We Are All Connected & These Machines Can Feel It. — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:00September 11th, 2001, around 4 am
- 0:02Eastern time, before most people were
- 0:04awake, before the planes had taken off,
- 0:06before anything had happened. There is a
- 0:08network of machines scattered across 30
- 0:10countries that started behaving
- 0:12strangely. Nobody noticed at the time,
- 0:14but the numbers they were generating,
- 0:15which should have been purely random,
- 0:17started showing a pattern, a coherence,
- 0:18like they were responding to something.
- 0:20And by the time the first plane hit the
- 0:22North Tower at 8:46 a.m., the network
- 0:25had already been moving for nearly 5
- 0:27hours. There's a Princeton researcher
- 0:29named Roger Nelson who has the data on
- 0:31this. He's been collecting it since
- 0:321998. And the 9/11 data anomaly isn't
- 0:35the only one that happened like this.
- 0:37It's the most dramatic one, but the
- 0:38machines have moved before with tsunamis
- 0:41before major disasters and during
- 0:43collective moments of grief and joy. And
- 0:45the cumulative case that Nelson has
- 0:47built over 25 years on this is now over
- 0:50seven sigma. Seven sigma means that the
- 0:52probability that this is random noise is
- 0:54roughly 1 in 10 trillion. So this is
- 0:57either one of the most important
- 0:58findings in the history of science or
- 1:00the most elaborate statistical illusion
- 1:02that was ever constructed. Princeton's
- 1:04engineering anomalies research lab pair
- 1:06had been running since the late 1970s.
- 1:08Robert Jan, the dean of engineering at
- 1:10Princeton, basically stumbled into this.
- 1:12A student wanted to study whether human
- 1:14intention could impact the output of a
- 1:16random number generator. And Jan said
- 1:18sure, he'd supervise it. He didn't think
- 1:20they'd find anything and that would be
- 1:21the end of it. But they did find
- 1:23something. Over two decades and
- 1:24countless trials, they found a small but
- 1:26statistically significant effect. Human
- 1:29operators just by intending particular
- 1:31outcomes seemed to slightly bias the
- 1:33machines. The effect was tiny, but it
- 1:35was there and they were able to
- 1:36replicate it. So Jan spent the rest of
- 1:38his career trying to understand it. His
- 1:40pair lab got attacked by skeptics and
- 1:42they defended their work and the lab
- 1:44eventually closed in 2007. Roger Nelson
- 1:47was a researcher at PAR through most of
- 1:49that period. And in the early 1990s, he
- 1:51started running what he called fieldreg
- 1:53experiments, taking portable random
- 1:55number generators into situations of
- 1:57high group coherence like religious
- 1:59ceremonies, music festivals, etc. The
- 2:02machines would run in the background
- 2:03generating data and then Nelson would
- 2:05look at whether the outputs changed or
- 2:07not. And they did. During moments of
- 2:09deep collective focus, a room full of
- 2:11people meditating together, a concert
- 2:13where the crowd was locked in, the
- 2:15machines would show increased order. It
- 2:17didn't happen every time, and the effect
- 2:19was small, but it was consistent enough
- 2:20that Nelson decided to scale it up. What
- 2:23if we put these machines all over the
- 2:24world and watched what happens during
- 2:26major events? That was the Global
- 2:28Consciousness Project. And the setup was
- 2:30actually easier than you'd think. Each
- 2:32node in the network is a hardware random
- 2:34number generator. A device that produces
- 2:36a sequence of ones and zeros that is by
- 2:38all measures truly random and based on
- 2:40quantum noise. Each machine generates
- 2:43200 bits every second and sends a result
- 2:45to the central server. By 2004, there
- 2:47were about 65 of these nodes scattered
- 2:49across six continents. The US, Europe,
- 2:52Australia, Japan, India, South America,
- 2:55Africa. Some were in university labs and
- 2:57some were in researchers homes. The only
- 2:59requirement was that there was a stable
- 3:01internet connection and that the machine
- 3:03kept running. The key measurement is
- 3:04network variance, which is basically how
- 3:06correlated the machines are to each
- 3:08other. If consciousness has no effect,
- 3:10the machine should behave independently,
- 3:12each one generating its own random
- 3:14sequence with no connection with what
- 3:16the others are doing, and the network
- 3:18variant should stay flat. But when
- 3:19something happens that captures global
- 3:21attention when hundreds of millions of
- 3:23people are focused on the same event at
- 3:24the same time, the machines start to
- 3:26correlate. Nelson pre-registered the
- 3:28events before analyzing the data. He
- 3:30specified in advance this event, this
