YouTube2Text

Why Google Hired a Chinese Spy — Transcript

by Paper Billions · 2,858 words · 448 segments · language en · Watch on YouTube

Full transcript

  1. 0:00This is Leon.
  2. 0:01And Leon has three jobs.
  3. 0:03Job one: he's an engineer at Google, on the supercomputers that train its AI.
  4. 0:08Job two: he's the technology chief of an AI startup in Beijing.
  5. 0:12Job three: he's the boss of his own AI company in Shanghai.
  6. 0:16Google only knows about the first one.
  7. 0:18Where are you going?
  8. 0:19Lunch.
  9. 0:20For how long?
  10. 0:21Keep swiping.
  11. 0:22For a year,
  12. 0:23Leon carried Google's most secret chip designs out of job one and into the other
  13. 0:27two.
  14. 0:28More than a thousand files.
  15. 0:29And he didn't need a rope.
  16. 0:31He used the Notes app.
  17. 0:32So why did Google hire a Chinese spy?
  18. 0:35And how did he rob it with copy and paste?
  19. 0:44For ten years, Google built a chip and wouldn't sell it to anyone.
  20. 0:49Not for sale.
  21. 0:50Not even for...
  22. 0:52Not for sale.
  23. 0:53It starts in twenty thirteen, with a sum.
  24. 0:55Google's engineers work out what happens if everyone talks to their phone for just
  25. 1:00three minutes a day.
  26. 1:01Three minutes a day, each.
  27. 1:03That's nothing.
  28. 1:05That's twice as many data centers.
  29. 1:07So you build more buildings?
  30. 1:09We build a better chip.
  31. 1:11Don't the chips we have already do everything?
  32. 1:14That's the problem.
  33. 1:15We need one that does one thing.
  34. 1:16They call it the Tensor Processing Unit, the TPU,
  35. 1:20and they have it working in fifteen months.
  36. 1:23A normal AI chip is a kitchen that can cook anything.
  37. 1:26Google's chip is a pizza oven.
  38. 1:28It makes one thing, the math AI runs on, and it makes it fast.
  39. 1:33That chip helped AlphaGo beat the world champion at Go.
  40. 1:36Today Google's Gemini is trained on it.
  41. 1:39And that makes Google strange,
  42. 1:41because almost everyone else in AI has to stand in one line.
  43. 1:45Next!
  44. 1:46Where's Google?
  45. 1:47Making their own.
  46. 1:48Can I skip the line?
  47. 1:51Nobody skips the line.
  48. 1:52When Google's chips had their big moment in November twenty twenty-five, Nvidia,
  49. 1:57which almost never talks about a rival,
  50. 2:00posted one line: "We're delighted by Google's success."
  51. 2:03Okay.
  52. 2:04Can I rent it?
  53. 2:05Now we're talking.
  54. 2:07Then the rest of the world wanted in.
  55. 2:09Anthropic signed up for as many as a million of them,
  56. 2:12and the bill runs into the tens of billions.
  57. 2:15Bloomberg's analysts expect TPU sales to grow more than ten times in two years,
  58. 2:21to over a hundred and thirty-five billion dollars.
  59. 2:24For a chip you can only rent.
  60. 2:26One firm put the chips and Google's AI lab together at about nine hundred billion
  61. 2:31dollars.
  62. 2:32That's about two and a half thousand dollars for every person in America.
  63. 2:36And the recipe for all of it is written down: how the chip is laid out inside,
  64. 2:41the software that makes thousands of them work as one machine,
  65. 2:44the network card that wires them together.
  66. 2:47It all sits in documents.
  67. 2:49And in twenty nineteen, Google gave a new hire the key.
  68. 2:55May thirteenth, twenty nineteen.
  69. 2:57Leon's first day at Google.
  70. 2:59He came to America in twenty ten for a master's degree.
  71. 3:02Quiet, polite, mid-level.
  72. 3:04He doesn't design the chips.
  73. 3:06His job is the software that keeps them busy inside Google's AI supercomputers.
  74. 3:11But you can't keep a chip busy if you don't know how it works,
  75. 3:14so he's cleared to read the blueprints.
  76. 3:17So that's why Google hired him.
  77. 3:19It didn't hire a spy.
  78. 3:20It hired a good engineer, and it gave him the keys,
  79. 3:24because the job can't be done without them.
  80. 3:26For three years, nothing happens.
  81. 3:29Then, on May twenty-first, twenty twenty-two,
  82. 3:32Leon makes his first upload of Google's files to his own account.
  83. 3:36Just backing up my notes.
  84. 3:38Twenty-three days later, an email arrives from Beijing.
  85. 3:41It's from Yuan Ye, the boss of a startup called Rongshu.
