Why Europe is still unsure on air conditioning despite record heatwaves | The Global Story — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:00How did air conditioning become part of
- 0:02the culture wars? When you walk anywhere
- 0:06in the United States in the heat of the
- 0:08summer, pretty much any shop or building
- 0:11is chilly, freezing even. In the United
- 0:14States, air conditioning has become
- 0:16expected, not just in shops or
- 0:19workplaces, but also in homes. Nearly
- 0:2190% of US homes have AC.
- 0:24But it's far less common in Europe,
- 0:26which has been experiencing
- 0:28record-breaking
- 0:30temperatures this summer, especially in
- 0:33France, where the question over whether
- 0:35to have air conditioning or not have air
- 0:37conditioning has bought a pretty fierce
- 0:39political debate, which has reached
- 0:41boiling point. From the BBC, I'm Tristan
- 0:44Redman in London, and this is the global
- 0:48story on YouTube.
- 0:54>> So, a bit later in the podcast, we're
- 0:56going to be speaking to one of the hosts
- 0:58of the BBC's Climate Question podcast.
- 1:01But before that, we're zooming in on
- 1:03France with a guest that you probably
- 1:05know pretty well by now, Tristan Redman,
- 1:07host of the Global Story.
- 1:08>> Hello.
- 1:10Thank you for inviting me on your show,
- 1:12Sumi.
- 1:13>> Well, actually, it's your show, but I'm
- 1:15happy to
- 1:16happy to talk to you about what an
- 1:17interesting topic, isn't it? Air
- 1:19conditioning.
- 1:20It might seem innocuous, Tristan, but I
- 1:23think you and I know it is anything but.
- 1:25>> It is anything but.
- 1:26>> I can tell you on this side of the
- 1:28Atlantic, there has been so much media
- 1:30coverage of late, not just about the
- 1:32heat wave in the US, but about air
- 1:34conditioning and the lack thereof in
- 1:36Europe. And there are a lot of strong
- 1:38feelings.
- 1:39>> There are strong feelings, um, on all
- 1:42sides, probably. Right?
- 1:45>> I want to give you just a taste of the
- 1:46headlines in some of the main
- 1:48publications here. There was an
- 1:50editorial in the Washington Post that
- 1:52claimed that European hostility towards
- 1:54air conditioning is suicidal.
- 1:57Um, a Wall Street Journal editorial
- 1:59called alternative cooling solutions
- 2:01green virtue signaling. Uh New York
- 2:04magazine called the debate in Europe
- 2:06bewildering. There's been a lot of focus
- 2:08on the picture in France. And Tristan,
- 2:10you live in Paris. So, paint this
- 2:11picture for us then. What is it like to
- 2:13live in Paris during a heat wave?
- 2:15>> Well, it can be a nightmare. It doesn't
- 2:17cool down really very much at night
- 2:19because there's a lot of stone uh a lot
- 2:22of heavy stone buildings and they they
- 2:25just radiate heat at night. Uh and
- 2:28people get used to um this feeling you
- 2:32sleep with your windows open cuz you
- 2:33most likely don't have air conditioning.
- 2:35And the feeling of being in Paris in the
- 2:37summer is the feeling of listening and
- 2:40hearing all of your neighbors and all
- 2:43the things that they're doing as you try
- 2:44to go to sleep. So, sometimes they're
- 2:45cooking, sometimes they're arguing,
- 2:48sometimes they're snoring, some a lot of
- 2:49the time they're having sex.
- 2:51>> Yeah, well, yes and no. Sometimes it's
- 2:54charming for a very short period of time
- 2:55and then it gets a bit much. I would say
- 2:58that the conversation that happens
- 3:00inside my family is something like a
- 3:03microcosm of the conversation about air
- 3:06conditioning maybe all the way across
- 3:09Europe. So, just to give you an example
- 3:11of like me and my wife. So, a couple of
- 3:14years ago we invested in a very um
- 3:17shoddy little air conditioning unit.
