UI Daniel (Vortex) vs James Lee (Amura) — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:01Okay, so the topic is UI Daniel vs.
- 0:03James?
- 0:04>> Yeah.
- 0:05>> Okay, yeah. So,
- 0:07uh Daniel is stronger
- 0:10because he has a perfect body and he
- 0:12uses perfectly, so
- 0:14he has the perfect hardware and the
- 0:15perfect software, which is the two parts
- 0:17of a fight.
- 0:20>> Sorry, you broke up for me. Can you
- 0:23repeat what you said?
- 0:25>> Yeah, I said that Daniel has the perfect
- 0:27body and he has the perfect software as
- 0:29well.
- 0:30>> All right, what do you mean by perfect
- 0:32Uh huh. What do you mean by perfect body
- 0:34in that?
- 0:35>> Uh peak human condition.
- 0:38>> Okay. Uh
- 0:40what do you mean like by peak human
- 0:41condition? Like
- 0:43uh
- 0:43>> I mean that out of all humans, like this
- 0:46is the best possible body for a fight.
- 0:49>> Uh okay. And what
- 0:52like Okay. Why would that be the case in
- 0:55the case of like why would perfect be
- 0:57index to uh the best possible body for a
- 1:00fight? What rather than something else?
- 1:03>> Because the model who is about looks is
- 1:05Sorry, it's not about looks, it's about
- 1:06fighting. And uh
- 1:08so as a author,
- 1:10right, it would be quite misleading if
- 1:12the whole scope of the series is about
- 1:14fighting, but then you talk about
- 1:15perfect body as something else, it would
- 1:16kind of be just an irrelevant statement,
- 1:18otherwise.
- 1:20>> It could be the model could be about
- 1:23fighting, but that doesn't mean like the
- 1:25perfect body would be index to like uh
- 1:27best possible, what do you say? Uh like
- 1:31fight best possible body for fighting or
- 1:33something like that. Uh it could just be
- 1:36uh perfect index to himself, right? So,
- 1:40you can say that um from
- 1:43all the times like from beginning to
- 1:47older, like from young to older, uh
- 1:51Daniel would have the best body, right?
- 1:53His body would remain like in the best
- 1:55possible condition relative to him, not
- 1:58relative to all possible fighters.
- 2:02>> Yeah, I know that it can be the case.
- 2:03That's not what I'm saying. I'm saying
- 2:05it's likely and I gave you a likely
- 2:06increase here. Like I know that it can
- 2:08be the case. It's possible. But is that
- 2:10the case? Is it possible or is it
- 2:11plausible? That's a different question.
- 2:13>> The likelihood increase that you gave
- 2:16was that it's a what to fighting manual,
- 2:18but the interpretation I gave is also
- 2:21compatible under that. So, I don't see
- 2:23how it's more likely than my
- 2:25interpretation.
- 2:26>> Do you realize that in deductive
- 2:27arguments, the conclusion is always
- 2:29going to be compatible with the
- 2:30evidence? That's not deductive
- 2:31arguments. Right? So, just because you
- 2:33gave me an alternative interpretation
- 2:35doesn't mean that it's not a likely
- 2:37increase here. Because I can I can
- 2:39explain why it increases likelihood.
- 2:40Because the author is more likely to act
- 2:42in this certain way as I described.
- 2:45Because the author doesn't want to
- 2:46mislead the reader. Right? So, he's more
- 2:47likely to act in a way that doesn't
- 2:49mislead the reader, which is my
- 2:50interpretation. I know that it's
- 2:51possible that it's your interpretation,
- 2:52but it would just be less likely, right?
- 2:55>> I asked you, okay, the likelihood
- 2:59increase that you said was because it's
- 3:01a fighting manual, correct?
- 3:03>> Uh partly, yes.
- 3:06>> And what's the other part?
- 3:08>> And that alone doesn't necessarily
- 3:10increase likelihood. I'm just saying
- 3:11that like the author, due to just basic
- 3:13writing principles and the way that
- 3:15the reader would interpret the the
- 3:17statements, he's more likely to make it
- 3:19so that the reader doesn't misinterpret
- 3:21the statements, right? So, it's not
- 3:22relevant as well. And it's also just not
- 3:25as misleading.
