Why it's ok to be lost | Shamil Chandaria โ Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:00Everything comes out of nothing and is
- 0:02made of nothing. It never ceases to be
- 0:04nothing. That is the great miracle.
- 0:07That's the great miracle that sets up
- 0:09the entire fantasmagoria we call
- 0:12existence. It is nothing convincingly
- 0:16pretending to be something while never
- 0:18ceasing to be nothing. Um that
- 0:21realization I had during a dinner with
- 0:25two friends in a noisy restaurant. Um,
- 0:28and I was only in my first glass of
- 0:32wine. So, it was not an abbriation. It
- 0:34just hit me like a 2x4 in my face. It
- 0:38just just came to me. It wasn't through
- 0:41meditation. Um, I was not taking
- 0:45psychedelics. It just just hit me out of
- 0:48left field for no reason. I cannot tell
- 0:51you any plausible causal chain that led
- 0:56to that. I was definitely not in an
- 0:58enlightened state of mind. It just like
- 1:02exploded in front of my eyes and and and
- 1:05then I could not help but see it. You
- 1:07know, you can't wish it away. Once you
- 1:09see it, you can't unsee it and stayed
- 1:13with me forever. Ever since then, it's
- 1:14been now some 10 years, maybe more.
- 1:18That's that's really beautiful that and
- 1:20and there are many
- 1:22and the way that
- 1:25some people talk about that is emptiness
- 1:28which is that you saw that everything
- 1:30was empty but
- 1:33in a in a in a deep sense this miracle
- 1:39that nothingness
- 1:42is pregnant with infinite potentiality
- 1:46And
- 1:48the real miracle is like how
- 1:53nothingness weaves itself into such a
- 1:55story that makes it
- 2:00>> seem substantial
- 2:01>> seem substantial. That is actually
- 2:04amazing.
- 2:05>> Yeah.
- 2:06>> Uh that is a real miracle that that that
- 2:08took about 13.6 billion years or
- 2:11whatever you know like
- 2:14>> it's actually fantastic and Um
- 2:19and that can give a sense of
- 2:23deep reverence, gratitude or
- 2:28just aesthetic
- 2:32uh uh uh uh you know appreciation of
- 2:35like wow the whole thing is this miracle
- 2:39of and and and how it's happening. The
- 2:42fact that you know when you go deep into
- 2:45meditation
- 2:48movement and stillness,
- 2:51movement being the sort of archetype of
- 2:53of of manifestation of of of creation of
- 2:56from something from nothing, stillness
- 2:58being being nothing.
- 3:02You see that
- 3:05that somehow
- 3:08they are made of the same. They're
- 3:10nothing but
- 3:12>> there's nothing there.
- 3:15Nothing ever happened.
- 3:18I'm probably too lumpen. My reaction to
- 3:21it was to have a laugh.
- 3:23Uh my reaction to it was to look around
- 3:26and then
- 3:28check the inside. So none of this is
- 3:31happening. None of this exists. And a
- 3:33very clear answer, of course not. And
- 3:36then I was like, come on, really? get
- 3:39out of here. And I start and and I
- 3:41started laughing. And I was with two
- 3:43friends who are a little further ahead
- 3:45in life than I am. And then they looked
- 3:48at me with a smile and said, "You were
- 3:50sort of catatonic and out of it for half
- 3:53an hour because I was I was just having
- 3:56a laugh. It's to me it wasn't deep. It
- 4:00was like a joke, like a cosmic joke. Uh
- 4:05um very a very funny one. Uh
- 4:09yeah, I don't know. I don't know. Maybe
- 4:10it's I'm [laughter] something's wrong
- 4:13with
- 4:13>> No, no. The cosmic joke is absolutely.
- 4:15So these are the these are these are
- 4:17what are called insights, okay? Or
- 4:19epiphanies or insights. And the cosmic
- 4:21joke
- 4:24is is is very deep
- 4:27is very deep in a sense that
- 4:33so I tune into the beauty often or the
- 4:36reverence and in you know this aesthetic
- 4:38but there is this you know another way
- 4:40to tune into it which is
- 4:43which is
- 4:46all the drama and the [laughter]
- 4:49>> you No, the the this is a game and I
- 4:52need to and the whole thing. What? What
- 4:55the hell?
