UI/UX разбор FormFactor: дизайн ошибки, визуальная иерархия, отступы, работа с цветом и выравнивание — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:00Hi, friends. Today we'll be analyzing
- 0:05all sorts of visual mistakes. I've been
- 0:10given a bunch of different layouts. And
- 0:14someone wasn't shy at all. Of course, I
- 0:16love people like that. Seriously, I
- 0:21love people who aren't shy, who just
- 0:23share everything they've got. Oh, well,
- 0:26we'll see, of course, we won't analyze
- 0:28everything, but I'll try to see how
- 0:30many of those we've given today, see
- 0:34how many we can get through. If we
- 0:36don't have time, we'll do another one,
- 0:38and then we'll look again. We need some
- 0:42recurring topics, because it's really
- 0:43hard to come up with new topics for
- 0:45broadcasts if you're hosting them
- 0:47regularly. There you go. But I know you
- 0:50like portfolio reviews, you like layout
- 0:52reviews. So, we'll host these stories.
- 0:57Well, I'll start at the beginning and
- 0:59then gradually move on. We have about
- 1:02an hour and a half. We'll see about the
- 1:05timing. I've already commented on a few
- 1:08things, but not everything. Let's start
- 1:12looking. Anyway, Vladislav, it's a job
- 1:15search service. I looked, and these are
- 1:19the layouts. I generally like almost
- 1:22everything here. The only thing I'd
- 1:27draw attention to, well, you only see
- 1:29one comment here, is the button size.
- 1:33We have these, well, nice, big fields.
- 1:3756 is trendy these days for different
- 1:40interfaces. My chat has disappeared
- 1:43somewhere. Just a second, I'll get it
- 1:45out so I can see if you write me
- 1:47anything. Aha. So, here are the trendy
- 1:54sizes, big, large, like in all foreign
- 1:57services, fields of 52, 56, and a
- 1:59modest button, 48, it doesn't quite
- 2:02match the sizes of the things you have
- 2:05in your layouts. Let's say you have
- 2:10this thing, you have a tag, well, a tag
- 2:13or a switch is 46, and the button is 48
- 2:15, but the button is clearly more
- 2:17important than the switch. So I think
- 2:23if you made it bigger, they would look
- 2:25secondary compared to that button of
- 2:27yours. There. Well, in general, you
- 2:32need to keep an eye on the different
- 2:34sizes you have, because there are some
- 2:36other rather atypical things here.
- 2:38Let's say the height is 30. That's a
- 2:41very specific size. Let me open it now.
- 2:44I always have supported files here. Uh,
- 2:48so now, oh, anyway, the file with my
- 2:57lectures. I regularly show this thing
- 3:02in almost every broadcast. And did you
- 3:07know that there's such a thing in
- 3:08product design as generally accepted
- 3:10sizes? Well, I mean, in reality, if you
- 3:15look at any design system, except for
- 3:17some very specific ones or where this
- 3:19is done intentionally, you'll come
- 3:21across this line of sizes, which came
- 3:23to us from Material Design. And here
- 3:28I've marked the indents in yellow,
- 3:30which are very rarely used. And many of
- 3:33the sizes aren't here at all, like, say
- 3:36, 42 or 38, because, well, you'll
- 3:38practically never see them. And the
- 3:40size 30, it just happens to fall into
- 3:42that category of indentation. The size
- 3:44six falls into that category. The size
- 3:47two too, but I use two quite often
- 3:49myself and like it. So there you have
- 3:52it. Well, in general, designers often
- 3:54pay attention to these things when they
- 3:56look at them. So, it looks, mm,
- 3:59peculiar. Well, that is, peculiar,
- 4:03because everyone has gotten used to
- 4:05these sizes over many years, and their
- 4:07eye catches them. So, for example, here
- 4:12it was 46. Well, that's a more specific
- 4:15size for interfaces, there 48 or 44,
- 4:18and here 30, and so on. Well, that is,
- 4:21in general, well, these are small
- 4:23things, that is, that are also worth
- 4:24paying attention to. In short, I would
- 4:27make the buttons larger, I would check
- 4:29the sizes. And if I were you, I would
- 4:34also do something with this color,
- 4:36because now I'll try to explain it. And
- 4:43, by the way, with this color here, too
- 4:45, since you're just drawing for concept
- 4:47, you need to make sure it doesn't
- 4:49blend. And what I don't like about
- 4:55color, I'll try to explain it now so it
- 4:57doesn't sound like some kind of blatant
- 4:59matter of taste. For example, two years
- 5:11ago we had this trend of slapping
- 5:13everything with a color from the upper
- 5:15right corner. Well, that is, some kind
- 5:20of maximally dopamine-inducing color.
- 5:24Well, maybe it's not very visible in
- 5:26this deep stuff, but let's say, you see
- 5:28, I'm scrolling through all the colors,
- 5:31and the colors in this corner are kind
- 5:33of the brightest, the most, ah, really
- 5:36brain-twisting. Before that, many years
- 5:41ago, during the flat design era, ah,
- 5:43the opposite colors were fashionable.
- 5:49Now I'll show you, for example, using
- 5:51yellow. Now it's too muddy. Well, in
- 6:03short, like pastel tones, some light
- 6:06things. I'll Google it for you now. You
- 6:09might remember these icons with shadows
- 6:11, where they were also diagonally
- 6:13scattered. They had these colors. And
- 6:18now it's the next level, in short, they
- 6:20were completely flat and not very
- 6:22contrasting. Then they were super
- 6:28bright here in this corner. And now
- 6:32they're kind of pale, but a little,
- 6:34well, either completely pale with, well
- 6:42, something like this, or even a little
- 6:44, in short, with dirt, that is, a
- 6:46little with a grayish tint, literally a
- 6:49few values into gray. And now you have
- 6:53this color, it's like, well, if you
- 6:57compare the difference, it's kind of
- 6:58neither here nor there. It's not bright
- 7:02, and not pale, and not completely dark
- 7:04. Well, that is, the dark ones are
- 7:08somewhere here, well, let's say, deep
- 7:10here, yes, and some other color is here
- 7:13and is neither bright, nor like that.
- 7:15That is, it's somewhere in the middle.
- 7:18And I would, well, I don't know, try,
- 7:20in short, to look for another option
- 7:23for the color, so that it would be
- 7:25either brighter, because if it were
- 7:27darker, it would turn into such a
- 7:29depressing, in short, shade. Or paler.
- 7:34Well, if I make it paler, then,
- 7:36naturally, I'd have to invert it, so
- 7:38that the buttons would not be, well,
- 7:41not light, but, let's say, even the
- 7:43text on them would be the same color.
- 7:45Now I'll try. Well, this is too, in
- 7:52short, pale. Well, like, I looked for
- 7:57something, in short, a little fresher,
- 7:59and, either higher or lower. Something
- 8:03like that. But overall, I like the
- 8:05design. By the way, I also like the
- 8:08gray colors. Everything here is done
- 8:10quite well. Well done. Go ask for a lot
- 8:13of money. Okay, Oksana. Oksana, she has
- 8:16here, I have a lot of questions about
- 8:19this layout. Ah, I'll start too. But
- 8:21before reviews, I always—I forgot to
- 8:24mention this just now, because the
- 8:26mockup was good. Oh, I say things like
- 8:29that. I'm commenting on the design,
- 8:31well, I've been picking it apart for
- 8:33years. And when people listen to it—
- 8:37well, for example, when we were
- 8:39reviewing the test assignments, many
- 8:41commented that the title was offensive,
- 8:43that it was reviewing failed test
- 8:45assignments. And people feel these
- 8:49negative emotions about feedback on
- 8:51work, even if it's useful, even if it's
- 8:53kind of correct, because they associate
- 8:55themselves with their work. So, if I
- 8:58say that the mockup, well, there's
- 9:00something wrong with it, then people
- 9:02think there's something wrong with them
- 9:04. But I don't mean that at all. I mean,
- 9:08if I say that something's wrong with
- 9:10the mockup, well, it can simply be
- 9:12quickly fixed, some problems can be
- 9:14fixed. Usually, these are minor issues.
- 9:17And very rarely do I get fundamentally
- 9:19broken mockups. Most often, ah, some
- 9:22kind of tweaking. Don't worry if I find
- 9:25a mistake, two or even many mistakes,
- 9:27or even a whole bunch of mistakes,
- 9:29because all of this can be fixed pretty
- 9:31quickly, in a couple of months. Today
- 9:35you have this design, tomorrow you'll
- 9:37have a different design, and, well,
- 9:39everything will be fine, don't take it
- 9:41personally. And I have some strange
- 9:45message in the chat about some system
- 9:47messages being disabled. Can you write
- 9:50something, or is something broken?
- 9:53Write a letter or something. Everything
- 9:57is great, thank you. Okay, let's start,
- 10:00in short, about Oksana's Mockup. But
- 10:05look, when you do a design, even a
- 10:07concept, well, anything you show is a
- 10:09concept. That is, even if you show it
- 10:14to your boss, or the design, or someone
- 10:16else, or the client, they will always
- 10:18look at everything. So, let's say you
- 10:22make a concept and upload a photo here.
- 10:25I understand that when users upload
- 10:27photos, they'll likely have the same
- 10:29problem. And here, specifically, the
- 10:31problem is the cropped head. But if
- 10:34you're working on a concept as a
- 10:36designer, try to upload a photo here
- 10:38and crop it so that your head isn't cut
- 10:40off, because it's, well, such a large
- 10:42graphic element on the screen, it
- 10:44affects the perception of your entire
- 10:46layout. Let's start with these little
- 10:50details. Then there's the second thing,
- 10:54I don't quite understand: you have an
- 10:56alignment line on the left. Well,
- 10:58that's pretty clear. Here, a little,
- 11:00well, yes, yes, the title is behind it.
- 11:03So, the question is, why? And why are
- 11:07you switching this alignment here? Well
- 11:11, I don't understand the reason, I
- 11:13don't understand the rationale. If you
- 11:18align everything to the left, you'll
- 11:19maintain the left border. But because
- 11:22you switch the alignment here to the
- 11:24center, you get a double switch. So,
- 11:26you have the left one here, then the
- 11:28center one, then the left one again.
- 11:32And when the eye will inevitably look
- 11:34at these lines, that is, because we
- 11:36connect all this with our eyes
- 11:37unconsciously, it will have this gap
- 11:39here. It will do this. And this thing,
- 11:43it immediately catches the eye. These
- 11:46are the little things that should be
- 11:48monitored. And then what else is here?
