YouTube2Text

Why Technical Analysis is Just Retail Noise · Paul Scott — Transcript

by Chat With Traders · 15,789 words · 2,318 segments · language en · Watch on YouTube

Full transcript

  1. 0:00said this to the cler who was that for
  2. 0:02he said this is for for Manfred upstairs
  3. 0:04and Manfred was the owner of the company
  4. 0:06so he clicks in on the phone line he
  5. 0:07says Manfred you bought you thousand
  6. 0:08tons we'll give you an average price at
  7. 0:10which point Manfred picked the phone up
  8. 0:12and said Harry I didn't say effing tons
  9. 0:15I said effing lots get your effing ass
  10. 0:17back in there and do what I've told you
  11. 0:19to do so he drops the phone goes running
  12. 0:22back into the ring just basically just
  13. 0:24buying everything that you possibly
  14. 0:26could bell goes at 5:00 it's closed
  15. 0:29above this price he cannot work out for
  16. 0:31the life of him why Manfred's asked him
  17. 0:33to do it. This was before 8:00. So the
  18. 0:35market opened at 8 and it was kind of
  19. 0:36like tumble weed before then. It was a
  20. 0:39real big calm before the storm and then
  21. 0:42the minute 8:00 boom like the phone
  22. 0:45boards just lit up and it must have been
  23. 0:47the same for every single, you know,
  24. 0:49company that was on the floor at the
  25. 0:50time. So that was crazy. I'd never seen
  26. 0:53and still to this day there has never
  27. 0:55been another day in the copper market
  28. 0:56like that. So, if you can imagine that
  29. 0:58we started out copper trading at around
  30. 1:00about 2,800 bucks a ton and by the time
  31. 1:02we'd finished it had dropped 50% in a
  32. 1:05day. It was just bonkers. You could
  33. 1:08literally, I mean, as a cler, you could
  34. 1:10not keep up with what your trader was
  35. 1:11doing cuz it was just yep, yep, yep,
  36. 1:13yep, yep, yep, yep. And, you know, and
  37. 1:16again, you know, you had to rely upon it
  38. 1:18being my word is my bond. This is what
  39. 1:21we did. You know, even if it cost your
  40. 1:23company money, you know, your word was
  41. 1:24your bond. And I remember going back to
  42. 1:27the office that evening. Obviously,
  43. 1:29everybody went back to the office that
  44. 1:30evening, but we got outside. You know,
  45. 1:32there's the BBC, you've got Reuters,
  46. 1:34you've got all of these reporters
  47. 1:36outside of the building. And we were
  48. 1:38told in no uncertain terms, if any of
  49. 1:40you speak to any of the media, you're
  50. 1:42sacked on the spot.
  51. 1:43>> First question to you, and that is, do
  52. 1:46you think traders can find success
  53. 1:48purely depending on technicals?
  54. 1:50>> I'm going to be biased and say no. Oh,
  55. 1:53what would the pit traders have said if
  56. 1:54somebody was walking through there with
  57. 1:56like oscillators and RSI and indicators
  58. 1:59and what would they say?
  59. 2:00>> They'd laugh them out the building.
  60. 2:02>> What would your trading look like if
  61. 2:04capital wasn't the constraint? That's
  62. 2:06the reality for most traders. It's not
  63. 2:08skill holding them back. It's size.
  64. 2:10Trade the pool changes that. Step into
  65. 2:12the US equity markets with up to
  66. 2:14$200,000 in buying power without
  67. 2:17committing your own capital. Full access
  68. 2:19to stocks and ETFs, long or short,
  69. 2:21executed with the precision and freedom
  70. 2:23serious traders expect. Your performance
  71. 2:25is measured by one standard. Disciplined
  72. 2:27risk management and consistent
  73. 2:29execution. Meet that standard and you
  74. 2:31operate at scale. No subscriptions, no
  75. 2:34ongoing obligations, just a clear path
  76. 2:36forward. For those ready to trade beyond
  77. 2:39limitations, this is the next level.
  78. 2:43Markets, [music]
  79. 2:43speculation, and risk. This is the Chat
  80. 2:46with Traders podcast.
  81. 2:48>> [music]
  82. 2:50>> All right, traders. Welcome to another
  83. 2:52episode of Chat with Traders. Very
  84. 2:54excited for this one. Today's guest,
  85. 2:55Paul Scott. He's a second generation
  86. 2:58trader whose education didn't begin with
  87. 3:00screens, with indicators, social media.
  88. 3:02It began through nearly 65 years of
  89. 3:05family market wisdom. Paul's father
  90. 3:07traded copper beginning in the 1970s,
  91. 3:10operating in a world where traders stood
  92. 3:11face to face in trading pits and prices
  93. 3:14were discovered through human behavior
  94. 3:16rather than algorithm. This is something
  95. 3:18his father Harry Scott talked about
  96. 3:19where we should trade intent. Less
  97. 3:21algorithms, less indicators, but more
  98. 3:23human intent. So Paul himself entered
  99. 3:25the business at just 16 years old,
  100. 3:27eventually building a career across
  101. 3:29commodities and forex markets, spanning
  102. 3:31more than three decades. What makes
  103. 3:33Paul's story real interesting is his
  104. 3:35philosophy often runs directly against a
  105. 3:38lot of what modern retail traders think,
  106. 3:40and he's focused more on capital
  107. 3:42preservation more so than chasing home
  108. 3:44runs. He says if you can't explain your
  109. 3:46trade in one sentence, you shouldn't be
  110. 3:48in it. He focuses on price and value
  111. 3:50rather than prediction. He also teaches
  112. 3:52traders to become directionally
  113. 3:54agnostic. Something I'm excited to dive
  114. 3:56into today. And perhaps the most
  115. 3:58controversial thing of all, he argues
  116. 4:00that technical analysis is largely
  117. 4:03noise. Because in the trading pits,
  118. 4:05traders were not staring at charts. They
  119. 4:06were actually watching price and human
  120. 4:08behavior. So today we'll explore old
  121. 4:10school market wisdom, what the trading
  122. 4:12pits can still teach us today, and
  123. 4:14whether modern traders have made markets
  124. 4:16unnecessarily complicated. So traders,
  125. 4:18here's my conversation with Paul Scott.
  126. 4:20Let's dive into it. Mr. Scott, how are
  127. 4:22you?
  128. 4:23>> Thank you very much for having me on.
  129. 4:24Excited to go through whatever you want
  130. 4:26to go through, my friend.
  131. 4:27>> Well, let's start with I mean your early
  132. 4:29journey. So a lot of traders discovered
  133. 4:31the markets, but Paul, you really grew
  134. 4:34up around the markets with your dad.
  135. 4:36What was that experience like growing up
  136. 4:37around?
  137. 4:38>> Well, as a young guy, like, you know,
  138. 4:40when you're a kid, not really aware of
  139. 4:42what your dad does as a as a job, but
  140. 4:44you know, then you get a bit older and
  141. 4:46um they said, you know, what does your
  142. 4:48dad do for a living? And I said, he's a
  143. 4:49he's a trader in the city, you know,
  144. 4:51buys and sells copper. And some people
  145. 4:53would say, you know, like a scrapyard
  146. 4:55dealer. And I said, no, he wears a suit
  147. 4:57and he goes to a trading floor. And um
  148. 5:00you know so I'd met a few of the guys uh
  149. 5:02that I would eventually work with
  150. 5:04through you know sort of family
  151. 5:05gatherings and you know barbecues and
  152. 5:07days out and stuff like that. And um
  153. 5:09then at the age of 16 when I'd finished
  154. 5:11my exams I had about a month off to you
  155. 5:14know go out with friends and go party
  156. 5:16and stuff like that. And then one day he
  157. 5:18grabbed me by the pals and said right my
  158. 5:20son what are you going to do for the
  159. 5:21rest of your life? And I said dad I've
  160. 5:23got no idea. And so he said, "Right, I'm
  161. 5:26going to buy some suits and some shirts
  162. 5:28and some ties and some shoes, and you're
  163. 5:30coming to work with me. By the way,
  164. 5:31you're not getting paid for it. You're
  165. 5:33just getting some experience." So yeah,
  166. 5:36I turned up uh the very first day at
  167. 5:38Triand Metals, not having really that
  168. 5:41much of a clue because he hadn't really
  169. 5:43introduced me to it that much. Took me
  170. 5:45down to the trading floor for the very
  171. 5:46first time. Walked in, absolute
  172. 5:49pandemonium. Had no idea what was going
  173. 5:51on. Uh the acoustics in the building
  174. 5:53were very strange. People were talking
  175. 5:55in a language that I didn't understand.
  176. 5:57You know, backations, contangos,
  177. 5:59spreads, deck, deck, jan jan, you know,
  178. 6:02may june and got to the end of the very
  179. 6:05first day and was quite a tradition. We
  180. 6:08went to the pub opposite the market, a
  181. 6:10pub called the wine lodge and he said,
  182. 6:11"Right, my son, what do you think?" I
  183. 6:13said, "I would never get the hang of
  184. 6:15that in a million years." And he said,
  185. 6:16"That is exactly what I said on the very
  186. 6:18first day that I came down here." And
  187. 6:20yeah, it was a baptism of fire, I would
  188. 6:24suppose you would call it. But over the
  189. 6:25next few months, I sort of got some
  190. 6:28experience and he was, you know, was
  191. 6:30asking around various brokers and banks,
  192. 6:32you know, are there any positions going?
  193. 6:34Um, he finally found one with a company
  194. 6:36called Credit Lea Rouse, which was the
  195. 6:38trading arm of the French bank, Credit
  196. 6:40Lea. They had a floor presence. Um, and
  197. 6:42the guy that worked there who got me the
  198. 6:44job, guy called Peter Chley, was
  199. 6:46actually there the day I was born. mom
  200. 6:48still has a picture of that in the uh
  201. 6:50family photo album. And so got there um
  202. 6:52and I kind of sort of started to get to
  203. 6:54know sort of some of the guys at Credit
  204. 6:56Lea, obviously working around the floor.
  205. 6:58Uh I got there and within the first 10
  206. 7:00or 15 minutes, Peter calls me into the
  207. 7:02coffee room. And he said, "Right, I
  208. 7:04don't care whose son you are, you've got
  209. 7:063 months. If you don't get it after 3
  210. 7:08months, you're gone. Lots of money
  211. 7:10moving around. Very serious job." And so
  212. 7:12that was my baptism into.
  213. 7:15>> So you felt the pressure early on. And
  214. 7:17look, your family been in this industry
  215. 7:20for 65 years. So a lot of wisdom
  216. 7:23instilled from your dad from an early
  217. 7:25age. What was your dad's reputation
  218. 7:27like? And did you feel the pressure as
  219. 7:29well to hold that?
  220. 7:30>> Well, put it this way. If you ask
  221. 7:33anybody of a certain generation, sort of
  222. 7:35my generation or above, do you know
  223. 7:37Harry Scott around the world? It's a
  224. 7:40definite yes. you know, he was a very
  225. 7:44very big character um on the markets.
  226. 7:47Helped out a lot of the younger guys.
  227. 7:49So, you know, every now and again I may
  228. 7:51put a post up, you know, giving a toast
  229. 7:52to the old man. He's passed away now.
  230. 7:54But then you'll get a lot of the guys
  231. 7:55that are sort of my generation or a
  232. 7:57little bit older and a bit older than
  233. 7:58that. Uh will come out and say I've got
  234. 8:00so many fond memories of your dad. He
  235. 8:02was they call him an an LM legend. But
  236. 8:04yeah, so he's known all across the
  237. 8:06world, New York definitely. Um he would
  238. 8:09often frequent um the Comx Copper
  239. 8:11dinner. He would go over there for
  240. 8:13business. They'd all be out um at the
  241. 8:15Tavern on the Green. Um lots of them. So
  242. 8:18the boys from the floor would uh or the
  243. 8:20Comx floor would uh would come to the
  244. 8:21Tavern on the Green and um many beers
  245. 8:23were had, put it that way,
  246. 8:24>> man. What was what were some of the
  247. 8:26great lessons that he taught you?
  248. 8:28>> He taught me a heck of a lot. I mean,
  249. 8:30obviously in the beginning, you're very
  250. 8:32fresh at what you're doing, so I had,
  251. 8:34you know, obviously a barrage of
  252. 8:35questions that I'd be asking him. Uh
  253. 8:37buddy taught me essentially that trading
  254. 8:40has never changed basically since that
  255. 8:42exchange opened. It hasn't changed
  256. 8:44today. It's always been about price
  257. 8:46discovery. It's always been about value
  258. 8:48of you know sort of particular prices.
  259. 8:50So it's kind of like how would you
  260. 8:52expand your knowledge from one
  261. 8:54generation to the next. So obviously if
  262. 8:56you think you know going back in the
  263. 8:58days precomputers you know it can't be
  264. 9:00based around technical analysis because
  265. 9:02it just didn't exist.
  266. 9:04>> Fundamentals are constantly changing.
  267. 9:06So, how on earth do you keep up with
  268. 9:08those? If you actually had a way of sort
  269. 9:10of looking at the market, reading a
  270. 9:12tape, you would say, "Right, well, if
  271. 9:14all of these markets are kind of split
  272. 9:16up into ranges, how do you discover
  273. 9:18those?" You discover those down on on
  274. 9:20the floor because when you get to
  275. 9:22certain prices, the volume goes up, not
  276. 9:24just in trading volume, but you know,
  277. 9:26audio volume. And you would kind of
  278. 9:28recognize, hey, that that's going to be
  279. 9:29the top of the range at the moment. Why?
  280. 9:31Well, because there's a heck of a lot
  281. 9:32more sellers than there are buyers and
  282. 9:34vice versa. And he told me to look at it
  283. 9:36that way because of what happened to him
  284. 9:40um back in the 70s when the charts were
  285. 9:42all paper. So graph paper seller taped
  286. 9:46together
  287. 9:47and he he told me a story uh which I
  288. 9:51have said you know a couple of times in
  289. 9:53a couple of podcasts but he there was a
  290. 9:55transitional period on the metal
  291. 9:57exchange where you would trade in tons.
  292. 10:00So you could trade in you know odd tons.
