What Makes A Marxist? | Dr. Paul Kengor — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:00I was 17 years old 1984 uh 1984
- 0:03presidential election and these people
- 0:04can't imagine that it actually was a
- 0:07time of unity and in those days just
- 0:09because the president had had an R next
- 0:10to his name didn't mean that you needed
- 0:12to hate him and call him a racist so you
- 0:14give them today a message of unity which
- 0:16they claim that they want and they hate
- 0:19it they want to divide they say they
- 0:21want inclusion and diversity right uh no
- 0:24they want to divide so that's a good
- 0:26point even if you had the right Reagan
- 0:27today there'd be a lot more hate of him
- 0:31uh regardless from the left Dr Paul
- 0:33kangor is a distinguished political
- 0:35scientist bestselling author and expert
- 0:36on communism and the political history
- 0:38of Ronald Reagan's presidency kangar is
- 0:40professor at Grove City College where he
- 0:41currently serves at the Helm of the
- 0:42school's Center for vision and values as
- 0:44well as a contributing editor at the
- 0:46American spectator kangar has also
- 0:47authored over 20 books on topics ranging
- 0:49from Reagan's relationship with Pope
- 0:50John Paul II to the bias of the American
- 0:52Media kar's analysis of marxist ideology
- 0:55and its historical implications position
- 0:56him as a leading voice in our
- 0:58contemporary debates about socialism
- 1:00capitalism and political freedom in fact
- 1:02the recent Blockbuster film Reagan was
- 1:03inspired by kangor's 2007 book the
- 1:05Crusader Ronald Reagan and the fall of
- 1:07Communism in today's episode Paul and I
- 1:09dissect the infiltration of marxist
- 1:10ideas among American progressives the
- 1:12ideological Crux of a marxists worldview
- 1:15and whether or not comml Harris can
- 1:16actually be classified as a Marxist
- 1:18herself we also examine the similarities
- 1:20and differences between the presidencies
- 1:21of Ronald Reagan and Donald Trump and
- 1:22how American conservatives can lead the
- 1:24way toward the less divisive future Dr
- 1:26Paul kangor's body of work has enriched
- 1:28The public's understanding of Marxism
- 1:29and issued an important warning about
- 1:31how damaging ideas can alter the course
- 1:33of history don't miss this important
- 1:34conversation with Dr Paul kangor on this
- 1:36episode of the Sunday
- 1:38[Music]
- 1:45special Paul thanks so much for taking
- 1:47the time really appreciate it yeah Ben I
- 1:49got to tell you this is kind of a
- 1:50reunion so you and I first met you
- 1:52probably didn't remember this but at the
- 1:54Reagan Ranch Center in Santa Barbara and
- 1:57so thus I have my Rancho Del Cho shirt
- 2:00on was there for a few a few weeks ago
- 2:03for the premiere of the Reagan movie I
- 2:04know we're probably going to be talking
- 2:05about that too but I was trying trying
- 2:08to remember when that was I I'm kind of
- 2:10dating it by the age of my daughter who
- 2:12remembers it all really well I think it
- 2:14was you know probably at least 10 years
- 2:16ago yeah and I think you're talking
- 2:17about 2014 2015 somewhere in that
- 2:20neighborhood yeah it's been it's been a
- 2:21while you weren't famous yet yeah
- 2:23exactly exactly it's better times but
- 2:27let let's talk about obviously you've
- 2:28written about a huge number of topics of
- 2:30interest to our audience most recently
- 2:32you've written a lot about Marxism and
- 2:34you know the the race today between
- 2:36Donald Trump and kamla Harris that the
- 2:38term Marxist has been thrown around by
- 2:40President Trump with regard to kamla
- 2:42Harris and there's some people who say
- 2:43that's unfair she's not totally in favor
- 2:45of say nationalization of all means and
- 2:48mechanisms of Industry she probably has
- 2:50never read Carl marks do do you think
- 2:52it's fair for president Trump to call
- 2:53her a Marxist how should we determine
- 2:55whether someone is is sort of a Marxist
- 2:57even colloquially in American politics
- 2:59these days days well this is a great
- 3:01question and by the way MCG grov City
- 3:02College or Institute for Faith and
- 3:04freedom and I teach a course on Marxism
- 3:06at grov city college and this current
- 3:08semester I'm teaching a course in
- 3:09comparative politics we're talking about
- 3:11Marxism right now and I told my students
- 3:14last week I said just as we don't like
- 3:16it when the left calls conservatives
- 3:19fascists right we want to be very
- 3:21careful about calling leftists even
- 3:24radical leftists maybe even Democratic
- 3:26socialists we could go through that uh
- 3:28calling them Marxist right I mean if if
- 3:31you want to just call him an extreme
- 3:33leftist I think that's good right but I
- 3:35want to call a Marxist a Marxist only if
- 3:38we're dealing with a legitimate Marxist
- 3:40all right now in in that debate um I
- 3:43think Trump was right about kamla's
- 3:45father I mean K's father I mean based on
- 3:48his writings and I've read some of his
- 3:50journal articles and he was on the um
- 3:52econ department at Stanford University
- 3:54and from what I can tell he was a
- 3:55Marxist now her yeah it's a good point I
- 3:59don't know if she reads has read Carl
- 4:01Marx um she certainly probably is not
- 4:04what we would call a classical Marxist
- 4:06right bouris Z proletariat um probably
- 4:10hasn't read The Communist Manifesto now
- 4:13when you get into the more General kind
- 4:15of broadening area of and this is where
- 4:18we are today taking the sort of marxist
- 4:20super structure of oppressed versus
- 4:23oppressor all right you find your two
- 4:25groups to pit together right and
- 4:27classical Marxism this was based on
- 4:29economic and class it was a proletariat
- 4:31Bourgeois there you had your oppressor
- 4:33and oppressed today with the race-based
- 4:35Marxist it's black versus white right
- 4:38with gender Marxist male versus female
- 4:41with Marxist operating culture it's some
- 4:44other cultural application and often
- 4:47times the people that are doing that
- 4:49have no idea that they're even part of
- 4:52that General Marxist superstructure so
- 4:54if you say to them you know that's a
- 4:56form of cultural Marxism or space more
- 5:00they'll scoff and maybe they should
- 5:02scoff because they don't even know what
- 5:03they're doing but in her case she might
- 5:06be coming more from that General
- 5:08superstructure and issues of race gender
- 5:11culture um but I'd stay away from saying
- 5:14in a national debate right she's a
- 5:16Marxist unless you can really defend it
- 5:19and explain it know kind of in the way
- 5:21that I just did yeah and I think one of
- 5:22the problems actually with doing that is
- 5:24that not only may it not be fair in
- 5:26terms of you know her actual belief
- 5:28system because again who knows what the
- 5:29hell she believes but it also actually
- 5:31Waters down what Marxism is and makes it
- 5:34more palatable for the masses because
- 5:35people go okay well if KLA Harris is a
- 5:37Marxist doesn't seem that bad I mean
- 5:38we're not talking about the Soviet Union
- 5:40we're not talking about Cuba we're not
- 5:41talking about Venezuela we're talking
- 5:42about a lady who's hobnobbing with tech
- 5:44CEOs and wants government
- 5:46interventionism in the economy and more
- 5:48redistribution whatever people think of
- 5:50her they tend to then box that in with
- 5:52the same sort of democratic socialism
- 5:54that Bernie talks about in Norway with
- 5:56the same you know Soviet fullscale
- 5:58Marxism that we we saw applied for
- 6:00nearly all of the 20th century yeah
- 6:02that's right on and then so then when
- 6:03you meet The Real McCoy right and when
- 6:05someone like me and you says um you know
- 6:08Bernie Sanders wasn't a member of the
- 6:11troia Socialist Workers Party but he was
- 6:14an actual formal presidential elector in
- 6:171980 right he was um he was Pro trosky
- 6:20he was a trotskyist in college at the
- 6:22University of Chicago uh he joined a he
- 6:25joined a stalinist kabut Ron Ros has
- 6:27written about this when he when he was
- 6:29in Israel so then when we say those
- 6:31things they're inclined not to believe
- 6:33us when I did I did a full book on
- 6:36Obama's Mentor Frank Marshall Davis and
- 6:39it was called the Communist it was
- 6:40published by Simon and Schuster Mercury
- 6:42Inc Glenn Beck and it was a bestseller
- 6:44so it debuted at like top 10 of the New
- 6:46York Times and I immediately got emails
- 6:48from people on the left saying you know
- 6:50you guys just call our people Communists
- 6:52all the time and then I had to say I
- 6:55know I know we do but this guy look at
- 6:58the cover of the book we put his
- 6:59Communist Party USA number right on the
- 7:01cover
- 7:0347544 right you know this guy testified
- 7:06before the Senate internal security
- 7:07subcommittee in December 1956 he had a
- 7:11security index on him there's a 500 to
- 7:14600 page FBI file on the guy you know
- 7:17this guy was really a communist and when
- 7:20you look at some of Obama's rhetoric all
- 7:22right early in his life and when he went
- 7:24to Accidental College it seems like he
- 7:26was at one point a Marxist today
- 7:29probably not although you still see some
- 7:31of that rhetoric right although he never
- 7:33ever reputed it but by the way this
- 7:34bothers me too um if you left that stuff
- 7:38come out and say it because it's part of
- 7:40your your narrative it's part of your
- 7:42conversion story right Hillary Clinton
- 7:45uh yeah I was a Goldwater girl right uh
- 7:47but I don't believe that anymore yeah I
- 7:49was in touch with sa Alinsky but you
- 7:51know maybe she's not an alinskyite right
- 7:54uh George W bush I was an alcoholic but
- 7:56I left that then I had my conversion
- 7:58right if you're Obama come out and say
- 8:00well in my youth you know like a lot of
- 8:02people at Colombia and some of these
- 8:04places I flirted with those ideas but I
- 8:06know better now you go up five points if
- 8:09if if you if you say something like that
- 8:11but instead the there's no public
- 8:13repudiation so it makes us suspicious um
- 8:16but but that said my point uh a guy like
- 8:18Frank Marshall Davis a guy like Bernie
- 8:20Sanders AOC Democratic Socialist so when
- 8:24we mislabel people it hurts our ability
- 8:27to label them correctly when they're
- 8:29indeed like you know the real Marxist
- 8:31McCoy we'll get some more on this in
- 8:33just a moment first did you know you
- 8:34spend a third of your life sleeping if
- 8:36you're not doing it right you're
- 8:37literally wasting years of your life I
- 8:38don't know about you I can't afford to
- 8:40do that which is why I want to tell you
- 8:41about Helix sleep Helix has genuinely
- 8:43transformed My Sleep Quality they have
- 8:4520 different mattress options because
- 8:46unlike the one size fits all crowd Helix
- 8:49understands that different people need
- 8:50different solutions here's how it works
- 8:52you take their sleep quiz I did it
- 8:53myself they match you with your perfect
- 8:55mattress when I took it they recommended
- 8:57a medium firm mattress because I
- 8:58mentioned my back pain issues with
- 8:59software mattresses let me tell you they
- 9:01got it exactly right whether you need
- 9:02the cloud light comfort of their Lux the
- 9:04premium experience of the elite or the
- 9:06extra support of the Helix plus they
- 9:07have you cover the best part they ship
- 9:09it directly to your door no awkward
