When might China take Taiwan?: Zhou Bo and Sreenivasan Jain | A Changing World? — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:00How can China allow a part of China
- 0:02still being separated from China? So, we
- 0:04would never tolerate the Taiwan's
- 0:06independence.
- 0:07>> [music]
- 0:07>> Taiwan will be back. The only question
- 0:09is when and how, is not a question of
- 0:11if.
- 0:12>> That, I must say, uh sounds like
- 0:15textbook old order big bully behavior of
- 0:18the kind that you often criticize the
- 0:19West for. Do want to understand how
- 0:21[music] would Chinese leadership differ
- 0:23from the West in tackling global
- 0:24challenges like Gaza. China had [music]
- 0:27the chance to take the moral leadership
- 0:29here. But, what has China done instead?
- 0:31You're also the world's biggest exporter
- 0:32[music] to Israel, the third biggest
- 0:34importer of Israeli goods.
- 0:36>> I think the China's attitude to what the
- 0:38Israelis massive killing is a clear-cut.
- 0:41Nobody would ever doubt over part of
- 0:43China China's a strong condemnation over
- 0:46what the Israel [music]
- 0:47has done. And uh in terms of trading,
- 0:50that should be somewhat separated from
- 0:52politics. So,
- 0:53>> [music]
- 0:53>> I think China is doing the the right
- 0:55thing.
- 1:01>> The international order is breaking down
- 1:03at a dramatic pace. Russia's invasion of
- 1:05Ukraine, Israel's genocide of
- 1:07Palestinians, and the joint US-Israel
- 1:10war on Iran, each has eroded the
- 1:12credibility of the rules-based order.
- 1:14For decades, the United States and key
- 1:17allies sat at the center of this global
- 1:19system built on Western political,
- 1:21military, and economic [music] power.
- 1:24Supporters say it underpinned an era of
- 1:26unprecedented prosperity
- 1:28>> [music]
- 1:28>> and relative stability. Critics argue
- 1:31that it placed power above principle.
- 1:33That debate is no longer academic.
- 1:36In this series, I speak [music] to world
- 1:38leaders and leading strategic thinkers
- 1:41about what comes next, the ideas [music]
- 1:43that could shape tomorrow's
- 1:45international system.
- 1:47No country is more central [music] to
- 1:49that conversation than China.
- 1:51President Xi Jinping says China rejects
- 1:54hegemony and offers a more multipolar
- 1:56world built on sovereignty and
- 1:58non-interference.
- 2:00But does its conduct match those
- 2:02principles?
- 2:04Beijing has refused to condemn Russia's
- 2:06invasion of Ukraine. It maintains deep
- 2:08commercial ties with Israel as Gaza lies
- 2:11in ruins [music] and the West Bank
- 2:13burns.
- 2:14And Taiwan contends with the permanent
- 2:16threat of military force.
- 2:19My guest is retired senior colonel Joe
- 2:22Bo. He's one of China's foremost [music]
- 2:25strategic voices and a former senior
- 2:27officer in the People's Liberation Army.
- 2:30I ask him, is China offering a genuinely
- 2:34different world order or simply
- 2:36>> [music]
- 2:36>> a different distribution of power?
- 2:39Senior Colonel Joe Bo, thank you very
- 2:41much indeed for joining us.
- 2:43The international order is under
- 2:45enormous strain. President Xi says that
- 2:47China is the keeper of the international
- 2:49order. That it upholds the authority of
- 2:51the United Nations. This sounds great in
- 2:54theory, but in practice, what has China
- 2:56done that entitles it to make that claim
- 2:59you think?
- 3:00>> Well, people have a lot of
- 3:01misunderstanding about regional national
- 3:03order because most people in the West
- 3:06would associate it with so-called
- 3:08liberal international order. I never buy
- 3:10that. I never believe there is anything
- 3:12called a liberal international order. I
- 3:13would say the international order is
- 3:16like what it was since time immemorial.
- 3:19>> So just to be clear, my my argument is
- 3:21not that the international order is only
- 3:22the liberal order, but that there is
- 3:24this current crisis or churn going on
- 3:26across the world.
- 3:28And the question was really on China
- 3:29that when President Xi says that you are
- 3:31the keeper of the order, that you
- 3:33respect the United Nations Charter.
- 3:36Is that just theory
- 3:38or is that in practice? What has China
- 3:40done? What are China's actions that that
- 3:42allow it to make that claim?
