Why Gifted Kids Are Actually Special Needs — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:00so oh boy i sure do love being perceived
- 0:02as a gifted child i hope i don't end up
- 0:04as being a perfectionist perfectionist
- 0:06burnout with
- 0:08burnt out i suppose with depression
- 0:10anxiety unfulfilled expectations and no
- 0:12real interests or goals
- 0:14so this is something that someone
- 0:16cross-posted to our subreddit you know
- 0:17it's a meme we've had a couple of
- 0:19streams about burnout and gifted kids
- 0:24so today what i'd like to talk to you
- 0:25all a little bit about is
- 0:28the pathway from gifted child to burnt
- 0:32out perfectionist
- 0:34as well as sort of the way that society
- 0:37actually sets gifted children up to kind
- 0:39of fail
- 0:41so i know it's kind of interesting but
- 0:42when we think about a gifted child
- 0:45we think about we perceive
- 0:47gifted as an advantage
- 0:49but in my experience working with a lot
- 0:51of gifted children it's not always an
- 0:53advantage and in fact oftentimes it can
- 0:55be a burden
- 0:56and so i've seen this a lot in our
- 0:58community i've worked with a lot of
- 0:59people who kind of fall into that this
- 1:01category i suppose i sort of fall into
- 1:02it as well
- 1:04where i grew up kind of get i'm gifted
- 1:06right so like school was easy for me i
- 1:08was told from a very young age that i
- 1:09was smart
- 1:11i was also kind of held accountable for
- 1:14like not studying right there like i'd
- 1:16kind of like not study very much and
- 1:18maybe get a b plus or an a minus
- 1:21and my teachers would tell my parents
- 1:23the same thing every single
- 1:25parent-teacher conference they'd always
- 1:26say well if all look just applied
- 1:28himself he would be the best student in
- 1:30the class
- 1:31if he only just like
- 1:33studied more he'd be the best student in
- 1:34the class right they were like he's
- 1:35super smart he has a lot of potential
- 1:38right so they use these words like they
- 1:40talk about how smart i am they talk
- 1:41about all the potential i have and if i
- 1:43just applied myself i'd be you know i'd
- 1:45be such a
- 1:46i'd be the best student
- 1:49so it's kind of interesting because we
- 1:50perceive giftedness as an advantage
- 1:53but as one of my teachers once told me
- 1:55we'll kind of get to this towards the
- 1:56end
- 1:57they once explained to me that um this
- 1:59is in in not in medical school but when
- 2:01i was training to become a psychiatrist
- 2:02i had a supervisor who once told me that
- 2:04gifted gifted children or special needs
- 2:06children and what that literally means
- 2:08is that like the needs of a child who's
- 2:11gifted are actually different from the
- 2:13average child and the parents who
- 2:15recognize that and recognize that this
- 2:17child is going to need like a slightly
- 2:19different structure a different
- 2:20curriculum or a different way of being
- 2:22raised are the ones that end up sort of
- 2:24doing a really good job and oddly enough
- 2:26in her clinical experience she found
- 2:29that much like any other special needs
- 2:31children um
- 2:32you know kids that were not
- 2:36treated appropriately despite their
- 2:38gifts were the ones that kind of
- 2:40struggled so this statement when i first
- 2:42heard it i thought was like absolutely
- 2:43ridiculous kind of blew my mind a little
- 2:45bit but i respected the supervisor a lot
- 2:47and i started thinking about it
- 2:49so what i'd like to share with you all
- 2:50today is sort of the pathway that a
- 2:53gifted child takes
- 2:55how a society treats them how parents
- 2:57treat them the kind of struggles they
- 2:59face or the influences that they have
- 3:00let's not even call it a struggle
- 3:01because it may not be a struggle and
- 3:03then sort of how they end up so i'd like
- 3:05to kind of share with that with you all
- 3:06today okay
- 3:08so the first thing that tends to happen
- 3:10is when a child is gifted they
- 3:13te school tends to be easy right so if
- 3:15you kind of think about it
- 3:16developmentally
- 3:17there are a lot of different things that
- 3:18happen in school so let's talk about
- 3:20school so school is a place where you
- 3:22get you socialize right so you get
- 3:24socialization skills it's a place that
- 3:26you learn and people think that school
- 3:28is primarily about learning and it is
- 3:30primarily about learning but it's just
- 3:31not about
- 3:32learning that the subject material so
- 3:34sure we learn like arithmetic and
- 3:36mathematics and all that kind of stuff
- 3:38we learn history and science and all
- 3:39that good stuff
- 3:41but really school if you kind of look at
- 3:42it developmentally is a wonderful
- 3:44opportunity to learn certain key things
- 3:47socialization is a really important
- 3:49piece the other thing is like habits and
- 3:52how to study and this is the first sort
- 3:54of disadvantage that i think gifted
- 3:55children sort of face
- 3:57is that you know if you're young and
- 3:58you're gifted school is so easy that you
- 4:01sort of get by without the luxury of
- 4:03studying and so we kind of perceive this
- 4:06as an advantage right like if you have
- 4:07to if you go through school and you
- 4:09don't study like that's easy like it's
- 4:11easy easy clap right
- 4:13and so it is and that sort of makes
- 4:15sense
- 4:16but the the interesting thing that i
- 4:18found is that oftentimes being
- 4:20intelligent especially when you're super
- 4:22young as a kid actually sets you up for
- 4:24failure down the road because you never
- 4:27need to learn
- 4:28the habituated study like
- 4:31technique that you kind of need to that
- 4:33that you need to succeed later on so for
- 4:35a normal kid what tends to happen is
