We Challenge EVERY Evolutionist to Watch This Film About Creation — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:02Does what we believe about [music]
- 0:03creation or evolution even matter?
- 0:06Or does what we believe about our
- 0:07ancient past have any impact on our
- 0:09lives today?
- 0:12Can we just believe whatever we want and
- 0:14live our lives the best [music] we can?
- 0:17What about the Bible?
- 0:19How many people today will trust what it
- 0:21says [music] about salvation
- 0:23if they believe it doesn't get the
- 0:24beginning correct?
- 0:26I mean, how [music] many pages will we
- 0:27have to turn in the Bible to run into
- 0:29truths that we can trust?
- 0:33You see, there's one simple question.
- 0:34[music]
- 0:35And depending on how we answer that
- 0:36question
- 0:38can cause our lives [music] to hang in
- 0:39the balance.
- 0:41Where do we come from?
- 0:45>> What compelling evidence is there for
- 0:47evolution?
- 0:49>> I mean, we have fossils, we have you can
- 0:51see it in certain bones, like we have
- 0:53whales who have
- 0:55I believe it's tailbones left over or
- 0:57hips.
- 0:58>> Well, I think over time, you know, we
- 1:01evolved.
- 1:02>> The apes are like you can see them
- 1:04evolving to look like us.
- 1:05>> We actually have a 99% um DNA with
- 1:09shared with them.
- 1:10>> You look at species like green tree
- 1:12pythons emerald tree boas who both have
- 1:14conversion evolutions with their
- 1:15ontogenetic color changes and they're
- 1:18across worlds to completely different
- 1:19species, to completely different genuses
- 1:21and they both have developed similar
- 1:23evolutions for that.
- 1:26>> So, can you observe evolution taking
- 1:28place? I mean, doesn't it take millions
- 1:30of years?
- 1:33>> Believe that there are actually some
- 1:34cases of squirrels developing
- 1:36resistances to certain
- 1:38venoms like
- 1:39>> Hey, sweetheart. What are you watching?
- 1:41>> It's an old video I found online.
- 1:44People talking about the origins of
- 1:46life.
- 1:47>> It In what way?
- 1:49Physical features.
- 1:50>> So, you think you're a talking primate?
- 1:52>> Maybe not like right now, but like I
- 1:54guess in the past.
- 1:55>> You really believe you're a primate?
- 1:57A talking primate?
- 1:59>> Yeah, I do.
- 2:01>> Do you think man has a common ancestor
- 2:02with primates?
- 2:03>> Yeah, for sure, man.
- 2:04>> Do you believe in evolution?
- 2:06>> Yes.
- 2:06>> How sad.
- 2:07>> Do you think you have a common ancestor
- 2:09with primates?
- 2:10>> Well, I'm not a biologist, so
- 2:11>> What is [music] their right?
- 2:13>> These are super specific questions. I
- 2:14mean,
- 2:15I believe I do have a common
- 2:16ancestor.
- 2:17>> So, you're not a talking primate?
- 2:19>> What would make you say that? What do
- 2:20you mean?
- 2:21>> How closely related we are.
- 2:22>> I don't know. It's just
- 2:27>> Connor and I were talking about creation
- 2:29and he said some things that got me
- 2:31thinking.
- 2:32I mean, the scientific evidence for
- 2:34evolution is
- 2:35>> [music]
- 2:35>> pretty overwhelming.
- 2:38What if God
- 2:39used evolution?
- 2:46>> What do you believe?
- 2:48>> Honestly, I don't know anymore.
- 2:51>> I remember I was I was just a little bit
- 2:53older than you when I had some of these
- 2:55same questions.
- 2:57I was fascinated with the how we came
- 3:00into existence.
- 3:02So, I studied both sides of the
- 3:04argument.
- 3:05And
- 3:07it all changed for me one day.
- 3:09>> How?
- 3:11>> I went to a lecture at the Natural
- 3:14History Museum. There was [snorts] a man
- 3:16there. He was giving a lecture on the
- 3:18evidence of human evolution.
- 3:20>> museum today.
- 3:21I encourage you to visit the exhibits
- 3:23that will help you visualize what we've
- 3:24discussed today.
- 3:26And these exhibits should be marked in
- 3:27the maps that we provided for you.
- 3:29First, we have a wonderful exhibit that
- 3:31shows that apes and humans share about
- 3:3398% of their DNA.
- 3:35Now, remember,
- 3:37after 6 million years, the human line
- 3:40diverged from chimps based on this 1 to
- 3:422% DNA difference. We also have fossil
- 3:44evidence of key ape to human icons.
- 3:50We also have the human family tree
- 3:52exhibit
- 3:53which shows the slow progression of
- 3:55human evolution over millions of years.
- 3:58And of course this exhibit
- 4:00it proves that human evolution is a
- 4:02clear fact.
- 4:05Now in closing today
- 4:07we've seen that the earth has gradually
- 4:09changed over millions of years
- 4:11and that the continents have drifted.
- 4:14Radiometric dating has solidly
- 4:16established that the earth is billions
- 4:18of years old
- 4:19leaving plenty of time for the engine of
- 4:23evolution
- 4:25natural selection
- 4:26and mutation [music] to drive
- 4:29evolutionary progress.
- 4:31Now Charles Darwin may have
- 4:34discovered the key principles of human
- 4:36[music] evolution that we base these
- 4:38principles on.
- 4:40But it is my hope
- 4:42that you
- 4:44the next generation
- 4:46will take these theories
- 4:48and continue [music] to help us prove
- 4:50just how evolution happens.
- 4:55Now with that I'll open up the floor to
- 4:56any questions you may have.
- 5:02Okay, well thank you for your time and
- 5:04enjoy the museum.
- 5:24>> Sir, I have a question. Well, quite a
- 5:27few questions actually.
- 5:28>> Uh okay, go ahead. Uh ask away.
- 5:31>> Well, you mentioned that one of the
- 5:34leading evidences that humans evolved
- 5:36from an ape-like ancestor is that human
- 5:38and chimp DNA is 98% similar.
- 5:41>> Uh yes.
- 5:42>> Well, how big is the human genome? How
- 5:45many base pairs?
- 5:47>> Well,
- 5:48the exact figure varies over the years,
- 5:51but the last count was 3.097
- 5:54billion base pairs.
- 5:56>> And how about chimps?
- 5:57>> Uh the last count was 3.231 billion.
- 6:02>> Okay, so
- 6:05chimps have about 134 million more base
- 6:09pairs than we have,
- 6:11which means their
- 6:13genome is about 4.3%
- 6:16bigger.
- 6:17How is it possible to say that our DNA
- 6:20is like 98% similar when actually it's
- 6:234.3% bigger?
- 6:25>> Uh well, when they made the comparison
- 6:27between our genome and theirs,
- 6:29uh they were so different that they had
- 6:30to break them apart into chunks that
- 6:32were similar, and then the comparisons
- 6:34were made.
- 6:35>> Well,
- 6:36how much of the human and chimp genome
- 6:37did they leave out?
- 6:39>> Well, when they came up with the 98%
- 6:41similarity figure, they excluded 25% of
- 6:44the human genetic material and 18% of
- 6:47the chimps.
- 6:47>> Isn't that called cherry picking?
- 6:50>> Well, you may see it that way.
- 6:52>> Sure seems like it to me.
- 6:55>> [snorts]
- 6:59>> I'm sorry, sir. I didn't mean any
- 7:01disrespect. I just I've been doing a lot
- 7:04of research and I'm really fascinated by
- 7:06all this.
- 7:07>> You know, there's no need to apologize.
- 7:08I like it when people do a little
- 7:10critical thinking.
- 7:11>> Thank you, sir.
- 7:13Well, how similar are the human and
- 7:15chimp genomes when the entire genome is
- 7:17compared without cherry picking like
- 7:19that?
- 7:20>> Well, when the researchers factored in
- 7:21the non-similar data into the
- 7:24comparisons, the similarities were only
- 7:26between 66% and 86%.
- 7:29>> That's a lot less than 98%. Doesn't
- 7:33sound very similar to me.
- 7:34>> Well, they recently re-sequenced the
- 7:36chimp genome, and the technology is
- 7:38getting better.
- 7:39>> So, what did the new study show?
- 7:42>> Let's
- 7:43see. Uh
- 7:48>> Uh okay, well, here it is.
- 7:50Based on the new data in 2018, they now
- 7:52say the human and chimp DNA similarity
- 7:54is a maximum of 84%
- 7:57but it says they didn't include the
- 7:59areas of human and chimp DNA that could
- 8:01not be matched up. [music] So,
- 8:04the actual estimate is lower.
- 8:08>> So, [music] we went from 98% similarity
- 8:11to 84% maximum similarity between the
- 8:14comparable regions. Plus, the chimp
- 8:16genome is 4% bigger.
- 8:18>> [music]
- 8:18>> Evolutionists claimed that 98%
- 8:21similarity figure supported their idea
- 8:23of humans branching off because they
- 8:25were so close.
- 8:27With the 84% maximum similarity figure,
- 8:30there would obviously be way too many
- 8:32genetic changes to make within their
- 8:34supposed 6 million year timeline when
- 8:36humans supposedly branched off. I mean,
- 8:38we're talking hundreds of millions of
- 8:40additional [music] changes above what
- 8:42their 98% estimate would equate to.
