What global trade deals are really about (hint: it's not trade) | Haley Edwards | TEDxMidAtlantic — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:00Translator: Mirjana Čutura Reviewer: Peter van de Ven
- 0:25Hello, everybody.
- 0:28I want you all to come away from the next 10 minutes
- 0:31with a single counterintuitive idea,
- 0:35and that is that trade deals aren't really about trade,
- 0:41not in any conventional sense of the word.
- 0:44They're not about tariffs, they're not about quotas,
- 0:47they're not about GDP growth,
- 0:48they're not even really about jobs.
- 0:51That's how we tend to talk about it: job loss and job gain,
- 0:54and that's what's in the news, and that's what's at the DNC,
- 0:57but that's not what they're really about.
- 0:59Not really.
- 1:01And we'll get to that,
- 1:03but for now, I want to start at the very beginning.
- 1:06The modern era of free trade, as we think of it today,
- 1:09started in about 1944,
- 1:11when all the great lights of liberal economics got together
- 1:14in a little place called Bretton Woods, New Hampshire.
- 1:18And at the time, the world was in a pretty dark place.
- 1:22You know, all the people there remembered World War I,
- 1:25they lived through the Depression,
- 1:26World War II was still raging across the Atlantic,
- 1:29and at the top of everyone's mind at the time was world peace:
- 1:36how do we create an economy that fosters and necessitates world peace?
- 1:43That was the entire idea.
- 1:45And they seized on this idea of economic interdependence.
- 1:50The idea was that if nation states were dependent on each other
- 1:54for their supply chains,
- 1:55then they couldn't go to war with each other.
- 1:57If Germany needed France for its coal and France needed Germany for its steel,
- 2:01then they couldn't go to war with each other.
- 2:05So, that was the idea behind what became, about four years later, the GATT,
- 2:10the General Agreement on Tariffs and Trade.
- 2:15And this little document created the world as we know it today.
- 2:19It created globalization, it created outsourcing,
- 2:22it created multinational corporation as we think of it.
- 2:26It's hard to imagine a world
- 2:28in which there weren't, you know, McDonald'ses and global corporations
- 2:31and the sort of structure that we have now.
- 2:34But the General Agreement on Tariffs and Trade is what did it.
- 2:38We created this.
- 2:40And it brought on this period of extraordinary disruption
- 2:43and convulsion and prosperity.
- 2:47From about 1948, when the GATT was first signed, till late '70s,
- 2:51the global GDP grew by about seven percent per year - just explosive growth.
- 2:58And for a while, people thought that wouldn't end,
- 3:01that was just it - we had cracked the code.
- 3:03But then it began to wane.
- 3:06And in the late '70s and early '80s,
- 3:08you had the great lights of a new generation of liberal economics
- 3:12get together for a second time:
- 3:15a new Bretton Woods.
- 3:16Only this time, it was the Uruguay Round, and it lasted for eight years.
- 3:22And the scenario there was a little different.
- 3:24Instead of world peace and economic interdependence,
- 3:29they were really motivated by this idea of global efficiency:
- 3:33so basically, How do we continue to boost the global economy
- 3:36as it has been boosted over the last 30 years?
- 3:38What do we do?
- 3:41And the scenario was different.
- 3:42So, in the 1940s, there were just really, really high tariffs and quotas
- 3:46and really protectionist policies at all the borders.
- 3:50And so, lowering those could have this profound influence,
- 3:54but by the '80s, a lot of those quotas were pretty low,
- 3:57a lot of those tariffs were already pretty low.
- 4:00So, they began to think outside the box,
- 4:02and they seized on this idea of non-tariff barriers.
- 4:05And now, this leads into the modern era of trade I'm talking about now.
- 4:11Now, non-tariff barriers are the idea
- 4:14that it doesn't really matter
- 4:16how low a tariff is around a country's border
- 4:19if, once a product gets inside, it has to compete at an uneven playing field.
- 4:25So, once you have, you know, Jim Bean, for example,
- 4:29it doesn't matter if Japan doesn't have a tariff on liquor
- 4:33if, once it's inside Japan,
- 4:35it has to compete on the same shelf next to a Japanese liquor
- 4:39that's subsidized by the Japanese government.
- 4:43So, the idea now was, you know, we just strip away all that other stuff
- 4:47and make the world's economy as efficient as possible.
- 4:52And that is the philosophy that governed trade beginning in the 1990s.
- 4:58In 1995, we got rid of the GATT,
- 5:01and we replaced it with something you've probably heard of:
- 5:04the World Trade Organization.
- 5:06And around that time, before and after,
- 5:08we had these extraordinarily, enormously powerful trade agreements -
- 5:12the NAFTA, the CAFTA,
- 5:15and literally thousands of bilateral investment treaties -
- 5:18all of which were governed by the same philosophy:
- 5:23non-tarrif barriers.
- 5:24How do you get nation states to sign on to this idea
- 5:29that their domestic industrial policies,
- 5:31their domestic laws, their domestic regulations
- 5:34needed to align with this global sense of efficiency?
- 5:39It's the whole idea.
