YouTube2Text

US History Lecture 4 — Transcript

by History On Fire · 4,546 words · 695 segments · language en · Watch on YouTube

Full transcript

  1. 0:00Hello and welcome to this new lecture in
  2. 0:02our US history survey. So last time we
  3. 0:05finished off with the material about
  4. 0:07pre-Colombian history. Now we are going
  5. 0:10to start soon with the arrival of
  6. 0:12Columbus, the meeting of natives and
  7. 0:14Europeans and all that kind of stuff.
  8. 0:17Now, before we get to 1492, one thing
  9. 0:20that we should mention, there's a whole
  10. 0:22debate regarding just how many Native
  11. 0:25Americans lived in this continent before
  12. 0:28contact with Europeans. And as you may
  13. 0:30imagine, this debate is not exactly, you
  14. 0:34know, nobody knows for sure. There are
  15. 0:37educated guesses been made about it, but
  16. 0:39that's what they are. Ultimately, there
  17. 0:40was no sensors. There's no way to know
  18. 0:43for sure. Um, so this is not the most
  19. 0:46precise science ever to figure out and
  20. 0:49not surprisingly
  21. 0:51the numbers are heavily influenced by
  22. 0:54people's politics.
  23. 0:56Native people themselves or people
  24. 0:58sympathetic to native interests tend to
  25. 1:00accept the higher estimates. People who
  26. 1:03are not so sympathetic to native
  27. 1:05interests tend to accept only the lower
  28. 1:06estimates. And again, why? Who cares?
  29. 1:10What's the big deal about it? Well, it's
  30. 1:13really simple in a way if you argue that
  31. 1:16there weren't that many natives to begin
  32. 1:18with. Now, we know how many natives will
  33. 1:21be left by the end of the 1800s when
  34. 1:23European colonization is complete. If we
  35. 1:26can say that the initial number wasn't
  36. 1:28that high, then it may the impact of
  37. 1:31European colonization may not look that
  38. 1:33dramatic. If on the other hand we say
  39. 1:36that that initial number was very high
  40. 1:39then it's a way to
  41. 1:42it kind of drives home the point that
  42. 1:44European colonization was indeed
  43. 1:46terrible for Native Americans. So it's a
  44. 1:49way to either magnify or sort of
  45. 1:53downplay the impact of European
  46. 1:56colonization which of course is a
  47. 1:58political issue in this. In any case,
  48. 2:01regardless, keep in mind the numbers I'm
  49. 2:03going to give you are approximations
  50. 2:05based basically on average between the
  51. 2:08more extreme positions.
  52. 2:10For North America alone, defined purely
  53. 2:13as modern United States and Canada, it's
  54. 2:16estimated that probably somewhere
  55. 2:18between 8 to 18 million people lived in
  56. 2:22this part of the country. For the
  57. 2:24entirety of the Americas, including
  58. 2:26these 8 to 18 million, plus Mexico, plus
  59. 2:30the rest of Central America, plus South
  60. 2:32America, we're looking at somewhere in
  61. 2:34the neighborhood of 75 million to maybe
  62. 2:38150 million people.
  63. 2:41So, what this means is this continent
  64. 2:42was not empty. There weren't just a few
  65. 2:45people here and there. There were
  66. 2:46clearly a lot of people living here. It
  67. 2:50also means that while North America was
  68. 2:53definitely heavily populated, I mean,
  69. 2:55we're talking about millions of people
  70. 2:56here, the bulk, the biggest native
  71. 2:59societies were in Mexico and south of
  72. 3:01that. That's where you find the vast
  73. 3:05numbers. But in any case, so with that
  74. 3:08in mind, I guess something else we
  75. 3:11should mention is there's all sort of
  76. 3:15speculation regarding the possibility
  77. 3:17that other people came to the Americas
  78. 3:20before Columbus other than Native
  79. 3:22Americans ancestors.
