Video Game Remakes Are Good (Even When They're Bad) — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:02After the credits roll for the first
- 0:04installment in the video game series
- 0:06Kingdom Hearts, there is an epilogue.
- 0:08Sora and his companions, Disney's Donald
- 0:10and Goofy, have defeated the villain of
- 0:12the first game, but are still on the
- 0:14hunt for their king, Mickey Mouse. And
- 0:17while walking on a grassy road, they met
- 0:19with none other than Mickey's dog Pluto.
- 0:21This is a very important cutscene to the
- 0:23series because it tells the player that
- 0:25even though this adventure is done,
- 0:27another one is just beginning. But
- 0:29during its sequel, Kingdom Hearts 2,
- 0:30there is a flashback to this scene. And
- 0:33um what's going on with Pluto in the
- 0:35background? His character is just sort
- 0:37of sliding, not animated. Now, you might
- 0:39think this is some kind of lazy mistake
- 0:41from the developers, but this is not the
- 0:43original Kingdom Hearts video game. This
- 0:45is an HD port of the game for PS4,
- 0:48Kingdom Hearts HD 1.5 2.5 Remix. So,
- 0:52what does this scene look like in the
- 0:53original game that came out in 2005?
- 0:56Here on a CRT, that old box TV you used
- 0:59to have, Sora, Donald, and Goofy spot
- 1:01Pluto.
- 1:03>> Gosh, that's the king's sail.
- 1:05>> Hey, have you seen King Mickey?
- 1:07>> But when you look at his sliding
- 1:09animation in the background, it looks
- 1:11totally fine. He still isn't animated,
- 1:13but the PS2 running Kingdom Hearts 2 at
- 1:15its original resolution on an old TV
- 1:18softens the character enough that he
- 1:20just looks like he's running. This
- 1:22detail is very small and inconsequential
- 1:24to the enjoyment of Kingdom Hearts as a
- 1:26whole, but it does give us a window into
- 1:28the overarching changes that HD
- 1:29remasters make importing an old game in
- 1:31its exact state to modern technology.
- 1:33>> Video game consoles from the very
- 1:35beginning have changed physically with
- 1:37the evolution of technology, meaning you
- 1:39can't take the original Pong joystick
- 1:41and plug it into your PS5. An Xbox 360
- 1:44can't play old Atari cartridges or later
- 1:47Xbox titles for the Xbox One or the Xbox
- 1:50Series X. Also, for people that don't
- 1:52play games a lot, while PlayStation was
- 1:53making the PlayStation 1, PlayStation 2,
- 1:563, 4, and 5. Xbox was making the Xbox,
- 2:00the Xbox 360, the Xbox One, the Xbox
- 2:03Series S, and the Xbox Series X. Just a
- 2:07simple way to keep track of what's
- 2:09coming out in what order. So, to keep
- 2:11these games from falling into obscurity
- 2:12in a basement closet, they need to be
- 2:14remade for the digital era. But, the
- 2:16second you start talking about remaking
- 2:18a piece of art, something starts
- 2:20bubbling deep in my core. Suddenly, I
- 2:23become extremely protective of the
- 2:25original. Like a mama bear protecting
- 2:27her cub, or like a mama wolf protecting
- 2:31her cub, or like a graphic tee wearing
- 2:34gaming YouTuber ready to make a
- 2:3520-minute-long video essay just
- 2:38absolutely screaming. Tifa's bra from
- 2:41the original, even though it was I'm
- 2:43sorry, I couldn't I couldn't even listen
- 2:44to it for a second. I couldn't take it.
- 2:46That mama bear is in me for good reason.
- 2:49But, allow us to talk to the mama bear
- 2:51in you for just a moment.
- 2:55Hey, mama. So, video games are actually
- 2:57a really interesting medium when it
- 2:58comes to remakes. There's a lot of
- 3:00really good reasons for them, and even
- 3:02when they suck, we think it can actually
- 3:04be a net good for the art form in
- 3:06general. Now, that doesn't mean that you
- 3:08should just shut up and consume. I would
- 3:10never tell you to shut up. You are a
- 3:12mother. But, video game remakes come in
- 3:14a ton of shapes and sizes. They range
- 3:16from soulless and broken to some being
- 3:19transformative of the original. So, to
- 3:21make this conversation a little easier,
- 3:24sail away with us to the land of video
- 3:27game remakes. We made a map.
- 3:33The land of video game remakes takes
- 3:35place in a region of the world that
- 3:36exists with our modern technology. The
- 3:38new world, if you will, sharing a side
- 3:40of the globe with new video game
- 3:42releases like Fortnite and Ghost of
- 3:44Tsushima. All of that old tech with its
- 3:47classic catalog of games exists across
- 3:50the sea and needs to be brought over to
- 3:52the new land with some kind of
- 3:53technological remake. This old land is
- 3:56one we like to call nostalgia.
- 4:00My hand went off screen, try to go
- 4:01lower.
- 4:02>> This is where controllers had wires and
- 4:04games played on discs or cartridges.
- 4:06Things you had to blow the dust off of
- 4:07before playing. When I was a kid, we
- 4:09used to blow our [laughter] games, okay?
- 4:12Kids these days are so [ __ ] soft,
- 4:14dude. It's crazy. This generation
- 4:16couldn't handle plugging in a
- 4:17controller, bro. We smart, they dumb.
- 4:20>> Easy. First we sail across the waters to
- 4:22the most direct line from nostalgia.
- 4:24Port.
- 4:26Port. One of the most productive states
- 4:27of the land of remakes and very
- 4:29important for video game preservation.
- 4:31This is where games are ported directly
- 4:33to new consoles and PC with an exact
- 4:35copy of the original code or a
- 4:37one-to-one recreation of it. If you go
- 4:39on Steam or any of the various console
- 4:41digital stores, you're sure to find a
- 4:43ton of these. However, when you port the
- 4:45exact code from something like Final
- 4:47Fantasy VII, for example, to modern
- 4:50monitors, it's not really the exact same
- 4:52game anymore, is it?
- 4:54>> The CRT aspect we mentioned before is a
- 4:56huge factor in this. We are not the
- 4:58first ones to point this out, but retro
- 5:00pixel art in games did not look like
- 5:02this because it wasn't displayed on
- 5:04high-resolution monitors. It looked more
- 5:06like this, a much softer image that
- 5:08displays a game's art style in a
- 5:10completely different way.
- 5:11>> This is what the original game looks
- 5:13like on my PS5, but this is what it
- 5:16originally looked like to anyone playing
- 5:18it in 1997.