- 8:44>> Yes, but the fact remains that we share
- 8:47many similar genes with apes. [music]
- 8:49Wouldn't you agree?
- 8:51>> Well, yes,
- 8:53but
- 8:54we also share many similar genes with
- 8:56other mammals [music]
- 8:57because we have similar metabolisms and
- 8:58biochemistries. It's a basic engineering
- 9:01principle. Common code doing a similar
- 9:03purpose.
- 9:04I mean, I could even pull up a National
- 9:06Geographic website with a gene
- 9:07calculator that shows me I'm 88% similar
- 9:10to a mouse, 85% similar to a cow, and
- 9:1384% similar to a dog.
- 9:15>> You really seem to know your stuff.
- 9:18You know, most people, they hear that
- 9:1998% figure, they have no idea about its
- 9:21limitations or [music] where the figure
- 9:23even came from.
- 9:24>> Yes, and because the mantra has been
- 9:27quoted so long in so many places,
- 9:29>> [music]
- 9:30>> most people just accept it as proof for
- 9:32evolution.
- 9:33>> Okay, so, what else is on your mind? You
- 9:35said you had uh several questions.
- 9:37[music]
- 9:38>> Yes.
- 9:41I had a couple questions on the leading
- 9:43fossils you showed that supposedly show
- 9:45how humans evolved over time.
- 9:48Could you go back to the side you have
- 9:49[music] on Ardi?
- 9:50>> Sure.
- 9:58I'm sure you're referring to
- 10:00this issue.
- 10:02Well, actually no. This skeleton was
- 10:05reconstructed from over 110 bone pieces
- 10:07that they found over a 30-ft area. Took
- 10:10them over a decade to put it together.
- 10:12And the picture on the cover is only a
- 10:14digital reconstruction of what they
- 10:16found.
- 10:16>> What kind of shape are the bones in?
- 10:19>> Well, they weren't found in very good
- 10:20shape at all. In fact, the scientists
- 10:23who found it, it took them 3 years to
- 10:24dig it up, about a decade to put it
- 10:26together.
- 10:28They said the bones were found in
- 10:30terrible condition
- 10:31and literally crumbled when touched. The
- 10:34lead scientist called it like roadkill.
- 10:37>> Were any of the bone pieces found
- 10:39connected together?
- 10:40>> No.
- 10:41All the 110-plus bone pieces were found
- 10:43separately over the 30-ft area.
- 10:47>> That doesn't sound odd to you?
- 10:50Let's take her head for example. What
- 10:52type of evidence did they find for
- 10:54reconstructing her head which is
- 10:55displayed in school textbooks and
- 10:56museums everywhere?
- 10:58>> Well,
- 11:00this skull was found in pulverized
- 11:02condition in 34 scattered pieces and it
- 11:04was compacted to about 1 and 1/2 inches
- 11:07thick. So, they tried making digital
- 11:09reconstructions.
- 11:10>> What about her skull made her seem
- 11:11anything but ape-like?
- 11:13I mean, did she have a bigger brain than
- 11:15most chimps have? Something else?
- 11:17>> Actually, no. Her brain was about the
- 11:20same size as bonobos or female
- 11:22chimpanzees. But, one of the ways we can
- 11:24tell she walked upright is based on her
- 11:26skull. Specifically, where the spine
- 11:28enters the base of the skull. Called the
- 11:30foramen magnum.
- 11:33>> Can you show me what you're talking
- 11:34about?
- 11:35>> Uh sure.
- 11:37Uh this is actually a version um that
- 11:41took them thousands of hours to develop
- 11:42digitally based on what remained of the
- 11:44skull. After the 11th digital version,
- 11:47they settled on this one.
- 11:48>> 11 versions?
- 11:50How can you tell where her spine enters
- 11:52her skull from the pieces they found? I
- 11:55mean, and do they have any of her other
- 11:57neck vertebrae so we can see how it
- 12:00might have gone into her skull?
- 12:03>> No.
- 12:05>> So, let me get this straight. They don't
- 12:08actually have the entire base of her
- 12:10skull to see where her spine entered,
- 12:12but they made a digital reconstruction
- 12:15so they could guess where it might have
- 12:16been, but they don't have her neck
- 12:18vertebrae either and they think she
- 12:20walked upright based in part on these
- 12:23two things, but they don't really have
- 12:25either one.
- 12:26>> Well,
- 12:27the human-like curve of her lower spine
- 12:30is another reason they thought she
- 12:31walked upright.
- 12:32>> Okay. How much of her lower spine did
- 12:34they find?
- 12:36Did they find any of her lower spine
- 12:37vertebrae?
- 12:38>> Um well, none actually. Um they
- 12:40estimated the curve of her spine, called
- 12:42lumbar lordosis, based on her pelvis.
- 12:45Dr. Lovejoy believed that her spine was
- 12:47probably long and curved like a human's
- 12:50rather than short and stiff like a
- 12:52chimp's, suggesting that she was an
- 12:54upright walker.
- 12:57You see, we have four curves in our
- 12:58spine to facilitate the upright walking.
- 13:01While chimps just have a slight bend
- 13:03over their entire spine. He based this
- 13:05assumption on the reconstruction of
- 13:07Ardi's pelvis and the belief that Ardi
- 13:09probably had six lower spine vertebrae.
- 13:12>> But they didn't actually find any of her
- 13:15lower spine vertebrae.
- 13:17>> No, uh but they were able to reconstruct
- 13:19what they think the pelvis looked like
- 13:21and that helped them guess what the
- 13:23lower spine may have looked like.
- 13:26>> How many lower spine do chimps have?
- 13:28>> Most apes typically have three or four.
- 13:31Uh humans have five.
- 13:32>> Okay. So, they don't have any of her
- 13:36lower spine vertebrae. So, they added
- 13:38some imaginary ones, gave her a couple
- 13:41extra beyond what typical apes have,
- 13:44gave her an entire imaginary spine
- 13:46complete with a human-like curve and fed
- 13:48it up to a hole in the imagined base of
- 13:51her skull with some neck vertebrae which
- 13:53they also didn't find.
- 13:56Don't any other evolutionary scientists
- 13:58have concerns about this?
- 14:00>> Uh well, actually,
- 14:02they do.
- 14:03>> [music]
- 14:03>> There are some who believe that the
- 14:05theory that's Ardi walked upright is
- 14:07faulty because it's based on highly
- 14:09speculative inferences
- 14:10>> [music]
- 14:11>> about the presence of lumbar lordosis
- 14:13and on relatively few features
- 14:15>> [music]
- 14:15>> on the pelvis and the foot.
- 14:17>> So, paleo experts aren't buying it.
- 14:20>> Uh yes, uh several are not.
- 14:24>> So, if they're basing her upright
- 14:26walking on her pelvis, what was her
- 14:28pelvis like?
- 14:36>> Well, it was too damaged and fragile to
- 14:38take it out of the matrix it was in. So,
- 14:40Dr. Lovejoy made a restoration based on
- 14:42his knowledge of primate anatomy and a
- 14:44micro CT scan. And after 14 different
- 14:47configurations,
- 14:49this is the one that they settled on.
- 14:50It's the one you see in most reports.
- 14:52>> They reconstructed her pelvis digitally
- 14:5514 times?
- 14:56>> Yes, and I'm sure you want to know what
- 14:59other paleontologist experts think about
- 15:00it.
- 15:01Well, there is speculation among some
- 15:04experts who believe that choosing the
- 15:06correct pelvis reconstruction is like
- 15:08seeing images in a Rorschach
- 15:10inkblot test.
- 15:15Thus, making it hard uh to think that
- 15:18it's accurate.
- 15:21Uh look, I know there are concerns about
- 15:23Ardi. Uh She's not the perfect proof of
- 15:26the ape-to-human lineup.
- 15:28Look at her hands and feet.
- 15:30They look ape-like.
- 15:31They're really curved and long with
- 15:33short thumbs, very similar to
- 15:34tree-dwelling apes of today that
- 15:37use them for getting around in trees.
- 15:39>> Why would a creature with such big
- 15:41divergent toes, which are used by every
- 15:44ape today for getting around in trees,
- 15:46be an upright walker like humans?
- 15:49Wouldn't that be awkward
- 15:50trying to walk on level ground with a
- 15:52big toe sticking out to the side?
- 15:58Could you go back to the side of Ardi's
- 16:00skeleton?
- 16:03See,
- 16:04I just don't buy that she's an early
- 16:06human ancestor. She had a brain the size
- 16:09of a chimp's and a head like a chimp's
- 16:11with an imagined base of the skull and
- 16:14an imagined curved spine.
- 16:16But because of a bump on her pelvis, she
- 16:19was supposedly walking around like a
- 16:21human?
- 16:23I mean, it looks like there's a lot of
- 16:24speculation going on here. In some
- 16:26cases, even exaggeration. It doesn't
- 16:29look like she would be a good walker to
- 16:31me.
- 16:32But I bet she'd get around in trees like
- 16:35other apes.
- 16:36You had a slide showing Ardi next to a
- 16:38bonobo, correct?
- 16:40>> Uh
- 16:44>> When you put her next to a bonobo, it
- 16:47sure looks like she fits into the ape
- 16:48family just fine.
- 16:50>> [laughter]
- 16:54>> You know, we have several fossils that
- 16:56show evolutionary steps between ape-like
- 16:58creatures and humans.
