Why You’ll Never Actually Spend Your Retirement Savings (as a Canadian) — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:00After 13 years of helping Canadians
- 0:02retire, I can tell you something that's
- 0:04going to sound completely backwards. The
- 0:07most financially prepared retirees, the
- 0:10ones who saved diligently their whole
- 0:13lives and did everything right, are
- 0:15almost always the ones who end up dying
- 0:18with more money than they had the day
- 0:21they retired. And I'm usually not
- 0:24talking about a little bit more. I've
- 0:26sat across from clients in their 80s who
- 0:28have significantly more wealth than when
- 0:31they stopped working, despite spending
- 0:34from their portfolio for 20-plus years.
- 0:37And they're not the exception, they're
- 0:39actually much closer to the norm than
- 0:41you would realize. Now, most people hear
- 0:44this and think, "Well, that must be
- 0:46because the markets did really well, or
- 0:48they just got lucky about their timing."
- 0:50But that's not actually what's
- 0:52happening. What's actually happening is
- 0:54that there are three forces built into
- 0:56the Canadian retirement system that are
- 0:58making it almost impossible for
- 1:01well-prepared Canadians to actually
- 1:04spend down their savings. And most
- 1:06people have never had anyone walk them
- 1:08through these three forces. So, today, I
- 1:12want to show you exactly why this
- 1:13happens, what the research from five
- 1:16different countries actually says about
- 1:18it, and most importantly, at the end,
- 1:21what this should change about how you
- 1:23plan for your own retirement. Because if
- 1:25you understand these three forces,
- 1:27you'll stop losing sleep over whether
- 1:29you have enough, and start asking a much
- 1:32better question, which is whether you're
- 1:34actually using up what you've built. I'm
- 1:38Chad. I'm a certified financial planner
- 1:40here in Canada, and I've spent the last
- 1:4213 years helping Canadians figure this
- 1:45stuff out. Let's get into it.
- 1:49And quickly, if you're watching this and
- 1:51wondering whether your plan is set up to
- 1:53actually use your money instead of just
- 1:55protect it forever, there's a link in
- 1:58the description to book a call. Now, let
- 2:00me show you the very first force. Force
- 2:03number one, your government benefits
- 2:05cover way more than you think they will.
- 2:08The first force is one that I think
- 2:10catches a lot of people off guard more
- 2:12than anything else and it has to do with
- 2:14how much of your retirement spending is
- 2:16already covered before your portfolio
- 2:19contributes a single dollar. Most
- 2:21Canadians I sit down with have a rough
- 2:23idea of what CPP and OAS will pay them.
- 2:26They know it's something but they're
- 2:28never actually really sure of what the
- 2:30calculations will work out to and what
- 2:32the real spending of these benefits will
- 2:34actually cover. And when we run the math
- 2:37for the first time together, the
- 2:38reaction is almost always surprised to
- 2:40see exactly how much is actually
- 2:43covered. So, let's take a look at a
- 2:46couple. Let's say they're both 65. Let's
- 2:48say they each qualify for a strong CPP,
- 2:5190% of the maximum. Now, I want to be up
- 2:54front that this is higher than the
- 2:55national average. The average Canadian
- 2:58gets closer to about 60% of the maximum
- 3:01but for someone who has worked a steady
- 3:03career at a decent income for 30 to 35
- 3:06years, 90% is absolutely achievable and
- 3:10it's the kind of person I tend to see in
- 3:12my practice. So, let's use it to make
- 3:15this point. In 2026, the maximum CPP for
- 3:18someone age 65 is $1,508.
- 3:23So, 90% of that is $1,357.
- 3:26If this is a couple, now we're looking
- 3:28at $2,714
- 3:31just in CPP.
- 3:33Add in two full OAS's of $728
- 3:38each and now between CPP and OAS, this
- 3:41couple is bringing in roughly $4,170
- 3:45per month or about 50,000 per year
- 3:49before we've touched a single dollar of
- 3:52their savings. And that's if they take
- 3:54everything at 65. But if this couple
- 3:57delays their CPP to 70, something I
- 4:00recommend in the vast majority of my
- 4:02cases, that CPP income jumps by 42%.