- 9:10mattress St interactions necessary Helix
- 9:13is so confident in their product they
- 9:14give you 100 nights to try it out that's
- 9:15more than 3 months to decide if it's
- 9:17right for you plus they back every
- 9:18mattress with a 10 to 15E warranty
- 9:20That's What I Call standing behind your
- 9:22product so if you want to sleep as
- 9:23soundly as I do head on over to Helix
- 9:25sleep.com take that sleep quiz plus
- 9:27Helix is offering up to 25% off offsite
- 9:29wide and two free dream pillows with any
- 9:31mattress purchase even better Helix is
- 9:33offering a free betting bundle which is
- 9:35two dream pillows a sheet set a mattress
- 9:36protector with any Lux or Elite mattress
- 9:38order that's right just head on over to
- 9:39helixsleep.com that's Helix sleep.com
- 9:42with Helix better sleep starts right now
- 9:44so one of the things that that you
- 9:45mentioned there is that there is this
- 9:47sort of no true Scotsman fallacy that
- 9:49people like to apply in a Marxist
- 9:50scenario where you'll say something is
- 9:52Marxist they'll say that's not real
- 9:53Marxism right the Soviet Union is not
- 9:54real Marxism or communist China in its
- 9:56original iteration not real Marxism Cuba
- 9:58not real Marxism so let's try to get to
- 10:00the nitty-gritty what would you consider
- 10:03to be real full-scale Marxism where
- 10:05would you feel comfortable saying this
- 10:07person abides by these principles that
- 10:08makes this person a Marxist as opposed
- 10:10to just say membership in the Communist
- 10:12party you know that that's sort of an
- 10:13easy out outlying indicator but somebody
- 10:15who's not a member of CP USI and and
- 10:17they are a Marxist in your view what
- 10:19principles do they have to fulfill well
- 10:22from a practical point of view a poster
- 10:23boy country would be North Korea okay
- 10:26North Korea Cuba in fact you look at
- 10:28something like the Heritage found
- 10:29foundation's index of economic freedom
- 10:31uh you North Korea has been at the very
- 10:33bottom of the ranking since they started
- 10:35doing this thing 30 years ago right um
- 10:38but theoretically go to The Communist
- 10:40Manifesto in fact people will say to me
- 10:43Ben they'll say Give me a one-sentence
- 10:46definition of communism say okay I'll
- 10:48make it easy Marx and Eng Les gave us
- 10:50one in the manifesto they say the entire
- 10:53communist Theory may be summed up in the
- 10:55single sentence abolition of private
- 10:57property so as the starting point I mean
- 11:00it's a war on private property and and
- 11:02of course that goes against uh you know
- 11:05the judeo-christian foundation uh you
- 11:08know Old Testament New Testament Thou
- 11:10shalt not steal the Ten Commandments
- 11:12right implies you have the right to
- 11:14property some people consider it a
- 11:16natural right a sacred right uh you know
- 11:18from the cave to the courthouse people
- 11:20have had the right to property when you
- 11:22do something like literally try to
- 11:24abolish all private property then you're
- 11:26really raising ra a z iing g uh the the
- 11:29foundations of everything and they were
- 11:31all about that in the manifesto too
- 11:33marks and Engles immediately immediately
- 11:35doubled down on that they say uh you
- 11:38were horrified at us intending to do
- 11:40away with private property they don't
- 11:42pause there and say well we don't really
- 11:45mean that what we mean is no they say
- 11:48precisely so that is precisely what we
- 11:51intend to do so at that point maybe one
- 11:54could argue different variations
- 11:56gradations degradations whatever of
- 11:58communism M to what degree is a
- 12:00communist Society abolishing private
- 12:03property right at the level of the home
- 12:05at the level of Agriculture at the level
- 12:07of you know popot in Cambodia whether
- 12:10you're allowed to own you know personal
- 12:12hygiene products uh you know toothpaste
- 12:14in Cuba uh whether not you're allowed to
- 12:17pick your mangoes from the front tree
- 12:20growing on your property in Cuba um I
- 12:23have a former student Lorenzo kazana
- 12:25whose aunt in Cuba um had a mango Tree
- 12:29in her front yard and the family was
- 12:32hungry and it pained them terribly to
- 12:35know that there were fresh beautiful
- 12:37mangoes growing on their property but
- 12:40because that belonged to the state and
- 12:43they weren't allowed to pick and sell
- 12:45their own produce because of the laws of
- 12:48Market control versus Central planning
- 12:50on prices in production level they
- 12:52couldn't even pick the mangoes from
- 12:54their front yard and when they took some
- 12:56in the middle of the night they they
- 12:58realized when got up in the morning what
- 13:00they did they threw the peels in the
- 13:01garbage oh so they go out and they bury
- 13:04them in the ground so the state won't
- 13:06see that they pick the mangoes now
- 13:08that's abolition of private property at
- 13:11a very severe level so as a starting
- 13:14point um property above all abolition of
- 13:17private property and you know that that
- 13:18that provides a really useful framework
- 13:20for thinking about because it also shows
- 13:22you the spectrum of Economic
- 13:24interventionism and and where things
- 13:26actually line up so one of the great
- 13:28lies of course is that that for example
- 13:30that that's been used by by Soviets and
- 13:32communist backers is the idea that the
- 13:34Nazism and Soviet economics were in 100%
- 13:37opposition and that basically you know
- 13:39the the capitalist side is closer to
- 13:41Nazi economics and the the Communist
- 13:43side is is therefore good because what
- 13:45what the What communists tend to do is
- 13:46they use the World War II model as a way
- 13:49of demonstrating that communism is
- 13:50actually good since the Soviet Army by
- 13:52the end of the war was on the right side
- 13:54of the war as opposed to at the
- 13:55beginning when they actually you know
- 13:56led to the war but with that said if you
- 13:58if use your framework of abolition of
- 14:00private property what you end up doing
- 14:01is also recognizing that heavy
- 14:03regulation of the use of private
- 14:05property is closer to actual public
- 14:07ownership of private property than it is
- 14:09to economic freedom so if you have a
- 14:12very corpor system as Nazi Germany did
- 14:14in which everybody is organized into
- 14:16guilds by the government in which the
- 14:17government is is reaching into
- 14:19everybody's pocket and determining how
- 14:21your private capital is used that is
- 14:23much closer to public ownership of the
- 14:25means of production than it is to you
- 14:26being able to make free decisions about
- 14:29the the dispensation and use of your own
- 14:31wealth that's exactly right I mean you
- 14:33know they're not following hyek and
- 14:35mises and Milton fredman right and Nazi
- 14:37Germany and of course the very name Nazi
- 14:39which is short hand for National
- 14:41Socialist it was a National Socialist
- 14:44German Workers Party and and Ben people
- 14:48will often say yeah but Hitler yeah
- 14:50Hitler was killing the Communists too
- 14:52well sure I mean but but but the these
- 14:55people on the left are always at each
- 14:57other's throats I mean trosky versus
- 15:00Stalin trotskyist and stalinists the
- 15:02American Communist party was um filled
- 15:06with um and in fact once the Hitler
- 15:09Stalin pack took place in August
- 15:121939 um huge numbers of American Jews
- 15:16left Communist Party USA because because
- 15:19joining Communist Party USA you swore
- 15:21loyalty oath to Stalin Soviet Union
- 15:23right to work to ensure the Triumph of
- 15:26Soviet power inside the United States uh
- 15:29USSA as Langston news called it so they
- 15:32knew at that point they couldn't they
- 15:34could no longer swore swear loyalty oath
- 15:37to Stalin Soviet Union because Stalin
- 15:39was now on the side of Hitler he ateed
- 15:40an Abed at Hitler so at that point a lot
- 15:43of them left and you can see there too
- 15:45Hitler and Stalin at that point found
- 15:47common cause and they worked together
- 15:49but but the left is filled with all
- 15:51kinds of angry militant factions I mean
- 15:54we have our disagreements and arguments
- 15:57on the right go to a conference of like
- 16:00far leftists I mean these people are are
- 16:03are at each other's throats over little
- 16:06tiny issues that um you know that that
- 16:09most people can't even relate to or
- 16:10explain or understand it wasn't wasn't
- 16:12capitalist who put an ice pick through
- 16:14through try's eye right right solist
- 16:16agents so you know with with all of that
- 16:18sort of pointed out and in the backdrop
- 16:20of of Marxism how do we distinguish
- 16:22between Marxism and something that
- 16:23you've talked about which is just the
- 16:25old biblical story of the oppressor
- 16:28versus oppressed false Matrix so I I've
- 16:30pointed this out myself you know as
- 16:31somebody who reads the Bible pretty
- 16:32regularly in the original Hebrew you
- 16:34know when when the Cain abble story is
- 16:36the probably single most indicative
- 16:38political story in all of human history
- 16:40that you have one sacrifice that that
- 16:42God takes Abel sacrifice and and Cain
- 16:44sacrifice for a reason that's
- 16:45unspecified by the text is is rejected
- 16:48and then God warns Cain and he says you
- 16:50have this inclination to do sin and it
- 16:52crouches at your door but you can Master
- 16:53over it and Kane rejects that and goes
- 16:55and kills Abel and that that sort of
- 16:57Matrix in which you know doesn't have a
- 16:59reason to hate Abel there it's on Abel's
- 17:00fault that God decides to accept Abel's
- 17:02sacrifice and and so Cain decides to
- 17:04kill Abel that that sort of sense of
- 17:06victimization that result in aggression
- 17:08toward people who are more successful in
- 17:10one way shape or form through a
- 17:12perceived sense of Oppression now that
- 17:14is the story of of so much of human
- 17:16history is this perceived sense of
- 17:18grievance against other people who are
- 17:19more successful how do we distinguish
- 17:21that from Marxism or is Marxism just
- 17:22sort of one offshoot of that General
- 17:24oppressor oppressed Matrix yeah in fact
- 17:26I I would argue others have too that the
- 17:29you know the the primary virtue in
- 17:31Marxism is Envy right uh Envy hate
- 17:34avarice and it's amazing to read Carl
- 17:37Marx and and hear him complaining about
- 17:40people's obsession with capital Marx was
- 17:42obsessed with capital I mean all Marx
- 17:44can think about is capital I mean Mark
- 17:47Marx gets up in the morning and
- 17:49bellyaches and moans and ruins his day
- 17:51just thinking about Capital all Marx
- 17:54wants is capital right in fact you know
- 17:56Marx's mother and wife both Express the
- 17:59wish that Carl would start earning some
- 18:01Capital rather than just writing about
- 18:03capital and by the way this is a classic
- 18:05example of of how the left thinks right
- 18:08they talk about diversity equity and
- 18:10inclusion and and but they don't include
- 18:13us right we don't fit under their
- 18:15diversity umbrella they talk about
- 18:17tolerance but no tolerance for us and
- 18:19their side they talk about hate when
- 18:22guys like you and I are looking at them
- 18:23smiling it's like I don't hate you man I
- 18:26mean I'm not angry at you at all you