- 17:00Take Lucy for example. She's probably
- 17:02the best evidence of human evolution.
- 17:04She's displayed in museums and school
- 17:06textbooks around the world as the
- 17:08leading ape-to-human icon.
- 17:10Well, here, check out this short BBC
- 17:12video narrated by Dr. Donald Johanson,
- 17:14the person who found Lucy.
- 17:17>> We now have 400 specimens of Lucy's
- 17:20species Australopithecus afarensis,
- 17:23named after the Afar region, and uh we
- 17:26know that there are very large
- 17:27individuals which were males, and the
- 17:30smaller ones uh are certainly female.
- 17:33>> Did they really find hundreds of
- 17:35complete skeletons like they show in the
- 17:38video?
- 17:39>> No.
- 17:40Here's what they actually found.
- 17:44>> [snorts]
- 17:44>> What they mean by 400 specimens is 400
- 17:47bone pieces, and over 30% of those are
- 17:50teeth.
- 17:51So, no, there's only enough to display
- 17:53on a picnic table.
- 17:56So, here's Lucy,
- 17:58and the rest of the fossils they believe
- 18:00are from her species uh they're
- 18:01scattered on the table. I'm sure you
- 18:03could only fill a bucket or two with
- 18:04them.
- 18:05>> That sure doesn't look like what they
- 18:07show on the video when they say they
- 18:08found 400 specimens. It looks like
- 18:11they're exaggerating quite deliberately.
- 18:14When it comes to Lucy's fossil
- 18:16specifically, did they find her bones at
- 18:19the same place, and were they all
- 18:21connected?
- 18:22>> Uh no. Uh she was found in hundreds of
- 18:25pieces scattered across a 3-m area on a
- 18:27hillside.
- 18:29Uh they sifted a total of 20 tons of
- 18:31sediment covering 50 square meters to
- 18:33find what resulted in only about 20% of
- 18:36all of her bones, but they didn't find
- 18:38any hand or feet bones except for one
- 18:41small finger bone.
- 18:43>> Yet, you showed us pictures of Lucy
- 18:45rendered by different artists with
- 18:48human-like hands, feet, and even eye
- 18:51whites.
- 18:52Could you pull that one up?
- 18:59Do apes even have eye whites [music]
- 19:02like the picture you showed?
- 19:04>> No.
- 19:10Look,
- 19:11I know that Lucy has some limitations.
- 19:14They didn't find much of her. But
- 19:15remember, Lucy is 3.2 million years old,
- 19:18and we have a few million years of
- 19:20ape-to-human progression since then.
- 19:22>> Okay. Tell me about the next million
- 19:24years, from say 3 million to 2 million
- 19:27years ago.
- 19:28What does [music] the fossil record look
- 19:30like during that period?
- 19:31>> The fossil record is quite sparse during
- 19:34that period.
- 19:35>> How sparse?
- 19:37>> Well, Dr. Kimbel, the director of the
- 19:39Institute [music] of Human Origins, said
- 19:41due to how rare the
- 19:43homo fossils are from 2 to 3 million
- 19:45years ago, you could probably fit all of
- 19:47the fossils into a small shoebox
- 19:50and still have room for a good pair of
- 19:52shoes.
- 19:53>> Don't you think that's an unusually long
- 19:55time to go without any supposed
- 19:57transitions between apes to humans?
- 20:09So, Charles Darwin said,
- 20:12"As by evolution theory, innumerable
- 20:14transitional forms must have existed.
- 20:16Why do we not find them embedded in
- 20:18countless numbers in the crust of the
- 20:19earth?"
- 20:21He also said,
- 20:22"Why is not every geological formation
- 20:24and every stratum full of such
- 20:26intermediate links? Geology assuredly
- 20:29does not reveal any such finely
- 20:31graduated organic chain. And this is the
- 20:33most obvious and serious objection which
- 20:36can be urged against the theory."
- 20:38>> You seem to have come prepared with
- 20:40props and books, just like I have.
- 20:42>> [laughter]
- 20:47>> I I'm just trying to understand.
- 20:50I mean, when you look at the big
- 20:51picture,
- 20:53how many ape-to-human fossils are there,
- 20:55all in all?
- 20:57>> Well, according to Dr. Tattersall, you
- 21:00could fit it all in the back of a pickup
- 21:01truck if you didn't mind how much you
- 21:03jumbled everything up.
- 21:05>> All the evidence for the entire human
- 21:07line?
- 21:07>> Yes. Look, I'm not saying we have
- 21:10hundreds and hundreds of clear
- 21:11connections between ape-like creatures
- 21:12and humans. The record is in fact
- 21:14sparse. I'm I'm admitting that. Look,
- 21:17watch this clip. I didn't show it during
- 21:19the presentation. This is the leading
- 21:21paleo expert, Dr. Berger, giving a
- 21:23speech at Google.
- 21:27>> I'm a paleoanthropologist.
- 21:29I look for early human ancestors. I
- 21:31actually look for the rarest
- 21:34sought-after objects on the planet. I'm
- 21:35in a field of science that actually
- 21:38probably has
- 21:39more scientists in it than it does
- 21:42objects that we study. There are
- 21:44literally just a a a few thousand of
- 21:46these incredibly precious objects. Most
- 21:49of them are just fragments, tiny little
- 21:51bits and pieces. About 80% of the record
- 21:53of human origins in Africa represents
- 21:56isolated teeth. The remaining, say, 18%
- 21:59of that represents little bits and
- 22:01pieces of postcranial bones, of which we
- 22:03almost have had no complete elements
- 22:06from the neck down. Those skulls and
- 22:08stuff that you see on National
- 22:10Geographic and such, those are
- 22:12incredibly rare, numbering in just a few
- 22:13dozens.
- 22:14>> All right, so there's the big picture.
- 22:16Now, let's focus in on some of the
- 22:17points about Lucy to see how she fits in
- 22:19the human evolution tree.
- 22:21Overall, Lucy was about 3 and 1/2 ft
- 22:24tall and likely weighed about 64 lb. To
- 22:27put that in perspective, female chimps
- 22:30are about the same height as Lucy and
- 22:32typically weigh between 70 and 100 lb.
- 22:35But, Lucy's body type was more similar
- 22:38to a pygmy chimp or a bonobo, which is a
- 22:42cousin to the chimp.
- 22:43They're about the same size as Lucy.
- 22:45Females average 3 ft 8 in and about 68
- 22:49lb.
- 22:50>> So, Lucy was basically the same height
- 22:53and weight as many chimps and most
- 22:55bonobos we see today in zoos?
- 22:57>> Well, in many ways, she was very similar
- 23:00to a bonobo, but we believe she had
- 23:02several features that show she was
- 23:04becoming more human-like. And let's
- 23:06start with the head and we'll work our
- 23:07way down to her toes.
- 23:09>> Lucy's complete skull is shown in
- 23:11museums and school textbooks across
- 23:13America. But did they actually find her
- 23:15skull?
- 23:16>> No,
- 23:17but we did find these skull fragments.
- 23:19[music]
- 23:22>> So
- 23:24these few brown pieces are what they
- 23:25actually found and the rest is well,
- 23:29imagined?
- 23:30>> I wouldn't go that far.
- 23:32>> But did they find the white parts?
- 23:35>> No.
- 23:37>> So how can they not be imagined?
- 23:40Besides
- 23:42don't you think her skull looks very
- 23:44similar to a modern bonobo skull?
- 23:46>> I see what you're saying. I mean Lucy's
- 23:48discoverers said Lucy's skull [music]
- 23:50was almost entirely missing. So
- 23:52knowing the exact size of Lucy's brain
- 23:54was the crucial bit of missing evidence.
- 23:56But from the few skull fragments we had,
- 23:58it looks surprisingly small.
- 24:00Later estimates revealed that Lucy's
- 24:02brain was just 1/3 [music] the size of
- 24:04the human brain making her brain about
- 24:06the average size of the average chimp.
- 24:09>> So just what is it about her skull that
- 24:12makes her anything but an ape?
- 24:14>> What do you want me to say?
- 24:19Yes, there's a lot of controversy about
- 24:20her skull.
- 24:21Some anthropologists believe her skull
- 24:23is very ape-like while others convinced
- 24:25it's more human-like.
- 24:28>> May I?
- 24:30Lucy's claim to fame is that she
- 24:32supposedly walked upright like we do.
- 24:34But how could she walk upright when
- 24:36studies show that the spine of her
- 24:39species entered the base of her skull at
- 24:41an angle just like chimps today.
- 24:44Also, her face was totally sloped like a
- 24:47chimp's.
- 24:48That certainly wouldn't have helped.
- 24:51Our spine enters into the middle of the
- 24:53base of our skull at a relatively
- 24:55straight angle so that we can walk
- 24:57upright with ease and turn our heads as
- 24:59we walk. But in both chimps and Lucy's
- 25:02kind, the spine enters more towards the
- 25:04rear of the skull and comes in [music]
- 25:05slanted, forcing her to walk hunched
- 25:07over, so she can see where she's going.
- 25:09I also understand that the semicircular
- 25:12canals in Lucy's species would have made
- 25:14it really difficult to walk on two legs.
- 25:17Have you heard about that?