  80. 3:25Well, we do know of at least one case
  81. 3:27that is confirmed where is not
  82. 3:29speculation. It happened for sure
  83. 3:32specifically around the year about 1,000
  84. 3:34common era a few years later actually
  85. 3:38the Vikings
  86. 3:40from northern Europe made their way to
  87. 3:43Iceland made their way to Greenland and
  88. 3:45eventually made their way to the eastern
  89. 3:48coast of Canada. They stuck around for a
  90. 3:51little bit. They got in conflict with
  91. 3:54local natives and they decided that it
  92. 3:56just wasn't worth it. So they sailed
  93. 3:58back home and forgot about it. So yes,
  94. 4:01Europeans arrived here before Columbus.
  95. 4:04But no, this did not alter human history
  96. 4:07as we know it didn't really have much of
  97. 4:09an impact other than for the few people
  98. 4:11involved. And even the knowledge of that
  99. 4:14trip was probably largely lost to most
  100. 4:16other Europeans. So that's the one
  101. 4:19confirmed case that we know it happened
  102. 4:22even though it wasn't that dramatic in
  103. 4:24terms of its impact on world history.
  104. 4:28There are all sort of other
  105. 4:29possibilities that have been thrown out
  106. 4:31there. There's um for example Japanese
  107. 4:35potry has been found in some pre-colian
  108. 4:38villages in South America.
  109. 4:41Now that's interesting but of course
  110. 4:43that's not a whole lot of evidence to go
  111. 4:46on. You know, more likely than not, what
  112. 4:48that means is that maybe some Japanese
  113. 4:50fisherman got blown off course and ended
  114. 4:53up in South America by a, you know, due
  115. 4:55to a storm.
  116. 4:57Could be possible. If it did happen, it
  117. 5:01definitely affected this guy's life, but
  118. 5:03not the rest of human history. So,
  119. 5:05again, interesting, but not
  120. 5:08There are a few other pieces of
  121. 5:09evidence. You know, there are evidence
  122. 5:11used to argue for Chinese people
  123. 5:13arriving in the Americas before
  124. 5:14Columbus. There's some pieces of
  125. 5:16evidence used to This is actually a
  126. 5:19funny one. At one point doing chemical
  127. 5:22analysis of Egyptian mummies from
  128. 5:25thousands of years ago, they discovered
  129. 5:28traces of plants that only existed in
  130. 5:32the Americas, specifically tobacco and
  131. 5:35coa, the plant from which cocaine is
  132. 5:37made. Which if that's the case is kind
  133. 5:40of funny because you know if indeed
  134. 5:42there was longd distanceance trade it
  135. 5:44tells you that some ancient Egyptians
  136. 5:46were mainly interested in trading drugs
  137. 5:49which sort of funny. It's also possible
  138. 5:52that the specimens of this mummy were
  139. 5:55contaminated in the lab by people doing
  140. 5:58strange things in the lab with cocoa
  141. 6:00leaves and um and tobacco. And maybe
  142. 6:04this does not reflect an actual real
  143. 6:06sample. Nobody knows. Again, it's a
  144. 6:08tantalizing piece of evidence, but not
  145. 6:10enough to go on. Other people have
  146. 6:13argued for, you know, this colossal
  147. 6:16statues left by the old Mexicanization
  148. 6:19in Mexico.
  149. 6:21People have argued that the faces there
  150. 6:23reflect more African features that they
  151. 6:26do Native American. And again, yeah,
  152. 6:28maybe, maybe not. So moral of the story
  153. 6:32is there are all sort of theories out
  154. 6:34there that somebody may have arrived
  155. 6:36before Columbus,
  156. 6:38but the only proven one is the Viking
  157. 6:41trip around the year 1000. And even that
  158. 6:45one did not alter the course of history.
  159. 6:491492 on the other hand, Columbus arrival
  160. 6:52will alter the course of history in very
  161. 6:54dramatic way. It's one of the most
  162. 6:57meaningful moment in human history
  163. 6:59because it will bring these two worlds
  164. 7:02together. You know, Native Americans who
  165. 7:04have been isolated from Europe, Asia,
  166. 7:07and Africa for thousands of years in
  167. 7:10contact with what some books refer to as
  168. 7:12the old world, which is basically Asia,
  169. 7:15Africa, and um and Europe.
  170. 7:18So, let's start with the whole Colbo
  171. 7:20story.