- 3:27>> Okay, yes. You said
- 3:29would make it more likely to the author
- 3:31that the
- 3:32sorry, that the reader do not
- 3:34misinterpret the statement. Well, like
- 3:36sure, but the question is what is the
- 3:39correct interpretation? You're
- 3:41presupposing that your interpretation is
- 3:43correct. Such that when you read the
- 3:46statement, are there any other
- 3:48interpretation would just be uh author
- 3:52misleading anyone else? What I'm asking
- 3:54why is your interpretation uh more
- 3:56likely than others?
- 3:58>> Oh, sorry. Can you repeat that?
- 4:00Uh I was I was doing something.
- 4:02>> I'm saying that uh you said that the
- 4:06author would be
- 4:08uh
- 4:09wouldn't want to mislead his readers,
- 4:11right? And the whole you mislead the
- 4:14reader is by uh
- 4:16not interpreting a statement in a way
- 4:18that is intended. But I'm asking why do
- 4:21you think your interpretation is the
- 4:24intended interpretation of the author
- 4:26rather than my interpretation, which
- 4:29also this is also compatible with
- 4:32uh being with Lookism being a manhwa
- 4:34about fighting.
- 4:36>> Yeah, but unlike it being compatible,
- 4:38mine is actually like it being a
- 4:39fighting manhwa that directly serves as
- 4:41evidence for my position, right? So, I'm
- 4:42going to explain this to For example, in
- 4:44speech. So, this is just a constant of
- 4:46house gone, right? You don't say
- 4:47something that would be relevant. So,
- 4:50for example, if I'm talking about
- 4:51cooking and I say that he has the
- 4:52perfect body, but I'm talking about
- 4:54cooking. It'd be quite to say
- 4:55that he has the perfect body for
- 4:58fighting, right? If the the whole manga,
- 4:59for example, is about cooking.
- 5:01Even though it's compatible that he has
- 5:03the perfect body for fighting in the
- 5:04manhwa and say that he has the perfect
- 5:05body for fighting, it's more likely to
- 5:06say that he has the perfect body for
- 5:08cooking because that's the actual scope
- 5:09of the manhwa. It'd be more relevant for
- 5:10the actual manhwa to say that he has the
- 5:12perfect body for fighting. Even though
- 5:14it's compatible with otherwise.
- 5:17>> Don't you see Don't you think that my
- 5:19interpretation is also compatible with
- 5:22it being for fighting? It's not It's not
- 5:25indexed to
- 5:27uh overall
- 5:28uh like all fighters, but it's indexed
- 5:30to him specifically.
- 5:33>> It's compa- I I already told you I I
- 5:34think it's compatible. I just don't
- 5:36think that what I said serves as
- 5:38evidence for that, which is different.
- 5:39Because for it serves as evidence for my
- 5:40interpretation. Do you understand that?
- 5:43>> Okay, why is it evidence for your
- 5:45interpretation over mine? Like this is
- 5:47actually that.
- 5:48>> I just told you, bro.
- 5:50>> No, you didn't. You just said that,
- 5:52"Okay, it's going to be uh
- 5:55You You gave the analogy with the
- 5:56cooking, right? And like you're going to
- 5:58say that uh the perfect body for it
- 6:00going to be the perfect body for cooking
- 6:03over the perfect body for fighting. But,
- 6:05I'm saying that there Is there any
- 6:07relevant difference between us? Like,
- 6:10mine isn't analogous to a perfect body
- 6:13for uh cooking uh and yours for
- 6:16fighting. It's going to be both under
- 6:18fighting. It's just going to be which
- 6:20one is indexed to him specifically or
- 6:24him overall as a fighter?
- 6:26That's what I'm saying.
- 6:28>> Both indexed to him specifically. Yeah,
- 6:30I know it's about fighting. But, you
- 6:31don't say you don't interpret a
- 6:32statement as, "Oh, just for him as
- 6:34specifically." If that was for If that
- 6:36was a statement, then yeah, sure. That's
- 6:37not a statement. So, like for you to
- 6:39Like that's like you have to jump
- 6:41through a lot of hoops to get that
- 6:42interpretation to begin with.