- 3:43>> Well, China likes the United Nation
- 3:46because anyway, United Nation is an
- 3:48intergovernmental organization, the
- 3:50largest one. Therefore, it would more
- 3:52authority. By supporting the United
- 3:54Nation, which you can take almost as a
- 3:57kind of international order, China would
- 4:00say that it is guardian of the
- 4:02international order. That means we're
- 4:03not a revisionist. We are the guardian
- 4:06of the existing international order. But
- 4:08what it is, it is the UN-centered
- 4:11international order.
- 4:12>> And you believe that if you look at it
- 4:14particularly that the turmoil around the
- 4:16world today, but do you see yourselves
- 4:18as a force for peace and for stability
- 4:21compared to let's say the countries of
- 4:23the West? Is that how you position
- 4:25yourself?
- 4:26>> China
- 4:27uh China's military actually has been
- 4:29involved in a lot of you know, military
- 4:31operation around the world, but they are
- 4:33exclusively in humanitarian area. So uh
- 4:37so be it peacekeeping, counter-piracy,
- 4:39or disaster relief, right? And that is a
- 4:41unique Chinese way of making
- 4:43contribution toward the world without
- 4:46you know, killing anyone.
- 4:47>> Okay.
- 4:48Some of your own neighbors might
- 4:50disagree with the idea of China as a
- 4:52peacekeeping force, as a non-hegemonic
- 4:54force. But I want to come to the
- 4:55neighborhood later. If I can test some
- 4:57of those contentions you made by looking
- 4:59at China's position when it comes to the
- 5:01current global conflicts. China's quite
- 5:04right to criticize the US Western
- 5:05liberal order as one that starts wars.
- 5:07China was very critical of the US Israel
- 5:11invasion in Iran. You said it's a
- 5:12violation of the international law.
- 5:14But those aren't the only countries
- 5:16starting wars. It's also countries
- 5:18outside the Western liberal axis like
- 5:20Russia unilaterally invades Ukraine
- 5:24denounced by the United Nations.
- 5:27China doesn't condemn it.
- 5:29What happened to respecting
- 5:31the UN Charter?
- 5:32>> No, you you you have misunderstood China
- 5:34because China actually has criticized
- 5:36Russia, but in in a subtle Chinese way.
- 5:39Because we immediately point out that
- 5:43uh sovereignty should be respected. In
- 5:45in saying, we are actually pointing out
- 5:47that this kind of sovereignty of another
- 5:49country is not respected.
- 5:51>> But in the UN vote, though, China
- 5:53abstained. 141 nations all over the
- 5:56world, including countries of the global
- 5:58south, voted to condemn the Russian
- 6:00invasion.
- 6:01You were very clear about condemning the
- 6:04invasion of Iran, but in the case of
- 6:06Russia, you didn't.
- 6:07>> Well, you see, there are actually a lot
- 6:09of UN resolutions regarding Russia's
- 6:12invasion of Ukraine. On some, yes, the
- 6:14China China abstained, but on some,
- 6:17China voted yes. So, it depends on which
- 6:19kind of resolution you're referring to.
- 6:22But given China's good relationship with
- 6:25Russia, I think this kind of, you know,
- 6:27abstaining itself is actually speaks
- 6:30about for itself.
- 6:31>> In some ways, you're admitting actually
- 6:33what many critics say that just weeks
- 6:35before the Russian invasion, President
- 6:37Xi said that there are no limits to
- 6:39China's friendship with Russia. So, you
- 6:41are taking positions not based on
- 6:43principles, but on ideology, on
- 6:45countries that are part of your axis.
- 6:48>> Well, on this unlimited friendship, it's
- 6:50very easy for for me to explain.
- 6:52Actually, in the same
- 6:54agreement between China and Russia, soon
- 6:57after this was was mentioned, they
- 6:59immediately it was pointed out that this
- 7:01relationship is not directed against any
- 7:04third parties. Why won't the people pay
- 7:05attention to this?
- 7:07>> But it's not just diplomatic support, by
- 7:09the way. You've been criticized, as you
- 7:10know, for providing military technology
- 7:12to Russia. China says you only supply
- 7:14dual-use material. The G7, though,
- 7:17issued a statement saying China is a
- 7:19decisive enabler of Russia's war.
