Why Using Autofire (Turbo) is NOT Cheating, Arcade vs. Speedrunning Rulesets — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:00hello everyone welcome to another shmup
- 0:02topic video
- 0:03this one is definitely long overdue it's
- 0:05something i've talked about in previous
- 0:07podcast episodes and that sort of thing
- 0:09but i think now is the time to make a
- 0:11standalone video
- 0:12more people are joining the genre more
- 0:14people are asking the question
- 0:16more information and debate is happening
- 0:18so i think now is the time to set the
- 0:20record straight and explain why
- 0:22definitively using auto fire in shmups
- 0:25and arcade games
- 0:26is not cheating in this video i'll also
- 0:28be explaining why i think this is
- 0:30different from other gaming scenes like
- 0:32speedrunning
- 0:33and where this difference may come from
- 0:36so to get started at explaining why
- 0:38shmups historically allow for auto fire
- 0:40and yet why speedrunning typically does
- 0:42not
- 0:43i think it dates back to the original
- 0:45score keeping
- 0:46organizations what their expectations
- 0:48were and what the rule sets were
- 0:51i think a lot of us are familiar with
- 0:52the organization twin galaxies
- 0:55especially as of late with all the
- 0:57dramas and documentaries and cheating
- 0:59scandals and
- 1:00lawsuits but outside all of that twin
- 1:03galaxies is also known as being the
- 1:05historical home
- 1:06for western arcade scores now the key
- 1:09word there
- 1:10is western because parallel to twin
- 1:12galaxies
- 1:13is another organization known as jha
- 1:16jha stands for the japanese high score
- 1:19association
- 1:20which has its roots in gaming magazines
- 1:22in the 90s
- 1:23and so the important thing to understand
- 1:25about jha is that there are massive
- 1:27differences between them and twin
- 1:29galaxies
- 1:30especially when it comes to ethos rule
- 1:32sets
- 1:33and score verification so for those who
- 1:35haven't tried to submit a score to twin
- 1:37galaxies before
- 1:38i do not think it is an exaggeration to
- 1:40say that their rule sets are incredibly
- 1:42restrictive
- 1:43to where even if autofire is available
- 1:46within the game
- 1:47like donald poche unless that auto fire
- 1:49is on by default
- 1:50it is a no go and i do understand thanks
- 1:54to pearl that
- 1:55under new management they are trying to
- 1:57be better about this sort of thing and
- 1:58be more flexible and welcoming
- 2:00but historically speaking i think there
- 2:02is no question that twin galaxies were
- 2:05restrictive to the point of being
- 2:06intentionally restrictive i even made a
- 2:08meme video about their donkey kong
- 2:11score submission guideline which is
- 2:13three pages long and involves tons of
- 2:15hoops involving
- 2:17making sure you have the right power
- 2:18supplies and it's absolutely absurd
- 2:21and so with jha when it came to auto
- 2:24fire they were
- 2:25much more lenient to say the least where
- 2:27you could have auto fires
- 2:28you'd have auto fires on your auto fires
- 2:30you could even auto fire your inputs up
- 2:32until 1996
- 2:34probably because of p47 aces and the
- 2:36frame button
- 2:37but needless to say the submission
- 2:40standards between the two
- 2:41is very very different and one thing
- 2:44that i think needs to be understood
- 2:46especially for those who do not know
- 2:47much about the shmup scene and
- 2:49shmup players is that the skill gap
- 2:52between the twin galaxies
- 2:53scores and the jha scores in shmups
- 2:56especially
- 2:58is absurd where it's hard to put this
- 3:01into terms but
- 3:02so if you look on twin galaxies their
- 3:04top score for donompache right now
- 3:07i actually have a higher score than that
- 3:09i use autofire so i can't submit it
- 3:11and then you look at jha the massive
- 3:14difference between those scores
- 3:15is very hard to articulate i guess you
- 3:18could say that it is likely
- 3:19that the top dodonpachi players probably
- 3:22beat that western record
- 3:24on their very first credit on their very