- 4:56>> Nothing's happening.
- 4:57>> The whole thing is just a complete and
- 5:00utter like what? You know,
- 5:04>> you you do find space for humor there.
- 5:06Uh
- 5:07>> yeah, absolutely. No, and I and I too
- 5:11wrong.
- 5:11>> No, no, no. I' I've had that cosmic
- 5:13joke. It's like totally like just
- 5:15laughing. But you know that's because
- 5:19we're coming from relieving the tensions
- 5:23that were there and you're unwinding
- 5:25them. But when the tensions get unwound
- 5:28and you get used to it, then the beauty
- 5:30and the love and the kind of awe and
- 5:33reverence and and and majesty and like
- 5:36also wanting to play the game. Now you
- 5:38know it's a joke. I want to play this
- 5:40game of Monopoly. It really really
- 5:42matters. And now you know what? I'm
- 5:45going to come and play beautifully with
- 5:48my family and d you know as in and and
- 5:52actually put on the clothes the garbs of
- 5:56a actor and play it and be this
- 6:02you know amazing
- 6:04uh uh uh
- 6:07gift that's going on you know and so the
- 6:11the there are there are these
- 6:13interesting different lenses is because
- 6:15there's elephant in the blind. There's
- 6:17no
- 6:20these are ways of holding these these
- 6:24these deep things the ways of looking
- 6:25and different traditions have different
- 6:27ways. You know the Buddha some of the
- 6:29Buddhists can like oh you just be a body
- 6:31suffer and we we we we help to alleviate
- 6:35the suffering of others or we could
- 6:38become you know just Sufi or in
- 6:41reverence like look at this great
- 6:42beautiful thing and I want to connect or
- 6:45you can be Christian love or you can be
- 6:47very zen ordinary chopping wood and
- 6:51carrying water is just extraordinary you
- 6:54know there are these different ways of
- 6:56holding
- 6:57>> that's The thing I don't have, that's
- 6:58why I said I'm I'm not an authority at
- 7:00all in in in awakening and
- 7:02enlightenment. I get sucked right in
- 7:05again. Um, it's my natural state to get
- 7:08sucked right back into the game and
- 7:11completely lose the awareness that
- 7:13nothing's happening. I can evoke that
- 7:15awareness again at will. Like I I did it
- 7:18during this conversation. I went back to
- 7:20that mind space. Oh yeah, none of this
- 7:22is actually happening. None of this
- 7:24actually exists. This a cosmic joke. I
- 7:27can tiptoe there again. I can dip my big
- 7:29toe in that lake at will, but not for
- 7:33long.
- 7:34>> Yeah,
- 7:34>> I get sucked right back in. And and I
- 7:38got to a point where
- 7:41and it's a good point. This is not a
- 7:43complaint. I I I'm in complete peace
- 7:46with the fact that I'm that's what I can
- 7:49do. I can dip my toe occasionally and
- 7:52not more. And I'm not even trying
- 7:55anymore. I'm perfectly in peace with
- 7:57being right back into the game into the
- 7:59demonic play and taking it very
- 8:01seriously and suffering and and all this
- 8:04show. Uh I I found peace in not
- 8:10trying to change
- 8:12what I am and what capabilities I have
- 8:15or don't have. I have accepted my faith.
