YouTube2Text

Why I Stopped Making Tangzhong the Popular Way | 24 Hour Method for Softer Bread — Transcript

by Novita Listyani · 4,645 words · 700 segments · language en · Watch on YouTube

Full transcript

  1. 0:00At a glance, the tang zhong method is
  2. 0:02the viral secret to making softer and
  3. 0:04fluffier bread that lasts for longer
  4. 0:07using just flour, water, and heat. That
  5. 0:11is the simple story that shows up
  6. 0:13everywhere. But, what if I told you that
  7. 0:15we got almost all of it wrong? From the
  8. 0:18myth of fluffy tang zhong to the
  9. 0:20temperature of 65° C,
  10. 0:23Western bakers are being shown a method
  11. 0:25that's been stripped of its identity and
  12. 0:28the real science behind it. In this
  13. 0:30video, we are debunking the tang zhong
  14. 0:32myths, finding out how it actually
  15. 0:34works, and I'm going to show you the
  16. 0:36best way to make it based on science.
  17. 0:39You're about to see the tang zhong
  18. 0:41method as you've never seen it before.
  19. 0:44Let's get into it. To define it simply,
  20. 0:46the tang zhong method, also known as the
  21. 0:48yudane method, requires only three
  22. 0:51things: flour, water, and heat. Whatever
  23. 0:54variation you see online always boils
  24. 0:57down to adding flour to water at a
  25. 0:59temperature beyond 65° C.
  26. 1:02You let that cool to room temperature,
  27. 1:04and then add it to your bread dough. In
  28. 1:06countless English YouTube videos and
  29. 1:08recipes on tang zhong, you will
  30. 1:09inevitably hear the words fluffy, light,
  31. 1:13and airy. That makes sense because
  32. 1:15fluffiness is a major overarching goal
  33. 1:18for many Western or English-speaking
  34. 1:20bakers. Good bread is supposed to be
  35. 1:22fluffy, light, and voluminous. But, if
  36. 1:25you dive into the original Japanese and
  37. 1:27Chinese sources, tang zhong or yudane
  38. 1:30bread is never described as fluffy.
  39. 1:35And I think that's probably because of
  40. 1:37two things. One, the tang zhong method
  41. 1:40generally does not make bread fluffier.
  42. 1:43This is supported by a lot of science.
  43. 1:44The gelatinized starch in tang zhong
  44. 1:46actually weakens the gluten network and
  45. 1:48results in issues with gas retention.
  46. 1:50So, it usually causes problems with
  47. 1:53bread volume.
  48. 1:54And two, fluffy bread was never the goal
  49. 1:59for these Asian bakers. You see, there
  50. 2:01are plenty of dough improvers and
  51. 2:03methods designed to ensure bread becomes
  52. 2:06voluminous and airy. What there aren't a
  53. 2:08lot of, however, are methods to make
  54. 2:11bread incredibly soft while being a
  55. 2:13little bit chewy. This chewiness is a
  56. 2:16concept that is barely talked about in
  57. 2:19Western discourse on tang zhong or
  58. 2:21yudane. It's never the focus of recipes,
  59. 2:24which is so ironic given that it was
  60. 2:27what spawned the original runaway
  61. 2:29success of the method. To start with,
  62. 2:32although the idea of mixing flour with
  63. 2:34hot water has a history in many
  64. 2:36countries around the world, this
  65. 2:38specific method and its use in making
  66. 2:40softer white breads originated in Japan,
  67. 2:44where it's called yudane. On one New
  68. 2:46Year's Eve in 1997, a general manager of
  69. 2:50a large Japanese bread corporation went
  70. 2:53out to greet long-time clients and
  71. 2:55resellers. His cheery day quickly turned
  72. 2:58sour when a client mentioned that his
  73. 3:00wife actually preferred bread from a
  74. 3:02rival company. The reason? Because it
  75. 3:05had a distinct soft and chewy texture.
  76. 3:09In Japanese, this texture is so
  77. 3:11significant, it's got its own term,
  78. 3:13mochi mochi, referring to Japanese
  79. 3:15mochi. In our story, the general manager
  80. 3:18was horrified when he realized that
  81. 3:20their bread lacked this very texture.
