What Jane Doe & Cornell 7 Said Happened That Night- All The Inconsistencies — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:01Barbie and Barbuda.
- 0:02>> Senior night at a high school football
- 0:04game. It's a very big ordeal. It's kind
- 0:07of like the Oscars and a [music] state
- 0:09of the union address coming together for
- 0:12one singular night. It's like a ceremony
- 0:14for the senior members of the high
- 0:16school football team, cheerleading team,
- 0:18and the marching band. So, all the
- 0:20graduating seniors are walking down the
- 0:22field, usually guided by a parent, where
- 0:25the crowd is chanting. Everybody's
- 0:27crying because this is the last regular
- 0:30home game of the season. There's usually
- 0:32some sort of giant balloon arch that the
- 0:34football players and their parents have
- 0:36to walk through as some sort of
- 0:38threshold. Okay, now you're going to be
- 0:40a college student. I don't know, but I
- 0:42do know that all of it is most likely
- 0:44going to be recorded and later edited by
- 0:46another student, probably chugging one
- 0:48too many Monster Energy drinks, and it's
- 0:50just like slow mos of the players
- 0:53getting ready in the locker room with a
- 0:54voice-over from the coach as he tries
- 0:57his very best Morgan Freeman
- 0:59impersonation.
- 1:00And then once they get on the field,
- 1:02suddenly the coach's voice pauses and
- 1:04[music] you hear the beginnings of a
- 1:06Kendrick Lamar song just thrumming in
- 1:08the background before the coach's voice
- 1:10comes back [music] and it's voice-over
- 1:12screaming like, "Give it all you got."
- 1:14Like that's the vibe. And it's all great
- 1:16because now there's a digital footprint
- 1:18to look back on. Either you go, "Look,
- 1:21see I told you I went to high school
- 1:22with that guy that's now in the NFL." Or
- 1:24you go, "See, look, I told you they all
- 1:26peaked in high school." It's like one or
- 1:28the other. There's no middle ground,
- 1:29okay? It's a very, very big deal, senior
- 1:32night. And in Boise, Idaho, Timberline
- 1:35High School is going to play the Post
- 1:37Falls High School. The Timberline Wolves
- 1:40versus the Post Falls Trojans. And it is
- 1:43said it's going to be a pretty tense
- 1:44game. These high schoolers take football
- 1:46just like way too seriously. Apparently
- 1:49last year Post Falls High School, there
- 1:51was like a little scandal in Idaho. No
- 1:52one really heard about it anywhere
- 1:53outside of Boise, Idaho. In Boise,
- 1:56Idaho, everyone was talking about it,
- 1:58but there was a protest because I guess
- 2:00these three Post Falls high school, so
- 2:03like three Trojans high school football
- 2:05players. Two of them were fully decked
- 2:07out [music] in Trojans gear, repping
- 2:09their own school. And they're on the
- 2:10football field and they had the third
- 2:12high schooler dressed up in their
- 2:15competitors gear, wearing [music] a
- 2:17t-shirt from the competition. And he's
- 2:19on his knees surrendering as the two
- 2:22Post Falls football players are pointing
- 2:24an airsoft gun at his head. Basically
- 2:27saying like we're coming for you to the
- 2:29other high school. You're going to bend
- 2:31to our will. You're going to surrender.
- 2:32You're going to get on your knees
- 2:33because we're going to destroy you in
- 2:35football.
- 2:37>> Is this recorded?
- 2:38>> No, the picture starts circulating all
- 2:39over the school campus. Now everyone's
- 2:42protesting at the school.
- 2:44But they're not protesting because the
- 2:45students took the picture and they
- 2:46needed to be disciplined. No,
- 2:50people are protesting because the
- 2:51students involved in that picture, they
- 2:53were suspended for 10 days and were
- 2:55removed from all athletics for the year.
- 2:57Students and parents were protesting the
- 2:59disciplinary action saying it was way
- 3:01too harsh.
- 3:02>> Mhm.
- 3:03>> Members of the football team, a fellow
- 3:04teammate said,
- 3:05>> Just see like our friends that are
- 3:07seniors not be able to play any more
- 3:09games, like that's it for them. Sad,
- 3:11hurts. So we're out here to show
- 3:13support.
- 3:14>> Especially their senior year, that's
- 3:15like their biggest year for sports and
- 3:16like getting looks at colleges, so I
- 3:18just think that they definitely deserve
- 3:19to play.
- 3:20>> Needless to say, I mean this year seems
- 3:22like it's going to be a lot more tense
- 3:23than last year. I mean it's not even
- 3:25because of Post Falls high school, but
- 3:27it's because of Timberline. Timberline
- 3:29high school has been in the national
- 3:31news as of recent. They have been having
- 3:34a rough month with protests, [music]
- 3:36police, authorities getting involved
- 3:38with their high school, as well as full
- 3:39blown student walkouts. Students are
- 3:42walking out of class and walking out of
- 3:44school as a form of protest. Timberline
- 3:47already missed the homecoming game. They
- 3:49still had the homecoming dance, just
- 3:50like none of the festivities. Like
- 3:52homecoming week [music] is huge in
- 3:55places like Boise, Idaho. In places that
- 3:57you would consider football nation,
- 3:59small town America, Friday night lights,
- 4:02Monday morning quarterbacking, like
- 4:04homecoming week is everything. Parents
- 4:06think homecoming week is everything.
- 4:08Parents who pay taxes and mortgages
- 4:10think no, homecoming week is end all, be
- 4:13all. But the school had to cancel most
- 4:15of it except for the dance and they
- 4:16released a statement. This is not a
- 4:18decision made lightly or easily.
- 4:20Homecoming is so much more than one
- 4:22game, one parade or one dance. This
- 4:24[music] is celebration of current,
- 4:26future and past presents and the
- 4:27families, educators and community who
- 4:29support them.
- 4:30>> [music]
- 4:30>> But they had to cancel it, even the
- 4:32game.
- 4:33Which is a pretty big deal.
- 4:35You know, where everything revolves
- 4:36around football.
- 4:37But it's all because a Snapchat group
- 4:39chat [music] started going viral.
- 4:43Supposedly, Timberline High School
- 4:45students of the football team, the
- 4:47Timberline Wolves, they were talking
- 4:49about how they were going to our word
- 4:51and kill a female student. The supposed
- 4:54Snapchat messages, and these have not
- 4:55been confirmed to be the right ones, but
- 4:57that have been circulating on social
- 4:58media read, "Drop her ugly [music] ass.
- 5:02Let's hang her from a light post and let
- 5:03the birds pick at her brain for days.
- 5:06Dumb what? Let's make her life hell.
- 5:08Hell yeah."
- 5:10But then [music] the conversation shifts
- 5:11to whether or not she deserves to die
- 5:13after being our worded and one of them
- 5:15even says, "She would definitely let us
- 5:17off her. [music] You think Cornell was
- 5:19bad? Just wait for us."
- 5:22>> This is a group of
- 5:24>> high school.
- 5:25>> And in in the how many people in the
- 5:27group chat?
- 5:27>> We don't know for certain, but one
- 5:29student and their parent apparently
- 5:31showed it to the school and that
- 5:32kick-started a whole it got leaked to
- 5:35the media, authorities started getting
- 5:38involved. They are still involved to
- 5:39this day. [music]
- 5:40A lot of female students are rightfully
- 5:42walking out, protesting as well as male
- 5:44students saying that they don't feel
- 5:45safe. They don't know what's [music]
- 5:46happening, they don't know what this
- 5:47culture is. They're also saying like
- 5:49everything about what the authorities do
- 5:52moving forward is [music] going to be
- 5:54defining for this entire area, probably
- 5:57for
- 5:58>> [music]
- 5:58>> decades.
- 5:59They did cancel the homecoming football
- 6:01game.
- 6:01>> Mhm.
- 6:02>> But they are going through with the
- 6:03senior night game that's happening in 2
- 6:06days.
- 6:07Yeah, the Timberline Wolves will be
- 6:09playing. We don't know if anyone in the
- 6:11group chat that is supposedly on the
- 6:13football team will be playing, but
- 6:15people are watching and it's It should
- 6:18be interesting to see how it plays out.
- 6:20>> Mhm.
- 6:20>> But they are on the news because they
- 6:21said, "You think Cornell was bad?
- 6:23>> [music]
- 6:24>> Just wait for us."
- 6:25This is part two of the Cornell 7 case.
- 6:35>> [music]
- 6:41[music]
- 6:49>> We would like to thank today's sponsors
- 6:50who have made it possible for Rotten
- 6:51Mango to support RAINN, aka the Rape,
- 6:53Abuse and Incest National Network. They
- 6:55provide free, confidential support
- 6:57services and information to survivors.
- 6:59This episode's partnerships have also
- 7:01made it possible to support Rotten
- 7:02Mango's team of dedicated researchers
- 7:04and we'd also like to thank you guys for
- 7:05your continued support. As always, full
- 7:07show notes are available at
- 7:08rottenmangopodcast.com.
- 7:10Before we begin, a content warning. This
- 7:12episode discusses an alleged sexual
- 7:14assault, including drug and alcohol
- 7:17usage, potential coercion, as well as
- 7:18the greater ripple effects that have
- 7:20resulted from this case. Whether that be
- 7:23a silver lining of people finally
- 7:25standing up and drawing more attention,
- 7:26or whether that just be a wholly
- 7:27negative impact. If you are a survivor
- 7:30or find this subject hard to hear,
- 7:31please take care of yourself. Skip this
- 7:33one if you need to. There are also lots
- 7:35of discussions of whether or not the
- 7:37victim in this case is to be believed it
- 7:40And I know that can be triggering for a
- 7:42lot of people, so take time off if you
- 7:43need. And I cannot stress this enough.
- 7:45This case is currently ongoing. When we
- 7:47describe what happened that night, we're
- 7:48describing what is alleged in court
- 7:50filings, lawsuits, reported by news
- 7:52outlets, what's found in public record
- 7:54up until the time of recording. Due to
- 7:56the current pending status legally, we
- 7:58have to use words like alleged,
- 8:00according to the lawsuit, according to
- 8:02Jane Doe, according to the accused, he
- 8:05said, she said, he states, she states.
- 8:08The usage of these words is not to
- 8:10discredit anybody's claims, but just for
- 8:12the purpose of
- 8:14I mean, I'm not the police. I'm not the
- 8:15DA on this. I don't know what happened.
- 8:17I don't have all of the resources to get
- 8:20all the information needed to give any
- 8:23sort of definitive or conclusive
- 8:25statement on this. I'm just telling you
- 8:27guys everything that we were able to
- 8:28find online, as well as any comments,
- 8:30theories, speculations, opinions,
- 8:32claims, or leaked information. They were
- 8:34found publicly online and do not reflect
- 8:35RawMingo's beliefs. If there are any
- 8:37massive developments or changes, we will
- 8:39do our best to keep you guys updated.
- 8:41Also, just a side note, because I feel
- 8:43like everyone's throwing around lawsuits
- 8:45and defamation, like defamation has
- 8:46become a big thing again all over the
- 8:48news for
- 8:50just everyone. A lot of the people that
- 8:52are involved in today's case have
- 8:53lawyered up, and it just feels like
- 8:55their lawyers have lawyers, and some of
- 8:57the lawyers are lawyers that we are
- 8:58familiar with. One of them just retained
- 9:02the Agnifilo firm. I don't think they're
- 9:04being represented by Mark Agnifilo, who
- 9:06was, you guys remember, represented Sean
- 9:09Combs, and then was later Luigi
- 9:10Manjione's attorney, was also Keith
- 9:12Raniere's attorney way back then, the
- 9:15NXIVM sex cult. But, um, yes, Tenny
- 9:18Geragos, who was also Sean Combs's
- 9:19attorney, daughter of another very
- 9:22famous TMZ-linked attorney, Mark
- 9:24Geragos. Tenny, she, I believe, is one
- 9:27of the accused attorneys, and she has
- 9:30been pretty vocal.
- 9:31>> Oh, yeah.
- 9:31>> And all of the accused have been pretty
- 9:34vocal, saying that these are lies, this
- 9:37is defamatory, basically. I just want to
- 9:39say be careful what you're posting
- 9:40online, as always. But with that, let's
- 9:43get started.
- 9:44I'm going to try to give you the best
- 9:46reconstruction of events of October
- 9:4819th, and I'm going to tell you exactly
- 9:49how we did it, because there's so many
- 9:51little pieces of information floating
- 9:52around, and I just wanted a clear idea
- 9:55of exactly what happened that night in
- 9:56terms of who said what happened that
- 9:58night. Because one party is saying this
- 10:00happened, the other parties are saying
- 10:01this has happened. Did any of them slip
- 10:03up? We keep hearing like, "Oh, Jane Doe
- 10:05kept changing up her story." But maybe
- 10:07she's not the only one that was changing
- 10:08up her story. So, we took Jane Doe's
- 10:10lawsuit as the template, since the
- 10:12alleged action has an accused name
- 10:14attached to it. So, there's no redaction
- 10:17in Jane Doe's civil lawsuit. She's like,
- 10:19"At this point, it was Gilio Lopes, for
- 10:22example. At this point, it was Winston
- 10:24Lee, for example." And so, we took that
- 10:26as a template of the allegations in
- 10:29terms of timeline. So, I'm not saying I
- 10:31took it as a template as the truth, but
- 10:33trying to figure out who was involved at
- 10:35which point of the night.
- 10:37>> [clears throat]
- 10:37>> And then we took that to cross-reference
- 10:40with other documents that are online.
- 10:42So, we cross-referenced it with the
- 10:44local DA's first initial very defensive
- 10:46statement that we covered in the first
- 10:47part. Then the full six-page report that
- 10:50the DA apparently received, that was
- 10:52obtained by CBS News and released to the
- 10:54public. So, we took that. That one has a
- 10:56ton of redactions. So, from there, we're
- 10:58cross-referencing with Jane Doe's
- 10:59lawsuit of, "Okay, at this point, we
- 11:01think these people were in the room."
- 11:03Now, with any redactions, I cannot say
- 11:05with 100% certainty that I think that
- 11:07this is the individual speaking or being
- 11:09spoken about. And so, I'm going to try
- 11:11to give you as much information of why I
- 11:13thought it was this person, but I'm also
- 11:15just going to keep saying like,
- 11:17"Maybe Winston. Maybe Matthew." And that
- 11:20just means it's redacted. I think it
- 11:22might be Matthew, but it's redacted, so
- 11:24I can't say with certainty. But it's
- 11:26kind of I would say it's somewhat easy
- 11:28if you pull from Jane Doe's lawsuit,
- 11:30because the first interaction, sexual
- 11:32encounter is Matthew and Jonathan. Then
- 11:34it's Jonathan and Jillia Lopes. Then
- 11:36it's Matthew and Winston and that's in
- 11:37the Fofis. So, like you can kind of see
- 11:39the timeline from there.
- 11:40>> matches up from Jane Doe and every other
- 11:43document, even though they're redacted.
