YouTube2Text

Why The Euro Was Built To Fail — Transcript

by Real Education · 4,086 words · 603 segments · language en · Watch on YouTube

Full transcript

  1. 0:00In March of 2013, a Euro zone country
  2. 0:02woke up to shut banks. For almost 2
  3. 0:04weeks, separates couldn't touch their
  4. 0:06own money. Then at the biggest bank,
  5. 0:09uninsured savers lost almost 50% above
  6. 0:12100K. They were left with the same euro,
  7. 0:14the same notes, but Cypress didn't
  8. 0:17control a single one of them. Iceland
  9. 0:19with its own currency took all the hits
  10. 0:21at once and recovered. So why did some
  11. 0:23countries adjust whilst others got
  12. 0:25adjusted? To answer that, we have to go
  13. 0:28back to 1999 when the euro was sold as a
  14. 0:31promise. Picture Europe in 1999. 11
  15. 0:34countries decide to adopt one currency.
  16. 0:37The advantages? Well, no exchange fees
  17. 0:39and no currency risk between countries.
  18. 0:42And it's sold as strong as the Deutsch
  19. 0:44mark. Sounds great, right? They also
  20. 0:46have a hope. The hope of convergence
  21. 0:49where poor countries are able to catch
  22. 0:50up to rich ones. And the rules? Well,
  23. 0:53they're simple. Your deficit can be no
  24. 0:56more than 3% of your GDP and debt has to
  25. 0:59be under 60%.
  26. 1:01There's only one catch. We have one
  27. 1:03currency for different economies,
  28. 1:05different governments, and different
  29. 1:06needs. What could go wrong, right? Also,
  30. 1:09to join the euro, you have to give up
  31. 1:11three tools. The ability to devalue your
  32. 1:14currency, to set your own interest
  33. 1:15rates, and to create money. Why does
  34. 1:18this matter? Well, these are the three
  35. 1:20textbook tools a country can use in a
  36. 1:22crisis. Whether they're good or bad,
  37. 1:23I'll touch upon later, but for now, if a
  38. 1:26country devalues its currency, that
  39. 1:28means that exports become cheaper, and
  40. 1:30this allows the country to recover
  41. 1:31through trade. Then, if it sets its own
  42. 1:34interest rate, this means they can match
  43. 1:36policy to the economy. So, if it has
  44. 1:37very low interest rates, that's
  45. 1:39stimulating the economy. All right? And
  46. 1:42finally, if it creates money, since the
  47. 1:45debt is in its own currency, it can make
  48. 1:47the debt cheaper to repay. But now
  49. 1:50before we understand why the euro is a
  50. 1:52scam, we first need to understand some
  51. 1:54of the problems with the euro. So the
  52. 1:55first problem, one rate fits none. So
  53. 1:58whether you're in France, Greece,
  54. 1:59Germany, Lithuania, you all have the
  55. 2:01exact same interest rate. And this is
  56. 2:03set by the ECB, the European Central
  57. 2:05Bank, which is in Frankfurt, Germany.
  58. 2:08And we can see how inefficient this is
  59. 2:09because in the early 2000s, Germany was
  60. 2:11stagnating. And the ECB had set low
  61. 2:14interest rates. So this was helping
  62. 2:16Germany at that time. But in Ireland and
  63. 2:18France at the exact same time we were
  64. 2:21getting a housing bubble which was
  65. 2:22fueled by this cheap credit. So in these
  66. 2:24countries there should have been a
  67. 2:26higher interest rate. It's also
  68. 2:28important to note that during this time
  69. 2:29cheap credit had flooded the periphery
  70. 2:31and this is basically the outskirts of
  71. 2:33the Euro zone where typically the
  72. 2:35economies are weaker. So we had banks
  73. 2:37lending money out, people borrowing and
  74. 2:39everyone felt rich.
  75. 2:41But Greece borrowed very heavily and
  76. 2:43this we're going to get on to in a bit.