- 4:07Their combined CPP goes from what was
- 4:102,714
- 4:12to now 3,854
- 4:15per month. If we're adding OAS back in
- 4:18starting at 65, this is now 5,310
- 4:23per month of government-backed income.
- 4:25That's over $63,000
- 4:27a year in guaranteed,
- 4:29inflation-protected,
- 4:31government-backed income. Now, let me
- 4:34ask you this. What does the average
- 4:36Canadian couple actually spend in
- 4:38retirement? When I sit down with clients
- 4:41and go through their real spending, not
- 4:43what they think they spend, but what
- 4:44they actually spend, most couples land
- 4:47somewhere between about 4,500 and 6,000
- 4:51per month. Some are obviously higher,
- 4:53some are obviously lower, but that range
- 4:55covers a huge portion of the Canadians
- 4:57that I work with.
- 4:59So, if this couple was bringing in
- 5:01$5,300 per month from the government,
- 5:04and their real spending is, let's say,
- 5:065,500 per month, the gap their portfolio
- 5:09needs to fill is only about 190 to 200
- 5:13per month, or $2,300
- 5:16per year. Using what I call Chad's
- 5:18ratio, which states that for every
- 5:20$1,000 per month you need in retirement
- 5:23from your portfolio, you need about 200
- 5:26to 250,000 dollars invested. This small
- 5:29$190 monthly gap requires somewhere
- 5:32between 40 to 50,000 dollars in savings
- 5:36to sustain. And yet this couple probably
- 5:40has around 500,000, maybe even a
- 5:42million, sitting in their accounts. They
- 5:45are funded for a gap that is a tiny
- 5:48fraction of what they've saved for. And
- 5:50this is force number one, the Canadian
- 5:53government benefit system, especially
- 5:55when you time CPP and OAS properly,
- 5:58covers way more of your retirement
- 6:00spending than most people ever realize.
- 6:03And because people don't run this math,
- 6:05they keep saving, and they keep
- 6:07protecting as if their portfolio needs
- 6:09to do all of the heavy lifting when in
- 6:12reality, in some cases, it barely even
- 6:15needs to show up. Force number two, your
- 6:18savings target is probably way too high.
- 6:21The second force is closely related to
- 6:23the first one, and it has to do with how
- 6:25people set their retirement savings
- 6:28target in the first place. If you've
- 6:30ever Googled, "How much do I need to
- 6:32retire in Canada?", you've probably seen
- 6:35numbers like 1 million, 1.5 million, or
- 6:37even 2 million thrown around. And those
- 6:39numbers feel authoritative, right? They
- 6:42show up in articles, in bank
- 6:44advertisements, and online calculators.
- 6:46So, you start to anchor to those
- 6:49numbers. But the problem is that those
- 6:51numbers are almost always based on a
- 6:54replacement ratio, meaning that they
- 6:56take your pre-retirement income and
- 6:58assume that you'll need 70 to 80% of
- 7:01that in retirement. And that assumption
- 7:03is where everything starts to go
- 7:05sideways. Your pre-retirement income
- 7:08includes a bunch of costs that disappear
- 7:10the day you stop working. You are no
- 7:12longer contributing to CPP. You're no
- 7:15longer contributing to EI. You're no
- 7:17longer making RRSP contributions. You're
- 7:20no longer commuting. You're probably not
- 7:23buying work clothes or eating lunch out
- 7:26four or five times a week. And for a lot
- 7:28of people, the mortgage is paid off, or
- 7:30at least close to it by the time they
- 7:31retire. So, when we strip away all of
- 7:34these other things and see what people
- 7:36actually need to live their life in
- 7:38retirement, the number is almost always
- 7:41lower than what they think from a
- 7:43generic calculator. And I usually don't
- 7:46mean by just a little bit. It's usually
- 7:47a pretty big gap. I have had people come
- 7:50to me convinced that they needed 1.2
- 7:53million to retire because they read it
- 7:55in an article somewhere. But when we sat
- 7:58down and went through all their real
- 8:00spending, we found they only needed
- 8:01about 650. They had been losing sleep
- 8:05over that number. The number that didn't
- 8:07even apply to them. And this connects
- 8:09directly back to force number one. If a
- 8:12couple with a delayed CPP is already
- 8:15getting close to $64,000 per year of
- 8:17government income and their actual
- 8:20spending is 66,000,
- 8:22they need their portfolio to generate
- 8:24two grand per year?
