Why Isn’t Heart Cancer a Thing? — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:00Most people know someone who’s faced a cancer diagnosis.
- 0:03Whether it's lung, skin, breast, or prostate, cancer is pretty common,
- 0:07with studies reporting an average lifetime risk around 40%.
- 0:11But ask yourself: Have you ever met anyone with heart cancer?
- 0:16Probably not, because that type of cancer is very rare.
- 0:20And it’s taken scientists years to finally figure out why.
- 0:28[♪INTRO]
- 0:28In theory, heart cancer can crop up in one of two ways.
- 0:32Either cells in the heart mutate and form primary cardiac tumors,
- 0:36or the heart gets hit with friendly fire from another organ that already
- 0:40has cancer, causing metastatic or secondary cancer in the heart.
- 0:43Primary cardiac cancer is rare enough to land it on the
- 0:46American Cancer Society’s rare cancer webpage.
- 0:49Studies estimate the incidence to be as low as
- 0:51around two in every one hundred thousand people.
- 0:54And this is surprisingly low, since the heart is an organ everyone has.
- 0:59And even if you end up being part of that statistic,
- 1:02there’s over a 75% chance the tumor is benign anyway.
- 1:06Metastatic heart cancer is more common than primary cardiac cancer,
- 1:10but only about 1% of cancers end up
- 1:13metastasizing to the heart and causing problems.
- 1:16Which is, again, unexpectedly low, since cancer cells
- 1:19from anywhere in the body can hop right into
- 1:22a blood vessel and make a beeline to the heart.
- 1:24And this is also not just a human heart quirk either.
- 1:27Dogs, cats, and many other mammals also
- 1:30enjoy a suspiciously low incidence of heart cancer.
- 1:34And this is why cancer doctors are right now
- 1:36trying to turn people into all heart.
- 1:39Just one big heart–
- 1:40they’re not doing that.
- 1:40All of this has caught the interest of scientists.
- 1:43Cancer not happening naturally is often a hint
- 1:46to how to make cancer not happen on purpose.
- 1:49Part of the answer is probably because
- 1:51heart cells rarely divide after you're born.
- 1:54Cancer is uncontrolled cell replication,
- 1:57but it’s kind of hard to get uncontrolled replication
- 2:00when you don’t have replication at all.
- 2:03So less cell division means lower chance of developing cancer.
- 2:06But thanks to a certain heart implant, scientists noticed that cell
- 2:10replication, and therefore the possibility of cancer, can ramp back up.
- 2:14A ventricular assist device or VAD is placed in a patient when the
- 2:19heart is too damaged and weak to pump blood on its own anymore.
- 2:23It pretty much steps in to do the heavy lifting.
- 2:25The thing is, some patients can eventually get their VAD removed.
- 2:30And the reason they can do that is because
- 2:32the damaged heart tissue healed meaning those cells divided.
- 2:36Having the VAD somehow triggered the cells to start replicating,
- 2:40allowing the heart to regenerate and pump on its own again.
- 2:44Animal studies found the same thing.
- 2:45After a heart attack, if the damaged heart got a little help, then cell
- 2:49division would restart, and stem cells would start multiplying.
- 2:52The only difference between a heart that can regenerate and one
- 2:55that can’t is whether it gets to phone in a friend to help with the work,
- 2:59so researchers hypothesized that there must be a relationship between
- 3:02the mechanical burden hearts are under and their ability to regenerate.
- 3:07For people with VADs, easing that burden is good, because
- 3:10it increases cell replication which translates to heart healing.
- 3:14But when you flip that around, it means maybe
- 3:16the day to day pumping stress of being a heart decreases
- 3:19cell proliferation and, by extension, the risk of cancer.
- 3:23If all stress worked that way, I’d never get cancer. Unfortunately…
- 3:30We’re going to learn how all of this works really soon,
- 3:32but first, a quick break.
- 3:34Happy Learn-a-thon!
- 3:36Learn-a-thon is a celebration of learning and the stuff
- 3:38we make at Scishow, Crash Course, and all of Complexly!
- 3:41We think these videos and all the great
- 3:43information in them should always be available
- 3:45for free for anyone who wants to watch them.
- 3:48And you can help keep that possible by
- 3:50participating in the third annual Complexly Learnathon!