- 11:53And, by the way, because you switched
- 11:56the alignment, you had to add this
- 11:57strip here. Well, a divider usually
- 12:01helps when switching alignment, so that
- 12:04everything looks, well, comfortable. By
- 12:07the way, I think that even if you
- 12:09collected all this here in a small box,
- 12:11like here, this thing would not catch
- 12:13the eye, because the left edge of the
- 12:15box would precisely support this
- 12:17alignment line. No one would notice
- 12:20that, ah, well, here the center is
- 12:22shifted like this. So, well, in short,
- 12:26it's better to simplify this story. And
- 12:32also, if you have a certain number of
- 12:34elements, well, let's say three or four
- 12:37elements, and all of them seem to be,
- 12:39well, here are four elements. 1 2 3 4
- 12:44and they are all in the same block. I
- 12:50advise you to group them, well, maybe
- 12:52even, I don't know, a little
- 12:54artificially, to achieve this beautiful
- 12:56dynamics. That is, what I mean is, if
- 13:02you group, well, like here now, these
- 13:04elements, they are all equal. Ah, and
- 13:07logically, this is correct. Well, that
- 13:09is, the same indentation here, the same
- 13:11indentation here, the same indentation
- 13:13here. That is, all four elements are
- 13:15equal. But in fact, it doesn't look
- 13:17very dynamic, because you're kind of
- 13:19spreading these elements out across the
- 13:21empty space. And in order to have, well
- 13:27, something good, we're trying to
- 13:29achieve a well-coordinated spot in the
- 13:32design, so that the grouping is clearly
- 13:34identified, so that we look here,
- 13:36examine all the information, look here
- 13:38sequentially, examine all the
- 13:40information sequentially. In short, I
- 13:43advise you to create an artificial
- 13:44grouping here. That is, either you
- 13:50group these three elements somehow,
- 13:52maybe you'll collect this story there
- 13:54in one line, or you group these two
- 13:56elements, and separate this thing. Or
- 14:03you group these two elements together,
- 14:05push this thing somewhere, or, well, I
- 14:08don't know, somehow else. Well, that is
- 14:11, essentially, here in this block, I
- 14:13wouldn't advise you to leave equal
- 14:16indents. Well, that is, I would try to
- 14:18artificially break it up, say, into two
- 14:20groups. Or something else might work,
- 14:23you know what? If you make this heading
- 14:26even bigger, and, in terms of size, so
- 14:29that it, well, like, so that this whole
- 14:31thing, it gathers into one dark spot.
- 14:35There. I'm not sure I'm explaining this
- 14:37clearly, but this topic is very, in
- 14:39short, not very subtle. So, in short,
- 14:44I'd work on the indents here in this
- 14:46block some more. And what else is here?
- 14:52I noticed that you have this indent on
- 14:54the left; I'll open the comments now so
- 14:56it's not convenient. This indent on the
- 15:01left looks very large. So it turns out
- 15:04that if the page continues to stretch,
- 15:06this indent will also increase. And I'd
- 15:11think about what will happen on
- 15:13resolutions larger than what you've
- 15:14drawn. Here it is 1.440. How will this
- 15:18story look on a wide screen? I'd
- 15:21measure these side indents on the right
- 15:23and left in the containers and probably
- 15:25make them the same. Right now, it's 58
- 15:29here, 62 here. They're a little
- 15:32different. And maybe, maybe I would,
- 15:40well, I would probably reduce this
- 15:42indent for this sidebar by half, to
- 15:44somewhere around this size, and somehow
- 15:47limit the sidebar so that it stretches
- 15:49at 1920, so that this access doesn't
- 15:52grow. Why is it bad that it grows?
- 15:57Because, well, if it continues to grow,
- 16:02these indents, they're roughly equal
- 16:04now. And then, if it grows, the left
- 16:09indent will get larger. This will
- 16:11create some kind of, I don't know, a
- 16:13slightly strange semblance of right
- 16:15alignment. The fact that you're sort of
- 16:18pushing the column here will also look
- 16:20pretty suspicious. So, in short, either
- 16:24align them, or somehow limit this
- 16:26column. Well, that is, show that it
- 16:28will continue to grow in that direction
- 16:31. Or, well, by the way, or you can add
- 16:35this line here artificially. Well,
- 16:39that's one option. So, what else is
- 16:43here? I looked at how the autoouts are
- 16:48assembled. And here it seemed to me,
- 16:51well, anyway, I'll take a look now,
- 16:53there are other things like this in
- 16:55various places in the layout. I don't
- 16:59really understand the purpose of these
- 17:01empty margins outside the autoout.
- 17:04After all, when front-end developers
- 17:06layout, they assemble blocks entirely.
- 17:10Well, that is, it makes sense if it's
- 17:13assembled, well, like this: well,
- 17:15whatever the block size, that size and
- 17:18the container around it. If you need to
- 17:22make some kind of large click zone,
- 17:24it's usually overlapped somehow on top
- 17:26of this story. And that's why this
- 17:29thing, it looks strange. Well, that is,
- 17:32when checking, the designer will dig up
- 17:34and ask why it's assembled here this
- 17:36way. I just found a story like that
- 17:39somewhere else. For example, here's a
- 17:43similar story. So, you have an element,
- 17:47well, these buttons, and you put them
- 17:49together in an additional autolayout
- 17:51and don't work with the spacing between
- 17:54the elements, even though you had those
- 17:56spacings, too. So, there are four here,
- 18:00four here, and you added an additional
- 18:02one around the button. So, how would it
- 18:04be put together correctly? You'd put
- 18:08this into one autolayout, put this into
- 18:10a separate autolayout, and then put the
- 18:13correct spacing between them in a
- 18:14larger block. That's how front-end
- 18:18developers do it. This could also be
- 18:24picked up on during a mockup review, if
- 18:26they looked at, say, test assignments.
- 18:30So, what else? This text is very pale.
- 18:36It looks like it's off. I don't
- 18:40recommend doing that. It's better to
- 18:42use regular gray text. Also, by the way
- 18:45, the white and blue background gets
- 18:47lost here. Here, either a shadow or a
- 18:49backing is needed, or, more precisely,
- 18:51either a shadow or a border is needed
- 18:53so that it doesn't dissolve like in
- 18:55this blue one. This thing right now
- 18:58looks desigable. How do you know if an
- 19:01element looks desigable? Let's take,
- 19:04well, let's say, the trendy white
- 19:06buttons, like in Yandex, on a gray
- 19:08background. Well, let's put together
- 19:11something similar. Let's say we have a
- 19:13button, how do we, uh, quickly disigine
- 19:16it? You take it and, well, 40%, in
- 19:18short, the opacity. Here you can simply
- 19:21overlay it on the text. This button
- 19:23will look like it's turned off. This
- 19:25white button will look like it's, uh,
- 19:28just, well, not pressed. That's why I
- 19:31recommend coloring the text here a dark
- 19:34color. What else is here? There are
- 19:36also dividers. I'll turn them off again
- 19:39now. These dividers between the blocks,
- 19:41you don't really need them. And why?
- 19:45Because you have the function of a
- 19:47separator between the blocks, and so
- 19:49the bottom border of this bar acts as a
- 19:51separator. So, you see, it's your
- 19:54separator. When you add an additional
- 19:59separator, you create visual noise here
- 20:02, because you have, look, one line, two
- 20:04lines, and between these three lines,
- 20:06there are no lines. Okay, 3 4 5. And
- 20:13this is the thing, the fact that, well,
- 20:15this thing is now also an independent
- 20:18object. That is, if it weren't here,
- 20:22then we would only have three, like,
- 20:24these stripes that the eye pays
- 20:26attention to. 1 time 2 3. But you see,
- 20:30you have five of them here. There. And
- 20:33you can, well, nothing falls apart here
- 20:36. You can easily align this thing to
- 20:40the center, you can align it to the top
- 20:42, just to support this invisible line.
- 20:47Here, by the way, look at how strangely
- 20:49the auto-layout is set up, with the
- 20:54numbers sticking out, slightly, along
- 20:56the edges. That is, this too, well, the
- 20:58front-end will tell you why. Why is it
- 21:01like this? So, I would probably move
- 21:04the text here. It would easily line up
- 21:07with this story. The eye would clearly
- 21:11understand that it should start looking
- 21:13from here, say, from the time, and then
- 21:15switch further. And how would you,
- 21:19using this invisible line that forms
- 21:21the top of this number plus this thing,
- 21:23well, sort of fulfill this function.
- 21:28That's it. So, what else? There's
- 21:36another interesting thing here, when
- 21:37you have plenty of space. Well, you
- 21:41understand, yes, that there is plenty
- 21:43of space here. You can write this text
- 21:45here. easily at length, but you are
- 21:48artificially folding it like this. It
- 21:52looks unnatural. Well, that is, well,
- 21:55like this, yes, such an error. I even
- 21:59think I wrote about unnatural-looking
- 22:01text somewhere in a lecture. When you
- 22:04fold it where there's some empty space
- 22:05where it could straighten out, people
- 22:07pay attention to that too. Naturally,
- 22:10you need to pay attention to dangling
- 22:12prepositions and all that jazz. But
- 22:14here, if you stretch out this text, and
- 22:16the card at the bottom becomes, well,
- 22:18it won't get worse, it'll only get
- 22:20better. There. Why not? Like, if it
- 22:25seems like there's not enough, well,
- 22:27that there's a lot of empty space, you
- 22:29need to fill it somehow, it's better to
- 22:32enlarge some objects, like, say,
- 22:33enlarge the numbers, and other things.
- 22:36There. What else would I recommend? I
- 22:40recommend making sure your icons are
- 22:42the same thickness, the same style, the
- 22:44same density. For example, you have
- 22:49rounded corners here, sharp corners
- 22:51there, and a different thickness. Here
- 22:55you have some small elements inside
- 22:57that, well, they start to merge from
- 22:59afar, they're not very noticeable
- 23:01either. And all three icons have
- 23:03different styles, and they're also
- 23:05different from these ones. So, I would
- 23:09probably pick this thing from the same
- 23:11set. There. And about...Well, okay,
- 23:15we'll kind of leave that aside, but
- 23:17whatever. So, well, here, well,
- 23:23basically, basically, that's probably
- 23:26it. Don't overdo it with center
- 23:29alignment. Well, that means some
- 23:32standard things. That is, the more
- 23:33simple, generally accepted solutions
- 23:35you have, the simpler the layout looks
- 23:37if you have a lot of complex elements.
- 23:40And I wouldn't recommend, well, where
- 23:42it's directly unnecessary, but using
- 23:45center alignment, like here, here.
- 23:47There. Overall, I like the design as
- 23:50it's done. I wouldn't add custom
- 23:53scrolls. They're expensive to code.
- 23:57Let's use standard ones to start. Well,
- 23:59it certainly looks nice, but, in short,
- 24:01just remember that it's expensive and
- 24:03that it has a state, you'll have to
- 24:05render it separately, how it looks when
- 24:08you hover it, when you click it, when
- 24:10you drag it, and so on. I still don't
- 24:14really understand how these buttons
- 24:15work. Like scrolling this thing up and
- 24:20down here, it probably wouldn't be very
- 24:22convenient either. So, I have A, well,
- 24:28there are a few more comments here.
- 24:30You're lucky. I started with you. Mm,
- 24:35on this layout. Note that, firstly,
- 24:40we've had the ruble sign for quite a
- 24:42while now, and I recommend using it if
- 24:45it's in the font. If not, use it as an
- 24:48icon from some other font that's
- 24:50similar. And here, I'd probably rather
- 24:54remove it. If you use spaces, and if
- 24:59you really get into the details of the
- 25:01numbers, then here, in short, there
- 25:03should be half a space, because now
- 25:05they're very widely separated. But if,
- 25:10well, in general, if you don't sweat it
- 25:12, if you take the ruble sign and space
- 25:14it out here, then no one will pay so
- 25:17much attention here. There. But, in
- 25:19short, pay attention, keep an eye on
- 25:21these things. So, what else is here?
- 25:25What else was interesting here? Here,
- 25:28ah, the left and right margin sizes
- 25:30don't match. I don't recommend doing
- 25:33that either. 32 and 45. 45 is also an
- 25:36odd, random value. At the top, you also
- 25:40have 29 here. I advise, well, avoiding
- 25:43such values, bringing them into line
- 25:46with generally accepted sizes. So, one
- 25:50more thing. So, in short, in the boxes.