  82. 3:24The company went into heavy research,
  83. 3:26which we're going to get into later, but
  84. 3:28for now, all you need to know is that
  85. 3:30this company is still one of the largest
  86. 3:32in Japan, and the bread they made has
  87. 3:35been number one in white supermarket
  88. 3:37breads for years. And the secret is, of
  89. 3:40course, the yudane method with a little
  90. 3:42twist. I do wonder if this general
  91. 3:45manager would be shocked to realize that
  92. 3:47one of the fundamental reasons behind
  93. 3:50why yudane and tang zhong became so
  94. 3:52popular in Asia is often absent from
  95. 3:55newer resources on the method these
  96. 3:58days. The uniqueness of this bread has
  97. 4:01been replaced with a general make bread
  98. 4:03fluffier tags. We'll come back to the
  99. 4:05story in a bit, but for now it's time to
  100. 4:08begin the chaos and explain how yudane
  101. 4:11and tangzhong became two different
  102. 4:14methods, as well as how the fluffy myth
  103. 4:17probably began.
  104. 4:19If Japan was the start of the method,
  105. 4:21then Taiwan was one of the first places
  106. 4:23it really started spreading to.
  107. 4:26According to one source, yudane bread
  108. 4:28was brought to Taiwan by 7-Eleven
  109. 4:30stores, which probably gave people a
  110. 4:32taste for soft and chewy bread. But it
  111. 4:35truly started taking off online when a
  112. 4:37Taiwanese baker wrote a widely spread
  113. 4:39book called 65° C
  114. 4:42bread doctor.
  115. 4:43This is what I consider as the first
  116. 4:46language barrier crossed. Yudane, a
  117. 4:48Japanese method, was introduced by this
  118. 4:50Taiwanese baker to a new market. And
  119. 4:53importantly, the book was written in
  120. 4:55traditional Chinese. Naturally, she
  121. 4:58didn't invent a new term for a method
  122. 5:01that already had a name. She simply took
  123. 5:04the Japanese kanji characters for yudane
  124. 5:06and stuffed them into her Chinese book.
  125. 5:09The exact same two characters read as
  126. 5:12yudane in Japanese became tangzhong when
  127. 5:15read in Chinese. So, they are literally
  128. 5:18interchangeable terms.
  129. 5:20But then the book became widely popular
  130. 5:23amongst Chinese diaspora, and they
  131. 5:25translated it into English. So now for
  132. 5:28people who are new to things, there were
  133. 5:30two methods in the world, tangzhong and
  134. 5:33yudane. To make things even more
  135. 5:35chaotic, the way of making tangzhong
  136. 5:38that this book popularized was pretty
  137. 5:40different from many of the original
  138. 5:42Japanese techniques. This is the same
  139. 5:44problematic method I talked about 3
  140. 5:47years ago.
  141. 5:48>> One part flour to five parts water that
  142. 5:50is commonly shared online. Because I
  143. 5:52think one, it's actually confusing
  144. 5:54something that's very simple. And two,
  145. 5:56it has some serious limitations that
  146. 5:58result in you not being able to get the
  147. 5:59full benefit from the method.
  148. 6:01>> The key feature of this method is that
  149. 6:03it calls for mixing a lot of water with
  150. 6:05the flour before cooking it in a pan.
  151. 6:08And I do suspect that this highly
  152. 6:10diluted way of making tang zhong might
  153. 6:13be why the method end up being falsely
  154. 6:16associated with extreme fluffiness.
  155. 6:19You see, the book itself never claimed
  156. 6:22this method would make bread fluffier.
  157. 6:24But because the amount of flour that can
  158. 6:26be used in a one to five ratio of flour
  159. 6:29to water is so incredibly small, the
  160. 6:32actual effect of the tang zhong on bread
  161. 6:35volume is likely to be truly negligible.
  162. 6:38Basically, you can't add more flour
  163. 6:41without adding five times the amount of
  164. 6:44water. So recipes using this method
  165. 6:46often only use about 5% of their total
  166. 6:49bread flour. According to one scientific
  167. 6:52paper, when adding a small amount of
  168. 6:54gelatinized flour, the bread remains
  169. 6:56relatively close to the control loaf in
  170. 6:59size. The loaf with the smallest amount
  171. 7:01of gelatinized flour added retained
  172. 7:03about 96.4%
  173. 7:05of its original height. This very
  174. 7:07slight, almost unnoticeable change in
  175. 7:10volume might be how bakers ended up
  176. 7:12connecting the idea of tang zhong with
  177. 7:15maximum fluffiness. We can actually see
  178. 7:18how this misunderstanding happened in
  179. 7:20one of the earlier blog post about the
  180. 7:22tang zhong method in 2010. While talking
  181. 7:25about a recipe from this book, this
  182. 7:27blogger makes a direct jump from what
  183. 7:29the book says about softness and ends up
  184. 7:32emphasizing fluffiness. In another post,
  185. 7:35she mentions that the reason the method
  186. 7:37itself works is in part by making the
  187. 7:39bread fluffier. This is what I think of
  188. 7:42as the second language barrier crossed.
