VINILO vs CD: la verdad que nadie quiere oír — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:00A vinyl record and a CD of exactly the
- 0:03same album. Vinyl is supposed to sound
- 0:05better, right? Or at least, that is
- 0:08what we have been hearing quite a bit
- 0:10over the last few years: that vinyl is
- 0:11warmer, that it is more natural; that
- 0:13digital sound is reconstructed based on
- 0:15steps and those steps produce noise;
- 0:16that analog is a continuous line and,
- 0:18therefore, has no loss, it is more
- 0:20faithful to the original wave. But
- 0:22there is a small problem, and that is
- 0:24that technically many of those claims
- 0:26are false, and yet there are many
- 0:28situations in which vinyl sounds better
- 0:30than CD. So, how can both things be
- 0:32true? Today we are going to pit both
- 0:34physical formats against each other
- 0:35with real data, for which I will
- 0:37actually leave a bibliography in the
- 0:38description in case you want to check
- 0:40any of these facts; but we will also
- 0:41try to understand why a format that, a
- 0:43priori, is noisier, more fragile, more
- 0:45expensive, and more inconvenient, has
- 0:46been growing steadily for practically
- 0:4820 years. This video, by the way, was
- 0:49suggested to me by a good friend,
- 0:50Miguel Delis, who I am sure many of you
- 0:52know from his channel, who has already
- 0:53been here on this channel, he already
- 0:54collaborated on a video, the video
- 0:56where we reviewed the entire year of
- 0:571998. So I take this opportunity to
- 0:59send you a greeting, Miguel, and I hope
- 1:00this comparison helps you, sheds a
- 1:01little light for you. First of all,
- 1:03what does it mean to sound better?
- 1:05Before comparing anything, you have to
- 1:06completely separate two concepts. One
- 1:08thing is for a format to be more
- 1:10faithful to the original recording and
- 1:11another very different thing is for a
- 1:13format to be more pleasant to you. For
- 1:15example, a tube amplifier can add
- 1:17distortion and you might like it more.
- 1:19A tape can slightly compress transients
- 1:21and give you a more pleasant sound. I
- 1:23have told a thousand times how I used
- 1:25to transfer my CDs to tape myself with
- 1:27the classic CD and tape player, because
- 1:29I liked it, and specifically with
- 1:30chrome tapes, I liked the sound it gave
- 1:32to the CDs, you know? It gave it a
- 1:34worse, more vintage sound, but I liked
- 1:36it. Just like a vinyl, it can color the
- 1:38sound in a certain way and a person
- 1:39might find it more pleasant. But if we
- 1:41want to know, on equal terms, which of
- 1:44the media best reproduces the same
- 1:45master as it came out of the studio,
- 1:47the answer is clear. The CD is
- 1:49technically superior. And now we are
- 1:51going to see why. Look, the CD stores
- 1:53linear PCM audio at 16 bits and 44,100
- 1:56samples per second. It has no type of
- 1:58compression, it has no type of loss, it
- 2:01doesn't remove instruments, it simply
- 2:03represents the signal using pure
- 2:05numbers. In fact, according to the
- 2:07Nyquist theorem, the sampling theorem,
- 2:10a frequency of 44,100 Hz allows for
- 2:12reproducing frequencies up to 22,050 Hz
- 2:14. As a matter of fact, the theoretical
- 2:16human limit is 20,000 Hz. We are
- 2:19supposed to hear from 20 Hz as a
- 2:20minimum to 20,000 Hz at the high end,
- 2:22but this reduces quite a bit with age.