- 4:37like they don't have to study like in
- 4:38first grade but maybe like second grade
- 4:39third grade they have to learn how to
- 4:41study like once a week maybe they like
- 4:43learn how to study the night before the
- 4:45test because it doesn't come easily to
- 4:46them
- 4:47and then fourth grade fifth grade now
- 4:49you're you're doing homework a couple
- 4:50days a week you know you're studying two
- 4:52or three days before the test then you
- 4:54kind of hit middle school where maybe
- 4:55you're studying like four days before
- 4:57the test and so there's this very
- 4:58graduated sense of increasing
- 5:01responsibility as you go further and
- 5:03further in school
- 5:04and it's sort of designed that way right
- 5:06we're not like no teacher has a six six
- 5:09year old that they're like giving 14
- 5:11hours of homework a week to it's just
- 5:13absurd and then at the top end of the
- 5:15spectrum in terms of study habits and
- 5:17what we demand of students you have
- 5:18something like let's say law school or
- 5:20medical school or things like that where
- 5:21people are regular studying like 60
- 5:24hours a week 80 hours a week in medical
- 5:25school because you know people have have
- 5:28grown up and have built enough of a
- 5:30study habit where they can actually
- 5:32handle that pace of study
- 5:34so what happens with the gifted kid so
- 5:36the gifted kid you know when you sort of
- 5:38level up your skill to level one like in
- 5:41the first grade and then you level up
- 5:42your studying skill to level two in the
- 5:44second grade and level three in the
- 5:45third grade so the gifted kid never
- 5:47actually has to like grind that xp for
- 5:50levels like one through five of studying
- 5:52habits
- 5:53and so they sort of managed to get b's
- 5:55or a's without really minimal with
- 5:57minimal studying or no studying at all
- 5:59and then seventh grade rolls around
- 6:01eighth grade rolls around they start to
- 6:02struggle a little bit maybe they get b's
- 6:04they're still not learning how to study
- 6:05because they sort of skipped that part
- 6:07of of the you know the skill building
- 6:10and we'll kind of get to that later and
- 6:12then what tends to happen with gifted
- 6:13kids is that they don't need to study
- 6:15don't need to study don't need to study
- 6:16and then they hit a wall
- 6:18they finally get into some kind of
- 6:20situation where their raw intellect
- 6:22cannot
- 6:24is no longer sufficient to handle the
- 6:26schoolwork that they're supposed to
- 6:28handle
- 6:28but they've trained themselves at that
- 6:30point they've customized themselves at
- 6:32that point to managing school with raw
- 6:35intellect
- 6:36and so when that kind of falls short
- 6:38they like they really kind of really hit
- 6:40a wall it's a very very hard cliff to to
- 6:44overcome
- 6:45and so this is kind of the first thing
- 6:46that that sort of shoots gifted kids in
- 6:48the foot and this also leads to kind of
- 6:50this idea of perfectionism and burnout
- 6:52because then they like you know then
- 6:53they they struggle a lot they don't
- 6:55understand why they can't do it they
- 6:56they try they know they're smart
- 6:58everyone's talking to them about
- 6:59potential they start to feel really bad
- 7:01about themselves so the first kind of
- 7:03interesting thing that gifted kids run
- 7:04into is the fact that they sort of don't
- 7:07develop the proper study habits because
- 7:09you know as a six-year-old it's kind of
- 7:10not your fault because like you're not
- 7:12mature enough as a six-year-old to
- 7:14realize like oh i need you know to have
- 7:16good study habits so even though the
- 7:18teacher said this last tuesday and i
- 7:20understand that i don't need to study
- 7:21i'm going to sit down and like practice
- 7:22my study habits it doesn't make any
- 7:24sense it's like completely artificial
- 7:26so that's the first thing that happens
- 7:28is that they kind of hit this wall of of
- 7:30you know not being able to study
- 7:32the second thing to consider is the
- 7:34expectation so another thing that really
- 7:36leads gifted kids kind of down the wrong
- 7:38path is
- 7:40the burden of expectation that's placed
- 7:42upon them so from a very young age
- 7:44they're told oh you're gifted you're
- 7:45smart you're special you have so much
- 7:47potential and so what that starts to do
- 7:49is it constructs like a very very lofty
- 7:52goal in their minds right so i'm going
- 7:54to use kind of an analogy which is kind
- 7:56of like you know if i think about an
- 7:59amazing home like i think about a
- 8:01mansion it can have a beautiful
- 8:03blueprint and i can buy a gigantic piece
- 8:05of land and i can look at that and i can
- 8:07say like oh like this this home or this
- 8:09this blueprint has so much potential
- 8:12and sometimes we kind of forget that
- 8:14like
- 8:15you can have like you can have a
- 8:16blueprint for a mansion but that's gonna
- 8:18actually take way more work to achieve
- 8:21than like building a shack so the other
- 8:24really interesting thing that that we
- 8:26sort of kind of get wrong societally is
- 8:28that we assume that when someone is
- 8:30gifted
- 8:31things are actually going to be easier
- 8:33for them that they need to work less to
- 8:35accomplish the same amount
- 8:37but in my experience living up to a
- 8:39gifted child's potential involves more
- 8:42work it's sort of like you know it's
- 8:44just like building a shack versus
- 8:46building a mansion like sure the mansion
- 8:48is capable of so much more than the shaq
- 8:50is capable of but let's not forget for a
- 8:53moment that the amount of effort that it
- 8:55goes into building a mansion is actually
- 8:57way more than what's required to build a
- 8:59shack this is the second place that
