WTF is WDT: History, Evolution, and Current Trends of the Weiss Distribution Technique — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:00foreign
- 0:08think come on John wise think what can I
- 0:12do to make a more even extraction
- 0:16stock flip doesn't work north south east
- 0:18west doesn't work none of these finger
- 0:20distributions work
- 0:22I've got to think of something maybe
- 0:24this acupuncture session will help me
- 0:25think think dang it
- 0:31[Music]
- 0:37workplace Park
- 0:44oh
- 0:55it works
- 0:57[Music]
- 1:10foreign
- 1:18[Music]
- 1:31distribution is the foundation for even
- 1:33extraction and even extraction is the
- 1:36foundation for excellence in the cup now
- 1:39this is a quote from an exchange I saw
- 1:41between John Weiss and another user on
- 1:43the home Barista Forum dating back to
- 1:452006. the Weiss distribution technique
- 1:48has now been heralded as probably the
- 1:50most important part of preparation in
- 1:52order to ensure consistency and even
- 1:54extraction but what's the history of it
- 1:57and what is the best way to do it today
- 2:00so let's get into that because I
- 2:02recently have done a lot of deep diving
- 2:04in order to understand the history and
- 2:06the evolution of the Weiss distribution
- 2:07technique in 2005 John Weiss a home
- 2:11Barista was on a form called coffee geek
- 2:14that is now defunct and was talking
- 2:15about experiences he was having using
- 2:18medically precise needles in order to
- 2:20de-clump and homogenize his bed of
- 2:22grounds before making espresso now at
- 2:25that time most of the Grinders out on
- 2:27the market were considered Clump
- 2:29monsters meaning that they were just
- 2:30producing a lot of clumps and it was
- 2:32impossible to properly distribute these
- 2:34clumps in order to make an even bed so
- 2:37the popular styles of distribution at
- 2:39the time which would include the stock
- 2:41fluff method and north south east west
- 2:43which I'll show you right now these
- 2:46methods were not sufficient to properly
- 2:49distribute the full bed of ground so you
- 2:50were Distributing the top layer but not
- 2:52really the bottom and considering all
- 2:54the clumps that was a big issue and was
- 2:57causing a lot of channels and a lot of
- 2:58frustrated home users so he took to
- 3:01these medically precise needles in order
- 3:03to do this job for him so he would take
- 3:06them and he would put them down and he
- 3:07was essentially stirring the grounds in
- 3:09order to ensure that they were declumped
- 3:11and homogenized and this led to that
- 3:13even extraction which he says is the
- 3:15foundation for excellence in the cup a
- 3:18quote that is 17 years old but which I
- 3:20thoroughly agree with the following year
- 3:22in 2006 John Weiss moved this
- 3:24conversation over to the brand new home
- 3:26Barista forum and on there that's when
- 3:29you kind of see and an adoption of this
- 3:32this sort of technique and the evolution
- 3:35of it to what it is today now along the
- 3:37way there are pitfalls there were
- 3:38regressions in my opinion like using
- 3:40toothpicks or uh using a I don't know
- 3:43things that are like Forks essentially
- 3:45just really anything that would bust
- 3:47clumps but people weren't taken into
- 3:49account the negative impact some of
- 3:51these tools could have on their bed so
- 3:53instead of improving it the way that he
- 3:55was with medically precise needles
- 3:57people were taking a cheaper more
- 3:59accessible way to replicate what he was
- 4:01doing assuming it was doing the same
- 4:03thing when in reality they were just
- 4:05creating massive pits in their bed which
- 4:07is going to cause channeling so it's a
- 4:09little counterproductive but as years
- 4:11continue to go on there were positive
- 4:13innovations that were brought to the
- 4:15table and now we have landed at what I
- 4:17think is near the top of what this uh
- 4:20this technique is supposed to be doing
- 4:22to your coffee now before we continue I
- 4:25want to say that this technique while I
- 4:26do think it is an imperative technique
- 4:28to adopt in your home routine it is not
- 4:31going to maximize your extraction to the
- 4:33point of you have a three percent bump