  77. 2:45But the lesson I want you to take away
  78. 2:46from this is that a single rate cannot
  79. 2:48accommodate different economies. Now
  80. 2:50back to Greece. Remember that in 2008 we
  81. 2:52had the great recession or the great
  82. 2:54financial crisis and what happened was
  83. 2:56credit dried up. Then in 2009 to 2010,
  84. 3:00Greece's real deficit was exposed. They
  85. 3:02said there was between 3.7% to 6.7% of
  86. 3:05their GDP. In reality, it was between
  87. 3:0815.1 to 15.6. That is a substantial
  88. 3:11difference. And when the bond market
  89. 3:13found out, it naturally panicked. Now
  90. 3:16the textbook response to this is of
  91. 3:17course devalue your currency, thereby
  92. 3:20making exports and holidays cheaper for
  93. 3:21foreigners. So basically get your way
  94. 3:23out of the crisis through trade.
  95. 3:26The only problem is Greece couldn't. It
  96. 3:28doesn't have its own sovereign currency
  97. 3:31and the only option it was left with was
  98. 3:33internal devaluation. So what that
  99. 3:35actually means is they cut wages, they
  100. 3:37cut spending and they cut jobs. So
  101. 3:39obviously not great if you're living in
  102. 3:40Greece at that time. And subsequently
  103. 3:42the Greek workers, pensioners and young
  104. 3:44people suffered the most. Basically, if
  105. 3:46you're a young person, your future was
  106. 3:48basically destroyed. And the crazy thing
  107. 3:49about this actually is the fact that
  108. 3:51none the politicians were arrested and
  109. 3:53the only guy who was being honest was
  110. 3:54prosecuted. In fact, he was only
  111. 3:56recently acquitted and they basically
  112. 3:58said that he hasn't done anything wrong.
  113. 4:00So, the key takeaway from this is that
  114. 4:02when you're unable to devalue a currency
  115. 4:04or even move the exchange rate even
  116. 4:06slightly, people will leave and that
  117. 4:08will lead to a brain drain. And we'll
  118. 4:09get on to that in two slides time. But
  119. 4:11first, let's go through the bailouts.
  120. 4:13So, Greece, Cyprus, Portugal, and
  121. 4:15Ireland all received bailouts, as well
  122. 4:17as Spain's banks. And Greece received
  123. 4:19290 billion across three different
  124. 4:21programs. The important thing to note
  125. 4:23here is that the money went straight to
  126. 4:25creditors, not to the Greeks themselves.
  127. 4:28And the banks lent to Greece at high
  128. 4:30rates as they understood that was
  129. 4:31insanely risky. The crazy thing is
  130. 4:33though, when it went wrong, the bailout
  131. 4:35paid them back. Now in capitalism you
  132. 4:38get paid on whether or not your risk was
  133. 4:40successful. Obviously if it's
  134. 4:41unsuccessful you have to accept the
  135. 4:43consequences of that. So how on earth is
  136. 4:45this capitalism? That's beyond me. But
  137. 4:46the important thing you need to
  138. 4:48understand is the fact that the risk
  139. 4:49shifted from the banks to the taxpayers
  140. 4:52because these are the guys that are
  141. 4:53bailing these guys out. Greek and
  142. 4:55Eurozone taxpayers actually paid the
  143. 4:57bill. So these guys paid these guys for
  144. 4:59[clears throat] issuing risky loans to
  145. 5:02the Greek government. And to make
  146. 5:03matters worse for Greece, these three
  147. 5:06programs, these bailouts they received
  148. 5:07had very strict conditions. They had to
  149. 5:10undergo austerity, privatization, and
  150. 5:12pension cuts. Now, privatization is
  151. 5:14especially bad for the country because
  152. 5:16it's basically losing some of its
  153. 5:18revenue generating assets. So, for
  154. 5:20example, its airports, its ports, it
  155. 5:22then has to sell them off to private
  156. 5:24investors. And instead of earning a set
  157. 5:26amount of money every month, every year,
  158. 5:28they could help repay this. they instead
  159. 5:31have to sell off the whole thing or a
  160. 5:33large share of that thing to a private
  161. 5:36investor making it much harder for them
  162. 5:38to repay the repayments. The best
  163. 5:40historical example I can give you is for
  164. 5:42example in 1923
  165. 5:44when France invaded the which is the
  166. 5:46industrial heartland of Germany they
  167. 5:49basically occupied Germany's wallet and
  168. 5:51then they told Germany keep paying you