- 18:28know Smoke's almost coming out of their
- 18:30ears as they're screaming hater right
- 18:33but they they project and this is what
- 18:35Marx and the marxists do I mean the Marx
- 18:38you talk about greed you don't see greed
- 18:40anywhere like you see among Marxist
- 18:42societies and Marxist leaders I mean
- 18:45they take all the capital they take
- 18:46everything they take all the production
- 18:48themselves you Marxism is not for the
- 18:51rulers it's for the ruled I mean
- 18:54everybody else has has to follow those
- 18:56rules um and I would forward here to I
- 19:00often hear as a Christian they'll point
- 19:02to acts acts 432 through 435 where it
- 19:06says the early Apostles held everything
- 19:08in common they pulled together their
- 19:10resources and shared everything and um
- 19:13and as even Pope Francis has said you
- 19:15know Pope Francis is hardly a li a
- 19:18capitalist right but but Pope Francis
- 19:20has said um that's not Marxism right um
- 19:24you know that that's that's charitable
- 19:26traditional Christianity by the way
- 19:28that's written in the first century
- 19:30Marxism comes you know 18 you know 17 18
- 19:33centuries after that but if you look in
- 19:36Acts and also the Old Testament they
- 19:39have the right to property they have the
- 19:41right to own things also we can get to
- 19:43this in a minute they don't hate
- 19:45religion right right they're they're not
- 19:48atheists you know Marxism is inherently
- 19:51atheistic as all the Marxist leninists
- 19:53and all the Marxist leaders have always
- 19:55said so to have a group of Apostles in
- 19:58the first century getting together
- 20:01voluntarily on their own all right by
- 20:03their own free will and if you read the
- 20:06whole text selling portions of the
- 20:08property that they're permitted to own
- 20:10in order to pull them together to help
- 20:12their fellow man um that's not Marxism
- 20:16right you know that's that's that's a
- 20:17free will choice now Marxism would be
- 20:20the heavy-handed state coming into that
- 20:23community and every community in the
- 20:25entire country and telling them forcibly
- 20:28all of your property will be banned by
- 20:30the way so will your religion all right
- 20:33and so will you know all traditional
- 20:35relations that that you have marks and
- 20:37Engles said communism represents quote
- 20:38the most radical rupture in traditional
- 20:40relations unquote we're going to take
- 20:42we're going to violate all of that and
- 20:44we're going to forcibly redistribute all
- 20:47of your wealth we're going to abolish
- 20:48the right of inheritance that's part
- 20:50three in their 10-point plan we're going
- 20:52to have a full progressive income tax
- 20:54right we're going to do this all this
- 20:55other stuff that's communism right
- 20:58people voluntarily getting together to
- 21:00live in community the Dominicans the
- 21:03franciscans right which is
- 21:080.00001% of all Americans right on their
- 21:11own to voluntarily share their stuff
- 21:14that is not a Marxist State that's not
- 21:16Marxism we'll get some more on that in a
- 21:18moment first let's talk about something
- 21:19that affects all of us responsible
- 21:21hardworking Americans taxes the October
- 21:2315th deadline has now passed are you
- 21:24prepared for what's coming next do you
- 21:26owe back taxes are your tax returns
- 21:28still on fire fed missed the deadlines
- 21:29file for an extension well now that
- 21:31October 15th is behind us the IRS may be
- 21:33ramping up enforcement let me tell you
- 21:34they're not playing around you could
- 21:36face wage garnishments Frozen bank
- 21:37accounts or even property seizures if
- 21:39you haven't taken action yet but here is
- 21:40the good news there's still hope tax
- 21:42Network USA has been in this game for
- 21:44years they know exactly how to navigate
- 21:45the complex world of tax law they've
- 21:47helped taxpayers save over a billion
- 21:48dollars in tax debt they' filed over
- 21:5010,000 tax returns that's billion with a
- 21:52be folks they specialize in helping
- 21:54hardworking Americans like you reduce
- 21:56their tax burdens so don't let the IRS
- 21:58catch guard get ahead of this right now
- 22:00with tax Network USA their team of
- 22:02professionals will work tirelessly to
- 22:03protect your assets and find the best
- 22:04solution for your unique situation so
- 22:06here's what you need to do for a
- 22:07complimentary consultation call today 1
- 22:09800 958 1000 or visit their website at
- 22:12TN
- 22:13usa.com Shapiro that's 1800 958 1000 or
- 22:17visit TN usa.com Shapiro today don't let
- 22:20the IRS take advantage of you get the
- 22:21help you need with tax Network USA well
- 22:24I mean as I've said to to you know
- 22:25people all the time I'm I'm the most
- 22:27capitalist person I know in my house I'm
- 22:29a Marxist meaning I share my my wealth
- 22:31in common with my wife right I mean we
- 22:32don't earn equivalent amounts of wealth
- 22:34and my kids certainly don't earn
- 22:35anything but we all have access to the
- 22:37pool of cash because when it comes to
- 22:39family obviously it's share and share
- 22:41alike that is not the same thing when it
- 22:42comes to things outside the family which
- 22:44is of course why markx is attempting to
- 22:45abolish the family because the family is
- 22:47in fact a Bull workk against the idea
- 22:49that everyone is family if you have
- 22:50family then you know there's a big
- 22:51difference between you and your wife and
- 22:53your kids and you know this guy in New
- 22:55York who you've never met before and you
- 22:57shouldn't be asked to treat that person
- 22:58as though they're a member of your
- 22:59family because that's not realistic to
- 23:01how human nature is and I think this is
- 23:03one of the points that that you make
- 23:04with regard to to Marxism in particular
- 23:06is that Marx Marxism for all of its talk
- 23:08about being a scientific theory which of
- 23:10course it absolutely is not I mean it's
- 23:12pseudoscientific absolute sheer trash it
- 23:14doesn't make mathemat sense
- 23:15mathematically doesn't make sense
- 23:16logically it promotes itself as a
- 23:18scientific theory because that way it
- 23:20can somehow get away with making the
- 23:22claims that it's making and that's why
- 23:24even today marxists will will attempt to
- 23:27avoid the reality of of the failures of
- 23:29marxist prediction right they've
- 23:30attempted to end around that in a wide
- 23:32variety of ways including Lenin who
- 23:34basically suggested that it wasn't
- 23:35descriptive it had to be normative that
- 23:37that instead of Marx attempting to
- 23:39describe the Arc of history in a sort of
- 23:41passive fashion you had to you had to
- 23:43enact it you had to grab it you had to
- 23:44do the thing and that really was called
- 23:45to action as opposed to what Marx
- 23:48thought it was going to be which was a
- 23:49prediction of the future that never came
- 23:50true and in fact turned out to be false
- 23:52in every respect ranging from the
- 23:54depression of wages to the idea that
- 23:56there would be a worldwide class
- 23:57uprising of the poor against the rich
- 23:59which of course never happened World War
- 24:00I being the best indicator that it never
- 24:02happened when everybody sided along
- 24:03National lines as opposed to along class
- 24:05lines what Marxism actually is a
- 24:07religious Theory it's a religious Theory
- 24:09positing an eschatology of man and when
- 24:12you read Marx what you see is that he
- 24:14substituting his own idea of the
- 24:16transformation of human nature that will
- 24:18erupt as a result of this inevitable end
- 24:21of capitalism and a new man will be born
- 24:23in which everybody is purely generous
- 24:25and purely benevolent and it turns out
- 24:27that that all of the evils of the human
- 24:29heart which he says were planted by
- 24:31capitalism in the same way that rouso
- 24:32suggests that all of the evils of the
- 24:33human heart were planted by the first
- 24:35man who created a fence basically you
- 24:36know that all of that will disappear and
- 24:38so you won't need government government
- 24:39will wither away this is what the anarco
- 24:42Communist which of course makes no sense
- 24:43this is what they claim what they're
- 24:44really shooting for is a time when
- 24:46government will wither away and we will
- 24:47all live in a voluntary Brotherhood of
- 24:49Man in which we ourselves have been
- 24:50transformed in Soul that's a religious
- 24:53promise and I think that's why Marxism
- 24:54will never die because if you're making
- 24:55a religious promise there's no way to
- 24:57actually determine whether it's true or
- 24:58not until you hit some sort of Messianic
- 25:00age yeah and especially if you're making
- 25:02that argument to people who aren't
- 25:04religious right so they're they're not
- 25:06um they don't follow Judaism or
- 25:08Christianity so instead they're
- 25:09atheistic so this gives them their
- 25:12secular Utopia right so most religious
- 25:14people would say come on dude that's
- 25:16what you get in heaven all right when
- 25:18all this is over right you you can't
- 25:19have that possibly here in this Earth
- 25:22but if you read statements from Marx
- 25:24from other early Communists Moses hes uh
- 25:27Arthur hler who was one of the people in
- 25:29The God That Failed I mean they talk
- 25:31about how this was like a religion and
- 25:34in fact Raymond Aaron his classic book
- 25:36is called the Opium of the
- 25:38intellectuals uh because really to them
- 25:40that's what it's like they make they
- 25:42make fun of religious people called
- 25:43religion the Opium of the masses I mean
- 25:45Marxism is is really absolutely the the
- 25:47Opium of the intellectuals Ronald Reagan
- 25:49said um well Marxism leninism that
- 25:52religion of theirs and and and indeed
- 25:55and you and you started off by saying um
- 25:59scientific yeah they have this phrase
- 26:01Scientific Socialism the Soviets use it
- 26:03all the time um Vladimir Lenin in the
- 26:07state and Revolution which he started
- 26:09writing and never really F fully
- 26:10finished that was the September October
- 26:131917 the revolution got in the way so he
- 26:15didn't finish it he describes Mark as
- 26:17this Marx as a scientific socialist this
- 26:19genius all this flowering gushing you
- 26:22know hagiographic language way way over
- 26:25the top people have to remember that um
- 26:27mark lived 1818 to 1883 so he he is
- 26:32alive in the period of Darwin when the
- 26:34Origin of Species comes out so they were
- 26:37hoping that Marx would do for the social
- 26:39sciences and for economics what Darwin
- 26:42did for the physical sciences so there's
- 26:44this idea of this evolutionary movement
- 26:47where where mankind would start in
- 26:50slavery serfdom capitalism socialism and
- 26:54eventually to Communism right socialism
- 26:57according to Marxist leninist Theory
- 26:59would be the final transitionary step
- 27:01into communism so this get this added a
- 27:04historical inevitability to the whole
- 27:06thing right so people could see this
- 27:09unfolding over time this evolution of uh
- 27:12of the history of the world and they Les
- 27:16at Marx's funeral and also at Marx's
- 27:19wife's funeral quoted Darwin right he's
- 27:23he's not quoting the scriptures he's not
- 27:25quoting the Old Testament or new
- 27:26testament he's quoting Darwin right here
- 27:29lies the vivacious Jenny right who who