- 7:22>> What
- 7:23G7 meant is that all these kind of
- 7:26dual-use items could actually provide
- 7:28kind of lifeline to Russia. That is what
- 7:30it means. China
- 7:32has been very strict in not providing
- 7:34any military equipment or arms to
- 7:37Russia, because if China has done that,
- 7:39it won't go uncovered. It will soon be
- 7:41be be be, you know, discovered. When
- 7:43something is dual-using nature, what is
- 7:46the first nature? The first nature is it
- 7:48is for civilian use. Because just like
- 7:50oil and gas, if you put it in in the
- 7:52back of a military truck, it is military
- 7:55product, but then normally nobody would
- 7:57consider gas and oil kind of a military
- 7:59product.
- 7:59>> But, you know, when they say decisive
- 8:01enabler of Russia's war, it seems beyond
- 8:03just W's. The Ukrainian foreign
- 8:05intelligence chief, by the way, was more
- 8:07specific. He said China supplies
- 8:08gunpowder and other components
- 8:10specifically to 20 Russian defense
- 8:13manufacturing industries that they've
- 8:14identified.
- 8:15>> Well, I cannot verify that, but even if
- 8:18it is gunpowder, it is not arms, right?
- 8:21Or ammunition, right? So, that is There
- 8:23is a critical difference. First of all,
- 8:25I really don't know how true that kind
- 8:27of allegation is, but even that is true,
- 8:29still there is a difference. If you look
- 8:32at the global South countries, very few
- 8:34country would criticize China as a
- 8:37hypocritical, right? And in the West,
- 8:41the the problem is because of
- 8:44their wish that Ukraine can win,
- 8:46therefore they would put pressure on
- 8:48China. In fact, it is the West that is
- 8:50widely criticized for a double standard,
- 8:52right? If we just see the war in Ukraine
- 8:55and the war in Gaza, well, this is just
- 8:57like a black and white kind of
- 8:58hypocrisy.
- 8:59>> I'm glad you mentioned Gaza because the
- 9:01Gaza genocide is clearly a failure of
- 9:03the Western liberal order. China had the
- 9:05chance to take the moral leadership
- 9:06here. But what has China done instead?
- 9:08You've condemned Israel's actions, but
- 9:11you're also the world's biggest exporter
- 9:12to Israel, the third biggest importer of
- 9:15Israeli goods. That doesn't sound like
- 9:17moral leadership. That sounds like
- 9:18business as usual.
- 9:20>> Well, I think you are just a mixing
- 9:21politics with the with the economy,
- 9:23right?
- 9:24I think China's attitude towards
- 9:26Israelis
- 9:27massive killing is a clear-cut. Yeah,
- 9:29nobody would ever doubt about China.
- 9:32China has a strong condemnation
- 9:34of Israel has done. And but the is
- 9:37different in the Middle East because it
- 9:40is only country that actually has
- 9:42befriend almost everyone yeah before
- 9:44this war. So China's position in the
- 9:47Middle East is considered quite
- 9:49impartial and neutral. And is that
- 9:51actually raise people's hope as to what
- 9:53China can actually do to to solve this
- 9:56problem or even as some people say could
- 9:58have feeling this sort of vacuum. China
- 10:00would not feel the vacuum.
- 10:02>> But the fact that you're trading with a
- 10:03country that's committing ethnic
- 10:06cleansing, committing genocide, isn't
- 10:08that a moral failure?
- 10:09>> Well, I don't believe any international
- 10:12would prohibit us from having kind of a
- 10:14normal trade relationship because this
- 10:17this kind of
- 10:19transaction has been done even before
- 10:21the before the war, right?
- 10:23>> I'm saying this because
- 10:24circumstances call for different
- 10:26measures.
- 10:27And clearly the condemnation China other
- 10:29countries is not working. It's it's
- 10:31creating no pressure on Israel.
- 10:33>> No, I
- 10:33>> And hence and hence the possibility of
- 10:35sanctions
- 10:36>> No,
- 10:36>> very much is on the table. Why would
- 10:39China not consider sanctions?
- 10:40>> Well, you see the sanctions do not
- 10:42always work. And for this question to be
- 10:45asked, and I believe that the right
- 10:48people for you to ask is the United
- 10:50States first, yeah? So because they are
- 10:52the countries that right behind Israel.
- 10:55I always argue yeah Israel
- 10:57Israel is America's Achilles heel.
