YouTube2Text

Viernes 02 de Octubre | Iniciamos Diálogo 21 — Transcript

by Diálogo 21 · 11,884 words · 1,847 segments · language en · Watch on YouTube

Full transcript

  1. 0:37program are the sole responsibility of
  2. 0:39those who broadcast them. Learn more
  3. 0:46about politics, the economy, and the
  4. 0:52country's social environment with
  5. 0:54analysis, debates, and consensus on the
  6. 0:57public opinion leader program, Diálogo
  7. 1:00.
  8. 1:04>> How are you? Good morning, viewers.
  9. 1:06Welcome to the public opinion leader,
  10. 1:09the morning dialogue. Thank you for
  11. 1:12being with us today on this Friday, and
  12. 1:14we love data here, it says so: we are
  13. 1:17public opinion leaders, and Friday is
  14. 1:19the peak audience time in this morning
  15. 1:21slot. So, we welcome our panelists, who
  16. 1:25are the ones doing the weekly political
  17. 1:27analysis on this Friday, October 2nd.
  18. 1:30Carlos Hueso, analyst, good morning.
  19. 1:32Thanks for being with us. Carlos.
  20. 1:33>> Luis, thanks for the invitation.
  21. 1:36Greetings to the Salvadoran people, and
  22. 1:38of course, a greeting also to the
  23. 1:40colleagues here on the panel.
  24. 1:43>> Well, Besi Ríos, analyst, good morning
  25. 1:45. Good morning, a pleasure to join my
  26. 1:48colleagues. A pleasure to have you with
  27. 1:50us, Luisito. Greetings to Ernesto. And
  28. 1:53well, a greeting to everyone watching
  29. 1:55us, even if they throw stones at the
  30. 1:57program, they are still tuned in and
  31. 1:59following.
  32. 2:01>> They are watching.
  33. 2:02>> Manuel Someta, how are you? Good
  34. 2:03morning.
  35. 2:04>> How are you, Luis? Greetings to the
  36. 2:05entire population. I want to take a
  37. 2:06moment to send a greeting to Daniela,
  38. 2:08my assistant, who is celebrating her
  39. 2:10birthday today, 23 years old. Thank you
  40. 2:11so much for all your support, and have
  41. 2:12a great time.
  42. 2:13>> Well, and also take advantage of this
  43. 2:15space to send greetings to my family,
  44. 2:18and also a message of recovery, a
  45. 2:20speedy recovery, for one of our regular
  46. 2:22panelists on the Grupo Megaavisión
  47. 2:25programs, Melida Villatoro, who is
  48. 2:27currently dealing with a health issue,
  49. 2:29so we wish her a speedy recovery. We
  50. 2:31are going to talk about several topics.
  51. 2:34If you want, let's start with what
  52. 2:36already happened at the Supreme
  53. 2:37Electoral Tribunal, which has called
  54. 2:40for elections. Our country begins its
  55. 2:44electoral campaign heading toward this
  56. 2:46February 28, 2027, with the official
  57. 2:48call from the Supreme Electoral
  58. 2:49Tribunal and the start of the calendar
  59. 2:52as defined by the presidency, to elect
  60. 2:54the president, vice president, the
  61. 2:56Legislative Assembly, and also
  62. 2:57municipal governments. It will be a day
  63. 3:01that puts 582 58 seats up for popular
  64. 3:07election and will call upon more than
  65. 3:106.5 million citizens registered in the
  66. 3:12electoral roll. It is a challenge to
  67. 3:16guarantee these processes with clear
  68. 3:18rules, electoral competition, citizen
  69. 3:20participation, and trust, above all, in
  70. 3:21the authority that administers these
  71. 3:23elections. Uh, we are going to dive
  72. 3:26right into this topic. Election call.
  73. 3:30It was done via National Broadcast, it
  74. 3:32is now official as of yesterday that
  75. 3:33candidates can register. Carlos, how
  76. 3:36does El Salvador find this electoral
  77. 3:39process?
  78. 3:39>> Luis, it is interesting. Well, as you
  79. 3:43said, the goal is the mobilization of
  80. 3:466.5 million Salvadorans registered in
  81. 3:50the electoral roll. It is also
  82. 3:53important to tell the Salvadoran
  83. 3:55population about the unification of
  84. 3:58these elections, the synchronization of
  85. 4:01terms
  86. 4:03>> where, of course, the winner will serve
  87. 4:06from 2027 to 2032. On the other hand,
  88. 4:11for deputies, municipal councils, and
  89. 4:14mayors, they will obviously be there
  90. 4:16for 3 years, they will serve for 3
  91. 4:19years. I am powerfully struck by what
  92. 4:23is happening abroad. Uh
  93. 4:26>> nearly 1 million Salvadorans,
  94. 4:28>> nearly a million Salvadorans, and keep
  95. 4:30an eye on this. I understand that there
  96. 4:34are 92 in-person centers abroad in 29
  97. 4:38different countries so that our
  98. 4:41brothers can exercise their right to
  99. 4:44vote. It is also important to tell them
  100. 4:49that in-person voting abroad begins a
  101. 4:51month earlier, that is, starting
  102. 4:54January 30th. So, I invite the
  103. 4:57Salvadoran population, both inside and
  104. 4:59outside the country, to come out and
  105. 5:01cast their vote.
  106. 5:03>> In the United States alone, there are
  107. 5:0553 centers that will be enabled. See,
  108. 5:08political parties have been able to
  109. 5:10register their candidates since
  110. 5:11yesterday. Today we are no longer
  111. 5:13talking about assumptions. In reality,
  112. 5:15you started by saying the campaign
  113. 5:17begins, but the campaign was already
  114. 5:19underway since last year, since we knew
  115. 5:21the elections were going to be on
  116. 5:23February 28, 2027, 2025,
  117. 5:25>> the campaign started from different
  118. 5:32actors, mainly those currently in power
  119. 5:35, very happily. What happened yesterday
  120. 5:40with the starting signal is actually
  121. 5:41the period to be able to register
  122. 5:45>> the submission of documentation for the
  123. 5:47lists, 582 unified positions in an
  124. 5:50electoral process for 6.5 million
  125. 5:52Salvadorans, a big challenge with a
  126. 5:55Supreme Electoral Tribunal that has
  127. 5:57been questioned by different sectors
  128. 5:59regarding its independence from the
  129. 6:02Executive. A reality we cannot deny
  130. 6:06that has generated questions, and from
  131. 6:08our opportunity here, at least in my
  132. 6:11case, participation has been questioned
  133. 6:13in terms of legitimization from the
  134. 6:16opposition's side. Participating in the
  135. 6:19electoral process, fielding candidates,
  136. 6:22mainly in the presidential one, implies
  137. 6:24submission to the referee, to the rules
  138. 6:27, to the process, and definitely to the
  139. 6:29result whatever it may be. Uh, this
  140. 6:33creates an interesting bit of noise,
  141. 6:35especially because yesterday you had a
  142. 6:37guest who called for non-participation,
  143. 6:39and I do want to tell you, look, don't
  144. 6:41stop going to an electoral process.
  145. 6:44there is no such thing as moral defeats
  146. 6:46. You have to participate in the
  147. 6:48electoral process, and if you are
  148. 6:50discontent, show it by annulling your
  149. 6:52vote, but don't stop attending, because
  150. 6:55absenteeism only results in whoever is
  151. 6:57in power finishing their consolidation.
  152. 7:00>> In the end, uh, you let others choose
  153. 7:02for you, because it's not like in El
  154. 7:04Salvador
  155. 7:05>> Correct. On the other hand, the
  156. 7:07mechanism to be able to express that
  157. 7:08you don't agree is the issue of voting,
  158. 7:10of annulling your vote, well, but
  159. 7:12particip
  160. 7:14>> uh, Ms. Rios was already putting these
  161. 7:16reforms on the table in 2000 25 that
  162. 7:22were done to be able to modify, because
  163. 7:25the people in 2024 voted for a 5-year
  164. 7:28term, this is modified, and now we go
  165. 7:31to a new board. Manuel, how do we see
  166. 7:35this this configuration? Unifying, it
  167. 7:38has been said that it is for savings to
  168. 7:41unify the elections, but the coattail
  169. 7:45effect could be sought there.
  170. 7:48>> In fact, it is the strategy that is
  171. 7:50intended to be followed. Let's remember
  172. 7:53that cutting the presidential term is
  173. 7:56completely illegal and is
  174. 7:57unconstitutional. People voted to have
  175. 8:01a president
  176. 8:02>> for 5 years. and it didn't exist, and
  177. 8:06to this day we haven't seen any legal
  178. 8:08basis that allows that reduction of the
  179. 8:11time. Everything else I have said, I
  180. 8:13have not agreed with, but it has been
  181. 8:15about having the votes.
  182. 8:17>> Ah, but but everything else has been
  183. 8:20reasonably coated in legality. I have
  184. 8:23said it, I don't agree, but they did it
  185. 8:24with the rules that were in place,
  186. 8:26>> except for the reduction of that term.
  187. 8:29In my opinion, that synchronization
  188. 8:31completely lacks legality and has been
  189. 8:33endorsed by the tribunal. Uh, they
  190. 8:35stayed quiet in the Assembly, the
  191. 8:37Constitutional Chamber hasn't said
  192. 8:39anything. Well, no matter, we are going
  193. 8:42to go to the elections like this, and
  194. 8:44the objective that was wanted is
  195. 8:47achieved: for it to be the president's
  196. 8:49image that coats all the other
  197. 8:51officials, which we have seen, and. And
  198. 8:54my friend who is watching me here, you
  199. 8:56are realizing that they are not
  200. 8:58campaigning, or they are doing the same
  201. 9:00campaign they criticized so much. That
  202. 9:02they go and give you calendars, that
  203. 9:04they go and give you pitchers, is not
  204. 9:06going to change anything for you. And
  205. 9:08we are falling into the same thing they
  206. 9:10always criticized. They are falling
  207. 9:12into the same old rhetoric that they
  208. 9:14themselves invented because they
  209. 9:16believe they will win all at once due
  210. 9:18to the president's image, and that is
  211. 9:21why it is very important, Luis, to go
  212. 9:23out and vote. Go, choose, go, and if
  213. 9:25the options that are there don't
  214. 9:28convince you, spoil your ballot, but go
  215. 9:30and vote. Let's see, to all three,
  216. 9:34unifying the process is about avoiding
  217. 9:36voter fatigue; it was said to avoid an
  218. 9:38expense, there are 40 million dollars
  219. 9:41already allocated for this election,
  220. 9:43but this coattail effect. Shouldn't
  221. 9:47local governments, for example,
  222. 9:48campaign when it's their turn, and
  223. 9:50shouldn't deputies also present their
  224. 9:52proposals, or should they just wait
  225. 9:53under the president's shadow?
  226. 9:56>> Look, the campaign is going to be "vote
  227. 9:58for Nayib." Who? For the assembly, for
  228. 10:00Nayib; for mayor, for Nayib. That is
  229. 10:03going to be the strategy that is being
  230. 10:05proposed. Simple, right?
