Why You're Still Confusing Be, Been & Being (And How to Fix It) — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:00Making [music] English easy for
- 0:01everyone.
- 0:02>> Speak English with Jay and May.
- 0:05>> Hey English learners, welcome back to
- 0:08Speak English with Jay and May, your
- 0:11cozy little place to build your English
- 0:13confidence. I'm May.
- 0:15>> Hello May, and hello everyone. I'm Jay.
- 0:19How are you today, May?
- 0:20>> I'm doing really well, Jay. Thanks for
- 0:22asking. How about you? You look like
- 0:25something's on your mind today.
- 0:27>> [laughter]
- 0:27>> Actually, yes. So, this morning I was
- 0:30texting my friend and I wrote, "I've
- 0:33been so busy lately." And she sent me
- 0:36back a question mark. Just one question
- 0:38mark. And I thought, "Wait, did I say
- 0:41something wrong?"
- 0:43>> [laughter]
- 0:43>> Oh, Jay. Yes, that's actually a really
- 0:46common mistake. It should be I have been
- 0:50so busy, or I've been so busy. You were
- 0:54missing the have.
- 0:55>> See, that's exactly what I mean. Be,
- 0:59been, being. I never know which one to
- 1:02use or when. It drives me crazy.
- 1:05>> You know what? I think so many of our
- 1:07listeners feel exactly the same way. So,
- 1:10today that's exactly what we're going to
- 1:13fix. Be, been, and being. By the end of
- 1:17this episode, it's going to feel totally
- 1:20natural.
- 1:21>> I cannot wait. Let's do this.
- 1:24>> Oh, yes. But before we dive in, if this
- 1:27podcast is helping you learn English in
- 1:29a fun and easy way, please subscribe,
- 1:33turn on notifications, and share it with
- 1:35a friend who's learning English, too. We
- 1:38make a new episode every single day, so
- 1:41you never run out of practice.
- 1:43>> Every day, people. Every day. Okay, May.
- 1:46Let's do this. So, be, been, being.
- 1:51Three words. They look similar. They
- 1:53sound related, but they're different,
- 1:55right?
- 1:56>> Exactly. Think of them like three
- 1:59members of the same family. Same last
- 2:02name, B, but each one has a different
- 2:05job.
- 2:06>> Oh, I like that. Same family, different
- 2:09jobs. Okay, so who's the first family
- 2:12member?
- 2:13>> The first one is B, and B is kind of the
- 2:17boss of the family. It's the base form,
- 2:20the root word. You use it in sentences
- 2:22like, I want to be happy, or she needs
- 2:26to be here by 8.
- 2:28>> Oh, okay. So, B comes after words like
- 2:32want to or need to?
- 2:34>> Yes, or after modal verbs like will,
- 2:38can, should, or must. So, you'd say, you
- 2:42should be careful, or it will be okay.
- 2:45>> Got it. So, B is the one that hangs out
- 2:48with those helper words.
- 2:51>> Exactly. And here's a simple way to
- 2:53remember it. Whenever you use a modal
- 2:56verb, the next verb is always the base
- 2:59form, and B is the base form of this
- 3:02whole family.
- 3:04>> Okay, okay. So, B, base form, after
- 3:08modal verbs.
- 3:10Now, what about been? This one confuses
- 3:13me the most, honestly.
- 3:15>> [laughter]
- 3:15>> You and every English learner on the
- 3:17planet. Okay, so been is the past
- 3:21participle, and the thing about been is
- 3:24it never works alone. It always needs a
- 3:27helper.
- 3:29>> You mean like it needs a buddy?
- 3:31>> Yes, a buddy. Specifically, it needs
- 3:34have, has, or had. So, you'd say, I have
- 3:39been busy, or she has been waiting, or
- 3:42we had been friends for years.
- 3:46>> Oh, so been is never by itself. It
- 3:49always needs have, has, or had before
- 3:53it.
- 3:54>> Right, and this is where people make
- 3:57that common mistake, like what Jay did
- 3:59this morning, saying, I've been busy,
- 4:02instead of I have been busy. The have
- 4:05got dropped.
- 4:07>> Yes, that was exactly my mistake. So,
- 4:10the have just disappears, and then the
- 4:12sentence sounds off.
- 4:14>> Exactly. In casual speech, people
- 4:17sometimes say, I've been. The have is
- 4:20shortened to v, but it has to be there
- 4:23in some form.