- 6:44>> If you said that not the statement
- 6:46>> No, I'm saying that you'd have to give
- 6:48jump through a lot of hoops to get to
- 6:50that interpretation. It's a lot less
- 6:51hoops for me to jump.
- 6:52>> With With what?
- 6:53>> I I
- 6:54I you can get my interpretation a lot
- 6:55simpler because my the way I'm
- 6:57interpreting it, I don't add things onto
- 6:59the statement, bro. I'm not reading the
- 7:00statement as, "Oh, just for him." You
- 7:02know that statement doesn't say it. It
- 7:03doesn't say that. You got anything to
- 7:05add to it?
- 7:06>> No, I'm not adding anything onto it. I'm
- 7:08interpreting different. Look, you could
- 7:10say that uh my interpretation is adding
- 7:12on "just for him," but I could also say
- 7:14that your interpretation is adding on
- 7:16the fact that it's going to be relative
- 7:18to all fighters.
- 7:20>> No, not.
- 7:21>> I don't see how yours is more simpler.
- 7:23>> No, that
- 7:24Uh What did you say?
- 7:26>> I don't see how it is How yours is
- 7:27simpler.
- 7:29>> Okay, you don't see it, but I see it.
- 7:31It's cuz you're adding thing You're
- 7:33adding thing You're literally adding
- 7:34words onto the statement.
- 7:35>> Okay, what
- 7:36>> it's just for him, but I'm just saying
- 7:38that perfect body I I'm just taking the
- 7:40word perfect means just from the actual
- 7:42denotation of it. Like that's just
- 7:44different.
- 7:46>> Okay, let's Okay, give the denotation of
- 7:48perfect.
- 7:50>> Search it up, bro. It's flawless.
- 7:53>> Let me check it.
- 7:54How do you get it? Like
- 7:56I sure as it is tough.
- 7:58>> Okay.
- 8:04>> Perfect meaning
- 8:08Cambridge dictionary meaning
- 8:17complete and correct in every way of the
- 8:20best possible type without fail, without
- 8:23fault or error.
- 8:24Like do you think that's it?
- 8:27>> Sure, bro.
- 8:29>> Yeah, so how would is that like this is
- 8:32compatible with mine and again, your
- 8:35doesn't have any likelihood ra- above
- 8:38mine. And I explained why it doesn't
- 8:41specifically raise
- 8:43uh the probability of your
- 8:45your hypothesis above mine.
- 8:48>> Yeah, sure, bro. Jorah, do you Were you
- 8:50listening?
- 8:53>> Uh yeah, I was, yeah.
- 8:55>> Okay, uh do you think we can conclude?
- 8:58>> Um if you guys want to conclude, yeah,
- 9:00I'd prefer that. But I don't think I
- 9:01need conclusions.
- 9:03>> Okay, so I'm ready when you conclude.
- 9:06>> Sure, we can conclude.
- 9:08>> Okay.
- 9:10So
- 9:11I mean, he said we don't need
- 9:12conclusions, so Jorah, what do you
- 9:14think?
- 9:16>> Uh I was like let me go to my room one
- 9:17second and I'll I'll say that right.
- 9:20>> Okay.
- 9:31>> Uh
- 9:32My fault.
- 9:34All right, my bad. Um okay, so said like
- 9:36uh both of the guys agree to conclude.
- 9:39Um, I feel like
- 9:41there's like some I guess I guess you
- 9:43guys were just talking past each other
- 9:45to something here.
- 9:46Um, I'm working like I feel like if
- 9:48we're just being charitable here, the
- 9:49way that I'm working for that the word
- 9:52compatible
- 9:53um, would be in the sense that it's
- 9:55compatible such that it serves as
- 9:57evidence equally for both views.
- 9:59Um, but yeah, I feel like that the
- 10:01established definition of the word
- 10:02compatible there would be
- 10:04like a sort of lack of contradiction
- 10:07with
- 10:08the evidence
- 10:09being expected on their view.