- 9:01gifted kids kind of get tripped up
- 9:02because everyone around
- 9:04is looking at them and they're sort of
- 9:05saying
- 9:06oh like this is an amazing mansion like
- 9:08you could build such an amazing mansion
- 9:10and we all kind of forget for a moment
- 9:12that like actually living up to that
- 9:14potential is very very difficult and
- 9:16requires a lot more of an investment
- 9:18than building a shack
- 9:20and so this gap between what people
- 9:23expect of you and also the idea that
- 9:25things should be easier for you
- 9:27kind of compound on themselves and sort
- 9:30of end up with gifted kids kind of
- 9:32feeling like they're they're failing at
- 9:33everything right because they have all
- 9:34this potential
- 9:36and they're not they're just not living
- 9:38up to it
- 9:39so the other thing that we'll see in
- 9:40gifted kids is that what what tends to
- 9:42happen is that they will put in some
- 9:44amount of work
- 9:46but they're expecting a mansion when
- 9:49all they've really put in is as much as
- 9:51building a shack
- 9:52i may have lost you a little bit there
- 9:54but let me just explain
- 9:56so
- 9:56you know what a gifted kid will do is
- 9:58they'll like look at their peers right
- 9:59and they'll say like oh like this person
- 10:01did this and they're able to accomplish
- 10:02this so like i should be able to do that
- 10:04too and so if you look at your neighbors
- 10:06who are building a shack and they're
- 10:07like whoa they went to home depot and
- 10:09they got like 100 pounds of wood and
- 10:11they built their shack over a weekend
- 10:13and then like you go and get your 100
- 10:15pounds of wood from home depot and you
- 10:16start like brought to you by home depot
- 10:19i suppose um and you start building your
- 10:21mansion like i know it sounds kind of
- 10:23weird but you know 100 pounds of wood
- 10:25may be enough to build a shack but it's
- 10:26nowhere near enough to build a mansion
- 10:28and then what gifted kids will do is
- 10:30they'll look at like the foundation that
- 10:31they've laid with a hundred pounds of
- 10:32wood and they'll be like where's the i
- 10:34don't even have a shack like you know
- 10:36it's it's like they look at what they've
- 10:38accomplished when they put in the same
- 10:39amount of energy as someone else and
- 10:41they get really confused because this
- 10:42person has a complete shack over here
- 10:44and like i have like barely the
- 10:46beginnings of a mansion and so then that
- 10:48sort of negatively impacts them they
- 10:50start to like feel like they're actually
- 10:52inferior to these other people because
- 10:53they've been told oh you're smarter than
- 10:55the kid next door like why the hell is
- 10:56the kid next door getting into college
- 10:58and like you're not even getting into
- 10:59college and so it all sort of sort of
- 11:01sort of compounds right because even for
- 11:03the gifted kid they're not trying to
- 11:05build a shack because they've been told
- 11:06they've been they're gifted their entire
- 11:07life so it's not enough to be average if
- 11:10you're gifted so what you have to do is
- 11:12you try to you know build a mansion
- 11:13because that's what you've been
- 11:15told that you're capable of that's the
- 11:17expectation you set for yourself and
- 11:19then you're you're left kind of
- 11:20scratching your head and wondering like
- 11:22why you don't even have a shack yet even
- 11:24though you studied for a month and they
- 11:26studied for a month you're not getting
- 11:27as much as that they're getting
- 11:30and it's kind of super bizarre right
- 11:31because we don't we just don't think
- 11:32about it that way we think that if
- 11:34you're gifted that means that everything
- 11:35should be easier for you that it not
- 11:37only they may need a hundred pounds of
- 11:39wood to build a shack but you should be
- 11:41able to build a shack and 50 pounds of
- 11:42wood it should be easier for you but it
- 11:45turns out paradoxically being harder
- 11:47and then we sort of end up with kind of
- 11:49the final state of a gifted kid which if
- 11:51we kind of think about it internally is
- 11:53a state of like really shame and low
- 11:55self-esteem so all this stuff kind of
- 11:57compounds right like you're told you're
- 11:59smart so you set this expectation of
- 12:01what you're capable of like way up here
- 12:03and then like you know first grade goes
- 12:05by and you're up here second grade goes
- 12:07by and you're up here third grade goes
- 12:08by and you're up here boom boom boom
- 12:10fourth grade fifth grade sixth grade
- 12:1210th grade 11th grade and then you kind
- 12:14of tank right and as you go to college
- 12:17suddenly like you don't have the study
- 12:18skills involved and now in the gap
- 12:20between what you're capable of and what
- 12:23you actually accomplish this gap is
- 12:26where shame comes from this is the shame
- 12:28gap that gifted kids inevitably fall
- 12:30into
- 12:31which is when they fall short of what
- 12:32their expectations are and this could be
- 12:35once again
- 12:36due to the fact that you're you know
- 12:38you're setting out to build a mansion
- 12:40and you ended up not even building a
- 12:42shack right so all of these
- 12:44discrepancies between your expectations
- 12:46and your accomplishments
- 12:48in that gap and the bigger the gap is
- 12:50the more it's filled with shame
- 12:52so then what happens is kids are ashamed
- 12:54right because they should be doing more
- 12:56they should be doing better
- 12:58and then like the shame then further
- 13:00compounds and makes it hard to find
- 13:02motivation and this is where you kind of
- 13:03get burnout so then like you have these
- 13:05gifted kids and you're like hey man just