  172. 7:22We do know that he will arrive in the
  173. 7:24Caribbeans in 1492.
  174. 7:27The power who financed this trip was
  175. 7:30Spain.
  176. 7:32The main reason for Columbus trip, you
  177. 7:34know, they weren't paying him to be a
  178. 7:35good boy scout and go find out new
  179. 7:37lands. They were paying him to find a
  180. 7:40faster way to get to East Asia because
  181. 7:43Europe was very interested in trade,
  182. 7:46particularly in luxury goods with East
  183. 7:48Asia.
  184. 7:49Now they have been there before. They
  185. 7:51had traded in the past. And if you look
  186. 7:54at the map, Europe and Asia, we call
  187. 7:57them two continents, but really they are
  188. 8:00one big land mass. So technically
  189. 8:02speaking, you can walk your way from
  190. 8:03Spain to China if you want or Spain to
  191. 8:06India. Of course, that's a very long
  192. 8:09trip. Problem number one. And problem
  193. 8:12number two is not a geographic one. It's
  194. 8:14a political one.
  195. 8:16In order to get to East Asia, starting
  196. 8:19from Europe, Christian traders of the
  197. 8:221400s, 1500s, and that period would have
  198. 8:25to cross through a bunch of lands
  199. 8:28inhabited by Muslim people. Now, Muslims
  200. 8:32and Christians did not love each other a
  201. 8:35whole lot in the 1400s.
  202. 8:37So, many Christian traders were trying
  203. 8:40to find a way to bypass
  204. 8:42having to travel through Muslim lands.
  205. 8:45So that's one of the reasons for why
  206. 8:48Spain will finance Columbus trip to go
  207. 8:50find another route to Asia.
  208. 8:54Spain had an interesting history by this
  209. 8:57point. They had been actually conquered
  210. 9:00by Muslims for a good 600 years. And it
  211. 9:05was only in the 1300s, at the very
  212. 9:07beginning of the 1300s, that what was
  213. 9:09known as the reconquista, which was the
  214. 9:11reconquering of Spanish homeland for
  215. 9:15Catholic Spain had been completed. So
  216. 9:18their culture had been built on fighting
  217. 9:21over religion
  218. 9:24with foreigners for a really long time.
  219. 9:26You know, centuries of this stuff
  220. 9:28happening. So that kind of colored their
  221. 9:31culture a little bit. this notion of um
  222. 9:34combining a warrior culture with uh
  223. 9:37faith was sort of a big deal to Spain at
  224. 9:40the time.
  225. 9:42Now by the time Columbus arrives in the
  226. 9:46Caribbeans, he does not really know
  227. 9:48where he is because nobody knows that
  228. 9:50there is this huge big continent
  229. 9:53right smack in the middle of the ocean
  230. 9:55there. So what happens there? That's
  231. 9:59where you get the term Indian because
  232. 10:01Columbus's goal was he had figured you
  233. 10:03know the prevailing theory unlike what
  234. 10:05you normally hear is that most people
  235. 10:07knew that the world was round. They did
  236. 10:10not by this point believe that the earth
  237. 10:12was flat. So Columbus was going in the
  238. 10:15right direction. He figured okay if the
  239. 10:17world is round I can go around and get
  240. 10:19to Asia from the other side. The problem
  241. 10:22was he had miscalculated the distance.
  242. 10:24He thought the trip was much shorter
  243. 10:26than it would have been and definitely
  244. 10:28didn't know that there was a continent
  245. 10:29in between. So that's where you get the
  246. 10:32whole idea of Indians to refer to Native
  247. 10:34Americans because initially he believed
  248. 10:37he may have arrived in India somewhere.
  249. 10:40The people whom he's going to meet in
  250. 10:43these islands are,
  251. 10:47you know, the Caribbeans were populated
  252. 10:49by a whole bunch of people. There were
  253. 10:52mainly native who had come from South
  254. 10:55America who had migrated centuries
  255. 10:58earlier to the islands and made a living
  256. 11:01there from fishing, hunting, gathering,
  257. 11:04but also articulture. They would planted
  258. 11:07corn, beans, squash, sweet potatoes and
  259. 11:10things like that.