- 27:34he gives this kind of depressing little
- 27:37sermet about basically Marx's wife now
- 27:42rotting in a casket turning to dust or
- 27:45worm food I don't know but but the great
- 27:47news is right through this historical
- 27:50darwinian Evolution that that Marx
- 27:52created and pioneered you know the world
- 27:55will eventually reach that Utopia in the
- 27:57sky full communism classless society uh
- 28:01and and that's just one of almost every
- 28:04prediction that Marx made which is
- 28:06complete fatuous nonsense and uh never
- 28:10came true so you know one of the things
- 28:12that we see is when when we talk about
- 28:14this again we come back to the same
- 28:15point which is when we talk about
- 28:16Marxism I think if you have an
- 28:18understanding of Marxism at all you see
- 28:20how how terrible it is it's it's
- 28:22terrible results but the the point that
- 28:24that Hayek makes in the road of surf is
- 28:26that it actually is a road to get there
- 28:27it's not as though you know one day you
- 28:29wake up it's not like Russia in 1917
- 28:31where you wake up one day and suddenly
- 28:32it's imposed top down this is something
- 28:35that you gradually slide into and this
- 28:37is where I think the Temptation is for
- 28:38the right saying that okay we're just
- 28:40going to describe kamla Harris or Barack
- 28:42Obama as chiefly marxists because
- 28:44warning you about where this is going as
- 28:46opposed to this is a step along the
- 28:48roads of predition we just go straight
- 28:50to the end we say okay well what they
- 28:51want is tomorrow like communist Utopia I
- 28:53mean they may want something like that
- 28:55in the back nether regions of their
- 28:56brain is sort of the lizard Marxist
- 28:58brain from college you know to you know
- 29:0030 years in the future but to get there
- 29:02they're willing to do an awful lot of of
- 29:04gradated actions and that's why you're
- 29:06seeing KLA Harris wooing CEOs and and
- 29:09you know treating capitalism as though
- 29:10capitalism is still you know you'll he
- 29:12Joe Biden say this all the time I'm not
- 29:14I'm not begrudging anybody the ability
- 29:16to earn a buck I'm not saying that I
- 29:18love capitalism capitalism but all we
- 29:20need is just one more restriction all we
- 29:22need is one more set of regulations all
- 29:24we need is just a little more control
- 29:26and it's always just a little more
- 29:27control
- 29:28yeah that's right you to quote Reagan in
- 29:30the time for choosing speech right the
- 29:31more the planners plan uh the the more
- 29:34that the plans fail the more that the
- 29:36planners plan and so at the very least
- 29:38they favor what you know W woodro Wilson
- 29:41called the administrative State the
- 29:43heavy regulatory State and and and once
- 29:45again did you notice this I mean for a
- 29:47while it seemed like the last few years
- 29:50the left the Democratic left had kind of
- 29:52given up on a lot of the class Warfare
- 29:54rhetoric that they were engaging in in
- 29:56the 1990s um you you might be you're
- 29:59younger than me probably about 10 years
- 30:00or so I don't know if you remember dick
- 30:02Gart in the yeah in the early 1990s and
- 30:05talking talking about how um people who
- 30:08are wealthier have done well are the
- 30:09winners in life's Lottery and so forth
- 30:12but every four years and younger people
- 30:15um wouldn't have experienced this but
- 30:16the Democrats they would just Trot out
- 30:19this he favors the rich he favors the
- 30:21rich tax cuts for billionaires on and on
- 30:23and on and on and on they seem to
- 30:25finally give it up with Donald Trump I
- 30:27think becauseum Trump so appealed to the
- 30:29middle class and the lower the lower
- 30:31working class I live in Western
- 30:32Pennsylvania I was born in Pittsburgh my
- 30:35family worked in colines and steel mills
- 30:37right my dad was a steel worker uh so
- 30:39you know that stuff appealed for the
- 30:40Democrats for a long time those people
- 30:42are all now voting for Trump all of them
- 30:46I mean uh Pittsburgh is about an hour
- 30:47from Morgantown West Virginia all the
- 30:49West Virginia coal miners are voting for
- 30:51Trump all of them so to hear kamla in
- 30:54the last debate and I've heard some
- 30:56commercials on television and radio
- 30:58since they're going after Trump on the
- 30:59tax cuts for billionaires again and when
- 31:02you look at Trump's tax cuts what were
- 31:04they 2017 2018 they were really tiny and
- 31:08and in fact you have to look at the
- 31:10brackets and the rates I think there's
- 31:12five brackets alog together this one
- 31:14came down a little bit that one went up
- 31:15a little bit they changed that bracket
- 31:17and this one it's hard to see any
- 31:19dramatic I would complain they didn't
- 31:21seem like much of a tax cut at all but
- 31:24they've gone back to that Playbook which
- 31:26tells me that um that that's KLA in my
- 31:29state of Pennsylvania probably trying to
- 31:31go back to that lower middle class but I
- 31:34don't think it's going to work because
- 31:35um they know that she represents the
- 31:38sort of Silicon Valley wealthy Elite and
- 31:41and it's the wealthy Elites that are
- 31:43that are now liberals I mean you know
- 31:46the corporate the corporate fat cats are
- 31:48Dei people uh you running operations
- 31:52like uh you
- 31:54know um Bud Light right when what are
- 31:58they doing Bud Light well that's the
- 31:59people they're hiring that's the people
- 32:01they're hiring from The Business Schools
- 32:02they're all left Wingers all righty
- 32:04folks let's talk about dressing sharp
- 32:05without sacrificing Comfort if you're
- 32:07tired of choosing between looking
- 32:08professional and feeling relaxed I've
- 32:10got excellent news for you collars and
- 32:12Co is revolutionizing men's wear with
- 32:13their famous dress collar Polo imagine
- 32:15this the comfort of a polo combined with
- 32:17the sharp look of a dress shirt It's the
- 32:18Best of Both Worlds giving you that
- 32:20professional Edge without the stuffiness
- 32:21gone are the days of floppy collars that
- 32:23make you look like you just rolled out
- 32:24of bed these polos feature a firm collar
- 32:26that stands up straight all day long the
- 32:28four-way stretch fabric means you can
- 32:30move freely and comfortably throughout
- 32:31your day it's office approved so you can
- 32:32look professional without feeling like
- 32:34you're trapped in a suit and get this it
- 32:35travels well so whether you're commuting
- 32:37to work or jetting off for a business
- 32:38trip you'll arrive looking crisp and
- 32:40feeling great but colars and Co isn't
- 32:41just about polos they've expanded their
- 32:43line impressively they've got Marino
- 32:44sweaters quarter Zips stretch chinos
- 32:46even a performance Blazer they call the
- 32:47Maverick it's versatility at its finest
- 32:49these pieces look great by themselves
- 32:51under a sweater or with a laser I mean
- 32:53take a look at this quarter zip do you
- 32:54see it it's magnificent look how good I
- 32:57look if you you want to look sharp feel
- 32:58comfortable and support a fast growing
- 33:00American company head on over to collars
- 33:01and co.com use code Ben for 20% off your
- 33:04first order that's collar and co.com
- 33:06code Ben col and Co because you
- 33:08shouldn't have to choose between looking
- 33:09good and feeling good I mean to me this
- 33:11is the great kind of story of why
- 33:13capitalism is having such trouble right
- 33:15now and I think the reason is is because
- 33:17it used to be that Rockefeller actually
- 33:19went to church I mean he went to the
- 33:20same church as many of the people who
- 33:21worked for him and and in in the United
- 33:24States if you were a corporate head
- 33:26there was a feeling of no obl that was
- 33:28largely church-based it was largely
- 33:30based on on membership in religious
- 33:31community and as that wore away you got
- 33:33this very odd sort of elitist
- 33:36combination of marxian social politics
- 33:39with capitalist with capitalist
- 33:41economics which is the smallest portion
- 33:43always of the American electorate every
- 33:45every four years for my childhood there
- 33:47was talk about a Libertarian Uprising
- 33:48where it would be I'm left on on social
- 33:50politics but I'm really right-wing on
- 33:51economics and it turns out that's like
- 33:53five people in the country and and it
- 33:55turns out that that's the thing that
- 33:57drove all the miners into the arms of
- 33:58trump I think this attempt to turn the
- 34:00the sort of trumpian Phenomenon with
- 34:02with the middle and lower classes and I
- 34:04even hesitate to use those terms in
- 34:05America because they really don't apply
- 34:06a huge percentage of people who start in
- 34:08the lower class will end up in the upper
- 34:10class or the middle class there there is
- 34:12no class distinction in the United
- 34:13States that the way the way that there
- 34:14was in in Continental Europe in in 1890
- 34:17or something so this sort of weird
- 34:19divide on social policy that came along
- 34:22with with the a atheistic revolution of
- 34:25the of the 60s and 70s in which the most
- 34:27successful people economically also
- 34:30hated the morality of sort of middle
- 34:32class churchgoers that's what's led to
- 34:35this divide and what Trump was doing to
- 34:36to those West Virginia Miners he he
- 34:38wasn't saying to them I'm going to bring
- 34:39to you all sorts of good economic
- 34:41goodies in the way that rich that dick
- 34:43Gart or or say John Edwards in 2004
- 34:46would have with his two America's
- 34:47nonsense right it's not going to be that
- 34:49right what what it will be is I'm going
- 34:51to respect the fact that you want to
- 34:52live with your family and go to church
- 34:54right I I don't look down on you I don't
- 34:55think that you need to trans your kids
- 34:57right those social policies the idea
- 34:59that he actually understood them and
- 35:00didn't scorn them that's the whole thing
- 35:02to me the the the signal break in sort
- 35:04of American politics pretty much occurs
- 35:06in 2008 it it goes by the wayside
- 35:08because we all pretend it didn't happen
- 35:10but when Barack Obama made that bitter
- 35:11Clinger speech in San Francisco that was
- 35:13like the hard divide in American
- 35:14politics where he's in San Francisco
- 35:16with a bunch of really really wealthy
- 35:17people in shiny buildings and they're
- 35:19talking about how the real downfall of
- 35:21the country is these schlubs who live in
- 35:23West Virginia and who have this whole
- 35:24thing about how they like God and guns
- 35:26and and they actually want borders and
- 35:28and I think that that was really more
- 35:30the thing and so there's been this
- 35:32unfortunate Gap that's now grown between
- 35:35I think Americans who have Traditional
- 35:37Values with regard to social politics
- 35:40and capitalism itself because this term
- 35:42neoliberal gets thrown around and I
- 35:44always wonder exactly kind of what that
- 35:45mean I'm very free market oriented and
- 35:47also incredibly socially conservative
- 35:49and for most of my childhood that those
- 35:50two things went together and it's only
- 35:52in the last decade or so they seem to
- 35:53have sort of gone separate ways yeah
- 35:55that's right in fact a couple thoughts
- 35:57there won Barack with Barack Obama I'm
- 36:00thinking of uh John Drew who went to
