What the actual science says about "brain rot" — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:00In 2022, a lab in Munich did something
- 0:03that I've been wanting to see. They gave
- 0:0560 people a cognitive test, then sent
- 0:07them away for a 10-minute break, and
- 0:09then tested them again. [music] Now, the
- 0:11difference was the break. Some people
- 0:12just sat there, some scrolled on
- 0:14Twitter, some watched a normal YouTube
- 0:16video, [music] and some went on TikTok.
- 0:20So, whose brain changed during that
- 0:23time? This is one of the few experiments
- 0:25that I've been able to dig up that has
- 0:26actually tested the idea of [music]
- 0:29brain rot. But the science is starting
- 0:31to catch up to the fact that short form
- 0:33video feeds are everywhere. [music] And
- 0:35almost all of the commentary says that
- 0:36they're making us dumber.
- 0:38>> I cannot physically [music]
- 0:40bring myself to study.
- 0:42>> I'm addicted, too. We're all addicted to
- 0:43this.
- 0:44>> Oh, no. It's
- 0:45>> horrible for you.
- 0:46>> Oh, and we're giving kids just the
- 0:47attention span of a walnut. This [music]
- 0:49is awkward because we make shorts and it
- 0:52has introduced us to a bunch of new
- 0:53viewers. If Brain Rod is real, then we
- 0:57might be part of the problem.
- 0:58>> I do have a lot of skepticism whenever
- 1:00there's a claim that like some new thing
- 1:02is fundamentally changing the way that
- 1:04humans operate.
- 1:05>> Yeah. Apparently, Socrates thought that
- 1:07writing was going to ruin our minds and
- 1:10you know, people worried about novels
- 1:12being addictive and the telegraph and
- 1:14all of that. Like on Howtown, we don't
- 1:17just take the conventional [music]
- 1:18wisdom.
- 1:19>> We're not running on vibes over here.
- 1:21We're trying to see if there's anything
- 1:22behind the vibes.
- 1:24>> So, I went hunting for evidence. We've
- 1:26heard about shrinking attention spans
- 1:28since the start of the smartphone era,
- 1:29but how can we measure those? And what
- 1:31are the studies saying about the video
- 1:33feeds specifically? After 10 [music]
- 1:35minutes of swiping through shorts, do
- 1:38people really think any worse?
- 1:45First, I wanted to know what makes this
- 1:46new format different from the hours of
- 1:49television that people watch every day.
- 1:51And you can hear it in how the companies
- 1:53talk about their own product. See, last
- 1:55year, a bunch of private conversations
- 1:57between Tik Tok employees came to light
- 2:00after 14 US states investigated and sued
- 2:02the company.
- 2:03>> This is multiple lawsuits coming from
- 2:05individual states attorney general, and
- 2:07the action alleges that Tik Tok exploits
- 2:09and harms young users. The state
- 2:11attorneys had agreed to black out the
- 2:13confidential materials, and I found the
- 2:15breadth of these redactions odd. That's
- 2:17a local reporter named Sylvia Goodman.
- 2:20She discovered that the redactions in
- 2:22the Kentucky complaint had not been done
- 2:24correctly. I copy and pasted it all out
- 2:27into a fresh document, and I could read
- 2:28all of those redactions. I'll be honest,
- 2:31my jaw was on the floor reading some of
- 2:33this. The document showed Tik Tok
- 2:35employees openly grappling with the
- 2:36potential harm of the bold glamour
- 2:38filter. bold glamour filter. This is
- 2:41without the filter.
- 2:42>> They admitted that those screen time
- 2:44reminders
- 2:46were a good talking point, but not
- 2:48altogether effective. One sentence that
- 2:50really stood out to me came from an
- 2:52internal document titled digital
- 2:54well-being.
- 2:55>> Tik Tok's success can largely be
- 2:57attributed to strong out-of-the-box
- 2:58personalization and automation, which
- 3:00limits user agency.
- 3:02>> We hear a lot about that
- 3:03personalization. That's the famous
- 3:05algorithm that decides what to show you
- 3:07based on what you watch and what people
- 3:09with similar watch behavior watch. But I
- 3:11want to zero in on that last part about
- 3:13how the interface limits user agency.
