Wells Fargo CEO John Stumpf 'Completely Unprepared' | Squawk Box | CNBC — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:00Yesterday, it was it was a extraordinary
- 0:02theater, political theater, of
- 0:04governance drama, and public
- 0:07you know, safety
- 0:08you know, financial wealth concerns all
- 0:11wrapped up at once. You were talking
- 0:13about just earlier on the show how your
- 0:15choice of music reveals something about
- 0:16your character. If we were to
- 0:18to take a look at what they did
- 0:19yesterday and consider the the music
- 0:22from Music Man, Ronnie Howard singing
- 0:24the song The Wells Fargo man man is a
- 0:26coming down the street. I wonder what
- 0:27he's coming for. You wonder what he what
- 0:29he was coming for.
- 0:31It is
- 0:33he went in there completely unprepared.
- 0:35He had a flat drafted public relations
- 0:37script that he read off of that that was
- 0:40contrived and seemed authentic and then
- 0:42was melted in the easiest of questions
- 0:45that came his way. Questions that should
- 0:47have been anticipated. When did he know?
- 0:49What did he know and who knew what when?
- 0:52He wasn't prepared to to deal with the
- 0:55Jeff of course the the clawback issues
- 0:58and
- 0:59And he managed to unify this highly
- 1:01fractious committee. It wasn't just the
- 1:03Democrats. The Republicans just as
- 1:04harsh. Hey Jeff,
- 1:06explain this though to us cuz it's a it
- 1:07is a true governance issue. He deferred
- 1:10often times in his answer and suggested
- 1:12that it really is the board. It was the
- 1:13board's call on his compensation. It was
- 1:16the board's call on whether to fire
- 1:18people perhaps. It was the board's call
- 1:20on clawbacks etc.
- 1:22That is true to some degree but how much
- 1:25responsibility do you hold to the board?
- 1:27I mean you could say that the board
- 1:28should have taken some action ahead of a
- 1:30hearing like that or do you say the
- 1:31board say look, we got to hear
- 1:33everything. We want to see where all the
- 1:35chips fall because by the end of this
- 1:37year they may fall farther than we know
- 1:39and we need to make a decision based on
- 1:41that.
- 1:42There's a lot of accountability to throw
- 1:44around. Of course you can add to the
- 1:45equation where are all the hundreds of
- 1:47regulators embedded in there from the
- 1:48consumer of
- 1:51financial protection bureau FDIC and the
- 1:53Federal Reserve. What were for those
- 1:55hundreds of people doing? But yes, it's
- 1:57it's largely a management failure, a
- 1:58management oversight, ridiculous
- 2:00incentive scheme that
- 2:01I guess my question is Jeff, my my
- 2:03question is is John Stumpf the board?
- 2:04Assuming the the board is involved in
- 2:06this, is John Stumpf supposed to go to
- 2:07the board and say, "Look, I'm going to
- 2:08go to this hearing. And they are going
- 2:10to slaughter me. And I need in advance
- 2:13of that, we need to make some some
- 2:15decisions so we can say certain things.
- 2:17Maybe I should maybe you should
- 2:19uh you know say that I'm going to get
- 2:21zero bonus this year or I'm going to get
- 2:23zero compensation this year or whatever
- 2:25it's going to be."
- 2:25claw back all the bonuses that I have
- 2:27made.
- 2:27Yes, if you take a look at what you know
- 2:30people are looking to who is going
- 2:31or is that the board or how do you look
- 2:33at that as a governance issue?
- 2:35It this is this is him. This is somebody
- 2:38uh it's like Ken Lewis at Bank of
- 2:39America uh blaming uh regulators for
- 2:41what he did. They're or the devil made
- 2:43him do it. In this case, he's he was
- 2:44deferring throwing the board under the
- 2:46bus. I know for fact I know for fact
- 2:48that the board was stunned by a lot of
- 2:50that testimony yesterday. Uh there
- 2:52there's some of the complexity of this
- 2:54that they didn't appreciate till
- 2:55yesterday. They they surely uh they they
- 2:58should have created an independent
- 2:59investigator as what Jamie Dimon did at
- 3:01Bank JP Morgan. Sir and and done very
- 3:03well of course with Mary Barra at GM. Uh
- 3:06here he's just blinking in the
- 3:07headlights uh spotlights unprepared.
- 3:09Jeff Jeff can I be it's Brian. Can I be
- 3:10more direct? If you were the chairman of
- 3:12of Wells Fargo's board, would you fire
- 3:14John Stumpf?
- 3:16I he certainly should be put on
- 3:18probation. I don't I don't think he'd be
- 3:19shot at sunset. Uh they should be called
- 3:21Jamie gave up money. People when they've
- 3:23gotten in trouble, there should be
- 3:23symbolically uh some punishment not just
- 3:26the you know 5,300
- 3:28people making $12 an hour and this guy's
- 3:30making $19 million and of course this
- 3:33head of the of the division who was
- 3:35perhaps scapegoated, we don't know what
- 3:37her accountability was, but she leaves
- 3:38with $125 million
- 3:39ultimately who is the key constituency
- 3:42that we care about? Is this a is it does
- 3:44he now whatever credit has he lost
- 3:46credibility with the investor community?
- 3:48Because by the way the stock is the
- 3:49stock has fallen clearly has uh lost
- 3:51some value, but now with some people are
- 3:53picking it up thinking it's uh
- 3:54uh a good value all of a sudden. So, you
- 3:56may be they they took the they took
- 3:58about a hit of 10% going into this. So,
- 4:00the fact that yesterday was was
- 4:02marginally up I don't think should give
- 4:03a lot of cheer. There's still a little
- 4:05bit of trauma out there. The board
- 4:07should have been hands-on. If you if
- 4:08you're on the board of the Home Depot,
- 4:09you have to be mystery shopper for seven
- 4:12at seven stores a quarter outside of
- 4:14your home state. UPS they meet you know
- 4:16in folding tables the board and in
- 4:18sorting hubs. They need to have more
- 4:19direct access to employees not have
- 4:21information filtered through them.
- 4:22However, throwing this to the board was
- 4:24ridiculous. He should have anticipated
- 4:26the clawback issue. Under Sarbanes-Oxley
- 4:28section 304
- 4:29Jim Cramer did you watch Jim's
- 4:31interview?
- 4:32Hey CNBC fans, thanks for checking out
- 4:34our YouTube channel. Here you're going
- 4:35to find videos packed with all of the
- 4:37information that you need to be smarter
- 4:39about your finances. You can subscribe
- 4:41by clicking right here and click on all
- 4:43the videos around me or the eye right
- 4:45here to watch the latest from CNBC.
- 4:48Thanks for watching.
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of Wells Fargo CEO John Stumpf 'Completely Unprepared' | Squawk Box | CNBC by CNBC, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 1,037 words across 156 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.