What Happens When Filmmakers Only Watch Movies? — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:00This is the director
- 0:00of Barbie talking
- 0:02about Stanley Kubrick's
- 0:032001: A Space Odyssey.
- 0:05I love Kubrick.
- 0:06Who doesn't love Kubrick?
- 0:07One thing when we started
- 0:08talking about the film
- 0:09was I was like, "I don't
- 0:10wanna do it just as, like,
- 0:11a parody where we do it
- 0:13kind of quick and dirty and
- 0:14it doesn't really matter.
- 0:15I wanna do it only if
- 0:16we can, like, do it.
- 0:18I wanna do it with
- 0:19front screen projection.
- 0:20I wanna do it with
- 0:21the original plates.
- 0:22I wanna build the set
- 0:23as they had built it.
- 0:24Let's make it count." The
- 0:25only way that this is, like,
- 0:26funny to me is that if it's
- 0:28executed with the utmost
- 0:30integrity and excellence.
- 0:32She wasn't describing
- 0:33a vague influence.
- 0:35The team brought the original
- 0:36footage from Kubrick's
- 0:37film into their edit.
- 0:39They studied the timing.
- 0:40They tried to line the
- 0:41opening with the older
- 0:43film right down to the
- 0:44moment when the ape strikes
- 0:46a skeleton with a bone.
- 0:48The joke depends on us
- 0:49feeling the weight of that
- 0:50earlier image, which is
- 0:52the arrival of something
- 0:53that changes the world.
- 0:54The filmmakers didn't hide
- 0:56where this idea came from.
- 0:57They practically invited
- 0:58us to recognize it, and
- 1:00millions of people encountered
- 1:02it in a film about a toy.
- 1:04I like to start here
- 1:04because it makes the
- 1:05question unusually clear.
- 1:06Somebody making a major
- 1:08film has openly admitted
- 1:09that a celebrated piece of
- 1:10cinema provided the model
- 1:12for part of their work.
- 1:13You can compare the
- 1:14two openings yourself.
- 1:16They're meant to
- 1:17resemble each other.
- 1:18There's a growing pleasure
- 1:19in recognizing cinema.
- 1:21We watch a film and notice
- 1:22an older one inside it.
- 1:24Someone posts both images
- 1:26next to each other, the
- 1:27resemblance becomes a
- 1:28discussion, and the filmmaker
- 1:30gets praised for knowing
- 1:31the history of the medium.
- 1:32I can understand the pleasure.
- 1:34There's real joy in
- 1:35finding connections
- 1:35between works of art.
- 1:36But I've begun to wonder
- 1:38about the point where
- 1:39recognition becomes the
- 1:40experience itself, where
- 1:41you're watching a film and
- 1:43part of your attention is busy
- 1:44identifying its influences.
- 1:46You know the director
- 1:47being quoted, the decade
- 1:48being recreated, the
- 1:49genre being celebrated.
- 1:51You know exactly what the film
- 1:53loves, but you're less sure
- 1:55about what it wants to say.
- 1:57The more virgin our eyes are,
- 2:01the more we have to say The
- 2:05mo- most detestable habit
- 2:08in all modern cinema is the
- 2:10homage A few decades ago,
- 2:13spotting an obscure reference
- 2:14was a private pleasure.
- 2:16You watched a film,
- 2:17remembered something you'd
- 2:18seen years earlier, and
- 2:20you made a connection.
- 2:21Maybe you talked about it
- 2:22with a friend, maybe you
- 2:23never mentioned it to anyone.
- 2:25But today, that connection
- 2:27can become the public
- 2:28life of the film.
- 2:29Side-by-side comparisons
- 2:31circulate before people
- 2:32have even watched the movie.
- 2:34A trailer gets broken
- 2:35down frame by frame.
- 2:37Every costume, every
- 2:38composition, every set
- 2:40piece becomes a clue.
