Who's making all of the money in the porn industry? | The Global Story — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:00Who's making all the money in porn these
- 0:02days? The industry is worth tens of
- 0:05billions of dollars. Some statistics
- 0:08suggest that at peak times, 10% of all
- 0:11traffic on the internet is porn. The
- 0:14days of porn barons like Hugh Hefner and
- 0:16Larry Flint are long gone. Today on the
- 0:19show, we meet a journalist who spent six
- 0:21years investigating who's getting rich
- 0:23from porn and how the industry is now so
- 0:26huge that it's changed the way the
- 0:29internet works and affected all of us.
- 0:32From the BBC, I'm Tristan Redman in
- 0:34London. Welcome to the Global Story on
- 0:37YouTube.
- 0:42>> My name is Patricia Nelson and um day to
- 0:46day I'm a reporter with the Financial
- 0:47Times and I have just um written a book
- 0:50called Guilty Pleasure, which is um
- 0:54about how the logic of porn shaped the
- 0:59internet and how this is changing us. I
- 1:01started writing about porn six years ago
- 1:03and
- 1:03>> What what set you off on this path?
- 1:05>> Well, it was um
- 1:08back in 2019 and it was when the UK was
- 1:11trying to introduce age verification the
- 1:13first time around.
- 1:15And um I um I became very interested in
- 1:21this this company called called
- 1:23MindGeek, which apparently was owning
- 1:25Pornhub and YouPorn and all these
- 1:27so-called tube sites where most people
- 1:29consume pornography today. And um I was
- 1:33trying to read up a little bit on the
- 1:34company and and realized there was
- 1:36almost no information. I mean, it was it
- 1:38was practically impossible to find out
- 1:39how is this company making money, who
- 1:41owns this company, um where are, you
- 1:44know, where are the profits flowing? Um
- 1:46and so that was the slow start to an
- 1:50investigation um that I did a couple of
- 1:53years ago, which
- 1:54which ended up with me, well, on on one
- 1:57side learning how the the company behind
- 2:00Pornhub managed to grow so big because
- 2:02it had been pumped full of debt by some
- 2:05of the biggest institutional investors
- 2:08on on on Wall Street. And what I
- 2:11discovered was that in this process the
- 2:14company had also secretly been taken
- 2:16over by former Goldman Sachs banker
- 2:20who virtually no one knew existed. I
- 2:22mean even people in the porn industry
- 2:24didn't know he existed. I mean I even
- 2:26spoke to
- 2:29journalists, like porn trade journalists
- 2:32who basically accused me of being
- 2:34conspiracy theorist when I said, hey,
- 2:36have you heard that this company might
- 2:38have been sold and we don't really know
- 2:41who it belongs to? So that was was quite
- 2:44an extraordinary
- 2:46discovery. And that was that was sort of
- 2:49it. That was the end of that
- 2:50investigation.
- 2:51>> So you you got hooked on the
- 2:52investigation essentially.
- 2:53>> Well, it was just such an incredible
- 2:55story, but the thing was that
- 2:58what really stuck with me was that
- 3:01so
- 3:02by by realizing the sort of the
- 3:04financialization of of porn and
- 3:09you know
- 3:11a pattern that that emerged in the story
- 3:13was of course that the people who were
- 3:14profiting from pornography were so far
- 3:17removed from the porn itself, were so
- 3:19far removed from the sex workers who
- 3:21actually make pornography.
- 3:24And what I found so galling was that
- 3:27many of these people, for example, this
- 3:29this this man who took over
- 3:33MindGeek without anyone knowing, a man
- 3:35called
- 3:36Bernd Berg Maier,
- 3:39you know, he and and many other people
- 3:41they they wanted to remain anonymous.
- 3:43They were basically saying, hey, this is
- 3:45our right. We're just running private
- 3:46companies.
- 3:48We have we have the right to to privacy.
- 3:51And this is while they are running a
- 3:53business where performers literally have
- 3:55to, you know, be naked in front of the
- 3:57world. And of course once you've
- 3:59uploaded or once there there is content
- 4:02of you, once your face is on the
- 4:04internet, once your body's on the
- 4:05internet, it can be very difficult to to
- 4:07get those that content taken taken down.
- 4:11>> In your work, you start off by
- 4:14describing uh the so-called golden age
- 4:18of porn, what existed before the
- 4:20internet came along um in the '70s,
- 4:22'80s, and early '90s. I mean, some of
- 4:24our listeners and some of our viewers
- 4:26might have seen the movie Boogie Nights
- 4:29uh which, you know, paints a picture of
- 4:30that. Is it like that or is it like
- 4:32something else?
- 4:34>> So when um when I talk about the golden
- 4:38age of porn, I really mean the sort of
- 4:41the '70s, '80s um California um when um
- 4:47when what is still uh endearingly called
- 4:50Silicon Valley they are so not the
- 4:53Silicon Valley you might be thinking of
- 4:55um was really the global hub for porn
- 4:58production and where
- 4:59>> Not not the Silicon Valley in San
- 5:00Francisco, a different one. Explain that
- 5:01to us.