- 4:25>> Wait, so I've been is correct, because
- 4:28I've is I have.
- 4:31>> Yes, perfect. I've been is totally
- 4:35correct. I been, without the apostrophe
- 4:38v, that's the mistake.
- 4:40>> Okay, this is making so much sense now.
- 4:43So, been is past participle, needs a
- 4:46helper verb, and that helper is have,
- 4:49has, or had. Got it.
- 4:52>> You're getting it. Now, here's the
- 4:54interesting part. Been also tells us
- 4:57something important about time. It
- 5:00usually means something started in the
- 5:02past and has some connection to now, or
- 5:06it lasted for a period of time.
- 5:08>> Like what? Can you give me a real
- 5:10example?
- 5:11>> Sure.
- 5:13Imagine you're on a phone call with your
- 5:15mom, and she asks, Where are you? And
- 5:19you say, I've been at the library all
- 5:22day.
- 5:23That means you were there earlier,
- 5:25you're still there now, or it just
- 5:28ended. It has that sense of a stretch of
- 5:32time.
- 5:32>> Oh, I love that. It's not just a single
- 5:35moment, it's like a stretch, like a
- 5:37ribbon of time.
- 5:39>> A ribbon of time. I'm using that from
- 5:42now on. Yes, exactly like that.
- 5:45>> [laughter]
- 5:46>> Okay, okay. So, now being, this is the
- 5:49mysterious one for me. When do we use
- 5:52being?
- 5:53>> So, being is the present participle, or
- 5:57we can also call it the ing form of be.
- 6:01And it has two main uses. First, it
- 6:04works with is, am, are, was, were to
- 6:09talk about something happening right now
- 6:12or in progress.
- 6:13>> Like, she is being weird.
- 6:16>> Yes, perfect example. She is being weird
- 6:20means right now, in this moment, her
- 6:22behavior is weird. It's ongoing. It's
- 6:25happening as we speak.
- 6:28>> Okay, so the difference between she is
- 6:30weird and she is being weird, what's
- 6:33that exactly?
- 6:35>> Oh, great question. She is weird is
- 6:38permanent, like that's just her
- 6:40personality. But she is being weird is
- 6:43temporary. Something is off today
- 6:46specifically.
- 6:47>> Whoa, that's such a big difference from
- 6:49such a small change.
- 6:51>> I know, right? That little word being
- 6:54completely changes the meaning. It makes
- 6:57the behavior temporary instead of
- 6:59permanent.
- 7:00>> Okay, so if my friend is acting strange
- 7:02today, I say, she is being weird. But if
- 7:06she's always like that, I say, she is
- 7:09weird.
- 7:10>> Exactly. You've got it. And honestly,
- 7:13native speakers use this all the time
- 7:15without even thinking about it.
- 7:18>> Wow, okay. So, that's the first use of
- 7:20being. What's the second one?
- 7:22>> The second use is in passive sentences.
- 7:25So, when something is done to the
- 7:28subject, like the cake is being eaten,
- 7:31or the house is being painted.
- 7:34>> You mean like, the cake didn't eat
- 7:36itself, someone is eating it, but we're
- 7:38focusing on the cake.
- 7:41>> Yes, the cake is the star of the
- 7:43sentence, even though someone else is
- 7:46doing the action. That's passive voice,
- 7:49and being shows up a lot there.
- 7:52>> Okay, wait. Let me make sure I have this
- 7:54right. Being is the ing form of be, and
- 7:58it's used when something is ongoing or
- 8:01in a passive sentence, right?
- 8:03>> You summarized that beautifully.
- 8:06Honestly, Jay, you're on fire today.
- 8:09>> [laughter]
- 8:09>> Thank you. Okay, so let's do a quick
- 8:12recap before we go deeper. Be is the
- 8:15base form, used after modal verbs. Ben
- 8:19is past participle, used after have,
- 8:22has, had. And being is the ing form,
- 8:27used for ongoing or passive sentences.
- 8:30>> That is textbook perfect. Seriously.
- 8:33>> Okay, so now I want to practice. Can we
- 8:36go through some real situations, like
- 8:39real-life ones?
- 8:40>> Yes, that's my favorite part. Let's
- 8:43start with a scene. Imagine you wake up
- 8:46Monday morning. You're exhausted. You
- 8:49look at your phone, and you have 50
- 8:51unread messages from work.
