YouTube2Text

Ucrania NO acepta las condiciones y Rusia NO da marcha atrás: Zelenski, entre la espada y la pared — Transcript

by TOP DE IMPACTO · 2,578 words · 453 segments · language en · Watch on YouTube

Full transcript

  1. 0:00Peace is closer than ever, they say from
  2. 0:02Moscow.
  3. 0:04There could even be an agreement before
  4. 0:06this year ends, they assure from Kyiv.
  5. 0:10It all sounds very promising, but if you
  6. 0:12look at the fine print of what the
  7. 0:14Ukrainian president just posted on his
  8. 0:16social media, you realize that behind
  9. 0:18the diplomacy there is an invisible wall
  10. 0:20blocking everything.
  11. 0:24Because although both sides promise
  12. 0:25peace, neither is willing to yield on
  13. 0:27the one thing that really matters to
  14. 0:29them: their own national security.
  15. 0:33Today I’ll explain what really happened
  16. 0:35behind closed doors in Abu Dhabi and why
  17. 0:37Zelensky is more on the ropes than ever
  18. 0:39.
  19. 0:41And I’m not saying it, the front line is
  20. 0:43saying it.
  21. 0:55Every inch of our land will be returned
  22. 0:57to Russia one way or another.
  23. 1:02Russia and Ukraine have moved closer to
  24. 1:04peace following negotiations in Abu
  25. 1:06Dhabi.
  26. 1:07That is what Vladimir Medinsky, advisor
  27. 1:09to the Russian president and head of the
  28. 1:11Russian negotiating delegation, declared
  29. 1:13.
  30. 1:16When asked by a journalist if the
  31. 1:18parties had managed to get closer to
  32. 1:20achieving peace, Medinsky responded, I
  33. 1:22believe so, but at this moment much
  34. 1:24depends on all the participants in the
  35. 1:26process.
  36. 1:29According to him, much depends on
  37. 1:31Ukraine, on the stance of the United
  38. 1:33States, and on whether Europe regains
  39. 1:35its common sense.
  40. 1:39But while peace was being played for in
  41. 1:41Abu Dhabi, Zelensky was traveling
  42. 1:43through Europe playing a different game
  43. 1:45, meeting with prime ministers and
  44. 1:46presidents, requesting more sanctions
  45. 1:48against Russia, and if possible, pretty
  46. 1:50please, if they had spare euros in their
  47. 1:52budgets, to allocate them to Ukraine.
  48. 1:58Sanctions against Russia are necessary,
  49. 2:01especially against Russian entities
  50. 2:02working for Putin, for his system.
  51. 2:07We ask all our partners in Europe and
  52. 2:09the world to focus on the sanctions.
  53. 2:16>> Zelensky even made ambiguous statements
  54. 2:18, saying he was worried about possible
  55. 2:20new attacks on Iran, but in reality, he
  56. 2:22didn’t mean it because of the suffering
  57. 2:24war brings, but because the weapons
  58. 2:26Ukraine needs won't reach them, but will
  59. 2:29be sent to the Middle East instead.
  60. 2:37>> Now, while we remain concerned about
  61. 2:39whether the United States will bomb Iran
  62. 2:40again and think about how many countries
  63. 2:42and people could be affected by it, we
  64. 2:44are not just waiting to see what happens
  65. 2:46next in that region.
  66. 2:53In reality, we are waiting to see what
  67. 2:55will happen to our own society due to
  68. 2:56price hikes and the shortage of weapons
  69. 2:58we need for our defense.
  70. 3:02We are already feeling that shortage of
  71. 3:04weapons.
  72. 3:08When we look for missiles for Patriot
  73. 3:10systems to protect our cities and
  74. 3:11communities from Russian ballistic
  75. 3:13attacks, time and again we face the same
  76. 3:15problem of shortages, because Patriot
  77. 3:17missiles are headed to the Middle East.
  78. 3:25>> If you only look at the Abu Dhabi
  79. 3:27headlines, it would seem that the end of
  80. 3:29the war is just around the corner, but
  81. 3:31if we set aside the diplomatic
  82. 3:33pleasantries and face reality, we
  83. 3:35encounter three walls that no official
  84. 3:37statement has managed to tear down.
  85. 3:42The first thing we must keep in mind is
  86. 3:44that Russia controls about a fifth of
  87. 3:46Ukrainian territory and demands that
  88. 3:48Kyiv recognize that new reality on the
  89. 3:50ground as a starting point.