- 25:54And what shape should the margin here
- 25:56in the corner be? There's a fairly
- 25:59simple formula for understanding this.
- 26:04So, if the box rectangle in which you
- 26:06place the content is horizontal, then
- 26:08your margin in the corner is also a
- 26:10horizontal rectangle. That is, it
- 26:15doesn't necessarily have to be exactly
- 26:17the same shape, but it could be
- 26:19something like this or it could be
- 26:21square. But when you have a horizontal
- 26:25rectangle with the same indentation as
- 26:27a vertical rectangle, this thing
- 26:29immediately catches the eye. Plus, you
- 26:34also need to understand how far you can
- 26:37push the text from the top border so
- 26:39that it, well, sort of falls off.
- 26:44There's also a simple way to check this
- 26:46. Take another similar object. If it
- 26:49fits here easily, then your island is
- 26:51too big, and you're starting to lose
- 26:52the connection with the top border.
- 26:56Well, that is, in theory, what's the
- 26:58maximum here? Well, maybe like this,
- 27:05for example. So, you see, in order for
- 27:10this connection to be lost, for this
- 27:12thing to stay in the corner, you need
- 27:14to roughly focus on the size of this
- 27:16object that you have in the corner.
- 27:20That is, accordingly, if your text is
- 27:22small, then, well, let's say this isn't
- 27:24an event, or let's say this is an event
- 27:27, but, I don't know, maybe a fourteenth
- 27:29font. So, to keep this font from
- 27:34falling off, well, to keep this size of
- 27:36text from falling off, you'll have to
- 27:38move it even closer. Okay, let's say we
- 27:42put one and a half H's of this font.
- 27:47There. It'll hold. But if you move it
- 27:50further, it starts to slowly fall off.
- 27:53It's still holding on like this. It's
- 27:55completely falling off at the top like
- 27:57this. In short, I hope the logic is
- 27:59clear. That is, tie it to the object's
- 28:02size. But if you have some gigantic
- 28:05text, on the contrary, well, let's say
- 28:07you have some, I don't know, gorgeous
- 28:10graphics, the size, oh, there's a whale
- 28:16there. Some size like this, yeah, you
- 28:22can slap something airy on it, but
- 28:24you'll start working in the opposite
- 28:26direction. That is, you'll start
- 28:28dividing, not enlarging. Let's say we
- 28:30have something of the same size. Here's
- 28:34half of an H. This will be a
- 28:36comfortable indent until this story.
- 28:42And it works not only vertically, it
- 28:44works horizontally too. So, you can
- 28:48measure it anyway, well, either insert
- 28:53a whole one, or like this. You see,
- 28:55you're tying yourself to some basic
- 28:57dimensions that you have in the text.
- 29:02All these dimensions, they'll be
- 29:04comfortable for inserting, uh, for
- 29:06inserting yours. Well, except for some
- 29:10kind of specific design, where you, say
- 29:13, have super-tight, well, I don't know,
- 29:16rbunol, like, he likes, in short, such
- 29:18tight indents, that's also possible.
- 29:21But what size will it be? Take this
- 29:24letter H, make it three or four, and
- 29:26you should use these dimensions
- 29:28everywhere. Okay, I won't look at all
- 29:33the layouts. This is your homework:
- 29:37look at the things I marked here with
- 29:39exclamation marks, try to guess, based
- 29:42on what I said, what's wrong here. The
- 29:46only thing I'll comment on is this
- 29:48thing. The margin to the edge here—
- 29:52well, from the perspective of the top
- 29:54margin, it's convenient, but from the
- 29:56perspective of the arrangement of all
- 29:58the elements, it's quite strange,
- 30:00because it violates the principle of
- 30:02proximity. So, you have menu items,
- 30:05they're like, well, friends, they
- 30:07should be together. And then, well,
- 30:11that is, it's one group, a menu item,
- 30:13and then they're surrounded by some
- 30:15kind of border. This is the next
- 30:18element in line. And here, well, you
- 30:21should perceive these object boundaries
- 30:23, these top and side ones, as if they
- 30:25were another object, and the principle
- 30:27of proximity works with them in exactly
- 30:29the same way. So now it turns out that
- 30:34you have this border and this text,
- 30:36they're kind of friends, and, well,
- 30:38these objects are on their own. That is
- 30:45, basically, since you have a big
- 30:47island here anyway, there's nothing
- 30:49stopping you from slightly shortening
- 30:51the length of this, the length of this
- 30:53menu, and at the same time, you won't
- 30:55have to worry about the fact that you
- 30:57have, say, this indentation here. And
- 31:02here it will be, well, I don't know how
- 31:04it will be larger here than here, if
- 31:06you fill in this story. And I would
- 31:10shorten it so that, well, the objects
- 31:13have the same mouth, well, that is,
- 31:15here, here, from here to this story,
- 31:18and so on. Then it will look harmonious
- 31:22. Okay. What's next? Well, good, by the
- 31:27way, we're moving at a good pace. Fine.
- 31:33But this layout, this one is a bit more
- 31:35complicated. Here, I'll tell you right
- 31:41away, in short, the same problem is
- 31:43everywhere. You've really compacted all
- 31:47the elements. This is the first problem
- 31:51that this layout has. Well, that is,
- 31:53there's not enough air here. You need
- 31:57to loosen things up a bit, because,
- 31:59well, these indents, they're starting
- 32:02to contrast with all the stuff you have
- 32:04inside, and there's no clear, well, any
- 32:06kind of consequential division. You
- 32:12need to either increase the indents, or
- 32:14specifically increase this one, this
- 32:16one a little bit, and on top of that,
- 32:18increase the hierarchy, because you're
- 32:20getting this thing now. Let's say I'll
- 32:26give you, well, contrast, I mean
- 32:28hierarchy, the contrast between the
- 32:30elements. And I'll give you this test
- 32:34story now. A lot. You can defocus your
- 32:40eyes, it'll be roughly the same thing.
- 32:44Here, I see that two objects have
- 32:46roughly the same visual weight. They're
- 32:50arguing with each other. But that can't
- 32:52happen in one group. You need to have
- 32:56something that's clearly more important
- 32:58than the other, so it's easy to
- 33:00navigate this story. Either you need to
- 33:05create a clear hierarchy, or you need
- 33:07to clearly separate these objects from
- 33:09each other so the eye perceives them
- 33:11individually as separate groups, and
- 33:13build a clear hierarchy within each
- 33:14group. Well, I mean, here, if all this
- 33:18—I don't really understand what it is
- 33:20, respect for Samara. I don't really
- 33:23understand what this is. Well, I mean,
- 33:25some kind of statement, but my
- 33:27understanding is that this is probably
- 33:29important. This, yes, this is the most
- 33:31important. If it's not the most
- 33:33important, why is it at the top? Well,
- 33:35let's say, or if it should be at the
- 33:37top, like some kind of title that
- 33:39characterizes the entire card, but is
- 33:41rarely looked at, then you need to make
- 33:43it even smaller so it doesn't interfere
- 33:45with that. So, you need to build a
- 33:47clear hierarchy here. Let me remind you
- 33:51, there are several things in the
- 33:53hierarchy. This is the placement. The
- 33:57higher and to the left of your object,
- 33:59the higher it is in the hierarchy,
- 34:01because we start reading, well, from
- 34:03here and then begin to study all this.
- 34:06What's going on here? It's the size of
- 34:08this element, it's the contrast of this
- 34:10element. Well, we look at size simply
- 34:13by the spots. That is, you have some
- 34:16spot. Now this thing is the most
- 34:17important. If it's the most important,
- 34:19it's unclear why it's at the bottom. So
- 34:22, I think you should understand my
- 34:24logic. Then, further on, let's say,
- 34:33here's the thing: because everything is
- 34:35tightly laid out, and if you had a
- 34:37larger indent, these two elements would
- 34:39be grouped at the top border. That is,
- 34:46they should be connected like this. But
- 34:49because you have a super small ost here
- 34:51, you ended up with this story: this is
- 34:53grouped with this, and this with this.
- 34:56So, this needs to be either separated
- 34:58somehow, maybe highlighted a little
- 35:00with color, maybe, well, this thing is
- 35:02already pressed to the top, but I would
- 35:05definitely fix this indent. So, what
- 35:08else? Uh-huh. Look, pay attention to
- 35:14this comment. In this dense layout, if
- 35:23you look at this box, it, well, it's,
- 35:25in short, royal. So, you layout
- 35:29everything tightly, tightly, tightly,
- 35:32tightly, but suddenly you get this
- 35:34loose story, and it's a little out of
- 35:36place here. And also, well, in short,
- 35:41what I don't like about this box,
- 35:42besides the fact that it doesn't fit
- 35:44the style of the airs. Here, you need
- 35:46to measure these things. So, let's say,
- 35:49look, you have a top indent. That's one
- 35:52. And you have a lower indent. Well,
- 35:58here, let's say, okay, well, I won't
- 36:00measure from the icon, because
- 36:02measuring, well, you see, why shouldn't
- 36:04you measure from the icon? Because all
- 36:06this air, it also plays a role in our
- 36:08assessment, and what's the size of the
- 36:10indentation from here to here when the
- 36:12eye isn't there? We need to find
- 36:16something in between here so that this
- 36:18compensation fits. Well, I mean, it's
- 36:22not like this, because we still have
- 36:24these protruding things, and it's not
- 36:26like this, because we can't ignore this
- 36:28amount of air. It's something in the
- 36:30middle, but most likely something like
- 36:32this. Optically, we can probably
- 36:34estimate this air to be approximately
- 36:37this size. But let's look from below.
- 36:41Even with this compensation, it turns
- 36:43out to be, well, much larger here,
- 36:45because the wheels won't stretch out
- 36:47here. And in the tram, in order to,
- 36:51well, somehow compensate for this thing
- 36:53, we have a hard bottom line here, and
- 36:55from it the eye will calculate the
- 36:57indentation to this border. So, in
- 37:00short, why am I telling you all this
- 37:02complicated stuff? These margins look
- 37:05different because of optical
- 37:06compensation, although you can measure
- 37:08it all. You'll have, I don't know, 14
- 37:12here, there, I don't know, they might
- 37:15even be the same from Figma's point of
- 37:17view, but they won't be the same from a
- 37:19visual standpoint. Basically, these two
- 37:22margins are different. The bottom
- 37:24margin looks a little bigger. And then
- 37:28we have this third margin from the
- 37:30bottom, which doesn't connect with
- 37:31either of these. Well, that is, for a
- 37:35bar like this, it should be there, if
- 37:42it were that big, let's get started.
- 38:03Well, even a big button doesn't matter.
- 38:0536. Oops, everything's broken. So, so
- 38:16many, so many things. So many things.