  169. 5:53know when you put it like that it's
  170. 5:54ridiculous because obviously how on
  171. 5:56earth they going to pay well
  172. 5:57privatization acts in a very similar way
  173. 5:59and even though I'm going to cover this
  174. 6:01later on Greece has basically undergone
  175. 6:02the great depression for the past 20
  176. 6:04years
  177. 6:06now the crazy thing about this whole
  178. 6:08situation is the fact that Greeks were
  179. 6:10called lazy and blamed but not the
  180. 6:12corrupt politicians that are obviously
  181. 6:13the ones to blame. Something that's also
  182. 6:15important to mention about this whole
  183. 6:17situation is that this created a moral
  184. 6:18hazard where the creditor banks came out
  185. 6:20on top as they were bailed by the
  186. 6:22taxpayers and a moral hazard is where
  187. 6:24you don't experience the full
  188. 6:25consequence of your actions. Basically
  189. 6:27meaning that these banks think that they
  190. 6:29will be bailed out next time too. And
  191. 6:32ultimately this makes the whole system
  192. 6:33even riskier. Now, it's important to
  193. 6:35note that when an economy is being
  194. 6:36squeezed, they typically implement
  195. 6:38capital controls. So, for example, in
  196. 6:40Greece in 2015, banks shut and cash
  197. 6:43withdrawals were limited to €60 a day.
  198. 6:47And the other thing that typically
  199. 6:48happens when an economy is squeezed is
  200. 6:49of course people lose money, even if
  201. 6:52it's in a bank account. So, for example,
  202. 6:54in Cyprus in 2013, the bank shut for
  203. 6:57almost two weeks. Those guys that had
  204. 6:59uninsured deposits who were hit the
  205. 7:00hardest. Now, it is true there was over
  206. 7:03€100,000 and you might ask the question,
  207. 7:05how many people had over €100,000 in
  208. 7:07their bank account, which is a fair
  209. 7:09question, but it doesn't take away the
  210. 7:10fact that if you had parked your money
  211. 7:11in the Bank of Cyprus, you would have
  212. 7:13lost 47.5% of that money above 100K and
  213. 7:17in this bank called Ly nearly 100%. So
  214. 7:21then an important question arises, who
  215. 7:23avoided it? Well, savers who move their
  216. 7:26money early and wealthy people who had
  217. 7:28options abroad. So, for example, if you
  218. 7:30had a bank account in Germany, you could
  219. 7:32just send that money to Germany
  220. 7:34beforehand, right? And from what I've
  221. 7:37noticed studying things in the past, it
  222. 7:39seems very advantageous to have bank
  223. 7:41accounts in different countries and
  224. 7:42jurisdictions. But that's not financial
  225. 7:44advice. Those are just things that I've
  226. 7:46noticed. But now, who couldn't move
  227. 7:48their money? Well, the ordinary saver
  228. 7:51and the person who depends on their
  229. 7:52local bank. These guys basically got
  230. 7:54crushed. And to make Greece's matters
  231. 7:56worse, they had a brain drain. So,
  232. 7:57remember how I mentioned that earlier?
  233. 7:59This is where the educated young people
  234. 8:00of the country leave. So for example
  235. 8:02doctors, engineers, they leave the for
  236. 8:04example western nations where they can
  237. 8:06get a higher salary and a higher
  238. 8:08standard of living. And the bad thing
  239. 8:10about this especially for Greece at this
  240. 8:12time is that they then have a shrinking
  241. 8:14tax pool because these guys they also
  242. 8:16higher paid in Greece. So when they
  243. 8:19leave to a different country, Greece's
  244. 8:21government's tax revenue will
  245. 8:23subsequently decrease. And something
  246. 8:25that I'd like to mention here is that in
  247. 8:27Eastern Europe, probably for the last 35
  248. 8:30years, the meta, the most effective
  249. 8:32tactic available has basically been
  250. 8:34learn English and come to England or
  251. 8:36America or learn French, go to France,
  252. 8:39basically just get to the west, you
  253. 8:40know. But the thing people don't realize
  254. 8:42is that the whole of Europe and the West
  255. 8:44is currently in a recession. So this
  256. 8:46strategy is no longer viable. In fact, I
  257. 8:48should probably make a video on how the
  258. 8:49whole of the West is in a recession and
  259. 8:51it has been probably for a few months
  260. 8:52now, but that'll probably be later on.
