What the NTSB Revealed About the New Orleans Allision: Atlantic Asphalt vs American Heritage — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:00Hey, what's going on with shipping? Sal
- 0:01Mercagleo here. So, recorded you about a
- 0:0420-minute video breaking down what has
- 0:06happened over the past couple of days
- 0:08here with the Alleion between the
- 0:10Atlantic Asphalt and the American
- 0:13Heritage, but NTSB came out with a
- 0:15follow-up news brief. And usually we
- 0:17don't get much out of this, but we
- 0:18actually got some substantial
- 0:20information from this brief. So, I want
- 0:22to take you over to that and go through
- 0:25the pertinent parts here that apply.
- 0:27Now, before we hear from Bart Barnum
- 0:30here, who's the senior accident
- 0:32investigator for the Office of Marine
- 0:34Safety, several pieces of information
- 0:36were released. First, American Heritage
- 0:39capsized in 22 minutes. Now, I mentioned
- 0:42the fact that when we watch that video,
- 0:44we see the ship roll over, but there is
- 0:45a period there where it has to
- 0:47completely roll over. So, they're saying
- 0:49from the moment of impact, 22 minutes
- 0:51until it capsized. At 11:00 a.m. that
- 0:53morning, Atlantic Asphalt departed from
- 0:56the lower nine mile point anchorage. She
- 0:58had a crew of 19 on board. They don't
- 1:01identify nationality of the crew, but
- 1:03there was one American pilot on board.
- 1:06[snorts] American Heritage came in that
- 1:08morning. I ran the track on Marine
- 1:10Traffic. So, I ran American Heritage on
- 1:13Marine Traffic. She got in about 10:50
- 1:16and then the collision takes place at
- 1:1812:39. So, I mean, you're talking about,
- 1:20you know, an hour and a half there
- 1:21between when the accident uh took place
- 1:24versus when she arrived. She had 140
- 1:27passengers on board and 50 crew. The
- 1:30NTSB is conducting their investigation,
- 1:34but I want to play this part here from
- 1:37Inspector Barnum.
- 1:38>> Um, as a note, uh, this information that
- 1:41I'm about to pass is preliminary in
- 1:42nature. Uh, please, uh, treat it as
- 1:45such. Uh I will discuss uh the voyage
- 1:48data recorder on board the Atlantic uh
- 1:51asphalt.
- 1:53Uh the Atlantic asphalt was equipped
- 1:55with a voyage data rec recorder or VDR.
- 1:59Investigators from the NTSB and our
- 2:02partners have downloaded over 9 hours of
- 2:04data from the unit around the time of
- 2:07the casualty.
- 2:09So VDRs are required on board all ships
- 2:12and they capture a variety of
- 2:14information including data from
- 2:16performance of the ship but most
- 2:18importantly they also have audio d uh
- 2:20recorders in the bridge. Now I will say
- 2:22this it's not mentioned in this the
- 2:24audio recording is always a bit hit and
- 2:26miss because they have fixed microphones
- 2:28in the bridge and so some point
- 2:31depending on where you are on the bridge
- 2:32and what's going on it can get muffled.
- 2:34It's kind of hard to hear. I, you know,
- 2:36if S was boss for a day, I would require
- 2:39the pilots which bring on board these
- 2:41portable pilot units to be able to
- 2:43record everything that they should wear
- 2:45mics, uh, both the captain, the pilot,
- 2:47and the helmsman, so that at least you
- 2:49have that clear information from them.
- 2:52It's a problem we've seen in marine
- 2:55investigations in the past.
- 2:59Data captured by the VDR includes
- 3:02navigational bridge audio,
- 3:06parametric data such as vessel rudder
- 3:10angle,
- 3:12main propulsion engine RPM,
- 3:15and vessel course and speed. So, the
- 3:18rudder angle is going to be really
- 3:20important. The data you want is what was
- 3:23input inputed into the helm. In other
- 3:25words, what you turn the wheel to versus
- 3:27what the rudder is actually doing. Cuz
- 3:28that's key because if you have the
- 3:30rudder set of midshipips and the rudder
- 3:31turns hard right, that's a problem
- 3:33indicating a malfunction. Investigators
- 3:36have conducted a preliminary review of
- 3:38this data.
- 3:40This is what I can share at the time.