- 38:20Everything's going to go boom now. Well
- 38:31, I guess if, in short, not...And if we
- 38:33don't save much space, well, more
- 38:35precisely, if we don't do anything with
- 38:37the space, well, I'd probably gather
- 38:40this into one group and try to make
- 38:42these indents the same, you know, so
- 38:44that you have a grouping. Or I'd make
- 38:51them all absolutely identical, but then
- 38:54you'll have, well, like, this thing, it
- 38:56will be smeared across the screen, if,
- 38:59say, I made them all the same. But it
- 39:02will still be, in short, better than if
- 39:04they are different. Well, that is, the
- 39:06best option here would be to tone down
- 39:08this story a little. By the way, maybe
- 39:15even, damn, a red background, blue. And
- 39:21that kind of story. Well, probably
- 39:32somehow give or take, in short, that's
- 39:34how I would look at it, but I'm not
- 39:40sure, like, a little unsure of the
- 39:47story, probably. Well, well, something
- 39:50like that. Well, now compare, in short,
- 39:53by grouping, how it's done. Okay, on
- 39:56with that. These things, this thing,
- 40:04it's really pressed here. Here, well,
- 40:09in short, I would trim it a little on
- 40:11the right and left. And that would free
- 40:16up, well, a little space would be freed
- 40:18up here, it wouldn't stick so tightly
- 40:20to these letters. And then it would
- 40:25look like, well, you see, there's no,
- 40:28let's say, continuation here, it would
- 40:30look like, well, just, I don't know,
- 40:32some kind of check mark and so on. Well
- 40:34, in short, I would think about this
- 40:36solution some more. There. Because now,
- 40:38uh, now it's causing you this, like,
- 40:43well, quite a big hole. So, in short,
- 40:51if you compress it a little, it will
- 40:53look like a timeline, it won't push
- 40:55this text block to the right too much
- 40:57and then there won't be, uh, well, this
- 40:59won't be pressed, and there won't be a
- 41:02gap here, in short, like that. So, this
- 41:06space here is empty. There. Because the
- 41:10more you move this text away from the
- 41:12left side, the bigger the hole here
- 41:13grows. So what else is there? Yeah.
- 41:23Here's another common thing with, well,
- 41:25one I constantly see in layouts. And
- 41:28when you, well, let's say you have an
- 41:30icon like this, well, like this chevron
- 41:37, a checkmark to the right, to the left
- 41:40, and it's aligned in a standard box
- 41:42like 32. And when you set up a standard
- 41:44box, you make equal indents on the
- 41:46right and left, but what you end up
- 41:48with is this icon, it doesn't maintain
- 41:51right alignment. And what do they do
- 41:54for this? For this, they create a twin
- 41:58brother for it in the design system,
- 42:00like this thing. Well, obviously, it
- 42:05also needs to be correctly aligned in
- 42:07the middle there and so on. So, they
- 42:14create this twin brother for it, so
- 42:16that you can put it here at the end of
- 42:18the line, and it would more or less
- 42:20maintain, in short, right alignment. Or
- 42:23they make a version of the icon that's
- 42:25aligned to the right edge in the box,
- 42:27and they place it specifically in these
- 42:29places. This also helps a lot, because
- 42:34now we have this alignment, it will
- 42:35wobble a little. How do the front-ends
- 42:40react to this? If you're making
- 42:42something like an icon in a box, they
- 42:44don't care at all which one to use. You
- 42:47have this, let's say, called, what's it
- 42:50called, "icon button small," and that
- 42:52one will be "icon battle button small,"
- 42:54or, I don't know, some other crap on
- 42:57the right front, and something in that
- 42:59style. So, it's just one extra icon in
- 43:02the design system. Well, it's not hard
- 43:04for the front-ends. They don't really
- 43:06care which one to choose. They just
- 43:08take the history books that are written
- 43:09and that's it. But for your design,
- 43:11this will be critical. So, I'd get rid
- 43:19of this bar, because you have bar, ...
- 43:21Well, you could just write two lines of
- 43:23text in the caption here, and that
- 43:25would make the story look less
- 43:26cluttered. Generally, try to minimize
- 43:32the number of boxes within boxes within
- 43:35boxes. It will make the design look
- 43:37much simpler. So, I looked at this
- 43:41mockup. Ah, everything is basically
- 43:46done more or less. It's the same story
- 43:50here as in the previous mockup. I
- 43:52recommend grouping things more clearly.
- 43:54So, let's say, put this together, and
- 43:57separate this a little. That is,
- 43:59decrease this indentation a little or
- 44:01increase this indentation a little to
- 44:03add a bit of dynamism to the mockup.
- 44:06Right now, it's like jelly, you see,
- 44:08spread all over the entire area, all
- 44:11these elements. The more tightly you
- 44:19group this story, that is, let's say
- 44:21you create several groups, the easier
- 44:23it is to look at them with your eyes,
- 44:25because people, well, they try to
- 44:27analyze these things in order to
- 44:29clearly see which group. So, you have
- 44:34this group, clearly green-20%. The next
- 44:39group is some text. So, they look here,
- 44:43then they look here, and then they
- 44:45decide whether to finish reading this
- 44:47thing or not. But when you spread this
- 44:53thing out evenly, it seems to turn into
- 44:55a single spot, which is a little more
- 44:56difficult to perceive. That is, such a
- 45:00subtle matter. I'm not crazy, I didn't
- 45:03make this up. By the way, you can read
- 45:05about this thing in Igrishtang. He also
- 45:07advises, in short, not to spread this
- 45:09story across layouts. Yes, I understand
- 45:12that, in short, sometimes trying to
- 45:15explain these things sounds simply like
- 45:17some kind of, well, esotericism, but it
- 45:20is not. It's just that people who can't
- 45:23explain how they feel it, they just
- 45:24don't like it. They're like, "I don't
- 45:27like it." And they won't say anything:
- 45:29"I just don't like it here, or I don't
- 45:31like everything." That is, it depends
- 45:34on how much a person works with these
- 45:36layouts. So here, too, it seems to me
- 45:43that you've pressed this date tightly
- 45:45against the box. Ah, well, that is, yes
- 45:52, you're sort of highlighting this with
- 45:54a separate box. Of course, it's a
- 45:58separate group inside, but because it's
- 46:00all sort of compressed, compressed,
- 46:02compressed, it's as if everything is
- 46:04more or less in one group. Because you
- 46:08don't separate it into separate groups,
- 46:11but, well, a person will have to
- 46:12perceive all these elements at once as
- 46:15one group. Well, that is, because of
- 46:17the proximity. They will start to
- 46:19figure it out: "Where should I look?
- 46:21Here, then here, then here, then there,
- 46:24then here, then at the button there, or
- 46:27at these." So, the more complex the
- 46:29group, the harder it is for the eye to
- 46:31move around it. And that feeling of
- 46:33some kind of lightness will disappear.
- 46:37Okay, next. And then I looked at it too
- 46:40. Okay, this has a cool design.
- 46:44Basically, I like the cards. The cards
- 46:48are well-organized. The buttons are
- 46:50large. And the spacing is fine. The
- 46:57only thing I'll find fault with here is
- 46:59your creative boxes, because you made
- 47:01them using a single vector shape. Well,
- 47:09no, that won't work. The front-ends
- 47:12won't like you like that. Look, you
- 47:15have Dr. Green. And if he's Dr. Green
- 47:18Gennadyevich, in short, you won't have
- 47:20room for a second line, this story will
- 47:23stretch down, but if it stretches down,
- 47:25you see, your button will stretch too.
- 47:29You'll have to get creative here;
- 47:31you'll have to, in short, cut this
- 47:34shape, well, at least into two parts.
- 47:38That is, you need to cut this story
- 47:40separately. And, let's say, okay, you
- 47:44make this button like this, a vector
- 47:47one right in SVG, and the fronts will
- 47:49forgive you for it. Okay, you make it
- 47:51clickable, damn it. Well, it will have
- 47:55a hitbox like this, and this thing will
- 47:57stretch downwards. Well, that is, like
- 48:01a regular rectangle. And this thing
- 48:04will move along it. So, when you do
- 48:06things like this, you can't just draw
- 48:08it like in Illustrator, you have to
- 48:09think about the behavior of the element
- 48:12itself. What happens if there are no
- 48:16tags? What happens if there is a long
- 48:18thing like this? Well, that is, at the
- 48:21very least, I would kill it. And
- 48:24regarding this story, damn, you leave
- 48:26me no choice at all here. I thought
- 48:32this was at least done through, uh,
- 48:34Union. Well, in short, at this size it
- 48:38looks like some kind of, well, forgive
- 48:41me, in short, some kind of dick. What
- 48:45would I try to do? I'd make the button
- 48:50a little bigger than it is now. And I'd
- 48:56make these things smoother. Now, you
- 49:00see, you have such a clearly defined
- 49:02neck. And on this neck, there are these
- 49:05breaks. Oh, how big. There are these
- 49:11breaks here, in this curve. And they're
- 49:15also not the same, you see, at the top
- 49:17and at the bottom. Well, that is, these
- 49:20two figures. I don't know, it seems to
- 49:23me. Well, it doesn't seem to me, anyway
- 49:27. Uh, the bottom one is bigger. So, I'd
- 49:32make these roundings, in short, somehow
- 49:34smoother, so that here, well, in short,
- 49:36this here here is not a neck, so that
- 49:39the neck is short, like I specifically
- 49:41need to make this place here rounder.
- 49:47This, this place here. And so I like
- 49:50this thing. That's cool, yeah, that it
- 49:52goes to the bottom. Well, really, in
- 49:54some random place, like, relative to
- 49:58these and these things. Anyway, I
- 50:05recommend making the buttons bigger.
- 50:09And these distances, you can reduce
- 50:11this distance a little, and make this
- 50:13thing smoother. There. I like
- 50:16everything else. The colors are trendy,
- 50:19the sizes are cool, the margins here
- 50:21are cool, the icons are good, the card
- 50:23is good, and these sizes are also good.
- 50:27Mm, yeah, and these are okay too, in
- 50:30short. Well, the layout is nice. The
- 50:32only thing that's a bit overcomplicated
- 50:35, in short, with this whole thing, I
- 50:38didn't think about how the text would
- 50:40be laid out on Atash. Well done. These
- 50:47also look nice, but I have some tricky
- 50:49questions here. For example, the month
- 50:53and year, how are they selected? I
- 50:56don't think I've ever seen such a
- 50:58solution with a calendar, or some kind
- 51:02of drop-down lists, well, then draw
- 51:04them. That is, I don’t know how nice
- 51:06the drop-down lists will look, how they
- 51:08will work, but I would probably think
- 51:10about something about scrolling,
- 51:12because I don’t think people change
- 51:14the year that often. Well, a year is
- 51:16clearly used less often than a month.
- 51:18Well, that is, you most likely, well,
- 51:20maybe you write down for next month,
- 51:22for next year, well, this only happens
- 51:25during some transitional period, well,
- 51:27there can be, well, December 30th, well
- 51:29, December 30th, and so on. That is, in
- 51:31short, the year clearly needs less
- 51:33attention. Well, that is, you can give
- 51:35the year as a gift, but the month
- 51:36should probably be a page. Okay. Second
- 51:39question. What date is my entry for?
- 51:41The entry is written here. And when
- 51:44will it be? Ah, well, this is what the
- 51:47selected day looks like. Let’s say
- 51:49this, as I understand it, is the
- 51:50selected day. It’s March 22nd. And I
- 51:52have two entries on March 22nd. But
- 51:54what does this thing look like in the
- 51:56calendar when I have another entry?
- 51:58This. So what does the gray dot mean?