  293. 10:02you could, you know, buy and sell 9
  294. 10:04tons, 11 tons, 12 tons, whatever. Uh,
  295. 10:06but the the the market started to get
  296. 10:08bigger and more business started to be
  297. 10:10done and they then said to themselves,
  298. 10:13right, well, we need to kind of
  299. 10:14standardize this. So, everybody these
  300. 10:16days knows lots, right? So, they
  301. 10:18standardized it in the copper market
  302. 10:20that one lot, which would now the
  303. 10:21smallest contract you can trade, is the
  304. 10:23equivalent of 25 tons. So, he's sitting
  305. 10:26in the ring on a Friday afternoon and
  306. 10:28it's what's known as the curb. So this
  307. 10:30is where we would trade all the metals
  308. 10:32all at the same time in instead of
  309. 10:34individually. And his clark whispers
  310. 10:36into his ear, Harry, buy a,000 lots at
  311. 10:39market. Make as much noise as possible
  312. 10:42and make sure you make it close above
  313. 10:44this price. So he said, I sat there for
  314. 10:46a couple of seconds and I thought, nah,
  315. 10:48the kid must mean tons. He can't mean
  316. 10:50lots because if he does mean lots,
  317. 10:52that's going to be the biggest order
  318. 10:53this market's ever seen. So he said,
  319. 10:54"So, you know, shouted out, you know,
  320. 10:56three months copper, 95 I sell." He
  321. 10:58said, "500." Guy says, "No, you can have
  322. 11:0150. 95 a give, 98 a give,05 a gift."
  323. 11:04Boom, boom, boom, boom, boom. Buy 1,000
  324. 11:05tons. Jumps out of the the ring, which
  325. 11:08is the pit, but we call it the ring on
  326. 11:09the London Metal Exchange. Um, says to
  327. 11:12the cler, who was that for? He said,
  328. 11:14"This is for for Manfred upstairs." And
  329. 11:16Manfred was the owner of the company. So
  330. 11:18he clicks in on the phone line. He says,
  331. 11:19"ManFred, you bought your thousand tons.
  332. 11:21We'll give you an average price." At
  333. 11:23which point, Manfred picked the phone up
  334. 11:25and said, "Harry, I didn't say effing
  335. 11:28tons. I said effing lots. Get your
  336. 11:31effing ass back in there and do what
  337. 11:33I've told you to do." So, he drops the
  338. 11:36phone, goes running back into the ring.
  339. 11:38Um, just basically just buying
  340. 11:41everything that he possibly could. Bell
  341. 11:43goes at 5:00. It's closed above this
  342. 11:45price. He cannot work out for the life
  343. 11:47of him why Manfred's asked him to do it.
  344. 11:51So he said, "Oh, he didn't buy all of
  345. 11:53it, but I did manage to get it to close
  346. 11:54above this price." He said, "Well, who's
  347. 11:56that order for, Manfred?" He said, "It
  348. 11:57was for me." He said, "Why on earth have
  349. 11:59you done that?" He said, "Come back to
  350. 12:01the office, my son, and I'll show you."
  351. 12:04So he truddles back to the office.
  352. 12:07[snorts]
  353. 12:07And Manfred's there and he gets out
  354. 12:09this, you know, old graph paper chart
  355. 12:14which had prices going, you know,
  356. 12:16probably back to the 40s or the 50s. And
  357. 12:19he said, "Look, Harry, this is the
  358. 12:20particular price I wanted you to go and
  359. 12:22get it to close above. What happened
  360. 12:23when we got here in let's say 1952?"
  361. 12:26We got there and it dropped. Okay. So,
  362. 12:28the val the global perception of value
  363. 12:31of that particular price at that
  364. 12:33particular time was that's expensive.
  365. 12:36So, if it's expensive and it's
  366. 12:37overvalued, then as a trader you want to
  367. 12:40sell, he said, "And then let's have a
  368. 12:42look." So, we got back here in 1959 and
  369. 12:44what happened? The same thing. We got
  370. 12:47back here in 1966 and what happened?
  371. 12:50Well, it closed above that price. What
  372. 12:53happened to the price of copper now? He
  373. 12:56said, "Oh, it went up." He said, "Yeah,
  374. 12:58because the global perception of a ton
  375. 13:00of copper,
  376. 13:02the price of it has changed." [snorts]
  377. 13:04So instead of people thinking it's
  378. 13:06expensive, it's actually now cheap. So
  379. 13:08the price goes up. He said, "So then it
  380. 13:10comes back down. This is where I've got
  381. 13:12you to today.
  382. 13:14I wanted you to make it go and close
  383. 13:16above this price because why? Because I
  384. 13:18wanted to change the global perception
  385. 13:20of the value of a ton of copper. And I
  386. 13:22tell you what, Harry, I guarantee you
  387. 13:24next week the price will go up. We can
  388. 13:27boot out what we bought today and we'll
  389. 13:29make a nice tidy profit. [gasps] So from
  390. 13:32that day onwards,
  391. 13:35that's like looking at particular prices
  392. 13:38and saying, "Right, when we reach these,
  393. 13:40these are going to be a key area of
  394. 13:42decision- making."
  395. 13:43So it's kind it's a range.
  396. 13:46>> So yeah,
  397. 13:47>> that's what that's what your dad was
  398. 13:49saying from I mean look the London Metal
  399. 13:51Exchange was founded in 1877, right? And
  400. 13:53from when your dad started even till
  401. 13:55then moving onward what your dad would
  402. 13:57say is there's no magic formula at all
  403. 14:00outside of human intent. Is that what he
  404. 14:03means?
  405. 14:04>> Yeah.
  406. 14:04>> Yeah. And and it's just based around
  407. 14:06price and it's just based around the
  408. 14:08value of that price. when you get there,
  409. 14:11it's kind of like what's going on
  410. 14:13globally,
  411. 14:15does that price reflect that it's cheap
  412. 14:18or it's expensive? I mean, it's a very
  413. 14:20simple concept, but you know, things are
  414. 14:22cheap, you buy them. Things are
  415. 14:24expensive in the futures markets, you
  416. 14:27sell them.
  417. 14:28>> Right. Right. I want to get back to
  418. 14:31going into the pit a little bit because
  419. 14:33I find that really fascinating and
  420. 14:36especially with how the modern era is
  421. 14:38and tech technology driven of course
  422. 14:40we're behind the computers less in the
  423. 14:43pits but what was it like you were
  424. 14:45mentioning the lots and tons like I I
  425. 14:48know it was there was a lot of it was
  426. 14:49noise driven for example I was reading a
  427. 14:52post you were making regarding you could
  428. 14:54kind of tell which side like where the
  429. 14:57momentum was going based on auditory
  430. 14:59just noise.
  431. 15:01>> It's noise.
  432. 15:01>> So, can can you share with us some of
  433. 15:04those experiences and what what that was
  434. 15:06like and particularly like for example,
  435. 15:09one of the emotions that runs the market
  436. 15:11wild these days is FOMO, right? The fear
  437. 15:13of missing out. Could can you identify
  438. 15:15that in the pit and what would that
  439. 15:17sound like?
  440. 15:18>> You could well I wouldn't necessarily
  441. 15:19say the fear of missing out because
  442. 15:22you're at the cold face. So if you kind
  443. 15:25of missed out on an opportunity, then
  444. 15:27you kind of missed out on an
  445. 15:29opportunity. But you know, I've
  446. 15:32remember the craziest day I've ever seen
  447. 15:36on the London Metal Exchange. That was
  448. 15:38in 1996.
  449. 15:40Um there was a copper scandal. So this
  450. 15:43is uh a rogue trader,
  451. 15:45>> Sumattomo.
  452. 15:46>> Yeah, Sumatmo. That's it. Right. So this
  453. 15:49rogue trader, Yasu Kamanaka, had
  454. 15:51basically been cornering the world's
  455. 15:52copper market and um we got a phone call
  456. 15:57from my dad's Japanese office. So tryand
  457. 16:00in Tokyo. Must have been about 3:00 in
  458. 16:02the morning. And in typical fashion, the
  459. 16:06phone rang. We're very blur eyed. He
  460. 16:09comes downstairs. This is the days. Do
  461. 16:11you remember the days when people would
  462. 16:12actually leave an answer phone message?
  463. 16:14>> Yeah.
  464. 16:15>> Yeah. Right. An answer phone message.
  465. 16:17And so they literally they'd left a
  466. 16:19message and it said Hamac has been
  467. 16:21sacked. Might be busy in the morning.
  468. 16:24Typically understated. And then they
  469. 16:26just put the phone down. So this is
  470. 16:28about 3:00 in the morning. I'm due to go
  471. 16:30and do my uh exams in the morning, which
  472. 16:33would be the equivalent of you guys
  473. 16:35doing like a series 7. Um and I said,
  474. 16:38"Do you think I should go into the
  475. 16:40office or go and do the exam?" And he
  476. 16:41said, "I think you might want to go into
  477. 16:43the office cuz it might be slightly busy
  478. 16:45tomorrow." And so we got there and it
  479. 16:48was [snorts]
  480. 16:49this was before 8:00. So the market
  481. 16:51opened at 8 and it was kind of like
  482. 16:53tumble weed before then. It was a real
  483. 16:56big calm before the storm and then the
  484. 17:00minute 8:00
  485. 17:02boom. It's like the the the phone boards
  486. 17:05just lit up and it must have been the
  487. 17:07same for every single, you know, company
  488. 17:10that was on the floor at the time. So
  489. 17:13that was crazy. I'd never seen and still
  490. 17:16to this day there has never been another
  491. 17:18day in the copper market like that. So
  492. 17:19if you can imagine that we started out
  493. 17:22copper trading at round about 2,800
  494. 17:24bucks a ton and by the time we'd
  495. 17:27finished it had dropped 50% in a day.
  496. 17:31the volume was absolutely crazy and
  497. 17:34[snorts] I remember at the time so it
  498. 17:36would have only been
  499. 17:38uh 17 [snorts] and what I was doing at
  500. 17:41that particular time as well as clarking
  501. 17:44I was giving uh what's known as a run to
  502. 17:46the office. So, I've got the office on
  503. 17:48the phone and I'm telling them what's
  504. 17:49going on. And that's coming out of a
  505. 17:50school box upstairs. And I remember
  506. 17:53going down to the very first copper ring
  507. 17:56and I said, "Hold on to your hats,
  508. 17:58ladies and gentlemen. This might get a
  509. 18:00little bit busy." And it goes ding ding
  510. 18:02ding ding ding copper ring. Cuz we used
  511. 18:04to trade things individually, but ding
  512. 18:06ding ding ding ding
  513. 18:07>> copper ring. One of the guys stood up
  514. 18:12and said, "Right, we're going to get all
  515. 18:13of our tom next out of the way.
  516. 18:16Once we've done that and everybody's
  517. 18:18square,
  518. 18:19then we'll go for it." Because we got to
  519. 18:21make sure that we don't screw up this
  520. 18:23Tom next cuz if you screwed that up,
  521. 18:24then you end up with a physical delivery
  522. 18:26and you don't want a physical delivery
  523. 18:27because you don't want to have to pay
  524. 18:28for the material. Everything's done in
  525. 18:30the future. So, most of those contracts
  526. 18:32have never come to fruition.
  527. 18:34So you spent like the first 90 seconds
  528. 18:37everybody's doing their Tom next and
  529. 18:40then it was like right off we go three
  530. 18:42months copper I don't know 2500 I'll
  531. 18:46give and the guy's like 10,000 no
  532. 18:51I've only got 500 to buy you know so
  533. 18:54he's just like 2500 I sold 2450 2400 so
  534. 18:59normally the market might you know have
  535. 19:01a bid off a spread of maybe $3, $4, $5.
  536. 19:05On this day, bit off a spread was $50.
  537. 19:09>> Oh, yeah. Which was crazy. And the
  538. 19:12tonnage, the volume that went through.
  539. 19:16So, if you had a fear of missing out
  540. 19:18that day,
  541. 19:20I mean, it must have been for the guys
  542. 19:23trading it at the time, cuz I wasn't old
  543. 19:24enough. So, on the metal exchange, you
  544. 19:25have to be 21 to trade.
  545. 19:27>> Okay.
  546. 19:28>> So, not 18 like it would have been on
  547. 19:29every other market. Uh [snorts] but you
  548. 19:31just see guys getting out and they're
  549. 19:33just soaked in sweat, adrenaline,
  550. 19:35>> soaked in. Wow. Yeah, I had read that
  551. 19:38that was 2.6 billion loss. One of the
  552. 19:42largest I mean scandals in the history,
  553. 19:44right, of the fundamental exchange. So
  554. 19:47what was I mean what was it like on the
  555. 19:48floor? Was was everyone just as far as
  556. 19:52the just selling? I know the hand
  557. 19:54signals, the noises. I mean what what
  558. 19:56were you hearing? Can you remember what
  559. 19:58you were hearing?
  560. 20:00Um
  561. 20:02I just I just remember the tonnage, you
  562. 20:05know, the size of the orders were crazy.
  563. 20:07You like 10,000 lots at a time. So if
  564. 20:09you think 10,000 times 25
  565. 20:13>> Mhm.
  566. 20:13>> that gives you the tonnage and then you
  567. 20:16times that by the price. So you've got a
  568. 20:20crazy crazy crazy amount of money being,
  569. 20:23you know, thrown around. And
  570. 20:27it was just bonkers. You could literally
  571. 20:29I mean as a cler you could not
  572. 20:31[clears throat] keep up with what your
  573. 20:32trader was doing because it was just yep
  574. 20:35yep yep yep yep y and you know and again
  575. 20:39you know you had to rely upon it being
  576. 20:41my word is my bond this is what we did
  577. 20:46you know even if it cost your company
  578. 20:47money you know your word was your bond I
  579. 20:50mean I remember we had um in the
  580. 20:52pre-market which is before we would you
  581. 20:54know we'd be in the office before we
  582. 20:56then physically went down to the trading
  583. 20:57floor. We had a five lot screw up. So,
  584. 21:01it's 125 tons of copper. It's nothing.
  585. 21:03It's tiny. But a five lot screw up. Cost
  586. 21:06us $50,000.
  587. 21:10It It was crazy because we we said, you
  588. 21:14know, this was a a trade done over the
  589. 21:16telephone with a company called Sugdan.
  590. 21:18And it was like, right, well, we thought
  591. 21:20we sold you five lots. And Sugdan said,
  592. 21:22well, no, you didn't sell us five lots.
  593. 21:24And so we had to basically take that
  594. 21:27back on board and it cost a heck of a
  595. 21:29lot of money. But I mean the adrenaline
  596. 21:31the the it was it was bonkers.
  597. 21:35>> But boy did you feel alive.