  260. 11:12All in all, not a bad life for these
  261. 11:15guys. They one of the nations that
  262. 11:19Columbus ran into first are known to us
  263. 11:22today as the Tyino.
  264. 11:25And their initial encounter is really
  265. 11:28interesting in lots of ways because
  266. 11:31neither group knows what to make of the
  267. 11:33next. Neither group has uh translators
  268. 11:36that can mediate the dialogue. They're
  269. 11:39both trying to figure out each other.
  270. 11:41And the way they perceive each other has
  271. 11:43a lot to do with the culture that they
  272. 11:46each had.
  273. 11:49By all accounts, and by all accounts, I
  274. 11:51mean mainly Columbus because the tino
  275. 11:52didn't exactly leave behind written
  276. 11:54records of his. By Columbus's accounts,
  277. 11:59he was actually fairly impressed with
  278. 12:00the Teno. He felt that they he praised
  279. 12:03their disposition. He said they were
  280. 12:04very nice. They were hospitable. kind of
  281. 12:07naive because for example they didn't
  282. 12:09know anything about steel weapons of how
  283. 12:11sharp they are or things like that but
  284. 12:14his attitude was like yeah very nice
  285. 12:17people they offered us food they seem
  286. 12:19very kind
  287. 12:21and you know you no longer finish
  288. 12:23reading this sentence and you're like oh
  289. 12:25that's a nice sweet meeting on the beach
  290. 12:28where they shake hands and they you know
  291. 12:30that you know invite them to lunch and
  292. 12:33they start trying to figure each other
  293. 12:34out that's so cute And then you get to
  294. 12:37the next passage where Columbus goes on
  295. 12:41to say, "With 50 men, we could subjugate
  296. 12:44them and make them do whatever we want."
  297. 12:47And you go like, "Wait, time out. What
  298. 12:48did I just read there?" Because
  299. 12:50essentially what Columbus is saying is,
  300. 12:52"Okay, they are nice, they are sweet,
  301. 12:54cool people. Um, it's going to be really
  302. 12:56easy to enslave them." Now, I don't know
  303. 12:59about you guys, but me, when I meet a
  304. 13:02new person and I'm like, I met this cool
  305. 13:05new person today, I'm not thinking,
  306. 13:06great, I got a new slave. So, it takes
  307. 13:09some peculiar mindset to make the
  308. 13:12connection from nice and naive to new
  309. 13:15slave.
  310. 13:18So let's explore that a little bit
  311. 13:19especially because the whole Columbus
  312. 13:22legacy is tricky to this day because on
  313. 13:25one end col you know we still have a
  314. 13:27Columbus day holiday. Uh there's a huge
  315. 13:31amount of ink has been spilled about the
  316. 13:35greatness of Columbus. And from an
  317. 13:37exploration standpoint sure what he did
  318. 13:40was amazing. From a historical
  319. 13:43standpoint the arrival of Columbus
  320. 13:45changes history. Yes.
  321. 13:48However, these accounts which are
  322. 13:50usually the one given in grade school to
  323. 13:52you guys tend to gloss over what happens
  324. 13:55next which is really really ugly. there
  325. 13:59just no way to spin it
  326. 14:02because basically one of the thing that
  327. 14:03Columbus begin to get a little
  328. 14:08disturbed by is that he's not finding
  329. 14:11the luxury goods to take to take back to
  330. 14:14Spain which is sort of the point of the
  331. 14:16trip to begin with. That's what they
  332. 14:18paid for. So, you know, running into
  333. 14:21some sweet people who offer you food,
  334. 14:23that's not exactly that doesn't justify
  335. 14:25the expenses of the trip.
  336. 14:28What he does notice, however, is they
  337. 14:31notice that some natives have um some
  338. 14:34silver jewelry.
  339. 14:36And so Columbus figure, okay, maybe we
  340. 14:41maybe we cannot bring back the luxury
  341. 14:44goods we wanted, at least not from here.