- 4:35or some sort of massive increase in
- 4:37extraction perhaps you will if you have
- 4:39a really clumpy grinder and this could
- 4:41really help homogenize the grounds but a
- 4:43lot of Grinders nowadays are not that
- 4:44clumpy and so really what you're just
- 4:46doing is homogenizing your bed and
- 4:48increasing your extraction efficiency
- 4:50and consistency less wasted coffee less
- 4:53wasty more tasty right right what we
- 4:56have over those years is this Evolution
- 4:57and so now we are at these these Cool
- 5:00Tools which we'll go over here in a
- 5:02second to get the technique and what my
- 5:04recommendations are as far as needle
- 5:05size spread Etc
- 5:08but first I want to go over my own
- 5:09adventure with wdt the Weiss
- 5:11distribution technique in 2016 I
- 5:13stumbled upon a coffee shop in my
- 5:15hometown of Chattanooga Tennessee this
- 5:17shop was called Revelator it's no longer
- 5:19there but the Barista was grinding his
- 5:22coffee and into a dosing cup and then he
- 5:25had a toothpick and he was sitting there
- 5:26stirring the grounds and I was intrigued
- 5:28by this and asked him what he was doing
- 5:29and he said well I'm de-clumping I'm
- 5:31taking these clumps that my grinder is
- 5:33creating and I'm breaking them and then
- 5:35he put it in the portafilter and then he
- 5:36tamped and pulled the shot and I was
- 5:38intrigued by this I'd never seen it
- 5:40before now mind you this was early in my
- 5:42I guess coffee loving career and I had
- 5:45not distembled upon the homebreast to
- 5:47form so this was a brand new technique
- 5:48I'd never seen so I began to adopt it
- 5:50just on occasion when I was at the at my
- 5:53shop in order to see what it would do
- 5:55but I never really saw much improvement
- 5:57with a toothpick so I I abandoned it
- 6:00pretty quickly and didn't touch it again
- 6:01until around the fall of 2019 that's
- 6:04when I began to see this push for using
- 6:07more precise instruments like
- 6:08acupuncture needles and that's what
- 6:10these are
- 6:12right here
- 6:14so the use of acupuncture needles in
- 6:16order to perform this wise distribution
- 6:19technique
- 6:20and so once I began to see that I went
- 6:22ahead purchased some on my own and began
- 6:24to experiment at home now the difference
- 6:26I saw between this and what I had been
- 6:29doing was drastic now to quickly go over
- 6:31what I was doing what I found to be the
- 6:33best way to distribute the grounds was
- 6:35not using a leveler or a distributor as
- 6:37they're called these levelers and what I
- 6:39mean by that are those little spinny
- 6:41tools that you put on your bed you spin
- 6:42it and it flattens the top they actually
- 6:44in my opinion in my testing do a little
- 6:47more harm than good now they might be
- 6:49okay in a bar setting because it will
- 6:51negate inconsistency from Barista to
- 6:53Barista but you're not doing anything to
- 6:55the bottom part of that Puck and on top
- 6:57of that you're compressing certain parts
- 6:59more than others with that initial push
- 7:01down and that's going to cause problems
- 7:03with channeling so I've never been a fan
- 7:05of that and in fact I loved a a study
- 7:08that Barista hustle did years back
- 7:09showing what the the most extraction you
- 7:12can get using the distribution Methods
- 7:14at the time were and they did not
- 7:15include Weiss distribution but at the
- 7:17time horizontal tapping or to taking
- 7:20your portafilter and tapping on the
- 7:22sides to kind of shake the grounds into
- 7:24place seem to be the most consistent and
- 7:27efficient way of Distributing the
- 7:28grounds and that's what the public the
- 7:30study was uh found to be I've been a
- 7:32huge proponent of this horizontal
- 7:34tapping technique because of that study
- 7:36and because of my own experiences but
- 7:38again in 2019 I rediscovered the wdt and
- 7:41kind of the evolved form it had become
- 7:43over the past 15 years at that point now
- 7:46what might be fun is if you all are
- 7:48interested I do have below a link to the
- 7:50original kind of discourse on home
- 7:52Barista about the about the Weiss
- 7:54distribution technique John Weiss his
- 7:56own comments are there you can go