- 52:03So, basically, what does a selected day
- 52:06look like, but not today? So, all these
- 52:10things. I generally advise you, if
- 52:13you're doing a case study, to, well,
- 52:15basically, avoid using calendars. There
- 52:19was this guy, he was making a service
- 52:27called Hey, I think it was a new, well,
- 52:29typer feature, a calendar killer from
- 52:31the guy who was doing the BNB thing or
- 52:34something. Oh, and they wrote an
- 52:39article about how they designed the
- 52:41calendar, and they said there were over
- 52:43300 corner cases in the calendar. So,
- 52:46can you imagine, yeah, all these
- 52:48overlapping dates, when you can, when
- 52:51you can't, this and that, selected, not
- 52:54selected. I once worked with a calendar
- 52:57, I had this thing called appinter,
- 53:04yeah, apppointman. It's appintermento,
- 53:08basically, in this VKalite. And we were
- 53:11creating blocked resources there. When
- 53:14something can't be done on a certain
- 53:15day. And I had a mockup with 148 states
- 53:19. And that was just one feature with
- 53:21blocked resources. Anyway, I try, well,
- 53:24try to avoid calendars in training
- 53:26cases, because if you come across a guy
- 53:28who was making a calendar, and he, well
- 53:31, he has these Vietnam flashbacks with
- 53:33helicopters, he'll just torment you.
- 53:36The worst test task, by the way, was
- 53:38booking meeting rooms at Alfa-Bank. I
- 53:42haven't yet met anyone who's solved
- 53:44this test task among my friends,
- 53:46although many people who earn 300,000
- 53:48have tried it. Horrible. Why would you
- 53:51choose such a difficult job for
- 53:53yourself? Okay, and here again, in
- 53:55figma, I also encountered this thing.
- 53:59These components, and they are very
- 54:01tightly designed. And there's something
- 54:03sticking out from the inside. I don't
- 54:05recommend making components where, well
- 54:07, some, well, where the component
- 54:09itself cuts off some internal structure
- 54:12. Especially since you have empty space
- 54:14here on the right and left. And if it,
- 54:18well, is filled evenly with Thursday
- 54:20and Wednesday, it will be easier to get
- 54:22your finger into this thing with a
- 54:24sausage. So, expand, well, don't make
- 54:28big indents here. It's better to use
- 54:31this space to make the collection wider
- 54:32. For each element. So, the colors are
- 54:39nice. I really like the colors. Here.
- 54:42By the way, here's an example of a
- 54:44trendy color for you. And this one is a
- 54:46trendy color. Now there's also this
- 54:48yellow combination. This one, although
- 54:53its relative is a little old-fashioned,
- 54:55so, in short, take this into account.
- 54:59By the way, Dribble has very good color
- 55:01combinations, because everyone there is
- 55:03trying to make trendy colors. If it's
- 55:05hard to match a picker, and, well, that
- 55:07can be difficult, feel free to come in,
- 55:10you can re-roll the palette exactly, no
- 55:12one will ever accuse you of stealing.
- 55:14Well, that is, well, the guys there
- 55:17really do bother, in short, they do,
- 55:19for example, these three colors, well,
- 55:22this one, maybe not, well, although,
- 55:24although no, they, in short, are in the
- 55:27same range of brightness. Now, if you
- 55:31made it through my four-hour lecture on
- 55:33color, I showed you how to build a
- 55:35palette so that in different colors you
- 55:37have, well, certain tones match in
- 55:39their lightness and brightness, there,
- 55:41with the help of a special plugin. This
- 55:44thing, it creates a very beautiful
- 55:46effect. You can also add a yellow like
- 55:49this, add an orange like this,
- 55:51otherwise Oh, thank you, Natasha. She
- 55:53made a layout for my lectures. So, in
- 55:57short, orange, purple, and other colors
- 55:59are very difficult to match by eye so
- 56:02that they are in the same range of
- 56:04lightness and brightness. That's a
- 56:06common mistake. I was also looking at a
- 56:09mockup there recently, and the blue is
- 56:11a little darker than the green, but
- 56:13it's noticeable. That is, some colors
- 56:16match, some don't. Everything's kind of
- 56:18cool here. Okay, well, it's the same
- 56:21mockup. Sorry, you have a lot of people
- 56:23here, there are a lot of people there.
- 56:25I'll move on. And the lecture is on
- 56:27YouTube, it's four hours long. You can
- 56:29sort the videos by length, basically.
- 56:31You don't have to watch the whole four
- 56:33hours. It's just an analysis of each
- 56:35palette for each color. Yellow, green,
- 56:37red, blue, purple, and other things.
- 56:41Okay, my dog came to me. Now he's going
- 56:44to click his feet, you'll hear him.
- 56:46Okay, next mockup. This is Roman. I
- 56:52have a good 4K monitor here, but I
- 56:54can't see the outline. To see it, I
- 56:58need to crank the brightness up to
- 57:00maximum. That means you've overdone it
- 57:03with this slight tonality. This color
- 57:08FA, FA FA, you see, for solid colors it
- 57:11even starts to dissolve into the
- 57:13background. Especially since you don't
- 57:17have A yet, your background color is
- 57:19white. So for solid colors, this is, in
- 57:22short, the most minimal color that's
- 57:24visible. Anything below that won't be
- 57:26visible. I try to do it this way. If I
- 57:30take a gray color, so that it's, well,
- 57:32there's a universal color that will
- 57:34definitely be visible, it's F5. F5. F5.
- 57:39Now, in my opinion, we even seem to
- 57:41need transparency. Come on. And that's
- 57:53for solid colors. Well, that is, let's
- 57:56say that to paint it with this color.
- 58:00It's a fairly gray, not too dark, not
- 58:02too light, but you can even see that I
- 58:05painted the stroke with double the
- 58:07thickness, well, two pixels thick. Well
- 58:11, it's visible, of course. Well, it's
- 58:13quite light, but that's the bare
- 58:15minimum. So, I would actually go and
- 58:18make it a little darker, this stroke.
- 58:24What's the next one? F4, F3, F2. Well,
- 58:30that's too much, well, if we're
- 58:32choosing it to suit your style. Well,
- 58:34at least something like F4, F3. Neither
- 58:37you nor I. Well, something like this,
- 58:38in short, like this. That is, because,
- 58:41you see, they completely disappear. And
- 58:45by the way, I don't really understand
- 58:52how it works for myself. And you have
- 58:58this separately, in fact, see, and here
- 59:04for this divider, and you took a darker
- 59:06color for some reason, and a lighter
- 59:08one for this one. Although, in general,
- 59:13making these sort of invisible dividers
- 59:15there in some color or paler would also
- 59:18be okay. Okay, what else? In short,
- 59:21what caught my eye here. What caught my
- 59:26eye here? Mm, you have very large
- 59:34differences in density here. This
- 59:39layout is, well, everything is super
- 59:42super airy, light, large, really big.
- 59:47We go through two screens, and here you
- 59:49have super dense stuff. Here is the
- 59:51layout like this. I'd think about the
- 59:55fact that what do we have now? It's 16.
- 1:00:00If you need to fit a lot of tasks in,
- 1:00:02it's better to maintain the airiness,
- 1:00:05slightly reducing, say, the signature
- 1:00:07font, well, 13 or 14, what 13. Just
- 1:00:19reduce the signature font a little,
- 1:00:22reduce it a little, in short, these
- 1:00:24dimensions of this text, but make more
- 1:00:26air here now. Damn, you have them made
- 1:00:30with, like, zero indentation. Maybe
- 1:00:32that's how it looks specific? Here it
- 1:00:36is. Well, at least here, in short, I
- 1:00:43added four. Well, they've shifted a
- 1:00:45little here for me, because, damn, I
- 1:00:50don't get it, you have it A, I get it.
- 1:00:54Well, in short, with center alignment,
- 1:00:56like you had, only with, well, a little
- 1:00:59more airiness. And also this thing,
- 1:01:04look, you have a divider here at the
- 1:01:06bottom, attached by the auto-out of
- 1:01:08this story, as far as I understand. But
- 1:01:16I would do it differently. I would
- 1:01:19assemble the auto-launch like this.
- 1:01:23Like this. Plus this thing. And here I
- 1:01:31would simply add either a lower border
- 1:01:32or make it a shadow from below. Well,
- 1:01:36that is, without, uh, without blur.
- 1:01:39Well, that is, in short, I would make
- 1:01:42this stripe using a border, and not a
- 1:01:44separate rectangle. Well, that's it,
- 1:01:47that's it, in short, it could be either
- 1:01:49way, but it seems like this would be
- 1:01:51more somehow, I don't know, in short,
- 1:01:53like it's right from a serious shib
- 1:01:55point of view. Like this. What else? Mm
- 1:02:00, choose mo. Okay, here, in short, it's
- 1:02:07acceptable to put a button here. Okay.
- 1:02:12So, 50 tasks for this day. Title
- 1:02:15description. Title description. And if
- 1:02:19you add this to a case somewhere, and
- 1:02:21if you want to make this as a case,
- 1:02:23then I also advise you not to leave the
- 1:02:25fish. That is, you have it good here,
- 1:02:29different icons, different texts. Do
- 1:02:31the same here and do this in the
- 1:02:32calendar. Because designers are looking
- 1:02:35at this, like they might come up with
- 1:02:37some new things later on in the final
- 1:02:39product. Wow, what a new feature. Hmm,
- 1:02:52some new type of comment. Cool. It just
- 1:02:58appeared. I looked recently, and I
- 1:03:00didn't see anything like that. So, well
- 1:03:02, maybe not, maybe, I haven't updated
- 1:03:04it in a while. Calendar for August
- 1:03:082025. And here, as I understand it,
- 1:03:13what's dropping out here? Both the year
- 1:03:15and the month. This arrow will confuse
- 1:03:22me a little, since it's sort of like a
- 1:03:24year and a month. And if it's just a
- 1:03:27year, then you need to move this thing
- 1:03:29around and move it to the right
- 1:03:30position. You can use Maru to list the
- 1:03:33available dates. So, well, overall,
- 1:03:39damn, I like the minimalist black and
- 1:03:42white design. I love it. Overall, I
- 1:03:46like everything. This indentation could
- 1:03:51be made a little bigger. Well, like
- 1:03:53this one here. Well, there will be some
- 1:03:59kind of compensation at the bottom.
- 1:04:02Honestly, that's how the training lasts
- 1:04:045 days. I don't really understand how
- 1:04:10this works right off the bat. It
- 1:04:14probably needs dates so it's clear
- 1:04:16which day it was. Otherwise, it's just
- 1:04:19a pretty thing. But it's pretty, I like
- 1:04:22it. Well, everything else is nice.
- 1:04:39Here's another way, by the way. Mm, he
- 1:04:42doesn't force this icon into 32, he
- 1:04:45just puts it in a small, small 24-bit
- 1:04:48frame. And overall, he has this country
- 1:04:52, you see, it holds up well, in short.
- 1:04:59That's good. Well, everything here is
- 1:05:02nice. Here, you see, I'll note another
- 1:05:04good thing. The icon thickness and the
- 1:05:06text thickness match. Nice, nice. Okay,
- 1:05:12let's move on. Although we've been
- 1:05:15sitting here for a while. Let's take a
- 1:05:17short break. A 5-minute sanitary break.