- 3:42This time at about 12:26 p.m. on
- 3:46November 13th, 2026, the Atlantic
- 3:50asphalt was upbound on the Mississippi
- 3:53River in the proximity of the Crescent
- 3:56City Connection Bridge. It experienced a
- 3:58steering casualty resulting in the
- 4:01rudder remaining to Starboard.
- 4:05Following the steering casualty, the
- 4:07Atlantic asphalt veered to starboard
- 4:10toward the east bank of the river.
- 4:16As the ship approached the east bank,
- 4:19the VDR audio recorded s the VDR
- 4:23recorded audio sounds consistent with
- 4:26the following. the ship's whistle,
- 4:30warnings and requests for assistance
- 4:33broadcasted over the vessel's marine
- 4:35radio. So, that's really key right
- 4:38there. There was been a lot of
- 4:38discussion about why they did not sound
- 4:40the horn. And according to the NTSB,
- 4:43they did. They just did it prior to all
- 4:46the videos that we have seen. And most
- 4:48importantly, as we've been hearing, they
- 4:50got on the VHF, channel 16 and and the
- 4:52Guard channels, whichever channels they
- 4:54use in New Orleans to report the
- 4:56steering casualty. They don't report
- 4:58what caused the rudder to go hard right,
- 5:01but they are reporting a steering
- 5:03malfunction.
- 5:05>> Commands to deploy the vessel's anchors.
- 5:08>> So, when we look at this video here, the
- 5:10starboard anchor is out. We can see it.
- 5:13It's out. Now in later images we see the
- 5:15starboard anchor missing but that is
- 5:17long after the accident is over. Here
- 5:19the starboard anchor is out. What this
- 5:21tells me is the ship has prepared to
- 5:22drop anchors. They have an anchor detail
- 5:24up on the bow. They have prepped not one
- 5:27but both anchors to drop because anchors
- 5:30have several safety devices you have to
- 5:32remove to be able to drop the anchor.
- 5:35They had already dropped the starboard
- 5:37anchor and what we see in the video is
- 5:38they're lowering the port anchor. Uh the
- 5:40problem with it this is that the bottom
- 5:43in the Mississippi River is mud and it's
- 5:46not the anchor, it's the anchor and
- 5:48chain, but you have to put enough out to
- 5:49drag the stop. And the problem is a mud
- 5:51bottom is terrible for stopping.
- 5:54Estimate that the ship hit uh at about 5
- 5:57to seven knots, although that is not
- 5:58confirmed by the NTSB here.
- 6:03And emergency ship handling orders.
- 6:07>> Emergency ship handling orders. They
- 6:08don't go into detail what that is. Uh
- 6:10I'm going to assume it's something with
- 6:12the engines, but we don't know. We don't
- 6:14think that the engine was ever put a
- 6:16stern on Atlantic Asphalt. It's a slow
- 6:19speed direct drive diesel engine. It
- 6:22takes time to stop the engine and to get
- 6:24it to go a stern, but we're not sure. We
- 6:26don't get a confirmation here from the
- 6:28NTSB.
- 6:29At about 12:28 p.m., the Atlantic
- 6:33asphalt collided with the passenger
- 6:35vessel American Heritage.
- 6:39Further review and analysis of the VDR
- 6:41data and other electronic evidence
- 6:44recovered from the scene is still
- 6:46ongoing. Thank you. So, we don't get a
- 6:50ton of information, but we do get some
- 6:52and and hats off to the NTSB for that.
- 6:54So, we know the ship's whistle was
- 6:56sounded. We know it's a steering
- 6:57malfunction. We don't know what caused
- 6:59the steering malfunction. Uh we don't
- 7:02know if the ship was able to back down
- 7:04their engine or not. Uh we know a pilot
- 7:06was on board. So we know that the ship's
- 7:09crew was getting the advice from the
- 7:10pilot. Uh we don't have the information
- 7:13from the pilot's portable uh pilot unit,
- 7:15the ppu. Uh that's going to be
- 7:17investigated. We don't have uh any sort
- 7:20of information about what was broadcast
- 7:22across VHF channel 16. There was a news
- 7:27conference earlier where they're talking
- 7:29about the salvage operation. So the
- 7:30salvage operation is ongoing. Uh, the
- 7:34American heritage has been bmed off.