- 2:41People compete to identify
- 2:43the oldest source or
- 2:45the most obscure one.
- 2:46There are entire channels
- 2:47devoted to this kind of
- 2:49attention, and I know
- 2:49that mine lives close
- 2:51to that world, too.
- 2:52There's a great deal
- 2:53to learn from it.
- 2:54A director who knows the
- 2:55work of other directors
- 2:56has a larger set of
- 2:58possibilities available
- 2:59when making decisions.
- 3:00The trouble begins
- 3:01when familiarity starts
- 3:02standing in for judgment.
- 3:04You can describe a film as
- 3:05a mixture of Taxi Driver, of
- 3:07Seven, of Chinatown, and a
- 3:09little German expressionism.
- 3:11That might tell someone
- 3:12what the film looks like,
- 3:13but it doesn't tell them
- 3:15in any way whether or not
- 3:16the film is actually good.
- 3:17Take The Batman Matt
- 3:19Reeves has spoken openly
- 3:21about the crime thrillers
- 3:22that shaped his approach,
- 3:24particularly Chinatown
- 3:25and The French Connection.
- 3:26He wanted Batman to be a
- 3:28detective investigating
- 3:29corruption, a young man
- 3:31whose moral certainty
- 3:32would be challenged by
- 3:33what he discovers about
- 3:34his city and himself.
- 3:36Those influences are
- 3:37easy to see if you know
- 3:38the older films, but
- 3:40Reeves wasn't making an
- 3:41exam for film student.
- 3:42He was looking for a way to
- 3:43make a familiar comic book
- 3:45character feel troubled and
- 3:46unsure of his own methods.
- 3:48You can disagree about how
- 3:49well The Batman achieves that.
- 3:51The film doesn't become
- 3:52interesting merely because
- 3:53it has good references.
- 3:54It becomes worth
- 3:55discussing when those
- 3:57references create different
- 3:58experience of Batman.
- 4:00There's a useful contrast
- 4:01here with The Joker.
- 4:02The film has references to
- 4:04Martin Scorsese's Taxi Driver
- 4:06and The King of Comedy.
- 4:08It even casts Robert De
- 4:09Niro in a role that draws
- 4:10attention to that lineage.
- 4:12Some viewers read that as
- 4:13a serious conversation with
- 4:14those films, while others
- 4:16felt that a familiar style
- 4:17of alienation has been placed
- 4:19around a comic book villain.
- 4:21Both reactions make sense
- 4:22to me because they reflect
- 4:23a real uncertainty about the
- 4:25work the reference is doing.
- 4:26If you already know the
- 4:27old movies, is the new one
- 4:28going to give you a fresh
- 4:30understanding of loneliness,
- 4:31or are you mainly enjoying the
- 4:33sensation of finding Scorsese
- 4:35inside a superhero film?
- 4:37I don't think a comparison can
- 4:38answer that question for us.
- 4:40A split screen will show
- 4:41you where two images
- 4:43resemble each other.
- 4:44It can't show you whether
- 4:45the newer film's added
- 4:46to the conversation.
- 4:48That takes more thought than
- 4:49recognition, and this is where
- 4:51criticism can become too lazy.
- 4:53Calling a filmmaker
- 4:54derivative is easy when
- 4:56you can name the source.
- 4:57Naming the source can feel
- 4:58like the end of an argument.
- 4:59Sometimes it's
- 5:00only the beginning.
- 5:01Filmmakers have always
- 5:02learned by watching films.
- 5:04That part of the story is old.
- 5:05If we're to go back, the
- 5:07French New Wave began with
- 5:08young critics whose education
- 5:09took place in cinemas and on
- 5:11the pages of film magazines.
- 5:12The American directors
- 5:14who emerged in the 1970s
- 5:15grew up surrounded by
- 5:16movies, television,
- 5:17photography, and music.
- 5:19They argued about
- 5:20their favorite and
- 5:21they borrowed freely.