- 5:02>> a different one. I mean, this is a sort
- 5:03of an
- 5:04term of endearment, but of course it's
- 5:06refers to Silicon breasts which became
- 5:09very popular
- 5:10uh in pornography in the sort of '80s
- 5:12and and and and '90s. But in this in the
- 5:15San Fernando Valley,
- 5:17the global hub for porn production it
- 5:20was basically a parallel universe to
- 5:22Hollywood. So you had producers and
- 5:25directors and of course porn stars and
- 5:27they were shooting a lot of films and
- 5:30they were shooting quite ambitious
- 5:31films. I mean, you have film scholars
- 5:32who have described pornography from that
- 5:35era as something uh much similar to a
- 5:38musical, you know, sort of describing
- 5:40the actual sex acts as the song and
- 5:42dance numbers that are sort of
- 5:44punctuating the narrative of um of of of
- 5:47a musical film, for example. And so you
- 5:49had this this came off the back of the
- 5:51sexual revolution of of of in the late
- 5:53late '60s and so you had this so-called
- 5:56porno-chic era where um you had a lot of
- 5:59mainstream cinemas showing pornography.
- 6:01I mean, you had uh
- 6:03you know, Andy Warhol made a porn film,
- 6:06you know, so it was really Yeah, it was
- 6:07it was cool, you know, there was
- 6:09something truly transgressive about
- 6:11pornography, especially in this in this
- 6:13era. But most importantly, there was
- 6:14this the rise of a new technology which
- 6:17was
- 6:18the VHS.
- 6:19>> Mhm.
- 6:19>> And so instead of going to cinemas or
- 6:23you know, going out to buy magazines,
- 6:25people could just rent or buy
- 6:28pornographic films and and watch them at
- 6:30home. So pornography became less visible
- 6:32in society, but the industry was
- 6:34thriving. So you had VHS and then DVD
- 6:37sales and of course hotel sales. That
- 6:39was a very big thing, you know, people
- 6:41going checking in at hotels and and then
- 6:43renting pornographic films. So the
- 6:46industry was very was making a lot of
- 6:48money in this in this era.
- 6:49>> Okay. Well, in the 2000s,
- 6:53online porn changes everything.
- 6:56The sort of thing that you would have
- 6:58had to have sorted out in a DVD store or
- 7:01on the top shelf becomes available
- 7:04anywhere at any time to anyone.
- 7:07And one of the reasons for this is a guy
- 7:11called Fabian, a German tech guy, who's
- 7:14somebody that you
- 7:16paint a very vivid picture of
- 7:18in your book. And the thing that really
- 7:21jumped out for me is this story that you
- 7:23tell about him at a Las Vegas conference
- 7:27in 2012. What actually happened at this
- 7:30conference and why was it such an
- 7:31important turning point for the
- 7:32industry?
- 7:34>> Yes. So when the tube sites came and so
- 7:38the tube sites are these places where
- 7:40you can watch porn for free,
- 7:43many people in in the traditional porn
- 7:45industry, they they watched their their
- 7:47content, their their films being being
- 7:49stolen and uploaded and and
- 7:51and they were losing a lot of money and
- 7:53there was a lot of anger at these tube
- 7:54sites, but the issue was no one knew who
- 7:57controlled them, no one knew who was
- 7:58behind them, no one knew who owned them.
- 8:00I
- 8:02I became very interested in this this
- 8:04company called called MindGeek, which
- 8:07apparently was owning and YouPorn and
- 8:10all these so-called tube sites where
- 8:11most people consume pornography today.
- 8:14And
- 8:15um I was trying to read up a little bit
- 8:17on the company and realized there was
- 8:18almost no information. I mean, it was it
- 8:20was practically impossible to find out
- 8:22how is this company making money, who
- 8:24owns this company, um where are, you
- 8:27know, where are the profits flowing. Um
- 8:29and so that was the slow start to an
- 8:33investigation which ended up with me
- 8:37well, on on one side learning um how
- 8:41um how the the company behind Pornhub
- 8:44had managed to grow so big because it
- 8:46had been pumped full of debt by some of
- 8:50the biggest institutional investors on
- 8:53on on Wall Street. And what I discovered
- 8:55was that in this process um the company
- 8:58had also secretly been taken over by a
- 9:01former Goldman Sachs banker um who
- 9:04virtually no one knew existed. I mean,
- 9:06even people in the porn industry didn't
- 9:08know he existed. So
- 9:10in 2012 um the porn industry had
- 9:15gathered um for one of their annual big
- 9:18conferences, um the sort of Oscars of
- 9:21the porn industry, if you so
- 9:24like, and um at this conference during
- 9:27the day there was going to be a keynote
- 9:29speaker and um there were so many people
- 9:33trying to get into the room that the the
- 9:35the this the speech was actually half an
- 9:37hour delayed. Um and the reason there
- 9:41were so many people trying to get in was
- 9:43that a man called Fabian Tillman was
- 9:46going to speak to them. And Fabian
- 9:48Tillman was the man who owned um a
- 9:52company that was then called Manwin,
- 9:55which was um
- 9:57which was behind Pornhub and loads of
- 10:01other tube sites that have completely
- 10:02upended the porn industry. Um and this
- 10:05was the first time he was going to show
- 10:08his face to
- 10:10um
- 10:11people who are very, very angry with
- 10:13him.