- 3:17They're saying that Tik Tok wins by
- 3:19making fewer things feel like your
- 3:21decision. And I think that's the key to
- 3:23understanding what short form video
- 3:24feeds might be doing to our [music]
- 3:26minds. And since we use that word feed,
- 3:30let's roll with the food analogy.
- 3:32[music]
- 3:35The restaurants we know have a menu. You
- 3:38browse, you pick something, you eat it.
- 3:40Streaming television is that kind of
- 3:41restaurant. YouTube is too, or it was.
- 3:45Their big innovation is that the menus
- 3:47are personalized based on what you've
- 3:49eaten there in the past.
- 3:51Now, imagine a restaurant without menus
- 3:54where you sit down, open your mouth, and
- 3:57a device places a morsel of something
- 4:00onto your tongue. You don't get another
- 4:02bite until you eat it or spit it out. By
- 4:06measuring your chew time, the restaurant
- 4:08can adjust the lineup of bites to
- 4:09feature more of the flavors that you
- 4:11tend to swallow.
- 4:13But they don't just hit you with the
- 4:14same flavor time after time. They can
- 4:16also test out some unexpected morsels
- 4:18[music] because even if it's not your
- 4:20favorite,
- 4:22it's [snorts] just a bite. And there's
- 4:23another one waiting that might be
- 4:25amazing. Without a menu, you lose the
- 4:28experience of choosing, but you gain the
- 4:31experience of being surprised over and
- 4:34over and over again.
- 4:36Plus, a lot more people can make morsels
- 4:38than can make a whole menu. So, this
- 4:40restaurant can recruit way more cooks
- 4:42trying way more tricks to make their
- 4:44morsels tasty.
- 4:46This restaurant is Tik [music] Tok and
- 4:49reals and YouTube shorts and all of the
- 4:51other imitators. and it is probably the
- 4:54most engaging media interface that I've
- 4:58ever seen. Just in terms of sheer
- 5:00entertainment by watch time. There's a
- 5:02catch, though. This sequential feeding
- 5:04system wouldn't work if the dishes were
- 5:06big or complicated. It only works with
- 5:08morsels. If you take away the user's
- 5:11agency, you arrive at short form. We've
- 5:14seen this happen before with Tinder.
- 5:17Instead of a dating app based on a menu,
- 5:19they showed one profile at a time,
- 5:21forcing feedback from the swiper. And
- 5:23what happened? The profiles became short
- 5:25form. Just photos, a couple of words,
- 5:27and an algorithm that encodes our
- 5:30subconscious responses more than our
- 5:32reflective intentions. Maybe you noticed
- 5:34that all the dating apps became Tinder.
- 5:38So, is all of media becoming Tik Tok?
- 5:41I've been trying to figure out just how
- 5:43much human attention has shifted into
- 5:45these feeds, but only the platforms know
- 5:47that and they don't release the data.
- 5:49But they do these quarterly calls with
- 5:51investors. And if you go back through
- 5:52the past few years, you can kind of hear
- 5:55just how big of a response Meta and
- 5:58YouTube have made to [music] the rise of
- 6:00Tik Tok.
- 6:01>> Reals already makes up more than 20% of
- 6:04the time, 50% of the time that people
- 6:06spend on Instagram.
- 6:07>> Over 15 billion views each day. 30
- 6:10billion billion plus 70 billion.
- 6:12>> We now average over 200 billion daily
- 6:15views on YouTube shorts.
- 6:16>> Social media has gone through two eras
- 6:18so far. First was when all content was
- 6:21from friends, family, and accounts that
- 6:22you followed directly. The second was
- 6:24when we added all of the creator
- 6:26content. Now, as AI makes it easier to
- 6:29create and remix [music] content, we're
- 6:31going to add yet another huge corpus of
- 6:33content on top of those.
- 6:37It's really easy for me to think of this
- 6:39as the bowl of potato chips that someone
- 6:41sticks on the table that you didn't
- 6:43order, but it's there, so you snack on
- 6:45it.
- 6:46>> No one can eat just one. [music]
- 6:49>> And it makes me wonder if How town
- 6:51shorts are kind of like, do you know
- 6:53those like pe-shaped potato chips?
- 6:56>> Uh-huh. Right. Right. Right. I know what
- 6:57you're talking about.
- 6:58>> It's like a green Cheeto.
