YouTube2Text

What Scientists Found About Audiobooks — Transcript

by The Upgrade with Makai Elías Calles · 2,420 words · 401 segments · language en · Watch on YouTube

Full transcript

  1. 0:00Which is better, reading a book or
  2. 0:02listening to an audiobook? Over 40% of
  3. 0:05Americans think that audiobooks don't
  4. 0:08count as real reading.
  5. 0:10And I'll be honest, I would usually
  6. 0:11agree. When someone tells me they
  7. 0:13finished [music] 50 books this year, but
  8. 0:15they just listened to them, it does feel
  9. 0:18a little bit like cheating. But it turns
  10. 0:19out I might be wrong, at least
  11. 0:22partially. Scientists have now mapped
  12. 0:24exactly what happens inside our heads
  13. 0:27when we listen to a story versus when we
  14. 0:29read one on a physical page. And the
  15. 0:31neuroscience tells a more complicated
  16. 0:34and even slightly contradictory [music]
  17. 0:36story. But the science does give an
  18. 0:38answer and it might just change the way
  19. 0:40that you consume [music] your content.
  20. 0:52So, check this out. Researchers at UC
  21. 0:54Berkeley had nine people listen to hours
  22. 0:56[music] of narrative stories inside an
  23. 0:59fMRI scanner. Every word was mapped to
  24. 1:03brain activity. Now, this is what your
  25. 1:05brain looks like when you're listening
  26. 1:07to a story. Every color represents a
  27. 1:10different category of meaning. Then, the
  28. 1:13same people came back and they read the
  29. 1:16exact same stories. Again, in the same
  30. 1:19scanner with the same words, the content
  31. 1:21didn't [music] change. And here's the
  32. 1:23same brain reading. Notice anything?
  33. 1:26Yeah, they're basically identical. All
  34. 1:29the red color is the brain processing
  35. 1:31meaning the exact [music] same way, no
  36. 1:33matter how the words arrived. The
  37. 1:36temporal cortex, the parietal cortex,
  38. 1:38and the prefrontal cortex are all
  39. 1:40responding pretty much identically. Your
  40. 1:44brain doesn't really care how the words
  41. 1:46arrived. It's already extracting meaning
  42. 1:48the same way. So, reading [music] and
  43. 1:50listening are far more similar than they
  44. 1:53are different.
  45. 1:54But both are a lot more complex than we
  46. 1:57give them credit for. Now, spoken
  47. 1:59language goes back tens of [music]
  48. 2:01thousands of years. Written language
  49. 2:04maybe 6,000. The printing press 600, and
  50. 2:08audiobooks about 90 years. [music] Your
  51. 2:11brain didn't build a separate new system
  52. 2:14for reading. It borrowed one it already
  53. 2:16had [music] for listening. So, if the
  54. 2:18brain wiring is the same, does anyone
  55. 2:22actually learn better one way than the
  56. 2:24other? Well, let's take a look.
  57. 2:31Let's get into the evidence because
  58. 2:32there is evidence showing that learning
  59. 2:35via audio is just not so good. Back in
  60. 2:392010, textbook publishers were pitching
  61. 2:42audio versions of their books [music] to
  62. 2:44professors. Now, Professor David Daniel
  63. 2:47wanted evidence that they actually
  64. 2:49worked before forcing students to pay
  65. 2:51for them. Seems [music]
  66. 2:52reasonable. So, he ran the experiment.
  67. 2:56He randomly divided his psychology
  68. 2:58students into two groups. One group read
  69. 3:01the textbook chapter. The other one
  70. 3:03listened to the audio version. It was
  71. 3:05the same content and they had 25 minutes
  72. 3:08each. After that, they had to take a
  73. 3:10high-stakes [music] quiz. So, what did
  74. 3:13the data show? Like how much worse were
  75. 3:15they performing? Was it just a little
  76. 3:16bit or was it like, "Okay, this is
  77. 3:18detrimental."
  78. 3:19>> I figured there was a difference between
  79. 3:20an A and a D, like 28% different. It was
  80. 3:23not pretty. Right?
  81. 3:25>> Both groups had the same content and the
  82. 3:27same amount of time, but the listeners
  83. 3:29scored [music] an average of 28%
  84. 3:32lower on the quiz. Now, the final number
  85. 3:35is telling, but so is what happened
  86. 3:37before the quiz.
  87. 3:39>> But before I told them I divided them
  88. 3:40up, I asked them, "Which group do you
  89. 3:42want [music] to be in?" Almost all of
  90. 3:43them wanted to be in the audio version.
  91. 3:45Most people, if there's an option
  92. 3:46between something easier and something
  93. 3:48harder, they're going to take the easier
  94. 3:49version to get the the result.
  95. 3:50>> So, they went in confident, then came
  96. 3:54the quiz.
  97. 3:54>> Well, the first question on the quiz was
