YouTube2Text

WTF is WDT: History, Evolution, and Current Trends of the Weiss Distribution Technique — Transcript

by Lance Hedrick · 3,483 words · 486 segments · language en · Watch on YouTube

Full transcript

  1. 0:00foreign
  2. 0:08think come on John wise think what can I
  3. 0:12do to make a more even extraction
  4. 0:16stock flip doesn't work north south east
  5. 0:18west doesn't work none of these finger
  6. 0:20distributions work
  7. 0:22I've got to think of something maybe
  8. 0:24this acupuncture session will help me
  9. 0:25think think dang it
  10. 0:31[Music]
  11. 0:37workplace Park
  12. 0:44oh
  13. 0:55it works
  14. 0:57[Music]
  15. 1:10foreign
  16. 1:18[Music]
  17. 1:31distribution is the foundation for even
  18. 1:33extraction and even extraction is the
  19. 1:36foundation for excellence in the cup now
  20. 1:39this is a quote from an exchange I saw
  21. 1:41between John Weiss and another user on
  22. 1:43the home Barista Forum dating back to
  23. 1:452006. the Weiss distribution technique
  24. 1:48has now been heralded as probably the
  25. 1:50most important part of preparation in
  26. 1:52order to ensure consistency and even
  27. 1:54extraction but what's the history of it
  28. 1:57and what is the best way to do it today
  29. 2:00so let's get into that because I
  30. 2:02recently have done a lot of deep diving
  31. 2:04in order to understand the history and
  32. 2:06the evolution of the Weiss distribution
  33. 2:07technique in 2005 John Weiss a home
  34. 2:11Barista was on a form called coffee geek
  35. 2:14that is now defunct and was talking
  36. 2:15about experiences he was having using
  37. 2:18medically precise needles in order to
  38. 2:20de-clump and homogenize his bed of
  39. 2:22grounds before making espresso now at
  40. 2:25that time most of the Grinders out on
  41. 2:27the market were considered Clump
  42. 2:29monsters meaning that they were just
  43. 2:30producing a lot of clumps and it was
  44. 2:32impossible to properly distribute these
  45. 2:34clumps in order to make an even bed so
  46. 2:37the popular styles of distribution at
  47. 2:39the time which would include the stock
  48. 2:41fluff method and north south east west
  49. 2:43which I'll show you right now these
  50. 2:46methods were not sufficient to properly
  51. 2:49distribute the full bed of ground so you
  52. 2:50were Distributing the top layer but not
  53. 2:52really the bottom and considering all
  54. 2:54the clumps that was a big issue and was
  55. 2:57causing a lot of channels and a lot of
  56. 2:58frustrated home users so he took to
  57. 3:01these medically precise needles in order
  58. 3:03to do this job for him so he would take
  59. 3:06them and he would put them down and he
  60. 3:07was essentially stirring the grounds in
  61. 3:09order to ensure that they were declumped
  62. 3:11and homogenized and this led to that
  63. 3:13even extraction which he says is the
  64. 3:15foundation for excellence in the cup a
  65. 3:18quote that is 17 years old but which I
  66. 3:20thoroughly agree with the following year
  67. 3:22in 2006 John Weiss moved this
  68. 3:24conversation over to the brand new home
  69. 3:26Barista forum and on there that's when
  70. 3:29you kind of see and an adoption of this
  71. 3:32this sort of technique and the evolution
  72. 3:35of it to what it is today now along the
  73. 3:37way there are pitfalls there were
  74. 3:38regressions in my opinion like using
  75. 3:40toothpicks or uh using a I don't know
  76. 3:43things that are like Forks essentially
  77. 3:45just really anything that would bust
  78. 3:47clumps but people weren't taken into
  79. 3:49account the negative impact some of
  80. 3:51these tools could have on their bed so
  81. 3:53instead of improving it the way that he
  82. 3:55was with medically precise needles
  83. 3:57people were taking a cheaper more
  84. 3:59accessible way to replicate what he was
  85. 4:01doing assuming it was doing the same
  86. 4:03thing when in reality they were just
  87. 4:05creating massive pits in their bed which
  88. 4:07is going to cause channeling so it's a
  89. 4:09little counterproductive but as years
  90. 4:11continue to go on there were positive
  91. 4:13innovations that were brought to the
  92. 4:15table and now we have landed at what I
  93. 4:17think is near the top of what this uh
  94. 4:20this technique is supposed to be doing
  95. 4:22to your coffee now before we continue I
  96. 4:25want to say that this technique while I
  97. 4:26do think it is an imperative technique
  98. 4:28to adopt in your home routine it is not
  99. 4:31going to maximize your extraction to the
  100. 4:33point of you have a three percent bump
  101. 4:35or some sort of massive increase in