- 6:59>> There's a version of this that's like,
- 7:00but our chips are made of vegetables. I
- 7:03suppose it's no surprise that a
- 7:04bottomless personalized mystery snack
- 7:07dispenser could take over our media
- 7:09diets, but there is such thing as a
- 7:11healthy snack, right? So, I'm going to
- 7:14tell you about all the research that
- 7:16I've read about this and then maybe we
- 7:18can decide how we feel about it.
- 7:19>> Yeah. Great. Yeah. It's interesting. As
- 7:21you've been researching all this, I have
- 7:23been feeling especially scatterbrained.
- 7:25I'm like distracted by the news. I've
- 7:27been moving between two different
- 7:28continents. So, it's a happy coincidence
- 7:31that the sponsor for this week's episode
- 7:33is [music] Headspace, the mental health
- 7:35platform.
- 7:36>> Did you try it?
- 7:36>> Yeah. Yeah. They sent me a free
- 7:38subscription and I've been taking their
- 7:40finding focus course, which [music] is
- 7:42basically 10-minute sessions of guided
- 7:45meditation, and it's been really nice,
- 7:47honestly, to have that break in my day.
- 7:49A couple days ago, I actually just did
- 7:51one while I was waiting for the bus. You
- 7:54know, I've done a fair amount of
- 7:55reporting on mindfulness meditation over
- 7:56the years, and there's a real growing
- 7:58body of evidence from some pretty robust
- 8:00studies that it can improve your working
- 8:02memory. It can improve your ability to
- 8:05sustain attention. In one study, people
- 8:08who meditated with headsp space for a
- 8:10month were less distractable than a
- 8:12control group who did these standard
- 8:13brain training exercises, things like
- 8:15puzzles and memory tasks. So, if you,
- 8:17dear viewer, want to help your brain to
- 8:19focus, you want to learn to meditate,
- 8:21maybe you just want to have these calm
- 8:23moments built into your day, you can
- 8:25start Headspace for free by following
- 8:27the link in our description box or
- 8:29scanning this QR code that's on screen.
- 8:31Usually, it's just a twoe trial, but
- 8:33with this link, you get a full 60 days
- 8:35completely free. Before we get to Tik
- 8:37Tok, there's a bigger question to
- 8:39answer. Have our attention spans really
- 8:42shrunk? According to a 2015 post by Time
- 8:45magazine, yes, they're now shorter than
- 8:47a goldfish. But this is one of those
- 8:50myths that won't die.
- 8:52>> Here's a fun fact.
- 8:53>> Some researchers have concluded that our
- 8:55attention span is now shorter.
- 8:56>> Shorter than a goldfish.
- 8:59>> That's a scientific fact.
- 9:01>> The claim came from a report published
- 9:03by Microsoft which had this graphic
- 9:05showing our attention span declining
- 9:06from 12 seconds to 8 seconds. But they
- 9:09were citing something called statistic
- 9:10brain which in turn cited these sources.
- 9:13And when journalists tried to track down
- 9:15those sources, they didn't exist. The
- 9:17numbers were entirely made up for both
- 9:19the humans and the goldfish. So what
- 9:23would it really take to measure
- 9:24attention spans? Well, I talked to one
- 9:26of the few people who have tried. My
- 9:28name is Gloria Mark. She's written a
- 9:31book called Attention Span. And way back
- 9:33in 2003, she convinced an investment
- 9:35management company to let her peek over
- 9:37the shoulders of 14 of their employees
- 9:39as they [music] worked.
- 9:41>> And we would just observe them and with
- 9:43stopwatches, every time they changed to
- 9:46do something else, we would click on the
- 9:48the stopwatch and [music] it was very,
- 9:50very tiring. Those employees spent about
- 9:542 and 1/2 minutes working on their
- 9:56computers before they switched to
- 9:58checking email or doing something else.
- 9:59[music] Fast forward to 2012. She
- 10:02convinces another workplace to let her
- 10:04install software that tracks [music] how
- 10:06often their employees click from one
- 10:08window to another and finds that they
- 10:10switch every 75 seconds on [music]
- 10:11average. Now it's closer to 40.
- 10:14>> So yes, empirically we can say that on
- 10:18screens attention spans have shortened.
- 10:22>> It's a little tricky because obviously
- 10:23we have this method switch like without
- 10:25that dot at 2004 the trend doesn't look
- 10:29as dramatic, right? It's sort of funny
- 10:30to me to think about the adjudicators or
- 10:33the watchers in that first test were
- 10:35also having their attentions tested.
