Victory Story of Kristine Bunch #TrueCrime #WrongfulConviction — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:23well hello there nicoo
- 0:27Chris wam
- 0:30I missed you the other night I was
- 0:33praying hope everything's okay with your
- 0:35dad Watcher will'll be back
- 0:38shortly so how's
- 0:43everybody missed you
- 0:53guys hey Tanya how are you doing
- 1:03hope everybody
- 1:04didn't pop in and pop back
- 1:10out warmer Chris I wish I could say that
- 1:15we it was snowing earlier I don't know
- 1:17if it still is or not
- 1:22here can everybody hear me okay
- 1:45I think Juan might have stepped out and
- 1:47I think nickel might have
- 1:52too hey
- 1:56Swifty I've got 11 people here I don't
- 1:58know and juny
- 2:02Bug how are
- 2:05you um two things I want to say
- 2:09um you're not going to see me tonight
- 2:12because I have a
- 2:14cold so I may have to blow my
- 2:17nose
- 2:19um
- 2:20and well the other I'll wait till some
- 2:23more people get in I guess I should
- 2:35oh Jason's going to be on tonight well I
- 2:37looked to see he doesn't have it
- 2:39scheduled yet at least I couldn't see it
- 2:41hey
- 2:43Sharon Jordan I don't know who Jordan is
- 2:50Tanya I don't
- 2:54think I might know his channel name
- 2:58though thank thank you Tanya yeah I woke
- 3:01up yesterday with a sore
- 3:04throat it went away but my sinuses which
- 3:08I have sinus issues all year around but
- 3:10right now I think I've got me a good
- 3:12head cold going
- 3:15on oh there's
- 3:18Watcher hey
- 3:20Mel how are you honey I hope you're
- 3:23doing okay I hope dough
- 3:26is
- 3:28um you know I'm thinking of you
- 3:31darling hey
- 3:34Ally me too I think I'm going to go get
- 3:37me some of this medicine juny told me
- 3:39about today or have my hubby Get It
- 3:42Anyway hey nicoo there you
- 3:48are so
- 3:56um so is that his channel name too Tanya
- 4:00hey D how are
- 4:11you I do
- 4:14want um new new New Zealand Mysteries
- 4:18was in here the other night guys but um
- 4:20y'all should really take a listen at her
- 4:22Channel she's got some good things going
- 4:25on over there and uh
- 4:30I like her channel so go check that out
- 4:33when you have time New Zealand
- 4:43Mysteries so um yeah so I'm going to do
- 4:47this story tonight Chris loves Victory
- 4:50stories um well I mean I love Victory
- 4:54stories um because it's awful for
- 4:56someone to sit in prison for something
- 4:59they did not do
- 5:02um
- 5:06but
- 5:07um I was hoping that Christine could
- 5:10come
- 5:11on and tell her story herself but
- 5:19um I thought we had it set up a couple
- 5:24of times but
- 5:27um she was just not able to work it out
- 5:31um she's she is super
- 5:33busy um she works for I had that pulled
- 5:38up I'm sorry give me just a second guys
- 5:49um she's an executive director
- 5:53at Justice for just us and I'll explain
- 5:57what that is she's an administrative
- 5:59assistant at Northwestern
- 6:02University
- 6:04um
- 6:06and she did work at Illinois Innocence
- 6:12Project now
- 6:16Justice for just us
- 6:19is um a program
- 6:23that they started her and some other
- 6:26people started here some sponsors in
- 6:28Indiana because Indiana doesn't
- 6:31have
- 6:32um the Innocence
- 6:35Project um or at the
- 6:40time I know that she made a video that I
- 6:43saw so they made that
- 6:47um and they made it for exonorees for
- 6:50when they're out of prison because like
- 6:52she said when she walked out of there
- 6:54she didn't have anything she had her
- 6:56family
- 6:58but there wasn't even anybody to help
- 7:00her make a resume or you know
- 7:04so um they help people when they get out
- 7:07you know with clothes they help them
- 7:10make resumees they just help them start
- 7:13over so she is a really busy person so
- 7:17I'm going to try to tell her story the
- 7:19best I can tonight um so let me see have
- 7:24I missed anybody coming in I
- 7:27hate missing people
- 7:32Shar
- 7:33doll I missed you
- 7:37Lake excuse
- 7:41me I think I've got everybody yeah
- 7:44Watcher I hope your Bible study was good
- 7:47ours got cancelled last night you know
- 7:51this
- 7:52weather has been a damper on that for us
- 7:56for a couple
- 7:57weeks so I think I've got it everybody I
- 8:00don't think I missed anybody I hope not
- 8:02if I did yell at
- 8:06me
- 8:08so I'm going to read a little bit
- 8:12um from
- 8:19this um it's right
- 8:21from excuse me it's right from um
- 8:25Northwestern School of Law Center on
- 8:27wrongful convictions
- 8:34um bear with me guys because my throat
- 8:36gets
- 8:39itchy so she was convicted of murder By
- 8:42arson but the fire was
- 8:46accidental
- 8:50So Christine bunch is her name and she
- 8:53is a client of the center on wrongful
- 8:56convictions languished behind bars for
- 8:58more than 7 years after she was arrested
- 9:01and charged with setting a fire that
- 9:02claimed the life of her three-year-old