  86. 3:45Chief technology officer.
  87. 3:47A hundred thousand yuan a month.
  88. 3:48Plus a bonus.
  89. 3:50Plus stock.
  90. 3:50That's very generous.
  91. 3:53So when do you quit Google?
  92. 3:55Why would I quit Google?
  93. 3:56How much is a hundred thousand yuan?
  94. 3:59About fourteen thousand eight hundred dollars.
  95. 4:01A year?
  96. 4:02A month.
  97. 4:02That's a decent used car, every single month.
  98. 4:06About a hundred and seventy-seven thousand dollars a year.
  99. 4:09He says yes, and he keeps the Google badge.
  100. 4:12Now Leon is a spy inside Google for a Chinese company,
  101. 4:16and Google is still paying him.
  102. 4:18Two jobs?
  103. 4:19Two badges.
  104. 4:20And which one does he need?
  105. 4:22The one that opens the vault.
  106. 4:23But the second job needs something from the first.
  107. 4:26And Google has an alarm for exactly that.
  108. 4:31So how do you get a secret file out of Google?
  109. 4:34You don't.
  110. 4:35Google logs every file that leaves for a cloud drive.
  111. 4:38Send one of its secret documents to your own account,
  112. 4:41and the alarm goes off at once.
  113. 4:43If I send the file...
  114. 4:45We see it.
  115. 4:46And if I never send a file?
  116. 4:49Then there's nothing to see.
  117. 4:50So Leon never sends a file.
  118. 4:52Step one, he takes a screenshot of a Google document.
  119. 4:56Step two, he pastes it into Apple Notes, on the MacBook Google gave him.
  120. 5:00Step three, he saves the note as a PDF.
  121. 5:04Step four, he uploads that PDF to his own Google account.
  122. 5:08To the alarm, that isn't a stolen file.
  123. 5:11It's a man backing up his own notes.
  124. 5:13Is that a shopping list?
  125. 5:14It is now.
  126. 5:16He robbed Google with the Notes app?
  127. 5:18And a PDF.
  128. 5:19So where does he keep it all?
  129. 5:21In the cloud.
  130. 5:22Whose cloud?
  131. 5:23Google's.
  132. 5:24The stolen files sit on Google's own servers,
  133. 5:27kept safe for him by the company he's stealing from.
  134. 5:30He keeps it up for a year.
  135. 5:32Screenshot, paste, save, upload.
  136. 5:35By the end, it's more than a thousand files, over two thousand pages.
  137. 5:40And what's on them is the recipe behind a business one firm valued at nine hundred
  138. 5:45billion dollars.
  139. 5:47So what's actually in here?
  140. 5:49How the TPU is built inside, part by part.
  141. 5:52And?
  142. 5:53The software that runs thousands of them as one giant computer.
  143. 5:57And?
  144. 5:57The secret chip in Google's network card, so they can all talk to each other.
  145. 6:02So, the cake recipe.
  146. 6:04The recipe, the oven, and the plans for the whole bakery.
  147. 6:08No rope, no mask, no lasers.
  148. 6:11Nobody carries the vault out of Google.
  149. 6:14Leon photographs it, one page at a time,
  150. 6:16and keeps the pages under his shopping list.
  151. 6:19Anything leaving?
  152. 6:20Just notes.
  153. 6:21So now he has the pages.
  154. 6:23What he doesn't have is the faintest idea how to build what's on them.
  155. 6:29In October twenty twenty-two, a Google engineer goes to China for five months.
  156. 6:35From December, Leon is sitting in Rongshu's meetings with investors.
  157. 6:39Early the next year, he and Yuan Ye start a new company together, Shanghai Zhisuan.
  158. 6:44By May, Leon is its chief executive.
  159. 6:47That's job three.
  160. 6:48The plan is simple: take Google's playbook and sell it in China.
  161. 6:52Google built it.
  162. 6:54I've read it.
  163. 6:55Then we build it.
  164. 6:56I have notes.
  165. 6:58The fundraisers helping them believe Leon has already built the technology.
  166. 7:02He hasn't.
  167. 7:03You built this yourself?
  168. 7:05I know it very well.
  169. 7:07How many chips has it run on?
  170. 7:09Ten thousand.
  171. 7:10Your chips?
  172. 7:11Give me a moment.
  173. 7:12In April twenty twenty-three, the investors want more detail.
  174. 7:17How exactly does your software hand out work to ten thousand chips?
  175. 7:21Great question.
  176. 7:22Let me check my notes.
  177. 7:23So Leon steals more.
  178. 7:25In the judge's words, he "hurriedly uploaded more documents."
  179. 7:29He's stealing to answer his own investors' questions.