- 11:45>> Yes. Then from there, we cross-reference
- 11:46news articles detailing snippets of Jane
- 11:48Doe's interviews with the Cornell police
- 11:50because some major news outlets were
- 11:52able to get their hands on the
- 11:53transcript of this
- 11:56I would imagine multi-hour-long
- 11:57interview that Jane Doe gave to the
- 11:59Cornell University Police Department.
- 12:01And they have just been releasing like
- 12:02random snippets of this transcript and
- 12:04they have not been made public, so we're
- 12:05combing through as many articles as
- 12:07possible trying to piece together the
- 12:09transcript because everyone's just
- 12:11releasing snippets. So, that's great.
- 12:13Then we took another lawsuit. We took
- 12:15John Doe's lawsuit against Cornell. We
- 12:16briefly went over this in part one, but
- 12:18one of the accused sued Cornell for the
- 12:20way the Title IX investigation was
- 12:22handled by the school. And because of
- 12:24that, there's a lot of snippets of this
- 12:25Title IX investigation that's included
- 12:27in the lawsuit. Which this lawsuit, you
- 12:29can find it available to the public
- 12:31online and it's filled with failed
- 12:32redactions.
- 12:33>> John Doe is one of the seven.
- 12:35>> Yes.
- 12:35>> He sued Cornell because
- 12:38>> because he did not agree with the
- 12:39conclusion Cornell came with of his
- 12:41involvement in the alleged crimes.
- 12:45>> Right. He got some sort of punishment on
- 12:47that.
- 12:47>> sort of sanction, right? And he's like,
- 12:49"I don't like this. I don't agree with
- 12:50this Title IX investigation, so I'm
- 12:52going to sue Cornell."
- 12:53>> Yes.
- 12:54>> And nothing fruitful came of it, but he
- 12:56did sue Cornell. This was actually a
- 12:57lawsuit that was filed before Jane Doe's
- 12:59lawsuit. This lawsuit is publicly
- 13:02available to you if you just
- 13:04Google it and maybe go through a few
- 13:06links on Google. And it is filled with
- 13:08failed redactions. Download it, you'll
- 13:11see what I'm talking about. So, do with
- 13:12that what you will. However, a lot of
- 13:14names are still redacted, meaning we had
- 13:16to use context clues from all the
- 13:17previous information to figure out who
- 13:19is who in this Title IX investigation
- 13:21because this actually gives us a lot of
- 13:23direct quotes from the accused.
- 13:26>> It wasn't in Jane Doe's lawsuit.
- 13:28>> No, it was not in Jane Doe's or
- 13:29>> it from John Doe's lawsuit.
- 13:31>> Yes.
- 13:32>> Okay.
- 13:32>> And that had failed redactions. But even
- 13:35without the failed redactions, you know,
- 13:37there are lots of snippets of who said
- 13:39what and then judging based off of the
- 13:41context of well, I came in at this time
- 13:45or when I came in this was who was in
- 13:46the room. You can kind of pinpoint who
- 13:47it is, right? Again, we can never be
- 13:49100% certain. So obviously because it's
- 13:51redacted, we will do our best to tell
- 13:53you, you know, like maybe Matthew, maybe
- 13:55this. But just keep in mind at the end
- 13:57of the day, we're just taking some
- 13:58guesses. We would like to call them
- 13:59educated guesses, but we also did not go
- 14:01to Cornell, so maybe they're just
- 14:03guesses. But with that, let us combine
- 14:05it all and give you a somewhat clear
- 14:08timeline of who said what happened
- 14:10October 19th, 2024. Making the time out
- 14:13of your day to go work out, I would say,
- 14:15is a big deal. And then you do that only
- 14:17to get robbed is the embodiment of the
- 14:19saying no good deed goes unpunished or
- 14:22as I guess the gym rats would usually
- 14:24say like no pain, no gain, okay? It's a
- 14:26bit more positive of an outlook on life.
- 14:29>> [music]
- 14:29>> Saturday, October 19th, 2024, Jane Doe
- 14:32is at Crunch Fitness. This is an
- 14:34off-campus gym. Someone takes her car
- 14:37keys without her knowing the afternoon.
- 14:39So it's like 5:00 p.m. She's working
- 14:41out. Someone takes her car keys. They
- 14:42unlock her car, break in, slip inside,
- 14:44steal her wallet amongst other things,
- 14:47and she realizes when she sees a $400
- 14:49charge to Walmart that she did not make.
- 14:52Her wallet is gone, her car keys are
- 14:54gone. Someone took her wallet and is
- 14:56buying stuff off of Walmart. She says,
- 14:58"Upon discovering this, I canceled all
- 15:00of my debit and credit card accounts."
- 15:01And this is kind of pertinent later.
- 15:03>> [music]
- 15:03>> Because of this whole gym incident, it
- 15:05seems like this series of events for
- 15:07October 19th get altered. [music]
- 15:09Jane Doe was originally supposed to be a
- 15:11sober sister for her sorority party,
- 15:13meaning she was going to be sober the
- 15:15entire night and her entire task was
- 15:17going to be keeping an eye on the
- 15:18sorority sisters at the bar that night
- 15:20cuz they're having like a whole event at
- 15:22Mooney's.
- 15:23>> Mhm.
- 15:23>> So they're going to go to Moonies and
- 15:24she's going to be sober because she's
- 15:2520, so she's not even legally of
- 15:26drinking age, which would make sense,
- 15:28but because her car keys and wallet were
- 15:30stolen, she had to go to the Ithaca
- 15:31Police Department and the sorority was
- 15:33saying like, "You don't have to be the
- 15:34sober sister because we don't even know
- 15:35when you're going to come back from the
- 15:36police station and like maybe it's just
- 15:38too much on your plate today. We're just
- 15:40going to find a different sober sister.
- 15:42It's fine."
- 15:43>> Mhm.
- 15:43>> So by the time that she makes it back to
- 15:44the sorority house, Tri Delta on Cornell
- 15:47campus, she's like, "Okay, I'm no longer
- 15:49the sober sister. I'm going to start
- 15:51drinking." So she starts drinking vodka
- 15:53from the bottle. She reports, "I was
- 15:55trying to catch up to my sorority
- 15:56sisters who had already started drinking
- 15:5830 minutes before I did." She says that
- 16:00she typically doesn't drink that much
- 16:02alcohol because she has POTS, which
- 16:04makes her feel very dizzy and she says
- 16:06on top of that that particular day, she
- 16:08probably ate about 400 calories
- 16:11the whole day. So she she's got an empty
- 16:13stomach. She's taken approximately six
- 16:15vodka shots in a very short amount of
- 16:17time. She's sipping mixed drinks from
- 16:19her sorority sisters' cups, I guess
- 16:21testing out their drinks.
- 16:22When she gets to the Moonies bar, she
- 16:24then orders another drink at the Moonies
- 16:26bar even though she's underage. She gets
- 16:28a drink called Sex on the Beach and she
- 16:29believes that drink had about two
- 16:31alcoholic shots in there.
- 16:32>> [music]
- 16:33>> And she has these giant X's on her hand,
- 16:34but they still served her the alcohol,
- 16:36she says. She doesn't even have a credit
- 16:38card. Her [music] friend lends him his
- 16:40credit card so that she can buy this Sex
- 16:42on the Beach drink. And this is part of
- 16:44the original six-page statement that the
- 16:46DA received. So from there, she makes
- 16:48her way to the other bar. It's called
- 16:51like Bar 10, where another sorority
- 16:54Pi Phi Phi Phi, it's another sorority.
- 16:57They're having a party. She stays
- 16:59briefly and then she starts walking back
- 17:01to campus so that she can go to the
- 17:03fraternity house. Remember the whole DA
- 17:05was like, "Oh, it was a mile" and there
- 17:07was a lot of emphasis on the distance.
- 17:09It's interesting because I didn't know
- 17:11this, but when she got to the fraternity
- 17:12house, I guess it's guest list only for
- 17:15for particular party. So she would have
- 17:16to prove that she knew someone inside
- 17:18the fraternity, that she was invited.
- 17:20She says, "When I got there, I remember
- 17:21feeling numb from being cold and
- 17:23intoxicated. I'd been texting Matthew
- 17:25along the way, but when I arrived, he
- 17:27was no longer responding to me. So, I
- 17:28was forced to wait outside of the
- 17:29fraternity. He's still not responding."
- 17:32So, Jane notices that there's these
- 17:33three individuals, fraternity brothers,
- 17:35standing outside the front door. So, she
- 17:37walks up to them and asks, "Do you guys
- 17:39know where Matthew is?" And she reports,
- 17:41"I said I could prove that I was a
- 17:42friend of Matthew's by showing them our
- 17:44text conversation, [music]
- 17:45and they responded by saying, 'We know
- 17:47who you are. You're Jane.'"
- 17:49She says, "I found this odd because I
- 17:51didn't think that I had met these three
- 17:52individuals before, but they allowed me
- 17:55to enter the fraternity. I remember them
- 17:57saying something nice along the lines of
- 17:58like, 'Make yourself at home' as I
- 18:00entered the fraternity."
- 18:01>> Hm.
- 18:02>> She thought it was odd. She says that
- 18:04this particular party was not packed.
- 18:07Usually the the Kai Phi parties, it's
- 18:09wall-to-wall people. People are jammed
- 18:11in there like sardines. This one seemed
- 18:14more chill. It didn't seem to be that
- 18:15packed at all. Walks into the main room,
- 18:17and she spots Matthew pretty quickly,
- 18:19and she's dancing with Matthew, and she
- 18:21says, "I was okay with dancing and being
- 18:24flirtatious because I was attracted to
- 18:25Matthew, and I was open to the idea of
- 18:27dating him." Remember the DA summarized
- 18:30the very first threesome, and like he
- 18:32summarized it in a way that was so
- 18:33bizarre to me. I kept reading it over
- 18:35and over again, and I was like asking
- 18:36everyone around me like, "Does this even
- 18:38make sense? I don't even understand
- 18:39what's happening right now." But he was
- 18:41like, "Jane Doe is asked by Matthew if
- 18:44they want to have a threesome, right?"
- 18:46And Jane Doe is so excited because that
- 18:49means Matthew and Jonathan, the first
- 18:51person in the sexual encounter, must be
- 18:53gay.
- 18:54>> Hm.
- 18:55>> And I'm like, "Wait, what? What does
- 18:56that have to do, right?"
- 18:57>> out and she was excited or something.
- 18:59>> It just kind of like In that moment, it
- 19:01made her sound like an airhead.
- 19:03>> Hm.
- 19:03>> Like, "Oh my god, that means you guys
- 19:04are gay." Like, it just sounded bizarre.
- 19:06I've never seen that sort of reaction,
- 19:08but the six-page statement gives so much
- 19:11more context Because the DA's
- 19:13paraphrasing doesn't give any context.
- 19:15It's confusing. So, by way of
- 19:16paraphrasing, it's kind of a failure cuz
- 19:18you're supposed to make it not
- 19:19confusing. But, the full statement is
- 19:21that Matthew pulled her to the side and
- 19:23asked if she wants to have a threesome.
- 19:25And she responds by saying, "With what
- 19:27woman?" I responded this way because the
- 19:28idea of having a threesome with one male
- 19:30partner and two female partners is safer
- 19:32to me. There is a long portion that's
- 19:34redacted, but [music] her statement
- 19:37reads, "But Matthew asked how I would
- 19:39feel about having a threesome with two
- 19:40male partners." [music]
- 19:41At first, I was kind of shocked, but I
- 19:43eventually agreed due to how attracted I
- 19:45was to Matthew on top of my drunken
- 19:47curiousness.
- 19:48>> [music]
- 19:48>> She says that she asked who the other
- 19:50party, who the other guy would be, and
- 19:52Matthew told her that they would find
- 19:54someone.
- 19:55Which a lot of people think is weird
- 19:56because usually when you proposition
- 19:58someone for something as big as a
- 19:59threesome, especially if you're not even
- 20:02dating this individual. I mean, I I was
- 20:04going through Reddit threads where
- 20:05people are like, "Even when you're in a
- 20:07relationship and the idea of a threesome
- 20:10comes up, people have someone in my It's
- 20:12like a lengthy process."
- 20:14It's not just like, "I'm sure we'll find
- 20:16a willing participant somewhere." Even
- 20:19in the craziest of college environments,
- 20:21this is kind of out there. This is kind
- 20:23of crazy. So, it seems like people are
- 20:25skeptical of Matthew's intentions
- 20:27because it was so out there.
- 20:30He leads her upstairs, drops her off in
- 20:32a room with the other fraternity brother
- 20:34that doesn't appear to be involved in
- 20:36really anything. Eventually, she's led
- 20:38to the alumni room and she sees
- 20:40Jonathan. So, it's now Matthew,
- 20:42Jonathan, and Jane in the alumni room.
- 20:44And she says, "I remember being excited
- 20:46because I thought that Matthew and
- 20:48Jonathan wanting to have a threesome
- 20:49meant that they were gay." Right? This
- 20:51is the the paraphrasing the DA gives.
- 20:54But then she says, and the DA has access
- 20:57to this, "Which would have meant that
- 20:58they were part of my community as I'm
- 21:00bisexual. I believe I said something
- 21:02along the lines of like, 'I didn't know
- 21:04you guys are all fruity?'
- 21:05>> [music]
- 21:05>> And either Matthew or Jonathan responds,
- 21:08"Uh, I'm homocurious."
- 21:10And the other just laughed and didn't
- 21:12say anything else.
- 21:14I mean, that just gives so much more
- 21:15context.
- 21:15>> Yeah.
- 21:16>> Like, because what do you mean? You just
- 21:18I got excited cuz I thought they were
- 21:19gay. But this gives a lot more context
- 21:22and also more context of why she might
- 21:23be more open to having a threesome even
- 21:25with another woman, because she's
- 21:26bisexual, right? And so, also, another
- 21:29thing to note is some that are
- 21:31interested in saying this might have
- 21:32made her feel more comfortable
- 21:33>> Mhm.
- 21:34>> because now she almost feels like she's
- 21:36helping other people awaken their
- 21:38sexuality, and that might be something
- 21:40that she would feel inclined or want to
- 21:42help with. The report reads, "I would
- 21:44say that I was pretty okay with having
- 21:45this threesome with Jonathan and
- 21:47Matthew. During the threesome, I began
- 21:49to feel Jonathan hitting me many times
- 21:51on my butt, and I remember that the hits
- 21:52were hurting me." And she says, again,
- 21:54in a later statement, that she was
- 21:57"okay with the first encounter," quote,
- 22:00"as much as I can be, because again, I
- 22:02was super drunk when I got there, but I
- 22:04was pretty okay with all of this."
- 22:07But she did not seem comfortable getting
- 22:09physically hit, she says. And then, of
- 22:10course, I was being hit at the same
- 22:12time, like physically very, very hard.