- 5:42And just take a moment, and appreciate that
- 5:44because it's totally different
- 5:46than anything that the granddaddies of trade would have considered trade.
- 5:51In the late 19th century, you know,
- 5:53David Ricardo and Adam Smith
- 5:55and all these people you learn about in textbooks,
- 5:57when they were talking about trade,
- 5:59they were not talking about someone's domestic policy on environmental law.
- 6:04They were not talking about, you know,
- 6:06how long a pharmaceutical company's data exclusivity should last.
- 6:13Should it last for 12 years or 7 years or 5 years
- 6:15and under what circumstances?
- 6:17All of a sudden, that became what we were talking about
- 6:19when we talked about trade.
- 6:21And that changed everything.
- 6:24So, to give you two examples,
- 6:26one of the biggest discussions about trade that we've been having since the late '90s
- 6:31involves - or fights, really - involves the Europeans and the Americans.
- 6:35And the Americans want to export their genetically modified beef to Europe,
- 6:42and the Europeans, for a variety of cultural and social mores,
- 6:48don't want that, don't want GMO beef.
- 6:50And so, you have this fight
- 6:51because the Europeans say that they're allowed for local rule
- 6:56and national sovereignty
- 6:57and democratic nations reflecting the preferences of their constituencies,
- 7:02they should be allowed to have those rules.
- 7:04And the USA, that's backed by the WTO, says, "No,
- 7:08your domestic policies are not aligning with the sense of global efficiency."
- 7:14And that is actually a much more interesting discussion to be having
- 7:18than, Is trade good or is trade bad?
- 7:21Suddenly, we're discussing national sovereignty,
- 7:23we're discussing local rule,
- 7:25we're discussing, What do we mean by environmental regulations,
- 7:29and are we okay with them being trumped?
- 7:33Under what circumstances?
- 7:35So, here's a second example, and this happened this year in the US.
- 7:40In the US, it used to be or it is
- 7:42that if you wanted to put your tuna on the shelf
- 7:44and say "dolphin-free tuna" on it,
- 7:46you had to use methods that actually excluded dolphins.
- 7:52And the Mexican government got wind of that and said,
- 7:57"You know, that's not fair.
- 7:58That discriminates against Mexican fishermen"
- 8:02because Mexican fishermen fish in waters that are dolphin heavy,
- 8:06and they use methods that don't exclude dolphins.
- 8:09So, by having this law, we're actually discriminating against Mexican fishermen.
- 8:15And the WTO agreed.
- 8:18So, we have, you know, these efficiency problems.
- 8:20How do we think about global efficiency?
- 8:24How do we promote the free movement of as much goods and as much services
- 8:29across as many borders as possible
- 8:31while at the same time preserving the laws and regulations
- 8:35that prize things that aren't about global efficiency,
- 8:40that are maybe about, you know, racial equality
- 8:43or about protecting the environment
- 8:46or laws that prize public health issues,
- 8:49things like that?
- 8:51That gets us up to where we are today.
- 8:53You may have noticed that the conversation that we're having about trade
- 8:57on the national stage right now
- 8:59is very confused.
- 9:02(Laughter)
- 9:04We've got both of our presidential candidates,
- 9:06who appear to be in favor of free trade
- 9:09but are against the Trans-Pacific Partnership,
- 9:12that's that massive trade deal
- 9:13that would connect the United States and 11 other Pacific Rim countries.
- 9:17And then, you have other organization like the AARP and the Sierra Club
- 9:22and Doctors Without Borders
- 9:24that are opposed to elements of it.
- 9:27And people are telling us, "Oh, you're either for free trade,
- 9:30or you're against it,
- 9:31or you're for globalization, or you're against it.
- 9:34What kind of the world do you want to live in?"
- 9:36Well, we're not talking about trade.
- 9:39We're talking about rules.
- 9:43We're talking about global rules, global standards,
- 9:47and what kind of world we want that to be.
- 9:51And as soon as you sort of change your mind
- 9:53and you realize that that's what we're talking about,
- 9:56it all starts to make a lot more sense.
- 9:59So, I want to leave you guys with that idea.
- 10:03We created the world that we live in now.
- 10:06Our forefathers got together at Bretton Woods,
- 10:08and they created this global economy that we have now,
- 10:12and we remade it in the late '80s and the '90s
- 10:15with the World Trade Organization.
- 10:16The rules that we pass and that we embrace are the rules of the game that we live in.
- 10:23So, let's think about that, let's think about trade in that context.
- 10:27Let's think about what rules we want to embrace,
- 10:31what we want them to serve.
- 10:34You know, do we want global efficiency to be the paradigm that we think of,
- 10:40or do we want it to be something else, maybe like global prosperity?
- 10:45Global prosperity for normal people:
- 10:48for farmers and ranchers and, you know, everyday Americans.
- 10:54It's because the rules that we pass are the rules of the game,
- 10:56and when we talk about trade, we're talking about rules.
- 10:59Thank you so much.
- 11:01(Applause)
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of What global trade deals are really about (hint: it's not trade) | Haley Edwards | TEDxMidAtlantic by TEDx Talks, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 1,631 words across 194 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.