YouTube2Text

무심해야 이긴다 그것이 세상의 이치다 | 쇼펜하우어 인생론 | 처세술 | 명언 | 인간관계 지혜 | 오디오북 — Transcript

by 깨달음의광장 · 6,517 words · 1,022 segments · language en · Watch on YouTube

Full transcript

  1. 0:00Most of the kindness and attention you
  2. 0:03pour out is actually nothing more than
  3. 0:05a useless burden to others. Why do we
  4. 0:08live our lives so hung up on the eyes
  5. 0:11of others and the world's judgment? The
  6. 0:14German philosopher Arthur Schopenhauer
  7. 0:17believed that most human unhappiness
  8. 0:19stems from futile efforts to please
  9. 0:22others. The world rarely returns our
  10. 0:25good intentions in kind; instead, it
  11. 0:27tends to exploit our weaknesses and dig
  12. 0:30in craftily. Therefore, the truly wise
  13. 0:33are those who have mastered the art of
  14. 0:35being thoroughly indifferent to the
  15. 0:37world's affairs. An attitude of
  16. 0:39focusing solely on one's inner self,
  17. 0:41rather than being swayed by the
  18. 0:43emotions of others, is the most
  19. 0:44powerful weapon for navigating this
  20. 0:46harsh world. Now, let’s take an
  21. 0:49in-depth look at how indifference can
  22. 0:52save us through the sharp insights
  23. 0:54offered by Schopenhauer. The first
  24. 0:57wisdom to note is the attitude of not
  25. 0:59being affected at all by the praise or
  26. 1:01criticism of others. Everyone wants to
  27. 1:05look good to others and feels
  28. 1:07unbearable pain when criticized.
  29. 1:10However, Schopenhauer cut to the chase,
  30. 1:12stating that the reputation of others
  31. 1:15is merely like a reed swaying in the
  32. 1:17wind, possessing no substance at all.
  33. 1:19In a certain village, there was an old
  34. 1:21man who spent his whole life running a
  35. 1:23shop honestly. The old man was kind to
  36. 1:26every single customer and lived by
  37. 1:28sharing his remaining profits with his
  38. 1:30neighbors. But every time he showed
  39. 1:33such kindness, the villagers whispered
  40. 1:36that he must have some hidden agenda.
  41. 1:39Some spread rumors that he had amassed
  42. 1:42wealth by selling fake goods, and
  43. 1:44others criticized him for being stingy.
  44. 1:47Hearing those unfair rumors, the old
  45. 1:50man fell ill, stopped eating, and
  46. 1:52suffered in anguish. He could not
  47. 1:54understand why the world was condemning
  48. 1:57him so harshly when he had never once
  49. 2:00harbored a dishonest thought. At that
  50. 2:02moment, a wandering philosopher passing
  51. 2:04through the village visited the old
  52. 2:06man’s room and offered this advice.
  53. 2:08He said that the reputation others
  54. 2:10speak of is only as large as the
  55. 2:12capacity of their own vessel. The
  56. 2:15philosopher reminded the old man that
  57. 2:18what people say about him has nothing
  58. 2:20to do with his own truth. It was
  59. 2:23nothing more than an illusion created
  60. 2:26by the envy, jealousy, and distrust
  61. 2:29they harbored in their hearts. Upon
  62. 2:31hearing those words, the old man
  63. 2:33finally realized the truth. He came to
  64. 2:35understand that no matter how hard he
  65. 2:37tried to prove his innocence, he could
  66. 2:40not change the biased gaze of others.
  67. 2:42From that day on, the old man closed
  68. 2:45his ears to whether the villagers
  69. 2:46insulted or praised him. Even to
  70. 2:50customers who came to the shop to find
  71. 2:52fault, he did not get angry or make
  72. 2:54excuses, but simply smiled silently.
  73. 2:57Surprisingly, as the old man stopped
  74. 2:59caring about others 'opinions, peace
  75. 3:01miraculously found its way into his
  76. 3:03heart. Whatever the world said, it was
  77. 3:07the world's problem and could not
  78. 3:09intrude upon his inner peace.
  79. 3:12Schopenhauer pointed out that we are
  80. 3:14hurt by the criticism of others because
  81. 3:17we lack confidence in ourselves. If you
  82. 3:20truly know who you are, the reputation
  83. 3:23of others will simply pass by like a
  84. 3:26pebble on the roadside. What do others
  85. 3:29think of me? Even in those moments of
  86. 3:32anxiety, our precious life force is
  87. 3:34being wasted on something futile.
  88. 3:36Therefore, if you want to truly live a
  89. 3:39winning life, you must boldly shatter
  90. 3:42the mirror of others' gazes. Secondly,
  91. 3:45a rule of life we must take to heart is
  92. 3:47maintaining a proper distance in human
  93. 3:49relationships. The saying that man is a
  94. 3:52social animal becomes a shackle for
  95. 3:54some, binding them to a life of
  96. 3:56unhappiness. Schopenhauer compared
  97. 3:59humans to hedgehogs, saying that if you
  98. 4:02get too close to others, you get
  99. 4:04pricked, and if you get too far, you
  100. 4:06freeze. On a cold winter day, many
  101. 4:09hedgehogs moved toward each other to
  102. 4:12maintain body heat. However, the closer
  103. 4:15they got, the more their sharp quills
  104. 4:17pierced each other's skin, and unable
  105. 4:20to bear the pain, they moved apart
  106. 4:23again. But moving away meant the biting
  107. 4:25cold attacked them again, and they
  108. 4:27couldn't endure it. Eventually, after
  109. 4:31much trial and error, the hedgehogs
  110. 4:33found the optimal distance to feel
  111. 4:35warmth without hurting one another.
  112. 4:39Human relationships are exactly the
  113. 4:41same. When you become too close, you
  114. 4:44learn each other's privacy and flaws,
  115. 4:46which inevitably leads to contempt or
  116. 4:49conflict. Even among close friends,
  117. 4:52there is a line to respect, and
  118. 4:54ignoring it to share everything
  119. 4:56eventually leads to ruin. In a certain
  120. 4:59kingdom, there were two courtiers who
  121. 5:01cherished each other more than their
  122. 5:02own lives. They were always together,
  123. 5:05whether discussing state affairs or
  124. 5:07drinking privately, and were so close
  125. 5:09they had no secrets from each other.
