Where Smells Go; Hypothyroidism and Depression | Robert Sapolsky Father-Offspring Interviews — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:00This is Robert Sapolsky and you're
- 0:03listening to Father Offspring
- 0:05Interviews.
- 0:10>> Greetings. Welcome back to Father
- 0:12Offspring Interviews. Starting off a
- 0:15question from Vinash in India who
- 0:17describes their struggles with
- 0:18depression and being hypothyroid. They
- 0:21ask to what extent might hypothyroidism
- 0:23contribute to the severity of my
- 0:25depression?
- 0:27>> To potentially a pretty dramatic extent.
- 0:31A link here between how your thyroid
- 0:34gland is functioning
- 0:36and vulnerability to depression. It's
- 0:39important. It's really interesting. It's
- 0:42got some counterintuitive elements. It's
- 0:44way under appreciated.
- 0:46And my guess is at least one person
- 0:50watching or listening to this, suddenly
- 0:52a whole bunch of medically unexplainable
- 0:56things are going to fall into place.
- 0:58Thyroid gland. Gland. It's an organ that
- 1:01releases chemical messengers into your
- 1:04bloodstream. Hormones. Your thyroid
- 1:06gland releases thyroid hormone
- 1:08shockingly enough. And it's the third
- 1:11step in a classic hormonal cascade
- 1:14termed a hypothalamic pituitary
- 1:17peripheral gland axis. Hypothalamus,
- 1:20base of your brain.
- 1:22It releases a hormone which gets your
- 1:24pituitary to release a hormone which
- 1:27gets your thyroid gland to release
- 1:29thyroid hormone. If you insist on
- 1:32jargon, the hormone that comes out of
- 1:34the hypothalamus abbreviated TRH, you
- 1:38don't even want to know what it stands
- 1:39for. TRH comes out of the hypothalamus
- 1:43which triggers the pituitary to release
- 1:45its thyroid stimulating hormone called
- 1:48TSH which gets the thyroid gland to
- 1:52release thyroid hormone.
- 1:54One extra detail, the thyroid hormone
- 1:57coming out is referred to as T4, an
- 2:00form, and it gets into cells all over
- 2:02the body and is then activated into T3,
- 2:07the form that actually does biological
- 2:09stuff.
- 2:10And if you are a neurobiologist, you
- 2:12were utterly bored by the thyroid axis
- 2:15and you once had to memorize it and
- 2:17remember it for an exam and you promptly
- 2:20deleted right afterward because it's
- 2:22totally boring stuff. Thyroid hormone
- 2:25does stuff to metabolism throughout your
- 2:28body, the rate at which your body is
- 2:30consuming energy, is building new
- 2:33complex molecules and muscle and bone
- 2:37and such. And what thyroid hormone does
- 2:40is it enhances metabolism throughout
- 2:43your body.
- 2:44And it does so by working on the famed
- 2:47powerhouse of every cell in our body,
- 2:50mitochondria, increasing mitochondrial
- 2:53energy production, increasing all sorts
- 2:56of building processes throughout the
- 2:59body that consume that extra
- 3:01mitochondrial energy. This is what
- 3:03thyroid hormone is about.
- 3:05And then every now and then you get
- 3:08somebody whose thyroid system stops
- 3:11working very well. You've got somebody
- 3:13who is hypothyroid.
- 3:16If it's in a fetus, if it's in a kid,
- 3:18this could be majorly consequential for
- 3:20brain development, but after that point,
- 3:24people really traditionally didn't think
- 3:25about the brain when getting to
- 3:27hypothyroid syndromes.
- 3:30What does it look like? For one thing,
- 3:32it is predominantly
- 3:34females over males and there are some
- 3:37interesting angles with that that we'll
- 3:39get to.
- 3:40What does it look like? You got somebody
- 3:43who's fatigued. No wonder their
- 3:46powerhouses are not powering so much
- 3:49energy production, so fatigue, slow
- 3:52heart rate, bradycardia,
- 3:54slow metabolic rate, person is cold, the
- 3:58body is not generating heat as readily.
- 4:01There is weight being put on in part
- 4:04because appetite increases,
- 4:06and for the extent of food being
- 4:08consumed, a disproportionate percentage
- 4:11of it is being stored. It's not being
- 4:13burned because you are hypothyroid.
- 4:16Your bones and joints hurt. Your periods
- 4:19become
- 4:21irregular. Okay, all that body
- 4:23physiological stuff. Hello.
- 4:26Okay. But then some stuff starts to
- 4:28creep in that's interesting to
- 4:30neurobiologists.
- 4:31Your concentration is impaired.
- 4:34Ooh, something brain related. Memory
- 4:38might begin to be affected in cases of
- 4:40severe untreated hypothyroidism. You
- 4:44even get people progressing to the point
- 4:46of dementia.
- 4:47Okay. So it's got a little bit of a
- 4:50brain flavor and they're mostly just
- 4:52your heart's kind of sluggish and
- 4:55everything is sluggish down there and
- 4:56while that isn't a great thing,
- 4:59neurobiologists generally ignore it. So
- 5:02what are the ways in which you can get a
- 5:04thyroid system that's not working right?
- 5:07Back to hypothalamus bugs the pituitary
- 5:11which prompts the thyroid into releasing
- 5:13its hormone which is then converted from
- 5:16its inactive form into the active one.
