Which is the BEST AI note taker? Plaud vs Zoom, Otter and more! — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:00Last time I checked, we're all still
- 0:01drowning in calls and meetings and it's
- 0:03so easy to forget what was said by who
- 0:06and what's going to happen next. So,
- 0:08I've spent the last few weeks testing a
- 0:10bunch of ways to fix it including this
- 0:12little gadget, the Plaud Note, [music]
- 0:13to see if you should pay for hardware
- 0:16and a subscription or just use what you
- 0:19already own.
- 0:22>> [music]
- 0:23>> Rewind a year or so ago and the Plaud
- 0:24Note was the latest go-to gadget for
- 0:27capturing calls and meetings, but this
- 0:29game is moving fast. My iPhone now
- 0:32records and summarizes calls natively,
- 0:34whilst Microsoft and Zoom have AI
- 0:37summaries baked in and there are other
- 0:39players like Otter automating it all in
- 0:41the background. So, I wanted to see if
- 0:43this little physical device still has a
- 0:45place in a world where software does
- 0:47most of the heavy lifting, especially
- 0:49when some of the alternatives are
- 0:50included with software or devices you
- 0:53might already have. In this video, I'm
- 0:54going to run down all the competition
- 0:56and see if Plaud is still something that
- 0:57I'd recommend because I do get it. Not
- 0:59everyone can justify a $160 device plus
- 1:02a monthly subscription to hear all your
- 1:05calls, meetings, and thoughts sent back
- 1:07to you as beautifully summarized notes.
- 1:10Oh, and this isn't sponsored by Plaud,
- 1:11by the way. I'm going to tell you about
- 1:12this video's sponsor in just a bit.
- 1:14Let's start with a brief recap on how
- 1:16the Plaud Note works. So, you press this
- 1:18button to record, you press it to stop,
- 1:20you sync it to your app, that generates
- 1:22a transcript. You can then choose a
- 1:24summary style and export it to your
- 1:26favorite note-keeping app or just keep
- 1:28it in Plaud and search using their AI
- 1:31later on. The battery lasts ages, it
- 1:32doesn't murder your phone, it's great in
- 1:34busy rooms, lectures, and especially
- 1:36when phones are banned or maybe frowned
- 1:39upon. And yeah, it does have a
- 1:40subscription, which is optional. You get
- 1:42300 transcription minutes thrown in
- 1:45every month when you buy the device. And
- 1:47of course, most of us hate
- 1:48subscriptions, but guess what? AI
- 1:50processing is not free to run. Now,
- 1:52whether it's worth it depends on what
- 1:54you want to remember and how much time
- 1:56it's going to save you each week. Now,
- 1:58before I get into our first comparison,
- 2:00what I really wanted to do in this video
- 2:02was take, say, five different meetings
- 2:05or interactions and run them through all
- 2:06the different products we're going to
- 2:07test today for a super objective test.
- 2:10Now, that sounds like it should be easy,
- 2:12but it is in fact pretty impossible due
- 2:14to the way some of these services work.
- 2:16So, what we'll do instead is have a few
- 2:17rounds of testing where I pit Plaud
- 2:19against its top competitors and see who
- 2:21comes out on top for each round. Let's
- 2:24go. First of all, let's take a look at
- 2:25the obvious competition, which was an
- 2:26update in the latest iOS, and that lets
- 2:29you record calls right on your iPhone.
- 2:31Now, if you're in a call and you hit the
- 2:33record button, this sends the caller an
- 2:35audible note to say that the call is
- 2:37being recorded. And then, to stop
- 2:38recording, you can just tap that button
- 2:40or hang up. Your iPhone then
- 2:42automatically saves call recordings to a
- 2:45special call recording folder over in
- 2:47your Notes app. Now, this new feature
- 2:49does offer a transcription service,
- 2:51though it's not usually available
- 2:52straight away.
- 2:53>> [music]
- 2:53>> You can see that transcription by
- 2:54clicking the little speech bubble icon,
- 2:56which lets you skip to the audio in the
- 2:58track. You can search through the
- 2:59transcript and also get a summary of the
- 3:01call if you've got Apple Intelligence
- 3:03switched on. Now, there isn't a choice
- 3:05of the format of the summary that you
- 3:06get, but based on my testing, it's
- 3:08relatively accurate. Sometimes it can
- 3:10get some words wrong, especially
- 3:12industry jargon or maybe listening to
- 3:14someone with a more heavy accent. So,
- 3:16that's the call recording feature, but
- 3:18you can use pretty much the same
- 3:19workflow for in-person meetings if you
- 3:21just put your phone on the table and hit
- 3:23record in the Voice Memos app. Android
- 3:26users, I've not forgotten about you. If
- 3:27you're on a Samsung S series or Google's
- 3:30latest Pixel devices, you get this type
- 3:32of thing included on your phones, too.