  189. 7:45And the true tragedy is that this fluffy
  190. 7:47myth has actually covered up where the
  191. 7:50method truly shines. And all of this
  192. 7:52chaos doesn't help us figure out how to
  193. 7:55properly use this method based on
  194. 7:57science. It's time to go back to to that
  195. 8:00Japanese bread company story. The
  196. 8:02company launched a bread called Chojuku,
  197. 8:04which turned out to be a pretty genius
  198. 8:06move Because Tangzhong become the
  199. 8:08absolutely number one white bread on the
  200. 8:11market from 2019 all the way to 2024.
  201. 8:16This was based on data for 15 years old
  202. 8:18to 79 years old. So, you know it was
  203. 8:21popular from grandchildren to
  204. 8:23grandparents.
  205. 8:25And the company is quite open about
  206. 8:26their patented production method.
  207. 8:28However, it's important to know what
  208. 8:30they actually patented wasn't the Yudane
  209. 8:33method itself. Their original patent
  210. 8:35notes the was already well known even
  211. 8:38back in 1999. What they patented was
  212. 8:41their specific process of making and
  213. 8:44aging the mixture for 15 up to 72 hours
  214. 8:48at cold temperatures. In their renewed
  215. 8:51patent, they've made some changes, but
  216. 8:53ultimately still let their mixture sit
  217. 8:55at cold temperatures for 24 to 72 hours.
  218. 8:59Their explanation was that this cold
  219. 9:01rest is meant to prevent the bread from
  220. 9:03caving in, which is an notorious
  221. 9:05downside of the method. However,
  222. 9:07according to a comprehensive thesis on
  223. 9:09the subject, this step of letting the
  224. 9:12Tangzhong rest in the fridge might also
  225. 9:14be beneficial for improving bread
  226. 9:16quality and long-term softness.
  227. 9:19This thesis states that bread made with
  228. 9:21Tangzhong refrigerated for exactly 24
  229. 9:24hours was among the absolute softest
  230. 9:27right after baking. And after 3 days, it
  231. 9:30had the best anti-staling effect. Now,
  232. 9:33if you're impatient and you can't wait a
  233. 9:35full day to make your Tangzhong, then
  234. 9:37your best bet is to use it immediately
  235. 9:39while it's fresh. Bread made with
  236. 9:41zero-hour Tangzhong was also incredibly
  237. 9:44soft and retain that softness for days.
  238. 9:47But, here's where you have to be
  239. 9:49careful. Outside of those two specific
  240. 9:51timings, you enter a textural danger
  241. 9:53zone. If you leave the Tangzhong out at
  242. 9:56room temperature for say 12 hours, or
  243. 9:58leave it in the fridge for 48 hours, the
  244. 10:00science shows it might actually make
  245. 10:02your bread a bit harder than it has to
  246. 10:05be. So, it's best to use it right away
  247. 10:08or wait a day.
  248. 10:09That rhymes. The softness was also
  249. 10:12influenced by how much tangzhong was
  250. 10:14used. 10 to 20% tangzhong resulted in
  251. 10:17the softest bread in this thesis,
  252. 10:19whereas percentages above 20% resulted
  253. 10:22in increasingly harder bread. This
  254. 10:24finding is a little troublesome because
  255. 10:26another paper found the opposite result.