- 5:18So problems could arise at every one of
- 5:20those levels. Suppose you find somebody
- 5:24has low levels of that TRH hypothalamic
- 5:27hormone
- 5:29and low levels of TSH, the pituitary
- 5:31hormone, and low levels of thyroid
- 5:34hormone,
- 5:35you've got a hypothyroid syndrome and
- 5:37where's the problem starting? Up in the
- 5:39brain. You can hardly ever identify it
- 5:42because it's really really hard to
- 5:44measure that hypothalamic hormone
- 5:46because it's tiny amounts just at the
- 5:49base of your brain. So you get a more
- 5:51common scenario where what you see is
- 5:54the person has low levels of the
- 5:57pituitary hormone TSH. We're ignoring
- 6:00the hypothalamic one because you can't
- 6:01measure it. You got low levels of TSH,
- 6:05low levels of thyroid hormone.
- 6:07What's the problem there? You got a
- 6:09pituitary problem.
- 6:11Then we get the more common scenario,
- 6:14which is it's low levels of thyroid
- 6:16hormone, both that T4 and T3, but
- 6:19there's elevated levels of the pituitary
- 6:21hormone, TSH. What's that about? The
- 6:25brain and the pituitary have decided we
- 6:27want a whole bunch of thyroid hormone
- 6:29and there's not much of it in the
- 6:30bloodstream and the brain pituitary is
- 6:32saying what's wrong with the thyroid
- 6:34gland down there? Why isn't it listening
- 6:37to us? Let's pump out a whole lot of
- 6:39that thyroid stimulating hormone and
- 6:42still not a whole lot of hormones coming
- 6:45out of the thyroid. What have you just
- 6:47diagnosed? The problem is at the level
- 6:49of the thyroid gland. You can see the
- 6:52upper levels, pituitary and or brain
- 6:55reacting to there's not much in the
- 6:57bloodstream, so let's scream even louder
- 7:00of a stimulatory signal. The thyroid's
- 7:03not responding. So that's the most
- 7:05typical scenario. One additional
- 7:07scenario where you see elevated levels
- 7:11of TSH, the pituitary hormone, screaming
- 7:16at the thyroid gland to release thyroid
- 7:18hormone, but weirdly you see elevated
- 7:21levels of T4 coming out of the thyroid
- 7:24gland,
- 7:25but there's suppressed levels of T3.
- 7:29What's going on there? You don't have a
- 7:31problem in the brain or the pituitary or
- 7:33the thyroid gland. There's problems
- 7:35throughout the body converting the
- 7:37inactive T4 into the active T3.
- 7:42And once again, the brain isn't getting
- 7:44much of a T3 signal, so it's elevating
- 7:47TSH, screaming what's going on down
- 7:49there at the thyroid gland. The thyroid
- 7:51gland says not my problem. I'm pouring
- 7:53out thyroid hormone, T4 like crazy. The
- 7:57problem is out in the periphery. Okay,
- 7:59so that's great. And what's done in any
- 8:01of those cases, you give the person a
- 8:04replacement version of the active
- 8:06thyroid hormone, the
- 8:08you give them a synthetic thyroxine, the
- 8:11drug Synthroid, and it fixes up
- 8:13everything. So, where does depression
- 8:16come in?
- 8:17And there's a link that people have been
- 8:19seeing for decades and decades. When you
- 8:22look at people with depression, 5 to 20%
- 8:25of them turn out to be having a
- 8:27hypothyroid syndrome, an undiagnosed
- 8:31problem at that level.
- 8:34Huh.
- 8:34And when you look at people with thyroid
- 8:36problems, any of these hypothyroid
- 8:39syndromes,
- 8:40up to about 50% of them get clinically
- 8:42depressed.
- 8:43Well, obviously, because you got a lousy
- 8:45disease and that's depressing. You got
- 8:47to have the right control groups. So,
- 8:49there's this linkage between depression
- 8:51and underlying thyroid problems and
- 8:54thyroid problems and resulting
- 8:56depression.
- 8:57What are some of the characteristics of
- 8:59it? Following up on what I said before,
- 9:01it's more common among women than among
- 9:04men.
- 9:05The link between the two becomes more
- 9:07common as you get older. And then you
- 9:10get a very interesting hint that it's
- 9:13not just the two of these independent
- 9:16symptoms. There's crosstalk. What do I
- 9:19mean by this? You take somebody with
- 9:22some sort of thyroid abnormality and a
- 9:26depression,
- 9:27and you give them low levels of that
- 9:29thyroid hormone replacement, and it
- 9:32often helps with the depression.
- 9:34Huh. The depression arising from a
- 9:38thyroid hormone insufficiency.
- 9:41That's really interesting. And people
- 9:43getting more details about it, it 's not
- 9:46so much that thyroid hormone could work
- 9:48as an antidepressant. It makes
- 9:50antidepressants
- 9:52work more effectively in the brain.