- 2:25This is just theorizing. Usually, an
- 2:27adult tends to reach up to 15,000, or
- 2:2817,000 in the best of cases. In other
- 2:30words, a CD can more than cover the
- 2:32entire audible spectrum for a human
- 2:34being. And a great myth: music on a CD
- 2:36is not shaped like a staircase. That
- 2:39famous image showing a digital wave
- 2:41full of steps is simply representing
- 2:43the stored samples. It is a way of
- 2:45representing how sound is reconstructed
- 2:47based on samples, but the analog wave
- 2:49reconstructed by the converter is once
- 2:51again a continuous signal. So, we can
- 2:53finally bury that first myth. The CD
- 2:55does not produce stepped waves; it does
- 2:57not produce distortion. In fact,
- 2:59furthermore, it is a cleaner format
- 3:01than vinyl. Look, so I don't get too
- 3:03tangled up, so I don't get into
- 3:05technical issues, a 16-bit audio file
- 3:06contains 96 dB of dynamic range. What
- 3:08does that mean? Take a look at this
- 3:09image. We see a stereo signal
- 3:11represented as a left channel and a
- 3:13right channel. And here we have 0
- 3:14decibels, which would be the highest
- 3:16peak. And here we have more or less
- 3:18represented down to -36. Well, we can
- 3:20actually go down to -96 decibels; that
- 3:23is, we can store music or extremely
- 3:26quiet sounds without them having any
- 3:29kind of audible distortion. Put into
- 3:32practice. It is true that you won't
- 3:34find any record that has that many
- 3:35negative decibels, but with vinyl,
- 3:37things are a little worse. There is no
- 3:39single figure because it depends a bit
- 3:41on the pressing, the quality of the
- 3:43materials, the condition of the record,
- 3:45the needle, the cartridge, the
- 3:47turntable; but let's say that an LP in
- 3:49good condition, like this one that is
- 3:51new, can be at more or less 60 decibels
- 3:53of dynamic range. But watch out, the
- 3:55container is one thing and what we put
- 3:56inside is another. What I mean by this
- 3:58is that vinyl has a noise floor, it has
- 4:00a background noise that everyone
- 4:02recognizes, a noise like this, okay? Ah
- 4:05, recorded with crackles, clicks,
- 4:06depending on the state of the record.
- 4:12Okay, I’m exaggerating it so you can
- 4:13see it, but everyone knows we have this
- 4:15background noise. That’s why, for
- 4:17example, classical music benefits a lot
- 4:19from CD releases, and in fact,
- 4:20classical music is rare. In the past,
- 4:22when there were no other formats, it
- 4:24was released on vinyl, but today, I am
- 4:26not an expert on classical music, not
- 4:28by a long shot. I don’t know if
- 4:31there’s a boom in classical music on
- 4:33vinyl right now, but I do know that
- 4:36classical music audiophiles don't like
- 4:38the vinyl format for their style. What
- 4:42they prefer is the CD format precisely
- 4:43for that reason: because it eliminates
- 4:45that noise and there is a greater
- 4:46dynamic range, something you don’t
- 4:47get in a death metal or metal song in
- 4:48general. Moving on. Vinyl is really a
- 4:51mechanical feat; I mean, reproducing
- 4:53music by having a microscopic needle
- 4:55travel through a groove is an
- 4:57engineering marvel, but it also implies
- 5:00limitations. For starters, a vinyl
- 5:01record uses the RIAA curve. What is
- 5:03that? A curve we use when we cut the
- 5:06disc. What we do is reduce the bass
- 5:08significantly and boost the highs a bit
- 5:10, and then the phono preamp does the
- 5:12reverse. Why is this necessary? Because
- 5:15powerful bass notes, for example,
- 5:17recorded at their original volume and
- 5:19size, would create enormous grooves. I
- 5:22mean, the RIAA curve is a brilliant
- 5:24solution; I insist, the whole vinyl
- 5:26subject is an engineering prodigy, but
- 5:29it also shows us that vinyl sound
- 5:31depends on a quite large, complex
- 5:33mechanical chain where many components
- 5:35might not be in their best state. The
- 5:38classic argument is that music is a
- 5:41continuous wave and since this is
- 5:43analog, it will reproduce better.