- 5:31>> [music]
- 5:33>> Now, it would be nice to be able to
- 5:35re-render the Final Fantasy VII
- 5:36backgrounds for modern monitors and see
- 5:38how they look instead of crudely hitting
- 5:40low-res art with an HD magnifying glass,
- 5:43but Square Enix literally does not have
- 5:45them anymore. The director of the remake
- 5:47told Eurogamer, "Game development back
- 5:49then was a lot more wild west. A lot of
- 5:51material was just not kept. Data
- 5:53management wasn't done to modern
- 5:55standards, so yeah, there's basically
- 5:57nothing. There's some character design
- 5:58sketches I think we've still got, and
- 6:00obviously anything that was published
- 6:01separately, written documents, design
- 6:03documents, etc. Yeah, there's basically
- 6:06nothing to work on. So even if they
- 6:08wanted to make a one-to-one copy, they'd
- 6:10have to start from scratch anyway." In
- 6:12all forms of media, things are
- 6:14constantly being remade, redone, and
- 6:16rebooted. Some of these things look to
- 6:18be blatant cash grabs at the original
- 6:20success of what it's remaking. But we
- 6:22think video game remakes sometimes
- 6:24unfairly receive the criticisms of being
- 6:26soulless and just made for profit, when
- 6:28they're actually completely different at
- 6:30their core than say a remake of a movie.
- 6:33Back in the days before streaming came
- 6:34along, the idea of a movie remake made a
- 6:36lot more sense. And that's due to
- 6:38something we like to call access to
- 6:41media.
- 6:42Beloved movies like Ocean's 11 or True
- 6:44Grit brought scripts and ideas to
- 6:46audiences that simply missed out on the
- 6:48originals. Sure, a 12-year-old in 2001
- 6:51could maybe hear about the original
- 6:53Ocean's 11 with the Rat Pack from his
- 6:56grandpa, go to a Blockbuster and hope
- 6:58that they have it on VHS there. However,
- 7:01the original came out in theaters. A VHS
- 7:04copy, if it exists, would be viewed on a
- 7:06tape on a CRT TV. The original intended
- 7:09experience of Ocean's 11 1960 was to see
- 7:11it on film in a theater. So not only did
- 7:14it take effort to get it on tape, but it
- 7:16was a format that didn't match the
- 7:17original. So that 12-year-old is
- 7:19probably going to just go watch Clooney
- 7:21in theaters and like it as a new thing.
- 7:24Nowadays, if they decided to remake
- 7:26Ocean's 11, you could swipe off the
- 7:28disgusting film announcement tweet, tap
- 7:30a few times, and cast the original 4K
- 7:32HDR stream to your TV, which is pretty
- 7:34damn close to experiencing it how it was
- 7:36intended. This is why we think some
- 7:38recent remakes feel even more
- 7:40unnecessary than ever. When Disney
- 7:42announced a live-action remake of Moana,
- 7:44my first reaction was, "What do you
- 7:46mean? Moana came out last year." Moana
- 7:49didn't come out last year. It actually
- 7:51came out 10 years ago. [ __ ] But since
- 7:54the 2016 release of Moana, it's always
- 7:57been just two clicks away. Unlike the
- 7:59old days of the Disney Vault, Moana and
- 8:02Frozen never left. Our niece loves them
- 8:04both like they came out yesterday. So
- 8:06when you tell me that they're making a
- 8:08new one with The Rock in a wig,
- 8:10>> it's just like, "We have one already."
- 8:12>> Right. Nice.
- 8:13>> This is not the case with video games
- 8:15that came out before the digital era and
- 8:17that exist on nostalgia. Because while
- 8:19something like Final Fantasy VII is just
- 8:21two clicks away, it looks and feels
- 8:24different from how it used to in a way
- 8:26that can't really be achieved digitally.
- 8:28And I promise you that we are not just
- 8:30being romantic about the CRT just to do
- 8:32it. There is a real warmth that comes
- 8:34from the softening of a game's jagged
- 8:36pixel edges and most of it is
- 8:38subconscious.
- 8:39>> I've been playing the original recently
- 8:40on this CRT and after a few minutes you
- 8:43stop thinking about it as an old game
- 8:45and just accept the experience playing
- 8:47on the magic box in front of you.
- 8:49>> For some reason, and we can't really
- 8:50explain why, playing an old game ported
- 8:53on a modern system makes it feel older.
- 8:55It shares a homepage with Red Dead 2 and
- 8:58GTA 6. An HD screen exposes the flaws
- 9:01that were never meant to be seen. Also,
- 9:03let's be honest with ourselves here.
- 9:04Whenever a remake gets announced and
- 9:06people talk about how it'll never be as
- 9:07good as the original and that you should
- 9:09just play that one,
- 9:10>> it can be expensive as hell to play in
- 9:12its original format.
- 9:13>> Let's say they announce a remake for
- 9:15Pokémon Sapphire, but you want to play
- 9:17the original. Then you'd have to go buy
- 9:18a Game Boy for like 50 to $100. And
- 9:21after that, you'd have to pay an
- 9:22additional $160
- 9:25to $200 to get Sapphire because it's so
- 9:28rare. And yeah, sure, you could play it
- 9:30on an emulator on your PC and it is
- 9:31still Pokémon Sapphire, but you're
- 9:33missing a large part of the experience.
- 9:36No matter how much you emulate it on
- 9:37your PC in your 30s, it will never feel
- 9:41like playing it on a Game Boy on your
- 9:42porch in the summer as a child. Even
- 9:45with a PS2 or GameCube game, you'd have
- 9:47to buy a heavy-ass CRT for hundreds of
- 9:49dollars and wheel it out every time you
- 9:51want to use it like a teacher showing a
- 9:53Bill Nye tape to distract her class from
- 9:55the horrifying footage they just saw of
- 9:579/11 or the Challenger explosion. So,
- 10:00yes, you can port the game or you can do
- 10:02something different. New Oldia is for
- 10:04games that have largely been kept the
- 10:06same but with a fresh coat of paint. The
- 10:08goal of this kind of remake is to
- 10:09preserve the core of the gameplay,
- 10:11keeping the mechanics, controls, and
- 10:13general layout identical while also
- 10:15upgrading the presentation through
- 10:16modern lighting, textures, and redone
- 10:18music. Spyro Reignited Trilogy on the
- 10:20PS4 plays nearly identical to how Spyro
- 10:23did on the PS1, but it has a completely
- 10:26modernized art style, menus, and a newly
- 10:29composed soundtrack.
- 10:30>> In 2018, a remake of the acclaimed 2005
- 10:33Shadow of the Colossus was remade for
- 10:35the PlayStation 4. The original was a
- 10:37very unique game with barely any combat,
- 10:39a large and empty world full of
- 10:41atmosphere, and maybe some of the worst
- 10:43performance for a game on the PS2.
- 10:45>> Colossus ran at 20 frames per second at
- 10:48best. However, the tone has been
- 10:50slightly changed due to the visuals. And
- 10:52while the game is known for its scale,
- 10:54it clearly pushed the PS2 to the limits
- 10:57of its power. This thing is at its
- 10:59limit.
