United States Government The Judicial Branch — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:01there are literally hundreds of courts
- 0:03in our country but there's only one like
- 0:05this it's the highest court in the land
- 0:08the United States Supreme Court and
- 0:11what's the first thing you see when you
- 0:12enter
- 0:16it nope the first thing you see is equal
- 0:21justice under law what does it mean that
- 0:25the United States is a nation built on
- 0:28laws and everyone must be treated
- 0:30equally by them everyone from the
- 0:33youngest citizen to the highest official
- 0:35all are bound and protected by the same
- 0:38laws so though it's above the door Equal
- 0:41justice under law is really the
- 0:43Cornerstone of the judicial branch of
- 0:45the United States
- 0:49government Give me liberty or give me
- 0:52death the only thing we have to fear is
- 0:56fear itself and St
- 1:00what your country can do for you Mr
- 1:04gorbachov tear down this
- 1:09wall I pledge allegiance to the flag of
- 1:13the United States of
- 1:20America Equal justice is part of what is
- 1:23known as the rule of law the rule of law
- 1:27means that laws not Kings or dictator
- 1:30ators govern our society still it's
- 1:33easier to carve a concept like Equal
- 1:35justice into stone than to put it into
- 1:38practice just what equal justice is and
- 1:41who it really covers has been hotly
- 1:42debated since the earliest years of our
- 1:45Republic this is the place where laws
- 1:47meet their match in the
- 1:50court now if I were to tell you there
- 1:52was a match in the court you might
- 1:54assume I was talking about a light in
- 1:56the halls of Justice you might even
- 1:58think I was planning a game of
- 2:00tenis the problem with words is they can
- 2:03mean different things to different
- 2:05people and the same thing is true of
- 2:07laws that's why someone has to decide
- 2:09what they mean and how they apply to
- 2:11specific situations cuz let's face it in
- 2:14the end a law is just words on paper
- 2:17laws are made by the Legislative Branch
- 2:20or congress they are put into action by
- 2:22the executive branch headed by the
- 2:24president and they are interpreted by
- 2:26the judicial branch don't you think the
- 2:28court should have been informed of
- 2:30most people think that when a law is
- 2:32enacted and it's written down that's it
- 2:34it doesn't need to be interpreted the
- 2:36words are what they are but in reality
- 2:38that isn't the case what happens is that
- 2:41a law gets passed and then it's not
- 2:43clear to people exactly what it means or
- 2:45to whom that law applies so that's the
- 2:48job of the courts often times the courts
- 2:51have to look at a law and say to people
- 2:53this is what this law means the courts
- 2:56often times are in the business of
- 2:57interpreting the law
- 2:59back in 1787 the people who wrote the
- 3:02blueprint for our government the United
- 3:04States Constitution divided up Powers so
- 3:07that no one group would have too much
- 3:09control it's called separation of powers
- 3:12but even if the three branches are
- 3:14separate they are not independent each
- 3:17one has ties to the others creating a
- 3:19system of checks and balances when our
- 3:22government was just starting out no one
- 3:24knew exactly how the judicial branch fit
- 3:26into that system of checks and balances
- 3:29in fact
- 3:30the Judiciary might have been completely
- 3:32overpowered by the other two branches if
- 3:34not for a landmark court
- 3:37case 1801 the country faces a
- 3:41constitutional crisis in a last ditch
- 3:44effort to save some of his part's power
- 3:46outgoing President John Adams creates
- 3:49many new Judiciary positions and fills
- 3:52them with his political allies Adams
- 3:54also appoints his friend John Marshall
- 3:56to Chief Justice of the United States
- 3:59the most important position on the
- 4:01Supreme Court but when the next
- 4:03president Thomas Jefferson takes office
- 4:06he is angered by Adam's lastminute
- 4:09attempt to retain power Jefferson orders
- 4:11his secretary of state James Madison to
- 4:14stop delivery on the remaining
- 4:16commissions preventing many of Adam's
- 4:18appointees from starting their new jobs
- 4:21one of them William Marbury is furious
- 4:24he sues Madison for failure to perform
- 4:26his duty and brings his case directly to
- 4:29the Supreme Court Court whoa Marbury
- 4:32versus Madison was one scene you had
- 4:36John Marshall the friend of the
- 4:38ex-president officiating over a case
- 4:40that directly affected the power of the
- 4:42new president Thomas Jefferson there