- 5:45You're overlooking that vinyl also has
- 5:47physical limitations; it doesn't
- 5:49reproduce music, it doesn't reproduce
- 5:51audio just as you hear it in the real
- 5:53world, okay? A whole lot of elements
- 5:55are involved. Vinyl depends on the
- 5:57needle, cartridge, tonearm, alignment,
- 5:59preamp, turntable stability, and the
- 6:01condition of the record. That’s
- 6:04another argument many people have told
- 6:06me: "No, CDs have a lifespan of 30, 40
- 6:08years and then they degrade and get
- 6:10ruined." Look, a vinyl record isn't
- 6:12eternal either. In fact, a vinyl record
- 6:13is producing friction against the
- 6:15needle the entire time. I mean, the
- 6:17whole time it's in contact with
- 6:19something, it wears down over time,
- 6:20whereas with a CD you have an optical
- 6:22reader that doesn't touch the disc.
- 6:24Another problem, too, the issue with
- 6:26the ends of the sides, and this is
- 6:27especially interesting and complicated
- 6:29for us metal and rock lovers. A vinyl
- 6:31always spins at the same speed. I don't
- 6:33have the vinyl open right now for you
- 6:34to see. I'm going to go get another one
- 6:36. A few moments later.
- 6:38Status quo. New stuff, Carmelo. Look,
- 6:40let's set it so you can see a little
- 6:41bit of shine. Okay, if that were
- 6:42possible. Here, in this part, at the
- 6:44same playback speed. There is much more
- 6:47length to cover on this outer part of
- 6:49the disc than on this inner part.
- 6:51It’s an exaggerated difference, but
- 6:52it’s a difference that exists. And
- 6:53that’s where the dreaded distortion
- 6:55of the circles, or discs, or grooves,
- 6:57rather, appears on the inner ones.
- 7:01Inner Groove Distortion, simply put,
- 7:03high notes and guitar distortions, for
- 7:05example, translate worse in those inner
- 7:08areas than in the outer areas. That’s
- 7:11why it’s often recommended that
- 7:14softer songs go toward the end of each
- 7:16side and louder ones are placed on the
- 7:19outside. But imagine a band like
- 7:22Cannibal Corpse, how do they do that,
- 7:23how do they put the softer ones on the
- 7:25inside? Tough, right? And for example,
- 7:28the CD doesn't have that problem. The
- 7:29CD plays a song at the beginning of the
- 7:30disc exactly the same as one at the end
- 7:32, it makes no difference at all. More
- 7:34physical limitations. For example, on a
- 7:36vinyl, the two stereo channels, left
- 7:37and right, physically share the same
- 7:39groove. That limits the ability to
- 7:41separate the left and right channels.
- 7:44For instance, when I have to master for
- 7:46vinyl, we really have to pay close
- 7:48attention to the stereo width so there
- 7:50aren't phase issues. Phase issues occur
- 7:52when we have a sound or two very
- 7:54similar sounds very close together,
- 7:57okay? It can happen, for example, when
- 7:59you use drum samples, okay? When you
- 8:01reinforce drums, sometimes phase issues
- 8:02occur, you have to be very careful with
- 8:04them. So, it can happen that the left
- 8:06and right channels generate phase
- 8:07issues between them. How do we reduce
- 8:09those phase problems? By making the
- 8:11signals closer together, not so far
- 8:12apart. Therefore, the stereo width is
- 8:15also slightly worse on vinyl. A record
- 8:18player can also have fluctuations—a
- 8:19player that isn't of very good quality
- 8:21—fluctuations, uh, well, small
- 8:23variations in speed, what we call wow
- 8:25and flutter, which I can demonstrate
- 8:26for you quickly here. Wow is this. I'm
- 8:38exaggerating it for you so you can see
- 8:39it, okay? It’s a record that keeps
- 8:41jerking. It can also oscillate in this
- 8:43way, okay? The record can oscillate
- 8:46broadly and produce this noise. Right,
- 8:57I’m exaggerating it a lot so you can
- 8:59see those effects that can happen. I
- 9:01mean, we aren't talking about something
- 9:03made up, or something we'll see if it
- 9:05happens. The thing is that often it’s
- 9:07so subtle you don't hear it, but I
- 9:09insist, comparing the two formats
- 9:11objectively, the CD wins by a landslide
- 9:14. Why? Because it offers less noise,
- 9:16greater dynamic range, less distortion,
- 9:18better stereo separation, greater
- 9:20stability, and no loss depending on how
- 9:22you arrange the songs. Now, here comes
- 9:24the catch, here comes the debate, what
- 9:25many of you were waiting for, right?