- 22:14She then states that while they're
- 22:15engaging in this act, Matthew was unable
- 22:17to maintain an erection, and apparently
- 22:19Matthew says, according to Jane Doe,
- 22:20quote, "I'm going to die." Jane says
- 22:23that she was confused because she wasn't
- 22:24sure if he was serious about dying or if
- 22:26this was a joke or if like something was
- 22:27happening, because this is after she
- 22:29claims that they did ketamine, Jamaican
- 22:31weed, and all of these other things. And
- 22:33so, she's kind of freaking out, and she
- 22:35seems to be taking it upon herself to
- 22:37take care of both Matthew and now
- 22:39Jonathan, because now Jonathan is like
- 22:41dry heaving into a trash can somewhere.
- 22:43And she keeps waking up Matthew every
- 22:45few minutes. She's helping Jonathan
- 22:46trying to throw up, even though he does
- 22:48not end up throwing up. On the flip
- 22:50side, Matthew Engles, in his written
- 22:53statement, claims that Jane Doe did not
- 22:54take any ketamine before this first
- 22:56sexual encounter. He also states that he
- 22:59took a lot. He says that he only really
- 23:01knows how much he did, which was
- 23:02multiple keys worth. I guess that's
- 23:05I guess maybe in like cocaine sense,
- 23:06which is a little more common, it's like
- 23:08multiple lines perhaps. But key is I
- 23:10guess a measurement for cocaine, you
- 23:12know, like put it on it, I don't know.
- 23:13And he snorted multiple lines or keys
- 23:16worth in rapid succession. He says, "No
- 23:19less than 10 minutes after consuming the
- 23:20ketamine, I began to struggle breathing,
- 23:22gasping for breath, and groaning
- 23:25uncomfortably. Several times I lost
- 23:27consciousness momentarily. I was too
- 23:29incapacitated to consent to sexual
- 23:31activity anymore."
- 23:32Matthew is the one that is now accusing
- 23:34Jane Doe potentially of SA. There's a
- 23:37crazy email that he had crazy is an
- 23:40opinion, you know, crazy email that he
- 23:42had sent to the Title IX investigators,
- 23:45where he said that there were rumors
- 23:46that he was sodomized by Jane Doe,
- 23:50and that he felt the Title IX
- 23:52investigation was completely being
- 23:54steamrolled by
- 23:56gender politics and, you know,
- 23:58>> Wait, how legitimate is this email?
- 24:01>> The email seems legitimate.
- 24:03>> Okay, he's telling the
- 24:06>> Title IX investigator.
- 24:07>> That he has been
- 24:08>> It's kind of vague. It's like, "I told
- 24:12you in November that I believed I was
- 24:14sodomized." That's kind of the
- 24:16paraphrasing that I'm giving of this
- 24:18email.
- 24:18>> I see, I see.
- 24:19>> But it's vague. We don't know for sure,
- 24:21but he it seems like he's consistently
- 24:23kind of throwing back the idea that he
- 24:26was more incapacitated, which means that
- 24:28he would have been the one that SA'd.
- 24:30>> Mhm.
- 24:31>> He says that, "I attempted to remain
- 24:33conscious. I could feel my face, you
- 24:35know, contorting as if I was crying, but
- 24:36no tears came out. That was the last
- 24:38clear memory I have up until that
- 24:40point." [music] He then recalls Jonathan
- 24:42was throwing up into a trash can while
- 24:44he's on the bed now trying to remain
- 24:47functional, right? But it's interesting
- 24:49because he was still able to maintain
- 24:51enough function to send multiple
- 24:54messages into the Kai Phi Snapchat. So,
- 24:57there is that. Jonathan Newville in his
- 25:00alleged statement to the Title 9
- 25:02investigators, and this is like
- 25:03redacted, his name is redacted, but I
- 25:06think it's Jonathan because the timeline
- 25:08adds up, right? So, the thing with
- 25:10Matthew, however, is he is involved in
- 25:13the Title 9 investigation, but he is one
- 25:15of the seven accused, the only of the
- 25:17seven accused that does not do
- 25:19interviews with the Title 9
- 25:20investigation. He gives one written
- 25:22statement, and that's about it. It's
- 25:24interesting because Matthew Engles' dad
- 25:27is allegedly an educator. He's high up
- 25:31on a school board in Dubai for an
- 25:32American college. So, people speculate
- 25:35that maybe his dad has extensive
- 25:36knowledge of Title 9 investigations and
- 25:39how they are not criminal investigations
- 25:41and how you do not have to partake in
- 25:43them, so that he's the only one that
- 25:45gave a written statement instead of
- 25:47multiple interviews. Some of these other
- 25:48guys, I mean, they were interviewed in
- 25:50January, multiple times in March, May,
- 25:53like there's a series of interviews that
- 25:55are had. And some of their stories
- 25:57evolve as well. So, if we're going to
- 25:59say Jane Doe's story is evolving, the
- 26:01accused, some of their stories are also
- 26:02evolving.
- 26:03>> Mhm.
- 26:04>> I'm not going to tell you how much
- 26:05weight to put into all of this, but it
- 26:07would make sense that at some point
- 26:09Matthew and Jonathan's statements are
- 26:11similar because, I mean, that would make
- 26:14the most sense. Jonathan also agrees
- 26:16that during that initial encounter Jane
- 26:17Doe declined the ketamine. So, she did
- 26:19not do ketamine before the very first
- 26:21sexual encounter. That's what Jonathan
- 26:23and Matthew are both claiming. But then
- 26:25later, in a statement, Jonathan says
- 26:28that they pulled out the bag of
- 26:29ketamine, asked if Jane wanted some, and
- 26:31she said no because she'd never done it
- 26:33before, so they didn't ask again. They
- 26:35didn't ask again, [music] right? That's
- 26:37key. However, later he talks about what
- 26:39substances were given to Jane, and he
- 26:41responds in that interview, I guess
- 26:43ketamine, alcohol, weed. Me and Matthew
- 26:46Engles did it. We offered it to her. She
- 26:48chose to take it. We didn't force her to
- 26:50do anything. Did you give it to her and
- 26:52she declined and then you never pushed
- 26:54her again and then you never gave her
- 26:55ketamine, you never offered ketamine
- 26:56again? Or did she take it and you did
- 26:59not push her to take it? I mean, it's
- 27:01just they're two vastly very different
- 27:02things. But the very first sexual
- 27:04encounter occurs and when they take a
- 27:06break because Matthew wanted to sleep,
- 27:07Jonathan is feeling nauseous. Also, I
- 27:10believe this is Jonathan in the
- 27:11redactions because it makes the most
- 27:13sense, but it appears maybe Jonathan is
- 27:15asked about if he was smacking Jane
- 27:17Doe's buttocks during the initial
- 27:18encounter and he claims that it was the
- 27:21other party. He's asked about how many
- 27:23times the other participant struck Jane
- 27:26Doe. He says, "After the first one, she
- 27:28asked him to do it again." He says Jane
- 27:30never indicated that she was in any pain
- 27:32and he was also unsure if it was a
- 27:34striking or a grabbing or a squeezing
- 27:36situation. He also can't remember which
- 27:38hand was used by the other participant.
- 27:41>> Okay, so Jonathan's saying Matthew's the
- 27:42one who's smacking.
- 27:43>> Yes, but he's also like, "I don't know
- 27:45if it was smacking or if it was
- 27:46squeezing or grabbing. I also don't know
- 27:47which hand. I also don't know how many
- 27:49times it happened, but I don't think it
- 27:51was me." And there's a lot of things
- 27:53that he doesn't think. He also reports
- 27:55not remembering sending the initial free
- 27:57yellow on PU Snapchat, so yeah.
- 28:01Okay. [laughter]
- 28:02When those Snapchat messages comes up,
- 28:04he maybe Jonathan says, "I don't
- 28:06remember using my phone at any point
- 28:07that night, so I don't remember sending
- 28:09that text. I was honestly kind of
- 28:10mortified when I saw it was me." He says
- 28:13that this has occurred before though,
- 28:15where he had sent a message without
- 28:16remembering. He said it happened the
- 28:17last time he blacked out, which is just
- 28:20in fantastic, isn't it? Because now a
- 28:21bunch of fraternity brothers are going
- 28:23to walk into the alumni room for
- 28:25whatever reason and this incident is
- 28:27going to get exponentially messier. But
- 28:29also, is he blacked out? Is he not
- 28:31blacked out? Like there's so much gray
- 28:33area. Back to Jane though, she says that
- 28:36Gillia Lopes walks in because it's his
- 28:39room. There's three beds, a lot of
- 28:40fraternity brothers live here. He's
- 28:42reportedly the first to walk in, so now
- 28:43[music] it's Jane, Matthew, Jonathan,
- 28:46and Gillio. He pulls Jane in for a kiss,
- 28:49and Jonathan starts coming up behind
- 28:50her, and according to her, basically
- 28:52groping her. She said she doesn't
- 28:54remember much of the sexual interaction
- 28:56with Gilio Lopes and Jonathan because,
- 28:57quote, "I was pretty intoxicated." The
- 29:00original report that the DA receives
- 29:02reads, "I remember hearing redacted and
- 29:04redacted say something about having a
- 29:06turn." After hearing that, I realized
- 29:08that the threesomes I had taken part in
- 29:09that night were not about each person
- 29:11getting their own gratification out of
- 29:13it, but more so about redacted and
- 29:15redacted using me without caring about
- 29:17what I was getting out of the situation.
- 29:19This made me feel really uncomfortable
- 29:20in the moment. She says that she felt
- 29:23really used. Then she says Matthew wakes
- 29:25up, sees activity going on between Gilio
- 29:28Lopes and Jonathan and Jane, and
- 29:32according to Jane, says something along
- 29:33the lines of, "Hell yeah." That's when
- 29:35he said he wanted to make it a foursome.
- 29:37Jane Doe declines.
- 29:40There is a portion of the Title IX
- 29:42investigation which I think could be
- 29:44attributed to Gilio Lopes and his
- 29:46interviews. I don't know with certainty,
- 29:48like the other times, but I was able to
- 29:50cross-reference some information. Maybe
- 29:52Gilio states to the Title IX panel that
- 29:54during his interactions with Jane in the
- 29:56alumni room, she seemed very positive,
- 29:58smiling, engaged, talkative, said that
- 30:01everything was completely consensual,
- 30:03the sexual stuff. She did not seem
- 30:04incapacitated,
- 30:06and another one of the accused who
- 30:07apparently witnessed the kiss between
- 30:10Jane and Gilio says, "My roommate Gilio
- 30:12walks in the room, Jane invites him in,
- 30:14they start kissing and talking, and I
- 30:16hear like from the side her telling him
- 30:18like, 'You don't know how long I've
- 30:21wanted to do this.'" And eventually,
- 30:23they start having sex on the bed.
- 30:25>> Wait, who is this witness?
- 30:27>> I think it's Jonathan. Again, it's
- 30:29redacted, right? But from what I could
- 30:32piece together from these redactions,
- 30:34what I concluded, and this is not a
- 30:36fact, this is just what I'm trying to
- 30:38decipher from the document, and that
- 30:40could not be the truth at all.
- 30:41Whatever's is the document could also
- 30:43not be the truth, right? We don't know
- 30:44what the truth is. But it seems like
- 30:46maybe Jonathan is insinuating Julio
- 30:48walks in, they start making out, and
- 30:50Jane is like, "You don't know how long
- 30:51I've been wanting to do this." They get
- 30:53on the bed, they start having sexual
- 30:54activities, and Jonathan makes it almost
- 30:57seem like well, maybe Jonathan makes it
- 30:58almost seem like he's not involved in
- 31:00that second interaction.
- 31:02>> Uh-huh.
- 31:03>> Matthews passed out and he says, "I'm
- 31:05still on the couch, still nauseous, like
- 31:07throwing up." And like these are the
- 31:09context clues I'm using to believe that
- 31:11this is Jonathan.
- 31:12>> Mhm. Because the first one she said she
- 31:15was okay with it.
- 31:16>> Yes.
- 31:16>> But the second one
- 31:18>> Yeah.
- 31:18>> Julio just walked in.
- 31:20>> And she seemed like she wanted this. She
- 31:22said, "You don't know how long I've
- 31:23wanted to do this."
- 31:24>> Uh-huh. Uh-huh.
- 31:25>> And they went to the bed, I'm throwing
- 31:27up.
- 31:28>> Uh-huh. But Jane Doe saying no, he's
- 31:31>> He was involved and it was rape.
- 31:33>> Okay.
- 31:34>> He states, "I don't remember having sex
- 31:36from that point I threw up to when I
- 31:38went to bed. I feel like I would
- 31:39remember it, but it's possible it did
- 31:42happen."
- 31:43>> It's possible it did happen.
- 31:45>> Yeah, which is kind of vague, okay?
- 31:47Whereas Jane says it was Julio and
- 31:50Jonathan. And again, I'm not saying one
- 31:52story is truer than the other, but I
- 31:54will say Hello?
- 31:56Eventually, Julio Lopes leaves the room.
- 32:00Then walk in Diego Sarabia and Winston
- 32:03Lee. They enter the room. It seems like
- 32:06they enter separately, but that's the
- 32:07timeline of when they come into the
- 32:09alumni room. And according to Jane Doe,
- 32:11a ton of guys start coming in. And I
- 32:13know it sounds like just two guys walk
- 32:14in, but it's going to be four because
- 32:16the two Scots come in. Julio later stops
- 32:18by again. So it is a lot of action of
- 32:20people moving in and out of the alumni
- 32:22room. And I'm sure maybe there were
- 32:23other times where maybe someone had
- 32:25poked their head in, I don't know.
- 32:27But according to Jane Doe, there's a lot
- 32:28of guys coming in and out of the room,
- 32:30and she is freaking out because [music]
- 32:32she's unclothed and she's just hiding
- 32:33under the covers naked. She says at some
- 32:36point one of the guys says something
- 32:37very offensive to her. The report reads,
- 32:39"I don't remember exactly what he said
- 32:41to [music] me. I instantly became
- 32:42defensive and I sat up quickly in the
- 32:43bed to confront I I think it's Diego,
- 32:47but again, don't take it with full
- 32:48certainty about what he said to me. And
- 32:50in doing so, the covers had fallen off
- 32:52my breasts, which are now exposed to
- 32:54everyone in the room." She's saying like
- 32:56I'm defending myself, I'm getting
- 32:57passionate and the covers are slipping
- 32:58down. She says, "I was defending myself,
- 33:00yelling at him. He apologized and
- 33:02grabbed my face and started kissing me."
- 33:05"I quickly backed away to stop redacted
- 33:07from kissing me and I remember not
- 33:08having many emotions at that point
- 33:10because I was starting to become
- 33:11completely numb to the whole situation.