- 36:02Accidental college with Obama and I
- 36:04interviewed him for the book The
- 36:05Communist and he was introduced to Obama
- 36:08by um by by his girlfriend John and John
- 36:11Drew's girlfriend and she said this is
- 36:13Barack right he's one of us and he ran
- 36:16the the the Marxist Club as John Drew
- 36:17called John Drew is now like a
- 36:19conservative Baptist today but but but I
- 36:22talked to him I I said do you think any
- 36:24way in any way do you see any of the
- 36:26Marxism residual stuff in Obama today
- 36:28this would have been like 2010 and I'll
- 36:30never forget Ben he used the phrase yeah
- 36:32I still see some of the Marxist mental
- 36:35architecture in phrases like bitter
- 36:38clingers right clinging to their God and
- 36:40guns right that's very much a kind of
- 36:42like marxis likee sentiment even if it
- 36:45doesn't make Obama a Marxist and the
- 36:47other one I think of you mentioned the
- 36:4960s radicals Mark Rudd who uh founded SD
- 36:52didn't he wasn't the founder of SDS but
- 36:54he ran SDS and shut down Columbia
- 36:56University April 1968 and I read his
- 36:59Memoir a few years ago which is a
- 37:01shocking book but but but but to to
- 37:04rud's credit he he's very honest and
- 37:07very very candid in that book and he
- 37:09talked about him and Bill SS and
- 37:11Bernardine Dorne and the people in SDS
- 37:13who eventually became the weatherman and
- 37:15eventually The Weather Underground they
- 37:17would go out into the workingclass
- 37:19neighborhoods he said of Chicago
- 37:21Pittsburg in Cleveland and they'd be
- 37:23preaching Marxism to to the unwashed
- 37:25masses right the working class kids the
- 37:28kids of the steel workers right and and
- 37:31he said what was the response of these
- 37:32people they would beat us
- 37:34up these are like these are like ethnic
- 37:36polls and Italians and Irish right like
- 37:39you know we don't want your stinking
- 37:41communism you atheist you know get out
- 37:42of here right and meanwhile you runting
- 37:45these guys or laying on the ground but
- 37:47don't you understand right you're
- 37:49preaching what they learned at Colombia
- 37:50we're here to bring you we're here to
- 37:52free you right to you know you're you're
- 37:55in this class and you're about to go
- 37:57here
- 37:58um but yeah th and those people have
- 38:00always wanted an American this is what
- 38:02so many people on the left in the
- 38:03Democratic party didn't get um a lot of
- 38:05them want to be maybe not rich but
- 38:09aspire to get out of the lower class and
- 38:11be as well off as they can be right so
- 38:15the the incessant class Warfare that the
- 38:18Democrats always engaged in like I said
- 38:20it seemed like it cooled in the last few
- 38:22years I think because Trump has won that
- 38:24element but um it's coming back right
- 38:27now the last few weeks probably because
- 38:29kamla is trying to make a push for some
- 38:31of those voters I I think this is also
- 38:33due to the failure of the race Marxism
- 38:35so in in the 2012 to 2024 era the
- 38:38Democrats really really stoed moving
- 38:40toward sort of the the economic Marxism
- 38:42of say John Edwards uh and and maybe
- 38:45even Bernie Sanders uh and and started
- 38:46moving very heavily in the direction of
- 38:48race Marxism the idea that you could
- 38:50determine whether someone was victimized
- 38:52or Not by membership in a racial group
- 38:53because racial groups don't Stack Up
- 38:54equivalently in terms of average income
- 38:57for example and and so Barack Obama won
- 38:59on that basis in 2012 and then Hillary
- 39:01kind of tried to run that same campaign
- 39:02in 2016 and she failed because she's an
- 39:04upper class white lady and then and then
- 39:06Joe Biden ran that campaign again in
- 39:08part in 2020 but it was already failing
- 39:11by 2020 he had to sort of run as the
- 39:12moderate in the room despite everything
- 39:14that was going on with the black lives
- 39:15matter riots and everything he sort of
- 39:16tried to ignore what was going on then
- 39:18throw a stop to his his supporters by
- 39:20picking kamla as his vice president and
- 39:23then by 2024 one of the things that's
- 39:24actually quite fascinating about the way
- 39:25the KL is running this campaign is not
- 39:27talking about race at all everybody on
- 39:29the left is begging her to talk about
- 39:30race you're the first female black woman
- 39:32you know who's going to run for
- 39:33president and win and all this and she
- 39:34doesn't want to talk about it she keeps
- 39:36avoiding it which I think is a smart
- 39:37strategy because I think this is played
- 39:39out I think they're moving back toward
- 39:41the sort of class-based economic Marxism
- 39:43if there are only a few games that they
- 39:45can play here then and one of them is
- 39:47played out they're going to turn to the
- 39:48others and those right now seem to be
- 39:49class-based Marxism and sex-based
- 39:51Marxism in which they're stacking up
- 39:53women against men and you're seeing the
- 39:54largest gender gap in American history
- 39:56breaking out in this election yeah and
- 39:58uh the in the last debate the two
- 39:59moderators from ABC right I think it was
- 40:02David Mir was the one who did it brought
- 40:05up the Trump comments about about the
- 40:07race about kamla's race and I remember
- 40:10telling my students right before that
- 40:11debate I said Trump in this debate can't
- 40:14do anything really stupid like bring up
- 40:16her race that would be a really dumb
- 40:19thing to do well he was pretty
- 40:20disciplined he didn't bring it up they
- 40:22did they brought it up and by the way
- 40:24when they did that I bet about 20
- 40:26million Americans went oh no don't
- 40:29please please don't bring race into this
- 40:31we're so happy race hasn't been a part
- 40:33of this and to Trump's credit he said I
- 40:35don't want to talk about he even said
- 40:37something like she's the one that
- 40:38brought it up and then he zipped it and
- 40:40then they went to her and she just got
- 40:41the knife out right and she just started
- 40:44talking about how divisive he is hateful
- 40:46he is pits people against each other
- 40:48over race and then they said Mr
- 40:49President they went back to him zip he
- 40:51he didn't say anything so he was very
- 40:53smart very very disciplined on that but
- 40:55yeah and the uh what could be more
- 40:58divisive literally divisive right which
- 41:00is what Marxism is it's about dividing
- 41:02people right dividing according to
- 41:05according to class right bour versus
- 41:07proletar what could be more divisive
- 41:09than telling everybody in America hey
- 41:11the world is this simple you're either
- 41:13black or you're white you're in one of
- 41:15these two blocks
- 41:18right my youngest son who's um who's
- 41:21adopted is black all right well his his
- 41:24he's half black I mean he's as black as
- 41:26Obama because Obama's father was black
- 41:28and so is so is his father is both of
- 41:30them have white mothers um he's
- 41:32technically considered black but if we
- 41:34did DNA tests and everybody in my family
- 41:37which we have they're all over the place
- 41:39I mean my wife has every ethnicity in
- 41:41the Middle East including Jewish right
- 41:43Jewish Syrian Lebanese Greek right Italy
- 41:46every everything so to tell to tell
- 41:48people in modern America the most
- 41:50diverse Melting Pot in history very
- 41:52simple you're black or you're white all
- 41:54right then you're oppressed or you or or
- 41:56you're the oppressor so then you go up
- 41:58to somebody and say now Kobe Bryant or
- 42:01Oprah okay I want you to know that
- 42:04you're oppressed you may have billions
- 42:07of dollars you may have this amazing
- 42:10life Kobe you you had wealth ever since
- 42:12you were a young kid but um but you're
- 42:15oppressed they're like why well because
- 42:17you're black and that white homeless guy
- 42:19over there all right he's your oppressor
- 42:22huh well he's your why because he's
- 42:26white and everyone no one in America
- 42:28wants any part of that gobletg divisive
- 42:32vicious nonsense but but that hails
- 42:36descends from Marxism race based in this
- 42:40case to shift topic slightly but it's
- 42:42still part of the same overall
- 42:43conversation you've written extensively
- 42:44obviously on on Ronald Reagan Ronald
- 42:46Reagan is the last Republican president
- 42:48to have won broad majorities you could
- 42:50say George HW Bush won a broad majority
- 42:52that was really on the back of of Ronald
- 42:53Reagan uh by by 1992 obviously he loses
- 42:56to Bill Clinton and Ross perau is not
- 42:57exactly like a Duo of of tremendous
- 42:59performance uh but in in in any case the
- 43:02the the Reagan Era you know does raise
- 43:04questions for how conservatives can win
- 43:07going forward because Donald Trump won
- 43:09what can best be described as you know
- 43:11statistically at least a fluke election
- 43:13in 2016 that is a fluke election in
- 43:15which you lose the popular vote by 3
- 43:16million but you win by just enough votes
- 43:18in just the right places in order to win
- 43:21and it looks very much as though he's
- 43:23going to have to pull off the same feed
- 43:24if he wishes to win this year it looks
- 43:25as though you know the the popular vote
- 43:28Gap is going to be I I would think
- 43:30relatively significant I'd be shocked if
- 43:31he wins the popular vote in this year's
- 43:33election he might just win in just
- 43:35enough places just you know just 10,000
- 43:37votes here in North Carolina and 12,000
- 43:39in Georgia and all the rest of that in
- 43:40order to pull off the presidency it's
- 43:42been a long time since a republican one
- 43:43sort of a broad sweeping Victory even
- 43:45George W Bush's victory in 2004 against
- 43:47John krey was a nearr run thing that was
- 43:49a very close election coming down to
- 43:51basically Ohio and Florida and so that
- 43:53when you look back at the Reagan Era one
- 43:55of the things that that is is clear is
- 43:56that because he has the Soviet Union to
- 43:58run against a thing where he can say
- 44:00look this is the thing right we have to
- 44:02beat this thing this thing is out here
- 44:03it's really bad and the only we're going
- 44:05to beat that is by getting rid of the
- 44:07ineffective right the argument that he
- 44:10was making against Jimmy Carter was that
- 44:12Jimmy Carter was a fool and in
- 44:14ineffective fool it wasn't that Jimmy
- 44:16Carter was actually deeply immoral it
- 44:18was that Jimmy Carter was deeply
- 44:19ineffective he almost became a figure of
- 44:21jocularity and because the Soviet Union
- 44:23was out here you had this dual threat
- 44:25you had the Dual threat from within of
- 44:26weakness you had the threat from without
- 44:28of a powerful and aggressive state that
- 44:31actively sought to destroy America's
- 44:32interests well now if you fast forward
- 44:34to 2024 I think there's been an attempt
- 44:36by by Republicans and some Democrats to
- 44:38say that China is is sort of like the
- 44:40USSR that that parallel hasn't gone
- 44:42quite as well because of the deep and
- 44:43abiding economic relations with with
- 44:45China but the the argument by a lot of
- 44:47conservatives has shifted from this sort
- 44:49of dual threat of inefficacy from the
- 44:51Democratic party and deep and abiding
- 44:52threat on the foreign front to ignore
- 44:55all problems on the foreign front the
