Why JonBenét Ramsey's Case Will Never Be Solved — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:03Boulder District Attorney Mary Lacy
- 0:04fully embraced the intruder theory.
- 0:08>> That just baffled my mind.
- 0:10>> Shocking fellow prosecutors.
- 0:13>> I'd never seen anything like that in the
- 0:15past from any other prosecutor and just
- 0:19couldn't believe she chose to do that.
- 0:21[Music]
- 0:25>> Soon, Jean Benet was herself entering
- 0:27children's competitions.
- 0:30sweetheart.
- 0:32[Music]
- 0:37>> Mary Lacy succeeded Hunter in 2001 with
- 0:40a reputation as a strong supporter of
- 0:42the intruder theories. When she issued
- 0:44her exoneration letter and apologized to
- 0:46the Ramsies, she created the impression
- 0:49that if someone could just identify the
- 0:51person whose DNA profile had been found,
- 0:53the case would be solved.
- 0:59So, you mean to tell me that a kidnapper
- 1:03lifted a great
- 1:05and entered the Ramsay house through an
- 1:08already broken window to enter the
- 1:10basement of this house and in doing so
- 1:15never disturbs this little spiderwe.
- 1:18Not in the slightest. And mind you, this
- 1:21is also the way he appears to have
- 1:23exited. So that would make this little
- 1:26critter the luckiest [ __ ] spider in
- 1:30all of the land. So now you have this
- 1:33intruder in a pitch black basement.
- 1:35Okay, he now he has a flashlight, right?
- 1:37He turns it on and he finds himself the
- 1:38light switch. The intruder now climbs up
- 1:41and out of the basement to the first
- 1:43floor where he finds the main kitchen of
- 1:46the house. And luckily there's a legal
- 1:49notepad there and a cup of pens. Now,
- 1:52mind you, this is a kidnapping ransom
- 1:55plot that this gentleman is is planning,
- 1:59but he doesn't write this ransom note in
- 2:01the leisure of his own hobvel. No, he
- 2:04waits until he breaks into this house
- 2:05because he knew he was going to find
- 2:07something to write with. Now, here is
- 2:10where he spends the next 20 minutes at
- 2:14least scribbling out a few rough drafts.
- 2:18as much as eight pages of discarded
- 2:21scribbling
- 2:23that I guess just weren't impactful
- 2:26enough, not dramatic enough before
- 2:28finally completing an entire two and a
- 2:32half page ransom note of cliches of
- 2:37melodramatic threats and he is proud of
- 2:40his work. He sees the bottom of a spiral
- 2:43staircase
- 2:44and he's going to leave those three
- 2:46pages there. The next part of his plan
- 2:49is to go up to the second floor where he
- 2:52just knows John Benet is sleeping. Goes
- 2:55into this child's room who is 6 years
- 2:57old and silently snatch her out of her
- 3:00bed, carry her without much fuss down
- 3:05two flights of stairs back to that wine
- 3:08celler. He finds Paty's art supply. See,
- 3:11this wine seller, it doesn't hold wine
- 3:12anymore. It's just a place to store junk
- 3:15for the Ramsies. And his part of that
- 3:18junk was Patsy's art supplies. And he
- 3:20finds himself a paintbrush, a nicesized
- 3:24paintbrush. He breaks it into three
- 3:26pieces. He finds some nylon string or
- 3:30rope. And he
- 3:32fashions himself a grot, a killing tool,
- 3:36a primal killing tool. That's all it's
- 3:38meant to do is to choke out your victim.
- 3:41So, I don't know what John Benet is
- 3:43doing in all this time. I'm assuming
- 3:45she's passed out. Maybe she got knocked
- 3:47out already. But he binds her wristes
- 3:50together, takes this makeshift Grot, and
- 3:53he starts strangling John Benet, but not
- 3:56before she lets out a scream. But once
- 3:59John Benet is dead, she's on the floor
- 4:02with her arms above her head. He then
- 4:05decides to duct tape her mouth, I guess,
- 4:08for fun. But oh,
- 4:11he completely forgot that this was a
- 4:15kidnap and ransom. Einstein over here
- 4:19just botched the easiest part of this
- 4:22kidnapping. Don't kill the golden goose.
- 4:26He grabs a hard suitcase, puts it up
- 4:29against, you know, that broken window
- 4:30that he had just come in. Well, it seems
- 4:32like it's hard to get out of, so he uses
- 4:34that as a stepping stool to propel
- 4:36himself out. But at least that's what it
- 4:37seems like because he's doing this in a
- 4:39perpendicular way and not just parallel
- 4:41to the wall, which I assume would make
- 4:43it a lot easier because this suitcade
- 4:45has [ __ ] wheels, you know, just to
- 4:48make things harder, you know, as he
- 4:51climbs his way out, making sure once
- 4:54again not to disturb that sleeping
- 4:57spider friend of his. I'm not sure why
- 4:59he needed a suitcase to get out of that
- 5:01window in the first place, because this
- 5:03[ __ ] can obviously levitate.
- 5:05There is one footprint of what is said
- 5:08to be a high-tech boot, but that was it.
- 5:12From that point on, he floated away
- 5:15because there would be no footprints uh
- 5:18found at the crime scene at all. He now
- 5:21simply disappeared into the night. But
- 5:25[ __ ]
- 5:26why didn't he just take John Benet's
- 5:29body along? Because it can still be a
- 5:31kidnapped ransom even if she's dead. But
- 5:34now that she's left in there and they
- 5:36find her body, why would they ever pay
- 5:40that $118,000
- 5:43strangely random number that he was
- 5:45demanding? John Benet couldn't have
- 5:47weighed more than 40 lbs. Man, dumb,
- 5:50dumb, dumb. Right.
- 5:53This is the most idiotic failed
- 5:56kidnapping in history which occurred on
- 5:59December 26th of 1996.
- 6:02not going to say that it could not
- 6:04happen. It just sounds like a story
- 6:07hatched by someone desperate who loves
- 6:10thriller movies and was simply running
- 6:13out of time. So obviously
- 6:16right off the bat of this video, you
- 6:18could see that the intruder theory to me
- 6:20at least sounds cockami.
- 6:25And as for the DNA on the long johns,
- 6:28heralded by Lacy is conclusive, our
- 6:30experts believe those two spots are
- 6:32mixtures of genetic material from more
- 6:34than two people.
- 6:35>> It looks and appears to me to be at
- 6:36least three individuals. And so that
- 6:38there's a mixture here that's not just a
- 6:40single profile,
- 6:41>> which is precisely what Mary Lacy knew
- 6:44before she exonerated the Ramsies. This
- 6:46report obtained by 9 News in the Daily
- 6:48Camera went to Lacy's office 3 months
- 6:51before she cleared the family. of the
- 6:53two spots on John Benet's long johns.
- 6:55The report says it's likely more than
- 6:57two people contributed to the mixtures.
- 7:00And after eliminating John Benet's DNA,
- 7:02the remaining DNA contribution should
- 7:04not be considered a single source
- 7:06profile. She knew based on your
- 7:10investigation that this DNA wasn't
- 7:13necessarily from one person and that it
- 7:16in fact was potentially accumulated DNA.
- 7:20she knew it at the time and why she used
- 7:23this evidence to clear the Ramsay family
- 7:27then a clearance that has continued
- 7:30because it's on the public record
- 7:32through today is is something I I can't
- 7:36explain and she should explain. you
- 7:39know, this is a case that I've been
- 7:42meaning to do for the longest time. And
- 7:44now that I have a little time to just,
- 7:47you know, sit down and um
- 7:51do it,
- 7:53you know, go over the interviews, m over
- 7:55articles or whatnot, you know, pretty
- 7:58much get the picture of what's going on
- 8:01in this case. An idea formulated in my
- 8:05head. Okay. And you know, sort of like
- 8:08the Meline McCann case that we just did.
- 8:12You know, I got a idea in that case
- 8:14also, but it also flipped a lot of the
- 8:16times. But this one, this one I just
- 8:20can't shake from start to finish of the
- 8:23script that I was writing. I just could
- 8:25not shake this one theory out of my
- 8:27head. In fact, it only got more intense.
- 8:29And I'm going to share that with you.
- 8:31But you know what? You know, I'm not
- 8:34delusional enough to believe that, you
- 8:36know, in a three decade old mystery,
- 8:39especially one as infamous and I guess
- 8:44dissected as the Jean Benet case, I'm
- 8:47not thinking that I'm going to crack
- 8:49some groundbreaking angle that make you
- 8:51guys go, whoa. Okay. But I can expand
- 8:54upon and I can add on my own thoughts
- 8:57to, you know, the pre-existing theories.
- 9:00I guess first we will dive into the main
- 9:02characters, right? The family members,
- 9:04you know, their backgrounds and
- 9:06eventually transition into the, you
- 9:08know, short life of Jean Benet when she
- 9:11came into this world up until the point,
- 9:14you know, of that fateful night. Once
- 9:16you guys have all that you need to know,
- 9:18you know, to make your own proper theory
- 9:21on this case, you know, then then I'll
- 9:23start to pepper in my own thoughts, you
- 9:25know, and my own personal concerns
- 9:28and then go into fully my theory. And I
- 9:32do encourage you guys to share your
- 9:33thoughts as well as tear into mines, you
- 9:36know, as well if you must, right? This
- 9:39definitely is a case that keeps me up at
- 9:42night. So hopefully, you know, all my
- 9:44lost sleep, maybe I can earn your
- 9:47subscription and at the very least, you
- 9:49know, a a like, a thumbs up on this
- 9:52video. And let's jump right into it.
- 9:56John Bennett Ramsey. I did not know this
- 10:01man's full name until I started to
- 10:03research for this story. So, it only
- 10:06occurred to me now that this man named
- 10:10his daughter after himself. So, John
- 10:13Bennett Ramsay's life starts in Lincoln,
- 10:16Nebraska on December 7th, 1943. His
- 10:20parents were married Jane Bennett and
- 10:22James Dudley Ramsay. Now, his father,
- 10:24James, was a decorated World War II
- 10:26pilot in the US Air Forces and an army
- 10:30dad, right, to say the least, who had to
- 10:32move his family around, you know, for a
- 10:35bit for work, but eventually settling in
- 10:38Michigan. So, John was a military brat,
- 10:40right? Meaning that he had to adjust to
- 10:42the frequent moves, different schools,
- 10:44environments, and in turn, they say that
- 10:48it would foster, you know, a type of
- 10:50resilience in John, right? adaptability
- 10:53and of course it was all he knew. So he
- 10:56had a strong sense of community among
- 10:58other military kids. Now the drawback
- 11:01you can say was that he was never really
- 11:04deeprooted in any one place in his
- 11:07childhood. You know a home to call his
- 11:09own. So this military background of
- 11:12course it shaped a lot of who John is
- 11:14and how he grew up. And from all
- 11:16accounts, he really looked up to his
- 11:19father. And uh from what's out there,
- 11:22John's early years were pretty much
- 11:24dramaree. You know, his dad was a World
- 11:27War II pilot and he was an army brat
- 11:30moving from, you know, station to
- 11:32station. You would think that there
- 11:33would be a lot of colorful stories to
- 11:34come out of John's side or at least this
- 11:37time in his life, but there really
- 11:40wasn't any. Right? So his mother, she
- 11:43was a homemaker and she provided a very
- 11:46stable household, making it a very safe,
- 11:49nurturing environment for her kids. And
- 11:52uh people who knew the family say that
- 11:54John, he was pretty disciplined, right,
- 11:56and driven just like his old man was.
- 11:59And he took to school very well because
- 12:01he took it seriously, you know, always a
- 12:05goal in mind, people would say, and he
- 12:07was always doing whatever it takes to
- 12:10achieve those goals. And that was just
- 12:12his elementary days, okay? That was when
- 12:14he was just a kid. So when it came time
- 12:16for high school, John went to Okimos
- 12:19High School in, I believe, Okimo City,
- 12:21located just out of Lancing, Michigan,
- 12:23which is a much more popular place if
- 12:25you guys need to know. And this is the
- 12:28late 50s and into the 60s. Okay, this is
- 12:31the age of the space race. And this was
- 12:33also the post-war economic boom and a
- 12:38golden age for middle class America at
- 12:41the time, at least compared to what it
- 12:43is now. So, if that was the golden age
- 12:45of the middle class, we're in the
- 12:47[ __ ] cardboard age now. John was
- 12:50described as pretty much unremarkable in
- 12:53a lot of ways, especially in sports or
- 12:56anything extracurricular, right? He
- 12:58didn't win trophies on the football
- 12:59field or he didn't even try out for the
- 13:01school play as a matter of fact. And you
- 13:04could just say that he was a square and
- 13:07uh maybe back then squares weren't as
- 13:09cool, but you know, today squares are
- 13:11pretty cool, right? If you like math and
- 13:12science or whatnot, that's exactly where
- 13:14he excelled at, right? Math and science.
- 13:17He was more of an academic. The fact
- 13:19that he ended up in Michigan State
- 13:21pretty much tells you definitely that he
- 13:24was on top of his class because that is
- 13:26a top university. So at Michigan State,
- 13:29John majored in electrical engineering,
- 13:32you know, inspired by his father who was
- 13:34a military engineer and pilot at the
- 13:36same time. And he was part of the
- 13:39generation that was actually pushed
- 13:41towards science and technology, right?
- 13:45and he eventually got his degree in
- 13:471966.
- 13:49Now, John, in similar spirit to his
- 13:51father, he wound up joining the US
- 13:54Navy's civil engineer corpse. And there
- 13:56he would spend 3 years stationed in the
- 14:00Philippines. And this was all during the
- 14:03Vietnam War era. And after eight more
- 14:05years in the Navy reserves, which was
- 14:08stationed in Atlanta. The experience
- 14:11that he gained from managing projects
- 14:12and working under, you know, that type
- 14:14of pressure of war pretty much molded
- 14:17him into the man that he became, which
- 14:20set him up for great things to come in
- 14:22his future. Hey, don't look at me. So,
- 14:25after his time in the Navy, he actually
- 14:27goes back to Michigan State where he
- 14:30picks up a master's of business
- 14:31administration, an MBA, and that would
- 14:34be in 1971. and incorporating that
- 14:37technical background from the army with
- 14:40his now MBA, it made Jon a very shrewd
- 14:43businessman in the tech industry. So
- 14:47John took those skills and just jumped
- 14:50into the private sector and he started
- 14:53his own technology and computer services
- 14:55company. And guess what? By the 1980s,
- 14:58he had carved out this name for himself
- 15:01in the Atlanta business scene. I guess
- 15:04you could call it business circles.
- 15:06Okay. In 1989 and he started a company
- 15:09called Advanced Product Group which grew
- 15:12to become access graphics by 1991. It
- 15:16had merged with Lockheed Martin which is
- 15:20a major American company which serves
- 15:23primarily the US Department of Defense.
- 15:25Right. So not bad. It was under John's
- 15:28leadership that the company took off,
- 15:30grossing over a billion dollars in
- 15:32revenue in just seven years of its
- 15:35inception. That's crazy. That same year
- 15:38of the merger, he moved the company's
- 15:41headquarters to Boulder, Colorado, where
- 15:43John was named entrepreneur of the year
- 15:46by the Boulder Chamber of Commerce. His
- 15:49reputation became that of an executive
- 15:51known for scaling up companies and
- 15:53building something out of nothing. And
- 15:56if you want an idea of how big John was
- 16:00back then, you can compare him to the
- 16:02likes of a Michael Dell, you know, the
- 16:05founder of Dell Computers. And now you
- 16:08kind of get a sense of, you know, what a
- 16:11big deal John Bennett Ramsey actually
- 16:15was back then. And of course, there's
- 16:17nothing like some monetary figures to
- 16:19really drive home how rich uh John
- 16:23Ramsay was. Let's say in 1996, okay,
- 16:26when the case went down, John Ramsay's
- 16:29net worth was valued at $6.4 million,
- 16:34which is roughly worth $130
- 16:38million in today's money. One of his
- 16:42bonuses, as you will come to find out,
- 16:44was already $118,000.
- 16:47So you can imagine his annual salary
- 16:50was.
- 16:53Now let's go ahead and jump into John's
- 16:56personal life which we could imagine you
- 16:58know because of his heavy workload you
- 17:00know had its shares of up and downs. So
- 17:03when he was fresh out of college okay
- 17:05we're rewinding back a little bit. He
- 17:07married uh Lucinda Pash in 1966 and they
- 17:11had three children together Elizabeth
- 17:13Melinda and John Andrew. his daughter
- 17:16Elizabeth heartbreakingly in 1992 would
- 17:20die in a car accident and she was just
- 17:2222 years old driving in the rain I
- 17:24believe with her boyfriend where they
- 17:26hydroplaned and lost control of the car.