  256. 10:28And very important note, softness is not
  257. 10:31only influenced by how we make the
  258. 10:33tangzhong or let it rest, it's also
  259. 10:35influenced by how we make the bread
  260. 10:38dough with tangzhong. And we'll see
  261. 10:40later on how we can probably make our
  262. 10:43bread much softer than these results. In
  263. 10:45terms of volume, the thesis states that
  264. 10:47the tangzhong rested for 24 hours in
  265. 10:49cold storage had almost no significant
  266. 10:52differences and negative effect on bread
  267. 10:54volume up to a 30% addition, which could
  268. 10:58be considered a way to minimize the
  269. 10:59volume loss usually associated with the
  270. 11:02method. I will note though the thesis
  271. 11:04did find that adding 10% tangzhong that
  272. 11:07was used immediately without rest
  273. 11:09resulted in a slight increase in bread
  274. 11:11volume by about 0.9%,
  275. 11:14but this wasn't statistically
  276. 11:16significant, so the increase in volume
  277. 11:18might not be because of the 10%
  278. 11:20tangzhong. And to add to that, if you
  279. 11:22check the hardness of this bread in the
  280. 11:23thesis, it was actually higher compared
  281. 11:26to certain other loaves that had a lower
  282. 11:29volume. So, the increased volume did not
  283. 11:32make the bread that much softer. Another
  284. 11:35interesting thing I found was that many
  285. 11:36of these textural changes are likely to
  286. 11:38be unnoticeable on the day the bread is
  287. 11:41baked. In the same thesis, the sensory
  288. 11:43panel who tested the bread didn't
  289. 11:45significantly prefer any specific
  290. 11:47tangzhong aging or resting methods. But
  291. 11:50in texture analysis, there were
  292. 11:52differences on the first day and then on
  293. 11:54the second or third days, these
  294. 11:56differences in hardness and chewiness
  295. 11:59widened further. Personally, I also find
  296. 12:01that using cold refrigerated tangzhong
  297. 12:03lowers the overall mixing temperature of
  298. 12:05your dough, which can drastically
  299. 12:07improve of gluten strength and final
  300. 12:09bread volume. Just don't age it for too
  301. 12:11long in the fridge or the volume of the
  302. 12:13bread might start to degrade even more.
  303. 12:15Now, this step isn't the only thing that
  304. 12:18you barely hear about in most English
  305. 12:20sources. So, before we start tweaking
  306. 12:23recipes, we have to correct the
  307. 12:25fundamental misunderstandings of the
  308. 12:27science. We have to ask, "How does this
  309. 12:30method actually work?" You might have
  310. 12:32heard that tangzhong or yudane is simply
  311. 12:34a way of binding water to the dough. The
  312. 12:37common wisdom is that because it locks
  313. 12:39moisture inside, the resulting bread is
  314. 12:41softer and stales much slower. But, that
  315. 12:44is only a fraction of the full picture.
  316. 12:48In most explanations, including my own
  317. 12:50previous videos, we tend to focus
  318. 12:52entirely on gelatinized starch. Flour
  319. 12:55contains starch granules that swell up
  320. 12:57and absorb water. As the heat rises,
  321. 13:00they absorb more and more until
  322. 13:02eventually they explode. This is starch
  323. 13:04gelatinization. According to a Japanese
  324. 13:06paper from 2014, adding this mix to
  325. 13:09bread makes it softer and delays staling
  326. 13:11due to three things. First off, as
  327. 13:14mentioned, tangzhong holds onto
  328. 13:15moisture. The more you use, the more
  329. 13:17moisture is maintained. But, beyond
  330. 13:20that, because the tangzhong method
  331. 13:22destroys starch granules, it also makes
  332. 13:25them highly susceptible to enzymes
  333. 13:28already present in wheat flour. These
  334. 13:30enzymes are like tiny scissors, and they
  335. 13:32basically chop up a sizable portion of
  336. 13:35the complex starches into bits and
  337. 13:37pieces, transforming them from large
  338. 13:39complex sugars into much simpler ones.
  339. 13:43These simpler sugars may weaken the
  340. 13:44cross-links between starch and gluten
  341. 13:46that normally cause bread to feel more
  342. 13:48firm during staling. So, this could be
  343. 13:51another way tangzhong makes bread softer
  344. 13:53for longer. As a bonus, simpler sugars
  345. 13:56are also the ones our tongues can easily
  346. 13:58taste, which is why tangzhong bread has
  347. 14:00a mildly sweeter flavor and browns well
  348. 14:03in the oven. Now, we're not done yet
  349. 14:06because the same enzymatic process that
  350. 14:08creates simpler sugars can also slow
  351. 14:11staling due to its effect on what's
  352. 14:13called starch retrogradation. You see,
  353. 14:15when we are making tang zhong with the
  354. 14:17hot water, again, we essentially tear
  355. 14:19apart the starch into bits and pieces.