- 9:04son Anthony who she calls Tony on June
- 9:0830th 1995 in a trailer home they shared
- 9:12in decater County Indiana which is
- 9:14Greensburg
- 9:15Indiana shortly after the
- 9:18fire Brian Frank a state arson
- 9:21investigator concluded that it had
- 9:22started in two places and that a liquid
- 9:25accelerant such as kerosene or charcoal
- 9:28lighter fluid had been used to start it
- 9:30at both locations 6 days later based
- 9:34largely on Frank's findings Christine
- 9:36was charged with arson and felony murder
- 9:39at her trial which opened on February
- 9:4126th
- 9:421966 Frank told the jury there were two
- 9:46separate fires one was in the South
- 9:49bedroom along the South wall that was
- 9:51caused by the liquid accelerant being
- 9:53present the second originated at the
- 9:56doorway the area of the doorway of the
- 9:58South bedroom into the living room and
- 10:01there was a liquid accelerant poured
- 10:03across the floor of the living room that
- 10:05went to the front door of the mobile
- 10:08home so
- 10:11um his testimony regarding the
- 10:14accelerant was collabor collaborated by
- 10:17William Canard a forensic analysis with
- 10:21us Bureau of Alcohol Tobacco and far
- 10:23Firearms ATF who testified that he had
- 10:26identified a heavy petroleum dis
- 10:31distillate if I'm saying that right in
- 10:33flooring samples taken from both the
- 10:35living room where the fire was believed
- 10:37to have started and from the bedroom in
- 10:39which Anthony died Tom Hol an
- 10:42independent arson investigator testified
- 10:44for the defense that the cause of the
- 10:47fire should have been classified as
- 10:49undetermined because there was a
- 10:51probability that it had been accidental
- 10:54jurors evidently believed the
- 10:56prosecution witnesses and on March 4th
- 10:5996 Christine then 22 and Pregnant guilty
- 11:04of murder and
- 11:06arson the following April decator
- 11:10County Circuit Court Judge John a Wester
- 11:13sentenced her to concurrent prison terms
- 11:16of 60 years for murder and 50 years for
- 11:22arson
- 11:26um on uh June 9th 98 the Supreme Court
- 11:31affirmed the murder conviction citing
- 11:33the presence of heavy Petroleum
- 11:36distillate distillate in several
- 11:39locations but vacated the arson
- 11:41conviction on Double Jeopardy
- 11:43grounds just one second I'm just
- 11:46checking
- 11:53chat
- 11:56okay um
- 11:59but vacated the arson conviction on
- 12:01Double Double Jeopardy
- 12:03grounds Christine's family retained an
- 12:06Indianapolis attorney Hillary Bo Ricks
- 12:09who filed a petition for post conviction
- 12:11relief with judge Wester in 2006 a few
- 12:16months later Betsy Marx a supporter of
- 12:18Christine's wrote to the center of
- 12:19wrongful convictions requesting
- 12:21assistance her letter was referred to
- 12:24CWC staff Attorney Jane
- 12:27rally so
- 12:30um after discussing the case with
- 12:32Hillary Ricks and reading the trial
- 12:35transcript Jane approached three fire
- 12:38forensic
- 12:39experts Jamie mallister John Dean and
- 12:44John Mali who occurred in the view that
- 12:47the arson testimony presented by the
- 12:49prosecution at the trial in all
- 12:51likelihood had been
- 12:53wrong agreed to join Hillary in
- 12:56representing Christine
- 13:00oh I'm sorry Jane NCW
- 13:03staff councel and Carol Daniel agreed to
- 13:07join
- 13:09Hillary so um one of the first things
- 13:13they did was subpoena ATF files on the
- 13:15original investigation in response ATF
- 13:19surrendered previously undisclosed
- 13:21documents showing that contrary to the
- 13:24trial testimony of William Kenard the
- 13:27ATF analyst no heavy petroleum
- 13:29distillate had been found in the bedroom
- 13:32or indeed anywhere in the trailer
- 13:34kerosene had been found only in the
- 13:36living room where there was an innocent
- 13:39explanation for its presence the family
- 13:41had used a kerosene heater in the living
- 13:43room during winter months and when
- 13:45filling it sometimes spilled kerosene on
- 13:47the floor the critical sample in Tony's
- 13:49bedroom was completely
- 13:53negative because kennard's trial
- 13:56testimony that a liquid accelerant had
- 13:57been found in both the bedroom and
- 13:59living room left an escapable impression
- 14:02that the fire had been set the ATF
- 14:04documents were highly exculpatory I
- 14:08probably said that wrong I'm sorry yet
- 14:09they had been withheld from Christine's
- 14:12trial Council in violation of the US
- 14:14Supreme Court's 1963 decision in Brady
- 14:17versus Maryland requiring prosecutors to
- 14:20turn over that word again exculpatory
- 14:23exculpatory materials to defense lawyers
- 14:26prior to trial
- 14:35so I'm trying
- 14:39to just try to get to the um so
- 14:43basically they they lied and then they
- 14:47withheld that
- 14:49information so after the evidentiary
- 14:51hearing in October 2009 Wester took the