  231. 10:06>> The only relevant figure. Let's see, I
  232. 10:09think something we are clear on, and it
  233. 10:11has been repeated constantly, is that
  234. 10:14flags, slogans, signs, and that whole
  235. 10:16reliquary of idealism is no longer
  236. 10:19something that charms the voter. What
  237. 10:22the voter wants is solutions, and they
  238. 10:24haven't just become pragmatic; they got
  239. 10:26tired. They got tired of the flags,
  240. 10:29they got tired of the signs and the
  241. 10:31slogans. So, what remains is to follow
  242. 10:34leaderships. The undisputed leader here
  243. 10:37, whether you like it or not, whether
  244. 10:39you agree or not? Is the figure of the
  245. 10:42president who
  246. 10:43>> covers and leverages the rest of his
  247. 10:46structure with his shadow, and surely I
  248. 10:48go as far as to say they will call for
  249. 10:50a vote by flag.
  250. 10:52>> Let's see, but they are going to hide
  251. 10:53in the shadow of that figure.
  252. 10:54>> Look, it's inevitable. Inevitable, the
  253. 10:58image and what the president represents
  254. 11:02for Salvadorans. Do you know what is
  255. 11:05transcendental about this, and what is,
  256. 11:08of course, the opposition's golden
  257. 11:10dream? It's that they haven't been able
  258. 11:13to, and will hardly be able to, since
  259. 11:15that February 27th
  260. 11:18>> to topple that governability that
  261. 11:21exists currently and, above all, mark
  262. 11:23my words, that articulated work between
  263. 11:25an executive and a legislative branch.
  264. 11:29Now there is an essential issue in this
  265. 11:32election, if it is that who is going to
  266. 11:37definitely, who is going to decide, who
  267. 11:41is going to validate this coming
  268. 11:45February are the Salvadorans. And the
  269. 11:49opposition has it easy. Well, go and
  270. 11:52ask the people to give you back the
  271. 11:55opportunity they took from you, and
  272. 11:57that's it. And no, that is democracy.
  273. 12:01It's just, look, in the end, there is
  274. 12:04something so precarious about the
  275. 12:06opposition that they have been left
  276. 12:09waiting for a defeat of the people to
  277. 12:14celebrate. And look what is the most
  278. 12:17terrible thing about this, that in the
  279. 12:19end, they start questioning a legality
  280. 12:22that the sovereign will grant at the
  281. 12:24polls, and it is important to tell the
  282. 12:27population that.
  283. 12:28>> Just a clarification, democracy is not
  284. 12:30the simple exercise of going to vote.
  285. 12:32Democracy has more indicators.
  286. 12:35>> Sure, no one is saying that it is, it
  287. 12:37is, uh, what do you call it, in a
  288. 12:39partial way. But, without a doubt,
  289. 12:42speaking of the election, because that
  290. 12:44is what we are talking about, the
  291. 12:46fundamental actor is the sovereign, and
  292. 12:49if the opposition wants to have a
  293. 12:51chance, well, they should win over the
  294. 12:53hearts of Salvadorans. So, you agree
  295. 12:55that in an electoral autocracy there
  296. 12:57are elections.
  297. 12:58>> Sure,
  298. 12:59>> it is resolved.
  299. 13:00>> You can romanticize the terms, but you
  300. 13:03know that in the end, that is what
  301. 13:05prevails.
  302. 13:07>> The sovereign's decision.
  303. 13:10>> In an electoral autocracy, there are
  304. 13:11also elections.
  305. 13:13>> Uh-huh. The way I see it. And the
  306. 13:14sovereign also votes. That's true. The
  307. 13:16problem is the options they have to
  308. 13:18vote for.
  309. 13:19>> Let's see, but regarding the options,
  310. 13:20and now that you bring it up. No, on
  311. 13:21the issue of options, that is where you
  312. 13:23and I have a debate.
  313. 13:24>> Let's see, there are 11 officially
  314. 13:26registered political parties. Of the
  315. 13:28four 10
  316. 13:29>> 10 parties have said they are going to
  317. 13:30participate.
  318. 13:31>> That is the point.
  319. 13:32>> Yes, but the issue of leadership in
  320. 13:33those parties
  321. 13:34>> there are options.
  322. 13:36>> Let's see, the opposition is only three
  323. 13:39parties, because don't try to include
  324. 13:41us in those 11 parties. They are all of
  325. 13:4510 are opposition. But there are only
  326. 13:50three opposition parties. They are
  327. 13:52called FMLN, Arena, and Vamos; Vamos is
  328. 13:55not running for president, Arena and
  329. 13:57the FMLN made the decision to validate
  330. 13:59the presidential process, and there are
  331. 14:01no options for the population because
  332. 14:03it is not something attributable to
  333. 14:05this administration. That is what we
  334. 14:08have a debate about, the lack of
  335. 14:10options for the population that is not
  336. 14:13happy with this administration depends
  337. 14:15solely on the opposition, which has not
  338. 14:17known how to build leadership or
  339. 14:19alliances that enchant the population
  340. 14:21enough to go exercise their right and
  341. 14:24give them their vote. hardly a lack of
  342. 14:26options. There are options, but perhaps
  343. 14:28they don't channel them. It will even
  344. 14:31be more interesting than the discussion
  345. 14:33with the opposition, how Nuevas Ideas
  346. 14:36is going to manage its allies, because
  347. 14:38we are already seeing the first signs;
  348. 14:41you already saw what happened with Will
  349. 14:44Salgado, who is he going to unseat from
  350. 14:46Nuevas Ideas? And even though I'm not
  351. 14:49from San Miguel, I believe he has a
  352. 14:51real chance of unseating someone from
  353. 14:52Nuevas Ideas. What is going to happen
  354. 14:53with the GANA candidacies? What is
  355. 14:55going to happen with the PCN
  356. 14:56candidacies? It's fine for now because
  357. 14:59they are small and they are allies, and
  358. 15:02they can't exert much pressure, but if
  359. 15:04the allied parties that aren't [part of
  360. 15:07the ruling party] manage to get a
  361. 15:09decent number of deputies, that's when
  362. 15:12the balance will start to shift. Don't
  363. 15:15be surprised to see the PCN acting as a
  364. 15:17swing party again, providing exactly
  365. 15:20the weight they need for those
  366. 15:22majorities. Is it opposition, or just
  367. 15:24dispersion? Talking about these 10
  368. 15:26political parties, there are only three
  369. 15:28opposition parties. The fact is there
  370. 15:29are only three opposition parties.
  371. 15:32>> Is there anyone who can—the
  372. 15:34satellites that revolve around the
  373. 15:36president, you even have officials
  374. 15:38saying, if the opposition doesn't want
  375. 15:41to field presidential candidates, we
  376. 15:43will do it, I mean, a quite evident
  377. 15:46servility. I think we should clearly
  378. 15:50state the questioning; at least in my
  379. 15:52opinion, both ARENA and the FMLN
  380. 15:54shouldn't have participated in the
  381. 15:56presidential race, simply because they
  382. 15:58have been saying for a long time that
  383. 16:00they don't trust the referee or the
  384. 16:02process, that they question its
  385. 16:04independence, but from the moment you
  386. 16:06participate, you are validating
  387. 16:07everything. Even you had the FMLN
  388. 16:11ticket on the podcast, and the one
  389. 16:14running for vice president said we are
  390. 16:16going to accept the results, and that
  391. 16:18is recorded so that later, when the
  392. 16:20data is in, they don't go around saying
  393. 16:23they don't accept the outcome. And I
  394. 16:26want to add someone else. Yes.
  395. 16:29>> The resolution issued by the Supreme
  396. 16:31Electoral Tribunal, which gives six
  397. 16:33more months of life to Cia Ortiz's—
  398. 16:35sorry, Cia Rivas's—secretariat in the
  399. 16:37Vamos party regarding the power
  400. 16:39struggle with Claudia Ortiz, that
  401. 16:41resolution they accept and consider
  402. 16:43valid, and then you ask them another
  403. 16:45question about how they view its
  404. 16:47independence, and they start
  405. 16:49questioning the referee. Look, Ms. Cia,
  406. 16:53one has to be consistent. If you agree
  407. 16:55with the resolution that allows you to
  408. 16:57remain as secretary for 6 more months,
  409. 16:59you are submitting to the arbiter and
  410. 17:01you are validating it for the electoral
  411. 17:03process.
  412. 17:04>> Let's see, uh, we'll go into detail on
  413. 17:06that point, but I was saying, is it
  414. 17:08opposition or dispersion what we have
  415. 17:10in our country with the amount there is
  416. 17:12? And Mr. Sometra mentioned, Carlos,
  417. 17:16can anyone dispute the Legislative
  418. 17:17Assembly? Look, even with Manuel Someta
  419. 17:23we discussed and analyzed this topic,
  420. 17:26and he said, more or less, the
  421. 17:28opposition is making a mistake because
  422. 17:31they should obviously aim at taking
  423. 17:34seats in the legislature and not in the
  424. 17:37presidency. But when you see the
  425. 17:41measurements, because I'm not going to
  426. 17:43speak to you as Carlos Hueso, but
  427. 17:45rather I want to rely on the
  428. 17:47measurements we are seeing, uh, what
  429. 17:49does it tell you? That the board, uh,
  430. 17:52the legislative board would practically
  431. 17:55remain as it is. What am I getting at
  432. 17:57with this? Can we talk about opposition
  433. 18:00parties? Yes, yes, of course, there are
  434. 18:02three. Well yes, the important thing is
  435. 18:06how relevant they are. For example, how
  436. 18:10can you say that the FMLN is an
  437. 18:12opposition party when it is the only
  438. 18:14left-wing party in Latin America that
  439. 18:16doesn't have a single representative in
  440. 18:19the legislature, that doesn't have a
  441. 18:21single mayor nationwide? What kind of
  442. 18:25opposition are you talking about? Of
  443. 18:26course, of what they once were. Well,
  444. 18:30we give life to the FMLN when we talk
  445. 18:32about them for these 2 minutes, but
  446. 18:34that is the precariousness of the
  447. 18:36opposition I am referring to. And do
  448. 18:39you know why, Luis? And it's that
  449. 18:42people tend to twist things, that I say
  450. 18:45it because I loathe the opposition,
  451. 18:47right? An opposition is always going to
  452. 18:51be healthy in any society. Do you know
  453. 18:55what is interesting about this? That
  454. 18:57this current opposition has to
  455. 18:59disappear for the good of Salvadorans.
  456. 19:04>> There is opposition that should
  457. 19:06disappear. There are parties that are
  458. 19:09exhausted, I would believe, and flags
  459. 19:11that are exhausted with slogans already
  460. 19:16weathered, uh, typical of the last
  461. 19:18century, uh, that one must mature and
  462. 19:21understand that this is no longer
  463. 19:23something that connects with the new
  464. 19:25generations. The fact of understanding
  465. 19:29that and transforming yourself
  466. 19:30generates maturity and confidence. But
  467. 19:33if you want to keep rooting yourself in
  468. 19:37the Cold War and its discourses, we are
  469. 19:40in trouble. You won't grow and you
  470. 19:42won't advance. In fact, you will
  471. 19:44implode, you will get smaller.
  472. 19:46>> Yes, they should disappear.
  473. 19:48>> They should disappear. The truth is
  474. 19:49that it already happened,
  475. 19:50>> not just becoming critical, but there
  476. 19:52was
  477. 19:53>> It no longer works for them to even
  478. 19:55clear out and fill themselves back up
  479. 19:57with new people, right? Instead, what
  480. 20:01they have to do now is go extinct; it
  481. 20:03has to be a new option because it's
  482. 20:06already too worn out, let's say, even
  483. 20:08the structure of the parties is too
  484. 20:10worn out to be able to survive. Now, uh
  485. 20:14, shrewdly, the ruling party's strategy
  486. 20:16is not to let them die
  487. 20:19>> because the easiest thing is to beat up
  488. 20:21the drunkard, so I keep him drunk, but
  489. 20:23don't let him die on me so I can keep
  490. 20:26beating him, right. So, and playing
  491. 20:29every election like that, every time it
  492. 20:31will be the same result.