- 5:22Their works changed the
- 5:23medium that taught them.
- 5:24It would be strange to
- 5:25tell a painter to stop
- 5:26looking at paintings or
- 5:27to tell a musician to
- 5:29stop listening to records.
- 5:30The problem cannot simply be
- 5:31that cinema has become one of
- 5:32the places filmmakers learn.
- 5:34Film is a language and
- 5:36languages are inherited.
- 5:37A close-up meant something
- 5:39way before any director
- 5:40alive today used one.
- 5:41A cut between two faces comes
- 5:43with more than a century
- 5:44of accumulated experience.
- 5:46Sometimes a filmmaker has
- 5:48absorbed a way of seeing so
- 5:50thoroughly that it no longer
- 5:51feels like a quotation.
- 5:53Sometimes two artists
- 5:54arrive at similar solutions
- 5:56because they are trying
- 5:57to solve similar problems.
- 5:58We should be very careful
- 5:59about assigning ownership
- 6:01to every image we recognize.
- 6:02There's a difference between
- 6:04knowing the history of
- 6:04a technique and treating
- 6:06every use of that technique
- 6:07as evidence of copying.
- 6:09The more interesting
- 6:10question concerns what
- 6:11happens between a finished
- 6:12work and its influence.
- 6:14A filmmaker sees something,
- 6:15it stays with them.
- 6:17Years later, they are
- 6:18faced with a story or a
- 6:19feeling they can't express
- 6:21An old image comes back.
- 6:23It may be useful, it
- 6:24may be completely wrong.
- 6:26They have to discover which.
- 6:27This is why I resist the
- 6:28idea that originality
- 6:30requires a filmmaker
- 6:31to have no influences.
- 6:32That will leave us with
- 6:33almost no art at all.
- 6:35But I also resist the
- 6:36comforting argument
- 6:37that all borrowing is
- 6:38automatically creative.
- 6:39Calling something an
- 6:40homage doesn't explain
- 6:42what it contributes.
- 6:43Label can come as an
- 6:44excuse for work that
- 6:45relies on the audience's
- 6:46affection for another film.
- 6:48We can hold both thoughts
- 6:49at once without pretending
- 6:51a line is easy to draw.
- 6:53Everything Everywhere
- 6:54All at Once lives in
- 6:56a busy collection of
- 6:57cinematic traditions.
- 6:59Its makers draw on Hong
- 7:00Kong action cinema, science
- 7:02fiction, comedy, and Wong
- 7:04Kar-wai romantic style.
- 7:05Some of its jokes are built
- 7:07around the pleasure of
- 7:07recognizing another movie.
- 7:09You can almost feel
- 7:10its directors enjoying
- 7:11the range of the film's
- 7:12language available to them.
- 7:14Yet the movie has a simple
- 7:16emotional concern at
- 7:17its center, a mother and
- 7:19daughter who struggle to
- 7:20understand each other.
- 7:21Daniel Kwan has spoken about
- 7:23how the film's family dynamic
- 7:25grew out of his relationship
- 7:26to his immigrant parents.
- 7:28Before the story
- 7:28begins traveling across
- 7:29universes, the family
- 7:31members already seem to
- 7:32inhabit different worlds.
- 7:34They speak past each other.
- 7:35They carry expectations
- 7:36that don't match.
- 7:37They're exhausted
- 7:38by the effort of
- 7:39explaining themselves.
- 7:40That gives the spectacle
- 7:41somewhere to return.
- 7:43The movie can turn people
- 7:44into rocks, use absurd
- 7:46visual jokes, and change
- 7:47genres repeatedly because
- 7:48those inventions are part
- 7:50of its way of reaching an
- 7:51ordinary emotional difficulty.
- 7:53And I think this is
- 7:54the kind of borrowing
- 7:55that expands cinema.
- 7:56It takes language that viewers
- 7:57already know and gives that
- 7:59language new work to do.