- 13:06like go to a community college you don't
- 13:08have to go to an ivy league school
- 13:09school you don't have to go to like
- 13:10harvard or stanford or mit just like go
- 13:12to your local community college and in
- 13:14that comes a bunch of shame because
- 13:16you've been told your entire life that
- 13:18you're better than that right
- 13:20and so you start to develop this ego
- 13:22of being a super smart kid and then this
- 13:25leads to avoidance of things because all
- 13:27you're left with is the identity of a
- 13:29smart kid so you can never even bring
- 13:31yourself to go to community college
- 13:32because smart kids don't go to community
- 13:35college in your mind that's where the
- 13:37stupid kids go and if you go to
- 13:39community college then suddenly you've
- 13:40lived your entire life for 20 years
- 13:42being told you're a smart kid it's the
- 13:44only that's your biggest strength it's
- 13:45the one that everyone keeps talking
- 13:46about and now like suddenly you have to
- 13:48relegate yourself to being a stupid kid
- 13:51and in that gap is where the shame lives
- 13:53in that gap is where the ego lives okay
- 13:57so it's really really hard right because
- 13:59you're set up with these expectations
- 14:01people don't really acknowledge that
- 14:03because you're capable of a lot it's
- 14:05actually going to take like a lot of
- 14:07work to take that potential and bring it
- 14:09to fruition
- 14:11right and that's like that's the biggest
- 14:12thing is people just lose sight of the
- 14:14fact that building a mansion actually
- 14:16takes more work than building a shack
- 14:18and your entire life people have told
- 14:20you like you should build this mansion
- 14:21because that's what you're capable of
- 14:24and so then we kind of get to all right
- 14:26so like what do we do about it right so
- 14:27if you're a gifted kid who's kind of
- 14:28perfectionistic and burnt out and like
- 14:30society has sort of set you up this way
- 14:32i'm not saying that you're not
- 14:33individually responsible as well but i
- 14:35do think that there's a whole reason so
- 14:37when we have like a generation of burnt
- 14:40out gifted kids i think we have to be
- 14:42fair and be a little bit scientific and
- 14:44kind of acknowledge that this may not be
- 14:46like an individual problem right we've
- 14:48got a generation of kids like this like
- 14:50maybe there's something societal going
- 14:52on and i think paradoxically we sort of
- 14:54set these kids up to
- 14:56struggle and so then the question
- 14:59becomes okay like what do we do about it
- 15:01so the first thing you should do if
- 15:02you're a gifted kid is to stop
- 15:04comparison right like comparison is is
- 15:07the foundation of getting out of this
- 15:09problem
- 15:10because as long as you are comparing
- 15:11yourself and this is part of the issue
- 15:13is that if you think about the word
- 15:15gifted
- 15:16what does the word gifted imply it is a
- 15:18word that has no meaning
- 15:20outside of a comparative framework you
- 15:23guys get that the only way you can be
- 15:25gifted is if there are other people who
- 15:27are not gifted
- 15:28and so essentially what happens is like
- 15:30the whole idea of a gifted kid only
- 15:33exists in relationship to another kid
- 15:36and so what we find in the minds of
- 15:38gifted kids is that they're comparing
- 15:40themselves all the time oh i don't want
- 15:42to go to community college that's where
- 15:43the stupid people go oh i don't know
- 15:45like why i can't do what my friend is
- 15:47capable of like he's able to do so much
- 15:49why am i not able to do so much i have
- 15:51an older sibling who did fantastic
- 15:53and now i have big shoes to fill right
- 15:56there's so much comparison all of the
- 15:58expectations that gifted kids have don't
- 16:01come from themselves
- 16:02right because if you actually based your
- 16:04expectations on what you're capable of
- 16:06you'd be capable of a b c d or an f
- 16:10that's what that would be a realistic
- 16:12expectation but instead you create these
- 16:14artificial expectations that are based
- 16:16on comparison and why do gifted kids do
- 16:18that because it starts with their
- 16:19parents it starts with their teachers
- 16:21we're all told that we're gifted which
- 16:23is by definition a comparison to all of
- 16:26the other kids
- 16:27and so then what happens is you're
- 16:28looking over at the shack and you've got
- 16:30this blueprint for a mansion and they
- 16:32give you some wood and then you try to
- 16:34build the mansion and like you don't
- 16:35even have a roof when this person has a
- 16:37completely built shack and then you kind
- 16:39of look at yourself well like man i must
- 16:40be like a super idiot right like and
- 16:42it's just it's so bizarre that when we
- 16:44set up this kind of when we start with
- 16:46this framework of a comparison
- 16:48we sort of doom ourselves to failure
- 16:50because there's like we're just
- 16:52it's just it's never going to work
- 16:53because you can't ever
- 16:55base the expectations of your life and
- 16:58what you're capable of based on what
- 16:59someone else is doing
- 17:01right if someone else is happy studying
- 17:03chemical engineering it doesn't mean
- 17:05that you're going to be happy studying
- 17:06chemical engineering if somebody else is
- 17:09happy dating someone of the opposite sex
- 17:10it doesn't mean that you're going to be
- 17:11happy dating someone of the opposite sex
- 17:14the whole point is as individuals as
- 17:16humans we're individuals and if you're a
- 17:18gifted kid the first thing you've got to
- 17:19do is let go of all comparison
- 17:23so next thing is to
- 17:25recognize that your road is going to be