  493. 20:34>> That calls participation into question
  494. 20:35because it's participating in that game
  495. 20:37>> because they are precisely validating
  496. 20:39the game and the and the administration
  497. 20:41. And now that you mention the the
  498. 20:44critics, well, of course, who would
  499. 20:47want to identify with such a clumsy
  500. 20:49opposition and, let's say, so
  501. 20:52ill-prepared for this electoral contest
  502. 20:55saying this, you can't join? And
  503. 20:59besides, my explanation about being
  504. 21:01critical is that to be an opponent you
  505. 21:03must have an opposing position, and by
  506. 21:05not having one, you can be critical.
  507. 21:08>> Greetings, Carlitos.
  508. 21:09>> Greetings, Carlitos. critical or
  509. 21:11hypocritical.
  510. 21:12>> Well look, I I consider that
  511. 21:15>> criticizing is not the same as opposing
  512. 21:18. Because here I think there is a
  513. 21:21reality. I criticize the state of
  514. 21:23exception because I consider that its
  515. 21:25use has been extended too much, I
  516. 21:27consider that there are too many human
  517. 21:29rights violations, and I consider that
  518. 21:31the entire legal framework is already
  519. 21:33in place to be able to withdraw it.
  520. 21:36That is criticizing it, but I cannot
  521. 21:38say that from the first day they
  522. 21:39implemented it I opposed it. Why?
  523. 21:41Because it's not true. Because the only
  524. 21:44way to enter those territories, and you
  525. 21:46know it, was by suspending rights. Now,
  526. 21:49my criticism is that they have already
  527. 21:51over-medicated,
  528. 21:52>> but not opposing the results.
  529. 21:54>> But you are not opposing the issue of
  530. 21:55the regime if it is the only way they
  531. 21:57have controlled it.
  532. 21:58>> The same goes for this juncture that
  533. 22:00has this stance. Eh, could it be that
  534. 22:04this has also led these critical or
  535. 22:06opposition sectors to this conflict of
  536. 22:08not defining things, because they want
  537. 22:10the world to be black and white, and if
  538. 22:12there is anything about the left, it's
  539. 22:15that it is varied? You have Lula's left
  540. 22:18, you have Petro's left, and you have
  541. 22:20Pepe Mujica's left, and none of them
  542. 22:23are the same. This, uh, in Carlos,
  543. 22:26perhaps has not allowed for an
  544. 22:29opposition to unify on a single issue
  545. 22:32so they can come out strengthened.
  546. 22:36>> Look, there is something very
  547. 22:38fundamental about the opposition. You
  548. 22:41could cite Thomas More here, utopia,
  549. 22:44and Caliano even cited it, which helps
  550. 22:46you keep moving forward. Another
  551. 22:49leftist.
  552. 22:50>> Not even that helps this country's
  553. 22:52opposition currently. Do you know why?
  554. 22:55Because there are simply personal
  555. 22:58interests above an interest that
  556. 23:01connects with the Salvadoran population
  557. 23:04. And note something, Luis, as long as
  558. 23:09this opposition doesn't disappear—and
  559. 23:12the Salvadoran really deserves to have
  560. 23:16an opposition that is proactive, that
  561. 23:19is dynamic—but when we see this
  562. 23:22opposition, regardless of whether some
  563. 23:25are one way or others are sugar-free,
  564. 23:28they are all Coca-Cola and they are all
  565. 23:32harmful. in the opposition in the
  566. 23:35country,
  567. 23:36>> right? Look, the truth is that this was
  568. 23:39convenient for the official narrative,
  569. 23:42because you called anyone who
  570. 23:44criticized you an opponent. So they put
  571. 23:48you on the playing field where the
  572. 23:49trolls would already attack you, those
  573. 23:51who indeed have the right to an opinion
  574. 23:53and the right to connect to the
  575. 23:54internet, like the brother of our dear
  576. 23:56friend Carlito.
  577. 23:59>> that, well, you have to have for
  578. 24:00breakfast because of the things he does
  579. 24:02, because he has the right to do them
  580. 24:03and can connect to the internet, right.
  581. 24:06So, it happens because of that, that
  582. 24:08everyone who criticizes is turned
  583. 24:10against and called an opponent. That
  584. 24:12was useful because it also generated a
  585. 24:14discourse of "them versus us." Now,
  586. 24:17when you come with a category of critic
  587. 24:20, because I can accept some things and
  588. 24:22criticize others and because I am not
  589. 24:24in a position of fighting them for
  590. 24:26power, then their narrative falls apart
  591. 24:29where they could be criticizing you and
  592. 24:31saying a bunch of things. That is why
  593. 24:35that has been the attack this character
  594. 24:38has had, of wanting to pigeonhole and
  595. 24:41label you. And perhaps the call,
  596. 24:45concluding with the topic of opposition
  597. 24:47parties, since we are citing people,
  598. 24:49you are not going to have a different
  599. 24:51result by doing the same things. It has
  600. 24:54been clear for 7 years and in three
  601. 24:56campaigns—in two and we are already
  602. 24:58going for the third electoral campaign
  603. 25:00—that they keep repeating the same
  604. 25:02slogans, that they keep repeating the
  605. 25:05same lies, and that once again, they
  606. 25:07will not get results. No, look, briefly
  607. 25:10by allusion, I have not cited people; I
  608. 25:13have referred to an opposition, Thomas
  609. 25:15More.
  610. 25:17>> Ah, no, but that, I mean, I am citing
  611. 25:19an author who obviously has nothing to
  612. 25:22do with political actors or
  613. 25:24communication actors within the country
  614. 25:26. If I have an issue with a media
  615. 25:31figure in this country, I address it
  616. 25:33personally, but I did want to make that
  617. 25:36clear. We are going to take a break and
  618. 25:40we will talk about political actors
  619. 25:42when we return, those you’ve said
  620. 25:44have been the opposition, who have
  621. 25:46mismanaged a crisis and who go back
  622. 25:49>> to internal issues, communication
  623. 25:51issues, and in every way
  624. 25:52>> and they keep doing the same thing.
  625. 25:54>> Yes. Well, let’s go to the break. But
  626. 25:57look, I want to recommend that if you
  627. 25:59have company at home, the solution is
  628. 26:01Laki soup packets. It’s 115g of
  629. 26:04flavor. For example, there’s spicy
  630. 26:07shrimp, if you prefer those, Lucky soup
  631. 26:09packets. 115g feeds more members of the
  632. 26:13family. Look for them in stores and
  633. 26:15supermarkets across the country.
  634. 26:17Let’s go to the break. Alright, thank
  635. 28:12you for staying with us. We are going
  636. 28:15to talk about this crisis within the
  637. 28:17Vamos party, which is entering a
  638. 28:18complex phase following the emergence
  639. 28:20of these conflicting party structures,
  640. 28:22with decisions being questioned by
  641. 28:24different sectors, even from within the
  642. 28:25organization itself. The Supreme
  643. 28:29Electoral Tribunal has already extended
  644. 28:32the functions of the National Executive
  645. 28:34Council, headed by Cesia Rivas, for 6
  646. 28:36months, while another sector linked to
  647. 28:38Claudia Ortiz has held a National
  648. 28:40Assembly and appointed its own
  649. 28:42authorities. The conflict puts this at
  650. 28:46the center of the discussion regarding
  651. 28:49the validity of internal decisions,
  652. 28:51compliance with the statutes, and a
  653. 28:53political party's ability to arrive at
  654. 28:55the elections organized and
  655. 28:56strengthened. And I will start, Carlos
  656. 29:00Hueso, does the crisis in the Vamos
  657. 29:03political party show that the
  658. 29:05opposition is not ready to govern,
  659. 29:07based on what we are seeing internally?
  660. 29:11Look, it’s interesting, Luis, because
  661. 29:14first of all, I must say it publicly,
  662. 29:17Deputy Claudia Ortiz’s role as a
  663. 29:20victim has run out, and it must be said
  664. 29:23frankly. For what reason? Look, what
  665. 29:27are we seeing inside Vamos? First of
  666. 29:33all, a Claudia Ortiz who is practically
  667. 29:37running out of the options she had
  668. 29:40internally engineered that could have
  669. 29:44happened. For what reason? Look, there
  670. 29:48is a Claudia Ortiz before going to Oslo
  671. 29:51and one upon her return from I must say
  672. 29:57it, I suspect there are progressive
  673. 30:02NGOs that have undoubtedly provided
  674. 30:05certain aid, I don’t know if to
  675. 30:08Claudia Ortiz or the Vamos party, but
  676. 30:11there is a dilemma there. I stated here
  677. 30:16categorically that the Vamos party was
  678. 30:19born politically dead. What have we
  679. 30:23found out? What have we learned? There
  680. 30:26was a guy who just moved money from one
  681. 30:30pocket into the Vamos pocket, right? 5
  682. 30:33cents. And we have realized there was a
  683. 30:39bank that handed over cash, knowing the
  684. 30:43rules as they are. So, Vamos was
  685. 30:49undoubtedly born artificially for other
  686. 30:53needs, but not a political need.
  687. 30:58>> Entering other leagues, even in terms
  688. 31:00of claims,
  689. 31:01>> they aren't claims, I said suspicions.
  690. 31:03I make it clear here, but watch out for
  691. 31:06this because I like to be categorical
  692. 31:08and I am very careful. I do want what
  693. 31:12is behind the scenes to be uncovered.
  694. 31:15And you know why? Because the
  695. 31:18Salvadoran population needs to know it.
  696. 31:21>> Licenciado Someta, on what legal basis
  697. 31:24does the Supreme Electoral Tribunal
  698. 31:26also extend this party leadership by 6
  699. 31:28months? Should the tribunal get
  700. 31:31involved in the internal life of
  701. 31:32political parties during this process,
  702. 31:34in the middle of a campaign? Well,
  703. 31:36>> look, this stopped being a monkey knife
  704. 31:39fight and has now become
  705. 31:40institutionalized. Okay,
  706. 31:43>> sure.
  707. 31:43>> When the Supreme Electoral Tribunal
  708. 31:45steps in, it means the fight has
  709. 31:47already transcended. We are no longer
  710. 31:50slapping each other like teenagers;
  711. 31:52they are now moving beyond the dispute.
  712. 31:57A new council is organized, who knows
  713. 32:00where Claudia got it from to stage a
  714. 32:03party coup against CES. If they are
  715. 32:07turning to the tribunal now, it's
  716. 32:08because when a consensus can't be
  717. 32:10reached within the party, it's the
  718. 32:12tribunal that has to—there, last
  719. 32:13Friday.
  720. 32:14>> That's it, exactly. So it is extended
  721. 32:17to more or less establish order, but
  722. 32:19this doesn't fix Vamos's problems.
  723. 32:22Vamos. It went from representing a
  724. 32:26viable opposition option because if
  725. 32:28Vamos had been able or had had the
  726. 32:31structure—I'm not talking about them,
  727. 32:33but Vamos as a structure—if it had
  728. 32:36the capacity to unite all the
  729. 32:38opposition's efforts, it would have
  730. 32:40been much stronger. Now, what happened?