  356. 14:21But, retrogradation is kind of the
  357. 14:24opposite process. This is when the
  358. 14:26starch bits reassemble and crystallize
  359. 14:29after being torn apart. This would be
  360. 14:31perfectly fine if it weren't connected
  361. 14:33to the bread getting harder during
  362. 14:35staling. The new structure of the starch
  363. 14:37components after retrogradation is a
  364. 14:39tight and rigid structure that's pretty
  365. 14:42much the main cause of bread staling.
  366. 14:45Retrogradation happens in bread after
  367. 14:47you bake it. Once it cools, it starts
  368. 14:49the process. And as we leave the bread
  369. 14:51for longer, the harder the bread gets.
  370. 14:54However, if we add tang zhong, we get a
  371. 14:56lot of damaged starch components that
  372. 14:58have been chopped up by the enzymes. And
  373. 15:00what this does is result in a bunch of
  374. 15:02complex sugars that have shorter outer
  375. 15:05chains. And because these complex sugars
  376. 15:07now have much shorter chains, they find
  377. 15:09it much more difficult to crystallize
  378. 15:11and retrograde. Simply put, the bread
  379. 15:14physically cannot go stale as fast. So
  380. 15:17far, that's a standard scientific story.
  381. 15:20You might have already heard of the
  382. 15:21benefits of gelatinized starch before.
  383. 15:23You might have even heard of some of the
  384. 15:24things I've said before. But, as it
  385. 15:26turns out, there is yet another element
  386. 15:29to this process, which is heated gluten.
  387. 15:32Okay, so flour doesn't just contain
  388. 15:34starch. It contains gluten proteins,
  389. 15:36which you probably know because they
  390. 15:38hold the entire dough together and allow
  391. 15:40it to trap gas cells, too. According to
  392. 15:42this paper, when these gluten proteins
  393. 15:44are heated, they physically change,
  394. 15:47becoming capable of holding onto
  395. 15:48significantly more water. Not only that,
  396. 15:51adding this heated gluten to bread dough
  397. 15:53can actually make bread fluffier, for
  398. 15:55real this time. This study recorded
  399. 15:57volume increases and improved softness,
  400. 16:00too, especially for gluten heated to 75°
  401. 16:03C
  402. 16:04and 80° C.
  403. 16:06Now, this was also an incredibly ironic
  404. 16:10scientific discovery. In previous
  405. 16:12studies, researchers actually believed
  406. 16:14this partially denatured gluten was a
  407. 16:17problem. They blamed it for the
  408. 16:18decreased bread volume. Heck, in my
  409. 16:21previous videos, I blamed it, too. But,
  410. 16:23as it turns out, this partially
  411. 16:25denatured heated gluten actually leads
  412. 16:27to better bread with a higher volume and
  413. 16:30delayed staling. So, knowing all of
  414. 16:32this, how do we actually improve our
  415. 16:34bread's volume and extract the absolute
  416. 16:37most out of the tang zhong method? Here
  417. 16:39is my newly updated science-backed way
  418. 16:42to do it. First, we need to choose the
  419. 16:44right flour. Keeping what we learned
  420. 16:46about heated gluten in mind, I think
  421. 16:47it's logical to speculate that the
  422. 16:49papers shows exactly why we should be
  423. 16:52using high-protein bread flour to make
  424. 16:54our tang zhong. More protein means more
  425. 16:57heated gluten, which means a softer,
  426. 16:59longer-lasting loaf, hopefully. After
  427. 17:01that, we determine the amount of flour
  428. 17:03we want to use. For the rest of the
  429. 17:05video, we're going to show the amount of
  430. 17:06tang zhong used as the percentage of
  431. 17:08total flour used to make it. So, for a
  432. 17:11recipe with 100 g of bread flour in
  433. 17:14total, if we're using 20 g of the flour
  434. 17:17to make tang zhong, then we are using
  435. 17:1920% tang zhong or tang zhong 20. For
  436. 17:21help on determining what percentage of
  437. 17:23tang zhong you want for your bread, you
  438. 17:24can skip ahead to the timestamp where I
  439. 17:27talk about tang zhong percentages in
  440. 17:29detail. For now, we determine the amount
  441. 17:31of water we want to add in. While a 1:1