- 1:05:23Let's see you in 5 minutes. Let's move
- 1:05:27on. Everything is fine. I'm just not
- 1:05:34sure about this, because it's kind of
- 1:05:36the other way around here. And now I'll
- 1:05:40color it so it's visible. Here's where
- 1:05:47my favorite blur tool for alignment is,
- 1:05:58when you visually look at a shape, it
- 1:06:00has, well, it has an end, yes, and then
- 1:06:03there's its end, well, in short, a
- 1:06:10point where this visual density is
- 1:06:12concentrated. And as a rule, if you
- 1:06:19draw some shape, well, let's say, a
- 1:06:21triangle or some kind of semicircle or
- 1:06:23something like that, then the alignment
- 1:06:26occurs not along this border, but
- 1:06:28slightly inward. You can notice this,
- 1:06:34this compensation, for example, open
- 1:06:36any font, you see these semicircles
- 1:06:38hanging down a little in order to, well
- 1:06:41, compensate, in short, this alignment
- 1:06:43line with the rectangles. You see, here
- 1:06:47is a rectangle, rectangle, rectangle.
- 1:06:49Here it's slightly slanted. And here
- 1:06:51it's the same, and here it's as if it's
- 1:06:53done in the opposite direction. That is
- 1:06:55, if you make this decision, well, that
- 1:06:57is, you want the button to be smaller,
- 1:07:00yes, make it much smaller. So, right
- 1:07:03now, A. She's like, I get it, you can
- 1:07:14make it a lot smaller. I don't know,
- 1:07:20we'll see how it all fits together.
- 1:07:25Well, no, it's not quite right here in
- 1:07:27the center. Basically, either a small
- 1:07:31half here, or, well, align, align, in
- 1:07:38short, along this story, because here
- 1:07:40you have this thing happening, this
- 1:07:43small, in short, break in this story.
- 1:07:47Actually, if you're a super-nerd and
- 1:07:51you have a kind front-end developer,
- 1:07:53you can do something like this, move it
- 1:08:00a couple of pixels. Front-end
- 1:08:02developers, of course, don't like this,
- 1:08:05but if you have a team of visual nerds
- 1:08:07and front-end developers who love
- 1:08:09design, they can support your
- 1:08:10alignments. But in general, you don't
- 1:08:14have to worry about it, basically, no
- 1:08:16one in product design is that picky, so
- 1:08:18they'll just place the button evenly.
- 1:08:20Well, that would be fine too. But the
- 1:08:24other way around, it looks a little
- 1:08:26weird, in short. I probably wouldn't do
- 1:08:30it that way. This one needs to be
- 1:08:36rounded a bit more smoothly. It's like
- 1:08:40in that mockup we looked at. There's a
- 1:08:44real break here. If you look closely,
- 1:08:46there's a really sharp thing. But
- 1:08:58overall, I like everything about it, of
- 1:09:00course. Um, well, the only thing they
- 1:09:14could have picked on, in short, in some
- 1:09:16test version. Maybe they'd want you to
- 1:09:19thicken it up a bit more. I don't know,
- 1:09:24by the way, who it is, a she or a he.
- 1:09:28That's how you have nicknames. Thicken
- 1:09:31the titles a bit, in short. Not to bold
- 1:09:34, but at least to seven bold. Your
- 1:09:36contrast will increase a bit then,
- 1:09:38because now this text is seventeenth,
- 1:09:40this one fifteenth, well, regular, well
- 1:09:43, I remember being chastised for this
- 1:09:45story, that they kind of don't contrast
- 1:09:47much with each other, that is, they are
- 1:09:50similar. So, I would add a little bit
- 1:09:55of emphasis, it wouldn't ruin your
- 1:09:57subtle style, and at the same time,
- 1:09:59well, it would look a little, in short,
- 1:10:01cleaner. Either increase the size a
- 1:10:05little, or add some density. Well, yeah
- 1:10:12, probably nineteen would be suitable
- 1:10:14here. There. And otherwise, of course,
- 1:10:17everything is beautiful. They'll find
- 1:10:20fault with this, with this. The fact
- 1:10:22that here, in short, they'll say you
- 1:10:24have, you see, here 17 and 17 are like
- 1:10:26the same. Well, these two values, they
- 1:10:29are in the hierarchy. In the hierarchy,
- 1:10:32they seem to be the same. That is, if
- 1:10:35you add all these headings up to the
- 1:10:36nineteenth and in all of these, it will
- 1:10:38be even better. But overall, of course,
- 1:10:42I like it this way too. Cool. Mm-hmm.
- 1:10:57Well, good, really well done. So. Oh,
- 1:11:02there are the bosses. So, well, what's
- 1:11:05here? So, how much is this? 39, 33. I
- 1:11:35don't see much point in making it
- 1:11:37smaller. Than this one. I mean, why add
- 1:11:43another size here? And if you want to
- 1:11:47make it less emphasized, just remove
- 1:11:49the outline and make it just .ru. Well,
- 1:11:53I wouldn't make this story any bolder
- 1:11:55than 39 sizes. I would at least round
- 1:12:00off the even numbers in web design from
- 1:12:02, well, I don't care about this ruler,
- 1:12:04which I was talking about in interfaces
- 1:12:06. I'm talking about this thing. In web
- 1:12:10design, you can easily use 40 and 50.
- 1:12:13Well, at least the even ones. This will
- 1:12:18make it easier for the front-end
- 1:12:20developer to remember what values you
- 1:12:21have. Okay, you've got everything done
- 1:12:27quite large. That is, you have nice big
- 1:12:31indents of 800. Here's the first screen
- 1:12:34. Well, so that this story fits clearly
- 1:12:39. And I always advise on the web to
- 1:12:42make it clear that there are other
- 1:12:43blocks there, because people often
- 1:12:45don't layout, well, don't scroll, in
- 1:12:47short, they don't know that there is
- 1:12:49something else below. They just open it
- 1:12:52and are like, "Ah, well, this is the
- 1:12:54entire site." This still happens. So, I
- 1:12:57would show that there's something else
- 1:12:59below, so they'll scroll down. Well,
- 1:13:02you can shorten this height a little
- 1:13:04without losing, well, like, style, and
- 1:13:07somehow show that it goes somewhere
- 1:13:09else. And that's the first thing. It's
- 1:13:14strange that everything is very airy
- 1:13:16vertically, but everything is super
- 1:13:18compressed horizontally. And these
- 1:13:23differences, they also raise questions,
- 1:13:25in short. Well, that is, you have a lot
- 1:13:29there and good indentation there, but
- 1:13:32at the same time, here it's super
- 1:13:34fluffy, let's say, some things like
- 1:13:36this. And now these are all the same,
- 1:13:48but there are also some fractional
- 1:13:50sizes, and they are not welcome on the
- 1:13:52web, like 35.5 and so on. Their fronts
- 1:13:55will round off their decimals, and not
- 1:13:57always in your favor, not the way you
- 1:13:59want. So, all these fractional sizes
- 1:14:02here need to be tidied up so that
- 1:14:04nothing sticks out. I don't think that,
- 1:14:10well, you have seven here, maybe 14. If
- 1:14:13it's 14, this field will have to move
- 1:14:16apart. But I would probably make it
- 1:14:18bigger, well, I would have prepared a
- 1:14:20bigger one right away. The sizes of
- 1:14:25these fields are for popular numbers.
- 1:14:28And I would reduce its width. If you
- 1:14:32have too much space, well, these
- 1:14:34margins, they seem very big. And it's
- 1:14:37strange that they seem small on the
- 1:14:39outside, but so big on the inside. I
- 1:14:43even have a picture on this topic in
- 1:14:44the lecture on margins. It's called Pug
- 1:14:48. Well, I call it Pug. So, what does
- 1:14:53this mean? You violate the principle of
- 1:14:55horizontal proximity. That is, imagine
- 1:14:58that these edges, the cards, are also
- 1:15:00objects. And you get that the fields
- 1:15:02there, they are grouped with the edges,
- 1:15:04but they are not supposed to be
- 1:15:05friendly with each other. Although,
- 1:15:07well, logically, it's not so. Logically
- 1:15:10, you have this one group, and this one
- 1:15:12is like the next group. So try to make
- 1:15:16the margin between objects inside the
- 1:15:18box either smaller than the outer
- 1:15:20margin, or at least the same. Then it
- 1:15:24won't be a problem. So, I'd add some
- 1:15:30weight or size to this button. It'll
- 1:15:34get lost now. And these buttons are
- 1:15:36even paler. We definitely won't pass
- 1:15:40the contrast test here. I'll use any
- 1:15:47plugin with a contrast checker for this
- 1:15:49. You see, even for the body text,
- 1:15:56we're seriously short on values. You
- 1:16:02see, the minimum font size is specified
- 1:16:04here. So, for font size 14, this is
- 1:16:08definitely too low-contrast. That is,
- 1:16:11many people won't see what's written
- 1:16:13there at all, or will see it with
- 1:16:14difficulty. So, 120 Maldives for three,
- 1:16:20Arabian cruise, Bermuda Pearl. If you
- 1:16:25pay attention to how product cards are
- 1:16:26designed in stores, you'll see that
- 1:16:32they put the price above the title. Why
- 1:16:36is this? Because if you have a two-line
- 1:16:41header, well, let's say you have a word
- 1:16:43sticking out, then all your cards will
- 1:16:45move, you have this clear thing with
- 1:16:47the price—it will start floating
- 1:16:49around the page like this, depending on
- 1:16:51how long your header is. This, well,
- 1:16:57that's why they design them so that the
- 1:17:00elements that don't change, exactly,
- 1:17:02well, that is, this content that
- 1:17:04changes, it should be, uh, either at
- 1:17:06the bottom, or there should be space
- 1:17:09left for it. Well, that is, let's say,
- 1:17:13if you move these texts down, well,
- 1:17:15that is, increase the card size a
- 1:17:17little, and press this thing here—so
- 1:17:20that it will be one group, and here you
- 1:17:22will have space to write the second
- 1:17:24line—then nothing will jump around
- 1:17:26either. In short, the most important
- 1:17:30thing here is that your price and
- 1:17:31button don't jump around the page like
- 1:17:33this, depending on the content you have
- 1:17:35. So, what's this aspect ratio thing?
- 1:17:50No, it's definitely not almost 4 by 3.
- 1:18:05Well, basically, we can leave it as
- 1:18:08almost 4 by 3. Okay. Okay, so it seems
- 1:18:14like something's fallen off here. The
- 1:18:17particular one is too big. Oh, the map
- 1:18:26icon. Damn, it seems to me that this
- 1:18:29whole thing is broken. They also advise
- 1:18:32making the boxes even. Icons. Well, of
- 1:18:35course, many don't bother, especially
- 1:18:37if they're big enough. But I also
- 1:18:40recommend, in short, if it's possible
- 1:18:42to make them even, so that they align
- 1:18:45correctly inside and so on. That is,
- 1:18:48because there will be less lag in the
- 1:18:50browser. I don't know if I can
- 1:18:52demonstrate this now or not. There's
- 1:18:54this setting here, it's called Pixel
- 1:18:56Preview. Well, basically, it's fine.
- 1:19:13Now, if you're sort of laying out this
- 1:19:16thing yourself, then, of course, you
- 1:19:18can ignore it. So what else is here?
- 1:19:31The stripe is kind of sad. I'd like to
- 1:19:35add some, I don't know, dynamics to it.
- 1:19:41Right now it's, well, it's having some
- 1:19:43problems, with things like that. It's
- 1:19:48probably better not to draw it with a
- 1:19:50pencil. Just draw it with a pen and
- 1:19:59adjust it the way you need. Just so the
- 1:20:03line is, well, in short, it should be
- 1:20:07dynamic, somehow interesting. I mean,
- 1:20:10right now it was kind of sad. I mean,
- 1:20:14I'd work on this story here. Well, like
- 1:20:21, something like, well, I don't know,
- 1:20:36in short, something more fluid, not so
- 1:20:40constricted. Maybe smaller, maybe
- 1:20:43longer, that is, but right now it's
- 1:20:45just tired here. So. icons. There's
- 1:20:49some kind of problem with this icon.