- 33:13I remember the room we were in had red
- 33:15lights on that were pretty hurtful to my
- 33:17eyes. Also, I remember someone bringing
- 33:19up the scars that I had on my legs
- 33:21from SH that I had done in August of
- 33:24that year. Hearing that my scars were
- 33:26brought up, but no one cared to ask
- 33:28about them made me feel super isolated
- 33:30and I don't even matter as a person
- 33:32[music] to these men. Adding to my
- 33:33feelings of isolation was the fact that
- 33:35my phone was across the room and I felt
- 33:37like I couldn't get to it. [music] As
- 33:38well as I didn't have any form of
- 33:39payment to order an Uber to get out of
- 33:41the situation I was in because remember
- 33:43she had canceled all her cards earlier
- 33:45that day."
- 33:45>> Mhm.
- 33:46>> She says, "At that point, I was still
- 33:48angry with the person who offended her,
- 33:51said that rude remark. So, I stood up
- 33:53and I began flexing towards him."
- 33:55>> [music]
- 33:55>> So, this is like a huge point the
- 33:57internet picked up of like, "Why is she
- 33:58flexing? Why is she getting up naked?"
- 34:01She's saying, "I was so scared. I got up
- 34:02naked and then I started flexing."
- 34:04People are like, "What's happening?
- 34:05You're either scared and hiding under
- 34:07the covers or you're getting up and
- 34:09showing off your body and flexing and
- 34:11consenting to at least visually being
- 34:13seen by people unclothed. She says, "I
- 34:16was still angry, so I stood up and began
- 34:18flexing towards him while telling him
- 34:20that I would mess him up. I also felt
- 34:22like it was a primitive self-defense
- 34:24manner as a reaction to the situation I
- 34:26was in."
- 34:27It sounds very confusing, right? It's a
- 34:29little difficult to understand. However,
- 34:31earlier in the statement, remember how I
- 34:33told you that she only ate 400 calories
- 34:35that day?
- 34:36>> Mhm.
- 34:37>> She is a weightlifter. She's a
- 34:39bodybuilder.
- 34:40>> Oh.
- 34:41>> So, it seems like she takes it very
- 34:42seriously. She ate 400 calories of
- 34:44chicken and rice. She was at Crunch
- 34:45Fitness. I don't know how serious, I
- 34:47don't know if she's involved in any
- 34:48competitions or anything like that, but
- 34:50it does seem like this could be
- 34:52additional context of why someone would
- 34:54get up and start flexing.
- 34:55>> Mhm.
- 34:56>> And people do report she kept doing like
- 34:58a bodybuilder pose.
- 34:59>> Mhm.
- 35:00>> Again, I think a lot of people were
- 35:00thrown off by that. Like, what do you
- 35:02mean she's doing a bodybuilder pose?
- 35:04>> Mhm.
- 35:04>> This is some context. You can still have
- 35:07the opinion that it is very odd and
- 35:08something that you would not do in her
- 35:10situation, but it is just further
- 35:11context that I think is necessary. The
- 35:14report continues to read, "I realized
- 35:16that I was standing in front of the
- 35:17group of men completely naked, so I sat
- 35:18back down on the bed and tried to cover
- 35:20myself with my arms as best as I could
- 35:21so I wasn't completely exposed." She
- 35:24later describes the situation as being
- 35:25surrounded by a ton of men and feeling a
- 35:27severe power imbalance. Whereas, who I
- 35:30believe to be Diego in the John Doe
- 35:32redactions, and I believe this to be his
- 35:34statement. I could be wrong though. Look
- 35:36up the John Doe lawsuit yourself. Maybe
- 35:38Diego says, "Basically, Jane just asked
- 35:40more about my involvement at Cornell.
- 35:42She is just saying I walked into the
- 35:43alumni room and I was just having a
- 35:45little chit-chat with Jane. They have
- 35:47the same major, so we started talking
- 35:49and bonding over our majors, and then at
- 35:51some point in that conversation, I just
- 35:52remember her smiling and kind of leaning
- 35:54in towards me a little bit, and then
- 35:56eventually I leaned in as well. Then I
- 35:59recall our lips touched in kind of like
- 36:01a pecking motion for maybe two or three
- 36:04seconds, and then I pulled my head away
- 36:05because I realized that there are other
- 36:07people in the room and I did not want to
- 36:08be kissing someone."
- 36:10Which is
- 36:11>> What?
- 36:11>> Again, I'm not saying it's not true. I'm
- 36:13just saying
- 36:15>> of events.
- 36:16>> And it's really weird usage. You're
- 36:18telling me a bunch of fraternity
- 36:19brothers who are writing free PC alum
- 36:22pull up.
- 36:23>> Yeah.
- 36:24>> You don't want PDA in front of your
- 36:25fraternity brothers. You don't even want
- 36:27to kiss someone in front of them.
- 36:28>> Yeah, but also who just like kiss and
- 36:32then realize like that's really odd.
- 36:34>> Yeah, it's very odd.
- 36:36>> Anyways.
- 36:37>> Yeah, not saying it's untrue, it's just
- 36:38odd. He says that while all of this is
- 36:40happening, Jane Doe seemed happy and did
- 36:42not seem incapacitated at all. He
- 36:45describes the group as appearing joyous
- 36:47and happy. Sometimes these fraternity
- 36:49brothers use words that boggle my
- 36:51[ __ ] mind. What do you mean joyous
- 36:53and happy? You're going to
- 36:55You're going to roll over because
- 36:56there's another guy who says some insane
- 36:59stuff. One thing to note is and this is
- 37:02could be speculation on my part, but
- 37:05going through some of these Title IX
- 37:07snippets and interviews by the redacted
- 37:10individuals, you can kind of see clicks
- 37:13even within the fraternity brothers. It
- 37:16seems that to me from my observation, it
- 37:18seems that Matthew, Jonathan, and
- 37:20Winston are closer. It seems Julio Lopes
- 37:23is kind of doing his own thing and then
- 37:26it seems the two Scotts and Diego are
- 37:29very close.
- 37:31And the two Scotts seem further removed
- 37:34than Diego from the others.
- 37:36Okay, this is all important because
- 37:39there's a separate fraternity room where
- 37:40the two Scotts are hanging out with
- 37:42Diego before they go to the alumni room.
- 37:45>> Yeah.
- 37:45>> So you got two Scotts and Diego. Diego's
- 37:48sitting there and the two Scotts say out
- 37:50of nowhere, Diego just kind of like gets
- 37:52up out of the room and leaves. We don't
- 37:55know what happened, you know, and the
- 37:56two Scotts are like, "We're doing our
- 37:57own thing. We're watching some TV." And
- 37:59then one of the Scotts, his vape pen
- 38:02dies. And this is like the trigger event
- 38:05of all of this, okay? So his vape pen is
- 38:08dead and he's like, "What am I going to
- 38:09do? My vape pen is dead." "Hey, one of
- 38:11the guys that lives in the alumni room
- 38:13has a vape pen. We should go there." And
- 38:15hey, maybe that's where Diego went
- 38:17because did you see this Snapchat? Is
- 38:19that where Diego left to? We should go
- 38:21investigate. So there's like a lot of
- 38:23weird things that are being claimed.
- 38:25However, Diego, based off of the
- 38:26context, I think this is Diego's
- 38:28statement from the John Doe lawsuit.
- 38:30But, a lot of these guys are asked,
- 38:32"What did you think when you saw the
- 38:33Snapchat message? Why did you go to the
- 38:34alumni room? Especially if you are not a
- 38:36resident of the alumni room, why did you
- 38:38go to the alumni room?" And this is
- 38:40maybe Diego's response, and it reads,
- 38:42"Basically, I just kind of questioned
- 38:43[music] it because it's something I've
- 38:45never seen before in my entire 4 years
- 38:47living in the Kai Phi house." Just like,
- 38:49okay. I don't know what that means.
- 38:52>> Question what?
- 38:53>> He just questioned the free C alum P U
- 38:55chat. Because he's like, "I just
- 38:57questioned it."
- 38:59>> Right. We are all questioning what that
- 39:01means, right?
- 39:02>> Yeah. Yeah. Exactly.
- 39:03>> What Whoever sent that, question marks,
- 39:06what do you mean by that?
- 39:08>> Exactly. And he says, um, and this I
- 39:10think is Diego, but I mean, they all
- 39:12kind of give similar responses to the
- 39:14Snapchat. And the Snapchat itself is not
- 39:17a criminal act. It could probably be, I
- 39:21don't know, if it's It's probably
- 39:22admissible. But, you get what I'm
- 39:23saying. I'm not accusing them of a crime
- 39:25by what they're saying about the
- 39:25Snapchat group. But, he says, someone
- 39:28says, "I honestly did not have a great
- 39:30understanding of what was happening at
- 39:31the time, but was very concerned and
- 39:34just overall curious about the matter."
- 39:37>> Mhm. Concerned.
- 39:39>> And overall curious about the matter.
- 39:40[music]
- 39:41>> Mhm.
- 39:42>> Just like, objectively a [ __ ] odd
- 39:44statement. I don't know what's
- 39:45happening, but I'm very concerned,
- 39:47overall curious about the matter. The
- 39:48matter being a Snapchat that reads,
- 39:50"Free C alum pull up." Then another one
- 39:52of the accused that was in the room that
- 39:54time says that when they saw Jane and
- 39:56Diego kissing, they were, quote, "Kind
- 39:59of laughing about it after." So, a lot
- 40:01of the accused are saying, "Well, I saw
- 40:02some other people engaged in sexual
- 40:04activities, and they all seemed happy."
- 40:06Jane Doe reports that she did not
- 40:07recognize a lot of the faces in the
- 40:09room. So, she, quote, "I remember
- 40:11grabbing redacted's arm." We don't know
- 40:13who this could be. We could presume it's
- 40:14Matthew, but it's unclear. And I grabbed
- 40:16his arm at some point, and I remember
- 40:18saying to him, "I don't know who any of
- 40:19these people are." Redacted replied by
- 40:21laughing and asking if I wanted to do
- 40:23more ketamine. When he asked that, it
- 40:25hit me that I had taken ketamine on the
- 40:26couch with Matthew and Jonathan earlier
- 40:28in the night. Redacted would later tell
- 40:30me that I had also smoked marijuana from
- 40:32a large bong, as well as consumed
- 40:33Jamaican liquor while on the couch with
- 40:35him and redacted. So, I remember smoking
- 40:38marijuana, but the ketamine and Jamaican
- 40:41liquor I have zero memory of. She says,
- 40:43"All I could remember was the feeling
- 40:45that I already done ketamine." So, this
- 40:47is a huge point of contention in Jane
- 40:49Doe's lawsuit. She brings up before the
- 40:51initial threesome that they ask her if
- 40:54she wants ketamine, and she feels like
- 40:55they're pushing her. That's kind of the
- 40:57vague language she gives. It's never
- 40:58straightforward of I did the ketamine
- 41:01right before the act. It's vague.
- 41:03However, during the Title 9
- 41:04investigations, the Title 9 panel, this
- 41:07is not a criminal investigation, but
- 41:08they concluded that they believe Jane's
- 41:11statements of taking ketamine. They
- 41:13believe that her not remembering the
- 41:15first time she took ketamine is on par
- 41:17with people taking ketamine because it
- 41:19is kind of a dissociating drug where you
- 41:21may not remember taking it. On top of
- 41:24that, they think that her candor, her
- 41:25honesty of being so straightforward of
- 41:28like, "I think I took it on the couch
- 41:30because I have this feeling." They think
- 41:31that actually goes against her
- 41:33credibility, and she, if she really
- 41:35wanted to have this story be believed,
- 41:38she would just say, "I did take the
- 41:39ketamine." Whereas the guys, they the
- 41:41panel points out in their decision, they
- 41:43have differing Matthew and Jonathan and
- 41:45then it's specifically Jonathan is like,
- 41:47"Well, she don't want the ketamine." And
- 41:49then later he's like, "Yeah, we gave her
- 41:50ketamine." So, it's very they they're
- 41:52inclined to believe Jane's story that
- 41:53this is now the second time.
- 42:00Black Friday's coming, and for
- 42:01businesses, that means it's almost time
- 42:03for one of the biggest shopping seasons
- 42:05of the year. Shopify gives you the tools
- 42:08to launch, sell, and grow, so you're
- 42:10ready for the rush. When we did our
- 42:11limited edition drop of hoodies, one of
- 42:14the team members was worried things
- 42:15would crash on our side, but honestly,
- 42:17it didn't even cross my mind because I
- 42:19knew Shopify would pull through. It
- 42:20wasn't even a worry of mine since
- 42:22Shopify handles drops 100 times larger
- 42:24than ours.
- 42:25Probably even more. And of course, we
- 42:27had nothing to worry about. The drop
- 42:29went amazing on our side of things and
- 42:31we had labels printing in no time. It
- 42:33was so seamless, all thanks to Shopify.
- 42:36With Shopify, you can launch your store
- 42:38and start selling in just a few simple
- 42:39steps. No e-commerce expertise required.
- 42:42And once you're up and running,
- 42:43Shopify's mobile app lets you manage
- 42:45your store from pretty much anywhere,
- 42:47including inventory, customer support,
- 42:50and payments. And if you launch before
- 42:52Black Friday, you can take advantage of
- 42:53the extra online traffic that comes with
- 42:55the holiday shopping season. If you're
- 42:57ready to launch your business before
- 42:58Black Friday, go to shopify.com/rotten
- 43:01to start your free trial. That's
- 43:03shopify.com/rotten.
- 43:04Go to shopify.com/rotten
- 43:06today to hear your first cha-ching.
- 43:14Spooky season might get your adrenaline
- 43:17pumping, but one thing that shouldn't be
- 43:19a total nightmare, college. With
- 43:21Southern New Hampshire University,
- 43:23earning your degree doesn't have to feel
- 43:24scary. They've got a super simple
- 43:26admissions process and tons of support
- 43:28for online students. Oh, and no jump
- 43:31scares either. Just predictable weekly
- 43:33deadlines you can count on. So yeah, let
- 43:35your favorite horror movie get your
- 43:37heart racing, but don't let college
- 43:39scare you. Apply for free at
- 43:41snhu.edu/rottenmango.
- 43:50She says, "I thought if I do ketamine
- 43:52again, maybe I'll pass out. My thought
- 43:54was if I pass out and these men had sex
- 43:56with me, they could be charged with
- 43:58rape."
- 43:58At that point, they poured a line of
- 44:01ketamine and she says that she did it
- 44:04from Jonathan's erect private [music]
- 44:06part. She snorted at She says, I snorted
- 44:08a line of ketamine which was a heavy
- 44:10amount of ketamine. I know it was a
- 44:11heavy amount based on how hard it hit
- 44:13me. At that point, I was back under the
- 44:14covers and redacted got under the covers
- 44:16with me where he again tried reaching
- 44:18for the area of my vagina. Side note, I
- 44:21will say some of the accused will either
- 44:23claim that they never saw her do that
- 44:25second hit of ketamine or that the
- 44:26timing of when they came into the alumni
- 44:28room was after they she did the
- 44:30ketamine. It's just everyone saying I
- 44:32didn't see any drugs or others that said
- 44:35they saw it were like, she didn't do it
- 44:36off of Jonathan's body part, she did it
- 44:38off of a key like we all did cuz that's
- 44:40how you do ketamine. As for Jonathan, he
- 44:41says he has no recollection of Jane Doe
- 44:43doing ketamine off of his body, but he
- 44:44also acknowledged, quote, there are
- 44:46pieces of his memory that he just can't
- 44:47remember. This is the panel decision.