- 10:11All right. And so that's a little that's
- 10:13a little bit different there. And so
- 10:14when Vortex keeps saying, "Okay, well,
- 10:16perfect." Which means flawless, right?
- 10:18Which, you know, the guy had basically
- 10:20no issues with.
- 10:21Um, and yeah, like I said, a fighters
- 10:23with the story.
- 10:24Granted that the
- 10:26point to the story would be to like
- 10:28flesh out some fighting skill.
- 10:30You know, granted the fighting model,
- 10:31right?
- 10:32Um, it seems as if it would be like more
- 10:35relevant to that goal for
- 10:37the perfect to mean there okay, well,
- 10:39it's a perfect fighter.
- 10:41All right. And I mean, I feel like I
- 10:43just had no response to that.
- 10:46>> Okay, I accept No, where you can
- 10:48interpret it how I meant compatible with
- 10:50correct the first time. I meant like the
- 10:52evidence doesn't specifically raise
- 10:55other the probability of one
- 10:57hypothetically over another.
- 10:58>> Yeah, I understand you. That's what I
- 10:59mean. Yeah, so I understand what you
- 11:01meant by compatible was um, it just
- 11:03doesn't serve as evidence for his view
- 11:04over your view.
- 11:05Meaning that uh, both hypotheses there
- 11:07expect evidence likely or equally as
- 11:10likely, I would say.
- 11:11Um, is that what you're saying?
- 11:13>> Yeah, that's what I'm saying. And you
- 11:15keep saying that um,
- 11:17it being a fighting manual where like
- 11:19the guy like
- 11:21fighting and you know, it being like
- 11:24fighting other guys, but like my
- 11:26interpretation, if you listen correctly,
- 11:29was that
- 11:31Yeah, it was like he has the perfect
- 11:33body in such a way that he doesn't get
- 11:37weaker over time. And it's like King's
- 11:41body. Well, I didn't say this, but like
- 11:43it is like King's body in Manager Kim,
- 11:45where his body doesn't degrade and it's
- 11:48called uh perfect in that way.
- 11:52So
- 11:52>> No, I understand. You're trying to
- 11:53define the word perfect in some
- 11:55different way. I'm saying that
- 11:56uh
- 11:57since there was some
- 11:59uh talking there you guys were just
- 12:01talking past each other working by the
- 12:02way that's the main issue.
- 12:04All right, so it seems as if the word
- 12:06compatible there would all all meant
- 12:07there in the other dialogue. To me at
- 12:09least the judge.
- 12:10Um it seems as if the word compatible
- 12:12they just meant logical possibility with
- 12:13or logical compatibility with both
- 12:15views, right? Excuse me.
- 12:18And so under that interpretation like I
- 12:19feel like you wouldn't disagree that
- 12:20probably word sex one if you didn't like
- 12:23engage with the evidence there outside
- 12:25of saying that it was compatible with my
- 12:26view. Well, yeah, no, he grants that
- 12:27it's compatible with your view, but they
- 12:29just not this sort of relevance
- 12:31um compatibility there, right?
- 12:34>> Yeah, but like but like under my
- 12:36interpretation of compatible like would
- 12:39you say that it's inconclusive?
- 12:42>> Uh mm not necessarily, no, but so under
- 12:47your
- 12:49Um
- 12:50>> Yo, Jorah.
- 12:50>> No, I feel like it's not relevant to
- 12:52talk about your definition of compatible
- 12:53there cuz
- 12:56Can't say my mom was like clocking me
- 12:57over one sec.
- 12:59>> Oh, sure.
- 13:01>> Okay, anyway,
- 13:02um no, cuz okay, so
- 13:04uh under word sex's view
- 13:06like all this would mean is that the two
- 13:08hypotheses are not incompatible with the
- 13:11evidence, right? By saying incompatible
- 13:12I mean they can coexist at the same
- 13:15time, right?
- 13:16Um so if all you mean by compatible
- 13:19there would be like a like evidential
- 13:21compatible there
- 13:22then
- 13:24just need to argue for something like
- 13:25that. The evidence there would be as
- 13:27compatible or not compatible, excuse me,
- 13:28like as expected on the year view as is,
- 13:30all right? Which you don't.