- 7:57through and read them his username is
- 7:59rapid coffee on there and so go check
- 8:02that out anyway now let's go and talk
- 8:04about how should we pick our tool what
- 8:06should we be looking for in a tool and
- 8:08how to actually observe this technique
- 8:11most efficiently so of course I have a
- 8:13few options here this one right here
- 8:15came from wug 2 so the grinder that I'll
- 8:18be doing review on soon this is the wdt
- 8:21they sent this is from swarks Design
- 8:23This is Sheldon Wong's design for a wdt
- 8:26tool then you have this I'm not sure who
- 8:29designed it but it's a 3D printed little
- 8:31tool and then you have this one which is
- 8:33made by Jay Kim again this is going to
- 8:35be linked in the caption below but this
- 8:37is a this is a 3D printed one that comes
- 8:40out in a little card a little business
- 8:41card you just break it apart and you
- 8:43build the wdt yourself it comes with a
- 8:45little pack of needles which is great so
- 8:47here these are some of the options of
- 8:49course a lot of These are 3D printed
- 8:51whoops this one is is pretty expensive
- 8:54for for what it is but you have
- 8:57different options and then you have of
- 8:58course the ones on Amazon with the
- 8:59little Loops at the end you have really
- 9:02thick needles you have ones with three
- 9:04needles ones with 12 needles you have
- 9:06the spinny ones which one should you buy
- 9:08well currently in my opinion the spinny
- 9:11ones none of them yet hit the mark for
- 9:14what I think is the best of what you can
- 9:16do with wdt now there is one coming out
- 9:18soon by Barista hustle which is which
- 9:20will be called the auto comb I have a
- 9:22lot of Hope in that one and so we'll see
- 9:24it hopefully in Q2 of 2023 that will be
- 9:26released hopefully this video ages well
- 9:28and it's out by then but
- 9:30anyway uh so what do we have when it
- 9:32comes to these tools what what is what
- 9:33do I think is the best what uh have I
- 9:35found the best results with well
- 9:37something with something like this I
- 9:40have not have not enjoyed so this has
- 9:42massive needles these are probably 0.5
- 9:44or 0.6 millimeters so really really
- 9:47thick relative relatively speaking and
- 9:50there's only a five needle spread so
- 9:52this doesn't really give me the motion
- 9:54in the bed that I really want
- 9:55essentially I want to be wdting so
- 9:58quickly and with such Precision that the
- 10:01bed turns a little fluid and that is
- 10:02what is ideal to kind of push everything
- 10:04into place right
- 10:07um he's got fluid uh any scrubs fans out
- 10:09there no okay
- 10:11um anyway so I'm this one I don't really
- 10:14I really like now this is another one
- 10:17that I got uh someone sent me this I
- 10:19think the angles on this are a little
- 10:20too drastic uh for my for my uh desires
- 10:24this and there's only five needles again
- 10:26there is a center needle which is a nice
- 10:27touch uh to kind of help with the
- 10:30spacing but
- 10:31um you know it's just it's not I don't
- 10:34really like it
- 10:36next we have these two these are my two
- 10:38favorite wdt tools as they stand on the
- 10:40current market this one because it's so
- 10:43cheap I actually have a video dedicated
- 10:44to this linked right there at its um at
- 10:47its first release Jay Kim was selling
- 10:49them for a dollar each and then you paid
- 10:51shipping but he got inundated with
- 10:53orders and had to change that I think
- 10:54his dad is now running that site so if
- 10:56you want to order you can check that
- 10:57below but it is more expensive now
- 10:59because it is his dad doing it
- 11:01um but you can also find this on uh
- 11:03online and you can print it yourself and
- 11:05just buy acupuncture needles and then
- 11:07whatever your cost is you're good to go
- 11:09so I love this one I think the spacing
- 11:11is really nice when the needles are at
- 11:13their full length of what He suggests
- 11:15with it it has a around a 29 millimeter
- 11:17diameter and the reason for that is
- 11:19that's half of a 58 millimeter
- 11:21portafilter so you can when you put it
- 11:23in and it's touching the wall it should
- 11:24be to the center so as your wdt you can