- 11:00>> The developer of the remake, Bluepoint,
- 11:02used the original code of the game and
- 11:04rebuilt the visuals on top of it. And
- 11:06the result is, by far, one of the
- 11:08prettiest games I've ever played in my
- 11:10life. But, the tone of the game has
- 11:11slightly changed due to the visuals. It
- 11:13clearly has an extra splash of color,
- 11:15mainly in its greens to the foliage or
- 11:18grass that's a little bit more lush than
- 11:20the original. Moving to another section
- 11:21of New Oldia, The Elder Scrolls Oblivion
- 11:24remake was released last year, and it
- 11:25rebuilt all of the visuals for modern
- 11:27hardware.
- 11:28>> Every model and texture was remade, ray
- 11:30tracing was added for photorealistic
- 11:32lighting and animations were completely
- 11:34redone. But, underneath all of the
- 11:35visuals, the original game is still
- 11:37running everything else. So, while the
- 11:39game looks entirely different, it plays
- 11:41functionally identical. So much so that
- 11:43bugs from the original game, like weird
- 11:46NPC movements and behaviors, are still
- 11:48in this version as well.
- 11:49>> These changes modernize old games, but
- 11:52also, duh, change them. It looks
- 11:55different, and how a game looks is very
- 11:57important. However, that's not
- 11:59inherently a bad thing. These remakes
- 12:01have their own meticulous art direction
- 12:03that has artists trying their best to
- 12:05reimagine everything in a modern way,
- 12:07while respecting the original vision and
- 12:10style of what came before it.
- 12:11>> This, there's a lot of detail that's
- 12:13been sculpted [music] into here.
- 12:15The original version of it was very
- 12:17flat. We went in and kind of banged
- 12:19[music] it up, scratched it, you know,
- 12:21kind of told a story in the model. Chips
- 12:23and broken things that were were implied
- 12:26in the original, but now that we have
- 12:28such
- 12:29high resolution, we can actually see it.
- 12:31>> Developers do not take an old disc of a
- 12:34game that you love and put it through a
- 12:36realistic graphics machine. Shadow of
- 12:38the Colossus looks different in a way
- 12:40that can spark a healthy debate on what
- 12:42the two atmospheres do for the general
- 12:44experience while having their own pros
- 12:46and cons. If you like the old, grayer,
- 12:49less green atmosphere, you might still
- 12:51prefer the working, newer frame rate in
- 12:54the Colossus remake.
- 12:55>> There is definitely a risk of new
- 12:57developers interpreting a game too much
- 12:59and going too far with the changes they
- 13:01make.
- 13:01>> But, before we tell you, a quick word
- 13:04from fan favorite Tiny Tony.
- 13:06>> Hi, I'm Tiny Tony and I'm so small I use
- 13:08a bottle cap as a swimming pool.
- 13:11This video is sponsored by Rocket Money.
- 13:13Tiny Tony is terrible at remembering
- 13:15just how many subscriptions are still
- 13:16active under my name. With nearly
- 13:18everything becoming a subscription these
- 13:20days, it's impossible to keep track of
- 13:21every business that is charging your
- 13:23card every month. Rocket Money has
- 13:24legitimately helped Tiny Tony in
- 13:26canceling those unwanted lingering
- 13:28subscriptions and saving me big bucks.
- 13:30The bucks are regular size, but I'm just
- 13:32so small. Rocket Money automatically
- 13:35tracks subscriptions in one place and
- 13:37helps cancel unwanted ones in app with
- 13:39just a few taps. It also sends real-time
- 13:41alerts for large transactions, upcoming
- 13:43bills, refunds, new subscriptions, and
- 13:46low balances. Rocket Money can help
- 13:47create budgets or category specific
- 13:49spending goals with special insights and
- 13:51weekly or monthly spending reports. The
- 13:53app also features no ads whether you're
- 13:55using the free or paid version, so you
- 13:57can manage your money without feeling
- 13:59like you're being marketed to. Go to
- 14:00rocketmoney.com/burback
- 14:02to sign up today. You can also scan the
- 14:04QR code or click the link in our
- 14:06description. I don't see a tiny
- 14:07lifeguard here. This can't be up to tiny
- 14:10code. Let's look at the PS5 remake of
- 14:12Demon's Souls, a game also made by
- 14:14Bluepoint. The original game was the
- 14:16first of the Souls genre and is iconic
- 14:18for its difficulty as well as its
- 14:20distinct dark fantasy atmosphere. It was
- 14:23a game that didn't come close to the
- 14:24reach of its successors in Dark Souls or
- 14:27Elden Ring, but is still beloved by its
- 14:29fans and a staple of the PS3 era. The
- 14:31remake was a launch title for the PS5,
- 14:33so Bluepoint made a lot of changes in
- 14:35the visuals in trying to showcase what
- 14:37the PS5 was capable of. Since the
- 14:39original was 14 years old at this point,
- 14:41not all of those changes were completely
- 14:43true to the original designs of the game
- 14:45and a lot of people were upset by that.
- 14:47There is an argument that a remake
- 14:49should stay 100% true to the original
- 14:51design that the creator and developers
- 14:52intended. That being said, here's what
- 14:54the creator of the game, Hidetaka
- 14:56Miyazaki, had to say about the remake in
- 14:58an interview with Edge Magazine. I have
- 15:00not played the Demon's Souls remake, but
- 15:02I'm very glad to see it get this fresh
- 15:04look. These brand new current gen
- 15:05graphics. It was an old game, so to see
- 15:08it get remade in this way and have new
- 15:10players playing it was obviously
- 15:12something that made me very happy. One
- 15:14thing that was really fun was seeing
- 15:16Bluepoint Games come up with things we
- 15:18didn't even consider and to approach
- 15:20certain elements of the game, the
- 15:21visuals and its mechanics, in a way that
- 15:23we either couldn't or didn't back in the
- 15:25day. So, to see them researching and
- 15:27applying these new thought processes and
- 15:29new techniques, this was something that
- 15:31was really exciting and interesting to
- 15:33me. Which is not a full-glowing review
- 15:35of the game, and hey, he could have just
- 15:37been polite because it's good business
- 15:39to be that way. But, an open
- 15:40conversation about these changes seemed
- 15:43to be a civil one when it comes to the
- 15:45original creator.
- 15:46>> These new versions can create really
- 15:48nuanced discussions about the
- 15:49transformation of art styles with
- 15:50technology. And thank god gamers are
- 15:53good at nuanced discussion.
- 15:56>> What's happening down there?
- 16:00>> All right.
- 16:02>> After years of anticipation, the Ocarina
- 16:04of Time remake has finally been
- 16:06announced. One of the most iconic games
- 16:09of all time is being remade for a modern
- 16:11audience, and the response has been a
- 16:13mix of excitement by some and also a lot
- 16:16of anger from long-time fans. This is
- 16:18one of the trickiest parts of doing
- 16:20remakes.