- 9:27Some have already left, some at this
- 9:29point have said, "Well, I don't like
- 9:31this guy's conclusions," but I am going
- 9:32to agree with many of you. Why can
- 9:35vinyl sound better than a CD? Or why is
- 9:38it possible that a vinyl sounds better
- 9:39to you than a CD? Are you crazy? Does
- 9:42it mean you're a snob, that you've been
- 9:44carried away by this trend, by this
- 9:45trick that the record labels are
- 9:47playing on us, right? What happened?
- 9:49During the era when the CD was king,
- 9:51the undisputed format, there was
- 9:53something called the loudness wars,
- 9:54which I won't dwell on here because
- 9:56I've talked about it a thousand times
- 9:58on the channel, and you can look up
- 9:59information on the "Loudness War." What
- 10:02was happening? That CDs were
- 10:03progressively getting louder in volume,
- 10:05and higher and higher and higher; but
- 10:07the CD also has physical limitations.
- 10:09And to get that sound to be louder and
- 10:12louder and louder, what has always been
- 10:14done in studios is to use compressors,
- 10:17limiters, and clipping. Clipping is
- 10:19when we chop a signal aggressively like
- 10:21this. Look, a signal with peaks, okay?
- 10:23Well, a clipped signal, there are no
- 10:24more peaks, they're cut off just like
- 10:26that, aggressively. If you look into
- 10:27the loudness wars, or if you already
- 10:29have, you'll see that 50 years ago
- 10:31records were at this volume, in the 80s
- 10:33they were like this, in the 90s like
- 10:35this, and in the 2000s they're like
- 10:37this, and so on, they're completely
- 10:39maxed out, inflated in volume. Okay, so
- 10:41this is a consequence of the loudness
- 10:43wars, which aimed to sound louder than
- 10:44the competition, to sound just a bit
- 10:46louder than the guy next door. What
- 10:48happens? Well, vinyl, as I told you,
- 10:50has its own technical limitations. A
- 10:52very aggressive master with intense
- 10:54highs and powerful lows can be much
- 10:57harder to cut correctly. What occurs?
- 11:00Some vinyl editions, and especially
- 11:02lately, can receive—or not usually,
- 11:04but sometimes—a different master or a
- 11:06different premaster. That is, there is
- 11:09a version mastered for CD and a version
- 11:11mastered for vinyl. At least in my
- 11:13studio, that’s how I do it. When a
- 11:15band knows for sure that they are going
- 11:17to release their work on vinyl, I make
- 11:19a master for CD and I make a master for
- 11:21vinyl. And the vinyl one often doesn't
- 11:23even have limiting or compression;
- 11:25it’s a totally different master, much
- 11:27lighter, much more dynamic. Watch out
- 11:30for the subject of dynamics, because
- 11:31the word "dynamic" has been used lately
- 11:33as something positive, as a positive
- 11:35characteristic just like that, okay?