- 25:19>> No, not yet, but I'm sure you would
- 25:21enjoy enlightening me.
- 25:24>> [laughter]
- 25:26>> May I use your laptop to pull something
- 25:28up?
- 25:29>> Be my guest.
- 25:34>> Well, humans and apes have three
- 25:36semicircular canals embedded deep within
- 25:38their ears to keep balance while moving.
- 25:41Scientists have learned from the skull
- 25:43scans of other australopithecines that
- 25:45they were best suited for walking
- 25:46occasionally on two feet, just like
- 25:49chimps do today.
- 25:50Dr. Woods' study revealed that the
- 25:52semicircular canals of Lucy's kind were
- 25:54more like those of chimps than modern
- 25:57humans and suggested that Lucy's species
- 25:59would not have been restricted to
- 26:01walking on two feet.
- 26:03Other studies in the Scientific American
- 26:04have found that the semicircular canals
- 26:06of Lucy's kind resemble those of African
- 26:09apes today.
- 26:10It seems like she was much better
- 26:12equipped for living in trees, like
- 26:14chimps today.
- 26:16So, now moving on from her head, what's
- 26:19that little bone at the bottom of her
- 26:20skull?
- 26:22>> Well, that bone is not supposed to be
- 26:24there anymore.
- 26:25>> Well, what do you mean it's not supposed
- 26:27to be there?
- 26:29>> Excuse me.
- 26:33That's her thoracic vertebrae, and
- 26:35scientists learned about 5 years ago
- 26:36that it belonged to an extinct relative
- 26:39of the baboon called the Theropithecus
- 26:40darti, a common ape-like creature around
- 26:43when Lucy was alive. It didn't belong to
- 26:45Lucy or her species.
- 26:47>> Then, how did it get mixed in with
- 26:49Lucy's skeleton?
- 26:51>> We're not sure, but remember Lucy is
- 26:54made up of hundreds of broken bone
- 26:56pieces that were scattered across a
- 26:57hillside, and they screened 20 tons of
- 26:59dirt over 50 square meters to be sure
- 27:02they collected everything. So, I guess
- 27:04it accidentally got included with her
- 27:06fossil.
- 27:07>> If this is the case, then
- 27:09why haven't you removed the bone from
- 27:10her her display case?
- 27:11>> We just haven't gotten around to it yet.
- 27:14>> Have any other natural history museums
- 27:16removed it?
- 27:17>> No.
- 27:19None that I'm aware of.
- 27:21>> This chick thinks this is all just a
- 27:22bunch of guesswork. Who does she think
- 27:24she is?
- 27:25>> I know, but the docent doesn't seem to
- 27:27be giving any solid [music] evidence to
- 27:29support his claims.
- 27:33>> What about her wrists and hands? Were
- 27:35they like those of apes or humans?
- 27:38>> Yeah, they were quite apelike. And we
- 27:40over 20 years after Lucy was found, some
- 27:43scientists discovered that Lucy had the
- 27:45same kind of locking wrists [music] with
- 27:46ledges and notches that are classic
- 27:49features of knuckle-walking apes.
- 27:51>> And we don't have locking wrists.
- 27:53>> Correct. It's only found in apes that
- 27:55walk using both their hands and feet.
- 27:58The fingers of Lucy's species were quite
- 28:00curved and apelike, even by ape
- 28:02standards,
- 28:03and best suited for swinging in trees.
- 28:06>> What about her feet?
- 28:07>> Well, they didn't find any of Lucy's
- 28:09foot or toe bones.
- 28:11>> Well,
- 28:12that sure didn't stop them from putting
- 28:14feet on her in basically every natural
- 28:16history museum in America.
- 28:18>> That's because they found a couple of
- 28:19hundred bones in another location that
- 28:21represented 13 to 17 or so creatures
- 28:23they believed were her same species, and
- 28:26some of those were foot or toe bones.
- 28:28Maybe enough to put into a lunch box.
- 28:31They also found some footprints, called
- 28:32the Laetoli footprints.
- 28:34They believe they were made by Lucy's
- 28:36species.
- 28:37>> Where did they find them, and did they
- 28:40date about the same time as Lucy's
- 28:42fossils?
- 28:43>> They found them in Tanzania, about a
- 28:45thousand miles away.
- 28:46And they dated the footprints to about
- 28:48half a million years older than Lucy's
- 28:49bones.
- 28:51>> I'm sorry. It's just I had no idea the
- 28:53case for human evolution was so weak.
- 28:56>> It's not weak. She's just not relying on
- 28:58science.
- 28:59>> Even if they did have Lucy's feet, based
- 29:02on the size of her species, how well
- 29:04would they fit into the footprints found
- 29:06at Laetoli?
- 29:07>> Now, that's a hot topic because experts
- 29:09agree that the footprints they found
- 29:10looked human. I mean, completely human.
- 29:13And some of them were quite long, like
- 29:15over 10 in. In modern terms,
- 29:17in modern terms, that equates to a 9 and
- 29:191/2 foot shoe size and a person about 5
- 29:22ft 9 in.
- 29:24Probably made by a male.
- 29:26>> How tall was Lucy again?
- 29:27>> About 3 and 1/2 ft tall.
- 29:30>> What
- 29:31That doesn't make any sense.
- 29:33They believe that Lucy was a full-grown
- 29:35female at only 3 and 1/2 ft tall.
- 29:38But they say that a male of her species
- 29:41was 5 ft 9 in and made the footprints
- 29:43with a massive 10-in feet. That's like
- 29:4665% taller than the female version.
- 29:49I'm not buying it.
- 29:52Sounds more like the human footprints
- 29:54were made by humans and your dating
- 29:57timeline is off.
- 29:59I mean,
- 30:00way off.
- 30:02Also, didn't they find 13 fossils
- 30:04belonging to the genus Homo
- 30:07in that region that looked human?
- 30:09>> Yes, but the team that found Lucy later
- 30:12reclassified those bones as Lucy's
- 30:14species.
- 30:15>> Sounds convenient. If the footprints
- 30:19looked unmistakably human, human-looking
- 30:21bones were found around the footprints,
- 30:23and Lucy's fossils were found about
- 30:251,000 mi away, wouldn't it make more
- 30:28sense that the footprints were actually
- 30:30made by humans and that your timeline is
- 30:32off?
- 30:33>> Sure, I guess one would certainly make
- 30:35that argument, but we know for sure that
- 30:37humans were not around back then.
- 30:40>> [laughter]
- 30:42>> I thought you might say that.
- 30:44Did you know that just a couple of years
- 30:46ago they found anatomically modern human
- 30:48footprints in western Crete that
- 30:50supposedly dated to 5.7 million years
- 30:54old? The article stated that the
- 30:56footprints were a million years older
- 30:58than Ardipithecus ramidus. That
- 31:00conflicts with the hypothesis that Ardi
- 31:02is a direct ancestor of later hominids.
- 31:05So, using the evolutionary timeline,
- 31:08these human footprints predate both Ardi
- 31:11and Lucy.
- 31:12It sure seems like the ape-to-man story
- 31:14doesn't line up with these footprints
- 31:16dating to a time before upright walking
- 31:18was even supposed to happen. It sounds
- 31:21more plausible to me that these apelike
- 31:24creatures died in ice age flooding that
- 31:26happened after Noah's flood just
- 31:29thousands of years ago.
- 31:30>> A [laughter] flood that there was no
- 31:32evidence for.
- 31:33>> Well,
- 31:34I actually believe there's a lot of
- 31:36evidence for Noah's flood, but the
- 31:38evidence that you claim to have for Lucy
- 31:40is based on hundreds of bone pieces
- 31:42glued together to make a fragmented
- 31:45skeleton of about 20% of her bones.
- 31:49By the way,
- 31:51may I pull up something else?
- 31:57Just a few years ago, CNN did a report
- 32:00on a study done by a team of scientists
- 32:02where Lucy fell 40 ft from a tree
- 32:05traveling 35 mph where she died.
- 32:11So,
- 32:13what was a little ape who was supposedly
- 32:15walking upright doing 40 ft up in a
- 32:18tree?
- 32:21>> [laughter]
- 32:23>> Yet, when millions of students every
- 32:26year see Lucy in museums, she's shown
- 32:29with complete human-like feet and hands,
- 32:32eye whites like a human, walking upright
- 32:34with human-like gazes and poses.
- 32:37Sometimes they even remove the hair from
- 32:38her skin.
- 32:39Again, trying [music] to make her appear
- 32:41more human-like.
- 32:42>> Hey, come on. You're not a credible
- 32:44source.
- 32:45I bet all these trained paleo experts
- 32:47don't even have these concerns about
- 32:48Lucy.
- 32:49>> As I've already brought up though,
- 32:52there's a whole lineup of famous paleo
- 32:54experts who'd stand up here and say
- 32:57these same types of things.
- 32:59Just read Dr. Oxnard's Order of Man.
- 33:02He said that Australopithecines are now
- 33:04irrevocably removed from a place in the
- 33:06evolution of human bipedals.
- 33:09All of this should make us wonder about
- 33:11the usual presentation of human
- 33:13evolution in introductory textbooks.
- 33:16Dr. Herbert says that his fellow
- 33:18paleoanthropologists
- 33:19compare the pygmy chimps [music] to
- 33:21Lucy, one of the oldest hominid fossils
- 33:24known, and find the similarities
- 33:26striking.
