What Princeton Really Looks For | Former Admissions Officer Answers Questions — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:00Hi everybody, this is Ananttha, your
- 0:02friendly neighborhood counselor. I'm
- 0:04sitting today with Ricky Canton, the
- 0:05former assistant director for admissions
- 0:07[music] at Princeton University. You
- 0:09sent us your most commonly asked
- 0:10questions and we're going to answer them
- 0:12[music] honestly.
- 0:19All right, so before we begin, uh a
- 0:21quick introduction. Ricky served the
- 0:22Princeton admissions team for 3 years.
- 0:24He's read tens of thousands of
- 0:26applications and has been directly
- 0:28involved in decision-m. So guys, this is
- 0:30really as real as it gets. Ricky, thank
- 0:32you so much for being here.
- 0:33>> Yeah, thank you so much for having me
- 0:35everyone.
- 0:36>> What do I schools actually look for in
- 0:38an applicant? Students are used to
- 0:41hearing so many different things from
- 0:42their counselors, from their friends,
- 0:44even from Reddit. What actually matters
- 0:46to a Princeton?
- 0:47>> The things that really matter to uh a
- 0:50Princeton university and I think by
- 0:51extension as well just you know Ivy
- 0:53League institutions in general are are
- 0:56really two things. I think the uh
- 0:58ability to sort of be taught the the
- 1:01sort of teachability and and the sort of
- 1:02coachability so to speak, right? Um you
- 1:05may be, you know, the the best student
- 1:06in your school u but that doesn't mean
- 1:08you don't have something new to learn or
- 1:11a new opportunity to sort of grow. And I
- 1:13think the other thing too is is a
- 1:15student who's going to sort of take
- 1:16advantage of all the resources that that
- 1:18institution has. So, you know,
- 1:20Princeton, for example, was is a school
- 1:22that has, you know, a a great wealth of
- 1:25resources, whether it's, you know,
- 1:26academic based or extracurricular based.
- 1:29Uh, and I think the student who, uh, you
- 1:31know, is looking to take advantage of
- 1:33all those things, uh, and not
- 1:35necessarily be the student who, you
- 1:36know, just goes to class and back to
- 1:38their dorm room, but rather really
- 1:40pushes what it means to be involved and,
- 1:42uh, be a member of the community is the
- 1:44student that typically fares, uh, the
- 1:46best in the admissions process.
- 1:48>> Right. Exactly. So far from being
- 1:49formulaic, you're looking for people who
- 1:51will actually break out of the mold,
- 1:53whichever way that is for them, right?
- 1:54There is no one perfect student.
- 1:57>> Absolutely. I'd say that's 100% correct.
- 1:59And I think that's the the part that
- 2:00really makes it difficult, right? Um so
- 2:03that's why I'd say you have to do some
- 2:05really deep introspection uh in in
- 2:07trying to understand what it is that you
- 2:09do that is unique because there
- 2:11certainly is something.
- 2:12>> Are Indian applicants at a disadvantage
- 2:14because the competition is so intense?
- 2:17I don't think that Indian applicants are
- 2:19at inherent disadvantage uh just because
- 2:22of being Indian um but I do think like
- 2:24any sort of aspect of the process um the
- 2:28more individuals who are uh sort of
- 2:30involved or applying to the institution
- 2:33uh the more difficult it is to become
- 2:35unique right I again I don't think it's
- 2:37related to the sort of cultural context
- 2:40but purely just based on the numbers
- 2:42right I'd say that anyone for example
- 2:44you know anywhere in the world applying
- 2:46to to computer science is inherently at
- 2:48a sort of disadvantage, right? Because
- 2:50there's thousands and thousands and
- 2:52thousands of individuals looking uh to
- 2:55sort of uh apply to this field. So the
- 2:57the opportunity and the the sort of
- 3:00lengths at which you have to go to to
- 3:02come across as a unique applicant is
- 3:04more uh difficult uh when obviously the
- 3:07the field is is sort of overs
- 3:09subscribed. There's a common belief that
- 3:11research is mandatory because obviously
- 3:13intellectual curiosity is important to
- 3:14universities. But is that a fact or a
- 3:17myth? Is research necessary to get into
- 3:18a top university? So I wouldn't say that
- 3:21research is a requirement or a necessity
- 3:24so to speak. Um but I certainly will say
- 3:27that research helps sort of push the
- 3:29narrative on your ability to do just
- 3:32that research right these universities
- 3:34are academic research institutions. uh
- 3:37first and foremost there's a variety of
- 3:39ways to sort of explore this uh that
- 3:41sort of intellectual vitality and
- 3:43research is just one of of many ways.