- 9:55So, what's going on with that? People
- 9:56have some hints at this point. There are
- 9:59receptors for thyroid hormone in all the
- 10:02usual suspect parts of the brain, the
- 10:04hippocampus, the amygdala, the cortex,
- 10:08also in the hypothalamus because that's
- 10:10doing all that temperature regulation
- 10:12and heart rate regulation stuff. So
- 10:14that's just part of the plumbing
- 10:16regulation of the system. But
- 10:18hippocampus, amygdala, cortex,
- 10:21and you begin to see thyroid hormone has
- 10:24effects on all sorts of neurotransmitter
- 10:27systems that have been implicated in
- 10:30depression. Number one on the list,
- 10:32neurotransmitter serotonin, the most
- 10:35common antidepressant drugs, SSRIs like
- 10:38Prozac, selective serotonin reuptake
- 10:42inhibitors. They're working on the
- 10:43serotonin system. Thyroid hormone, if
- 10:46there's an insufficiency, the
- 10:48antidepressants won't work as well. Give
- 10:50the replacement thyroid hormone, you
- 10:52potentiate their action. That makes tons
- 10:54of sense.
- 10:55Even more interesting is thyroid hormone
- 10:59modulation of the neurotransmitter
- 11:02norepinephrine.
- 11:04Now it is most localized in a part of
- 11:07the brain called the locus coeruleus.
- 11:09Totally obscure, in part because it's
- 11:12impossible to spell.
- 11:14Thyroid hormone, norepinephrine, locus
- 11:16coeruleus. What's the locus coeruleus
- 11:18about? Alerting, arousal. You're drowsy
- 11:22and somebody plays the symbols behind
- 11:25you and your locus coeruleus activates
- 11:28and your whole brain becomes alert and
- 11:30that pathway is making use of
- 11:32norepinephrine.
- 11:33So thyroid hormone potentiates some of
- 11:37that norepinephrine signaling.
- 11:39Alertness, arousal. Where does this fit
- 11:41in with depression?
- 11:43Really interesting. You want to break
- 11:46all the symptoms of depression into
- 11:47three different domains. One is
- 11:50anhedonia,
- 11:52inability to feel pleasure,
- 11:54anticipation, so on.
- 11:56A second one is rumination, which we've
- 11:59talked about recently. Bad aversive
- 12:02emotions, thoughts just looping around
- 12:04and around. And the third one is what's
- 12:06called psychomotor retardation. It's
- 12:09exhausting to think. It's exhausting to
- 12:12do anything. It's you got a sluggish
- 12:15locus coeruleus, and some of the
- 12:17antidepressant drugs that boost up
- 12:20norepinephrine signaling
- 12:22are working by boosting up this locus
- 12:24coeruleus and are working on the
- 12:26psychomotor elements.
- 12:28So that produces an interesting
- 12:31prediction which turns out to be
- 12:32absolutely correct when thyroid hormone
- 12:36is enhancing some antidepressant
- 12:38effects. It's particularly effective
- 12:41working on the psychomotor retardation,
- 12:44boosting up the energy. And where that's
- 12:46most interesting is in this weirdo
- 12:49subtype of depression,
- 12:51atypical type called atypical depression
- 12:54where people are not so much having
- 12:57trouble with the anhedonia, not so much
- 12:59having trouble with the rumination, but
- 13:01it's dominated by the psychomotor
- 13:04retardation stuff. And a number of
- 13:06studies show
- 13:08replacement thyroid hormone is
- 13:11particularly effective there.
- 13:14Low thyroid hormone disorders, like we
- 13:16talked about, are particularly linked to
- 13:19atypical depression.
- 13:21And that forms two out of three legs of
- 13:24an interesting trio. Low thyroid hormone
- 13:27function, atypical depression,
- 13:30and chronic fatigue syndrome. They all
- 13:33have a lot in common. Okay, so that's
- 13:35great. So that's working on that system.
- 13:37Then there's all those receptors for
- 13:39thyroid hormone in the hippocampus, and
- 13:42it's doing interesting stuff there. It's
- 13:45increasing the metabolism of hippocampal
- 13:48neurons. It's increasing excitability of
- 13:51synapses. They're learning something
- 13:54called long-term potentiation. It's
- 13:56increasing the levels of growth factors
- 13:59in the hippocampus primarily, something
- 14:02we've talked about a number of times, a
- 14:04chemical called BDNF, brain-derived
- 14:07neurotrophic factor. And what does BDNF
- 14:10do? It helps you make new synaptic
- 14:13connections. It helps you make neurons
- 14:16in the adult hippocampus, and there's
- 14:19this whole emerging story by now that
- 14:22part of the problem in depression is the
- 14:24hippocampus is less resilient. It can't
- 14:27make new synapses that are being
- 14:30destroyed by stress. It can't make new
- 14:32neurons. So there's a whole cluster of
- 14:34things here that wind up making sense in
- 14:37terms of a linkage between thyroid
- 14:40abnormalities, hypothyroid states of any
- 14:43of the versions we talked about here,
- 14:46depression, particularly centered around
- 14:49norepinephrine arousal, energy,
- 14:52alertness in the brain, and the
- 14:54hippocampus, lack of neuroplasticity,
- 14:57and depression. Okay, so that makes for
- 14:59a really nice, clean story.
- 15:01Two complications come up that are
- 15:03majorly interesting.
- 15:06Sometimes you get somebody who's
- 15:09clinically depressed and you're
- 15:11wondering, well, let's just check out
- 15:12their thyroid system just to make sure
- 15:14that's not the problem. And they come
- 15:16back with perfectly normal levels of the
- 15:19pituitary hormone and the thyroid
- 15:21hormone and the conversion of the T4 to
- 15:24T3, and it looks perfectly normal. Yet,
- 15:28just because you're feeling adventurous
- 15:29and you try out an experiment, this
- 15:32turns out to be somebody who is
- 15:34sensitive to thyroid hormone. Giving
- 15:37them some supplementary
- 15:39synthetic thyroid hormone makes them
- 15:42more sensitive to antidepressants.