- 11:37People say something sounds more
- 11:39dynamic, sounds like it has less
- 11:40compression, and often it’s not clear
- 11:42exactly what it means for music or a
- 11:44signal to have compression or more
- 11:46dynamics. Dynamics means there are many
- 11:48differences or a greater fluctuation
- 11:50between low volumes and high volumes. I
- 11:53, for example, have been speaking at a
- 11:54more or less similar volume throughout
- 11:55this video. It wouldn't be normal if I
- 11:58whispered some parts and other parts,
- 12:00uh, I yelled like a goat herder. No,
- 12:02that wouldn't be normal. In fact, I’m
- 12:04going to put a limiter on my voice so
- 12:06you don't perceive a huge difference
- 12:08between these two sections, which is
- 12:10what compressors, limiters, etc., are
- 12:11used for, to reduce those differences,
- 12:13okay? But having dynamics or more
- 12:16dynamics doesn't always equal better
- 12:18sound, though it might be that to your
- 12:19ears, that sensation of greater
- 12:21dynamics or less compression, less
- 12:23limiting, and the absence of clipping
- 12:24in many cases is more pleasant for you.
- 12:27Of course it is. If the vinyl is
- 12:29receiving a version with greater
- 12:30dynamics, with fewer effects that push
- 12:32the music to the extreme, then it might
- 12:34sound better. Of course, but not
- 12:35because the medium is better, but
- 12:37because they are being fed better food.
- 12:39But I insist, with the same master,
- 12:41because for a long time studios were
- 12:42saying, hey, damn, we had everything
- 12:44analog and you made us switch to
- 12:45digital format because digital is
- 12:47better. And now it turns out that now
- 12:49that we have everything digital, now we
- 12:50are going back to analog. Now we are
- 12:52making vinyls again. Well look, let the
- 12:54vinyl factories do whatever they want
- 12:55and that's it. I am going to make the
- 12:57same master for everything and, in fact
- 12:59, to this day many masters are still
- 13:00like that; I mean, many, many
- 13:02technicians and many studios give you a
- 13:04general master for everything and you
- 13:05fend for yourself, or the record label
- 13:07fends for itself, and releases the CD
- 13:09edition however they want, the vinyl
- 13:10edition however they want, okay? I give
- 13:12you a master and you manage. That's not
- 13:14my case, but many studios work like
- 13:15that. And of course, the ritual of
- 13:18taking out our vinyl, placing it on the
- 13:21turntable, dropping the needle, pin,
- 13:23sitting down to listen, having to
- 13:25bother to get up to flip the side, well
- 13:27all that has something ritualistic,
- 13:30doesn't it? Of attention. I have often
- 13:32complained about that like a proper old
- 13:34timer, right? That I liked the era when
- 13:37I would take a CD and unwrap it, look
- 13:38at my booklet, listen to it with
- 13:40attention, right? Now in these times,
- 13:42well, everything is much more immediate
- 13:44, it is true that it is much more
- 13:45convenient, but the sensations change.
- 13:47The big question, why then has vinyl
- 13:49been resurrected? Why, being a worse
- 13:51format, does it have this boom in
- 13:52recent years? Well, because streaming,
- 13:55as I was telling you, has turned music
- 13:57into something invisible, into a
- 13:58thumbnail on your phone, but that
- 14:00thumbnail is not the same as holding
- 14:02this record in your hands with this
- 14:03cover, with this booklet, the lyrics, I
- 14:05don't know, the experience changes.
- 14:09There is also, on the part of young
- 14:11people, I have noticed that there is a
- 14:12fairly large resurgence, or more than a
- 14:14resurgence because I don't think it's
- 14:16like a fad, right? Calling it a
- 14:18resurgence, a revival, makes it seem
- 14:20like it's a trend, but rather there is
- 14:22a rejection of the excess of technology
- 14:24, of the excess of connectivity. There
- 14:27are many kids who reject this
- 14:29hyper-connectivity from social media,
- 14:31all day long, reels, short-form info;
- 14:33many kids are pushing back against that
- 14:36. Actually, it shocked me: not long ago
- 14:39a guy came in, a singer; he was 17 and
- 14:41came with two of his buddies, his
- 14:43girlfriend, a couple of mates, and I
- 14:44thought, "Let's see, this kid, 17 years
- 14:46old? Let's see what kind of mess they
- 14:48make." And then they were super polite,
- 14:49honestly, and super nice. And it really
- 14:51struck me that they brought a digital
- 14:52camera. They told me, "Look, Jose, how
- 14:54cool," they had a digital camera, but a
- 14:55super old one. I mean, like the first
- 14:57digital cameras I saw, I don't know,
- 14:59back in the early 2000s; they had a
- 15:00camera like that, rescued from their
- 15:02parents, and they were taking photos
- 15:04with it because that's what they liked.