- 4:45were even rumors flying that Jefferson
- 4:48intended to have chief justice Marshall
- 4:50removed from
- 4:51office fortunately John Marshall
- 4:54believed that a strong and independent
- 4:56judicial branch is essential for a
- 4:58democratic government
- 5:00it is emphatically the province of the
- 5:02judicial Department to say what the law
- 5:05is Marshall's solution to Marvy versus
- 5:08Madison was simple and Brilliant the
- 5:11Chief Justice agreed that Marbury should
- 5:12have gotten his commission But
- 5:14ultimately he said that was not the
- 5:17point the real issue was whether the
- 5:19Supreme Court should be hearing his case
- 5:21at all marbury's case had come before
- 5:24the court based on a law called the
- 5:25Judiciary Act of
- 5:281789 but the United States Constitution
- 5:31is clear about what kinds of cases can
- 5:33be heard by the Supreme Court it's a
- 5:35pretty short list and marber is was
- 5:38definitely not on it the beauty of Marb
- 5:41versus Madison is that with that case we
- 5:44finally got a clear understanding of how
- 5:46the various court systems fit together
- 5:49and how they all should work together
- 5:52Chief Justice John Marshall found that
- 5:54marbury's case should have started in a
- 5:56lower court and because it was in
- 5:58conflict with the Constitution tion he
- 6:00also ruled that the Judiciary Act was
- 6:04unconstitutional Marshall dismissed
- 6:05Marberry versus Madison averting the
- 6:08political crisis most importantly he
- 6:11established the Supreme Court as the
- 6:13last word on the
- 6:15Constitution the Court's power to decide
- 6:18if a law agrees with the US Constitution
- 6:20is known as judicial review do you know
- 6:23what happens to a law that doesn't agree
- 6:25with the Constitution I would think they
- 6:28would pass another law that counters
- 6:30it a law that doesn't agree with the
- 6:33Constitution does not get passed if the
- 6:36Court decides that a law is
- 6:38unconstitutional it is declared null and
- 6:40void as if it never
- 6:42existed Marbury versus Madison was the
- 6:45first time the judicial branch declared
- 6:47a law made by Congress
- 6:50unconstitutional firmly establishing the
- 6:52Supreme Court's ability to check the
- 6:54other branches of
- 6:56government in America some laws apply to
- 6:59the whole country While others only
- 7:01concern individual states so we have two
- 7:04different court systems the federal
- 7:06court system for the whole country and
- 7:08the state court systems one for each of
- 7:11the 50 States state cases deal with
- 7:15cases that are based upon laws enacted
- 7:17by the States Federal cases deal with
- 7:21cases based upon laws enacted by the
- 7:23federal government so any federal laws
- 7:26are laws based upon the United States
- 7:28Constitution
- 7:30and any state laws are based upon laws
- 7:32enacted by state legislates and based
- 7:34upon state
- 7:36constitutions a Court's authority to
- 7:38hear a case is known as jurisdiction and
- 7:41the first court to hear a case has
- 7:43original jurisdiction state court
- 7:46systems have jurisdiction over the vast
- 7:47majority of court cases since most
- 7:49offenses happen within a single State's
- 7:52boundaries let's say somebody steals
- 7:54your car takes it for a joy ride and
- 7:57leaves it on the next block when the
- 7:59police NAB the thief he gets tried in
- 8:01the state court system but if he whisks
- 8:04your wheels across state lines he gets a
- 8:07one-way ticket to the federal court
- 8:09system crossing state lines moves
- 8:12jurisdiction from the state court system
- 8:14to the federal system since the crime
- 8:16and apprehension of the offender
- 8:18happened in two different states the
- 8:21state courts may do the bulk of the work
- 8:23but there's still plenty of Cases left
- 8:24over for the federal
- 8:26government most federal cases enter the
- 8:29system through the district courts as
- 8:31the main trial courts in the federal
- 8:33system district courts hear both
- 8:35criminal and civil cases criminal cases
- 8:38deal with broken laws anything from
- 8:41traffic violations to kidnapping but
- 8:43civil cases involve private disputes
- 8:46like bankruptcy and divorce every state
- 8:49has at least one district and many have
- 8:51more and every district has at least two
- 8:54judges assigned to it usually judges
- 8:57Pride alone those sometimes a panel of
- 9:00three judges hears a
- 9:02case in all there are about 630 district
- 9:06court judges hearing more than 300,000
- 9:09cases per year that's like
- 9:12475 cases per judge what a workload when
- 9:16I'm sent a trial a criminal trial to