- 3:45>> What's the most unique way you've seen a
- 3:47student demonstrate intellectual
- 3:48vitality? I think one of the the sort of
- 3:51most unique ways is um with regards to
- 3:55this one student who was in a rural part
- 3:57of the US uh and and specifically spoke
- 4:00uh about their experiences designing uh
- 4:03this sort of uh lowcost uh wind sensor
- 4:07for uh farmers in their region. Um this
- 4:10individual had no engineering
- 4:12experience. They didn't you know take
- 4:13any advanced coursework at a local
- 4:15university. um you know they hadn't done
- 4:17research in a lab or anything like that
- 4:19um but they simply used the power of you
- 4:21know YouTube and you know I think Tik
- 4:23Tok as well to sort of understand the
- 4:25sort of mechanics behind you know wind
- 4:27sensors at the time and actually used
- 4:29like uh local like metal scraps that
- 4:32they had access to um just being in the
- 4:34the region that they were to build this
- 4:36wind sensor to then implement on farms
- 4:38and you know approve crop efficiency.
- 4:41So, uh, I think that to me was much more
- 4:44of a a learning for the sake of learning
- 4:46and a a measure of intellectual
- 4:47vitality. That really was impressive to
- 4:50me. Um, despite, you know, the the sort
- 4:52of lack of resources, essays are a super
- 4:54important part of college applications.
- 4:56It's uh about showing who you are to
- 4:58your admissions officer. It's about
- 5:00finding and demonstrating your fit to a
- 5:02particular college. You've probably read
- 5:04thousands of essays.
- 5:06>> What makes an essay stand out instantly?
- 5:09If you are uh thinking about you know
- 5:12when an admissions officer reads an
- 5:13application they're reading it alongside
- 5:15of you know hundreds or you know
- 5:16thousands depending on you know the
- 5:18length of the season uh and and I've
- 5:20really found that the essays that are
- 5:22the most successful evoke some sort of
- 5:24emotion in the admissions off uh
- 5:27officer. So whether that's something
- 5:29like uh you know laughing or or crying
- 5:32or um you know uh a sort of more deeply
- 5:35maybe intellectually engaging sort of
- 5:37insight um you know the the individuals
- 5:40who often times you know write their
- 5:42essay and make me sort of walk away
- 5:45thinking like I need to grab a cup of
- 5:46coffee with this kid to learn more are
- 5:48the ones that are you know sort of most
- 5:50successful I think in the process.
- 5:52>> No, I love that. Right. because you're
- 5:54generally reading thousands of
- 5:55applications and something that
- 5:56emotionally touches you and evokes an
- 5:58emotion in you is going to be so much
- 6:00more memorable. Are there any red lines
- 6:03any topics that you wouldn't encourage
- 6:05students to talk about even if it is
- 6:06emotionally uh you know invoking? I
- 6:10think topics if we're if we're going to
- 6:12get into like emotional nuance, I think
- 6:14topics where you haven't necessarily
- 6:16resolved or you're not necessarily in
- 6:18process of resolving that emotion um can
- 6:20be really difficult to talk about and
- 6:22often times don't give the admissions
- 6:25officer um a feeling that you've either
- 6:28figured out a way to grapple with it or
- 6:30you know you've uh understood the the
- 6:32sort of nuances that it takes to um you
- 6:35know find a solution to to solving that.
- 6:36Right? So, what you don't want to leave
- 6:38your your admissions officer on is a
- 6:40sort of cliffhanger or an unresolved
- 6:42tension, right? If it's if it's
- 6:44something that maybe uh you wouldn't
- 6:47share with your mom or dad or your
- 6:49sister or brother or someone who knows
- 6:50you deeply, um then that's possibly, you
- 6:54know, not the the best topic to talk
- 6:56about with an admissions officer, right?
- 6:57You have to remember that admissions
- 6:59officers are people, too, right? Uh so
- 7:01you know uh despite not having met you
- 7:04in person um they do want what's best
- 7:07for you right you know I think we look
- 7:09at this process from a um an assets
- 7:11based approach of you know they're not
- 7:13looking to deny they're looking to
- 7:14accept right so I think that's an
- 7:16important nuance that sort of gets to
- 7:18the crux of you know what to maybe avoid
- 7:20or how to sort of uh uh fall into some
- 7:23essay pitfalls or things like that. No,
- 7:25I think that's an excellent barometer.