  90. 3:54For Zelensky, signing a peace deal that
  91. 3:56cedes territory without recovering his
  92. 3:591991 borders, Crimea included, not only
  93. 4:01violates the Ukrainian constitution but
  94. 4:04also spells political suicide.
  95. 4:07And that is the key to all of this.
  96. 4:09Is Zelensky really willing to sign off
  97. 4:11on a defeat?
  98. 4:12In other words, his own defeat.
  99. 4:16Another point to consider is that while
  100. 4:18negotiators in Abu Dhabi were talking
  101. 4:20about moving toward peace, the front
  102. 4:22line remained ablaze.
  103. 4:25The Russians kept bombing the Ukrainian
  104. 4:27power grid, and the Ukrainians kept
  105. 4:29attacking Russian oil terminals with
  106. 4:31drones.
  107. 4:34In geopolitics, when negotiating without
  108. 4:37a prior ceasefire, each side tries to
  109. 4:39gain ground with fire and blood to reach
  110. 4:41the next meeting with a better hand.
  111. 4:45And for the moment, it seems that Russia
  112. 4:48holds the better cards.
  113. 4:50And as for the reality of security
  114. 4:52guarantees, here we return to the very
  115. 4:54beginning.
  116. 4:56Zelensky says that if Ukraine gives up
  117. 4:58joining NATO so that Russia can
  118. 5:00guarantee its security, Ukraine is left
  119. 5:03without any guarantees.
  120. 5:05As we can see, this vicious cycle has no
  121. 5:08exit.
  122. 5:09In the end, what happened in Abu Dhabi
  123. 5:12shows that diplomacy is back, but the
  124. 5:14central dilemma remains intact.
  125. 5:17For Russia, peace means redesigning
  126. 5:19European security and slamming the door
  127. 5:21on NATO forever.
  128. 5:24For Ukraine, peace means surviving as a
  129. 5:26sovereign state protected by the West.
  130. 5:31With the clock ticking toward the end of
  131. 5:342026 and pressure from Washington on the
  132. 5:36table, the question is no longer whether
  133. 5:38they want peace, but who is willing to
  134. 5:40pay the political price of yielding
  135. 5:42first.
  136. 5:45There was a notable moment in the press
  137. 5:47conference when the Russians were asked
  138. 5:49why they didn't accept the European
  139. 5:51delegation at the negotiating table.
  140. 5:53And this was the response.
  141. 5:56>> We did not hold any dialogue with the
  142. 5:58European delegation.
  143. 5:59We don't really understand what they are
  144. 6:01doing here. The delegations were agreed
  145. 6:03upon on a trilateral basis. The stance
  146. 6:06of many European countries is well known
  147. 6:08.
  148. 6:10That is why I don't understand what
  149. 6:11there is to talk about with them.
  150. 6:16They arrived here like tourists.
  151. 6:18Let them talk among themselves at the
  152. 6:20hotel bar about their own affairs, and
  153. 6:22when they have a concrete proposal, well
  154. 6:24, we will analyze it.
  155. 6:28>> To understand why peace in Ukraine is
  156. 6:29stalled, we must detail the vicious
  157. 6:31cycle we are in, because that explains
  158. 6:33everything.
  159. 6:37That Ukraine aspires to join NATO, and
  160. 6:39that preventing it was one of Russia's
  161. 6:41stated reasons for starting the invasion
  162. 6:43, is no secret to anyone.
  163. 6:47Amidst all this, we hear a key
  164. 6:48geopolitical term daily: the national
  165. 6:51security of each state.
  166. 6:55And this is where we face what experts
  167. 6:57call a security dilemma.
  168. 7:02On one hand, Moscow maintains that
  169. 7:03Ukraine's entry into NATO is an
  170. 7:05existential threat to Russia, while Kyiv
  171. 7:07maintains that staying out of that
  172. 7:09military alliance leaves Ukraine
  173. 7:10defenseless against its neighbor.
  174. 7:15Ukraine appeals to the principle of
  175. 7:17sovereignty: every state has the free
  176. 7:19right to choose its alliances, and
  177. 7:21joining NATO is the only security
  178. 7:22guarantee they have left.
  179. 7:26This, of course, is from Kyiv's point of
  180. 7:28view.
  181. 7:29Russia, on the other hand, appeals to
  182. 7:31the principle of indivisible security.
  183. 7:34No country can guarantee its security by
  184. 7:36putting another's security at risk.
