What's Up With Capitalism? A Marxist Perspective — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:00This video is about some of the basic ideas of Marxist economics. Since it is a short video and
- 0:06not a huge multi-volume text, it inevitably will glaringly oversimplify this incredibly nuanced
- 0:11and complex topic. This is no replacement for any of the actual readings but perhaps it will
- 0:16be helpful. "Owning the means of production." You depend on material conditions to survive. This is
- 0:26stuff made out of things, like food, clothing and shelter. You also depend on what is needed to make
- 0:31these things, like land, farming tools, building tools, building materials - that kind of thing.
- 0:36The first kind of thing is called the means of subsistence, and the second is called the means of
- 0:41production. This is important. Notice that if you have access to the sufficient means of production,
- 0:46you can produce some of your own means of subsistence. But having the means of
- 0:50subsistence does not allow you to produce anything if you have no access to means of production. Here
- 0:55is a central characteristic of capitalism people can own the means of production all this really
- 1:01means is that other people either aren't allowed to use it or must use it on the owners terms so
- 1:07if you don't own any means of production you must arrange a deal of it as satisfying to someone who
- 1:11does in order to get your means of subsistence and thus survive use-value and exchange-value usually
- 1:21we find things valuable because they are useful I could trade you a basket of food for a shovel
- 1:26and this would make sense because you have a use for food and I have a use for a shovel exchanging
- 1:31your shovel for a bag of garbage would not make sense to you because I assume you do not have much
- 1:36use for garbage so generally speaking in order for something to be valuable for trade it must
- 1:41be useful this is a pretty fundamental principle here exchange value something valuable for trading
- 1:47depends on use value something valuable in its utility however it's something with use value
- 1:53doesn't necessarily have exchange value air is useful we use it to breathe but we do not trade
- 1:59for it because it is everywhere so in addition to use value there is one more variable that is
- 2:04critical for something to have exchange value and that is labour shoes have use value because they
- 2:11protect our feet but if like air they required no labor to get why would you trade anything for
- 2:16them no one in their right mind would sew shoes would have no exchange value but alas we live in a
- 2:21world where people need to work to produce shoes thus they are indeed valuable for trade notice
- 2:27that labor does not always create exchange value either I doubt you would find my crown doodles
- 2:32very valuable even though I put a lot of work into them it is only when labour creates a previously
- 2:37unavailable use value that exchange value is also created one characteristic of exchange value is
- 2:44that it is more easily quantifiable than use value it is hard to say whether a potato is more useful
- 2:49than a match but it is easier to imagine a potato being worth that is exchangeable for a number of
- 2:55matches this is where money comes in to serve as a universal unit of account through which to compare
- 3:01all items with exchange value appropriation of surplus value part of me for assuming but
- 3:10I imagine that you want means of subsistence so that you can survive let's also further imagine
- 3:14that you don't own the means of production and let's say that some fine lad comes to you and
- 3:20says I'm a capitalist which means that I own the means of production and I pay others to operate it
- 3:27you can use what I pay you to purchase means of subsistence and it will all be hunky-dory let's
- 3:32say you accept and work the means of production all day using your labor to create things with
- 3:37use value thus creating new exchange value the capitalist takes everything you produce and gives
- 3:43you some money which represents much less than the exchange value you've produced this is enough for
- 3:48your means of subsistence for the day but no more and guess you'll have to come work tomorrow too as
- 3:53the week's go by and you continue to work for the capitalist the capitalist continues to accumulate
- 3:58the value you produce some of this he uses for maintenance keeping the means of production in
- 4:03good working order some is used to get the raw materials used in production the rest is either
- 4:08used to scale up and get more means of production or for his own means of subsistence and personal
- 4:13luxuries this last bit here is known as a surplus value which is important here's a fascinating
- 4:20question if you the worker are doing the actual productive labor and the capitalist is not why
- 4:27does the surplus value go to him and not to you wouldn't it be more fair for you to have it as
- 4:32you're the one doing the actual work after all since your wages are only covering your means
- 4:37of subsistence your only choices are to continue working for the capitalist or starve therefore
- 4:42under Marxism the capitalist profiting that is taking the surplus value generated by workers
- 4:47is considered exploitation this exploitation is only made possible by the institution of
- 4:53private property and private property is only made profitable through exploitation private property
- 4:59where no one was exploited where everyone got to keep the value that they themselves produced would
- 5:04hardly be private at all private property and exploitation are inseparable so we are
- 5:10presented with a choice to accept exploitation as a part of how we live or declare private property
- 5:15inherently unjust and abolish it altogether crisis and revolution let us assume that capitalists are
- 5:25not a huge fan of the idea of abolishing private property they decide to keep their control of
- 5:30the means of production and keep profiting through exploiting people so our capitalist
- 5:34keeps taking the surplus value you produce uses it to get better productive equipment so you can
- 5:39produce more and makes an even larger profit now imagine a neighboring capitalist is competing by
- 5:45selling the same commodities for a lower price to attract consumers it's not a huge deal though
- 5:51our capitalists can just lower his prices to after all his new equipment makes production faster and
- 5:57cheaper larger amounts can be produced and sold cheaply while the profits remain the same and
- 6:02since this competition is producing this effect with all capitalists the means of subsistence has
- 6:07gotten cheaper for you to buy the capitalists can thus lower your wages to increase his profit and
- 6:12you will still be able to survive and come back and work for him but then the neighbor gets even
- 6:16better equipment scales up production and again lowers his prices so our capitalists must again
- 6:22upgrade his means of production scale up and lower his prices along with your wage since this is
- 6:29happening across the board a problem soon arises more goods are being produced than society needs
- 6:35and because wages are so meager no one can afford to buy them anyway so the capitalists cannot sell
- 6:41their goods and their profits begin to fall since it is no longer profitable to hire people
- 6:46and produce goods the capitalists lay off their workers and try to sell their means of production
- 6:51no one who wants it can afford to buy it so we end up with means of production that no one is
- 6:55allowed to use at a population producing nothing not even their own means of subsistence so what
- 7:01do we do one obvious answer is for the workers to say to hell with this and come together and
- 7:06work the means of production anyway regardless of whose private property it is the capitalists
- 7:11may object but they are sorely outnumbered so the means of production is seized from them by force
- 7:16this time around the value that is produced will go directly to the people who put labour
- 7:21into producing it this is known as a communist revolution and it must happen sooner or later
- 7:27or else all of the world's productive forces will grind to a halt forever this was a simple overview
- 7:36of some of the thoughts of Karl Marx there are many more of his ideas that are central to his
- 7:41work that we did not even touch upon so hopefully the stoat your curiosity to learn more in many
- 7:47ways conditions today are different from how they were in Marx's time it's hard to say what
- 7:51a modern-day communist revolution would look like but it is clear that a deep change must happen if
- 7:56we want to survive what will it take for humans to live in peace thank you for watching this
- 8:02video I do not run ads and I never will so if you want to support me you can do so on patreon
- 8:13you
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of What's Up With Capitalism? A Marxist Perspective by Jimi Sol, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 1,523 words across 88 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.