- 3:26first day playing the game i mean within
- 3:28two years they're getting 600 mills and
- 3:30that sort of thing
- 3:31and so the skill gap between the two
- 3:34there's no competition the japanese
- 3:36have the genre dominated in terms of
- 3:39historical
- 3:40wet record scores and so they were all
- 3:42playing with auto fire so the genie is
- 3:45out of the bottle so to say
- 3:46and i also think the reason why they're
- 3:48doing it is because from a practical
- 3:50sense
- 3:51i think playing with auto fire off is
- 3:53kind of a
- 3:54archaic idea to begin with and so that
- 3:57is the first reason why auto fire is
- 4:00allowed in shmups is that
- 4:01we have 20 years or more history
- 4:04of world record scores being achieved
- 4:08with auto fire on so it makes no sense
- 4:10to disallow that
- 4:12and on that point of twin galaxies
- 4:14disallowing auto fire i do want to just
- 4:16sort of speculate that i think this is
- 4:18probably the reason why speedrunning
- 4:20does not allow auto fire either
- 4:22because speed running actually has its
- 4:24roots in twin galaxies
- 4:26and it's kind of a similar story to
- 4:27where they began following twin galaxy's
- 4:30rule sets but then when twin galaxy says
- 4:32oh you can't use glitches you can't use
- 4:33shortcuts they realize okay
- 4:35these rule sets are too restrictive so
- 4:37they went to speed demos archive
- 4:38and then onward to speedrun.com but i
- 4:41think interestingly they sort of
- 4:43carry this archaic rule set of banning
- 4:45auto fire along with them
- 4:47or maybe it was just far behind because
- 4:50most popular speed games don't involve
- 4:52auto fire for the most part and so i
- 4:55would be interested
- 4:56to see if speedrunners become more aware
- 4:58of this history if they maybe rethink
- 4:59this position because
- 5:01at times it does seem a little bit silly
- 5:03to me while i'm watching a summoning
- 5:04salt video and he's talking about
- 5:06i think the contra speed running record
- 5:08progression he's like oh but this player
- 5:10was really good at mashing and so he's
- 5:12able to beat this guy's time it's like
- 5:14awesome you know as a shmup player that
- 5:17sounds a little bit ridiculous that
- 5:18mashing is considered a world record
- 5:21tier skill
- 5:22and so that's my second point that the
- 5:24reason why i think autofire
- 5:26should definitely be emphasized and used
- 5:28is we have to ask ourselves
- 5:29the question of what skill are we
- 5:31testing here with auto fire
- 5:33in some games maybe like contra on this
- 5:35on the nes or whatever yeah
- 5:37pressing the shot button might be a lot
- 5:38of what the skill involves
- 5:40but with shmups there's a lot more going
- 5:42on than pressing that shot button
- 5:44and to the point where if you're playing
- 5:46these games for
- 5:47dozens and dozens of hours a week or
- 5:50like eight hours a day like i've done a
- 5:52few times
- 5:53you literally cannot press that button
- 5:54enough it adds to way
- 5:56more inconsistencies than reward for
- 5:59skills and what what is your claim to
- 6:01fame oh i can press a button
- 6:02way faster than other people can you
- 6:04know i understand
- 6:06that playing video games does come down
- 6:08to pressing buttons but
- 6:09there is purpose and intent and timing
- 6:11behind those button presses whereas
- 6:13just mashing the button doesn't quite
- 6:16seem like
- 6:17quite the skill we're looking for and
- 6:19shmups again
- 6:20are so heavily dependent on shooting to
- 6:23the point where
- 6:23it becomes un unfun to play honestly
- 6:26like i don't really enjoy playing shmups
- 6:28in american arcades all that much
- 6:30because
- 6:31after mashing shot and ryden for three
- 6:33hours like my hand gets sore and he
- 6:35can't use the same strats and so that's
- 6:38another reason why i think auto fire
- 6:40definitely should be allowed and i do
- 6:42know that depending on the game auto
- 6:44fire can get a little bit
- 6:45weird and complicated where especially