  126. 5:12The king praised their friendship and
  127. 5:14even bestowed upon them great rewards.
  128. 5:17However, as time passed, a subtle crack
  129. 5:20began to form between the two. One
  130. 5:23courtier misunderstood a minor slip of
  131. 5:25the tongue by the other, and the
  132. 5:27accumulated resentment eventually
  133. 5:29turned into a major quarrel. Because
  134. 5:32they knew each other's most painful and
  135. 5:35vulnerable parts, they wounded each
  136. 5:37other with words that struck right at
  137. 5:40the heart. In the end, the two became
  138. 5:43lifelong enemies and parted ways,
  139. 5:45bringing great chaos to the kingdom.
  140. 5:48Having watched that tragic situation,
  141. 5:51the royal advisor recorded this in his
  142. 5:53diary. That humans are beings whose
  143. 5:56ugly nature is easily revealed the
  144. 5:58closer one gets. Schopenhauer also
  145. 6:01warned against the fantasy of forming
  146. 6:03deep connections with others. The
  147. 6:06moment we open our hearts completely to
  148. 6:09someone, they will seize that opening
  149. 6:12to control or exploit us. True wisdom
  150. 6:16in life lies in expecting nothing from
  151. 6:19others and cultivating the independence
  152. 6:22to stand tall alone. Even when mingling
  153. 6:25with others, you must always keep a
  154. 6:27corner of your heart at a proper
  155. 6:29distance. It is not coldness, but the
  156. 6:32wisest barrier to protect yourself and
  157. 6:34maintain the dignity of your
  158. 6:36relationships. Excessive intimacy
  159. 6:39inevitably leads to disappointment and
  160. 6:41betrayal, so you must get into the
  161. 6:43habit of keeping a certain distance.
  162. 6:46The third principle to examine is the
  163. 6:48courage to resolutely refuse
  164. 6:49unreasonable demands from others. Many
  165. 6:52people cannot refuse unreasonable
  166. 6:54requests because they want to be called
  167. 6:57kind or fear being disliked.
  168. 7:00Schopenhauer sharply criticized the
  169. 7:02foolishness of sacrificing one's own
  170. 7:04life to please others. If you refuse a
  171. 7:07request, the other person might be
  172. 7:10upset for a moment, but if you cannot
  173. 7:12refuse, you will live like their
  174. 7:14servant forever. In a small port city,
  175. 7:17there lived a carpenter who was known
  176. 7:19for being hardworking. Whenever
  177. 7:22neighbors reached out for help, the
  178. 7:23carpenter never said no, even when he
  179. 7:25was busy with his own work. He stayed
  180. 7:29up all night fixing neighbors 'fences
  181. 7:31and repairing their boats, unable to
  182. 7:34speak up even as his own house crumbled
  183. 7:36. Neighbors praised the carpenter for
  184. 7:39being kind, but they gradually took it
  185. 7:42for granted and began demanding more
  186. 7:44labor. One day, when the carpenter
  187. 7:47politely declined, saying he was too
  188. 7:49exhausted and wanted a day of rest, the
  189. 7:51neighbors turned on him and criticized
  190. 7:53him. They gave him cold glares,
  191. 7:55accusing him of losing his humble
  192. 7:57beginnings because he was well-fed or
  193. 7:59of having a changed personality. Only
  194. 8:01then did the carpenter realize the
  195. 8:03truth. The kindness he had shown had
  196. 8:06not remained as gratitude, but had
  197. 8:08taken root as an expected right. From
  198. 8:11that day on, the carpenter began to
  199. 8:13firmly refuse the neighbors'
  200. 8:15unreasonable requests. At first, the
  201. 8:18neighbors protested and turned their
  202. 8:20backs on him, but as time passed, they
  203. 8:22could no longer treat him carelessly.
  204. 8:25As he valued his own time and drew a
  205. 8:27line against unreasonable demands, the
  206. 8:29neighbors actually began to respect him
  207. 8:31. Schopenhauer advised not to fear
  208. 8:35being called indifferent toward others.
  209. 8:39A reputation for being overly kind is
  210. 8:41no different from being a pushover who
  211. 8:44is easy to exploit. The moment we hand
  212. 8:47over the reins of our lives to others,
  213. 8:49our existence is reduced to a
  214. 8:51consumable for someone else's happiness
  215. 8:53. Refusal is not cruelty toward others,
  216. 8:56but the minimum line of defense to
  217. 8:59protect yourself. The world does not
  218. 9:01protect the gentle and those who cannot
  219. 9:04refuse; instead, it exploits their
  220. 9:06weaknesses to squeeze them dry.
  221. 9:08Therefore, you need the cold courage to
  222. 9:10firmly shake your head in the face of
  223. 9:12unreasonable demands. The fourth wisdom
  224. 9:15lies in the attitude of not fearing
  225. 9:18solitude, but rather enjoying it. Most
  226. 9:21people cannot stand time spent alone,
  227. 9:24so they constantly meet others and
  228. 9:26search for noise. However, Schopenhauer
  229. 9:29said that the greater a person's mind,
  230. 9:32the more they love solitude and avoid
  231. 9:34mingling with the crowd. Fools seek
  232. 9:37stability in the company of others, but
  233. 9:41the wise discover true freedom only in
  234. 9:44conversation with themselves. There was
  235. 9:48a philosopher who lived alone in the
  236. 9:50deep woods, devoting himself to his
  237. 9:51research. He had no interest in the
  238. 9:55village's fancy parties or political
  239. 9:57quarrels, finding his only joy in books
  240. 10:00and meditation. The villagers whispered
  241. 10:03about him, calling him an eccentric and
  242. 10:06unsociable human being. But the
  243. 10:09philosopher believed that the villagers
  244. 10:11'empty chatter and exhausting
  245. 10:13encounters were toxins that destroyed
  246. 10:16the soul. One day, a young man from the
  247. 10:19village visited the philosopher and
  248. 10:21asked why he lived in isolation instead
  249. 10:23of mingling with people. Smiling, the
  250. 10:26philosopher handed the young man a
  251. 10:28glass of clear water and said this. He
  252. 10:32said that if you stir muddy water into
  253. 10:34this, it might look abundant for a
  254. 10:36moment, but eventually, only murky
  255. 10:38residue remains at the bottom. Human
  256. 10:41relationships are the same; if you
  257. 10:43indiscriminately mingle with others,
  258. 10:46your inner clarity becomes entirely
  259. 10:48corrupted like muddy water. Through
  260. 10:51that metaphor, the young man finally
  261. 10:53realized how valuable the solitude of
  262. 10:56being alone truly is. Schopenhauer
  263. 10:59warned that when we are in a crowd, we
  264. 11:01lose half of our true selves. While we
  265. 11:05laugh and chat to match the level of
  266. 11:07others, our unique individuality and
  267. 11:09capacity for deep thought gradually
  268. 11:11wear away. Great thoughts or art in the
  269. 11:15true sense are born not in loud
  270. 11:17drinking parties, but in the perfect
  271. 11:19silence of solitude. Those who cannot
  272. 11:22endure time alone cannot escape the
  273. 11:24fate of being a puppet controlled by
  274. 11:27the thoughts of others. Solitude is not
  275. 11:30a punishment that weakens us, but the
  276. 11:32most sacred sanctuary for washing away
  277. 11:35worldly dust and tempering the soul.