- 8:00The people who know
- 8:01the references have
- 8:02one experience.
- 8:03Those who don't can still
- 8:04follow the emotional
- 8:05life of the film.
- 8:06In 2025, Ryan Coogler
- 8:08released Sinners.
- 8:09It has vampires, it has the
- 8:11pleasures of a genre film.
- 8:12It knows the history of horror
- 8:14and American popular music.
- 8:15You can identify similar
- 8:16storytelling traditions within
- 8:18it without much difficulty.
- 8:20But when listening to Coogler
- 8:21talk about where the film
- 8:22began, horror gave him a
- 8:24way to tell that story.
- 8:26His family history gave
- 8:27him a reason to tell it.
- 8:29You could remove the vampire,
- 8:30and there would still be a
- 8:31subject worth exploring, what
- 8:33people carry when they leave
- 8:34home, how music holds memory,
- 8:36and why a culture can survive
- 8:38attempts to destroy it.
- 8:40The genre doesn't
- 8:41erase those questions.
- 8:42It creates a particular
- 8:43experience around them
- 8:45This is the sort of depth
- 8:46no amount of film watching
- 8:47can supply on its own.
- 8:49You can know every vampire
- 8:50movie ever made and still
- 8:51have no idea what the blues
- 8:53meant to Coogler's uncle.
- 8:54And then there's
- 8:55Sean Baker's Anora.
- 8:57Baker's work has echoes of
- 8:58early independent cinema
- 9:00and screwball comedy.
- 9:01But when he discusses Anora,
- 9:03he talks about years of
- 9:05interest in Brighton Beach,
- 9:07people he met, the stories he
- 9:08heard, and conversation with
- 9:09sex workers whose experiences
- 9:11inform the protagonists.
- 9:13He worked with people who knew
- 9:14that world from the inside.
- 9:16The film's detail comes from
- 9:17contact with lives beyond
- 9:19the filmmaker's imagination.
- 9:20Those choices matter ethically
- 9:22as well as artistically
- 9:24Research doesn't grant
- 9:25a director ownership of
- 9:27other people's experiences.
- 9:28It can help them listen with
- 9:29greater care, question easy
- 9:31assumptions, and make room
- 9:33for details an inherited movie
- 9:35image might never suggest.
- 9:37Something similar
- 9:38happened with Past Lives.
- 9:39Celine Song said it began with
- 9:41a moment that happened to her.
- 9:43She was in a New York bar with
- 9:44her husband and a man she'd
- 9:46known as a child in Korea.
- 9:48They came from different
- 9:49parts of her life and
- 9:49didn't share a language.
- 9:51She found herself
- 9:52translating between them.
- 9:53It was a strange feeling that
- 9:54both men knew something about
- 9:56her that the other didn't.
- 9:58Sitting between them
- 9:59brought together separate
- 10:00versions of her life.
- 10:01It's a small experience.
- 10:03Nothing about it suggests
- 10:04a large cinematic event.
- 10:06Three people having a
- 10:07conversation in a bar would
- 10:08pass unnoticed anywhere.
- 10:10But Song understood that
- 10:11the situation contained
- 10:12an emotional problem.
- 10:14Leaving one country
- 10:15and building life in
- 10:16another doesn't erase the
- 10:17person you were before.
- 10:19The relationship that survive
- 10:20in memory may no longer fit
- 10:22into the life you've chosen.
- 10:24A chance meeting can
- 10:25reveal how many versions
- 10:26of ourselves we carry.
- 10:27Past Lives takes that feeling
- 10:29and makes a film from it.
- 10:31There are influences.
- 10:33Song is a playwright as well
- 10:34as a filmmaker, and she's
- 10:36spoken about other work
- 10:37that helped her think about
- 10:38conversation and intimacy.
- 10:40Yet I doubt the film would
- 10:41feel the same if it began with
- 10:43an instruction to recreate
- 10:44an admired romantic drama.