- 10:37Like were they able to catch like
- 10:39they're also having to focus? The other
- 10:41big question I would have is like is
- 10:43this measuring
- 10:45our ability to focus or just how much
- 10:49distracting stuff there is in our lives.
- 10:51What I'm worried about is that I'm no
- 10:53longer able to read a book for 6 hours
- 10:56like I did when I was 12.
- 10:57>> Has something changed about your brain?
- 10:59>> Yeah. Has has something changed about
- 11:00the ability of my brain? It's obvious to
- 11:03me that something has changed about the
- 11:05way that computers work. Like, yeah,
- 11:07I've just got notifications. There's
- 11:09literal sounds that are telling me you
- 11:11should be distracted by this other thing
- 11:12right now. And so, I still have I'm
- 11:14still curious about like if there's
- 11:17actual damage being done to our mental
- 11:20systems. I guess
- 11:21>> the advantage of Gloria Mark's approach
- 11:23is that it captures real life. It's not
- 11:26just bringing people into a laboratory,
- 11:28having them sit for an hour in front of
- 11:30a computer, but we actually observed
- 11:33what people did over the day in the
- 11:36course of their actual work. The
- 11:39limitation is that it can't distinguish
- 11:41between these three different influences
- 11:43on our ability to focus. There's our
- 11:46attentional capacity. That's what we
- 11:47generally think of when we say attention
- 11:49span. Then there's our motivation, how
- 11:51much we need or care about focusing on
- 11:54this task. And there's competition. How
- 11:57much is our environment distracting us?
- 11:59Now, in a lab, they can get closer to
- 12:02controlling for motivation and
- 12:03competition. But the tasks that they
- 12:05give people don't look anything like
- 12:08real life. Let me show you. This is a
- 12:10classic attention test. They tell you to
- 12:12memorize this image. And then you go
- 12:14through these rows, crossing out the
- 12:16items that match the one that you
- 12:18memorized. You get 20 seconds per row.
- 12:21There's 14 rows. They look at how many
- 12:23errors you make, how fast you work,
- 12:25whether you get worse over time. And on
- 12:27this test, performance in adults has
- 12:30actually been increasing. That's
- 12:32according to a study that compiled
- 12:34scores from three decades [music] and 32
- 12:36countries. In children, overall
- 12:38performance hasn't changed, but their
- 12:40test taking style has. They've become
- 12:42faster, making more errors, but also
- 12:45completing more items. Now, researchers
- 12:47who run lab tests like these don't claim
- 12:50to be measuring attention span. I think
- 12:52we often in daily life, and I even do
- 12:55this myself, we just talk about
- 12:56attention, and it feels obvious, like we
- 12:58know what it means to pay attention, but
- 13:00actually if we give people different
- 13:01tasks, we can see that there's distinct
- 13:04components of attention that aren't
- 13:05necessarily related to each other.
- 13:07>> Monica Rosenberg studies patterns of
- 13:08brain activity during attention tests.
- 13:10the same.
- 13:11>> When I'm watching a really engaging
- 13:12movie, like my lab collected data as
- 13:15people watched a Hitchcock film and
- 13:17YouTube videos about cooking, is this
- 13:19the same kind of attention or is there
- 13:21something fundamentally different about
- 13:23right being engaged in a narrative that
- 13:25I'm motivated to follow versus forcing
- 13:27myself to do this boring task? Um, and
- 13:30it, you know, it turns out there's some
- 13:31similarities, but there's also some
- 13:32differences. And so I think how well I
- 13:35do on one task with pictures is not
- 13:37indicative of how well I pay attention
- 13:39all the time in all contexts. It's
- 13:42certainly related, but it's not a
- 13:44perfect measure. So let's set aside the
- 13:46concept of attention spans. It's a
- 13:48really fuzzy term. It's hard to measure.
- 13:51The sharper question to ask is if you
- 13:54binge short form video, what exactly
- 13:56gets worse? Is it your memory? Your
- 13:58reasoning? That's what the next few
- 14:00studies are trying to pin down.