- 15:06I mean, the photos came out terrible,
- 15:08just like back then, right? With flash,
- 15:11all like that, but they were
- 15:12deliberately going for that aesthetic.
- 15:15I have, for example, clients, bands,
- 15:17like the band Medalla, for whom we did
- 15:19a live session here in the studio, and
- 15:21this band gives a VHS effect to
- 15:23everything on their new album, right?
- 15:25Everything that accompanies it, all the
- 15:27music videos and everything coming out
- 15:28of this new record, is accompanied by
- 15:30that VHS aesthetic. I do it myself here
- 15:32in the studio, the live footage you see
- 15:34is recorded here in my studio, and
- 15:35it’s deliberately made to look like a
- 15:37guy filming with a crappy camera and a
- 15:39VHS effect. I mean, there’s a real
- 15:41revival. I insist, I don't like calling
- 15:43it a revival because it sounds like a
- 15:45fad, right? Let’s say there’s a
- 15:47rejection of the excess of technology.
- 15:48There are many people who want that,
- 15:50that ritual, right? I compare it, for
- 15:53example, to cinephiles, right? People
- 15:55who love cinema and have certain fetish
- 15:57films, which they own and want to have
- 15:59in physical format; they don't want to
- 16:01depend on Netflix, or HBO, or whatever,
- 16:03so that one day they might say this
- 16:05movie is no longer in the catalog; well
- 16:07, you’re stuck and have no way to
- 16:09watch it. Well, I have my physical film
- 16:11, actually. Well, those of you who like
- 16:13video games know there's been a lot of
- 16:15stir lately about Sony moving away from
- 16:17physical formats, with everything going
- 16:19digital and all the implications that
- 16:21brings. Well, the exact same thing is
- 16:22happening with music. I like having my
- 16:24collection on CD; I like that at any
- 16:26time, without needing a connection or
- 16:29anything, I can just put my CD in the
- 16:31player, sit back, listen to it, smell
- 16:33it, sniff it right up and that's it.
- 16:36Another reason why I think vinyl has
- 16:38resurged is because it has resurged as
- 16:41a luxury object. It has an aura that
- 16:44the CD doesn't have, since we have
- 16:46those famous editions, well, with
- 16:48colored vinyl, alternative covers,
- 16:50numbered editions, signed editions,
- 16:53luxury boxes, and versions exclusive to
- 16:55one store or another. In a tiny format,
- 16:59in a little box like the CD, you have
- 17:01to admit it looks less impressive. I
- 17:03really like the Digipak, honestly I do,
- 17:05but I admit that, damn, when it comes
- 17:06to vinyl, that large cover art, for
- 17:08someone who loves cover art like I do,
- 17:10it's true that I like it more. But
- 17:11anyway, going back to vinyl, here in
- 17:13these editions, what we call FOMO comes
- 17:16into play. FOMO is the acronym for Fear
- 17:18of Missing Out, the fear of being left
- 17:21out or the fear of missing something,
- 17:23right? A lot of people who see, damn, a
- 17:25limited edition of such-and-such album
- 17:27has come out that I love, limited to so
- 17:29many copies and in a gorgeous color,
- 17:30because on top of that, of course, when
- 17:32you display the vinyl, you see those
- 17:33colors too, right? I mean, it's all
- 17:35part of the experience and you can get