  261. 8:54And we can see just how much this
  262. 8:56affected Greece because of the fact that
  263. 8:58it lost 25% of its economy. Not just
  264. 9:00because of the brain drain, but
  265. 9:02obviously because of the austerity, the
  266. 9:03privatization, this that and the other.
  267. 9:05And they had 58% youth unemployment.
  268. 9:07Basically meaning that if you are young
  269. 9:09there, your future was not looking so
  270. 9:11bright. So again, your best option was
  271. 9:13to move. So the three most important
  272. 9:16things I want you to note is the fact
  273. 9:17that if you couldn't move your money or
  274. 9:20yourself
  275. 9:22then you would have lost. That's the
  276. 9:23first thing. Second thing is that rich
  277. 9:26people move their money. The middle
  278. 9:28class got squeezed and the poor people
  279. 9:30basically had no options. And finally
  280. 9:32just like in the Roman Empire basically
  281. 9:342,000 years ago they don't fix the
  282. 9:36system. They just close the exits. They
  283. 9:37implement capital control so that you
  284. 9:39can't move your money. But now the
  285. 9:40logical question arises. What did the
  286. 9:42ECB do during that time? Well, in 2012,
  287. 9:45Draghy, who was the president of the ECB
  288. 9:47at that time, promised to do whatever it
  289. 9:49takes to save the euro. His strategy,
  290. 9:52well, of course, cheap loans for banks
  291. 9:54and QE, which is basically money
  292. 9:56creation by the central bank.
  293. 9:59Subsequently, the ECB's balance sheet
  294. 10:01grew to around €8.8 trillion at its
  295. 10:04peak. And obviously, this bought time,
  296. 10:07but this did not fix the structural
  297. 10:09issues or the problems, right? It's kind
  298. 10:11of like if you think back to the Roman
  299. 10:13video where the emperor they based the
  300. 10:15coin to buy time but this then eroded
  301. 10:18the trust in the coin.
  302. 10:20And something that's rarely spoken about
  303. 10:23actually is the fact that Germany
  304. 10:24basically gave all these countries a
  305. 10:26hidden loan. And this will be important.
  306. 10:28Remember this because when I cover why
  307. 10:30the euro is a scam, this will be quite
  308. 10:32relevant. So how' they do it? Well,
  309. 10:34target 2, which is basically the payment
  310. 10:37system used between the European central
  311. 10:39banks, showed us that the periphery
  312. 10:41savers money flowed into German banks,
  313. 10:44showing us that this is where people
  314. 10:45thought that their money would be safe,
  315. 10:48right? And the German central bank's
  316. 10:50claims grew past €1 trillion. Now, let
  317. 10:53me break that down into simple English.
  318. 10:55So, imagine I'm Greek, right? I have
  319. 10:58€100,000 in my bank account, but I'm
  320. 10:59worried about those €100,000 just
  321. 11:02vanishing. So what I do is I move that
  322. 11:04money into a German bank. So what
  323. 11:07happens is it now leaves the Greek
  324. 11:09financial system and goes into the
  325. 11:10German financial system or the banking
  326. 11:12system to the other banking system. And
  327. 11:14behind the scenes, the Greek central
  328. 11:16bank now owes the German central bank
  329. 11:19€100,000
  330. 11:21and that IOU is recorded on target 2.
  331. 11:25Now when you do this over millions of
  332. 11:26people, billions of euros, you
  333. 11:29eventually get to this. Now why is it a
  334. 11:31hidden loan? Well, these countries were
  335. 11:33in a financial crisis. So, there was a
  336. 11:35chance that they simply would not be
  337. 11:36able to pay this money. So, the central
  338. 11:38bank would basically default on those
  339. 11:41€100,000 being sent to the German
  340. 11:43central bank. So, that was essentially
  341. 11:44the risk here. Now, the ECB obviously
  342. 11:47thinks that this was a great success
  343. 11:48because it prevented the collapse of the
  344. 11:50euro and borrowing costs did fall. But
  345. 11:53obviously, they did not pay the price.