- 14:04If you ask, do people who say they're
- 14:07addicted to short form video also have
- 14:09trouble focusing? So far, the answer to
- 14:12that seems to be yes. A recent review of
- 14:1514 studies found that increased SFV use,
- 14:18that's short form video, was associated
- 14:21with poorer cognition, including
- 14:23attention and inhibitory control. But
- 14:25whenever you see that term was
- 14:27associated with that scientist code for
- 14:30we're not saying this causes the
- 14:32problem,
- 14:32>> right? It's sort of our social media and
- 14:35teen health all over again where it's
- 14:37are depressed teens becoming depressed
- 14:40because they are on social media or are
- 14:42they seeking it out?
- 14:43>> Yeah, I think this is the question with
- 14:45basically all of the harmful effects
- 14:46that people are attributing to these new
- 14:48technologies is almost all the research
- 14:51can't distinguish correlation from
- 14:53causation. But there are a few
- 14:55experimental studies that I wanted to
- 14:56highlight. There are at least two
- 14:59different cognitive tests where people
- 15:00perform worse after scrolling a shorts
- 15:03feed. One is a kind of trick question
- 15:05quiz and the other is about whether you
- 15:07can remember to do something that you
- 15:08plan to do. So first there's a measure
- 15:12based on these three questions.
- 15:14>> A bat and a ball cost $110 in total. The
- 15:18bat cost $1 more than the ball. How much
- 15:20does the ball cost?
- 15:23This is supposed to capture analytical
- 15:25thinking. To get these questions right,
- 15:26you have to switch out of autopilot like
- 15:29your gut is screaming
- 15:30>> 10 cents and you need to override that.
- 15:3372 college students at Ping University
- 15:36in Beijing took this test after either
- 15:38spending 30 minutes scrolling Tik Tok or
- 15:41the Chinese version of Tik Tok or 30
- 15:44minutes reading. And the Tik Tok group
- 15:46did worse. The researchers wanted to
- 15:48know does what you watch matter? So,
- 15:51they ran a second study, but this time
- 15:53people watched either a cute animals
- 15:55playlist or a science experiments
- 15:57playlist. They also changed how people
- 16:00watch. Some could swipe through the
- 16:02videos like a normal feed. Others had to
- 16:04sit and watch the same clips stitched
- 16:07together into one long video. And here's
- 16:09what they found.
- 16:11It didn't matter whether you watched
- 16:12animals or science, but the swiping
- 16:14groups consistently did worse on the
- 16:17cognitive reflection test. They got 38
- 16:20fewer questions right out of the three
- 16:22questions total. That's 12% of the scale
- 16:25after 30 minutes from just swiping
- 16:28alone.
- 16:29>> Okay. Interesting. So, if you're you're
- 16:32subjected to essentially just a montage
- 16:35of videos that you don't have control
- 16:38over, you are not degrading your
- 16:42analytical thinking as much as if you're
- 16:43swiping through and getting to just skip
- 16:46whenever you are bored. It's sort of
- 16:48interesting because you you think of
- 16:50that decision is interacting with the
- 16:52interface, right? That decision is
- 16:55cognitively more intense than just
- 16:58sitting back and letting something
- 16:59happen to you, right?
- 17:00>> Yeah. Unless boredom is cognitively
- 17:02intense in a way that we don't
- 17:05recognize.
- 17:06>> Okay. So, that's one test that short
- 17:08form video makes you worse at. The other
- 17:10is a test of prospective memory, which
- 17:12is when you remember to do something
- 17:14that you intended to do, like picking up
- 17:17the dry cleaning or joining a Zoom
- 17:19meeting or taking a medication that
- 17:20you're supposed to take. Researchers at
- 17:22the University of Munich wanted to know
- 17:24how short form video feeds affect that
- 17:27ability
- 17:28>> because it was coming from a general
- 17:30observation that like if you scroll a
- 17:33bit, you feel like don't want to say
- 17:35that you feel like new, but like you
- 17:37kind of
- 17:38>> dissociate. Yeah. Yeah. Dissociated a
- 17:40bit. So it was something like we said
- 17:41okay is this actually really happening
- 17:43like and we felt that. So we said okay
- 17:46let's figure out uh how we can you know
- 17:49make this uh solid user study and
- 17:51investigate what can be a cognitive um
- 17:55function that be associated.
- 17:57>> So how would you test perspective
- 17:58memory?
