Why trying to love people doesn't work, and what does | Eckhart Tolle — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:00One could almost say there are two
- 0:01halves to your to who you are.
- 0:05And most humans only know one half,
- 0:08which is the form, the physical form and
- 0:10the psychological form, the ideas they
- 0:13have about themselves, the stories and
- 0:15so on. That's the one half is your form
- 0:17identity. The other half, which most
- 0:20humans don't know
- 0:22themselves as, is the
- 0:26>> [bell]
- 0:29>> There's the story that you may have
- 0:31heard. There's a man sitting
- 0:34in a in a small town in a cafe and an
- 0:38old man
- 0:39and a a man approaches him and says,
- 0:42"Oh, are you a native here? You live
- 0:44here?" Yes, and the man says, "I'm
- 0:46thinking of moving here. Do you think
- 0:49it's a good place to live? And what are
- 0:52the people like here?" Uh and the old
- 0:55man says, "Well,
- 0:57what were the people like where you used
- 0:59to live?" And the man says, "Well,
- 1:02oh, they were dreadful. They were They
- 1:04are dishonest, deceitful,
- 1:08full of envy and malice. I can't just
- 1:10can't stand that place anymore. I have
- 1:12to get out."
- 1:13Okay. Then the old man says, "It's very
- 1:17much the same here."
- 1:20>> [laughter]
- 1:22>> And the next day, the old man sits again
- 1:25in the cafe and somebody else turns up
- 1:28by coincidence and says,
- 1:31"My wife and I are thinking of moving
- 1:33here
- 1:34because we like this town. What's What
- 1:36are the people like?" And the man says,
- 1:38"Well, what were the people like where
- 1:40you come from?" And he says, "Oh,
- 1:42they're great. They're very They're
- 1:44helpful, kind, couldn't be nicer
- 1:46people."
- 1:48And the old man says, "It's very much
- 1:49the same here."
- 1:54And of course the old man is right.
- 1:57You
- 1:58create
- 2:01according to your conditioning. Your
- 2:03conditioning to a large extent
- 2:04determines the way in which you
- 2:07experience
- 2:09other people and reality.
- 2:14And when you go beyond your
- 2:17conditioning,
- 2:19you reach a place
- 2:21where
- 2:24you give the greatest gift to other
- 2:26humans that you can give,
- 2:29and that is the gift of your pure
- 2:31attention.
- 2:33When you look at somebody and you give
- 2:35them attention,
- 2:37that is a there's a an outflow of energy
- 2:40towards them. Just look. And attention
- 2:43means you're you're not pure attention
- 2:45is you're not labeling anymore. It's not
- 2:49you're
- 2:50just looking,
- 2:51perceiving, and there's an outflow
- 2:53perhaps they are talking to you.
- 2:56There's an outflow. Attention is energy.
- 2:59Or you give attention to a child through
- 3:02it. Many parents can't do that because
- 3:04they they're continuously
- 3:06saying to the child, "Do this. Don't do
- 3:09that. Now we must do that. Get ready for
- 3:11this." There's always something. There's
- 3:12never a pure attention or rarely.
- 3:15There's always something to sort out and
- 3:17to make better. Of course, those things
- 3:19have their place. Brush your teeth. Of
- 3:22course, they need to brush their teeth,
- 3:23but if that's the only reality of do
- 3:25this, do that, come to
- 3:27There's never that spaciousness which is
- 3:29attention, giving it to the other.
- 3:32And the child can feel that. If you give
- 3:35a child, you just look at the child and
- 3:37you listen to the child or look.
- 3:42It's a beautiful thing. There's a flow.
- 3:45And then something comes back to you
- 3:46from the other
- 3:48because it ultimately attention is a
- 3:50form we could almost say a form of love.
- 3:53In a deeper sense, it's there's a
- 3:56there's a giving and outflow. Of course,
- 3:58it's not your personal. It's it's not
- 4:00something
- 4:02of your personal belonging that you
- 4:04give. Attention comes through you. It
- 4:07doesn't come from you. It comes through
- 4:10you from the
- 4:13the divine called the one consciousness.
- 4:17And you become a an opening for that.
- 4:20And then the way in which you experience
- 4:24reality changes dramatically. So, a
- 4:28wonderful shift happens.
- 4:30Situations
- 4:32are no longer
- 4:34the life in general is no longer
- 4:37perceived as hostile. It becomes
- 4:39helpful. So, that. And this And again,
- 4:44when you look at a tree or you listen to
- 4:46the sounds, that's the outflow of
- 4:48attention. And that's attention of what
- 4:51is just a word. It's a mysterious,
- 4:54ultimately unnameable
- 4:57energy that is
- 5:00goes.
- 5:01It has no form.
- 5:05And you
- 5:07you can become an an opening for that.
- 5:10And then it begins to live through you,
- 5:14that essence,
- 5:15and express itself
- 5:18through you.
- 5:20In what form it expresses itself varies
- 5:23from person to person.