- 11:00>> Absolutely, and that's why I said at the
- 11:01outset this is very much a failure of
- 11:03that axis. But as I said, this was a
- 11:05chance for China to take the leadership.
- 11:07If you take a country like Spain,
- 11:09Senior Colonel, they're very much part
- 11:10of the Western liberal axis. They
- 11:12actually broke from that. They've taken
- 11:14a very strong stand against Israel.
- 11:16They've called for economic sanctions.
- 11:17They've put a arms embargo.
- 11:20That in some ways represents the new
- 11:22world order.
- 11:23>> Well, you see sanction for China is not
- 11:26the whole thing because China has been
- 11:28sanctioned time again in in the past. So
- 11:30therefore we do not really buy
- 11:33buy buy that. I think the China's role
- 11:35in the future is a kind of three role.
- 11:37One is a facilitator, another is a
- 11:39mediator, and the third is a security
- 11:41guarantor along with some other
- 11:43countries. So, people have a high
- 11:45expectation for China, and I believe
- 11:48this is what China's role will be in the
- 11:50future.
- 11:50>> So, is there any scenario in which
- 11:52Beijing would use its economic clout to
- 11:55stop mass atrocities?
- 11:56>> Well, I don't believe you know, first of
- 11:59all, it is has a such a strong
- 12:01association with China. China's attitude
- 12:03on the Middle East issue is clear-cut,
- 12:06right? And in terms of trading, that
- 12:09should be somewhat separated from
- 12:11politics. So, I think China is doing the
- 12:14right thing. And I think the Arab
- 12:16countries have no doubts about China.
- 12:18>> And so, perhaps there is some scope
- 12:20there for China to do more.
- 12:22But, let me switch to the region now.
- 12:24President Xi says that China is opposed
- 12:26to hegemony and power politics. You've
- 12:28often said that the West is the sole
- 12:32sort of space that fears China. The
- 12:34reality is this, under President Xi's
- 12:35watch, China has turbocharged its
- 12:37military might. All your neighbors are
- 12:39reporting heightened Chinese territorial
- 12:41aggression, hegemonic behavior. This
- 12:43isn't the West. This is India. These are
- 12:45nations of the South China Sea.
- 12:47>> No, not at all. You see, on the China's
- 12:49land border, we only have territory
- 12:51issue with two countries. That is India
- 12:53and Bhutan, which is very much under
- 12:55control. Only India, you see. China
- 12:57actually, since 1979, has resolved all
- 13:00the border issue with the 12 countries.
- 13:02So, you can hardly say that China is not
- 13:04sincere in resolving this kind of border
- 13:06issue. With with India, it's more
- 13:08complicated because even we cannot agree
- 13:10on the length of the border. It's such a
- 13:12big issue. In the South China Sea,
- 13:13people Yes, China does have a problem
- 13:16with some countries, but the people
- 13:17often forget one thing. These claimants
- 13:19also have a, you know,
- 13:21question of demarcation among
- 13:22themselves. So, it's not a question of
- 13:24China versus other claimants. It's also
- 13:26a issue very much among these other
- 13:28claimants of South China Sea countries.
- 13:30>> So, I'm not saying other parties are
- 13:32blameless, senior colonel, but China
- 13:35also is being the aggressor, has been
- 13:37found to be in the wrong. A tribunal
- 13:39under the UN Law of the Sea ruled in
- 13:402016 that China's maritime claims
- 13:43vis-a-vis the Philippines violated
- 13:45international law. Beijing simply
- 13:47rejected the ruling. What happened to
- 13:48respecting global order?
- 13:50>> No, because the case actually happened
- 13:52in in 2013, right? And then the ruling
- 13:55came in to to 2016,
- 13:58but actually China back in the 2006 has
- 14:01been declared that we would not accept
- 14:04any ruling under Article 298. So, that
- 14:07means China already said that without
- 14:09knowing Philippine one day we just
- 14:11assume China because we believe it's
- 14:13about the sovereignty and the UN
- 14:15convention law of sea would not deal any
- 14:17issues on the sovereignty.
- 14:19>> But again, as I said, isn't that
- 14:20cherry-picking which UN convention?
- 14:22Because you say that you respect the UN
- 14:24Charter. A UN convention that doesn't
- 14:26suit you, you reject it.
- 14:27>> No, wow.
- 14:27>> Surely that seems like double standards.