- 11:27make sure you're hitting all sides of
- 11:28that portafilter with your uh with your
- 11:30motions uh I've actually cut these a
- 11:32little shorter I like thinner needles
- 11:34that are shorter but we'll get to that
- 11:35in a second this is Sheldon's from
- 11:37Swartz design
- 11:39so this one has the capability of adding
- 11:42or lessening needles you can take a tool
- 11:44to loosen right here and you can add
- 11:47more needles if you'd like you can add a
- 11:49ton if you want but I don't see any need
- 11:50for more than eight or nine but yeah I
- 11:52have 0.3 millimeters on here as well so
- 11:55this is a nice one if you want a little
- 11:56bit more of a I guess a premium feeling
- 12:00wdt tool and it's got magnets on the end
- 12:03so you can kind of shove it on your
- 12:04machine or hang it somewhere and it's
- 12:06it's really nice I actually usually
- 12:07stick it
- 12:08on the side of my machine like that just
- 12:10a little all right I'm done boom which
- 12:12is kind of nice I like that but this
- 12:15this does the job just as well so don't
- 12:17feel the need to go spend money in fact
- 12:18you could take a wine cork take a really
- 12:21thin drill bit drill some holes in it
- 12:22and shove acupuncture needles in there
- 12:24the most important part of this is
- 12:26definitely the thickness or thinness I
- 12:27should say of the needles I prefer 0.3
- 12:30millimeters but I would suggest no less
- 12:34than about .22 or 0.25 and no more than
- 12:370.4 I've actually found there's some
- 12:39inconsistency at 0.4 so I usually don't
- 12:42like above 0.35 but 0.4 is a pretty
- 12:44universally used one and so I don't want
- 12:46you to throw that out if you have it I
- 12:48do think it's it's sufficient I just
- 12:49think it's a little better when if you
- 12:51get a little thinner and if you think
- 12:53that it's a little too dainty for your
- 12:54coffee you can just make them a little
- 12:56shorter as I did here anyway now let's
- 12:59get on to what I think is the best
- 13:00technique there are three techniques
- 13:02that have kind of been shown over the
- 13:03years uh the the first one would that I
- 13:06would that I'll talk about is Puck
- 13:07raking this is simply you're grinding
- 13:09from a grinder that's very low clumpage
- 13:11and you're just kind of scraping the top
- 13:14kind of raking it as you see right there
- 13:15and the idea here is the the Grinder's
- 13:18not really producing clumps so it should
- 13:20distribute pretty pretty evenly in the
- 13:22portafilter into the basket and all
- 13:24you're really having to do is level off
- 13:25of the top now the second one would just
- 13:28be called Deep wdt this is just getting
- 13:30down all the way at the bottom of the
- 13:32basket just kind of stirring the mess
- 13:34out of it now we're really making this
- 13:35fluid we're stirring it stirring it
- 13:37stirring it and boom we've got our
- 13:38concoction we're good to go and then the
- 13:40last one is one that I started to do
- 13:43um I don't know a few years back and at
- 13:46the time I hadn't seen anyone else doing
- 13:47this but since then I've seen a lot of
- 13:49people doing this which is great but I
- 13:51started calling it in my first WT video
- 13:53wdt video which is linked right here
- 13:56the audio in it is awful but you feel
- 13:59free to watch it
- 14:01um I started doing this style here and I
- 14:02call it Earth and Sun technique now the
- 14:04reason I call it that is because with my
- 14:07tool I'm doing small rotations they're
- 14:09not technically rotations rotation would
- 14:11look like this of course but they're
- 14:12small rotations
- 14:14and one big revolution so kind of how
- 14:16the Earth is revolving around the sun
- 14:18while also rotating we're doing small
- 14:21rotations
- 14:23with a revolution we start at the bottom
- 14:26of the basket and then we slowly come up
- 14:28you see I'm coming up and up and up and
- 14:30up what this is going to allow is nice
- 14:33even homogeneity from the bottom all the
- 14:35way to the top including the center
- 14:37portion so you're really stirring it all
- 14:39together slowly coming up so that
- 14:41everything is as homogenized as possible