- 7:27If it's not something you talk about
- 7:28with your parents or sibling or a close
- 7:29friend, maybe you shouldn't mention that
- 7:31in your essays as well. Uh, something
- 7:33that I see all the time on the internet
- 7:34is is this conception that there is an
- 7:38extracurricular that will get you into
- 7:39an IV league? I've seen people talk
- 7:41about fencing and all kinds of weird
- 7:43things. So, what kind of
- 7:44extracurriculars matter? And is there a
- 7:46secret list of the top extracurriculars
- 7:48that will get you into Princeton
- 7:49somewhere like hidden in the break
- 7:50[laughter] room?
- 7:52Uh I I to answer the question, there is
- 7:54no uh secret list. Uh [laughter] you
- 7:57know, I think if there was one or two or
- 7:59three extracurriculars that get you into
- 8:01Princeton or get you into a Harvard, um
- 8:03I think I would be sort of out of
- 8:05business, [laughter] so to speak. Uh but
- 8:07no, in all seriousness, I I think um the
- 8:10activities that demonstrate that you've
- 8:13maximized what's offered to you, whether
- 8:15that's, you know, making an impact on
- 8:17the life of one person or a thousand,
- 8:20right? uh those activities that sort of
- 8:22talk about uh really utilizing whatever
- 8:24your resources are to the highest extent
- 8:26possible um are the ones that I think
- 8:29oftent times are you know uh most
- 8:31impactful. So there's this um uh student
- 8:34that I still remember to this day who
- 8:36was like an alpaca farmer in uh the mid
- 8:39somewhere in the Midwest in the US and
- 8:42uh that's not a really common uh uh you
- 8:45know type of farm to have in in in the
- 8:48Midwest. Um but the student talked about
- 8:50how you know their family uh was from uh
- 8:53South America and this was like a
- 8:55traditional practice that they had
- 8:56actually brought with them you know
- 8:58across the border and and and and you
- 9:00know brought them to um uh into you know
- 9:03where they lived in the Midwest then.
- 9:05And they were just able to talk about
- 9:06you know how this experience of you know
- 9:08raising alpacas really taught them a lot
- 9:10about what it means to be like a a
- 9:12sustainable farmer in in the modern era.
- 9:14And that was just something so deeply
- 9:17cultural, so deeply thought through. You
- 9:18know, they ultimately wanted to study
- 9:20economics and it just felt so well tied
- 9:22in. Um, and it just felt authentic,
- 9:25right? And that's uh something that to
- 9:26this day has stood out to me. Um, just
- 9:29by nature of the activity.
- 9:30>> Oh, like that that's amazing, right?
- 9:32It's like I mean it's it's
- 9:34vitracurricular
- 9:37particular stands out to you. That's
- 9:39that's fantastic.
- 9:39>> Absolutely. Yes. Based on your
- 9:41experience, what is the biggest mistake
- 9:43international applicants make?
- 9:45>> Yeah, I think based on my experience,
- 9:47the biggest mistake that international
- 9:49applicants make is not to sort of share
- 9:54uh uh an aspect of of vulnerability,
- 9:57right? Um I think everyone thinks that,
- 9:59you know, everything needs to be so
- 10:00sharp, so perfect. And I think often
- 10:03times when things come across as so
- 10:06refined, um I as an admissions officer,
- 10:09at least as a former one, felt that
- 10:11>> that student wasn't being real with me,
- 10:14right? And it felt like they were trying
- 10:16to put on a facade instead of trying to
- 10:19show me, you know,
- 10:20>> despite, you know, having all these
- 10:22experiences and doing well in school and
- 10:24doing all these activities, you know,
- 10:26there's still this one thing I actually
- 10:27struggle with. and making sure that you
- 10:29have like an action plan to address that
- 10:31is I think the one of the best ways that
- 10:33uh you can address you know some of the
- 10:34pitfalls in the the application.
- 10:36>> Okay. Uh one thing I've always been
- 10:38curious about is how do admissions
- 10:39officers make decisions? I I know
- 10:41there's a multi-ter system but could you
- 10:43walk us through an actual scenario like
- 10:44what happens when you once you receive
- 10:46an application?
- 10:47>> I I view admissions as a sort of at
- 10:49least the the process in the application
- 10:50as a sort of two-step process here. So
- 10:54specifically, uh I think academics gets
- 10:56you to the door. Everything else gets
- 10:58you through, right? So uh for me, I
- 11:01always looked at the academic portion
- 11:03first, right? So I'm going straight to
- 11:04your transcript. I want to know, you
- 11:06know, what you've been studying, you
- 11:08know, how you've been doing, what the
- 11:10sort of course progression was, what
- 11:12your sort of grade progression was to
- 11:13get an understanding really of
- 11:16particularly while I was at Princeton,
- 11:18why you would be a good academic fit. If
- 11:21I feel like there's enough support,
- 11:22whether that's with the, you know,
- 11:24between the transcript, the SAT, the the
- 11:26course rigor, and all these other
- 11:27things, then I'm going to look into your
- 11:29your sort of activity list and how you
- 11:31spend your time outside of school.