- 1:20:51It's not clear what it means. There
- 1:20:53should clearly be two white stripes in
- 1:20:55the middle. If it's a map, I would pick
- 1:20:57something like that. Phones 247, I
- 1:21:01don't know, in short, like in the
- 1:21:04modern world, maybe people don't buy
- 1:21:06them anymore, what does that mean. This
- 1:21:09handset. I would also think about it, I
- 1:21:13would look for a more modern,
- 1:21:15contemporary icon set. So, we present
- 1:21:20services with and something went wrong
- 1:21:22there. The alignment principle is
- 1:21:24broken here. You have these objects
- 1:21:27grouped together, and these are grouped
- 1:21:28together, although they should be
- 1:21:30connected like this. Well, that is,
- 1:21:34last-minute tours, places you can visit
- 1:21:36right now, along the vertical axis.
- 1:21:40There should be an em dash here. Now
- 1:21:47it's short, long, here's a medium,
- 1:21:50short, long. Here's a specifically long
- 1:21:54one. And I wouldn't do such an
- 1:21:56artificial hyphenation. First of all,
- 1:21:58you're creating a hole here. Well, that
- 1:22:00is, we're building everything according
- 1:22:02to the rectangle principle. Here we
- 1:22:03have a rectangle. You need to close the
- 1:22:05corners. Here you're creating a hole
- 1:22:07for yourself with this hyphenation.
- 1:22:09Better in the opposite direction. If
- 1:22:12you need to highlight last-minute tours
- 1:22:14, then it's better to make a large
- 1:22:15heading and subheading. And this one,
- 1:22:19which you can visit right now. Here, we
- 1:22:27also need to do something with the
- 1:22:29proximity principle, since you have it,
- 1:22:31well, not at the top, but pressed
- 1:22:33against the bottom, and there is no,
- 1:22:35well, no connector here. You have this
- 1:22:38story, it’s grouped here, in short.
- 1:22:40The proximity principle is also
- 1:22:42violated. And it’s hard to read the
- 1:22:45tour distance, the tour duration is
- 1:22:47seven nights, then you have to search
- 1:22:49back for this line. The nearest date,
- 1:22:52five nights. Well, that is, in such a
- 1:22:54configuration, I would be better off
- 1:22:56not doing elements here. I would simply
- 1:22:59layout everything along the left margin
- 1:23:00. Well, that is, you can easily write
- 1:23:03the tour duration here in two lines and
- 1:23:05, well, in short, the tour duration,
- 1:23:13the nearest date—pull it here, and
- 1:23:15the price there, say, here, if you have
- 1:23:17plenty of space here, and the button—
- 1:23:20down here. Then it will be, then there
- 1:23:23will be no problem with the right
- 1:23:25corner. And in general, you like 1.40
- 1:23:31drawings. It'll be much easier for you
- 1:23:35to design for 1.280, and just add
- 1:23:39margins on the sides, because people
- 1:23:41find it uncomfortable to look that wide
- 1:23:43anyway. A sixteenth-inch font is a
- 1:23:46comfortable width for reading, and the
- 1:23:49layout, well, it's reading, after all,
- 1:23:51so it's somewhere between 800 and 1,000
- 1:23:53pixels wide. So, in this, well, in this
- 1:23:57range, 800 dashes, 1000, 1.200, in
- 1:23:59short, the maximum is with margins, and
- 1:24:03it's convenient to place the content.
- 1:24:06When you stretch it all out, it becomes
- 1:24:08a little harder to read the story. So,
- 1:24:11for 1.40, I would make margins of 80 or
- 1:24:14120 along the edges and I could lay it
- 1:24:17out without any problems. That's all. I
- 1:24:20wouldn't have any problems with it all
- 1:24:21stretching out. It'll be easier. This
- 1:24:25looks strange. I can't remember what a
- 1:24:31widow is and what an orphan is. But, in
- 1:24:35short, when you have text, and it's
- 1:24:37trying to either, well, it has two
- 1:24:39shapes, or it's trying to take the
- 1:24:41shape of a flag like this, well, that
- 1:24:44is, either, well, like this triangle,
- 1:24:46in short, or it's trying to take the
- 1:24:48shape of a rectangle with a ragged
- 1:24:50right edge. When you have text, the
- 1:24:55bottom line doesn't reach the middle,
- 1:24:57that is, the ideal end of this line is
- 1:24:59somewhere around here. Well, that is,
- 1:25:03you need to put it together like this
- 1:25:05and find a word so that, well, or
- 1:25:07rewrite this text so that your bottom
- 1:25:09line goes beyond the center or at least
- 1:25:11touches it. If not, then you get a hole
- 1:25:14here. This size. Like this. Well,
- 1:25:19here's the simplest thing, damn it.
- 1:25:32Well, like this. That is, more or less
- 1:25:34rectangular. Well, at a pinch. Like
- 1:25:41this. So, here, of course, we don't
- 1:25:44reach the middle either, but at least
- 1:25:46it's better than just leaving one word
- 1:25:48on that side. We can't wrap this one to
- 1:25:51the next line. Justification is a very
- 1:25:57controversial thing, just like
- 1:25:59right-aligned alignment. It's better
- 1:26:03not to, well, it's better not to. If
- 1:26:08you can avoid using it, don't use it.
- 1:26:12Okay, I'm using index. This story is
- 1:26:15too tightly compressed. And here, well,
- 1:26:18the margins generally need to be
- 1:26:20adjusted. I wouldn't spread this out
- 1:26:22over the entire screen either,
- 1:26:24especially since I'd simply align it,
- 1:26:30well, I'd align these two to the left.
- 1:26:33Here would be something like this, and
- 1:26:34I'd align this to the right. That's it.
- 1:26:37Well, we still have enough layouts for
- 1:26:39another broadcast. Anyway, I'll
- 1:26:41probably sort out someone else now and
- 1:26:43then we'll go take a rest. Okay, Sergey
- 1:26:49, immediately move the prepositions,
- 1:26:57the icons will immediately get to you.
- 1:27:07Try your best. Anyway, there's the
- 1:27:09principle of contrast. Is it possible
- 1:27:12to move prepositions in the interface?
- 1:27:15Of course, there's a glitch in the Sbol
- 1:27:17Typograph plugin. It automatically
- 1:27:25converts this thing. So, what does it
- 1:27:28do? It creates invisible spaces in
- 1:27:31interfaces, an invisible space
- 1:27:33character after prepositions. And so
- 1:27:36automatically, well, there are scripts,
- 1:27:38in short, for the front-end that do
- 1:27:40this. These things do hyphenation. Well
- 1:27:42, you should definitely do this at the
- 1:27:44very least in layouts. Well, not
- 1:27:46hyphenate it with Enter, oh yeah. And
- 1:27:48rot it with a sbol. Okay, we've
- 1:27:51collected all the important theoretical
- 1:27:53information. I don't recommend using
- 1:27:57font size 10 in interfaces; it's too
- 1:27:59small, people won't see it. Here, it's
- 1:28:03sometimes used only because it's always
- 1:28:05visible, but for reading, well, it's at
- 1:28:08least font size 11, in short, font size
- 1:28:1013 is better for captions. How many
- 1:28:15sizes do you have here? 1 2 3 4 5 6 7
- 1:28:26No, that's six seven. Yes. Seven, eight
- 1:28:36. In short, you need to reduce the
- 1:28:40number of fonts you use. And I usually
- 1:28:42give this exercise to the guys, this is
- 1:28:44a common problem. I say, "You only have
- 1:28:47three sizes. That's it, go ahead and
- 1:28:49work, you'll learn how to do everything
- 1:28:52with just three sizes, and then you'll
- 1:28:54be able to add, ah, new additional
- 1:28:56sizes." Because, look, you're starting
- 1:29:00to get this story here: each size, ah,
- 1:29:03well, we're trying to save literally
- 1:29:05everything in the interface: colors,
- 1:29:07techniques, groups, the number of
- 1:29:10groups we work with, the number of
- 1:29:12indents, the number of styles, the icon
- 1:29:15style. I'm really talking about doing
- 1:29:18less, ah, achieving the result you need
- 1:29:21with fewer resources. And when you
- 1:29:26create a lot of different sizes, each
- 1:29:28of, well, each text gets its own line
- 1:29:30thickness, which appears in the
- 1:29:32interface. This thickness of each line
- 1:29:37is the thickness of this thing. And
- 1:29:40when there are a lot of different, well
- 1:29:43, that is, these lines, these lines,
- 1:29:45these lines, these lines, icons of even
- 1:29:47more lines. That is, we usually also
- 1:29:52try to make icons as thick as the
- 1:29:54vertical line on the letter H or P if
- 1:29:56they have text, because we're either
- 1:29:58creating similarity or contrast. And
- 1:30:04here, there's not enough contrast,
- 1:30:06because, well, it's thicker, almost
- 1:30:08like this one, but not quite like that.
- 1:30:11And it's better to make it so that,
- 1:30:13well, in short, the fewer lines of
- 1:30:15these thicknesses you have in the
- 1:30:17interface, the better. And you work
- 1:30:19with hierarchy, you work with fonts, do
- 1:30:21this exercise, try, in short, doing
- 1:30:24this. You only have three text sizes,
- 1:30:26and you don't even have a weight. Learn
- 1:30:28to work with gray. Do these things with
- 1:30:31contrast, and the whole design will
- 1:30:33automatically become cleaner and better
- 1:30:35. Believe me, we've already cured a lot
- 1:30:38of people of this. So, I don't
- 1:30:42understand the indentations either.
- 1:30:44Here, like, here's one indent. Here's a
- 1:30:47second indent. Let's measure. One. Aha.
- 1:30:58These. Well. It's roughly the same, but
- 1:31:01not the same, but these are clearly
- 1:31:03some kind of indents between blocks.
- 1:31:07They should be repeated. Especially
- 1:31:09since you have the same situation. You
- 1:31:12have a straight border at the top, and
- 1:31:14H1-sized text at the bottom. By the way
- 1:31:19, there should be only one H1-sized
- 1:31:21text on the page. This is usually the
- 1:31:24main heading. Usually, these headings
- 1:31:27make them H2. If there is no main
- 1:31:29heading, they often start with H2. Well
- 1:31:33, this happens, I don't know, I can't
- 1:31:35say it's customary, but this would also
- 1:31:38catch the eye of someone looking at the
- 1:31:40layouts. In short, these indents need
- 1:31:42to be clearly brought to some kind of
- 1:31:44uniform look. This one can be pushed,
- 1:31:47in principle, to the top. It will be
- 1:31:49fine. A plus to you for drawing some
- 1:31:53illustrations inside here yourself. It
- 1:31:57turned out nice. There. This thing also
- 1:32:02looks good overall, but here this
- 1:32:04heading wasn't big enough to become
- 1:32:06dominant here. That is, it's by...So,
- 1:32:12here it is, my thing. You see, you have
- 1:32:25this, basically, bright spot, it's
- 1:32:27competing with it a little. That is,
- 1:32:30it's winning the competition. Ah, but
- 1:32:33it's difficult for it. And this and
- 1:32:37this thing, they're about the same
- 1:32:39weight. In short, a larger title would
- 1:32:45probably save us here. And I would
- 1:32:48probably either remove the icons or
- 1:32:50move them somewhere larger, because
- 1:32:52right now you can't see anything going
- 1:32:54on there. There are a lot of very small
- 1:32:56details there at size 12. Well, that is
- 1:32:58, right now they just look like some
- 1:33:00kind of visual noise. This, for example
- 1:33:02, you can't see anything going on here.