- 8:26The idea that they need 1.5 million in
- 8:29savings for that is honestly kind of
- 8:31absurd when you run the real math. So
- 8:33the second force is that most Canadians
- 8:35are saving towards a target that was
- 8:38never accurate to them in the first
- 8:39place. They overshoot their actual
- 8:42target and then they spend 30 years in
- 8:44retirement afraid to touch that surplus
- 8:47because they think they really need
- 8:48every dollar of it. They don't. You You
- 8:51probably don't.
- 8:53They just never had anyone show them the
- 8:55actual math. Force number three, your
- 8:58spending will naturally decline whether
- 9:01you plan for it or not. Now the third
- 9:04force here is one that I think is
- 9:06absolutely fascinating. And it's the one
- 9:09backed by the most research and almost
- 9:11no one in the Canadian retirement space
- 9:13ever talks about it. Your spending in
- 9:15retirement is not going to stay flat. It
- 9:18is going to decline. And not because you
- 9:21run out of money or because you're being
- 9:23really disciplined about it. It declines
- 9:26because as you age, you simply will
- 9:29spend less. The research on this is
- 9:31overwhelming and I want to walk you
- 9:34through it because I think once you see
- 9:36how consistent this finding is across
- 9:39every country where this has been
- 9:40studied, you'll never think about
- 9:42retirement savings in the same way. Now,
- 9:45I'm about to go full nerd mode here for
- 9:49a minute. So, bear with me because this
- 9:51is genuinely important. I've got Fred
- 9:54Vettese's book Retirement Income for
- 9:56Life sitting on my desk at all times. He
- 9:59compiled findings of academic studies
- 10:02across five countries, and every single
- 10:05one of them found the same thing. Let's
- 10:07start in Germany. In 1992, a researcher
- 10:10named Axel Börsch-Supan,
- 10:13I definitely butchered that, studied the
- 10:15spending patterns of what he called, not
- 10:18my words, the very old across 40,000
- 10:22German households. He found that
- 10:24retirees maintained their spending in
- 10:27real terms during their 60s, which is
- 10:29exactly what he expected. But, what
- 10:31surprised him was what happened around
- 10:33age 70. Instead of retirees continuing
- 10:37to draw down their savings, their assets
- 10:39actually started to climb again.
- 10:42They were accumulating wealth in their
- 10:4470s and 80s because they were spending
- 10:47less. And, he found that the
- 10:4980-year-olds were saving more than the
- 10:5245-year-olds.
- 10:53The reason came down to two things.
- 10:55Number one, a reduced ability to spend
- 10:58due to declining health. And number two,
- 11:01a reduced desire to spend. Now, let's
- 11:04jump to Canada. An actuary named Malcolm
- 11:07Hamilton, I bet I pronounced that one
- 11:09right, produced a landmark study in '01
- 11:12looking at Canadian seniors
- 11:13specifically. He found that senior
- 11:16couples age 75 and over were either
- 11:18saving or giving away as cash gifts an
- 11:21average of 16.1%
- 11:24of their income. Couples 85 and older
- 11:27were saving or giving away even more.
- 11:30And the average income for couples 85
- 11:32and over was just 31,300
- 11:35per year. That's about 54,000 adjusted
- 11:38for inflation. These were not wealthy
- 11:41people hoarding money. They simply
- 11:43didn't need to spend what was coming in
- 11:45anymore. Over to Sweden where David
- 11:48Domij and Magnus Johannson confirmed the
- 11:51same pattern. Swedes spend less as they
- 11:55age and the explanation that best fit
- 11:57the data was that failing health made
- 12:00spending both more difficult and less
- 12:03enjoyable. Essentially the same
- 12:05conclusion as the German study. In the
- 12:07UK a 2015 study by Brancati and
- 12:11colleagues looked at two very large data
- 12:14sets and found a precipitous drop in
- 12:16spending between the ages of 60 and 80.