- 16:20>> Ocarina of Time was one of the very
- 16:23first fantasy 3D worlds that you could
- 16:25explore. It was able to take a 2D
- 16:27adventure game and properly translate it
- 16:29to 3D with a sense of adventure and
- 16:31wonder that no one had seen yet. That
- 16:33kind of experience leaves a big
- 16:35impression on a person and resonates
- 16:37emotionally. Everyone who grew up
- 16:39playing it has their own moments that
- 16:40wowed them. It could be the first time
- 16:42they saw Hyrule Field, or exploring
- 16:44their first temple, or just being
- 16:46impressed by the scale of the giant
- 16:48mustache tree, or it could just be
- 16:50watching your older sibling beat a boss,
- 16:52or a specific NPC interaction. But, the
- 16:55problem with remaking a game is there
- 16:56are many ways to interpret it both
- 16:58visually and mechanically, and every
- 17:00choice in that interpretation might take
- 17:03away that one specific thing that you
- 17:05liked as a child. Was having a fixed
- 17:07camera that rotates to follow Link
- 17:09around a town an artistic choice, or was
- 17:11it done because the N64 couldn't
- 17:13possibly render an entire town and
- 17:16animated people outside of the camera
- 17:18view at the same time. But the feeling
- 17:20of that camera may be something that a
- 17:22fan of the original felt was important
- 17:24to the experience. These are the types
- 17:26of decisions a team remaking a game
- 17:28would have to consider. What was
- 17:29intended, what was a limitation, and
- 17:31what could be improved upon without
- 17:33changing the core aspects of the game's
- 17:34identity. Luckily for Ocarina of Time,
- 17:37it's being produced by two of the
- 17:39longest working creators of the Zelda
- 17:41games. One of which was the director of
- 17:43both Ocarina of Time and Majora's Mask.
- 17:46And a big criticism of the game has been
- 17:48its art direction. Specifically, that
- 17:50the modern lighting and textures look
- 17:52like this fan-made version of the game
- 17:54made in Unreal Engine from a few years
- 17:56ago. But we'd argue that beyond the fact
- 17:58that both have realistic lighting and
- 18:00shadows, there aren't many similarities
- 18:02between the two of them as it seems.
- 18:04First being that the remake has an
- 18:06actual art direction to it. And to be
- 18:08clear, the fan-made version of the game
- 18:10is extremely impressive. This single
- 18:12person, CryZENx, passionately recreated
- 18:15the game with their own faithful
- 18:17modernized art style for years. Here is
- 18:19the frame of the Unreal Engine fan-made
- 18:21version that people are saying the new
- 18:23remake looks just like. And this is what
- 18:26they're saying looks exactly the same.
- 18:28The big criticism here is that
- 18:30Nintendo's remake is just a company
- 18:32modernizing a piece of art by
- 18:33prioritizing realistic graphics. This is
- 18:36not realism. This is a fantasy art
- 18:38style. You may not like what you're
- 18:39looking at, and that's totally fine. But
- 18:42it's not a video game company just doing
- 18:44a remake with realistic graphics just to
- 18:46modernize it.
- 18:47>> And I'm sure some of you are like, "Come
- 18:49on, they both look similar." Yeah,
- 18:52because they're both based off of
- 18:53Ocarina of Time. They're both a little
- 18:55blonde boy in a forest. But you can't
- 18:57sit here and tell me that this art style
- 19:00looks like this. And before anyone says
- 19:03we're just defending Nintendo, I don't
- 19:05care about that company enough to argue
- 19:07with gamers for them.
- 19:09>> I don't even own a Switch.
- 19:10>> I do. I got one off credit card points
- 19:12to play Picopia and it's been collecting
- 19:14dust ever since.
- 19:15>> Even when it comes to the faces of the
- 19:17characters in the remake, which some
- 19:18people criticized for looking off, is
- 19:20most likely an intentional style. For
- 19:22one, young Link's appearance seems to be
- 19:24taken almost directly from the concept
- 19:27art of the original game. So, if we're
- 19:28talking about being true to the original
- 19:31vision, you can't really get closer than
- 19:33that. The lead artist for Majora's Mask
- 19:35said that the designs could have been
- 19:36inspired by Shigeru Miyamoto's love for
- 19:38Japanese wooden dolls.
- 19:40>> Replying to the announcement with, "What
- 19:42I felt when I saw this model, I feel
- 19:44that Mr. Miyamoto's doll play lover is
- 19:46firmly expressed here."
- 19:48>> What?
- 19:49>> I feel like I need to translate that
- 19:50again.
- 19:50>> Oh, okay. That makes more sense.
- 19:52>> He likes dolls. He's not a doll play
- 19:54lover.
- 19:54>> The thing is, even if you know about the
- 19:57wooden puppets or the fantasy art style,
- 19:59you still don't have to like the way it
- 20:01looks. Visual art styles are, duh,
- 20:04visual. And if you don't like what you
- 20:06see, we can't sit here and be like, "Um,
- 20:08checkmate. There are wooden puppets that
- 20:10inspired it. You actually do like what
- 20:12you're looking at."
- 20:13>> If I'm being honest, I didn't even like
- 20:14looking at the original design, so I'm
- 20:16not surprised people don't like the new
- 20:18one. Okay, so New Oldia is a direct
- 20:20remake of a game with modern graphics.
- 20:22>> Yes.
- 20:23>> Okay, then what is Final Fantasy VII
- 20:25then?
- 20:28I did.
- 20:35But games in New Oldia are based on
- 20:37discs that were experienced with no
- 20:39internet connection and no interaction
- 20:41with the outside world. Most games were
- 20:43this way up until the early 2000s.
- 20:45Online gaming slowly grew in the general
- 20:47public's eye with internet adapters for
- 20:49the PS2 and the Xbox, but really first
- 20:52took hold on PC with games like Quake,
- 20:54World of Warcraft, or Counter-Strike.
- 20:56>> And yes, there were games before that,
- 20:57but
- 20:58general public didn't [ __ ] know.
- 21:00>> Consoles followed suit with the
- 21:01explosion of Xbox Live, party chat, and
- 21:03the era of first-person shooters.
- 21:07>> You see, we're already signed up. It was
- 21:09way easy, just took a couple of minutes
- 21:10and we're good to go.
- 21:12Once you've signed up, you never have to
- 21:13do it again. Plus, you get to pick your
- 21:15gamer tag, you know, your online
- 21:17identity. Mine's uh Dark Master. I play
- 21:20every game as Dark Master
- 21:22>> [music]
- 21:22>> and uh people are starting to recognize
- 21:24who I am.
- 21:25>> like Halo 3 and Call of Duty 4 could not
- 21:27exist without a server for your PC or
- 21:29console to connect to. Running servers
- 21:31like this costs money. So, similar to
- 21:33the way that Square Enix deleted old
- 21:35Final Fantasy VII files to save space,
- 21:38once Microsoft and Activision saw player
- 21:39numbers dwindle as new Call of Duty and
- 21:41Halo games came out, they shut down the
- 21:43servers of the older games.