- 3:20Now, in the in the United States you
- 3:21laugh at it. It's barely big enough to
- 3:23cool one room. Um but we put it in our
- 3:26bedroom and then on really hot nights um
- 3:29my daughters, two of them, will come in
- 3:31and sleep in the room with us. So, there
- 3:33are four of us huddling in in in one
- 3:35room. But the difference between my wife
- 3:38and I comes from the fact that I grew up
- 3:40in the United States. So, I I'm quite
- 3:42attached to air conditioning as a
- 3:43concept. So, I will sneak down the
- 3:46corridor like maybe two or three hours
- 3:48before we're going to go to bed and I'll
- 3:49turn on the air conditioning and I'll
- 3:51close the door in the bedroom because I
- 3:53want the room to be cool when we come to
- 3:55bed. And if my wife gleans that I have
- 3:58done this, she will tend to then sneak
- 4:01down the corridor and then turn it off
- 4:02again because she thinks I'm being
- 4:04irresponsible. And she'll look at me and
- 4:07she will think that I am some sort of
- 4:09profligate wastrel uh and I will look at
- 4:13her and think that she is preaching at
- 4:15me and that's those those are the
- 4:16divisions uh that exist. Um and that you
- 4:20can extrapolate throughout European
- 4:22society in some ways.
- 4:24>> Yeah, so why has the debate, do you
- 4:25think, been so loud this year?
- 4:28>> Well, I think the reason ultimately is
- 4:30change. Europe is changing. Um
- 4:33climate change is a real thing. As a
- 4:36continent, it's
- 4:38temperatures are creeping up faster than
- 4:41any other continent on Earth. Uh
- 4:43historically, you haven't needed air
- 4:46conditioning in Europe. So, as recently
- 4:47as 20 years ago, when when I lived in
- 4:50Paris, there would be, you know, maybe
- 4:52five or six nights a year where it was
- 4:54unbearably hot. So, it wasn't really
- 4:55worth getting air conditioning. Now, it
- 4:57can be weeks and weeks at a stretch. Let
- 4:59me run you through, Sumi, some of the
- 5:01things that have happened this spring
- 5:04and summer cuz it started in spring. So,
- 5:06the first heatwave was in May, which is
- 5:08very early. There was a second 11-day
- 5:11heatwave in June. A lot of schools and
- 5:14hospitals, Sumi, are not
- 5:16air-conditioned. Thousands of schools
- 5:18have had to close. Thousands more had to
- 5:21adjust their schedules. Uh at the
- 5:23beginning of July, the French National
- 5:26Public Health Agency said that it
- 5:29recorded an increase of more than 2,000
- 5:31deaths during the last week of June. We
- 5:35don't know how many of those were
- 5:36attributed to the heat, but that's 2,000
- 5:38excess deaths in that period. All of
- 5:40this then transformed into a political
- 5:42debate. The French government, the
- 5:44government of Sébastien Lecornu, who's
- 5:47the prime Minister of Emmanuel Macron,
- 5:49has been criticized for not doing
- 5:50enough. But political camps are kind of
- 5:52coalescing on this issue. So,
- 5:55Marine Le Pen, notably,
- 5:58who is a hard-right leader in France, a
- 6:01favorite to become the next president of
- 6:02France. So, her party has traditionally
- 6:05been climato-skeptic, as they would call
- 6:08themselves. Now, they're saying they're
- 6:10sort of saying climate change is a real
- 6:12thing and we need to deal with it and
- 6:14the way we need to deal with it is by
- 6:15investing properly in air conditioning.
- 6:18Her opponent on the hard left is a guy
- 6:21called Jean-Luc Mélenchon, who he he's
- 6:24taken the opposite position. He says
- 6:26climate change is a real thing
- 6:28and it's going to become worse if
- 6:30people, especially in cities, where lots
- 6:33of people are concentrated together,
- 6:35start using air conditioning a lot.
- 6:39And the people who would be affected
- 6:40most in cities would be the poorest
- 6:42people who cannot afford air
- 6:44conditioning. Because all you're doing
- 6:45when you take air con and put air
- 6:47conditioning into your building is
- 6:49you're taking heat from inside your
- 6:50building and you're shoving it outside
- 6:52the building. And for the first time,
- 6:53the leader of the Green Party in France
- 6:56is a woman called Marine Tondelier. She
- 6:58has started saying that the situation is
- 7:02so serious that air conditioning needs
- 7:05to be part of the solution, which is not
- 7:07something you would have expected
- 7:10just a few years ago. And it's been a
- 7:12kind of whole political ding-dong ever
- 7:13since then, really.