  180. 7:32His last big batch goes up on April seventeenth.
  181. 7:35That same day in Beijing,
  182. 7:37Yuan Ye tells investors Leon is Rongshu's technology chief.
  183. 7:41To prove the tech is his, Leon films a demo.
  184. 7:45It shows him running a test on Google's own chips.
  185. 7:48Impressive.
  186. 7:49Where's it running?
  187. 7:50The cloud.
  188. 7:51Whose cloud?
  189. 7:52Next question.
  190. 7:53His company later wrote its strategy down for its own team.
  191. 7:56Quote: "We have experience with Google's ten-thousand-card computational power
  192. 8:01platform; we just need to replicate and upgrade it."
  193. 8:04Replicate.
  194. 8:05And upgrade.
  195. 8:06And it works.
  196. 8:08One of China's best-known startup schools, MiraclePlus,
  197. 8:11puts in about seven hundred thousand dollars for seven percent of the company.
  198. 8:16That's about four years of Leon's Rongshu salary.
  199. 8:19Seven percent.
  200. 8:20For a company with no product.
  201. 8:22Yet.
  202. 8:23And when do we see it?
  203. 8:24Soon.
  204. 8:25That makes Zhisuan worth about ten million dollars.
  205. 8:28Google spends that in about twenty-six minutes.
  206. 8:31That's about three hundred and ninety thousand dollars a minute.
  207. 8:35Ten million dollars?
  208. 8:36For what?
  209. 8:37A copy of Google.
  210. 8:39Has he made the copy?
  211. 8:40He's made the PDF.
  212. 8:41There's just one problem.
  213. 8:43The boss of a Shanghai startup has to be in China.
  214. 8:46A Google engineer has to be in California.
  215. 8:49And Google's doors keep score.
  216. 8:51Three jobs and a notes app.
  217. 8:53I can't even get a second one.
  218. 8:55Try a legal one.
  219. 8:57Funny you say that.
  220. 8:58You've been watching one for nine minutes.
  221. 9:00The cartoon?
  222. 9:01This video.
  223. 9:02The script, the voices, the lasers.
  224. 9:05Every shot and every sound effect, from a topic to a finished four K film,
  225. 9:10overnight.
  226. 9:11We make every video on this channel with a studio called Overnight.
  227. 9:15And they've just opened the app they use to the public.
  228. 9:18You give it an idea.
  229. 9:19Your own Claude researches it, writes it, voices it,
  230. 9:23builds every shot and mixes the sound, on your own Mac or PC.
  231. 9:27So I could make this.
  232. 9:29Myself.
  233. 9:30At this quality.
  234. 9:32Yes.
  235. 9:32With the charts?
  236. 9:33Yes.
  237. 9:34And the lasers?
  238. 9:35And the lasers.
  239. 9:37There are more than twenty-five styles in it.
  240. 9:39Money stories like this one.
  241. 9:41Three D news documentaries.
  242. 9:43Three D cartoon Shorts.
  243. 9:44Minecraft Shorts.
  244. 9:46It was a hundred forty-seven dollars a month, and right now it's eighty-seven.
  245. 9:50But the price is going up as more people join.
  246. 9:53Whatever you join at stays yours.
  247. 9:55And at three hundred members, Overnight closes the doors to the public again.
  248. 10:00Nobody wants the internet flooded with these.
  249. 10:03Three hundred.
  250. 10:04Got it.
  251. 10:04Make fourteen videos in your first thirty days.
  252. 10:07If you're not happy with them, you get your first month back.
  253. 10:10made overnight dot com.
  254. 10:12It's on screen, and it's the first link in the description.
  255. 10:15Now, back to the man with three jobs.
  256. 10:18He can't be in two countries at once.
  257. 10:20And Google's doors are about to notice.
  258. 10:25Google has a second alarm, and it has the best name in security.
  259. 10:29It's called the Impossible Location Signal.
  260. 10:32Impossible Location?
  261. 10:34Your laptop logs in from Beijing.
  262. 10:36Your badge says you're in California.
  263. 10:38Can't be both.
  264. 10:39So the alarm fires.
  265. 10:41So how do you beat it?
  266. 10:42You lend someone your badge.
  267. 10:44November twenty-fourth, twenty twenty-three.
  268. 10:47Leon walks onto a stage in Beijing, at MiraclePlus's big investor day,
  269. 10:52as the chief executive of Zhisuan, a
  270. 10:54ten-million-dollar company with no product.
  271. 10:57His slide says "government agencies" and "supercomputing centers" "will be our
  272. 11:03customers."
  273. 11:03Chief executive now.
  274. 11:05And Google engineer.
  275. 11:07Not tonight.