- 10:13>> What happens next?
- 10:16>> Fabian is a sort of self-proclaimed
- 10:19nerd. He's wearing a um hoodie, a grey
- 10:23hoodie. Someone in the audience
- 10:25described him as sort of trying to be
- 10:28look a little bit like Mark Zuckerberg,
- 10:30and he walked on to the stage and leaned
- 10:33on leaned at his table and and he
- 10:35started his his his speech by basically
- 10:38saying something similar to, you know,
- 10:40I'm not this
- 10:42evil person who you who you think I am.
- 10:45Um but before he could actually start
- 10:47speaking, some of the people in the
- 10:49front row actually started humming this
- 10:52the song that they play in Star Wars
- 10:54when Darth Vader [laughter]
- 10:56sort of sort of appears, this this
- 10:58ominous
- 10:59ominous song.
- 11:00>> da da da da da
- 11:02>> Exactly. Yes.
- 11:04Um so there was really an atmosphere in
- 11:06the room of here is
- 11:10um you know, here comes the source of
- 11:12all of our problems.
- 11:13>> And what's his reaction on stage to this
- 11:16reception he's getting from people in
- 11:17the front row?
- 11:19>> He um does not appear to understand the
- 11:23anger in the room and sort of uh sets
- 11:25out to basically explain why uh what he
- 11:30has done
- 11:31makes economic sense.
- 11:33And one of the reasons he wanted to uh
- 11:37appear um at this conference was that
- 11:40there had been a lot of rumors about the
- 11:43source of his money that had enabled him
- 11:45to come in and basically take over some
- 11:47of the biggest companies in porn. I
- 11:49mean, it's quite bizarre, right? You
- 11:51have a German coming in uh like in his
- 11:54late 20s, early 30s, a
- 11:57developer suddenly having enough money
- 12:01to take over all these sort of storied,
- 12:03famed big porn businesses. Where was he
- 12:06getting the money from? And there were
- 12:07some rumors around the time that the
- 12:09money was coming from the Mafia because
- 12:11there had been involvement
- 12:13um you know there had been mafia
- 12:14involvement and
- 12:15and and porn uh and the sort of golden
- 12:18days back in the days before porn became
- 12:20more um legalized.
- 12:23Um
- 12:24and so he set out to dispel these rumors
- 12:26and basically told them like
- 12:28I got these this money from Wall Street
- 12:31and I mean this was so incredible to the
- 12:34people in the room that that many people
- 12:36to this day still don't believe it's
- 12:38true. You know we're not talking about
- 12:40enormous enormous amounts
- 12:43of money but in porn it was it was a
- 12:47lot. A lot of people had seen their own
- 12:49profits sort of disappear and they were
- 12:51going into the pockets of of this one
- 12:54man and I mean every day
- 12:57tens of thousands of hours of fresh porn
- 13:01is uploaded to
- 13:03these websites. I mean there's some
- 13:04statistics showing that you know at peak
- 13:07hours close to 10% of of online traffic
- 13:11is people watching
- 13:13pornography. Uh it's it's truly enormous
- 13:17uh the the amounts of time that the
- 13:20people that we spend watching porn
- 13:22online.
- 13:23>> In this moment in 2012 when Fabian
- 13:25Tilmann comes out onto the stage um
- 13:29where has he got the money from to
- 13:32control the porn industry in the way he
- 13:34did? I mean you said maybe there were
- 13:36rumors that the money had come from the
- 13:38mafia but
- 13:39how did he get the funds?
- 13:42>> Some of his earliest backers uh included
- 13:45uh JP Morgan uh
- 13:47Fortress Investment Group and even
- 13:49Cornell University
- 13:51who were sort of pulled together by um
- 13:55by two
- 13:57two bankers um who um
- 13:59who Fabian Tilmann managed to um
- 14:02to to convince to back this project by
- 14:05basically offering them huge amounts of
- 14:07money if they could actually
- 14:09get him the cash um that he needed.
- 14:12>> So establishment lenders essentially?
- 14:14>> Yes yes definitely and
- 14:16>> How did he persuade these establishment
- 14:18lenders to to do this?
- 14:19>> To ignore
- 14:21the pornography. The pitch was
- 14:22basically, this is not about porn. The
- 14:25porn, the content is is just incidental.
- 14:28This is an attention business. This is
- 14:31an internet business.
- 14:32>> And what was Fabian Tillmans method? How
- 14:36did he succeed in making money where
- 14:38others um had yet to succeed?
- 14:41>> So he never built a porn site. Um what
- 14:44he built was one of the world's first
- 14:46so-called um affiliate marketing
- 14:50software packages. So he built a tool
- 14:54that enabled uh website owners to see
- 14:58where users were clicking.
