18you hit power plants with any kind of
- 3:02:20missile, that's more
- 3:02:23>> Well, well, just to be super super
- 3:02:25clear, there's two aim points on the
- 3:02:28electric power. And And this is a target
- 3:02:30set that we've uh the American Air Force
- 3:02:33has had many times.
- 3:02:33>> it. Yeah.
- 3:02:35>> [laughter]
- 3:02:35>> So, air
- 3:02:37Well, in order to understand why not to
- 3:02:39do it,
- 3:02:40to be And by the way, from the moment of
- 3:02:42Tom Griffith's paper, and we did this in
- 3:02:44the mid-90s, until right now, we've not
- 3:02:47targeted electric power. So, that paper
- 3:02:50for 20 years has been the paper
- 3:02:52>> a warning.
- 3:02:53>> to of the warning to all the generals in
- 3:02:55CENTCOM, this is what it means to target
- 3:02:58electric power. And it shows And so,
- 3:03:01what you were um
- 3:03:03uh what you were seeing in in the plant
- 3:03:05itself, so if we could imagine I don't
- 3:03:07see a good thing to use as a plant, but
- 3:03:09you can hit the um the cables that
- 3:03:12connect the plant to the grid, the
- 3:03:14electric power grid. That's like blowing
- 3:03:17a fuse in your home. That knocks it out
- 3:03:19for like a four
- 3:03:20Yeah, about a week, okay? Maybe two at
- 3:03:22most, but maybe which really about four
- 3:03:24or five days.
- 3:03:25>> But if you hit the hulls, the actual
- 3:03:27generating hulls, those are each special
- 3:03:30made, they're gigantic, they're much
- 3:03:33bigger than this whole building, and it
- 3:03:35takes 6 months to even design them and
- 3:03:38produce them, much less bring them back
- 3:03:40in. So, once you go after the hulls, so
- 3:03:43when President Trump his his rhetoric
- 3:03:45here is worrisome, because he's talking
- 3:03:49about when he's talking about these
- 3:03:51massive consequences,
- 3:03:54this would be fit this would fit with
- 3:03:56the description of going after the
- 3:03:57hulls, and you're not bringing this back
- 3:04:00with the Red Cross, and you're not going
- 3:04:02to come in and you're not going to
- 3:04:03support this with a giant Berlin airlift
- 3:04:07of massive water to all these people.
- 3:04:10This is This is going to be This would
- 3:04:11be much more horrendous.
- 3:04:14And if you take out Tehran, that's 10
- 3:04:16million people. It wouldn't be long
- 3:04:19before you took out another like 10
- 3:04:21different nodes and the entire 70% of
- 3:04:25the population would be without electric
- 3:04:27power. It's a It's a much bigger problem
- 3:04:29than people realize.
- 3:04:32>> That is scary.
- 3:04:34That is terrifying. Gentlemen, I
- 3:04:35appreciate you all. This is I I don't
- 3:04:37know whether I'm reassured, but I'm
- 3:04:38definitely more educated, which is nice.
- 3:04:41Where should people go to check out
- 3:04:42everything that you've got going on?
- 3:04:43>> I'm on YouTube and Substack Predictive
- 3:04:45History.
- 3:04:46>> Oh, yeah.
- 3:04:46>> I'm on Substack here at Escalation Trap,
- 3:04:49Professor Pape, and starting tomorrow a
- 3:04:51brand new YouTube channel that's coming
- 3:04:54tomorrow afternoon.
- 3:04:56Pape on the politics of force, so stay
- 3:04:58tuned.
- 3:04:59>> And a new book.
- 3:05:00>> And And a new book coming, Our Own Worst
- 3:05:03Enemies, America in the Age of Violent
- 3:05:05Populism. And my nightmare scenario was
- 3:05:08always that we'd have
- 3:05:10an election as this contentious with an
- 3:05:13international crisis and they're both
- 3:05:15happening.
- 3:05:16>> Heck, yeah.
- 3:05:17>> And for me, geopoliticalfutures.com
- 3:05:21is where you can visit.
- 3:05:23And I'm of the opinion humanity will
- 3:05:25survive again.
- 3:05:27It's extremely improbable is my theme.
- 3:05:30>> Beautiful. Gentlemen, I appreciate you
- 3:05:32all. Thank you very much. Goodbye, my
- 3:05:33beauties.
- 3:05:34>> Thank you. That was great. Thanks so
- 3:05:35much.
- 3:05:36>> George, thank you very much. That was
- 3:05:38awesome. That was awesome. Enjoy that.
- 3:05:42>> Congratulations, you made it to the end
- 3:05:44of a podcast episode without dying. Now,
- 3:05:47here's another one.
- 3:05:49Go on.
- 3:05:50Watch it.
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of WW3 DEBATE: “We’re On the Brink of Global Collapse” by Chris Williamson, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 31,807 words across 5,160 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.