  598. 21:38>> He felt alive. You know there was a
  599. 21:40recent in 2022 perhaps you'll recall the
  600. 21:44London Males Exchange nickel crisis
  601. 21:46where there was a lot of controversy
  602. 21:49here. I mean, look, if you go back to
  603. 21:51the event, the Sumattomo event, why
  604. 21:53couldn't they have just canled all the
  605. 21:55orders like they did in 2022? I mean,
  606. 21:58>> that was unprecedented.
  607. 22:00>> It was. And it was so deep then. It had
  608. 22:04been going on for so long. That's the
  609. 22:06thing,
  610. 22:07>> right? It was like 10 years, right?
  611. 22:08>> Yeah. It was a heck heck of a long heck
  612. 22:10of a long time. But I mean, I was
  613. 22:12working at Credit Lea.
  614. 22:14um we would clear Sumatmo's business.
  615. 22:18So, we were quite involved in what was
  616. 22:21going on. And I remember going back to
  617. 22:24the office um that evening. Obviously,
  618. 22:27everybody went back to the office that
  619. 22:29evening, but we got outside, you know,
  620. 22:31the BBC, you got Reuters, you've got all
  621. 22:34of these reporters outside of the
  622. 22:36building. And we were told in no
  623. 22:38uncertain terms, if any of you speak to
  624. 22:41any of the media, you're sacked on the
  625. 22:44spot.
  626. 22:46You're sacked on the spot. So, you know,
  627. 22:47we had to go back inside. And you know
  628. 22:50the next day
  629. 22:53it was really weird cuz it was just like
  630. 22:55you nothing kind of really happened.
  631. 22:58>> It was the calm after the storm.
  632. 23:00>> Yeah, it was like Yeah, it was it was a
  633. 23:04very very strange time but fun.
  634. 23:06>> Was it eerie? Was it just eerie feeling
  635. 23:08the day thereafter? Yeah, it was because
  636. 23:11it was because you you'd come out of
  637. 23:13that I mean you I suppose looking back
  638. 23:15at it was like an out of body experience
  639. 23:17because it was just so crazy and then
  640. 23:20you come in the next day and it's just
  641. 23:22like
  642. 23:24and did yesterday really happened you
  643. 23:26know it was crazy but then yeah I mean
  644. 23:30that then over the years we had uh
  645. 23:32somebody tried to put a squeeze on the
  646. 23:34tin market that went horribly wrong for
  647. 23:37them because that's the thing you
  648. 23:39>> [snorts]
  649. 23:39>> Being on a trading floor, if you find
  650. 23:41out that somebody is trying to put a
  651. 23:42squeeze on a market, then you put the
  652. 23:44squeeze on the squeezer
  653. 23:46>> and inevitably it ends up costing them
  654. 23:49money because their position is so big
  655. 23:51and they are the dominant position
  656. 23:53holder. When people find out, it's like
  657. 23:55sharks with blood,
  658. 23:57>> right? Well, there was a very large uh
  659. 23:59squeeze that did happen the few years
  660. 24:01ago from a large holder who was hedging
  661. 24:04a position uh that was in that was
  662. 24:07nickel.
  663. 24:07>> That was nickel. Yeah.
  664. 24:09>> Yeah. What are your thoughts on that?
  665. 24:10Now, that received a lot of legal
  666. 24:12backlash, a lot of regulatory scrutiny
  667. 24:14um over that. What were your thoughts,
  668. 24:16the London Metals Exchange cancelling
  669. 24:19all those orders?
  670. 24:21>> Um I think it was kind of a bit
  671. 24:23[clears throat] of a fair thing to do. I
  672. 24:25mean, exchanges do change their rules
  673. 24:28every now and again. Um, I remember my
  674. 24:32dad telling me about the uh the Bunker
  675. 24:34Hunt brothers trying to put a squeeze on
  676. 24:36the silver market back in the early '7s
  677. 24:37and early 80s. Um, until the day when
  678. 24:41Comx had basically had enough and said,
  679. 24:43"Right, we're changing the rules."
  680. 24:46Called it silver Thursday. We're
  681. 24:47changing the rules. You cannot buy
  682. 24:49silver on margin in the spot month.
  683. 24:52There was something that they didn't
  684. 24:53say. They didn't say you couldn't sell
  685. 24:55it.
  686. 24:56>> Mhm. [snorts] So you know that's again
  687. 24:58that was another crazy day back in 19
  688. 25:01you know back in 1980 but these things
  689. 25:03do happen and you know markets h have to
  690. 25:06adapt exchanges have to adapt and I
  691. 25:08think the fair thing was to cancel the
  692. 25:10contracts because otherwise it could
  693. 25:12have just been an exponential rise and
  694. 25:15if you can't get your hands on the
  695. 25:16material [sighs]
  696. 25:18you know it's going to people so
  697. 25:22you kind of
  698. 25:23>> you know
  699. 25:23>> let's talk about the the pit logic that
  700. 25:26that you've discussed in your writings.
  701. 25:28So yeah, explain that.
  702. 25:30>> So basically for me that is having the
  703. 25:32ability in a in the digital age to read
  704. 25:36the intentions of the people that are
  705. 25:39buying and selling and where they're
  706. 25:40making key decisions from. So this is
  707. 25:42kind of like the the real noise points,
  708. 25:44the real key decision- making points.
  709. 25:47And it's kind of like, you know, if you
  710. 25:49imagine being in a pit and you're in the
  711. 25:53middle of a range,
  712. 25:55right? All you're doing there is you're
  713. 25:56just executing business for clients.
  714. 25:58You're not really interested in stepping
  715. 25:59up for yourself. So I would say probably
  716. 26:02about 95% of what we would do would be
  717. 26:05to trade for customers. That's your
  718. 26:08bread and butter. That's your
  719. 26:09commission, you know, yada yada. It's
  720. 26:11only when you sort of get to these sort
  721. 26:12of certain places, certain prices I
  722. 26:15should say, you know that a decision has
  723. 26:16to be made. So if you've been there
  724. 26:18before,
  725. 26:19you can see that a decision's been made.
  726. 26:21So then you know when you get back there
  727. 26:23again the decision has to be made again.
  728. 26:26Do we keep the previous valuation or do
  729. 26:29we change it?
  730. 26:31That's kind of like a language that you
  731. 26:33can read on a chart. But if you're
  732. 26:35standing in a pit, you got to say to
  733. 26:36yourself, right, what do I need to know?
  734. 26:39What's the number at the top of the
  735. 26:40range and what's the number at the
  736. 26:41bottom of the range?
  737. 26:44When we get to either one of them, and
  738. 26:45again that could be at any particular
  739. 26:47point in the day, point in the week,
  740. 26:49point in the month. When I get there,
  741. 26:53are there more buying orders? Are there
  742. 26:55more people shouting they want to buy?
  743. 26:56Which means the general perception is
  744. 26:58okay, so this is actually undervalued
  745. 26:59when we get here. So then we, you know,
  746. 27:02the top of the range then becomes the
  747. 27:03bottom of the range as we break above
  748. 27:05there, we close above there, and then
  749. 27:06the momentum takes it higher or vice
  750. 27:08versa if it's, you know, in the opposite
  751. 27:09direction. That is a language you can
  752. 27:12read on a chart
  753. 27:14if somebody shows you. I've been
  754. 27:17teaching people over the last 10 years.
  755. 27:19And in the last 10 years, there's only
  756. 27:22been one student of mine, very clever
  757. 27:25guy, one student of mine. When I showed
  758. 27:28him,
  759. 27:30he said, "Yeah, I've noticed that."
  760. 27:33Everyone else has been like, "What on
  761. 27:36earth are you showing me? This is crazy.
  762. 27:37This is just naked chart with price and
  763. 27:41a horizontal line on it." You know,
  764. 27:44where are the chart patterns? Where are
  765. 27:45the indicators? Where is the you know
  766. 27:47>> are you essentially saying like this is
  767. 27:48where liquidity lies? I' I've heard you
  768. 27:50mention it's this wholesale level and
  769. 27:54then retail level uh just where supply
  770. 27:57and demand are right simply put is that
  771. 27:59what you're saying
  772. 28:00>> it is well if you'd said right so if you
  773. 28:02said support and resistance supply
  774. 28:05demand overvalued undervalued cheap or
  775. 28:08expensive it's kind of like well
  776. 28:11whichever one of those makes the most
  777. 28:12sense in your mind
  778. 28:15think of it in those terms but then
  779. 28:17think of the think of the intentions so
  780. 28:19Why would I get support? Well, because I
  781. 28:21think the market's undervalued. [snorts]
  782. 28:24So, people want to buy.
  783. 28:26Why do I get resistance? Well, because
  784. 28:29we think it's expensive. We think it
  785. 28:31wants to sell. And so, the liquidity
  786. 28:33there would be to the sell side. So,
  787. 28:35that's, you know, that's a price and
  788. 28:37that's a value,
  789. 28:39>> you know. So, it goes back to it goes
  790. 28:41back to human intent. It definitely
  791. 28:45>> like our perception our perception of
  792. 28:47what the value should be which you
  793. 28:50believe can be altered right
  794. 28:52>> yeah and it will change over time
  795. 28:53depending on what's going on externally
  796. 28:55but it's [snorts]
  797. 28:56>> you know it's a very primeval thing
  798. 29:00because I would say to you and anybody
  799. 29:02that's listening you remember going to
  800. 29:04the store when you were a kid mom can I
  801. 29:06have this no [laughter] it's too
  802. 29:09expensive okay mom can I have Yes. Yes.
  803. 29:13You didn't ask if it was cheap enough.
  804. 29:15You knew it was cheap enough because she
  805. 29:17said yes. So then what you got to think
  806. 29:19is right, well, all the people that are
  807. 29:21trading this around the world working at
  808. 29:23investment banks and hedge funds and
  809. 29:25wherever, well, their perception of
  810. 29:28value is exactly the same as yours. It's
  811. 29:31derived in the same way. So if you then
  812. 29:33have a collective group of people that
  813. 29:35essentially are the key decision makers
  814. 29:37inside of that market if they want to
  815. 29:39change the perception of value.
  816. 29:42>> Yeah. Do you have an example of seeing
  817. 29:44that? So this perceived value what is um
  818. 29:47do you think it's most important then to
  819. 29:50rather than indicators like we've like
  820. 29:52you've mentioned knowing what are what
  821. 29:55are 90% of people what do they perceive
  822. 29:57this value as?
  823. 29:58>> Yeah. So I mean a perceived value the
  824. 30:00the thing is it's very different when
  825. 30:02you're at the coldface when you're on a
  826. 30:04trading floor
  827. 30:06to describe to somebody else looking on
  828. 30:09a digital chart what that actually
  829. 30:12really looks like because I think one of
  830. 30:15the things that people actually forget
  831. 30:17in the digital age is that there are
  832. 30:20people doing this as a real job but
  833. 30:23they're creating what you see.
  834. 30:26>> Mhm. [snorts]
  835. 30:27>> Does that make sense? So if you're
  836. 30:28looking at a candlestick chart, well the
  837. 30:30actions that we take are creating that
  838. 30:32candlestick and that's what you see
  839. 30:34whereas that's not what we see. So what
  840. 30:38we could do is is we could say let's say
  841. 30:39as an example u let's say copper's
  842. 30:42trading at $7,000 a ton. Uh the last
  843. 30:46couple of times we got there that was
  844. 30:47perceived to be expensive.
  845. 30:49We get there today
  846. 30:52and something external's happened. All
  847. 30:55right. Something external's happened and
  848. 30:57it's changed the global perception. So
  849. 31:00we are sorry, we're going to change the
  850. 31:01global perception through the actions
  851. 31:03that we take.
  852. 31:05So then what could happen is is you
  853. 31:06could you could get to the price of
  854. 31:087,000 and then all of a sudden you go
  855. 31:09straight through it
  856. 31:13on a digital chart. You might completely
  857. 31:16and utterly miss that. Well, most people
  858. 31:18would. retail traders would miss it
  859. 31:19because they've not been taught, you
  860. 31:20know, how to look essentially for, you
  861. 31:23know, pit logic, trading, you know, ring
  862. 31:25logic, and they'll just go, "Oh, well,
  863. 31:27it's just gone through that price, yada
  864. 31:29yada yada," without actually really
  865. 31:31understanding that on a global scale,
  866. 31:33that's going to change people's
  867. 31:35perception of value of that particular
  868. 31:36price, but they might not be looking for
  869. 31:38those particular prices. Because if your
  870. 31:42trading is all based around technical
  871. 31:43indicators or fundamentals or trend
  872. 31:47lines and stuff like that, you're more
  873. 31:49focusing on what the chart is telling
  874. 31:51you rather than what the price is
  875. 31:53telling you. Where we are more focused
  876. 31:56on what the price is telling us, not
  877. 31:57what it looks like on a screen. Does
  878. 31:59that make sense?
  879. 32:01>> Yeah, it does. And I had a conversation
  880. 32:03actually even recently just off of what
  881. 32:05you've said with Steven Claian where he
  882. 32:06says prices lead indicators lag and he's
  883. 32:11been doing this for 50 years. I think
  884. 32:12it's very aligned with what you're
  885. 32:14saying. Um
  886. 32:16>> so you've said it you know also at no
  887. 32:19point in time
  888. 32:20that you know you were doing some
  889. 32:22trading uh for big client right with
  890. 32:25Goldman Sachs. I heard you say and you
  891. 32:27said at no point in time were they want
  892. 32:29you to look at a head and shoulders on a
  893. 32:31fiveminute chart. Uh they were what what
  894. 32:34were they wanting you to look at?