- 5:26But it begins to It could just be that
- 5:29you become more You stay where you are,
- 5:31become more
- 5:32more kind and loving. And not because
- 5:36you're thinking, "I need to be kind and
- 5:38loving."
- 5:39Yeah, that doesn't work.
- 5:41You can try very hard. Love your
- 5:43neighbor as yourself.
- 5:46Okay, I'll try.
- 5:49>> [laughter]
- 5:52>> Except that guy and that one.
- 6:01When you feel that
- 6:03you are something is living through you
- 6:07without being obstructed anymore.
- 6:11It was living through you before also,
- 6:13but only a trickle. It's a little bit
- 6:16like let's imagine you are
- 6:19a ripple on the surface of the ocean.
- 6:24And the ripple
- 6:25for a moment, which is a lifetime for
- 6:28the ripple,
- 6:29forgets
- 6:31that it is part of the ocean and it's
- 6:34only an expression
- 6:36a brief expression of the totality in
- 6:38this particular form.
- 6:41And the ripple thinks
- 6:43I'm a ripple.
- 6:46That's my life. That's my ripple life.
- 6:49My
- 6:50my life.
- 6:53The ripple thinks that its life is its
- 6:56own.
- 6:57>> [laughter]
- 6:58>> It doesn't know it is the ocean.
- 7:01And then of course the this the ripple
- 7:03becomes unhappy. The
- 7:07>> [laughter]
- 7:10>> It doesn't realize that it is the ocean.
- 7:13>> [laughter]
- 7:14>> But once the ripple realizes the ocean
- 7:16then then and now we have to let go of
- 7:19this analogy because then something
- 7:21happens to the ripple that is
- 7:24would not happen to a normal ripple.
- 7:26That's why we're letting go of it.
- 7:29It becomes a beautiful formation
- 7:31suddenly.
- 7:33Oh, and now the ocean is expressing
- 7:36itself fully through that.
- 7:54So use every moment here. And when I say
- 7:57every moment
- 7:59it's not entirely correct. There is not
- 8:01no such thing as every moment. There's
- 8:03only this moment.
- 8:07Well, I have never met any other moment.
- 8:09I can't find any other.
- 8:11It's always been this moment. So,
- 8:14could one in language one says
- 8:17every moment or many moments, but
- 8:20ultimately there's no such thing.
- 8:23There's only the appearance of many
- 8:25moments because
- 8:27there's always something different that
- 8:28arises,
- 8:30that changes all the time in your
- 8:33in the space of consciousness.
- 8:36Things arise and subside and arise and
- 8:39subside. Thoughts, emotions,
- 8:41perceptions, experiences
- 8:44come and go. And so, when you only see
- 8:47the surface, then you think
- 8:49everything that arises, this is one
- 8:51moment that arises and one moment that
- 8:53arises and the next moment that But of
- 8:56course it's not really like that
- 8:58because it all arises in the present
- 9:00moment,
- 9:02which is eternal.
- 9:04And the present moment, the deeper
- 9:05meaning of it,
- 9:07of course is
- 9:09that the present moment is
- 9:12consciousness itself.
- 9:14That's what the real meaning of the
- 9:15power of now is. The the of the what the
- 9:19now is.
- 9:21It's not It's not what happens. The now
- 9:24in its deeper sense
- 9:27is not what happens.
- 9:29It's the space
- 9:31in which everything happens. And that
- 9:33space is eternal. In other words,
- 9:35timeless. And that space is you
- 9:38in your essence.
- 9:40>> [laughter]
- 9:44>> Oh.
- 9:46Uh but if this is not of course
- 9:47something to believe in,
- 9:50but to sense
- 9:53that spaciousness in you
- 9:56as that which underlies
- 10:00all perceptions and all thinking.
- 10:06So, the shift in consciousness or the
- 10:09evolutionary leap in consciousness, is
- 10:11from
- 10:13being exclusively identified with form,
- 10:17the me, the thought forms of me,
- 10:21to
- 10:26being rooted
- 10:28in the dimension of the formless.
- 10:32So, this is why I sometimes say,
- 10:34although again, don't believe don't take
- 10:37these words as absolutely true, they're
- 10:39only temporary pointers.
- 10:42One could almost say there are two
- 10:44halves to your to who you are.
- 10:47And most humans only know one half,
- 10:50which is the form, the physical form and
- 10:53the psychological form, the ideas they
- 10:55have about themselves, the stories, and
- 10:57so on. That's the one half is your form
- 11:00identity. The other half, which most
- 11:03humans don't know
- 11:05themselves as, is the more essential the
- 11:08essence of identity that is formless,
- 11:12that you cannot know.
- 11:14The other half you can know,
- 11:16but the the formless essence identity,
- 11:19you cannot know it because
- 11:21it is the essence through which
- 11:24everything is known.
- 11:27This is why it's sometimes called the I,
- 11:29the eternal I am.
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of Why trying to love people doesn't work, and what does | Eckhart Tolle by Eckhart Tolle, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 1,424 words across 265 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to translate the transcript into 100+ languages.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, translation to 100+ languages, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.