  278. 11:37Therefore, when a moment comes where it
  279. 11:39feels like everyone has left and you
  280. 11:41are all alone, there is no need to be
  281. 11:43afraid at all. In fact, that very
  282. 11:46moment is the best opportunity to face
  283. 11:48your true self and realize the deep
  284. 11:51principles of life. The fifth truth to
  285. 11:54keep in mind is the attitude of not
  286. 11:56being angry or sad at the irrationality
  287. 11:58of the world. As we live our lives, we
  288. 12:01encounter far too many absurd and
  289. 12:03unreasonable things. It’s
  290. 12:05heartbreaking to see those who work
  291. 12:08hard fail, while those who act
  292. 12:09recklessly succeed through sheer luck.
  293. 12:13Schopenhauer emphasized that we must
  294. 12:15abandon the illusion that this world
  295. 12:17operates in a moral and fair way early
  296. 12:20on. The world is moved by the blind
  297. 12:23force of will, having no interest in
  298. 12:25the values humans call justice. In an
  299. 12:29era long ago, there was an official
  300. 12:31whose only creed was to live with
  301. 12:33integrity. He never committed
  302. 12:35corruption and dedicated his life to
  303. 12:37the people, but was frequently demoted
  304. 12:40due to slanders whenever the regime
  305. 12:42changed. On the other hand, another
  306. 12:44official who catered to the powerful
  307. 12:47and committed all sorts of corruption
  308. 12:49rose rapidly and amassed huge wealth.
  309. 12:52As he lay old and sick, the honest
  310. 12:54official wept, lamenting the injustices
  311. 12:57of the world. How heartless the heavens
  312. 13:00are. He cried out, asking why the good
  313. 13:04suffer while the wicked live in such
  314. 13:06comfort. Just then, his disciple, who
  315. 13:09was by his side, quietly took his
  316. 13:11master’s hand and spoke. He said that
  317. 13:14blaming the heavens for the ways of the
  318. 13:16world only returns an empty echo to us.
  319. 13:20The disciple reminded him that one must
  320. 13:22accept that the world is inherently
  321. 13:24imperfect and full of contradictions.
  322. 13:27The wicked succeed only because they
  323. 13:30understand the cold nature of the world
  324. 13:33and act cleverly to suit it. The good
  325. 13:37suffer because they naively hold the
  326. 13:39expectation that the world should
  327. 13:41follow common sense. Hearing this, the
  328. 13:45official reached a deep realization and
  329. 13:47resolved to no longer be angry at the
  330. 13:50world’s irrationality. From that day
  331. 13:53on, he didn't glance at how others
  332. 13:56lived, focusing only on the inner peace
  333. 14:00he could control. Once he fully
  334. 14:03accepted that the world was unfair, he
  335. 14:06felt the heavy burden in his heart melt
  336. 14:09away. Schopenhauer believed we feel
  337. 14:12unhappy because the world does not move
  338. 14:15according to our expectations. Trying
  339. 14:18to change the world or feeling angry
  340. 14:20because it doesn't meet our standards
  341. 14:23is like punching the wind. The only
  342. 14:26wisdom is to calmly observe the
  343. 14:28contradictions of the world without
  344. 14:30losing one's own center. When you learn
  345. 14:34to become indifferent in the face of
  346. 14:35absurd reality, you finally gain a
  347. 14:37solid armor that isn't swayed by
  348. 14:39external environments. The sixth piece
  349. 14:42of wisdom to remember is to maintain a
  350. 14:44kind detachment toward the faults and
  351. 14:47follies of others. We often get angry
  352. 14:50and cannot tolerate it when people
  353. 14:52around us act foolishly or display
  354. 14:54selfishness. We struggle to understand
  355. 14:57why they act that way and sometimes
  356. 14:59meddle, trying to correct their wrongs.
  357. 15:03Schopenhauer asserted that since humans
  358. 15:06are born with irredeemable flaws,
  359. 15:08trying to change others is a waste of
  360. 15:10time. In a village, there was a man
  361. 15:14with a wicked disposition who enjoyed
  362. 15:15backbiting and taking pleasure in the
  363. 15:17misfortune of others. Whenever the
  364. 15:20villagers saw him, they would frown,
  365. 15:22and whenever he appeared, they would
  366. 15:25avoid him or throw bitter words at him.
  367. 15:28However, an old man in the village went
  368. 15:31about his way silently, showing no
  369. 15:34emotion whenever that man passed by.
  370. 15:38One day, a young man asked the old man.