- 3:34So, compared to Plaud, there's already
- 3:36one clear advantage. It's already on
- 3:38your phone without you needing to pay
- 3:39anything extra on top of the cost of
- 3:42your device. And it does work. In the
- 3:44case of Apple's recording, it's also
- 3:45private and on your device by default,
- 3:48so it's really simple and secure. But in
- 3:50terms of downsides, well, there are
- 3:52quite a few. Firstly, using this feature
- 3:54setting me on iPhone absolutely hammers
- 3:57your phone's battery. As an example, I
- 3:59recorded a 60-minute call the other day
- 4:00on my phone, and it dropped my battery
- 4:02by 25%
- 4:04on a single [music]
- 4:05call. The Plaud Note, on the other hand,
- 4:07lets you record around 30 hours
- 4:09straight, so you can keep your phone
- 4:10battery for when you need it. Secondly,
- 4:12the transcription on iOS isn't the best,
- 4:15and it only really works on one-to-one
- 4:17conversations. There's no obvious way of
- 4:19separating speakers out on things like
- 4:21conference calls, and there's only one
- 4:23kind of summary, which doesn't really
- 4:25understand any context [music] that
- 4:27you're working in. Plaud Note, on the
- 4:28other hand, covers multiple speakers
- 4:30with ease, and it gives you literally
- 4:31hundreds of summary formats to choose
- 4:33from, or you can even make your own.
- 4:36Plus, you can program in your own
- 4:37industry terms, so it always understands
- 4:39the context or any regular abbreviations
- 4:42that you use. That is not, however, an
- 4:44excuse to keep saying "circle back."
- 4:46Finally, if you want to use this feature
- 4:47on your phone, if you didn't record the
- 4:49audio using your phone, yeah, that's it.
- 4:52You can't import other audio into Apple
- 4:54Notes or Voice Memos to transcribe or
- 4:56summarize. But, yeah, you guessed it,
- 4:58with Plaud, you absolutely can. So, it
- 5:00can kind of work in reverse. If you
- 5:02recorded [music] a note in your phone
- 5:04app, but you didn't have your Plaud Note
- 5:05with you, you can still import the audio
- 5:08into Plaud, [music]
- 5:09and it'll do its thing. So, round one,
- 5:10it's an easy one. This one goes to
- 5:12Plaud. Before we go on, have you ever
- 5:13just [clears throat] wished you could
- 5:14click your fingers and be in your
- 5:16favorite coffee shop or on a beach
- 5:18streaming your own favorite show? Well,
- 5:20Surfshark is basically the digital
- 5:22version of that. It lets you teleport
- 5:24your favorite devices to a choice of 140
- 5:26locations with just one click. If you
- 5:29want to unlock US Netflix, it's easy. If
- 5:32you want cheaper flight deals by
- 5:33pretending you're in Argentina, yeah, no
- 5:35problem. And then, here's the part I
- 5:36love. Unlike other VPNs that make you
- 5:38pay more to cover extra devices,
- 5:40Surfshark gives you unlimited
- 5:42connections on all the devices in your
- 5:44home. One account protects all your
- 5:46stuff, and no extra fuss. And they've
- 5:48just added some brand new features that
- 5:50help you check emails for scams and
- 5:51phishing plus a web content blocker to
- 5:54help keep your family secure from
- 5:55inappropriate content and malicious
- 5:57sites. Oh, and of course, it keeps all
- 5:59your browsing private and your data safe
- 6:01even on dodgy public Wi-Fi. I've [music]
- 6:04teamed up with Surfshark to get you four
- 6:06extra months free plus a 30-day
- 6:08money-back guarantee. Click the link
- 6:10below or scan the code on screen to get
- 6:12started and a big thanks to Surfshark
- 6:14for sponsoring this video. Next, I want
- 6:15to show you a free alternative to Plaud,
- 6:17which a lot of people don't know about.