  185. 7:40As you can see, each argument has its
  186. 7:42own logic.
  187. 7:45The bad thing is that each one clashes
  188. 7:46head-on with the rival's, leaving us all
  189. 7:48at a dead end.
  190. 7:52To understand Moscow's stance, analysts
  191. 7:55often look back to 1962, during the
  192. 7:57Cuban Missile Crisis.
  193. 8:00At that time, two sovereign states, Cuba
  194. 8:02and the Soviet Union, agreed to install
  195. 8:05nuclear missiles on the island.
  196. 8:10Washington considered that an
  197. 8:11intolerable red line in its neighborhood
  198. 8:13, and the world was on the brink of
  199. 8:15nuclear war until the Russian missiles
  200. 8:16were removed.
  201. 8:21From the Russian perspective, NATO's
  202. 8:23expansion toward its borders creates a
  203. 8:25similar strategic threat that the West
  204. 8:27monumentally ignores.
  205. 8:31Much has been said about NATO's promises
  206. 8:33after the fall of the Soviet Union.
  207. 8:36Don't worry, Mikhail, we will not expand
  208. 8:38a single inch further toward the Russian
  209. 8:40borders.
  210. 8:44The problem is that the Russians took it
  211. 8:46at their word; nothing was written down
  212. 8:49, and as years passed, all European
  213. 8:50countries that were Soviet allies, like
  214. 8:53Romania or Hungary, and even former
  215. 8:55Soviet republics, joined NATO one by one
  216. 8:57.
  217. 9:01And naturally, in the 90s, with a weak
  218. 9:03Russia governed by an alcoholic, the
  219. 9:05Russians could do little to nothing.
  220. 9:09But trying to integrate Ukraine into
  221. 9:11NATO, a military alliance that
  222. 9:13officially labels Russia as its number
  223. 9:15one geopolitical rival, was something
  224. 9:17Putin was not going to allow.
  225. 9:20Listen, Ukraine is a sovereign country
  226. 9:22and can join wherever it wants.
  227. 9:26Yeah, Cuba is a sovereign country too,
  228. 9:29but look at how the United States raised
  229. 9:31hell in 1962, claiming national security
  230. 9:33, and in the end, the Russians
  231. 9:35understood those concerns and left Cuba
  232. 9:37.
  233. 9:42If you can't understand those security
  234. 9:43concerns of the world's major nuclear
  235. 9:45powers, it's clear, Federico, that you
  236. 9:47just need to read a bit more.
  237. 9:52The tension between Russia and NATO has
  238. 9:54existed for many years and was put in
  239. 9:57writing on December 15, 2021, two months
  240. 9:59before the invasion.
  241. 10:03That day, Russia handed the United
  242. 10:05States and NATO two draft treaties on
  243. 10:07security guarantees with three core
  244. 10:09demands.
  245. 10:12First, a legal commitment to stop NATO's
  246. 10:15expansion and veto the entry of Ukraine
  247. 10:17or any other former Soviet republic.
  248. 10:22Second, the withdrawal of NATO troops
  249. 10:24and weaponry from countries that joined
  250. 10:27the alliance after 1997, like Poland,
  251. 10:29Romania, or the Baltic states.
  252. 10:35And third, a ban on deploying missile
  253. 10:37systems near Russian borders, as well as
  254. 10:39stopping military maneuvers at the
  255. 10:40doorstep of the world's largest country
  256. 10:42.
  257. 10:46We are talking about quite valid Russian
  258. 10:48concerns regarding their national
  259. 10:50security, but they were met with
  260. 10:51resounding silence.
  261. 10:56Faced with the movement of Russian
  262. 10:58troops near Ukraine in January 2022,
  263. 11:00Washington and Brussels took their time
  264. 11:02to respond, but instead of seeking
  265. 11:04compromises, they rejected every central
  266. 11:06point.
  267. 11:11They argued that NATO's open-door policy
  268. 11:13is not negotiable with anyone who isn't
  269. 11:15a member and that Russia has no veto
  270. 11:16power over third countries or alliances
  271. 11:18it's not part of.
  272. 11:23Come on, those diplomatic responses in
  273. 11:25plain language meant only one thing.
  274. 11:30Putin, shut your mouth and watch us do
  275. 11:32whatever we please, even near your
  276. 11:34borders.
  277. 11:36If a fight is inevitable, you must
  278. 11:38strike first.
  279. 11:41That is what the streets of Leningrad