  442. 17:34ratio, in other words, equal parts water
  443. 17:37and flour is technically sufficient, I
  444. 17:40highly prefer pouring in about 1.5 to
  445. 17:43two times the amount of water to flour
  446. 17:45in grams. It makes it much easier to mix
  447. 17:48thoroughly and ensures the mixture holds
  448. 17:50its temperature. So, for example, if I
  449. 17:52were using 50 g of flour to make tang
  450. 17:54zhong, I would aim to add at least 75 to
  451. 17:57100 g of water during this step. Next,
  452. 18:00let's figure out how to cook this. So,
  453. 18:03you have two options here. You can
  454. 18:05either pop it in the microwave, which
  455. 18:06calls for mixing the flour and water
  456. 18:09together, then covering it and cooking
  457. 18:11it in the microwave for about 1 to 2
  458. 18:13minutes,
  459. 18:15or you can heat up a glass bowl before
  460. 18:18measuring water in and then throwing in
  461. 18:22the pre-measured flour, mixing it
  462. 18:24together. I've done this a million times
  463. 18:26in making my bread recipes, but
  464. 18:29recently, I do prefer the microwave
  465. 18:31method because it allows the temperature
  466. 18:33to get much higher. Because while many
  467. 18:35of the tang zhong recipes tell you to
  468. 18:37aim for 65° C, where 90% of the starch
  469. 18:41gelatinizes, that temperature completely
  470. 18:43ignores the benefits of the heated
  471. 18:44gluten we just talked about. The paper
  472. 18:46we showed earlier had the absolute best
  473. 18:49bread results happen when the gluten was
  474. 18:51heated to around 75 to 80° C. So, we
  475. 18:54want to make sure that the tang zhong is
  476. 18:56getting hot enough. For the final step,
  477. 18:58we have to remember the element of time.
  478. 19:00Research shows that you're better off
  479. 19:02either using the tang zhong immediately
  480. 19:03for pretty soft bread, or let it rest
  481. 19:06for 24 hours for the softest bread, and
  482. 19:09potentially added gluten strength due to
  483. 19:12a colder dough. If you let the tang
  484. 19:14zhong sit at room temperature for too
  485. 19:15long, it can adversely affect your bread
  486. 19:18quality. Same thing goes for putting in
  487. 19:20the fridge, although the timing is
  488. 19:22longer. Beyond just making and storing
  489. 19:24it, we have to talk about how much tang
  490. 19:26zhong to actually put in your dough.
  491. 19:28Everything depends on your percentages.
  492. 19:30In many Japanese scientific papers, a
  493. 19:33standard recommended amount used is 20%
  494. 19:36of the total flour. But, remember, the
  495. 19:39softness that these papers are measuring
  496. 19:41is that of a chewy, marshmallow-like
  497. 19:44elasticity. If your ultimate goal is a
  498. 19:46hyper light, soft, and fluffy sensation,
  499. 19:50tang zhong will help a little, but you
  500. 19:53might want to use less of it and
  501. 19:54experiment with adding more solid fats
  502. 19:57like butter or shortening, which can
  503. 19:59increase bread volume. So, let's break
  504. 20:01down exactly what happens at every level
  505. 20:04of tang zhong addition based on science.
  506. 20:06We start with 10% tang zhong. This is
  507. 20:09frequently cited as the optimal
  508. 20:11replacement level for casual bakers. It
  509. 20:13improves flavor and softness, and acts
  510. 20:16as a pretty good anti-staling agent.
  511. 20:18While it does begin to slightly affect
  512. 20:20the structure, the loaf height does not
  513. 20:22drop as significantly as in loaves with
  514. 20:25higher amounts of tang zhong. Following
  515. 20:27that at 20% tang zhong, this level of
  516. 20:29tang zhong addition is a pretty popular
  517. 20:31sweet spot for a lot of Asian breads
  518. 20:33like shokupan or other soft milk breads.
  519. 20:36Using this much tang zhong marks a
  520. 20:38significant shift in quality. The bread
  521. 20:40becomes very soft, incredibly moist, a
  522. 20:43little bit chewy, and stales at a pretty
  523. 20:46slow rate. Moisture content jumps
  524. 20:48significantly and the saccharide content
  525. 20:50increases, giving you a sweeter taste.