- 17:29Now Melinda, she would go on to become a
- 17:31nurse and pretty much stay out of the
- 17:33public eye while John Andrew has been
- 17:36pretty much outspoken, you know, about
- 17:39his family's story and he also works in
- 17:41technology. Although John and Lucinda's
- 17:44marriage only survived 12 years, you
- 17:47know, and uh they got a divorce in 1978.
- 17:50John did stay pretty much present in his
- 17:54children's lives as they were growing up
- 17:56and from all accounts was very close to
- 17:58them and was a good father. And so it
- 18:01was after this divorce that John met
- 18:03Paty Paw in Atlanta. She was gorgeous
- 18:06and she was charming. She was also the
- 18:10former Miss West Virginia of 1977.
- 18:14The two met through friends and they
- 18:16married in 1980. John and Paty built a
- 18:19life together in Atlanta and later of
- 18:21course moved to Boulder, Colorado. They
- 18:24had two more children of their own named
- 18:26Burke, born in 87, and of course John
- 18:29Benet who was born in 1990.
- 18:32The Ramsies were known in Boulder as
- 18:35friendly, social people, right? They
- 18:37hosted gatherings and were involved in
- 18:39the community. As people in Boulder got
- 18:42to know John, they said that he was, you
- 18:44know, a very nice man, you know, and he
- 18:46was very protective of his family. And I
- 18:49just want to say real quick that no
- 18:50matter, you know, how we feel about John
- 18:54Ramsay, the fact doesn't change that he
- 18:56is a man that has lost two children in
- 18:58his lifetime. And after these tragedies,
- 19:01John would spend pretty much his golden
- 19:03years, right? the latter years of his
- 19:05life technically fighting for justice
- 19:08for his daughter while at the same time
- 19:10dealing with you know the relentless
- 19:12public scrutiny you know of defending
- 19:14his family's name in court even and in
- 19:17the press and I do want to touch upon
- 19:19that the following four years since John
- 19:22Benet went missing John didn't work his
- 19:26company pretty much gave him time off
- 19:28you know for grievance but things never
- 19:32really got back on track for John in
- 19:34terms of how I guess wealthy he was and
- 19:38um at certain points while Paty was
- 19:42still alive, they were dealing with a
- 19:44lot of financial struggles. I'm pretty
- 19:45sure they still had a lot of money, but
- 19:48they weren't living in that big fancy
- 19:50mansion anymore. They had to downgrade
- 19:51to a much smaller house and live a much
- 19:53more simple, I guess, financially
- 19:56responsible life.
- 19:58Paty would die from ovarian cancer just
- 20:01a decade after John Benet was murdered.
- 20:05And after having to deal with all that,
- 20:07which could not be easy, John would find
- 20:11companionship with another lady named
- 20:13Beth Holloway. And she too was dealing
- 20:16with her own loss of um I believe her
- 20:19child went missing in Aruba and they
- 20:21never found her. So they pretty much
- 20:23bonded over that, you know, kind of
- 20:26tragedy of losing a child. That was
- 20:28actually a very brief relationship.
- 20:30Okay. So, um, he would find love, uh, a
- 20:35companion. I'm not too sure, but in
- 20:372011, uh, John married Jan Russo, you
- 20:40know, and she was a fashion designer.
- 20:42And these days, uh, John just lives a
- 20:45pretty much basic life. and he has a
- 20:47home in Michigan, but he has been known
- 20:49to travel to Moab, Utah on occasion
- 20:52where he has another home. So yeah, if
- 20:54you want to cry for John for not being
- 20:56as rich as before, he's probably still
- 20:57richer than most of us now. And I will
- 20:59give this to him. I mean, he's in his
- 21:0180s now and he has never stopped pushing
- 21:04for answers in the John Benet case. He's
- 21:07written books, okay? Uh one was called
- 21:10The Death of Innocence and um The Other
- 21:13Side of Suffering. and he'll tell you
- 21:16these are not money grabs, okay? That
- 21:18he's hoping that sharing his story might
- 21:21help others and maybe finally bring some
- 21:23closure to this case, you know, keep it
- 21:24in the public eye. Sort of what we're
- 21:26doing right now for this case that is
- 21:30pretty much one of America's most
- 21:32haunting mysteries.
- 21:35Now, let's talk about Paty Ramsay. And
- 21:39uh she wasn't always Paty Ramsey, of
- 21:41course. She was born Patricia Paul in
- 21:43December 29 of 1956
- 21:46in Parkerburg, West Virginia. Now Paul,
- 21:50I looked it up and that's a name of
- 21:52German descent. So I assume she's
- 21:54German. Hers was described as a
- 21:56bluecollar family in a bluecollar town
- 21:59along the Ohio River. Sounds like
- 22:01something right out of a Tom Sawyer
- 22:05book, right? So her dad, his name is
- 22:07Donald, and he worked as an engineer and
- 22:09a manager at Union Carbide. Now, Paty
- 22:14was the oldest of three girls in the Paw
- 22:16family. Now, this brings me to her mom,
- 22:19and her name was Nedra, and she was a
- 22:22homemaker, okay? But for some reason,
- 22:25she really, really liked pageantss. She
- 22:29had a real passion for local beauty
- 22:32pageantss. And the only reason I figured
- 22:35that she did was because her daughters
- 22:38were gorgeous. Py, as we found out, was
- 22:42Miss West Virginia of 1977. And now get
- 22:45this, her sister Pamela would go on to
- 22:48win Miss West Virginia in 1980. So
- 22:52definitely a very good-looking family.
- 22:55Now growing up, Paty grew up in what you
- 22:58might call a solid middle class life.
- 23:00Her parents pushed education and
- 23:03achievement, but this was the old south,
- 23:07okay? The old school south where manners
- 23:10pretty much was on par with academics,
- 23:14you know, and a strong sense of, you
- 23:16know, family pride was neck and neck
- 23:18with how smart you were. And it was said
- 23:20that Nedra, you know, mom, especially
- 23:23had big hopes for her daughters, her
- 23:25girls, especially for Paty, always
- 23:29encouraging Paty, you know, to get up on
- 23:31stage to outshine others, you know,
- 23:35whether it was a local pageant or a
- 23:37school talent show, you could say that
- 23:40in many ways, Nedra was Paty's biggest
- 23:43fan, you know, and people that knew Paty
- 23:46back in those days, when she was a kid,
- 23:49described her as very outgoing, very
- 23:52ambitious, and very sweet at the same
- 23:56time. She was always ready to please,
- 23:59you know, and she had a knack of making
- 24:00friends no matter where she was.
- 24:03Probably because she was never really
- 24:05shy about standing out. And uh, you
- 24:08know, all a result of how her mom Nedra
- 24:11raised her. Like, I'm telling you, Nedra
- 24:14was Paty's biggest fan. I'm going to
- 24:17need to put on some mosquito spray. I
- 24:18saw one mosquito fly across my face and
- 24:22I panicked. Okay, so um like I was
- 24:25saying, uh her mom was her biggest fan,
- 24:28right? And she instilled in her that
- 24:31looks and charisma were gifts not to be
- 24:34taken for granted, right? That she was
- 24:36actually lucky to even possess this and
- 24:40they were a ticket to something much
- 24:42grander if she utilized them. This
- 24:46belief from her mother was all the
- 24:50encouragement that Paty needed. It
- 24:51pretty much lit a fire, making Paty both
- 24:55competitive and determined to succeed.
- 24:58Now, from everything that we know, she
- 25:01was fiercely loyal as well. Something
- 25:03that would be described as one of her
- 25:05key traits throughout her entire life
- 25:07was this loyalty and especially to her
- 25:11mother, right? And she tended to see
- 25:13relationships in black and white. It's
- 25:15either you were with her or you were
- 25:18against her. You had to be on board with
- 25:20the program with Patricia Paul. So Paty
- 25:23went to Parkerburg High School where she
- 25:26built a reputation as a hard worker and
- 25:28someone who just pretty much got
- 25:29involved in everything, right? We all
- 25:31know somebody back in high school that
- 25:33just I don't know managed their time so
- 25:36well that they were able to just be part
- 25:38of everything in yearbook, right? Their
- 25:40pictures were everywhere. And that was
- 25:42Paty. She did well in school, doing all
- 25:45these things and still finding time to
- 25:47do well in school. I still to this day
- 25:50don't know how those kids did it. She
- 25:52generally gave the impression of someone
- 25:54who'd go very far in life. There aren't
- 25:58a ton of detailed stories from this time
- 26:01as well, just like John, because it was
- 26:03just a long time ago. But I mean, we
- 26:05could surmise, you know, that it appears
- 26:07her home life gave her a solid
- 26:10foundation and lack of confidence was
- 26:13never ever something people would say
- 26:16about Paty. And at 19, she would immerse
- 26:19herself, I guess you could say, more
- 26:21thoroughly in pageantry. And you already
- 26:24know Nedra is right by her side every
- 26:26step of the way. and she was entering
- 26:28local pageantss in order to get more
- 26:30comfortable on stage and you know and
- 26:32sharpen her public speaking abilities.
- 26:35Eventually, you know, just by being very
- 26:38pretty and very charming, she would
- 26:40actually go on to win these local
- 26:43titles. And her peers remembered her as
- 26:46the kind of girl who once she got an
- 26:48idea in her head, she would not let go.
- 26:52she would chomp down and never release
- 26:55it until she chased it down and got it
- 26:59done. I pretty much just compared her to
- 27:02a jackal. But at the same time, people
- 27:05said that she was very friendly even in
- 27:10doing so, even in competing with you.
- 27:12And this is where the charm is.
- 27:14Definitely. She was popular in school
- 27:17and she had this certain magnetism that
- 27:20just made people
- 27:22gravitate to her. By the time she
- 27:24finishes high school, you know, it was
- 27:27very clear to a lot of people that Paty
- 27:29wasn't going to be satisfied by being
- 27:31some type of background character. You
- 27:33know, what the kids call today as NPCs,
- 27:36right? Non-playable characters. And in
- 27:39her first big step, you know, into
- 27:41adulthood, you could say, Paty enrolled
- 27:43in the West Virginia University in
- 27:45Morgantown. And she majored in
- 27:46journalism and um her focus, I believe,
- 27:49was advertising. She would also join the
- 27:51sorority there, which was called Alpha Z
- 27:54Delta. From there, she would actually
- 27:56meet and maintain a lot of key
- 27:58friendships that would help build a key
- 28:02network uh for her future. And it was in
- 28:061977
- 28:08that all that work and I'm talking about
- 28:10the pageant side, right? Uh all the
- 28:14values that her darling mom Nedra had
- 28:17instilled in her, she won the Miss West
- 28:20Virginia crown in 1977, which was a very
- 28:24huge deal. Right. The Paul family could
- 28:27not be any more elated, especially
- 28:29Nedra. Right. And this would actually
- 28:32send Py to the Miss America pageant in
- 28:36Atlantic City. Now, even though she
- 28:38would not go on to win that, her
- 28:40confidence at this point was through the
- 28:43roof. Definitely an exciting time for
- 28:46all that were involved and she would go
- 28:48on to graduate college with a degree in
- 28:51journalism in 1978. And so now with
- 28:56college out of the way, Paty moved to
- 28:59Atlanta where she would try her hand at
- 29:01journalism and advertising. Now how she
- 29:04did in this field isn't too clear, at
- 29:06least not anything specific that I could
- 29:09find out about it, but most likely she
- 29:11was working in uh media and promotions I
- 29:14read. But regardless, her career isn't
- 29:16actually a key part of her coming of age
- 29:19tale. And people who knew her at this
- 29:22stage in her life uh described her still
- 29:25as strong willed. These are the
- 29:26co-workers, right? Loyalty again comes
- 29:29into the conversation when you talk
- 29:31about Paty. If you were on her good
- 29:33graces, she will defend you till her
- 29:36dying day, it appeared. And I I think
- 29:38it's interesting that this is a key
- 29:40trait that people throughout her life so
- 29:43far keeps bringing up. You could say
- 29:45just as her mother stressed to her, she
- 29:48would use that southern charm, you know,
- 29:50to win over anyone. Paty would never
- 29:55really stick full-time to this career in
- 29:58journalism. And part of why she never
- 30:01really had to focus on that career, that
- 30:03degree that she has, was because Paty
- 30:06met John Ramsey. And as we know, he is
- 30:10super successful. I myself am a firm
- 30:13believer that opposites do attract.
- 30:16Okay, so the way they met is very
- 30:18simple. They ran in similar social
- 30:20circles and they started talking one day
- 30:22and they pretty much hit it off. Paty
- 30:24doing most of the heavy lifting in the
- 30:26conversation and John going, "Uh-huh.
- 30:28Uh-huh. Uh-huh. I can see it now, right?
- 30:30Can you guys see it?" But he was
- 30:32successful anyways. And at the time he
- 30:35was going through a divorce himself. And
- 30:38uh he was coming with three kids if Paty
- 30:41would accept him. Like I said, opposites
- 30:43attract, okay? Like her outgoing,
- 30:45positive energy. It it was just a
- 30:48welcome balance to his quiet nature. And
- 30:51so they got married on November 5th of
- 30:541980 at the Peach Tree Presbyterian
- 30:57Church. Even though John was bringing
- 31:00three kids into this marriage already,
- 31:03you know, it seemed like it didn't
- 31:04bother Paty much at all. And by this
- 31:07picture that I found, that's Paty right
- 31:09there. That's John. He's almost
- 31:11unrecognizable to me. But those are his
- 31:14three kids from his previous marriage.
- 31:16And they all seemed to be getting along
- 31:20just fine. And of course, we all know
- 31:22that they would go on to have two more
- 31:23kids, Burke and John Benet. And so a
- 31:26year after John Benet was uh born, of
- 31:29course, this was about the time where
- 31:30Axis Graphics was really taking off in
- 31:331991 and the family moved to Boulder.
- 31:36Okay, for John's growing success in
- 31:39Boulder, Paty threw herself into local
- 31:41society, you know, charity events and
- 31:44not surprisingly, eventually putting
- 31:46Jean Banet in her first beauty pageant
- 31:48when she was four years old. Paty, very
- 31:51similar to her mother, Nedra, was
- 31:53incredibly hands-on and she was visible
- 31:56in the community and known for her
- 31:58dedication to her children and her
- 32:01family. But a dark cloud seemed to be
- 32:05just over this family in the early '9s
- 32:08and I guess you could say pretty much
- 32:11the rest of their lives. And it started
- 32:14with 1992 and the death of Elizabeth in
- 32:17that car crash. But the cloud remained.
- 32:20It's like it never left even after that
- 32:22because the very following year Paty's
- 32:25doctor gave her an extremely grim
- 32:28diagnosis that she had stage 4 ovarian
- 32:32cancer. And it dampened an otherwise
- 32:36great life. But this was Paty that we
- 32:39were talking about. And I would say in
- 32:41Paty fashion, she just trucked on
- 32:44staying positive. And that's just who
- 32:47she was, you know, hoping to find that
- 32:49semblance of normality again in her
- 32:51life, the joy, the happiness, and she
- 32:53was finding it. And then it all changed
- 32:56again in 1996 when John Benet was
- 33:00murdered. It was a tragedy that made the
- 33:02headlines sensationalized by the media,
- 33:05which needless to say changed Patsy's
- 33:08life for the worse. And not long after
- 33:10that, Paty
- 33:13had to face a cancer that had gone into
- 33:16remission, but now it was back. And her
- 33:18battle with ovarian cancer raged on once
- 33:21again, which she fought with for several
- 33:25years before she finally lost the battle
- 33:28in 2006, and she was just 49 years old.
- 33:35Burke Ramsay was born on January 27,
- 33:381987 in Atlanta, Georgia. At the time,
- 33:41his father John was, you know, building
- 33:44and making a name for himself in the
- 33:46tech industry. And his mother, Paty, who
- 33:48used to be a journalist and an ex beauty
- 33:51queen, was now a stay-at-home mom and a
- 33:54socialite. And Burke was their first
- 33:56child together. Burke was really young
- 33:58when his father started making waves,
- 34:01you know, in the tech industry. And he
- 34:02was bringing home more and more bacon,
- 34:05right, to make life for Burke extremely
- 34:08comfortable with a mom that devoted
- 34:10herself completely to the home to Burke.