- 11:33>> Um, so for those types of things, you
- 11:35know, those help me get a picture of of
- 11:38what's important to you, what you value,
- 11:40and things along this line. And then
- 11:42ultimately what I sort of typically, you
- 11:44know, round out the application by doing
- 11:46is looking about looking at the the
- 11:47pieces of the application that are um,
- 11:50you know, letters of recommendation,
- 11:51what others think about you. And then
- 11:54ultimately um, you know, at this point I
- 11:56feel like I have an understanding of who
- 11:58you are. And what I do then is move on
- 12:00to the writing to see if that's
- 12:02confirmed, right? to see if what my sort
- 12:05of understanding of your application is
- 12:07is what's being brought out in the sort
- 12:09of writing because that's writing is the
- 12:10the the portion I like to say it's like
- 12:13the sort of lifeblood of the application
- 12:14right it moves your uh application it
- 12:17connects these different pieces and such
- 12:20um and I think that the the writing
- 12:21portion um acts as a sort of
- 12:24confirmation of of fit uh for that
- 12:26institution and whether or not you'll
- 12:28you know utilize uh everything that the
- 12:30institution has to offer. Well,
- 12:32>> so I think that's that's really what uh
- 12:34I'd say in response to that question.
- 12:36>> No, that's amazing. And I think that is
- 12:38such a great level of nuance, right? I
- 12:40think a lot of people uh don't get to
- 12:42see that and they don't really
- 12:43understand like the things you mentioned
- 12:45that writing is the life of your
- 12:47application and that these things it
- 12:48gives meaning to the fact that
- 12:50admissions are holistic, not it's it's
- 12:51not so much a buzz word. So, it's it's
- 12:53amazing to hear you explain that to us.
- 12:54>> Absolutely. And like I said, you know,
- 12:56I've I've met other admissions officers
- 12:58who start with the writing and and work
- 12:59backwards, right? Um and that's
- 13:01certainly a different approach but uh
- 13:03you know there's no one right approach
- 13:04here but I I just want you to sort of
- 13:06understand that you know there is such
- 13:08nuance in the process and the admissions
- 13:11officers are really sort of taking their
- 13:12time to understand you know why that
- 13:14applicant has has put in so much work to
- 13:17get to this place of applying to the
- 13:19institution
- 13:20>> with that in mind but how much time do
- 13:22you actually spend per application
- 13:24because it's it's a lot to do right
- 13:26>> I don't want to raise any [laughter]
- 13:27alarms it is a very short amount of
- 13:30time, right? I'd say anywhere between 5
- 13:33to 10 minutes, but closer to to about 5
- 13:36minutes. You know, I'd say I'd average,
- 13:38you know, if I'm spending more than
- 13:40seven or eight minutes on on an
- 13:41application, um there should be a
- 13:44significant reason as to why I'm doing
- 13:45that, right? So, um and that's reading
- 13:47everything, right? you know, so I I
- 13:49think it's really important to to think
- 13:51of the admissions process as as, you
- 13:53know, um as as someone basically trying
- 13:57to uh dissect as much information as
- 14:00possible. So, you really want to present
- 14:01it in the most clear way. Right. Right.
- 14:04Right. Okay. Cool. So, you're obviously
- 14:05used to doing things in a small amount
- 14:07of time, which is why we're going to do
- 14:08a rapid fire round.
- 14:09>> Okay, let's go. Are you ready for this?
- 14:11>> Yeah, let's do it.
- 14:12>> Uh SAT or no SAT?
- 14:14>> I'm of the mindset uh SAT? Yes.
- 14:17>> Do it. Internships matter?
- 14:19>> Do internships matter? Uh it depends on
- 14:22what you're getting out of the inter
- 14:24internship to be specific. You know, uh
- 14:26if it's a very, you know, nuanced
- 14:28experience that has led you to explore
- 14:30something, then yes. Uh if you're just
- 14:32doing an internship to to say that
- 14:34you've had, you know, a Google
- 14:35internship, then no. [laughter]
- 14:37>> Do I need to have a bunch of awards in
- 14:38my application?
- 14:39>> Uh no, you don't need to have a bunch of
- 14:42awards. Uh but is it helpful in in
- 14:44demonstrating why you're unique?