  342. 14:46We can use this as a base to explore
  343. 14:48fter. But in the meantime, I have to
  344. 14:50bring back something. Maybe we could
  345. 14:53open silver mines out here and make some
  346. 14:56money from mining and bring that back to
  347. 14:58Spain and then the people who paid for
  348. 15:00my trip will be satisfied and all will
  349. 15:02be okay.
  350. 15:04Opening mines, of course, means you need
  351. 15:07slaves. And oh, look who's here. There's
  352. 15:09a bunch of Tino natives who seem uh not
  353. 15:13to have the technological edge needed to
  354. 15:16compete with Spaniards on a military
  355. 15:19level.
  356. 15:20And so that's I'm going to give you the
  357. 15:22quick version because Columbus has
  358. 15:24multiple trips and things get
  359. 15:26progressively uglier with each trip. I
  360. 15:28won't bother you with all the details,
  361. 15:30but the long arc of the story is that
  362. 15:31eventually the Spaniards will proceed to
  363. 15:36enslave the Tatino and the whole I mean
  364. 15:40when you read the accounts everything
  365. 15:41that happened from here is just so ugly
  366. 15:44that it's a wholesale origy of rape,
  367. 15:48slavery, absolute brutality.
  368. 15:51native women who give birth to their
  369. 15:53kids. They kill them as soon as they are
  370. 15:55born rather than have them see live in
  371. 15:58the slavery that they were experiencing
  372. 16:00being as brutal as it was.
  373. 16:03You know, the whole story is not pretty
  374. 16:05and that's why it's usually that part is
  375. 16:07left out of grade school narration of
  376. 16:10the encounter because
  377. 16:12it really is exact. you know, it kind of
  378. 16:14reminds you of the horrible things that
  379. 16:16human beings do to one another,
  380. 16:19unfortunately, very often throughout
  381. 16:21history.
  382. 16:22So, yeah, there's that, which is um, you
  383. 16:26know, there are a couple of images on
  384. 16:28the PowerPoint that sort of give you a
  385. 16:31vibe for the degree of brutality.
  386. 16:34I won't bother you with all the details
  387. 16:36right now, but you know, you got the
  388. 16:38picture. Now, another factor that's
  389. 16:40going to spell doom for the native
  390. 16:42populations, not just here, not just the
  391. 16:44Tino, but also for
  392. 16:47basically any encounter from here
  393. 16:49forward between Europeans and natives.
  394. 16:52There's a biological factor that will
  395. 16:54play a huge role, which is that the
  396. 16:57Americas were remarkably disease-free.
  397. 17:01Not all diseases but most of the
  398. 17:02epidemic diseases that today we still
  399. 17:06have things like anything as simple as
  400. 17:09the common cold to the flu to smallpox
  401. 17:13to you know bunch of these diseases that
  402. 17:16were very prevalent in Europe in Africa
  403. 17:18and in Asia. They were completely
  404. 17:21unknown in the Americas,
  405. 17:24which of course on the surface it sound
  406. 17:26great, right? I would rather be in the
  407. 17:27continent without all the nasty disease
  408. 17:30than the ones with the diseases.
  409. 17:33Well, yes, until the day with somebody
  410. 17:36bringing these diseases show up because
  411. 17:39what that means is that their people
  412. 17:42have had exposure to these diseases for
  413. 17:44generations and generations. So, they
  414. 17:46have kind of built an immunity. I mean,
  415. 17:47they still die from them, but not nearly
  416. 17:50at the rate that a population that has
  417. 17:52never been exposed to these diseases
  418. 17:55will die once they are first introduced
  419. 17:59to them. So, beside the monstrous amount
  420. 18:02of violence that the Spaniards unleash
  421. 18:05on the native population,
  422. 18:08you even more deadly is the fact that if
  423. 18:10a Spaniard just sneeze on somebody, the
  424. 18:13following week half of the village is
  425. 18:14dead. You know, mortality rates will be
  426. 18:18insane when you, you know, you could
  427. 18:21have easily mortality rates between 50
  428. 18:23to 90% of a population. And each
  429. 18:26epidemic disease can wipe out a
  430. 18:28population even further.