  102. 4:37extraction perhaps you will if you have
  103. 4:39a really clumpy grinder and this could
  104. 4:41really help homogenize the grounds but a
  105. 4:43lot of Grinders nowadays are not that
  106. 4:44clumpy and so really what you're just
  107. 4:46doing is homogenizing your bed and
  108. 4:48increasing your extraction efficiency
  109. 4:50and consistency less wasted coffee less
  110. 4:53wasty more tasty right right what we
  111. 4:56have over those years is this Evolution
  112. 4:57and so now we are at these these Cool
  113. 5:00Tools which we'll go over here in a
  114. 5:02second to get the technique and what my
  115. 5:04recommendations are as far as needle
  116. 5:05size spread Etc
  117. 5:08but first I want to go over my own
  118. 5:09adventure with wdt the Weiss
  119. 5:11distribution technique in 2016 I
  120. 5:13stumbled upon a coffee shop in my
  121. 5:15hometown of Chattanooga Tennessee this
  122. 5:17shop was called Revelator it's no longer
  123. 5:19there but the Barista was grinding his
  124. 5:22coffee and into a dosing cup and then he
  125. 5:25had a toothpick and he was sitting there
  126. 5:26stirring the grounds and I was intrigued
  127. 5:28by this and asked him what he was doing
  128. 5:29and he said well I'm de-clumping I'm
  129. 5:31taking these clumps that my grinder is
  130. 5:33creating and I'm breaking them and then
  131. 5:35he put it in the portafilter and then he
  132. 5:36tamped and pulled the shot and I was
  133. 5:38intrigued by this I'd never seen it
  134. 5:40before now mind you this was early in my
  135. 5:42I guess coffee loving career and I had
  136. 5:45not distembled upon the homebreast to
  137. 5:47form so this was a brand new technique
  138. 5:48I'd never seen so I began to adopt it
  139. 5:50just on occasion when I was at the at my
  140. 5:53shop in order to see what it would do
  141. 5:55but I never really saw much improvement
  142. 5:57with a toothpick so I I abandoned it
  143. 6:00pretty quickly and didn't touch it again
  144. 6:01until around the fall of 2019 that's
  145. 6:04when I began to see this push for using
  146. 6:07more precise instruments like
  147. 6:08acupuncture needles and that's what
  148. 6:10these are
  149. 6:12right here
  150. 6:14so the use of acupuncture needles in
  151. 6:16order to perform this wise distribution
  152. 6:19technique
  153. 6:20and so once I began to see that I went
  154. 6:22ahead purchased some on my own and began
  155. 6:24to experiment at home now the difference
  156. 6:26I saw between this and what I had been
  157. 6:29doing was drastic now to quickly go over
  158. 6:31what I was doing what I found to be the
  159. 6:33best way to distribute the grounds was
  160. 6:35not using a leveler or a distributor as
  161. 6:37they're called these levelers and what I
  162. 6:39mean by that are those little spinny
  163. 6:41tools that you put on your bed you spin
  164. 6:42it and it flattens the top they actually
  165. 6:44in my opinion in my testing do a little
  166. 6:47more harm than good now they might be
  167. 6:49okay in a bar setting because it will
  168. 6:51negate inconsistency from Barista to
  169. 6:53Barista but you're not doing anything to
  170. 6:55the bottom part of that Puck and on top
  171. 6:57of that you're compressing certain parts
  172. 6:59more than others with that initial push
  173. 7:01down and that's going to cause problems
  174. 7:03with channeling so I've never been a fan
  175. 7:05of that and in fact I loved a a study
  176. 7:08that Barista hustle did years back
  177. 7:09showing what the the most extraction you
  178. 7:12can get using the distribution Methods
  179. 7:14at the time were and they did not
  180. 7:15include Weiss distribution but at the
  181. 7:17time horizontal tapping or to taking
  182. 7:20your portafilter and tapping on the
  183. 7:22sides to kind of shake the grounds into
  184. 7:24place seem to be the most consistent and
  185. 7:27efficient way of Distributing the
  186. 7:28grounds and that's what the public the
  187. 7:30study was uh found to be I've been a
  188. 7:32huge proponent of this horizontal
  189. 7:34tapping technique because of that study
  190. 7:36and because of my own experiences but
  191. 7:38again in 2019 I rediscovered the wdt and
  192. 7:41kind of the evolved form it had become
  193. 7:43over the past 15 years at that point now
  194. 7:46what might be fun is if you all are
  195. 7:48interested I do have below a link to the
  196. 7:50original kind of discourse on home
  197. 7:52Barista about the about the Weiss
  198. 7:54distribution technique John Weiss his
  199. 7:56own comments are there you can go
  200. 7:57through and read them his username is