  346. 11:55These guys did, the savers and the wage
  347. 11:57earners. Because if you're a wage
  348. 11:59earner, you see that your purchasing
  349. 12:00power starts to decrease as asset prices
  350. 12:02start to rise and then after a while
  351. 12:05obviously we'll see that consumer goods
  352. 12:08also start to rise. And obviously it's
  353. 12:09the same concept here with the savers.
  354. 12:12Now the only people that benefited from
  355. 12:14this of course are the asset holders and
  356. 12:16the governments. They were able to
  357. 12:18continue to borrow cheaply. And now
  358. 12:19before we cover why the euro is a scam,
  359. 12:21we first need to go through two more
  360. 12:23concepts. So number one shocks on the
  361. 12:25system. So obviously we had COVID and
  362. 12:27then we had energy issues because
  363. 12:29Germany along with the rest of the EU
  364. 12:31decided to implement sanctions on
  365. 12:33Russian energy and Germany operates on
  366. 12:36an industrial model. So by getting rid
  367. 12:39of your cheap energy you you destroy
  368. 12:42that industrial model everything takes a
  369. 12:44very severe hit and we can see that as
  370. 12:46the Euro inflation peaked in October of
  371. 12:482022 at 10.6%.
  372. 12:51It's also important to note that Germany
  373. 12:53is basically the heart of the system. If
  374. 12:56your heart gets weaker, you also get
  375. 12:58weaker, right? So, suffice to say, this
  376. 13:01is not good for the EU and specifically
  377. 13:02the Euro zone. Now, in my opinion at
  378. 13:05least, they let two countries join so
  379. 13:07that they could offset some of that
  380. 13:09inflation and to try and alleviate that
  381. 13:11strain. So, they let Croatia join. And
  382. 13:13even though officially what I'm saying
  383. 13:15is incorrect, from people I know, I
  384. 13:17definitely know this is true. Basically
  385. 13:18overnight prices in Croatia increased by
  386. 13:2140%. And the exact same thing is true in
  387. 13:24Bulgaria because I mean I've seen that
  388. 13:26you know when they accepted the euro for
  389. 13:28example if something used to cost one in
  390. 13:31the Bulgarian currency they just flipped
  391. 13:32that into euros. You know it's it would
  392. 13:34be funny but obviously most people are
  393. 13:37suffering out there because of something
  394. 13:38like that. And the most ridiculous thing
  395. 13:40about the fact that they let these two
  396. 13:42countries join is that the politicians
  397. 13:44misled their people thinking that
  398. 13:46they're now going to be rich because
  399. 13:47obviously these countries are I mean I
  400. 13:49can't really speak so much about Croatia
  401. 13:51but Bulgaria is literally the poorest
  402. 13:52country in the EU. So when you have
  403. 13:55desperate people and you're promising
  404. 13:56them something that they're now going to
  405. 13:58be rich well obviously they're going to
  406. 13:59vote for that thing right out of
  407. 14:01desperation. In fact in Bulgaria they
  408. 14:03told him that they are now joining the
  409. 14:04club of the rich so they're now going to
  410. 14:06be rich. It's honestly absurd. But
  411. 14:08enough with that tangent. The only thing
  412. 14:10I want you to understand here is that I
  413. 14:11personally think that these two
  414. 14:13countries were allowed to join to try
  415. 14:14and offset some of that inflationary
  416. 14:16pressure. In fact, someone asked me, how
  417. 14:18does America keep inflation so low? And
  418. 14:20the concept is basically the same
  419. 14:22because of the fact that the whole world
  420. 14:23basically accepts US dollars as payment.
  421. 14:26When they print these dollars, they're
  422. 14:28able to export that inflation abroad. So
  423. 14:30for example, some of that inflation has
  424. 14:31felt in China, in India, in the UK
  425. 14:35because the dollar is still the global
  426. 14:37reserve currency and subsequently a lot
  427. 14:39of trade is still conducted in the
  428. 14:41dollar. And now the final thing I want
  429. 14:42you to understand before I explain why
  430. 14:44the euro is a scam is the importance of
  431. 14:47having your own currency because in 2008
  432. 14:49both Greece and Iceland felt the shock.