- 34:14Again, there aren't many stories, you
- 34:15know, about Burke during his time as a
- 34:17baby and a toddler. And it's most likely
- 34:20because the Ramsies aren't sharing that
- 34:24part of their lives, which is perfectly
- 34:26respectable. But for the most part, you
- 34:28know, we can easily assume that it was a
- 34:31warm, steady home with plenty of family
- 34:34time, southern traditions, and
- 34:36vacations. So Burke was just 3 years old
- 34:39when the Ramsies told him that he was
- 34:41about to have a little sister. And from
- 34:43the accounts of the family, he was very
- 34:46excited to be a big brother. But still
- 34:49there aren't a lot of detailed accounts
- 34:51of their interactions during this time.
- 34:55Though the family would say that, you
- 34:58know, he took to the role easily.
- 34:59According to them, they would say that
- 35:01Burke was very excited to become a
- 35:03bigger brother. And as they were growing
- 35:06up together, it was pretty much a normal
- 35:09relationship between a brother and a
- 35:10sister. You know, you mix in the
- 35:12playfulness and the bickering and pretty
- 35:16much nothing out of the ordinary.
- 35:18He's just circling around looking for a
- 35:21moment so it could land on my head. It's
- 35:23probably because the product in my hair,
- 35:27you bonsel. I knew it.
- 35:29Anyways, so in 1991, this is about the
- 35:32time that John Ramsay, his father, would
- 35:35become president and CEO of his company,
- 35:37Access Graphics. and uh the money would
- 35:40start rolling in because once he got the
- 35:43power to do so, he spearheaded a merger
- 35:47acquisition by Loheed Martin and pretty
- 35:51much turned
- 35:52Access Graphics into a billiondoll
- 35:55company that year in 1996. And Burke saw
- 36:00his modest little house that he grew up
- 36:03in turn into this giant mansion. So now
- 36:08young Burke is in Boulder, Colorado, and
- 36:11he settled in there, right? Well, I
- 36:12mean, what else can he do? He's just a
- 36:14child, right? So he went to the local
- 36:16schools. He had neighborhood friends,
- 36:18birthday parties, you know, relatively
- 36:20normal upbringing. And the family
- 36:22noticed right from the start that Burke
- 36:24was pretty much taking after John in a
- 36:27lot of ways. He loved to build things,
- 36:29Legos, fiddling with gadgets, and
- 36:32playing video games for the most part.
- 36:34The people of Boulder, their impression
- 36:36of the Ramsies when they moved in was
- 36:38basically they were friendly, social
- 36:40people, pretty much on the back of Paty,
- 36:43I'm pretty sure. Uh, she was very
- 36:45involved in everything and Burke was at
- 36:48her side and he was often seen, you
- 36:51know, at community events and playdates.
- 36:53Now, words like quiet, shy, and smart
- 36:57were used to describe him. pretty much
- 37:00the same words that you would probably
- 37:01use to describe John Burke as well
- 37:04wasn't the type to draw attention, you
- 37:06know, which is in heavy contrast with
- 37:09how John Benet is going to be. It almost
- 37:13takes you back when you realize how much
- 37:17Burke was like John and how much John
- 37:19Benet was like Paty. Now, there would be
- 37:21future interviews with Burke that would
- 37:23ask him, you know, how he felt because
- 37:25his sister pretty much got all the
- 37:28spotlight, pretty much got all the
- 37:29attention, right? He was fine with it,
- 37:31that he actually didn't mind it because
- 37:34he didn't want it. He didn't care to be
- 37:36the center of attention and he didn't
- 37:38mind that his little sister was. He said
- 37:41that he loved science and tech and
- 37:43according to his teachers, that's
- 37:45exactly what he was a selling in. you
- 37:47know the STEM system, science,
- 37:49technology,
- 37:51English and math is e English,
- 37:52engineering and math. Ah, I obviously am
- 37:55not STEM. And now we're going to move to
- 37:58when everything changed on December 26
- 38:01of 1996.
- 38:03Now Burke was nine when it happened when
- 38:06John Benet was killed. After the family
- 38:08actually moved back to Atlanta out of
- 38:11Boulder. they just didn't want to be
- 38:12there anymore because of the sheer media
- 38:15blitz that was going on about this
- 38:17story. It pretty much left them wanting,
- 38:20you know, some more privacy and that's
- 38:22completely understandable. And for a
- 38:25while, even after the tragedy, Burke was
- 38:29homeschooled because of I guess they're
- 38:31just trying to avoid the ridicule, the
- 38:36harassment possibly. These were hard
- 38:38times for the Ramseies in general, you
- 38:41know, emotionally and also financially
- 38:43as John would not work for the next four
- 38:46years.
- 38:47>> Life has never been the same and it has
- 38:51basically ruined us financially and
- 38:54emotionally and everything else.
- 38:57>> As they're watching their fortunes
- 38:59pretty much dissipate, so Burke would
- 39:02eventually return to public schooling.
- 39:05Now, I want to take you guys back to the
- 39:08day that John Benet was murdered. Now,
- 39:10Burke was interviewed, and he was
- 39:13interviewed several times during the
- 39:14course of the investigation. I will say
- 39:17that nothing flagged to the detectives,
- 39:20at least as him being a part or even
- 39:24knowing what happened to his sister
- 39:26early on in the case. They never flagged
- 39:29him as a major concern. And even 2 years
- 39:32after his sister's death, they ruled him
- 39:35out, cleared him as a suspect. And
- 39:38despite all the rumors and wild stories
- 39:40online about him being jealous or, you
- 39:43know, misbehavior, people close to Burke
- 39:46insist that he was just a regular kid
- 39:48who had been hit with a horrible loss.
- 39:50And, you know, he didn't talk about the
- 39:54case. You know, even at home with his
- 39:56parents, he's that kind of person,
- 39:59right? We look at him and he's a bit
- 40:01odd. I guess the word that most people
- 40:04would describe him seeing his interviews
- 40:06even today, he had a Dr. Phil interview
- 40:08and first word to come to mind is odd,
- 40:12but it wasn't odd to his family. They
- 40:14said that he's the kind of person that
- 40:16would process everything quietly. And so
- 40:19in the Atlanta school system, right,
- 40:22Burke made it through with as little
- 40:25fuss as possible. There's not much to
- 40:28glean in terms of public records of
- 40:31these school days of uh Burke and that's
- 40:34pretty much by design. Those that did
- 40:37know him, his peers said that he was a
- 40:40strong student, especially in the STEM
- 40:42uh subjects. He would um have his tight
- 40:46little circle of friends which he never
- 40:48veered very far away from. and he just
- 40:51pretty much avoided doing any type of
- 40:53activity that brought him any attention.
- 40:56And then came, you know, the time in
- 40:582006 where he also had to deal with the
- 41:01loss of his mother. He should be about
- 41:0318 or 19 at this time, right? Just
- 41:06entering adulthood. Burke pretty much
- 41:08coped with this, pretty much how Burke
- 41:11coped with everything, right? by keeping
- 41:13his head down and focusing on whatever
- 41:16it is he was focusing on at the time
- 41:19which was um Purdue University. He was
- 41:22studying computer science and software
- 41:24engineering. During this time you know
- 41:27there was no interviews, no media, just
- 41:30school and friends. And when he left
- 41:33college he jumped into the tech world
- 41:35working as a software engineer. And
- 41:37these days, Burke is now 38 years old
- 41:40and he lives in Michigan, still working
- 41:42on STEM and keeping his life private.
- 41:44And he's done pretty well for himself
- 41:46for the most part. He says that he has a
- 41:48strong relationship with his father. And
- 41:51according to John himself, his father,
- 41:54uh, Burke avoids talking about his life
- 41:57in general. That's just not a topic that
- 42:00he goes into. and he won't talk about um
- 42:05his little sister's death at all. And
- 42:07you know, to the outside world, Burke
- 42:09can easily be perceived as a recluse,
- 42:11right? Shaped by, you know, the
- 42:13tragedies of his life, being hounded by
- 42:16rumors and conspiracy theories, you
- 42:18know, that can really have a toll on
- 42:20somebody's psyche. And like I've been
- 42:22hammering home, he just wants to stay in
- 42:24the shadows. But in 2016,
- 42:28he decided to come out of the shadows a
- 42:29little bit, right? and he sat down for a
- 42:32Dr. Phil interview on the 20th
- 42:35anniversary of his little sister's
- 42:37death. And the world got to see, you
- 42:39know, Burke for who he is, right? And
- 42:44get some of the takes that only a
- 42:48grieving brother can have. Burke simply
- 42:51said that he missed John Benet from what
- 42:54he could remember of her. I mean, she
- 42:55was, you know, just a brief part of all
- 42:58their family's lives. I mean, she was 6
- 43:00years old and he was 9 years old when
- 43:02she died. He will have fond memories.
- 43:05The things that he does remember about
- 43:07his little sister um warms his heart and
- 43:10it makes him miss her and he tries to
- 43:13remember her, you know, outside of the
- 43:15constant news coverage. He said that
- 43:18when he learned about the news of his
- 43:19sister, you know, he was confused and
- 43:22once things started to sink in, you
- 43:24know, there was a bit of disbelief that
- 43:26he felt that morning. at nine years old,
- 43:28how do you process loss? How do you
- 43:30process the fact that someone that
- 43:32you've known for pretty much your
- 43:35conscious existence will no longer be
- 43:38there because of death. And he would try
- 43:40to explain how hard it was for him at
- 43:44the time to process this loss. In this
- 43:46interview, you know, he wanted to
- 43:47tackle, you know, the rumors about his
- 43:50jealousy and their relationship issues
- 43:52or whatnot, you know, between him and
- 43:54John Benet. And in the interview, you
- 43:56could see that at moments that he should
- 44:00be uncomfortable, he would crack a smile
- 44:02or he would even just laugh all while
- 44:05talking about how it hurts, you know,
- 44:09too much for him to talk about John
- 44:11Benet. He
- 44:13talks and fumbles his words in a clumsy
- 44:17way, I guess, you know, talking about
- 44:19how he's connected with, you know, the
- 44:21surviving family and how he deals with
- 44:24things in his own quiet way and that he
- 44:27completely supports the search for
- 44:30answers. His belief of what happened to
- 44:33his little sister is that an intruder
- 44:35did come in that day and kill her. and
- 44:38he expressed immense amounts of
- 44:40frustration by all the speculation aimed
- 44:43towards him, towards any of his family
- 44:46members. Him and his father did file a
- 44:48lawsuit against CBS for $750 million
- 44:51over a documentary that pretty much said
- 44:54that Burke killed his little sister. And
- 44:57they settled for some undisclosed amount
- 45:00with uh no party ever admitting, you
- 45:02know, fault. It was settled in 2019.
- 45:05John and Burke, they targeted several
- 45:07news outlets that were spewing all types
- 45:09of misinformation, uh, rumors or whatnot
- 45:12as fact, and they would settle
- 45:14confidentially with a lot of these
- 45:16outlets. Now, there was a 2024 Netflix
- 45:20documentary on the Ramsay case, on the
- 45:23John Banet case, and Burke pretty much
- 45:25stayed away from that altogether. Burke
- 45:27saying that he was tired of being
- 45:28mistreated in the media, you know, by
- 45:31amateur detectives, I guess, sort of
- 45:33like me. John actually is still an
- 45:35advocate for getting DNA analyzed, you
- 45:39know, IGG, investigatory genetic
- 45:42genealogy. But Burke and John were
- 45:44spotted at Crime Con and shaking hands
- 45:47and taking pictures or whatnot. What I
- 45:48would assume is attempts to keep the
- 45:51John Benet Ramsey case alive.
- 45:55>> Okay. What is your favorite animal at
- 45:59the zoo?
- 46:00The monkeys think because they laugh
- 46:03with stuff and hanging around.
- 46:07>> Now, let's go ahead and meet John Benet
- 46:10Patricia Ramsay. So, John Benet made her
- 46:13debut to life on August 6th of 1990. And
- 46:18even the phrase a star is born, that
- 46:20that had to be penned for
- 46:24a character like John Benet. So her
- 46:26parents took her home from the North
- 46:28Side Hospital in Atlanta, Georgia, and
- 46:30plopped her straight into the lap of
- 46:33luxury, so to speak, right, of southern
- 46:35comfort to an ambitious mom who knew her
- 46:38way around a tiara and a microphone. A
- 46:41mom who brought pageant queen energy to
- 46:44just about everything. Now she had the
- 46:46most adorable baby girl to cultivate. So
- 46:50here was John Benet. She was now the
- 46:52baby of the house with Burke just being
- 46:54a few years ahead of her. And she was in
- 46:57a family that was incredibly wealthy
- 47:00that had all the trappings of success
- 47:03and pretty much every means for their
- 47:06children to succeed. So when John Benet
- 47:10was about one, the Ramsies packed up
- 47:12their lives and headed west to Boulder,
- 47:14Colorado because John's company was
- 47:16growing and their house just got a lot
- 47:19lot bigger. We're talking about three
- 47:22stories and a basement. And so they
- 47:25landed in this tutor style mansion,
- 47:287,000
- 47:30square feet that would basically be the
- 47:34backdrop for the remainder of John
- 47:36Benet's short life. So from the stories
- 47:39that friends and family tell about John
- 47:41Benet, that she was just pure sunshine.
- 47:45I mean, she'd be the kid that would hand
- 47:46out hugs. You didn't even need to bribe
- 47:49her with candy. As corny as it sounds
- 47:52now, she'd light up a room with her
- 47:54smile. And she really did. You see these
- 47:57pictures here? It almost felt like she
- 47:59was a little adult, which is a little
- 48:02troubling at the same time, I must
- 48:03admit. And because her mother Paty, just
- 48:06like her mother before her, Nedra,
- 48:08taught them southern hospitality and
- 48:10manners, little Jean was very mindful of
- 48:13others. One example was that she
- 48:15insisted on writing a get well card for
- 48:18a sick neighbor even though she didn't
- 48:20know that sick neighbor at all. She just
- 48:22happened to hear that the neighbor was
- 48:24sick. And of course Paty being who she
- 48:26was made sure that her beautiful little
- 48:29darling was front and center even at
- 48:32church even at the St. John's Episcopal
- 48:35church. John Benet would attend Sunday
- 48:37school in nothing but the best clothing.
- 48:40If there was a Christmas pageant, you
- 48:41know, John Benet would be entered. When
- 48:43it came to Paty Ramsay, it was the whole
- 48:46nine yards. But of course, John Benet,
- 48:49she was still a child. She still loved
- 48:51playing with dolls, still loved riding
- 48:54her bike around the neighborhood, and
- 48:56her drawings could be found scattered
- 48:59all over the mansion. Now, her
- 49:01caretakers, because of course she had
- 49:03caretakers, right? They also find her
- 49:05very bright and very social. They said
- 49:08that this little girl was very eager to
- 49:10learn and pretty easy to get along with.
- 49:13She was not a problematic child from the
- 49:15experiences uh they had with her. And as
- 49:18she got older, it was very easy to see
- 49:20that she genuinely liked people. She she
- 49:22liked to be around people to make people
- 49:26happy. A people pleaser similar to Paty
- 49:29herself. So by the age of four, Paty
- 49:32started entering little John Benetan
- 49:35pageantss. All of this was pretty much
- 49:37inevitable, right, because of Pat's own
- 49:39pageant pedigree. There were little
- 49:42crowns, you know, costumes, a bunch of
- 49:44little sashes everywhere, if you could
- 49:46imagine it. Just a bunch of little
- 49:48people, little girls pretending to be
- 49:50adults, you know, while, you know, other
- 49:53little kids of their age were collecting
- 49:55bugs. You know, here was John Benet,
- 49:58four years old, collecting beauty
- 50:00pageant titles. You know, titles such as
- 50:03America's Royal Miss, Little Miss
- 50:06Charlavoy, Little Miss Colorado, and
- 50:10National Tiny Miss. Even at that early
- 50:14age, she was already loving to sing and
- 50:16loving to dance, loving to perform in
- 50:18front of crowds. But according to the
- 50:21Ramsies, it was nothing serious. It was
- 50:24treated as more of a family event, a f a
- 50:28time that they could bond together. So
- 50:29if you asked Paty, you know, she wasn't
- 50:32pressuring John Benet to do these
- 50:34things. You know, these were things that
- 50:35John Benet just happened to want to do.