  98. 3:56which group would you have rather been
  99. 3:58in? And the people who wanted to be who
  100. 4:00were in the audio condition almost
  101. 4:02universally wish they were in the other
  102. 4:03condition. They knew they didn't know.
  103. 4:05Now, they didn't know they didn't know
  104. 4:07until they had to
  105. 4:08be forced with recalling it in front of
  106. 4:11a quiz. If I had
  107. 4:12I asked them while they were learning
  108. 4:13it, they said, "Oh, I'm fine. This is
  109. 4:14great." But when when they started to
  110. 4:15think, "Do I know this stuff?" Uh-oh, I
  111. 4:17don't.
  112. 4:19And they didn't.
  113. 4:20>> They felt like they were learning, but
  114. 4:22they [music] weren't. That's kind of
  115. 4:24scary. How often do you finish a podcast
  116. 4:26feeling smart and realize an hour later
  117. 4:29you couldn't explain a single thing you
  118. 4:31[music] just heard? This happens to me
  119. 4:33pretty often.
  120. 4:34But why does it happen? Why would
  121. 4:36students perform worse with audio? There
  122. 4:38are a couple of reasons.
  123. 4:40First, reading on paper engages our
  124. 4:43decoding [music] pathway. Your eyes scan
  125. 4:46the letters, recognizing and
  126. 4:47distinguishing [music] shapes. Then in
  127. 4:49the brain, grapheme-to-phoneme mapping
  128. 4:52converts symbols [music] to sounds, and
  129. 4:55working memory blends these into
  130. 4:57meaningful
  131. 4:58>> [music]
  132. 4:58>> units. Second, audiobooks strip out
  133. 5:01spatial cues.
  134. 5:03When you read, your brain builds a map.
  135. 5:05You remember an idea was at the top of
  136. 5:08the left page or a definition was
  137. 5:10halfway through the chapter.
  138. 5:12Audio doesn't quite have that.
  139. 5:14Third, your eyes regress constantly
  140. 5:17while reading. You go back, recheck,
  141. 5:20re-read. [music]
  142. 5:21Technically, you can rewind audio, but
  143. 5:24come on, be honest. [music] Almost
  144. 5:26nobody does. And other studies back this
  145. 5:28up. Compared to reading aloud and
  146. 5:30reading silently to yourself, [music]
  147. 5:32listening to audio leads to the highest
  148. 5:35rate of mind wandering.
  149. 5:37>> [music]
  150. 5:37>> And the same study found that the audio
  151. 5:39group had the poorest memory performance
  152. 5:42and the least [music]
  153. 5:43interest in the material.
  154. 5:44And lastly, there are no natural places
  155. 5:47to stop.
  156. 5:48>> There were no pages that were natural
  157. 5:50places to pause, to build the knowledge.
  158. 5:53This kept going and going and going.
  159. 5:55>> So, that's the case against [music]
  160. 5:57audio, pretty damning. But, hold on
  161. 6:00because the next study tells a different
  162. 6:03story.
  163. 6:05>> [music]
  164. 6:08>> Beth Rogowsky is a professor at
  165. 6:10Bloomsburg University of Pennsylvania.
  166. 6:12[music]
  167. 6:12She was an English teacher for 14 years
  168. 6:15and wondered what role different
  169. 6:17learning mediums have on her students.
  170. 6:20So, she asked, "Does modality matter?"
  171. 6:23And then she went ahead to test it. She
  172. 6:25invited 91 college-educated adults and
  173. 6:28randomly assigned them to
  174. 6:30>> [music]
  175. 6:30>> three groups. Group one listened to
  176. 6:33sections of Unbroken,
  177. 6:34>> [music]
  178. 6:35>> a book about World War II. Group two
  179. 6:38read the exact same sections, but on a
  180. 6:40Kindle. [music] And group three did
  181. 6:42both, listening and reading at the same
  182. 6:44time. After that, everyone took the
  183. 6:47exact [music] same 48-question quiz.
  184. 6:50The quiz had basic comprehension
  185. 6:52questions.
  186. 6:53>> [music]
  187. 6:53>> For example, what branch of the military
  188. 6:55did the castaways represent? The
  189. 6:58participants took the exact same quiz 2
  190. 7:00weeks [music] later.
  191. 7:01>> We found no difference in the three
  192. 7:03groups.
  193. 7:04>> Here are the results. The Y axis is the
  194. 7:07[music] quiz score. The X axis has the
  195. 7:09audio, text, and dual modality groups.
  196. 7:13No significant differences, not
  197. 7:15immediately and not 2 weeks later, and
  198. 7:17not between men and women. And Beth was
  199. 7:21genuinely surprised.
  200. 7:22>> I was surprised because I thought that
  201. 7:26there would be some effects. Um I was
  202. 7:29thinking that with the dual modality,
  203. 7:34you know, a double dose will do better.
  204. 7:37And
  205. 7:38yeah, not at all.
  206. 7:40>> So wait, Professor Daniel and
  207. 7:42researchers have found massive gaps, but
  208. 7:45Beth and colleagues found basically