- 7:14>> I wonder, Tristan, what do people in
- 7:16France then think of the US and how
- 7:18Americans are addicted to really cold
- 7:22indoor spaces in the summer?
- 7:23>> So, there was a headline that you read
- 7:25read out earlier on, which I just like
- 7:27to
- 7:29just address. So, it was an editorial
- 7:31that called alternative cooling
- 7:33solutions, quote, green virtue
- 7:37signaling. So, you know, I can't speak
- 7:40for all Europeans, but I don't know
- 7:41about that. I mean, I'm not sure that
- 7:43many Europeans are choosing
- 7:46to swelter in their houses just to prove
- 7:48a point to people in the United States,
- 7:50but it is fascinating to us over here in
- 7:53Europe that people in the United States
- 7:54are so interested in this question. Why
- 7:56do you think it is?
- 7:57>> You know, I'm in two minds and two
- 7:59hearts about this because I spent a
- 8:01decade and a half living in Berlin,
- 8:04which is pretty similar to what you
- 8:05described to Paris. There is no AC to be
- 8:08found anywhere. That is partly because
- 8:11in Germany you also haven't seen the
- 8:13type of temperatures that Europe is
- 8:15experiencing now. In the past you would
- 8:17have, as you said, maybe a week of
- 8:19really hot temperatures and that was
- 8:21dealt with with open windows. The
- 8:23Germans have something called Lufton and
- 8:25Stosslüften, which is creating a cross
- 8:27breeze by opening several windows. And
- 8:30that's how you try to cool down a space
- 8:32even if it's hot outside.
- 8:34Here in the US, and I grew up here and
- 8:35have come back here a few years ago,
- 8:38there is a sense that convenience is the
- 8:41most important thing. And why would you
- 8:43suffer in the heat when you can be cool
- 8:46inside? So, I think part of what the
- 8:49concern is, I would say, about Europeans
- 8:52here is a bit of head-scratching. That
- 8:53bewildering title, I think, describes it
- 8:56quite well. Why would you want to sit
- 8:59through unbearable heat and try to fall
- 9:01asleep with all your windows open in the
- 9:03summer and not be able to cool down when
- 9:05there is a solution there ready at hand.
- 9:07And actually,
- 9:09that perception also goes along with
- 9:11that virtue signaling.
- 9:13There are Americans, I've talked to many
- 9:15of them, who say, "Well, the Europeans
- 9:17just think they're better than us, that
- 9:19they don't need air conditioning and
- 9:21that they can be more green than we can
- 9:24here in the US." So, I think it's kind
- 9:26of those two things together. I think
- 9:28one point Americans do make is when you
- 9:31have such extreme heat, and here in
- 9:32Washington D.C., there are days where
- 9:34you simply could not function with
- 9:36without air conditioning. Um but that
- 9:39would really uh reduce the productivity
- 9:42of society here because in the summer
- 9:44that means there are people who perhaps
- 9:45could not go to work. Maybe their kids
- 9:47could not go to school, so they would
- 9:48have to stay home.
- 9:49>> That kind of conversation is being had
- 9:52in France as well. So, Marine Le Pen
- 9:55says that it's an economic imperative uh
- 9:58to cool temperatures down for people in
- 10:01France. And you know, if you listen to
- 10:03people on the endless radio debates that
- 10:05are raging on right now, there will
- 10:07often be people who say, "Okay, yes,
- 10:10installing air conditioning in buildings
- 10:12which are very old uh and not meant to
- 10:14have air conditioning can be
- 10:16extortionately expensive. But what can
- 10:18be even more expensive is losing
- 10:21productivity in the economy. So, we're
- 10:23just trying to make the best of a
- 10:24difficult situation over here because
- 10:26things have suddenly got a lot hotter
- 10:28than they used to be. And we're doing
- 10:30the best we can."
- 10:31>> I think Americans would be very
- 10:32understanding of that.
- 10:34>> Well, assuming in all of this, one of
- 10:36the questions is
- 10:38is air conditioning actually a
- 10:40one-size-fits-all solution that works
- 10:42for everything? I wanted to know a
- 10:44little bit more about this, Sumi. So, I
- 10:46got in touch with our colleague Greya
- 10:48Jackson, who's the host of the BBC
- 10:51podcast The Climate Question.