- 17:37that feeling of, wow, I'm going to miss
- 17:38out on this. If I don't buy it, I miss
- 17:39out. There's a lot of FOMO there too. I
- 17:41mean, the real fan no longer just buys
- 17:43a piece of music, they are now buying a
- 17:45collector's item of their favorite
- 17:47artist or they can do it as support. I,
- 17:50for example, keep buying a lot of music
- 17:52from bands that, well, Spanish bands
- 17:54mostly, that I see, I like what they do
- 17:56, it catches my attention. Maybe I
- 17:58won’t become a superfan or anything,
- 18:00but I see they have a good offering; I
- 18:02can tell they’ve worked hard, they
- 18:04have an interesting sound, there’s a
- 18:05strong vision behind it, so I buy the
- 18:07record just to support the band, and
- 18:09that’s it. This also explains why
- 18:132025 marked 19 years of consecutive
- 18:16global growth. Consider that in the
- 18:19United States, about 46.8 million vinyl
- 18:21records were sold compared to 29.5
- 18:23million CDs. In fact, in Spain, vinyl
- 18:26accounted for nearly 69%of physical
- 18:28market revenue. Actually, CD sales also
- 18:31grew, interestingly enough. I think
- 18:32there are a lot of people who might
- 18:34feel a bit like I do. I mean, I already
- 18:35had a huge CD collection and I thought,
- 18:37"What am I supposed to do now? Switch
- 18:39to vinyl, buy all these records I
- 18:40already have on vinyl, set up an
- 18:41expensive record player, and so on?
- 18:43I’m sticking with CDs, which is what
- 18:45I’ve always bought. Besides, it’s a
- 18:47better format, it’s cheaper, it works
- 18:49for me, and I think many people have
- 18:50gotten a bit tired of those editions
- 18:52and the higher prices, so they’ve
- 18:54switched back to CDs, simple as that.
- 18:55And I don’t think it’s a matter of
- 18:57nostalgia for vinyl, because, as I
- 18:59insist, the CD is making a comeback too
- 19:00. I think it’s more of a reaction to
- 19:03the idea that our entire culture
- 19:05depends on a subscription, right?
- 19:07Movies, a subscription; music, a
- 19:08subscription; and the day you stop
- 19:10paying, you lose access or are forced
- 19:12to deal with ads. Well, my record
- 19:14doesn't have ads; I play it whenever I
- 19:15want, seventy times in a row if I feel
- 19:17like it, and there are no ads. And of
- 19:19course, streaming is the absolute king
- 19:21of all this; it has the highest
- 19:22consumption. In fact, record labels
- 19:25have realized that the vinyl and CD
- 19:27consumer isn't necessarily the same as
- 19:29the streaming consumer. I mean, not
- 19:31that they aren't the same people, but
- 19:32that they don't compete, right? A
- 19:33person isn’t going to stop buying a
- 19:34vinyl record just because they can
- 19:35listen to it online, because you can
- 19:37download the album anyway. If you want
- 19:38it for free, you don't even have to
- 19:39rely on that; you just go to one of
- 19:41those pirate sites, download it, and
- 19:42that’s it. But that’s not what
- 19:43it’s about. I mean, those of us who
- 19:44buy music don't buy it because we
- 19:46necessarily want to listen to the
- 19:47record. In fact, people come to the
- 19:48studio and say," Damn, you've got a ton
- 19:49of records still shrink-wrapped. "Why?