- 17:28a rough one right so like when someone
- 17:29sets out to build a mansion they know in
- 17:32their mind that like this is gonna take
- 17:34a while right
- 17:35you can't expect to build a mansion in
- 17:38the same amount of time it would take
- 17:39someone to build a shack
- 17:41and so if you're a gifted kid and you
- 17:43expect a lot from yourself
- 17:45okay
- 17:46recognize that this is going to be a
- 17:48long road and the greater your potential
- 17:50is the longer it's going to take for you
- 17:52to get there and this is something that
- 17:54i can understand in hindsight like so i
- 17:56grew up as a gifted kid and was like in
- 17:59you know the special classes or whatever
- 18:01i actually still remember when i was in
- 18:03eighth grade my grades started to dip
- 18:05and when i went to high school
- 18:08um i didn't qualify for based on my
- 18:11grades like my high school was like yeah
- 18:13he needs to be in like regular english
- 18:15he can't be in like advanced english or
- 18:16he doesn't meet the criteria for
- 18:17advanced english and so my parents were
- 18:19really really not happy with that
- 18:21because they have they have such a smart
- 18:22boy you know he's so smart he just needs
- 18:25to apply himself so they went to the
- 18:26school and i remember having a meeting
- 18:27with the the honors english teacher or
- 18:30whatever and then he's like do you want
- 18:31to be in this class and i was like yeah
- 18:32i want to be in the class and my parents
- 18:33were like yeah he should be he belongs
- 18:35he belongs in the class
- 18:37right and so the teacher was like okay
- 18:38fine because you know
- 18:40i mean you're not gonna you know there
- 18:42are some parents that could potentially
- 18:43be annoying so you're like whatever
- 18:45and so i ended up being in the class
- 18:46that i really didn't belong and i really
- 18:48didn't do very well
- 18:49right because i didn't have the work
- 18:50ethic but it propagates sort of this
- 18:53idea of like you can handle it
- 18:56so like i started off you know going on
- 18:58the wrong track kind of like in in high
- 19:00school it took me
- 19:02i took me five years to graduate from
- 19:04college right with a 2.5 gpa
- 19:07took me another three or four years to
- 19:09even get into medical school
- 19:11and so like my road has been long
- 19:14and like that's just sometimes what it
- 19:16takes if you're a gifted kid right you
- 19:18take the scenic route in life so
- 19:20oftentimes people would ask me you know
- 19:22like
- 19:23about stuff
- 19:24when i remember when i was going to when
- 19:26i started medical school and i saw
- 19:27friends of mine right who were who i was
- 19:29in high school with they're already
- 19:30fully trained doctors and you know
- 19:32flying around and all that good stuff
- 19:34and i'm just like starting medical
- 19:35school and i was like yeah i took the
- 19:36scenic route in life and so recognize
- 19:39that if you're a gifted kid like it's a
- 19:40long road like you're not going to do
- 19:42things faster you're not going to build
- 19:44a mansion
- 19:45as fast as someone else is going to
- 19:47build a shack the other thing to
- 19:48recognize about it being a long road if
- 19:50you're a gifted kid is don't expect to
- 19:53see the form of your mansion for a long
- 19:56time
- 19:57when other people have built their
- 19:59shacks you will still just have the
- 20:01foundation of the mansion it's not going
- 20:03to have a roof for a long time it's not
- 20:04going to have windows for a long time so
- 20:06this is the other problem that gifted
- 20:07kids run into
- 20:08is as they put in an equal amount of
- 20:11effort compared to their colleagues they
- 20:13actually see less return on their
- 20:15investment and that in turn shatters
- 20:18their motivation and what makes them
- 20:20want to give up
- 20:21right because i'm putting in all this
- 20:22effort i'm still not seeing anything yet
- 20:24so it's a long road be patient with
- 20:26yourself and try your best not to
- 20:28compare to other people
- 20:30the last thing to kind of consider is
- 20:32that is the shame so gifted kids
- 20:34oftentimes struggle a lot with
- 20:35self-esteem and shame and that once
- 20:37again is because their expectations are
- 20:39up here and their performance is down
- 20:41here right
- 20:42and so in that gap is where your shame
- 20:45is going to live
- 20:46and so as long as there is a gap in what
- 20:48you expect from yourself
- 20:50with what you accomplish
- 20:52you will have shame and the solution to
- 20:55that oddly enough is one of two ways
- 20:57right
- 20:57one is you can actually
- 20:59live up to the expectations that you
- 21:01have right so you can actually shoot up
- 21:03here and land up here so you can go to
- 21:05an ivy league school or whatever right
- 21:07you can go you can start
- 21:09you can do a tech startup or whatever
- 21:11like you can like
- 21:12do everything that everyone has always
- 21:14known you're capable of doing so you can
- 21:16actually hit all of those metrics that's
- 21:18one option then the shame will go away
- 21:20or what you can do is let go of your
- 21:22expectations
- 21:23and bring yourself down here because the
- 21:25shame exists in the gap so even if you
- 21:28accept yourself as being like sort of a
- 21:30failure oddly enough the shame will go
- 21:33away and as you accept yourself as you
- 21:36are which is not wasted potential but
- 21:39like in the present like you are
- 21:41everything that you're capable of
- 21:42everything that you've ever been capable
- 21:44of is exactly what you've achieved and
- 21:46once you sort of take that attitude
- 21:48bring your expectations down to here you
- 21:50will be amazed at like what happens to