- 8:53>> Oh, no. That's too real.
- 8:57>> So, you text your friend and say, "I
- 9:00have been so stressed lately." Which
- 9:03word are we using there?
- 9:04>> Been, with have before it, because it
- 9:07started in the past and it's still going
- 9:09on now.
- 9:10>> Perfect. Now your friend calls you and
- 9:13says, "You should be honest with your
- 9:16boss." Which word now?
- 9:18>> Be, because it's after should, a modal
- 9:21verb.
- 9:21>> Amazing. And then, your boss calls. And
- 9:25in the meeting, you notice your boss is
- 9:27acting unusually kind, like suspiciously
- 9:31kind.
- 9:33>> Uh-oh. What do I say?
- 9:35>> You whisper to your coworker, "Why is he
- 9:38being so nice today?"
- 9:40>> And that's being because it's temporary
- 9:42behavior happening right now.
- 9:45>> Yes, you got all three in one little
- 9:48story.
- 9:48>> That was so good. Oh my goodness. I feel
- 9:52like I've known these words my whole
- 9:53life but never understood them until
- 9:56right now.
- 9:57>> That's exactly how English works
- 9:59sometimes. You've heard the words a
- 10:01thousand times, but when someone
- 10:03explains the why, it just clicks.
- 10:07>> It really does. Okay, May, here's
- 10:09something I'm curious about. What are
- 10:11the most common mistakes people make
- 10:14with these three?
- 10:15>> Oh, there are a few. The biggest one,
- 10:18like we said, is I been instead of I
- 10:21have been or I've been. The helper verb
- 10:25goes missing.
- 10:26>> Yeah, and honestly, I made that mistake
- 10:28just this morning,
- 10:30even after learning English for years.
- 10:32>> Right, because in fast speech, have gets
- 10:36swallowed, but when you're writing or
- 10:38speaking carefully, it has to be there.
- 10:41>> What's the second mistake?
- 10:42>> Using being when you should use be.
- 10:46Like, someone might say, "You should
- 10:48being careful." That's wrong. After
- 10:51should, you need the base form. You
- 10:54should be careful.
- 10:55>> Oh, so being doesn't go after modal
- 10:59verbs.
- 11:00>> Never. Modal verbs always want the plain
- 11:03base form, be, not being, not been.
- 11:07>> That's such a helpful rule. So, after
- 11:10will, can, should, must, would, may,
- 11:14always be.
- 11:16>> Always. You can write that on a sticky
- 11:18note and put it on your wall. Modal verb
- 11:21plus be. Done.
- 11:23>> [laughter]
- 11:24>> I'm literally going to do that. Okay,
- 11:26what's another common mistake?
- 11:28>> This one is interesting, confusing have
- 11:31been and had been. Some people use them
- 11:34interchangeably, but they're a little
- 11:36different.
- 11:36>> You mean like I have been waiting versus
- 11:39I had been waiting?
- 11:41>> Exactly. I have been waiting, that
- 11:44connects to now. The waiting is recent
- 11:47or still relevant. I had been waiting,
- 11:50that's further back in the past. Like
- 11:53the waiting was finished before
- 11:55something else happened.
- 11:56>> Can you give me a story example?
- 11:58>> Sure. Imagine your friend was late to
- 12:01meet you at a restaurant. When they
- 12:03finally arrive, you say, "I have been
- 12:06waiting for an hour." Because it just
- 12:08ended, you're still feeling it.
- 12:10>> Right. The frustration is still fresh.
- 12:14>> But if you're telling the story later to
- 12:16someone else, you might say, "By the
- 12:18time she arrived, I had been waiting for
- 12:21an hour." Because now you're talking
- 12:24about two past moments, the arriving and
- 12:27the waiting before it.
- 12:28>> Oh. So, have been is connected to now or
- 12:32very recently, and had been is all in
- 12:36the past. One thing before another past
- 12:39thing.
- 12:39>> That is exactly right. You're really
- 12:42getting this today, Jay.
- 12:43>> I feel it. Okay, can we talk about being
- 12:46a little more? I feel like it's the most
- 12:48flexible one.
- 12:50>> It really is. And honestly, being is
- 12:53also used as a noun sometimes. Like a
- 12:57human being or a living being.
- 13:00>> Oh. So, being can mean a person or a
- 13:03creature.