- 19:51Well, for the simple reason that I
- 19:52bought it. I have access to the album
- 19:55via streaming, and the occasion hasn't
- 19:57come up for the ritual of unwrapping it
- 19:59, putting it on, sitting down,
- 20:01listening to it, sniffing it, as I call
- 20:04it, in peace. So, as a consequence, I
- 20:06think the resurgence of vinyl has had
- 20:08many positive aspects. It has had this
- 20:11revival, let's say, of buying—now I'm
- 20:13using the word revival—of buying
- 20:15physical music, which is phenomenal. I
- 20:17mean, I totally support it. It has
- 20:19brought back the large cover art, it
- 20:20has brought back carefully crafted
- 20:22editions. It really bugs me that,
- 20:24lately, CDs have such poorly cared-for
- 20:26editions; I mean, the typical format as
- 20:28if it were vinyl, but in tiny cardboard
- 20:30. Like, man, put some work into it for
- 20:32those of us who buy CDs too, since
- 20:33we're going to buy it, man, just take
- 20:34care of it a little. I mean, I don't
- 20:35mind paying a little more if the
- 20:37edition is freaking awesome. But well,
- 20:38it has also allowed many artists to
- 20:40monetize their old catalogs again, okay
- 20:42? There are many reissues of back
- 20:44catalogs on vinyl. It also has its
- 20:46negative consequences, of course:
- 20:48exorbitant prices, speculation, many
- 20:49delays at the factories. At the
- 20:51beginning, this revival caught the
- 20:52factories completely off guard. In fact
- 20:54, there are companies—well, yes,
- 20:56companies, actually bands like
- 20:57Metallica—that have bought a part or
- 20:59bought an entire plant themselves so
- 21:01they wouldn't have delays, so they
- 21:03could press the vinyl they wanted
- 21:05without having to fight against those
- 21:09bottlenecks. There are many small
- 21:11labels competing against big labels to
- 21:12get their runs made. There are fans who
- 21:14are buying the same record four times
- 21:16so they don't miss out on the different
- 21:17colors, the different editions. And
- 21:19well, not to mention the increased
- 21:21consumption of PVC, cardboard, ink,
- 21:22packaging, shipping—mind you,
- 21:24streaming, that whole" cloud "thing, I
- 21:26laugh at the cloud, you know? People
- 21:28are like," No, the cloud just seems to
- 21:29be floating up there, right? "And that
- 21:30doesn't consume anything? That consumes
- 21:32too, that also costs to maintain. And
- 21:33in fact, they're already talking about
- 21:35serious water problems coming because
- 21:36of the whole artificial intelligence
- 21:38issue. But well, that's another debate.
- 21:40I mean, buying maybe 10 versions of the
- 21:42same album just so you don't miss out
- 21:44isn't exactly an example of responsible
- 21:45consumption. I'm not criticizing anyone
- 21:47who does it, though. We’re just
- 21:49talking, in general, about the pros and
- 21:52cons of this format. So, let's get to
- 21:54the final conclusions. For my part, if
- 21:56we talk about facts, data, objectives,
- 21:59and technical issues, the CD wins by a
- 22:01landslide. Less noise, less distortion
- 22:04—sorry, distortion—more dynamic
- 22:05range, fewer physical limitations. So
- 22:07you hear vinyl better than CD? You're
- 22:09probably listening to a different
- 22:10master; it’s not the same master. But
- 22:11the true milestone for vinyl isn't that
- 22:13it's technically better. I mean, there
- 22:16hasn't been a revival—uh, a
- 22:17resurgence; I'm stuck on the word
- 22:19revival today—there hasn't been a
- 22:21resurgence of vinyl for technical
- 22:22reasons; it's happened because it gives
- 22:24you something streaming can't: a giant
- 22:26object you can display on your shelf,
- 22:27right? A ritual, cover art, a
- 22:30collection, an extension of your
- 22:32personality for many people, right? It
- 22:35has managed to sell us the feeling that
- 22:37an album still matters, and that, to me
- 22:38, is incredibly powerful. But now I ask
- 22:40you, which format do you prefer? Do you
- 22:42prefer vinyl, do you prefer CD? Do you
- 22:43prefer a mix of both? Or better yet, if
- 22:45you had to stick with just one format
- 22:47for the rest of your life, which would
- 22:48you choose? Vinyl or CD? Let me know in
- 22:50the comments.
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of VINILO vs CD: la verdad que nadie quiere oír by Metal Chronicles by JFT, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 4,744 words across 700 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.