  895. 32:37>> Well, they would be giving us um because
  896. 32:40they didn't have a a floor presence. So
  897. 32:42they were a category 2 member although
  898. 32:44you know look biggest you know one of
  899. 32:46the biggest banks in the world but they
  900. 32:47just didn't have a floor presence. And
  901. 32:49so they would be looking at outright
  902. 32:52markets. They would be looking at
  903. 32:53spreads. you know, they've got their
  904. 32:55customers that want to do business. So,
  905. 32:57their customers do business through
  906. 32:58Goldman. Goldman does business through
  907. 33:00us. So, we execute it on the floor. So,
  908. 33:03you got a variety of things. I couldn't
  909. 33:05differentiate between what Goldman were
  910. 33:07doing for themselves
  911. 33:10because they're one step back. So, what
  912. 33:13they're telling me to do might not
  913. 33:15necessarily be for them. It might be for
  914. 33:16one of their clients. But you know you
  915. 33:19might be borrowing Feb March because
  916. 33:22you're expecting you know a tightness in
  917. 33:24the market in February but probably ease
  918. 33:27by March. So you might sort of borrow
  919. 33:29something in a backquidation thinking
  920. 33:31it's going to go to a a higher
  921. 33:33backquidation which means you would make
  922. 33:35money. Or you might say the market's
  923. 33:37running in a contango but there's going
  924. 33:39to be a shortage of metal here. So that
  925. 33:42month that spread might turn into a
  926. 33:44backquidation but the rest of it might
  927. 33:46be in a contango market. The way in
  928. 33:48which the metal exchange was prices
  929. 33:51things is totally unique um in the
  930. 33:56trading world because if I was to look
  931. 33:59at US markets you have one specific day
  932. 34:02in any month that's your contract day
  933. 34:07right on the metal exchange you can
  934. 34:10trade every single day between cash
  935. 34:13which is 2 days forward
  936. 34:16out to 3 months excluding holidays and
  937. 34:18bank sorry holidays and weekends. So
  938. 34:22every single one of those days can have
  939. 34:24a different value,
  940. 34:27>> right? [clears throat]
  941. 34:27So it's a very complex way of doing
  942. 34:29things. Um in the retail market, you
  943. 34:33wouldn't need to worry about all of this
  944. 34:34kind of stuff because you wouldn't be
  945. 34:35trading those things. But um from the
  946. 34:38institutional side, then yes, you
  947. 34:40definitely would and you'd be interested
  948. 34:42in that. So they might, like I say, they
  949. 34:43might be interested in borrowing
  950. 34:44particular days or particular months,
  951. 34:46particular weeks or lending particular
  952. 34:48months, particular days, particular
  953. 34:49weeks. And all of that business is going
  954. 34:52through all day, every day. But then
  955. 34:55don't just think, Robert, it's not just
  956. 34:57Goldman Sachs that are doing it. So
  957. 34:59we've got big copper producers, Cadelo
  958. 35:01down in uh down in Chile. you know,
  959. 35:04you've got producers, consumers, you've
  960. 35:06got speculators,
  961. 35:08you've got a whole mid of people that
  962. 35:11are trading in that market. And then you
  963. 35:13are there as a floor presence to execute
  964. 35:16all of that business. And then when you
  965. 35:18get to particular places, that's when
  966. 35:20you step up and you say, "Right
  967. 35:22now, I'm going to trade with the
  968. 35:23company's money."
  969. 35:26>> Right. And so you say institutional,
  970. 35:29these institutional orders are really
  971. 35:30what's moving the market. you want to
  972. 35:33kind of follow the trend with the with
  973. 35:34the large money with the big money. Um I
  974. 35:38actually had one of the one of the one
  975. 35:40of the market wizards on who was
  976. 35:41discussing that he said he had an edge
  977. 35:43for several years where he would just he
  978. 35:45would see these block shares coming
  979. 35:47through in which case he would join the
  980. 35:50wave with them just ride that wave. Is
  981. 35:52that something you would you would see
  982. 35:54kind of in the pit or uh
  983. 35:57>> Yeah, you would you would you would see
  984. 35:59that. And for
  985. 36:01some of the older guys maybe that
  986. 36:03especially listening to this, maybe
  987. 36:04they've had some experience with the
  988. 36:06pits and stuff like that, like you might
  989. 36:08get an order that comes in, you know,
  990. 36:09buy 2,000 at market and then you'd have
  991. 36:11this head pop up. Buy 10 for me,
  992. 36:14[laughter]
  993. 36:15right? Buy 10 for me. So, it's just like
  994. 36:18the trader's like, "Okay, the first 10
  995. 36:20that comes back, right, you've bought
  996. 36:22those. The next, you know, 50 that comes
  997. 36:25in, that's for the client." And then the
  998. 36:27trader might turn around and say, "Well,
  999. 36:28I've only got 50 left to buy." And then
  1000. 36:30this head would pop out and say, "Sell
  1001. 36:3210 for me, right? So, you've moved
  1002. 36:35you've moved the market up." Um, and
  1003. 36:38it's, you know, quick a quick in and
  1004. 36:39out. Uh or I remember one day
  1005. 36:43uh with a big big customer of ours uh
  1006. 36:46when I was at credit lea it was like
  1007. 36:48borrow 10,000 lots of let's say March
  1008. 36:51April and the guy says down the phone
  1009. 36:54don't book it
  1010. 36:57cuz there's more coming. So whatever you
  1011. 36:59do, don't book it because it's going to
  1012. 37:00cost you money. Right? So sometimes you
  1013. 37:03would get these little things that would
  1014. 37:04come down the line and you'd whisper in
  1015. 37:05his ear, don't book it. [gasps]
  1016. 37:07And then the guy like might come in and
  1017. 37:09then just say, "Right, this is the last
  1018. 37:1010,000. If you want to book some of
  1019. 37:12that, be my guest." So again, you'd say
  1020. 37:15that to the you whisper it into his ear
  1021. 37:17and he might book, you know, the last
  1022. 37:18thousand or something like that. So
  1023. 37:22yeah, you know, there are a few
  1024. 37:23shenanigans I think of, you know, that
  1025. 37:26would, you know, that would go on and
  1026. 37:28and and things.
  1027. 37:29>> Can't get away with that with that
  1028. 37:30anymore. Not these days. No,
  1029. 37:32>> probably not so much these days. No, but
  1030. 37:35you know, I mean, back then again, it
  1031. 37:37was all face to face.
  1032. 37:40>> So I suppose you had plausible
  1033. 37:42deniability really, didn't you?
  1034. 37:44>> Yeah. So if if we were to drop a modern,
  1035. 37:47let's take a modern retail trader today,
  1036. 37:49Paul. Let's let's drop them in that pit
  1037. 37:51with you when you were 16. Do you think
  1038. 37:53they survive?
  1039. 37:56It depends.
  1040. 37:58>> Yeah, depends. It's a different
  1041. 38:01environment because again, what you got
  1042. 38:02to then think about is instead of being
  1043. 38:05by yourself as a retail trader, [snorts]
  1044. 38:07you're surrounded by professionals.
  1045. 38:10>> Yeah. So it's, you know, it's it's on
  1046. 38:12the job training. Um, I think if I was
  1047. 38:16to take a modern retail trader, let's
  1048. 38:18say somebody in their 20s, somebody in
  1049. 38:20their 30s or something like that, and
  1050. 38:22then just say, "Right, so instead of
  1051. 38:24looking at this screen here, and you're
  1052. 38:27trying to read price action there,
  1053. 38:29right, you come and stand there and then
  1054. 38:31you try and [snorts] decipher what's
  1055. 38:33going on and then use that to trade
  1056. 38:36with." I think that would be a huge
  1057. 38:39culture shock for them. huge culture
  1058. 38:41shock,
  1059. 38:42>> right?
  1060. 38:43>> It would do them some good. I mean,
  1061. 38:45really do them some good because they
  1062. 38:46might then sort of stop thinking in
  1063. 38:48terms of, you know, cup sources and
  1064. 38:52trend lines and, you know, what do they
  1065. 38:55call them? Dogey candles and hammer
  1066. 38:57candles and all this kind of jazz. I
  1067. 38:58don't, you know, I think they'd kind of
  1068. 39:00maybe lean away from that and go, "Yeah,
  1069. 39:02actually that doesn't mean a thing down
  1070. 39:04here."
  1071. 39:04>> May, maybe this is a good segue into the
  1072. 39:07technical analysis. So you know do you
  1073. 39:11do here's first of all first question to
  1074. 39:13you and that is
  1075. 39:15>> do you think traders can find success
  1076. 39:18purely depending on technicals?
  1077. 39:22>> I'm going to be biased and say no.
  1078. 39:25>> Oh we're going to get some comments
  1079. 39:27Paul.
  1080. 39:27>> Oh I know. I know. I know. I'm going to
  1081. 39:29be biased and say no because
  1082. 39:34technical analysis for me is a way to
  1083. 39:36describe something that's already
  1084. 39:37happened.
  1085. 39:39So technical analysis for me is like if
  1086. 39:43I want our research department to put
  1087. 39:48together
  1088. 39:49a report. Yeah. I could say to them,
  1089. 39:53right, well look, this is what happened
  1090. 39:54and I want you to go and find a piece of
  1091. 39:56technical analysis that actually fits
  1092. 39:58the narrative. Right? So their job is to
  1093. 40:01do what? Their job is to go and write a
  1094. 40:02load of blurb. Um have something to
  1095. 40:04justify it and put it together. nice,
  1096. 40:08you know, glossy document and then send
  1097. 40:10that out to the client and the client
  1098. 40:11reads it and goes, "Oh, this this all
  1099. 40:13looks fantastic."
  1100. 40:16But that's all based on the past,
  1101. 40:18[snorts]
  1102. 40:19right? So then they might put in the
  1103. 40:21blurb, right? Well, we think if the
  1104. 40:23market gets to here, uh, this is what
  1105. 40:25you should be doing because we think the
  1106. 40:26momentum might take it higher or it
  1107. 40:28might take it lower or whatever. So
  1108. 40:29again, there you're planting seeds in
  1109. 40:31people's minds that reading this kind of
  1110. 40:33stuff. But for me, it's just there to
  1111. 40:35make a report look good. I remember
  1112. 40:37teaching one analyst that worked for
  1113. 40:39HSBC
  1114. 40:41on the retail side and he picked the
  1115. 40:44phone up when we had an initial phone
  1116. 40:45call and he said I am an analyst. I work
  1117. 40:47at HSBC. Please don't hate me.
  1118. 40:51And I said okay fair enough. He I said
  1119. 40:54so come on then. I said so what are your
  1120. 40:56reports judged on? He said it's more
  1121. 40:58what it looks like rather than the
  1122. 40:59content.
  1123. 41:01You know what the writing is. It needs
  1124. 41:03to look all jazzy. It needs to you know
  1125. 41:05fit together.
  1126. 41:07Technical analysis is is one of those
  1127. 41:09things where you could say, "Right,
  1128. 41:11okay. Well, we we've marked this out,
  1129. 41:12this Fibonacci level here, and you know,
  1130. 41:16according to technical analysis
  1131. 41:18principles, the market's going to bounce
  1132. 41:20from here.
  1133. 41:22>> Well, it wouldn't necessarily be
  1134. 41:24according Let me just I can maybe try to
  1135. 41:27push back a little bit and uh say I mean
  1136. 41:30what you mentioned before is that some
  1137. 41:32stocks trade in a range, right? So the
  1138. 41:34range is essentially a form of technical
  1139. 41:36analysis, right? Where you have there's
  1140. 41:38supply here, demand there and if the
  1141. 41:40stock falls down to this level, maybe
  1142. 41:42there'll be uh some supply at that level
  1143. 41:45and then or or demand. Is that not a
  1144. 41:47form of technical analysis?
  1145. 41:49>> I suppose you could look if you want to
  1146. 41:51call that technical analysis, I would
  1147. 41:53call that more sort of market logic
  1148. 41:55really. Um I'm when I sort of slate
  1149. 41:59technical analysis, I'm talking things
  1150. 42:01like chart patterns and you know in
  1151. 42:04these kind of indicators and things like
  1152. 42:05that because what you got to think about
  1153. 42:07is you go you go, "Oh, well, the market
  1154. 42:12went straight through the 200 day moving
  1155. 42:15average."
  1156. 42:17What is a 200 day moving average? It's
  1157. 42:19just an average price over the last 200
  1158. 42:21days. What does that actually really
  1159. 42:23mean
  1160. 42:23>> to [snorts] the guy that when it gets to
  1161. 42:26that particular price, his customer says
  1162. 42:28to him, "Go and sell me 50,000
  1163. 42:30contracts." He's not looking at
  1164. 42:33>> he's not looking at the average price in
  1165. 42:35the last two years.
  1166. 42:36>> You're focused on the big You're focused
  1167. 42:37on the big money. Where's the big money
  1168. 42:38at? And I suppose we should define as
  1169. 42:40well what time frame we're looking at
  1170. 42:42because some traders do scalp intraday
  1171. 42:45like certain patterns, but you're you're
  1172. 42:47more so position trading, correct? Like
  1173. 42:49you're looking at month like weeks,
  1174. 42:51months.
  1175. 42:52>> Well, I'm looking at days, weeks, months
  1176. 42:55is a bit of a stretch. I mean [gasps]
  1177. 42:58how many people have got the patience to
  1178. 43:01wait
  1179. 43:02>> you know a couple of months you know
  1180. 43:04especially in today's social media world
  1181. 43:07[clears throat] you know the um the
  1182. 43:09attention span of the world's population
  1183. 43:11I think has steadily decreased
  1184. 43:13>> you know to say the least um but no I
  1185. 43:16mean I' I'd look for
  1186. 43:19uh markets that are not ridiculously
  1187. 43:21volatile because you look volatility can
  1188. 43:24be your friend but you don't want it to
  1189. 43:26your worst enemy. So, I look for sort of
  1190. 43:28something that is volatile enough to
  1191. 43:30give me maybe a couple of trades a week.
  1192. 43:35But the the time frame aspect of it is,
  1193. 43:38and I suppose this is where this really
  1194. 43:40differs from what most people think
  1195. 43:42about is that if I say I'm going to
  1196. 43:45trade from I copper at $7,000.
  1197. 43:49If I look at a monthly chart, well, the
  1198. 43:51price is still $7,000. If I look at a
  1199. 43:53weekly chart, the price is still $7,000.
  1200. 43:55on a daily chart, the price is still
  1201. 43:57$7,000 and so on and so forth. So,
  1202. 44:00because I'm trading from a price,
  1203. 44:02doesn't actually really matter what time
  1204. 44:06frame I'm looking because I'm actually
  1205. 44:08looking at the price rather than using
  1206. 44:10time as a as a guide. Does that make
  1207. 44:13sense?
  1208. 44:14[clears throat]
  1209. 44:14>> Yeah. So, where where does time play a
  1210. 44:17part or does it?
  1211. 44:18>> It doesn't. It's all about numbers.
  1212. 44:23So, I mean, this is a big thing.
  1213. 44:25Everybody is taught, hey, look at the
  1214. 44:265-minute chart, 15-minute chart. Look at
  1215. 44:28this breakout on a, [snorts] you know, a
  1216. 44:3030 minute chart. What does that mean?
  1217. 44:33Nothing really in the grand scheme of
  1218. 44:34things. It's like, right, well, did you
  1219. 44:36trade from the right price?