- 14:54case under advisement for8 months before
- 14:56denying relief on June 8 2010 while
- 15:00Bunch had new resources available to her
- 15:03at the postconviction hearing new
- 15:05experts do not create new evidence he
- 15:07wrote the issues raised and the
- 15:10conclusions reached while packaged
- 15:11differently remain basically the same as
- 15:14they were at trial in 96 he added that
- 15:17he did not believe the ATF documents
- 15:19would have changed the outcome of the
- 15:22trial really
- 15:24okay so the defense
- 15:27appealed and John laramore
- 15:31of I cannot say
- 15:34this vager bake
- 15:38Daniels LLP a leading Indianapolis Law
- 15:41Firm joined the legal team Ron safer
- 15:43argued the case before a three-member
- 15:45panel of the Court appeals of Indiana on
- 15:48July 13 2011 eight months later on March
- 15:5121st 2012 the court reversed the
- 15:54conviction holding 2 to one that
- 15:56Christine was entitled to a new trial
- 15:58both because the evolving fire science
- 16:00met the legal criteria for new evidence
- 16:03and because the undisclosed ATF evidence
- 16:07directly contradicted canard's trial
- 16:11testimony supporting fires originating
- 16:13in two places on August 8th 2012 the
- 16:17Indiana Supreme Court unanimously
- 16:19declined to disturb the court of appeals
- 16:22decision Christine who had earned
- 16:24undergraduate degrees in English and
- 16:27anthropology from from Ball State
- 16:29University in prison was released on her
- 16:31own ronance 24 days later 17 years 1
- 16:36month and 16 days after her wrongful
- 16:39arrest she walked out of the decor
- 16:41County Jail where she had been sent to
- 16:44await trial and into the arms of her
- 16:47family who had steadfastly supported her
- 16:49throughout her ordeal 8 days before
- 16:52Christmas 2012 the prosecution dropped
- 16:55the
- 16:57charges and
- 17:00if you do not mind there is a video here
- 17:04at the end of all that that I just read
- 17:06hey hey
- 17:09Dana hey hey
- 17:15Amber thank you all for being here isn't
- 17:18that something though can you
- 17:26imagine that it's not enough that
- 17:29fire begins in your
- 17:31home it kills your
- 17:34baby and you're blamed for
- 17:37it she says that um I don't I I I got
- 17:42this put up late today guys so I don't
- 17:44know if you had a chance to read
- 17:46anything or watch any of her
- 17:49videos but she said she lost
- 17:52friends she didn't have anybody but her
- 17:55family so even her own friends believed
- 17:58this
- 18:04but we probably every single one of us I
- 18:07think
- 18:13probably haven't gone through exactly
- 18:15this but I'm sure we have been through
- 18:19something in our lives and we've learned
- 18:22who are real friends are and who our
- 18:24real friends aren't
- 18:29but man
- 18:32alive
- 18:37so I just couldn't imagine I
- 18:41mean she was
- 18:44arrested she had to grieve over her
- 18:47son's
- 18:50death her mother had to raise her other
- 18:52son because her other son was born she
- 18:56in in Pres
- 18:59had to be taken away from her and then
- 19:02her
- 19:03family her mother had to raise her other
- 19:09son but then she had to be so strong and
- 19:13fight all these years and had nobody on
- 19:16her side but her
- 19:21family hey Annie Ferguson how are you
- 19:24have I missed anybody else I don't think
- 19:26I have so
- 19:29um I'm not sure how long this video is I
- 19:31think it's
- 19:40uh yeah
- 19:43Watcher um I'm looking back at the
- 19:45comments guys real
- 19:47quick and then I'm going to ask y'all if
- 19:50it's okay to watch this video it's
- 19:54really in I
- 19:57mean if it's one I think it is
- 20:03but it's so good to see all of
- 20:07you I'm looking at W's comment so good
- 20:10to see you all it's so good to see you
- 20:14WAM and it's always good when I come on
- 20:17here and see all of
- 20:20you thank you
- 20:22[Music]
- 20:26Sharon so um um give me a yes y'all want
- 20:30to watch this
- 20:32video oh I know what else I was going to
- 20:34say is I've been having internet
- 20:35problems today so that I hope I don't
- 20:38run into
- 20:40those
- 20:45um thank you you guys for being so nice
- 20:48to each other in here I mean that's
- 20:51something else I can say for my
- 20:56chat they're always so welcoming and
- 20:59friendly okay so we're going to watch
- 21:01this video really
- 21:03quick let me get over
- 21:13here sorry I was just making sure I
- 21:17had oh and I want to get my volume
- 21:19turned up so you guys can hear it too so
- 21:22if you got your headphones in watcher
- 21:32hope Mel's still
- 21:35here okay
- 21:37guys I want to know if you can see that
- 21:40first so let me know that you can see it
- 21:43somebody say yes or no real
- 21:48quick you see that guys hey
- 21:56Melissa okay here we go guys
- 22:03[Music]
- 22:09[Applause]
- 22:54you guys are going have turn the cameras