- 15:45Whoa, what's up with that? Because their
- 15:47system's perfectly normal. Look at all
- 15:49these things you're measuring in their
- 15:50bloodstream. Everything looks fine.
- 15:53And this brings in a concept that's
- 15:55getting more and more solidity, the
- 15:57notion that the brain itself can be
- 16:00hypothyroid while everything else is
- 16:03normal. How can this be? You've got that
- 16:06T4 hormone circulating around, and some
- 16:09of it gets into the brain. And lots of
- 16:12you will remember a key step is getting
- 16:14past the blood-brain barrier, and
- 16:17there's a transport protein that brings
- 16:19T 4 into the brain.
- 16:22So maybe you got a problem with that
- 16:24transport protein. So everything out in
- 16:26the body is fine, just none of it's
- 16:28getting into the brain.
- 16:30Or maybe the transport system is okay. T
- 16:334 is getting in, but the enzyme and
- 16:36glial cells that converts the T 4 to T
- 16:393, that's where your problem is. So
- 16:43everything's normal then throughout the
- 16:44body, but you're not getting a T 3
- 16:47hormone in the brain and thus you've got
- 16:50this weird, mysterious connection with
- 16:53depression. Everything's fine in the
- 16:55periphery,
- 16:56but this turns out to be a depressed
- 16:58person who is euthyroid, e u t h,
- 17:01they're good thyroid values. It's a
- 17:04brain hypothyroidism status. So this is
- 17:07something that's just getting sorted out
- 17:09these days. The other complication is
- 17:12the most common route by which people's
- 17:14thyroid glands poop out and become
- 17:17hypothyroid, where that's the primary
- 17:19problem, which is when the immune system
- 17:23attacks the thyroid gland, an autoimmune
- 17:26disease termed Hashimoto's disease,
- 17:29Hashimoto's thyroiditis, your immune
- 17:31system gets it into its imprudent head
- 17:34that some key cells in your thyroid
- 17:36gland are in fact invasive Ebola viruses
- 17:40or God knows what and starts attacking
- 17:42your thyroid gland, killing the cells in
- 17:44there. Your thyroid gets wiped out,
- 17:46loses its ability to make and secrete
- 17:49thyroid hormone and you become
- 17:51hypothyroid
- 17:53because of this autoimmune disorder.
- 17:55How do you spot that? First off, this is
- 17:58exactly the scenario where you see low
- 18:01levels of thyroid hormone in the
- 18:03bloodstream, both T 4 and T 3, and high
- 18:06levels of T S H. Same logic as before,
- 18:09your brain, your pituitary are measuring
- 18:12it saying, oh my God, there's no thyroid
- 18:14hormone in the bloodstream. Let's pour
- 18:16out a stimulatory signal at the thyroid
- 18:19gland trying to get it release more
- 18:21thyroid hormone, and it can't because
- 18:23it's under attacked by the immune
- 18:24system. That's the profile. But then
- 18:27there's a second piece that confirms
- 18:28that profile. You look in the person's
- 18:31blood and you find antibodies that have
- 18:34formed against aspects of the thyroid
- 18:38gland.
- 18:40You could find antibodies that for
- 18:41example attack the receptor
- 18:45for that pituitary stimulating hormone.
- 18:47So the pituitary is pouring out tons of
- 18:50that stimulatory hormone, but the
- 18:52autoimmunities wiped out the receptors
- 18:55in the thyroid gland that would listen
- 18:56to it. So that's one way in which you
- 18:59can get into trouble. Then often you see
- 19:01antibodies forming against a protein, an
- 19:05enzyme in the thyroid gland called TPO
- 19:08thyroid peroxidase
- 19:11and that used to be known as
- 19:13antimicrosomal antibodies. Now they're
- 19:16called anti TPO antibodies. You find
- 19:18antibodies against something called
- 19:20thyroglobulin. That's your diagnosis.
- 19:24You see the pituitary is screaming in
- 19:26effect at the thyroid gland.
- 19:29Thyroid gland down on the pike there.
- 19:31None of the hormones are showing up and
- 19:34you've got the autoimmune antibodies
- 19:37that are attacking the thyroid.
- 19:39So what do you do at this point?
- 19:41Standard treatment in most autoimmune
- 19:43diseases is the immune system is wacky.
- 19:46It's over the top, attacking,
- 19:48hyperactive,
- 19:50bizarrely, inappropriately, damagingly
- 19:53some part of your body. Lupus, juvenile
- 19:56diabetes, rheumatoid arthritis, multiple
- 20:00sclerosis, any of those. And the
- 20:02standard treatment is throw in a drug
- 20:05that's going to take this manic
- 20:07overactive immune system and suppress
- 20:09it. You take immunosuppressives very
- 20:11often corticosteroids,
- 20:14steroidal anti-inflammatory, steroidal
- 20:18immunosuppressive drugs.
- 20:20But the standard of care with Hashimotos
- 20:22is different.
- 20:24And it's really interesting. The normal
- 20:27route at this point would be throwing
- 20:29some immunosuppressive drugs so you damp
- 20:32down the whole immune system so you're
- 20:34not making those antithyroid antibodies
- 20:36anymore. Everyone can live happily ever
- 20:39after. No, that's not what's standardly
- 20:41done. Nothing is done to damp down the
- 20:45immune system.