- 10:46This one started with
- 10:46something that troubled
- 10:47and interested her.
- 10:49The cinematic form
- 10:50came afterward.
- 10:51There's a danger in learning
- 10:52an art form very well.
- 10:54At the beginning,
- 10:55everything feels new.
- 10:56You watch a film and discover
- 10:58that a camera can move in a
- 11:00way you've never imagined.
- 11:01You hear a cut and suddenly
- 11:03understand rhythm differently.
- 11:04You realize that an
- 11:05actor doesn't have to
- 11:06explain every emotion.
- 11:08It's exciting because the
- 11:09language is opening up.
- 11:11Over time, you develop taste.
- 11:12You know what sophisticated
- 11:13filmmaking looks like.
- 11:15You can recognize a
- 11:16well-managed camera movement,
- 11:17elegant production design, and
- 11:19a convincing film emulation.
- 11:21These are valuable skills,
- 11:23and they can also become
- 11:24habits of approval.
- 11:25A film arrives looking
- 11:26very much like what we
- 11:27already consider good
- 11:28cinema, and we respond
- 11:29before we really examine it.
- 11:31The composition is beautiful.
- 11:32The references are impeccable.
- 11:34The work has all the marks
- 11:36of seriousness, but it can
- 11:37still leave us untouched.
- 11:39I think there's one reason
- 11:40debates about cinephile
- 11:41filmmaker get so heated.
- 11:42People aren't only disagreeing
- 11:44about individual movies,
- 11:45they're disagreeing about
- 11:46what evidence of artistic
- 11:48value should look like.
- 11:49There's one question
- 11:50I keep coming back to.
- 11:51Imagine a viewer who
- 11:52hasn't seen any of the
- 11:53film being referenced.
- 11:54They don't know Kubrick, or
- 11:56Scorsese, or Wong Kar-wai.
- 11:58They walk into a cinema
- 11:59carrying none of that history.
- 12:01Does the movie still give
- 12:02them a reason to care?
- 12:03They may miss a joke
- 12:04in Barbie, but they
- 12:05can understand what
- 12:06the opening is doing.
- 12:07They may never recognize
- 12:09the romantic references in
- 12:10Everything Everywhere All
- 12:11at Once, but the mother
- 12:12and the daughter can
- 12:13still break their hearts.
- 12:14That doesn't prove that
- 12:15every choice works.
- 12:16It's proof that a film
- 12:18can have life beyond the
- 12:19pleasure of just recognition.
- 12:21So to wrap this up, are
- 12:23cinephile filmmakers
- 12:24ruining cinema?
- 12:25I don't think the films
- 12:26we love are the problem.
- 12:27Cinema would be a poorer
- 12:28art if directors had to
- 12:30pretend they hadn't seen
- 12:31anything before them.
- 12:32Borrowing can be generous.
- 12:34It can be funny.
- 12:34It can give a new film an
- 12:36old language that suddenly
- 12:37becomes useful in an
- 12:38unexpected way, and I don't
- 12:40think every familiar image
- 12:41deserves our suspicion.
- 12:43Sometimes a film reminds us
- 12:44of another because a director
- 12:46has absorbed an influence
- 12:47so deeply it has become
- 12:48part of how they think.
- 12:49The path worth watching
- 12:51is what happens next.
- 12:52Does the filmmaker follow that
- 12:53influence towards something
- 12:55they've genuinely been trying
- 12:56to understand, or does the
- 12:58filmmaker discover a person,
- 12:59a place, or a feeling that
- 13:02wasn't already contained
- 13:03in its reference, or does
- 13:05it stop at recognition and
- 13:06wait for us to applaud?
- 13:08We can learn how to make
- 13:09movies by watching movies,
- 13:10but we still need somewhere to
- 13:12look when the screen goes dark
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of What Happens When Filmmakers Only Watch Movies? by Abu Cinema, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 2,439 words across 573 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.