  433. 14:52But Iceland actually let it banks fail
  434. 14:55and the corona failed by 50%. Which is
  435. 14:57obviously painful. But exports and
  436. 14:59tourism recovered quickly. Whereas if we
  437. 15:02contrast this with Greece, they have no
  438. 15:04currency to fall. They can't do
  439. 15:06anything. They're basically a slave to
  440. 15:07the ECB. And what they have is a decade
  441. 15:10plus of depression. They literally have
  442. 15:12the modern day equivalent of the Great
  443. 15:13Depression. You can even Google that.
  444. 15:15And in my opinion, that was meant to
  445. 15:17happen in the whole of the West if they
  446. 15:19didn't intervene with low rates and QE.
  447. 15:22But unfortunately, I believe that this
  448. 15:24time they won't be able to stop it as
  449. 15:26we're at a point where we can no longer
  450. 15:28just kick the can down the road.
  451. 15:31It's also important to mention that the
  452. 15:33UK, Poland, and Sweden were also in the
  453. 15:36EU at that time, but they had their own
  454. 15:38currencies, meaning that of course they
  455. 15:40had their own central bank and their own
  456. 15:41exchange rates. And it's important to
  457. 15:44note that actually Poland avoided a
  458. 15:46recession in 2009. It was the only
  459. 15:47member of the EU that did not have a
  460. 15:49recession. And that's because of the
  461. 15:51fact they actually kept a sound banking
  462. 15:53principles. It had, if I'm not mistaken,
  463. 15:55a debt to GDP ratio of under 50%. In
  464. 15:582008 and it's important to note that
  465. 16:00even though their currency fell sharply
  466. 16:02in 2009, it actually ended the year
  467. 16:04stronger than at the beginning of the
  468. 16:06year. So even though I am against
  469. 16:08central banks devaluing your currency,
  470. 16:11creating money and all those things, I
  471. 16:13personally do think that it's better at
  472. 16:15least if you have your own central bank
  473. 16:17rather than a random central bank in a
  474. 16:19far away place that dictates your own
  475. 16:21policy even if it's not in your best
  476. 16:22interest. But now let's now cover why
  477. 16:25the euro is actually a scam. So the euro
  478. 16:27was sold as the heir to the Deutsch
  479. 16:29monk. And in order for the German
  480. 16:31populace to agree to this, they gave
  481. 16:33three promises. The first one was no
  482. 16:35bailouts,
  483. 16:37but obviously that crumbled because they
  484. 16:38bailed Greece out. But what they
  485. 16:40promised was the EU would not be a
  486. 16:42transfer union where Germany because
  487. 16:44it's the strongest economy in Europe
  488. 16:46would have to bail out the weaker
  489. 16:47economies. But naturally this promise
  490. 16:50was defaulted on and they broke it. Then
  491. 16:53Chancellor Cole gave a pledge. He said
  492. 16:55that we are not adopting as in we the
  493. 16:57Germans, we are not adopting a weaker
  494. 16:59European standard. No, no, no. They are
  495. 17:02rising to our level. They're adopting
  496. 17:04our stronger standard, our stricter
  497. 17:07monetary culture. And then of course the
  498. 17:09finance minister Vigirl's slogan where
  499. 17:12he said that the euro would be as hard
  500. 17:14as the Deutsch mark. And in this
  501. 17:16promise, what he's saying is that savers
  502. 17:18should rest assure that their purchasing
  503. 17:20power will not be eroded by inflationary
  504. 17:22policies of neighboring countries. Well,
  505. 17:25let's see how that went.
  506. 17:27Also, I'd like to point out that this
  507. 17:29solves a problem that never existed
  508. 17:32under sound money. From 1871, from 1871
  509. 17:35to 1914, Europe trade traded under the
  510. 17:38gold standard. And in fact, that was
  511. 17:40literally the golden era of Europe where
  512. 17:42there were so many inventions and Europe
  513. 17:44improved so much as a civilization, as a
  514. 17:47continental civilization. And it's also
  515. 17:48important to note that countries traded
  516. 17:50completely freely under this system.