  201. 7:59rapid coffee on there and so go check
  202. 8:02that out anyway now let's go and talk
  203. 8:04about how should we pick our tool what
  204. 8:06should we be looking for in a tool and
  205. 8:08how to actually observe this technique
  206. 8:11most efficiently so of course I have a
  207. 8:13few options here this one right here
  208. 8:15came from wug 2 so the grinder that I'll
  209. 8:18be doing review on soon this is the wdt
  210. 8:21they sent this is from swarks Design
  211. 8:23This is Sheldon Wong's design for a wdt
  212. 8:26tool then you have this I'm not sure who
  213. 8:29designed it but it's a 3D printed little
  214. 8:31tool and then you have this one which is
  215. 8:33made by Jay Kim again this is going to
  216. 8:35be linked in the caption below but this
  217. 8:37is a this is a 3D printed one that comes
  218. 8:40out in a little card a little business
  219. 8:41card you just break it apart and you
  220. 8:43build the wdt yourself it comes with a
  221. 8:45little pack of needles which is great so
  222. 8:47here these are some of the options of
  223. 8:49course a lot of These are 3D printed
  224. 8:51whoops this one is is pretty expensive
  225. 8:54for for what it is but you have
  226. 8:57different options and then you have of
  227. 8:58course the ones on Amazon with the
  228. 8:59little Loops at the end you have really
  229. 9:02thick needles you have ones with three
  230. 9:04needles ones with 12 needles you have
  231. 9:06the spinny ones which one should you buy
  232. 9:08well currently in my opinion the spinny
  233. 9:11ones none of them yet hit the mark for
  234. 9:14what I think is the best of what you can
  235. 9:16do with wdt now there is one coming out
  236. 9:18soon by Barista hustle which is which
  237. 9:20will be called the auto comb I have a
  238. 9:22lot of Hope in that one and so we'll see
  239. 9:24it hopefully in Q2 of 2023 that will be
  240. 9:26released hopefully this video ages well
  241. 9:28and it's out by then but
  242. 9:30anyway uh so what do we have when it
  243. 9:32comes to these tools what what is what
  244. 9:33do I think is the best what uh have I
  245. 9:35found the best results with well
  246. 9:37something with something like this I
  247. 9:40have not have not enjoyed so this has
  248. 9:42massive needles these are probably 0.5
  249. 9:44or 0.6 millimeters so really really
  250. 9:47thick relative relatively speaking and
  251. 9:50there's only a five needle spread so
  252. 9:52this doesn't really give me the motion
  253. 9:54in the bed that I really want
  254. 9:55essentially I want to be wdting so
  255. 9:58quickly and with such Precision that the
  256. 10:01bed turns a little fluid and that is
  257. 10:02what is ideal to kind of push everything
  258. 10:04into place right
  259. 10:07um he's got fluid uh any scrubs fans out
  260. 10:09there no okay
  261. 10:11um anyway so I'm this one I don't really
  262. 10:14I really like now this is another one
  263. 10:17that I got uh someone sent me this I
  264. 10:19think the angles on this are a little
  265. 10:20too drastic uh for my for my uh desires
  266. 10:24this and there's only five needles again
  267. 10:26there is a center needle which is a nice
  268. 10:27touch uh to kind of help with the
  269. 10:30spacing but
  270. 10:31um you know it's just it's not I don't
  271. 10:34really like it
  272. 10:36next we have these two these are my two
  273. 10:38favorite wdt tools as they stand on the
  274. 10:40current market this one because it's so
  275. 10:43cheap I actually have a video dedicated
  276. 10:44to this linked right there at its um at
  277. 10:47its first release Jay Kim was selling
  278. 10:49them for a dollar each and then you paid
  279. 10:51shipping but he got inundated with
  280. 10:53orders and had to change that I think
  281. 10:54his dad is now running that site so if
  282. 10:56you want to order you can check that
  283. 10:57below but it is more expensive now
  284. 10:59because it is his dad doing it
  285. 11:01um but you can also find this on uh
  286. 11:03online and you can print it yourself and
  287. 11:05just buy acupuncture needles and then
  288. 11:07whatever your cost is you're good to go
  289. 11:09so I love this one I think the spacing
  290. 11:11is really nice when the needles are at
  291. 11:13their full length of what He suggests
  292. 11:15with it it has a around a 29 millimeter
  293. 11:17diameter and the reason for that is
  294. 11:19that's half of a 58 millimeter
  295. 11:21portafilter so you can when you put it
  296. 11:23in and it's touching the wall it should
  297. 11:24be to the center so as your wdt you can
  298. 11:27make sure you're hitting all sides of
  299. 11:28that portafilter with your uh with your