  431. 18:31In many ways, this is probably the worst
  432. 18:34demographic disaster in all of world
  433. 18:36history. When you look at the numbers of
  434. 18:38how many native people were here and how
  435. 18:41much they will be wiped out by a
  436. 18:44combination of violence and diseases is
  437. 18:47downright apocalyptic.
  438. 18:50But quick question, why was it that
  439. 18:54Europeans, Africans and Asians had these
  440. 18:57diseases and Native Americans did not?
  441. 19:02primarily boils down to one issue that
  442. 19:04even to farming and domestication of
  443. 19:07plants is something that was discovered
  444. 19:09in throughout the world. Domestication
  445. 19:12of animals is something that will not
  446. 19:14happen much in the Americas. For the
  447. 19:17most part, people will domesticate dogs.
  448. 19:20There are a few places in South America
  449. 19:21where people domesticate llamas. It's
  450. 19:24about it. There's not a whole lot of
  451. 19:26real domestication of animals going on.
  452. 19:30And most of the viruses that affect the
  453. 19:32human population today, most of the
  454. 19:34epidemic diseases at least, they come to
  455. 19:37us from living in close contact with
  456. 19:39animals. I mean, even today, we heard
  457. 19:42things like the swine flu or the bird
  458. 19:45flu or things like that.
  459. 19:48There are diseases that
  460. 19:52are
  461. 19:53common among barn animals and because of
  462. 19:56living in close contact with those
  463. 19:58animals, these diseases are able to
  464. 20:00mutate, attach themselves to a human
  465. 20:02host and then they become human
  466. 20:04diseases.
  467. 20:06Of course, just for the sake of grossing
  468. 20:09you guys out and giving you a disturbing
  469. 20:11image. The way these diseases are
  470. 20:13passed, you have of course blood to
  471. 20:15blood contact. you know, when butchering
  472. 20:17some of these animals or some of these
  473. 20:20things could be passed could be
  474. 20:21airborne. You know, you breath the same
  475. 20:24air and you pick up some of these um
  476. 20:27germs.
  477. 20:28Of course, those are not the only ways
  478. 20:30that diseases are passed along. Some of
  479. 20:33the most disgusting statistics I've ever
  480. 20:36seen report that pretty much everywhere
  481. 20:38where people have barn animals,
  482. 20:41ridiculous numbers of human beings ended
  483. 20:45up having sex with said barn animals,
  484. 20:49you know, spend lots and lots of time
  485. 20:51alone on the farm. That sheep begin to
  486. 20:53be looking more and more attractive by
  487. 20:56the second. Yes, gross, I know, but
  488. 21:00that's the reality of it. So now, while
  489. 21:02I've implanted this gross image in your
  490. 21:04brain, I'll try to move on to something
  491. 21:07else. And I hate to tell you, but I'm
  492. 21:0999% sure that no matter how much you're
  493. 21:12going to try to shake that image of the
  494. 21:14sheep is still going to be there hours
  495. 21:16from now. So sorry about that.
  496. 21:20But the point being,
  497. 21:23Europe, Asia, and Africa, they all
  498. 21:25domesticated animals. They all were in
  499. 21:28contact with one another. They were all
  500. 21:30exposed to similar diseases. The
  501. 21:33Americas were not. So when Europeans
  502. 21:36first show up,
  503. 21:38these new diseases just wreck the native
  504. 21:42populations. In some cases, the diseases
  505. 21:44reach the tribes before even Europeans
  506. 21:47do. So Europeans will have kind of the
  507. 21:49way paved for them as they arrive in
  508. 21:51areas that used to be densely populated.
  509. 21:54But because of being diseases being
  510. 21:55passed from European to native and then
  511. 21:57from native to native by the time
  512. 22:00European show up many tribes are already
  513. 22:02heavily suffering from these diseases.
  514. 22:06Keep in mind that at the end of the
  515. 22:081400s early for 1500s nobody's fully
  516. 22:11understanding how diseases are passed
  517. 22:13along. Nobody understand germs and
  518. 22:16bacteria and all that stuff. So the way
  519. 22:20people respond,
  520. 22:22well, they don't really fully know how
  521. 22:24to explain it. I mean, there will be
  522. 22:25cases, for example, when British
  523. 22:28Puritans will show up in the 1600s in
  524. 22:30the Americas and they will see native
  525. 22:33people dying like flies as a result of
  526. 22:35these diseases. Their interpretation
  527. 22:38will be basically the same way they
  528. 22:40interpret everything else, which is,
  529. 22:42"Thank you, God, for wiping out these
  530. 22:44evil pagans and proving that you we are
  531. 22:46your chosen people.