- 13:04>> Yes. Being as a noun means an entity, a
- 13:08living thing. So, you might say, "Every
- 13:12human being deserves kindness."
- 13:15>> Wow. So, being does three jobs. It's
- 13:18used for ongoing actions, passive
- 13:20sentences, and it can even be a noun.
- 13:23>> Very busy word. Hardest working member
- 13:26of the family.
- 13:27>> [laughter]
- 13:28>> I love it. Okay, so I want to ask, for
- 13:30beginners who are just starting out,
- 13:33what's the one thing they should focus
- 13:35on first?
- 13:36>> Honestly, just start with be after modal
- 13:39verbs. That alone will fix so many
- 13:42sentences. If you can say, I want to be
- 13:45better, it will be fine, you should be
- 13:49careful, you're already ahead.
- 13:51>> So, start with be and the modal verbs,
- 13:54then move to been with have, has, had,
- 13:58and then being for ongoing things.
- 14:01>> Build it step by step. Don't try to
- 14:04master all three on the same day.
- 14:06English is a journey, not a race.
- 14:09>> I love that. English is a journey, not a
- 14:12race. Okay, May, one last thing. Can we
- 14:15do a quick fun little quiz for our
- 14:17listeners?
- 14:18>> Oh, yes, let's do it. Listeners, try to
- 14:21answer in your head before Jay says the
- 14:23answer.
- 14:24>> Okay, first one. Fill in the blank. She
- 14:27has blank working here for 10 years.
- 14:31>> Think about it.
- 14:32>> The answer is been. She has been working
- 14:35here for 10 years, because it's after
- 14:38has, a helper verb.
- 14:40>> Perfect. Next one. You must blank on
- 14:44time tomorrow.
- 14:46>> Listeners, what do you think?
- 14:47>> The answer is be. You must be on time
- 14:52tomorrow, because must is a modal verb.
- 14:55It needs the base form.
- 14:57>> And last one. The report blank written
- 15:00right now by the team.
- 15:02>> Hmm, this one's a little trickier.
- 15:05>> The answer is is being. The report is
- 15:08being written right now. That's passive
- 15:11voice. Something is happening to the
- 15:13report.
- 15:14>> Three words, three different jobs, and
- 15:17now they're officially part of your
- 15:19English toolkit. Be, been, being. You've
- 15:23got this.
- 15:25>> And honestly, once you understand why
- 15:27they're different, you stop guessing.
- 15:29You just know.
- 15:31>> That's the goal. Confidence, not
- 15:33memorization. We want you to feel it,
- 15:36not just repeat it.
- 15:37>> Okay, before we wrap up, May, any final
- 15:40thoughts for our listeners today?
- 15:42>> Yes, I want you to pick one sentence
- 15:45today, just one, and say it out loud.
- 15:48Use be, been, or being in it. Say it to
- 15:52yourself, say it to a friend, write it
- 15:54in the comments below. That small action
- 15:57is how fluency is built, one sentence at
- 16:00a time. [music]
- 16:01>> I love that. One sentence today. That's
- 16:04your homework, everyone.
- 16:05>> And speaking of comments, we have a
- 16:07question for you. Tell us in the
- 16:09comments which one confuses you the
- 16:12most, be, been, or being, and why. We
- 16:16read every single comment, and we love
- 16:18hearing from you.
- 16:19>> Every comment, people. May really does
- 16:22read them.
- 16:22>> I do.
- 16:24And if you enjoy learning English with
- 16:26us, please subscribe. Hit the like
- 16:28button, and share this episode with one
- 16:31friend who's learning English. It really
- 16:33helps us reach more learners around the
- 16:35world.
- 16:36>> And remember, we're here [music] every
- 16:38single day with a brand new episode. So,
- 16:40come back tomorrow and keep learning
- 16:42with us.
- 16:43>> Thank you so much for spending this time
- 16:45with us today. You're doing amazing.
- 16:48Just by showing up and listening, you're
- 16:50already better than you were yesterday.
- 16:53>> That's true. Every day, a little better.
- 16:55[music]
- 16:55We'll see you in the next one.
- 16:57>> Take care, English learners. Bye for
- 16:59now.
- 16:59>> Bye, everyone.
- 17:05>> [music]
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of Why You're Still Confusing Be, Been & Being (And How to Fix It) by Speak English with J & May, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 2,535 words across 406 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.