- 6:19Now, if you have Microsoft Word on your
- 6:21machine, it actually has a feature to
- 6:23transcribe any audio file. It's really
- 6:25basic, but yeah, it's free, you know, if
- 6:27you or your employer already pay for
- 6:29Microsoft Word. And that's about the
- 6:32only benefit here because in order to
- 6:33use this, you will need access to
- 6:35Microsoft Word, which requires a
- 6:37subscription these days, and they've
- 6:39actually just put the price up. And
- 6:41also, Microsoft Word is famous for doing
- 6:43stuff like this. Now, you can also get a
- 6:45summary here as well as a transcription,
- 6:47but you'll need to use Microsoft's AI to
- 6:49generate it, and in my testing, it was
- 6:51very hit and miss in terms of accuracy.
- 6:53Unpopular opinion, but I think we should
- 6:55probably just bring back Clippy. [music]
- 6:56Plaud, on the other hand, will work in a
- 6:58nice, clean web app or your phone app,
- 7:00and it'll separate out speakers and do
- 7:02you a bunch of different summaries
- 7:04depending on what you're transcribing,
- 7:05which Word, unfortunately, just cannot
- 7:08compete with. Round two goes to Plaud
- 7:11again. Next up, we've got a real
- 7:12contender, and that's Otter AI. This is
- 7:14one of the OGs of the AI recording game
- 7:17and was probably one of the first auto
- 7:18transcription tools I ever tried, and
- 7:21that experience really [music] shows.
- 7:23Otter is an app that automatically joins
- 7:25your meetings in Zoom, Google, and
- 7:27Teams, and then gives you an AI summary
- 7:30in real time with searchable notes.
- 7:32[music] It even has built-in agents for
- 7:34different use cases like sales,
- 7:36recruitment, education, and media. It
- 7:39also has some AI built in so that you
- 7:41can ask it questions from any past
- 7:43conversation or meeting that you've had.
- 7:45Now, in terms of Otter's advantages over
- 7:47Plaud, well, there is a free plan that
- 7:49gives you 300 minutes of transcription
- 7:51every month. Or, you can pay a monthly
- 7:53fee for 1,200 transcription minutes,
- 7:56unlimited storage, and the ability to
- 7:59import your own audios and video files
- 8:01into Otter. I'd say the auto
- 8:03transcription is genuinely excellent,
- 8:05and it has some of the best search and
- 8:07keywording I've seen so far. It also
- 8:10lets you join concurrent meetings if you
- 8:11ever need to be in two places at once.
- 8:14Plus, while it is possible to use Plaud
- 8:16in virtual meetings either by putting
- 8:17your device next to the speaker or using
- 8:20the Windows desktop app, it's not easy
- 8:22if you're mainly using headphones or
- 8:24using a Mac as the Plaud desktop app
- 8:27isn't available for Mac users, although
- 8:29I am told it's on the way. [music] Are
- 8:31there any ways that Plaud beats Otter?
- 8:32Well, in my view, Plaud is certainly
- 8:34more optimized for in-person audio such
- 8:37as meetings and lectures, conferences,
- 8:41that kind of thing. If you're a busy
- 8:42professional who conducts lots of
- 8:43in-person meetings, Plaud's probably
- 8:45going to work better for you. It's worth
- 8:46saying you can use Otter for in-person
- 8:49meetings, too, but it's a much more
- 8:51complicated workflow involving an app.