- 22:56off no cameras in
- 23:14what does this game mean to
- 23:17you it's everything
- 23:21I put in the
- 23:23words more than I can
- 23:26say you've talked about this for year
- 23:30did you believe a year ago that this
- 23:32would be
- 23:33happening no and now that it's here it
- 23:36still feels really
- 23:37surreal I just want to spend some time
- 23:40with myself what's the first thing
- 23:41you'll do when you get
- 23:43home probably disturb my son while I
- 23:46watch him do
- 23:47everything because I want to see
- 23:50everything he does how difficult have
- 23:52the last 16 years
- 23:55been I don't even have wor to describe I
- 23:59did you ever give up hope no never like
- 24:03you had hope why did I have hope because
- 24:06I knew that it was going to work out in
- 24:09the end and I had a lot of
- 24:12support can you imagine being out of
- 24:14handcuffs and
- 24:15shackles not right at this moment but
- 24:18soon what's it going to be like when you
- 24:20walk out the doors breathing at fresh
- 24:22air
- 24:25again I very
- 24:29Serene and a very blessed and merciful
- 24:34moment for first thing you going to eat
- 24:37or do I don't know right now it's
- 24:41overwhelming to be able to do anything
- 25:13[Music]
- 25:19thank you
- 25:47how did you
- 25:48feel when they arrested you in the first
- 25:50place when you were
- 25:58um I think honestly during that time I
- 26:02was in shock so it's really hard to
- 26:07articulate what I felt um where I was I
- 26:12I think everybody feels kind of leg
- 26:14dream and you just can't believe it's
- 26:17happening it's happen is this is this
- 26:20process what in a way made me say want
- 26:26lawyer I believe so I worked in the law
- 26:29library at the facility for several
- 26:31years and everybody need some help what
- 26:36do you think of the Northwestern folks
- 26:37who came came I cannot say enough about
- 26:41the Northwestern folks I cannot say
- 26:42enough about my local Council Hillary
- 26:45started with me and then it snowball and
- 26:51Northwestern come on and Sh Harden and
- 26:54and Daniel and they have been incredible
- 26:58yeah there's no way we could have
- 27:00afforded the experts that they were able
- 27:02to get we started talking to them
- 27:08[Music]
- 27:18just CLE yes fully Clearo
- 27:36you want to practice you want to help
- 27:37people in the same situation I I want to
- 27:43work there's still a lot of to
- 27:46be's
- 27:49a do you you seem so happy obviously
- 27:53you're going to be happy but you it
- 27:55would seem like you might be tempted to
- 27:57be a little bit bitter about waiting
- 27:58this long to get out but you don't seem
- 28:00to show that can you explain that yeah
- 28:03why we don't see the heading you
- 28:06um I think because this entire time I
- 28:10haven't been by myself I had a family
- 28:13that stood by me I've had people that
- 28:16believed in me and stepped up and you
- 28:19can't receive blessings like that and be
- 28:23better it's you know bringing awareness
- 28:26to what different people do it's
- 28:29bringing awareness to how long it takes
- 28:31to get through our justice system it's
- 28:33bringing awareness to a whole lot of
- 28:35friends and I think that's worth the
- 28:39journey so how do you remain optimistic
- 28:43um say my dream thing yeah
- 29:03wasn't that
- 29:05something however that that was a
- 29:08awesome video I think that's not the one
- 29:10I thought it was going to be hey
- 29:13crime
- 29:15um I have the others linked below um and
- 29:20some
- 29:23articles
- 29:26um where she talks about
- 29:29the one
- 29:34organization that was a good question
- 29:37they asked her wasn't
- 29:39it how she's not
- 29:44bitter
- 29:50H
- 29:52so she is a very sweet person
- 29:58there's a whole lot more people just
- 30:00like her though sitting in these
- 30:03prisons for something they did not
- 30:09do
- 30:13and in a lot of
- 30:15cases for
- 30:20murder
- 30:22um of of of you know other
- 30:26crimes meaning
- 30:28there's someone else out there walking
- 30:33free so that is Christin's story I know
- 30:37it's short I'm sorry I really wanted her
- 30:40to come on and tell
- 30:42it um and you know she may still come on
- 30:45someday and talk about it but she really
- 30:48is a busy
- 30:49person
- 30:53um yeah another
- 30:56reason um
- 30:58that's a lot of people that I mean
- 31:00that's a reason a lot of people don't
- 31:03like the death penalty you guys have all
- 31:06heard why I don't like it um but that's
- 31:08another
- 31:13reason yeah quite a few people thought
- 31:16um because sometimes when I mentioned
- 31:18her coming on I didn't say um her last
- 31:21name and a lot of people thought it was
- 31:23our
- 31:24joy um
- 31:28yeah Mel's still here
- 31:31good
- 31:36um yeah I mean
- 31:40um it is good you know it's a victory
- 31:43story but you
- 31:45know she lost 17 years that she'll never