- 21:45>> So, hop on your horse and let's head
- 21:46over to the solution to saving these
- 21:48games, Server City. Server
- 21:52City, where the games are saved on
- 21:55servers. There's nothing you can do.
- 22:00>> to. Here in Server City, developers
- 22:02bring back online games that have been
- 22:04long forgotten. Giving millennials and
- 22:06Gen Xers the opportunity to shut the
- 22:08[ __ ] up for a second about the old games
- 22:10they loved being gone, so they can play
- 22:13them again. In reality, though, there is
- 22:15a real magic to bringing these game
- 22:17servers back. Let's take Halo 3 for
- 22:19example, one of our favorite games of
- 22:21all time. Halo 3 isn't just connected to
- 22:23fond childhood memories of our singular
- 22:25or sibling experiences. It was a real
- 22:28cultural moment. This was a social space
- 22:30that we spent time in for years. But as
- 22:33time went by, we all
- 22:35>> moved on to newer that didn't play it
- 22:37anymore.
- 22:38>> Then in 2014, Microsoft announced the
- 22:40release of Halo: The Master Chief
- 22:41Collection, a package of all the major
- 22:43Halo games together, including their
- 22:45multiplayer modes running on modern Xbox
- 22:48hardware. Now, the launch of that was
- 22:49kind of a mess and the two largest
- 22:51player bases in gaming were PC and PS4.
- 22:54So, it wasn't until the PC release in
- 22:562019 that Halo returned to the cultural
- 22:58zeitgeist. And by that time, the online
- 23:01for Halo 3 on the 360 was essentially
- 23:03dead because most people like us were
- 23:05not playing our Xbox 360s anymore. The
- 23:07move to have active Halo servers on PC
- 23:09sort of forever cemented old Halo games
- 23:12as a social space you could play and
- 23:14return to now with no specific console
- 23:16required.
- 23:17>> These games essentially die when their
- 23:19servers get shut down and then are
- 23:21resurrected much more future-proof when
- 23:23they come out on the PC or the PS5.
- 23:26>> Or the Xbox Series S and X.
- 23:28>> That's the thing about this side of the
- 23:29globe in gaming. Once a game crosses
- 23:32over the ocean with modern tech, it's
- 23:34much more likely to be here forever.
- 23:36Server city is like one big time machine
- 23:38that brings the past to the future. But
- 23:40just because a game servers are still
- 23:42active
- 23:43>> doesn't mean the original is preserved.
- 23:45Live service games that have constant
- 23:46updates and expansions can move away
- 23:48from the original to being a completely
- 23:50different game than when you started
- 23:51playing. Fortnite looks much different
- 23:53than the days of its release and the
- 23:55same goes for Overwatch, Runescape,
- 23:57World of Warcraft and many more.
- 23:59>> And while intensely dedicated fans that
- 24:01constantly want new content may be happy
- 24:03with that, a large portion of people
- 24:05stop playing and miss what the original
- 24:07had to offer. So much so that Fortnite,
- 24:10WoW, Overwatch and Runescape all had
- 24:12loud rallying cries from the public to
- 24:14bring back the original game they loved.
- 24:17>> Runescape released an old school
- 24:19Runescape game that became so much of a
- 24:21hit it surpassed the current version
- 24:22they had leading them to go back to
- 24:24basics and start making new content in
- 24:27the spirit and actual 2007 game.
- 24:30>> And your reaction to the return of the
- 24:31original is completely based off of your
- 24:33taste and also your memory of it.
- 24:35Fortnite OG came out and we were both
- 24:37instantly like, yeah, this game is much
- 24:40better than what Fortnite has become,
- 24:41full stop. And we think people agreed
- 24:43because the release of Fortnite OG was
- 24:45the most played day in the game's
- 24:47history.
- 24:47>> But taking that cruise back to nostalgia
- 24:50sometimes isn't the best trip. I played
- 24:52Overwatch in 2016 and while I still play
- 24:55the game all the time, I was someone who
- 24:58was nostalgic for the original 2016
- 25:00version of the game. Then OverWatch
- 25:02introduced an OG 6v6 mode, and the
- 25:05second I saw the old UI and clicked to
- 25:07play one of the old versions of the
- 25:09characters, I was like, "Yeah, the the
- 25:11new one's way better." So, the OG
- 25:13versions of live service games move
- 25:15through server city sort of like a
- 25:16traveling circus. Some leave like
- 25:19OverWatch 2016 and Fortnite OG being the
- 25:22main mode of the game, and some stay
- 25:24forever like Old School RuneScape or
- 25:26WoW. So, let's move over to its sister
- 25:28city. All aboard the train Damn, is
- 25:30there a train here? What era is this?
- 25:32Sequel City is for when a game has
- 25:34already been beaten to death, but that
- 25:36intellectual property is just too damn
- 25:38good. Call of Duty 4: Modern Warfare
- 25:40released in 2007. Modern Warfare 2 came
- 25:43out in 2009. Then we got a third, and
- 25:45after that Call of Duty went down a long
- 25:47path of making increasingly mid games
- 25:49until people couldn't take it anymore.
- 25:51Then back in Server City, Call of Duty
- 25:534: Modern Warfare released for modern
- 25:55tech, and everybody praised how good it
- 25:56felt years later. So, the next obvious
- 25:59step was to reboot Call of Duty by
- 26:01making Call of Duty 4: Modern Warfare 1
- 26:05again. Call of Duty: Modern Warfare 2019
- 26:09released as a reboot and a sort of
- 26:11remake of the original. It wasn't a
- 26:13reskin of the old game like games in New
- 26:15Oldia, but more so developed while
- 26:17constantly looking at the poster of Call
- 26:19of Duty 4 2007 with hearts in their
- 26:22eyes. Except for some of the maps. The
- 26:24maps were like New Oldia because some of
- 26:25the maps were exactly the same and
- 26:28reskinned with modern graphics.
- 26:29>> Some were the same and some were
- 26:30different. The same goes for Doom 2016
- 26:33and Battlefront 1 and 2 made by Dice.
- 26:35There already was a Doom. There already
- 26:37were Battlefront 1 and 2, but these
- 26:40beloved games got a complete reboot with
- 26:42the same name made in the image of what
- 26:44the original felt like, but built from
- 26:46the ground up. It's less so a reskinned
- 26:48clone of a game and more like its child
- 26:51named after them. Now, this can get
- 26:53pretty dicey in what counts as a reboot
- 26:55and what counts as a direct sequel. God
- 26:57of War 2018 is the fourth game in the
- 26:59main series, but simply has the name God
- 27:01of War. It's the first in a trilogy and
- 27:03a spiritual successor to the old PS2
- 27:05games, but the story is a direct
- 27:07continuation of Kratos's life. Oh, so
- 27:10this is where Final Fantasy fits. It's
- 27:12like a reboot from the ground up, but
- 27:13they're changing the story in reference
- 27:15to the original in a way that it might
- 27:17be a sequel. Not exactly, Tony.