- 44:56real threat is the internal threat and I
- 44:58just wonder if that's a winning
- 44:59electoral message because I don't think
- 45:01that most Americans look at kamla Harris
- 45:03and want to see kamla Harris as a sort
- 45:05of Crisis level Red Alert threat if
- 45:08she's elected we're all going to die
- 45:09it's going to be Castro Cuba I think in
- 45:12other words that the the Reagan message
- 45:13which is Democrats are misguided wrong
- 45:16cowardly and ineffective and over here
- 45:18we have some real threats we have to
- 45:19face is probably going to be a better
- 45:20electoral message then ignore everything
- 45:22that's going on over here nothing really
- 45:23important is happening outside our
- 45:24borders the real threat is kamla Harris
- 45:26or Barack Obama even as deeply as we may
- 45:28feel that that is a real threat yeah you
- 45:31know in our print edition of the
- 45:32American spectator I'm the editor of the
- 45:34American spectator I have a piece called
- 45:35Reagan conservatism is alive and well
- 45:38it's a special print edition on
- 45:39conservatism and I'm hearing a lot of
- 45:41conservatives today saying well Reagan
- 45:43conservatism is dead it's not in fact um
- 45:46I have a book it's called 11 principles
- 45:48of Reagan conservative I lay out the 11
- 45:50principles Faith Freedom sany Dignity of
- 45:52human life anti-communism belief in the
- 45:54individual I won't go through all of
- 45:55them here but I've said that Trump can
- 45:57check the box I'm probably 11 out of 11
- 46:01um certainly in terms of how he governed
- 46:03as President right um even if you don't
- 46:06think that he's maybe in his heart a
- 46:07prolifer I mean he did more for the
- 46:09pro-life movement than Reagan did as as
- 46:11as president the difference though it's
- 46:14not the message it's the messenger and
- 46:16Reagan was just so likable now he did
- 46:19have the Soviet Union to run against
- 46:21right but people liked him they just
- 46:24liked him even even the left who didn't
- 46:26vote for him liked him um I quote in in
- 46:29one of my books U Walter kronite and
- 46:32Walter kronite was cbs's news anchor and
- 46:35America's news anchor he's also very
- 46:36liberal and he said I've never seen
- 46:39anything like this everybody loves
- 46:42Reagan nobody hates him I was alive for
- 46:45Franklin Roosevelt I never thought I'd
- 46:46see a president as liked as Roosevelt
- 46:49Reagan has it he's even more beloved
- 46:51than Roosevelt so because of that and
- 46:54keep in mind 1984 Berlin w didn't go
- 46:57down yet right Cold War isn't over yet M
- 46:59Gorbachev didn't even come in yet so at
- 47:01that point Reagan can just run on
- 47:04restoring America strength make America
- 47:07great again that was originally a Reagan
- 47:08statement econom is taking off so even
- 47:11without the the crash of the Soviet
- 47:13Union he won 49 out of 50
- 47:17states he he took the Electoral College
- 47:22525-13 the the only state he didn't win
- 47:25Minnesota by the way this is interesting
- 47:27the only state Reagan never won was
- 47:30Minnesota he didn't win Minnesota in
- 47:321980 either Reagan twice won California
- 47:35New York New Jersey my home state of
- 47:37Pennsylvania Reagan twice won
- 47:40Massachusetts okay so it's um I think
- 47:43the message still works I I I I think
- 47:46it's the messenger and Donald Trump is
- 47:51hated just absolutely and utterly
- 47:54loathed by over 50% of the the
- 47:57population and if you if your ceiling is
- 48:00like
- 48:0147% right you're going to it's going to
- 48:04be a one to 2% Race by the way if he
- 48:06loses a popular vote by one to two I
- 48:09think he'll win the electoral college um
- 48:11but I'd be amazed if he got 50% uh but
- 48:16but my my thesis argument here Ben is
- 48:19you got somebody else with Reagan's kind
- 48:21of background like ability um I think
- 48:25the conservative message can win big
- 48:27like that again but it takes the right
- 48:29Messenger to pair with the message we'll
- 48:32get to more on that in a moment first
- 48:33getting in credit card debt is really
- 48:34easy but getting out well the system is
- 48:36set up so it's really hard if you're
- 48:38struggling with credit cards personal
- 48:39loans collections or medical bills you
- 48:40need to check out PDS Deb PDS provides a
- 48:43service to match you with debt solutions
- 48:44tailored to your financial situation if
- 48:46you're making payments every month on
- 48:48your debt your balances aren't going
- 48:49down PDS has solutions for you everyone
- 48:51with 10 grand or more and eligible that
- 48:53qualifies there is no minimum credit
- 48:54score required bad and Fair Credit are
- 48:57accepted listen I have friends who've
- 48:58gotten into debt it is brutal to get out
- 49:00of it unless you have a plan this is
- 49:01where PDS debt comes in PDS debt has
- 49:04customized options for anyone struggling
- 49:05with credit cards personal loans
- 49:07collections or medical bills they strive
- 49:08to understand your specific scenario
- 49:10they can help provide alternative
- 49:11solutions to becoming debt free save
- 49:13more while paying off your debt in a
- 49:14fraction of the time stop waiting start
- 49:16saving get a free debt analysis right
- 49:18now PDS debt.com Sunday it only takes 30
- 49:22seconds that's PDS de.com Sunday today
- 49:26PD psd.com Sunday getting out of debt it
- 49:29can be really difficult if you don't it
- 49:30can ruin your life so why not give my
- 49:32friends a call over at psd.com Sunday
- 49:35today do you think that the country has
- 49:37fundamentally changed so much since that
- 49:38year that it's a bit of a different math
- 49:40meaning that you know it's it's it's
- 49:41almost impossible to see any Republican
- 49:43winning say New York or California
- 49:45absent some serious existential threat
- 49:47even George W bush in the aftermath of
- 49:49911 had to run a super competitive race
- 49:51against John KY in in 2004 that came
- 49:54down to a few different states we're
- 49:56seeing it obviously W with President
- 49:58Trump this is coming down to a few
- 49:59different states it's almost impossible
- 50:00for me to imagine as as a transplant
- 50:02from California to Florida the idea that
- 50:04a republican whatever when say
- 50:06California again or New York or
- 50:08Massachusetts are the divides in the
- 50:09country just too wide and and if so what
- 50:12can be what can be done about that I
- 50:14think that's right but I think a
- 50:15republican could win 40 out of 50 states
- 50:18and and also um and I'm not trying to
- 50:20say this to dump on Donald Trump in this
- 50:22interview um but 2016 2020 and 2024 I
- 50:27mean your opponent is Hillary Clinton
- 50:29Joe Biden and kamla Harris that should
- 50:32be an easy sweep for any remotely
- 50:36decently likable Republican and and I
- 50:38know people on our side will say you
- 50:41know but Trump gets out the vote has a
- 50:43core of supporters he does absolutely
- 50:45true um you know Nicki Haley couldn't do
- 50:47that I don't I don't know who it would
- 50:49be right well actually I do have some
- 50:50ideas of some of the people could I
- 50:52won't go through it because then we end
- 50:53up arguing about each of those people
- 50:54but but but those are three easy to beat
- 50:57opponents they really those should be
- 51:00slam dunks and I and I think if you get
- 51:02somebody if you had somebody who was
- 51:04more likable they they'd beat him fairly
- 51:06easily I mean I think that one of the
- 51:08things that that President Trump had for
- 51:10a moment in this election cycle when he
- 51:11was running against Biden particularly
- 51:13uh and then in the afterm the
- 51:15assassination attempt I what what since
- 51:18basically 2014 I think the American
- 51:19people have been craving both two two
- 51:22things that seem to be in Conflict one
- 51:23is is normaly and the other is change uh
- 51:26they they they want to change from the
- 51:27direction of the Obama years but they
- 51:28also want some semblance of normaly they
- 51:31just don't want to think about what's
- 51:32going on in the presidential race three
- 51:34years in advance of an election like
- 51:36they they don't want to be dealing with
- 51:38whatever is the crazy level I think
- 51:39that's what was behind whatever desire
- 51:41there was for Joe Biden in 2020 was more
- 51:43like okay fine he's dead what what what
- 51:44bad could happen I mean he's a corpse
- 51:46and and they did get a dead person the
- 51:48problem was that he did things and they
- 51:49didn't like any of the things that he
- 51:50did he actually made incredibly
- 51:51controversial moves he governed like a
- 51:53far- leftist he basically took Bernie
- 51:54Sanders's agenda then just tried to run
- 51:56the table with it and on foreign policy
- 51:58set the world on fire but I think that
- 52:00that the thing that most Americans right
- 52:01now are craving this was true I think
- 52:03Trump was doing a good job of this for a
- 52:04little while in the election was was
- 52:06just a sense of okay you know we need
- 52:08everything to just go back to normal
- 52:10leave everything alone calm down take a
- 52:12breath and so there was a period between
- 52:14that that debate and and the
- 52:16assassination attempt and then the RNC
- 52:18when Trump really went silent and that
- 52:20was the best point of the election for
- 52:21him because he was just allowing the
- 52:23story to be Joe Biden and not be Donald
- 52:25Trump and then the assassination attempt
- 52:26happened and then the RNC happened I
- 52:28think there were a couple of tactical
- 52:29errors at the RNC I I think JD Vance is
- 52:32incredibly smart I'm not sure that JD
- 52:33Vance added anything to the ticket that
- 52:34Donald Trump didn't already have going
- 52:36for him on the ticket I would have
- 52:38picked somebody like Glenn yunan if it
- 52:39had been me and tried to make some sort
- 52:40of play for the middle tried to make
- 52:41some play for for for Women Voters and
- 52:43then I think that Trump's speech at the
- 52:45RNC was was a very bad move for him I
- 52:47think that he had a unique opportunity a
- 52:49week after the assassination attempt to
- 52:51do something almost reaganesque right I
- 52:53mean obviously they you know he was
- 52:55Reagan was shot by hankley and and he
- 52:57there was a unifying kind of rally round
- 52:59Reagan moment because of that because
- 53:00Reagan treated that with such geniality
- 53:02and joviality and and let's come
- 53:04together and and Trump could have done
- 53:06that he could have given a speech where
- 53:07he said listen you know I've said
- 53:08divisive things in the past I'm going to
- 53:09keep saying things that piss some people
- 53:10off that's just who I am but when a
- 53:12bullet whizzes past your ear and kills
- 53:14somebody behind you that makes you start
- 53:16to think about the things that are
- 53:17important in life the thing that's
- 53:18important to me is making America strong
- 53:20that's the thing I've always cared about
- 53:21that's the thing I care about you and
- 53:22your family like that would have been a
- 53:23moment when he could have done that he
- 53:25didn't do that and so and people asked
- 53:27me at at the RNC when he was up in the
- 53:28polls what I felt like and I said I feel
- 53:30like a baseball fan who is in the sixth
- 53:32inning and we're up three runs and we
- 53:35just left Bases Loaded no outs and you
- 53:37know that it's going to come back on you