- 18:00>> Boy oh boy. Well it feels like yeah
- 18:02we're getting tested all the time. If
- 18:04you tell me to do something and then you
- 18:06wait 30 minutes and see if I did it. Is
- 18:08that long enough to be considered
- 18:10perspective memory or does it have to be
- 18:12like I know I have a meeting on
- 18:14Wednesday at 1 and do you show up at the
- 18:17meeting? Is that is there a time scale
- 18:20involved in what is considered
- 18:21perspective memory?
- 18:22>> Yeah. Well, I mean the way that the way
- 18:24that psychologists define it for their
- 18:26purposes is is even much shorter than
- 18:28that because
- 18:29>> they need a way to measure it in the lab
- 18:31>> with subjects that they don't have
- 18:33access to for very long. So, the way
- 18:36they try to capture perspective memory,
- 18:37which is this idea of remembering a
- 18:40previous goal or intention, is they
- 18:42embed a task within a task. So, you're
- 18:45going to try this out.
- 18:46>> No. Great. I should have slept more last
- 18:48night.
- 18:50>> Fly sheet.
- 18:50>> The subjects were told to press N on
- 18:52their keyboard if the word on the screen
- 18:54is a real word.
- 18:55>> My heart is racing.
- 18:57>> And M if it's a fake word.
- 19:00>> No.
- 19:01But if they saw the words blue, purple,
- 19:04or green, they were supposed to press Q,
- 19:07W, or E, respectively.
- 19:09>> Purple is that's the perspective memory
- 19:11[music] task.
- 19:12>> Nope, I did it wrong. [laughter]
- 19:14I got it wrong already. I already know.
- 19:16Houseman
- 19:18joust green. I love green. They had
- 19:22people do this task and then take a
- 19:2410-minute break in which they either
- 19:26just rested, scrolled Twitter, watched a
- 19:28YouTube video, or scrolled Tik Tok, and
- 19:31then they took the test again. When they
- 19:33compared the scores from before the
- 19:34break and after the break, the
- 19:36performance on the real word, fake word
- 19:38task was the same. But for the blue,
- 19:41purple, green task, where they needed to
- 19:43remember that second intention, one
- 19:46group saw a big drop in their scores. It
- 19:48was the group that scrolled Tik Tok
- 19:50during the break.
- 19:52>> What this is basically getting at is if
- 19:55you should be keeping something in mind,
- 19:57you lose that with the scrolling
- 20:00behavior,
- 20:00>> but not just scrolling because Twitter
- 20:03is a scroll behavior as well,
- 20:04>> right? That's true. It's short form
- 20:06video specifically.
- 20:07>> That study took place in Germany, but I
- 20:10was able to give this test to Adam in
- 20:11English because researchers in the UK
- 20:14replicated it in their own sample of 45
- 20:16students. And this time they tested
- 20:19different ways of watching short form
- 20:20video. One group was limited to 10
- 20:22swipes. The other group was allowed to
- 20:24swipe as much as they wanted. And there
- 20:26was a control group that just sat
- 20:28quietly. The group that watched shorts
- 20:30but was limited to 10 swipes didn't see
- 20:32a drop in their performance. The
- 20:34unlimited swiping group did. So again,
- 20:38it's like
- 20:40something about just being able to do
- 20:42this
- 20:44mindlessly is is the problem. So, if
- 20:47you're watching this in a clipped short,
- 20:48don't swipe away.
- 20:49>> Actually, what you should do is download
- 20:51all the Howtown shorts, but watch them
- 20:53in one big stream.
- 20:55>> There you go.
- 20:55>> Um, so that's basically where we're at
- 20:58with this with the research. There's a
- 21:00few of these experimental studies.
- 21:02They're using a few different types of
- 21:04cognitive tests, none of which really
- 21:07map on to our popular conception of
- 21:09attention span, but are related
- 21:11cognitive skills. and they're raising a
- 21:14few red flags, but obviously the the
- 21:17caveats of small samples um and tasks
- 21:21that are very different from our
- 21:23[clears throat] everyday lives. Now, I
- 21:25want to know if I'm scrolling TikTok
- 21:27every night before bed for 2 hours, am I
- 21:31just generally having a worst
- 21:33perspective memory in my life, or is
- 21:35that confined to just right after I use
- 21:37it? long-term studies would actually
- 21:40really inform uh and maybe guide better
- 21:44ethics and policy in designing the
- 21:46interface. I think this is actually
- 21:47something that could really impact the
- 21:50quality of life of people probably and
- 21:52provide evidence that maybe something
- 21:54has to change.