- 50:38You know, every time I see footage, you
- 50:40know, of the pageantss, you know, the
- 50:42ones that John Benet were in or whatnot,
- 50:45the first thing I think is that's a lot
- 50:48of work, okay, for an adult even, and
- 50:51we're talking about a little kid here to
- 50:53learn a whole entire choreographed
- 50:55performance, learn a song, sing in front
- 50:57of a crowd in your little dress. Um, I
- 51:01don't know what goes through the head of
- 51:03a four-year-old in a case like that. And
- 51:05this isn't even some type of
- 51:06controversial take on my part at least
- 51:08because you know after her death after
- 51:11the world learned that she was
- 51:14participating in these type of
- 51:15pageantss, these little miss pageantss,
- 51:19it looked really bad. I mean you had
- 51:21these pictures of John Benet in full
- 51:23makeup, big hair and performing arguably
- 51:28grownup performances. you know, they got
- 51:30splashed all across everybody's TV, all
- 51:32across the tabloid sections of your
- 51:35local grocery store, which prompted the
- 51:37family to say publicly that, again, this
- 51:41was all for fun. That the newspapers and
- 51:44the media was just twisting her story
- 51:46into something that never really was
- 51:48because those that actually knew her
- 51:50knew that she was just a regular kid.
- 51:53She was just a regular six-year-old that
- 51:55spent more time at home playing with her
- 51:57brother or baking cookies with mommy
- 51:59than out at these pageantss. Okay, so
- 52:03now we're going to go into the month of
- 52:05December 1996, which is a very big month
- 52:08for the Ramsies every single year
- 52:10because of all the festivities that are
- 52:12planned, the family traditions. The
- 52:14house was decked out in Christmas
- 52:16decorations. And inside would be this
- 52:19giant Christmas tree with decorations
- 52:23from foot to tip.
- 52:27Foot to tip. Just at the start of this
- 52:29month, it would be even more to
- 52:31celebrate than just the holidays because
- 52:33John Benet had just won Little Miss
- 52:36Christmas and she got the crown at a
- 52:38pageant in Denver, Colorado. And so,
- 52:41needless to say, everyone was fully in
- 52:44the holiday spirit. John Benet was
- 52:46wrapping up gifts, baking cookies, and
- 52:49thinking about her wish list for Santa,
- 52:52which I'm going to tell you now, she
- 52:53wanted a bike. And spoiler alert, she
- 52:56was going to get that bike. Now, just a
- 52:58few days before Christmas, right on
- 53:00December 23rd, the Ramseies threw their
- 53:02own yearly Christmas party, and it's
- 53:05said to have 30 to 40 people there. This
- 53:08would consist of neighbors, friends, and
- 53:10family. John would even invite, you
- 53:12know, co-workers from access to attend.
- 53:16It was said that John Benet, she was
- 53:19dressed up to the nine for this occasion
- 53:21and that she was just this little human
- 53:24charming everybody. She said hello. She
- 53:28said thank you. She even sang carols.
- 53:30And
- 53:32at the same time, they said that she was
- 53:34really soaking up all this attention.
- 53:36She loved it. Now, I read that there was
- 53:37a Santa Claus impersonator there. How?
- 53:40How? Santa Claus.
- 53:44Santa Claus is not real from the last
- 53:45time I checked. So, this man was named
- 53:48Bill McRyns and he handed out gifts and
- 53:51of course sat the kids on his lap and
- 53:53listened to their wishes. These holiday
- 53:55festivities that the Ramsies would have
- 53:58would somewhat be a headache for
- 54:00investigators in the future because
- 54:02there was just so many people to account
- 54:04for, so many people in the house from
- 54:08just that time of the year, which would
- 54:12create so many unknowns leading up to
- 54:15the 26th. So now we move to Christmas
- 54:17Eve where the family would attend
- 54:19church, you know, where John Benet took
- 54:21part in a nativity pageant. uh they said
- 54:24and afterwards they would go to a
- 54:26friend's house for dinner. Uh presents
- 54:28were exchanged, kids ran wild, and John
- 54:31Benet was her usual bubbly self
- 54:34according to those who attended the
- 54:35party. Just more activities for
- 54:37investigators to dig into more
- 54:39characters, right? And now we get to
- 54:41Christmas morning and according to the
- 54:43Ramsies, it was just picture perfect.
- 54:46Okay, this beautiful family wakes up and
- 54:49they're all going to open their
- 54:50presents. It's the kind of thing that
- 54:52you'd see in a movie, right? So, John
- 54:55Benet wakes up early, tore into her
- 54:57present, and guess what? She got what
- 54:59she asked for. That Santa impersonator
- 55:02really came through. She got her bike.
- 55:04She even got jewelry and even more toys.
- 55:07And uh she would ride her bike outside
- 55:10the house. There was a back alley and
- 55:12the front. Neighbors would remember
- 55:14seeing her and Burke do this. And for
- 55:16the most part, the Ramsies enjoyed the
- 55:18day. And into the afternoon around 400
- 55:21p.m. they would go on over to the White
- 55:24House where they were having their
- 55:26annual Christmas dinner. That would be
- 55:28Fleet and Priscilla White. And it wasn't
- 55:31this giant party or anything like that.
- 55:33It was more of a get together of close
- 55:35friends, uh, more so. There were about
- 55:3910 to 12 people in total, and dinner was
- 55:42had about 6:30 p.m. Afterwards, everyone
- 55:46simply relaxed and chatted while the
- 55:48kids played. John Benet played with the
- 55:50White's daughter, Daphany, singing and
- 55:52dancing. I mean, even Burke was mingling
- 55:55with the kids, and the overall mood for
- 55:58everybody is considered joyful. So,
- 56:00around 9:00 p.m., it was said that a
- 56:03group of neighbors, uninvited, came by
- 56:06and started singing carols. Now, it's
- 56:08really like a movie that I've never
- 56:10experienced in real life. If someone
- 56:12came to my door today and started
- 56:14singing carols, I would probably be on
- 56:16the verge of calling the police. So, the
- 56:19unannounced neighbors started caroling.
- 56:21And it was about 9:30 p.m. At this
- 56:23point, everyone was still happy, but
- 56:26exhausted. All right. And according to
- 56:28the Ramsies, the kids were already half
- 56:30asleep before they even got to the car.
- 56:32And on the ride home, uh, Jean Benet had
- 56:36completely knocked out cold, fast asleep
- 56:39in the back seat. And once the car
- 56:41pulled up in the driveway, John scoops
- 56:44up Jean Banet and carries her upstairs
- 56:46to her bedroom, and everybody gets
- 56:48themselves ready for bed. Now, it's
- 56:50about 1000 p.m. Py goes up to the
- 56:54bedroom. According to John and Burke,
- 56:57Burke would actually go back downstairs
- 56:59to put something together. Okay.
- 57:01something that he really needed to get
- 57:02done. But once he finishes that, he goes
- 57:05back to his room and he goes to sleep.
- 57:07Now, for the very fact that John Benet
- 57:09did not have on the same clothes that
- 57:12she had on at the Christmas party, she
- 57:14was now fully dressed in sleepwear. We
- 57:17know that probably John helped her
- 57:19change into that that night when he
- 57:21brought her to the room. So, in general,
- 57:23the Ramsies are finally home and
- 57:25everyone's supposed to be tucked in for
- 57:28the night. Also, they needed to get as
- 57:31much sleep as possible because that
- 57:33morning at 700 a.m. the Ramsies had a
- 57:35private jet that was going to fly them
- 57:39to Michigan with John's other surviving
- 57:42kids, Melinda and John Andrew. They were
- 57:45going to go to Charavoy, Michigan, and
- 57:47because they had a summer home there,
- 57:49sort of a continuation of Christmas and
- 57:51festivities just amongst family. Of
- 57:54course, that would never happen because
- 57:56sometime between the White's Christmas
- 57:58party and that morning, Jean Banet was
- 58:02found murdered. Now, let's go through
- 58:05the facts, at least the facts that we
- 58:08know. So, Paty says that she was up
- 58:10before dawn. It was about 5:30 a.m. in
- 58:13the morning, and she began getting
- 58:15ready, you know, for this family trip.
- 58:18She walked down the spiral staircase and
- 58:20she noticed sheets of paper at the base
- 58:22of the stairs which turned out to be a
- 58:25ransom note that somebody had kidnapped
- 58:29John Benet. Paty would say that she only
- 58:33read a few lines to understand what was
- 58:36going on here and she immediately flew
- 58:38to John Benet's room and found her
- 58:41missing. At this point, she's starting
- 58:43to go into hysterics, right? And she
- 58:45calls out Jon's name. John comes over
- 58:48and he reads the letter. John, I'm not
- 58:50sure. I forgot. Did he check on Burke
- 58:54before he read the letter or after?
- 58:56Maybe it doesn't really matter. But once
- 58:58he got the idea of what this was, he
- 59:01told Paty to immediately call the
- 59:03police.
- 59:07>> 911 emergency.
- 59:09Police.
- 59:10>> What's going on street?
- 59:12>> What's going on there, ma'am?
- 59:13>> We are kidnapping. All right. Please
- 59:15explain to me what's going on. Okay.
- 59:17>> There we have a there's a note left and
- 59:20our daughter is gone.
- 59:21>> A note was left and your daughter is
- 59:23gone. How old is your daughter?
- 59:24>> 6 years old. She's gone. 6 years old.
- 59:30How long ago was it?
- 59:32>> I don't know. I took down her notes. My
- 59:34daughter.
- 59:35>> Does it say who took her?
- 59:37>> What?
- 59:37>> Does it say who took her?
- 59:39>> I don't know. There's a There's a ransom
- 59:41note here.
- 59:42>> It's a ransom note. It says airt
- 59:46victory,
- 59:48[Applause]
- 59:51please.
- 59:52>> Okay. What's your name? Are you going to
- 59:53ask me the lover?
- 59:55>> Oh my god. Please.
- 59:57>> I'm okay. I'm sending you an office
- 59:59over. Okay. Do you know how long she's
- 1:00:01been gone?
- 1:00:01>> No, I don't. Please. We just got out and
- 1:00:04she weren't here. Oh my god. Please.
- 1:00:07>> Okay. Somebody
- 1:00:08>> I am. Honey,
- 1:00:09>> please
- 1:00:10>> take a deep breath with me. Okay.
- 1:00:11>> Hurry. Hurry.
- 1:00:12>> Catch me. Kathy, Kathy, Kathy.
- 1:00:20>> There's been a kidnapping. She says
- 1:00:22there's a ransom note. She says that her
- 1:00:24daughter is gone. So, within minutes,
- 1:00:27Boulder police officers are at their
- 1:00:29door and one of them is named Rick
- 1:00:31French and the other is Carl Vic. Now,
- 1:00:34John Ramsey meets them at the door. He
- 1:00:36immediately shows them the ransom note
- 1:00:39and, you know, goes over the events, uh,
- 1:00:41what happened. The cops are looking
- 1:00:43around and they would do, I guess you
- 1:00:46could say, a cursory check of, you know,
- 1:00:49what they can get into, but they never
- 1:00:51get into the basement. This ransom note,
- 1:00:55they would notice off the bat, is by far
- 1:00:57not your average note. I mean, for one,
- 1:01:01it's absurdly long, two and a half
- 1:01:03pages. And there's this strange
- 1:01:06unnatural tone, you know, to this
- 1:01:08message. One that is just chalk full of
- 1:01:13stuff that sounds like it's straight out
- 1:01:15of a movie. And if it was even in a
- 1:01:16movie, it would be a B movie at that.
- 1:01:19Interestingly, the note demands an odd
- 1:01:22amount as the ransom of $118,000,
- 1:01:27which we'll get into later. It also says
- 1:01:30not to call the police or John Benet
- 1:01:33will be beheaded and signs off as SBTC
- 1:01:38victory. So, as I mentioned, the cops
- 1:01:40are doing, you know, a quick walk
- 1:01:41through and they notice that there's no
- 1:01:43signs of a break-in, no forced entry.
- 1:01:46John tells them that he locked the door.
- 1:01:48From what he remembers, the doors were
- 1:01:50locked when he got home and he made sure
- 1:01:52they were locked when they all went to
- 1:01:54bed. Now there is a home security system
- 1:01:58and it's funny officers but we just
- 1:02:00never set that security system. We
- 1:02:02bought we bought it for no reason and
- 1:02:03that's just me being facitious. Anyways
- 1:02:05the the family would always forget to
- 1:02:07arm this system according to John and it
- 1:02:10just became a bad habit that I guess
- 1:02:12they never really fixed. Nobody heard a
- 1:02:14scream, a thud, anything. John says that
- 1:02:17his first instinct was to check on Burke
- 1:02:19and since he was still asleep, he just
- 1:02:22left him asleep. He chose not to wake up
- 1:02:24Burke. So by 6:10 a.m. more police
- 1:02:26arrived. One was detective Renimbach.
- 1:02:28Then there was a detective Linda Art and
- 1:02:31a detective Fred Patterson. It's been
- 1:02:33noted that Paty is already on the phone
- 1:02:36with uh friends and family alerting them
- 1:02:39to the situation. A couple of the
- 1:02:41families that she called were the
- 1:02:43Fernies and the Whites. And of course in
- 1:02:46a dire situation like this, they all
- 1:02:49show up. They're all trying to help, you
- 1:02:51know, trying to comfort, you know, just
- 1:02:53trying to do whatever they can. The
- 1:02:56problem is this house is like an open
- 1:02:58spigot at this point, okay? It's filling
- 1:03:00up with people, which in hindsight was a
- 1:03:04huge mistake because there's a missing
- 1:03:06child. This was a potential crime scene
- 1:03:08and none of the police thought to
- 1:03:11restrict it. They didn't stop people
- 1:03:13from moving around the house at will and
- 1:03:17let alone from entering the house in the
- 1:03:19first place. I mean, they're in the
- 1:03:21kitchen. They're in the living room.
- 1:03:23Some people were said to even be tidying
- 1:03:26up. They're tidying up potential
- 1:03:28evidence, wiping away fingerprints.
- 1:03:31According to Fleet White, at some point
- 1:03:33he was in the basement and he was
- 1:03:35searching and he notices that there is a
- 1:03:37broken window, which John later would
- 1:03:40explain that he was the one that broke
- 1:03:42it months ago when he forgot the keys to
- 1:03:44his house and he needed a way in, but it
- 1:03:48slipped his mind to ever fix that window
- 1:03:50and so it was just never replaced. Now,
- 1:03:53while Fleet is in the basement, he tries
- 1:03:55to check the wine celler, but he just
- 1:03:58wasn't able to find where the light
- 1:04:00switch was. So, he didn't go in there
- 1:04:02because it was just way too dark. He
- 1:04:04stops and he just doesn't see anything
- 1:04:07and goes back upstairs. And I'm sure he
- 1:04:10probably trembles now at the thought at
- 1:04:13how close he was to John Benet, to
- 1:04:16finding John Benet. Okay, so now it's
- 1:04:19around 7:00 a.m. Burke is finally
- 1:04:22awakened and he is promptly sent to the
- 1:04:25White's house for the day. Now, whose
- 1:04:27idea it was to send Burke away, I'm not
- 1:04:30too sure, but that's where he will be.
- 1:04:32And in the beginning of this case, it
- 1:04:35said that Burke didn't even know yet
- 1:04:37that his sister was murdered or at this
- 1:04:40point that his sister was even missing.
- 1:04:43So, back at the Ramsay's house, uh, a
- 1:04:46Reverend Hoverstock from the Ramsay's
- 1:04:49church comes over to comfort the family.
- 1:04:51So, as you can see, word is traveling
- 1:04:54fast, and now it's two hours since they
- 1:04:57found that ransom note, and since
- 1:04:59effectively John Benet has been missing.
- 1:05:02By 8:10 a.m., the detectives put a
- 1:05:05recording device on the Ramsay's phone
- 1:05:07per the ransom note that said that they
- 1:05:10would be calling them between 8 to 10
- 1:05:12a.m. So now the recording device was in
- 1:05:15place, you know, in case the kidnapper
- 1:05:17calls, the phone does ring a few times,
- 1:05:20but it's never the call that they were
- 1:05:21waiting for. And guess what? The
- 1:05:24deadline comes and goes. And something
- 1:05:27peculiar occurred to Detective Art.
- 1:05:3010:00 comes and goes and there's no
- 1:05:32acknowledgement within the house from
- 1:05:35anyone that the deadline imposed by the
- 1:05:38author of the ransom note has come and
- 1:05:40gone.
- 1:05:41>> Nobody said it's 10:00 and the
- 1:05:44kidnappers haven't called.
- 1:05:45>> Nobody said that.
- 1:05:47>> Was that something else you took note
- 1:05:48of?
- 1:05:49>> Absolutely.
- 1:05:50>> As if they weren't surprised that this
- 1:05:52call never came. So, the deadline comes
- 1:05:55and goes without a word from anyone. By
- 1:05:5810:35 a.m., most of the police and
- 1:06:01advocates have left for the day. Only
- 1:06:03Detective AR was there alone and uh
- 1:06:06she's overseeing the house all by
- 1:06:08herself now. And that's about 4 hours
- 1:06:11now into her shift. But the house is
- 1:06:13still filled with family and friends.