- 12:19And this is the part I really want you
- 12:21to hear. When they asked 80-year-old
- 12:24respondents about their spending most of
- 12:26them said it was not constrained by a
- 12:29lack of money. They weren't spending
- 12:31less because they couldn't afford to.
- 12:34They were spending less because they
- 12:35didn't want to or they didn't need to.
- 12:39The tipping point in that study was
- 12:41around the age of 70 to 74. And then
- 12:44we've got a pile of US data pointing in
- 12:47the same direction. A 2012 study by
- 12:49Michael Hurd and Suzanne Rohwedder found
- 12:53that real spending for college-educated
- 12:55married couples fell by 1.23%
- 12:59per year in the late 60s, 1.75% in their
- 13:0370s and 2.75%
- 13:06per year in their 80s. David Blanchett
- 13:09at Morningstar estimated that real
- 13:11spending declined by about 1% per year
- 13:14in the first decade of retirement, 2%
- 13:16per year in the second decade and back
- 13:19to 1% per year every year after that. JP
- 13:22Morgan ran their own data on affluent
- 13:25households and found real spending
- 13:27dropping by 1% per year for the first 20
- 13:30years of retirement. And then back to
- 13:33that Swedish study from '06,
- 13:35they calculated that the total
- 13:37consumption fell by 25% between the ages
- 13:40of 60 and 80. The UK study found that a
- 13:44household uh headed by an 80-year-old
- 13:46spends 43%
- 13:49less on average than a household headed
- 13:51by a 50-year-old. That is five
- 13:54countries, multiple decades of data, and
- 13:58tens of thousands of households studied,
- 14:01and every single one of them found the
- 14:02same thing. Spending goes down as you
- 14:04age. And it has almost nothing to do
- 14:07with running out of money. Now,
- 14:08Frederick Varady's base all of this
- 14:10research suggests that spending keeps
- 14:13pace with inflation until about age 70,
- 14:16then falls by roughly 1% per year
- 14:19through your 70s, about 2% per year
- 14:21through your 80s, and then levels off in
- 14:23your 90s. Personally, I believe the
- 14:26generation that is currently in their
- 14:2870s will be pushing this tipping point
- 14:30from 70 to about 75. People are more
- 14:34active. People are healthier. And
- 14:36they're spending longer in what I'd call
- 14:38the go-go years. But even with that
- 14:40adjustment, that trajectory will be the
- 14:42same. Your spending will decline. Not
- 14:46because you planned it to do so, not
- 14:48because you're being careful, but
- 14:50because it's just what happens.
- 14:53And what this means for your retirement
- 14:55plan is significant.
- 14:57If your plan assumes that you're going
- 14:59to spend the same inflation-adjusted
- 15:02amount at 85 than you are at 65, your
- 15:05plan is almost certainly overfunding
- 15:08your later years. You're protecting a
- 15:10future that the data says is extremely
- 15:13unlikely to happen. And that overfunding
- 15:16is another reason why you'll end up with
- 15:18more money than you'll have ever use.
- 15:21Now, if you're watching this and
- 15:22starting to wonder whether your own plan
- 15:24is built on assumptions that don't match
- 15:27reality, that's exactly the kind of
- 15:29thing that we look at when someone books
- 15:31a call with us. There's a link in the
- 15:33description below. But, let me show you
- 15:35what happens when all three of these
- 15:37forces work together. The triple
- 15:39overlap, what happens when all three
- 15:41forces compound. So, we've got three
- 15:44forces working together at the same
- 15:46time.
- 15:47Government benefits covering more of
- 15:49your spending than you'd expect, a
- 15:51savings target that was too high to
- 15:53begin with, and spending that naturally
- 15:56declines as you age. Each one of these
- 15:59individually would leave most Canadians
- 16:01with a surplus. But, when all three
- 16:04stack on top of each other, they feed
- 16:06off of each other. Let me show you what
- 16:08this looks like with some real numbers.
- 16:10Let's take a couple, Peter and Joan.
- 16:13They're both 62. They've got about
- 16:15600,000 invested between RRSPs and
- 16:19TFSAs, and they own their home. They're
- 16:22planning to spend about $5,000 per month
- 16:25in retirement, or about 60,000 per year.