- 14:29>> No, no, no. UN Charter UN Charter is law
- 14:31itself, but there are many other laws.
- 14:33UN Convention Law of the Sea is not
- 14:35about sovereignty and this is clearly
- 14:37written in the preamble. Read it.
- 14:40>> Okay, but on India
- 14:42it's not just a complex border question.
- 14:45In 2020 an estimated 20 Indian soldiers
- 14:48were killed in a violent brawl with the
- 14:49Chinese army. I believe four Chinese
- 14:51troops were killed as well.
- 14:53Time magazine says the clash was
- 14:54triggered by China's more aggressive
- 14:56posture in the region since President Xi
- 14:58came to power. That doesn't sound like
- 15:00you've resolved border issues or that
- 15:02you're a peaceful neighbor.
- 15:03>> Well, I think it depends on how you look
- 15:05at this issue. Before that, actually
- 15:07over four decades, yeah, the the border
- 15:11was by and large peaceful and even Prime
- 15:13Minister Modi pointed putting that out.
- 15:15This actually line of actual control was
- 15:17never demarcated. So, sometimes, you
- 15:19know, Chinese troops and Indian troops
- 15:21would would end up
- 15:23being in the territory that was
- 15:25considered by the other side to be their
- 15:26territory and that was most unfortunate.
- 15:29But look at the
- 15:31the history since 1979. That was the
- 15:34only incident that the China had to do
- 15:36from 1979. So nobody would disagree that
- 15:40the China's rise has been most peaceful
- 15:42compared to any other powers in the
- 15:44history.
- 15:44>> Okay, interesting.
- 15:46Some would say that this almost could
- 15:48have become a much greater clash.
- 15:49Mercifully it didn't.
- 15:51But let's come to Taiwan senior colonel
- 15:53and tell me if here China's actions do
- 15:55not translate into direct hegemonic
- 15:58behavior. It's a tiny island of 23
- 16:00million the majority of whom in poll
- 16:02after poll say they do not want to live
- 16:04under Beijing's rule. China's response
- 16:06has been to fire rockets, simulate air
- 16:08and naval strikes, basically threaten
- 16:11invasion.
- 16:12>> Well, I think you are just putting you
- 16:14know Taiwan as an independent country
- 16:15while more than 180 countries
- 16:18including India
- 16:20and the United States all these
- 16:21countries consider Taiwan to be part of
- 16:23China. So we are still having patience.
- 16:26Yeah, we still look for peaceful
- 16:29reunification but they have to behave.
- 16:31Yeah? So in certain circumstances
- 16:34actually three kind of circumstances
- 16:36according to China's anti-secession law
- 16:38we might resort to use of force but I
- 16:40hope that it would be the last resort.
- 16:43>> But when you say they have to behave do
- 16:45explain to our viewers what that means.
- 16:47If a majority of the population do not
- 16:49want to be part of China, identify as
- 16:52Taiwanese, surely there has to be some
- 16:54respect for the will of the people.
- 16:56>> Well, you know I I I I mean they have to
- 16:58behave because the ruling party is is
- 17:01DPP who actually champion a kind of
- 17:04Taiwan independence and it's under their
- 17:07leadership
- 17:08we basically have no any exchanges
- 17:11across the strait. But this DPP led you
- 17:14know authority by Lai Ching-te even
- 17:17refused to consider yeah, Taiwan to be
- 17:20part of China. That is a big problem.
- 17:21>> Right. You're talking about the current
- 17:23president of Taiwan, Li Ching-te. But I
- 17:26was asking more about the people because
- 17:28quite outside of whoever's in charge, if
- 17:30a growing number of people, and I'm
- 17:31quoting a Pew poll from 2024 which said
- 17:3480% of Taiwan's young consider
- 17:36themselves Taiwanese, not Chinese. 2/3
- 17:38consider China as a major threat to
- 17:40their sovereignty. Again,
- 17:42>> Wow.
- 17:43>> This is This is the public view.
- 17:44>> No. No. This is not
- 17:45>> Surely Surely that's something that
- 17:47China should respect.
- 17:48>> No, this this is not the whole of public
- 17:50view because you will have a different
- 17:51pose. Actually,
- 17:54the the latest poll shows that actually
- 17:56young people are really, you know,
- 17:58happy to see what it was happening in
- 18:01mainland China. And there are more and
- 18:02more people actually are coming to work
- 18:05work in mainland China.