  280. 11:42taught me, Putin once said.
  281. 11:46And realizing that war in Ukraine was
  282. 11:48inevitable because Kiev was preparing to
  283. 11:50take back Crimea, Russia struck first.
  284. 11:55Mind you, I'm not justifying anything;
  285. 11:57I'm recounting verifiable facts.
  286. 12:01This is key because this is precisely
  287. 12:03where the circle closes with what is
  288. 12:05happening today in Abu Dhabi.
  289. 12:08The Russian delegation is now demanding
  290. 12:10a new European security framework and a
  291. 12:12definitive stop to NATO's advance toward
  292. 12:14Russian borders.
  293. 12:18That is essentially the same thing Putin
  294. 12:20put on NATO's table in December 2021,
  295. 12:22but they ignored it.
  296. 12:26It’s not for nothing that Trump repeats
  297. 12:28like a parrot that with him in power
  298. 12:30Russia would have never invaded Ukraine
  299. 12:31, implying that he would have listened
  300. 12:33to the security concerns of Russia that
  301. 12:35Grandpa Biden refused to hear.
  302. 12:39Are you telling me that all of this
  303. 12:40could have been avoided, Big Mustache?
  304. 12:42Well friend, why would I tell you
  305. 12:44otherwise. Yes, yes.
  306. 12:48The big question we face today is
  307. 12:49whether the attrition of the war in
  308. 12:51Ukraine and the changing political
  309. 12:52landscape in the U.S. have forced a
  310. 12:54reopening of a debate that seemed closed
  311. 12:56years ago.
  312. 12:59To listen, after all, to the security
  313. 13:02concerns of Moscow.
  314. 13:06But before seeing if an agreement is
  315. 13:08possible, we must ask two key questions
  316. 13:10that explain what is happening behind
  317. 13:11the scenes.
  318. 13:14Why did they meet in Abu Dhabi and what
  319. 13:16do the names of the people sent to
  320. 13:17negotiate tell us?
  321. 13:19First, the location.
  322. 13:22The United Arab Emirates has become the
  323. 13:24new Switzerland of modern geopolitics.
  324. 13:28Unlike European countries, Abu Dhabi did
  325. 13:31not join the Western sanctions against
  326. 13:33Moscow, maintains direct lines to the
  327. 13:35Kremlin, and is simultaneously a
  328. 13:37strategic U.S. ally.
  329. 13:41That pragmatic neutrality has already
  330. 13:43allowed it to successfully mediate
  331. 13:45dozens of prisoner exchanges between
  332. 13:46Russia and Ukraine.
  333. 13:51It is literally one of the few places in
  334. 13:53the world where both sides can sit down
  335. 13:54without feeling like they are in enemy
  336. 13:56territory.
  337. 14:00Second, and even more important, who is
  338. 14:02sitting at the table.
  339. 14:05In diplomacy, the profile of the envoys
  340. 14:07reveals what is actually being discussed
  341. 14:09.
  342. 14:11On the U.S. side, figures close to the
  343. 14:13White House inner circle appear, such as
  344. 14:15special envoy Steve Witkoff and Donald
  345. 14:17Trump’s son-in-law, Jared Kushner.
  346. 14:22This indicates that Washington is
  347. 14:24applying a much more direct and
  348. 14:26transactional diplomacy, seeking to
  349. 14:27close a deal quickly outside of
  350. 14:29traditional bureaucratic channels.
  351. 14:34On the Russian side, Putin sent Vladimir
  352. 14:36Medinsky, a historic presidential
  353. 14:38advisor and ideologue who already led
  354. 14:40negotiations with Ukraine in 2022.
  355. 14:44But accompanying Medinsky was Igor
  356. 14:46Kostyukov, the head of Russia’s military
  357. 14:48intelligence.
  358. 14:50And Ukraine responded in the same
  359. 14:52language.
  360. 14:54They sent their Defense Minister Rustem
  361. 14:56Umerov alongside Kyrylo Budanov, the
  362. 14:58head of Ukrainian military intelligence
  363. 15:00.
  364. 15:02When you see the heads of military
  365. 15:04intelligence from both countries sitting
  366. 15:06face-to-face in Abu Dhabi, the message
  367. 15:08is quite clear.
  368. 15:12They are not just discussing political
  369. 15:14statements here; they are negotiating
  370. 15:16front lines, demilitarized zones, and
  371. 15:18very concrete military conditions.
  372. 15:22And let’s take a pause here because