- 44:49Holes in his memory from that night. He
- 44:51also says he doesn't remember if he did
- 44:53ketamine off of Jane's body, but that it
- 44:55definitely could have happened. Jane
- 44:56Doe's statement continues. At that
- 44:58point, the group of men began flooding
- 44:59me with compliments about my body. All
- 45:01of them were talking about how pretty I
- 45:03was which was very confusing to me
- 45:04because although it's very nice to hear
- 45:06those things being said, I was still
- 45:08very uncomfortable with the situation I
- 45:10was in. Okay, side note, this is an
- 45:12opinion by a lot of netizens and it's a
- 45:15very nuanced opinion that I think a lot
- 45:16of people are going to be upset about.
- 45:18I'm not saying I agree with this
- 45:20opinion, but it's just food for thought.
- 45:22Some people are saying this statement is
- 45:24very interesting because she's saying
- 45:26they're complimenting me and they're all
- 45:28saying how perfect my body is. People
- 45:30thought, oh, this girl is so insecure
- 45:32and so vain. She's like, oh my god, you
- 45:34think my body is perfect? Yeah, do lines
- 45:37of me off of me. But some netizens are
- 45:38saying
- 45:39this sounds like a group of men who are
- 45:43humiliating you and coercing you into
- 45:45things. All of them are complimenting
- 45:47your perfect body and she's saying I'm
- 45:49still very uncomfortable. Maybe she
- 45:51feels it's not genuine. Maybe she feels
- 45:54that there's something weird going on.
- 45:56It's just a very odd statement. I think
- 45:58people are trying to wrap their minds
- 45:59around and I I a lot of people are
- 46:00pulling from their own anecdotal
- 46:02experience of being around certain
- 46:04people. That does not mean that that's
- 46:06what these seven were doing, but
- 46:08>> Yeah.
- 46:08>> It's interesting. It's food for thought.
- 46:10She says shortly after that, I believe
- 46:11it was redacted and everyone fights
- 46:14about who asked the question of if they
- 46:16can do ketamine off of her body first.
- 46:18So the seven accused are fighting about
- 46:20who it was, right? So we don't know, but
- 46:22one of them asks if they could do drugs
- 46:23off of her perfect body. She says,
- 46:25"Seeing as I was already laying down and
- 46:27feeling extremely tired, I told him
- 46:29sure." And then a group of men all
- 46:31started pouring various things all over
- 46:32my body. I couldn't tell what they were
- 46:34pouring on me as I had my face covered
- 46:36with my hands. They allegedly snort
- 46:38ketamine off of her unclothed body. And
- 46:41this point becomes a huge debate because
- 46:45of the words "I had my face covered with
- 46:48my hands." A lot of the defense
- 46:50attorneys and a lot of the Title 9
- 46:52investigation was pushing back on, "Then
- 46:55how do you know who took ketamine off
- 46:57your body if you weren't seeing it?"
- 46:59It's a whole thing. In a separate room
- 47:01in the fraternity house that night, like
- 47:02I said, there are three people: Scott
- 47:04Norris, Scott Kretschmar, and [music]
- 47:06Diego Sarabia. Diego at one point, just
- 47:09like leaves the two Scotts. Scott K's
- 47:12vape dies, he wants to borrow someone
- 47:13else's, and Scott K apparently knows
- 47:15that Jonathan in the alumni room has got
- 47:18a vape. So he's like, "I'm going to go
- 47:20and I'm going to check it out." Scott K
- 47:21is like, "Hey Scott Norris, you want to
- 47:23come check it out with me?" And also,
- 47:25remember that Snapchat message that we
- 47:27saw? And like also, Diego was kind of
- 47:29drunk and he left abruptly, so like we
- 47:31should check up on him because where did
- 47:33he go?
- 47:34>> I love how the reason for them of going
- 47:36is number one, get a vape pen. Number
- 47:38two, check out their friends. Number
- 47:40three, by the way, there's a Snapchat.
- 47:41>> It's like a afterthought.
- 47:42>> Yeah.
- 47:43>> About the whole Snapchat, you know, who
- 47:44I believe to be Scott Norris says, "We
- 47:46saw that text and we were somewhat
- 47:47concerned, but thought it could just be
- 47:49crude humor." In a later follow-up, who
- 47:52I believe to be Scott Norris says, "I
- 47:53thought at that point it was just kind
- 47:54of an absurd joke. No one really thought
- 47:56I was being serious. Like when we went
- 47:58in there, I thought at the time like
- 47:59thinking it was kind of a joke and
- 48:00attention-seeking joke, kind of like to
- 48:02get people to come to the alumni room.
- 48:04And my concerns that it wasn't kind of
- 48:07alleviated because people are just
- 48:08hanging out in there.
- 48:09>> [music]
- 48:09>> So, on his way to the alumni room, he's
- 48:11having a lot of thoughts, I guess,
- 48:13right? I don't know how big this
- 48:14fraternity house is, but he's on a
- 48:16journey [music] and he's just thinking,
- 48:18"Ooh, maybe it's a joke. Maybe it's not
- 48:19a joke. Maybe it is a joke. It's kind of
- 48:21weird. Let's go check it out. My
- 48:22friend's in there. Vape pen. Oh, but
- 48:24also like maybe it's not a joke. Then
- 48:26that's very scary if it's not a joke."
- 48:27But then he opens the door and he's
- 48:28like, "Oh, everyone seems to be just
- 48:30hanging out. So, good thing. I feel
- 48:31better about this." Like that's the vibe
- 48:33he gives.
- 48:34>> So, he's saying like there is a part of
- 48:36his brain thinking something really bad
- 48:38is going on in there.
- 48:39>> It's kind of like, "Ooh, I don't know.
- 48:41Yeah."
- 48:42>> is I'm worried, but he also felt like
- 48:44could be something bad, right? Like that
- 48:46part.
- 48:47>> I think they get tripped up. I This is
- 48:49my opinion. This is my opinion. I think
- 48:51they get tripped up because they're
- 48:53like, "We wanted to check up on Diego,
- 48:54our friend, cuz we were worried about
- 48:55him." Why are you worried about him if
- 48:57it's just a joke? So, then it's like,
- 48:58"Well, then a part of me is like, I
- 48:59don't think it's That's the vibe I get."
- 49:01>> he worried about?
- 49:02>> Exactly. Exactly.
- 49:04>> is like there's so many ways of
- 49:06explaining a situation that we all are
- 49:10understanding what all everyone's going
- 49:13there trying to do.
- 49:14>> And in the panel decision in the John
- 49:16Doe lawsuit, it seems to hint at the
- 49:18fact that the panel acknowledges that
- 49:20the two Scotts don't typically hang out
- 49:23in the alumni room. So, like I said,
- 49:24they're further removed from the group
- 49:26of people, the group of the seven. It
- 49:28seems like their link is Diego in this
- 49:30Snapchat group. But he emphasizes later,
- 49:32"We seriously, I'll emphasize, seriously
- 49:36did not think there was anything going
- 49:38on. We thought it was a joke." So, then
- 49:40one of the Scotts, I think it's Scott
- 49:42Norris, but I could be wrong, is asked
- 49:44by the panel, "Okay, well, you think
- 49:45it's a joke, but like how do you
- 49:47interpret the words free pussy?" And he
- 49:49responds, "It's just that. There's a
- 49:51free girl in the room." But again, no
- 49:52one took that literally as meaning
- 49:54there's a free girl in the room.
- 49:55>> This is crazy.
- 49:56>> And this investigation spans months, and
- 49:58they couldn't even think of a better a
- 49:59better statement than that? It stated
- 50:01that perhaps Scott Norris and Scott K go
- 50:03to investigate, and um Scott Norris
- 50:06says, "And also, it sounds kind of
- 50:08silly, but Scott K's vape had died, and
- 50:11he knew Jonathan Newell had a vape in
- 50:13there. So, that's just another reason,
- 50:14right, that they're going to the alumni
- 50:16room." And they were probably in there
- 50:17for maybe 5 minutes. And while they were
- 50:19in there, they say that Jane Doe was
- 50:20laughing and talking with the others.
- 50:21She did not seem incapacitated. She They
- 50:24did not observe any drug usage from Jane
- 50:26or anybody else. Nobody was doing
- 50:28cocaine or ketamine off of Jane or
- 50:29whatever. Nothing. Scott K also has a
- 50:32similar story, and he says, "Yes, it was
- 50:34because of his vape." He says, "I was
- 50:35hitting a nicotine vape at that point."
- 50:38It was almost dead. And this is where I
- 50:39will say it gets very confusing. So,
- 50:42when they opened that Snapchat message,
- 50:44when I was interpreting these snippets,
- 50:46and obviously these are snippets, so I
- 50:47don't have the full story, but at some
- 50:49point I was under the understanding that
- 50:52the two Scotts are in the room, Diego
- 50:53leaves, and then they open the Snapchat
- 50:55together, and they're like,
- 50:56>> Yeah.
- 50:56>> "What happened, right?"
- 50:57>> Yeah.
- 50:57>> But, then later one of them was like, "I
- 50:59was in the foyer area when I opened it,
- 51:01and then I went to go up to the room
- 51:02where Scott K was." So, it I was getting
- 51:05confused. Now, I don't know if that's
- 51:07the fault of there only being snippets
- 51:09in the Jane Doe lawsuit, or if it's the
- 51:11fault of my reading comprehension,
- 51:12though I would hope that it's not, or if
- 51:15it's just unclear.
- 51:17>> What is exactly would be the difference?
- 51:20>> The difference would be that everyone's
- 51:21pointing out small discrepancies in Jane
- 51:23Doe's story, but there are also parts of
- 51:26these random snippets of the Title IX
- 51:27investigation where I go, "Wait, I feel
- 51:29like that's not what was said earlier."
- 51:31>> You just feel like there's inconsistency
- 51:33with the account. Like
- 51:34>> Yes.
- 51:34>> Did you see this in the beginning, or
- 51:36did you see it later in the room?
- 51:38>> Yes. Now, to everybody's defense,
- 51:41including Jane Doe and the seven
- 51:42accused, just because there are
- 51:44discrepancies does not mean that anyone
- 51:45was committing a crime. I mean,
- 51:47everybody was drunk and high at some
- 51:49point in the night, so it could just be
- 51:51that, but I was just noticing if
- 51:53everyone's pointing out Jane Doe's small
- 51:54inconsistencies, there are other
- 51:56inconsistencies out there.
- 51:58>> Where did they point out Jane Doe's
- 51:59inconsistency so far? Or is it later
- 52:02>> Uh the biggest one has to do with the
- 52:04fact that in these reports, the six-page
- 52:06report, the transcripts, and in earlier
- 52:08statements, even in much of the Title IX
- 52:10investigation, it seems that Jane Doe
- 52:12reports that the very first sexual
- 52:14encounter with Matthew and Jonathan, she
- 52:16pretty okay with it. Then her lawsuit in
- 52:182026 states that that was an instance of
- 52:22>> Got it.
- 52:23>> Scott K says he's hitting his nicotine
- 52:25vape at that point and it's almost dead.
- 52:27Then Scott Norris gets there and they
- 52:29talk for about two minutes. Diego leaves
- 52:32the room, they don't know why. So now
- 52:34it's just two Scotts and a dead vape.
- 52:36After about 10 or 15 minutes with Diego
- 52:38still being gone, I checked my phone in
- 52:40the actives group and there was a text
- 52:41message that said free [ __ ] and alumni.
- 52:43I had no idea what that text meant. I
- 52:44was kind of befuddled. These are the
- 52:46words. I was kind of befuddled. So me
- 52:48and Scott talked about it and the person
- 52:50that sent the message, he lived in that
- 52:51room. Jonathan lives in the alumni room.
- 52:53And I knew he had a vape.
- 52:54>> Oh, yeah.
- 52:55>> This is when they connect Jonathan has a
- 52:57vape. It's after they see the text
- 52:58message, after they see the Snapchat.
- 53:01Jonathan apparently has other things in
- 53:02that room, okay? But no, you're like, I
- 53:04need the vape. And he says, and my vape
- 53:06had just died. And we also speculated
- 53:08that maybe this is where redacted, I
- 53:10think Diego, had just got up and left.
- 53:12And us not knowing the nature of if this
- 53:14was a joke or what was going on in the
- 53:16alumni room, me and Scott Norris decided
- 53:18to go into that room. When asked about
- 53:20his specific motivations of going into
- 53:21the alumni room, he says, "By no means
- 53:23were we going there to get free [ __ ]
- 53:25That was not our intention at all. We
- 53:27were just checking out to see if
- 53:28everything was okay." They get to the
- 53:30alumni [music] room and it's reported
- 53:32that they see Jane in bed with people
- 53:33underneath the covers and they say, "We
- 53:36don't even see her nude." That she was
- 53:38just engaging in conversations.
- 53:39Everybody was talking coherently. That
- 53:41Jane at some point laughed because
- 53:43[music] the two Scotts had the same
- 53:44first name, but they were probably in
- 53:45there for like 5 minutes. They're pushed
- 53:48The two Scotts are pushed about this
- 53:49even more because, again, like I said,
- 53:51some of the fraternity brothers, they
- 53:53have a reason to be in there because
- 53:54they live in there or they have friends
- 53:55in there. The two Scotts are a little
- 53:57bit more removed and this vape excuse is
- 53:59bizarre. So, they're pushed and one of
- 54:01them says, "The text could have meant
- 54:02anything. There was a lot of things
- 54:04going on through my head. I didn't know
- 54:05if there was a lot of girls in there or
- 54:07what was going on, but again, free [ __ ]
- 54:09just seems like someone could be in
- 54:11danger, could have been in danger. It's
- 54:13just free." What does free mean?
- 54:18anything." They elaborate, "Because if
- 54:21someone's having sex with someone in the
- 54:22room, they're not going to send that
- 54:23text out. So, again, I just didn't know
- 54:25what was really happening in the room. I
- 54:27just didn't think it was real." Then
- 54:29Scott K is asked, "Well, then why did
- 54:32you respond in the Snapchat group?"
- 54:34Because he responds, "The alumni [ __ ] is
- 54:36not a bit. Firsthand POV, not a bit."
- 54:41So, you're saying you went in there like
- 54:44free [ __ ] this could be dangerous. You
- 54:46went in there, vape, Diego, free [ __ ]
- 54:49oh no, do I need to save someone?
- 54:51And then you're like, no, I don't need
- 54:53to save anyone because everyone's having
- 54:54a good time, but you text the alumni
- 54:56[ __ ] is not a bit. Firsthand POV, not a
- 54:59bit.