  371. 15:41He complained that he could not
  372. 15:43understand how such a wicked and
  373. 15:45selfish person could exist, even after
  374. 15:47seeing him. The old man smiled faintly
  375. 15:50and answered the young man. He asked
  376. 15:53rhetorically if there was anyone who
  377. 15:55would get angry at a sharp, vicious
  378. 15:57thistle on the roadside, asking why its
  379. 15:59thorns were so sharp. He meant that a
  380. 16:02thistle is born with thorns, so it is
  381. 16:05not a target for anger. Likewise, he
  382. 16:07meant that the man's selfishness and
  383. 16:10tendency to disparage others were his
  384. 16:12innate nature, so there was no need to
  385. 16:15try to fix them. The old man advised
  386. 16:17him to abandon the arrogance of
  387. 16:19thinking he could change others' flaws
  388. 16:21and simply look on indifferently,
  389. 16:23thinking that such people also exist in
  390. 16:25the world. The young man took those
  391. 16:28deep words to heart, and from then on,
  392. 16:30he stopped reacting sensitively to
  393. 16:33others 'faults. Even when others did
  394. 16:35foolish things, he did not mock or try
  395. 16:37to teach them; he simply watched them
  396. 16:39calmly. Surprisingly, as he became
  397. 16:42indifferent to others' flaws, his
  398. 16:44stress vanished, and he gained
  399. 16:46tremendous peace of mind. Schopenhauer
  400. 16:49warned that trying to correct others '
  401. 16:51foolishness is a product of arrogance
  402. 16:53and, at the same time, the main culprit
  403. 16:55that drains our energy. Diverse groups
  404. 16:59of people live in the world, and they
  405. 17:01are bound to live, showing off their
  406. 17:03foolishness in their own ways. Pointing
  407. 17:07those things out one by one and getting
  408. 17:09angry is ultimately the most foolish
  409. 17:10act that harms our precious mental
  410. 17:12health. Becoming indifferent to others'
  411. 17:16flaws is a way of acknowledging them
  412. 17:18and the most dignified shield to
  413. 17:21protect ourselves. Seventh, what is
  414. 17:23needed to maintain the center of life
  415. 17:25is to completely free oneself from
  416. 17:27anxiety about the future and regrets
  417. 17:29about the past. Humans constantly
  418. 17:32ruminate on past failures in agony and
  419. 17:35worry in advance about disasters that
  420. 17:37have not yet come. Schopenhauer
  421. 17:40emphasized that only the present moment
  422. 17:42is the sole truth, and everything else
  423. 17:44is merely an illusion created by the
  424. 17:46human mind. Regretting things that have
  425. 17:49passed is like trying to revive ashes
  426. 17:51that have already burned out, and
  427. 17:53worrying about the future that has not
  428. 17:55arrived is like trembling while being
  429. 17:57hit by rain that has not yet fallen. In
  430. 17:59a countryside village, there was a
  431. 18:01farmer who spent his whole life awake
  432. 18:04in anxiety. The farmer lived in
  433. 18:06constant fear, worrying about a poor
  434. 18:09harvest this year or his children
  435. 18:11falling ill the next. Although the
  436. 18:15harvest was actually bountiful and his
  437. 18:17children were healthy, his mind was
  438. 18:20always clouded by the shadow of
  439. 18:22impending misfortune. As a result, he
  440. 18:25failed to enjoy the present joy or
  441. 18:28abundance and eventually fell ill,
  442. 18:30becoming bedridden. On his deathbed, an
  443. 18:33old monk visited the farmer, handed him
  444. 18:35a teacup, and spoke softly. He taught
  445. 18:39him to learn how to stay only in this
  446. 18:41moment, just as one focuses solely on
  447. 18:43the coolness when drinking cold water.
  448. 18:46Hearing this teaching, the farmer
  449. 18:48finally realized the truth. He learned
  450. 18:51that he had never once lived in the
  451. 18:53present, but had always been suffering
  452. 18:54within the illusions of a future that
  453. 18:56had not yet arrived. With his last
  454. 18:59breaths, he let go of his worries about
  455. 19:02the future and fully embraced the warm
  456. 19:04sunlight shining through the window. In
  457. 19:07that moment, a peaceful smile, the
  458. 19:09first in his entire life, spread across
  459. 19:11the farmer's face. Schopenhauer
  460. 19:14identified our tendency to ignore the
  461. 19:16gift of the present while living in
  462. 19:19delusions as the greatest folly. Time
  463. 19:22does not flow; it always remains with
  464. 19:25us in the form of the present.
  465. 19:28Therefore, we must become indifferent
  466. 19:29to the coming future and completely
  467. 19:31indifferent to the past that has
  468. 19:33already gone. Focusing only on the
  469. 19:36reality unfolding before my eyes right
  470. 19:38now, the moment I am breathing, is the
  471. 19:41only key to leading a victorious life.
  472. 19:44Only by closing your heart to the noise
  473. 19:46and anxiety of the world and sinking
  474. 19:48deeply into the silence of the present
  475. 19:51can you find true liberation. The
  476. 19:53eighth pinnacle of conduct to examine
  477. 19:56is completely severing the obsession
  478. 19:58with the approval and honor of others.
  479. 20:01These people want to be seen as great
  480. 20:03by others and dedicate their youth to
  481. 20:06gaining social status or prestige.
  482. 20:09Schopenhauer criticized honor as merely
  483. 20:11a vain shadow existing in others 'minds
  484. 20:14, arguing that a life chasing it is no
  485. 20:16different from the life of a slave.
  486. 20:19True value depends not on how others
  487. 20:22see me, but on how I evaluate myself. A
  488. 20:26famous painter once lived in the
  489. 20:29capital of a great empire. The painter
  490. 20:31received the highest honors from the
  491. 20:34king, basked in the praise of the
  492. 20:36people, and enjoyed wealth and fame.
  493. 20:39However, as days passed, he suffered
  494. 20:41from the obsession that he must attain
  495. 20:43even greater fame, and could not sleep
  496. 20:45peacefully for a single day. Eventually
  497. 20:48, collapsing from exhaustion and near
  498. 20:50death, he called his apprentice to
  499. 20:53leave his final will. He confessed that
  500. 20:56all the numerous medals and accolades
  501. 20:58he had chased throughout his life were
  502. 21:00nothing more than dust blowing in the
  503. 21:02wind. The painter confessed to his
  504. 21:05disciple how deeply he regretted living
  505. 21:08a life tethered to the praise of others
  506. 21:11. Deeply moved by his master's final
  507. 21:14words, the disciple rejected worldly
  508. 21:16fame and retreated to a mountain valley
  509. 21:19to paint alone. He sought no
  510. 21:22recognition, finding freedom by
  511. 21:24capturing only the landscapes and
  512. 21:26colors he truly loved. Though the world
  513. 21:30remained unaware of him, a peaceful
  514. 21:32smile never left his face. Schopenhauer
  515. 21:36warned that becoming addicted to the
  516. 21:38drug of others' praise leads to a
  517. 21:40miserable end, losing one’s autonomy
  518. 21:43and becoming a slave to their judgment.