- 10:54And I wanted to start off by asking
- 10:56Greya if she actually had air
- 10:58conditioning herself. And she told me
- 11:00that she had um a much more unusual
- 11:03solution to the problem.
- 11:04>> I have a fan.
- 11:05>> Yeah.
- 11:05>> So, I'm not without entirely without
- 11:08means. So, if it gets really hot, I
- 11:09sleep under a wet sheet. That's my other
- 11:11technique. But when I was pregnant and
- 11:14having to work, I was living in a 70s
- 11:16house that was really poorly insulated.
- 11:18So, I used to um sit with a big bucket
- 11:21of water under the desk with my feet in
- 11:23the bucket of water. And that was the
- 11:25best thing I could find to keep cool and
- 11:29do some work.
- 11:30>> Does that work?
- 11:31>> It works really, really well. Yeah.
- 11:32>> Our Our American listeners right now are
- 11:34going [laughter] like, "What are these
- 11:36people doing? They've got buckets of
- 11:38water
- 11:39>> [laughter]
- 11:39>> under their desks." All right. Well,
- 11:41Gray, it's so great to have you with us
- 11:43here at The Global Story. As you know,
- 11:45we look at stories where the world and
- 11:47America meet. And um one of the things
- 11:50that has amazed some of the Americans on
- 11:52our team is that some of the Europeans
- 11:55on our team don't have air conditioning
- 11:58at home. Um and somehow this summer it
- 12:02feels like air conditioning has become
- 12:04part of the conversation in a way that I
- 12:06don't really remember. Have you noticed
- 12:09more people buying air conditioning
- 12:11units in the UK?
- 12:14>> Somewhat. I mean, people have mentioned
- 12:17it to me, but mostly, I think cuz
- 12:19they're British, they just complain
- 12:20about how hot it is. And if they got air
- 12:22con, then they wouldn't be able to
- 12:23complain about how hot it is. We love
- 12:25complaining about the weather here. Um
- 12:27that's sort of anecdotally, air
- 12:29conditioning units have been on the rise
- 12:32for a long time. I was looking at some
- 12:34data. Uh 1990 to 2016, sort of fourfold
- 12:38increase in air conditioning units sold
- 12:41uh during that period. That's globally.
- 12:43So, people are
- 12:44>> fourfold of not very much could also be
- 12:47not very much. Or is it genuinely a lot
- 12:49now?
- 12:49>> I mean, if you look at China, there are
- 12:51hundreds of millions of units installed.
- 12:54It's the same in the US. Um South Korea,
- 12:57Japan are sort of third and fourth on
- 12:58the list. And then there are some
- 13:00emerging markets where maybe something
- 13:02like 27 million units are installed in
- 13:04places like India and Brazil. So, there
- 13:08are still hundreds of millions of units.
- 13:10Granted, there are many more people than
- 13:13that. Many people of which you would
- 13:14obviously never be able to afford air
- 13:17conditioning or might not even have
- 13:18access to electricity. So, um that kind
- 13:21of puts it into perspective. But that
- 13:23that is expected to rise. That
- 13:26projection, if you like, of air
- 13:27conditioning sales is only going to go
- 13:29up and up. I have some data here that
- 13:31the UN says the need for air con could
- 13:33triple by 2050.
- 13:35>> I think that probably deep down in the
- 13:36British
- 13:38psyche there is the idea that
- 13:41succumbing to air conditioning is
- 13:42somehow shows weak moral fiber.
- 13:46>> [laughter]
- 13:48>> But what are some I mean apart from the
- 13:50kind of
- 13:51sense of guilt that some British people
- 13:54or Europeans feel, what are the
- 13:56arguments against using air
- 13:58conditioning?