- 15:00>> Mhm.
- 15:01>> So when he built this software, what he
- 15:03basically gained insight to was the back
- 15:05end of a lot of porn sites and he could
- 15:07see one, how can you optimize uh
- 15:10advertising on these sites, but also how
- 15:12can you optimize the funneling of
- 15:15people's attention because that's
- 15:16basically what affiliate marketing is.
- 15:18If you're getting a lot of attention,
- 15:20how do you get people, you know, how do
- 15:22you sort of direct people to where they
- 15:24go where they go next?
- 15:26>> If if you imagine sort of individual A
- 15:30um
- 15:31and they are sitting in front of their
- 15:32computer, what do they have to do
- 15:35to what are they clicking on and doing
- 15:37in order to put money in Fabian
- 15:40Tillman's pocket as uh
- 15:43as a affiliate marketer?
- 15:45>> So from a porn site perspective, uh you
- 15:48know, to use a porn site example, it
- 15:49would be um if a uh
- 15:53a studio uploads a uh 10-minute long
- 15:57snippet of one of their porn films to
- 15:58Pornhub and people then go and they um
- 16:02they they they watch the content and
- 16:04maybe they would like to see more of the
- 16:05film and they then click on the link
- 16:08that there will be like a sort of a link
- 16:10to the to another website and then when
- 16:13they go and sort of buy a subscription
- 16:15or buy this film, then the porn will
- 16:18have to pay Pornhub.
- 16:21And this is
- 16:21>> So it's like a finder's fee almost?
- 16:23>> Yes, yes. And so this is a story that I
- 16:25heard from um from early Tube site
- 16:29Tube site entrepreneurs that
- 16:32you know, at first the porn studios were
- 16:34trying to fight the Tube sites and they
- 16:37were just sort of trying to get their
- 16:38content removed from the Tube sites
- 16:40constantly. And slowly it sort of
- 16:42evolved into this point where it was
- 16:43like, okay, fine, it's impossible. We're
- 16:45We're going to have to collaborate with
- 16:47them. And so the Tube sites started
- 16:49offering these this affiliate marketing
- 16:51where they would say, okay, you can
- 16:53advertise on on our platform and um
- 16:57uh and then, you know, if if if people
- 17:00actually go and purchase something on on
- 17:02your site, you just you just sort of pay
- 17:04us this so-called finder's fee. Um and I
- 17:07spoke to one man um who worked for one
- 17:10of
- 17:11um one of these these Tube sites in the
- 17:13network in in the early days who
- 17:14basically said that many of these
- 17:16studios couldn't afford it. You know,
- 17:17they were putting businesses
- 17:19out of business essentially.
- 17:21>> Because they were directing so much
- 17:22traffic to these other businesses.
- 17:24>> Because they were taking such great fees
- 17:27for I mean, they could be taking for
- 17:29example, 50% of any subscription that um
- 17:32that these um that these studios could
- 17:35could get from um when people were
- 17:37coming in through the
- 17:39the Tube sites.
- 17:40>> Above and beyond porn, how ubiquitous is
- 17:44this affiliate marketing on the
- 17:45internet?
- 17:46>> This is how the internet works today.
- 17:47This is why news organizations, you
- 17:50know, this is why the BBC keeps posting
- 17:51its content on on X and Instagram and
- 17:54TikTok and and and and and Facebook
- 17:57because it needs this attention. It's
- 17:58trying to get some of the attention that
- 18:00these platforms have. And then when
- 18:02people actually click through and pay
- 18:04for any of the journalism that they
- 18:06consume, then they also have to pay
- 18:09these platforms a fee. But it's also one
- 18:11of the foundational legs of businesses
- 18:14like Amazon. I mean, Amazon managed to
- 18:16become so big and so powerful because of
- 18:19its affiliate marketing program, which
- 18:21was basically saying that um if you it
- 18:24was telling owners of other websites, if
- 18:27you're hosting links that lead to Amazon
- 18:31and that makes people to make a purchase
- 18:33on on Amazon, we will pay you some
- 18:36money. I mean, we've seen it also, for
- 18:37example, with OnlyFans. You know, they
- 18:40also use affiliate marketing where
- 18:42OnlyFans performers um start hosting
- 18:46content from other performers and then,
- 18:49you know, they take a cut when when they
- 18:51sort of manage to funnel some of their
- 18:54uh
- 18:55you know, manage to
- 18:56funnel some of their fans to to someone
- 18:59else. But there's also I mean, OnlyFans
- 19:01still to this day operates a finders fee
- 19:03where if I'm an OnlyFans performer and I
- 19:06get you to sign on, then I will get 5%
- 19:09of everything you make in your first
- 19:12year, which of course is the sort of
- 19:14like incentivizes
- 19:16uh you know, would incentivize me to go
- 19:18out and find as many potential OnlyFans
- 19:20models as as as possible.