- 9:18preside over there are lots of things
- 9:20that I have to do right away I have to
- 9:22meet the lawyers I have to find out what
- 9:25the case is all about from the lawyers
- 9:27and then I have to make some decisions
- 9:28about what evidence can come into court
- 9:30and what can't come into court and I do
- 9:32all of that before the jury is even
- 9:34picked so I basically set all the rules
- 9:36up then the trial begins Witnesses
- 9:38testify and I'm asked periodically to
- 9:40rule on objections whether or not
- 9:42something is a proper question or not a
- 9:44proper question we try the whole case
- 9:47and then I have to instruct the jury
- 9:49about what the law is what law is going
- 9:51to apply in this case then the lawyers
- 9:53get to argue the case and I again have
- 9:54to decide if the argument is proper or
- 9:57not and then I send the jury off to
- 9:59deliberate they go off to deliberate and
- 10:02while they're doing that I get sent
- 10:03another trial and I bring in the next
- 10:05load of lawyers and we start the whole
- 10:06thing all over again most of the time
- 10:09the district judge's verdict is final
- 10:12but say you think the district court
- 10:13made an error somehow you even believe
- 10:16that the mistake led the court to reach
- 10:18the wrong conclusion do you have to put
- 10:20up with it no way you can ask a higher
- 10:23Court to take another look at that
- 10:25decision it's called an appeal which is
- 10:28why these courts are are known as courts
- 10:30of appeals or appell at
- 10:32courts less than 15% of the cases from
- 10:35the district courts wind up in appet
- 10:37court and the number of Courts shrinks
- 10:40accordingly the more than 90 district
- 10:42courts are divided between a dozen
- 10:44judicial circuits and each circuit has
- 10:46its own court of appeals here it's
- 10:49determined if errors were made in the
- 10:51original trial if so the earlier
- 10:54decision can be overturned Circuit Court
- 10:57judges hear cases in panels of three
- 11:00are their decisions three times as good
- 11:02the reason we have three is that there
- 11:04may be a variety of opinions as to
- 11:06whether or not what that judge did was
- 11:07right or wrong and so we have decided to
- 11:10make the system a fair system instead of
- 11:12having one person look at what one other
- 11:15judge did we're going to have at least
- 11:17three people and they have to vote and
- 11:19if two of the three agree that's enough
- 11:22to have a decision come out of the
- 11:23appell court to just let us know whether
- 11:25or not what that judge did was right or
- 11:28what that judge did was wrong
- 11:29well if three judges are better than one
- 11:32imagine what nine of them could
- 11:34do and now at the top of the pyramid the
- 11:38crem de La Creme the only Court created
- 11:41by the Constitution and the one they
- 11:43call Supreme the United States Supreme
- 11:48Court Oh yay Oh yay Oh yay all persons
- 11:54having business before The Honorable the
- 11:56Supreme Court of the United States are
- 11:58admonished to draw near and give their
- 12:00attention for the court is now sitting
- 12:03God save the United States and this
- 12:05honorable
- 12:07Court it takes a special kind of case to
- 12:10make it to the highest court in the land
- 12:12because decisions made here affect every
- 12:14other court in the country of the
- 12:17thousands of requests that come in each
- 12:19year only about 150 get their day in
- 12:22this court the Supreme Court has
- 12:24original jurisdiction on cases involving
- 12:26constitutional interstate and National
- 12:29and international issues but that's a
- 12:31small fraction of the Court's case load
- 12:34mostly the Supreme Court serves as the
- 12:36ultimate court of appeals hearing cases
- 12:39from both the federal and the state
- 12:40court systems it's up to the nine
- 12:43Supreme Court Justices themselves to
- 12:45decide which cases they'll take on what
- 12:48makes a case Supreme Court material the
- 12:51Supreme Court is very picky and deciding
- 12:55what cases it will review and it has to
- 12:57be picky the Supreme Court cannot review
- 13:00every case that everyone wants it to
- 13:01review they'd never get their work done
- 13:04so the Supreme Court's job really is to
- 13:07decide cases that will have an important
- 13:10impact on everyone in society for that
- 13:14reason they must be very selective in
- 13:17the cases that they will
- 13:19hear as the country's oldest and most
- 13:22distinguished Court the Supreme Court is
- 13:25heavy on tradition for one thing you