  1220. 44:39If you did, well done. If you didn't,
  1221. 44:42you're just trading in noise. Because
  1222. 44:45another thing again that I don't think
  1223. 44:47many people think about is is the
  1224. 44:50differentiation between what you would
  1225. 44:52call commercial business. So that's
  1226. 44:54trading for your clients and then your
  1227. 44:57proprietary trading which would be
  1228. 44:58trading for the company.
  1229. 45:01So within that range top and the bottom
  1230. 45:05that's where you want to trade from. In
  1231. 45:07between you're just executing business
  1232. 45:09for clients. So then my thing would be
  1233. 45:14if you think you can tell me what my
  1234. 45:17client's going to do before he even
  1235. 45:19rings me,
  1236. 45:22go ahead, be my guest. [snorts]
  1237. 45:26That's that's a very
  1238. 45:28>> So you think between that range? You
  1239. 45:29think between that range is essentially
  1240. 45:32noise? Like the the institutional
  1241. 45:34orders, the big money, they're at the
  1242. 45:36top and bottom of the range. Outside of
  1243. 45:38that's just retail noise. Yeah, it's
  1244. 45:40just noise and it's not necessarily
  1245. 45:41retail noise. Yes, retail volume has
  1246. 45:43gone up in the last, you know,
  1247. 45:44definitely in the last decade. [snorts]
  1248. 45:47But again, that the retail understanding
  1249. 45:50of, you know, the dynamics of a market,
  1250. 45:52what makes it move, it's, you know,
  1251. 45:54that's sort of not really thought about
  1252. 45:56too much. It is based around what they
  1253. 45:58see on a chart. And
  1254. 46:02for me, it's um
  1255. 46:05it's not all about charts. It's right,
  1256. 46:08>> you know, it's not all about charts. It
  1257. 46:10is about numbers and it is about the
  1258. 46:12real world.
  1259. 46:14>> You know, something I learned from, you
  1260. 46:15know, I recently interviewed Jack
  1261. 46:17Schwagger and he a lot of his market
  1262. 46:19wizards, they they found success from
  1263. 46:22many different paths. Like the one theme
  1264. 46:24I've learned is there's no really
  1265. 46:26singular approach. I mean some utilize
  1266. 46:28technicals heavily, some utilize
  1267. 46:30fundamentals heavily, some just re But
  1268. 46:33one thing I will grant you here is like
  1269. 46:36a lot of traders do they will their
  1270. 46:39charts almost look like air traffic
  1271. 46:41control. They try to put so many
  1272. 46:42different indicators on them, right?
  1273. 46:45Trying to essentially find the holy
  1274. 46:47grail. Do you think traders need to take
  1275. 46:49a more simplistic approach entirely?
  1276. 46:51let's say they're even using indicators
  1277. 46:53or fundamentals or do do you think
  1278. 46:55traders need to simplify their process?
  1279. 46:57>> I think as a
  1280. 47:00race of beings most of the time we're
  1281. 47:03idiots because we over complicate
  1282. 47:05things. Um I've often said to people I
  1283. 47:09could write my trading strategy on the
  1284. 47:10back of a napkin and explain it to a
  1285. 47:1210-year-old.
  1286. 47:14If you can't do that, it's way too over
  1287. 47:17complicated. Um, I think the more that
  1288. 47:20you strip things back, the more that you
  1289. 47:22focus on price and value. Again, I'm
  1290. 47:26going to say I'm biased because this is
  1291. 47:28the world that I come from, but I do
  1292. 47:29kind of come from a world that is
  1293. 47:32slightly different from, you know, the
  1294. 47:34retail approach,
  1295. 47:35>> but if you focused on that rather than
  1296. 47:38all of these flashy indicators and
  1297. 47:41[snorts] chart patterns and the pit
  1298. 47:43trader, what would the pit traders have
  1299. 47:44said if somebody was walking through
  1300. 47:46there with like oscillators and RSI and
  1301. 47:51indicators and what would they say?
  1302. 47:54They'd laugh them out the building.
  1303. 47:58They would they'd laugh them out the
  1304. 47:59building. Um or they'd say they well
  1305. 48:04typical bunch, what would we do if they
  1306. 48:06walked in with a laptop with all this
  1307. 48:08stuff on and said, "Right, I'm going to
  1308. 48:09start trading electronically using all
  1309. 48:11of this." What would we have done? We'd
  1310. 48:13have grabbed the laptop. We'd have
  1311. 48:14thrown it out the window and gone,
  1312. 48:15"Right,
  1313. 48:17off you go. You haven't got those
  1314. 48:19[clears throat] anymore. Now what you
  1315. 48:20going to do?"
  1316. 48:22So you say that we got to explain our
  1317. 48:24trade in one sentence. If you that's the
  1318. 48:27simplistic approach that kis keep it
  1319. 48:30simple stupid. So [gasps] what I mean
  1320. 48:32what is that one sentence give us some
  1321. 48:34examples of what it looks like. Is it
  1322. 48:35this is a head and shoulder on the five
  1323. 48:37minutes.
  1324. 48:39>> I'm only kidding. [laughter] I'm only
  1325. 48:41>> head and shoulder on the five. I mean
  1326. 48:43that's just
  1327. 48:43>> I'm kidding. Look, I look again if
  1328. 48:46people are listening to this, just think
  1329. 48:48really is there a customer on the phone
  1330. 48:51to a trader at Goldman Sachs, right? And
  1331. 48:53he says, uh, I want a market for, I
  1332. 48:57don't know, a thousand lots of copper.
  1333. 48:59>> Yeah.
  1334. 49:00>> And the guy's sitting there and he's
  1335. 49:01like, you know, this is the client, the
  1336. 49:02aison guy is asking the trader for a
  1337. 49:04market, right? And he's like, just stall
  1338. 49:06him. Stall him. Why? [laughter]
  1339. 49:08Just want to see if this Head and
  1340. 49:10Shoulders plays out on this 5minute
  1341. 49:12chart. Stall him. Stall him. We got 60
  1342. 49:14seconds left. Talk about the football.
  1343. 49:16Talk about the weather. Talk about
  1344. 49:18anything. I just need to That's not
  1345. 49:20going to happen, right? That's never
  1346. 49:22going to happen. So, what would my one
  1347. 49:25sentence be? Right. I got to this
  1348. 49:27particular level. I know it's a key
  1349. 49:28level of decision- making. The decision
  1350. 49:32has to be made. It's going to be
  1351. 49:33probably a long sentence this one, but
  1352. 49:35the decision has to be made. Am I the
  1353. 49:38one that's in control of that decision
  1354. 49:40about what the current value is? No, I
  1355. 49:41am not. What do I want the market to do?
  1356. 49:43Show me your hand. You make the
  1357. 49:45decision. Then what I'll do is I've got
  1358. 49:48that range defined there. I'll let you
  1359. 49:51move a certain percentage either up or
  1360. 49:53down within that range. Now you've shown
  1361. 49:56me your hand. Now you've shown me what
  1362. 49:58the current value is. Now we'll trade.
  1363. 50:02>> Very long sentence. Sorry guys.
  1364. 50:05[laughter]
  1365. 50:05>> No, that's great though. Now, how does
  1366. 50:07that coincide with
  1367. 50:09>> being directionally agnostic? So, you
  1368. 50:12have your one sentence, but then you
  1369. 50:14also got to follow that principle that
  1370. 50:16Paul Scott lives by. Be agnostic about
  1371. 50:19it.
  1372. 50:19>> Be agnostic to direction. Right? Always
  1373. 50:21understand as a retail trader, you are a
  1374. 50:25tiny
  1375. 50:27cog. You are a grain of sand on on the
  1376. 50:30beach. you will never ever have any um
  1377. 50:35persuasion over what the current value
  1378. 50:36is. That's not your decision to make and
  1379. 50:38it never will be, you know. So, you've
  1380. 50:40got to take yourself out the game and
  1381. 50:42stop thinking of yourself as important
  1382. 50:43and stop trading with your ego and stop
  1383. 50:46saying to yourself, I think because the
  1384. 50:50minute you say I think, you've screwed
  1385. 50:52yourself
  1386. 50:54>> because you're trading with your ego cuz
  1387. 50:57the market doesn't know who you are.
  1388. 50:58doesn't know what you think. Quite
  1389. 51:00frankly, it wouldn't care anyway.
  1390. 51:02[sighs and gasps]
  1391. 51:02>> I've heard it put this way. It's just
  1392. 51:04very expensive to try to prove to the
  1393. 51:06market that you're right.
  1394. 51:08>> Yes. Hugely expensive for people and I
  1395. 51:11have heard some horror stories over the
  1396. 51:12years. But getting back to this
  1397. 51:13directionally agnostic. So if I have a
  1398. 51:16particular price level that I know is a
  1399. 51:18key decisionmaking price level,
  1400. 51:22what do I want to do when it gets there?
  1401. 51:24First understand that when it gets
  1402. 51:27there, value has to be established. Is
  1403. 51:30it cheap? Market goes up. Is it
  1404. 51:31expensive? Market goes down. That has to
  1405. 51:34be established by the people that make
  1406. 51:36that decision.
  1407. 51:38So then what I would do is is I would
  1408. 51:39say right so I want to use a certain
  1409. 51:41percentage of that range to say as an
  1410. 51:44example
  1411. 51:46it goes
  1412. 51:48up 25% into that into the range. All
  1413. 51:52right. And I go, okay, so the value here
  1414. 51:56is basically the market showing me is
  1415. 51:58that they thought at this particular
  1416. 52:00point in time that the pro the price
  1417. 52:02again, let's just use 7,000 on copper
  1418. 52:04because we've been using that one. So
  1419. 52:06that the the value of 7,000 on the
  1420. 52:09copper market at the minute is cheap.
  1421. 52:11Now the market then goes up. It goes
  1422. 52:14through 25%. I'm going to I want to open
  1423. 52:16a stop. So I want to buy stop there. But
  1424. 52:20similarly, it might get to 7,000
  1425. 52:24and the value might be expensive. So the
  1426. 52:26market comes down. So then I have a sell
  1427. 52:29stop at the like the 25%
  1428. 52:32price, right? Whatever that might be,
  1429. 52:34however big that range is, 25% of that.
  1430. 52:38So being directionally agnostic means
  1431. 52:41that instead of trying to guess or
  1432. 52:44predict the direction
  1433. 52:47of where the market's going to go, I'm
  1434. 52:50actually saying to the market, well, you
  1435. 52:52make your determination and then I'll
  1436. 52:55follow up behind you. So I don't care if
  1437. 52:58you go up or if you go down. Quite
  1438. 53:00frankly, it makes no bloody difference
  1439. 53:02to me whatsoever. I'm not attached to a
  1440. 53:05particular direction. I'm not
  1441. 53:07emotionally attached to predicting where
  1442. 53:09a market's going to go. I don't care. I
  1443. 53:12just want it to move, Kevin. That's the
  1444. 53:14thing.
  1445. 53:15>> You know, how do I make money? By
  1446. 53:17predicting where things are going to go
  1447. 53:18and hopefully getting it right or just
  1448. 53:21saying, "Well, move because when you
  1449. 53:24move, I can make money."
  1450. 53:27>> So, is that much of your approach is
  1451. 53:29trend following, you would say, and then
  1452. 53:31just following that towards the big
  1453. 53:33money liquidity? Yeah, I mean that again
  1454. 53:35that's the things you what you got to
  1455. 53:37think of in terms of what our
  1456. 53:40institutions doing. Well, we are always
  1457. 53:42going after liquidity.
  1458. 53:44It's a liquidity hunt all the time, you
  1459. 53:47know. So, if we think that the market is
  1460. 53:50currently overvalued, so we sell it,
  1461. 53:52well, we want that market to come down
  1462. 53:54until we then find another place where
  1463. 53:56people are willing to buy cuz that's
  1464. 53:57where then the the liquidity is going to
  1465. 53:59be. So in particularly volatile times,
  1466. 54:02what you might find is as you're at the
  1467. 54:04top of a range, you go you get to the
  1468. 54:06bottom, nobody wants to buy there.
  1469. 54:08>> Yeah.
  1470. 54:09>> So it just goes straight through again,
  1471. 54:11right? And then you get to the bottom of
  1472. 54:12the next range, still nobody wants to
  1473. 54:15buy.
  1474. 54:17>> So you're still holding this short
  1475. 54:18position.
  1476. 54:19>> What did that look like on the on the
  1477. 54:21pit? Because you maybe you have since we
  1478. 54:24acknowledge that the institutions are
  1479. 54:26looking for liquidity. Let's say you do
  1480. 54:28have a whale coming in with a large
  1481. 54:30order. I mean, you can you're fairly
  1482. 54:33exposed and vulnerable out there. Is was
  1483. 54:35there a way to I I don't to kind of
  1484. 54:38secretly get your order filled? I mean,
  1485. 54:40how how did Wales go about that?
  1486. 54:44>> Well, what they would do was one of the
  1487. 54:46things that they would do is that they
  1488. 54:47wouldn't give one specific broker or
  1489. 54:50bank the whole
  1490. 54:52>> They break it up. I got it.
  1491. 54:54>> Yeah. So, they'd break it up, right? So,
  1492. 54:56what you could then do is if let's say
  1493. 54:58you had, I don't know, a 10,000 lot
  1494. 55:00order, right? And you split that across
  1495. 55:03four separate companies.
  1496. 55:07What that allows those companies to then
  1497. 55:09do is to then phone their clients and
  1498. 55:11say, "Hey, look, I've got a a seller
  1499. 55:13that wants to sell here. You're
  1500. 55:15interested in buying." So, some of that
  1501. 55:17business might not even hit the ring or
  1502. 55:20hit the pit.
  1503. 55:22>> So, that will be done. you can cross
  1504. 55:23that business exter you know internally
  1505. 55:26right then whatever's left you might
  1506. 55:29come and then and then you trade that on
  1507. 55:30the open outcro
  1508. 55:32>> I see I see interesting yeah because I
  1509. 55:35mean these days in the modern digital
  1510. 55:36age you know you everyone's always I
  1511. 55:38guess there uh they think the market's
  1512. 55:40out for them right to grab the liquidity
  1513. 55:42they're coming for the stop orders so I
  1514. 55:44was interested in how that
  1515. 55:46>> well that's really looked
  1516. 55:47>> yeah well again so let's let's hop back
  1517. 55:50to what we said earlier if You're
  1518. 55:52trading in that noise.
  1519. 55:54>> Yeah.