- 13:59>> Well,
- 14:00it's expensive to install, right? I
- 14:02think that puts a lot of people off,
- 14:04especially when we're living in a cost
- 14:05of living crisis. Energy prices are
- 14:07soaring, so expensive to buy, expensive
- 14:10to run. But if you look at the
- 14:11environmental side, there are also some
- 14:13issues around the climate. So, these air
- 14:16conditioning units use refrigerant
- 14:17gases, things like CFCs,
- 14:20and those if they leak are really,
- 14:23really potent planet warming gases, or
- 14:26if they're not disposed of at end of
- 14:27life, they're really problematic. There
- 14:29is quite a big push for those to be
- 14:31edged out or phased out and more
- 14:33climate-friendly gases used instead, but
- 14:36the main bulk of emissions that come
- 14:39from air conditioners are actually how
- 14:40they're powered, the electricity they
- 14:42use. So, that really depends on how the
- 14:46grid is powered and where you live in
- 14:48the world. So, if you take two air
- 14:50conditioning units and you run one in
- 14:52China and one in Brazil, they will have
- 14:55totally different carbon footprints or
- 14:58climate footprints. So, in China, that's
- 15:00because around 50% of the grid is
- 15:02powered with coal. So, huge amount of
- 15:06fossil fuel energy, and coal is the
- 15:08dirtiest of the fossil fuels that we
- 15:10have.
- 15:10Brazil, on the other hand, 80%
- 15:13renewables on the grid. So, the carbon
- 15:14footprint is far, far less. So, it
- 15:17really depends on where you are in the
- 15:19world. So, environment, cost, those are
- 15:22the sort of the main sort of cons if you
- 15:24like, but there's a trade-off because
- 15:26people need to stay cool. People can't
- 15:28live in some of the conditions
- 15:30that they're experiencing. I mean, India
- 15:32in May was seeing
- 15:34uh temperatures sort of 40, 50°. I mean,
- 15:37it's that's unlivable, really.
- 15:39>> But in theory, it would be possible to
- 15:41have a carbon neutral
- 15:44uh air conditioning system in your house
- 15:45if all of the energy that you burned in
- 15:48your house were renewable.
- 15:50>> Yes, in theory. I mean, nearly zero. It
- 15:53depends on the refrigerant gases that
- 15:54we've talked about, but in theory, you
- 15:56could The UN has actually published a
- 15:58report last year at um COP, the big
- 16:00climate conference, that said we could
- 16:02get to nearly zero emissions via in the
- 16:06cooling sphere. So, there's lots of
- 16:08solutions to be had, but it's also just
- 16:10not about, you know, how we power our
- 16:12grids and what gases we use. There are
- 16:15lots of solutions that help us bring
- 16:17down the amount of power and electricity
- 16:20we need because
- 16:21don't forget, if we install so much air
- 16:24conditioning, we're going to have to
- 16:26grow our grids exponentially to keep up
- 16:29with that power demand. I mean, maybe
- 16:3120% more of the power that we're using
- 16:34today in 2050 just for cooling alone,
- 16:37and there's lots of other industries
- 16:38that are going to need renewable power
- 16:40like cement and steel and the aviation
- 16:43industry to produce sustainable fuel.
- 16:45So, there's going to be much higher
- 16:46demand on the grid, so we need to reduce
- 16:48our energy consumption and make it much
- 16:50more energy efficient when we do need
- 16:52it.
- 16:53>> Are air conditioning units as bad for
- 16:56the environment as some people would
- 16:58have us believe?
- 16:59>> So, it's hard to weigh in whether
- 17:01they're really bad or not because like
- 17:03we've said, it depends on how your grid
- 17:05is being powered. It depends on how
- 17:07energy-efficient your unit is or even
- 17:09the standards in your country are very
- 17:11different depending on government laws
- 17:13and rules. So, I think it's it's hard to
- 17:15say whether it's {quote} and {unquote}
- 17:17good or bad because I think it's also
- 17:20necessary for a lot of people. People
- 17:22cannot live at these sorts of
- 17:25temperatures and indeed lots of people
- 17:27die in these sorts of temperatures.
- 17:30>> What are some of the alternatives? I
- 17:31mean, um
- 17:33you suggested putting a tub of cold
- 17:35water under the desk. Um but for people
- 17:39who don't want to or cannot install air
- 17:42conditioning as we enter times the where
- 17:45it's just unbearably hot. What are some
- 17:47of the best tips and tricks?