- 55:00>> Exactly, that's contradicting.
- 55:01>> Yeah, it doesn't make any sense and he's
- 55:03like, you know, it's crazy. It's crazy,
- 55:06but I sent that text message before I
- 55:08went into the alumni room. So, I'm
- 55:09outside the alumni room and people are
- 55:11chitter-chattering about what's
- 55:13happening inside and like I guess the
- 55:15indicate like the insinuation is like,
- 55:17oh, people are saying some crazy things
- 55:18like, oh my god, they're like having an
- 55:19orgy in there. And he got so excited, he
- 55:22texted back into the Snapchat group. But
- 55:24he's like, that was before I went into
- 55:26the alumni room. He says, quote, I found
- 55:28out from someone passing by as I was
- 55:30walking into the alumni room that there
- 55:31was a girl in there. So, I was just
- 55:33saying like I mean firsthand from
- 55:35somebody else that was, you know, there
- 55:37was a girl in that room and it started a
- 55:38joke.
- 55:39Yeah. Again, these are Cornell students.
- 55:42I don't know how the [ __ ] they got in,
- 55:43but again, he says it was immature and
- 55:46dumb, kind of just following along with
- 55:48what everybody else was saying in there.
- 55:49I shouldn't have said it and it was
- 55:51immature and a stupid message for sure.
- 55:53However, one thing I will note is that
- 55:55the two Scotts, their their involvement
- 55:59in all of this is confusing compared to
- 56:02the others.
- 56:03Jane Doe in multiple reports says that
- 56:06the two Scotts were
- 56:08more like voyeurs in the situation.
- 56:11So, they were not maybe necessarily
- 56:14involved in a lot of the acts. At some
- 56:16point, it seemed like it was alleged
- 56:18that the two Scotts had taken ketamine
- 56:20off of Jane Doe's body. However, one of
- 56:22them submitted a hair follicle test that
- 56:24came back negative for ketamine and this
- 56:26was just like a month after. And
- 56:28ketamine usually stay stays in the hair
- 56:30quite a bit. So, there's a lot of debate
- 56:32and in other reports, Jane Doe states
- 56:34that the two Scotts, they were
- 56:35comforting her to degree because she was
- 56:37trying to get up and she was very dizzy
- 56:39and nauseous and they were just telling
- 56:40her like take all the time you need. So,
- 56:42the the Scotts' involvement, I guess, is
- 56:45a little more unclear for netizens.
- 56:48Should they have gone to the alumni
- 56:49room? No, and I think that's what the
- 56:50panel is saying. But the panel did not
- 56:53find the two Scotts
- 56:55guilty by the panel standard of sexual
- 56:58assault. So, they found the two Scotts
- 56:59guilty of sexual exploitation, meaning
- 57:02they walked into the alumni room wanting
- 57:05to see someone naked who probably would
- 57:06not consent to being seen naked by them.
- 57:09Because they don't even hang out in the
- 57:10alumni room. So, they you went out of
- 57:12your way to go to the alumni room. So,
- 57:13they didn't believe the whole vape Diego
- 57:15and like let me just check it out
- 57:17excuse. And the Scotts, um, they don't
- 57:20like the panel decision. Then Gillio
- 57:22walks back in, according to Jane Doe,
- 57:24okay? So, Gillio, he's the one that was
- 57:26in the room making out with Jane Doe,
- 57:28according to Jane Doe, and engaged in
- 57:30the sexual activity with Jane Doe and
- 57:32Jonathan. Giulio apparently walks back
- 57:34in and is like, "We're shutting down
- 57:35whatever the [ __ ] this is." And Jane
- 57:38Doe's statement reflects a lot of
- 57:39netizen confusion. Her report that lands
- 57:42on the DA's desk, it reads, "I found
- 57:44this strange because Giulio was acting
- 57:45as if he hadn't been in the room with me
- 57:47earlier that night. I think I even said
- 57:49something along the lines of like,
- 57:50'Wait, didn't this guy just [ __ ] me?'
- 57:52When Giulio and redacted said they were
- 57:54shutting it down, the group of men all
- 57:56began to scatter. I attempted to get up
- 57:58off the bed but became very dizzy due to
- 58:00my POTS as well as the fact that I had
- 58:02consumed the extra bump of ketamine. I
- 58:03remember one of the, I believe the
- 58:05Scots, had his hand on my back and he
- 58:07encouraged me to stay seated for as long
- 58:09as I needed to. Even told the other men
- 58:11to give me a second so that I could
- 58:12gather myself." Eventually, I was able
- 58:14to stand up from the bed and someone was
- 58:16able to get my dress and bring it to me.
- 58:18I then put my dress on but I had to sit
- 58:20down again due to how dizzy I was. At
- 58:22this point, she says that she's ushered
- 58:23upstairs to the faux-fice by Matthew and
- 58:26Winston Lee.
- 58:27>> So this is when Winston Lee finally
- 58:29showed up?
- 58:30>> Well, he's in the alumni room. He's
- 58:31accused of doing ketamine off of Jane
- 58:33Doe's body.
- 58:33>> Oh, oh, so he came in way much earlier.
- 58:36He's just been around, okay.
- 58:38>> Yes. So he's been around and now he is
- 58:40allegedly taking Jane Doe upstairs with
- 58:42Matthew. [music]
- 58:43And this is who I believe to be Winston
- 58:45Lee in the redacted Title IX snippets of
- 58:48the John Doe lawsuit. And most of the
- 58:49context is pulled from the fact that
- 58:51he's upstairs in the faux-fice. So
- 58:53Winston is a very, like he has distinct
- 58:55markers that I think indicate it's
- 58:57Winston even though his name is
- 58:58redacted. Because he's the only other
- 59:00party in the faux-fice, Matthew was not
- 59:02interviewed by Title IX.
- 59:03>> Ah, so this is this person's account
- 59:06upstairs.
- 59:06>> Yes. So it seems to me, again, I can't
- 59:09say with certainty because it's
- 59:10redacted, but it seems to me to be
- 59:12Winston. Winston says that he met Jane
- 59:14Doe a week before the incident. They had
- 59:16some casual conversations but Winston
- 59:18wasn't really like bonding with Jane
- 59:20Doe. So it seems like Jane Doe had come
- 59:22to Kai Phi a week prior. Winston meets
- 59:24her. He's not really engaged. He said
- 59:26that he was on his phone playing poker
- 59:28most of the time. The night in question
- 59:30though, when he gets to the alumni room,
- 59:32he says this is not odd for him. The
- 59:34alumni room is a social room of his
- 59:36pledge class. So, these are like his
- 59:38pledge classmates. Which usually in a
- 59:41fraternity you're the closest to your
- 59:42pledge class. These are the people that
- 59:44you went through initiation and hazing
- 59:45with typically.
- 59:46>> Yeah.
- 59:47>> So, he says, you know, this is our
- 59:47pledge class. It's the social room and I
- 59:49go at least like once a day in that
- 59:51room. So, he walks into the alumni room
- 59:53again on October 19th. He recalls three
- 59:55people under the sheets in one of the
- 59:57beds and he walks in. So, this seems to
- 1:00:00be Jane, Matthew, and Jonathan. So,
- 1:00:02after Gilio leaves, it's Winston. I
- 1:00:05believe to be Winston. Now, he's talking
- 1:00:06to some of the other people in the room
- 1:00:08and while everyone's talking, he says he
- 1:00:09remembers Jane Doe took off the covers
- 1:00:12and I think at one point she was
- 1:00:13flexing.
- 1:00:14>> Okay.
- 1:00:14>> Right. So, this is like when she maybe
- 1:00:16is upset at Diego.
- 1:00:18>> I love how, you know, these accounts are
- 1:00:20it could be a similar incident, but the
- 1:00:22focal point is always different for
- 1:00:24everybody's POV. For his POV it's just
- 1:00:26like, oh yeah, she out naked and posing.
- 1:00:29>> Yeah. She is just like took off the
- 1:00:31covers.
- 1:00:31>> Yeah, there's no context. There's no
- 1:00:33why. It's
- 1:00:33>> Yeah.
- 1:00:34>> He later says in a different interview
- 1:00:35that when Jane Doe did this, by default,
- 1:00:37the covers fell off, right? And that is
- 1:00:40when he also discovered that Jonathan
- 1:00:42was unclothed as well. So, he seems it
- 1:00:46seems like maybe Winston is expressing
- 1:00:47shock that not only is Jane unclothed,
- 1:00:50but woah, like now I'm looking at this
- 1:00:52other guy that's un- like what's
- 1:00:53happening? What's going on under the
- 1:00:54covers? He's like, I wasn't expecting to
- 1:00:56see that. That's the vibe. In a later
- 1:00:58interview, he says that an alarm bell
- 1:00:59rang in his head when he first realized
- 1:01:01Jane Doe was nude, but quote, it kind of
- 1:01:03quickly dissipated when she spoke and
- 1:01:05she seemed like she was having fun. He
- 1:01:06says that he recalls Jane Doe joking
- 1:01:08about an attempted threesome that
- 1:01:10failed. And then they start doing the
- 1:01:12ketamine off of Jane Doe's body. And
- 1:01:14maybe Winston says, and I asked her,
- 1:01:16Jane, is this okay? And to which she
- 1:01:19said that I could take ketamine off of
- 1:01:20her body. So, given that I had consent,
- 1:01:24he says he took the ketamine that was
- 1:01:25laid out for him around Jane Doe's
- 1:01:27stomach, around her belly button area.
- 1:01:29And, quote, "While I was taking the
- 1:01:31ketamine off of Jane Doe's body, she was
- 1:01:32actually pulling down my pants, like
- 1:01:34tugging down my pants, and kind of like
- 1:01:36in a sexual way. I kind of flinched, and
- 1:01:38I kind of took a step back because I
- 1:01:39didn't want to engage in anything like
- 1:01:40sex."
- 1:01:42But, he says that after he snorted the
- 1:01:43ketamine off of Jane Doe's body, he
- 1:01:45starts feeling the effects. And again, I
- 1:01:47think this is Winston. "I remember
- 1:01:49talking to them. Then the ketamine
- 1:01:51started to hit harder, maybe [music]
- 1:01:53like 5-7 minutes later, and I decided to
- 1:01:56lay down on the bed where Jane Doe was
- 1:01:58sitting on. And I just laid there for
- 1:01:59like 30 minutes unconscious."
- 1:02:03Remember how the Scotts walk in?
- 1:02:05No one said they saw a dude that's
- 1:02:06unconscious. Everybody's talking,
- 1:02:08everybody's having a good time,
- 1:02:09everybody's coherent, but now suddenly
- 1:02:11we got a man that's unconscious, okay?
- 1:02:13>> Yeah.
- 1:02:15>> He goes on to elaborate. "When I was
- 1:02:16unconscious, I remember people coming
- 1:02:18and going into the alumni room, but I
- 1:02:20did not know who they were. And then
- 1:02:21when I woke up, everyone had left the
- 1:02:22alumni room."
- 1:02:24How do you know that if you're
- 1:02:25unconscious? Unconscious has a pretty
- 1:02:27firm definition. I'm sorry. Like, are
- 1:02:29you guys not students at Cornell
- 1:02:30University, one of the most prestigious,
- 1:02:32oldest institutions of high academia?
- 1:02:35Like, it's so odd. I guess he ends up
- 1:02:37clarifying to the panel, the Title IX
- 1:02:39panel. "When I said I was unconscious in
- 1:02:41the alumni room, what I was trying to
- 1:02:43say is that I was out of it. I was
- 1:02:45looking at the ceiling the entire time,
- 1:02:47closing my eyes, and going into a lapse
- 1:02:49of
- 1:02:50just was sleeping, I guess, and waking
- 1:02:53up and blinking and then closing my eyes
- 1:02:54again. I was very much
- 1:02:56>> [music]
- 1:02:56>> concerned more about my sense of being
- 1:02:58and my own consciousness."
- 1:03:01Which seems to be a very lengthy way to
- 1:03:04describe [music]
- 1:03:05being conscious to some degree, right?
- 1:03:08Rather than unconscious. I mean, this
- 1:03:10one is really putting his Ivy League
- 1:03:12education to use. I'm not saying that
- 1:03:14his version of events isn't true, and it
- 1:03:16honestly could be true that that is what
- 1:03:18he felt he experienced because that is
- 1:03:21the effect of ketamine a lot of netizens
- 1:03:22are arguing. So, it does sound on par
- 1:03:24with ketamine usage of like you're
- 1:03:26there, but you're not really there. Like
- 1:03:28you can see people coming and going, but
- 1:03:29you're kind of
- 1:03:30>> out of it.
- 1:03:31>> Yeah, but you're not unconscious. I
- 1:03:33mean, that's a very limited definition.
- 1:03:36It's not a vague definition by any
- 1:03:37means, but
- 1:03:39it's a disorienting experience, sure.
- 1:03:41But one thing that is odd is nobody
- 1:03:42reports seeing a guy that's unconscious.
- 1:03:45So, it's semi-conscious or
- 1:03:46semi-unconscious, who knows? One of them
- 1:03:49are even asked because the panel is
- 1:03:51like, "Okay, well now now we know
- 1:03:52someone's unconscious. Let's go ask
- 1:03:54everybody else. What do you guys do
- 1:03:55about the unconscious guy?"
- 1:03:57>> No way.
- 1:03:58>> Yeah.
- 1:03:59And one of the Scotts responds, "No.
- 1:04:01If when I walked in, someone was
- 1:04:03sleeping, I would have been like, 'Is he
- 1:04:04okay?' or that kind of thing. So, I know
- 1:04:06that no one was sleeping. Everyone was
- 1:04:07pretty lively and awake."
- 1:04:09>> Oh, so who's lying?
- 1:04:11>> Exactly. I mean, I guess you could argue
- 1:04:13that perhaps timelines are not matching
- 1:04:14up, but that doesn't seem to be the
- 1:04:16case.
- 1:04:17>> Mhm. I see.
- 1:04:18>> Maybe he awoke and was suddenly
- 1:04:21just so full of energy.
- 1:04:23>> Mhm.
- 1:04:23>> Another one of the accused stated that
- 1:04:26everyone was awake the whole time. Kind
- 1:04:28of weird, [music] yeah. So, then the
- 1:04:29panel goes back to this individual who I
- 1:04:31believe to be Winston, but I could be
- 1:04:32wrong just judging by the timeline.