- 13:32>> Wait, wait, he didn't he he didn't he
- 13:34didn't argue that.
- 13:36>> He didn't? No, cuz he's saying, "Okay,
- 13:38well,
- 13:38um and and he talked about different
- 13:40things like for example, he said that
- 13:42year view would be semantical, that's
- 13:43simple.
- 13:44Um so he's trying to give some sort of
- 13:46IBE for Give me a second.
- 13:48Um so he's trying to give some sort of
- 13:50IBE for his view, all right? Maybe like
- 13:52it's a weaker sense, but you know, like
- 13:54being like neutral here, like he
- 13:56probably was giving an IBE.
- 13:58Um and so like when you're talking about
- 14:00the expected power of both of your
- 14:02views, all right?
- 14:04Um it seems as if what he's saying,
- 14:06"Okay, well, the view although it's
- 14:08compatible, right? In the sense of
- 14:09compatible he's using there he's not
- 14:10sure whether or not this serves as
- 14:11evidence for your view.
- 14:13Um or at least evidence such that it
- 14:15confirms your view over his view.
- 14:17Um it seems like you need to engage with
- 14:18that rather than just say, "Okay, well,
- 14:21um you know, well, it does serve as
- 14:23evidence for me cuz it just seems to beg
- 14:24the question."
- 14:26>> Yeah, I understand that, but
- 14:30I think you misinterpreted what I meant
- 14:32by compatible, right? Like why would you
- 14:35say that uh we take his
- 14:38Why would
- 14:39interpretation of compatible be
- 14:41irrelevant, but his is relevant when I'm
- 14:43the one who invoked the term?
- 14:47>> Uh I'm not saying that anyone's version
- 14:50of the word is more or less
- 14:52relevant. What I'm saying here is that
- 14:54um directly what Vertex was asking was
- 14:56for
- 14:57uh you to support the evidential power
- 15:00of your view or your hypothesis to
- 15:02support the evidence that the guy was
- 15:04saying to be perfect, all right? So
- 15:05you're saying, "Okay, well, the
- 15:06hypothesis they're being
- 15:07yeah, um perfect would just mean, "Okay,
- 15:09well,
- 15:11you know, Daniel doesn't age, he stays
- 15:12in perfect condition throughout his
- 15:13aging." Yeah, yeah, yeah, whatever he
- 15:15said.
- 15:16Um so
- 15:18it again like it just I I I hear an
- 15:20argument for that, all right? Which I
- 15:21believe you granted that the
- 15:24you know, the story being a fighting
- 15:25manual would serve as some evidence for
- 15:26what you have on the other hand.
- 15:29>> Yeah, but if I also say that if it will
- 15:33serve as evidence for my view, I don't
- 15:35remember when he asked me for
- 15:38for for me to justify why
- 15:41him being a fighting manual or whatever
- 15:43would also serve for evidence under my
- 15:45view.
- 15:46>> Well, what he's doing
- 15:47more like it's pretty clear. So, if he's
- 15:50saying it is compatible, which in this
- 15:52case just means that there's no
- 15:53contradiction with the view being
- 15:56with your view being true with evidence.
- 15:58Right, so it's compatible in that sense.
- 16:00But, he's saying okay, well, my view is
- 16:01still more likely. I granted that you
- 16:03agree that his view was evidence in some
- 16:05way.
- 16:06What he's asking there is whether or not
- 16:08you have evidence for your own view in
- 16:09virtue of the statement. Right?
- 16:13>> All right, so like it's me
- 16:15misinterpreting like
- 16:18what you're saying.
- 16:20>> Um well, maybe I wouldn't say it's
- 16:22misinterpreting cuz I don't I don't feel
- 16:23like it was your like entirely your
- 16:24fault.
- 16:25But, I'm saying there just was some sort
- 16:27of mis- like miscommunication there
- 16:28where both guys were passed I guess I
- 16:30guess like passed each other in some
- 16:31sense. Right?
- 16:34>> All right, sure.
- 16:40>> Uh so, that's it?
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of UI Daniel (Vortex) vs James Lee (Amura) by Jesusbull, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 2,977 words across 499 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.