π π‘ π Why Can't We Have Everything We Want? | Scarcity and Choice β Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:00We live in a world of scarcity.
- 0:03This fact is beyond question.
- 0:04Our time, land, and work are scarce.
- 0:07Producer and consumer goods are scarce as well.
- 0:10Human needs, however, are limitless.
- 0:13Economics studies the relationship between limitless goals and scarce means used to realize
- 0:17these goals.
- 0:19Though these means indeed can help us achieve our goals, due to their scarcity we must constantly
- 0:24decide on which needs are the most urgent, while taking into account which goods we can
- 0:29use to satisfy them.
- 0:30First, consider the concept of scarce means, or simply goods.
- 0:35For something to be called a good, it must meet two conditions: People must consider
- 0:39it able to satisfy their needs, and its amount must be limited.
- 0:44An example might be a nice way to explain this:
- 0:46Imagine you have a very rare germ that causes a terrible disease.
- 0:50Is it a good?
- 0:52Of course not, because you cannot use it to further your goals.
- 0:55Just because something is scarce does not mean that it is useful.
- 0:59But sunlight and air are useful.
- 1:01True, both are very much needed, though they are not scarce β in most situations anyone
- 1:06can easily get any needed amount of them.
- 1:09Of course, we can imagine some exceptions.
- 1:12For example, the germ we mentioned can be used as a biological weapon, and as such can
- 1:16be valued on the black market.
- 1:19Or we can imagine someone selling a diving cylinder filled with air to a person who wants
- 1:23to dive at great depths.
- 1:24In most situations, however, these are not goods.
- 1:28Now letβs deal with types of goods.
- 1:30We can divide them into three categories: The first category is natural resources or
- 1:36original factors of production β these goods are supplied by nature itself and are not
- 1:40created by use of human action.
- 1:42Such resources are both human work, understood as expenditure of human energy, and land.
- 1:48When we talk about land as a natural resource, we are not talking about farmed land.
- 1:53Land that is already farmed is a capital good.
- 1:55Land is a natural resource if untouched by human hand, and includes raw materials, climate
- 2:00and all other elements that humans can use.
- 2:02The second category is capital goods or intermediate goods.
- 2:06They are called intermediate, because they are not directly serviceable in the satisfaction
- 2:10of wants, but may be transformed into such directly serviceable goods.
- 2:15In other words, they are only used in production of goods that consumers can use directly.
- 2:20Suppose you want to satisfy your need to eat bread.
- 2:23You need an oven to bake bread.
- 2:25An oven cannot satisfy your need directly, but can be used as a mean to this end.
- 2:29Thus, capital goods include machines, factory buildings, tools, or computers used in the
- 2:34process of production.
- 2:37Natural resources and capital goods can be called by a common name of factors of production.
- 2:42The third category is consumer goods or final goods.
- 2:45They satisfy human needs directly.
- 2:48The production process is as follows: People transform natural resources into capital goods,
- 2:53and then transform capital goods into consumer goods.
- 2:57Consumer goods can then be consumed.
- 2:59As we mentioned earlier, human needs are limitless, and in that they differ from natural resources.
- 3:05Natural resources are scarce in any point of time, and because of that you cannot have
- 3:09everything at once.
- 3:10So you must always judge what you value the most at the moment or, in other words, what
- 3:15specific use of scarce means will satisfy your needs the most.
- 3:19Confronted with the necessity to choose between different uses of scarce means, you create
- 3:23your own value scale that ranks the ends you value.
- 3:27The values are completely subjective.
- 3:29As an illustration imagine an employee working in a high position whose great results were
- 3:33rewarded with a bonus of 50 thousand dollars.
- 3:37The 50 thousand dollars are a scarce resource, so he must decide on the use of the money
- 3:41most valuable to him.
- 3:43Assume that the employee has the following value scale, and each value can be satisfied
- 3:47by use of exactly 50 thousand dollars:
- 3:511. Having a yacht β this would make his childhood dream come true, and he values it the most
- 3:572. Going on a trip around the world β this is his second-best choice, as he always wanted to do it
- 4:043. Having a motorcycle β buying a Harley is his third-most valued choice
- 4:104. Having his house renovated β his fourth-most valued choice
- 4:155. Setting up his own bar β this is his last choice that will allow him to lead
- 4:21a more modest but calmer life.