  209. 7:47nothing. Why?
  210. 7:50I'll answer that soon, but there's one
  211. 7:52thing I have to address. When I first
  212. 7:53read Beth's study, I noticed something
  213. 7:55in the acknowledgements that, as a
  214. 7:57journalist, made me raise an eyebrow.
  215. 8:00The study was partially funded by
  216. 8:02Audible. Mhm. The audio company. So, I
  217. 8:05asked her about it.
  218. 8:06>> They were completely hands-off with us.
  219. 8:10We set up the study and wrote the
  220. 8:14results, and they were completely
  221. 8:15hands-off. We chose the book, the
  222. 8:17material, and the results are the
  223. 8:19results, which doesn't really say much
  224. 8:23for any modality. Maybe Audible would
  225. 8:25have liked it to have turned out
  226. 8:27differently, but it is what it is.
  227. 8:29>> Okay, but there is another issue with
  228. 8:31her study that I think it's worth
  229. 8:33knowing. The reading group wasn't
  230. 8:35reading paper books. They were reading
  231. 8:37books on Kindles. And screen reading
  232. 8:40tends to score lower than ink on paper.
  233. 8:43We have a whole video on this, so go
  234. 8:45check it out. So, if this study had
  235. 8:47pitted traditional print [music] against
  236. 8:50audio, print might have had a benefit.
  237. 8:54The researchers acknowledge this
  238. 8:55themselves. They also caution that
  239. 8:58Unbroken is a narrative non-fiction and
  240. 9:00may not represent Dan's technical
  241. 9:03writing,
  242. 9:04>> [music]
  243. 9:04>> which brings us back to the
  244. 9:06contradiction.
  245. 9:12So, we have two studies that appear to
  246. 9:14disagree. David Daniel found a 28% gap.
  247. 9:18Beth Rogowsky found no gap at all. Both
  248. 9:21are rigorous studies. Both are
  249. 9:23peer-reviewed. What's going on? Well,
  250. 9:26the answer is in what the participants
  251. 9:28were trying [music]
  252. 9:29to do. David's students were studying
  253. 9:31textbook material for a college
  254. 9:33psychology quiz. Beth's participants
  255. 9:35were reading a narrative for a
  256. 9:38Daniel Willingham, a cognitive
  257. 9:39psychologist at the University of
  258. 9:41Virginia, who studies how the brain
  259. 9:43learns, outlined this problem for me.
  260. 9:46>> Most people experience narratives as
  261. 9:49easier to follow in an audiobook format.
  262. 9:52You get a lot of support from your own
  263. 9:55knowledge of the conventions of a
  264. 9:58narrative. When you're reading something
  265. 10:01like Aristotle, information-dense
  266. 10:04texts are organized hierarchically. As
  267. 10:07I'm on page, say six, I'm really,
  268. 10:11ideally, supposed to be relating that to
  269. 10:14what I read on page two. That's very
  270. 10:17difficult to do. It's easier with print.
  271. 10:21It's easy to flip back.
  272. 10:22>> That's the key. Narrative content flows
  273. 10:25forward. Textbook content is layered and
  274. 10:28hierarchical.
  275. 10:30You have to hold pieces in your head and
  276. 10:32connect them. The thing is that audio
  277. 10:34doesn't really give you that
  278. 10:35flexibility.
  279. 10:37>> People who love print have a way of
  280. 10:39reading that is more contemplative.
  281. 10:44You like to really marinate in the text.
  282. 10:48You like to set the pace, and there are
  283. 10:50moments you like to sort of pause and
  284. 10:53really think about the idea that you've
  285. 10:56just read. And this is one of the key
  286. 10:59differences between reading print
  287. 11:00[music] and read and listen to an
  288. 11:02audiobook. With print, you set the pace.
  289. 11:04With an audiobook, the narrator is
  290. 11:06setting the pace. And so you don't have
  291. 11:09those opportunities to sort [music] of
  292. 11:11like, "No, I want to enjoy that sentence
  293. 11:14that I just read. That was beautiful."
  294. 11:15Or I want to reflect on that idea, cuz
  295. 11:18the damn narrator is off, you know,
  296. 11:20they're still they're still talking.
  297. 11:22>> So the contradiction isn't really a
  298. 11:25contradiction. Both findings are true.
  299. 11:28The format should match the purpose.
  300. 11:31Okay, but what about both at once? What
  301. 11:34if we combine them, reading and
  302. 11:36listening at the same time? Well, I used
  303. 11:39to do this in grad school all the time.
  304. 11:41Audio at 1.5, eyes on the page. It feels
  305. 11:44like a superpower, and I thought it was
  306. 11:45quite helpful. But, a meta-analysis of
  307. 11:4830 studies with nearly 2,000
  308. 11:50participants tested exactly this, and
  309. 11:54the overall effect was trivially