  519. 21:46Without approval, one feels anxious,
  520. 21:49and with it, one falls into an endless
  521. 21:51hell of craving ever more. Therefore,
  522. 21:54one must become thoroughly indifferent
  523. 21:57to flashy decorations like fame and
  524. 21:59titles. Whether the world acknowledges
  525. 22:02you or not, your value neither falls
  526. 22:04nor rises because of it. Only by
  527. 22:07building a solid internal foundation
  528. 22:09and casting off the mask of others '
  529. 22:11expectations can you truly be reborn as
  530. 22:14a free person. The ninth and final
  531. 22:17wisdom to engrave on your heart is to
  532. 22:19let go of all attachments and reach a
  533. 22:22state of indifference. We suffer
  534. 22:25because we desire things too intensely
  535. 22:28and struggle desperately to hold onto
  536. 22:31them. Schopenhauer declared that human
  537. 22:34desire is like seawater: the more you
  538. 22:37drink, the thirstier you become. All
  539. 22:40suffering stems from desire, and the
  540. 22:42only way to break that chain is to
  541. 22:45realize life's impermanence and become
  542. 22:47indifferent. An elderly monk in an
  543. 22:50ancient monastery left his final
  544. 22:52teaching to his disciples before he
  545. 22:54passed away. The disciples earnestly
  546. 22:57asked the master what the secret to
  547. 22:59living the wisest life in this world
  548. 23:01was. With a faint smile, the monk
  549. 23:04whispered this softly to his disciples.
  550. 23:07He said that the ultimate liberation is
  551. 23:10to desire nothing, hate nothing, and
  552. 23:12remain unswayed by the affairs of the
  553. 23:15world. Carrying that teaching, the
  554. 23:18disciples lived their lives avoiding
  555. 23:20desire and maintaining peace of mind.
  556. 23:24The ultimate message of Schopenhauer's
  557. 23:26philosophy aligns perfectly with this.
  558. 23:30How the world treats us or what others
  559. 23:34say about us is merely a passing breeze
  560. 23:37. The moment we react to that breeze
  561. 23:41and get hurt, we become slaves to the
  562. 23:44world. Conversely, when we step back
  563. 23:47from all that noise and desire to be
  564. 23:50truly indifferent, we finally stand as
  565. 23:53the masters of our own lives. "
  566. 23:56Indifference is victory"—it is not
  567. 23:58about coldness or giving up, but the
  568. 24:00greatest way to live, keeping a solid
  569. 24:02inner peace without being swayed by the
  570. 24:04illusions of the world. From this
  571. 24:06moment on, I hope you free yourself
  572. 24:09from the gaze of others and vain
  573. 24:11desires, and walk only your own quiet
  574. 24:13and confident path. The tenth wisdom
  575. 24:16you must cherish in your heart is to
  576. 24:18liberate yourself from the heavy prison
  577. 24:21of others' expectations. Countless
  578. 24:24people lose their true voices while
  579. 24:26trying to meet their parents '
  580. 24:28expectations, their lover's wishes, or
  581. 24:30the standards of success set by society
  582. 24:32. Schopenhauer strongly cautioned that
  583. 24:36dedicating one's life to meeting others
  584. 24:38' expectations is the most miserable
  585. 24:40form of self-alienation. In the palace
  586. 24:44of a vast kingdom, there was a prince
  587. 24:46born with the destiny of governing the
  588. 24:48nation for generations. From a young
  589. 24:51age, the prince never lived for himself
  590. 24:53for even a moment, as he strove to meet
  591. 24:55the expectations of his people and
  592. 24:57officials. When studying, he stayed up
  593. 25:00all night to earn the praise of
  594. 25:02scholars, and when practicing martial
  595. 25:04arts, he swung his sword until he was
  596. 25:06bloodied to gain the recognition of
  597. 25:08generals. Though he was seen by all as
  598. 25:11an excellent and perfect successor, his
  599. 25:14heart was always bruised with cold
  600. 25:16emptiness. Even after ascending the
  601. 25:19throne, he was obsessed with the
  602. 25:20compulsion to repay the people's cheers
  603. 25:22, never stopping his performance as the
  604. 25:25virtuous king they desired. Then, a
  605. 25:27tragic moment arrived when the palace
  606. 25:30was surrounded by a massive rebel army,
  607. 25:32and he lost all his power. All his
  608. 25:35officials fled or betrayed him, and the
  609. 25:37deposed king, left alone, lay on the
  610. 25:40cold floor of the prison and finally
  611. 25:42realized the truth. He realized that he
  612. 25:45had spent his entire life wearing the
  613. 25:47mask of others 'expectations, dancing
  614. 25:50like a puppet they desired, never once
  615. 25:52living as himself. Watching the morning
  616. 25:56sunlight streaming through the prison
  617. 25:59bars, he smiled bitterly. All the
  618. 26:02praise and expectations others had
  619. 26:04bestowed upon him vanished like smoke
  620. 26:06the moment his power disappeared,
  621. 26:08leaving no trace behind. Schopenhauer
  622. 26:11viewed a life spent trying to fulfill
  623. 26:14the expectations of others as pouring
  624. 26:16water into a broken jar that can never
  625. 26:18be filled. While we tremble in fear of
  626. 26:21falling short of someone's expectations
  627. 26:24, our unique souls slowly suffocate and
  628. 26:27die. Therefore, you must become
  629. 26:29thoroughly indifferent to the image
  630. 26:31others wish for you to embody. Whoever
  631. 26:34is disappointed or whoever criticizes,
  632. 26:36it is because their expectations were
  633. 26:39excessive, not because you are at fault
  634. 26:41. Only when you walk silently according
  635. 26:44to the path of life that you define
  636. 26:46yourself can you finally break free
  637. 26:48from the shackles of others'
  638. 26:49expectations. The eleventh piece of
  639. 26:52wisdom we must deeply engrave in our
  640. 26:54minds is the attitude of remaining
  641. 26:55indifferent to the trends and gossip of
  642. 26:57the world. Mass media and the world are
  643. 27:00desperate to capture people's attention