- 20:46You just give the person synthetic
- 20:48thyroid hormone to replace the missing
- 20:50stuff.
- 20:51Drug Synthroid. You just do that. Why
- 20:54that pathway that's very different from
- 20:56how most autoimmune diseases are
- 20:58treated. Synthroid works incredibly
- 21:01well. It's safe. It's really well
- 21:03tolerated and you immunosuppress
- 21:06somebody instead and yeah, you're
- 21:08damping down this hysterical
- 21:09autoimmunity. You're damping down a lot
- 21:11of the immune system. Lots of side
- 21:14effects not easily tolerated. So somehow
- 21:16it's emerged. What you do with
- 21:18Hashimoto's disease is you just replace
- 21:20the missing thyroid hormone with this
- 21:22Synthroid stuff. Great. Everything's
- 21:25taken care of. The person's symptoms get
- 21:27better. They've got more energy. They're
- 21:29not sleeping all the time. Their heart's
- 21:31beating at a normal rate. That's
- 21:33terrific. How can you tell when you're
- 21:35giving the right dose? You look at that
- 21:38pituitary hormone, that stimulating
- 21:40hormone yelling at the thyroid. As you
- 21:43raise the thyroid hormone level
- 21:45synthetically
- 21:47through your medication, the brain and
- 21:49pituitary are finally satisfied and the
- 21:51levels go down and everything evens out.
- 21:54So that cures Hashimoto's except there's
- 21:57a problem.
- 21:58Which is you just fixed up everything
- 22:01with the thyroid gland and all the
- 22:03relevant hormones are hunky-dory and
- 22:05exactly what they should be. But because
- 22:08you use this treatment route, the immune
- 22:11system is still blasting with that
- 22:14autoimmunity, making those antibodies
- 22:17that are wreaking havoc in your now
- 22:19totally superfluous abandoned thyroid
- 22:22gland. Your immune system is still in
- 22:25chronic activated inflammatory state.
- 22:29And people have been wondering for a
- 22:31long time that hooray for you, you fixed
- 22:34up the thyroid hormone problem. This
- 22:36can't be a great thing having
- 22:38nonetheless an immune system going
- 22:40gangbusters all the time. Are there
- 22:43downsides to it? And people have
- 22:45increasingly appreciated there's
- 22:46downsides and then you see a really
- 22:49interesting downside to it. And this was
- 22:52a paper a couple of years ago in the
- 22:54Journal of Translational Autoimmunity
- 22:57looking at people with Hashimoto's
- 22:59disease where you had treated them with
- 23:01Synthroid, you replaced the missing
- 23:03hormone and that took care of
- 23:05everything. They were now euthyroid and
- 23:08everything was great with that, but the
- 23:09immune system was still way overactive.
- 23:12And what they showed was a lot of these
- 23:15people were still having problems with
- 23:17concentration and anxiety and
- 23:21depression.
- 23:23And the higher the levels of those
- 23:25anti-thyroid antibodies in the
- 23:27bloodstream, the worse these
- 23:29neurocognitive, neuropsychiatric
- 23:32symptoms, exactly suggesting that
- 23:35somehow a chronically activated
- 23:38inflammatory system can cause
- 23:40depression. People know this. This was
- 23:43known for a long time. There's a whole
- 23:45new world of the link between chronic
- 23:48inflammation and depression. So whoa,
- 23:50that suggests maybe this chronic
- 23:53hyperactivation
- 23:54of the autoimmune system, maybe that's
- 23:57contributing to some of the affective
- 24:00concentration memory problems of
- 24:03Hashimoto's disease even when you've
- 24:05cured it with your Synthroid.
- 24:08So that suggests something really like
- 24:11nutty which was then carried out in an
- 24:14actual study few years ago, Annals of
- 24:16Internal Medicine, a Norwegian group
- 24:19headed by Ivar Goldvarg who did
- 24:22something kind of radical. You got
- 24:24somebody with Hashimoto's
- 24:26and their thyroid gland has been carpet
- 24:30bomb, but there's still some of it left
- 24:32there whimpering and drooling out a
- 24:34little bit of this or that. And you
- 24:36still got the immune system trying to
- 24:39attack it, take out the thyroid gland of
- 24:42these people.
- 24:44Take it out so there's nothing to goad
- 24:47your immune system
- 24:49into having an autoimmune attack. Take
- 24:51out the thyroid gland. Oh my god,
- 24:53they're not going to have any thyroid
- 24:54hormone secreted. Oh my god, they
- 24:56already don't have any thyroid hormone
- 24:57secreted. You've already fixed that up
- 24:59with your synthetic version of the drug.
- 25:01It's just this
- 25:03like
- 25:04punching bag there for your immune
- 25:05system. Take it out.
- 25:07It's surprisingly
- 25:09a non-complicated surgery. Tiny
- 25:12percentage of people get damage to the
- 25:14nearby parathyroid gland. And what they
- 25:17showed in the study is take out the
- 25:19thyroid gland in these people and you
- 25:21see dropping levels of those
- 25:24anti-thyroid antibodies, dropping levels
- 25:28of markers of chronic inflammation, and
- 25:32the psychiatric problems get better. So
- 25:34this is totally exciting new possible
- 25:37direction. Okay, so what are our
- 25:38take-home messages first? First off, you
- 25:41got somebody with a hypothyroid
- 25:42disorder, be really attuned to whether
- 25:45they getting clinically depressed and
- 25:47there's a good chance it's not just
- 25:48because this is a bummer of a disease.