- 1:06:15And from Detective Art's perspective,
- 1:06:17she notes that Jon's emotions are all
- 1:06:20over the place. Sometimes he's calm,
- 1:06:22sometimes he's sobbing, and sometime
- 1:06:24he's just making small talk. And Paty,
- 1:06:27meanwhile, she's actually pretty
- 1:06:28consistent. Um, she was more stuck in a
- 1:06:32loop of grief.
- 1:06:34>> 10:01 p.m. Although the house had
- 1:06:36already been searched by patrolman
- 1:06:37before she arrived, Art says that in
- 1:06:39order to break the building tension, she
- 1:06:42asked John Ramsay and his friend Fleet
- 1:06:44White to search the house again, top to
- 1:06:46bottom, looking for anything out of
- 1:06:48place. which we would find out later
- 1:06:51that this actually goes against protocol
- 1:06:54that no parent should be searching for
- 1:06:57evidence in their own child's
- 1:06:59disappearance. And it makes a lot of
- 1:07:01sense, right? I mean, I'm pretty sure I
- 1:07:04don't have to explain why, especially
- 1:07:06since they were both completely
- 1:07:08unsupervised. So, after giving this
- 1:07:11order, the first thing that AR sees is
- 1:07:13Jon and Fleet head directly to the
- 1:07:16basement. She says she gave them
- 1:07:18specific instructions not to touch
- 1:07:20anything. She says John Ramsay headed
- 1:07:23straight to the basement. She heard
- 1:07:25Fleet White scream for an ambulance and
- 1:07:27then a chilling discovery.
- 1:07:29>> Now Fleet says that he was poking
- 1:07:31around, you know, a different part of
- 1:07:33the basement as uh John, he just made a
- 1:07:37direct beline to the wine celler. You
- 1:07:40know, the wine seller that Fleet didn't
- 1:07:41know where the light switch was. Well,
- 1:07:43John does. He flipped the switch and uh
- 1:07:46the next thing Fleet heard was an oh my
- 1:07:50god what Jon sees on the floor wrapped
- 1:07:54in a blanket lies Jean Benet. Her mouth
- 1:07:57is covered with a duct tape. Her wrists
- 1:07:59are bound above her head and there is a
- 1:08:02homemade gurat wrapped around her neck.
- 1:08:05She is cold and stiff to the touch. She
- 1:08:09definitely appears dead. According to
- 1:08:12John himself, he quickly picks up his
- 1:08:15daughter and starts up the stairs.
- 1:08:18>> And I see John Ramsay carrying Jean
- 1:08:21Banet up the last three steps from the
- 1:08:24basement. And um and my mind exploded
- 1:08:29and Jean Bonnet was clearly dead and
- 1:08:32she's been dead for a while. I ordered
- 1:08:34him to put Jean down. I knelt next to
- 1:08:38her and I leaned down to her face.
- 1:08:41and John leaned down opposite
- 1:08:45me and um
- 1:08:48his face was just inches from mine and
- 1:08:51we had
- 1:08:53a non-verbal exchange that I will never
- 1:08:57forget
- 1:08:59and he asked if she was dead and I said
- 1:09:02yes she's dead.
- 1:09:05Detective Art is a bit taken aback by
- 1:09:09this question because John Benet clearly
- 1:09:11is dead. She's stiff. Her arms are still
- 1:09:15stuck above her head in rigor mortise.
- 1:09:18Your child is dead. So she tells Jon,
- 1:09:21"Yes, she's dead." And this discovery,
- 1:09:25as sad as it was, was also again
- 1:09:29contaminating the crime scene even
- 1:09:31further. And that simply is why you
- 1:09:33don't let parents do the searching
- 1:09:35because for one, emotions take over and
- 1:09:38they do things like this, right?
- 1:09:39Completely destroying the crime scene,
- 1:09:41taking the tape off, embracing the body,
- 1:09:44and two, the off chance that it was the
- 1:09:48parents that killed the child, giving
- 1:09:50them more ways to stage things. And so
- 1:09:54again, the house begins to fill with
- 1:09:57officers as the investigation now went
- 1:09:59from a missing child's case to a
- 1:10:02homicide. The transition into a
- 1:10:05homicide, it it began in earnest, but
- 1:10:07you know, the damage in terms of
- 1:10:10preserving a crime scene, it was already
- 1:10:12done. No matter which way you look at
- 1:10:15the handling of this case and there are
- 1:10:17some people that will disagree and and
- 1:10:19felt that uh detective aren't you know
- 1:10:22under the circumstances did a fine job
- 1:10:24or whatn not I don't know I can't see it
- 1:10:27that way you know even under pressure I
- 1:10:29mean that's why you're a detective you
- 1:10:31know to be able to do these things under
- 1:10:34the most dire of circumstances you know
- 1:10:36to get to the facts to preserve the
- 1:10:38crime scene so I will just say in my
- 1:10:40opinion the ball wasn't just dropped. It
- 1:10:43was punctured and [ __ ] thrown over
- 1:10:45the fence. It was a [ __ ] mess. So,
- 1:10:48after the discovery of John Bane's body,
- 1:10:50Detective uh Linda Art and Fred
- 1:10:52Patterson, they would start to question
- 1:10:55the parents, right? Started to gather
- 1:10:57detailed statements from John and Paty.
- 1:10:59At this point, this interview was being
- 1:11:03had at the White's home and from police
- 1:11:06accounts, the parents were extremely
- 1:11:09distressed. Paty was described as
- 1:11:11sobbing uncontrollably and John as
- 1:11:14stunned as and withdrawn as he's known
- 1:11:18to be. Right. And Fred Patterson would
- 1:11:21have an interview with Burke at around
- 1:11:24200 p.m. And the interview was conducted
- 1:11:27outside of John and Paty's presence,
- 1:11:30which Patterson would later conclude
- 1:11:32that he really felt Burke had no idea
- 1:11:35what was going on. This particular
- 1:11:38assessment by Patterson was um in an
- 1:11:41effort to evaluate, you know, family
- 1:11:43members as potential witnesses or
- 1:11:44suspects. Though interpretations of the
- 1:11:47interview have varied uh over the years,
- 1:11:51not only amongst armchair detectives
- 1:11:54like I, but even with the experts, as
- 1:11:57more and more people learn about this
- 1:11:59case, learn the handling of this case,
- 1:12:02more criticism of the detectives was
- 1:12:04had. One was they didn't even separate
- 1:12:07the parents when they initially
- 1:12:08interviewed them to see if their stories
- 1:12:11matched up. Instead, that first day,
- 1:12:14that crucial first few hours, John and
- 1:12:18Paty, the couple, remained together when
- 1:12:21they were interviewed. Separate
- 1:12:23interviews were eventually done after
- 1:12:26the fact on the 27th and the 28th at the
- 1:12:29Boulder City Justice Center, although by
- 1:12:32then
- 1:12:33attorneys were already involved. And you
- 1:12:36know how that goes when a lawyer has the
- 1:12:38client's ear. And now I'm going to get
- 1:12:40into the autopsy and I'm going to try to
- 1:12:42do it in as much detail as I can. As
- 1:12:45much detail that I could fact check and
- 1:12:47present to you guys. And I will warn you
- 1:12:51right off the bat, okay? If you haven't
- 1:12:54deep dived into this case before, deep
- 1:12:56dove, I believe you will find the
- 1:12:58discoveries of this autopsy
- 1:13:01very surprising. Surprising in a very
- 1:13:05shocking, disturbing way. So the autopsy
- 1:13:07was done by Dr. John Meyer, you know,
- 1:13:10from the Boulder County Corner's office
- 1:13:13that same day on the 26th. So it
- 1:13:16confirmed that John Benet did die of
- 1:13:18asphyxiation caused by strangulation and
- 1:13:20it also revealed an eight and a half
- 1:13:24skull fracture from a blunt object to
- 1:13:27the right side of her skull. Now there
- 1:13:30was minimal blood present at this crime
- 1:13:33scene and to crack a child's skull like
- 1:13:37that you would assume that there would
- 1:13:39just be blood gushing everywhere but
- 1:13:41that didn't happen. This 8- in gash bled
- 1:13:45internally. There were other injuries as
- 1:13:48well suggesting you know a violent
- 1:13:50struggle like John Benet really fought
- 1:13:53this person off. The time of death was
- 1:13:55placed sometime between late Christmas
- 1:13:58night and early that next morning. The
- 1:14:01ligature furrows you know around the
- 1:14:04neck made by the cord was consistent
- 1:14:06with strangulation by that gro that was
- 1:14:09found still wrapped around her throat.
- 1:14:11Now deep liature on her wrists as well
- 1:14:14from being bound. They would find
- 1:14:15petikio hemorrhaging on the face and
- 1:14:17neck which is common you know in
- 1:14:19strangulations. They would also find
- 1:14:21abrasion and small contusions on various
- 1:14:23parts of her body including her cheek,
- 1:14:27her lower back and her legs. And now
- 1:14:32the disturbing things that were brought
- 1:14:34to light by this autopsy. The
- 1:14:37pathologist
- 1:14:39uncovered what is called vaginal trauma.
- 1:14:43So the report describes chronic and
- 1:14:46acute inflammation of the vaginal
- 1:14:48mucosa. Now I looked this up for all of
- 1:14:51us and in plain English it means that
- 1:14:53there is evidence of irritation or
- 1:14:56injury that had been there for quite
- 1:14:58some time. If they had to guess it would
- 1:15:01be weeks or longer now. redness,
- 1:15:05swelling, and healing tissues suggests
- 1:15:09to the pathologist that the area had
- 1:15:12been hurt or bothered before. Now, with
- 1:15:18the usage of the word acute, that just
- 1:15:21simply means that there was also fresh
- 1:15:25recent irritation or injury.
- 1:15:29And it alarmingly suggests
- 1:15:32that she may have gotten hurt in her
- 1:15:34private regions just before she died.
- 1:15:37That along with cellulose splinters
- 1:15:40simply meaning that they were fragments
- 1:15:43from plant or wood. And in this case, of
- 1:15:45course, the broken paintbrush that was
- 1:15:47used to make the gar. Well, these
- 1:15:49splinters, they were found in her
- 1:15:52vaginal area, suggesting that she had
- 1:15:55been violated with that gurote
- 1:15:59beforehand. To sum up what the
- 1:16:01pathologist found, you know, it was
- 1:16:04signs that John Benet had both old and
- 1:16:06new damage in that area, which raised
- 1:16:10serious concerns about the possibility
- 1:16:14of ongoing abuse, SA, not just a
- 1:16:18one-time injury. And even though this
- 1:16:21evidence was clearly present, okay, the
- 1:16:24report was still careful to say that
- 1:16:27while the findings was consistent
- 1:16:30with current or prior essay, they were
- 1:16:32not definitive proof. Why did this case
- 1:16:35have to go there, right? Like as a when
- 1:16:38this case was just surfaced to me, you
- 1:16:41know, it was a kidnapping gone wrong,
- 1:16:45you know, a murder. the dad did it, the
- 1:16:47mom did it, the the Burke did it,
- 1:16:49whatever. Right. But then it had to go
- 1:16:51into this realm. I just hate it when it
- 1:16:54goes into this realm. Uh especially
- 1:16:56concerning kids. A lot of the times I
- 1:16:59would not choose a case if I knew this
- 1:17:00was uh you know, but I was already deep
- 1:17:03into you know, researching it and this
- 1:17:06came up. But hey, they're saying that
- 1:17:08it's not definitive proof, but just the
- 1:17:11possibility. I would even say the
- 1:17:13likelihood just makes me die a little
- 1:17:17inside. And she's exactly as old as my
- 1:17:20son. Now,
- 1:17:22we still have to talk about two more
- 1:17:25significant finds. Okay, the first being
- 1:17:28that they found half digested pineapples
- 1:17:31in her stomach, in her intestines. And
- 1:17:34this clearly indicates that besides the
- 1:17:37crab or whatever else she ate at the
- 1:17:38White's house at that Christmas party,
- 1:17:41pineapples was the last thing she ate,
- 1:17:44most likely just before bed. Now, get
- 1:17:47this. They also found unknown DNA on
- 1:17:50John Benet's underwear and the same DNA
- 1:17:53on the waistband of her leggings of her
- 1:17:56long johns. It was also pointed out that
- 1:17:59it was peculiar that Jean Benet was
- 1:18:02wearing oversized underwear. Now, this
- 1:18:05would be explained by Paty in interviews
- 1:18:08in the future. In 1997, she said they
- 1:18:11were Bloomies and that was a
- 1:18:12Bloomingdale brand. Now, what made this
- 1:18:15underwear special was that it had the
- 1:18:17words Wednesday printed on it. That's
- 1:18:20because it came from a pack that had
- 1:18:23every single day of the week printed on
- 1:18:25it and Wednesday was when you wore this
- 1:18:27one, right? So, this was part of a set
- 1:18:30and this was actually supposed to be a
- 1:18:32gift for John Benet's cousin, an older
- 1:18:35cousin cuz John Benet is size 6 to 8.
- 1:18:38This underwear was size 12 to 14.
- 1:18:41Clearly very oversized for a little girl
- 1:18:44like Jean Benet. But when she saw the
- 1:18:47underwear with the prints of the date or
- 1:18:50the name of the day, Paty said that John
- 1:18:53Benet just really liked them and she
- 1:18:55wanted them. And so Paty said, "Okay,
- 1:18:57here I mean try to wear it." And uh from
- 1:19:01that day, John Benet did. She wore that
- 1:19:03underwear and Paty wound up getting
- 1:19:05another set for Jenny. That was her
- 1:19:08cousin's name. Okay, so now we need to
- 1:19:10talk about the gurat. the grot or the
- 1:19:12gurat anyways that was used to strangle
- 1:19:15Jean Banet in short the gro was it's
- 1:19:18pretty much a simple tool right it has a
- 1:19:20handle and it's tied together with a
- 1:19:23cord or a wire and its main usage is to
- 1:19:26strangle someone now in this case it was
- 1:19:29a makeshift one assembled with a white
- 1:19:31cord and with the handles that were made
- 1:19:33from a broken paintbrush from Paty
- 1:19:36Ramsay's art set that was also
- 1:19:37discovered in the basement said that the
- 1:19:40brush was broken into three pieces, but
- 1:19:42the third piece was never found. The
- 1:19:45very nature of the Grot and how it was
- 1:19:48made pretty much confirmed that the
- 1:19:50killer seemed to be keen on using items
- 1:19:52that he could find in the home already.
- 1:19:54Now, John Bernay's mouth was duct taped.
- 1:19:57And that's another can of worms for
- 1:19:59detectives because from that duct tape
- 1:20:03which John took off her, remember,
- 1:20:05police found fibers that matched Patsy's
- 1:20:07apparel, the things that she was wearing
- 1:20:10that night to the White's Christmas
- 1:20:11party. And she she never changed. When
- 1:20:15she woke up, she still had on the same
- 1:20:17exact apparel. The fibers from those
- 1:20:19apparel, like her turtleneck, her
- 1:20:21jacket, her pants, were on the sticky
- 1:20:25side of that duct tape. Tess showed that
- 1:20:28it came from these articles of clothing
- 1:20:31that she wore, not something random. And
- 1:20:34get ready for this. The duct tape itself
- 1:20:37because of its condition, you know,
- 1:20:39there was minimal saliva on it, no
- 1:20:42damage from struggle. It simply supports
- 1:20:45the notion that it was applied on John
- 1:20:48Benet's mouth when she was already dead.
- 1:20:51And so over the next few days, the
- 1:20:53national media descended on Boulder and
- 1:20:55the Ramsies became the focus of endless
- 1:20:57rumors and speculation. And once John
- 1:21:00Bernay's body was released, the Rams
- 1:21:02buried her on December 31st in Georgia
- 1:21:05next to her halfsister Elizabeth. The
- 1:21:08police, for their part, now had to
- 1:21:10struggle with a botched crime scene,
- 1:21:14contaminated evidence, and a wealthy
- 1:21:16family that on their lawyer's advice now
- 1:21:20clammed up and hired a PR team. The
- 1:21:23investigation dragged on for years and
- 1:21:26with every theory from the random
- 1:21:28intruder to a family member, it was
- 1:21:31picked apart on TV and on true crime
- 1:21:34books and
- 1:21:36YouTube videos. Now, the DNA that was
- 1:21:39found on John Benet, it was never
- 1:21:40matched to anyone, not anyone in the
- 1:21:43family or anyone else. So, the case
- 1:21:46remains unsolved nearly three decades
- 1:21:50later. And I do want to talk more about
- 1:21:52that DNA. Hey, we all want to know what
- 1:21:55today's technological advances can do,
- 1:21:58you know, for this case. So, to
- 1:22:01reiterate, it was found on John Benet's
- 1:22:03underwear and on the waistband of her
- 1:22:05leggings. It was identified as being
- 1:22:08male DNA, but it did not match any of
- 1:22:11the Ramsay's family members or anyone
- 1:22:13close to the family uh that they tested
- 1:22:16at least as far as DNA technology
- 1:22:19improving in the early 2000s. Uh it was
- 1:22:22entered into Cotus, but there never was
- 1:22:25any match from that. Now we're going to
- 1:22:27move into today, you know, as we have
- 1:22:30things like genetic genealogy, which is
- 1:22:34a major breakthrough in this science.