- 1:04:34Seems like it's Winston, but again. And
- 1:04:36they ask, "Were you engaging with other
- 1:04:38people when you were unconscious, not
- 1:04:39unconscious, laying there for 30
- 1:04:41minutes? What were you doing?" And they
- 1:04:43respond, "I was very much concerned more
- 1:04:45about my sense of being and my own
- 1:04:47consciousness. It could be possible, but
- 1:04:49I would doubt it. Perhaps I was, [music]
- 1:04:51I'm not completely sure." He explains
- 1:04:53why he even participated in snorting
- 1:04:55ketamine off of Jane Doe and he goes on
- 1:04:57to explain,
- 1:04:58>> [music]
- 1:04:58>> "I think when I first entered the alumni
- 1:05:00room, I was first of all greeted by
- 1:05:02three people who seemed to be having a
- 1:05:04lot of fun and who seemed not to mind
- 1:05:07the fact that ketamine was active in
- 1:05:09that room. But also, I feel
- 1:05:11maybe I was charmed [music] by their
- 1:05:13energy and the fact that they were
- 1:05:15having fun and I wanted to have fun as
- 1:05:17well.
- 1:05:18Which is a very strange description.
- 1:05:20Even in my most dramatic of days where I
- 1:05:23believed I was a character in Vampire
- 1:05:25Diaries just journaling away, I have
- 1:05:27never uttered the words, written down
- 1:05:29the words, I was charmed by the energy.
- 1:05:32If someone wrote this in a book, BookTok
- 1:05:34would flame them because it's so What
- 1:05:36are you even talking about right now?
- 1:05:38What are you saying? I was charmed by
- 1:05:39the energy. The energy being a
- 1:05:41fraternity room and atmosphere, it's so
- 1:05:43far removed from the word usage, it
- 1:05:46doesn't even remotely register in my
- 1:05:49brain. If I just read that, I would
- 1:05:50never imagine it's a fraternity room.
- 1:05:52>> Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah.
- 1:05:54>> Like maybe a pep rally, but strange. But
- 1:05:57that's why they did the ketamine. And
- 1:05:59they say, you know, in hindsight, the
- 1:06:00act of consuming substance off of
- 1:06:02someone's body is ludicrous in
- 1:06:05hindsight.
- 1:06:07Now, this next statement, it's kind of
- 1:06:08hard to decipher whether it's Winston or
- 1:06:10Diego. It is redacted, but this is
- 1:06:13talking about doing ketamine off of
- 1:06:15Jane's body. Another one of the accused
- 1:06:16states in the Title IX panel,
- 1:06:19"When I was first uncomfortable, I kind
- 1:06:21of felt overridden by how positive
- 1:06:23everyone was in the room. Maybe I'm the
- 1:06:25one that's being weird if everyone
- 1:06:26around me is looking so joyous and happy
- 1:06:29to be talking to one another."
- 1:06:31And yeah, eventually after redacted
- 1:06:33[music]
- 1:06:34did the action of ketamine off of her
- 1:06:35body, he said something to the effect of
- 1:06:38I should do it as well. And since being
- 1:06:40in [music] this positive atmosphere, I
- 1:06:41eventually asked as well.
- 1:06:44>> Crazy.
- 1:06:45>> Joyous, happy, positive, charmed.
- 1:06:49>> Yeah.
- 1:06:49>> What's happening? Like I think it would
- 1:06:52have been better if they were just like,
- 1:06:53"Hey,
- 1:06:54I was getting [ __ ] up like a frat
- 1:06:55bro."
- 1:06:56>> Yeah.
- 1:06:57>> Cuz that's what I do, cuz I'm a
- 1:06:58brainless frat bro. And everyone would
- 1:06:59say, "That actually makes a little more
- 1:07:01sense."
- 1:07:02>> Yeah.
- 1:07:02>> This individual becomes more conscious
- 1:07:04around 3:15 a.m. where he walks to the
- 1:07:06pents, the president's room, which this
- 1:07:08is why I think this is Winston Lee's
- 1:07:10statement, right? Cuz this is upstairs
- 1:07:11now.
- 1:07:12So, and Matthew was not interviewed by
- 1:07:14the panel. Where they say that they go
- 1:07:16into the president's room and they see
- 1:07:18Orazio Patito and they also see Orazio
- 1:07:20Patito's date
- 1:07:22>> [music]
- 1:07:22>> and Matthew, Jane Doe, and Winston.
- 1:07:24They're all in the president's room now.
- 1:07:25But this girl was later interviewed by
- 1:07:28the panel and she said that Jane Doe
- 1:07:31seemed not disoriented. She did not seem
- 1:07:34incapacitated.
- 1:07:36>> Okay.
- 1:07:37>> This individual claims that they were
- 1:07:38all up there for an hour having lively
- 1:07:40nice conversations in the president's
- 1:07:42room. And Jane specifically mentions
- 1:07:45something along the lines of quote,
- 1:07:46"It's weird, but I don't think I can
- 1:07:48feel the effects of ketamine."
- 1:07:50Who I believe to be Winston says his
- 1:07:52reaction was just surprise. He says,
- 1:07:54"For me, I was like, oh, so you were
- 1:07:55taking ketamine in the alumni room?" I
- 1:07:56was shocked. So, he's saying like he
- 1:07:58didn't see Jane do ketamine all night.
- 1:07:59So, he's like, "Oh, I didn't even know
- 1:08:01you were you did ketamine."
- 1:08:03It seems to be Winston because the
- 1:08:04previous week there was conversations
- 1:08:06about ketamine
- 1:08:07>> Mhm.
- 1:08:08>> when they met and he seems to be one of
- 1:08:09the people that met her the previous
- 1:08:10anyway.
- 1:08:11He states that there were people outside
- 1:08:13the president's room just lingering,
- 1:08:15listening in on the conversations
- 1:08:17because rumors had already started
- 1:08:18coming out that quote, "Some weird
- 1:08:20sexual activities were happening in the
- 1:08:21alumni room." But later he adds, "I do
- 1:08:24not know there were rumors going around
- 1:08:25that night."
- 1:08:27He's like, "I didn't know there were
- 1:08:29rumors."
- 1:08:30>> Okay.
- 1:08:30>> Which is kind of weird because if this
- 1:08:32is Winston, he did [music] respond in
- 1:08:34the Snapchat group. So, if there were
- 1:08:36rumors going around that night, it would
- 1:08:37be pretty easy in his mind to piece two
- 1:08:39and two together of what the rumors were
- 1:08:40and why they were starting and why
- 1:08:41people are lingering outside the room.
- 1:08:43But he's just
- 1:08:45describing that people are lurking. He
- 1:08:46doesn't know why. People are lurking
- 1:08:48outside the president's room and this
- 1:08:50individual who may be Winston, I think
- 1:08:53it's Winston, but again, right? They're
- 1:08:55just saying that they know people are
- 1:08:58lurking because quote, "You could hear
- 1:08:59the whispers and a little fidgeting of
- 1:09:01them walking." And Jane was telling us
- 1:09:03about it and
- 1:09:04>> [music]
- 1:09:04>> we were like, "Yeah, we should probably
- 1:09:05go somewhere that's more private,
- 1:09:06right?" So, we went to the room that's
- 1:09:08actually right next to Matthew's room,
- 1:09:10which is called the foffice.
- 1:09:13Okay, this is
- 1:09:15I I can tell you're confused.
- 1:09:16President's room is upstairs.
- 1:09:18>> Mhm.
- 1:09:19>> There's a foffice connected. [music]
- 1:09:21It's like a closet office.
- 1:09:22>> Uh-huh.
- 1:09:23>> Matthew also has a room upstairs.
- 1:09:25Matthew Engles is the friend that
- 1:09:26invited her to the fraternity house. He
- 1:09:28does not live in the alumni room. This
- 1:09:30foffice is like in between the
- 1:09:31president's room and Matthew's room,
- 1:09:34somewhere on the third floor. And they
- 1:09:36want to go there because I believe Jane
- 1:09:38told us that she was uncomfortable with
- 1:09:40these random people in the other corner
- 1:09:41of the house listening to our
- 1:09:42conversations. And again, there's
- 1:09:44mentions that rumors are circulating,
- 1:09:47but everyone seems confused why there
- 1:09:49would be rumors. Even though there's
- 1:09:51some weird Snapchat messages being sent
- 1:09:54into the 57-person
- 1:09:57group [music] Snapchat, and most of
- 1:09:58these individuals are in the fraternity
- 1:10:00house, but this individual is like, "I
- 1:10:02mean, I don't know what rumors are going
- 1:10:03around."
- 1:10:04It seems like Jane knew about the
- 1:10:05rumors. Why would Jane know about the
- 1:10:07rumors? She's not in that Snapchat
- 1:10:08group, but it's just weird. Does that
- 1:10:09make sense? It's just weird.
- 1:10:11>> Yeah, yeah, yeah.
- 1:10:12>> like, "We had to move to the foffice
- 1:10:13because Jane is like, I want to go
- 1:10:15somewhere private because all these
- 1:10:16people are lurking and they're listening
- 1:10:18to our conversations." And I think at
- 1:10:19this point rumors were already
- 1:10:20circulating about something going on.
- 1:10:22It's just everything is weird.
- 1:10:24>> really odd. What what what do you mean?
- 1:10:26>> And again, if this Snapchat group was
- 1:10:29out of the question, and maybe Jane is
- 1:10:31sitting there like, "Oh, I think people
- 1:10:33are talking about me and everything
- 1:10:35that's happened in the alumni room
- 1:10:37because people saw or people witnessed
- 1:10:38or people heard," then that must mean it
- 1:10:40was loud enough that more people should
- 1:10:42have been concerned. Like, it's just
- 1:10:44weird. The whole thing is just puzzling.
- 1:10:46And Jane Doe, when she's confronted with
- 1:10:47this information, she tells Title IX
- 1:10:49panel, she's like, "I don't know what
- 1:10:52any of this is." She's like, "I went
- 1:10:54upstairs with Matthew and Winston. I was
- 1:10:56in the president's room for like 2
- 1:10:58seconds
- 1:10:58>> [music]
- 1:10:59>> and then I was taken into a faux office.
- 1:11:01Like, what do you mean? I was having a
- 1:11:02conversation with one of the accused
- 1:11:04saying, "I don't even feel the
- 1:11:05ketamine."
- 1:11:06She's like, "This never freaking
- 1:11:08happened." She says the ketamine made
- 1:11:11her feel like, quote, "It made my eyes
- 1:11:12feel like they were spinning in opposite
- 1:11:14directions. I remember feeling extremely
- 1:11:16high and trying to close my eyes to stop
- 1:11:18them from spinning." She also says, "If
- 1:11:20I had gone to the president's room, like
- 1:11:22I wish I was there, not the faux office,
- 1:11:24because I would have just fallen asleep
- 1:11:25on his couch and called it a day. I was
- 1:11:27so tired." [music]
- 1:11:29But instead, she says that she's taken
- 1:11:30into the faux office and there Matthew
- 1:11:32and Winston are sitting in front of the
- 1:11:33door so that she can't leave. She feels
- 1:11:35like there's no escape. It's a small,
- 1:11:36claustrophobic room. It's like a tiny
- 1:11:38closet office with a desk and some
- 1:11:41chairs and she's just sitting on the
- 1:11:42ground [music] and she says, "I don't
- 1:11:43remember how it started." But she says
- 1:11:46that she was given some ketamine. She
- 1:11:47doesn't really have a recollection of
- 1:11:49how she took the ketamine, but she
- 1:11:50thinks it was lined up on a chair cuz
- 1:11:53she recalls some sort of hard surface
- 1:11:54for her snorting the ketamine. And she
- 1:11:56says she has no recollection of how the
- 1:11:58threesome in the faux office even
- 1:11:59started.
- 1:12:00>> [music]
- 1:12:00>> She says, "I remember being totally
- 1:12:02disgusted at the situation. I felt very
- 1:12:03tired and intoxicated. I would say that
- 1:12:05my level of overall intoxication was an
- 1:12:07eight [music] out of 10 of intoxicated.
- 1:12:09I would say that it was the most
- 1:12:11intoxicated that I've ever been in my
- 1:12:13life. I felt like I was unable to form
- 1:12:15any decisions because of how intoxicated
- 1:12:17I was."
- 1:12:18Meanwhile, who I believe to be Winston
- 1:12:20from the John Doe lawsuit and the little
- 1:12:22snippets of the Title IX panel,
- 1:12:24he says that they were in the faux
- 1:12:25office for like an hour and a half just
- 1:12:27conversing, having deep conversations,
- 1:12:29listening to music. He says the
- 1:12:31conversations were really deep, but he
- 1:12:33doesn't remember a lot of the deep
- 1:12:35conversations. But he remembers Jane
- 1:12:37holding eye contact with who I believe
- 1:12:39to be Matthew and looking at him and he
- 1:12:42[music] states that he remembers
- 1:12:43thinking, "Oh, wow, this girl like
- 1:12:45really likes Matthew."
- 1:12:47>> Oh, that's it? He's didn't uh he's
- 1:12:49saying there's nothing else that
- 1:12:51happened?
- 1:12:51>> He says that there was no ketamine in
- 1:12:52the faux office, but they eventually do
- 1:12:54have sexual interactions. But it's like
- 1:12:57after an hour and a half of talking. He
- 1:13:00says, "This is we were talking in the
- 1:13:01president's room, then we came into the
- 1:13:03faux office, and everyone's
- 1:13:04chitchatting, and I thought that she
- 1:13:05just really liked Matthew. And because
- 1:13:08everyone's talking so much, I just
- 1:13:09assumed like all of us were pretty sober
- 1:13:11at this point. So if this is Winston,
- 1:13:14the story would be they go into the
- 1:13:16president's room.
- 1:13:17>> Mhm.
- 1:13:17>> Jane Doe is like, "I don't feel
- 1:13:18ketamine." Winston's like, "You're on
- 1:13:19ketamine? I didn't even see who do
- 1:13:21ketamine." Then they go into the faux
- 1:13:23office, and everyone's talking for an
- 1:13:24hour and a half, and so he's like, "Oh,
- 1:13:26like everyone's sobering up. It's
- 1:13:27getting really late or really early in
- 1:13:29the morning.
- 1:13:31Everyone's chill."
- 1:13:32>> Mhm.
- 1:13:33>> And then all of a sudden,
- 1:13:35it seems Matthew brings up the topic of
- 1:13:37redemption. Because remember the very
- 1:13:39first threesome that he asked for, he
- 1:13:42could not perform because he was
- 1:13:45Yeah. And again, who I believe to be
- 1:13:47Winston claims to title nine.
- 1:13:50But something I specifically remember,
- 1:13:52Matthew had asked [music] Jane if we
- 1:13:53could have a threesome, and I had
- 1:13:55specifically stated, I said, "Jane, by
- 1:13:57the way, if you're uncomfortable, and
- 1:13:58you don't want to do this, that's
- 1:14:00perfectly okay. We can just call it a
- 1:14:01night." Which is oddly specific. But the
- 1:14:04statement continues. He says, "You know,
- 1:14:06I think we were all feeling a little bit
- 1:14:07tired at that time. I didn't know if she
- 1:14:09wanted to have another sexual activity
- 1:14:10so close [music] to the prior failed
- 1:14:11threesome. I myself was reluctant to
- 1:14:14have a threesome. I guess [ __ ] just
- 1:14:16happens, right? Even if you're
- 1:14:17reluctant." He's
- 1:14:19who I believe to be Winston says, "I
- 1:14:21asked Jane if I could have oral sex.