- 16:28Now, if Peter and Joan delay their CPP
- 16:30to 70 and start OAS at 65, they have a
- 16:34few distinct phases to walk through.
- 16:37Phase one from age 62 to 65, they have
- 16:40zero government income. Every dollar of
- 16:43their 60,000 per year spending needs to
- 16:45come from their savings. That's about
- 16:47$180,000
- 16:49drawn down over these three years,
- 16:51mostly from their RRSPs as part of a
- 16:54strategic meltdown to reduce future
- 16:57taxation. Phase two from age 65 to 70,
- 17:00OAS kicks in for both of them, bringing
- 17:02about $17,500
- 17:05per year combined. Now, they only need
- 17:0742,500
- 17:09from their portfolio. Over five years,
- 17:11that's another 212,500.
- 17:14So, across those eight year bridge
- 17:16years, they've drawn down roughly
- 17:19392,000
- 17:21of their 600,000. Add some growth along
- 17:24the way, of course, and they're still
- 17:25sitting at about 230 to 250,000 dollars
- 17:29by the time they hit age 70. And then
- 17:32everything changes. At 70, their delayed
- 17:35CPP kicks in at the full 42% permanent
- 17:39increase.
- 17:41Combine this with their OAS, their
- 17:43government income is now roughly 63,700
- 17:46per year, and their spending goal is 60
- 17:49grand. The government benefits alone now
- 17:52exceed what they actually spend. Their
- 17:54portfolio doesn't need to contribute a
- 17:57single dollar to their day-to-day life
- 18:00after age 70. It only needs to cover off
- 18:03the tax. Now, let's add force number
- 18:06three. By the time Peter and Joan are
- 18:0875, their real spending has probably
- 18:11dropped by about 5% based on the
- 18:14research we went through. By 80, it's
- 18:16dropped by 10%. They're spending less.
- 18:19Their government benefits are more than
- 18:22enough, and their portfolio is
- 18:25compounding completely untouched. By the
- 18:28time they're in their mid-80s, that 230
- 18:31to 250,000
- 18:33could easily turn into 350,000 or more,
- 18:36depending on their returns.
- 18:38They spend less every year. They get
- 18:40more every year because, of course, CPP
- 18:42and OAS are indexed to inflation. And
- 18:46their portfolio has been growing in the
- 18:48background, hardly being touched.
- 18:50Peter and Joan will almost certainly
- 18:53finish their retirement with more money
- 18:55than they had at age 70, despite having
- 18:59spent exclusively from that portfolio
- 19:01for 3 years and very heavily for another
- 19:04five. And they will almost certainly
- 19:07finish with more purchasing power than
- 19:09they needed. That is what the triple
- 19:12overlap looks like. It's not one force
- 19:15creating small surpluses. It's three
- 19:18forces compounding to make it nearly
- 19:21impossible to spend down your savings if
- 19:24you've done the basic planning in the
- 19:26first place correctly. My number one
- 19:29objection, "But what about healthcare
- 19:31costs?" Now, I know what many of you are
- 19:33thinking because I get it almost every
- 19:35day. People say, "Chad, what about
- 19:38healthcare? What if I end up in a
- 19:39long-care facility? Won't that wipe
- 19:43everything out?"
- 19:44And I want to take this seriously
- 19:46because this is a major concern.