  731. 32:46They thought that allying with the
  732. 32:49other opposition parties would stain
  733. 32:51their new flag that had never been in
  734. 32:54power. They treated them badly, looked
  735. 32:58down on them, even used them, because
  736. 33:00they forgot that the defense of the
  737. 33:02vote in the territory was Arena and the
  738. 33:04FMLN helping Vamos. They kick them in
  739. 33:08the back, they separate, and they
  740. 33:09believed they could survive and thought
  741. 33:11they were the prettiest princesses in
  742. 33:13the world
  743. 33:15>> and that they were untouchable and that
  744. 33:17they would resolve it—that was what
  745. 33:19intensified the fight.
  746. 33:21>> They called Claudia Ortiz the most
  747. 33:23visible opposition in the country. Now
  748. 33:25he puts it into question. There has
  749. 33:33been media support regarding the
  750. 33:35construction of Claudia Ortiz's figure,
  751. 33:39>> who has even been called the most
  752. 33:41important leader of the opposition, uh,
  753. 33:44with 70,000 votes. The most voted
  754. 33:49deputy in San Salvador from Nuevas
  755. 33:51Ideas, who is Mr. Castro, 383,000 marks
  756. 33:54. This girl, Alexia, is the most voted
  757. 33:58female deputy in San Salvador with
  758. 34:00360,000 marks. This girl 79,000 marks
  759. 34:04and they inflated a recognition so much
  760. 34:07that it is reduced to San Salvador, but
  761. 34:10today they want to sell it nationally,
  762. 34:13globally, Central American-wide. In
  763. 34:16other words, here there has been a dose
  764. 34:19, evidently of arrogance with a real
  765. 34:23dispute. over the party. Vamos is
  766. 34:26looking to see which direction to go.
  767. 34:30What they haven't wanted to explain is
  768. 34:32which direction, because while it is
  769. 34:33true that you can open the party, you
  770. 34:35have to answer to your base, open it to
  771. 34:37whom and for what,
  772. 34:39>> because it is quite simple. The party
  773. 34:42has a structure based on a religious
  774. 34:45theme. It is a pastor who was behind it
  775. 34:47. If you have cults inside, it's the
  776. 34:49least you can expect, but it is a
  777. 34:51religious structure and they have said
  778. 34:53it openly and have not denied it. Now
  779. 34:56what, but what is being sought with
  780. 34:58this, I mean right now in an internal
  781. 35:00dispute that was saying, will she be
  782. 35:02expelled?
  783. 35:04>> I don't think so.
  784. 35:04>> Why not? Because there are
  785. 35:07inconsistencies, because in the payroll
  786. 35:10there is what is a control of the party
  787. 35:12, a control of the car, a control of
  788. 35:15that structure that is needed, because
  789. 35:18Claudia is a person who evidently is
  790. 35:21not going to leave Vamos to go form a
  791. 35:24new party. That is a lot of work that,
  792. 35:27uh, not just anyone does.
  793. 35:29>> If Vamos falls, who capitalizes on that
  794. 35:32?
  795. 35:33>> Marcela. Villatoro, for sure.
  796. 35:35>> Arena. I already brought out the
  797. 35:37pompoms, Mr. President.
  798. 35:38>> But, but do you guys really believe,
  799. 35:41because for example, when you review,
  800. 35:44uh, Claudia Ortiz, for example, in the
  801. 35:46Miramonte as such, she has a
  802. 35:49significant influx of votes. Uh, I
  803. 35:53don't think that those people look
  804. 35:56favorably upon Marcela Villatoro. I
  805. 36:00don't think that sector of the
  806. 36:01population connects with a Marcela
  807. 36:03Villatoro. But they won't vote for
  808. 36:05Nuevas Ideas.
  809. 36:06>> Well, I'm not saying that. I mean, I'm
  810. 36:08not saying that. That's why, you know
  811. 36:10what, do you consider that that vote
  812. 36:12will be lost?
  813. 36:12>> The ruling party, Arena, or
  814. 36:15>> What I do, what I do consider is that
  815. 36:18what little there is of the opposition
  816. 36:20continues to crumble to pieces, but I
  817. 36:22highly doubt that that vote will emerge
  818. 36:24for a Marcela Villatoro.
  819. 36:26>> to migrate, because the truth is, if
  820. 36:28you are someone on the right, let's go
  821. 36:30to a right-wing, conservative party. Uh
  822. 36:33, let's say Arena is more, uh, more
  823. 36:37right-wing,
  824. 36:38>> uh, and quite conservative. Let's say,
  825. 36:43if I'm a Claudia voter and I see that
  826. 36:45there's nothing left there, because
  827. 36:47that fight proves to me that what they
  828. 36:48sold me isn't what it is; I mean, I'm
  829. 36:50not going to go vote for the FMLN, nor
  830. 36:52am I going to go vote for Nuevas Ideas,
  831. 36:54because supposedly I am voting against
  832. 36:55that. Abstention is opposition. It's
  833. 36:59opposition.
  834. 37:00>> to migrate to where Marcela is. Marcela
  835. 37:02is the one who should be working bit by
  836. 37:03bit, right? In the territory.
  837. 37:06>> Abstention, at the moment of abstention
  838. 37:08, there will be a quota of abstention.
  839. 37:11There are people who may be more
  840. 37:13aligned with Claudia's ideas
  841. 37:17>> that at a given moment could choose to
  842. 37:19abstain. But here is where it depends,
  843. 37:22because although these votes won't
  844. 37:24automatically go to Marcela Villatoro,
  845. 37:25she will have to do a little bit of
  846. 37:27advertising or campaigning to woo them
  847. 37:29over. The groundwork is already laid,
  848. 37:32they have more or less the same
  849. 37:33ideological line, they have some
  850. 37:35criteria there where she has to go and
  851. 37:36catch those votes that she's now going
  852. 37:38to need to keep the seat because today
  853. 37:39she's going to have to get more. The
  854. 37:42opportunity Vamos wasted, because the
  855. 37:45idea was to get two deputies in San
  856. 37:48Salvador and Cesia and Claudia should
  857. 37:50have gone hand in hand, uh, seeking and
  858. 37:53working for the votes, but they got
  859. 37:56into a fight.
  860. 37:57>> This must have been a dispute over a
  861. 38:00position on the list. It is a power
  862. 38:04struggle aimed, in the very particular
  863. 38:06case of Claudia, at her own personal
  864. 38:09interests.
  865. 38:11>> That is something Cesia has denounced
  866. 38:13and she said it, she wants to turn the
  867. 38:15party into a replica of Nuevas Ideas in
  868. 38:17the sense that she is the only leader
  869. 38:19and whatever she says gets done. would
  870. 38:22Deputy Ortiz have a way out, uh, right
  871. 38:25now with another vehicle if she were
  872. 38:28left out of
  873. 38:30>> Look, after what I have seen from
  874. 38:32Claudia Ortiz,
  875. 38:34>> uh, after she fires the party's
  876. 38:37secretary general,
  877. 38:40>> uh, you know what I can sense is that
  878. 38:43she is looking for, uh, a way out
  879. 38:46abroad to be able to keep company with
  880. 38:49even that dying pamphlet, uh, that does
  881. 38:52propaganda for her, 724, uh, and sell
  882. 38:58herself as another paper exile and go
  883. 39:01talk abroad about the dictator. That is
  884. 39:05what there is to Claudia Ortiz.
  885. 39:07>> I don't think it is a viable aspiration
  886. 39:09. Uh, I think what the party needs to
  887. 39:13do right now to at least have a chance
  888. 39:15of surviving is to register Claudia.
  889. 39:18>> Surely, because she's on the ballot.
  890. 39:21>> Yes, she is on the ballot, but since
  891. 39:23registration opens now, we won't know
  892. 39:24until she's registered, because
  893. 39:26anything can happen here; very serious
  894. 39:28accusations have already been made.
  895. 39:31There is a reality based on all the
  896. 39:32movements, at least those that have
  897. 39:34been seen publicly. Actually, the only
  898. 39:35thing blocking her is the fact that she
  899. 39:37is secretary general. And the latest
  900. 39:41statements Claudia made, saying: "If
  901. 39:43the court forces us to stay 6 more
  902. 39:45months with this board of directors," I
  903. 39:47imagine that means she won't appeal and
  904. 39:49will have to submit to it until she
  905. 39:51becomes a congresswoman and deals with
  906. 39:53the internal elections. We will have to
  907. 39:57see if this situation holds up.
  908. 40:00>> You already take it for granted,
  909. 40:02Licenciada, and the statements she
  910. 40:03makes are
  911. 40:04>> as a congresswoman.
  912. 40:05>> Yes, I believe she managed to get in,
  913. 40:07maybe just barely. But look, if Vamos
  914. 40:10doesn't run Claudia, whether we agree
  915. 40:12with her or not, if Vamos doesn't run
  916. 40:13Claudia, the same thing will happen to
  917. 40:15them as Nuestro Tiempo: they will
  918. 40:17disappear. Because the truth is, the
  919. 40:20voter base—which is undeniable—the
  920. 40:22voter base belongs to Claudia. Well,
  921. 40:25very well. We are going to take a break
  922. 40:27, it's 7:15 in the morning. Upon
  923. 40:28returning, I want us to talk about the
  924. 40:31priorities regarding economic issues.
  925. 40:35The general national budget presented
  926. 40:37grew by 17%, and we are going to go
  927. 40:39into detail on this. Let's go to the
  928. 40:41break. We continue and put another
  929. 42:41topic on the table. The government has
  930. 42:43already presented the 2027 budget draft
  931. 42:45to the Legislative Assembly on time:
  932. 42:4712.421 billion dollars, an increase of
  933. 42:531.865 billion compared to the budget
  934. 42:58currently in effect for 2026. The main
  935. 43:01bet this time is education, with 3.416
  936. 43:04billion, while health also gets a
  937. 43:08portion, followed by infrastructure,
  938. 43:10subsidies, and other strategic programs
  939. 43:13that would also be receiving more
  940. 43:14resources. The central debate now will
  941. 43:19be determining how this growth will be
  942. 43:22financed, that it yields results—
  943. 43:24which is exactly what is expected—and
  944. 43:26how they handle debt obligations and
  945. 43:29the pension issue, which we also saw
  946. 43:31yesterday was validated by the
  947. 43:33International Monetary Fund, at least
  948. 43:36the second review, for another new
  949. 43:38disbursement regarding that. How do we
  950. 43:42view a budget when the priorities are
  951. 43:44put on the table? Carlos, doubling
  952. 43:48education is the national commitment
  953. 43:50that had been promised; 8.1%of the GDP
  954. 43:53is what has been allocated to education
  955. 43:55.
  956. 43:56>> Undoubtedly, 3.416 billion dollars, as
  957. 44:00the president announced,
  958. 44:02>> now we have finalized it in the
  959. 44:04Legislative Assembly, 8.1%of the GDP.