  644. 27:03, constantly churning out new trends
  645. 27:05and sensational gossip. Schopenhauer
  646. 27:08criticized being swept away by popular
  647. 27:11gossip or vain trends as the most
  648. 27:13foolish way to erode one's intellectual
  649. 27:16assets. In the heart of a bustling
  650. 27:19metropolis lived a recluse who spent
  651. 27:21his life quietly collecting and
  652. 27:23studying ancient books. Though the
  653. 27:26world was noisy with new luxury goods,
  654. 27:29celebrity scandals, and political
  655. 27:31infighting, he paid no attention to
  656. 27:34that world of noise. One day, his young
  657. 27:38nephew visited, chattering about the
  658. 27:41latest trends and hot topics, and urged
  659. 27:43his uncle to take an interest. The
  660. 27:47scholar quietly closed his book, looked
  661. 27:49at his nephew, and asked in a low voice
  662. 27:51. He asked whether those countless
  663. 27:54stories touted in the marketplace would
  664. 27:57provide even a handful of nourishment
  665. 27:59for his soul a year later. The nephew
  666. 28:02could not answer the question and
  667. 28:04hesitated. The scholar reminded him
  668. 28:08that worldly trends are like seawater;
  669. 28:10the more you drink, the thirstier you
  670. 28:12become, and it only devastates the mind
  671. 28:15. Our lives do not suffer any great
  672. 28:18loss simply because we are unaware of
  673. 28:20the gossip that everyone else knows. On
  674. 28:22the contrary, when we do not let our
  675. 28:24minds be stolen by such useless
  676. 28:26information, our spirits naturally
  677. 28:28become clearer and deeper. Schopenhauer
  678. 28:32emphasized that those with great minds
  679. 28:35have no interest in trivial worldly
  680. 28:37rumors and only explore eternal truth
  681. 28:40and wisdom. Therefore, remain
  682. 28:43thoroughly indifferent to what others
  683. 28:45buy, where they go, and whom they
  684. 28:47criticize. Only when you close your
  685. 28:50eyes to the thorns of the world do your
  686. 28:52inner ears open, and you begin to see
  687. 28:54what is truly important. The second
  688. 28:57wisdom lies in the indifference that
  689. 28:59protects you from the tools of jealousy
  690. 29:01and envy. Humans are instinctively
  691. 29:04seized by unbearable envy when they see
  692. 29:06others accumulate more wealth or gain
  693. 29:09greater fame than themselves.
  694. 29:12Schopenhauer saw jealousy as the
  695. 29:14cruelest hell that burns the human
  696. 29:16heart, and believed the only way to
  697. 29:18overcome it is to be completely
  698. 29:20indifferent to others 'achievements. In
  699. 29:24a peaceful rural village, there were
  700. 29:26two friends who ran farms side by side.
  701. 29:30One friend became rich as his harvest
  702. 29:32increased every year, while the other
  703. 29:34friend barely managed to get by due to
  704. 29:37droughts and pests. The impoverished
  705. 29:40friend felt a burning jealousy whenever
  706. 29:42he looked at the abundant harvest
  707. 29:44visible over the fence of his wealthy
  708. 29:46friend's farm. He could not sleep at
  709. 29:50night, and instead of blessing his
  710. 29:52friend's success, he cursed him,
  711. 29:54wishing he would fail instead. In the
  712. 29:57end, that intense envy ate away at his
  713. 30:01body and mind, making him ill, and he
  714. 30:04met a miserable end. On his deathbed,
  715. 30:08he held his rich friend's hand and
  716. 30:10confessed with tears that the jealousy
  717. 30:12he had harbored was the very blade that
  718. 30:15killed him. Listening to that sad
  719. 30:17confession, his rich friend came to a
  720. 30:19profound realization deep in his heart.
  721. 30:22He learned that the heart that envies
  722. 30:24and covets the success of others is
  723. 30:26like a poisonous mushroom that
  724. 30:28eventually leads one to ruin.
  725. 30:30Schopenhauer asserted that keeping an
  726. 30:32eye on others' luck or success and
  727. 30:34feeling bitter about it is the most
  728. 30:37foolish way to waste one's life.
  729. 30:39Whether that person is wealthy or
  730. 30:41powerful, it is merely their destiny
  731. 30:44and has nothing to do with my own life.
  732. 30:48True peace comes when we become
  733. 30:49indifferent to the achievements of
  734. 30:51others and focus solely on tending to
  735. 30:53our own small field. Not coveting
  736. 30:56another's bowl, but being satisfied
  737. 30:57with the water filled in my own. That
  738. 31:00is the secret to yielding to the way of
  739. 31:02the world and winning. The thirteenth
  740. 31:04principle of life we will examine is
  741. 31:06the power of silence: not reacting
  742. 31:08immediately to the rudeness or attacks
  743. 31:10of others. Living in this world, it is
  744. 31:13impossible to avoid people who pick
  745. 31:14fights unreasonably or heap insults
  746. 31:16upon you. Schopenhauer warned that
  747. 31:19getting angry and retaliating against
  748. 31:22such rude people is like wrestling with
  749. 31:24a pig in the mud. If you wrestle with a
  750. 31:28pig, you only get dirty, and the pig
  751. 31:30actually enjoys the fight. In a market
  752. 31:33square, a troublemaker known for his
  753. 31:36violent temper slapped a mild-mannered
  754. 31:38merchant for no reason at all. The
  755. 31:41onlookers held their breath, watching
  756. 31:43to see how the merchant would retaliate
  757. 31:46. However, far from getting angry or
  758. 31:49striking back, the merchant simply
  759. 31:51rubbed his cheek quietly and went on
  760. 31:54his way without a word. The
  761. 31:56troublemaker felt awkward and spat out
  762. 31:59a few more insults, but when the other
  763. 32:01person didn't react, he lost interest
  764. 32:03and left. Later, people asked the
  765. 32:06merchant how he could endure such an
  766. 32:08insult and just stay silent. The
  767. 32:11merchant wore a broad smile and
  768. 32:13answered like this. He asked who would
  769. 32:16stop to bark back just because a mad
  770. 32:19dog was barking as they walked past it.