- 17:50>> Well, I want to zoom out a little bit if
- 17:52that's okay because I don't want the
- 17:53onus just to be on what individuals
- 17:56should or could do because there's lots
- 17:58that town planners and governments can
- 18:00do. So, I talked about before how the UN
- 18:02said we could get emissions down to
- 18:04nearly zero from cooling systems and
- 18:06that is through energy efficiency as I
- 18:07mentioned but also how we build our
- 18:10cities. Um that's where the majority of
- 18:12us live and there's also something
- 18:13called the urban heat island effect
- 18:15which is where our cities are much much
- 18:17hotter than the surrounding areas. And
- 18:20that's because
- 18:21uh we use lots of materials like
- 18:23concrete and asphalt which are dark so
- 18:26they absorb more sunlight and because of
- 18:27the nature of the material they also
- 18:29hold on to that heat much much more.
- 18:32There's much less vegetation which makes
- 18:34it much much warmer. So, cities are just
- 18:36much much hotter as a result. So, why
- 18:39don't we think about redesigning and
- 18:41rebuilding our cities or when we're
- 18:42building new cities or extending them,
- 18:44how do we design cities in a way that
- 18:46are much more climatically comfortable?
- 18:49And one of the main solutions is green
- 18:50spaces.
- 18:51>> Mhm.
- 18:52>> Lots of co-benefits, you know? They keep
- 18:54our air cleaner, they make us happy as
- 18:56well, but they also keep us cooler
- 18:58because they provide shade and all the
- 19:00plants do something called
- 19:01evapotranspiration which is basically a
- 19:03fancy way of plant sweating.
- 19:05Uh fancy way of saying that. So, there's
- 19:07that sort of level of stuff but also the
- 19:09buildings that that build, think about a
- 19:11glass skyscraper in the middle of Dubai.
- 19:15That's going to require a lot of cooling
- 19:17cuz glass is not a very good material
- 19:20for thermal regulation. Conversely, in
- 19:21somewhere like the UK in winter, it will
- 19:24still need a lot of heating. So, how do
- 19:25we build our buildings
- 19:27that are much more sort of thermally
- 19:30efficient? And we know how to do this.
- 19:32It's called passive cooling. It's where
- 19:33we use natural solutions to cool our
- 19:35homes. And we've been doing it for
- 19:37hundreds of years. So, have you been to
- 19:40Morocco before?
- 19:41>> Yes.
- 19:42>> So, you've walked stood outside and then
- 19:43walked into a riad. There's beautiful
- 19:46shaded courtyards. And I bet you noticed
- 19:49the temperature difference. That is a
- 19:51way that you can design a building
- 19:53really cleverly so that it's cool. And
- 19:55again, that's water features help cool
- 19:57the air plants and using shading. Thick
- 20:00walls as well help keep the cooler air
- 20:02the heat out and narrow windows. In
- 20:04Egypt, they use those sorts of
- 20:06techniques and but they also use
- 20:07something called a wind catcher.
- 20:09>> Wait.
- 20:10>> Go on.
- 20:10>> Really beautiful. So, on the tops of
- 20:12buildings, they have almost like a
- 20:14gazebo. Like they're beautiful. They're
- 20:16often beautiful wooden lattice work or
- 20:17brick work. And it's got lots of holes.
- 20:20And so, as the wind blows across the top
- 20:22of the city, the wind catchers are then
- 20:24caught in these in these little gazebos
- 20:26and they get diverted. The air gets
- 20:28diverted down into the building. So, it
- 20:30keeps it keeps ventilation but it also
- 20:32keeps that cooler air ventilating around
- 20:35the building and keeping the building
- 20:36cool. So, there's lots of interesting
- 20:38ideas about how you can do this at low
- 20:40cost with materials that are widely
- 20:42available that don't cost the moon to
- 20:45do. Um so, that's sort of how you can
- 20:47think about it top level. But there are
- 20:48lots of things that we can do and I've
- 20:51gone out and done and seen lots of
- 20:53interesting things including, would you
- 20:55believe it, painting windows with
- 20:57yogurt.
- 20:58>> Go on.
- 20:59>> Dairy or non-dairy?
- 21:01Although there's probably a slightly
- 21:02lower carbon footprint in the non-dairy
- 21:04version. But basically, I met a guy
- 21:07called Tom who's been looking at
- 21:09low-cost solutions to stopping heat
- 21:12traveling through windows. And he found
- 21:14that with yogurt and a bit of a paint
- 21:16roller, he painted yogurt onto the
- 21:18window and he then measured that that
- 21:21yogurt film
- 21:23could reflect 80% of the sun's thermal
- 21:26energy, which meant that your room was
- 21:29much, much cooler as a result. I was
- 21:32really skeptical cuz I was like, "Smell,
- 21:34flies, you know,
- 21:35>> Yeah.