- 25:51Make sure you're not seeing a downstream
- 25:54depression arising from it. Second, you
- 25:57see somebody with depression and go
- 25:59check out their thyroid hormone levels
- 26:02because again, 5 to 20% of cases,
- 26:05particularly in women, turn out to have
- 26:07an undiagnosed thyroid disorder or a
- 26:10subclinical one. Uh-oh, let's keep an
- 26:13eye on this. So that's important.
- 26:16Next thing to consider, next take-home,
- 26:19you got somebody whose thyroid hormone
- 26:21levels are perfectly normal, nothing
- 26:24wrong there at all, but they're
- 26:25depressed and especially if they are
- 26:28showing atypical treatment-resistant
- 26:31depression
- 26:33might be worth trying out giving a
- 26:34little bit of synthetic thyroid hormone
- 26:38even though their levels are normal
- 26:40because there may be a brain hypothyroid
- 26:42state. So try to flood the system there
- 26:44a bit, see if that amplifies the effects
- 26:47of some of these antidepressants.
- 26:50Finally, Hashimoto's, this very common
- 26:54autoimmune disease among women, you have
- 26:56not cured it and fixed up everything
- 26:59just by replacing the missing hormone.
- 27:01The immune system is still yelling
- 27:04hysterically all the time. That might be
- 27:06a whole extra front to try to control
- 27:09when it comes to neuropsychiatric
- 27:10problems. Final take home message, oh my
- 27:13god, thyroid hormone, it's so boring.
- 27:16It's just doing stuff to your
- 27:17mitochondria down in your big toes so
- 27:19your toes don't get all blue and chilled
- 27:23and it's like
- 27:24psychiatry, what's going on in your
- 27:27brain, what's going on in a healthy
- 27:28brain and unhealthy brain is so
- 27:30intimately intertwined with what's going
- 27:33on elsewhere in your body that you
- 27:35better be thinking about what's
- 27:36happening outside that brain to make
- 27:39sense of what's happening inside the
- 27:40brain.
- 27:42>> Now, Joel from Manchester asks, if smell
- 27:45is particles hitting your nose, then why
- 27:47don't things that smell dissolve?
- 27:50>> Oh, fantastic question.
- 27:52As soon as you hear it,
- 27:54you realize
- 27:55it must work that way because when
- 27:57you're smelling something, it's
- 27:59molecules from that thing that have
- 28:02gotten aerosolized, airborne and gotten
- 28:05into your nose. And if you do that
- 28:07long enough, the whole thing should
- 28:09disappear. And the answer is it works
- 28:12exactly that way, sort of.
- 28:14So you got a food that has a smell. You
- 28:17got cheese or something and you've got
- 28:20the molecules in it that aerosolize,
- 28:23volatile molecules, things like esters
- 28:27and aldehydes and terpenes and they
- 28:30become airborne and they get into your
- 28:31nose and they bind to olfactory
- 28:34receptors there and you smell the smell
- 28:36of the cheese.
- 28:38And then these receptor odorants come
- 28:40floating off and you
- 28:42catch them up in your mucus there where
- 28:44they're decayed or they're absorbed into
- 28:47your skin or some of them get down into
- 28:49your gut and your lungs. And this is how
- 28:52it works. And the key thing is most of
- 28:55your food, most of a block of cheese for
- 28:58example, is not made up of these
- 29:01molecules that can aerosolize, that can
- 29:04get airborne. Only a tiny percentage.
- 29:07Most of it is like the starch and the
- 29:09sugar and the proteins and that stuff
- 29:13can aerosolize at an incredibly slow
- 29:15rate, which means if you stay in a
- 29:18hermetically sealed room for enough
- 29:21thousands of years, eventually you can
- 29:23get a faint faint whiff of the salt
- 29:25shaker from the other side of the room.
- 29:27But for the most part, the vast majority
- 29:30of a food item, the vast majority of
- 29:32anything that we can get a smell from
- 29:36is not getting airborne. So it's just
- 29:38the airborne part that can ever so
- 29:41slowly dissipate over time. And what
- 29:43happens when all the airborne stuff is
- 29:45gone?
- 29:47The thing has lost its odor. It's lost
- 29:49its fragrance. It's become a dry husk.
- 29:51The water has evaporated also. So within
- 29:54the tiny percentage that show that
- 29:58it actually works that way.
- 30:00And as an additional piece of the story,
- 30:02those volatile molecules that can
- 30:05potentially come off and carry a smell,
- 30:07most of them are caught up in a matrix
- 30:10inside the food and thus they get
- 30:13released more readily when they're
- 30:15heated.
- 30:16Mm. The aroma of food becomes stronger
- 30:19when you microwave it or when you chew
- 30:22it up, when you break down those
- 30:24matrices and the flavor is enhanced.
- 30:27Okay, so it's worth asking at this
- 30:29point. So you look at a piece of cheese,
- 30:31you look at a cup of coffee, what
- 30:33percentage of the molecules in there are
- 30:36the that can actually get airborne in
- 30:38theory, potentially at a maximum, and
- 30:41carry an odor. It's an incredibly tiny
- 30:44percentage in cheese and coffee. It's
- 30:47less than 1/10 of 1% of the material in
- 30:51there that has the potential to ever get
- 30:53aerosolized. Then you got stuff like
- 30:56plants that need to advertise themselves
- 30:59to pollinating insects. They've got very
- 31:03odoriferous flowers. They make spices
- 31:06that are like cloves or nutmeg. And when
- 31:10you get into that range, like 1 to 20%
- 31:14of the mass of those plants are
- 31:16potentially volatile molecules.