- 33:27They're almost identical in [music] body
- 33:29size, in stature, and in brain size.
- 33:38>> Okay, everybody.
- 33:41What's your name by the way?
- 33:42>> Christina.
- 33:42>> Christina. Hey Christina, I think all
- 33:44these folks really want to get to the
- 33:46exhibits that they all paid to come and
- 33:47see.
- 33:49>> I'm not stopping anybody.
- 33:52I simply had some questions I was hoping
- 33:54you could help me with.
- 33:55>> Let me guess. You have more.
- 33:58>> Yes.
- 34:00We move on from Lucy. The next in the
- 34:03line for human evolution is Homo
- 34:05habilis, correct?
- 34:07>> Yes.
- 34:16>> Okay.
- 34:17How many complete Homo habilis creatures
- 34:19have they found? Like a few hundred
- 34:22skeletons?
- 34:23>> No, not that many.
- 34:25>> I'm guessing a dozen skeletons?
- 34:27>> Actually, they haven't found any.
- 34:30>> You're losing me here.
- 34:32They haven't found any?
- 34:33>> Well, of course they found fossil
- 34:35pieces.
- 34:36Fewer than 100 they believe belong to
- 34:37Homo habilis, but they haven't found any
- 34:39complete creatures.
- 34:41>> Okay, so this creature is shown in
- 34:43complete form
- 34:45even with human-looking eyes with eye
- 34:47whites in museums around the world, but
- 34:50they haven't found any complete
- 34:51creatures. What is the best shot for
- 34:53Homo habilis? The most defining fossil
- 34:55set?
- 34:56Are there enough bones from the same
- 34:58creature to recreate it as they do as
- 35:00they do in the museums?
- 35:01>> Well, they've never found even a
- 35:02partially complete habilis skeleton, but
- 35:04they do have up to 100 bone pieces
- 35:06categorized in this species and a few
- 35:09partial skulls.
- 35:11The best set they have is a small
- 35:13collection of bones they refer to as the
- 35:15official type specimen.
- 35:19It was found over a widely excavated
- 35:21area and was mixed with bones from
- 35:22species from the cow, the pig, the
- 35:25horse, and the tortoise families and a
- 35:28few catfish and birds.
- 35:30This defining specimen consists of a
- 35:32jawbone with 13 teeth, a molar, a couple
- 35:35of skull fragments, and 21 finger, hand,
- 35:38and wrist bones.
- 35:39>> How did they know all these bones were
- 35:41from the same Homo habilis creature?
- 35:44>> Well, it went through some uh revisions.
- 35:47They later found out that six of the 21
- 35:49finger bones
- 35:51did not belong in a one of the finger
- 35:53bones was a vertebral fragment. Two
- 35:55others belonged to a monkey. Originally,
- 35:57they described the hand as human and
- 35:58because it looked like it had precise
- 36:00grasping abilities, they called it Homo
- 36:03habilis, which means handyman.
- 36:05They suspected that it was a slightly
- 36:07larger-brained early human that made the
- 36:09thousands of stone tools found in the
- 36:11same area.
- 36:12>> Interesting.
- 36:14Do they know whether the stone tools
- 36:16they found near the fossils were used by
- 36:18Homo habilis or if they were used on
- 36:21Homo habilis by humans?
- 36:23>> They don't know.
- 36:24Uh in the same archaeological beds,
- 36:26several sites were found where a
- 36:28thousands of animals of different kinds
- 36:30were butchered and eaten along with
- 36:31thousands of stone tools of many
- 36:34varieties. They also found the rock
- 36:36foundation on a 12-ft circular hut
- 36:38nearby also in the same archaeological
- 36:40bed and they describe this circular
- 36:42stone foundation as having a striking
- 36:44similarity to the shelters made by
- 36:46present-day nomadic people in the same
- 36:48area today.
- 36:49>> I also heard they found the stone circle
- 36:51in a layer beneath the type set bones
- 36:53for Homo habilis. Is this the case?
- 36:56>> Yes.
- 36:57>> So, wouldn't this mean that whoever was
- 36:59there working with tools and making huts
- 37:02was on the scene before Homo habilis
- 37:05even showed up on the fossil record?
- 37:07>> Well, I guess it would.
- 37:09>> So, how does using this creature support
- 37:12the evolutionary theory?
- 37:14It seems backwards to me. Yes, I see
- 37:16what you mean. I mean [music] it seems
- 37:18out of order compared to what we would
- 37:19expect. It's a good point.
- 37:22Could you please go back to the slide
- 37:24showing the stone hut foundation they
- 37:25found? Sure.
- 37:29What types of animal bones are shown
- 37:31scattered all around the hut? Well,
- 37:33they're bones from species [music] in
- 37:34the croc, crow, hippo, elephant, horse,
- 37:38tortoise, and pig families. How many
- 37:41bones did they find outside the hut
- 37:42area?
- 37:44It looks like 348. And how many were
- 37:47found inside the hut foundation? Only 11
- 37:50small fragments, mostly toes and teeth.
- 37:53And what about the leftover of rock
- 37:55pieces that get chipped off when they're
- 37:57making tools called
- 37:59debitage?
- 38:00Debitage. Was that found mostly inside
- 38:04or outside of the hut foundation?
- 38:07Well, this slide shows that they found
- 38:0950 pieces of debitage and 48 of 50 were
- 38:13found outside the stone hut foundation.
- 38:16You've got to be kidding me.
- 38:20So, just to be clear, they found a 12-ft
- 38:22stone hut foundation below Homo habilis
- 38:25bones with almost all discards from tool
- 38:27making outside the hut. And they also
- 38:30found over 300 bones from eight
- 38:32different [music] types of butchered
- 38:33animals outside the hut. And the paleo
- 38:35experts who discovered the site said it
- 38:37was similar to how nomadic people still
- 38:40live, even today.
- 38:42It seems quite obvious that humans were
- 38:44living here, not apes.
- 38:47>> Well, that line of thinking would agree
- 38:48with Mary Leakey. [music] Uh she was the
- 38:50lead paleo expert over the site, and she
- 38:53said that the two key giveaways that the
- 38:55stone hut foundation [music] was an
- 38:57artificial, like a man-made site, were
- 38:59the six mounds of heaped rocks, um
- 39:02evidently for support poles,
- 39:04>> [music]
- 39:04>> and the disproportionate uh number of
- 39:06bones and tools they found outside of
- 39:07the hut, not inside, along with the 2-ft
- 39:10buffer around the circle
- 39:12without a lot of tools or bones. Um she
- 39:15said it was a
- 39:16a lot like the one that people in the
- 39:17same area built today.
- 39:27>> Can you please tell me about the types
- 39:28of stone tools they found at the site
- 39:30where the hut foundation was found?
- 39:32>> They found choppers, polyhedrons,
- 39:34discoids, and many small tools like
- 39:37scrapers, burins, and flakes.
- 39:39>> Where did they get the materials to make
- 39:41the stone tools? And did they just use
- 39:44any kind of rock?
- 39:45>> Actually, they mostly use a rock called
- 39:47quartzite
- 39:49um because it can be be flaked to a
- 39:50razor-like edge. Uh that type of rock
- 39:53was not found in the area. They had to
- 39:55quarry it from a location miles away and
- 39:57bring it to where they used it to
- 39:58butcher the animals.
- 40:00>> What steps would need to be taken to
- 40:01turn this quartzite rock into the tools
- 40:03they found, these animals butchering
- 40:05sites? I mean, is it easy to do?
- 40:09>> Actually, it's a really difficult to do,
- 40:11and there are several steps that have to
- 40:13be taken. Well, first, you've got to
- 40:15have the right kinds of rocks, uh like
- 40:17the quartzite they found, because it can
- 40:19be flaked and shaped into sharp handheld
- 40:21tools for animal butchering. Then you
- 40:23have to shape the rock using percussion
- 40:25or pressure tools like pointed
- 40:28hammerstones or cylindrical hammers,
- 40:32like long bones. Most of the stone tools
- 40:35found were sized to be held in the hand
- 40:37for processing the meat off of animals,
- 40:40like
- 40:41primitive slaughterhouse.
- 40:44>> One more thing.
- 40:46Didn't the Leakeys,
- 40:47the very scientists who discovered Homo
- 40:49habilis,
- 40:50find fossil evidence that led them to
- 40:52believe that Australopithecus, Homo
- 40:55habilis, and Homo erectus all lived at
- 40:58the same time?
- 40:59How is one supposed to evolve into the
- 41:01other if fossil evidence points to them
- 41:03living at the same time?
- 41:04>> Well, actually they did say that, and
- 41:07their position perplexed many
- 41:08evolutionary scientists.
- 41:10And many do not agree with them.
- 41:12But I respect their opinion because
- 41:13their family spent more years excavating
- 41:15and mapping the areas where these early
- 41:17fossils were found than anyone else did.
- 41:20>> That sounds a lot like nomadic tribes of
- 41:22humans were setting up camp, making
- 41:24specialized hand tools using special
- 41:27rocks found miles away, and
- 41:29butchering and eating animals, including
- 41:31apes.
- 41:31Just like people have been doing for a
- 41:33long time.
- 41:34>> Okay, look, you made your point about
- 41:36Homo habilis.
- 41:38Suppose you know all about the next in
- 41:39the evolutionary lineup, Neanderthals.