- 21:52your motivation and what you are truly
- 21:54capable of
- 21:55but you can't achieve it as long as
- 21:57there is that shame gap right like in
- 22:00terms of performance
- 22:03so questions
- 22:06anyway so let me just kind of summarize
- 22:08so i think that like
- 22:10you know we see this a lot where a lot
- 22:12of people are gifted
- 22:13and we think of that as an advantage but
- 22:15like i was saying earlier
- 22:17i think that
- 22:18you know sometimes being gifted comes
- 22:21with its own set of needs
- 22:24and by properly addressing those needs
- 22:26we can avoid some of these things like
- 22:27gifted kids you know feeling ashamed of
- 22:29themselves gifted kids
- 22:32you know not like comparing themselves
- 22:34to like all the other normal kids and
- 22:36and finding themselves lacking
- 22:38um and also that we have to kind of
- 22:40acknowledge that our school system is
- 22:42sort of set up in a particular way that
- 22:44oftentimes causes gifted kids to stumble
- 22:47and through understanding like how a
- 22:49gifted kid you know a child who is
- 22:51gifted becomes an adult who's
- 22:53perfectionistic and burnt out
- 22:55we have to understand that whole life
- 22:57cycle in order to sort of
- 22:59start taking steps to change it
- 23:04um
- 23:09okay so i'm sure you've been asked this
- 23:11question before and have answered before
- 23:12so feel free to tell me where i can
- 23:14finally answer this question how are you
- 23:16able to get accepted to harvard medical
- 23:17school let alone medical school alone
- 23:19with such a low gpa when that is such a
- 23:21critical deciding factor
- 23:23how did i stand out so that's a great
- 23:25question so the short answer is so i i
- 23:27did some amount of graduate education so
- 23:29i did a master's degree to boost my gpa
- 23:32the second thing that i did i didn't go
- 23:33to harvard for medical school i went to
- 23:36tufts for medical school and then i did
- 23:38my psychiatry training at harvard at
- 23:40mass general mclean hospital
- 23:42and so the short answer of like how i
- 23:44wound up there is like one step at a
- 23:46time
- 23:47so you have to do you know in each of
- 23:49those things involved like
- 23:53a reality check or some degree of
- 23:55humility in terms of like thinking like
- 23:57i actually don't belong at harvard like
- 24:00i'm never going to wind up there i had
- 24:01to accept that right let alone get into
- 24:03medical school
- 24:04and the more that i accepted like i i
- 24:06did a lot of things that were you know
- 24:10humbling to say the least i wouldn't
- 24:12quite say undignified but i had to
- 24:14really let go of a lot of ego and like
- 24:16take one step at a time it also took
- 24:17perseverance i mean i applied to 120
- 24:19medical schools before i got into a
- 24:21single one and that was the break that i
- 24:23needed
- 24:24and then like understanding having all
- 24:26that failure behind me i really
- 24:28worked hard in medical school
- 24:31and really tried to excel
- 24:33and then i actually did an away rotation
- 24:35for those of you don't know what that is
- 24:37or for those of you do know what that is
- 24:39so i basically did an audition rotation
- 24:41at harvard which is like super
- 24:42competitive you show up there with a
- 24:44bunch of other people who want to go
- 24:45there and it's basically like a test
- 24:47it's like a month-long test of what
- 24:49you're capable of and i did really well
- 24:52so thankfully i had set up you know a
- 24:53lot of good stuff over the last
- 24:56eight years
- 24:57in terms of being myself and like owning
- 24:59the person that i was and not being
- 25:01ashamed of the fact that i failed
- 25:02and you know recognizing that most of
- 25:04the students most of the other students
- 25:06who were auditioning
- 25:08um were four years younger than i was
- 25:10that i was actually older than some of
- 25:11the residents there
- 25:13despite the fact that like they were
- 25:14evaluating me right so like there's
- 25:16someone two years younger who's like
- 25:18giving me a grade
- 25:20so navigating all that stuff was
- 25:21difficult but i did a good job at it and
- 25:23stayed focused and that's how i wound up
- 25:25at harvard so i trained there for four
- 25:27years and that's where i'm faculty now
- 25:33right but it's all about like letting go
- 25:35of the ego
- 25:45um how do you lower expectations
- 25:49uh you lower expectations by accepting
- 25:52what you're capable of
- 25:54like actually and so expectation and and
- 25:57acceptance are at opposite ends of the
- 25:59spectrum
- 26:00okay so
- 26:01practicing acceptance
- 26:03is
- 26:05how you lower expectations
- 26:07so let me give you guys an example so
- 26:09the theme today is
- 26:11right so like let me think about a nyani
- 26:13yoga exercise to let go of expectations
- 26:16um
- 26:21let me just think about this for a
- 26:22second
- 26:29so here's a good example of a nyani yoga
- 26:31exercise actually i don't know if this
- 26:32is a good example
- 26:34this is one of the ones that i feel less
- 26:35confident this is maybe a bad example of
- 26:37a yoga exercise
- 26:39so for the next
- 26:41month or two months
- 26:42when you go to a restaurant
- 26:47and someone asks you what you want to
- 26:49want what you want to order just tell
- 26:50the waiter to surprise you
- 26:54just tell them surprise me
- 26:56and then pay attention
- 26:58to your enjoyment or lack of enjoyment
- 27:01of the food
- 27:04right so when we go to restaurants
- 27:06we have expectations and if we think
- 27:09about the least
- 27:10the worst experience that you can have
- 27:12at a restaurant is not actually to have
- 27:14bad food
- 27:15it's to expect really good food and get
- 27:18bad food that's actually worse than