- 19:22>> Well, we're going to get onto OnlyFans
- 19:23in a little bit. Um at this point in our
- 19:26story in in 2012,
- 19:28um Fabian is maybe at the height of his
- 19:31powers, but not very long after that in
- 19:342013, he has to sell this company Manwin
- 19:38um because uh he has some issues over
- 19:41the payment of taxes. Who does he sell
- 19:44the business to? Introduce, please, for
- 19:47us the the the second character um in
- 19:49terms of, you know, kind of porn
- 19:51magnates in the digital age.
- 19:54>> Fabian Tilman gets arrested for tax
- 19:56evasion um and um the lenders who are
- 20:02essentially controlling the company uh
- 20:04basically kick him out and they tell him
- 20:07that uh they don't want him
- 20:10uh
- 20:10running things anymore because he is
- 20:12attracting unwanted attention and they
- 20:15want to remain anonymous. I mean, at
- 20:16this point um the sort of first cast of
- 20:19of
- 20:20backers has been changed because um as
- 20:24soon as the sort of names of
- 20:26of the investors who who helped build
- 20:29the company behind Pornhub League, they
- 20:31pulled out and sold the debt. So at that
- 20:33point, he sort of makes this
- 20:35announcement where he says that he is
- 20:37going to sell the company to uh his
- 20:40executive team,
- 20:42uh two men called Firas Antoon and David
- 20:44Tassillo, um and an investor, he says.
- 20:48And that is sort of the end of the
- 20:50story. I mean, if there was if there was
- 20:52a slight moment of relative transparency
- 20:56with Fabian, uh
- 20:58MindGeek, which the company is then
- 21:00renamed as, uh just becomes,
- 21:04you know, a fortress. In this era, I
- 21:06think the CEO does does one interview. I
- 21:10mean, no one really speaks of of what
- 21:12they do. Um there're loads of really
- 21:14weird practices, like for example, their
- 21:17executives uh giving quotes, MindGeek
- 21:20executives giving quotes um in the press
- 21:23and without there actually being any
- 21:26evidence that these people exist. They
- 21:28seem to be even making up people and and
- 21:31and in this way.
- 21:33So that is sort of the state of affairs
- 21:35um when um I come along and I'm I'm
- 21:39trying to figure out essentially who is
- 21:42making money from from from this
- 21:44business. And so at this point,
- 21:46>> year is this?
- 21:48>> This is in uh well, it was probably 2019
- 21:512020.
- 21:52>> Okay, so quite a lot of time passes.
- 21:55>> yes.
- 21:55>> years have passed between the sale of
- 21:57Manwin to Nobody really knows who is
- 22:00controlling this business, which is now
- 22:02called Mo uh MindGeek.
- 22:05>> MindGeek.
- 22:05>> Uh and then you come into the story. So
- 22:07what happens?
- 22:08>> Yeah. I mean, just also quickly to say
- 22:10that I think it's no one really knows
- 22:12and no one really cares. I mean, part of
- 22:13the reason that no one really knew about
- 22:15this is that we don't talk about
- 22:17pornography. I mean, there's a massive
- 22:18taboo and no one Even though uh this
- 22:20company has is commanding so much um has
- 22:24so much influence over over online
- 22:27culture and sexual culture. And no one's
- 22:29really asking these these questions.
- 22:31But so I want to try and figure out who
- 22:33is actually making making money from
- 22:35from online pornography. So there is Do
- 22:37we already have this I I find out I
- 22:40learned a story about sort of the the
- 22:42marriage between porn and Wall Street
- 22:44and and how they influenced the creation
- 22:47of this sort of of this pornographic
- 22:49conglomerate.
- 22:51But still there's some things that don't
- 22:53really make sense. And so
- 22:55the way that MindGeek is structured is
- 23:00very similar to the way that many
- 23:01multinational corporations is
- 23:02structured, which is that they will have
- 23:04companies and and and and and various
- 23:07different jurisdictions where they were
- 23:08operating. But the actual intellectual
- 23:11property of these companies So for
- 23:13example, the intellectual property of
- 23:15Pornhub will sit with a subsidiary which
- 23:20is based in a
- 23:23in a country where you don't have to pay
- 23:24a lot of tax. In this case in in
- 23:26Luxembourg.
- 23:27And this is how multinational
- 23:29corporations often don't pay tax because
- 23:32that means that the sort of parent
- 23:33company has to pay the subsidiaries for
- 23:37the right to use the IP of, you know,
- 23:39the the various brands that they own.
- 23:42And that means that the parent company
- 23:43itself is making very little money and
- 23:46sometimes it's even loss-making while
- 23:48the money is being funneled elsewhere
- 23:50where you don't have to
- 23:51where you don't have to pay tax on them.
- 23:54But what was interesting in the case of
- 23:56MindGeek was that some of these
- 23:57subsidiaries
- 24:00MindGeek actually only owned a third
- 24:02>> Mhm.
- 24:02>> and two-thirds of these total companies
- 24:05were owned by a sort of
- 24:08by another shareholder, an unnamed
- 24:10shareholder. And so I I started trying
- 24:13to figure out who who this person was.