- 41:42>> Have they always been regarded as some
- 41:45type of evidence for supporting the idea
- 41:47that humans are evolving?
- 41:48>> Just decades ago they were regarded in
- 41:50textbooks and museums as gorilla-like
- 41:52cavemen.
- 41:53But now
- 41:55we know that they had families with
- 41:57humans.
- 41:58>> That's probably because they were
- 42:00humans.
- 42:01>> Yes, DNA samples extracted from them
- 42:04show that they were basically human, and
- 42:06we've found the remains buried together
- 42:08with humans, showing that they lived
- 42:09together,
- 42:10worked together, had kids together, and
- 42:12were accepted as members of the same
- 42:14family, clan and community with humans.
- 42:17Neanderthal burial sites include jewelry
- 42:19and purses, artwork, weaponry and
- 42:23some grave sites even have clues of
- 42:25burial rituals.
- 42:27In fact, they've recently found
- 42:28Neanderthals comb beaches and went
- 42:31diving to find certain shells to be used
- 42:33as tools.
- 42:34>> That's definitely not my dad or my
- 42:36grandfather's version of Neanderthals
- 42:38where they're presented as
- 42:40brutish
- 42:41gorilla-like cavemen carrying clubs.
- 42:44Just like the sides you showed, could
- 42:46you pull those up?
- 42:50But now they're diving for shells
- 42:53found buried with humans, creating
- 42:55artwork and musical instruments. They're
- 42:58even portrayed in museums as
- 43:00sporting stylish ponytails and suits.
- 43:04So much for that evolutionary icon.
- 43:07Could you pull up the sides you showed?
- 43:10That showed the different human
- 43:12evolution tree?
- 43:13>> Uh
- 43:14this one?
- 43:15>> Can you explain this slide to me?
- 43:18>> Uh sure. It shows the idea of the human
- 43:20evolution tree over time. Uh this chart
- 43:24is from Professor Klein at Stanford. It
- 43:26was published on the 200th anniversary
- 43:28of Darwin's birth to show how much we've
- 43:30learned about human evolution since
- 43:31Darwin's time.
- 43:32>> And what do the eight question marks on
- 43:34the chart mean?
- 43:36>> Well, they are inferred relationships
- 43:38between the different fossil icons on
- 43:40the chart.
- 43:41Uh same with the dash lines and the thin
- 43:42solid lines. They show the [music]
- 43:44theoretical evolutionary connections
- 43:45between the fossil icons.
- 43:47>> They're all based on guesswork?
- 43:50>> Uh yes. Um only the thick vertical bars
- 43:54show the actual [music] fossil evidence
- 43:56that was discovered.
- 43:57>> Sir,
- 43:58there is no fossil evidence connecting
- 44:01Ardi to afarensis, none connecting
- 44:04afarensis to habilis, none connecting
- 44:07habilis to ergaster or erectus, and no
- 44:10fossil evidence whatsoever [music]
- 44:12connecting them to homo sapiens in any
- 44:15intermediate form. The lines drawn from
- 44:18early australopithecine apes to the
- 44:20first humans are
- 44:22speculation and inference.
- 44:24>> Well, that going back through time, we
- 44:26can't see the actual connection, so yes,
- 44:29it's inference.
- 44:31>> Forgive me, but every topic we've
- 44:34discussed has some loophole and a whole
- 44:37lot of guesswork. I mean, is there
- 44:39anything in the theory of evolution that
- 44:42you would consider to be your number one
- 44:43proof?
- 44:44>> Well, yeah.
- 44:46Darwin's finches.
- 44:47>> What do they show? I mean, how do these
- 44:50finches support the idea of evolution?
- 44:52>> When Darwin visited the Galapagos
- 44:54Islands in the 1830s, he observed the
- 44:56finches that lived on the different
- 44:58islands and found that the sizes and
- 45:00shapes of their beaks tended to vary
- 45:02island by island. He believed that this
- 45:04was evidence of evolution by nature
- 45:07selecting the fittest birds to survive
- 45:10because certain types of beaks were
- 45:11better suited for gathering the food
- 45:13resources available on the different
- 45:15islands.
- 45:17>> So, changes in beak sizes and shapes
- 45:20based on which island they lived on?
- 45:22Sounds like they're just adapting to
- 45:24their environment and food sources
- 45:26within their own God-prescribed genetic
- 45:28programming.
- 45:29How is that evolution?
- 45:31>> Well, we believe that adding millions of
- 45:33years to the process can lead to changes
- 45:35that add up and new kinds can emerge.
- 45:39>> Wow, that takes an incredible amount of
- 45:41faith, doesn't it? I mean, we have
- 45:43thousands of years of recorded history
- 45:46and no one has ever seen a new kind
- 45:48emerge. Sure, we see speculation and
- 45:51changes, but there are over 300 breeds
- 45:53of interfertile dogs, but dogs can only
- 45:56breed dogs.
- 45:57There's also over 300 breeds of the
- 45:59horse kind and
- 46:01we can breed the largest horses with the
- 46:03smallest horses and they'll still always
- 46:05be horses.
- 46:07>> Excuse me,
- 46:09but I can add to this discussion?
- 46:12She's totally right.
- 46:14Modern science has now shown us that
- 46:17Darwin's single best evidence for
- 46:19evolution,
- 46:20Darwin's finches,
- 46:21uh never really actually supported
- 46:24Darwin's ideas for evolution.
- 46:26Um modern studies have tracked over a
- 46:28thousand finches that lived in either
- 46:30rural or urban environments to determine
- 46:33how and why their beak sizes and shapes
- 46:36would differ based on where they lived.
- 46:38The studies revealed significant
- 46:40differences
- 46:41in beak depth and [music] width between
- 46:43urban and rural population of finches
- 46:47that were caused by epigenetic
- 46:48mechanisms
- 46:50such as DNA methylation.
- 46:53Methyl tags change the way a gene is
- 46:55expressed without changing its DNA.
- 46:58This mechanism enables rapid adaptation
- 47:00in finch [music] beaks and other traits
- 47:02as they fit their new environments even
- 47:04between a couple generations.
- 47:06So, rather than Darwin's evolutionary
- 47:08ideas
- 47:10explaining the changes in finches,
- 47:14I believe
- 47:16the changes are evidence for an
- 47:18intelligent
- 47:19master engineer
- 47:21who designed creatures with built-in
- 47:23adaptive mechanisms that enable them to
- 47:25turn on and off certain features
- 47:29as they continuously track environmental
- 47:30changes
- 47:32to fill the earth
- 47:35as their creator commanded.
- 47:45>> Sir,
- 47:46I don't mean any disrespect, but I
- 47:49believe that the theory of evolution is
- 47:51the most fluent, ever-changing theory on
- 47:53the face of the planet.
- 47:55Just in my lifetime, this theory keeps
- 47:59changing over and over and over again.
- 48:02Articles keep coming out with headlines
- 48:04like, "We still have not found the
- 48:06missing link between us and apes." And
- 48:08[music]
- 48:09"The human-ape missing link is still
- 48:11missing." And new fossils keep
- 48:13re-drawing the human evolution tree and
- 48:15pushing back supposed human [music]
- 48:17evolution hundreds of thousands of
- 48:19years. I mean, to me it makes way more
- 48:22sense that humans were put here by God
- 48:24in complete functioning [music] form.
- 48:27We did not evolve into the image of God.
- 48:29We were made in the image of God. Drawn
- 48:31from the dust and given dominion,
- 48:34charged to be stewards over the earth.
- 48:36If we evolved, then you'd have to
- 48:38explain [music] to me things like a
- 48:40conscience and all of these
- 48:42all-or-nothing systems we have.
- 48:44Our complex [snorts]
- 48:45five-part hearing [music] system that
- 48:46has mechanical, hydraulic, chemical, and
- 48:49electrical systems that all [snorts]
- 48:51work together in perfect unison. And
- 48:53don't even get me started on the eye.
- 48:56And
- 48:56which evolved first? The blood, veins,
- 48:59or a pumping heart? I mean, you kind of
- 49:02need all three at the same time for the
- 49:03system to work.
- 49:04>> [snorts]
- 49:05>> And what about blood coagulation?
- 49:06[music]
- 49:07There's like five really complicated
- 49:09automatic systems that our bodies put
- 49:12[music] into place as soon as we get a
- 49:13cut to automatically stop bleeding.
- 49:16Without that entire [music] stepwise
- 49:18system in place
- 49:19right from the start every person would
- 49:22bleed to death after their first cut,
- 49:24leaving no way for evolution.
- 49:27All these things had to be in place at
- 49:29the same time for everything to work.
- 49:45>> Um
- 49:46you know, Christina, you uh
- 49:48you bring up some good points, but
- 49:51I believe that radiometric dating
- 49:52completely debunks the theory that a God
- 49:55created everything out of nothing.
- 49:57The Earth is billions of years old,
- 49:59which allows evolution to take place.
- 50:01>> You said in your lecture that dinosaurs
- 50:03lived between about 220 million years
- 50:06and 65 million years ago. And the human
- 50:09line started to branch off several
- 50:11million years ago.
- 50:11>> That is correct. [music] Verified
- 50:13evidence.
- 50:15>> And this timeline is based on
- 50:16radiometric dating?