- 27:19getting bad food if you know a
- 27:20restaurant is crap and you go there and
- 27:22you order something the food that you
- 27:23get is crap like what were you expecting
- 27:25it's totally fine actually right we do
- 27:27that every day like if you go to a fast
- 27:28food like mcdonald's or taco bell or
- 27:30whatever like you're not expecting you
- 27:32know like a gourmet meal you're just
- 27:34expecting some like mediocre arguably
- 27:36incredibly tasty
- 27:38depending on whether you're getting a
- 27:39mexican pizza or not
- 27:40which you can't get anymore because
- 27:42they're out of
- 27:43sad
- 27:44but
- 27:45so like a lot of if you guys want to
- 27:46really understand so this is the way
- 27:48that nyanio works if you really want to
- 27:50understand expectation and acceptance
- 27:53you have to put yourself in situations
- 27:55that are like free from expectation
- 27:58and you can't put yourself in a
- 27:59situation because the expectation
- 28:01doesn't come from the situation right
- 28:04it's even that's
- 28:06even what i said was kind of wrong
- 28:07you have to practice
- 28:10messing with your expectations so go to
- 28:11restaurant just say surprise me
- 28:14or you can ask if they don't know like
- 28:15if they're taking it back you can say
- 28:16what's good here okay i'll take that
- 28:19right if you've got dietary restrictions
- 28:20tell them about the dietary restrictions
- 28:23and just like and then you're like but
- 28:25what if i don't like the food that i get
- 28:27well yeah i mean that's the point right
- 28:29so like just eat what you get and see
- 28:31what happens
- 28:33and they're like but i don't like it and
- 28:34it's like yes so like pay attention to
- 28:36that and be like how hard is it for you
- 28:38to order food that you're not gonna like
- 28:40or you order without expectations what's
- 28:42it like to go to a restaurant and accept
- 28:45that you're going to just get some
- 28:46random pile of food that could be
- 28:48amazing and could be something that you
- 28:49really dislike
- 28:51that's how you gain acceptance that's
- 28:53how you let go of expectations by
- 28:55literally going to a restaurant and like
- 28:57actively letting them go
- 28:58that is the nyani yog
- 29:00and then you may discover all kinds of
- 29:02cool things right you may even discover
- 29:03for example that if you go to the
- 29:06restaurant and you expect
- 29:08crap if you're like this is going to be
- 29:10an absolute train wreck i'm gonna have
- 29:12to go home and like have a bowl of
- 29:14cereal after the meal
- 29:17it'll be really interesting
- 29:20how much you enjoy your meal it'll be
- 29:22really interesting because in that
- 29:23moment what you're doing is letting go
- 29:25of the expectation
- 29:27right and then like suddenly even if you
- 29:29get crap it's not a big deal and if you
- 29:31get something delicious it's like such a
- 29:33huge win and that's what it means to let
- 29:35go of expectation the more you let go of
- 29:38expectation the more you start to enjoy
- 29:39life and the better life gets
- 29:41it's kind of bizarre
- 29:43so literally if you guys wanted nyani
- 29:44yoga practice to let go of expectations
- 29:47and earn acceptance and you can't just
- 29:48do this once right so you can't like
- 29:51wuss out of it
- 29:52you have to do it for a month
- 29:55presuming you're going to go out to eat
- 29:56you know and you can afford that and all
- 29:58that good stuff
- 29:59otherwise like make it three months
- 30:01like
- 30:02you know do it for a while like commit
- 30:04yourself this is my life now gg get
- 30:06wrecked noobs
- 30:09so
- 30:15try it you guys want to learn nyan yog
- 30:17try it
- 30:23okay someone else is asking how should a
- 30:24parent teacher or manager support the
- 30:26special needs of gifted people if what's
- 30:29happening now is bad that's a great
- 30:31question so i'll give you an example
- 30:34so sometimes i get parents that come
- 30:35into my office
- 30:38they have a kid who's addicted to video
- 30:39games why is a kid addicted to video
- 30:41games really simple
- 30:44because video games match the pace of
- 30:46the child right that's why that's why
- 30:47gifted kids in a nutshell the reason
- 30:49that gifted kids get addicted to video
- 30:51games is one very very very simple
- 30:53reason can all be reduced to this
- 30:55games match the pace of the child and
- 30:57school doesn't
- 30:58so you've got a kid goes to school gets
- 31:01a worksheet does the worksheet i still
- 31:03remember i i had this experience i
- 31:04skipped the first grade so this is what
- 31:06happened
- 31:08i went to a school
- 31:10where you know i'd do a worksheet and
- 31:11then like they'd give me another one and
- 31:13so in in my first day of first grade i
- 31:15moved schools i i gave them you know i
- 31:18got a worksheet i did the worksheet i
- 31:19gave it back to them and i said can i
- 31:21have the next one and she's like what do
- 31:23you mean the next one it's like the next
- 31:24one like whatever's next like i'm done
- 31:26with this we've got class for another 45
- 31:28minutes i'm done with this can i have
- 31:29the next one she's like there is no next
- 31:31one i'm like what
- 31:33and it didn't take long where like you
- 31:35know she gave me the then she evaluated
- 31:37me and i got moved up a grade but same
- 31:38problem there
- 31:40and then eventually like what heck is
- 31:41like school moves at the pace of like
- 31:42the slowest person now here's the really
- 31:45addictive thing about a video game now
- 31:46imagine you're just bored at school
- 31:48because it's moving at a snail's pace
- 31:50right because there's like other
- 31:51six-year-olds and like you're a