- 53:39and and that's kind of what I felt like
- 53:40ever since then right I I mean I felt
- 53:42like 30 40 minutes into it I I was
- 53:44telling my kids I'm like this is
- 53:46fascinating this is just great this is
- 53:48this is a grand slam to right baseball
- 53:51uh but then he just went on too long and
- 53:53that that I I mean hour and a half
- 53:54almost two hours um and then he started
- 53:57taking some shots of Biden not as harsh
- 53:59as usual but he but he should have
- 54:00stopped there uh by the way the most
- 54:02meaningful thing to me in that speech
- 54:05especially being a Reagan scholar after
- 54:07Reagan was shot March 30th 1981 and and
- 54:10Reagan says to a number of different
- 54:12people he wrote this in his diary said
- 54:15it to Billy Graham said it to his son
- 54:16Michael he said it to Mother Teresa he
- 54:18said it to Terrence Cardinal cook uh
- 54:21whatever time I have left is for him
- 54:23Capital H am him right uh my life has
- 54:26been spared tells this to John Paul II A
- 54:29year later when they meet at the Vatican
- 54:30after both had survived assassination
- 54:32attempts and Trump said that night in
- 54:35Milwaukee and he said it I'm I I you
- 54:38know I'm a scholar of this stuff I'm
- 54:40writing these down right there's about
- 54:4212 examples now where Trump has said God
- 54:44spared my life God spared my life so
- 54:47that's a very humbl humbling thing but
- 54:49unless the humility is further and I
- 54:51think he has softened he doesn't seem as
- 54:54harsh as before but but he still has
- 54:56that edge to him that I don't think is
- 54:58going to push him over 48 49% even after
- 55:01the shooting in Butler by the way you
- 55:04probably don't this Butler Pennsylvania
- 55:05is my hometown you believe that is that
- 55:08great now we're Infamous at Butler High
- 55:10School Class of 84 um which is only a 25
- 55:14minute drive from where I am in Grove
- 55:15City Grove City College um but but but
- 55:19yeah I mean he
- 55:20was that's probably about the peak of
- 55:22where he got um I'm going to probably
- 55:25too many directions he's also lost the
- 55:29The Edge he had with Hispanic voters
- 55:32which was looking not he I don't think
- 55:35he was going to win
- 55:3650% I thought he should have picked
- 55:38somebody like Cruz or Rubio I hate doing
- 55:40identity politics I but those guys are
- 55:43the future of the party not that JD
- 55:45Vance isn't uh but but that would have
- 55:48really done something for him and I I
- 55:49think one of the areas where kamla is
- 55:51really taking a step up on him is with
- 55:54latino voters uh cuz they weren't voting
- 55:56for Biden at least not in the numbers
- 55:58they usually were she seems to pulled a
- 56:00good number of them away from Trump so I
- 56:02think that was kind of a strategic
- 56:04electoral political Mistake by Trump I
- 56:07think the other thing that that is
- 56:09really fascinating about how Trump has
- 56:10campaigned and and this is true since
- 56:112016 he took the the sort of position
- 56:14against the field in 2016 that the Iraq
- 56:16War was inherently bad he said some
- 56:17things that you would have expected to
- 56:18hear actually on the Democratic stage in
- 56:202016 with regard to both Iraq and
- 56:22Afghanistan code pink International
- 56:24answer right push lied lied he lied EXA
- 56:29exactly he was using that kind of
- 56:30language and because by that point the
- 56:32country had turned on the Iraq war that
- 56:33allowed him to be the Insurgent inside
- 56:35the candidacy but that also has meant
- 56:37that there's been this growing wing
- 56:39inside the Republican party when you
- 56:40talk about the rejection of reaganism I
- 56:42would say that the rejection of
- 56:43reaganism has come in a couple of
- 56:45flavors it's not on the socially
- 56:46conservative front I think that the
- 56:47rejection of reaganism has come in the
- 56:49economic flavor and it's come in the
- 56:51foreign policy flavor and I would say
- 56:52more on the foreign policy flavor than
- 56:54on the economic flavor uh there's
- 56:55there's been a new sort of papuc Canan
- 56:57isolationism that is cropping up in the
- 56:59Republican party it's always been there
- 57:01I mean there to pretend that it wasn't
- 57:03there in the 30s 40s 50s is to be
- 57:05ignorant of sort of the the split in the
- 57:06Republican party that that has been
- 57:08there for a very long time but it was it
- 57:10was sort of in abeyance for a while and
- 57:12now it seems to have come back with a
- 57:13with a fair bit of of laity this sort of
- 57:16anti- hawkishness anti- muscularity in
- 57:19in foreign policy and it's been
- 57:21exacerbated by by sort of the the
- 57:23bifurcated way that Trump has dealt with
- 57:25foreign policy he talks like Pap
- 57:26Buchanan and then he actually acts like
- 57:28Ronald Reagan his foreign policy is
- 57:30extremely reaganesque let's build up the
- 57:31military strength yeah exactly let's
- 57:33let's threaten our enemies if they
- 57:35decide that they want to you know try
- 57:36and threaten us we will back them off
- 57:37that point and I remember I did a
- 57:39fundraiser for president Trump and in
- 57:40that fundraiser he he was we were in the
- 57:42back room and he was saying that he had
- 57:44that the reason that he says the reason
- 57:46Vladimir Putin never went into Ukraine
- 57:47is because I said to him Vlad Vlad if
- 57:49you go into Ukraine I'm going to bomb
- 57:50the out of you and Vlad looked at me and
- 57:53he said no you won't and I said well I
- 57:55might and then and then Trump looks at
- 57:57me and says if if you're the United
- 57:58States and and they think there's a 5%
- 58:00chance you're going to blow the out of
- 58:01them then they don't want to tr I mean
- 58:03that's like pure kind of Reagan back him
- 58:05off the back him off the the point with
- 58:07theer and so what he did as actual
- 58:10president is very Reagan the way he
- 58:11talks about foreign policy is very not
- 58:13reaganesque and so it's led to this this
- 58:15bizarre split in the Republican party
- 58:17where people who are perceived as too
- 58:19hawkish on foreign policy are now
- 58:21considered sort of hyper
- 58:22interventionists who are willing to get
- 58:24involved anywhere as as opposed to what
- 58:26most of the battles in the Republican
- 58:27Party are which are really about sort of
- 58:31which it's more situ situational like
- 58:33does this fall into we shouldn't be
- 58:35involved category or not involved
- 58:36category not into a democracy building
- 58:38woodro Wilson category I I I don't see a
- 58:41lot of people who are in that sort of
- 58:42George W bush 2005 mode yeah in fact
- 58:45Reagan told Gorbachev directly to his
- 58:47face he said um we're going to challenge
- 58:49you to an arms race and you know you
- 58:51can't win it right and and and Gorbachev
- 58:54knew that and and he understood that and
- 58:56when you look at um a lot of
- 58:58conservatives Trump supporters are angry
- 59:00that George W bush and Dick Cheney won't
- 59:02endorse Donald Trump but I mean when you
- 59:04say about the primary issue of their
- 59:06foreign policy that bush lied about that
- 59:09stuff that Ted Kennedy code pink
- 59:12International answer was saying in in
- 59:14those days you know Reagan's former arms
- 59:16negotiator Ken Ken Adelman um endorsing
- 59:19comma Harrison even saying that if
- 59:21Reagan were alive I think he would
- 59:23endorse Kamala well that's that's that's
- 59:26absurd okay U but I can see why they
- 59:30wouldn't support Trump because of that
- 59:32all right you don't need to take the
- 59:33step and Endor commala I mean do you
- 59:35think she's your peace through strength
- 59:36anti-communist can I mean come on but uh
- 59:40but you know you say things like that
- 59:41like Trump did in a very unsophisticated
- 59:44UNC kind of vulgar way you're going to
- 59:47have to take your lumps and expect
- 59:48people like George W bush who you
- 59:50accused of lying about
- 59:53wmds um you're going to have to expect
- 59:56them not to support you so when you look
- 59:58at sort of the future of the Republican
- 1:00:00party I agree with you that I think that
- 1:00:01the the sort of the Reagan is dead what
- 1:00:03did what did reaganism ever do for you
- 1:00:05is is just ignorant of history and also
- 1:00:07when you look at at sort of his platform
- 1:00:09his platform still resonates with the
- 1:00:10vast majority of the Republican Party by
- 1:00:12every polling metric Americans tend to
- 1:00:14be very in favor of a muscular foreign
- 1:00:17policy they're not in favor of
- 1:00:18intervention or boots on the ground
- 1:00:20everywhere but neither was Reagan
- 1:00:21they're they're very much in favor of a
- 1:00:23of a private property based free market
- 1:00:25economy they're not favor of heavy
- 1:00:26interventionism and subsidization of the
- 1:00:28economy and and they tend to be more
- 1:00:31socially conservative certainly than the
- 1:00:32left is at at this point when you when
- 1:00:35you look at that you know it's it's
- 1:00:37bewildering to me I think why there's
- 1:00:39been this attempt to to pair away from
- 1:00:42Reagan why why do you think there has
- 1:00:44been this attempt to say by many in in
- 1:00:47sort of the the Maga movement as as
- 1:00:49opposed to kind of grasping onto the
- 1:00:50Reagan Legacy and saying yeah we're a
- 1:00:52continuation of that there's been this
- 1:00:53attempt to say no no we're we're
- 1:00:54something completely new we have nothing
- 1:00:56to do with that that for forget all of
- 1:00:57that yeah I think it's kind of almost an
- 1:00:59anger that they feel um hey you know
- 1:01:02we're following some of these Reagan
- 1:01:04principles and they're not working for
- 1:01:05us the way that they did for Reagan but
- 1:01:07that gets back to my point of it's not
- 1:01:09the message it's the messenger all right
- 1:01:12you know Ronald Reagan running on those
- 1:01:13things today could still win and I
- 1:01:16mentioned those 11 principles of Reagan
- 1:01:18you just mentioned a few of them there
- 1:01:20right limited government lower taxes
- 1:01:22peace peace through strength belief in
- 1:01:24the individual anti communism those are
- 1:01:27all winning issues I I mean you beat the
- 1:01:30Democrats in every election on that even
- 1:01:32sanctity and dignity of human life you
- 1:01:34know maybe not on the abortion issue
- 1:01:36depending on how you frame it and so
- 1:01:38forth um uh freedom family you those are
- 1:01:44still socially conservative you people
- 1:01:46still support the family generally so
- 1:01:48you might lose on certain cultural
- 1:01:50social issues maybe same-sex marriage
- 1:01:53maybe uh IVF right maybe uh although on
- 1:01:56gender issues gender ideology I mean
- 1:01:59that's um I think even Bill Mah said if
- 1:02:01if I was a Republicans i' I'd run on
- 1:02:03drag queen Story Hour in every every
- 1:02:07campaign in my state right now
- 1:02:09Pennsylvania Dave McCormack who's
- 1:02:11running against Bob Casey Jr is
- 1:02:13constantly hitting him on uh gender
- 1:02:15transitioning for teenage girls uh you
- 1:02:18know that you know that's that's a
- 1:02:19winning issue so um those are still
- 1:02:22winning issues it's still the right
- 1:02:24message you just need the right message
- 1:02:25Meer can you win 49 out of 50 states
- 1:02:28probably not but can you win 40 yeah I
- 1:02:31think so with the right with the right