  960. 44:09Uh, look how important it is, uh, to
  961. 44:11have the vision that has been held. Uh,
  962. 44:16it really catches my attention that we
  963. 44:18are currently, with this investment,
  964. 44:21the country that invests the most of
  965. 44:24its economy for children and youth in
  966. 44:26Latin America, just as President Bukele
  967. 44:29had announced. It also catches my
  968. 44:34attention, the reduction or rather the
  969. 44:37reorientation regarding the security
  970. 44:41ministries, uh, which total 40 million
  971. 44:44dollars in reorientation toward
  972. 44:47education. Without a doubt, uh, the
  973. 44:51focus is on classrooms and, of course,
  974. 44:54on connectivity, artificial
  975. 44:56intelligence, and technological tools
  976. 44:59for our children and youth. That is to
  977. 45:02say, uh, without a doubt, without a
  978. 45:05doubt this step, uh, it definitely
  979. 45:07marks the rebirth of this new El
  980. 45:09Salvador in terms of education, this
  981. 45:11investment. When you budget, that is
  982. 45:14where you place your priorities. And I
  983. 45:16go to Mr. Someta, uh, regarding this,
  984. 45:18because it is clear that it is
  985. 45:21education that they have bet on. It
  986. 45:24increased by 27, it is 27.5%of the
  987. 45:26entire budget that goes to education.
  988. 45:30It is consistent with what Hueso just
  989. 45:33mentioned. There is a reduction now for
  990. 45:35, let's say, the entire security
  991. 45:37cabinet. Note that in last year's
  992. 45:40education budget there was a part,
  993. 45:42because there is a word that caught my
  994. 45:44attention from what Hueso mentioned
  995. 45:46regarding the reorientation. I'm going
  996. 45:48to mention it now. Uh, a good part was
  997. 45:51for infrastructure. Now what they have
  998. 45:53done is that what was spent on
  999. 45:55infrastructure has been put into the
  1000. 45:57same budget. It means that now schools
  1001. 46:00will no longer come from the Ministry
  1002. 46:02of Public Works budget, but now they
  1003. 46:05will come directly from the budget. Mm.
  1004. 46:08of the Ministry of Education. Allow me,
  1005. 46:12allow me, I am finishing my point. I
  1006. 46:14did not interrupt yours.
  1007. 46:15>> No, but what you are saying is false.
  1008. 46:16I'm telling you because I have
  1009. 46:18information. That is to say,
  1010. 46:19>> then wait until you are given the floor
  1011. 46:20and you can correct it then. Let's
  1012. 46:22finish the point.
  1013. 46:23>> Uh, so what has been done is that the
  1014. 46:25infrastructure part has been
  1015. 46:26incorporated into the budget. But look,
  1016. 46:28one thing is what is budgeted, what is
  1017. 46:29allocated, and another thing is what is
  1018. 46:31actually executed.
  1019. 46:33>> I want to remind the public that while
  1020. 46:36we are in a state of emergency, the
  1021. 46:39shifting of budget items and accounts
  1022. 46:41and these money reorientations are
  1023. 46:44authorized at their discretion because
  1024. 46:47we are in a state of emergency. These
  1025. 46:51are the things being criticized. I
  1026. 46:53agree with the state of emergency in
  1027. 46:55terms of security, but I do not agree
  1028. 46:57with giving full control of the budget
  1029. 47:00to make these reorientations that
  1030. 47:02Carlos Hueso mentions. And the last
  1031. 47:04point, what about the US (University of
  1032. 47:05El Salvador)? Is the US included in
  1033. 47:08that education budget? In last year's
  1034. 47:11budget, they left the US with a debt of
  1035. 47:1310 million. Then Alejandro Gutman comes
  1036. 47:16out saying it's because the rector
  1037. 47:18spoke ill of him. Man, those are not
  1038. 47:21valid arguments to exclude this
  1039. 47:23country's main university and the only
  1040. 47:26public one that houses 62,000 students;
  1041. 47:29just because Mr. Gutman says the rector
  1042. 47:31spoke ill of him, he wants to exclude
  1043. 47:34more students than he has in his own
  1044. 47:36scholarship program. Look, uh, just to
  1045. 47:40add to the response you're going to
  1046. 47:43give,
  1047. 47:44>> at least I read it in the media, this
  1048. 47:46reorientation plus this budget
  1049. 47:49indicator of 8.1%
  1050. 47:52>> is going to "My New School,"
  1051. 47:53infrastructure, uniforms, supplies,
  1052. 47:55scholarships, and connectivity. My
  1053. 47:58criticism
  1054. 47:59>> in this sense is very clear. We have a
  1055. 48:02backlog regarding the issue of
  1056. 48:06infrastructure in education, but the
  1057. 48:09true indicator is not budgeting,
  1058. 48:11because that is just what I suppose I
  1059. 48:14will spend; it is execution, the real
  1060. 48:17capacity to execute double the budget.
  1061. 48:21The true indicator is whether, by the
  1062. 48:23time of next year's fiscal closing,
  1063. 48:25that 8.1%has actually been executed,
  1064. 48:30and if that execution is truly aimed at
  1065. 48:33changing educational quality. Because I
  1066. 48:36will tell you one thing, how do these
  1067. 48:38results look in the classrooms? It is
  1068. 48:41useless to have new schools if the
  1069. 48:43teacher you have is not being trained.
  1070. 48:47If you don't change an educational
  1071. 48:49curriculum that is oriented toward
  1072. 48:51science and technology, that is going
  1073. 48:53to modernize the student, which isn't
  1074. 48:55something stated here—here it only
  1075. 48:57says school infrastructure, supplies,
  1076. 48:59uniforms, scholarships. The real change
  1077. 49:04in education is giving the student the
  1078. 49:06necessary tools to make them critical,
  1079. 49:08so we don't keep having graduates like
  1080. 49:10the ones we have today: submissive,
  1081. 49:12quiet, and grateful to employers who
  1082. 49:14pay them the minimum wage. Although he
  1083. 49:18defended it last time, because he had
  1084. 49:21put it on a silver platter for me as he
  1085. 49:23always does when he defends him, but
  1086. 49:26look: there are 100 million destined
  1087. 49:28for public works, for infrastructure
  1088. 49:30and 112 million for the DON which, uh,
  1089. 49:33continues the two-schools-a-day project
  1090. 49:35, just, just to correct, because what
  1091. 49:38he was saying is a fallacy. Watch out
  1092. 49:42for this. I do agree that we must, that
  1093. 49:46we must and, by the way, I should say
  1094. 49:49it publicly because I have looked into
  1095. 49:51it, teachers are being trained. Without
  1096. 49:56a doubt, all Salvadorans should commit
  1097. 50:00to this effort. It is important that
  1098. 50:04education takes that turn and that leap
  1099. 50:06in quality
  1100. 50:08>> that we need so much. What Carlos is
  1101. 50:10saying, that is the, the intention
  1102. 50:12behind proposing the education plan, to
  1103. 50:14say that we are investing here, that we
  1104. 50:15are doing things. I want to see at the
  1105. 50:18end of next year if that budget is
  1106. 50:20really executed. 81. of GDP in
  1107. 50:25education, 27.5 of the budget.
  1108. 50:29>> A very nice headline.
  1109. 50:30>> The important thing is execution. And
  1110. 50:32precisely, I’m getting to this. Does
  1111. 50:35El Salvador have the capacity to
  1112. 50:37execute double the budget that it had
  1113. 50:39this year for 2027 in education, and
  1114. 50:42above all, how do we measure it in the
  1115. 50:44classrooms? Not just in dollars, how do
  1116. 50:48we measure the results of a
  1117. 50:50>> was it PISA in the case of classrooms?
  1118. 50:52Uh, the issue of the criteria on how
  1119. 50:54university students are turning out,
  1120. 50:57university professors who receive high
  1121. 50:59school graduates, uh, they are the ones
  1122. 51:02who can give you the indicator. As of
  1123. 51:05today, you have had about 10 years or
  1124. 51:07so of universities complaining about
  1125. 51:10the type of graduate that is coming out
  1126. 51:12, that they don't know how to read,
  1127. 51:14that they don't know spelling. Uh, it
  1128. 51:19is truly a very complicated issue, a
  1129. 51:21very strong deficiency, and it is not
  1130. 51:23just the student's fault, because they
  1131. 51:25can tell you here, look, since they
  1132. 51:26cannot fail, look, since they cannot,
  1133. 51:28no. The fault here also lies with the
  1134. 51:32teacher, and that is a very personal
  1135. 51:34criticism of mine, who has hidden under
  1136. 51:37the unions. The unions became nests,
  1137. 51:41defenders of bad teachers, even
  1138. 51:44including teachers and principals who
  1139. 51:47harass children and adolescents within
  1140. 51:50the public system. As of today, you
  1141. 51:54have a lot of reports of harassment in
  1142. 51:56private and public schools and I would
  1143. 51:58like the minister dressed in fatigues
  1144. 52:01to go in kicking those schools open and
  1145. 52:03drag the harassers out by their hair.
  1146. 52:06It is a specific issue to measure these
  1147. 52:08results, not just in dollars, as I was
  1148. 52:10saying, but how are we going to have
  1149. 52:12indicators to see these results from
  1150. 52:14the double budget execution. Well, he
  1151. 52:18already read us if the indicators are
  1152. 52:20indeed oriented towards infrastructure
  1153. 52:23and connectivity there, Carlitos,
  1154. 52:25because just because he says he wins
  1155. 52:27the debates doesn't mean he actually
  1156. 52:29does, even if he celebrates it, it's a
  1157. 52:32habit, but the parameters are already
  1158. 52:34set. Now, budgeting it is one thing
  1159. 52:38that, as Besi said, is a beautiful
  1160. 52:41speech, saying we are investing double
  1161. 52:43in education; as is customary for this
  1162. 52:46administration, they are excellent at
  1163. 52:49headlines in terms of communication,
  1164. 52:51but the execution doesn't work. How
  1165. 52:54many schools were there supposed to be?
  1166. 52:56>> Yes,
  1167. 52:58>> by now there should be, what, 2,000 and
  1168. 53:00something, because it was two per day.
  1169. 53:04But no. But there are nice schools,
  1170. 53:06that's true. And I am not, I am not
  1171. 53:08against the schools. There are schools,
  1172. 53:10but what was the headline?
  1173. 53:12>> The headline was almost that they were
  1174. 53:13going to build them all from scratch,
  1175. 53:14and in reality, there are some that
  1176. 53:16just got a quick touch-up,
  1177. 53:17>> that they're just getting a fresh coat
  1178. 53:18of paint, but it's good that they are
  1179. 53:20intervening. It's fine. I, I like to
  1180. 53:22see the nice little schools and
  1181. 53:24everything. That's perfect. When are we
  1182. 53:27going to work? On the quality of
  1183. 53:29education. When are we going to focus
  1184. 53:32on that? Because you can have children
  1185. 53:36all combed, pressed, bathed, in a nice
  1186. 53:40school and with a computer. But, what
  1187. 53:44kind of student are we forming? Because
  1188. 53:47they resemble robots more than students
  1189. 53:49, right?
  1190. 53:50>> But this leap, how can we measure it?
  1191. 53:52You can't measure a result like that in
  1192. 53:54one year either. Look, as if there were
  1193. 53:59a budget
  1194. 54:01>> for a quality educational system,
  1195. 54:05>> as if we came from having the best in
  1196. 54:07the world. We sure are good at
  1197. 54:12criticizing. But look, do you know what
  1198. 54:16is important? That as of today, seeds
  1199. 54:20are being sown, and without a doubt,
  1200. 54:23this project in the medium and long
  1201. 54:26term, we all hope that our children and
  1202. 54:29our grandchildren can really see the
  1203. 54:32fruits of this investment.
  1204. 54:36Congratulations that you think that way
  1205. 54:38. Very well, we are going to take a
  1206. 54:40break, we will continue talking about
  1207. 54:42the budget, and I'll leave the topic on
  1208. 54:44the table right now because there will
  1209. 54:46be no more taxes, they said, the
  1210. 54:47Minister of Finance was clear when
  1211. 54:49asked about these issues. There will be
  1212. 54:51no more taxes. There is a gap of 515
  1213. 54:54million dollars. How is it covered?