  276. 11:08And your background?
  277. 11:09Google.
  278. 11:10Does Google know you're here?
  279. 11:12Next slide.
  280. 11:13Back in California, his badge keeps going to work.
  281. 11:16His intern swipes it into his Google office
  282. 11:19on December fourth, sixth and eighth.
  283. 11:21Monday, Wednesday, Friday.
  284. 11:23It's Wednesday.
  285. 11:25I swiped.
  286. 11:26Good.
  287. 11:26Friday too.
  288. 11:28Do I have to do your smile?
  289. 11:30Just swipe.
  290. 11:31And if someone asks where you are?
  291. 11:33Traveling.
  292. 11:34But the badge can't cover everything.
  293. 11:36Two days before the first swipe, on December second, from China,
  294. 11:40Leon uploads more files to a second personal account.
  295. 11:43And this time, Google notices.
  296. 11:46A second account.
  297. 11:47Full of our files.
  298. 11:49Leon.
  299. 11:49On December eighth,
  300. 11:51the investigator who never saw a thing finally asks Leon a simple question.
  301. 11:59Why are our files in your account?
  302. 12:01Evidence of my work.
  303. 12:03These are our chip designs.
  304. 12:05Which I work on.
  305. 12:06And are you planning to leave?
  306. 12:08No.
  307. 12:09He tells Google he has "no intention of
  308. 12:12leaving Google." Then he signs a sworn paper
  309. 12:15saying he has deleted every file.
  310. 12:17It's called a self-deletion affidavit.
  311. 12:20Everything's gone?
  312. 12:21Everything.
  313. 12:22Six days later, on December fourteenth,
  314. 12:24Leon downloads every stolen file to his computer at home.
  315. 12:28The same day, he books a one-way ticket from San Francisco to Beijing,
  316. 12:33for January seventh.
  317. 12:34Six days.
  318. 12:35A carton of milk lasts longer than that promise.
  319. 12:38On December twenty-sixth, he quits by email.
  320. 12:41His last day will be January fifth.
  321. 12:43Hang on.
  322. 12:44Didn't he say he had no intention of leaving?
  323. 12:47Yes.
  324. 12:48When?
  325. 12:48Eighteen days ago.
  326. 12:50Then, on December twenty-ninth, Google finds the keynote.
  327. 12:54The chief executive of a startup in Beijing is one of its own engineers.
  328. 12:58That's Leon.
  329. 13:00Lock it.
  330. 13:00Google cuts off his access and locks his laptop from afar.
  331. 13:04It goes back through his history and finds nineteen months of uploads.
  332. 13:09Then it checks the door cameras, and someone else is holding his badge.
  333. 13:13If Leon was on a stage in Beijing...
  334. 13:16who's been going to work for him?
  335. 13:18Cut off,
  336. 13:19Leon rushes into the office at seven in the morning to get back on the network.
  337. 13:23Come on.
  338. 13:24Come on.
  339. 13:25Okay.
  340. 13:26Plan B.
  341. 13:27It doesn't work.
  342. 13:28So he deletes the files on his laptop.
  343. 13:31He deleted the files?
  344. 13:32From the laptop.
  345. 13:33And the copies in his cloud?
  346. 13:35Forgot those.
  347. 13:36Still on Google's servers.
  348. 13:38Still full.
  349. 13:38On January fourth,
  350. 13:40Google's security team collects his laptop and phone from his home.
  351. 13:44On January sixth, one day before the flight, the FBI is at his door.
  352. 13:49Going somewhere?
  353. 13:50Tomorrow.
  354. 13:51Not anymore.
  355. 13:52A week later, agents open his cloud accounts.
  356. 13:55More than a thousand files, sitting on Google's own servers the whole time.
  357. 14:00Caught, with the note in his hand.
  358. 14:02Now America had to decide what Leon was.
  359. 14:08March sixth, twenty twenty-four.
  360. 14:10The Attorney General of the United States announces one arrest.
  361. 14:14The Justice Department will not tolerate the theft of artificial intelligence and
  362. 14:18other advanced technologies that could put our national security at risk.
  363. 14:22In January twenty twenty-six, Leon goes on trial in San Francisco.
  364. 14:27Eleven days.
  365. 14:28Our note is now Exhibit A.
  366. 14:30His lawyer's best line went after the victim.
  367. 14:33Google chose openness over security.
  368. 14:36Is that a defense?
  369. 14:37It's a complaint about the lock.
  370. 14:39Google's security team takes the stand and walks the jury through the trick: notes
  371. 14:44turned into PDFs, so every upload looked like his own new file.