- 31:52six-year-old two and maybe you're a
- 31:53little smarter than the other
- 31:54six-year-olds now enter a video game
- 31:57what happens when you don't beat level
- 31:59one
- 32:00you replay level one and what happens
- 32:02when you beat level one you go straight
- 32:04to level two and if you beat level two
- 32:06you go straight to level three you beat
- 32:07level three you go straight to level
- 32:09four
- 32:10so games perfectly match
- 32:12the challenge
- 32:14that a human being is capable of right
- 32:17if you get stuck on a boss in dark souls
- 32:19like
- 32:19you don't get to move past the boss
- 32:22because your parents make a phone call
- 32:24to from software and they're like hey my
- 32:26son is really good at video games can
- 32:27you please advance him past this boss
- 32:29and stick him to the next boss it's like
- 32:31you can't do that in dark souls like
- 32:33dark souls doesn't give a
- 32:35right
- 32:36so like kids get addicted to video games
- 32:39because they perfectly match what you're
- 32:42capable of which is exactly what kids
- 32:44like there's this whole thing called
- 32:45intent to mastery we teach all this
- 32:47stuff to parents and things like that
- 32:50so what do you do if you've got a kid
- 32:51who's gifted you challenge them and you
- 32:53don't rely on school to do it for you so
- 32:56when parents come to me and they're like
- 32:58i have a kid who's addicted to video
- 32:59games he's 16. he thinks school is i ask
- 33:01him okay what do you think about schools
- 33:03like school is boring
- 33:04then what i do is i you know i make a
- 33:06couple of phone calls and i'm like we're
- 33:07gonna like you so we were i was back
- 33:09when i was in boston a lot of cool
- 33:11startups in boston so what i'll do is
- 33:12we'll make some phone calls we'll stick
- 33:14them in an internship somewhere like
- 33:15we'll take some college-level internship
- 33:17it's some kind of startup so like we'll
- 33:19look around at like incubators from like
- 33:21mit or whatever like harvard will be
- 33:23like hey like there's a kid do you guys
- 33:26have any internship opportunities
- 33:27available and we'll stick him there and
- 33:29he'll like be he'll work there for the
- 33:30summer and it like turns the kid right
- 33:32around no more video games because he's
- 33:34actually like learning so i stuck one
- 33:36kid in this startup that was
- 33:38that there's an app you take a picture
- 33:41of a mole on your body and it tells you
- 33:42the percentage chance that the mole is
- 33:44cancerous
- 33:45right so we stick the kid there we're
- 33:47like go help them
- 33:49and then like sometimes the kid is like
- 33:51what am i supposed to do like you start
- 33:52by getting them coffee
- 33:54and then maybe you'll learn something
- 33:56and then it's it's actually fantastic
- 33:58like they do they do really well you
- 33:59challenge them right and because the
- 34:00cool thing is that a lot of the startup
- 34:02folks they sort of recognize because
- 34:03some of them are like misfits too so
- 34:06they're like okay there's like a kid
- 34:07here like let's put them to work because
- 34:08they recognize that okay you're 16. so
- 34:10you know how to like manage sql data
- 34:12databases and the kid is like no they're
- 34:14like
- 34:15google it
- 34:16and learn and then you're going to
- 34:18manage our sql database next week
- 34:20and the kid is like what and like yeah
- 34:22and then suddenly the kid is like goes
- 34:23home he's not playing video games he's
- 34:24like reading about sql databases
- 34:27or whatever
- 34:28right just just stick them stick them
- 34:30into it and challenge them
- 34:32so as a parent you know or a teacher
- 34:34like i'd say like ask them so here's the
- 34:36biggest mistake that parents and
- 34:37teachers make with gifted children
- 34:40is that you
- 34:41when when a gifted child fails what we
- 34:44tend to do is slow down instead what you
- 34:46need to do is speed up it's absolutely
- 34:48terrifying so if a gifted child is
- 34:50failing what they need more than
- 34:52anything else is a bigger challenge not
- 34:54like an easier environment now you have
- 34:56to make sure for a couple of other
- 34:57things like you need to make sure
- 34:58there's not adhd going on depression
- 35:00going on learning disabilities or other
- 35:03things like that going on but in the
- 35:05absence of all of those things challenge
- 35:07them more not less
- 35:09ask them to do more give them put them
- 35:10in positions of leadership
- 35:12right
- 35:13and just push them
- 35:15because like it's so fulfilling when
- 35:17when you're a take a kid in that
- 35:19situation and you're like
- 35:21you're gonna need to do this thing and
- 35:22they're like i can't do that thing and
- 35:24you're like okay so then fail
- 35:25but try if you fail like no big deal but
- 35:28i'm not gonna i'm not gonna expect less
- 35:30of you i know it's kind of paradoxical
- 35:31because we just talked about letting go
- 35:32of expectation
- 35:34but it's not really expectations it's
- 35:36really having faith in them it's a
- 35:37subtle difference but be like i have
- 35:39faith in you i think you can handle it
- 35:41so like give it your best shot
- 35:45that's what you do you challenge them
- 35:47respect them
- 35:49is instead of expect things from them
- 36:02you
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of Why Gifted Kids Are Actually Special Needs by HealthyGamerGG, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 7,524 words across 1,121 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to translate the transcript into 100+ languages.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, translation to 100+ languages, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.