  1214. 54:57With more debt? Who is going to pay for
  1215. 55:00this later? Uh, it must be mentioned
  1216. 55:02that revenue rose 13.8%compared to the
  1217. 55:04previous year, but spending also rose
  1218. 55:06by 17. That's where that gap comes in.
  1219. 55:09Let's go to a break, and we will talk
  1220. 55:11about this because there is also a
  1221. 55:13sensitive issue in the budget, and that
  1222. 55:15is the pension system debt. All right,
  1223. 57:39thank you for staying with us. We are
  1224. 57:42talking about the budget and how they
  1225. 57:45are going to cover this gap regarding
  1226. 57:48current income of 10,419. 13.8%more,
  1227. 57:54and they assure that there will be no
  1228. 57:57new taxes or increases. Also, $ 40
  1229. 57:59million dollars are being reserved for
  1230. 58:01the elections, which must be taken into
  1231. 58:03account. Mr. Someta, I was asking, what
  1232. 58:07will cover these $ 515 million dollars?
  1233. 58:11Nice headline, we won't impose new
  1234. 58:14taxes, but we have presented an
  1235. 58:17underfunded budget that is missing a
  1236. 58:19little something, and it's not just
  1237. 58:22that, there are also the loans that
  1238. 58:25must be paid. Notice that the budget is
  1239. 58:30only fed by four items of current
  1240. 58:33income that come from VAT, which is the
  1241. 58:36main income, from special contributions
  1242. 58:39, from bonds and treasury bills, and
  1243. 58:42from loans. So, if this budget
  1244. 58:46continues to be executed or is intended
  1245. 58:50to be executed this way, we will
  1246. 58:52necessarily have to take out another
  1247. 58:55loan to cover that part, and it
  1248. 58:57continues to bury us as the most
  1249. 59:00indebted country in the region. This is
  1250. 59:04very important to point out because the
  1251. 59:07truth is that we are going to pay for
  1252. 59:10it, you and I, my dear viewer. We are
  1253. 59:12going to end up paying for this huge
  1254. 59:14pile of loans. Then comes the big blow,
  1255. 59:17which will be the pension reform. We
  1256. 59:21have—the state has a debt of around
  1257. 59:2386%of the pension funds. The way
  1258. 59:27pensions are fixed without reform is
  1259. 59:29for the state to pay that 86%it has
  1260. 59:31borrowed, along with its interest and
  1261. 59:33profitability. Does the state have that
  1262. 59:36capacity? Is it included in this budget
  1263. 59:38? I didn't see it.
  1264. 59:39>> Yes. The specific amount allocated for
  1265. 59:42the payment of pension debt was not
  1266. 59:43detailed in, uh...
  1267. 59:44>> coincidentally, it is...
  1268. 59:46>> at least in the presentation, but the
  1269. 59:48project does assure that it covers
  1270. 59:50domestic and external debt commitments
  1271. 59:52and the pro...The thing is, we keep
  1272. 59:54continuing with the issue of loans.
  1273. 59:56Let's remember that they are going to
  1274. 59:58give us the second disbursement
  1275. 59:59>> from the International Monetary Fund.
  1276. 1:00:01We also keep courting the IDB, right?
  1277. 1:00:05Which has promised an amount equal to
  1278. 1:00:07that of the International Monetary Fund
  1279. 1:00:09. Uh, here we keep digging one hole to
  1280. 1:00:12fill another, don't we? We are, we are
  1281. 1:00:17in a situation of over-indebtedness
  1282. 1:00:20that, uh...Undoubtedly, after the
  1283. 1:00:26electoral process of February 28, 2027,
  1284. 1:00:29around March or April, the bitter pill
  1285. 1:00:32will have to be swallowed, uh,
  1286. 1:00:34regarding, uh, how they are going to
  1287. 1:00:36tighten the belt to reduce expenses,
  1288. 1:00:39including the issue of pensions, which
  1289. 1:00:42is the toughest one expected.
  1290. 1:00:45>> Yes,
  1291. 1:00:46>> which follows what the International
  1292. 1:00:49Monetary Fund has requested, the
  1293. 1:00:51increase in years of labor, the
  1294. 1:00:53increase in years worked, and the
  1295. 1:00:56increase in payments from both the
  1296. 1:00:59worker and the employer, uh, for this
  1297. 1:01:02fund. Carlos, regarding the debt issue,
  1298. 1:01:06uh, this Wednesday, in fact, we were
  1299. 1:01:09analyzing with economists how the debt
  1300. 1:01:11has been increasing for 20 years and
  1301. 1:01:14how it accelerated in recent years.
  1302. 1:01:19Even with good financial management,
  1303. 1:01:22there comes a point where it is
  1304. 1:01:24unsustainable. Look, Luis, uh,
  1305. 1:01:27regarding what is being handled, uh, it
  1306. 1:01:30is undoubtedly part of the evolution.
  1307. 1:01:33Why do I say this?
  1308. 1:01:34>> But, but this government will have to
  1309. 1:01:36solve that big problem.
  1310. 1:01:39>> The fact is that this government is
  1311. 1:01:41assuming, because it is like that, for
  1312. 1:01:43example, the debt of previous
  1313. 1:01:45governments, in this case, the FMLN,
  1314. 1:01:47right? This government has already
  1315. 1:01:50borrowed more than the FMLN and Arena
  1316. 1:01:52governments combined. That, that is no
  1317. 1:01:55longer a matter of the past. That, that
  1318. 1:01:58debt, for example, there is currently a
  1319. 1:02:00gap, yes, there is a gap, but it is
  1320. 1:02:03reoriented toward education and that
  1321. 1:02:05reorientation more than Arena and the
  1322. 1:02:11FMLN. Combined. The thing is that there
  1323. 1:02:14are still, uh, people who have not
  1324. 1:02:16understood that it is a medium-and
  1325. 1:02:19long-term project
  1326. 1:02:21>> and it is part of that narrative they
  1327. 1:02:23want to instill in the population. But,
  1328. 1:02:25you know what is very interesting? It's
  1329. 1:02:29that, for example, when you ask a
  1330. 1:02:31parent if the child indeed received
  1331. 1:02:33their computer, their laptop, and has a
  1332. 1:02:36different school environment, the
  1333. 1:02:38results are there. There it is. So,
  1334. 1:02:42they received a computer. Yes. Oh, so
  1335. 1:02:44they shouldn't care that we go into
  1336. 1:02:46more debt,
  1337. 1:02:46>> that no. You have a computer. No, no,
  1338. 1:02:48it's not, it's not like that. I just
  1339. 1:02:50want by deduction
  1340. 1:02:52>> that narrative. Look, look at how
  1341. 1:02:55clumsy a narrative it is, one that the
  1342. 1:02:57Salvadoran people keep rejecting time
  1343. 1:03:00and again, and they want to insist on
  1344. 1:03:02the same thing. What stubbornness. Look
  1345. 1:03:05, uh, the financing is, yes or yes,
  1346. 1:03:08part of the evolution to have a better
  1347. 1:03:12El Salvador and this project is medium-
  1348. 1:03:15and long-term.
  1349. 1:03:18>> They are hitting a brick wall day and
  1350. 1:03:21night with that type of narrative and
  1351. 1:03:23they keep insisting. On the economic
  1352. 1:03:26front, there is a reality here. Either
  1353. 1:03:29you raise taxes to have the money to
  1354. 1:03:31pay debt, or you keep getting into debt
  1355. 1:03:33. I mean, there is no other way.
  1356. 1:03:36>> That's why here, it's not
  1357. 1:03:41>> Mathematics is an exact science.
  1358. 1:03:43>> Exactly.
  1359. 1:03:44>> Period. Someone here is going to have
  1360. 1:03:46to pay, and it is not the one who
  1361. 1:03:48governs who pays, it is the governed.
  1362. 1:03:51>> How they love headlines, uh, historic
  1363. 1:03:54investment or fiscal risk.
  1364. 1:03:57>> There it is. And they hide from you
  1365. 1:03:59what isn't a good headline, because in
  1366. 1:04:01the budget, how much are we, how much
  1367. 1:04:03is allocated from the budget for debt
  1368. 1:04:05payment? How much, how much did they
  1369. 1:04:07put in there that they were going to?
  1370. 1:04:09Didn't they put it in? They didn't put
  1371. 1:04:11it in. Meaning that, because by putting
  1372. 1:04:14it in the budget, it would
  1373. 1:04:16automatically give rise to these types
  1374. 1:04:18of comments, because they want us to
  1375. 1:04:21look the other way and not realize that
  1376. 1:04:23this government has gone into more debt
  1377. 1:04:26than all the governments we have had
  1378. 1:04:28since the peace accords. So, and in
  1379. 1:04:33just the 6 years they have been in, we
  1380. 1:04:35have around 71 or 72 approved loans,
  1381. 1:04:37because the one from the fund still
  1382. 1:04:39isn't—it is important to say that
  1383. 1:04:42behind every headline of a historic
  1384. 1:04:44investment, we also have to remember
  1385. 1:04:46that it is a historic indebtedness that
  1386. 1:04:49is supporting that.
  1387. 1:04:51>> And, and to this
  1388. 1:04:52>> It’s good that you say that. But this
  1389. 1:04:55leads me to the question for the three
  1390. 1:04:57of you: this historic investment as
  1391. 1:05:00such of 12 billion dollars, 12.4
  1392. 1:05:02billion projected, at home, how am I
  1393. 1:05:05going to feel it?
  1394. 1:05:08>> While, look, we go back to the same
  1395. 1:05:11topic. When they give you the
  1396. 1:05:13indicators of macroeconomic figures,
  1397. 1:05:15that means the big entrepreneur is
  1398. 1:05:17growing, but that does not translate
  1399. 1:05:19into salary increases. The worker, the
  1400. 1:05:22female worker, mind you, formal, which
  1401. 1:05:24is only two out of every 10, because
  1402. 1:05:27eight are in informality,
  1403. 1:05:29>> are not seeing that income reflected.
  1404. 1:05:31Yesterday it was said through social
  1405. 1:05:33media that the entire state received
  1406. 1:05:35their Christmas bonus. The rest of the
  1407. 1:05:38entrepreneurs, as it is optional, can
  1408. 1:05:40stretch it out until December. It will
  1409. 1:05:43be the 25th paycheck, the first one
  1410. 1:05:45next year, which let's say might give
  1411. 1:05:47some relief to a couple of regularized
  1412. 1:05:49employees, but not to the rest who are
  1413. 1:05:51in an irregular condition, meaning they
  1414. 1:05:54don't pay pension funds or social
  1415. 1:05:56security. As long as economic growth
  1416. 1:06:00doesn't translate into the user, the
  1417. 1:06:02Salvadoran, having enough salary; that
  1418. 1:06:05the money reaching their pocket is
  1419. 1:06:07enough to cover housing, health,
  1420. 1:06:09education, recreation, and still save a
  1421. 1:06:12few cents, you aren't growing: the big
  1422. 1:06:14business sector is growing. And to this
  1423. 1:06:18, you have to add the idea they've come
  1424. 1:06:21up with of increasing the workday by 11
  1425. 1:06:23hours. If the ones drooling and rubbing
  1426. 1:06:27their hands together are the
  1427. 1:06:28industrialists who are going to exploit
  1428. 1:06:30the worker, we are going to go into
  1429. 1:06:31detail on that topic because we also
  1430. 1:06:33have it as part of this week's topics
  1431. 1:06:35of interest, but speaking of budgets,
  1432. 1:06:37how are you feeling at home?