- 4:23As the employee values the yachtβs purchase the most, he will do exactly that.
- 4:28Can we assume that he judges other things unimportant?
- 4:30Obviously, the other things are important as well.
- 4:33All these things are worth more to him than 50 thousand dollars.
- 4:37He values the yacht the most, however.
- 4:40If he had gotten a bonus of one hundred thousand dollars, he would have bought a yacht AND
- 4:44taken a trip around the world.
- 4:45If he had gotten two hundred thousand dollars, he would have bought a motorcycle and renovated
- 4:50his house as well.
- 4:51However, scarcity of means allows him to satisfy only one of his needs.
- 4:56Every time you decide on how to use scarce means, you create a subjective value scale
- 5:01by assigning ranks to your various ends in a process of value judgment.
- 5:05Obviously, such value scales are fluid.
- 5:08Subjective value judgments can and do change.
- 5:11And they are inseparable from human action, as only action can reveal oneβs priority.
- 5:16Letβs say that you are walking along a street after receiving your wage.
- 5:20You had your expenses planned in your head, but suddenly you see your favorite bandβs
- 5:24album displayed in a store window, so you buy the album.
- 5:28Does it mean that you have acted against your value scale?
- 5:31No.
- 5:32It only means that your situation has changed and you have adjusted your value scale to
- 5:35include your valuation of the album.
- 5:39Before taking any action, you judge how it might satisfy your needs, and compare it with
- 5:44every other value on the scale.
- 5:45To satisfy your most valued want in your value scale, you need to forgo the opportunity to
- 5:50satisfy your second-most valued want.
- 5:53And this foregone opportunity is called cost.
- 5:56For the employee with the bonus, the 50 thousand dollars are not an end in itself.
- 6:01The bonus is merely a means to an end.
- 6:03So the real cost here is not the money, but the second want on the value scale, that is
- 6:08going on a trip around the world.
- 6:10The employee decides on a yacht, because he judges that satisfying this need will outweigh
- 6:14the cost.
- 6:16Every person taking action believes that the resulting satisfaction will outweigh the cost.
- 6:21From this perspective, human action is always rational, even if it seems otherwise to an
- 6:26external observer.
- 6:27Of course, after taking action, it may turn out that you have made a mistake, and that
- 6:32the need was actually less urgent than expected.
- 6:35You may think that if you could turn back time, you would make a different choice.
- 6:38This is because the future is uncertain.
- 6:40It might turn out that the employee who bought the yacht is prone to seasickness, which he
- 6:45was unaware of before, and for him every trip on his new yacht is a nightmare.
- 6:50Looking back, he will regret not spending his money on a trip around the world.
- 6:54But it does not mean that his decision to buy a yacht was irrational.
- 6:58People are always trying to improve their future situation precisely because the future
- 7:03is uncertain.
- 7:04If the future was known and certain, everyone would just wait idly for the inevitable to
- 7:09happen instead of trying to act.
- 7:12Only a choosing person knows his subjective value scale, and through action reveals only
- 7:16a small part of it.
- 7:18If I buy a mug for 10 dollars, it means not only that at this moment the mug is worth
- 7:22more to me than having 10 dollars, but also that it is worth more than anything else you
- 7:27can buy for 10 dollars.
- 7:29Meanwhile, the role of the producer is to try to anticipate the future human needs and
- 7:33act to satisfy them.
- 7:35If his anticipation is correct, then he will succeed.
- 7:38If not, he will fail.
- 7:40I encourage you to visit the econclips.com website, where you can find additional materials
- 7:43that expand on the topic.
- 7:44Thank you very much for all the support you give us and for further help allowing us to
- 7:48develop.
- 7:49We encourage you to subscribe to our YouTube channel and to like our Facebook page.
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of π π‘ π Why Can't We Have Everything We Want? | Scarcity and Choice by EconClips, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 1,449 words across 133 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator β no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.