- 14:43so once you have done this once you have
- 14:46done all the little revolutions little
- 14:48rotations little rotation
- 14:51um all you're going to do is do a little
- 14:52tap on the table to kind of collapse
- 14:54because it's going to get fluffy this is
- 14:55going to get real fluffy it's going to
- 14:57be exploding like popcorn out of that
- 14:59basket so you're gonna go a little tap
- 15:02tap tickly lap and what's going to
- 15:04happen is it's going to flatten the bed
- 15:05down it's going to kind of collapse any
- 15:07of those gaps in those air pockets that
- 15:09have formed from you
- 15:11all the way up now of course feel free
- 15:14to experiment with those three that I
- 15:15named but to ensure the Jonathan gagne
- 15:18has made created an article about a year
- 15:21ago or so I can't remember when he did
- 15:22this but he showed the the the
- 15:24superiority of Deep wdt Over Puck raking
- 15:27uh just because even if you have a clump
- 15:29free grinder it's always more
- 15:31advantageous to get all the way to the
- 15:32bottom to really homogenize the ground
- 15:34so take a look at that but to me that
- 15:37already rolls out Puck raking I want as
- 15:39much consistency as possible if I'm
- 15:40going to take the hassle of doing the
- 15:42little rotation Revolution
- 15:44easy tests that you can do at home is
- 15:46you can pull five shots in a row with
- 15:47your coffee completely dialed in and
- 15:49note the times that your target recipe
- 15:51is hit and then get your wdt do five
- 15:55shots in a row doing it and you should
- 15:57see a slower extraction by a couple of
- 15:59seconds the slower the extraction is
- 16:01kind of showing you that you have a more
- 16:03even extraction it's not flying out of
- 16:05any of the channels so that should
- 16:07really kind of be a good signifier of
- 16:09that and now this is this is kind of a
- 16:10test that I I heard from Scott Rayo he's
- 16:12one who really popularized wdt in the
- 16:15coffee professional World a couple of
- 16:16years back so before then it had been
- 16:19kind of resisted and I think that's why
- 16:20there wasn't much evolution in the
- 16:22practice for a while because it was kind
- 16:24of spotty with home users there were a
- 16:25lot of them doing it but there wasn't a
- 16:28ton of innovation in the ways it's been
- 16:29in the last couple of years and I think
- 16:31that's because it's now on the Forefront
- 16:33of the consciousness of the masses due
- 16:35to Scott rayo's kind of infamy in the
- 16:37coffee world
- 16:38and I think the reason for the
- 16:41um
- 16:42hesitancy to adopt this on bar and in
- 16:45coffee shops is because it's a little
- 16:46impractical for shops to wdt every shot
- 16:49so it was not even thought about I never
- 16:51thought about adding it to the shop I
- 16:53started up when I was in Memphis
- 16:54Tennessee because it just was
- 16:56Impractical so
- 16:57I think as we are learning how to make
- 17:00this more adequate for bar flow we
- 17:02should be able to be seeing this more
- 17:04often in shops and hopefully have much
- 17:06better espresso a lot of people have
- 17:08implemented those spinning levelers well
- 17:10hopefully with this Auto comb that's
- 17:12coming out we'll have something else
- 17:13that we can Implement on bar and the
- 17:15shot quality and consistency should be
- 17:17going through the roof
- 17:18so
- 17:20go ahead give this a try let me know
- 17:23down below if you see any difference or
- 17:24if you've already been practicing if
- 17:26you've learned something from this video
- 17:27I would really appreciate a like a share
- 17:29a subscribe you know check out my
- 17:31patreon below but I I love making these
- 17:34videos I love making them for you and I
- 17:35love conversing in the comments below
- 17:37let me know your thoughts on this let's
- 17:40chat anyway in the meantime I hope that
- 17:43you brew something tasty
- 17:44and cheers
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of WTF is WDT: History, Evolution, and Current Trends of the Weiss Distribution Technique by Lance Hedrick, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 3,483 words across 486 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.