YouTube2Text

¿Votar a Vox o al PP? Las cuentas REALES de tu voto, provincia a provincia | 29-N — Transcript

by Salvar a España · 1,751 words · 257 segments · language en · Watch on YouTube

Full transcript

  1. 0:00This week, the Popular Party and Vox
  2. 0:02have sealed something they didn't in
  3. 0:052023. They are going together to the
  4. 0:06Senate. In 20 provinces they share a
  5. 0:09list, but for Congress, where the
  6. 0:11president is elected, they are going
  7. 0:13separately. And that decision has a
  8. 0:15price. We have calculated it seat by
  9. 0:18seat with the official results of 2023
  10. 0:21and today's polls. And the answer to
  11. 0:23the question half the country is asking
  12. 0:25, "do I vote for the PP or for Vox?" is
  13. 0:29not what either side tells you; it
  14. 0:31depends on one thing: the province
  15. 0:32where you live. Let's start with what
  16. 0:36happened this week. The agreement for
  17. 0:38the Senate has two formulas. In six
  18. 0:41provinces, Vox occupies the second spot
  19. 0:43on the Popular Party lists: Valencia,
  20. 0:46Castellón, Cádiz, Balearic Islands,
  21. 0:48Gran Canaria, and Tenerife. In another
  22. 0:5114, from Seville to Pontevedra, Vox is
  23. 0:53presenting only one name to leave the
  24. 0:56other two to the PP. Only in Guipúzcoa
  25. 0:58, Girona, and Tarragona. Vox is going
  26. 1:01on its own. Why in the Senate yes, and
  27. 1:03in Congress no? Because in the Senate,
  28. 1:05the rule is brutal. In each province,
  29. 1:08the most-voted party usually takes
  30. 1:09three of the four senators. Going
  31. 1:12divided there meant handing the chamber
  32. 1:14to Sánchez. In Congress, Vox has made
  33. 1:17it clear in its statement.
  34. 1:20>> In all of them, our voters will, of
  35. 1:22course, be able to vote for Vox for the
  36. 1:23Congress of Deputies quite normally.
  37. 1:26>> And Abascal, this week in Plasencia.
  38. 1:29Vox's autonomy remains intact, so on
  39. 1:31November 29th you will have two
  40. 1:33right-wing ballots on the table. The
  41. 1:36question is, what does that cost? To
  42. 1:39know, you have to understand one single
  43. 1:42rule. In each province, the votes for
  44. 1:45each party are divided by one, by two,
  45. 1:47by three, and the highest quotients
  46. 1:50take the seats. That rule punishes
  47. 1:52those who divide. If two similar
  48. 1:55parties split their votes, each ends up
  49. 1:58with a lower final quotient and the
  50. 2:00remaining seat can fall to the opposing
  51. 2:02party. But the punishment is not the
  52. 2:05same throughout Spain. In Madrid, 37
  53. 2:07deputies are distributed. With just
  54. 2:10under 3%, you already have a seat. In
  55. 2:12Soria, two are distributed. To have one
  56. 2:15guaranteed, you need more than a third
  57. 2:17of the votes. And in between is half
  58. 2:21the country, 26 provinces of three,
  59. 2:24four, or five seats where a party needs
  60. 2:26between 17 and 25%to secure one. That
  61. 2:30is where everything is at stake. Let's
  62. 2:33go with the facts. 2023. Official
  63. 2:36results from the Ministry of the
  64. 2:38Interior. The Popular Party won 137
  65. 2:41seats, Vox 33, and with the Navarrese
  66. 2:44People's Union, the bloc totaled 171,
  67. 2:47five short of a majority. We have
  68. 2:50recalculated the distribution as if the
  69. 2:52PP and Vox had run on a single list
  70. 2:54with all their votes. Result 181.
  71. 2:58Absolute majority. 10 seats lost just
  72. 3:01by running separately. Almost half a
  73. 3:04million Vox votes, 493,000, didn't help
  74. 3:07elect anyone, scattered across 27
  75. 3:10provinces. But watch out, because
  76. 3:12there’s a trap in that calculation. A
  77. 3:15single list doesn't automatically keep
  78. 3:17all the votes. If just one in every 10
  79. 3:20voters had stayed home, the single list
  80. 3:22would have won 169, fewer than by
  81. 3:24running separately. In other words,
  82. 3:26joining forces wasn't a magic solution
  83. 3:28either. The key lay elsewhere, in where
  84. 3:31each vote was placed. And here is what
  85. 3:35no one has told you. We looked for the
  86. 3:38provinces where a small shift in votes
  87. 3:40between the PP and Vox would have given