- 50:18>> Uh precisely. It's It's a tried and true
- 50:20method for telling the age of things.
- 50:22For example,
- 50:23the unstable isotopes in uranium
- 50:25eventually change into stable atoms such
- 50:27as lead. And [music] we can estimate how
- 50:29long this process takes. These methods
- 50:30are useful for dating igneous rocks,
- 50:33which are formed when hot molten rock
- 50:34crystallizes [music] and solidifies.
- 50:37Radiometric dating is also useful for
- 50:39dating the ash layers in which we find
- 50:41the dinosaurs.
- 50:43>> Since we can't [music] go back in time
- 50:45to watch these rocks get formed or check
- 50:47the decay rate of these atoms over time,
- 50:50what are some of the assumptions that
- 50:52radiometric dating studies make? [music]
- 50:53>> Well, you listed one of them, which is
- 50:55the rate of decay.
- 50:57We can only know what the decay rate is
- 50:59today based on what [music] we observe
- 51:00in laboratories.
- 51:02We don't know what the decay rate might
- 51:04have been in the past or
- 51:06in different Earth environments. We have
- 51:07to assume this. In addition to this
- 51:09assumption, we also have to assume the
- 51:11starting amount of the parent element
- 51:13like uranium and the starting amount of
- 51:15the daughter element like lead, using
- 51:17the examples I mentioned.
- 51:19>> Again, we have to assume them to be true
- 51:21when we date things using radiometric
- 51:23dating.
- 51:24And if these three major assumptions are
- 51:27not correct, then the ages we get from
- 51:30the study are also incorrect.
- 51:34What if we took some rocks that were
- 51:36formed in a volcanic eruption? Rocks
- 51:38that people actually watched right out
- 51:40of written history and then dated these
- 51:43rocks. Shouldn't the radiometric dating
- 51:45age of these rocks be the same as the
- 51:48known age of the rock? The age we know
- 51:50for sure because people actually watched
- 51:52the rock form out of an eruption.
- 51:54>> Well, that sure seems like a fair way to
- 51:56test it. If the radiometric age of the
- 51:58rock was the same as the known age of
- 52:00the rock based on when people watched
- 52:02the rock form, it would validate the
- 52:04assumptions in the analysis and the
- 52:06process as a whole to be correct.
- 52:09>> Did you know that these types of studies
- 52:11have already been done and that
- 52:14radiometric dating missed the known ages
- 52:16by millions and millions of years?
- 52:22>> What do you mean?
- 52:23>> Several studies have been done on rocks
- 52:25around the world to try to validate
- 52:27radiometric dating and it fails all the
- 52:30time.
- 52:31In each of these studies, the
- 52:32radiometric age of the rocks far exceeds
- 52:35the actual known ages by
- 52:38millions and millions of years.
- 52:40In fact, I know of an example if you let
- 52:43me
- 52:47In the 1980s, [music]
- 52:48Mount St. Helens in Washington erupted
- 52:50and produced all kinds of volcanic
- 52:52material including rock called dacite
- 52:55just like this one and sent it in for
- 52:56radiometric dating.
- 52:58The results?
- 52:59This 10-year-old rock showed ages from
- 53:03340,000
- 53:04[music] to 2,800,000
- 53:07years all for a rock that we know was
- 53:10only about 10 years old.
- 53:12>> Okay, so we can't actually prove it. So,
- 53:16what's the biblical idea about the age
- 53:19of the earth? I mean, does the Bible
- 53:21offer anything better?
- 53:23>> Actually, the Bible is very
- 53:24straightforward about this. We have
- 53:26clear genealogies [music] in Genesis
- 53:28which are even repeated in the New
- 53:29Testament that go all the way back to
- 53:32Adam, the first man who was breathed
- 53:34into [music] existence by God.
- 53:36He was made from the dust of the earth,
- 53:38not evolved from some ape-like creature.
- 53:41[music]
- 53:42He was given charge over the earth and
- 53:44named everything, including the apes.
- 53:46Within a couple thousand years later,
- 53:49the earth was flooded and all life on
- 53:51earth was wiped out, except those on the
- 53:54ark. This
- 53:55>> [music]
- 53:55>> happens to be the same time even secular
- 53:58historians admit that human writing
- 54:00disappears from the face of the earth.
- 54:02A strange coincidence, no doubt. So, the
- 54:06Bible's clear that God [music] breathed
- 54:07creation into existence with all the
- 54:10planets in order spiraling through the
- 54:12universe in perfect order to sustain
- 54:14life.
- 54:15Days, nights, season, oxygen, it's all
- 54:18perfectly calibrated to sustain life on
- 54:20earth.
- 54:21>> So, if God created everything in perfect
- 54:24order,
- 54:25how do you explain Pangaea?
- 54:28>> The theory that all the continents used
- 54:30to be joined together?
- 54:31>> Exactly.
- 54:32I mean, it's quite obvious that they fit
- 54:34together like a puzzle,
- 54:36but they've been moving slowly apart for
- 54:38over millions of years.
- 54:42Plus, we have correlated fossils on each
- 54:45side of the continents that were
- 54:46together and now they're separated.
- 54:49We can see this on the continents on
- 54:50each side of the Mid-Atlantic Ridge, for
- 54:52example, which is a 10,000-mi tear or
- 54:55rift, like a baseball seam, running
- 54:58right down the middle of the earth.
- 54:59>> Have you ever considered that the
- 55:01continents were once together and were
- 55:03quickly and catastrophically separated,
- 55:06not slowly over millions of years? I
- 55:09mean, you do have millions of the same
- 55:11creatures like trilobites that are
- 55:13buried in mud layers on each side of the
- 55:15matching continents. We can also see how
- 55:18they match perfectly if they're put back
- 55:20together. And we have quite a clue about
- 55:23how they were split apart. The obvious
- 55:25Mid-Atlantic Ridge you pointed out.
- 55:27>> Uh yes, but it took millions of years
- 55:30and it did not happen quickly. We know
- 55:32this because today they're moving apart
- 55:34slowly, only inches per year based on
- 55:36GPS measurements.
- 55:38>> Well, then how do you explain the
- 55:39Morrison Formation where 13 states of
- 55:42dead dinosaurs in the middle of America
- 55:44are buried with marine creatures under
- 55:47unimaginable amounts of mud and ash?
- 55:49>> I'm not sure I'm following you.
- 55:51>> Oh, well, I have a mobile app from
- 55:52Genesis Apologetics that has a video
- 55:54that explains it in just a few minutes.
- 55:59Check this out.
- 56:02>> Have you ever wondered how the massive
- 56:04dinosaur kills known in the middle of
- 56:05America happened? We're talking about
- 56:07three countries, 14 states, and a
- 56:09stretch over 1,800 mi long and 1,000 mi
- 56:13wide. Over a million square miles are
- 56:16filled with the remnants of most known
- 56:18dinosaur species, and they're all mixed
- 56:20with other land animals, fish, birds,
- 56:22and all sorts of sea life. The leading
- 56:24theory asserted by evolutionists is that
- 56:26an asteroid hitting the Yucatán
- 56:28Peninsula in Mexico, over 1,000 mi away
- 56:31from the heart of this disaster zone, is
- 56:33why millions of dinosaurs are buried in
- 56:35mud and ash. But, that doesn't make
- 56:37sense because the billions of fossils in
- 56:39this area were buried in multiple mud
- 56:42and ash layers from successive watery
- 56:44events. There's also vast areas of
- 56:46crumpled and buckled geology from land
- 56:49masses that were laid down wet and then
- 56:51folded. And this action was obviously
- 56:53driven by rapidly subducting plates.
- 56:55Evolutionists explain how oceanic
- 56:57plates, like the Farallon Plate, slowly
- 57:00subducted over tens of millions of years
- 57:02under the North American continent
- 57:04uneventfully. While the millions of
- 57:06dinosaurs now buried in this kill zone
- 57:08somehow just kept living and thriving.
- 57:10Both secular and creation scientists
- 57:12agree that the Farallon Plate subducted
- 57:15under North America, even carrying
- 57:17massive volcanic plateaus like the
- 57:19Conjugate Shatsky Rise along with it,
- 57:21going from the west to the east. But, we
- 57:23disagree, and with good reason, that the
- 57:26dinosaurs somehow just kept peacefully
- 57:28thriving in this area while this was
- 57:30happening. This subducting action would
- 57:32be like a spatula sliding beneath an
- 57:34undercooked pancake, creating massive
- 57:37folding and buckling just like we see
- 57:39all over North America today. The
- 57:41process even explains the rapid and
- 57:43catastrophic formation of the Rocky
- 57:45Mountains. This happened just thousands
- 57:47of years ago during Noah's flood when
- 57:49the fountains of the great deep were
- 57:51broken apart and the year-long process
- 57:53of the worldwide flood unfolded. Massive
- 57:55oceanic rifting on a worldwide scale
- 57:58created new seafloor that was pulled
- 58:00under the continents, creating cycles of
- 58:02tsunamis that occur when the seafloor
- 58:04binds and then releases, just like
- 58:06tsunamis are generated today. This
- 58:08explains the multiple layers these
- 58:09creatures are found in as they were
- 58:11buried by the ever-increasing flood
- 58:13waters and tsunamis. These dinosaurs
- 58:15were buried furiously with over 90% of
- 58:18them now found disarticulated or torn
- 58:20apart. Many of them are even found
- 58:22choking on mud as they died with their
- 58:24necks arched backwards. Widespread
- 58:27volcanism that occurred during this
- 58:28process also shows this happened quickly
- 58:31over a year and not millions of years.