- 1:22:37It's a it's a major technology. I mean,
- 1:22:39just ask the Golden State Killer how
- 1:22:42major it was in catching him, right? But
- 1:22:45even that has proven fruitless in the
- 1:22:48case of John Benet. You know, as time
- 1:22:51goes by with no results, people are
- 1:22:54starting to believe that the blood is
- 1:22:55simply a red herring, you know, to throw
- 1:22:58detectives off the scent. And if it was,
- 1:23:03it worked, right? So, now I get to share
- 1:23:06the troubling scenario that I just can't
- 1:23:08get out of my mind. And these are just
- 1:23:10my opinions, okay? There's no
- 1:23:12accusations here. Let's just take this
- 1:23:14as an exercise of my armchair detective.
- 1:23:18Okay? So, I'm going to start off with uh
- 1:23:22something very petty. Okay. So, I've
- 1:23:25always had this notion that when parents
- 1:23:28name their children, I apologize to any
- 1:23:31parents that do this. Okay? I don't mean
- 1:23:32this in some type of strange blanket
- 1:23:34statement, but I've always had this
- 1:23:36notion that when parents name their kids
- 1:23:39after themselves, it shows a bit of
- 1:23:42narcissism, right? you know, the fact
- 1:23:46that, hey, I made this child, so I'm
- 1:23:49going to name him after me. I'm saying
- 1:23:51this because when I read John Bennett
- 1:23:54Ramsay's name for the first time, his
- 1:23:56full name, that's when it occurred to me
- 1:23:59that he named his daughter after
- 1:24:01himself. He genderbended his name just
- 1:24:05so that it could fit his daughter. And I
- 1:24:08guess I raised a judging eyebrow, but I
- 1:24:12do think I'm on to something. Okay, so
- 1:24:15allow me to continue
- 1:24:18because I did another case where the
- 1:24:20mother's name of the missing child was
- 1:24:23Dana and she named her son Dwan and she
- 1:24:27turned out to be somewhat of a piece of
- 1:24:29[ __ ] violent woman and her son was
- 1:24:31never found. So no accusations there as
- 1:24:35well. Now back to John. You know, at a
- 1:24:37certain point, I wondered why he didn't
- 1:24:39name Burke John. And of course, I would
- 1:24:42go on to find out that he already did
- 1:24:44that with his first son from his first
- 1:24:46marriage named John Andrew. So, he
- 1:24:49couldn't do that again, I guess. So, now
- 1:24:51we know that he named two kids after
- 1:24:54himself. You know, it's like John just
- 1:24:58felt there just wasn't enough of himself
- 1:25:01in this world. So clearly, okay, I am
- 1:25:04leaning towards
- 1:25:07John being a narcissist. So the textbook
- 1:25:10definition of a narcissist according to
- 1:25:13Google anyways is having this overly
- 1:25:16inflated self-importance. Okay, an
- 1:25:19excessive need for attention and
- 1:25:21admiration as well. And one of the key
- 1:25:24traits that I will say is the lack of
- 1:25:26empathy for others. They often display
- 1:25:29what is called as grandiosity.
- 1:25:32They have entitlement and they're
- 1:25:34preoccupied with fantasies of success.
- 1:25:38Whatever success or power means to them,
- 1:25:40they're going to be completely absorbed
- 1:25:42into getting that. And also, you can
- 1:25:46never say a bad word about them because
- 1:25:48they will struggle with that criticism
- 1:25:51and
- 1:25:52lash out, you know, such as exploiting
- 1:25:55others to achieve said goal. And now I
- 1:25:59will talk about John in accordance to
- 1:26:02this theory of mines that he is a
- 1:26:04narcissist. Okay. In his life we also
- 1:26:06know that he did have immense power you
- 1:26:09know at the time of John Benet's murder
- 1:26:11because he was the CEO of Access
- 1:26:14Graphics which is a billion-doll
- 1:26:17company. Now, I will mention that I
- 1:26:20heard once upon a time that CEOs of big
- 1:26:23companies
- 1:26:25usually tend to show signs of being a
- 1:26:28narcissist. Now, I wouldn't go as far as
- 1:26:30to make, you know, that giant brush that
- 1:26:34they all are, but I think some of the
- 1:26:36qualities of a narcissist is what, you
- 1:26:39know, let's just say, helps a CEO
- 1:26:43get a $118,000 bonus. I mean, we're
- 1:26:46talking about confidence, leadership,
- 1:26:48and the ability to yell the [ __ ] out of
- 1:26:51somebody without a shred of guilt.
- 1:26:55Sounds like something that'll get the
- 1:26:58job done in these high stakes
- 1:27:00corporations or whatever. Now, I'm being
- 1:27:02pretty transparent and I'm sure by now
- 1:27:04that you're seeing the path that I'm
- 1:27:06choosing. And be forewarned that going
- 1:27:11forward, it's going to be a dark path
- 1:27:15that I've drawn up here, but
- 1:27:19unfortunately, it's the only one that I
- 1:27:21see right now that makes any sense. And
- 1:27:24like in the beginning of the video,
- 1:27:27you know, I said in the Maline Macccan
- 1:27:30case, I had my theory. A lot of you guys
- 1:27:34didn't like it. But that is a theory
- 1:27:36that flipped so many times. And even
- 1:27:39today, I think if you present me with
- 1:27:41another bit of evidence or theory, I can
- 1:27:45still flip again. But man, this one,
- 1:27:49this one I can't help but believe
- 1:27:52is the right one for this case. It all
- 1:27:54stems from the fact that I just cannot
- 1:27:58ignore John Benet's autopsy report about
- 1:28:02the trauma to her, you know, private
- 1:28:05regions. And
- 1:28:07I don't begin my story at the birth of
- 1:28:09John Benet.
- 1:28:11My mind has taken me all the way to the
- 1:28:13birth of Burke. I mean, I could take it
- 1:28:15further, but I'm going to just begin at
- 1:28:18the birth of Burke. In my opinion, the
- 1:28:21abuse begins with him. You know, I think
- 1:28:24John Ramsay is a man that likes power,
- 1:28:28is addicted to power, right? Dominance
- 1:28:30over those he feels should be under his
- 1:28:33thumb because, hey, he is the Michael
- 1:28:35Dell of his era. right now. From the
- 1:28:37countless interviews that I had to sit
- 1:28:39through of watching John, he is pretty
- 1:28:42convincing because I think everyone's
- 1:28:45come to the conclusion that that's just
- 1:28:48his baseline, you know, of his
- 1:28:49personality that he comes off as such a
- 1:28:52timid, quiet man, you know, with Paty
- 1:28:56usually, you know, the focal point for
- 1:28:58all these interviews because she has
- 1:29:00things to say, she has real emotions,
- 1:29:03you know, and so she was actually in the
- 1:29:05forefront of most of the suspicions
- 1:29:07early on in this case and I believe
- 1:29:10everything concerning John Ramsay
- 1:29:14knowing how he is now the more that I
- 1:29:17think about him everything is by design
- 1:29:22with this man he is very clever a
- 1:29:25brilliant man you could say and those
- 1:29:28videos of Burke when he was just nine
- 1:29:30okay this is why I go back to when Burke
- 1:29:34was born before Jean I should say. Okay.
- 1:29:37Because Burke right after his sister's
- 1:29:39death, he is odd, right? His the way he
- 1:29:43behaves is a little bit odd to the rest
- 1:29:46of us looking. That's not a normal
- 1:29:489-year-old.
- 1:29:49We feel, right? That child to me is
- 1:29:54disconnected. And I will say this,
- 1:29:57wouldn't we all learn to be
- 1:29:59disconnected, too? Here's where it gets
- 1:30:02dark. If if our father sometimes stood
- 1:30:06in our room at night
- 1:30:09when he just shouldn't be there. I'll
- 1:30:12put it that way. Okay. Now, if you have
- 1:30:16watched, you know, Burke's interview
- 1:30:18with, you know, Dr. Phil, he is an adult
- 1:30:22at this point, right? But he still is a
- 1:30:24very peculiar character. You know, he's
- 1:30:27smiling at the wrong times, laughing
- 1:30:29when it would be more appropriate not
- 1:30:32to. But Dr. Phil explained it away to
- 1:30:35his audience that Burke was nervous, you
- 1:30:37know, that was his tick, right? That he
- 1:30:39would smile and laugh, you know, at all
- 1:30:40the wrong times because he just he's
- 1:30:43just anxious. Please, I would never say
- 1:30:46that I'm smarter than Dr. Phil, but we
- 1:30:49are both unacredited psychologists.
- 1:30:52And of course, that's a stupid hacky
- 1:30:54joke. And I will say that he was once a
- 1:30:58real accredited psychologist that I
- 1:31:00never was. But that doesn't change the
- 1:31:02fact that I believe that Burke acts
- 1:31:06strange not because he's nervous, but
- 1:31:09because he something happened to him
- 1:31:12when he was younger that disconnected
- 1:31:14him from being normal. Rewinding back,
- 1:31:17okay, to 9-year-old Burke, you This is
- 1:31:19where the adage of hurt people hurt
- 1:31:23people. You know, it applies to this
- 1:31:25theory here and it adds to my already
- 1:31:28sad assumption that SA is a learned
- 1:31:34behavior. Especially when stats show
- 1:31:38that when you SA a young male, he is
- 1:31:42more likely than a female that has been
- 1:31:45SAD, the male counterpart is more likely
- 1:31:49to commit SA himself. So, I'd say that
- 1:31:53Burke's a hurt person that hurt his
- 1:31:57sister like how his father hurt him.
- 1:32:00Now, tell me if you think this is normal
- 1:32:03behavior for a child. Okay.
- 1:32:05Burke used to smear feces on John
- 1:32:08Benet's stuff. Now, a lot of people have
- 1:32:11taken that for being jealous of John
- 1:32:14Benet, that he did not get along with
- 1:32:16John Benet because there are a lot of
- 1:32:17people out there that believe that Burke
- 1:32:20is the one that murdered John Benet and
- 1:32:22her parents covered it up. Now, you
- 1:32:24know, I am not subscribed to that. I
- 1:32:27think Burke
- 1:32:30is just acting out because he's gone
- 1:32:33through some things that are quite
- 1:32:35confusing and his
- 1:32:38perception of right and wrong has been a
- 1:32:40bit skewed. And so he would smear his
- 1:32:43[ __ ] on John Benet's toys and stuff like
- 1:32:46that. And why we know this is from the
- 1:32:50housekeeper who reported this. Okay,
- 1:32:52this is not from the Ramsies themselves,
- 1:32:54but she said that once she was cleaning
- 1:32:56up John Bernay's bed and she straight up
- 1:32:59found a ball of poop under her sheets
- 1:33:03and she knows that Burke did it simply
- 1:33:06because of that past behavior. Now, this
- 1:33:10housekeeper, her name is Linda Hoffman
- 1:33:13Pew, and she was definitely their
- 1:33:16housekeeper for quite some time. I think
- 1:33:18I'm gonna leave the Burke situation at
- 1:33:22that, okay? Because whether it does or
- 1:33:25doesn't add to my theory,
- 1:33:29it's something that has been in my head
- 1:33:31and I'm just going to let you guys know.
- 1:33:33If you ask me if Burke was the one that
- 1:33:36killed John Benet, I will tell you
- 1:33:38outright, I don't think so. I mean, did
- 1:33:41you see the way that Groat was tied? I
- 1:33:45would say that that's not even something
- 1:33:46a regular adult can tie. You know, a
- 1:33:48complicated knot like that, I assume
- 1:33:50there has to be some rhyme or reason to
- 1:33:52the way those are being threaded. So,
- 1:33:55you know what? If I had to take a guess,
- 1:33:58I would guess it could be, you know, an
- 1:34:00ex-naval man could make a knot like
- 1:34:02that. I'm just preparing myself because
- 1:34:05my theory is dark, right? So
- 1:34:10eventually
- 1:34:11a father is standing in his young
- 1:34:15daughter's bedroom
- 1:34:17at night when he shouldn't be.
- 1:34:22Why would we ever ignore what the
- 1:34:25pathologist said about John Benet's
- 1:34:28vaginal trauma? Something was going on
- 1:34:31for that to happen. Now, is it possible
- 1:34:34that John Benet did that to herself? The
- 1:34:38answer is yes, of course, right? But
- 1:34:40six-year-olds are usually adverse to
- 1:34:42anything painful, right? And you know,
- 1:34:45these injuries
- 1:34:47are also something I think Paty knows
- 1:34:51about because I think John Benet is
- 1:34:52going to complain about the pain, the
- 1:34:54itching, the irritation, right? The
- 1:34:57discomfort basically. So, I think Paty
- 1:35:00knew that something was happening in
- 1:35:02those nether regions,
- 1:35:06but she kind of
- 1:35:09didn't want to make a big deal out of
- 1:35:13it. Something that maybe she felt she
- 1:35:16should be ignorant of and not pry any
- 1:35:21further into, you know, chalk it off to
- 1:35:24just John Benet injuring herself some
- 1:35:26way. Maybe it was her bike. But we also
- 1:35:28have to remember she's the wife of a
- 1:35:32very wealthy, powerful man and the
- 1:35:35mother of two young kids. Her whole
- 1:35:39family and identity will be destroyed if
- 1:35:43this was anything more than a mishap,
- 1:35:47let's say, right?
- 1:35:49A lot of things could be normalized when
- 1:35:51they happen early in a child's life,
- 1:35:54right? to John Benet. I mean, this was
- 1:35:57her father, you know, this was daddy.
- 1:36:00Daddy wouldn't do anything wrong to me,
- 1:36:04right? He's her protector. The last
- 1:36:07thing he should be doing is hurt her
- 1:36:10until he finally did. So,
- 1:36:14what could have triggered him the night
- 1:36:16of December 26, 1996? Right? Why would a
- 1:36:19father kill his own daughter? to try to
- 1:36:22get the answer to this, then we'd have
- 1:36:25to understand what lengths a narcissist
- 1:36:29would go to protect himself. Okay. Now,
- 1:36:34like we've discussed before, some of the
- 1:36:36core traits of a narcissist are
- 1:36:38grandiosity, right? The need for
- 1:36:40admiration, and of course, the
- 1:36:42everpresent lack of empathy. The
- 1:36:46narcissist cares about the purpose that
- 1:36:48you serve him rather than you yourself.
- 1:36:52Okay? The purpose of John Benet was to
- 1:36:55satisfy something dark within himself.
- 1:37:00But John Benet was not like Burke. Okay?
- 1:37:06She did not disconnect to please her
- 1:37:08father. She was turning out to be
- 1:37:10headstrong and flashy like who? just
- 1:37:14like her mother, Paty. And by six,
- 1:37:18she's starting to realize that what dad
- 1:37:21was doing was wrong. Now, John could
- 1:37:24probably sense it, right? Maybe it was
- 1:37:27just his own fears eating away at him,
- 1:37:29right? Like the beating heart underneath
- 1:37:31the floorboards.