  373. 15:24there has been a most curious event.
  374. 15:28To start, be aware that the head of the
  375. 15:30Ukrainian presidential office, who is
  376. 15:32involved in peace negotiations, was
  377. 15:34fined in his own country for speaking
  378. 15:36Russian while resolving a dispute
  379. 15:37between neighbors and security forces.
  380. 15:43The Commissioner for the Protection of
  381. 15:45the State Language of Ukraine confirmed
  382. 15:47that the official broke the language law
  383. 15:49by not using the official language while
  384. 15:50performing his duties.
  385. 15:59The stipulated fine ranges between 80
  386. 16:01and 150 dollars.
  387. 16:04Budanov acknowledged the violation
  388. 16:06without offering excuses and agreed to
  389. 16:08pay the fine within the legal deadline.
  390. 16:12In Abu Dhabi, a curious incident
  391. 16:14occurred during a press conference when
  392. 16:16he was asked a question in English, and
  393. 16:18although he understood it, he asked for
  394. 16:19a translation into Ukrainian.
  395. 16:24The translator, surprised, seemed to say
  396. 16:26, "Hey, but you understood the question
  397. 16:28," but he responded in Russian, "Of
  398. 16:30course I understood it, but I need time
  399. 16:32to think about my answer."
  400. 16:59The thing is, ladies and gentlemen, most
  401. 17:01high-ranking Ukrainian officials have
  402. 17:03Russian as their mother tongue.
  403. 17:06Zelenskyy himself, or the aforementioned
  404. 17:08Budanov, speak Russian in private
  405. 17:10because it is more comfortable and
  406. 17:12natural for them.
  407. 17:14However, at the state level, the
  408. 17:16Ukrainians have banned the Russian
  409. 17:18language.
  410. 17:21And the fact that Vladimir Medinsky is
  411. 17:23once again heading the Russian
  412. 17:25delegation brings us directly to the
  413. 17:27biggest ghost haunting these talks: what
  414. 17:29happened in Istanbul in March 2022.
  415. 17:33A few weeks after the invasion began,
  416. 17:35Russia and Ukraine were already on the
  417. 17:37verge of signing a peace draft in Turkey
  418. 17:39.
  419. 17:41That document proposed a formula very
  420. 17:43similar to the one being echoed again in
  421. 17:45Abu Dhabi today.
  422. 17:49Ukraine would renounce joining NATO and
  423. 17:51accept a status of permanent neutrality
  424. 17:53in exchange for receiving international
  425. 17:55security guarantees from several Western
  426. 17:57powers.
  427. 18:01So, why did those peace negotiations
  428. 18:03fail, and why is there so much distrust
  429. 18:05between both sides today?
  430. 18:10According to the Russians, then-British
  431. 18:12Prime Minister Boris Johnson arrived in
  432. 18:14Kyiv to advise Zelenskyy to withdraw
  433. 18:15from negotiations and fight until the
  434. 18:17last Ukrainian.
  435. 18:23According to the Ukrainian version, they
  436. 18:25noted a lack of real commitment from
  437. 18:27Western powers to act as Ukraine's
  438. 18:29military guarantors, and the conviction
  439. 18:30that Kyiv could at that time expel the
  440. 18:32Russians by force with Western aid.
  441. 18:40Four years later, with hundreds of
  442. 18:42thousands of casualties and entire
  443. 18:43cities destroyed, the negotiators are
  444. 18:45once again facing the same Istanbul
  445. 18:47puzzle, but this time with a brutal
  446. 18:49difference.
  447. 18:52Today, Russia controls much more
  448. 18:54territory, and Ukraine is much more worn
  449. 18:57down.
  450. 18:59Do you believe we will see a peace
  451. 19:01agreement before the end of this year,
  452. 19:03or are we looking at another tactical
  453. 19:04pause?

About this transcript

This page contains the full transcript of Ucrania NO acepta las condiciones y Rusia NO da marcha atrás: Zelenski, entre la espada y la pared by TOP DE IMPACTO, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 2,578 words across 453 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.

What you can do with it

Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.

Free YouTube transcript tool

YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.