  526. 20:53However, you will start to note a more
  527. 20:55noticeable decrease in your specific
  528. 20:58loaf volume and your final proofing
  529. 21:00times might take a little longer. Moving
  530. 21:01on to 30% tang zhong, several sources
  531. 21:04suggest this is the absolute ideal upper
  532. 21:07threshold. At 30%, the crumb remains
  533. 21:10exceptionally soft and the retardation
  534. 21:12of staling is at a very high level of
  535. 21:15effectiveness. However, the reduction in
  536. 21:17volume becomes quite stark. That being
  537. 21:19said, I have seen some recipes where
  538. 21:22this really works like in cinnamon rolls
  539. 21:24or breads where you're not too obsessed
  540. 21:26with the idea of a super fluffy crumb.
  541. 21:29Beyond 30%, we have 40% tang zhong.
  542. 21:32Welcome to the danger zone. This is
  543. 21:34where bread volume really starts to take
  544. 21:37a hit and it's a percentage of tang
  545. 21:38zhong that is honestly beyond most
  546. 21:40applications. I've played around with
  547. 21:42this percentage of tang zhong, but I
  548. 21:44think it's probably not what most of us
  549. 21:46require. And next, we take a quick peek
  550. 21:49at 50% tang zhong. Crazy. At this level,
  551. 21:53the bread's height and volume decreases
  552. 21:56severely. This level requires the
  553. 21:58absolute longest proofing time because a
  554. 22:00weakened gluten network simply cannot
  555. 22:02retain fermentation gases. The dough
  556. 22:04becomes excessively soft, sticky, and a
  557. 22:07total nightmare to handle. So, it's
  558. 22:10basically never used. Ever. Okay. We've
  559. 22:14gone through the science and you've
  560. 22:15picked your tang zhong percentage. A
  561. 22:18fast and quick tip before you just dump
  562. 22:20the tang zhong into the mixer, I highly
  563. 22:22recommend breaking it up in a separate
  564. 22:24bowl with a little bit of the water
  565. 22:26first. If you don't, it can form
  566. 22:28stubborn clumps inside your dough in
  567. 22:30some cases. But more importantly, here
  568. 22:32is a golden rule of recipe formulation
  569. 22:35with a tangzhong method. Tangzhong
  570. 22:37doughs can handle more water. And in
  571. 22:39fact, you should probably add enough
  572. 22:42hydration. If you don't, your bread will
  573. 22:44probably go stale faster. Tangzhong acts
  574. 22:48like a sponge preserving water. Because
  575. 22:50of this, you can safely push your
  576. 22:51dough's hydration limits to a little
  577. 22:54higher than normal. And you want to do
  578. 22:56this because water itself makes bread
  579. 22:58softer, and it also slows staling down
  580. 23:01directly. According to the paper, at 20%
  581. 23:04tangzhong, the dough's water absorption
  582. 23:06is closer to 72% increasing from the
  583. 23:09control dough without tangzhong by about
  584. 23:112 to 3% water. So, not exactly a ton of
  585. 23:16moisture, but of course, this does
  586. 23:18depend on your flour as well. If your
  587. 23:20flour's original water absorption was
  588. 23:22lower, it can't handle as much water,
  589. 23:24and then you used 72% hydration, then
  590. 23:27you might end up with a much stickier
  591. 23:29and weaker dough. This is probably why
  592. 23:31it's a good idea to test out different
  593. 23:33hydrations and be clear on the
  594. 23:35properties of your flour. I will also
  595. 23:37note that whole wheat flours or other
  596. 23:39specialty flours often need a lot more
  597. 23:42water just because the bran present
  598. 23:44absorbs a lot as well. So, if you're
  599. 23:46using tangzhong for those breads, you'll
  600. 23:48want to keep this in mind. When you mix
  601. 23:50the dough, you should also keep an eye
  602. 23:51on it. Tangzhong doughs feel stronger
  603. 23:54and more cohesive, but they are actually
  604. 23:55weaker and generally less resistant to
  605. 23:58extension. The same thesis we covered
  606. 24:00before also showed that they are less
  607. 24:02resistant to over mixing and have a
  608. 24:04lower stability, which means that it's
  609. 24:06not a good idea to mix them for too long
  610. 24:08past their peak. When you shape the
  611. 24:09dough, you might also notice this fact
  612. 24:11as the dough doesn't stretch quite as
  613. 24:13neatly or easily. I usually counter this
  614. 24:16by allowing the dough to rest before
  615. 24:18continuing to work on it. For the final
  616. 24:20tip, patience is key. Tangzhong doughs
  617. 24:23are absolutely going to take longer to
  618. 24:25prove and rise because the gluten
  619. 24:27network is not as good at retaining gas.