  300. 11:30motions uh I've actually cut these a
  301. 11:32little shorter I like thinner needles
  302. 11:34that are shorter but we'll get to that
  303. 11:35in a second this is Sheldon's from
  304. 11:37Swartz design
  305. 11:39so this one has the capability of adding
  306. 11:42or lessening needles you can take a tool
  307. 11:44to loosen right here and you can add
  308. 11:47more needles if you'd like you can add a
  309. 11:49ton if you want but I don't see any need
  310. 11:50for more than eight or nine but yeah I
  311. 11:52have 0.3 millimeters on here as well so
  312. 11:55this is a nice one if you want a little
  313. 11:56bit more of a I guess a premium feeling
  314. 12:00wdt tool and it's got magnets on the end
  315. 12:03so you can kind of shove it on your
  316. 12:04machine or hang it somewhere and it's
  317. 12:06it's really nice I actually usually
  318. 12:07stick it
  319. 12:08on the side of my machine like that just
  320. 12:10a little all right I'm done boom which
  321. 12:12is kind of nice I like that but this
  322. 12:15this does the job just as well so don't
  323. 12:17feel the need to go spend money in fact
  324. 12:18you could take a wine cork take a really
  325. 12:21thin drill bit drill some holes in it
  326. 12:22and shove acupuncture needles in there
  327. 12:24the most important part of this is
  328. 12:26definitely the thickness or thinness I
  329. 12:27should say of the needles I prefer 0.3
  330. 12:30millimeters but I would suggest no less
  331. 12:34than about .22 or 0.25 and no more than
  332. 12:370.4 I've actually found there's some
  333. 12:39inconsistency at 0.4 so I usually don't
  334. 12:42like above 0.35 but 0.4 is a pretty
  335. 12:44universally used one and so I don't want
  336. 12:46you to throw that out if you have it I
  337. 12:48do think it's it's sufficient I just
  338. 12:49think it's a little better when if you
  339. 12:51get a little thinner and if you think
  340. 12:53that it's a little too dainty for your
  341. 12:54coffee you can just make them a little
  342. 12:56shorter as I did here anyway now let's
  343. 12:59get on to what I think is the best
  344. 13:00technique there are three techniques
  345. 13:02that have kind of been shown over the
  346. 13:03years uh the the first one would that I
  347. 13:06would that I'll talk about is Puck
  348. 13:07raking this is simply you're grinding
  349. 13:09from a grinder that's very low clumpage
  350. 13:11and you're just kind of scraping the top
  351. 13:14kind of raking it as you see right there
  352. 13:15and the idea here is the the Grinder's
  353. 13:18not really producing clumps so it should
  354. 13:20distribute pretty pretty evenly in the
  355. 13:22portafilter into the basket and all
  356. 13:24you're really having to do is level off
  357. 13:25of the top now the second one would just
  358. 13:28be called Deep wdt this is just getting
  359. 13:30down all the way at the bottom of the
  360. 13:32basket just kind of stirring the mess
  361. 13:34out of it now we're really making this
  362. 13:35fluid we're stirring it stirring it
  363. 13:37stirring it and boom we've got our
  364. 13:38concoction we're good to go and then the
  365. 13:40last one is one that I started to do
  366. 13:43um I don't know a few years back and at
  367. 13:46the time I hadn't seen anyone else doing
  368. 13:47this but since then I've seen a lot of
  369. 13:49people doing this which is great but I
  370. 13:51started calling it in my first WT video
  371. 13:53wdt video which is linked right here
  372. 13:56the audio in it is awful but you feel
  373. 13:59free to watch it
  374. 14:01um I started doing this style here and I
  375. 14:02call it Earth and Sun technique now the
  376. 14:04reason I call it that is because with my
  377. 14:07tool I'm doing small rotations they're
  378. 14:09not technically rotations rotation would
  379. 14:11look like this of course but they're
  380. 14:12small rotations
  381. 14:14and one big revolution so kind of how
  382. 14:16the Earth is revolving around the sun
  383. 14:18while also rotating we're doing small
  384. 14:21rotations
  385. 14:23with a revolution we start at the bottom
  386. 14:26of the basket and then we slowly come up
  387. 14:28you see I'm coming up and up and up and
  388. 14:30up what this is going to allow is nice
  389. 14:33even homogeneity from the bottom all the
  390. 14:35way to the top including the center
  391. 14:37portion so you're really stirring it all
  392. 14:39together slowly coming up so that
  393. 14:41everything is as homogenized as possible
  394. 14:43so once you have done this once you have
  395. 14:46done all the little revolutions little
  396. 14:48rotations little rotation