- 31:19So you look at this and what this tells
- 31:21you is in theory eventually you could
- 31:24run out of a smell, but that's an awful
- 31:26lot of stuff that needs to go floating
- 31:28off cuz that's a trillion little
- 31:30molecules carrying odors and they're
- 31:33caught in the matrix. So in theory they
- 31:35could be very long-lasting.
- 31:38In reality it turns out they can be very
- 31:40long-lasting. Archaeological site few
- 31:43years ago in Cyprus unearthed a 4,000
- 31:46year old perfume factory
- 31:49and found shards of pottery there with
- 31:51residues of perfume on it and they
- 31:54scraped it off and did fancy chemical
- 31:58analyses and they isolated stuff like
- 32:00anise and pine and almond and coriander
- 32:05and parsley and they were even able to
- 32:07reconstitute
- 32:09some of these perfumes, 4,000 year old
- 32:12odors that could be reconstituted there.
- 32:15So yeah, some of these odorants can stay
- 32:17for a long time. Okay, so that's
- 32:18completely great and fascinating. But
- 32:20now we get to something discomforting
- 32:22which is okay, the smell of flowers, the
- 32:25smell of cloves, the smell of cheese,
- 32:27the smell of fecal matter, the smell of
- 32:31rotten carcass, the smell of vomit, the
- 32:34smell of farts. Those things get
- 32:37aerosolized also.
- 32:39And think about it. When you are
- 32:42smelling some vile poop, that means like
- 32:46little molecules have come off the
- 32:48surface of that stuff and have gotten
- 32:50into your nose and maybe even after you
- 32:52smell them distastefully, they're going
- 32:55to wind up in your stomach or your lungs
- 32:57and yuck. And we've now entered into the
- 33:00world of sensory disgust.
- 33:03Now we've talked about interesting
- 33:05things your brain does confusing sensory
- 33:08disgust with moral disgust. Put somebody
- 33:11in a room with a bad smell in it and
- 33:13they become more socially conservative
- 33:16because they're just feeling disgusted
- 33:19and they don't quite know why and oh,
- 33:21they figure out why. It must be because
- 33:23of those people and the things they do
- 33:25are wrong, wrong, wrong. We do this
- 33:27weird cross talk between the literal
- 33:30nature of sensory disgust and the
- 33:33metaphorical nature of moral disgust and
- 33:36it actually involves the same brain
- 33:38pathways we've talked about the insular
- 33:39cortex.
- 33:41What we've got now is the psychology of
- 33:44sensory disgust cuz there's interesting
- 33:46stuff going on with that because you
- 33:49know there's bizarre irrational stuff.
- 33:52Take a cockroach and sterilize it and
- 33:55put it into somebody's drinking water
- 33:58and people are really not going to want
- 34:01to drink it. Take a very authentic
- 34:02looking plastic cockroach and put it in
- 34:05there and some people are even going to
- 34:07get some hesitancy after that. All sorts
- 34:10of psychologically irrational things we
- 34:13do with disgusting smells. And a lot of
- 34:16this work was pioneered by this guy
- 34:18University of Pennsylvania, Paul Rozin,
- 34:21fantastic scientist, good guy, who has
- 34:23shown that there's an underlying
- 34:25psychological disease that we have about
- 34:29bad smells, the fear that it's somehow
- 34:32getting incorporated into our bodies.
- 34:35And we do really nutty asymmetric things
- 34:37with that. For example, you're sitting
- 34:40there with your sandwich ready for lunch
- 34:42and suddenly a cockroach runs across
- 34:45your sandwich.
- 34:46There's two possible ways of
- 34:48interpreting what just happened. Yuck,
- 34:50the disgustingness of the cockroach has
- 34:53just rubbed off onto your sandwich and
- 34:56you don't want to eat it now.
- 34:57Alternatively, in principle, just as
- 35:00logically, the yumminess of your
- 35:02sandwich has just rubbed off onto the
- 35:05feet of the cockroach. Overwhelmingly,
- 35:08there is an asymmetry there. Cockroaches
- 35:11spread yuckiness to sandwiches.
- 35:14Sandwiches don't spread palatability to
- 35:17cockroaches. And Rozin and others have
- 35:20pointed out this is a logical asymmetry.