- 31:48get
- 31:50back but I knew it would make you happy
- 31:53Chris I know you like the victory
- 31:56stories
- 31:59yeah right
- 32:02crime exactly
- 32:05Watcher
- 32:09exactly
- 32:20yeah let me look here at the
- 32:25comments see if I missed anything
- 32:35Watcher thought it was Tobe for a
- 32:49minute okay so you guys were mostly
- 32:52saying hello to each other
- 33:05oh thank you crime Mel made it for me
- 33:07for my
- 33:09birthday she made me one for my backdrop
- 33:12too you know or um you know for my
- 33:15channel but it wouldn't fit oh let me
- 33:19turn my volume down now I don't want to
- 33:21I hope I don't sound like I'm yelling at
- 33:23y'all but I couldn't get it
- 33:26to fit in there it said it wasn't big
- 33:29enough
- 33:36and
- 33:38so anybody got anything else on their
- 33:41mind they want to talk about or any
- 33:44cases
- 33:53that a we love you too Taff you know
- 33:56that oh by the way way has anybody heard
- 33:59from uh L of
- 34:08Love W that's very true lot easier for
- 34:12an innocent person to get into prison
- 34:13then get out that's sure
- 34:17right um lots of love hasn't been here
- 34:19for a while
- 34:21so um if we can throw some prayers up
- 34:24because
- 34:26um you know she was was kind of sick the
- 34:28last
- 34:29time and kind of
- 34:39worried oh you're funny
- 34:48Watcher me neither kme me neither
- 35:02a sure thing
- 35:10Watcher so you guys are being quiet you
- 35:13don't have nothing to
- 35:15say nothing to ask nothing to suggest
- 35:20nothing hey I just wanted to let you
- 35:22know I haven't been I don't watch the
- 35:24news um
- 35:28so I don't see a lot that's going on um
- 35:30I did see on the Orin and Orson case
- 35:36um their other four children are in
- 35:38protective care right
- 35:40now
- 35:43so
- 35:45um and that's just because I it popped
- 35:48up on YouTube and they're not saying why
- 35:51or
- 35:56anything m
- 36:05I am too Watcher I am I I get worried
- 36:08when I don't see my people you know what
- 36:11I
- 36:15mean unless I know you know of of a
- 36:19reason why or if I you know I'm like
- 36:21well this is probably why or whatever if
- 36:23I don't you know or if I don't
- 36:26personally know you know they haven't
- 36:28told me something or something I get
- 36:30worried when I don't see one
- 36:33ofans it is interesting isn't it w if
- 36:36you're talking about the or the West
- 36:39boys but I think that's probably a good
- 36:44idea maybe I don't
- 36:55know really Swifty
- 37:00I should probably watch that because you
- 37:02know I don't know as much as I probably
- 37:04should know on
- 37:06that John Bonet Ramsey
- 37:13Chris what you got what do you what's
- 37:16your
- 37:19comment I would say do you want to come
- 37:21on panel but I know you won't
- 37:31um lots of love
- 37:41share kids were giving back
- 37:45crime the West boys
- 37:48were well I just saw they weren't they
- 37:53were oh well that kind of bothers me
- 37:56then
- 37:58now that's a rabbit hole you're right
- 38:07crime yeah there is
- 38:11Watcher they so they gave the kids back
- 38:13crime
- 38:24golly that's weird I'm not even talking
- 38:26I wasn't even I was just sitting here
- 38:28being silent and I saw my thing you know
- 38:31moving on my screen like I was
- 38:36talking like right it was doing it again
- 38:39it must background noise like the TV in
- 38:41the living room
- 38:44anyways
- 38:56um hey hey ancy how are
- 39:04you oh I
- 39:08know I know children's cases are really
- 39:12hard
- 39:15um they really they they are really
- 39:18hard True Crime itself I think I was in
- 39:21Jason's chat today and I said that uh
- 39:26True Crime
- 39:29I don't know how I said it but this is
- 39:31how I'm going to say it now True Crime
- 39:34can really get to you after a while and
- 39:36lots of it can really get to you and
- 39:37then you know sometimes you just got to
- 39:40you know take a little break sometimes
- 39:42you do
- 39:45um thank you
- 39:47schwifty
- 39:50um wow
- 39:53crime huh
- 40:08[Laughter]
- 40:11Chris says it's not a rabbit hole
- 40:18crime Ken Mains about John Bonet
- 40:29I knew too Amber I'm G put Amber's
- 40:31comment up here oh hold on I got to jump
- 40:34over here streamyard now I probably
- 40:35won't find it h there it is I was on
- 40:39YouTube
- 40:41um oh that's not the comment they gone
- 40:45it where did it
- 40:47go I'm not that far behind am
- 40:51I well d g it well anyways I agree with
- 40:55your comment Amber wherever it went to
- 40:58I'm surely not that far behind
- 41:04though kids do fall through the crack it
- 41:08it a
- 41:09lot and I know in in in cps's or DCS
- 41:17they call it different different places
- 41:19in their defense I know that they're you
- 41:22know they have a huge workload and
- 41:26there's short staffed and all that but
- 41:31sometimes there's just no excuse for
- 41:33what happens I
- 41:35mean look at