  310. 11:55positive. A bump barely clearing
  311. 11:58statistical noise. So, basically, it
  312. 12:01doesn't seem to work. Beth Stol modality
  313. 12:03group confirmed it. She expected a
  314. 12:05double dose to help, but it didn't. More
  315. 12:08is not always better. So, if you enjoy
  316. 12:12it, keep doing it. It'll help you stay
  317. 12:14engaged. Just don't expect it to make
  318. 12:16you a super learner.
  319. 12:22Now, here's something important I have
  320. 12:24to flag, because all three researchers
  321. 12:26brought it up independently. And it's a
  322. 12:28thing that worries them most about how
  323. 12:30their findings will be used.
  324. 12:32>> If we apply this to children, so I came
  325. 12:35from the K-12 environment. I taught
  326. 12:39middle level English for a long time.
  327. 12:41Students need to be able to read. And
  328. 12:45when we allow them to just listen to the
  329. 12:48audio, we are denying them practice in
  330. 12:52reading. We don't want this to be
  331. 12:54misinterpreted as, "Okay, let's just
  332. 12:58have students listen to audiobooks and
  333. 13:00not tackle reading." Creating a literate
  334. 13:03society is important.
  335. 13:05>> None of these studies were about kids
  336. 13:06[music] learning to read. They were
  337. 13:08about adults who already can. The
  338. 13:11finding is about comprehension, [music]
  339. 13:13not about building the skill of reading
  340. 13:14itself.
  341. 13:16These are two completely different
  342. 13:17things. So, is listening to a book
  343. 13:20really the same as reading one? Here's
  344. 13:22the honest answer. For [music] general
  345. 13:24comprehension, reading and listening are
  346. 13:26functionally equivalent, the same.
  347. 13:29The brain processes meaning the same
  348. 13:31way. [music]
  349. 13:31>> If you're doing a book club or just want
  350. 13:35to relax and you're driving [music] or
  351. 13:38commuting to work, listening to an
  352. 13:40audiobook is perfectly fine. It's you're
  353. 13:43going to get the same
  354. 13:45comprehension out [music] of it.
  355. 13:47>> However, for deep learning of complex
  356. 13:49material, print holds a small but
  357. 13:52consistent advantage with self-pacing
  358. 13:54and spatial memory [music] cues.
  359. 13:56And crucially, the attentional demands
  360. 13:59of reading reduce mind-wandering.
  361. 14:02>> [music]
  362. 14:02>> So, use audiobooks to expand the breadth
  363. 14:05of what you consume during time that
  364. 14:07would otherwise be [music] dead. All the
  365. 14:10researchers I spoke with said the same
  366. 14:12thing about their own habits. Beth
  367. 14:14listens in the car and [music] while
  368. 14:15folding laundry, but reads text when
  369. 14:18she's preparing for a class.
  370. 14:19>> I don't start with [music] print. I
  371. 14:21start and end with print. I leave
  372. 14:23audiobooks solely for [music]
  373. 14:26stuff that is, you know, pretty light
  374. 14:28stuff.
  375. 14:29>> Here's the single most important [music]
  376. 14:31finding. The variable that matters the
  377. 14:33most is not the format. It's attention.
  378. 14:36An audiobook listened to with full
  379. 14:39concentration will beat reading a print
  380. 14:41book while distracted [music] and vice
  381. 14:44versa. And the same applies to other
  382. 14:46audio mediums like podcasts.
  383. 14:48>> If you listen to a podcast and you want
  384. 14:49to remember it, stop it and say, "Do
  385. 14:52[music] I remember what I just what I
  386. 14:53just heard?" Check yourself
  387. 14:56before you wreck yourself.
  388. 14:58>> So, the medium is not the message. Your
  389. 15:01focus is. If you found this interesting,
  390. 15:04drop a comment. And which do you think
  391. 15:06is more effective for you,
  392. 15:09listening to or reading a book, and why?
  393. 15:11Share this video with friends and
  394. 15:13family. They might learn a thing or two.
  395. 15:16And if you want to see more content like
  396. 15:18this one exploring the science of human
  397. 15:20cognition and learning, make sure to
  398. 15:23subscribe.
  399. 15:25Thank you for watching or
  400. 15:27listening.
  401. 15:33>> [music]

About this transcript

This page contains the full transcript of What Scientists Found About Audiobooks by The Upgrade with Makai Elías Calles, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 2,420 words across 401 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.

What you can do with it

Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.

Free YouTube transcript tool

YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.