- 1:37:33Maybe it was the harsh reality when John
- 1:37:36Benet actually told him no. one night
- 1:37:40and he knew from that point on that she
- 1:37:43knew what he was doing was wrong. So
- 1:37:47what would a narcissist be concerned
- 1:37:49about at this point? For John, he's
- 1:37:52going to be worried about his legacy,
- 1:37:54his empire, right? Everything he's built
- 1:37:57would crumble in an instant if John
- 1:38:00Benet were to just let their little
- 1:38:03secret slip to someone, the wrong
- 1:38:06person. the immediate
- 1:38:10backlash if one day she were to tell
- 1:38:13somebody. I think John got sucked into
- 1:38:15his own paranoia about his sins coming
- 1:38:17to light and there was only one way to
- 1:38:21rid himself of this burden and that was
- 1:38:23to pretty much snuff out that light. So
- 1:38:28on Christmas night 1996 after the whites
- 1:38:31party, Jon carries John Benet, you know,
- 1:38:35up to her bedroom and Paty and Burke,
- 1:38:36they head off to their respective
- 1:38:38bedrooms. Paty is so tired, okay, that
- 1:38:41she falls asleep in her clothes. And
- 1:38:44Burke, he would head back downstairs so
- 1:38:46that he could put some toy or some
- 1:38:48project together that he's been anxious
- 1:38:50to. So he's down in the first floor, you
- 1:38:54know, building this thing. And at the
- 1:38:56same time, Jon is upstairs with John
- 1:38:59Benet on the second floor helping her
- 1:39:01change into sleeping clothes, which
- 1:39:02included those oversized undies and the
- 1:39:05long johns. And as Jon is putting them
- 1:39:08on, he smears something on the waistband
- 1:39:12of the long johns and a little bit on
- 1:39:15her undies. So, John Benet is now lying
- 1:39:19in her bed ready to fall asleep again as
- 1:39:21her father is leaving. Okay. So John
- 1:39:24goes downstairs to the first floor and
- 1:39:26he's surprised to see that Burke is down
- 1:39:28there and he's building something. Now
- 1:39:30Burke of course doesn't really notice
- 1:39:32his father. Maybe he does, but he's
- 1:39:34absorbed. He he seems to be the kind of
- 1:39:37person that would just lose track of
- 1:39:39reality if he's absorbed into something,
- 1:39:41right? A bit autistic if you ask me. So
- 1:39:44I will say that Burke notices his father
- 1:39:47but you know continues on with his
- 1:39:49little project. And John at this point
- 1:39:53after the whites party, I mean, he's
- 1:39:54really had no time to change. So, he's
- 1:39:57still in what he was wearing at the
- 1:39:58whites party, including his mits. Okay,
- 1:40:02his gloves. Now, he will prepare what I
- 1:40:05can only assume as an Asian man, a very
- 1:40:08peculiar bowl of pineapples and milk.
- 1:40:11And he puts a spoon in there. Now, this
- 1:40:13happens to be Burke's favorite treat.
- 1:40:16Okay, a snack or something, right? So
- 1:40:19Burke sees this and he goes over to his
- 1:40:21dad, takes the bowl, and he has himself
- 1:40:24some pineapple as well, but the rest is
- 1:40:27not for him, right? It's for John Benet.
- 1:40:30And so Burke goes back to his project
- 1:40:33and John goes back upstairs to John
- 1:40:36Benet's room. Now, of course, Jon is
- 1:40:38going to find his little daughter
- 1:40:40asleep. So he wakes John Benet up which
- 1:40:44always fills her with a little bit of
- 1:40:47dread, right? But this time he only
- 1:40:50wanted her to have a piece of pineapple
- 1:40:53before bed. And John Benet eats some
- 1:40:56pineapple. Okay? Anything to get him to
- 1:41:00just leave and leave her alone. And
- 1:41:02thankfully after she eats it, he does.
- 1:41:05Now we will get to why this is happening
- 1:41:09right now. Okay. The significance of
- 1:41:12this innocuous seeming bowl of milk and
- 1:41:15pineapples, I feel it cannot be
- 1:41:17underestimated. Okay? Because here's
- 1:41:20why. Paty in subsequent interviews that
- 1:41:24I saw when asked about that bowl of
- 1:41:28pineapples has always claimed that she
- 1:41:31had no knowledge of where those
- 1:41:32pineapples came from. And for damn sure,
- 1:41:35she definitely did not feed them to Jean
- 1:41:39Benet. And now I want you to stop and
- 1:41:41think about
- 1:41:43her saying that. Okay?
- 1:41:46There is absolutely no need for her to
- 1:41:50lie about those pineapples
- 1:41:53at all. I mean, so what if a mother fed
- 1:41:56her daughter pineapples before bed? If
- 1:41:59Paty did it, she'd admit to it because
- 1:42:01there's no I mean, it tells me that Paty
- 1:42:06really had no clue about those
- 1:42:08pineapples. Now, if she played a part in
- 1:42:11this crime, she could have easily have
- 1:42:13just said, "Yeah, I fed my kid
- 1:42:15pineapples. So what?" Which leads me to
- 1:42:18believe that the bowl of pineapples,
- 1:42:22they were planted there. And I know for
- 1:42:24a lot of you guys who follow this case
- 1:42:26for years are already thinking, "But
- 1:42:28monks,
- 1:42:29Paty's fingerprints were all over that
- 1:42:32bowl." To that I say, go dust off some
- 1:42:36fingerprints on the bowls in your own
- 1:42:38house. I bet the fingerprints of the
- 1:42:40person that handles those bowls the most
- 1:42:43will be on them, washed or not. I also
- 1:42:47must remind you who you're dealing with
- 1:42:50here. John Ramsay. like I said is a very
- 1:42:54clever man. His demeanor, the way he
- 1:42:57speaks in interviews
- 1:42:59is very calculated. Seems like he
- 1:43:02doesn't waste breath. He doesn't waste
- 1:43:04words. And that should already tell you
- 1:43:06a lot about him.
- 1:43:09So, how easy was it for John to identify
- 1:43:13a bowl that Paty had handled at some
- 1:43:16point? one that John knew had her
- 1:43:19fingerprints all over it.
- 1:43:23How easy would it be for him to just
- 1:43:24take that bowl and put it aside?
- 1:43:27Very easily, right? Burke's fingerprints
- 1:43:30were on that bowl as well. But of
- 1:43:32course, that is no matter. This was all
- 1:43:34premeditated because the killer felt
- 1:43:37comfortable in the house to do things
- 1:43:40that
- 1:43:42obviously a real intruder would not. He
- 1:43:45would not spend 20 to 30 minutes writing
- 1:43:47a ransom note. He would bring that from
- 1:43:49home. He would not feed the child he is
- 1:43:51kidnapping a bowl of pineapples for
- 1:43:54what? And if the plan was to kill John
- 1:43:56Benet from the very start, he would have
- 1:43:58made that garage at his house and
- 1:44:01brought it. He would have brought
- 1:44:02everything if this was an actual plan.
- 1:44:05And now I'm going to ask you guys a very
- 1:44:08simple question and it might open your
- 1:44:10mind up to this. Okay.
- 1:44:14Did you ever find it curious
- 1:44:18that all roads lead to Paty? All the
- 1:44:23evidence pointed towards Paty. The
- 1:44:27ransom note was written on Paty's legal
- 1:44:29pad. The pen that was used was hers. The
- 1:44:32Groat was made from Patsy's paint
- 1:44:34brushes. And guess what fibers were
- 1:44:38found underneath the duct tape of John
- 1:44:40Bernay's mouth? They were from Paty's
- 1:44:42clothes that she wore that night to the
- 1:44:45whites party that she fell asleep in.
- 1:44:47And they would find more fibers on that
- 1:44:49garage as well. Now, think about the
- 1:44:52letter that demanded exactly $118,000.
- 1:44:56We all know now that that is John's
- 1:44:58bonus from February earlier that year.
- 1:45:02$118,000 and some change, but we get the
- 1:45:05picture here. No one's coming up with
- 1:45:07that arbitrary number as a ransom,
- 1:45:12especially to a millionaire. Why don't
- 1:45:14you ask for a million? Now, the only
- 1:45:16reason I could come up with that the
- 1:45:19person that wrote that note put that
- 1:45:21number in there was because he knew that
- 1:45:23detectives would eventually link that to
- 1:45:26the amount, you know, to this CEO of
- 1:45:29Access Graphics John Ramsey had received
- 1:45:33earlier that year and to whoever wrote
- 1:45:36this letters, well, this is my theory to
- 1:45:38John's credit, right? That number of
- 1:45:41course was just way too on the nose.
- 1:45:44John being the clever devil that he is,
- 1:45:48chose that number because who would be
- 1:45:50stupid enough to demand his own bonus
- 1:45:53amount, right? A red herring from Dear
- 1:45:57John. Now, detectives would think that
- 1:46:00it would have to be someone from inside
- 1:46:03the company, right, that knew about this
- 1:46:05bonus. There's not going to be many
- 1:46:07people that's privy to this knowledge,
- 1:46:09right?
- 1:46:10But who else would know about a big
- 1:46:14bonus like that?
- 1:46:17The spouse, of course. Right. So, from
- 1:46:22the start, John wanted all the arrows to
- 1:46:25point to Paty. And I would imagine
- 1:46:28because Paty has stage four cancer. In
- 1:46:32John's eyes, her life is over. Anyways,
- 1:46:37just another FYI.
- 1:46:39Paty claimed to have no idea about that
- 1:46:43bonus until all this came up, right? And
- 1:46:47since I choose to believe that Paty
- 1:46:49didn't know anything, some interviews,
- 1:46:50those were raw emotions in my eyes,
- 1:46:52okay? She couldn't have written that
- 1:46:54note because she would have never known
- 1:46:56$118,000.
- 1:46:58But it also reveals what a secretive man
- 1:47:01John was to keep that from his own wife
- 1:47:05and the actual relationship he had with
- 1:47:08her. Right? I would say it's not the one
- 1:47:12she thought she had with him, if that
- 1:47:14makes sense. And if the detectives
- 1:47:17didn't pin it on Paty, then that could
- 1:47:20only veer their attention to some
- 1:47:22jealous underling at his company. And I
- 1:47:25would dare to guess that the DNA found
- 1:47:27on John Benet's waistband and her undies
- 1:47:31was somebody that John had a real
- 1:47:34distaste for or just did not care about.
- 1:47:37And all he had to do was pretty much do
- 1:47:39what the cops do when they need
- 1:47:41someone's DNA, right? They just lay and
- 1:47:43wait. And if this man happens to spit
- 1:47:45somewhere, well, John will be Johnny on
- 1:47:47the spot and collect that. Smear a
- 1:47:49little bit on, you know, those items.
- 1:47:52Now, back to the timeline. Okay. So,
- 1:47:54after planting the bowl, John basically
- 1:47:57took his time to write this ransom
- 1:48:00letter with his off hand. And I do think
- 1:48:04a man as meticulous as John has
- 1:48:06carefully for some time now. And I'm
- 1:48:09thinking he's planned this out for 5
- 1:48:12months. And I'll tell you why I have
- 1:48:13that number of five months. Okay. So for
- 1:48:16some time he has analyzed his wife's
- 1:48:19handwriting and practiced certain habits
- 1:48:22of Patsy's handwriting and that night
- 1:48:25after eight pages of rough drafts he
- 1:48:28finally got the letter to look the way
- 1:48:30that he wanted and actually to now that
- 1:48:32I it doesn't even have to be that night
- 1:48:34he could have did this days ago even a
- 1:48:37month ago right whatevers right and
- 1:48:41finally it was good the ransom note was
- 1:48:43good it was good enough that Paty Ramsay
- 1:48:47was never ruled out as being the person
- 1:48:49to pen that letter. They just couldn't
- 1:48:52say that she didn't do it because when
- 1:48:56you compared that ransom note to Paty's
- 1:48:59prior writings, they shared similar
- 1:49:02traits. 200 similar traits according to
- 1:49:06the experts. Now, you would think that
- 1:49:08finding 200 similar traits in two
- 1:49:11different pieces of writing would lead
- 1:49:13the handwriting expert to believe that
- 1:49:15that is the person that wrote both
- 1:49:17notes, that they would be confident to
- 1:49:20say that it was Paty,
- 1:49:23but they never did. So, wouldn't it make
- 1:49:26more sense that they could never say she
- 1:49:29wrote it because it looked more like
- 1:49:33someone trying to mimic her writing. The
- 1:49:37ransom note was also planted to point to
- 1:49:41Paty. I also can't imagine an intruder
- 1:49:46with adrenaline, fear flowing through
- 1:49:49his veins. You know, I can't imagine him
- 1:49:53being able to sit down and write as
- 1:49:56nicely as that. It still looks a bit
- 1:49:57like chicken scratch, but that does not
- 1:49:59look like a person that is shaking at
- 1:50:02all. How do I subscribe to the fact that
- 1:50:05an intruder in a house, a house that he
- 1:50:08knows that everybody is home, sitting
- 1:50:11there with the chance of being caught at
- 1:50:14any moment, just sitting there and
- 1:50:18having this penmanship in that
- 1:50:21situation.
- 1:50:23But here it is, right? A nicely written,
- 1:50:26though bizarre letter. It's that way
- 1:50:30because it was written to be that way by
- 1:50:33someone who was not scared. Even if
- 1:50:36someone saw him there writing this
- 1:50:38letter, he was supposed to be there.
- 1:50:41There's just something calm and cold
- 1:50:44about John. He once talked about John
- 1:50:46Benet and it appeared that he broke down
- 1:50:50as he was talking only that it was just
- 1:50:53momentary and there didn't appear to be
- 1:50:56any tears. It almost appeared he tried
- 1:50:58to muster up the tears and when they did
- 1:51:01not come out he composed himself.
- 1:51:04>> When I open the the door there there are
- 1:51:06no windows in the b in that room and I
- 1:51:08turn the light on and I
- 1:51:14think
- 1:51:15>> it was her
- 1:51:18I hope that uh
- 1:51:22she was still okay but I could tell that
- 1:51:25she probably wasn't. whereas Paty fully
- 1:51:28broke down, tears and all, and you could
- 1:51:30feel the heartbreak, at least to me,
- 1:51:32right? Because so many people think it's
- 1:51:34possibly Paty as well. So, I'll just say
- 1:51:38at least to me. So,
- 1:51:40back to the back to the timeline. Okay,
- 1:51:43so once everything was in place, John
- 1:51:45walked into John Benet's room where he
- 1:51:47found her sleeping soundly. Of course,
- 1:51:50he picked her up and she probably
- 1:51:51thought, "Oh no, it's happening again."
- 1:51:55But John knew to reassure his little
- 1:51:57girl that it wasn't that. That he just
- 1:52:00wanted to show her something. I would
- 1:52:03think maybe a special Christmas gift
- 1:52:05that he was saving for last. And so he
- 1:52:09carries her down to the first floor. He
- 1:52:12grabs the mag light off the counter that
- 1:52:14is sitting in the kitchen and then he
- 1:52:16goes down to the basement. Eventually,
- 1:52:19John Benet finds herself in the wine
- 1:52:21celler and her dad puts her down. Now
- 1:52:24she's standing there when all of a
- 1:52:25sudden she is struck with the magnite
- 1:52:29which cracks her skull. Leaves an 8 and
- 1:52:311/2 in gash on the right side of her
- 1:52:34skull. But this doesn't knock her out.
- 1:52:37Okay. She let out a loud guttural scream
- 1:52:41that was immediately silenced when the
- 1:52:44tight cords of the garage cut off her
- 1:52:47air. Now, how do we know that a scream
- 1:52:50was heard coming from the Ramsay
- 1:52:52residence in the middle of the night?
- 1:52:55Because their neighbor an Stanton
- 1:52:58reported that she heard one. And that's
- 1:53:00why she described it like something of a
- 1:53:04child in distress, blood curdling, and
- 1:53:08terrifying. Now, at the same time, how
- 1:53:11is it possible that Paty and Burke
- 1:53:13didn't hear it? But Paty was on the
- 1:53:16third floor. If she heard something, it
- 1:53:18would have been faint at best, I would
- 1:53:20think. And Burke, he's a child. He
- 1:53:22doesn't pay attention very well. Even if
- 1:53:25it disturbed him, he wouldn't think much
- 1:53:27of it and would simply fall back asleep.
- 1:53:29Okay, so
- 1:53:31once John Benet is dead, John placed a
- 1:53:35blanket over her. And this is simply
- 1:53:39because this wasn't something that he
- 1:53:42wanted to do, right? It was something
- 1:53:44that he felt he had to do to save
- 1:53:48himself. So he placed a white blanket
- 1:53:50over her. Something that suggestes two
- 1:53:54criminal profilers that it was done by
- 1:53:56someone who had a personal connection
- 1:53:58with the victim. Burke is not going to
- 1:54:00do this. There's only one other person
- 1:54:02in this house that has that type of
- 1:54:05connection to John Benet. Another arrow
- 1:54:09pointing at Paty. And so after he puts
- 1:54:12the blanket on her body, her arms are
- 1:54:14still up in this position, by the way.