- 1:33:04And here is some kind of very complex
- 1:33:06image. They don't work at this size.
- 1:33:08Well, for such an icon, a good size is,
- 1:33:11I don't know, well, from 3t2, probably.
- 1:33:16And even then I can't see anything
- 1:33:18going on there. Probably even bigger
- 1:33:20than 44 or 50. That is, it will work
- 1:33:22then. Well, in short, it's better not
- 1:33:26to use such complex detailed images for
- 1:33:28small things. There should be
- 1:33:31minimalist, simple forms. That's it.
- 1:33:34But this applies to, in short,
- 1:33:36everything. That's okay. That's okay.
- 1:33:38That's complicated. That's complicated.
- 1:33:44That's not the style here. They're all
- 1:33:48different, in short, in style. Well,
- 1:33:51these two are the same, like a fil, but
- 1:33:53this one is different in style. This is
- 1:33:56the third one in style. So, well, yeah,
- 1:34:03here, in short, we've looked at all of
- 1:34:08that. Ah, the shadows are generally
- 1:34:26okay, but I probably wouldn't do them
- 1:34:28now, in short, look. And when you have
- 1:34:37such a large blur, the shadows start to
- 1:34:39overlap each other, and in some places
- 1:34:42they look dirtier, uh, than you need.
- 1:34:47But if you want a clean, gray design,
- 1:34:49or, well, first of all, I would get rid
- 1:34:52of this Y so that it is more even in
- 1:34:54all directions. Now, let's say, if I
- 1:35:09remove the shadows completely, I can
- 1:35:14still see the highlights, but I want to
- 1:35:16give them a little bit more definition,
- 1:35:19make them a little brighter. That's the
- 1:35:21blur I need so it's not noticeable
- 1:35:26where they intersect. And you have both
- 1:35:34blur and spread here. No, spread is
- 1:35:37either blur or spread. Or better yet,
- 1:35:41one of them. Well, look, you see, I've
- 1:35:44reduced it a little, so there's
- 1:35:45actually a shadow. It stands out better
- 1:35:48against the background. Not just as
- 1:35:50white, but at the same time, there's no
- 1:35:52orphan here between these things. You
- 1:35:54see, there's a concentration here, in
- 1:35:56short, like this. That is, it's become
- 1:35:59lighter, more neat. Something's broken
- 1:36:04here. Well, it needs to be centered
- 1:36:08relative to this story. Spots within
- 1:36:15spots. Another excuse. Spots within
- 1:36:18spots, in short, I don't recommend it.
- 1:36:20Moreover, you have the same problem
- 1:36:22with the indents here, only vertically,
- 1:36:24like with a pug. This is grouped here.
- 1:36:26This is grouped here, there's more
- 1:36:28indentation between them. Those, on the
- 1:36:30contrary, need to be gathered together
- 1:36:32like a core, gathered all together,
- 1:36:36compressed, and have more indentation
- 1:36:38at the edges. But you don't need that
- 1:36:40here. You see, you have a triple, uh,
- 1:36:43stroke. You have a shadow, you have a
- 1:36:46box, you have another box. Well, that
- 1:36:50is, even if I simply delete it, nothing
- 1:36:52much will change at all. The only thing
- 1:36:56is that, well, you probably did it
- 1:36:57because you didn't like this alignment;
- 1:36:59you need to switch it. But you can add
- 1:37:02a light border here, basically, a gray
- 1:37:04one, then it will work well. And I also
- 1:37:08recommend, otherwise I would probably
- 1:37:18simplify, ah, this little question,
- 1:37:20that is, I would make it linear. So,
- 1:37:23you have linear icons along the edge,
- 1:37:25and you see, they also have different
- 1:37:27indents, just like in the other layouts
- 1:37:30. This would probably also make it
- 1:37:33linear, because right now, in terms of
- 1:37:35volume, it should either be black in
- 1:37:37weight, well, because you have black
- 1:37:39here, or light, like this one. Well,
- 1:37:42that is, it needs to be somehow. Well,
- 1:37:45and this thing too, if it relates to
- 1:37:47this text, it would be better to make
- 1:37:49it thicker. Well, here, too, the
- 1:38:12indents turned out different because
- 1:38:14there is a container inside here, from
- 1:38:16to the container, another two pixels. I
- 1:38:19noticed that right away. This
- 1:38:21difference, for example, between these
- 1:38:23things. This one, it seems to me, even
- 1:38:27if I write a two, your layout will
- 1:38:30start to shift. You need to expand this
- 1:38:33container so that another number fits
- 1:38:35in it. And also this small thing. Not
- 1:38:50everyone does this, but I, for example,
- 1:38:53use it all the time. I recommend that
- 1:38:55if you're separating something with a
- 1:38:57border, you want to make sure it's not,
- 1:38:59well, like, sticking out, because it's
- 1:39:01the eye that stumbles over it when
- 1:39:03you're looking at it. I simply draw
- 1:39:05lines all the way to the end. So, I
- 1:39:08extend this story here and there, and
- 1:39:10then it looks like a simple bar divided
- 1:39:13into two parts. It's not perceived as a
- 1:39:17separate element hanging on the screen,
- 1:39:19because as soon as it's there, the
- 1:39:21question immediately arises: "Can I
- 1:39:23remove it? After all, I have this story
- 1:39:25here, there's another floor here, and
- 1:39:28then, well, this floor here, and so on.
- 1:39:30" Basically, simplify it, try to use
- 1:39:34fewer bars, rulers, and so on.
- 1:39:37Literally, when you're cleaning up a
- 1:39:39layout, try to make some layout cleaner
- 1:39:41. So, everything needs to be torn down,
- 1:39:43everything that breaks needs to be
- 1:39:45restored later, and everything that
- 1:39:47didn't break, well, because here, well,
- 1:39:51basically, this thing just fell off,
- 1:39:53like from, well, this amount. Well,
- 1:39:55maybe we just need to redesign it here.
- 1:39:58That is, maybe I would also write the
- 1:39:59amount without a box right below. Okay.
- 1:40:02Or Well, yeah, then I would get rid of
- 1:40:04another box. There are already plenty
- 1:40:06of them here. Well, that is, they are
- 1:40:08creating these stains, and you are
- 1:40:10fighting them. Putting out a fire like
- 1:40:13gasoline, I add additional boxes,
- 1:40:15additional borders, you don't need them
- 1:40:17, so I advise making this thing wider
- 1:40:28because people will miss. 36 is too
- 1:40:30small. 44 is the minimum click size on
- 1:40:33mobile phones, so in short, you can hit
- 1:40:35it with a fat finger with a sausage. So
- 1:40:48, there's some kind of disconnect here
- 1:40:50too. Let's connect them. It's not
- 1:40:54accidental here. Introduction, receipt,
- 1:40:56write-off. All documents. No documents.
- 1:40:59Let's say you don't have any documents
- 1:41:01for this either. You have this thing.
- 1:41:04So, why not use it and put it here,
- 1:41:07this whole story? You can even
- 1:41:11artificially fold this text to get,
- 1:41:17well, more like a, well, like a dot, in
- 1:41:20short, because now you have, you see,
- 1:41:23this figure, it's like a triangle. When
- 1:41:30you align it relative to the center,
- 1:41:31you'll have a lot of problems, because
- 1:41:33where should I put it? And how high
- 1:41:36should it be? But if you fold this text
- 1:41:41below in half, then you can very easily
- 1:41:43align this story by prices. The colors
- 1:41:50are great, I like it. A nice gray, a
- 1:41:55nice green. These are also not bad. The
- 1:42:03small gradient in these has become cool
- 1:42:05. Well, it needs a little more. Here,
- 1:42:16for example, is the same story. These
- 1:42:20two look almost identical. And this
- 1:42:23whole thing sticks together in one
- 1:42:25group because of this. This is either
- 1:42:28here, and this is below, or this is
- 1:42:30here, and the icons are smaller. In
- 1:42:35short, we need to make sure these
- 1:42:37things don't try to group together, but
- 1:42:39are trying to cling to some single
- 1:42:41group with a hole. Either space will
- 1:42:48save you here, or you need some kind of
- 1:42:50big board where it all fits, and so on.
- 1:43:00This is very good. Well done. This is
- 1:43:06well done. These should probably be in
- 1:43:21black because they are important, after
- 1:43:23all. That's the meaning of this story.
- 1:43:32Fine, everything is fine. Well, that's
- 1:44:02how it is, friends. Okay, I'll put the
- 1:44:04fat cart here where we left off. Well,
- 1:44:12that should be enough for us for two
- 1:44:14broadcasts. So, guys, write a few words
- 1:44:18about how you are, are you doing, is it
- 1:44:21difficult, hard, easy, clear, unclear?
- 1:44:24Did you learn anything new today? Did
- 1:44:34it demotivate you or, on the contrary,
- 1:44:36inspire you? All these things can be
- 1:44:47corrected fairly quickly. Well, it's a
- 1:44:51question of, well, we simply don't see
- 1:44:53many of the things that we have in our
- 1:44:55mockups. Then they show us them, and
- 1:44:59we're like, "Aha, right, I knew that,
- 1:45:01but I didn't do it." So. And working
- 1:45:04with visuals, well, like if there's a
- 1:45:06base like this, I looked at the mockups
- 1:45:08today, basically, everyone's mockups
- 1:45:11are more or less okay, but they all
- 1:45:13have one or two problems, like making
- 1:45:15the indentation a little clearer,
- 1:45:17making the hierarchy a little clearer.
- 1:45:19This can be quickly fixed there in,
- 1:45:21well, a month, in short, you can fix it
- 1:45:23all and everything will be like the
- 1:45:25guys with whom I found practically no
- 1:45:27problems. And so, if they found a lot
- 1:45:34of problems in yours, don't worry, they
- 1:45:36can be fixed fairly quickly. Okay,
- 1:45:42friends, thank you very much for coming
- 1:45:44to the broadcast. If anyone hasn't
- 1:45:48attended our consultations yet, be sure
- 1:45:50to go; you'll learn a lot of new words
- 1:45:53there, in addition to what I came to
- 1:45:55you with today. We'll send you a link
- 1:45:57there, we'll post it. Here. Let's move
- 1:46:00on to the next part, we'll announce it
- 1:46:02in this mini-channel too. Oh, well,
- 1:46:04either it, well, it'll be there now, or
- 1:46:07an analysis of the next test ones.
- 1:46:09Anyway, stay tuned for announcements,
- 1:46:11come to the broadcasts, we really enjoy
- 1:46:13analyzing all this. Here. See you. See
- 1:46:19you in a week, two weeks or so. So,
- 1:46:22until next time, friends. Thank you.
- 1:46:26Bye.
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of UI/UX разбор FormFactor: дизайн ошибки, визуальная иерархия, отступы, работа с цветом и выравнивание by Артур Кузьмин • Formfactor , generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 13,942 words across 2,013 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.