- 18:07>> So, I'd be very interested to see polls
- 18:09which actually show a reverse because
- 18:10these polls show very big numbers, 80%,
- 18:1360%, 70% would prefer to
- 18:16remain Taiwanese and not have
- 18:19Chinese control. But
- 18:21again, just coming back to the idea of
- 18:22what that would mean, Senior Colonel,
- 18:24because the fear is surely that if there
- 18:27is going to be greater Chinese control,
- 18:29then you will have repression, you will
- 18:31have the stripping away of a freer
- 18:33society.
- 18:34They're looking at what happened in Hong
- 18:36Kong with the protests and the way that
- 18:37China cracked down. And I'm not sure if
- 18:39they want to go there.
- 18:41>> Well, you are just looking at this issue
- 18:43from the eyes of some Taiwanese. But as
- 18:45a
- 18:46a mainlander, I can
- 18:48provide another angle. Just think of
- 18:50this. Yeah. If 180 countries believe
- 18:54Taiwan is part of China, how can China
- 18:56allow a part of China still being
- 18:58separated from China?
- 19:00It's just as simple as that. So, we
- 19:02would never tolerate the Taiwan
- 19:03independence. Taiwan will be back. The
- 19:06only question is when and how. It's not
- 19:08a question of if.
- 19:10>> That I must say
- 19:12sounds, senior colonel, like textbook
- 19:14old order big bully behavior of the kind
- 19:16that you've often criticized the West
- 19:18for.
- 19:19>> No, because the West is talking about
- 19:21peace reunification. People always talk
- 19:23about the stick part of our policy, but
- 19:26it but people have forgotten
- 19:28mainland China has actually offered a
- 19:29lot of carrots. For example, yeah, those
- 19:32children from the Taiwanese families
- 19:34could go to kindergartens and the card
- 19:36that we issue to them is
- 19:38uh very much like our own you know ID
- 19:41and we're giving them more and more
- 19:43preferential treatments. It is the
- 19:44Taiwanese society who who refuse this
- 19:47kind of offers because they are afraid
- 19:49that
- 19:50the more the two sides become
- 19:52integrated, the more the Taiwanese
- 19:54people would be you know
- 19:56uh attracted by the mainland, which is
- 19:58the fact because you know China now is
- 20:00the center of gravity almost. Of course
- 20:02this is the this is the Taiwanese people
- 20:04would not be exception.
- 20:06>> So so there could be a difference
- 20:07between seeking economic opportunities
- 20:09here to actually being governed uh by
- 20:12China, but let me move on, Colonel.
- 20:14China treats non-interference as a
- 20:16cornerstone of your foreign policy, it's
- 20:18the holy grail. We won't tell you what
- 20:20to do, you don't tell us what to do. But
- 20:22there's another way to read it. Is
- 20:24non-interference a way of shutting down
- 20:26any questions on how China treats its
- 20:28own citizens? They have no voting
- 20:29rights, no free press, no meaningful
- 20:31right to dissent.
- 20:33>> Well, non-interference
- 20:35is a part of you know
- 20:38uh Chinese foreign policy, yeah. And and
- 20:40this is
- 20:42what you're talking about is kind of a
- 20:44domestic situation. Well,
- 20:46I just give you a quote. According to a
- 20:48poll, okay, you like poll, right?
- 20:49According to a poll by Harvard
- 20:50University, 90% Chinese people actually
- 20:54are happy with with the with the China's
- 20:56the the status quo, yeah? And we believe
- 20:59we're much better than the rest of the
- 21:00world. It's a poll from Harvard
- 21:02University. Read it.
- 21:04>> I'm not disputing that China has made
- 21:06rapid strides in terms of economic
- 21:09success, but again, the fact is that
- 21:10internally there is no way for people to
- 21:13actually signal whether they're happy or
- 21:14not because there are no pipelines of
- 21:16feedback. There's no pipelines of
- 21:17dissent. There's no public opinion
- 21:19that's allowed.
- 21:20>> Now,
- 21:20>> Which is which could be critical of the
- 21:21regime. President Xi is essentially
- 21:23elected by about 3,000 of his party
- 21:25colleagues in a country of over 1
- 21:28billion.
- 21:29A majority of Chinese have no say in
- 21:30determining who elects them.