- 19:48Long-term care in Canada can cost
- 19:50anywhere from 2 to 10,000 or more per
- 19:53month depending on your province and
- 19:55your level of care. That is a
- 19:57significant expense. But I want you to
- 20:00consider a few things. First, the
- 20:03province's healthcare system in Canada
- 20:05covers a portion of long-term care
- 20:07costs. You cover a portion out of
- 20:09pocket, too, but the system does cover a
- 20:12big chunk. Number two, if you look at
- 20:14the data we just went through, by the
- 20:16time people need that level of care,
- 20:19their other spending has already dropped
- 20:22dramatically. You're not paying for
- 20:24vacations, you're not maintaining a car,
- 20:27you're probably not even in the house
- 20:29that you lived in anymore. The
- 20:31healthcare costs don't stack up on top
- 20:35of your full retirement spending. They
- 20:37largely replace that spending that is
- 20:40already starting to disappear. And
- 20:42third, if you structured your accounts
- 20:44properly and you've built up a healthy
- 20:47TFSA through the meltdown strategy over
- 20:49the years, you've got a pool of tax-free
- 20:52money that you can access without it
- 20:55affecting any of your other incomes or
- 20:57benefits. Now, I am not I am not telling
- 21:00you to ignore healthcare costs. Plan for
- 21:03them. Build them into your projection if
- 21:05you need to, but do not let the fear of
- 21:08health care expense that may or may not
- 21:11happen keep you from using the money you
- 21:13save for the retirement that is
- 21:15definitely happening right now. Because
- 21:19fear without actual numbers or data is
- 21:22not planning, it's just anxiety with a
- 21:25financial tilt. So, what do you do about
- 21:28this? How this should change your
- 21:31planning. So, if all of this is true,
- 21:33and I believe the data is very clear
- 21:35that it is, what should you actually do
- 21:38about it? The first thing is to run the
- 21:40real math in your CPP and OAS. Don't
- 21:43guess. Log in to your My Service Canada
- 21:46account, look at your actual CPP
- 21:48estimate, and calculate what your
- 21:50combined government benefits will be,
- 21:53especially if you delay. Then compare
- 21:55that to what you actually spend every
- 21:57month. Again, don't guess. Not what you
- 21:59think you spend, what you actually
- 22:01spend. Most people who do this for the
- 22:04first time are genuinely surprised by
- 22:06how small the gap is. The second thing
- 22:09is to stop anchoring your retirement
- 22:11savings target to a number that you read
- 22:13in an article that doesn't know who you
- 22:15are.
- 22:16Those benchmarks are built on generic
- 22:18assumptions that probably don't apply to
- 22:21you.
- 22:22Get your actual number based on your
- 22:24actual spending and your actual
- 22:26government benefits and your actual
- 22:28accounts. The third thing, and this is
- 22:30the one most people resist, give
- 22:33yourself the permission to use what
- 22:36you've built. I know how hard this one
- 22:40is.
- 22:40You spend 30, sometimes 40 years
- 22:43training yourself to save.
- 22:46Every dollar saved was a win. Every
- 22:48dollar spent unnecessarily felt like a
- 22:51failure. And now here I am telling you
- 22:53to flip that switch. That can't be easy.
- 22:56I I get that.
- 22:58But I want you to think about something.
- 23:01I have sat across from people in their
- 23:0380s who have more money than they have
- 23:07ever had in their lives. And do you know
- 23:09what they talk about? They do not ever
- 23:12talk about their portfolios.
- 23:14They talk about the trips they wish they
- 23:16had taken.
- 23:18They talk about the things they wish
- 23:19they had fixed. They talk about the
- 23:21grandkids that they wish that they had
- 23:23helped out sooner, started a business
- 23:26with them, something like that. You did
- 23:28not save your money to die with it. You
- 23:30saved your money to use it. The research
- 23:33from five countries and multiple decades
- 23:36is telling you the same thing. You will
- 23:38almost certainly not run out. The real
- 23:41risk is that you run out of time while
- 23:43your money just sits there.
- 23:46And that is the part that no spreadsheet
- 23:49will ever show you. So, that's why most
- 23:51well-prepared Canadians will never
- 23:54actually spend their retirement savings.
- 23:57But one of the biggest levers in
- 23:59everything we just talked about today
- 24:01was the timing of your CPP. Taking it at
- 24:04the right time versus the wrong time can
- 24:07be the difference between your
- 24:08government benefits covering most of
- 24:10your spending or barely making a dent.
- 24:13And the math on this decision is not
- 24:16what most people assume, which is
- 24:18exactly why I made this video right
- 24:20here, where I walk through the real CPP
- 24:23timing math that no one else really
- 24:25shows you, including including when
- 24:29delaying actually does not make sense.
- 24:32That's the next one for you to watch.
- 24:34I'll see you there.
- 24:38>> [music]
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of Why You’ll Never Actually Spend Your Retirement Savings (as a Canadian) by Pathway Wealth - Chad Wiebe CFP, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 3,805 words across 586 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.