- 27:19>> Please move on. We'll talk about it
- 27:20later.
- 27:21>> Next, we will walk. Damn, we have to
- 27:23walk?
- 27:23>> We We didn't make a scale. It could be
- 27:25100 ft. It could be 3,000 mi.
- 27:28>> Okay, let's take a walk to Remake
- 27:30Empire, but first a stop in Texture
- 27:32Town. Texture Town is for games that are
- 27:34essentially ports, but have had their
- 27:36visuals upscaled for modern TVs. These
- 27:38are games like Kingdom Hearts 2 that
- 27:40were originally made for screens with a
- 27:41resolution of 480p. When you run that
- 27:44game in HD or even 4K, it reveals just
- 27:46how low quality the textures were.
- 27:48Here's the PS2 version of Kingdom Hearts
- 27:502 running on my computer at 4K. You can
- 27:53see just by looking at the characters in
- 27:55the environment that the textures are
- 27:56noticeably low resolution. Here is the
- 27:59same location in the HD collection,
- 28:01where all of the textures have been
- 28:02upscaled and cleaned up for HDTVs.
- 28:05Texture Town is where all the standard
- 28:06HD remasters of video games live. They
- 28:09require a lot of work, but if done well,
- 28:11you probably won't even notice the work
- 28:13they did that much because it'll just
- 28:14look how you remembered it in HD. Now,
- 28:17we find ourselves at the gates of the
- 28:19fastest rising clan in the land of video
- 28:21game remakes,
- 28:22>> Remake Empire.
- 28:24>> You know that was right in my ear.
- 28:26>> So, we've established that old games
- 28:27stay all the way over on nostalgia and
- 28:30take a great amount of effort to play if
- 28:32you want. When a game gets ported or
- 28:34brought over with updated textures, it's
- 28:36much easier to access, but an old game
- 28:39like that probably won't be bringing in
- 28:41many new players. New oldia games do
- 28:44bring some new fans to old games, but
- 28:46they still aren't modern additions to
- 28:48culture when it comes to gameplay,
- 28:50narrative, or acting performances. But,
- 28:52when it comes to video game series, we
- 28:53seem to see the same path to remake
- 28:55empire. Original games come out, and as
- 28:57new installments release, the series
- 28:59strays farther from what the originals
- 29:01were. People who have played the first
- 29:02six Assassin's Creeds are not getting
- 29:04the same experience out of Valhalla or
- 29:06Shadows. People that played Resident
- 29:08Evil 6 and loved it are enjoying it for
- 29:10different reasons than Resident Evil 2.
- 29:12Slowly, as video game series continue,
- 29:14>> it's very common that they experience a
- 29:16rift between fans. Old fans fall out of
- 29:19the series and beg for the games to be
- 29:20what they once were, while new fans
- 29:22enjoy the latest games without an
- 29:24appreciation for or connection to what
- 29:26came before them. And as a business,
- 29:28this is a problem because you don't want
- 29:30your customers to be split so heavily,
- 29:32especially if your latest additions are
- 29:34not as popular as the originals. So,
- 29:36years ago, Capcom, in a dire state as a
- 29:39company, did something interesting. They
- 29:41went back to their old Resident Evil
- 29:42games and started completely remaking
- 29:45>> them as if they were intended to come
- 29:46out today. They listened to what fans
- 29:48loved about the originals and made them
- 29:50into something new to bring them back
- 29:51into culture.
- 29:52>> To long-time fans, it's a way to
- 29:54experience some nostalgia, but also have
- 29:56a conversation with developers about
- 29:58what they loved about the series and
- 29:59inform the next sequels. And for newer
- 30:01fans, they got a completely new game
- 30:03that introduced them to the original.
- 30:05>> They go from someone who liked Resident
- 30:06Evil 7 as their first Resident Evil game
- 30:09to someone who knows ball about Resident
- 30:11Evil 4.
- 30:12>> One of the earliest 3D games to be
- 30:14transformed by a remake was the original
- 30:16Resident Evil, which came out in 1998
- 30:19for the PlayStation 1. Much like the PS1
- 30:21version of Final Fantasy 7, it relied on
- 30:233D characters standing on top of
- 30:25pre-rendered image backgrounds. But,
- 30:27instead of revisiting 20 years later for
- 30:29nostalgia, just 6 years after it
- 30:31released, Capcom went on to remake the
- 30:33game for the GameCube using much more
- 30:35complex and detailed renders,
- 30:37high-resolution characters, and motion
- 30:39capture performances. Just look at the
- 30:41difference between these two. The
- 30:42results are a complete transformation of
- 30:44the game into a much more atmospheric
- 30:46setting and a much greater emphasis on
- 30:48the game's horror. The remake ditches
- 30:50the almost fluorescently lit
- 30:52environments with bare walls and sharp
- 30:54edges for much more textured and
- 30:55detailed scenes that help sell the sense
- 30:57of space.
- 30:58>> It's a remake, but with way more sauce
- 31:00than the original. It's an example of
- 31:02how a remake doesn't have to be a
- 31:04reduction of an original vision, but
- 31:06actually through more time and better
- 31:08tech, it can bring that vision to life
- 31:10even more.
- 31:11>> And speaking of Resident Evil 4, Capcom
- 31:13was faced with a pretty big challenge to
- 31:15do the game justice when remaking it in
- 31:172023. Not only is Resident Evil 4 the
- 31:20most popular game in the series, it's
- 31:22also a staple of the survival horror
- 31:24genre, and it's regarded as probably one
- 31:26of the greatest games ever made. So, to
- 31:28reimagine the game for a modern audience
- 31:30while also staying true to how beloved
- 31:32the original was for old fans was like
- 31:34walking into a bear's den or like
- 31:37walking into a wolf's den.
- 31:39>> Luckily, Capcom was able to do just that
- 31:41and made a game that works for both old
- 31:43and new players. The original Resident
- 31:45Evil 4 is an action game with horror and
- 31:47survival elements.
- 31:49>> In the original, Leon is heavy. He turns
- 31:52slow and can only move forward and
- 31:53backward. When you aim, Leon stands
- 31:56still. So, if you're trying to defend
- 31:57yourself, you're always watching enemies
- 31:59slowly close in on you while you miss
- 32:02half of your shots. In the years since
- 32:04Resident Evil 4's release, fluidity in
- 32:06the way your character moves has become
- 32:07more common in the game's replay. And
- 32:09the original stop-to-aim style could
- 32:12feel outdated to a lot of new players.
- 32:14>> Something that a modern remake would
- 32:15have to acknowledge if the idea is to
- 32:17draw in a new audience.