- 21:36>> No flies, no smell, he says. And when
- 21:40it's the heat wave saver, you can just
- 21:42>> Yeah, I mean, you say that,
- 21:44>> [laughter]
- 21:44>> but we're not doing a very good job of
- 21:47convincing our American cousins that we
- 21:49are not insane.
- 21:50>> [laughter]
- 21:52>> That's true. I mean, something that I
- 21:54like to do, and I I learned this I was
- 21:56doing a bit of reporting um about the
- 21:58Little Ice Age, which was conversely a
- 22:00very cold time in England. It's where
- 22:02Have you ever seen pictures of the frost
- 22:04fairs on the River Thames where it
- 22:05freezes over?
- 22:06>> Yes.
- 22:07>> That period of time. And this building
- 22:09called Hardwick Hall in the north of
- 22:10England was built then. It's It's a
- 22:12stunning piece of architecture.
- 22:15Um
- 22:16and what was really interesting about
- 22:17that is they had designed the building
- 22:19to be used based on the sun's position
- 22:21in the sky.
- 22:23So, kitchen in the cold northern area,
- 22:26they had breakfast where the sun rises,
- 22:29and their dinner where the sun sets. So,
- 22:31they literally followed the sun around
- 22:33the house.
- 22:34>> Yes.
- 22:34>> And I then went home and I moved my desk
- 22:38where I spend the majority of my day to
- 22:40follow the sun in winter and to hide
- 22:43from the sun in summer. And I I can
- 22:45notice there's about a 2° temperature
- 22:48difference from moving from back and
- 22:50forth from my house. So, you can do
- 22:52these like little weird, quirky things
- 22:54if you can if they're available to you.
- 22:55And all these little differences, they
- 22:58might not sound like much, but I think
- 23:00collectively they can add up.
- 23:01>> We've been talking a little bit about
- 23:03France in this episode and last week
- 23:05Marine Tondelier who's the leader of the
- 23:08French Green Party
- 23:11who you know
- 23:13the Orthodox thinking would be that they
- 23:15would be against air con. Now Marine
- 23:18Tondelier acknowledged that it's now
- 23:19becoming necessary to have air
- 23:22conditioning as part of the solution. Do
- 23:25you think we're at a turning point in
- 23:27Europe? Quite possibly. I mean if you
- 23:30look back over the last couple of
- 23:32decades
- 23:34one statistic I saw from the UN was
- 23:37something like 489,000
- 23:39people have died as a result of heat
- 23:41related deaths. I wish I found that
- 23:43figure shocking. 489,000 people that's
- 23:45nearly half an half a million people
- 23:48dying from heat every single year that
- 23:50is every single year.
- 23:53I was I was so shocked to read that and
- 23:56so
- 23:57actually it's very hard to put a cost
- 24:01of life against a cost of the
- 24:03environment. You know so there are
- 24:05always going to be there are always
- 24:07going to be trade-offs at least in the
- 24:08short term and maybe you know the
- 24:10raising awareness of the fact that
- 24:12climate change is making heat waves more
- 24:15intense more frequent. We've seen this
- 24:18one massive heat wave in June and we're
- 24:20in the midst of the next one. So I
- 24:22wouldn't be surprised if air con at
- 24:24least in the UK and Europe became a much
- 24:27more normal convention but we'll have to
- 24:30wait and see.
- 24:31>> Karina thank you so much.
- 24:32>> You're welcome.
- 24:33>> It's been great to have you.
- 24:34>> It's been nice to be here.
- 24:35>> That was [music] Graihagh Jackson host
- 24:37of the BBC podcast the climate question
- 24:40which is also available here on YouTube
- 24:42and that's it from us. The global story
- 24:44is also an audio pod. We're available
- 24:46every weekday on bbc.com or wherever you
- 24:49listen. Thanks for tuning in. We'll be
- 24:51back again tomorrow. Cheerio.
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of Why Europe is still unsure on air conditioning despite record heatwaves | The Global Story by BBC News, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 4,578 words across 699 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.