- 14:46Certainly.
- 14:48Do APs give you an advantage?
- 14:50>> Uh APs, uh I would say don't inherently
- 14:54give you an advantage. Uh I think your
- 14:56core curriculum and maxing out what's
- 14:58offered to you is what's going to be
- 15:00expected right of you?
- 15:02>> And I think I know the answer to this
- 15:03question, but do universities and
- 15:05admissions officers look at social
- 15:06media?
- 15:07>> You know, another admissions officer may
- 15:09have another opinion on this. I did ne I
- 15:11never looked at an a social media
- 15:14profile. Um, actually maybe one time I
- 15:16looked and it was because I was directed
- 15:18to look at it, right? So, uh, of my own
- 15:20valition, no, I don't look at social
- 15:22media for
- 15:22>> I figure that you guys probably have
- 15:24better things to be doing with your
- 15:25>> Yeah. Yeah. 8 minutes, you know, reading
- 15:27it [laughter] for a while. I don't have
- 15:28the time to be quite honest. Okay, cool.
- 15:31A final question. Uh, I know college
- 15:32admissions is a constantly evolving
- 15:35landscape, right? And so much has
- 15:36changed in the past couple of years. um
- 15:38with a affirmative action being struck
- 15:40down with uh AI becoming such a huge
- 15:44thing. I don't want to get into all the
- 15:45details, but I want to ask you today
- 15:46that if you were applying to college
- 15:49right now, what would you do? What would
- 15:51you do differently?
- 15:52>> So, I think mom and dad may want to
- 15:54cover their ears when they hear this.
- 15:55[laughter]
- 15:56Um this
- 15:58I when I was applying to university, I
- 16:01uh really only thought about the sort of
- 16:05uh financial bottom line, right? I was
- 16:07only thinking about uh institutions that
- 16:10could serve me in getting that job, not
- 16:13thinking about what would make me the
- 16:15happiest, right? And I know that's a a
- 16:17little bit of a a trade-off there, but
- 16:19um you know, I initially went into my
- 16:21university experience thinking I wanted
- 16:23to be a doctor. Uh and that was not at
- 16:26all what I did. I stepped into uh my
- 16:29first chemistry class at at Pomono. Uh
- 16:32and I said absolutely not. Uh so I I you
- 16:36know I I found that I was unhappy right
- 16:38and the experience of a college
- 16:41education is to help you grow beyond
- 16:43what you thought was uh you know what
- 16:45you thought you wanted to do or what you
- 16:47thought was previously possible. So, I
- 16:49think to to sort of answer this
- 16:50question, what I would really do is sort
- 16:52of just keep an open mind to things that
- 16:55aren't necessarily what you thought you
- 16:57would do, right? Um, take, you know, try
- 16:59a new class, try a new experience, you
- 17:02know, o open your mind to something
- 17:03that, um, you didn't think was
- 17:06previously of interest to you. I think
- 17:07you would have made an amazing doctor,
- 17:09but I am also glad that you you're not
- 17:11so you could sit here with us today and
- 17:14share shareh answers to these questions.
- 17:16Honestly, I'm sure our audience would
- 17:18really appreciate it. So, Ricky, thank
- 17:19you so much for being here and uh like I
- 17:21said, we're being transparent. To our
- 17:23viewers, uh make sure you drop your
- 17:25questions in the comments. We'll try to
- 17:26get to them as well if they weren't
- 17:28already covered. And I don't know if
- 17:30this video gets maybe a thousand likes,
- 17:31we'll do a part two. Are you game for
- 17:33that?
- 17:33>> I'm game for that.
- 17:35>> All right, cool. And any parting words
- 17:36uh to our viewers, people applying this
- 17:38year?
- 17:39>> Yeah, absolutely. I know there's, as you
- 17:41mentioned, you know, a lot of intensity
- 17:43around the process. Uh I think one of
- 17:45the most important things to realize is
- 17:47that uh you will end up at an
- 17:49institution that is an ideal fit for you
- 17:52and I know it doesn't feel like that
- 17:53right now but take a deep breath uh
- 17:56double down on what you're already doing
- 17:58and uh you know make sure you're taking
- 18:00care of your sort of mental health as
- 18:02well, right? Because that's as just as
- 18:03important as what this process
- 18:05ultimately yields.
- 18:06>> All right, thank you guys. Uh stay
- 18:08classy and we'll see you on the next
- 18:10video. Goodbye.
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of What Princeton Really Looks For | Former Admissions Officer Answers Questions by Athena Education, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 3,683 words across 531 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.