  372. 14:49To our alarms, it looked like notes.
  373. 14:51It was our chips.
  374. 14:53Then the jury goes out.
  375. 14:54They're back already?
  376. 14:56About three hours.
  377. 14:57For fourteen counts?
  378. 14:59About thirteen minutes a count.
  379. 15:01Guilty on all fourteen counts.
  380. 15:03Seven for stealing trade secrets, and seven for economic espionage.
  381. 15:08The government calls it the first-ever
  382. 15:10conviction on AI-related economic espionage
  383. 15:13charges.
  384. 15:13On paper,
  385. 15:14those counts add up to a hundred and seventy-five years in prison and nearly
  386. 15:19thirty-seven million dollars in fines.
  387. 15:22So when would he get out?
  388. 15:24Around the year twenty-two hundred.
  389. 15:25And the fines?
  390. 15:27About two hundred years of his Rongshu pay.
  391. 15:29But in August, the judge throws out all seven espionage counts.
  392. 15:33For spying,
  393. 15:34the law needs him to mean to help China's government at the moment he stole.
  394. 15:39And the stealing came months before he ever pitched anyone in government.
  395. 15:43So who was he spying for?
  396. 15:45Not Beijing.
  397. 15:46Then who?
  398. 15:47Leon.
  399. 15:48Ding had no product; he was just pretending he had one.
  400. 15:51The judge called the plot to help China "ad hoc, disorganized,
  401. 15:56and feeble." The theft was another matter.
  402. 15:59This was a systematic, brazen effort to steal Google's property.
  403. 16:03On September first, twenty twenty-six, he sentences Leon to twelve months,
  404. 16:08minus one day.
  405. 16:09From a hundred and seventy-five years...
  406. 16:12To three hundred and sixty-four days.
  407. 16:14That's not even a year.
  408. 16:16By one day.
  409. 16:17That's still more than the Apple engineer who took self-driving car secrets to a
  410. 16:22Chinese car startup.
  411. 16:23He got four months.
  412. 16:24Then came the bill.
  413. 16:26In October, America put Zhisuan and MiraclePlus on a sanctions list.
  414. 16:30The startup school's seven-hundred-thousand-dollar
  415. 16:33bet now sits on a blacklist.
  416. 16:35Their money in America is frozen, and no American can invest in them.
  417. 16:40Seven percent of what, exactly?
  418. 16:42Replicate and upgrade?
  419. 16:45Frozen.
  420. 16:45And the case is back in court, on appeal.
  421. 16:50Leon started this story with three jobs.
  422. 16:53Now he has none.
  423. 16:54His own lawyers said he will "never again hold a position of trust at a technology
  424. 17:00company."
  425. 17:00Do you want this back?
  426. 17:02Nowhere left to swipe it.
  427. 17:04Google is spending about two hundred billion dollars this year to build AI.
  428. 17:08That's more than half a billion dollars a day.
  429. 17:11In the time it took to watch this, it spent about six million.
  430. 17:15And the lock on its most valuable recipe was beaten by a notes app, a PDF,
  431. 17:20and an intern with a badge.
  432. 17:21So why did Google hire a Chinese spy?
  433. 17:24It didn't.
  434. 17:25It hired an engineer, handed him the recipe, and trusted him with it.
  435. 17:29The spy showed up three years later, by email.
  436. 17:32The price for trying was three hundred and sixty-four days.
  437. 17:36And Leon got caught because he couldn't stay off a stage.
  438. 17:40So who's still sitting quietly at their desk tonight?
  439. 17:46Me.
  440. 17:46But I'm not copying anything.
  441. 17:48Good.
  442. 17:49Make your own.
  443. 17:50The app this video was made in is open to the public right now,
  444. 17:54at made overnight dot com.
  445. 17:56It was a hundred forty-seven dollars a month, and right now it's eighty-seven.
  446. 18:01But the price is going up as people join,
  447. 18:03and at three hundred members it closes again.
  448. 18:06The link is first in the description.

About this transcript

This page contains the full transcript of Why Google Hired a Chinese Spy by Paper Billions, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 2,858 words across 448 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.

What you can do with it

Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.

Free YouTube transcript tool

YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.