- 3:53It’s happening right now until November 20th at
- 3:55COMPLEXLYLEARNATHON.COM.
- 3:57At that site, you’ll find the SciShow University
- 3:59hoodies that you’ve been asking for,
- 4:01livestreams taking you behind the scenes of our shows,
- 4:04games with our staff, and video premieres
- 4:06where you can live chat with the creators.
- 4:08It’s a celebration of curiosity and a fundraiser for our non-profit.
- 4:12Thank you for supporting us,
- 4:13because good information is worth it.
- 4:16To test that hypothesis, in a 2026 paper in the journal Science,
- 4:20researchers did some mouse studies.
- 4:22Fair warning, the one I’m about to talk about gets pretty gory,
- 4:25so if you’d prefer to skip it, jump to the time code on the screen.
- 4:28First, the researchers took mice and made them super
- 4:31susceptible to cancer by ramping up a cancer-promoting gene
- 4:35and turning off a major cancer prevention gene.
- 4:38Then they transplanted a healthy heart onto each of their necks,
- 4:42and got the heart all wired up so that blood went through that heart, but
- 4:47the actual pumping was still being done by the mouse’s regular heart.
- 4:51Yeah, I know. But there are lots of rules in place around
- 4:54these sorts of experiments, including using as few animals
- 4:57as you possibly can to learn the thing you need.
- 5:00It’s all in service of making human lives better.
- 5:03Anyway, this setup created two stress scenarios.
- 5:06The regular hearts were under the usual amount of
- 5:09mechanical stress that a heart deals with when it
- 5:12has to pump blood through a whole body.
- 5:14The transplanted heart, meanwhile, was a freeloader that
- 5:17had the same kinds of cells without any of the responsibility.
- 5:21The researchers injected cancer cells
- 5:23into both hearts and waited two weeks.
- 5:26What they saw was that the transplanted hearts ended up
- 5:28chock full of cancer cells, while only small portions of
- 5:32the stress-addled hearts became cancerous.
- 5:35Also the non-beating hearts had more cell proliferation,
- 5:38mirroring what the VAD studies had shown.
- 5:40They did a similar experiment with engineered heart tissue.
- 5:44Some of the heart tissue was exposed to ions that made it beat,
- 5:47while the rest wasn’t and stayed still.
- 5:50Then they added cancer cells to see how
- 5:52the movement affected cancer growth.
- 5:54And again, the movement of the heart seemed to stave off the cancer.
- 5:58The cancer cells stayed on the outer layers of the beating tissue,
- 6:02but spread all the way through the unbeating counterpart.
- 6:06They concluded that as long as your heart is beating,
- 6:09cancer’s gonna have a hard time getting a foothold.
- 6:11At least in that organ.
- 6:13And the why for that seems to be the protein Nesprin-2.
- 6:17Nesprin-2 is part of a complex that connects a cell's cytoskeleton,
- 6:22its internal scaffold, to the nucleus.
- 6:24Nesprin-2’s main responsibility is communicating
- 6:27mechanical signals between the two.
- 6:29If the cytoskeleton is sensing a lot of movement from outside,
- 6:32Nesprin-2 will tell the nucleus about it.
- 6:34In response, the nucleus makes adjustments to allow genes
- 6:38involved in stopping cell proliferation to be expressed.
- 6:41Apparently having other cells beating down
- 6:43your door doesn’t scream “great time to replicate”.
- 6:47So Nesprin-2 blocks proliferation if there’s a lot of movement…
- 6:51like in beating heart cells.
- 6:53And when scientists blocked Nesprin-2 from warning
- 6:55the nucleus about the pounding outside, cancer cells were
- 6:58able to spread whether the heart tissue was beating or not.
- 7:02So in your heart, less Nesprin-2 means more cancer.
- 7:05But nobody is really looking for a way to get more cancer.
- 7:09Instead researchers think that Nesprin-2 and related proteins could
- 7:12be exploited as a treatment for cancer in other parts of the body.
- 7:17What exactly that might look like is still a big TBD though.
- 7:21But maybe we should keep looking to the heart for answers here.
- 7:25Because it sure seems like this mighty organ
- 7:28might have beating cancer down to a science.
- 7:31[♪OUTRO]
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of Why Isn’t Heart Cancer a Thing? by SciShow, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 1,302 words across 146 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.