  532. 22:48in many way reinforced this idea that
  533. 22:50this must be a divine act um paving the
  534. 22:54way for a superior civilization and
  535. 22:57wiping out these evil people were not
  536. 22:59Christian that's basically the way they
  537. 23:01saw it
  538. 23:04in any case so in addition to fighting
  539. 23:08wars against European invasions natives
  540. 23:13were
  541. 23:15seeing their numbers been dramatically
  542. 23:18reduced from diseases.
  543. 23:20So these in many ways explain why more
  544. 23:24than technology more than anything else
  545. 23:26this explain why Europeans will be able
  546. 23:29to eventually conquer in the Americas
  547. 23:31and it still take a long time
  548. 23:35but you know if um native Americans had
  549. 23:38domesticated animals and the same
  550. 23:40diseases when Europeans showed up it
  551. 23:42would have not have been an easy thing
  552. 23:43to take over the Americas. They may have
  553. 23:45not been able to. Maybe they would,
  554. 23:47maybe they wouldn't.
  555. 23:49If natives had the diseases and
  556. 23:51Europeans did, when Europeans would have
  557. 23:53shown up, when they showed up, they
  558. 23:55would have quickly gone back home
  559. 23:56realizing that this was not a healthy
  560. 23:58place for them. So this one element,
  561. 24:02this one random piece of history, the
  562. 24:05fact that natives did not domesticate
  563. 24:08animals is what make European
  564. 24:10colonization possible. Without that, it
  565. 24:14would have been a very different story.
  566. 24:18Before we leave off Columbus and get
  567. 24:21into something else, one thing I should
  568. 24:23mention, I kind of hinted at this
  569. 24:24earlier when I said that the culture of
  570. 24:28the times has an impact on the encounter
  571. 24:31between the Tyino and the Spaniards.
  572. 24:34Well, here is one thing. If you recall
  573. 24:36our first lecture when we discussed the
  574. 24:38whole difference between inclusive
  575. 24:40religious worldviews and the exclusive
  576. 24:42ones, the encounter between the Tyino
  577. 24:45and the Spaniard is very representative
  578. 24:47of that because the inclusive approach
  579. 24:51which is sort of the Tyino worldview is
  580. 24:53these guys are different. The Spani are
  581. 24:55showing up. They are obviously different
  582. 24:57people with different beliefs. Let's
  583. 24:59check them out. Maybe we'll hate them.
  584. 25:01Maybe we'll get into wars with them. But
  585. 25:03maybe we won't. So, you don't know until
  586. 25:06you check them out what it's going to be
  587. 25:08like. So, come on in, have some food,
  588. 25:11and let's figure it out if we like you
  589. 25:13or we hate you.
  590. 25:15The Spanish approach is a bit different
  591. 25:17and it is influenced by that exclusive
  592. 25:20mindset. You know, the moment
  593. 25:23they find out that the tyino don't
  594. 25:25belong to what they believe to be the
  595. 25:28one true religion, it's pretty much all
  596. 25:31they need to know about them. It's then
  597. 25:34there are only two possibility you're
  598. 25:35either one of us or you are a servants
  599. 25:38of the devil and if you are a servant of
  600. 25:40the devil I mean the nice approach will
  601. 25:42be Spanish priests will try to convert
  602. 25:44them or the other approach is we you
  603. 25:46know we can do whatever you want because
  604. 25:49you're on the side of evil and so
  605. 25:51inevitably these two have lead to a less
  606. 25:55uh friendly interaction which is
  607. 25:57basically what you see happening in this
  608. 26:00encounter between the two sides.
  609. 26:03Now having said that, the encounter
  610. 26:06between
  611. 26:08the new and old world has a big impact
  612. 26:11on everyone. For one, what what become
  613. 26:14known as the Colombian exchange is the
  614. 26:16fact that it's an exchange that's very
  615. 26:18profitable for Europe, Africa, and Asia,
  616. 26:21and not so much for the Americas.