  1520. 55:55>> Right. And you put a trade on and you've
  1521. 55:57got a, you know, a stop wherever it is.
  1522. 56:02You're going to get beat up a heck of a
  1523. 56:04lot because you're trading through
  1524. 56:06noise. That's a totally random act.
  1525. 56:09[snorts] I mean, I've again, I've said
  1526. 56:11this 10 years ago. [sighs and gasps]
  1527. 56:15I ring you up. You're sitting at your
  1528. 56:18desk. You see my lines flashing.
  1529. 56:22Right. You click into the line.
  1530. 56:26Hello.
  1531. 56:29Right after that, now what am I going to
  1532. 56:32say to you? No idea.
  1533. 56:35>> No idea. No clue.
  1534. 56:36>> Yeah. No idea.
  1535. 56:37>> Not a clue what's coming.
  1536. 56:38>> Not a clue. Right. So, if you're trading
  1537. 56:41within all of that noise, this is what I
  1538. 56:43mean. It's like you're trying to guess
  1539. 56:45what my client's going to tell me to do
  1540. 56:47before he's even rung me up. It's It's
  1541. 56:50crazy. That's a really really random
  1542. 56:52act. Does that make sense?
  1543. 56:54>> Yeah. You just state of confusion. The
  1544. 56:57analysis by paralysis.
  1545. 56:59>> Well, there's that. And it's like, well,
  1546. 57:01how can you use technical analysis
  1547. 57:04to essentially work out where commercial
  1548. 57:08business is going to be, what commercial
  1549. 57:10business might need to be done.
  1550. 57:12>> [snorts]
  1551. 57:13>> I mean, there's this crazy theory out
  1552. 57:15there that the uh the whole financial
  1553. 57:18markets are all governed by one big
  1554. 57:21giant algorithm.
  1555. 57:23Yeah.
  1556. 57:24>> Just absolute gibberish again. And you
  1557. 57:27know, you've got
  1558. 57:29all the types. Market on open, market on
  1559. 57:32close. You've got good for the day, good
  1560. 57:34till cancelled.
  1561. 57:36You've got at market orders. You've got
  1562. 57:39limit orders. You got buy on stop
  1563. 57:41orders, sell on stop orders, you all of
  1564. 57:43these different order types
  1565. 57:46and obviously
  1566. 57:46>> yeah it almost feels like we're in the
  1567. 57:48way of the big institutions. I mean
  1568. 57:49that's what it would sometimes feels
  1569. 57:52like uh that high frequency trading is
  1570. 57:55after the high frequency traders that
  1571. 57:57the algos are almost after the algos
  1572. 57:59that the institutions are after the
  1573. 58:00institutions and the retailers are just
  1574. 58:02in the way in the way of the big boys.
  1575. 58:06I wouldn't necessarily say in the way,
  1576. 58:08but you're trading in the way.
  1577. 58:11>> In the noise. Yeah,
  1578. 58:12>> you're trading in the noise. So, high
  1579. 58:14frequency trading and and algorithmic
  1580. 58:15trading. Why is that there? Well,
  1581. 58:17because a computer can execute an order
  1582. 58:19quicker than a human being can. So, it
  1583. 58:20saves us a job of having to do it,
  1584. 58:23right? But then again, traders also need
  1585. 58:26to know that these algorithms, they get
  1586. 58:28turned off.
  1587. 58:29>> Yeah.
  1588. 58:30>> Right. So if I again if I give you uh
  1589. 58:33another example of the copper market. So
  1590. 58:34back in July of last year so 2025
  1591. 58:38uh Mr. Trump announces that they're
  1592. 58:39going to be tariffs on copper coming
  1593. 58:41into the US. Right? So the he didn't
  1594. 58:44actually
  1595. 58:46say which type of copper. He just said
  1596. 58:48copper.
  1597. 58:50Right? So the first thing that happens
  1598. 58:51is price of copper starts to come down
  1599. 58:54very very quickly because there's going
  1600. 58:55to be tariffs and it's you know it's all
  1601. 58:56of that hoo-ha that's going to go on.
  1602. 58:59brother-in-law works at JP Morgan.
  1603. 59:02He runs what's known as the averaging
  1604. 59:04book there. We won't go into that
  1605. 59:05because that's too complex. But anyway,
  1606. 59:08[snorts]
  1607. 59:09the first thing they were told in the
  1608. 59:11morning by the bosses at JPM was turn
  1609. 59:15those bloody elos off.
  1610. 59:18turn them off because they're only
  1611. 59:21programmed to do what they've been
  1612. 59:22programmed to do and they could cause a
  1613. 59:24you know an absolute catastrophic move
  1614. 59:26in a market which
  1615. 59:29>> didn't need which didn't need to happen.
  1616. 59:31So that's when you, you know, you go
  1617. 59:33back to the human beings. You go back to
  1618. 59:35the people that can think and change
  1619. 59:37their mind and jump on the phone and go,
  1620. 59:38"Hey, look, let's not all go, you know,
  1621. 59:41bat here. We don't need to. Let's
  1622. 59:43find out what did he mean by that." It
  1623. 59:45turns out he meant concentrates.
  1624. 59:48[snorts] So not LME grade copper or not
  1625. 59:51Comx copper, you know, not that grade.
  1626. 59:54Didn't mean that. So then the price
  1627. 59:56stabilized
  1628. 59:58and then it went back up again.
  1629. 1:00:01Now these are gone. Okay.
  1630. 1:00:03>> Yeah. So these are like execution
  1631. 1:00:06things. These are like you know they can
  1632. 1:00:07hedge for companies without you know
  1633. 1:00:10because they can do it electronically
  1634. 1:00:12whereas before you would have to do it
  1635. 1:00:13manually. Now they can just do it
  1636. 1:00:15electronically. So if a market moves
  1637. 1:00:17outside of a certain parameter the
  1638. 1:00:20computer says well we've got a bit of
  1639. 1:00:21exposure here. We need to go and cover
  1640. 1:00:23that exposure. So again it can work it
  1641. 1:00:26out very very quickly.
  1642. 1:00:29Ever watch a stock rip and think, "I
  1643. 1:00:31could have nailed that if I had real
  1644. 1:00:33capital." The truth is, many capable
  1645. 1:00:35traders never reach their potential. Not
  1646. 1:00:37due to lack of skill, but lack of scale.
  1647. 1:00:40Trade the Pool was built to solve
  1648. 1:00:42exactly that. A firm designed for
  1649. 1:00:44serious individuals who want access to
  1650. 1:00:46the US equity markets with meaningful
  1651. 1:00:48buying power up to $200,000 without
  1652. 1:00:51committing their own capital. Get access
  1653. 1:00:53to virtually every stock and ETF. Go
  1654. 1:00:55long or short freely with the
  1655. 1:00:57flexibility professional traders expect.
  1656. 1:00:59You're evaluated on one thing, your
  1657. 1:01:01ability to manage risk and execute with
  1658. 1:01:04consistency. Meet the standard and you
  1659. 1:01:06trade at scale. No subscriptions, no
  1660. 1:01:09ongoing commitments. Whether you're
  1661. 1:01:10still refining your strategy, a trader
  1662. 1:01:12with experience who hasn't yet broken
  1663. 1:01:14through, or a seasoned professional
  1664. 1:01:17simply looking for more capital, Trade
  1665. 1:01:19the Pool is built to meet you where you
  1666. 1:01:21are and take you that next step further.
  1667. 1:01:23The markets have evolved. Access has
  1668. 1:01:26evolved. Now so has the way traders
  1669. 1:01:28operate within them. Trade the pool.
  1670. 1:01:31Yeah. I'd be interested in, you know,
  1671. 1:01:32the last few years especially. I mean a
  1672. 1:01:35lot of the traders I know they for
  1673. 1:01:37example keep truth social some of the
  1674. 1:01:40social media up to see what Trump is
  1675. 1:01:42saying because I mean it almost sounds
  1676. 1:01:45like every single day is nearly a turn
  1677. 1:01:47the algo off event not knowing you know
  1678. 1:01:50what's going to be posted out there,
  1679. 1:01:52right?
  1680. 1:01:52>> No. not knowing it's it's and again you
  1681. 1:01:56know today's in today's market you've
  1682. 1:01:58got everybody's got access to the same
  1683. 1:02:00information. Yeah,
  1684. 1:02:02>> cuz the technology has really really
  1685. 1:02:03changed. But I mean, you know, I
  1686. 1:02:04remember being down on the metal
  1687. 1:02:06exchange trading floor and you'd get,
  1688. 1:02:08you know, a phone call had come in or
  1689. 1:02:10there's been a rumor of an earthquake in
  1690. 1:02:12Chile and it's just a rumor. Hasn't come
  1691. 1:02:14out on Reuters yet.
  1692. 1:02:16>> It's just a rumor, you know. So you'd be
  1693. 1:02:18[snorts] ringing around your clients and
  1694. 1:02:20I might ring into Dylan Morgan at
  1695. 1:02:21Goldman and I'd be like, "Dylan, Dylan,
  1696. 1:02:24Dylan, Dylan, Dylan over the scorebox."
  1697. 1:02:26Come, "What? There's been a rumor of an
  1698. 1:02:29earthquake in Chile." He'd go, "I know."
  1699. 1:02:31I started it and put the phone down.
  1700. 1:02:33That's not how I started.
  1701. 1:02:37>> Oh goodness.
  1702. 1:02:38>> Right. So, you know, but in today's
  1703. 1:02:42world, everybody can find out everything
  1704. 1:02:43at exactly the same time.
  1705. 1:02:46>> I know it goes, it really goes back to
  1706. 1:02:48the perceived value that you were
  1707. 1:02:49discussing earlier. And now it's more
  1708. 1:02:51prevalent than ever. What are the
  1709. 1:02:55masses? What are they getting fed? How
  1710. 1:02:57are they perceiving the value of uh
  1711. 1:03:00commodities, stocks, anything out there?
  1712. 1:03:02So, let's uh get into capital
  1713. 1:03:05preservation because I know that's one
  1714. 1:03:06of one of your big points is you're less
  1715. 1:03:09looking for home runs, right? You're
  1716. 1:03:10more focused on look, I got we got to
  1717. 1:03:12survive. We got to preserve the capital.
  1718. 1:03:15There's uh even Dr. Brett Steamoger who
  1719. 1:03:17was on chat with traders, he mentioned
  1720. 1:03:19that we have to survive our learning
  1721. 1:03:21curve. I had a conversation as well with
  1722. 1:03:24David Capablaga who was echoing that
  1723. 1:03:27it's so important. Do do you think how
  1724. 1:03:28important do you think that is? We got
  1725. 1:03:30to survive that learning curve enough
  1726. 1:03:32>> to withstand the storm and to come out
  1727. 1:03:34triumphant.
  1728. 1:03:36>> I you I think you should learn your
  1729. 1:03:39craft before you engage.
  1730. 1:03:41[snorts]
  1731. 1:03:42>> I think you should not spread yourself
  1732. 1:03:44too thin. So don't go looking at, you
  1733. 1:03:46know, a hundred different markets
  1734. 1:03:48because you're not going to get to
  1735. 1:03:49understand the characteristics of them.
  1736. 1:03:50I mean, you know, so really hone that
  1737. 1:03:52in. Maybe pick one, two, three, four,
  1738. 1:03:55five, but then get to know them inside
  1739. 1:03:57out. Yes, you can have, you know, real
  1740. 1:04:02skin in the game. You can have money in
  1741. 1:04:03the game,
  1742. 1:04:05but keep it small. You can always scale.
  1743. 1:04:07You know, there's there's no point in
  1744. 1:04:10rushing in. Although, again, [snorts]
  1745. 1:04:13people look at trading as a very quick
  1746. 1:04:15way to make money and social media and
  1747. 1:04:17which I don't do at all. So, I can't
  1748. 1:04:21give you an opinion on that. I can only
  1749. 1:04:23go what, you know, what I've heard and
  1750. 1:04:25stuff like that. But if it's
  1751. 1:04:28your perception that a 20-year-old kid
  1752. 1:04:31is riding around in a Ferrari or a
  1753. 1:04:34Lamborghini and he's got a mansion and
  1754. 1:04:36he's got a yacht and he's always at the
  1755. 1:04:37beach and all stuff like that. If that's
  1756. 1:04:39your perception, then you're looking at
  1757. 1:04:40it totally wrong cuz that's not what it
  1758. 1:04:42is.
  1759. 1:04:43If you
  1760. 1:04:47look at that and think, well, how am I
  1761. 1:04:49going to achieve that?
  1762. 1:04:51Well, you're going to achieve that by
  1763. 1:04:52taking ridiculous risks.
  1764. 1:04:54>> Yeah.
  1765. 1:04:55>> You know, you're not going to be focused
  1766. 1:04:57on learning your craft. You're just
  1767. 1:04:59focused on the money. You see the thing
  1768. 1:05:01is once you learn your craft, once you
  1769. 1:05:03get good at your craft, once you
  1770. 1:05:05understand the dynamics of the market,
  1771. 1:05:07how it works, knowing it, understanding
  1772. 1:05:09it's a process to go from one level to
  1773. 1:05:10the next because we are looking for the
  1774. 1:05:12liquidity,
  1775. 1:05:14the money will come later,
  1776. 1:05:16>> right? Right.
  1777. 1:05:18>> Well, I mean certainly that was the in
  1778. 1:05:20introduction to your story, right?
  1779. 1:05:22Because you you were told if you don't
  1780. 1:05:25manage this risk in three months, you're
  1781. 1:05:27out of here, Paul. And
  1782. 1:05:29>> yeah,
  1783. 1:05:29>> you must have done it.
  1784. 1:05:31>> I did. I must have done it cuz I'm still
  1785. 1:05:32here. Um, you know, I must have done it.
  1786. 1:05:36But it was one of those things where
  1787. 1:05:38Yeah. you understand from day one there
  1788. 1:05:40is pressure
  1789. 1:05:42because there's a lot of money flying
  1790. 1:05:44around.
  1791. 1:05:45>> Mhm.
  1792. 1:05:46>> Heck of a lot of money flying around.
  1793. 1:05:47You got to be able to pay attention to
  1794. 1:05:48what you're doing. You need to really
  1795. 1:05:50really understand what you're doing and
  1796. 1:05:55the effects that your screw-ups
  1797. 1:05:59can have.
  1798. 1:06:01You know, this is I mean this is again
  1799. 1:06:04this is harkarking back to the 1980s
  1800. 1:06:07uh where the London Metal Exchange was
  1801. 1:06:09in um Lenol market. This and this is
  1802. 1:06:12about paying attention to detail, right?