  88. 3:42the right one more seat. There are six.
  89. 3:46In three, the Popular Party was short
  90. 3:48of votes. Girona, 285 votes. Lleida,
  91. 3:523,500. Murcia, 7,400. You won't see
  92. 3:57this on TV. If this is useful for you,
  93. 3:59stick with the channel. And in the
  94. 4:01other three, Vox was short of votes.
  95. 4:04Albacete, 1,411 votes from the PP to
  96. 4:06Vox, and Vox would have taken the seat
  97. 4:09from the PSOE. Tarragona 2,700, Seville
  98. 4:1377,700. 23,000 well-placed votes, half
  99. 4:18to the PP and half to Vox. And Feijóo
  100. 4:22would have had 177 seats without
  101. 4:24needing anyone. So the famous "useful
  102. 4:28vote" of 2023 was neither true nor
  103. 4:30false. In some provinces, the useful
  104. 4:33vote was the PP, in others it was Vox.
  105. 4:37And there is a third list that is even
  106. 4:39more dizzying: the provinces where
  107. 4:40moving votes from one side to the other
  108. 4:42would have taken a seat away from the
  109. 4:44right. Ceuta, a single deputy. The PP
  110. 4:48won with 38.8%, the PSOE had 34%. With
  111. 4:531,600 votes from the PP moving to Vox,
  112. 4:56the Ceuta seat would have gone to the
  113. 4:58PSOE. Madrid, 1,900 votes from the PP
  114. 5:01to Vox, and the right would have lost a
  115. 5:04deputy. And in Badajoz or Castellón it
  116. 5:06happened in reverse, a few thousand
  117. 5:09votes from Vox to the PP and the bloc
  118. 5:11would have lost a seat. The conclusion
  119. 5:13is uncomfortable for both parties.
  120. 5:15There is no "useful vote" that applies
  121. 5:18to all of Spain. Anyone who tells you
  122. 5:20otherwise is asking for your vote, not
  123. 5:22doing the math. And now the scenario
  124. 5:24has changed significantly. In 2023, Vox
  125. 5:27had 12%. Today, the average of 15
  126. 5:31pollsters puts them at almost 19. We
  127. 5:34have applied that average province by
  128. 5:36province to the actual results. It is
  129. 5:39an indicative estimate, not a
  130. 5:41prediction. And this is the result: PP,
  131. 5:44Vox, and UPN, 198 seats with a single
  132. 5:47list, and all votes would be 211, but
  133. 5:50again, if one out of every 10 voters
  134. 5:53leaves, the advantage almost disappears
  135. 5:57, 200. The most important thing is
  136. 5:59another figure. With Vox near 19%, its
  137. 6:02votes without a seat drop from almost
  138. 6:05half a million to about 300,000 and
  139. 6:07from 27 provinces to 15. The vote for
  140. 6:10Vox is lost in far fewer places than 3
  141. 6:13years ago. And there is data from the
  142. 6:15polls that explains the fight.
  143. 6:17According to microdata from several
  144. 6:19firms, Vox retains more than eight out
  145. 6:21of every 10 voters and captures more
  146. 6:23than 1 million former PP voters. That
  147. 6:26is why the Popular Party talks about
  148. 6:28the useful vote and why Vox strives so
  149. 6:31hard to distance itself. And what do
  150. 6:34the two parties say? Feijóo put it
  151. 6:36this way the day Sánchez called the
  152. 6:38elections.
  153. 6:40>> This is not simply about the PP beating
  154. 6:42the PSOE. These are not elections like
  155. 6:45previous ones in democracy. This is
  156. 6:48about Spain beating Sánchez and what
  157. 6:50he
  158. 6:51>> Translated. The Popular Party asks for
  159. 6:53the vote to oust Sánchez, not just for
  160. 6:55the PP. It is the argument for the
  161. 6:57useful vote without saying the word.
  162. 6:59Vox responds with another idea: do not
  163. 7:01let anyone get overconfident. Abascal
  164. 7:03this week in Talavera de la Reina.
  165. 7:06>> Please, let us not take these elections
  166. 7:08for granted. Let us not think that
  167. 7:10Sánchez is already defeated.
  168. 7:11>> And in Galicia, Vox goes further. Its
  169. 7:14official video of Abascal's visit to A
  170. 7:16Coruña summarizes it like this: The
  171. 7:18seat is at stake between Vox or the
  172. 7:20Galician Nationalist Bloc. We have
  173. 7:22checked it with our estimate. A Coruña
  174. 7:24allocates eight deputies and Vox would
  175. 7:27be around 8%. With about 3,000 more
  176. 7:30votes, Vox would indeed get its deputy,
  177. 7:32but that seat would be taken from the
  178. 7:34Popular Party itself, which holds the