  397. 14:51um all you're going to do is do a little
  398. 14:52tap on the table to kind of collapse
  399. 14:54because it's going to get fluffy this is
  400. 14:55going to get real fluffy it's going to
  401. 14:57be exploding like popcorn out of that
  402. 14:59basket so you're gonna go a little tap
  403. 15:02tap tickly lap and what's going to
  404. 15:04happen is it's going to flatten the bed
  405. 15:05down it's going to kind of collapse any
  406. 15:07of those gaps in those air pockets that
  407. 15:09have formed from you
  408. 15:11all the way up now of course feel free
  409. 15:14to experiment with those three that I
  410. 15:15named but to ensure the Jonathan gagne
  411. 15:18has made created an article about a year
  412. 15:21ago or so I can't remember when he did
  413. 15:22this but he showed the the the
  414. 15:24superiority of Deep wdt Over Puck raking
  415. 15:27uh just because even if you have a clump
  416. 15:29free grinder it's always more
  417. 15:31advantageous to get all the way to the
  418. 15:32bottom to really homogenize the ground
  419. 15:34so take a look at that but to me that
  420. 15:37already rolls out Puck raking I want as
  421. 15:39much consistency as possible if I'm
  422. 15:40going to take the hassle of doing the
  423. 15:42little rotation Revolution
  424. 15:44easy tests that you can do at home is
  425. 15:46you can pull five shots in a row with
  426. 15:47your coffee completely dialed in and
  427. 15:49note the times that your target recipe
  428. 15:51is hit and then get your wdt do five
  429. 15:55shots in a row doing it and you should
  430. 15:57see a slower extraction by a couple of
  431. 15:59seconds the slower the extraction is
  432. 16:01kind of showing you that you have a more
  433. 16:03even extraction it's not flying out of
  434. 16:05any of the channels so that should
  435. 16:07really kind of be a good signifier of
  436. 16:09that and now this is this is kind of a
  437. 16:10test that I I heard from Scott Rayo he's
  438. 16:12one who really popularized wdt in the
  439. 16:15coffee professional World a couple of
  440. 16:16years back so before then it had been
  441. 16:19kind of resisted and I think that's why
  442. 16:20there wasn't much evolution in the
  443. 16:22practice for a while because it was kind
  444. 16:24of spotty with home users there were a
  445. 16:25lot of them doing it but there wasn't a
  446. 16:28ton of innovation in the ways it's been
  447. 16:29in the last couple of years and I think
  448. 16:31that's because it's now on the Forefront
  449. 16:33of the consciousness of the masses due
  450. 16:35to Scott rayo's kind of infamy in the
  451. 16:37coffee world
  452. 16:38and I think the reason for the
  453. 16:41um
  454. 16:42hesitancy to adopt this on bar and in
  455. 16:45coffee shops is because it's a little
  456. 16:46impractical for shops to wdt every shot
  457. 16:49so it was not even thought about I never
  458. 16:51thought about adding it to the shop I
  459. 16:53started up when I was in Memphis
  460. 16:54Tennessee because it just was
  461. 16:56Impractical so
  462. 16:57I think as we are learning how to make
  463. 17:00this more adequate for bar flow we
  464. 17:02should be able to be seeing this more
  465. 17:04often in shops and hopefully have much
  466. 17:06better espresso a lot of people have
  467. 17:08implemented those spinning levelers well
  468. 17:10hopefully with this Auto comb that's
  469. 17:12coming out we'll have something else
  470. 17:13that we can Implement on bar and the
  471. 17:15shot quality and consistency should be
  472. 17:17going through the roof
  473. 17:18so
  474. 17:20go ahead give this a try let me know
  475. 17:23down below if you see any difference or
  476. 17:24if you've already been practicing if
  477. 17:26you've learned something from this video
  478. 17:27I would really appreciate a like a share
  479. 17:29a subscribe you know check out my
  480. 17:31patreon below but I I love making these
  481. 17:34videos I love making them for you and I
  482. 17:35love conversing in the comments below
  483. 17:37let me know your thoughts on this let's
  484. 17:40chat anyway in the meantime I hope that
  485. 17:43you brew something tasty
  486. 17:44and cheers

About this transcript

This page contains the full transcript of WTF is WDT: History, Evolution, and Current Trends of the Weiss Distribution Technique by Lance Hedrick, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 3,483 words across 486 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.

What you can do with it

Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.

Free YouTube transcript tool

YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.