- 32:18>> So, what Capcom did was allow the player
- 32:20to move slowly while they shoot, to
- 32:22parry the occasional attacks, and to
- 32:24move from left to right while walking
- 32:26and aiming. At the same time, they made
- 32:27enemies a little faster and more
- 32:29aggressive. This way, the controls can
- 32:31feel more responsive and modern to a new
- 32:33player while also maintaining the sense
- 32:35of anxiety when you're under attack that
- 32:37people had come to love.
- 32:39>> This also offers an adjusted experience
- 32:41from the original, giving you a reason
- 32:42to go back and play it.
- 32:44>> Do you like the slower stop-and-go feel
- 32:46of the older game? These experiences are
- 32:48now something to compare and discuss.
- 32:50>> But as an old fan, the remake has
- 32:51moments that are intended to directly
- 32:53pull the rug out from under you if you
- 32:55know it by heart.
- 32:56>> For example, in the opening of the game,
- 32:57you're attacked by a violent mob of
- 32:59infected villagers.
- 33:00>> You're stuck in the town square for a
- 33:01set amount of time and expected to
- 33:03survive.
- 33:04>> In the original, if you know it well,
- 33:05you'd likely climb the tower to safety
- 33:07and collect extra ammo. But if you do
- 33:09the same thing in the remake expecting
- 33:11safety,
- 33:14the floor collapses under you and forces
- 33:16you to improvise suddenly while being
- 33:18chased by Mr. Chainsaw.
- 33:19>> All of these changes are relatively
- 33:21small and do more to add to the
- 33:22experience rather than substantially
- 33:24change its core designs or philosophy.
- 33:27>> We've both played the remake and the
- 33:28original and can say that we had the
- 33:30same general experience with each. But
- 33:33what's cool is there's a reason to go
- 33:35back to the original after to see what's
- 33:37different.
- 33:37>> past few years, we've gotten Final
- 33:39Fantasy VII Remake and Rebirth, Dead
- 33:41Space, Silent Hill 2, all of the
- 33:43Resident Evil games, and Assassin's
- 33:44Creed Black Flag. Some of which, like
- 33:46Resident Evil, have actually informed
- 33:48the sequels by going back to the basics.
- 33:51>> Resident Evil Village, even though it's
- 33:52the eighth game in the series, is much
- 33:54more in line with the titles before
- 33:56five.
- 33:56>> Some of the aspects of these games are
- 33:58modernized in ways that new fans will
- 34:00love and old fans will hate.
- 34:02>> But overall, games in remake empire are
- 34:05the best of the best when it comes to
- 34:06remakes.
- 34:07>> Yes,
- 34:08>> it's changed a little and modernized in
- 34:10a way you might dislike.
- 34:11>> But it gives new fans the opportunity to
- 34:13feel that same feeling you felt when you
- 34:16played the original.
- 34:17>> Think about the first time you looked at
- 34:18an older kid playing Resident Evil 4 or
- 34:21Final Fantasy VII.
- 34:22>> Think about the world that unfolded in
- 34:24front of you.
- 34:25>> Not yet eroded by the passage of time or
- 34:27old technology.
- 34:29>> No matter what, you will never be able
- 34:31to give that experience to somebody who
- 34:33didn't live it in that moment. You won't
- 34:35even be able to relive it yourself. And
- 34:37once a remake that's actually really
- 34:39good pulls in a new fan, they are 1
- 34:41million times more likely to go back and
- 34:44appreciate the original than before.
- 34:46Growing up, we did not have anyone
- 34:48introduce us to Final Fantasy. At 6
- 34:50years old, the older kid down our
- 34:51street, Ryan, shout out Ryan, showed us
- 34:54Kingdom Hearts 1. This sparked a 23
- 34:57years long fandom with this fuck-ass
- 34:59series that is going strong to this day.
- 35:01>> But Cloud Strife was just that guy from
- 35:03that old game, Final Fantasy VII, and
- 35:06Hercules Coliseum to us. Until this
- 35:08year, when I gave Final Fantasy VII
- 35:10Remake a chance. Okay, so we can finally
- 35:13talk about Final Fantasy VII. Let's take
- 35:16our trip and pass through the plane of
- 35:18dead horses.
- 35:22Oh my god, there's something out there.
- 35:24What is it?
- 35:27Oh, it's just all the Skyrim releases.
- 35:29>> Yeah, look, it's Skyrim
- 35:30>> Xbox 360,
- 35:31>> Skyrim Special Edition, Skyrim
- 35:32Anniversary Edition.
- 35:34>> Oh, they added fishing to that one.
- 35:35>> Who's that in the back? Oh, it's Skyrim
- 35:37VR. Nobody ever talks about you.
- 35:39>> Doing fire spells in that one made it
- 35:40feel like I was that kid from Sky High.
- 35:43The fire one, not the goo one.
- 35:45>> Right.
- 35:45>> When looking at the land of video game
- 35:47remakes, Final Fantasy VII is a region
- 35:50of its own. The original Final Fantasy
- 35:52released for the PS1 in 1997. And since
- 35:552020, that one game has been remade into
- 35:58a modern trilogy. The game has
- 36:00completely modernized maps and levels,
- 36:02characters, controls, camera
- 36:04perspectives, writing, acting, menus,
- 36:06and combat, which all point to it being
- 36:09a part of remake empire. But unlike the
- 36:11games we just listed, as you progress in
- 36:13the remake trilogy, the story starts to
- 36:15not only have simple changes, but
- 36:17deviates from the original. Now, Tony
- 36:20hasn't started Rebirth yet, so we're
- 36:21going to do this spoiler-free. But the
- 36:23ending of Remake sets up a narrative
- 36:25that just would not be possible in the
- 36:27original. So, maybe this belongs in
- 36:29sequel city. Is it a disconnected reboot
- 36:31of the original like Modern Warfare 2019
- 36:34or Doom 2016? Well, no, because not only
- 36:37is the main story nearly identical, it
- 36:39seems to be connected to the original in
- 36:41a way that a remake never has. Okay, I
- 36:43lied. Tony hasn't played Rebirth, so I'm
- 36:45going to get a little bit into spoiler
- 36:47territory, so skip to this point in the
- 36:50video if you don't want to hear anything
- 36:51about Final Fantasy VII Rebirth. So, in
- 36:53Final Fantasy VII, the planet runs off
- 36:55of a gooey green energy called mako.
- 36:58But, mako is less of a chemical resource
- 37:00and more of a spiritual blood to the
- 37:02planet, given its power by the cycle of
- 37:04life. Sephiroth, the villain, and
- 37:06Aerith, an angel, are connected to what
- 37:08is called the lifestream. Basically,
- 37:10it's like a spirit oil pipeline.