  771. 32:22It meant that the troublemaker's
  772. 32:24rudeness was merely proof that his
  773. 32:27character was only that shallow, and
  774. 32:29responding to it would be lowering my
  775. 32:31own dignity to his level. Schopenhauer
  776. 32:35taught that the most powerful revenge
  777. 32:37against the malice or rudeness of
  778. 32:39others is complete disregard and
  779. 32:41silence. The moment we get angry and
  780. 32:44worked up, the other person will be
  781. 32:45delighted as if they’ve found our
  782. 32:47weakness, and they will shake us even
  783. 32:49more. However, if you remain coolly
  784. 32:52indifferent and treat them as if they
  785. 32:54were invisible, they will eventually
  786. 32:57tire of their own childishness and
  787. 32:59drift away. Do not draw your sword for
  788. 33:02every attack from others; instead, pass
  789. 33:04them by resolutely behind the great
  790. 33:07shield of silence. The fourteenth truth
  791. 33:10to keep in mind is the firmness of not
  792. 33:12devaluing yourself based on the world's
  793. 33:15assessments or criticisms. People often
  794. 33:18become easily discouraged and lose
  795. 33:20confidence depending on how others
  796. 33:22perceive them. Schopenhauer emphasized
  797. 33:26that criticism from others is merely a
  798. 33:28product of their subjective prejudices
  799. 33:30and narrow vision, and one must never
  800. 33:32be crushed by its weight. There was
  801. 33:36once an outstanding artist in a kingdom
  802. 33:38who received praise from countless
  803. 33:40people. He dedicated his entire life to
  804. 33:43completing a massive statue and
  805. 33:45displayed it in the royal square. The
  806. 33:47people were filled with wonder, but a
  807. 33:49jealous critic in the palace poured out
  808. 33:52harsh remarks, claiming the statue's
  809. 33:54ankles looked awkward. As the critic's
  810. 33:57disapproval spread, people began
  811. 33:59pointing fingers at the statue, busy
  812. 34:02finding flaws. Unable to bear the
  813. 34:05criticism, the artist was heartbroken
  814. 34:07and shattered the statue. Just then, a
  815. 34:11sage passing through the village
  816. 34:12stopped the artist and gave quiet
  817. 34:14advice. He said that public criticism
  818. 34:16is like a light breeze, and there is no
  819. 34:19need to be shaken by it. The sage asked
  820. 34:22the artist if the critic who disparaged
  821. 34:24the statue's ankles actually knew
  822. 34:27anything about art. The artist realized
  823. 34:30that the critic was, in fact, an
  824. 34:32ignorant person who knew nothing about
  825. 34:35art at all. He composed his shaken mind
  826. 34:38and regained confidence in his own
  827. 34:41artistic sense. Schopenhauer pointed
  828. 34:44out that accepting constructive
  829. 34:46criticism is strictly different from
  830. 34:48being swayed by others 'malicious
  831. 34:50gossip. No matter what others say, if
  832. 34:53you have solid standards and skills
  833. 34:55within you, the world’s criticism is
  834. 34:58nothing more than a passing breeze.
  835. 35:01Becoming indifferent to the evaluations
  836. 35:03of others is the only shield to protect
  837. 35:05your self-esteem and lead your life
  838. 35:07with dignity. The fifteenth requirement
  839. 35:10for firmly holding onto the center of
  840. 35:13your life is a resolute attitude not to
  841. 35:15be buried in past pain or trauma.
  842. 35:18Everyone lives carrying memories of
  843. 35:20past betrayals or failures, sometimes
  844. 35:23reopening those wounds to torment
  845. 35:26themselves. Schopenhauer flatly stated
  846. 35:29that there is no punishment more
  847. 35:31foolish than wasting the present by
  848. 35:32being obsessed with the past. In a port
  849. 35:35city, there lived an old merchant who
  850. 35:38had lost all his wealth and even his
  851. 35:40family in a great maritime accident in
  852. 35:42his youth. Even decades later, the
  853. 35:45merchant would sit at the pier every
  854. 35:48day, recalling that stormy day and
  855. 35:51shedding tears. Regret and resentment
  856. 35:54over a past accident weighed down his
  857. 35:56present, preventing him from fully
  858. 35:58enjoying the happiness left in his life
  859. 36:01. One day, a young sailor sat beside
  860. 36:04the old merchant and asked quietly. He
  861. 36:07asked if clinging to a sunken ship
  862. 36:09would ever bring the treasure hidden at
  863. 36:11the bottom of the sea back to the
  864. 36:13surface. The merchant was jolted awake
  865. 36:16by that piercing remark. He realized
  866. 36:20that while his body was living in the
  867. 36:22present, his mind had been trapped in
  868. 36:24the sea of the past for decades. From
  869. 36:27that day on, the merchant stopped
  870. 36:29visiting the pier that reminded him of
  871. 36:31his past wounds and focused only on the
  872. 36:34tasks and breath given to him each day.
  873. 36:36Surprisingly, as he stepped out of the
  874. 36:39shadow of the past, he felt his
  875. 36:41emotional wounds heal and new vitality
  876. 36:43surge within him. Schopenhauer viewed
  877. 36:46that events already passed in the flow
  878. 36:49of time are like cosmic dust, unworthy
  879. 36:51of any emotional investment. Being
  880. 36:54completely indifferent to the past and
  881. 36:57fully immersed in the present moment is
  882. 36:59the only way to save one's life. The
  883. 37:02sixteenth wisdom to remember is how to
  884. 37:05let go of anger toward the world's
  885. 37:07inequalities and absurdities. The world
  886. 37:10was not made fair from the start; some
  887. 37:13are born with a silver spoon in their
  888. 37:15mouths, while others are born with a
  889. 37:18dirt spoon. Schopenhauer warned that
  890. 37:21resenting and complaining about this
  891. 37:23fundamental inequality is like spitting
  892. 37:26into the sky. In one country, there was
  893. 37:29a young man who cursed the unfairness
  894. 37:32of the world, blamed the government,
  895. 37:34and envied the rich every single day.