- 41:37Gabriel Hernandez you know I mean
- 41:41there's just times where they you know
- 41:45Indiana CPS um Evansville you know
- 41:48they're suing they're getting sued
- 41:49because of
- 41:51their you
- 41:54know and uh I had a c casew worker
- 41:58outright admit to me that they you know
- 42:02and they're working on it they're trying
- 42:03to
- 42:07so there's just both sides of it you
- 42:21know hey
- 42:25Doris how are you thanks for
- 42:32coming yeah crime yeah we do we all we
- 42:37do and um and and you're
- 42:45right those are those are so very
- 42:49sad those are the ones that are close to
- 42:52watcher
- 43:06yeah
- 43:07Amber is niiko still
- 43:11here I'm just gonna tease him if he
- 43:19is in which one
- 43:25crime in your opinion which
- 43:29one uh what we were talking about the
- 43:32west or a different
- 43:41one well you didn't send it to me Chris
- 43:44I'm I'm
- 43:47sad I'm
- 43:49joking nicoo you want to come on
- 43:55panel I'm just giving you hard time
- 44:06son parents need support services and
- 44:10parent education so they can be better
- 44:12parents that they might not have had
- 44:14themselves that's true
- 44:19Amber yeah I didn't know what case crime
- 44:22was talking about either
- 44:33Mel oh I gotta get over here see I like
- 44:36watching it on YouTube but can't do
- 44:39certain thing Mel says anyone heard of
- 44:42the organization stand for children I
- 44:44got a message from them today about
- 44:46stopping Indiana from putting minors in
- 44:49adult prisons like what that makes me
- 44:53mad
- 44:57I haven't heard of
- 44:58it
- 45:04um well I would say if it's a violent
- 45:10crime murder
- 45:14uh abusing you
- 45:17know sexual abuse on you know I I don't
- 45:21want to come out and say the word but
- 45:23you know with
- 45:25children then they deserve to go to a
- 45:28adult prison I think that's my
- 45:33opinion but if it's something
- 45:35minor you know I mean if they just
- 45:38shoplifted or something I don't think
- 45:40they should have to go to an adult
- 45:42prison I think they have juvenile
- 45:44detentions but they should have to go to
- 45:48jail
- 45:52um they should have to be taught lessons
- 45:55um you know
- 45:58because typan new County which is
- 46:00Lafayette which was where I was born and
- 46:02raised they did away with their Juvenile
- 46:04Detention Center a long time
- 46:07ago so when kids got in trouble
- 46:12and almost you know trouble
- 46:16period they spent no
- 46:19time none they went to the police
- 46:23station they sat in a little
- 46:25bitty I don't even want to call it a
- 46:27holding cell their parents were called
- 46:30Mommy and Daddy came and picked them
- 46:32up and then if if they thought it was
- 46:36something serious enough maybe they had
- 46:39to go talk to a probation
- 46:43officer once or twice
- 46:46and and I thought well okay then when
- 46:50these kids keep on and keep on and keep
- 46:53on and then later in life when they're
- 46:56you know
- 46:59whose fault's that but that's my opinion
- 47:01on that Mel I don't think all juveniles
- 47:04should go to prison I think it depends
- 47:06on the
- 47:08crime if it's a violent crime for
- 47:15sure is that how you feel Mel
- 47:32oh Tanya I'm
- 47:40sorry okay crime was talking about John
- 47:45Bonet yeah that's a rabbit hole for
- 47:49sure you know I always said I didn't
- 47:53think anybody in that family was guilty
- 47:54but I don't know I watched something and
- 47:57maybe it was what Watcher sent me I
- 47:59don't know because I watched something
- 48:00recently and it really made me
- 48:02think I don't know oh okay juny I hope
- 48:06you're not already gone because I just
- 48:08saw your comment good night I love
- 48:15you well and that's another thing Tanya
- 48:19is what I don't like about and and this
- 48:21is just what I've seen okay this is just
- 48:24what I've seen in around where I live
- 48:27I've seen so many kids
- 48:30taken with no proof of neglect or
- 48:35anything no investigation you know they
- 48:39just take kids that shouldn't be
- 48:42taken but kids that
- 48:45do or should be
- 48:51left and then later
- 48:55on guess what what
- 49:27yeah that's that's I'm so sorry
- 49:35T
- 49:40yeah thanks for reminding me like don't
- 49:42they have
- 49:43a juvenile
- 49:48prison
- 49:54but not sure
- 50:16oh goodness
- 50:17Amber that's
- 50:20funny okay there's Mel miners shouldn't
- 50:24go to adult prison until they are an
- 50:26adult regardless of their crime that's
- 50:28what Mel thinks okay
- 50:32well I don't
- 50:36know oh good night Tanya thank you for
- 50:38coming
- 50:42sweetheart so we disagree uh
- 50:46oh I'm going to get a scolding tonight
- 50:49on the phone from Mel no I'm teasing
- 50:52well I don't we do though like Lake said
- 50:56I thought we did have that juvenile
- 50:58prison but I don't know I mean Mel you
- 51:00think if they commit murder they