  1803. 1:06:15So dad says outside having a cigarette
  1804. 1:06:18and he said all of a sudden I see this
  1805. 1:06:20huge truck pull up
  1806. 1:06:24right with tons of copper wire on the
  1807. 1:06:26back of it.
  1808. 1:06:28And he said, and I'm looking at it
  1809. 1:06:30thinking,
  1810. 1:06:32blime me, what's he doing here? You
  1811. 1:06:34know, I'm outside the metal exchange.
  1812. 1:06:36This guy pulls up with a truckload of
  1813. 1:06:37copper. And so the guy says, guy got out
  1814. 1:06:41of the cab and he starts walking to the
  1815. 1:06:44metal exchange.
  1816. 1:06:46Uh there come over from Germany. And so
  1817. 1:06:49my dad said to him, so I'm standing
  1818. 1:06:50there having a cigarette and he said,
  1819. 1:06:53"Can I help you?" He says, "Yes." He
  1820. 1:06:56said, "I am looking for hair patty
  1821. 1:06:57crab."
  1822. 1:06:59And he said, "Right." [snorts] And
  1823. 1:07:02Paddyy was down on the trading floor. He
  1824. 1:07:04said, "I'm looking for Mr. You know,
  1825. 1:07:06hair crab." He said, "One moment, I'll
  1826. 1:07:08go and get him for you." So he said, "I
  1827. 1:07:10ran in, found Paddyy." Paddyy comes out,
  1828. 1:07:14stands there looking at the truck.
  1829. 1:07:17He says, "Hair crab?" He said, "Yes." He
  1830. 1:07:19says, "I have your copper for you."
  1831. 1:07:22He said, "Can I see the, you know, the
  1832. 1:07:24docket sheet?" So he says, "Yes." He
  1833. 1:07:26gives him the sheep and he goes, "Shit,
  1834. 1:07:30I forgot to put I forgot to put
  1835. 1:07:32Liverpool warehouse."
  1836. 1:07:35[laughter] Right. So this guy's cupboard
  1837. 1:07:36actually dropped it off at the London
  1838. 1:07:38Metal Exchange itself, thinking that
  1839. 1:07:41that was where it had to go. It was
  1840. 1:07:42actually supposed to go to a warehouse
  1841. 1:07:44in Liverpool.
  1842. 1:07:47[laughter]
  1843. 1:07:47>> That's a That's a funny one.
  1844. 1:07:50>> All right. So then now the guy's got to
  1845. 1:07:51drive from London to Liverpool to go and
  1846. 1:07:53drop the cover off and stuff like that.
  1847. 1:07:54But it's about paying attention to
  1848. 1:07:56detail.
  1849. 1:07:57>> Paying attention to detail. So speaking
  1850. 1:07:59of detail, I mean, you went from trading
  1851. 1:08:01to now you you teach a lot with your
  1852. 1:08:03students, you know, what what are some
  1853. 1:08:04of those details in the students that
  1854. 1:08:06you recognize early on? It's like, hey,
  1855. 1:08:08this is this person's got good traits
  1856. 1:08:10that can lead them to success. This
  1857. 1:08:12person's got maybe not those traits. Uh
  1858. 1:08:15what are some things you can identify?
  1859. 1:08:17Uh but I and I often ask them, you know,
  1860. 1:08:21um trade duration and charts, you know,
  1861. 1:08:25what are you what are you looking at?
  1862. 1:08:26And if somebody says to me, oh, you
  1863. 1:08:28know, I trade off the 5m minute chart
  1864. 1:08:29and
  1865. 1:08:31>> yeah, I have to hold a trade for about
  1866. 1:08:3220 minutes and then after that it's, you
  1867. 1:08:34know, it's real squeaky bum time, then
  1868. 1:08:36you're like, okay, well, my philosophy
  1869. 1:08:40would have to make you change it
  1870. 1:08:42yourself a heck of a lot. would you be
  1871. 1:08:45able to make that change?
  1872. 1:08:47>> Yeah.
  1873. 1:08:47>> Uh some people will just openly admit to
  1874. 1:08:50me. They just go really impulsive. Um I
  1875. 1:08:53hold on to my losses as soon as I'm in
  1876. 1:08:56profit. I you know I'm I just want to
  1877. 1:08:58take that profit because I'm I'm I'm too
  1878. 1:09:01used to losing. Now I do say that you
  1879. 1:09:03have to be the best loser because you
  1880. 1:09:06have to learn how to differentiate and
  1881. 1:09:08you know and extrapolate the monetary
  1882. 1:09:10value and say
  1883. 1:09:14this trade went wrong this trade went
  1884. 1:09:16wrong right there's nothing wrong with
  1885. 1:09:18your execution there's nothing wrong
  1886. 1:09:19with what you thought it's just maybe
  1887. 1:09:21that that particular time again well
  1888. 1:09:24let's mention Mr. Trump, right? So, the
  1889. 1:09:25market, we're in a short position,
  1890. 1:09:27market's going down. Something comes out
  1891. 1:09:28on X and all of a sudden, boom, market
  1892. 1:09:31turns and goes the other way. I mean,
  1893. 1:09:33there's nothing you can do about it. So,
  1894. 1:09:35it's like you got to learn how to lose
  1895. 1:09:37and get over it and be just as agnostic
  1896. 1:09:40with losing as as with winning,
  1897. 1:09:43>> right? So, if you can treat and there's
  1898. 1:09:45a great poem by Rajard Kipling, right?
  1899. 1:09:48So, if you can meet triumph and disaster
  1900. 1:09:50and treat those two imposters just the
  1901. 1:09:52same, right? If you can do that then
  1902. 1:09:56that detachment of money
  1903. 1:09:59is a very very good thing though that's
  1904. 1:10:01a great trait to have detachment for
  1905. 1:10:04money.
  1906. 1:10:04>> Yeah. Yeah. You know I've read a lot of
  1907. 1:10:06Mark Douglas and that's what he teaches
  1908. 1:10:08and preaches you know detach from the
  1909. 1:10:10outcome entirely. Money becomes a
  1910. 1:10:12byproduct of just good trading right.
  1911. 1:10:14Just good trading focusing on that. But
  1912. 1:10:16like you're saying I've heard of a book
  1913. 1:10:18the best a best loser wins. So yeah,
  1914. 1:10:21this is uh it's important to lose well,
  1915. 1:10:23isn't it?
  1916. 1:10:24>> Yeah, it is. It's because it's
  1917. 1:10:28what? So it's mentally
  1918. 1:10:31[snorts] that when you get I lost money
  1919. 1:10:32there and your brain says, hey, that's
  1920. 1:10:35okay. Hey, look, we've been here before.
  1921. 1:10:38You know, we're battle hardened to this.
  1922. 1:10:39Yeah, we got a few scars, but we're
  1923. 1:10:41battle hardened to it. So it's it's
  1924. 1:10:42okay. So what it doesn't do, it doesn't
  1925. 1:10:44put you off taking your next trade. Does
  1926. 1:10:46that make sense?
  1927. 1:10:47>> Right.
  1928. 1:10:48>> So I'll give you a great example of
  1929. 1:10:50this. Uh he's still on the metal
  1930. 1:10:52exchange, bless him. Uh first copper
  1931. 1:10:55trader I worked under apart from my dad.
  1932. 1:10:57Uh was a guy called Gary Casey. He's
  1933. 1:11:00still down there. Um this was a credit
  1934. 1:11:02Lea. I remember Gary had just got back
  1935. 1:11:04off of holiday. He had a beautiful tan.
  1936. 1:11:07He walked into the second copper ring
  1937. 1:11:11and in the last six or seven seconds of
  1938. 1:11:15that sort of
  1939. 1:11:17trading time, he managed to lose a
  1940. 1:11:20million dollars in the last six or seven
  1941. 1:11:22seconds. And when he walked out of that
  1942. 1:11:26ring, he was white as a sheet. He had to
  1943. 1:11:29get on the phone to Jim Bolan, who was
  1944. 1:11:32his boss, say, "Jim, I've just lost a
  1945. 1:11:34million dollars."
  1946. 1:11:36And as you can imagine, Jim said, "Well,
  1947. 1:11:38how on earth did you do that?" [snorts]
  1948. 1:11:40And he said, "Well, uh, Bugsy from
  1949. 1:11:44Barclays was selling copper, let's say,
  1950. 1:11:46I don't know, 85." [gasps and snorts]
  1951. 1:11:48And I said, "A,000, thinking that there
  1952. 1:11:50was no way that Bugsy would say yes."
  1953. 1:11:54So he said, "So what happened?" He said,
  1954. 1:11:55"I said a,000 and Bugsy said yes." And
  1955. 1:11:57then Bugsy said, "I'll sell at 80. I'll
  1956. 1:11:59sell at 75." Ding, ding, ding, ding,
  1957. 1:12:02ding. Bell goes.
  1958. 1:12:05So imagine being him
  1959. 1:12:11going to the office, telling Jim and the
  1960. 1:12:14other big bosses there what's happened.
  1961. 1:12:17Gets told to go home for the rest of the
  1962. 1:12:19day. Comes back in the next morning. Now
  1963. 1:12:21obviously everybody on our desk knows
  1964. 1:12:25what's happened. I was in charge of
  1965. 1:12:28manually doing the profits and losses.
  1966. 1:12:31So, I 100% know what's happened and how
  1967. 1:12:34much that exact trade cost cost us, but
  1968. 1:12:38then having to go down to the trading
  1969. 1:12:40floor
  1970. 1:12:42and every other bugger on the floor
  1971. 1:12:44knows exactly what happened yesterday,
  1972. 1:12:47exactly how much money it's cost him,
  1973. 1:12:49yet he had to still get back in that
  1974. 1:12:52ring and trade again and do his job.
  1975. 1:12:56That must have been immense pressure.
  1976. 1:13:01But he had to do his job. And so if you
  1977. 1:13:03look at trading as a job and as a
  1978. 1:13:07business,
  1979. 1:13:09then you have to say that sometimes
  1980. 1:13:11you'll screw up.
  1981. 1:13:13Losing money is part of the game that
  1982. 1:13:16you play [snorts] and sometimes it's
  1983. 1:13:19just a cost
  1984. 1:13:21>> operating.
  1985. 1:13:22Yeah, but you can learn from it as well,
  1986. 1:13:24you know, cuz you go, well, you might
  1987. 1:13:26say, well, where was I emotionally at
  1988. 1:13:28that particular point in time?
  1989. 1:13:31>> Was I overly excited? Was I down in the
  1990. 1:13:33dumps? You know,
  1991. 1:13:35>> was I being distracted by something
  1992. 1:13:37else?
  1993. 1:13:38>> You know,
  1994. 1:13:39>> you know, everything ties in. Everything
  1995. 1:13:41ties in that you that you said. Be
  1996. 1:13:43directionally agnostic. you know, don't
  1997. 1:13:46have an ego trying to avoid saying I
  1998. 1:13:49think this is going here. Uh so yeah, I
  1999. 1:13:53mean it all and the risk management, the
  2000. 1:13:55capital preservation, it all ties in
  2001. 1:13:57together everything you've been saying.
  2002. 1:13:58Do you looking back, do you have an
  2003. 1:14:00example of any trades that uh maybe your
  2004. 1:14:04dad took that stand out to you?
  2005. 1:14:07Well, I remember one trade that the old
  2006. 1:14:09man tried to do after he'd been out for
  2007. 1:14:12lunch. And let me just tell you guys
  2008. 1:14:14when I say been out for lunch, [snorts]
  2009. 1:14:16um the market closed from 1:30
  2010. 1:14:19until 20 3.
  2011. 1:14:23So that's not just going to quickly run
  2012. 1:14:26down, grab a sandwich, throw it down my
  2013. 1:14:27neck, and get back to work. This was
  2014. 1:14:29right, we're going out to lunch. We're
  2015. 1:14:31going to go and have some beer, and
  2016. 1:14:33we're going to go and sit down and have
  2017. 1:14:34a proper meal.
  2018. 1:14:36Um, so let's just say that maybe dad's
  2019. 1:14:39watch wasn't working on this particular
  2020. 1:14:41day and he didn't actually get back down
  2021. 1:14:44to the trading floor till about 4 in the
  2022. 1:14:47afternoon having been out for about 3
  2023. 1:14:49hours. Um,
  2024. 1:14:52quite welloiled, let's [snorts] say,
  2025. 1:14:54right? Quite welloiled.
  2026. 1:14:57And within the ring, you would have the
  2027. 1:15:00traders, but you should also have people
  2028. 1:15:02that worked for the metal exchange
  2029. 1:15:04itself that would be sitting in there
  2030. 1:15:06with a microphone on relaying prices
  2031. 1:15:08back to other people upstairs that could
  2032. 1:15:12then type all these out and you would
  2033. 1:15:14get basically the settlement prices for
  2034. 1:15:16the day. Yeah. [gasps]
  2035. 1:15:18At 5:00.
  2036. 1:15:21So anyway,
  2037. 1:15:24dad's sitting there in the ring for
  2038. 1:15:25Triand and there's this kid is about
  2039. 1:15:27five seats down.
  2040. 1:15:30The guy next to him
  2041. 1:15:33is a trader, but the kid sitting five
  2042. 1:15:36seats down, he works for the metal
  2043. 1:15:38exchange. [sighs and snorts]
  2044. 1:15:40So dad can hear this other guy sitting
  2045. 1:15:43next to him trading copper, you know,
  2046. 1:15:46not 70 or so. My dad's like, "Yep, 10
  2047. 1:15:4910
  2048. 1:15:53o."
  2049. 1:15:55He's not talking to the trader. He's
  2050. 1:15:57talking to the kid that's relaying the
  2051. 1:15:59prices back, right? So the bell goes at
  2052. 1:16:025:00. That's absolutely fuming cuz this
  2053. 1:16:05he thinks this kid's ignoring him,
  2054. 1:16:08right? [gasps]
  2055. 1:16:08And so he walks over to him and he said,
  2056. 1:16:10"I was trying to trade with you. you
  2057. 1:16:13were selling at 70 and I said 10 and you
  2058. 1:16:15just ignored me and you ignored me three
  2059. 1:16:17or four times.
  2060. 1:16:19[snorts] He said Harry said I work for
  2061. 1:16:21the exchange. He said I wasn't trading.
  2062. 1:16:24He said the guy next to me was trading.