  1433. 1:06:39>> Having financing means there is
  1434. 1:06:41confidence. The IMF itself has said so,
  1435. 1:06:45without a doubt. This is a process, and
  1436. 1:06:48I reiterate it with that certainty, for
  1437. 1:06:51the Salvadoran people in the medium and
  1438. 1:06:54long term. Now, there are many things
  1439. 1:06:58to do, without a doubt, but we all know
  1440. 1:07:01where we come from, where we are, and
  1441. 1:07:03where we are going. I only know that
  1442. 1:07:07when they lend you money and say: "You
  1443. 1:07:09give me confidence," it's because the
  1444. 1:07:10bank knows you're capable of stopping
  1445. 1:07:12feeding your children just to pay the
  1446. 1:07:13installment, and that makes you a good
  1447. 1:07:15payer and A-rated for credit. But that
  1448. 1:07:18doesn't make you a good administrator
  1449. 1:07:19of your household.
  1450. 1:07:22>> This that Carlos poses as investment
  1451. 1:07:24and as hope, let's look at it through
  1452. 1:07:26the example of our own house. This is
  1453. 1:07:30like you needing to make a repair on
  1454. 1:07:31the roof of your house and they give
  1455. 1:07:32you a loan. You go, you have money at
  1456. 1:07:35that moment, which is our indicator of
  1457. 1:07:37having, you have money at that moment,
  1458. 1:07:39you go, you repair the roof of your
  1459. 1:07:41house until the first installment comes
  1460. 1:07:43that you have to pay on that loan. In
  1461. 1:07:45other words, the fact that you have
  1462. 1:07:47money and that you invest it in
  1463. 1:07:49repairing your little house doesn't
  1464. 1:07:51mean it doesn't have to be paid back.
  1465. 1:07:53And that money is paid by us
  1466. 1:07:55Salvadorans, and we want to know how we
  1467. 1:07:58are going to pay it, where it will be
  1468. 1:08:00paid from, because according to the
  1469. 1:08:03budget, our income isn't enough to pay
  1470. 1:08:05what has been budgeted that we are
  1471. 1:08:08going to spend. And that is a fact that
  1472. 1:08:10is presented there.
  1473. 1:08:11>> Look, good one. Look how good the first
  1474. 1:08:13illustration he makes is. Undoubtedly
  1475. 1:08:16there are loans that are necessary,
  1476. 1:08:19there are financings that are necessary
  1477. 1:08:21no matter what, and what we are seeing
  1478. 1:08:24is undoubtedly more than necessary to
  1479. 1:08:26have a new El Salvador. Look how
  1480. 1:08:31interesting what they want to reach to
  1481. 1:08:33confuse the Salvadoran population.
  1482. 1:08:36Seeing financing that is positive, that
  1483. 1:08:39comes in order to keep moving forward,
  1484. 1:08:42will always be necessary.
  1485. 1:08:45>> Let's see, because that thesis is
  1486. 1:08:46>> But it has to be paid for, Carlos.
  1487. 1:08:47>> That thesis is also heard a lot on the
  1488. 1:08:49streets, that although it is true they
  1489. 1:08:51go into debt and borrow, you see works,
  1490. 1:08:53this is being done, that is being done.
  1491. 1:08:55>> But, what about before, what did we see
  1492. 1:08:56? 103 million dollars are going to the
  1493. 1:08:59airport, 59 million for the Pacific
  1494. 1:09:02airport.
  1495. 1:09:04>> They are priorities.
  1496. 1:09:08>> For this government these are the
  1497. 1:09:09priorities, that's why when Manuel
  1498. 1:09:11Someta says that, it's laughable, do
  1499. 1:09:12you know why? What happened with the
  1500. 1:09:15debts of the past? Where were they?
  1501. 1:09:17Where are the works? When the secretary
  1502. 1:09:21general of the Front, for example, says
  1503. 1:09:22, "Close your eyes and let's see how we
  1504. 1:09:24were in the past and what you found."
  1505. 1:09:27>> 20 homicides a day. I, I, that thing
  1506. 1:09:31about closing your eyes, the Chino said
  1507. 1:09:33it, and the president also said it,
  1508. 1:09:35there are works that are transcendental
  1509. 1:09:37and there is an investment today in
  1510. 1:09:40education that undoubtedly marks a
  1511. 1:09:42before.
  1512. 1:09:44>> Yes Carlos, it's just that, it's just
  1513. 1:09:45that I could even agree with that, but
  1514. 1:09:47you would have to agree with me that it
  1515. 1:09:49has to be paid because
  1516. 1:09:50>> Not agreeing, no one is saying it won't
  1517. 1:09:53be paid. Agreed that it has to be paid.
  1518. 1:09:57It has to stop that narrative of fear
  1519. 1:09:59that they want to That the state only
  1520. 1:10:03receives income from two sources,
  1521. 1:10:05either through taxes or debt.
  1522. 1:10:07>> And that always has to be paid and
  1523. 1:10:09there has to be an adjustment. Remember
  1524. 1:10:12the bitter medicine, they will probably
  1525. 1:10:14give you your spoonful after the
  1526. 1:10:15elections.
  1527. 1:10:16>> Well, the pension issue is undoubtedly
  1528. 1:10:18already there. By 2027 a profound
  1529. 1:10:20reform must be made if it is to be
  1530. 1:10:22sustained, because otherwise it is
  1531. 1:10:24already unsustainable. We're going to a
  1532. 1:10:26break and upon returning let's talk
  1533. 1:10:27about this review of the workday. There
  1534. 1:10:30are already concrete proposals and we
  1535. 1:10:31are going to talk about this. Oh. Thank
  1536. 1:12:36you for being with us for the morning
  1537. 1:12:38dialogue. El Salvador is moving forward
  1538. 1:12:40in an analysis, a possible modification
  1539. 1:12:43of the workday, proposals that seek to
  1540. 1:12:45reorganize working time without
  1541. 1:12:46eliminating established workers 'rights
  1542. 1:12:48. It is what has been said among the
  1543. 1:12:52main changes in this discussion are
  1544. 1:12:55workdays concentrated into 4 days that
  1545. 1:12:57could extend the amount of hours worked
  1546. 1:12:59per day as such. Uh, one of the central
  1547. 1:13:05points is to determine how these
  1548. 1:13:07extraordinary or ordinary hours can be
  1549. 1:13:10calculated according to the changes,
  1550. 1:13:12the rest days, and the compensation
  1551. 1:13:15under these new schemes, because this
  1552. 1:13:17is precisely what has not been
  1553. 1:13:19discussed. Ms. Ríos, we were talking
  1554. 1:13:24about headlines and such. That three
  1555. 1:13:28days off improves family quality of
  1556. 1:13:30life. That’s how it’s been
  1557. 1:13:33presented,
  1558. 1:13:33>> it’s how they’re trying to sell it,
  1559. 1:13:35>> uh. It sounds nice.
  1560. 1:13:39>> The truth is that under that headline
  1561. 1:13:42and with none of the ways they’ve
  1562. 1:13:44tried to spin it
  1563. 1:13:46>> can they convince people about a person
  1564. 1:13:51working 11 hours a day for 4 days. I
  1565. 1:13:56agree with a—there was a clash
  1566. 1:13:58between congresswoman Marcela Villatoro
  1567. 1:14:01and the Minister of Labor. I agree with
  1568. 1:14:04something the minister said. What has
  1569. 1:14:06been conquered shall not be surrendered
  1570. 1:14:08. It’s not just a saying, it’s a
  1571. 1:14:10slogan from the Chicago martyrs.
  1572. 1:14:13>> But don’t forget, you had the
  1573. 1:14:15industrialist here saying, "No, we
  1574. 1:14:16aren't going to touch the 44 work hours
  1575. 1:14:18." Let’s not forget that it’s not
  1576. 1:14:21just about 44 hours a week. The main
  1577. 1:14:25achievement is not working more than 8
  1578. 1:14:28hours, and that already has a technical
  1579. 1:14:31basis. In fact, it was consulted that
  1580. 1:14:33this would require a constitutional
  1581. 1:14:34reform. A person who works 11 hours is
  1582. 1:14:39not productive the next day, much less
  1583. 1:14:4248 hours of 11-hour days, 72 hours of
  1584. 1:14:4511-hour days, they are not productive.
  1585. 1:14:51What reform was made in the, in the, in
  1586. 1:14:53the health sector? I want to remind you
  1587. 1:14:56of the shifts that were given to
  1588. 1:14:59doctors and students, working 3-day
  1589. 1:15:02full shifts. What conclusion was
  1590. 1:15:04reached? You are not a productive
  1591. 1:15:08person when you have that kind of
  1592. 1:15:10schedule. Of course, the industrialists
  1593. 1:15:15go and show their fangs because
  1594. 1:15:17they’re going to add an extra shift
  1595. 1:15:19and they’re going to exploit that
  1596. 1:15:21class of worker more without having to
  1597. 1:15:23pay more hours, nor night differentials
  1598. 1:15:25, nor overtime. Well yes, if the one
  1599. 1:15:28who is going to exploit you is happy.
  1600. 1:15:31When proposals like this come along and
  1601. 1:15:33it’s the business owners who happily
  1602. 1:15:35come to the media to tell you how kind
  1603. 1:15:37the reform is and how respectful they
  1604. 1:15:40are, that they aren't going to touch
  1605. 1:15:42the 44 weekly hours, be afraid. Be
  1606. 1:15:46afraid, because if the business owner
  1607. 1:15:48is happy, it benefits them and
  1608. 1:15:51>> the issue of productivity is what we
  1609. 1:15:53are seeing. Notice that I don't see the
  1610. 1:15:56danger here so much in the hours, in
  1611. 1:15:57the redistribution of the hours. I see
  1612. 1:16:01the danger in the reform that must be
  1613. 1:16:04made regarding the payment of overtime.
  1614. 1:16:07>> I mean, they sell it to you as if
  1615. 1:16:08you’re going to have a day left over.
  1616. 1:16:10>> 10 and 11 must be paid as overtime.
  1617. 1:16:13Exactly.
  1618. 1:16:13>> And if it's nighttime,
  1619. 1:16:16>> but there has to be a reform if you're
  1620. 1:16:18going to exceed it; if you start work
  1621. 1:16:20after 9 a.m., you pass the hour that
  1622. 1:16:23the labor code already defines as
  1623. 1:16:25nighttime. That's where the danger is,
  1624. 1:16:28that's the issue. You'll have people
  1625. 1:16:31working 11 hours, you're going to
  1626. 1:16:33reform the nighttime hours. Where are
  1627. 1:16:36you going to put the nighttime hours?