- 51:01shouldn't go to an adult
- 51:04prison I mean I see what you're saying
- 51:07though I mean I kind of do
- 51:09because oh I don't
- 51:24know crime says I have with juveniles in
- 51:27a program with Department of Juvenile
- 51:29Justice I believe that adolescence 12 to
- 51:3318 should go through adult for murder
- 51:36should be looked at Case by case well
- 51:39yeah that makes sense and well like um
- 51:43like L said the juvenile um we also
- 51:47have
- 51:50um I don't know if this is the same
- 51:53thing but Logan sport you know the
- 51:56mental
- 51:58hospital
- 52:02um it's not that anymore um I mean for
- 52:07like the mentally ill
- 52:09people they like pretty much just threw
- 52:12them all out I mean it's like boom boom
- 52:15I mean they just they like there's
- 52:17nowhere here anymore around here for the
- 52:20mentally ill so now it's for
- 52:22the criminally
- 52:24insane but then they all also have a
- 52:27section
- 52:29that is
- 52:31for uh
- 52:34juveniles for criminal
- 52:37juveniles I know it's a detention center
- 52:40but I don't know if it's classified as
- 52:42um like a Department of Correction thing
- 52:45so I don't know if that is where they
- 52:46would send juveniles that do those adult
- 52:50crimes as
- 52:52well but it is it's it's it's in it's
- 52:56it's out there where the Logan sport
- 52:58Memorial Hospital was but it's in a
- 53:01different section in a different
- 53:04building and I don't know exactly how
- 53:06that's
- 53:12classified but there are you know
- 53:15there's there's there's you know they
- 53:17get tried as an
- 53:20adult like I I'm I'm reading part of
- 53:23Watcher's comment it all depends on the
- 53:26age if they are 17 and they go kill a
- 53:29bunch of people they need to be in adult
- 53:31jail now if they are 10 that's
- 53:37different okay Annie thank you have a
- 53:40good night
- 53:59transfer to adult once they're an adult
- 54:02hell yes if they're
- 54:04murderers now I could see that
- 54:07too I can see that
- 54:11um I was going to say something else and
- 54:13I just lost it pertaining to this of
- 54:16course
- 54:20um oh I was going to tell you about my
- 54:23son um when he was younger
- 54:27I was talking to Mel about this a week
- 54:29or so ago when he was younger and he'd
- 54:30do his crazy things he'd sneak out at
- 54:32night not come home have me going crazy
- 54:36and um him and his friend went into a
- 54:39VP he was only
- 54:4116
- 54:43and um they went in there to steal some
- 54:47beer V VP means Village Pantry around
- 54:50here by the way I don't know if they
- 54:52have them
- 54:53everywhere well when they were on their
- 54:55way out his friend
- 54:56didn't they didn't even have a
- 54:59gun but his friend threatened the
- 55:01clerk so that made it
- 55:06robbery my
- 55:09son so they were charged with uh theft
- 55:13and
- 55:15robbery
- 55:17and he was facing 30 years all because
- 55:22of that threat and he wasn't even the
- 55:24one that made that threat
- 55:27so he had to go to juvenile
- 55:32court and usually doesn't happen in
- 55:35juvenile court they set a
- 55:42bond and I bonded him
- 55:47out they turned
- 55:51around and well she told me that she was
- 55:54transferring to adult Court
- 56:01and so they charged him as an adult and
- 56:04when they did when it went through the
- 56:06adult Court they turned right around and
- 56:08then issued a $1,000
- 56:12Bond so they were going to charge him as
- 56:15an adult and he would have had to have
- 56:18gone I'm pretty sure I mean I don't know
- 56:20how it would have worked all I know is
- 56:21they were going to charge him as an
- 56:22adult and he was facing 30 years and I
- 56:25mean you want to talk about a terrified
- 56:30[Music]
- 56:32mother and I you
- 56:35know I wasn't going to let it happen he
- 56:37wasn't the one that threatened I you
- 56:39know he did do time for what he went in
- 56:42there to do which was to steal the beer
- 56:45you do the crime you do the time but he
- 56:47didn't threaten the clerk his friend did
- 56:50and so I did get him a good lawyer and
- 56:52so he
- 56:54did get in trouble for the theft
- 56:57but yeah I mean the reason I told you
- 56:59that story is because I was just trying
- 57:00to use that example he was 16 they were
- 57:02going to charge him with an adult for
- 57:11robbery
- 57:13yeah
- 57:15yeah you guys I agree with you guys okay
- 57:19wam you're probably back now though I
- 57:21just seen your comment because I've been
- 57:23Jibber jabbering I think you guys are
- 57:25right I think probably every case needs
- 57:26to be looked at differently and
- 57:31um right Mel yeah
- 57:39um yeah sent to adult prison once
- 57:42they're 18 but they definitely you know
- 57:46if it's a violent crime murder or you
- 57:49know they definitely need to go to jail
- 57:52juvenile jail fine but and then
- 58:12prison you can't even buy lighter till