  179. 7:36last spot there, not from the Galician
  180. 7:38Nationalist Bloc. To take a seat from
  181. 7:41the left, Vox would need almost 30,000
  182. 7:43more votes and they could not come from
  183. 7:45the PP. Mixed verdict. It is an
  184. 7:49estimate, and in Galicia, there are few
  185. 7:51polls per province. But with today's
  186. 7:54data, in A Coruña, Vox is competing
  187. 7:56for the seat with the PP, not with the
  188. 7:58left. And no one is exempt here. Now we
  189. 8:01go to the map, province by province.
  190. 8:04Let's get practical. We have classified
  191. 8:06the 52 provinces and a map with three
  192. 8:09colors emerges. Every week until
  193. 8:12November 29, a new scenario. Stay with
  194. 8:15us. Gray. In 42 provinces, according to
  195. 8:18the estimate, it makes no difference
  196. 8:20for the bloc. A couple of points up or
  197. 8:22down between PP and Vox doesn't move a
  198. 8:25single seat. Madrid, Seville, Malaga,
  199. 8:28Murcia, almost all of Castile,
  200. 8:30Extremadura, and a good part of
  201. 8:32Andalusia. Blue: provinces where the
  202. 8:35seat in play depends on the People's
  203. 8:37Party adding up. Lleida, the Balearic
  204. 8:39Islands, Gipuzkoa, and Valencia. In
  205. 8:41Lleida, the difference is just a few
  206. 8:43hundred votes. Green: provinces where
  207. 8:46the seat in play depends on Vox
  208. 8:48reaching the threshold. La Rioja by a
  209. 8:50few hundred votes and Asturias by less
  210. 8:53than 3,000. And Red: provinces where if
  211. 8:56the PP loses more votes to Vox, the
  212. 8:59right loses a seat. Las Palmas,
  213. 9:01Barcelona, Almería, and Alicante. Now
  214. 9:05for an honest warning. We have tested
  215. 9:07four scenarios. The average, polls
  216. 9:10failing like in 2023, Vox going up two
  217. 9:12points, or the PP going up two. And the
  218. 9:15sensitive provinces change. In Valencia
  219. 9:17, the Balearic Islands, or Lleida, the
  220. 9:20direction even flips, which doesn't
  221. 9:22change in any of the four. In 26
  222. 9:24provinces, there are no seats in play
  223. 9:27between the PP and Vox. There, vote for
  224. 9:30whoever convinces you. And for the rest
  225. 9:33, there is a simple rule you can apply
  226. 9:35yourself. See how many deputies your
  227. 9:37province allocates and divide 100 by
  228. 9:39that number plus one. If the party you
  229. 9:43like is clearly above that percentage,
  230. 9:45your vote counts. Murcia, Almería,
  231. 9:48Toledo, or Guadalajara. Vox is hovering
  232. 9:50around 30%. Your vote is not wasted. If
  233. 9:54it is well below, your vote probably
  234. 9:56won't elect anyone. In Galicia, the
  235. 9:59Basque Country, or Navarre, Vox is
  236. 10:02between 3 and 9%, far from a seat.
  237. 10:05There, the vote that adds to the right
  238. 10:07goes through the People's Party. And if
  239. 10:10it's right on the border, like in La
  240. 10:13Rioja, Asturias, or Ceuta, where PP and
  241. 10:15Vox are almost tied for a single seat,
  242. 10:17there, every vote is gold. And there,
  243. 10:21it is worth checking your province's
  244. 10:23latest poll before voting. Sánchez
  245. 10:26doesn't need to win on November 29th;
  246. 10:28it's enough for the right to distribute
  247. 10:30votes poorly in a handful of provinces.
  248. 10:33In 2023, 23,000 was enough for him.
  249. 10:36That's why this time the question isn't
  250. 10:39PP or Vox; the question is, where are
  251. 10:41you voting? Tell us your province and
  252. 10:43who you are voting for in the comments,
  253. 10:45and we'll tell you what color it
  254. 10:47appears on the map. We will continue
  255. 10:49with the data until the day of the vote
  256. 10:50. If you want to be there, you know
  257. 10:52where to find us.

About this transcript

This page contains the full transcript of ¿Votar a Vox o al PP? Las cuentas REALES de tu voto, provincia a provincia | 29-N by Salvar a España, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 1,751 words across 257 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.

What you can do with it

Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.

Free YouTube transcript tool

YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.