  617. 26:23Because part of this exchange is that
  618. 26:25the Americas will receive a bunch of
  619. 26:27diseases that will wipe out big chunks
  620. 26:29of the local population.
  621. 26:32The Europe, Africa, and Asia on the
  622. 26:34other hand receive a whole lot of
  623. 26:37products that will help life in those
  624. 26:39continents quite a bit.
  625. 26:42Think of things like tomatoes, which
  626. 26:45kind of makes me wonder what Italian
  627. 26:46cooking was like before contact with the
  628. 26:49Americas. Uh, potatoes are an American
  629. 26:52crop that will have a huge demographic
  630. 26:54impact on the old world, allowing for
  631. 26:57the survival of many more people thanks
  632. 26:59to this food that's rich in calories and
  633. 27:01relatively easy to grow. So, potatoes
  634. 27:04will have a big impact in growing the
  635. 27:06population of Europe, Asia, and Africa.
  636. 27:09Corn come from the Americas. uh things
  637. 27:13like chocolate. You know, there are 10
  638. 27:14million things that come from the
  639. 27:16Americas that will make life better for
  640. 27:19the old world. So that's part of that
  641. 27:23Colombian exchange.
  642. 27:25One thing that the Spaniards will do as
  643. 27:28they begin to venture in and exploring
  644. 27:31first in other islands throughout the
  645. 27:33Caribbeans and then on the mainland
  646. 27:36because at this point the Spaniards will
  647. 27:38be the dominant power on the ocean. the
  648. 27:40Portuguese a little bit but the
  649. 27:42Spaniards in a big way and they will
  650. 27:44have a virtual monopoly over
  651. 27:46colonization in the Americas in the
  652. 27:48early days.
  653. 27:50And one thing that they will do they
  654. 27:52create this document known as the
  655. 27:54requirment
  656. 27:58was something that Spanish soldiers were
  657. 28:00required to read when they will
  658. 28:02disembark on a new land and meet the
  659. 28:05local population.
  660. 28:07The requirement is a really funny weird
  661. 28:09document because essentially gives
  662. 28:11native people a choice which sound very
  663. 28:13sweet except not so much because what
  664. 28:17the requirement does essentially is
  665. 28:18telling them look you have a choice
  666. 28:20here. you can become our subjects,
  667. 28:23in which case will be somewhat fair to
  668. 28:25you. Or if you stubbornly resist to
  669. 28:29become our subjects, then I'm sorry to
  670. 28:31tell you, but you brought it upon
  671. 28:33yourself, and it's only right for us to
  672. 28:35start wars against you and enslave you
  673. 28:37and wipe you out, which is kind of like,
  674. 28:40well, neither choice sound all that
  675. 28:42exciting. Do you want to be my subject
  676. 28:43or do you want to die? It's like, can I
  677. 28:45get the third option here?
  678. 28:48But that's no, sorry, you don't got a
  679. 28:51third option. That's the And somehow
  680. 28:54reading this document and giving this
  681. 28:56ridiculous choice to natives made
  682. 28:58somebody back home feel better about the
  683. 29:00whole process of colonization of how
  684. 29:02they were still the good guys.
  685. 29:05By the way, to make the whole thing even
  686. 29:07funnier in a tragic kind of way is the
  687. 29:09fact that the document was usually read
  688. 29:11in either Latin or Spanish. Of course,
  689. 29:14neither language being spoken by native
  690. 29:16people. So the whole thing went like
  691. 29:18going once, going twice, they're not
  692. 29:20becoming our subject. Okay, forget it.
  693. 29:22Let's just move in and start conquering.
  694. 29:25So it's odd to say the least. And with
  695. 29:28this, it's a wrap for today's lecture.

About this transcript

This page contains the full transcript of US History Lecture 4 by History On Fire, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 4,546 words across 695 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.

What you can do with it

Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to translate the transcript into 100+ languages.

Free YouTube transcript tool

YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, translation to 100+ languages, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.