- 7:36They've got a containment boom around
- 7:37it. The first thing will be to get the
- 7:3916,000 gallons of marine oil out of her
- 7:43that's used her diesel fuel that powers
- 7:45her engine. And then uh they'll bring in
- 7:48a salvage company to conduct the overall
- 7:50salvage of the ship. In the meantime, a
- 7:53federal court has authorized the arrest
- 7:55of the tanker after the Port of New
- 7:58Orleans launched legal actions seeking
- 8:00more than 1 million dollars in damages
- 8:02following the collisions. Now, the port
- 8:04alleges the collision has caused
- 8:05extensive damage. Let me be clear about
- 8:07a couple of things on this one. Number
- 8:08one, the Port of New Orleans wanted to
- 8:10make sure this ship didn't leave, and it
- 8:12can't leave right now for a couple of
- 8:14reasons, not the least, which has a hole
- 8:15in the bow right of the bulbous bow. So,
- 8:17she's unseaorthy. however, putting a
- 8:20lawsuit against it. And understand, this
- 8:22is from the Port of New Orleans. This is
- 8:24not from individuals on the ships. It's
- 8:26not from American cruise lines. This is
- 8:29just from the Port of New Orleans. This
- 8:31is meant to keep the ship in port, not
- 8:33allow it to sail. Under Madel law, you
- 8:36can arrest a ship. You don't go on board
- 8:38and slap handcuffs on it. What happens
- 8:40is a federal uh uh official will go on
- 8:42board. They'll put a notice up on the
- 8:44bridge. You won't be able to get pilots.
- 8:46You won't be able to undock. You can't
- 8:47leave. And if you try to leave, you're
- 8:48going to get seized by the Coast Guard.
- 8:50So the ship is arrested and ships can be
- 8:52held liable under Admiral Ty law for
- 8:55damages. And when Atlantic Asphalt
- 8:57rammed into American Heritage, American
- 9:00Heritage went up against the dock,
- 9:01smashed into the side of the dock. What
- 9:04you can see here is on the starboard
- 9:05side, deck two of the ship. It is bashed
- 9:08in right here. This is the damage that
- 9:11was inflicted when Atlantic Asphalt hit
- 9:14American Heritage and pushed it into the
- 9:16dock. And that's what's going to wind up
- 9:19with the ship being arrested. The other
- 9:22piece of news we get comes from American
- 9:24Cruise Lines. They issued this statement
- 9:27talking about uh we are proud of our
- 9:29captain and crew for the professional
- 9:31response and we are grateful to the
- 9:32first responders in New Orleans who
- 9:35stepped in quickly to assist. all
- 9:36passengers and crew are safe and
- 9:38accounted for. American Cruise Lines is
- 9:40going to be helping both the guests and
- 9:42crew in the area. It goes on to sit
- 9:44there and say, "We would like to
- 9:45recognize Captain Leonard Stewart, whose
- 9:47immediate and decisive actions with the
- 9:50crew allowed for the rapid evacuation of
- 9:52the vessel. Captain Stewart remained on
- 9:54the bridge as the vessel capsized,
- 9:56calling for aid and keeping the ship
- 9:58alongside the dock for as long as
- 10:00possible." So, this is Captain Leonard
- 10:02Stewart. Used to sail for Edison Shouest
- 10:05down in the Gulf. Holds a 1600 ton
- 10:08merchant marine license. Uh, he left
- 10:11there, worked for what was the parent
- 10:13company for American Heritage before it
- 10:16was bought by ACL, American Cruise
- 10:19Lines. He's sailed for ACL as a bosen,
- 10:21as a chief mate, now as a master.
- 10:24according to reports I've been hearing
- 10:26down in New Orleans. He not only stayed
- 10:28on the bridge, he was hurt. He was uh uh
- 10:30wounded during this uh event, but
- 10:32maintained himself there organizing the
- 10:34evacuation of the 190 people on board
- 10:37the ship. Remember, the ship had just
- 10:39come in. It was dumping its passengers
- 10:41from a seven from an 8-day, seven night
- 10:43cruise up to Mississippi to Nachez had
- 10:46come back down and were getting ready to
- 10:48load a new contingent of passengers to
- 10:50head back up. It's that churn and burn
- 10:52that is in the cruise industry. Uh Port
- 10:55of New Orleans is back open. Matter of
- 10:57fact, there's a Carnival Cruise Liner in
- 10:58the dock right now. The uh Atlantic
- 11:01Asphalt is across the river from
- 11:03American Heritage up against the dock
- 11:06arrested uh under investigation. So,
- 11:09we're going to keep you up to date as
- 11:10more information comes out about this.