- 21:32>> Well, you do not understand China's, you
- 21:34know, elections system because
- 21:37we we just have a different election
- 21:39levels at a different constituencies and
- 21:42these people are represented at each
- 21:44constituency and those people at the
- 21:46higher constituency would need to vote
- 21:48for this kind of, you know, leadership.
- 21:50>> But it's still a one-party system.
- 21:51There's no alternative.
- 21:52>> Well, no, you are wrong. In China, it's
- 21:55not a one party. We have many other
- 21:57parties, but the dominant party is the
- 22:00Chinese Communist Party.
- 22:01>> I mean, the other parties are
- 22:02essentially supervised by the the
- 22:04Communist China Party. But when you talk
- 22:07about people being happy,
- 22:09Senior Colonel, are the Uyghurs happy?
- 22:11The UN Human Rights Office report of
- 22:13August 22nd says that China's abuses in
- 22:15the Xinjiang region may constitute
- 22:16crimes against humanity.
- 22:18>> No, I don't think so
- 22:20because if you look at the world, ethnic
- 22:22problem is always most difficult to
- 22:24resolve, yeah? And if you look at the
- 22:27people in Xinjiang, actually
- 22:29the life is becoming is becoming longer,
- 22:31yeah? And if you
- 22:32>> Not according to the United Nations.
- 22:33>> Well, the life is certainly much longer
- 22:36because people's living standard are
- 22:38much higher. This is This doesn't need
- 22:39any statistic. This is just a common
- 22:41sense, yeah? If you just a Google, well,
- 22:45easily whether the people in Xinjiang's
- 22:47life are getting longer, the answer is
- 22:49definitely yes. How can you just
- 22:51convince me that their life is just
- 22:53becoming shorter because because
- 22:56over, you know, politics in China, this
- 22:58is impossible.
- 22:59>> This is not me saying it. Human Rights
- 23:01Watch says hundreds and thousands of
- 23:02Uyghurs remain imprisoned as part of the
- 23:04government's crimes against humanity in
- 23:06the region.
- 23:07>> No, we do not we we do not describe it
- 23:09as such. We we we had a time when the
- 23:13some of these people would have to go
- 23:15through a re-educating center where we
- 23:17actually teach them all all kinds of
- 23:19techniques. So, it's not about what you
- 23:22have described as a prison. No,
- 23:24we don't have do not have so many
- 23:26prisons.
- 23:27>> Let me ask you in conclusion because
- 23:29you've been very critical of the Western
- 23:30liberal order, but how is the Chinese
- 23:32model of a state that is repressive
- 23:34towards its own citizens a better
- 23:36alternative for the world?
- 23:38>> If you ask Chinese people, let's compare
- 23:40Okay, Chinese people life now and
- 23:41Chinese people in the past. In my age,
- 23:43yeah, I have gone through cultural
- 23:44revolution before 1976.
- 23:48You know, was it really really horrible.
- 23:50And even the Chinese Communist Party has
- 23:52drawn a conclusion that they see the
- 23:53havoc to the whole Chinese nation. And
- 23:55as today we are here, we are almost neck
- 23:57to neck to the United States. How can
- 23:59you believe that the second strongest
- 24:01economy in the world, you know, is
- 24:03having a miserable life for all the
- 24:04Chinese people? Is it possible, right?
- 24:06>> The thing is when you say ask the
- 24:07Chinese people, that's the whole point.
- 24:09There are no mechanisms to poll public
- 24:11opinion in this country because you
- 24:12don't have the democratic pipelines. You
- 24:14don't have elections. You don't have a
- 24:15free press. You can't criticize the
- 24:17government.
- 24:17>> Well, you see, to understand how people
- 24:20feel, you don't need such a
- 24:21sophisticated, you know, polls. You look
- 24:23at the people's basket, and look at what
- 24:25is inside the salary, and look at the
- 24:27GDP, right? And look at the China's
- 24:29growth rate. All All these will tell you
- 24:31what how Chinese people would have felt.
- 24:33>> All right, so you believe that the
- 24:34Chinese model is working for its people.
- 24:37Now, whether that's something that plays
- 24:39out on the global stage, we'll have to
- 24:40wait and see. But, Senior Colonel, thank
- 24:42you very much indeed for talking to us
- 24:44[clears throat] and taking our
- 24:44questions. Thanks very much.
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of When might China take Taiwan?: Zhou Bo and Sreenivasan Jain | A Changing World? by Al Jazeera English, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 4,475 words across 730 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.