- 13:27don't call these folks judg judges
- 13:29they're
- 13:30justices at the top is the Chief Justice
- 13:33of the United States and the other eight
- 13:35are associate
- 13:36justices behind closed doors they debate
- 13:39the merits of each case and what is said
- 13:42is a closely guarded
- 13:44secret every day starts with a group
- 13:46handshake a custom started by Chief
- 13:49Justice Melville Fuller to remind the
- 13:51justices that even though they might
- 13:53disagree they need to be United in their
- 13:56purpose Supreme Court Justices often
- 13:59worked together for many years since
- 14:01federal judges are appointed for Life
- 14:04once in they're tough to remove only if
- 14:07a judge is suspected of behaving in a
- 14:09way Unbecoming to the office can he or
- 14:12she be impeached by the House of
- 14:14Representatives talk about job security
- 14:17lifelong appointment means federal
- 14:18judges have got to be topnotch Justice
- 14:22John Paul Stevens once wrote it is
- 14:24confidence in the men and women who
- 14:26administered the judicial system that is
- 14:28the true backbone of the rule of
- 14:36law the first African-American appointed
- 14:39to the Supreme Court th Good Marshall
- 14:42inspired such confidence prior to
- 14:44joining its bench Mr Marshall had a long
- 14:47association with the Supreme Court as
- 14:49the legal director of the
- 14:51NAACP he argued 32 cases before it
- 14:55including Brown versus the Board of
- 14:57Education of Topeka can Kansas in Brown
- 15:00versus Board of Education the United
- 15:02States Supreme Court did something that
- 15:05was probably the most important thing
- 15:06it's ever done and that is by one
- 15:09decision it made tremendous change in
- 15:11this country by helping those who had
- 15:14been kept out of the system in this case
- 15:16African-American people from getting an
- 15:18equal education as those who are not
- 15:21African-American by one decision enabled
- 15:24a whole group of people to have access
- 15:26to a public education system in this
- 15:28country It's a Wonderful example of how
- 15:30the courts can make wonderful and
- 15:32positive social change during that case
- 15:36Marshall expanded the notion of equal
- 15:38justice under law equal he said means
- 15:42getting the same thing at the same time
- 15:44and in the same
- 15:46place it was a definition that would
- 15:48change
- 15:49America made by an American
- 15:55original the president of the United
- 15:57States nominates all federal judges but
- 16:00the Senate must consent to the nominees
- 16:03it's a check on the judicial branch by
- 16:05the Legislative Branch even though
- 16:07they're picked by the president and
- 16:09confirmed by the Senate judges are
- 16:11beholden to neither the independence of
- 16:14the Judiciary is what makes it work and
- 16:18what ensures the independence of the
- 16:20Judiciary are the lifetime appointments
- 16:23of all of the justices this means that
- 16:25when the justices occasionally have to
- 16:27make a decision that might not be very
- 16:29popular these justices don't have to
- 16:32look over their shoulders and say oh I'm
- 16:34making someone unhappy that means I
- 16:36might lose my job what it means is that
- 16:38they have lifetime tenure they can make
- 16:41the tough calls and make the courageous
- 16:42decisions and know that they will still
- 16:45have their
- 16:46jobs how the Constitution is interpreted
- 16:49has widespread political
- 16:51implications so why does everybody seem
- 16:54to have a different idea about how it
- 16:55should be done blame the Constitution
- 16:59the people who wrote the Constitution
- 17:01known as the framers of the Constitution
- 17:04left it short and vague on purpose they
- 17:07hoped a skeletal document would weather
- 17:09a changing society and stand the test of
- 17:13time their strategy worked no other
- 17:17country in the world has such a
- 17:19longlasting
- 17:20constitution some believe that even
- 17:23though it's more than 200 years old its
- 17:25word should still be taken literally
- 17:28like justice antonine Scalia he says the
- 17:31words are the law I think that's what is
- 17:34meant by a government of laws not of men
- 17:37others argue that it's not the words
- 17:39themselves that matter but the original
- 17:41intent of the framers but it's pretty
- 17:43tough to know for sure what some 18th
- 17:46century guy was
- 17:48thinking and then there are those who
- 17:50believe the Constitution is a living
- 17:53document its interpretation has to
- 17:56change to suit the times as our society
- 17:59changes as we feel differently about