- 24:15And it it wasn't until I had a
- 24:17conversation with someone who had been
- 24:18involved with financing the company at
- 24:21at one stage.
- 24:23And I was trying to I was trying to ask
- 24:25questions. This person on the phone
- 24:27said, you know, sweetest words
- 24:29journalists can hear. He said, you know,
- 24:32I will tell you something that very few
- 24:33people know.
- 24:35That is a sweet thing to hear.
- 24:36>> That is a sweet thing to hear.
- 24:38>> Mind Geek has a secret owner.
- 24:41And then he said his name is Bernard
- 24:43Burgemar.
- 24:45And
- 24:47I held the phone with my shoulder and I
- 24:49began typing it into my laptop and you
- 24:52know, I couldn't I couldn't find
- 24:54anything. There were no hits and so I
- 24:55asked him to spell the name again and I
- 24:57was like, are you are you sure? And he
- 24:59was like, yes.
- 25:01This is your guy. And he wouldn't answer
- 25:02any other questions.
- 25:03And so I went out and I did some more
- 25:05research and I actually managed to find
- 25:07only one hit on on this person which
- 25:10preferred to a 10-year-old
- 25:13court case which mentioned that Bernard
- 25:16Burgemar was a director of a tube site
- 25:19called Red Tube.
- 25:21A tube site which Mind Geek
- 25:24interestingly enough bought around the
- 25:26time that Fabian Tillman exited the
- 25:30company. But I eventually managed to
- 25:32find someone who could, you know, could
- 25:33confirm that this
- 25:35that this Bernard man existed
- 25:38and that he was this this Austrian
- 25:42investor. A couple of weeks later I get
- 25:44a call from one of my colleagues on the
- 25:48FT's investigative desk, Cynthia Mertru,
- 25:51who
- 25:53who told me that an old contact had
- 25:55called her and said that he knows this
- 25:57Bernard Burgemar guy
- 26:00and he knows his big secret which is
- 26:03that Bernard Burgemar is a fake name. So
- 26:07even though this is the name he's used
- 26:08in all his business dealings, he's even
- 26:10used it in court,
- 26:13it's a fake name. And his real name is
- 26:15Burnt Bergmeyer which of course is very
- 26:18similar. I mean, it's not a very
- 26:19creative
- 26:21alias. But
- 26:23this was quite, you know, this was a
- 26:24very important moment because while
- 26:27Bernard Burgemar had gone through great
- 26:29lengths to make sure that no one knew
- 26:31nothing about him. Bernd Bergmeier
- 26:33actually had a real life. He had a wife,
- 26:35he had kids, he had former colleagues.
- 26:39Um, and this is basically where we
- 26:40started
- 26:42learning that he was this former Goldman
- 26:44Sachs banker
- 26:46um, who had
- 26:48retired
- 26:50many years ago. He was Austrian and he
- 26:51had moved back to Vienna and he had
- 26:53become a financial advisor and he had
- 26:55then come across
- 26:57these tech guys who were trying to sell
- 27:01an internet business called Red Tube
- 27:04because one of the founders had fallen
- 27:06in love with a Catholic woman and he
- 27:08needed to get out of the business very
- 27:09quickly.
- 27:11Um, and at one point it appears that
- 27:15Bernd Bergmeier decided that rather that
- 27:18rather than to help
- 27:20these guys find a buyer for the company,
- 27:23he was just going to buy it outright
- 27:24himself.
- 27:25>> Mhm.
- 27:25>> And
- 27:26it's quite extraordinary. I mean, in
- 27:28these early days as a as a porn mogul,
- 27:31like he had no idea what he was doing.
- 27:32He knew nothing about the porn industry.
- 27:34He knew nothing about running, you know,
- 27:36one of the most trafficked websites in
- 27:38the world and he was actually
- 27:41reaching out to rivals, I mean, other
- 27:43sort of
- 27:44porn platform owners and just asking if
- 27:46he could take them out for lunch and you
- 27:48know, pick their pick their brains on on
- 27:50on how the business actually works.
- 27:52>> Okay, so he buys the company off Fabian.
- 27:56How different is the way that he then
- 27:59chooses to run the organization?
- 28:02>> I mean, he's very much an anonymous
- 28:04investor in a way.
- 28:05But something something else happens
- 28:08around this time, which is that
- 28:10um,
- 28:12up until this point
- 28:14sort of traditional advertising, I mean,
- 28:16banner ads, these sort of things have
- 28:17been sort of a big money maker for
- 28:20companies like Pornhub and for all user
- 28:23generated sites on on the internet. But
- 28:25around this time
- 28:27something starts changing. First thing
- 28:29is that we become much more concerned
- 28:32with privacy. A lot of people start
- 28:33using ad blockers, which sort of means
- 28:36that um rather than just capturing
- 28:40sort of as much data as possible on on
- 28:43on users, the business becomes more
- 28:45about like using that data to learn as
- 28:48much as possible about the user. So the
- 28:52analytics sort of become more important.