  1628. 1:16:38Because fitting 11 hours, fitting 11
  1629. 1:16:40hours into, let's say, work schedules,
  1630. 1:16:43most will end up in the middle. In
  1631. 1:16:46other words, most will end up with half
  1632. 1:16:48their workday that should be considered
  1633. 1:16:51additional. That's why the business
  1634. 1:16:53owners are happy. Allow me. And add to
  1635. 1:16:55this that you have people working four
  1636. 1:16:58days. But it doesn't mean that
  1637. 1:17:01manufacturers and merchants are going
  1638. 1:17:02to stop, they aren't going to stop
  1639. 1:17:03selling on Friday, Saturday, and Sunday
  1640. 1:17:05. They'll hire other people there or
  1641. 1:17:08they'll tell you to get another job if
  1642. 1:17:10you want, and now you'll have to put in
  1643. 1:17:1211 hours everywhere. Now, what happened
  1644. 1:17:16? We simply raised the work schedule in
  1645. 1:17:19general and lost the hard-won right to
  1646. 1:17:22not work more than 8 hours. The same,
  1647. 1:17:25but we gave it up, rather, because they
  1648. 1:17:26didn't take it away from us. And where
  1649. 1:17:28will the salary improvement be? Which
  1650. 1:17:30is what we were talking about with the
  1651. 1:17:32economic issue: with this,
  1652. 1:17:34macroeconomic numbers will grow. That
  1653. 1:17:37means the big businessman is earning
  1654. 1:17:38more, but that doesn't translate into
  1655. 1:17:40salary improvements for the one who
  1656. 1:17:41generates the wealth, which is the
  1657. 1:17:43worker.
  1658. 1:17:44>> They've said this would be optional,
  1659. 1:17:46but who decides what's optional? The
  1660. 1:17:49employee, the boss. And what happens to
  1661. 1:17:52the one who doesn't decide to enter
  1662. 1:17:56into this option? Let's see, regarding
  1663. 1:18:00being able to renew the workday, these
  1664. 1:18:04two proposals that exist, one to work 4
  1665. 1:18:07days, rest three, the others to work 10
  1666. 1:18:11hours from Monday to Thursday and four
  1667. 1:18:14on Friday. It's being done by the
  1668. 1:18:20Superior Labor Council, where the
  1669. 1:18:23current head of that ministry is. Let's
  1670. 1:18:29see, there is something that is very
  1671. 1:18:31elementary in this, because I have been
  1672. 1:18:34very consistent in inquiring about what
  1673. 1:18:37happened. Up until now, they are just
  1674. 1:18:40proposals, Luis. Uh, I was actually, uh
  1675. 1:18:43, watching the statements from the
  1676. 1:18:46deputy president of the Legislative
  1677. 1:18:48Assembly, where he said, uh, clearly
  1678. 1:18:51that he has not received from the
  1679. 1:18:53Presidency of the Republic, that is,
  1680. 1:18:56from the Executive branch, a proposal
  1681. 1:18:58to be, uh, analyzed and to be, uh,
  1682. 1:19:01what's it called?,approved from within
  1683. 1:19:04the legislative body. That is to say,
  1684. 1:19:07up to this moment, up to this day, uh,
  1685. 1:19:09October 2nd, there is no formal
  1686. 1:19:11proposal. Uh, maybe if, the current
  1687. 1:19:17head of that portfolio, uh, has reached
  1688. 1:19:20a consensus, uh, we will have to wait
  1689. 1:19:23to see if those measures could favor
  1690. 1:19:27the, uh, working sector and without.
  1691. 1:19:31doubt and, without a doubt, uh, the
  1692. 1:19:33important thing is that it arrives, uh,
  1693. 1:19:36at the Legislative Assembly, which is
  1694. 1:19:38where the corresponding decision will
  1695. 1:19:40be made. Look, on that part, I have a
  1696. 1:19:43certain affinity with the terms
  1697. 1:19:46Carlitos has used. It gives me the
  1698. 1:19:49impression that in a pre-election year,
  1699. 1:19:52with the sensitivity that the
  1700. 1:19:54Salvadoran worker has regarding being
  1701. 1:19:56told about 11-hour workdays, it seems
  1702. 1:19:59more like a test, uh, of measurement,
  1703. 1:20:01to see how much they can endure, uh,
  1704. 1:20:04this reform, rather than it really
  1705. 1:20:06happening. Uh, what worries me is that
  1706. 1:20:09later on, after the electoral process,
  1707. 1:20:11the reform might actually come to pass.
  1708. 1:20:15And because the business owners are
  1709. 1:20:17very happy, especially the industrial
  1710. 1:20:18ones, who are the ones who will extract
  1711. 1:20:20the exploitation, and also those in the
  1712. 1:20:22construction industry from the workers,
  1713. 1:20:24it is very complicated; because
  1714. 1:20:26regarding services, well, there's the
  1715. 1:20:27schedule, and we will all be working 11
  1716. 1:20:29hours. No, no, no, no, it's not that
  1717. 1:20:33they benefit more. Let's see, the
  1718. 1:20:35debate here also enters between
  1719. 1:20:37productivity and time, meaning that
  1720. 1:20:39>> yes, the thing is that you are only
  1721. 1:20:42talking about 11 effective hours of
  1722. 1:20:44work, but here you have people who take
  1723. 1:20:46up to 2 hours to get to work and almost
  1724. 1:20:48three to return and
  1725. 1:20:51>> that is why in the council they are
  1726. 1:20:53even including the transport operators,
  1727. 1:20:54it's very complicated
  1728. 1:20:56>> that they would have to extend their
  1729. 1:20:57hours and so on,
  1730. 1:20:59>> the education schedules of those who
  1731. 1:21:01are studying and who are working,
  1732. 1:21:05>> either in the public or private sector,
  1733. 1:21:07who manage to, uh, go to classes to
  1734. 1:21:09take one or two subjects during the
  1735. 1:21:11week. What is going to happen to these
  1736. 1:21:13people?
  1737. 1:21:14>> It is unknown if there will be any rest
  1738. 1:21:16. Remember that you currently have 4
  1739. 1:21:18hours of rest and another 4 hours, but
  1740. 1:21:21today you will have a 4-hour rest
  1741. 1:21:23period and a 7-hour continuous block.
  1742. 1:21:26So there will be a break between these
  1743. 1:21:28periods. These are things that must be
  1744. 1:21:30analyzed. There is also a proposal for
  1745. 1:21:3335 hours, earning the same salary, and
  1746. 1:21:36this has been talked about a bit,
  1747. 1:21:39meaning that, in the end, the worker,
  1748. 1:21:42uh...
  1749. 1:21:43>> The thing is, that doesn't benefit the
  1750. 1:21:44employer. To me, it's clear that this
  1751. 1:21:46is a...
  1752. 1:21:47>> But the time for this rest, because
  1753. 1:21:48that's more or less where this proposal
  1754. 1:21:50is heading...
  1755. 1:21:52>> to become productive; here you have
  1756. 1:21:54business owners, like those in
  1757. 1:21:56restaurants, who already make people
  1758. 1:21:57work 11 hours without paying them for
  1759. 1:21:59it. They have you start work at 9, at 2
  1760. 1:22:03in the afternoon they send you home—
  1761. 1:22:06they send you home in theory—and at 5
  1762. 1:22:08you come back in, so they don't have to
  1763. 1:22:10pay for those hours, and they split
  1764. 1:22:12your 8 or 9-hour workday. into two
  1765. 1:22:15parts so they don't have to pay more.
  1766. 1:22:17And I haven't seen anyone coming in to
  1767. 1:22:19follow up on these people, and those
  1768. 1:22:21people are being exploited. You also
  1769. 1:22:23have private security guards who also
  1770. 1:22:25receive that kind of treatment. In
  1771. 1:22:28other words, it's already happening,
  1772. 1:22:30and we already know how they are
  1773. 1:22:32treated, and since our time is running
  1774. 1:22:34out, it's time to modernize the way we
  1775. 1:22:36work as well. That includes the issue
  1776. 1:22:39of working from home,
  1777. 1:22:41>> working from home and so on. the days
  1778. 1:22:44you contribute to the pension fund and
  1779. 1:22:46the days you contribute to something
  1780. 1:22:48else. But, but I'm getting to this.
  1781. 1:22:51It's time to review these workdays
  1782. 1:22:53because times are changing; there are a
  1783. 1:22:56lot of bosses who think if they don't
  1784. 1:22:58see you sitting down, you aren't
  1785. 1:23:00working, and they want to pay you for
  1786. 1:23:02hours spent sitting.
  1787. 1:23:05>> That's why I said, productivity versus
  1788. 1:23:07time, because someone can be productive
  1789. 1:23:09in a short amount of time,
  1790. 1:23:11>> but if the full workday isn't there, no
  1791. 1:23:13.
  1792. 1:23:13>> Look, Luis, there are undoubtedly these
  1793. 1:23:15proposals. You know what? I haven't
  1794. 1:23:18referred to this topic much because, in
  1795. 1:23:21the end, they are just speculations.
  1796. 1:23:24Now, once it is within the legislative
  1797. 1:23:26body and submitted for the
  1798. 1:23:28corresponding study, I will undoubtedly
  1799. 1:23:30make a statement. But at this moment, I
  1800. 1:23:34reiterate, as far as I have inquired
  1801. 1:23:36and heard statements from the presiding
  1802. 1:23:38deputy, there is no formal proposal
  1803. 1:23:39from the executive branch to submit for
  1804. 1:23:41study to the Assembly. So, therefore,
  1805. 1:23:46as long as these proposals exist and
  1806. 1:23:48haven't been brought where they need to
  1807. 1:23:50be for a decision to be made, I won't
  1808. 1:23:52—look, only those made by the
  1809. 1:23:53National Labor Council,
  1810. 1:23:56>> for a couple of quick things. Uh, a
  1811. 1:24:00call to the state. I know you already
  1812. 1:24:03made the Christmas bonus payment
  1813. 1:24:05yesterday for public workers, men and
  1814. 1:24:06women. Man, don't forget the child
  1815. 1:24:09support payments for the kids. They
  1816. 1:24:12won't have it in December, and there
  1817. 1:24:14are a lot of irresponsible people who,
  1818. 1:24:15there will be no human power that can
  1819. 1:24:17pry the money that belongs to those
  1820. 1:24:18minors out of them, regarding support
  1821. 1:24:20payments, same with the 25th paycheck.
  1822. 1:24:23And finally, a greeting to the national
  1823. 1:24:25team. Hopefully today we won't be, uh,
  1824. 1:24:28the laughingstock, and we give the
  1825. 1:24:30Salvadoran people the joy they deserve.
  1826. 1:24:33>> We must continue to trust in the
  1827. 1:24:35process.
  1828. 1:24:35>> We must continue to trust in the
  1829. 1:24:36process.
  1830. 1:24:37>> We must continue to trust in the
  1831. 1:24:38process.
  1832. 1:24:39>> Thank you,
  1833. 1:24:39>> because today we can't blame the last
  1834. 1:24:4120 years.
  1835. 1:24:42>> Thanks to the three of you. Thank you,
  1836. 1:24:46Carlos Hueso. Thanks to the three of
  1837. 1:24:47you.
  1838. 1:24:47>> Luis, thanks for the invitation. Happy
  1839. 1:24:49Friday to all the Salvadoran people,
  1840. 1:24:51and stop defending your method so much
  1841. 1:24:53because if you don't, it will never
  1842. 1:24:54walk, it will always keep crawling. A
  1843. 1:24:56hug.
  1844. 1:24:57>> Very well. Thank you, dear viewer, for
  1845. 1:25:00being there every morning. Stay tuned
  1846. 1:25:02to the programming of Grupo Megavisión
  1847. 1:25:04. Good morning.

About this transcript

This page contains the full transcript of Viernes 02 de Octubre | Iniciamos Diálogo 21 by Diálogo 21, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 11,884 words across 1,847 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.

What you can do with it

Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.

Free YouTube transcript tool

YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.