- 18:01different issues there is always that
- 18:03Constitution that Bedrock that
- 18:05Foundation that continues to say to
- 18:07people these rights that people have in
- 18:10this country will always be here no
- 18:13matter what we face and no matter for
- 18:15how long we Face them these rights will
- 18:17always be there the Constitution
- 18:19continues to live as do we for instance
- 18:23the framers could never have foreseen
- 18:24the internet yet we can take the
- 18:26underlying principles of freedom of
- 18:28speech granted by the First Amendment
- 18:30and apply them to it so the Constitution
- 18:34stands still but Society changes all the
- 18:37time no wonder interpreting the
- 18:39Constitution is so tricky if you stick
- 18:42to the letter of 18th century law you
- 18:44run the risk of becoming seriously out
- 18:46of date then again if you modernize too
- 18:49much you might lose sight of the
- 18:51framer's original ideas it's a balancing
- 18:54act that is constantly played out in the
- 18:56Supreme Court
- 18:59December
- 19:011965 in De Mo Iowa several students
- 19:04decide to wear black armbands to school
- 19:06to protest the war in Vietnam worried
- 19:09that the armbands will disrupt
- 19:11classrooms School authorities issue a
- 19:13statement Banning them 16-year-old
- 19:16Christopher eart 15-year-old John tinker
- 19:18and his 13-year-old Sister Mary Beth
- 19:21wear them anyway oh man you can see
- 19:24what's coming kids go to school flaunt
- 19:27the rules big Riot erupts teachers freak
- 19:30out kids get thrown out of school lives
- 19:32are
- 19:33ruined actually none of that happened
- 19:36the students wore the armbands but no
- 19:38disturbances occurred still all three
- 19:42kids were suspended angry and frustrated
- 19:45the students decided to sue the school
- 19:47district for violating their First
- 19:49Amendment right to free speech Tinker
- 19:52versus the de Mo Independent Community
- 19:54School District went all the way to the
- 19:56United States Supreme Court at the heart
- 19:58of the case was whether kids in public
- 20:00schools have a right to free speech at
- 20:02all one of the biggest holes in the
- 20:04school district's argument that the
- 20:06students were disruptive was effectively
- 20:08exposed by associate Justice third Good
- 20:10Marshall the court found that the
- 20:13protest had not been disruptive but that
- 20:15the civil rights of Christopher ehart
- 20:17and Mary Beth and John Tinker had been
- 20:19violated writing the opinion for the
- 20:22majority of justices associate Justice
- 20:24Abe foris noted it can hardly be argued
- 20:27that either student or teachers shed
- 20:30their constitutional rights to freedom
- 20:32of speech or expression at the
- 20:34schoolhouse gate in our system State
- 20:37operated schools may not be enclaves of
- 20:42totalitarianism but two of the nine
- 20:44justices disagreed justi as Hugo Black
- 20:46wrote I wish wholly to disclaim any
- 20:50purpose on my part to hold that the
- 20:52Federal Constitution compels the
- 20:54teachers parents and elected school
- 20:57officials to surrender render control of
- 20:59the American public school system to
- 21:02public school students I
- 21:06disent you know the process of Tinker
- 21:08versus de Mo was just wonderful I mean
- 21:10it was great because what you had you
- 21:12had the justices disagreeing arguing and
- 21:15you know they argued because two of the
- 21:17justices at least had very different
- 21:19views and very different positions on
- 21:21what should happen in the case and
- 21:23that's the beauty of the whole system
- 21:25the beauty is that you bring people
- 21:27together with different views with
- 21:30Divergent positions on an issue they
- 21:32talk they discuss sometimes they argue
- 21:35but in the end they come out with a
- 21:37decision and most of the time it's the
- 21:39right decision it's the right
- 21:42call that's the phenomenal power of the
- 21:45judicial branch from the district and
- 21:47state level on up to the Supreme Court
- 21:49it constantly interprets and applies the
- 21:52thousands of laws that govern the
- 21:53American
- 21:55people Tinker versus De Moine changed
- 21:58the way people people thought about the
- 21:59First Amendment rights of kids in a very
- 22:02real sense it expanded the idea of who
- 22:04Equal justice applies to you and me
- 22:08[Music]
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of United States Government The Judicial Branch by Cathleen Hayes, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 3,509 words across 536 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.