- 28:55Another big change is that this is the
- 28:58era of the smartphone. So we start using
- 29:01our phones to consume content rather
- 29:04than our laptops, which means that you
- 29:07know, these big sort of banner ads that
- 29:09you will have on on websites when you
- 29:12when you look at a site through a laptop
- 29:15um they're not really working anymore
- 29:17and and these were the the big money
- 29:19makers. So
- 29:21and the book I I refer to it as a sort
- 29:23of
- 29:24you know, the user generated economy and
- 29:26especially the porn industry is like a
- 29:28one sided mirror. It's collecting so
- 29:30much data on us, some of our most
- 29:32private impulses and it's using this
- 29:35data to inform what it is we
- 29:40we we see in order to to get us to stay
- 29:42on these sites and engage with these
- 29:44sites as long as possible. But so while
- 29:47so while the company is at this point
- 29:49starting to learn more and more about
- 29:51us, we actually see a retreat in terms
- 29:54of transparency about who
- 29:57who is running the company uh and who's
- 30:00owning the company and and how.
- 30:02>> Well what have Bergmar
- 30:05or Berg My, if you want to call him by
- 30:07his his real name, and Mind Geek been
- 30:09able to do with that huge trove of data
- 30:12that they have? Like how do they
- 30:14actually monetize it?
- 30:15>> I mean one of the things they do is of
- 30:16course like any internet business is
- 30:19that they trade this data. So they share
- 30:22it with other companies so that to
- 30:25create these sort of online profiles of
- 30:28of us which are then commodities that
- 30:30can be that can be bought and sold.
- 30:32>> Do you mean as individuals or do you
- 30:34mean on a kind of macro level?
- 30:36>> As individuals.
- 30:38>> So is there a world in which MindGeek
- 30:40actually has kind of compromising
- 30:42information on hundreds of millions or
- 30:45even billions of people?
- 30:47>> Well, that's a very good question, isn't
- 30:49it?
- 30:50I mean,
- 30:51look, internet companies basically say,
- 30:53especially with today that you know,
- 30:55they abide by GDPR and so on that data
- 30:57is anonymized etc etc. But we've seen in
- 31:01leaks time and time again that actually
- 31:03it's very easy to identify people,
- 31:05especially when you have leaks from sort
- 31:08of logged in accounts and so on when
- 31:10I mean, it wasn't it was just a couple
- 31:12of months ago that Pornhub had data leak
- 31:15where they were they had
- 31:18you know, sexual preferences and and
- 31:19search histories linked to
- 31:22email addresses. So
- 31:25these companies know way more about us
- 31:27than than we perhaps
- 31:30want to know. Something that's really
- 31:31interesting about MindGeek in particular
- 31:33is how they were a leader, a pioneer in
- 31:38what some researchers have called data
- 31:40led creativity, which basically meant
- 31:42that they were taking data on what
- 31:44people click
- 31:46click on and they were they were using
- 31:49it to make decisions on what kind of
- 31:51content to produce. And this is
- 31:54something that you know, today this is
- 31:56what Amazon does, this is what Apple
- 31:58does, this is what Spotify does. A lot
- 32:00of the content that we're consuming is
- 32:02being informed by data on what we
- 32:04actually click on. And this was
- 32:05something that MindGeek was a pioneer
- 32:07in. But more importantly, this sort of
- 32:10have been a new revolution in
- 32:11pornography. So while
- 32:14Pornhub was you know, a symbolic of the
- 32:17business model of free porn, now we're
- 32:20actually entering an era again where
- 32:21people are paying for porn and we're
- 32:23seeing the rise of of OnlyFans and
- 32:25people sort of wanting bespoke
- 32:27pornography, but also
- 32:30wanting
- 32:33wanting what
- 32:34the rise of parasocial intimacy and
- 32:37basically people being willing to pay
- 32:39for the illusion of having a um a
- 32:42relationship with the people they see on
- 32:43their screens.
- 32:44>> Well, how has OnlyFans changed the
- 32:47industry?
- 32:48>> It basically married um the cam site
- 32:51business model. So camming comes from
- 32:53webcams. That's when sex workers talk to
- 32:55people often on the other side of the
- 32:58world uh through a through a screen.
- 33:00This is a business that has existing
- 33:02since, you know, the mid early nineties.
- 33:04Um and so it it it married this idea of
- 33:08sort of the parasocial intimacy with
- 33:10really the
- 33:12the vocabulary of the internet today,
- 33:14you know? Because OnlyFans just looks
- 33:16like a normal feed and rather than uh
- 33:20sort of talking to people, you know,
- 33:22like this over video call, um most of
- 33:26the interactions take place via text,
- 33:28which of course is the way we prefer to
- 33:31to communicate with people um these
- 33:33days.
- 33:34>> Okay. So that's a that's a big change in
- 33:37porn, but how is OnlyFans changing the
- 33:40rest of the internet? We've asked that
- 33:42question um about MindGeek. We've asked
- 33:45it about Fabian's business before that,
- 33:47but what's OnlyFans done for the wider
- 33:50internet?