- 58:34With no volcanoes in the Morrison
- 58:36Formation itself where the bulk of these
- 58:38dead dinosaurs are found, logic demands
- 58:40that the huge volume of volcanic ash in
- 58:42the Morrison Formation to have been
- 58:44erupted from mega volcanoes on the west
- 58:46coast, lofted and carried far to the
- 58:48east by wind. The Morrison Formation's
- 58:51Brushy Basin Member alone spans five
- 58:53states and includes over 4,000 cubic
- 58:56miles of volcanic material. That's
- 58:58enough to cover the state of New Jersey
- 59:00in ash 740 m deep and there are plain
- 59:04indicators that this happened rapidly,
- 59:06not over millions of years. How else can
- 59:08we explain this recently discovered
- 59:10massive dinosaur graveyard where 10,000
- 59:13adult Maiasaura were found buried in mud
- 59:15without a single young mixed in with the
- 59:17entire herd that was buried. Every
- 59:20single dinosaur in the area was at least
- 59:229 ft long. It sounds like the adult
- 59:24dinosaurs were stampeding away from the
- 59:26imminent danger of raging floodwaters,
- 59:29their young could not keep up and became
- 59:31engulfed in some lower part of the
- 59:32peninsula. These evidences sure point to
- 59:35the rapid and widespread catastrophe of
- 59:37the flood.
- 59:40>> Okay, I'm not sure I'd agree with
- 59:42everything on that video, but they do
- 59:45explain a few possible theories.
- 59:47>> But, sir, don't you see? The real
- 59:50clincher for me is the soft tissue they
- 59:52found in dinosaur bones.
- 59:55Over just the last few decades,
- 59:57scientists have been discovering soft
- 59:59tissue in dinosaur bones. And I'm not
- 1:00:02talking about creationist publications.
- 1:00:04I'm talking about over 50 peer-reviewed
- 1:00:07secular science journals that have now
- 1:00:09reported 14 bio-organic materials found
- 1:00:12in dinosaur bones.
- 1:00:13They're finding blood cells, blood
- 1:00:16vessels,
- 1:00:17connective tissue, and even collagen,
- 1:00:20which has a maximum shelf life of just
- 1:00:22tens of thousands of years, with some
- 1:00:24stretching it out to 900,000 years.
- 1:00:27Either way, with a maximum shelf life of
- 1:00:30less than 1 million years, what's
- 1:00:32collagen doing in dinosaur bones that
- 1:00:34are supposedly 65 million years old?
- 1:00:38Many dinosaur bones are even found
- 1:00:39unfossilized in places like Madagascar,
- 1:00:42Alaska, and Montana.
- 1:00:45Even the founder of the largest dinosaur
- 1:00:46museum in the world admitted that
- 1:00:49usually most of the original bone is
- 1:00:51still present in a dinosaur fossil.
- 1:00:53I mean, just look at how stretchy and
- 1:00:56pliable this dinosaur bone is. It sure
- 1:00:58doesn't look like a 65 million-year-old
- 1:01:01rock to me.
- 1:01:05>> You've made your points, nicely done.
- 1:01:08Um, I bet to seal the deal it'd be nice
- 1:01:11for a creationist to find a living
- 1:01:12dinosaur somewhere
- 1:01:13>> [laughter]
- 1:01:14>> in the swamp in the Congo.
- 1:01:15>> Actually,
- 1:01:17I think that what we've covered is even
- 1:01:19better than discovering a living
- 1:01:20dinosaur somewhere.
- 1:01:21>> And why is that?
- 1:01:23>> Well, if someone found a living
- 1:01:25dinosaur, it would be easy for
- 1:01:27evolutionists to explain it away. They
- 1:01:30would just say that evolution was idle
- 1:01:32for eons. They've already done this many
- 1:01:35times when so-called living fossils are
- 1:01:37found.
- 1:01:38Like
- 1:01:40this live coelacanth someone hauled up
- 1:01:42in a fishing net off Madagascar in 1938.
- 1:01:46Before they found it alive, coelacanths
- 1:01:48were considered a key missing link
- 1:01:50between fish and amphibians dating back
- 1:01:53to the time of dinosaurs and beyond. So,
- 1:01:56the reason that the discovery of
- 1:01:57dinosaur biomolecules, cells, and
- 1:02:00tissues is even better than finding a
- 1:02:02live dinosaur is that the laws of
- 1:02:04chemistry hold evolutionists accountable
- 1:02:07for claiming either that thermodynamics,
- 1:02:10the process by which tissues break down,
- 1:02:12were idle for eons or even more far out,
- 1:02:15that the bio-organic materials are not
- 1:02:17even there.
- 1:02:19But, because we know these bio-organic
- 1:02:21materials were present when they were
- 1:02:23living, and we still have them now,
- 1:02:25leaves undeniable evidence for Noah's
- 1:02:27flood staring the world right in the
- 1:02:29face.
- 1:02:36>> Kristina, you've given me a lot to think
- 1:02:38about.
- 1:02:42You believe this is a joke?
- 1:02:47Just get out of here.
- 1:02:55Yeah.
- 1:02:57You okay?
- 1:03:01>> I've never felt so wrong about anything
- 1:03:03in my entire life.
- 1:03:10My life completely changed [music] that
- 1:03:12day.
- 1:03:13Mark and I, we tried to continue having
- 1:03:16a relationship, but he wasn't too happy
- 1:03:18with me suddenly believing in God. So,
- 1:03:21we argued a lot.
- 1:03:24And then, we ended up breaking up.
- 1:03:27But, I ended up becoming friends with
- 1:03:30the girl who was debating with the
- 1:03:32[music]
- 1:03:33museum docent that day.
- 1:03:39She showed me the truth.
- 1:03:43And I believed her.
- 1:03:46And I surrendered my life to Jesus.
- 1:03:50And I haven't been the same since.
- 1:03:53In fact, if Christine and I [music]
- 1:03:55hadn't become friends, then I probably
- 1:03:57wouldn't have met your dad. She
- 1:03:59introduced me to him.
- 1:04:01And then, you probably wouldn't be here.
- 1:04:06I love you, sweetheart.
- 1:04:08And I want you to know
- 1:04:10that you can believe
- 1:04:12that God's word is true.
- 1:04:17>> [music]
- 1:04:18>> But, the choice is yours.
- 1:04:28>> You believe in the Bible?
- 1:04:29>> Yes, I do.
- 1:04:30>> Do you believe what Jesus said?
- 1:04:32>> Yes, I do.
- 1:04:32>> Do you know Jesus destroyed evolution in
- 1:04:34one sentence? This is what he said, "In
- 1:04:37the beginning, God made them male and
- 1:04:40female." He didn't make them as
- 1:04:41primates, he made them as male and
- 1:04:43female.
- 1:04:44So, do you believe that?
- 1:04:46>> Yes, I do.
- 1:04:46>> Then, you don't believe evolution.
- 1:04:48>> I don't believe in evolution.
- 1:04:50>> Do you know what the Bible says is the
- 1:04:51cause of death, why we die?
- 1:04:54>> What is it, according to the
- 1:04:55>> According to the Bible, it says the
- 1:04:56wages of sin is death. God is paying you
- 1:04:59in death for your sins. Sin is so
- 1:05:00serious in his eyes, he's given you the
- 1:05:03death sentence. Whosoever calls upon the
- 1:05:05name of the Lord shall be saved. He that
- 1:05:07believes in him shall not perish, but
- 1:05:09have everlasting life. This
- 1:05:11dozens of promises saying the same
- 1:05:13thing. Repent, trust in the savior, and
- 1:05:16God will remit your sins, grant you
- 1:05:18everlasting life as a free gift. Is this
- 1:05:19making sense?
- 1:05:21>> I very much.
- 1:05:22>> You're going to think about what we
- 1:05:23talked about today?
- 1:05:24>> Oh, yes.
- 1:05:25Yes.
- 1:05:26>> You have a Bible at home?
- 1:05:27>> Yes, I do.
- 1:05:28>> Does this make sense what I'm saying?
- 1:05:30>> Yes, it does.
- 1:05:31>> Does that make sense?
- 1:05:31>> Yeah. Yeah.
- 1:05:32>> You're going to think about this
- 1:05:33seriously?
- 1:05:33>> Yeah, I will. I'm a sinner who needs to
- 1:05:35change and change my ways.
- 1:05:37And I just wanted to say that like
- 1:05:39you really have me like
- 1:05:41thinking about what I should do like now
- 1:05:42and in the future.
- 1:05:43>> To put your faith in Jesus, is that what
- 1:05:44you're saying?
- 1:05:45>> Yes.
- 1:05:46>> When you going to get right with God?
- 1:05:49>> As soon as possible.
- 1:05:52>> [music]
- 1:06:04[music]
- 1:06:10[music]
- 1:06:15[music]
- 1:06:23[music]
- 1:06:39[music]
- 1:06:56[music]
- 1:07:20>> Mhm.
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of We Challenge EVERY Evolutionist to Watch This Film About Creation by Genesis Apologetics, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 10,406 words across 1,823 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.