- 1:02:33messenger it really is interesting the
- 1:02:35way that the the left has sort of
- 1:02:36retconned Reagan uh so the the the usual
- 1:02:39critique of Reagan now and it was at the
- 1:02:41time but but they've really sort of
- 1:02:42amped this up is the idea that Reagan
- 1:02:44was an idiot and if you read Reagan's
- 1:02:46Diaries if if you read anything that
- 1:02:48Reagan ever wrote if you listen to his
- 1:02:49speeches from the GE circuit you know
- 1:02:52that that that is one of the stupidest
- 1:02:54contentions ever I mean this idea that
- 1:02:56Ronald Reagan was some sort of complete
- 1:02:58first of all I would just point
- 1:03:00out that if you play even a George W
- 1:03:02bush alore debate now it sounds like
- 1:03:04deanes debating Socrates it's insane I
- 1:03:07mean like every political debate from 25
- 1:03:0930 years ago sounds like people who
- 1:03:10actually know things and George W Bush
- 1:03:12was ripped as like the dumbest person in
- 1:03:14America I was there I mean in 2000 they
- 1:03:15were talking about how he was a complete
- 1:03:17he couldn't pronounce he said
- 1:03:18nuclear instead of nuclear and then you
- 1:03:20watch the debates between him and Goron
- 1:03:21you're like these are fairly substantive
- 1:03:23and they like they actually know about
- 1:03:24issues he and John krey that was only 20
- 1:03:27years ago that that's it I mean it's
- 1:03:29crazy I watch that debate and and with
- 1:03:32with Reagan um so I my book the Crusader
- 1:03:36Ronald Reagan and the fall of Communism
- 1:03:37lays out that this had been a strategy
- 1:03:39for Reagan to take down the Soviets
- 1:03:42dating back to the 1960s and and our
- 1:03:44Reagan movie focuses on that and so for
- 1:03:47for people who say even some people on
- 1:03:49our side well you know it's kind of
- 1:03:51hagiographic I mean what's hagiographic
- 1:03:54do you want us to not say that we didn't
- 1:03:55win the Cold War you want it to end with
- 1:03:57a mushroom cloud over Manhattan you want
- 1:03:59us not to have the tear down the wall
- 1:04:01speech do you want Reagan and Gorbachev
- 1:04:03not to be shaking hands peacefully
- 1:04:05ending the Cold War together do you want
- 1:04:06him not winning 49 out of 50 states uh I
- 1:04:10I mean that actually happened and then
- 1:04:12you and I we both been to the Reagan
- 1:04:14Ranch the end of that film where he
- 1:04:16rides off into the Reagan ran the sunset
- 1:04:18with John Barletta and they overplay his
- 1:04:21November 5th 1994 Alzheimer's letter
- 1:04:24describing getting Alzheimer say now I
- 1:04:26will ride off into the sunset of my life
- 1:04:29everyone's balling in the theater while
- 1:04:31they're watching it guess what that
- 1:04:33actually happened he actually said that
- 1:04:36you know this was a time of unity and
- 1:04:39it's a good story um that story can be
- 1:04:43can happen again I think with the right
- 1:04:46leadership you know I think it also can
- 1:04:49happen if there is a a left that is no
- 1:04:52longer as radical as as it was that's
- 1:04:55right
- 1:04:56like vicious today I mean it really has
- 1:04:58gotten so much worse mean people talk
- 1:05:00about it in sort of again hagiographic
- 1:05:02terms that the sort of tip O'Neal
- 1:05:04Ronald's Reagan relationship the fact
- 1:05:05that they would that they would you know
- 1:05:06get together and that they were friendly
- 1:05:08with one another but that that was a
- 1:05:09real thing they did hold hands together
- 1:05:11and pray yeah I mean can you imagine
- 1:05:14Nancy Pelosi and Donald Trump holding
- 1:05:15hands together and praying like that is
- 1:05:17not a thing that's ever going to happen
- 1:05:18impossible and by the way the the worst
- 1:05:21vicious reviews we've gotten on the
- 1:05:23movie from leftist I've tried to look up
- 1:05:25the birthday of some of them they were
- 1:05:26born after the 80s or in the 80s and I
- 1:05:29think a lot of them just can't real
- 1:05:31can't comprehend see I I came of age in
- 1:05:34the 80s I was I turned I was 17 years
- 1:05:37old 1984 1984 presidential election um
- 1:05:41and these people can't imagine that it
- 1:05:43actually was a time of unity and
- 1:05:45everybody didn't hate the guts of the
- 1:05:46president and in those days just because
- 1:05:48the president had had an R next to his
- 1:05:50name didn't mean that you needed to hate
- 1:05:52him and call him a racist right so you
- 1:05:55give them to today a message of unity
- 1:05:57which they claim that they want and they
- 1:05:59hate it um they want to divide they say
- 1:06:03they want inclusion and diversity right
- 1:06:05uh no they want to divide so that's a
- 1:06:07good point even if you had the right
- 1:06:09Reagan today there'd be a lot more hate
- 1:06:11of him uh regardless from the left that
- 1:06:14that's one of the things that's sort of
- 1:06:15fascinating about the the transition
- 1:06:17from Carter to Reagan is that that
- 1:06:18Carter who I think was one of the worst
- 1:06:20Presidents in in American history I
- 1:06:21think that Joe B Joe Biden and and
- 1:06:23Carter are the two worst Presidents of
- 1:06:24the last 100 years by far not close um
- 1:06:27and and when you when you look at at
- 1:06:29Carter however Carter was in 1976
- 1:06:32campaigning as a cultural conservative
- 1:06:34Carter campaigned as a churchgoing man
- 1:06:36who wanted to restore honor and normaly
- 1:06:39to the White House almost in the same
- 1:06:40way that that George W bush tried to
- 1:06:42campaign that way in 2000 against the
- 1:06:43Clinton Legacy right and and so in 76 by
- 1:06:47the time you get to 80 there is this
- 1:06:48backlash that has materialized almost on
- 1:06:50both sides of the aisle against the
- 1:06:52McGovern night 1960s leftwing far
- 1:06:55radical Coalition uh and and so the the
- 1:06:59the in certain kind of cultural ways
- 1:07:02Carter almost presages Reagan so in
- 1:07:05terms of policy for sure not in terms of
- 1:07:08policy Reagan reverses everything Carter
- 1:07:09does but in terms of sort of the Persona
- 1:07:11which is the I'm I live on a ranch I
- 1:07:13like you know I I I'm a farmer I I like
- 1:07:16God I like I like talking about the
- 1:07:17Bible right like that that was a thing
- 1:07:19that like can you imagine a Democrat
- 1:07:20campaigning in 2024 on I live on a ranch
- 1:07:23and I like the Bible like that that
- 1:07:24would not even be remotely thinkable
- 1:07:27yeah in fact Mark rud and those guys uh
- 1:07:29created in 2008 the group progressives
- 1:07:31for Obama right and in fact they were
- 1:07:34they really were was ex weatherman
- 1:07:36marxists for Obama and they said that uh
- 1:07:40Obama was really the first candidate
- 1:07:41they could support right Jimmy Carter
- 1:07:43was a hick and a HED right they didn't
- 1:07:46like uh RFK senior in fact prair uh
- 1:07:50Prairie Fire the manifesto of the
- 1:07:51Weather Underground has among the
- 1:07:53dedications in the beginning to Siran
- 1:07:56the shooter of RFK senior right uh so
- 1:07:59for them they've they've needed a
- 1:08:01Democratic party that could move to the
- 1:08:03far left which it has it's no longer the
- 1:08:06Jimmy Carter 1977 Democratic party yeah
- 1:08:09and and that that's sort of My Hope for
- 1:08:10for the backlash that is to come I think
- 1:08:12it is not fully materialized
- 1:08:13specifically because of all the incoming
- 1:08:15fire that Trump has taken and Trump's
- 1:08:16pugnaciousness and and all of that
- 1:08:19because of that I think that no one has
- 1:08:21really been able to take advantage of
- 1:08:22the fact that the Democratic party has
- 1:08:23moved this far to the left and so I I
- 1:08:25think that Trump positionally has tried
- 1:08:27to occupy the middle in this election in
- 1:08:28some ways that frankly I don't
- 1:08:30particularly like as a conservative
- 1:08:31right on abortion he has moved really
- 1:08:33far to the center on economics he's
- 1:08:35basically now throwing out proposals to
- 1:08:37various subsidies to various groups
- 1:08:38depending on on where he's campaigning
- 1:08:39these days but it's very obvious what
- 1:08:41he's trying to do he's trying to
- 1:08:42positionally grab the center and take it
- 1:08:43away from KLA Harris it's just he's sort
- 1:08:46of prohibited by the amount of hatred
- 1:08:48against him from ever being able to be
- 1:08:49perceived as sort of the Centrist
- 1:08:51candidate in in the election but what
- 1:08:53that does say is that whatever comes
- 1:08:54next you know again God willing Trump
- 1:08:56wins and and some sense of normaly is
- 1:08:58restored and he governs well and then
- 1:08:59whoever comes after him is is the person
- 1:09:01who sort of picks up both the the
- 1:09:03trumpian enthusiasm but also campaigns
- 1:09:05in the more optimistic and and warm way
- 1:09:08that that you've talked about whatever
- 1:09:09comes next for the Republican party that
- 1:09:11the Democrats have moved so far to the
- 1:09:13insane left it's hard to see them
- 1:09:15recovering and I I I for the life of me
- 1:09:18would would be you know kind of shocked
- 1:09:19if Republicans is I'm a little scared of
- 1:09:21the primary process I'll be honest with
- 1:09:22you just because it seems to being be
- 1:09:24selecting for in many cases some of the
- 1:09:26worst candidates but like the
- 1:09:28opportunity is right there for somebody
- 1:09:29to grab yeah in fact and the left is so
- 1:09:32radical about it that if Trump wins in
- 1:09:34November 2024 they should calm down
- 1:09:37because they'll be out by November 2020
- 1:09:39uh by January 2029 right he'll have only
- 1:09:42one term left but they're so radical and
- 1:09:44they've so radicalized themselves with
- 1:09:46slogans like Hitler dictator fascist
- 1:09:50Trump's going to destroy democracy that
- 1:09:53they're making it sound like he's going
- 1:09:55to barricade himself in the Oval Office
- 1:09:58with the Marines and somehow not be able
- 1:10:01to be removed right they're so radical
- 1:10:04and here to return to where we started
- 1:10:06the conversation not marxists but just
- 1:10:08extreme radical leftists right that that
- 1:10:12that they can't even accurately portray
- 1:10:14the scenario in front of us right
- 1:10:17they're that divisive and hateful well
- 1:10:20Paul thank you so much for taking the
- 1:10:21time folks you can go check out all of
- 1:10:23his books they're all fantastic Paul
- 1:10:24again thank thank you thanks so much ben
- 1:10:26thanks for all you do it's great joining
- 1:10:32you the Ben Shapiro Sunday special is
- 1:10:35produced by Savannah Morris and Matt
- 1:10:37Kemp associate producers are Jake
- 1:10:39Pollock and John Crick production
- 1:10:40coordinator is Jessica cran production
- 1:10:43assistant is Sarah steel editing is by
- 1:10:45Jeff tomblin audio is mixed by Mike
- 1:10:47Corina camera and lighting is by Zach
- 1:10:49ginta hair makeup and wardrobe by
- 1:10:51Fabiola Christina title Graphics are by
- 1:10:54Cynthia Angulo executive assistant Kelly
- 1:10:56carvalo executive in charge of
- 1:10:58production is David wormis executive
- 1:11:00producer Justin seagull executive
- 1:11:02producer Jeremy boring the Ben Shapiro
- 1:11:04show Sunday special is a daily wire
- 1:11:06production copyright daily wire 2024
- 1:11:08[Music]
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of What Makes A Marxist? | Dr. Paul Kengor by Ben Shapiro, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 14,759 words across 2,059 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.