- 6:47when you're putting auto fires on your
- 6:49auto fires
- 6:50i think that's where a score split can
- 6:52be necessary
- 6:53but basically i think default auto fire
- 6:56should be the standard and then from
- 6:58there if the game has weird auto fire
- 7:00issues or reasons to play it without
- 7:02autofire maybe that would be
- 7:04something to consider but by default i
- 7:06think yes autofire should definitely be
- 7:08allowed so that's the
- 7:09second reason why is just what are we
- 7:12testing what skills
- 7:13are separating players from one another
- 7:16the third reason why it
- 7:17actually comes down to just sheer hand
- 7:20health right
- 7:21like i cannot sit and hammer these
- 7:24buttons for eight hours a day and
- 7:25continue to enjoy and play this genre
- 7:27it's funny because hand health is
- 7:29becoming more of a thing and gaming and
- 7:31you know especially like melee and
- 7:33fighting games right like that becomes a
- 7:35topic
- 7:36well imagine hand health and shmups
- 7:38where you're hammering buttons for
- 7:40you know 20 hours a week you know like
- 7:43you're gonna get carpal
- 7:44tunnel syndrome and again it's just
- 7:46leading to more inconsistencies and also
- 7:48shmups
- 7:49are not contra you know contrast the
- 7:51short little game people mash and get
- 7:52through the level
- 7:53some shmups are like an hour long so can
- 7:55you mash a button for an hour you get to
- 7:57hibachi and you're like
- 7:59you know so i think there's just a lot
- 8:02of reasons why
- 8:03beyond the obvious that playing shmoops
- 8:06with autofire just wakes
- 8:07makes way more sense and i would be
- 8:09interested to see if speedrunning does
- 8:11catch up on this because
- 8:13i mean you liking that contra world
- 8:15record progression
- 8:16you eliminate the ability for that dude
- 8:18to mash can he
- 8:20hang now can uh can more routes be found
- 8:22can the game be pushed further right
- 8:24it's an arbitrary barrier of skill in my
- 8:27opinion where
- 8:28there are certain sections like in a
- 8:29metal slug 2 where
- 8:31the developers are like hey let's just
- 8:33see how fast they can mash like in the
- 8:35subway and you have to sit there and
- 8:36just crouch and mash the button
- 8:37imagine doing that with auto fire off
- 8:39that would be the hardest part of the
- 8:41game
- 8:41the hardest part of the game would not
- 8:42be the end where you have to
- 8:44coordinate all these dodges and line
- 8:47things up and
- 8:48spend hours routing and practicing no
- 8:50the hardest part of the game would be
- 8:51can you sit and mash on these subways
- 8:53for like four minutes or however long
- 8:55that subway section is
- 8:56so i think those are the reasons why
- 8:58auto fire is allowed in shmups and will
- 9:00continue to be allowed and hopefully
- 9:02this video is helpful for people who
- 9:04are questioning this who are suffering
- 9:07under the delusion that they have to
- 9:08play
- 9:09gradius and other shmups and manually
- 9:11press all the firing buttons or
- 9:13you know metal slug especially i can't
- 9:15imagine having to manually auto
- 9:17mentally fire all of metal slugs so
- 9:19anyway thanks so much for tuning in and
- 9:21let me
- 9:22end by thanking my patrons so thank you
- 9:24to adam pearson
- 9:25adrian ryan's dingo handicapped anthony
- 9:28a
- 9:28ben nguyen borgie 22 choreo disco star
- 9:31slayer dominic ng
- 9:33eric h full set retro shmupper hausu
- 9:36kiwi
- 9:36jlab jb rpg joe angelo gameboy guru
- 9:39k malays mark toms martin worrell maz
- 9:42maher klendrian queen charlene nathaniel
- 9:45davis and elektron
- 9:46nine o'clock coogles philip mason ramku
- 9:50raul sketchy raccoon smacky factor trm
- 9:53sugumo plasmo yishi and yutakaya
- 9:56thanks for watching
- 10:16you
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of Why Using Autofire (Turbo) is NOT Cheating, Arcade vs. Speedrunning Rulesets by The Electric Underground, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 1,834 words across 314 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.