- 35:23This is a realm where you really don't
- 35:26want to have a false negative and decide
- 35:28a cockroach is much more edible,
- 35:30something disgusting is much more edible
- 35:32than you might think. So you want to
- 35:34overgeneralize it because that can be
- 35:36carrying an infection. The fears of
- 35:38cockroach feet smelling like peanut
- 35:40butter and jelly sandwiches, that's not
- 35:43a big challenge to health. So there's
- 35:44some underlying logic to it. Now what
- 35:46you see is, of course, lots of
- 35:48cross-cultural specificity to this and
- 35:51that endless cultures on earth consume
- 35:53insects and don't find them to be
- 35:55remotely disgusting and instead quite
- 35:58yummy and those cultures have things
- 36:00that they're disgusted by. And you see
- 36:03all sorts of odd versions of it. Masai
- 36:06people, nomadic pastoralists I've talked
- 36:09about in the past who were my neighbors
- 36:11for years and years, they live
- 36:13predominantly off of cow blood, cow
- 36:16milk, and something that disgusts the
- 36:18most
- 36:19stoic, unshakable,
- 36:22taciturn,
- 36:24weather-beaten Masai elder is the notion
- 36:26of eating fish. They get queasy at the
- 36:29thought of it, which is so bizarre
- 36:31because you have periods where there's
- 36:34shortages of food, where there's protein
- 36:36malnutrition during the dry season. You
- 36:38got streams full of fish and they get
- 36:41This is not just, oh, we're not supposed
- 36:44to fish, so I'm just going to follow the
- 36:46rules. This is visceral disgust, and
- 36:49people who do not get viscerally shaken
- 36:52by much of anything, you see taboos like
- 36:54this all over the place. The
- 36:56anthropologist Marvin Harris, an
- 36:58American anthropologist,
- 37:00did a lot of work noting that in an
- 37:02enormous percentage of cultures on
- 37:04Earth, there is at least one food item
- 37:08which is irrationally taboo. Here in the
- 37:11US, eating insects or eating horse meat
- 37:14or eating a whole list of those things,
- 37:17and among lots of pastoralists, fish
- 37:20totally disgust them. Harris did a lot
- 37:23of work trying to show why there was an
- 37:25underlying nutritional logic to these
- 37:28things. Another anthropologist, Mary
- 37:30Douglas, British, emphasized and said
- 37:33the irrationality of this. This is just
- 37:35a good way of having a group
- 37:38identification. We are the people who do
- 37:41not eat bacon, lettuce, and tomato
- 37:43sandwiches. That is who we are. There's
- 37:45a lot of other things that make us who
- 37:46we are. Food taboos, irrational food
- 37:50taboos, that's just part of an
- 37:51intragroup identification.
- 37:54Now, what's implicit in thinking that
- 37:56yuck, more bad stuff rubs off from the
- 37:59cockroach onto the sandwich than the
- 38:01other way around, is this whole realm of
- 38:04magical thinking that we fall for.
- 38:07People who are about to get a
- 38:09life-saving organ transplant, they and
- 38:12their families often are very, very
- 38:15perturbed when it turns out they don't
- 38:18like the kind of person who's donating
- 38:21the organ. There's some magical essence
- 38:24on this person's kidney that's going to
- 38:26somehow get transferred to their loved
- 38:28one and magically have adverse effects.
- 38:32People even show this for objects made
- 38:36by people who are outgroup members. This
- 38:38was one great study with Tanzanian kids,
- 38:41and they had a choice, how much money
- 38:43would you pay to get a recording of a
- 38:45song made by a mass murderer or a song
- 38:49made by a wonderful wise elder. And they
- 38:52would spend more money for the songs
- 38:54from the wise elders. Yuck, who wants to
- 38:56listen to music from a murderer? You
- 38:58find this in the West as well. Some sort
- 39:01of magical transference of the yuckiness
- 39:05even by listening to their music. Now my
- 39:07favorite example of this was a study
- 39:09carried out by Paul Bloom of Yale. He's
- 39:12now University of Toronto. We've talked
- 39:14about his work published 2014
- 39:17Proceedings National Academy of Sciences
- 39:19looking at magical thinking about who
- 39:23wore this piece of clothing.
- 39:25And what they showed was with subjects,
- 39:28here's a piece of clothing that was
- 39:30hypothetically worn by some beloved
- 39:33celebrity or worn by some total
- 39:37repulsive societal sort of outgroup
- 39:40factor. And how much would you pay for
- 39:43the sweater? A sweater worn by
- 39:46John F. Kennedy, for example, or worn by
- 39:50Bernie Madoff, the sociopathic Ponzi
- 39:53scheme thief.
- 39:54And what you saw was people would pay
- 39:56more money to get a sweater that was
- 39:59worn by JFK than by Bernie Madoff.
- 40:02Then an additional wrinkle, you take
- 40:05this sweater that was supposedly worn by
- 40:07JFK and say how much would you pay for
- 40:10it? We washed it, we thoroughly washed
- 40:12it, and here it is. Yuck, you washed off
- 40:15all the good JFK sweat armpit stuff.
- 40:19People wanted to pay less money if it
- 40:22had been washed.
- 40:24And here we've got the sweater that was
- 40:26sweated on by that repulsive bug Bernie
- 40:29Madoff, except we've washed it, we've
- 40:31sterilized it, we've autoclaved it.
- 40:33People would pay more money after the
- 40:36Bernie Madoff yuck had been sterilized
- 40:39off of it. Magical thinking. Okay, so
- 40:41what if we managed to get to here we in
- 40:44one large meandering free associative
- 40:46arc have gotten to why only about
- 40:50of 1% of your cheese will dissipate as
- 40:53it loses its smell to Bernie Madoff's
- 40:57cooties and it all ties together in a
- 41:00seamless magnificent tale.
- 41:03>> And remember, always flush with the lid
- 41:05closed. [laughter] I'm offspring Sarah
- 41:07Sapolsky and thanks for your continued
- 41:08support of Science and the Beard.
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of Where Smells Go; Hypothyroidism and Depression | Robert Sapolsky Father-Offspring Interviews by Robert Sapolsky, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 5,860 words across 987 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.