- 58:14you're 18
- 58:16Lake not just cigarettes you can't buy a
- 58:19vape you can't buy pods you can't buy
- 58:22cigarettes you can't buy a lighter you
- 58:25can't buy alcohol till you're 21 oh gosh
- 58:27don't get me started cuz I want to say
- 58:29something else and I can't say
- 58:33it welcome back
- 58:37W
- 58:50um oh goodness crime I'm sorry about
- 58:54that
- 59:14I mean I I I I know I was
- 59:18terrified I
- 59:20mean he still did his time and you know
- 59:24what he got a felony on his record
- 59:2716 years
- 59:33old but there wasn't no way I was going
- 59:35to let him get the other charge that he
- 59:43didn't oh I have to show my ID all the
- 59:47time but it's not
- 59:49because it's just because you know it's
- 59:51the law and
- 59:54they cuz they do have
- 59:56excise people go in there and make sure
- 59:59you know they can get in
- 1:00:04trouble I wish it was because I didn't
- 1:00:07look my
- 1:00:23age W it's SM
- 1:00:45that's right Amber take it as a
- 1:00:48compliment M I'm going to leave your
- 1:00:49smile up there okay
- 1:01:01I don't I I miss L's whatever you're
- 1:01:03saying answering back to Lake but that
- 1:01:06is funny
- 1:01:07crime because of the
- 1:01:16chicken oh that's right Mel it's 21 Now
- 1:01:19isn't it yeah it's 21 now they keep
- 1:01:23changing the law
- 1:01:28that's
- 1:01:32right Mom we just love
- 1:01:37you I forgot 21 is that what you were
- 1:01:40saying like and I didn't catch it I'm
- 1:01:45sorry
- 1:01:48so well
- 1:01:50guys I hope I told Christine's story
- 1:01:53good because she will see it and I hope
- 1:01:55she
- 1:01:56approves it would be nice for her to
- 1:01:59come and tell though you
- 1:02:01know and I hope you I I if you guys did
- 1:02:04not watch the videos in the link will
- 1:02:07you please when you have time they're
- 1:02:09they're not
- 1:02:10long
- 1:02:14um um none of them are long really um
- 1:02:20even the True Crime daily ones aren't
- 1:02:21long but I I think they're really good
- 1:02:24videos and
- 1:02:29uh probably tells her story better than
- 1:02:32I did you know and you get to hear it
- 1:02:35from her well niiko um
- 1:02:38s sounds like they might you know
- 1:02:41they're trying to do it federally
- 1:02:48so well I'm sorry
- 1:02:50like you know I'm bad at missing
- 1:02:53comments I try to get them though then I
- 1:02:56start
- 1:03:01talking um Chris is that who um uh Tanya
- 1:03:07was no who said Jordan tonight that who
- 1:03:10they were talking about earlier
- 1:03:12though they said Jason and Jordan was
- 1:03:15coming live tonight is that who they
- 1:03:16were talking about Jordan Brown
- 1:03:38yeah
- 1:03:46nicoo yes we love M I love all of you
- 1:03:50guys
- 1:03:56yes it will Amber it it sure freaking
- 1:04:05will of course I mean I'm I'm for real
- 1:04:12though any CBD I've ever tried like
- 1:04:15whether it was lotion oil
- 1:04:20oral oil or oral I can't even say that
- 1:04:24right oral
- 1:04:28never worked for me
- 1:04:32but when I get it from the hemp Farm in
- 1:04:37Crawfordsville that stuff is good and it
- 1:04:40does help my
- 1:04:43pain oh no I hope my mom's not getting
- 1:04:46my cold she just sneezed
- 1:04:59yeah crime sees
- 1:05:03monkeys Mel said why
- 1:05:06crime why do we love you Mel
- 1:05:26it really does
- 1:05:30Amber I think it's about on the way I
- 1:05:33really do this I think it might
- 1:05:36be yeah because you're
- 1:05:41Mel well guys I think I'm going to sign
- 1:05:43off because there might
- 1:05:45be other chats you want to get to and
- 1:05:48I've been on here for a while just
- 1:05:50talking your heads off and well thank
- 1:05:52you w I hope things are well with you
- 1:05:55and your
- 1:06:00dad but Mel that was great conversation
- 1:06:03thank you for bringing it
- 1:06:08up yes she does crime she rocks good
- 1:06:13night
- 1:06:17Ley have a good night
- 1:06:21sweetart okay guys well I will be back
- 1:06:24on Tuesday day and I'm not sure what
- 1:06:28yet
- 1:06:31um real quick before we
- 1:06:35go has anybody looked at the Victoria
- 1:06:39Rose Smith
- 1:06:49case don't go
- 1:06:53yet oh go ahead I see you guys leaving
- 1:06:58already I'll talk to you Tuesday about
- 1:07:01it good night you guys I love you all I
- 1:07:04thank you so much for being here every
- 1:07:07freaking
- 1:07:09time have a great
- 1:07:12night great weekend I'll see you Tuesday
- 1:07:15if not before another
- 1:07:18chats God
- 1:07:21bless toodles
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of Victory Story of Kristine Bunch #TrueCrime #WrongfulConviction by ⚖️Truth & Justice Channel⚖️, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 6,263 words across 1,071 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to translate the transcript into 100+ languages.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, translation to 100+ languages, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.