  2063. 1:16:30Oh
  2064. 1:16:33Okay. Sorry. Sorry for you know
  2065. 1:16:36being massively angry with you. [snorts]
  2066. 1:16:39But yeah, I mean, you know, these little
  2067. 1:16:41silly things do crop up. I mean, on a
  2068. 1:16:44open out cry strange, everybody has
  2069. 1:16:46their tail. It's like a poker game.
  2070. 1:16:48Everybody has their tail, right? So, I
  2071. 1:16:51remember his tail was when he had a
  2072. 1:16:53fairly sizable order,
  2073. 1:16:56right? Cuz he would do the same thing at
  2074. 1:16:57home when he would be getting ready to
  2075. 1:16:59give you a rolling cuz you'd done
  2076. 1:17:01something wrong, right, when you were a
  2077. 1:17:03kid.
  2078. 1:17:04>> But what he would do is he would lean
  2079. 1:17:06forward in his chair. He'd put his
  2080. 1:17:08elbows on his knees and he would clear
  2081. 1:17:11his throat.
  2082. 1:17:12And I knew Yeah. You just knew. But
  2083. 1:17:15right. But the other thing is you and
  2084. 1:17:17he'd look around at all these other
  2085. 1:17:18guys. I remember one guy who would when
  2086. 1:17:21he would get a big order, he would sit
  2087. 1:17:23there with, you know, both feet on the
  2088. 1:17:25floor, but then when he had a big order,
  2089. 1:17:27one foot would go back and then the leg
  2090. 1:17:29would go out and you'd be like, "He's
  2091. 1:17:31got a big order to do or, you know, he's
  2092. 1:17:32got a big order to do and all stuff like
  2093. 1:17:34that." So that was fun. You're reading
  2094. 1:17:36people as well as reading the market.
  2095. 1:17:37>> Huh. So all the gest I mean Yeah. Cuz
  2096. 1:17:40when I was thinking about it, I thought,
  2097. 1:17:43okay, maybe the hand gestures or some of
  2098. 1:17:44those are maybe universal, but then
  2099. 1:17:46there's also the tails, right? Everyone
  2100. 1:17:48has their
  2101. 1:17:49>> There is the tails. Yeah. So you're
  2102. 1:17:50you're using the you know your hands
  2103. 1:17:52within which to speak for you because
  2104. 1:17:54then obviously sometimes you just can't
  2105. 1:17:56hear what somebody's actually saying. So
  2106. 1:17:58you have to use your hand signals.
  2107. 1:18:00>> Uh yeah. So some of those would be
  2108. 1:18:02unique to one particular market or
  2109. 1:18:04universal across you know most. So I
  2110. 1:18:07mean for us that you know fingers up is
  2111. 1:18:08bid fingers down is offered. Um for us
  2112. 1:18:13if you were shaking your hand or shaking
  2113. 1:18:15your fingers you know that's trading at
  2114. 1:18:18a particular price you know um but then
  2115. 1:18:21you would have you know yours
  2116. 1:18:24mine. So, you know, I'm selling, I'm
  2117. 1:18:27buying. So, all of this kind of
  2118. 1:18:29>> selling, your hand goes out, buying
  2119. 1:18:31comes in. Yeah. Towards you, right? Um,
  2120. 1:18:36and then of course, everybody's favorite
  2121. 1:18:38was double O trading, which is
  2122. 1:18:42so you could [laughter]
  2123. 1:18:44so you could you didn't like a
  2124. 1:18:46particular guy, you could say he was a
  2125. 1:18:47double O trader. [laughter]
  2126. 1:18:49Gotcha. All right, Paul, you have so
  2127. 1:18:51much experience over the years. I mean,
  2128. 1:18:53give us a give us a funny story. you
  2129. 1:18:55have.
  2130. 1:18:57>> Ah, right. Um, so one of the guys I used
  2131. 1:19:00to work with, everybody on the trading
  2132. 1:19:02floor has a nickname. Um, his nickname
  2133. 1:19:04was Jaws because he looked like Jaws
  2134. 1:19:06from the old Bond films. Uh, guy called
  2135. 1:19:10Barry Smith.
  2136. 1:19:12Um, and this is to just prove that you
  2137. 1:19:14don't have to be a genius within which
  2138. 1:19:16to trade, right? You know, you don't
  2139. 1:19:18have to have a degree and all that kind
  2140. 1:19:20of jazz. So, for those of you that are
  2141. 1:19:22old enough to remember the film Titanic,
  2142. 1:19:25uh when the film Titanic came out, it
  2143. 1:19:28was 1999, I think it was.
  2144. 1:19:32So, I'm sitting in the office in the
  2145. 1:19:33pre-market. There's not too much going
  2146. 1:19:35on. Uh one of the other guys, guy called
  2147. 1:19:38Lee Davis, whose nickname was Flee, he's
  2148. 1:19:41sitting there and he's he's got his feet
  2149. 1:19:43up on the desk and he said, "Oh," he
  2150. 1:19:44said, "I had to take my wife Tracy to go
  2151. 1:19:46and see uh the film Titanic last night.
  2152. 1:19:51At which point Jaws or Barry Jaws jumps
  2153. 1:19:55out of his seat, stands up and he's
  2154. 1:19:56about 6'4, 6'5. He's a big guy and he
  2155. 1:20:00looks down at Lee who's only about 5'6.
  2156. 1:20:03So it's like little and large. It was
  2157. 1:20:04hilarious. [snorts]
  2158. 1:20:06And so he's like, you know, shut the f
  2159. 1:20:08up, flee. Shut the f up, flee. And he's
  2160. 1:20:10like, why? What's the problem? He said,
  2161. 1:20:13"Well, I've got to take my girlfriend to
  2162. 1:20:15see that film tonight, and I don't want
  2163. 1:20:18to know what happens at the end."
  2164. 1:20:21And we looked at him, we were like,
  2165. 1:20:23"What do you mean? What do you mean?"
  2166. 1:20:25And we were crying with laughter. "What
  2167. 1:20:26do you mean?" She's like, "It's the
  2168. 1:20:27Titanic, Jaws." Yeah,
  2169. 1:20:32Titanic. He goes, "Yeah, it's a film."
  2170. 1:20:36Yeah. Yeah. It's a film, but it's about
  2171. 1:20:39the Titanic. He said, "Never heard of
  2172. 1:20:41it.
  2173. 1:20:43They were like, "Oh, come on. There's
  2174. 1:20:45not a rock big enough on this planet
  2175. 1:20:47that you could have lived under all of
  2176. 1:20:48your life that you've never heard of the
  2177. 1:20:50Titanic." "Never heard of it," he says.
  2178. 1:20:53So, I mean, that, you know, we're
  2179. 1:20:54killing ourselves laughing at that.
  2180. 1:20:5710, 15 minutes later, the price of
  2181. 1:21:00copper starts going down really rapidly.
  2182. 1:21:03I cannot remember for the life of me who
  2183. 1:21:05shouted it out, but somebody shouts out,
  2184. 1:21:07"Look at copper. It's going down like
  2185. 1:21:10the Titanic." At which point he jumps
  2186. 1:21:13back out of his seat again and goes,
  2187. 1:21:15"You absolute I bet it sinks,
  2188. 1:21:18doesn't it?" Right. At which point
  2189. 1:21:21people that were literally on the floor
  2190. 1:21:24crying with laughter hanging up phones
  2191. 1:21:26to clients cuz we just can't talk.
  2192. 1:21:28[snorts]
  2193. 1:21:29And I swear to God, he was just kept
  2194. 1:21:31there for comedy value sometimes because
  2195. 1:21:32he was amazing the things he'd come out
  2196. 1:21:34with. Absolutely amazing. So, hey, look,
  2197. 1:21:38let's uh if you could Paul, look, let's
  2198. 1:21:40revisit the Paul the 16 day one stepping
  2199. 1:21:44into this world. So, I mean, consider it
  2200. 1:21:46like the newer trader these days. If
  2201. 1:21:47you're giving them a piece of advice or
  2202. 1:21:49you're giving your your young self,
  2203. 1:21:5116-year-old, I mean, what would you say
  2204. 1:21:53to 16-year-old Paul the stepping into
  2205. 1:21:57this world? What advice would you give
  2206. 1:21:58him?
  2207. 1:21:59>> Uh, buy nickel and hold on to it.
  2208. 1:22:02[laughter]
  2209. 1:22:02>> Love it.
  2210. 1:22:04Now apply that to today's world.
  2211. 1:22:07>> I'm [laughter] joking. No. What would I
  2212. 1:22:09what would I say to myself? Um, learn
  2213. 1:22:12your craft. Understand what you're doing
  2214. 1:22:15before you do it cuz that's really
  2215. 1:22:17really vital. Um, understand that you
  2216. 1:22:20are just a cog in the machine. Uh,
  2217. 1:22:22whether you're a big cog or a tiny cog,
  2218. 1:22:24you're just inside the machine. Um, will
  2219. 1:22:27you ever have an influence over it? If
  2220. 1:22:29I'm talking to a retail trader, no, you
  2221. 1:22:31won't. And just, you know, just
  2222. 1:22:33understand it's okay not to be in
  2223. 1:22:35control,
  2224. 1:22:37you know, of the market. Be in control
  2225. 1:22:38of yourself because that's the one thing
  2226. 1:22:40that you can control. You can't control
  2227. 1:22:42what the market does and you never will
  2228. 1:22:43do, but you can control what you do. So
  2229. 1:22:45if you noticed that a market was in a
  2230. 1:22:47particularly volatile state or the world
  2231. 1:22:49was in a particularly volatile state and
  2232. 1:22:51the market's moving up and down and back
  2233. 1:22:53you know backwards and forwards and
  2234. 1:22:54whatever say to yourself okay so is the
  2235. 1:22:58market in
  2236. 1:23:00situation at the moment where there's
  2237. 1:23:02lots of uncertainty if the market's
  2238. 1:23:04uncertain I can't be certain
  2239. 1:23:09you know that must induce uncertainty in
  2240. 1:23:10me which means well what do I do well
  2241. 1:23:12this goes back to capital preservation
  2242. 1:23:16stay on the sidelines. Let things ride
  2243. 1:23:18out. Let things play out. The market
  2244. 1:23:21will eventually get back to normality.
  2245. 1:23:25Well, then I start playing again. You
  2246. 1:23:28know, this trading is not about trading
  2247. 1:23:30just because the market's open,
  2248. 1:23:33just be just because it's there. You
  2249. 1:23:35know again if you understood that this
  2250. 1:23:37commercial business in any market has to
  2251. 1:23:40be done every single day it does not
  2252. 1:23:42mean that you have to trade just because
  2253. 1:23:46it's open and moving you know so if we
  2254. 1:23:49are you know where are we geopolitically
  2255. 1:23:52right now and I mean I sure as hell
  2256. 1:23:55wouldn't want to be an oil trader at the
  2257. 1:23:57moment
  2258. 1:23:58>> you know one day way up one day way down
  2259. 1:24:02you just don't know what's going to
  2260. 1:24:03happen so there's so much uncertainty
  2261. 1:24:05there that if you were an oil trader,
  2262. 1:24:07the most sensible thing that you could
  2263. 1:24:09do would be like, well, I'm taking some
  2264. 1:24:10time off because the market has got no
  2265. 1:24:13rhyme or reason to it at the moment.
  2266. 1:24:17>> Yeah, brilliant. I mean, lots of great
  2267. 1:24:18lessons learned here today and really
  2268. 1:24:21just
  2269. 1:24:22>> eliminating the ego, letting letting the
  2270. 1:24:24stocks or commodities, whatever you're
  2271. 1:24:26trading, let let them kind of find
  2272. 1:24:28themsself. Don't try to force what you
  2273. 1:24:31want on the market is what I'm hearing
  2274. 1:24:32from you, Paul. Like, just
  2275. 1:24:34>> Yeah. Pay attention to what the market's
  2276. 1:24:36doing. Don't try to force what you want
  2277. 1:24:38because that ultimately will end up
  2278. 1:24:40costing us a lot of money. So traders,
  2279. 1:24:42Paul's story, it's a reminder really the
  2280. 1:24:45markets change a lot less than we think.
  2281. 1:24:48Of course, there's all the the fear, the
  2282. 1:24:50greed, everything that's still there.
  2283. 1:24:51The human behavior never really changes.
  2284. 1:24:53It's that intent intent that your dad,
  2285. 1:24:56you know, spoke on so much and you're
  2286. 1:24:58echoing that as well. Uh, a lot of these
  2287. 1:25:01lessons continue to survive. So, uh, cuz
  2288. 1:25:04they're very true. Very, very true. Uh,
  2289. 1:25:06Paul, thank you so much for coming on
  2290. 1:25:08chat with traders. I appreciate you
  2291. 1:25:11stepping on and adding some value to the
  2292. 1:25:12traders. Where can, uh, where can the
  2293. 1:25:14traders find you if they want to reach
  2294. 1:25:15out or follow your work?
  2295. 1:25:17>> Just the website. It's, um,
  2296. 1:25:19www.poolscottfx.com.
  2297. 1:25:24Uh, that's about it really. I don't do
  2298. 1:25:26social media. Uh,
  2299. 1:25:29just of that generation.
  2300. 1:25:30>> I appreciate that.
  2301. 1:25:32>> Yeah. Well, you're such a great
  2302. 1:25:33conversationalist and uh it was great
  2303. 1:25:36speaking with you and traders, hope you
  2304. 1:25:38find value. Let us know what you think
  2305. 1:25:39in the comments below. We appreciate
  2306. 1:25:41you, Paul. Take care.
  2307. 1:25:42>> Thank you very much, sir. Take care.
  2308. 1:25:44>> You've reached the end of this episode
  2309. 1:25:46of Chat with Traders, but rest assured,
  2310. 1:25:48there are more episodes loaded [music]
  2311. 1:25:50with real market insight and zero hype
  2312. 1:25:53on the way soon. So, to stay [music]
  2313. 1:25:55updated with each great new release,
  2314. 1:25:57subscribe to the podcast. And we'd love
  2315. 1:25:59it if you'd leave a rating and review.
  2316. 1:26:01We'll catch you next [music] time on
  2317. 1:26:03Chat with Traders.
  2318. 1:26:08[music]

About this transcript

This page contains the full transcript of Why Technical Analysis is Just Retail Noise · Paul Scott by Chat With Traders, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 15,789 words across 2,318 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.

What you can do with it

Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.

Free YouTube transcript tool

YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.