- 11:13So, last thing I want to end on here is
- 11:15really the vulnerability of the American
- 11:18maritime infrastructure. On Friday, I
- 11:20literally had a video I was going to
- 11:22drop. I'll drop it on Monday. This video
- 11:24here about a bridge alleion. The Motor
- 11:27Vessel Strategic Alliance struck the
- 11:28Tacone Palmyra Bridge just north of
- 11:31Philadelphia on the Delaware River on
- 11:34November 12th. And you know, when you
- 11:36start looking at this, man, we've had a
- 11:38lot of close calls. I mean, and not just
- 11:40close calls, we've had major incidents.
- 11:42The Dolly in 2024 ticking down the
- 11:44Francis Scott Keybridge killing six
- 11:46people. Now you have this incident with
- 11:48a ship losing power. We've had an
- 11:50incident with the Mexican training ship
- 11:51hitting the Brooklyn Bridge. I mean, I
- 11:53can give you a litany of these. Since I
- 11:55started running the channel 5 years ago,
- 11:57we've had a lot of close calls in and
- 11:59around US waters, and we need to have a
- 12:02serious discussion about what are we
- 12:03doing to prevent this from happening?
- 12:05For example, should we be assigning
- 12:07trailing tugs and tugboats with vessels
- 12:10going through key infrastructure areas?
- 12:12This is really important. If this had
- 12:14happened anywhere else on the river, you
- 12:16wouldn't know about it. The ship would
- 12:17have lost power, would have nudged
- 12:18ashore, would have been pulled off, and
- 12:20it's not a big deal. But because it
- 12:22happened right there in downtown New
- 12:23Orleans, we almost didn't just have a
- 12:26vessel strike where 190 people found
- 12:29themselves the subject of an illusion.
- 12:32But that ship, the Atlantic asphalt,
- 12:34could have hit the Crescent Bridge
- 12:36there. They could have knocked down a
- 12:38bridge. If you look at the the pilings
- 12:40and the structure for that bridge, looks
- 12:41a lot like the the uh Francis Scott Key
- 12:44bridge in Baltimore, when you look at
- 12:46the pilings, they are exposed. Uh ship
- 12:48can hit it. Now, I'm not 100% sure that
- 12:50even if Atlantic Asphalt hit it, it's
- 12:53not a big ship. It's nowhere near as big
- 12:54and heavy as Dolly was. However, I mean,
- 12:57it is exposed and there is a great deal
- 12:59of traffic that goes under that bridge
- 13:01all the time. We need to have a serious
- 13:03discussion about it. Right now,
- 13:04everyone's focus is on air travel.
- 13:06Secretary Duffy is trying to with duct
- 13:09tape and, you know, and bailing wire put
- 13:11together an air traffic control system.
- 13:13If you knew what was maritime traffic
- 13:16control and how we have the maritime
- 13:17infrastructure put together, you'd lose
- 13:19your hair. I mean, I lost my hair. I
- 13:20started this 5 years ago. Had an afro.
- 13:22It was huge. It was massive. It was just
- 13:24But since doing this, it shows me how
- 13:26precarious this situation is. And we
- 13:29need to have a serious discussion about
- 13:30it. There's got to be hearings. There
- 13:31needs to be discussion about it because
- 13:33let me be clear, it's going to happen.
- 13:35And we've already seen the warnings
- 13:37before. If you think you can't happen
- 13:39again, you're wrong. And this should be
- 13:41the loud indicator of that. I hope you
- 13:43enjoyed today's episode. If you did,
- 13:44hey, take a moment, subscribe to the
- 13:46channel, and hit the bell so we learn
- 13:47about new videos as they come out. Leave
- 13:48a comment, share it across social media,
- 13:50and if you can, support the page. How do
- 13:52you do that? You hit that super thanks
- 13:53down below or head on over to Patreon
- 13:55and become a monthly yearly subscriber.
- 13:58until next episode. Sign
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of What the NTSB Revealed About the New Orleans Allision: Atlantic Asphalt vs American Heritage by What's Going on With Shipping?, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 2,555 words across 372 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.