- 8:53There's also the challenges in terms of
- 8:55different languages and accents. Plaud
- 8:57supports over 200 different languages,
- 8:59which might be really important if you
- 9:02work [music] in a multilingual team. And
- 9:04again, in my experience, Plaud generally
- 9:05does a pretty good job of tracking
- 9:07accents even from a here across the UK
- 9:10where regional differences in accent can
- 9:12vary a lot. So yeah, I'd say this round
- 9:14is more of a draw, I think, and
- 9:15whichever wins out for you will kind of
- 9:17depend on what kind of meetings you tend
- 9:19to have. I think Otter is still superb
- 9:22for virtual meetings, but if you work in
- 9:23a hybrid way, in conferences, cafes,
- 9:27[music] and in-person conversations on
- 9:29the go, that press and forget workflow
- 9:31from Plaud is probably going to be much
- 9:33easier. Okay, so we're on to our final
- 9:34round, and I wanted to group together
- 9:35the built-in note takers from Zoom,
- 9:38Google Meet, and the complete horror
- 9:40show that is Microsoft Teams. Now, in
- 9:42terms of pros with these ones, well,
- 9:44there's no extra app. You just fire it
- 9:46up when the meeting starts and forget
- 9:48about it. You also get things like auto
- 9:50notes for the whole team joining the
- 9:51call, which can definitely save time in
- 9:54terms of follow-up. And also, from a
- 9:55data privacy perspective, I think this
- 9:57is likely to suit your compliance setups
- 9:59if you're already using them within an
- 10:00organization as it'll probably have been
- 10:02set up that way when your IT department
- 10:05configured it all. Now, in terms of
- 10:06downsides, well, quality definitely
- 10:09varies here. Summaries can be a bit
- 10:10vague at best or at worst completely
- 10:13inaccurate. [music] They're also
- 10:14platform locked, so they will work
- 10:16inside a Google Meet session or Zoom or
- 10:18Teams call, but pretty useless if you're
- 10:20also taking phone calls, WhatsApp calls,
- 10:23or in-person sessions. And if, like me,
- 10:25you're a solo business, there are often
- 10:27hidden paid tiers here for things like
- 10:29storage, and they can really add up over
- 10:31time. So, yeah, I think these options
- 10:33can be really great if you spend all day
- 10:35in one of these app ecosystems.
- 10:37Otherwise, I think Plaud or Otter is
- 10:39just more flexible all round. Yeah, so
- 10:42round four
- 10:43goes to Plaud.
- 10:45So, after testing out a number of
- 10:46alternatives, all things considered,
- 10:48[music] I think there is still a case to
- 10:50be made for having a physical recording
- 10:53device
- 10:53>> [music]
- 10:53>> that records and summarizes your
- 10:55meetings and calls. I've got a couple of
- 10:57other things that I need to tell you
- 10:58about though. First of all, a point on
- 11:00accessibility and inclusion. I think for
- 11:02folk with memory issues, visual
- 11:04impairments, ADHD, or multilingual
- 11:08workspaces, accurate recordings and
- 11:10action item summaries are not a luxury.
- 11:13They represent [music] independence. And
- 11:14this is where reliable capture and clear
- 11:17intelligent summaries matter way more
- 11:19than just saving a fiver every month on
- 11:22another subscription. Secondly, a note
- 11:24on data security and privacy. I think if
- 11:26you're recording any kind of
- 11:28conversation, whether it's a deeply
- 11:30personal one or an everyday business
- 11:31meeting, you should have an eye on where
- 11:34that data is going. I used to run a
- 11:35business involved in collecting personal
- 11:37data, so I know quite a bit about
- 11:39various privacy standards. And I've been
- 11:41really pleased to see Plaud continuing
- 11:43to strengthen its approach here. They've
- 11:44just added two ISO certifications to
- 11:46their lineup alongside [music] GDPR, SOC
- 11:492, and HIPAA. I do know from experience
- 11:52how much work will have to go on in the
- 11:54background to get those certifications,
- 11:56and yeah, it is a lot. So, in
- 11:58conclusion, this is my verdict on
- 12:00everything I've experienced whilst
- 12:01making this video. I think if you live
- 12:03in Zoom or Teams all day, use the
- 12:06built-in apps, or maybe something like
- 12:07Otter. I reckon if you're all about
- 12:09sticking to a tight budget, or you're a
- 12:11student maybe, use the free workflows
- 12:13that I showed. And if you don't mind
- 12:15some additional time spent in getting
- 12:16everything set [music] up exactly the
- 12:18way you want it across multiple
- 12:20platforms, and you're happy to deal with
- 12:22some quirks along the way, they can
- 12:25absolutely be good enough. If you're
- 12:27more of a hybrid meeting attendee, I'm
- 12:29talking phone calls with in-person and
- 12:32random rooms with occasional virtual
- 12:34meetings thrown in, and you want
- 12:35something that you can rely on with the
- 12:37press of a button, I do think that Plaud
- 12:40still earns its place in your setup. If
- 12:42you want to grab one of these for
- 12:43yourself, there's a link and a discount
- 12:45code in the description, or you can scan
- 12:46this code up here. Meanwhile, if you're
- 12:48interested to know more about how the
- 12:50Plaud Note Pro works differently to the
- 12:52regular Plaud Note, check out my
- 12:54comparison video. It's just over here.
- 12:56See you next time.
- 13:06>> [music]
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of Which is the BEST AI note taker? Plaud vs Zoom, Otter and more! by That Mark Gilroy, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 2,653 words across 395 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.