- 1:54:16And I assume Rigger Mortise would soon
- 1:54:19set in in the next couple of hours. But
- 1:54:22besides that, he finds a hard suitcase
- 1:54:24and he just pushes it up against the
- 1:54:26wall. This is for the detectives to
- 1:54:28believe that the killer, you know, went
- 1:54:30out the way he came in. That that same
- 1:54:32broken window that Jon had broken months
- 1:54:34ago was the escape route as well. So now
- 1:54:38we get to the window. Well, why was the
- 1:54:40window broken in the first place if
- 1:54:43there was never any intruder in this
- 1:54:46theory? Right? So, in John's own words
- 1:54:49to the police, he himself broke that
- 1:54:52window. Okay? And last summer is when he
- 1:54:54broke that window, which would be from
- 1:54:56that time about five months before John
- 1:55:00Benet's death. That's why I use five
- 1:55:02months before. This was premeditated
- 1:55:05months down the line. John would never
- 1:55:07leave anything to error, right? And five
- 1:55:10months ago, this was during a time when
- 1:55:12Paty and the kids were on vacation in
- 1:55:14Michigan and John was still there. He
- 1:55:16had work and he forgot his keys or
- 1:55:18something, right? And he had no way of
- 1:55:20getting in the house. And when Paty came
- 1:55:24back from that vacation, she
- 1:55:25corroborated this story that when she
- 1:55:28did come home, she helped the
- 1:55:29housekeeper clean up the glass shards,
- 1:55:31you know, from off the floor. But John
- 1:55:35meant to get this window fixed but just
- 1:55:38never got around to it. Which sounds
- 1:55:41very unlikely to me considering John was
- 1:55:44filthy rich. You know, fixing a broken
- 1:55:47window is is light work and he could
- 1:55:50have easily called himself or told
- 1:55:53someone else to call. You know, I mean,
- 1:55:56really,
- 1:55:57does this sound like the behavior of the
- 1:56:00CEO of a billion-dollar company, right?
- 1:56:04He he wanted to keep that window as is
- 1:56:08because a plot was already brewing in
- 1:56:12his head. He doesn't seem like a man
- 1:56:14that forgets his keys as well. He had to
- 1:56:16come up with this story just in case the
- 1:56:19police were to somehow gather evidence
- 1:56:22that he was the one to break this
- 1:56:24window. Right? So with this story, he'd
- 1:56:27be already in front of that potential
- 1:56:30evidence. Now, if one of his neighbors
- 1:56:33just simply saw him break that window,
- 1:56:35well then again, he would be in front of
- 1:56:37this story as well. And seriously,
- 1:56:42in this mansion, there's got to be so
- 1:56:44many windows. Okay. Of all the places to
- 1:56:48break the window of would be the one
- 1:56:51that's underneath a grate that he had to
- 1:56:53pull up, break the window, stick his
- 1:56:56hand in, open the lock, open it up, and
- 1:56:59then go into the basement.
- 1:57:02Why not just break a window? That is
- 1:57:04just more convenient. Okay, so if you
- 1:57:07don't want your neighbors to see, go
- 1:57:09break a back window, go break a side
- 1:57:11window, something. And if they do call
- 1:57:12the police, you broke into your own
- 1:57:15house.
- 1:57:17No one cares about that. Yeah, just tell
- 1:57:19the police what happened. Show them your
- 1:57:21ID. But you chose the window that is
- 1:57:23hard to climb through under a great that
- 1:57:25you had to remove. You see where I'm
- 1:57:27going with this? The story sounds bogus
- 1:57:31and the story is being told by John. And
- 1:57:35so now we have John Ramsay standing over
- 1:57:39John Benet's body, right? He grabs that
- 1:57:42mag light and he makes his way back
- 1:57:44upstairs. Now, at this point, Burke has
- 1:57:47already gone to bed. So, he takes that
- 1:57:48mag light to the kitchen and he washes
- 1:57:51it off. Washes off all the evidence, the
- 1:57:53DNA that could have been on there. Maybe
- 1:57:55they had specks of John Bernet's blood,
- 1:57:57whatever. But he cleans it up so well
- 1:58:00that when detectives find that mag light
- 1:58:03in the kitchen,
- 1:58:05there was just no fingerprints or any
- 1:58:08signs that anyone has ever touched this
- 1:58:10item ever because he had washed not only
- 1:58:14the evidence away, but he washed off
- 1:58:16everybody's fingerprints. A flashlight
- 1:58:18in the kitchen should at least have
- 1:58:20fingerprints. Do we agree on that? Even
- 1:58:23when they took out the batteries of the
- 1:58:25flashlight to inspect it, there was no
- 1:58:27fingerprints on the batteries as well.
- 1:58:29Now, maybe it's OEM, maybe a machine put
- 1:58:32it in and they just never used this
- 1:58:33flashlight. It might have been dead, but
- 1:58:34there should have been at least
- 1:58:35fingerprints on it. This should have
- 1:58:37been a red flag for sure for detectives.
- 1:58:40And I believe that it was. It's just
- 1:58:42what can they do about it, right? This
- 1:58:44heavy metallic flashlight had to have
- 1:58:47been something they looked into because
- 1:58:48it kind of fit perfectly that blunt
- 1:58:51object theory that broke the right side
- 1:58:53of John Benet's head. And this is not
- 1:58:55just coming from me. This is including a
- 1:58:58lot of professionals that believe that
- 1:59:00that magite would have been the perfect
- 1:59:03weapon to cause that particular injury.
- 1:59:06Now, let's touch on more about, you
- 1:59:09know, that ransom note. Okay, so the
- 1:59:11killer leaves this note at the foot of
- 1:59:14the spiral staircase.
- 1:59:16That I think is also very strange. This
- 1:59:19giant mansion of a house had several
- 1:59:22stairs in which Paty could have taken to
- 1:59:24get down to the first floor.
- 1:59:27Now, it's almost as if the killer knew
- 1:59:29that the stairs Paty prefers to use each
- 1:59:32morning were those spiral staircases.
- 1:59:35So, he left it at the base of the spiral
- 1:59:38staircase, ensuring that Paty be the
- 1:59:41first one to read this letter. And she
- 1:59:44did. Now, he needed her to be the first
- 1:59:46to find this letter because of how
- 1:59:47dramatic she is. You can see in her
- 1:59:49interviews, she is a very
- 1:59:54dramatic woman, right? She uses her
- 1:59:55eyes. She opens them big and talks
- 1:59:59almost like a damsel in a movie in a
- 2:00:01way, right? And a lot of people found
- 2:00:03that distasteful, I guess, or whatnot.
- 2:00:07But I think that's just how she was. And
- 2:00:09John needed her to be hysterical and he
- 2:00:12could not be the one because he's not a
- 2:00:14good actor to call the police. As you
- 2:00:18heard in the 911 call, he's never on the
- 2:00:22phone. it's all her because he knew that
- 2:00:24her emotions would be
- 2:00:28natural and of course he wants to put
- 2:00:30her in the front, you know, killer
- 2:00:32calling the police, right, for the
- 2:00:34things that she's committed or whatnot.
- 2:00:36So on this phone call, she's hysterical.
- 2:00:38And in subsequent interviews, Paty would
- 2:00:41explain that when she found the note,
- 2:00:43she didn't read the complete note. She
- 2:00:45just got that John Benet was missing and
- 2:00:48you know, SBTC victory or whatever. and
- 2:00:52she called out for John. And John, he
- 2:00:54came and read it. That's what she said.
- 2:00:56And it was John that told her to call
- 2:00:59the police, even though the ransom note
- 2:01:01said that they're going to behead John
- 2:01:04Benet if they bring the police into this
- 2:01:07at any point, but automatically call the
- 2:01:11police. And during this time, Burke was
- 2:01:14sound asleep. John said that he had
- 2:01:15checked on Burke, finding him asleep,
- 2:01:17and left him that way. Now, in the note,
- 2:01:21it says that this small foreign faction
- 2:01:24is going to behead their daughter if
- 2:01:26they call the police. So, what does Jon
- 2:01:27tell Paty to do? Immediately, without
- 2:01:30hesitation, he tells Py to call the
- 2:01:32police because in this theory, he knows
- 2:01:35there's no foreign faction. A small
- 2:01:37foreign faction at that. Who indicates
- 2:01:39themsself as a small foreign faction?
- 2:01:41You tell me that they're just a foreign
- 2:01:43fa faction. Do they even know the word
- 2:01:46faction? John had no fear of calling the
- 2:01:49police because he knew that John Benet
- 2:01:52was safe and sound and deceased in the
- 2:01:56wine celler. All he needs now is for
- 2:01:59someone to find her. Now, I will say if
- 2:02:02you're still in the Burke camp, okay, if
- 2:02:04you feel that you heard Burke in the
- 2:02:06background of that call, which I
- 2:02:08personally never heard or I really
- 2:02:10tried, I still can't. Maybe I need some
- 2:02:12more audio sampling. But if you're still
- 2:02:15in the camp that Burke did it, like he
- 2:02:16hit John Benet over the head with a
- 2:02:18flashlight,
- 2:02:20then who made the garat? Because there's
- 2:02:22no way a 9-year-old kid is tying that
- 2:02:24knot. Okay. And then you would jump to
- 2:02:28Well, Burke uh hurt Jean Banet
- 2:02:32cuz he did not kill her. Okay. that 8 in
- 2:02:358 and 1/2 in
- 2:02:37gash to her skull did not kill her
- 2:02:40because in the autopsy report she died
- 2:02:43from the esphyxiation. So, what you're
- 2:02:46trying to say is Burke hit her and
- 2:02:49instead of helping the six-year-old
- 2:02:51daughter that they love so much by
- 2:02:54taking her to the hospital, which
- 2:02:55probably would have saved her, they
- 2:02:58instead came up with a plan to save
- 2:03:02Burke by killing John Benet
- 2:03:07by taking a
- 2:03:10in the most brutal fashion because John
- 2:03:12Benet fought for her
- 2:03:15strangle your own six-year-old daughter.
- 2:03:17Let that sink in in your head. Both
- 2:03:19parents have to agree to this plan.
- 2:03:22How does it work? Did one parent only
- 2:03:25agree to this plan and the other is just
- 2:03:27in the dark? But these are not stupid
- 2:03:29people. They know that. Okay, so Burke
- 2:03:32is going to need a little bit of
- 2:03:33counseling, right? He's 9 years old.
- 2:03:35He's not lost yet. If he hit his sister
- 2:03:38with a mag flashlight, why go to the
- 2:03:41extremes
- 2:03:43of covering up for your son by killing
- 2:03:46your daughter? It makes no sense. I
- 2:03:48don't care. It makes no sense to me. And
- 2:03:50the thing with the duct tape on John
- 2:03:53Bane's mouth, because the duct tape was
- 2:03:54already off by the time John had brought
- 2:03:56John Bane's body up to the Christmas
- 2:03:59tree, where he set her down at the
- 2:04:00command of Detective Art, the duct tape
- 2:04:04was found to have fibers on it, didn't
- 2:04:05it? And the garage was found to have
- 2:04:07fibers all from Paty's clothing. Her
- 2:04:09turtleneck, her jacket, the pants she
- 2:04:12was wearing, whatever.
- 2:04:16That's staged, right? John just took a
- 2:04:19piece of duct tape and dabbed her
- 2:04:21clothes with it. How did it get to the
- 2:04:24underside of the duct tape when it was
- 2:04:26already taken off her mouth when Paty
- 2:04:29was embracing John Benet?
- 2:04:32Correct me if I'm wrong, but that duct
- 2:04:34tape was already off her mouth and not
- 2:04:37even near the vicinity. How am I
- 2:04:38supposed to believe that all this
- 2:04:41evidence that points to Paty was not
- 2:04:44planted? Remember, my theory has Paty
- 2:04:48just overly exhausted. She's coming off
- 2:04:51stage 4 cancer. There's got to be
- 2:04:52something like chemo or some type of
- 2:04:55drugs that she's taking that just,
- 2:04:57you know, she's using every last bit of
- 2:04:59her energy to attend this party and be
- 2:05:01jolly cuz that's the way she was. And
- 2:05:03when by the time she got home, her
- 2:05:05energy was at zero, right? She needed to
- 2:05:08recharge. She pretty much fainted on her
- 2:05:11bed, I would think. And John knew that.
- 2:05:14He could probably hear her snoring or
- 2:05:15whatnot. takes that duct tape and just
- 2:05:18dabs her clothes up a little bit.
- 2:05:21Because I will repeat, the pathologist
- 2:05:23says that the structure of that tape is
- 2:05:26not consistent
- 2:05:28of ever being on
- 2:05:30someone who was alive. Now, Paty wearing
- 2:05:33the same clothes that morning is a
- 2:05:36problem for a lot of people, but it
- 2:05:39seriously is not a problem for me. I
- 2:05:41think a lot of people forget that she
- 2:05:42had cancer at this time and the things
- 2:05:45that she was feeling, the way that she
- 2:05:46was feeling, the happy front that she
- 2:05:49was putting up for the people during the
- 2:05:51holiday seasons, that had to be
- 2:05:54extremely exhausting for a person with
- 2:05:57stage 4 cancer, there's no going back,
- 2:05:59right? This ovarian cancer, the
- 2:06:01treatments or whatnot, she would never
- 2:06:04be the same. All of this has left her in
- 2:06:05a more weakened state than before. And
- 2:06:08it would not surprise me that she had
- 2:06:11every intention of showering and going
- 2:06:13to bed, but once she got upstairs, you
- 2:06:15know, she plopped onto that cozy bed and
- 2:06:20just straight fell asleep. And you know
- 2:06:23how I know this can happen because I've
- 2:06:25done it myself. I like to think of
- 2:06:26myself as a person that has pretty high
- 2:06:30regard for hygiene and taking showers
- 2:06:32before bed or whatnot. But even when I
- 2:06:35was in my 20s, after long karaoke
- 2:06:37nights, when I got home, I just laid on
- 2:06:40the floor and I just knocked out. I
- 2:06:43didn't even know it. I woke up. I'm
- 2:06:44like, "What the fuck?" Now, about that
- 2:06:47DNA found on John Benet's underwear and
- 2:06:50waistband of her leggings. I have to
- 2:06:52say, how convenient to find DNA in those
- 2:06:56areas to indicate a possible SA
- 2:07:01predator, right? But the pathologist
- 2:07:04clearly states that no essay happened
- 2:07:07that night of the murder, but possibly
- 2:07:10just prior. Now, it appeared that she
- 2:07:14was violated with the garat as well,
- 2:07:17which was very disturbing to read
- 2:07:19because there was this thing called
- 2:07:20cellulose splinters. Okay. And that
- 2:07:24would be basically wood particles from
- 2:07:27that garage was found in her vaginal
- 2:07:30area. And again, I think John did it to
- 2:07:35make everyone scratch their heads a bit
- 2:07:37more, right? He's just that detail
- 2:07:40oriented enough to harvest and plant
- 2:07:43some random DNA he gathered. Now, if I
- 2:07:47needed to speculate further, that DNA is
- 2:07:50from somebody at his work at Axis
- 2:07:54Graphics that he particularly did not
- 2:07:56care for. That would conveniently, you
- 2:08:00know, tie into the conspiracy theory
- 2:08:03that it was someone in his company.
- 2:08:05Knowing his bonus, if Paty didn't go
- 2:08:08down for this, at least that idiot from
- 2:08:10Axis Graphics would, right? So he
- 2:08:13gathered some spit or cigarette butts or
- 2:08:16something he knew he could use, you
- 2:08:18know, in trace amounts as a red herring
- 2:08:21and
- 2:08:22it [ __ ] worked from all we know up to
- 2:08:26this point, right? People are being
- 2:08:27eliminated as suspects for not matching
- 2:08:30this DNA.
- 2:08:32He and Paty were never truly eliminated.
- 2:08:34But at least for some people, there was,
- 2:08:38you know, a crazy killer out there that
- 2:08:40doesn't know how ransoms work. Now, even
- 2:08:43today in 2025, John is a big proponent
- 2:08:46along with his son of getting DNA
- 2:08:48properly tested, right? championing the
- 2:08:52latest technology such as something
- 2:08:54called IGG, investigative,
- 2:08:57learn to speak, investigative
- 2:09:00genetic genealogy, because he knows the
- 2:09:02DNA sample that they have will lead to
- 2:09:05someone he could give two shits about.
- 2:09:08And that's just my theory. And I'll say,
- 2:09:12okay, I'm wrong about a lot of things.
- 2:09:15So, you're fine, John. You know, this is
- 2:09:17just a bit of fanfiction, if you will.
- 2:09:20And with that, now you know the story of
- 2:09:24John Bené Ramsay and what I think about
- 2:09:26the story. So, go ahead and go enjoy
- 2:09:29your family. Go protect the ones that
- 2:09:32you love. And don't forget to love the
- 2:09:35ones that protect you.
- 2:09:42[Music]
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of Why JonBenét Ramsey's Case Will Never Be Solved by MONKS Intrigue, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 20,317 words across 2,923 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.