  896. 37:36Frustrated by the reality that he could
  897. 37:38not become rich despite working hard,
  898. 37:40he spent his days drinking. Then, he
  899. 37:44happened to meet an enlightened old man
  900. 37:46living in the mountains, and he
  901. 37:47lamented his situation and cried out
  902. 37:49that the world was unfair. The old man
  903. 37:52pointed to the wildflowers blooming in
  904. 37:54the yard and spoke to the young man
  905. 37:56quietly. He asked if any of those
  906. 37:59wildflowers would resent the sky just
  907. 38:01because some receive plenty of sunlight
  908. 38:04while others wither in the shade. The
  909. 38:07young man looked at the old man, unable
  910. 38:09to offer a response. The old man
  911. 38:11explained that the world's inequalities
  912. 38:14are like the providence of nature and
  913. 38:16are not something humans can change. He
  914. 38:20advised that instead of wasting energy
  915. 38:22on anger, one should focus on blooming
  916. 38:24one's own flower within the given
  917. 38:26environment. The young man realized the
  918. 38:29teaching, set aside his resentment
  919. 38:31toward the world, abandoned the habit
  920. 38:33of comparing himself to others, and
  921. 38:35immersed himself in his work.
  922. 38:37Schopenhauer emphasized that inner
  923. 38:39peace and true growth begin only when
  924. 38:42one becomes indifferent to the
  925. 38:44unfairness of the world. An attitude of
  926. 38:47stopping complaints and focusing on
  927. 38:49what one can do right now is the wisest
  928. 38:51way to navigate this rough world. The
  929. 38:5417th principle for arming your mind is
  930. 38:56the indifference required to not be
  931. 38:58deceived by the hypocrisy and fake
  932. 39:00kindness of others. There are far too
  933. 39:03many people in this world who approach
  934. 39:05you disguised in pure good intentions
  935. 39:07while hiding selfish motives.
  936. 39:10Schopenhauer warned not to open your
  937. 39:13heart easily to others' sweet words,
  938. 39:15noting that human nature is
  939. 39:17fundamentally rooted in selfishness.
  940. 39:20There was once a con artist in a
  941. 39:22wealthy merchant town who captured
  942. 39:24hearts with all sorts of kindness while
  943. 39:26stealing profits behind the scenes. The
  944. 39:29con artist gave out gifts and spared no
  945. 39:32praise to win people's favor. While the
  946. 39:36villagers were taken in by his kindness
  947. 39:39, only one seasoned merchant kept a
  948. 39:42distance and showed no reaction at all.
  949. 39:46The con artist offered even more
  950. 39:48exaggerated kindness to win the
  951. 39:50merchant over, but the merchant always
  952. 39:52met him with an indifferent gaze.
  953. 39:56Eventually, the con artist's true
  954. 39:57colors were revealed, and while
  955. 39:59everyone else lost their wealth and
  956. 40:01suffered, only the seasoned merchant
  957. 40:03was unharmed. People asked the merchant
  958. 40:06in admiration how he had known the con
  959. 40:08artist’s true nature in advance. The
  960. 40:11merchant smiled broadly and replied
  961. 40:14briefly that there is no such thing as
  962. 40:16kindness without a price in this world.
  963. 40:19Schopenhauer advised that when others
  964. 40:21are excessively kind or pushy, you must
  965. 40:24be wary of hidden motives and maintain
  966. 40:26a thoroughly indifferent attitude.
  967. 40:29Excessive favor often turns into a
  968. 40:31burden, so you must always harbor a
  969. 40:34cold sense of caution in your heart.
  970. 40:37Only by staying centered and not swayed
  971. 40:40by others 'honeyed words can you safely
  972. 40:42escape the world's subtle traps. The
  973. 40:4518th and final wisdom to engrave on
  974. 40:47your heart is to transcend the world's
  975. 40:50judgment and become the master of your
  976. 40:52own life. The core of Schopenhauer’s
  977. 40:55art of living is to be completely
  978. 40:57independent of others' perspectives and
  979. 41:00the world's noise to preserve inner
  980. 41:02peace. Ironically, when we become
  981. 41:04indifferent to the affairs of the world
  982. 41:07, what we gain is the immense power to
  983. 41:09fully control our own lives. There was
  984. 41:12an old scholar who lived alone by a
  985. 41:14quiet lake, filling his entire life
  986. 41:16with contemplation. The world judged
  987. 41:19him as eccentric or ignorant of worldly
  988. 41:23ways, but he never once paid any heed
  989. 41:25to those voices. His face carried a
  990. 41:29deep peace and dignity that remained
  991. 41:32unshaken by any storms of the world.
  992. 41:35Facing his final moments, a student
  993. 41:37visited the old scholar and desperately
  994. 41:40asked what the most victorious life in
  995. 41:42the world was. The old scholar closed
  996. 41:45his eyes, offered a faint smile, and
  997. 41:48whispered this to his student. No
  998. 41:50matter what the world says, close your
  999. 41:53eyes and listen only to the voice of
  1000. 41:55your own soul. He said that this is the
  1001. 41:58one and only truth that overcomes all
  1002. 42:00the storms of the world. Taking that
  1003. 42:02last wish to heart, the disciple lived
  1004. 42:05a steadfast life, unmoved by the praise
  1005. 42:08or criticism of the world. The message
  1006. 42:11Schopenhauer intends to convey to us is
  1007. 42:14exactly the same. A life shackled by
  1008. 42:17the gaze of others and swayed by the
  1009. 42:19world's judgment is nothing more than a
  1010. 42:21puppet's life, controlled by others. A
  1011. 42:24true victor is someone who remains
  1012. 42:26completely indifferent to the noise of
  1013. 42:28the world and walks their path in
  1014. 42:29silence, with their inner self as a
  1015. 42:31sanctuary. From today on, I hope you
  1016. 42:34boldly set down the heavy burden of
  1017. 42:37others 'standards and walk your own
  1018. 42:39quiet, solid path. To one who
  1019. 42:42understands the ways of the world,
  1020. 42:44external winds are merely passing
  1021. 42:47breezes, and no hardship can ever
  1022. 42:49destroy your true peace.

About this transcript

This page contains the full transcript of 무심해야 이긴다 그것이 세상의 이치다 | 쇼펜하우어 인생론 | 처세술 | 명언 | 인간관계 지혜 | 오디오북 by 깨달음의광장, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 6,517 words across 1,022 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.

What you can do with it

Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.

Free YouTube transcript tool

YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.