- 8:18Let let me put it this way. and and and
- 8:20that's a level of meta peace
- 8:22>> meaning I I I don't indulge in meta
- 8:24suffering anymore but I do I do suffer
- 8:28>> honestly that you've put it very very
- 8:31beautifully and by the way there are
- 8:35examples of people who have done this
- 8:38and you you know I almost have used this
- 8:41word meta
- 8:43meta piece or like okay with being lost
- 8:47>> yeah I'm fine
- 8:49[laughter] and and and and
- 8:52actually that is
- 8:55in the end I will say because I'm not
- 8:59see I don't believe in perfection. Uh I
- 9:02I think that all of us constantly get
- 9:06lost and find and lost and find and and
- 9:10in the end the real thing is exactly
- 9:13what you talk about that recognizing
- 9:15that even that cycle of of be lost and
- 9:19found is part of the cycle is part of
- 9:23like there is a meta awareness that that
- 9:25is going on that oh I was lost again
- 9:27look at that I got really caught up you
- 9:29know and and and knowing that and then
- 9:32other people say, "Yeah, okay." But like
- 9:36check out kind of having every day a
- 9:40period where we really allow the system
- 9:46to to to to really um see the day
- 9:50reification of everything
- 9:53and and soak in that for 20 minutes or
- 9:55half an hour, an hour. Um and then go
- 10:00about your day. And what you do is you
- 10:01bring a little bit of quality and then
- 10:03you get more and more lost. And then and
- 10:05then over time what happens is that you
- 10:09start to notice that certain things
- 10:14get you more lost like emotional
- 10:16patterns. And then there are mindfulness
- 10:20bells that go off. You start to program
- 10:22that every time this reaction happens,
- 10:25you look at the reaction
- 10:27and that sort of you get sort of sort of
- 10:30recognition. And then
- 10:33what happens is that like you slowly
- 10:36just through a kind of habituation
- 10:38sense, you slowly those triggers that
- 10:42tend to really wrap you into the story
- 10:46get loosened and so we float more easily
- 10:50through life. But you still play in
- 10:51life. This is I you know these are paths
- 10:54and these are anywhere you want to go
- 10:56and like I think this met you know what
- 10:58you what you have in meta
- 11:01piece is is absolutely beautiful. I just
- 11:06I tend to say, "Hey, check out this cool
- 11:09way of
- 11:11doing something called
- 11:14auto extinction therapy,
- 11:17which is the patterns that tend to be
- 11:19really sticky.
- 11:21You make them a little bit of an object
- 11:23throughout your day and then over time
- 11:25they get less sticky." And also go in
- 11:29the ocean or the river once a day.
- 11:33You can
- 11:35>> there's a um a meditation teacher that I
- 11:39admire from Tibet, Mingorache. Uh but
- 11:42there's a clip that just went on YouTube
- 11:44where he shares something that is
- 11:45normally kept a bit more private. Um as
- 11:49a traditional meditation instruction in
- 11:52Tibet, uh I think for beginners and
- 11:54advanced people, which is to meditate
- 11:56like an old cow peas. Uh because an old
- 12:00cow peas um very little many times a
- 12:03day. There's not like a long continuous
- 12:06stream. It's just a little comes out and
- 12:08nothing happens for a while then a
- 12:09little that comes out and so to meditate
- 12:12just a tiny bit throughout the day kind
- 12:14of. So that's something Bernardo if you
- 12:15wanted you could do if you said you can
- 12:18call it up at will for a split second
- 12:19that's actually the perfect this was an
- 12:21excerpt from one of the weekly Q&A with
- 12:23Bernardo Castra and you can find the
- 12:25whole video at with realityinmind.com
- 12:28you also get access to live Q&As with
- 12:31Bernardo every week uh which often
- 12:33include special guests like Michael
- 12:35Leaven, Rupert Spear, Kristoff Co, many
- 12:39other amazing scientists, philosophers,
- 12:41mystics, meditators, academics
- 12:44And it's also a chance as a closed group
- 12:46to hear Bernardo's more private
- 12:49intuitions and for us to share personal
- 12:52perspectives on the ramifications and
- 12:55implications of considering idealist
- 12:58philosophy in our personal lives. So
- 13:00again, you can find us at
- 13:01withrealityinmind.com
- 13:04and get access to live weekly meetings
- 13:07and a recorded archive of previous
- 13:09meetings.
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of Why it's ok to be lost | Shamil Chandaria by Bernardo Kastrup ๐ช๐บ, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 1,877 words across 286 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to translate the transcript into 100+ languages.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator โ no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, translation to 100+ languages, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.