- 37:12Sephiroth attempts to use the power of
- 37:14this spirit oil pipeline to change the
- 37:16fate of the original game. This is shown
- 37:19by the brand new existence in the
- 37:20remakes of these freaky dementor ghosts
- 37:22called whispers. There are light
- 37:24whispers and dark whispers. And they
- 37:26basically show up to either alter the
- 37:28fate of the original game or desperately
- 37:30try to keep things as they were. And
- 37:32with the power of the lifestream, this
- 37:33Sephiroth seems to know what happened in
- 37:36the original game. It seems to be that
- 37:38Sephiroth in Final Fantasy VII Remake
- 37:40may very well be the villain Sephiroth
- 37:43from the original. And I get it, you
- 37:44hear that and you're like, "Duh, of
- 37:45course Sephiroth is Sephiroth." But,
- 37:47what I'm saying is it's probably the
- 37:49actual guy who lived through the
- 37:51original game and is now having a second
- 37:53go of it in the remake. This is plan B
- 37:56for him. And I think that's such a fun
- 37:58and bold way to remake a video game.
- 38:00Because not only does it do all of the
- 38:02things we said Resident Evil 4 does for
- 38:04the original, it makes them narratively
- 38:06a pairing rather than one to go back to
- 38:09just to appreciate. Like two fine wines.
- 38:12No one knows where the story will go,
- 38:14and no changes disrespect the original
- 38:17because it's not the original. It's a
- 38:19parallel universe where the original
- 38:20villain is trying again. It is a direct
- 38:23remake and also somehow a direct sequel.
- 38:26Despite some of its quirks and flaws, I
- 38:28love these games and a lot of the
- 38:30reasons I love them are what makes the
- 38:32original great. I had no idea how
- 38:34political the story was, how great the
- 38:36world-building of Midgar is, or how
- 38:38compelling the characters were.
- 38:40Admittedly, I didn't know all of this
- 38:41because I used to just look at these
- 38:43low-poly characters and think, "This
- 38:45game was just before my time." And
- 38:47personally, I find that every remake I
- 38:48play that points me to an original makes
- 38:50me more likely to try other old
- 38:52acclaimed games. It's sort of like
- 38:54before I started watching foreign films
- 38:56or listening to certain genres of music.
- 38:58It just takes a few accessible good ones
- 39:00to show you what you're missing. And
- 39:02that's exactly what the new Final
- 39:03Fantasy VII Remake did for me. Because
- 39:06after I went to my local game store and
- 39:08bought a copy of the original. And now I
- 39:10can say after playing like 10 hours on
- 39:12my CRT so far, that I love this one,
- 39:15too.
- 39:17I'm back. This is what remakes can offer
- 39:20in a medium where original pieces of art
- 39:22can fade away due to the original
- 39:23experience being a retro one. They help
- 39:25people discover something that was
- 39:27worthy of a remake in the first place.
- 39:29So yes, even when you don't like a
- 39:30change in a remake, the discussion of
- 39:32artistic choices can be one that
- 39:34highlights what made the originals work.
- 39:36But for all of this to still be good for
- 39:37everyone, the original game needs to
- 39:39still exist. In 2021, Rockstar released
- 39:42a collection of the classic Grand Theft
- 39:43Auto games in one bundle called Grand
- 39:45Theft Auto: The Trilogy - The Definitive
- 39:47Edition. It contained GTA III, San
- 39:50Andreas, and Vice City with substantial
- 39:52upgrades to the visuals and better
- 39:53support for modern hardware. While they
- 39:55added things like improved draw distance
- 39:57and better reflections, they also broke
- 39:59a huge number of visuals like rain,
- 40:01fire, and glass. They changed the
- 40:03lighting in a way that completely
- 40:04clashed with the old art style, and they
- 40:06seem to have added extra detail to the
- 40:07models by haphazardly applying more
- 40:10geometry to everything in the game. It
- 40:12was just flat-out a bad, probably rushed
- 40:14job made by an outsourced team funded by
- 40:16Rockstar Games. Now, after endless bad
- 40:18press, Rockstar released multiple
- 40:20updates to get the games into a more
- 40:21acceptable state, but it does raise one
- 40:23of the core issues with ports,
- 40:25remasters, and remakes. It is totally
- 40:27fine to remake a game and change things,
- 40:30but that's only if you allow people to
- 40:32still play the original if they want to.
- 40:35Because following the launch of this new
- 40:36bundle, Rockstar removed the old
- 40:38versions of each game from stores,
- 40:40meaning these aren't just the definitive
- 40:42versions of the games, but the only ones
- 40:45buy. Remakes and remasters should live
- 40:47alongside their originals. They should
- 40:49never completely override them. That's
- 40:51when any change made to a game becomes a
- 40:53valid criticism because it's rewriting
- 40:55what the original was, erasing a piece
- 40:57of history and ripping away the memory
- 40:59of what you loved. Remakes, ports, and
- 41:01remasters work as an addition to the
- 41:03original work, not a mandatory
- 41:05replacement of it. It was as if Rockstar
- 41:07sent a nuke from Texture Town and
- 41:09obliterated old GTA from nostalgia.
- 41:12That's against the GameCube conventions.
- 41:15That is a God of War crime. But all of
- 41:17the games that make up this land are in
- 41:19pursuit of a long conversation between
- 41:21artists and players. Millions of people,
- 41:23old and new, discovering something for
- 41:25the first time or rediscovering why they
- 41:27love something in the first place. But
- 41:29when you look closer, there's so much
- 41:31care and artistic expression to most of
- 41:33them. And with the conversation between
- 41:35artists across decades also bridges the
- 41:37gaps between fans. Previously, you may
- 41:40have never had a connection with someone
- 41:41you care about over Final Fantasy VII,
- 41:43but the remake brought you into the
- 41:45world of loving these games. And that
- 41:47connection over video games, for us at
- 41:49least, is at the core of our
- 41:51relationship as brothers. It's the
- 41:52reason why we play video games. A remake
- 41:55can open a window directly into our old
- 41:57basement where two 9-year-olds sat in
- 42:00front of a CRT excited about what next
- 42:02world and Kingdom Hearts they would
- 42:04visit. Not to just go back and relive
- 42:06it, but to experience it in a new
- 42:08context. I just like seeing the better
- 42:10lighting in the new ones.
- 42:12What?
- 42:13>> I just think I just think it's cool. I
- 42:14just I'm kind of a nerd about the tech
- 42:15of it. I kind of just like seeing the
- 42:17the upgrades.
- 42:18>> but I just had the whole thing about
- 42:19like us as brothers. That's why we play
- 42:20games, opening up a window of nostalgia.
- 42:22>> true. I agree that the games and we were
- 42:25when we were young and we played uh
- 42:27Kingdom Hearts.
- 42:28>> It seemed like you couldn't even
- 42:28remember it for a second though.
- 42:29[laughter]
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of Video Game Remakes Are Good (Even When They're Bad) by Burback, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 8,504 words across 1,256 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.