- 33:50>> I mean, the the way I the way I think
- 33:53about it was that the first people to
- 33:55really start um to curate online
- 33:58personas and to think of of of
- 34:02themselves in this slightly different
- 34:04way, which I think is very second nature
- 34:06to us today, were actually sex workers,
- 34:08were cam performers. They were the first
- 34:10people who were out there on proto
- 34:12algorithms trying to vie for attention
- 34:15in a way that um well, it's basically
- 34:18foundational today for the content
- 34:20creator economy and and and the
- 34:21influencer economy. And so the way I see
- 34:24it um
- 34:26OnlyFans is the sort of
- 34:28uh I don't know, the most logical
- 34:30conclusion of these forces that have
- 34:32been shaping the internet for for all
- 34:33these all these years because it's
- 34:35basically if we can say that we've
- 34:38normalized this type of platform labor,
- 34:40being an influencer, posting content, uh
- 34:42trying to attract attention, what
- 34:44OnlyFans is offering in a way is to
- 34:46actually cash in on it. And so,
- 34:49if this is already normal, if being like
- 34:52this on the internet is already normal,
- 34:54why not take the extra step and just
- 34:56make money off? The way you make money
- 34:58is by making your audience feel seen, by
- 35:02validating them, by upholding this
- 35:04fantasy that they that they have.
- 35:06>> Mm. Okay. Well, you've described for us
- 35:08today three ways in which porn has
- 35:12arguably changed the internet and the
- 35:14way it functions. So, if we consider
- 35:17that the broader internet is kind of
- 35:20downstream of pornography, what's the
- 35:22next frontier in that case? Like, where
- 35:24does porn go next that uh continues to
- 35:27shape the world after that?
- 35:29>> Mm. I think for me um this there's two
- 35:33main trends. I mean, the first is the
- 35:34rise of parasocial intimacy, and I think
- 35:37the normalization I think it's becoming
- 35:39more and more normal that we're paying
- 35:42uh people for attention online, the way
- 35:45that we not that long ago would only pay
- 35:48for sex workers' attention. Um but I
- 35:52also think that you can see
- 35:55in the sort of in this sycophantic way
- 35:58that chatbots are engaging with us. And,
- 36:02you know, we've already heard so many
- 36:03stories about people falling in love
- 36:04with their chatbots and, of course,
- 36:05having sex with their chatbots. And why?
- 36:08Because they are so good at making us
- 36:11stay longer and give away more and more
- 36:14of ourselves and making us feel feel
- 36:18feel validated and upholding these
- 36:19fantasies we have about ourselves, which
- 36:22is
- 36:23to me so striking because this is when
- 36:26I've been talking to cam models, this is
- 36:28exactly what what they do. And so, I
- 36:31think that the way uh chatbots have been
- 36:33designed to interact with us is
- 36:36also eerily um alike with with the the
- 36:41role that sex workers have played in
- 36:43many people's lives.
- 36:44>> So,
- 36:44>> the next frontier is sort of the nexus
- 36:46of AI and pornography.
- 36:50>> Yes.
- 36:51>> Okay. Patricia, I have to ask you one
- 36:54final question. I know journalists don't
- 36:56like to talk about themselves, but how
- 36:58do you feel after six or seven years of
- 37:00going
- 37:02so in such detail on such a like very
- 37:05[clears throat] intense subject,
- 37:06investigating it in the depth that you
- 37:07have?
- 37:09>> There's some things that once you
- 37:11understand them, it completely changes
- 37:13your perspective on the world. And
- 37:15online porn is truly like it. I mean, at
- 37:19some point during this investigation, I
- 37:22just realized that the online porn
- 37:24industry is not actually about porn and
- 37:26it's not actually about sex. It's about
- 37:30our online lives today and
- 37:34the incentives that are keeping us
- 37:36there. I think that
- 37:38watching porn that is stimulating a
- 37:43psychosocial need by staring at content
- 37:45that has been
- 37:47algorithm algorithmically engineered to
- 37:50arouse us and doing so in isolation,
- 37:54that is the perfect metaphor of our
- 37:56relationship with our devices. That is
- 37:59what we do on our phones. We pick them
- 38:01up to soothe ourselves, to seek
- 38:03gratification, and we do it
- 38:06on our own. And so that's what I call
- 38:09the masturbatory business model
- 38:11of of the internet.
- 38:13>> Patricia, thank you so much. It's been
- 38:15fascinating talking this through with
- 38:16you. Thank you.
- 38:17>> Thank you for having [music] me here.
- 38:19>> That was Patricia Nelson of the
- 38:20Financial Times and author of Guilty
- 38:23Pleasure, the pornification of the
- 38:24internet, the economy, and everything
- 38:27else. Thanks so much for tuning in.
- 38:29We'll be back again soon. The Global
- 38:31Story is also an audio podcast. We're
- 38:33available every weekday on bbc.com
- 38:36or wherever you listen. Thanks for
- 38:37tuning in. Cheerio.
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of Who's making all of the money in the porn industry? | The Global Story by BBC News, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 6,377 words across 993 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.