- 3:33time window, this analysis. The list
- 3:35eventually ran to over 500 formal tests,
- 3:38and the cumulative result across all of
- 3:39them was a zcore of about 7.3. That's
- 3:42odds against chance of more than a
- 3:44trillion to one. The 911 is the one that
- 3:47hits the hardest. The machines were
- 3:48showing anomalous behavior around 4:00
- 3:50a.m. and the planes didn't hit until
- 3:528:46 a.m. That's nearly 5 hours of
- 3:54deviation before any plane left the
- 3:56ground, before any news broke, before
- 3:58anything had happened. Dean Raden,
- 4:00another researcher in this space,
- 4:01analyzed the 911 data and put the odds
- 4:04that that pre-event spike occurring by
- 4:06chance at around 6,000 to one for that
- 4:08window alone. And the network continued
- 4:10deviating for days after the event. And
- 4:12there's other data sets that they've
- 4:14analyzed aside from 9/11. They did
- 4:16tsunamis. They did New Year's Eve. They
- 4:18did the US embassy bombings and even the
- 4:20American Idol finale. Cumulative, there
- 4:23was 500 plus formal pre-registered
- 4:25events. And the pattern across all of
- 4:27them was pretty much the same. When
- 4:28large groups of people focus on the same
- 4:30thing at the same time, the machines
- 4:32correlate. And sometimes, with the 9/11
- 4:34data being the clearest case of this,
- 4:36they correlate before the event even
- 4:38happens. And worth noting is the
- 4:39American Idol finale at 2.8 eight sigma
- 4:42which is either reassuring it works for
- 4:44trivial things too or slightly
- 4:45depressing depending on your
- 4:47perspective. The skeptics are all over
- 4:49this as they should be. This is a big
- 4:50claim and the core critique is event
- 4:52selection. Who decides what counts as a
- 4:54significant global event? Nelson and his
- 4:56team decide. There's no governing body.
- 4:58There's no list of pre-qualifying
- 5:00events. And critics point out that if
- 5:01you get to pick which events you
- 5:03analyze, you can find patterns in pretty
- 5:05much any random data set. Jeffrey
- 5:07Scargle, a statistician at NASA, looked
- 5:09at the GCP data and rated the results
- 5:11cogency as low. He flagged issues with
- 5:13the analysis methods where the choices
- 5:15made during analysis could produce
- 5:17apparent effects from noise. Edwin May
- 5:19and James Spotties did a reanalysis
- 5:22specifically on the 911 data and found
- 5:23that if you adjust the time window
- 5:25slightly, just shift the start point a
- 5:27few hours, the statistical significance
- 5:29drops dramatically. what looks like a
- 5:31dramatic pre-event spike becomes
- 5:33consistent with chance depending on
- 5:35exactly where you draw the line. But
- 5:36Nelson pushed back on that reanalysis,
- 5:38arguing that they were picking their
- 5:40window to make the effect disappear. And
- 5:42that's the core problem. Without fixed
- 5:44criteria for what counts as an effect,
- 5:46both sides can make the data say what
- 5:47they want. And there's also the
- 5:49mechanism problem. Nobody has any idea
- 5:51how human intention could affect a
- 5:52quantum random number generator
- 5:54thousands of miles away. There's no
- 5:56physics around this and no pathway that
- 5:58we know of. If the effect is real, it
- 6:00requires something outside of our
- 6:01current scientific understanding to
- 6:03explain it. And there's a little bit of
- 6:04a problem with the replication. The GCP
- 6:06data mostly comes from one source, one
- 6:08team. Independent researchers that are
- 6:10trying to replicate this have found
- 6:12effects roughly half the size and some
- 6:14major events are showing nothing. So, if
- 6:16the Global Consciousness Project data is
- 6:18real and the machines are actually
- 6:20responding to human attention, what
- 6:21would have to be true? Option one is
- 6:23kind of the weak version. Consciousness
- 6:25produces some kind of physical field
- 6:26that hasn't been characterized yet.
- 6:28Something like an electromagnetic
- 6:30effect, but different. Mass attention
- 6:32creates a measurable disturbance in the
- 6:34environment that random number
- 6:35generators happen to be sensitive to.
- 6:37This is weird, but it's not
- 6:39philosophically impossible. It would
- 6:40just mean that there's physics out there
- 6:42that we haven't found yet. Option two is
- 6:44a little harder. The 9/11 data, the
- 6:45pre-event spike, doesn't fit option one.
- 6:48If the machines are responding to human
- 6:50attention and there was no event yet,
- 6:51what were they responding to? Unless
- 6:53attention can propagate backwards
- 6:55through time or unless there's some form
- 6:57of collective premonition that preceded
- 6:58the event at a scale that affected
- 7:00hardware in 30 countries simultaneously.