- 1:14:23When she was giving me oral sex, I was
- 1:14:25sitting on the chair. I struggled to get
- 1:14:26an erection, and I remember her telling
- 1:14:28me specifically not to be embarrassed,
- 1:14:29and that this was perfectly fine, and no
- 1:14:31one would judge me. And she gave me oral
- 1:14:33sex for about 2 minutes." He says that
- 1:14:36then she turned and gave the other
- 1:14:37party, I believe Matthew, oral sex, and
- 1:14:41then [music] tried to swap back in,
- 1:14:43Matthew is now having penetrative sex.
- 1:14:46Quote, "After that, Matthew inserted his
- 1:14:47penis into Jane Doe's vagina and Jane
- 1:14:49Doe gave me oral sex." He says that his
- 1:14:52interaction with Jane Doe at that point
- 1:14:53lasted about two to three minutes.
- 1:14:56>> Okay.
- 1:14:56>> So, I don't know why it stops. I don't
- 1:14:58know. He doesn't At least from the
- 1:14:59snippets I read, it doesn't seem he
- 1:15:01gives a reaction of
- 1:15:03Was it I don't know, right? But, when
- 1:15:05he's asked about the sexual activity
- 1:15:06continuing for the other parties, cuz
- 1:15:08the panel is like, "Okay, well, if it
- 1:15:10stopped for you in two to three minutes,
- 1:15:11what about Jane Doe and who I believe to
- 1:15:13be Matthew? Like, what happened to
- 1:15:14that?"
- 1:15:14>> Mhm.
- 1:15:15>> He responds, "I'm sorry, but from that
- 1:15:17night I remember things about what
- 1:15:19happened with me, so [music] I don't
- 1:15:20remember."
- 1:15:22>> Oh.
- 1:15:22>> Ooh.
- 1:15:23Yeah.
- 1:15:23>> Oh, wow.
- 1:15:24>> Yeah.
- 1:15:25>> Wow.
- 1:15:27>> Whatever that means.
- 1:15:28It's not even like a I don't remember.
- 1:15:30It's just like, "Hey, so I have very
- 1:15:32selective memory and if I was not
- 1:15:33involved in the experience, I don't
- 1:15:35[ __ ] remember."
- 1:15:36>> Wow. That's so interesting. Wow.
- 1:15:39>> Yeah.
- 1:15:40>> Huh.
- 1:15:40>> He denies ketamine being used in the
- 1:15:42faux fest. He says, "No, no, there was
- 1:15:44no drugs, there was no alcohol in the
- 1:15:45faux fest."
- 1:15:46>> [music]
- 1:15:46>> Now, there are lots of gaps and
- 1:15:48omissions in this individual's
- 1:15:50statements, who again I believe to be
- 1:15:52Winston, but I could be entirely wrong.
- 1:15:54I could literally be a bozo trying to
- 1:15:56decipher this lawsuit, right? Go
- 1:15:58decipher it yourself. But, when the
- 1:15:59panel asks him about it, he responds,
- 1:16:02"There are a lot of I believe gaps in my
- 1:16:04memory that I recollected. And after
- 1:16:06receiving a notice of the formal
- 1:16:08complaint charges, I was [music] trying
- 1:16:09to rationalize in my head how it was
- 1:16:11false and providing an explanation that
- 1:16:14I figured out and I thought was
- 1:16:16reasonable as to why those things were
- 1:16:18false."
- 1:16:19>> Mhm.
- 1:16:19>> I'm sorry, what are we saying? He
- 1:16:21continues, "For that reason, I was
- 1:16:23feeling very defensive about some of the
- 1:16:25accusations that were being pointed at
- 1:16:27me. Because of that, I think I left a
- 1:16:28lot of parts that I remembered from that
- 1:16:30night out that didn't have to do with
- 1:16:32the things that I was directly being
- 1:16:33accused of. I put myself in a very
- 1:16:36defensive position."
- 1:16:38Obviously, there are differences between
- 1:16:40his story and Jane Doe's story.
- 1:16:44She also says that they kept asking for
- 1:16:46a threesome and she just kept saying no
- 1:16:48and no in the sense of she kept giving
- 1:16:51the excuse that she was tired. She said
- 1:16:53that I also felt that my eyes it felt
- 1:16:55like one was going in one direction and
- 1:16:57the other one was going in another
- 1:16:58direction.
- 1:17:00She claims that Winston and Matthew were
- 1:17:02in front of the door, the only exit to
- 1:17:04the Fofis
- 1:17:06and she further elaborates that she was
- 1:17:08given more ketamine. She says, "I don't
- 1:17:10know how much they poured. I don't know
- 1:17:11where I took it from. I don't know where
- 1:17:13it came from or how it got in my system.
- 1:17:15I'm pretty sure it was that kind of
- 1:17:17final bump that made my eyes do the
- 1:17:19weird eye jerking thing."
- 1:17:22Which again, a lot of ketamine users say
- 1:17:24is on par with heavy ketamine usage. So
- 1:17:27they're saying, "We don't It's unclear
- 1:17:28how many times she did ketamine." It
- 1:17:30seems like the everyone, even the seven
- 1:17:32accused, seem to agree that maybe it was
- 1:17:35one time, right? But a lot of ketamine
- 1:17:37users are like, "The amount to have your
- 1:17:40eyes like jerk around." They said that's
- 1:17:42a very prominent feeling and you're
- 1:17:44usually deep in like a K-hole.
- 1:17:47That is not, "Ooh, I took a little
- 1:17:48ketamine." That is, "You have been doing
- 1:17:51ketamine all night." I mean, of course,
- 1:17:53everybody's tolerance is different, but
- 1:17:56they're just saying this is not This is
- 1:17:58not a once type of thing.
- 1:18:00>> Got it.
- 1:18:00>> And she's very honest about things that
- 1:18:02she doesn't remember, which I think a
- 1:18:04lot of netizens believe add to her
- 1:18:05credibility. She says, "I just remember
- 1:18:07ketamine was done because I had my nose
- 1:18:09on something. It's kind of like
- 1:18:12I want to say my nose was on a table,
- 1:18:13but
- 1:18:14it could been that my nose was actually
- 1:18:16on a chair. That's all I remember from
- 1:18:17that.
- 1:18:18I don't know. It's just been a long time
- 1:18:20at that point. Uh there's a lot of time
- 1:18:23that elapsed in the Fofis or whatever
- 1:18:25that I have no memory of whatsoever.
- 1:18:28It's maybe the most [ __ ] up I've been
- 1:18:30ever in my life. I remember saying a lot
- 1:18:32of things, but I don't know what I was
- 1:18:33saying. I was apparently just talking
- 1:18:35and talking. My eyes were closed and my
- 1:18:38mouth was running and I felt like my
- 1:18:39eyes were going in different directions.
- 1:18:41I said I talked a lot because I felt
- 1:18:44like I talked a lot, but it could be
- 1:18:45that I didn't talk at all. But, there
- 1:18:47were a lot of moments where
- 1:18:49there was talk cuz I remember just like
- 1:18:51sitting there and was kind of staring at
- 1:18:53the wall and talking like this
- 1:18:56over and over. Maybe trying to distract
- 1:18:57from the fact that I thought my eyeballs
- 1:18:59were going like a chameleon, like just I
- 1:19:01just remember being debilitating the
- 1:19:03feeling. I couldn't have communicated my
- 1:19:05middle name, I don't think.
- 1:19:07Well, actually, I probably could have
- 1:19:09said my middle name, but any sort of
- 1:19:11thought about my perception of the world
- 1:19:13was not good, like not possible.
- 1:19:15Also, when Matthew was asking me about
- 1:19:17having sex again while in the office
- 1:19:19space, I told him that I was tired and I
- 1:19:21believe said I said something along the
- 1:19:23lines of like, "I don't have it in me."
- 1:19:25She says she doesn't even know how the
- 1:19:27threesome started. And she has a
- 1:19:29different story about the erection. She
- 1:19:31says, "I remember Redacted asking me to
- 1:19:33give him oral sex and he said he
- 1:19:35couldn't get erect. I told him that if
- 1:19:36he couldn't get himself erect, then I
- 1:19:38wouldn't be able to."
- 1:19:40>> Hm.
- 1:19:41>> Yeah.
- 1:19:42She says, "I don't remember how that
- 1:19:44threesome started, but I do remember
- 1:19:45that both Redacted and Redacted, but
- 1:19:47probably Matthew and Winston, were
- 1:19:49asking me to have sex so many times that
- 1:19:51I finally gave in. To me, that felt like
- 1:19:53coercion. Also, I felt like due to my
- 1:19:54intoxication, they should have known how
- 1:19:56intoxicated I was based on how I was
- 1:19:58slurring my words." Jane Doe says the
- 1:20:00ketamine left her with a quote vague
- 1:20:02consciousness. She says, "It's like you
- 1:20:05look like an operating human being. You
- 1:20:07don't look dead or asleep necessarily.
- 1:20:10So, it's like the lights are on, but
- 1:20:11nobody's home. Your brain is not
- 1:20:13functioning at its proper level. I know
- 1:20:14it sounds super weird to say. I know it
- 1:20:17happened, but I don't remember it."
- 1:20:21She says that at some point, someone
- 1:20:22came into the faux office and asked,
- 1:20:24"Y'all are still going?" To which she
- 1:20:27responded, [music]
- 1:20:28"Yeah, unfortunately." In a quote sad,
- 1:20:31not enthusiastic [music] tone."
- 1:20:34Now, this person is also a very
- 1:20:37contentious individual. One of the It
- 1:20:39seems maybe Winston is asked about like,
- 1:20:41did someone stop by? And they're like,
- 1:20:43no, nobody stopped by. And then later
- 1:20:45it's changed to like, oh yes, someone
- 1:20:46did stop by, slipped my mind. And he
- 1:20:49looked like he was freshly showered in
- 1:20:50PJs.
- 1:20:52Now, it seems, and I cannot tell you
- 1:20:54this with certainty, it seems like this
- 1:20:55individual that stopped by was Jonathan
- 1:20:57based off of little snippets that I got
- 1:20:59from all over the John Doe lawsuit that
- 1:21:00is information and I've deciphered in my
- 1:21:03mind that it's Jonathan based off of the
- 1:21:04fact that someone else said it was
- 1:21:05Jonathan and like the way that it was
- 1:21:07redacted made it seem like it was
- 1:21:09Jonathan. It could not be Jonathan. It
- 1:21:11could be Jonathan. But if it is Jonathan
- 1:21:13or one of the seven accused, it's being
- 1:21:16used perhaps as like an argument of
- 1:21:18well, how [ __ ] up were they? Because a
- 1:21:21lot of the seven accused seem like
- 1:21:22either they're saying, I had nothing to
- 1:21:25do with anything or I was so [ __ ] up
- 1:21:28too.
- 1:21:29Like we were all [ __ ] up.
- 1:21:32But how can you be that [ __ ] up if
- 1:21:33you're showering and getting in PJs and
- 1:21:35then you're like, hey, are you guys
- 1:21:36still going at it?
- 1:21:38>> Yeah.
- 1:21:40>> But again, we don't know if this is
- 1:21:41Jonathan. She later describes the
- 1:21:42experience as, I couldn't get much and
- 1:21:45of anything out. I just kind of felt
- 1:21:46trapped with Winston and Matthew.
- 1:21:49They're sitting in front of the door, in
- 1:21:50front of the exit. I mean, things are
- 1:21:51still being asked of me sexually.
- 1:21:53Ketamine is still being given to me
- 1:21:54during this point in time. It was just I
- 1:21:56don't think [music] I felt like I could
- 1:21:58get out. I didn't want to, but I felt
- 1:22:00like I had to.
- 1:22:02She eventually gets brought into a
- 1:22:04different room to fall asleep, Matthew's
- 1:22:05[music] room. And she says, at some
- 1:22:07point while she's in Matthew's room,
- 1:22:09quote, "At one point a group of guys
- 1:22:10knocked on the door and they asked if
- 1:22:12they could snort cocaine out of my
- 1:22:14anus."
- 1:22:16But
- 1:22:16>> [music]
- 1:22:16>> redacted told them to go away and they
- 1:22:18did.
- 1:22:20>> Damn.
- 1:22:21>> She says that she wakes up around 10:00
- 1:22:23a.m. on Sunday. Which like, how did they
- 1:22:25know she was in Matthew's room? Because
- 1:22:26that's not the alumni room? I'm just
- 1:22:28saying if this is true, it's very
- 1:22:29suspicious and weird to me.
- 1:22:32But anyway, she says that she wakes up
- 1:22:33around 10:00 a.m. on Sunday, October
- 1:22:35[music] 20th. She says, "Shortly after I
- 1:22:37woke up, uh redacted was hovering over
- 1:22:40me with both of his arms on either side
- 1:22:42of me."
- 1:22:43So, this is Matthew's room, but again,
- 1:22:45because it's redacted, I can't say with
- 1:22:46certainty it's Matthew. It could be
- 1:22:47anyone. Like, we don't know if people
- 1:22:48lock their doors. We don't know if
- 1:22:49anyone else came in later.
- 1:22:51I asked him what he was doing and he
- 1:22:52said he was going to put his in my
- 1:22:54mouth.
- 1:22:54>> [music]
- 1:22:54>> I replied by saying, "No." in a mean way
- 1:22:56to him and at that point he got away
- 1:22:58from me.
- 1:22:59Shortly after, she is driven back
- 1:23:01[music] to her sorority house where she
- 1:23:02passes out.
- 1:23:04And this is not even [music] the point
- 1:23:07that netizens are fighting about. What's
- 1:23:09crazy is October 19th and October 20th
- 1:23:11isn't the thing that netizens are so
- 1:23:12divided on.
- 1:23:13>> [music]
- 1:23:14>> It's everything that happens after in
- 1:23:16text messages and interactions between
- 1:23:18Jane Doe and the Cornell 7, which will
- 1:23:21be in the next part. There's so many
- 1:23:24text messages that have been released.
- 1:23:25There are so many different narratives
- 1:23:27that have been spinning around. New text
- 1:23:29messages from Jane Doe's roommate that
- 1:23:31have been released. It's just been
- 1:23:32getting messier day by day. I don't even
- 1:23:35think that this is slowing down anytime
- 1:23:36soon. Cornell has just recently
- 1:23:38suspended all fraternity and sorority
- 1:23:40parties. Yeah, it's not slowing down.
- 1:23:42It's not becoming yesterday's news
- 1:23:44anytime soon.
- 1:23:45What are your thoughts? Let me know in
- 1:23:47the comments. Stay safe and I will see
- 1:23:50you in the next one.
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of What Jane Doe & Cornell 7 Said Happened That Night- All The Inconsistencies by Rotten Mango, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 17,707 words across 2,697 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.