  620. 24:30It's not as strong. In one study, the
  621. 24:32final proofing time for a control dough
  622. 24:34without udane was 84 minutes, and it
  623. 24:37increased to 86 minutes with a 20% tang
  624. 24:40zhong addition. This 2-minute increase
  625. 24:42might not sound like much, but you have
  626. 24:45to remember their recipe was much closer
  627. 24:47to an industrial bread recipe since they
  628. 24:50used a relatively large amount of yeast
  629. 24:52as well as additions of sugar,
  630. 24:54shortening, and ascorbic acid. that can
  631. 24:57raise the bread volume. They also proof
  632. 24:59their dough at a temperature of 38° C
  633. 25:02with a humidity of 85%. So, this was a
  634. 25:05very expedited proofing stage. As home
  635. 25:08bakers, the timing of our tang zhong
  636. 25:10doughs could vary greatly depending on
  637. 25:12the room temperature and recipe. Also,
  638. 25:14at higher percentages of tang zhong
  639. 25:16addition, the proofing time definitely
  640. 25:17extends for longer as well, as we
  641. 25:19mentioned. The way that you let your
  642. 25:21tang zhong rest might also influence how
  643. 25:23long you have to proof the bread dough
  644. 25:24for as well. Tang zhong rested at room
  645. 25:27temperature for longer generally led to
  646. 25:29longer required proofing times for the
  647. 25:32final dough compared to the ones put in
  648. 25:34cold storage. All right, if you've made
  649. 25:36it this far into the video, you are
  650. 25:38officially in the advanced category of
  651. 25:41tang zhong bakers. Before we go, I want
  652. 25:44to rapid-fire a few unknown benefits of
  653. 25:46tang zhong that you can explore further
  654. 25:48in some of my previous videos. For
  655. 25:50starters, there's a chance that tang
  656. 25:52zhong can actually help doughs survive
  657. 25:54the freezer. Partially preheated doughs
  658. 25:57improve in frozen quality, allowing you
  659. 25:59to meal prep, basically, and store your
  660. 26:02doughs for much longer. You can check
  661. 26:03out my dedicated video on frozen doughs
  662. 26:06for the full breakdown. Next up, and I
  663. 26:08love doing this, we can use tang zhong
  664. 26:10to make artisan bread and pizzas with
  665. 26:12incredibly crisp crust that refuse to
  666. 26:15dry out even in standard home electric
  667. 26:18ovens. I have a whole video on making
  668. 26:20incredible pizzas without a specialized
  669. 26:22pizza oven where I cover the exact
  670. 26:24science of this. And I also have a video
  671. 26:26on using tang zhong to make super high
  672. 26:28hydration ciabattas. It's a lot easier
  673. 26:30than the regular method. For the third
  674. 26:32tip, you can use a non-wheat tangzhong
  675. 26:35to create a wildly crisp crust that
  676. 26:37survives humid climates. I only recently
  677. 26:40discovered this myself, and it is the
  678. 26:42only time I will ever recommend that
  679. 26:44highly diluted 1:5 flour to water ratio
  680. 26:47because we use it as a glaze. You simply
  681. 26:50brush the watery mixture onto the crust
  682. 26:52right before baking. I use this exact
  683. 26:55method in my shio pan video to keep the
  684. 26:57rolls crispier for longer. Finally, if
  685. 26:59you're feeling adventurous, try making
  686. 27:01your tangzhong with rice flour or toss
  687. 27:03in a bit of cooked rice into your bread.
  688. 27:06Unlike wheat starch, gelatinized rice
  689. 27:08starch actually does increase bread
  690. 27:10volume while still improving softness
  691. 27:12and delaying staling. If you cook rice
  692. 27:14every day, this could be a very
  693. 27:16interesting hack or a way to use
  694. 27:18leftover rice. We do have one shokupan
  695. 27:21recipe made with rice flour that tastes
  696. 27:23delicious, and you can check it out
  697. 27:25here. And that is the true unfiltered
  698. 27:27science of tangzhong. Thank you so much
  699. 27:29for geeking out over bread with me
  700. 27:31today. Thanks for watching, and bye.

About this transcript

This page contains the full transcript of Why I Stopped Making Tangzhong the Popular Way | 24 Hour Method for Softer Bread by Novita Listyani, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 4,645 words across 700 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.

What you can do with it

Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.

Free YouTube transcript tool

YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.