- 7:03There have been studies on individual
- 7:04premonition, people's bodies registering
- 7:06emotional images a few seconds before
- 7:08the images are shown. The GCP data might
- 7:11be showing the same phenomenon at
- 7:12civilizational scale. Hundreds of
- 7:14millions of people picking up something
- 7:16before it happens and the aggregate
- 7:18signal being large enough to display in
- 7:20a network. If that really is what's
- 7:22happening, it means that information can
- 7:23travel in a direction that our physics
- 7:25says it can't. Option three is the one
- 7:27that Hoffman would recognize. If
- 7:28consciousness is fundamental, if the
- 7:30physical world is an interface that
- 7:32consciousness constructs rather than the
- 7:34other way around, then consciousness
- 7:36affecting physical systems isn't
- 7:37strange. It's expected. The machines
- 7:39aren't detecting a weird anomaly.
- 7:41They're detecting the substrate that
- 7:43everything else is running on. And
- 7:44there's more data points on this than
- 7:46just a global consciousness project. The
- 7:47pair lab ran for 30 years at Princeton
- 7:49and published dozens of papers showing
- 7:51that human attention affects random
- 7:53systems. The effect sizes were small but
- 7:55replicated across millions of trials in
- 7:57multiple independent operators. Dean
- 7:59Rden at the Institute of Noetic Sciences
- 8:01ran dozens of experiments showing
- 8:03pre-event physiological responses in
- 8:05human subjects and the double blind
- 8:07methodology in some of his work is
- 8:09cleaner than what the GCP uses. Rupert
- 8:11Sheldrake's morphic resonance work shows
- 8:13a similar thing from a different
- 8:15direction. the idea that memories and
- 8:17information are properties of fields and
- 8:19they're not stored in individual brains.
- 8:21And that one is a little bit more
- 8:22controversial. But either way, none of
- 8:24this really fits what we think about
- 8:25consciousness. We think the brain
- 8:27creates experiences the way the liver
- 8:28generates bile. Like neurons fire and
- 8:30awareness just happens. Random firing of
- 8:32neurons produces awareness and that's
- 8:34it. Not something that could affect
- 8:36hardware in another country. But that
- 8:38doesn't really explain anything. It just
- 8:40states the relationship. How the
- 8:41physical processes produce experience
- 8:43has never been fully demonstrated. The
- 8:45hard problem of consciousness is what
- 8:47philosopher David Chmers named that in
- 8:491995. What the GCP data might be showing
- 8:52is that the assumption is wrong. That
- 8:54consciousness is not a product of brains
- 8:56but something the brain participates in.
- 8:59Something that extends beyond the skull,
- 9:00interacts with the physical world, and
- 9:02sometimes in ways that show up in data
- 9:04from 65 machines scattered across six
- 9:06continents know something before it
- 9:08happens. Roger Nelson is in his 80s and
- 9:11he ran this project for over 20 years,
- 9:13collected data through hundreds of major
- 9:15world events and built a strong
- 9:16statistical case. What Nelson built is
- 9:19an instrument for measuring something
- 9:20that the scientific establishment
- 9:22doesn't have a name for. He calls it
- 9:23global consciousness, the noosphere. A
- 9:26word that Pierre Tyhard Chardin used in
- 9:28the 1920s to describe the layer of human
- 9:30thought surrounding the earth the way
- 9:32the atmosphere surrounds it. But at the
- 9:34end of the day, those machines were
- 9:35running and the numbers are what they
- 9:37are. So, what was moving them? And I was
- 9:40thinking about this and I have had times
- 9:41when I've been at like a concert or
- 9:42something like that and you just feel a
- 9:44little bit more connected to everybody
- 9:45there. Is that collective consciousness
- 9:47or maybe the fact that we all just like
- 9:49the same music? And anytime you talk
- 9:51about consciousness, stuff can get a
- 9:52little bit confusing. And I do my best
- 9:53to try to explain it in simple terms,
- 9:55but this is building around something I
- 9:57have coming up on Sunday around
- 9:58Hoffman's work, which is kind of crazy.
- 10:00So, watch out for that one. I personally
- 10:02lean towards there being some type of a
- 10:04universal consciousness that we all kind
- 10:06of tap into. like we are radios that are
- 10:08each tuned to our own station and that's
- 10:11how we perceive the world and our
- 10:12reality. Whether that's true or not, I
- 10:14don't really know, but it is the funnest
- 10:15way to think about it in my opinion. As
- 10:18always, thank you so much for your time.
- 10:19I really appreciate each and every one
- 10:20of you. If you haven't done so already,
- 10:22please subscribe, like, leave that
- 10:24comment. I love reading through those
- 10:25things. There's a lot of interesting
- 10:26stuff that you guys bring to the table
- 10:27that I haven't thought about. So, keep
- 10:30that stuff coming. Until next time, I'll
- 10:32talk to you
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of We Are All Connected & These Machines Can Feel It. by The Archivist's Journal, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 2,118 words across 333 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.