  517. 17:52Now, it's also important to note because
  518. 17:54of the bailouts in 2008 and the packages
  519. 17:57after that, what we get is a bailout
  520. 17:59union. And when you have something like
  521. 18:02that, it eventually and inevitably leads
  522. 18:05to a gradual monetary collapse. So,
  523. 18:06that's what I would expect to happen in
  524. 18:07the euro in the future. I can't say
  525. 18:09when, but I would expect the euro to
  526. 18:10collapse sometime in the future because
  527. 18:12this is just a failed experiment.
  528. 18:15In my opinion, the point of the euro was
  529. 18:17simply control. Because if you have no
  530. 18:20central bank, what you're actually
  531. 18:21giving up is complete control. If the
  532. 18:24central bank is not accountable to the
  533. 18:26government in your country and to some
  534. 18:29far away place, well, you you're not in
  535. 18:31charge. And subsequently, they could
  536. 18:33implement policies that actually damage
  537. 18:35your economy. And on the topic of
  538. 18:37control, remember how at the beginning I
  539. 18:39said that the idea of the euro was for
  540. 18:41convergence, for poorer countries to
  541. 18:42catch up to the rich ones, right?
  542. 18:45Well, if you don't adhere to the party
  543. 18:47line, basically, as is the case in
  544. 18:49Slovakia and Hungary up until recently,
  545. 18:52they don't give you any money. So, for
  546. 18:54example, when Slovakia or Hungary would
  547. 18:56not agree to the Russian sanctions, they
  548. 18:59wouldn't receive the money that they
  549. 19:00were owed by the EU. And even though
  550. 19:02this is slightly off topic, I think that
  551. 19:04Christine Lagard has decided to step
  552. 19:06down as the president of the ECB because
  553. 19:09of the fact that France is obviously in
  554. 19:12financial turmoil and they're looking
  555. 19:14like the first country that may crack in
  556. 19:15the upcoming collapse. And it would be a
  557. 19:18bad look if you were to have a French
  558. 19:19national as the head of the ECB. So
  559. 19:22naturally, I would not expect the next
  560. 19:24president of the ECB to be French. And
  561. 19:26now that I've explained how the euro
  562. 19:27basically broke every single promise
  563. 19:29that was sold to the public, I will now
  564. 19:31summarize everything that we learned
  565. 19:32here today. So the promise in 1999, one
  566. 19:35currency as good as the Deutsch mark
  567. 19:37with poorer countries catching up to the
  568. 19:39rich ones. Sounds great. The design, one
  569. 19:42central bank for the whole of the Euro
  570. 19:44zone.
  571. 19:46Now remember, a sovereign currency gives
  572. 19:49each country three tools. The ability to
  573. 19:51devalue its money, to set its own
  574. 19:52interest rates, and to create money. And
  575. 19:54we can see how detrimental it was within
  576. 19:56the union itself where Spain and Ireland
  577. 19:57were booming. Then we got a crash and
  578. 19:59then Greece was in serious trouble. In
  579. 20:01fact, they as I already said they went
  580. 20:02through the great depression, their
  581. 20:04great depression.
  582. 20:06We had job cuts, wage cuts, bank shot
  583. 20:08and young people had to move. And also
  584. 20:11the euro has basically defaulted on
  585. 20:13every single promise. In fact, I forgot
  586. 20:14to mention this, but at at the time of
  587. 20:17recording this video, I'm pretty sure
  588. 20:19that every single country currently
  589. 20:21inside the Euro zone, if it had to meet
  590. 20:22the requirements right now, would fail.
  591. 20:24So, ironically, every single country
  592. 20:27should not actually be inside the Euro
  593. 20:28zone. But on the topic of scams, the
  594. 20:30next video will be on how the Fed is a
  595. 20:32scam. Also, feel free to join the
  596. 20:34Discord to help build the community and
  597. 20:36get the free crash checklist in the
  598. 20:38description below or the pinned comment.
  599. 20:40And if you like the video, give it a
  600. 20:42like. Subscribe if you want to see more.
  601. 20:43And let me know if you had any
  602. 20:44questions, as always, in the comment
  603. 20:45section down below.

About this transcript

This page contains the full transcript of Why The Euro Was Built To Fail by Real Education, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 4,086 words across 603 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.

What you can do with it

Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.

Free YouTube transcript tool

YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.