- 21:57>> In 1890, the pioneering American
- 21:59psychologist William James [music]
- 22:01wrote, "My experience is what I agree to
- 22:04attend to. My experience is what I agree
- 22:07[music] to attend to. And there's more.
- 22:10He said, "Only those items which I
- 22:12notice shape my mind. Without [music]
- 22:14selective interest, the consciousness of
- 22:16every creature would be a gray chaotic
- 22:19indiscriminatic
- 22:28indiscriminately,
- 22:34[music]
- 22:41my relationship to mangoes will never be
- 22:43the fame. [music] And yet, I keep coming
- 22:46back to this question of user agency or
- 22:49what James called selective [music]
- 22:51interest. Agency is at the heart of both
- 22:54analytical thinking and perspective
- 22:56[music] memory. Those weird little tests
- 22:58are basically asking if your brain is on
- 23:00autopilot [music] or if you can slow
- 23:02down, make a turn, remember where you
- 23:05intended to go. It's not just your
- 23:08intentions that [music] get lost. Feeds
- 23:10that nudge the customers into autopilot
- 23:12tend to nudge the cooks [music] into
- 23:14autopilot, too.
- 23:16>> Scientists just created Here's what
- 23:17would happen.
- 23:17>> Scientist Here's what happened.
- 23:19Scientist,
- 23:22>> but not everyone. Last time I checked,
- 23:24Smarter Everyday, you guys had not
- 23:26posted anything into the shorts feed. Is
- 23:28that still the case?
- 23:29>> That's the case. I have elected not to
- 23:31do that because I don't think it's good
- 23:34for [music] people. I don't think the
- 23:36infinite scroll is healthy for our
- 23:39minds. It's easy for me to say this
- 23:41because Smarter Everyday has been around
- 23:43for a while and there's a lot of really
- 23:45awesome people that support the channel,
- 23:47but I think saying no to shorts is
- 23:49powerful. Um, [music] and I think it
- 23:52ultimately increases trust in the
- 23:54creator. Um, I could be wrong about
- 23:55that, but I don't know. [music] That's
- 23:58where I'm at.
- 23:59>> Dustin's such a good guy. Um, yeah. I
- 24:02mean, I think, you know, obviously we
- 24:04want to be acting with integrity and
- 24:06sort of like living our values in all
- 24:08parts of our life, including the way we
- 24:10make this channel, but like having
- 24:11bite-sized information, you know, when I
- 24:13was at NPR, we would make 3minut radio
- 24:16pieces all the time, right? That was
- 24:17like a pretty typical length. And I
- 24:19didn't feel like those were bad for the
- 24:21world just because it was a compressed
- 24:22amount of information about a complex
- 24:24subject. I thought like, oh, this is
- 24:26good. Like someone is learning something
- 24:28that they wouldn't otherwise know. The
- 24:30question is, do we want to participate
- 24:31in this in these endless scrolls?
- 24:34>> I don't know if you see these comments
- 24:35sometimes on our shorts. This one says
- 24:37like, "Your contents are the most
- 24:39anti-brain rot content [music] out
- 24:41there. Actually, genuine and very high
- 24:43quality." And then someone responded,
- 24:46"No such thing as anti-brain rot [music]
- 24:48content when it's short form."
- 24:49>> So, that's basically kind of the
- 24:51question that we need to answer.
- 24:53>> Yeah. Yeah, that's right. Is there such
- 24:55thing as a good short [music] uh as an
- 24:58anti-brain rot short?
- 25:00>> What do you think? Is this research
- 25:02strong enough that we should be making a
- 25:04change? Let us know in the comments. You
- 25:06can also find more of my conversation
- 25:08with Destin and hear Adam and I
- 25:11processing all of this over on our
- 25:13Patreon. And if you're interested in
- 25:15meditation, which is arguably the
- 25:18opposite of binging a shorts feed, click
- 25:20the link in our description to try
- 25:21Headspace free for 60 days. That deal
- 25:24doesn't last. So try it now. See how
- 25:27your mind responds. Thanks for watching.
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of What the actual science says about "brain rot" by Howtown, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 4,543 words across 709 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.